California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 15, 2001

Student v. Desert Sands Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 279-00 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim

Desert Sands Unified must provide make-up inclusion specialist and Tourette's consultation services; parent's request for a specific type of expert denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 5 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parent of a 10-year-old fourth grader eligible for special education under autism filed against Desert Sands Unified School District. The student has Asperger's syndrome and Tourette's syndrome and attended general education at Washington Charter School with a paraeducator. The parent claimed the District failed to deliver IEP services from 1998 to early 2001. The parent also asked that the student's social skills program and case management be run by a certified cognitive behaviorist who is an educational psychologist experienced with Asperger's syndrome.

The Hearing Officer found that the District stopped providing the inclusion specialist required by the October 1998 IEP. The specialist, Laura Anesko, was reassigned in late November 1998, and no one replaced her through May 25, 1999. The IEP also required up to two hours of Tourette's consultation each quarter, but the District called its consultant, Colleen Wang, only twice. The IEP did not support the District's argument that the service was "as needed." Both failures denied FAPE. The District did meet its duty to provide an autism consultant by contracting with Denise Pollard.

As compensatory education, the District must provide 45-minute inclusion specialist sessions three times a month during the first half of 2001-2002. It must also add one extra quarterly Tourette's consultation of up to two hours during 2001-2002. On the third issue, the Hearing Officer applied Rowley and denied the requested expert. Ms. Anesko may run the program, but only with at least monthly consultation from a psychologist experienced with Asperger's syndrome and nonverbal learning disability.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated an IEP as a commitment to deliver every listed service. A staff reassignment, or an "as needed" reading the IEP did not contain, did not excuse missed services. It also shows how the Rowley standard applied to provider qualifications. Instead of ordering the parent's preferred expert, the Hearing Officer required psychologist consultation.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1A. Did the District fail to provide services required by Student's IEPs during 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and the first half of 2000-2001 — specifically, the services of an inclusion specialist?

    The District provided no inclusion specialist from late November 1998, when the assigned specialist was reassigned, to May 25, 1999, despite the October 1998 IEP. This denied FAPE.

  2. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1B. Did the District fail to provide the services of a Tourette's consultant as required by Student's IEPs?

    The IEP required up to two hours of Tourette's consultation each quarter from September 1999. Except for the fourth quarter of 1999-2000, the District did not provide it. The Hearing Officer rejected the District's 'as needed' argument because the IEP did not say that. This denied FAPE.

  3. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1C. Did the District fail to provide the consultation and program-monitoring services of a nonpublic agency with expertise in autism/Asperger's syndrome as required by Student's IEPs?

    The District acted in good faith and as soon as possible when it contracted with a qualified consultant (Denise Pollard), whose services substantially met the IEP. Services stopped after May 2000 because the parent withdrew her consent to that consultant.

  4. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 2. If the District failed to provide the required services, is Student entitled to compensatory education?

    Both service failures caused lost educational opportunity. The Hearing Officer ordered make-up inclusion specialist services for half a school year and an extra quarterly Tourette's consultation during 2001-2002.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Does Student require the services of a certified cognitive behaviorist with experience in applied behavior analysis, who is an educational psychologist with sufficient experience in diagnosing, assessing, and developing appropriate programs for students with Asperger's syndrome?

    Under Rowley, the District did not have to provide the specialist the parent requested. The District's inclusion/behavior specialist could run the social cognition program and case management, but only with at least monthly consultation from a psychologist with expertise in Asperger's syndrome and nonverbal learning disability.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Compensatory education. During the first half of the 2001-2002 school year, the District must provide inclusion specialist services three times per month for 45 minutes each time. The inclusion specialist must consult with the case manager/coordinator on modifications and accommodations in general education and attend the monthly case management meetings. The District must amend the IEP to reflect these services.
  • Compensatory education. During the 2001-2002 school year, the District must provide Tourette's specialist consultation one additional time per quarter for up to two hours. This is in addition to the once-quarterly, up-to-two-hour consultation the parent already agreed to in the November 20, 2000 IEP. The District must amend the IEP to reflect it.
  • Order to provide or change services. The District must add to the IEP regular and frequent (at least monthly) consultation from a psychologist with some expertise in serving students with Asperger's syndrome and nonverbal learning disability in the educational setting (for example, school psychologist Vikki Nabozny). That psychologist must be part of the team at the monthly case management meetings.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm.; Burlington; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.342(b)(1)(ii); 34 C.F.R. § 300.350(a)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a)

People named in the decision

  • Cynthia Norall, Ph.D., licensed educational psychologist; assessor under District contract and expert witness for Student, Comprehensive Autism Services and Education (nonpublic agency)
  • Susan Krupnick, paraeducator, Desert Sands Unified School District
  • Maureen Boren, program specialist, Desert Sands Unified School District
  • Debra Wright, parents' former advocate
  • Joan Taylor, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessor), Desert Sands Unified School District
  • Allen Lehmann, principal, Washington Charter School
  • Angela Johnson, fourth-grade general education teacher, Washington Charter School
  • Vikki Nabozny, school psychologist (licensed educational psychologist), Desert Sands Unified School District
  • Carolyn Rounsaville, director of special education and student support services, Desert Sands Unified School District
  • Kathryn Walsh, speech-language pathologist, Desert Sands Unified School District
  • Laura Anesko, inclusion and behavior specialist, Desert Sands Unified School District
  • Colleen Wang, R.N., Tourette's syndrome consultant, Tourette's Spectrum Disorder Association
  • Denise Pollard, District autism consultant (consultation and program monitoring), Center for Autism Research, Evaluation, and Service
  • Kristen Farmer, autism consultant requested by parent (contract not finalized), Autism Comprehensive Consultation Services (ACES), nonpublic agency
  • Ivar Lovaas, Ph.D., autism expert under whom Denise Pollard interned (referenced)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in La Quinta, California, on January 16 and 17, February 16, 20, and 22, and March 20 and 22, 2001.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney J.S. Hermanson from the Law Office of J.S. Hermanson. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Desert Sands Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Jack Clarke from the firm of Best, Best & Krieger. Also present on the District’s behalf was Carloyn Rounsaville, its director of special education and student support services, and attorney Maria Gless from the firm of Best, Best & Krieger.

The parties called the following witnesses: Cynthia Norall, Ph.D., a licensed educational psychologist; MOTHER; FRIEND, a family friend and mother of twin children diagnosed with autism; Susan Krupnick, STUDENT’s paraeducator; Maureen Boren, a District program specialist; Debra Wright, the parents’ former advocate; Joan Taylor, a District school psychologist; Allen Lehmann, the principal of Washington Charter School; Angela Johnson, STUDENT’s fourth-grade teacher; Vikki Nabozny, a District school psychologist; Ms. Rounsaville; Kathryn Walsh, a District speech language pathologist; Laura Anesko, a District inclusion and behavior specialist; Colleen Wang, R.N., nonprofit administrator for the Tourette’s Spectrum Disorder Association; and Denise Pollard, a District consultant and supervising consultant for the Center for Autism Research, Evaluation, and Service.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 1)

1. Did the District fail to provide services to STUDENT as required in his individualized education programs during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years and the first half of the 2000-2001 school year?(Footnote 2)

2. If the District failed to provide the required services, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

3. Does STUDENT require the services of a certified cognitive behaviorist with experience in applied behavior analysis, who is an educational psychologist with sufficient experience in diagnosing, assessing, and developing appropriate programs for students with Asperger’s syndrome?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a ten-year-old fourth-grade student who resides within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District. He was first identified as a child with exceptional needs under the category of autism while a preschool student. He has been diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome, Tourette’s syndrome, obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), and nonverbal learning disability (NLD). He has attended Washington Charter School (Washington), a District school, since the 1995-1996 school year. STUDENT’s programs at Washington have consisted of placement in the general education program during the entire school day or the majority of the school day, often with the assistance of a paraeducator, and related services such as speech and language therapy.

On March 10, 1998, while STUDENT was in the first grade, the District convened a meeting to review and develop his individualized education program (IEP). The IEP team agreed that STUDENT should spend five periods in the general education program every school day, with some assistance from a paraeducator, and receive the services of an inclusion specialist two times per month for sixty minutes each time. The inclusion specialist assigned to STUDENT’s case was Laura Anesko.

When another IEP meeting was convened on October 19, 1998, the IEP team agreed to continue the services of the inclusion specialist but increased the amount of service Ms. Anesko would provide to three times per month for forty-five minutes each time. In late November 1998, Ms. Anesko was reassigned to teach a preschool special day class (SDC) for autistic students. The District did not assign a new inclusion specialist to STUDENT’s case.

On March 25, 1999, STUDENT’s IEP team met again. The team was not able to complete the IEP process but agreed to reconvene the meeting on a later date to develop behavior and social goals for STUDENT. On May 26, 1999, the IEP team reconvened and agreed that, among other things, the District would contract with Tourette’s consultant Colleen Wang, R.N., to provide up to two hours of consultation for STUDENT every quarter. The team also agreed that the District would contract with a nonpublic agency (NPA) to provide consultation and program monitoring, with the frequency to be determined later. The parent requested that the District contract with autism consultant Kristen Farmer for these services. The IEP did not include a provision for the services of an inclusion specialist.

Although contract negotiations were begun with Ms. Farmer, they were unsuccessful. The District instead contracted with Denise Pollard to provide the consultation and program monitoring services for STUDENT’s program. Ms. Pollard performed six observations of STUDENT in his educational program during the course of the 1999-2000 school year, with the first occurring on November 1, 1999. Most of the observations were followed immediately by a meeting with Ms. Pollard, MOTHER, STUDENT’s paraeducator and teacher, and other District personnel involved with STUDENT’s program.

On May 4, 2000, an IEP meeting was convened to conduct the annual review of STUDENT’s program. During the meeting, MOTHER requested that the District provide STUDENT with the services of an NPA consultant with expertise in autism to assist in developing behavioral interventions for STUDENT (specifically to address behaviors arising out of his OCD, tics, stress, and low frustration tolerance) and that the frequency and duration of the services be determined by the NPA consultant. MOTHER also requested that the District have an NPA consultant with expertise in autism provide an assessment to make recommendations for behavioral goals. Finally, MOTHER requested that the District provide STUDENT with the services of a Tourette’s consultant. The District agreed at the meeting to provide the resources of an outside autism consultant to provide further suggestions and input for STUDENT’s program, but noted that its agreement to provide an outside consultant was not intended to imply that its staff (specifically, its inclusion specialist) did not have the expertise necessary to develop and manage both behavior and social cognition programs for STUDENT. The District noted in the IEP that its agreement to provide an outside consultant was intended to maintain and promote an “objective climate of information” to allow staff and the parents to function as a team in support of developing an appropriate program for STUDENT. With regard to the parent’s request for a Tourette’s consultant, the District indicated that it would consider providing such services one time per year for a total of four hours and noted that Ms. Wang was scheduled to observe STUDENT on May 24, 2000, and would consult with staff at that time. Additionally, the District’s recommended program included the services of an inclusion specialist. At the conclusion of the meeting, MOTHER indicated that she wanted to review the IEP before deciding whether to agree to it. MOTHER did not thereafter provide her agreement to the IEP.

Four days later, on May 8, Ms. Wang conducted her first observation of STUDENT in his educational program and provided consultation to the staff working with him with regard to Tourette’s and its effects on STUDENT’s performance in the classroom.

On August 10, 2000, another IEP meeting was held. The District agreed to contract with an NPA with experience in Asperger’s syndrome to conduct an assessment. The team agreed that the NPA would be selected and agreed upon between the District and the parents, and would be contracted to complete the assessment as quickly as possible. MOTHER suggested that the District contract with Cynthia Norall, Ph.D. By letter dated August 23, 2000, the District agreed to contract with Dr. Norall for an assessment in the area of social cognition, as well as provide consultation services to the District team that would be completing the upcoming triennial assessment for STUDENT.

In October and November 2000, District personnel and Dr. Norall completed a multidisciplinary assessment for STUDENT. The assessment included a psychological evaluation by Dr. Norall, a psychoeducational evaluation by school psychologist Joan Taylor, a functional assessment observation by Ms. Anesko, a speech and language evaluation by Kathryn Walsh, academic achievement testing, and an occupational therapy evaluation.

Ms. Taylor and Dr. Norall reported that STUDENT’s performance on the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale - Fourth Edition indicated cognitive ability within the average range. Ms. Taylor noted that STUDENT displayed personal strength in verbal reasoning and vocabulary and that his weakest performance was on a subtest that required some inferential thinking and social understanding. Ms. Taylor reported that, when administered the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), STUDENT performed at or above grade level in the areas of reading and writing, and that mathematical reasoning and numerical operations continued to be his weaker academic areas. She also noted that he continued to have difficulty with critical thinking and abstract problem solving, and that his teacher reported that inferences and predictions were areas of weakness for him. In terms of social-emotional development and functioning, Ms. Taylor reported that his teacher, Ms. Johnson, indicated that STUDENT continued to have social skills problems, including problems modulating the volume of his voice and initiating conversations in the classroom. Specifically, Ms. Taylor stated the following in her report:

Mrs. Johnson also stated that STUDENT generally does not initiate conversation in the classroom, but does respond with appropriate remarks. STUDENT’s comments are on topic, and related to the discussion on hand. When STUDENT is interested in a topic, he will raise his hand and volunteer information. ... STUDENT has certain preferred friends, who are generally female. He will often play imaginary games with one or two female classmates. STUDENT does engage in give and take conversation and is talkative with peers. STUDENT is described by his classroom teacher as a student who is liked by peers and seems to be accepted. Mrs. Johnson does, however, have some concerns regarding STUDENT’s use of unstructured time in the classroom setting and social skills. STUDENT continues to display tics, consistent with his diagnosis of Tourette’s. These tics are both motor and vocal in nature. STUDENT does seem to be anxious regarding his performance. Structure, routine, and consistency all have a calming effect on his emotional state.

Finally, Ms. Taylor noted that Ms. Anesko offered some suggestions for STUDENT’s program, including having him participate in a social skills program with regular education students, where STUDENT could learn from and model appropriate behavior. According to Ms. Anesko, the social skills program would be best implemented in STUDENT’s fourth-grade classroom. Ms. Anesko also suggested that the services of the inclusion/behavior specialist be utilized on a weekly basis in the classroom and in working with support staff.

In her assessment report, Dr. Norall stated that STUDENT displayed specific behaviors on the autism spectrum that affected his ability to interact appropriately with others. For example, Dr. Norall noted that, according to STUDENT’s mother, he can be very controlling during a social interaction with other children. Dr. Norall reported that this behavior is most likely due to his need to keep the social interaction one in which he can predict what is going to happen next. Dr. Norall also noted that in the area of verbal communication STUDENT has a well-developed vocabulary and can often give the dictionary definition of words. However, according to Dr. Norall, STUDENT has great difficulty in the area of nonverbal communication. She stated that STUDENT shows great difficulty reading social situations accurately and demonstrates “mindblindness,” in which he believes others should be able to know his thoughts but refuses to acknowledge that others may think differently than he does.

Dr. Norall stated in her report that her general impression was mild autism. Dr. Norall also noted in her report that STUDENT’s profile also indicated nonverbal learning disabilities. She stated that these were evident in his remarkable rote memory skills but difficulty with fine motor skills, faulty spatial relations, and lack of ability to comprehend nonverbal communication. She stated that when a child presents with issues related to both Asperger’s syndrome and NLD, a very specific educational plan has to be implemented. Additionally, she noted that STUDENT displayed Tourette’s syndrome, which was manifested in the many tics which impeded his participation in the classroom setting. According to Dr. Norall, behavioral modification techniques would not necessarily impact the tics stemming from Tourette’s and that these would have to be addressed in any program implemented for STUDENT.

Dr. Norall offered a number of recommendations for STUDENT’s educational program. Among other things, Dr. Norall stated that STUDENT’s unique learning style would have to be explained to all of those working with him because it was essential that staff members understand STUDENT’s perspective and realize that he has difficulty taking their perspective. With regard to social communication, Dr. Norall recommended that STUDENT be provided therapy in a small social understanding group of “children with similarities.” She stated the following with regard to this recommendation:

[I]t will be necessary to promote STUDENT’s ability to engage in perspective taking. He needs to consider what a person may be feeling based on their facial expressions, gestures and environmental cues. He also needs to consider what the other person ‘believes’ to be past knowledge of their actions, their opinions, and overall interests. ... It is recommended that some attention is focused on STUDENT’s ability to ‘self-monitor’ the appropriateness of his conversational style and nonverbal communication means. He would benefit from explicit instruction on how to self-monitor his style of communicative means by considering his listener’s perspective and adjusting his communicative acts appropriately. Role-playing and mime activities will be useful. [¶] STUDENT would benefit from therapy in a small social understanding group. It is important to recognize that his communicative functioning impedes his performance both in the classroom and in his daily interactions with peers. The group should work specifically on reading nonverbal cues as well as friendship skills. Although inclusion has been a focus of STUDENT’s program in the past, it is recommended that the friendship skills be taught in a group of children with similarities. It is noted that no assumptions can be made about what STUDENT and other children with similar difficulties understand about social situations. Because the skills must be broken down into concrete activities, neuro-typical children may find the group sessions boring and un-necessary.

On November 20, 2000, the District convened an IEP meeting to review the results of the multidisciplinary assessment. After the review of the assessment, the team identified STUDENT’s four major areas of deficit as communication, behavior, organization, and socialization. The District offered STUDENT the following program: placement in the general education program with the services of a one-on-one assistant or shadow aide during the entire school day; speech and language therapy on an individual basis thirty minutes per week and in a small group of one to three peers thirty minutes per week; a social cognition program implemented by a District behaviorist/psychologist in a small group and on an individual basis two times per week for thirty minutes each time; the services of a Tourette’s specialist consultant for staff training and consultation each quarter for up to two hours; and case management/coordination services by a credentialed behaviorist or a psychologist experienced in working with Asperger’s syndrome one time per month for sixty to ninety minutes to conduct monthly case management meetings (except in August). The District recommended that Ms. Anesko fulfill the role of the case manager/coordinator. The parent disagreed and requested that the District contract with Dr. Norall to provide the case management/coordination services.

MOTHER signed the IEP but indicated agreement only with the offer of speech and language therapy, aide assistance, and Tourette’s specialist services. The parents attached a written dissent to the IEP that stated the following, in pertinent part: “Parents are requesting a certified cognitive behaviorist with experience in applied behavior analysis. The person should be an educational psychologist with sufficient experience in diagnosing, assessing, and developing appropriate programs for students with Asperger’s syndrome and nonverbal learning disability (NLD). The parents are requesting the services of Cynthia Norall and her organization Comprehensive Autism Services and Education, a certified nonpublic agency. This organization has been working with STUDENT and has both the expertise and history with STUDENT to provide the minimum educational benefit.”

No further IEP meetings have been held for STUDENT.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District fail to provide services to STUDENT as required in his individualized education programs during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years and the first half of the 2000-2001 school year?

Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “free appropriate public education” consists of special education and related services that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, that is provided to meet the unique needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). State law refers to related services as “designated instruction and services” (DIS) and, like federal law, provides that DIS services shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b) (1997) (amending 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1994)). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

Petitioner alleged that the District failed to implement STUDENT’s IEPs by failing to provide the services of an inclusion specialist, a Tourette’s consultant, and an NPA with expertise in autism, particularly in Asperger’s syndrome. Petitioner did not put at issue any other matters concerning whether FAPE had been provided in the past.(Footnote 3) Each argument will be addressed in turn.

A. Inclusion Specialist

According to the evidence produced at hearing, STUDENT’s IEPs first included the services of an inclusion specialist on March 10, 1998. STUDENT’s next IEP was developed on October 19, 1998, and continued to include the services of an inclusion specialist. Pursuant to the IEP dated October 1998, which was agreed to by MOTHER, the District was to provide the services of an inclusion specialist in three forty-five-minute sessions per month. When the IEP team met again on March 25, 1999, the District’s recommended program did not include the services of an inclusion specialist. However, for reasons unrelated to the provision of an inclusion specialist, MOTHER did not sign agreement to the IEP. Therefore, the IEP dated October 19, 1998, remained in effect until the team met again on May 26, 1999, at which time MOTHER agreed to an IEP that did not include the services of an inclusion specialist. Consequently, based on the foregoing facts, the District had an obligation to provide STUDENT with the services of an inclusion specialist from approximately March 10, 1998, to May 25, 1999.

Petitioner contended that the District failed in its duty to provide STUDENT with the services of an inclusion specialist during some portion of the 1998-1999 school year. There is no dispute that Laura Anesko was the inclusion specialist providing services to STUDENT pursuant to his IEP at the beginning of the 1998-1999 school year. According to Ms. Anesko’s testimony, she ceased providing services to STUDENT in late November 1998 because she was reassigned to teach the preschool SDC for autistic students. She testified that she taught the SDC until June 1999.(Footnote 4) The evidence established that no one was assigned to take Ms. Anesko’s place as the inclusion specialist on STUDENT’s case after her reassignment in late November 1998.

On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with the services of an inclusion specialist from late November 1998 to May 25, 1999, in accordance with his IEP. By failing to provide the inclusion specialist services called for by STUDENT’s IEP, the District violated the IDEA requirement that a school district implement an IEP as soon as possible after the meeting at which it is agreed upon. 34 C.F.R. § 300.342(b)(1)(ii) (formerly at § 300.342(b)(2) (1996)). While an IEP does not constitute a guarantee that a child will progress at a specified rate, it does constitute a commitment to provide services. 34 C.F.R. § 300.350(a)(1) (formerly at § 300.350 (1996)). To be in compliance with the IDEA, a school district must provide all the services listed in a child’s IEP. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 45 (1996). Having failed to provide STUDENT with the inclusion specialist services required by his IEP from late November 1998 to May 25, 1999, the District failed to provide services in conformity with the IEP, as required by 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), and therefore failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE.

B. Tourette’s Consultant

STUDENT’s IEP dated May 26, 1999, which was consented to by MOTHER, stated that the District would contract with Colleen Wang, R.N., to provide consultation services for STUDENT’s educational program starting September 1999. The IEP stated that up to two hours of consultation services would be provided per quarter. At the next meeting conducted to review STUDENT’s IEP, which was held on May 4, 2000, the District’s program offer did not include the services of Ms. Wang or any other Tourette’s consultant. MOTHER requested at the meeting that the District provide STUDENT with consultation services and, although the District indicated that it would “consider” including such services as part of STUDENT’s program again, no agreement was reached at the meeting with regard to the services of the Tourette’s consultant. In fact, MOTHER did not agree to any portion of the District’s proposed program at that meeting and therefore the IEP dated May 26, 1999, continued to remain in effect. On November 20, 2000, when the IEP team met again, MOTHER agreed to the District’s proposal for consultation by a District Tourette’s specialist one time quarterly for up to two hours. Thus, the foregoing facts establish that the District has had an obligation since September 1999 to provide STUDENT with the services of a Tourette’s consultant one time per quarter for up to two hours each time.

Petitioner contended that the District failed to provide STUDENT with the services of a Tourette’s consultant as required through his IEPs. The evidence produced at hearing established that the only person who has provided consultation services as a specialist in Tourette’s to STUDENT’s program has been Ms. Wang. According to Ms. Wang’s testimony, on September 21, 1999, she signed a contract with the District to provide support and assistance in developing strategies for working with students diagnosed with Tourette’s syndrome. Ms. Wang testified that the contract provided for six hours of services and that it was her understanding that she was to provide services to STUDENT under this contract. Ms. Wang stated that the first time she came to the District to provide services for STUDENT was May 8, 2000, when she performed a one-hour observation of STUDENT in his classroom and a one-hour inservice for the staff working with STUDENT and his mother. According to Ms. Wang, the only other time she came to the District to provide services to STUDENT was February 2, 2001. When Ms. Wang was asked why she had not provided services to STUDENT on any other occasions, she replied that the District had not asked her to come out to serve STUDENT on any other dates. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that, except for the fourth quarter of the 1999-2000 school year, the District failed to provide STUDENT with the quarterly consultation services of a Tourette’s specialist from September 1999 to the end of the second half of the 2000-2001 school year, as required by his IEP.

The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive the District’s argument in its closing brief that it fulfilled its duty provide STUDENT with the consultation services of a Tourette’s specialist because the services were to be provided only on an “as needed” basis. The District argued that the services were not needed, except on those dates on which they were actually provided. The District cited page one of the IEP dated May 26, 1999, and Ms. Wang’s testimony to support its position. A review of the first page of the May 1999 IEP does not indicate that the team agreed that the Tourette’s consultation services would be on an as-needed basis. The IEP simply states that the services would be provided “up to 2 hrs quarterly.”(Footnote 5) Further, while Ms. Wang did testify that it was her understanding that under the provisions of the IEP she would come out and provide services up to two hours quarterly and would be called on an as-needed basis, she was not present at any of STUDENT’s IEP meetings. Accordingly, Ms. Wang’s testimony only established what her understanding of the IEP requirements were, as communicated to her by the District, and did not establish that the IEP team agreed to provide her services only on an as-needed basis.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that, except for the fourth quarter of the 1999-2000 school year, the District failed to provide STUDENT with the services of a Tourette’s specialist from September 1999 to the end of the second half of the 2000-2001 school year. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.342(b)(1)(ii), 300.350(a)(1). Having failed to provide STUDENT with the Tourette’s specialist required by his IEP, the District failed to provide services in conformity with the IEP, as required by 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), and therefore denied STUDENT a FAPE.

C. NPA With Expertise In Autism/Asperger’s Syndrome

At the IEP meeting held on May 26, 1999, the parent (through her advocate) requested that the District provide STUDENT with the consultation services of an NPA with expertise in Asperger’s syndrome. Specifically, the parent requested that the Asperger’s consultant address issues regarding social skills, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and theory of mind. The parent requested that Kristen Farmer of Autism Comprehensive Consultation Services (ACES), an NPA, be retained for this purpose. The IEP team agreed to include as part of STUDENT’s educational program the services of an NPA to provide “consultation and program monitoring,” with frequency and duration to be determined later, and noted on the IEP the parent’s request for Ms. Farmer. As mentioned earlier, although the next IEP meeting was held on May 4, 2000, the team was unable to agree on a program for STUDENT at that meeting, and therefore the IEP dated May 26, 1999, remained in effect. At the IEP meeting held on November 20, 2000, the team again failed to come to agreement, except with regard to speech and language therapy, aide services, and Tourette’s specialist services. Accordingly, on the basis of the foregoing facts, the District has had an obligation since May 26, 1999, to provide STUDENT with the consultation services of an NPA with expertise in autism/Asperger’s syndrome to provide consultation and program monitoring.

Ms. Rounsaville’s testimony established that the District made efforts during the summer of 1999 to retain Ms. Farmer to provide consultation services for STUDENT as an NPA, but that significant contract problems prevented the contract from being finalized. Ms. Rounsaville also testified that when contract negotiations with Ms. Farmer failed, the District contacted other NPAs and other districts in an attempt to find another NPA to serve STUDENT. The District finally signed a contract with Denise Pollard in approximately October 1999. Ms. Pollard began to provide services to STUDENT in November 1999 and continued to do so until May 2000. While Ms. Pollard was not an NPA, there was no dispute that she was qualified to provide services to STUDENT under the IEP. Ms. Pollard received a bachelor of arts degree in 1994 and a master of arts degree in May 2000, both in psychology with an emphasis in applied behavior analysis. She has interned under the supervision of Dr. Ivar Lovaas, a recognized expert in autism; worked for Behavior Analysts Incorporated as a senior consultant; and, for the past one and a half years, has been a supervising consultant for the Center for Autism Research,Evaluation, and Service. Ms. Pollard’s testimony established that she has worked with a number of children with high functioning autism.(Footnote 6)

In his closing brief, Petitioner does not dispute Ms. Pollard’s qualifications to provide services to STUDENT. Instead, Petitioner asserted that the services provided by Ms. Pollard failed to meet the requirements of the IEP, because the level of services provided was determined through contractual negotiations and not based on STUDENT’s unique needs, and she was not invited to attend the IEP meetings held for STUDENT. First, the Hearing Officer agrees that the level of services that Ms. Pollard provided should have been determined by the IEP team at a meeting where STUDENT’s needs could be discussed in relation to the services to be provided, and not through contractual negotiations between the District and Ms. Pollard. However, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the level of services ultimately provided by Ms. Pollard failed to meet STUDENT’s needs. There is no dispute that STUDENT required a consultant who would observe him in his program and interview staff working with him, and then who would conduct monthly case management meetings where the consultant and the team could discuss STUDENT’s progress and needs. This is the level of services that Ms. Pollard provided for STUDENT’s program. While Ms. Pollard testified that she later suggested a higher level of services because of the additional time requested by STUDENT’s paraeducator and mother, the evidence did not establish that STUDENT required additional services to be able to benefit from his education, only that additional services would have been beneficial. Second, the IEP did not require specifically that Ms. Pollard attend STUDENT’s IEP meetings. Ms. Pollard met with many of the members of STUDENT’s IEP team during the monthly case management meetings, where she provided comments regarding what she observed of STUDENT that day and her recommendations. She also provided her observations and recommendations in writing after each of her monthly observations. Further, Ms. Boren compiled a written summary after each monthly case management meeting that was then made available to members of the IEP team. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Pollard’s input was adequately provided to the IEP team, despite her absence from the meetings.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District proceeded in good faith in securing the services of an autism/Asperger’s specialist to provide consultation and program monitoring services for STUDENT’s program following the IEP meeting on May 26, 1999. Thus, the District complied with the IDEA requirement that the services in the IEP be provided “as soon as possible” following the IEP meeting. 34 C.F.R. § 300.342(b)(1)(ii). Further, the District’s provision of Ms. Pollard’s services substantially fulfilled the IEP requirement for an autism/Asperger’s specialist. Additionally, although Ms. Pollard ceased providing services to STUDENT after May 2000, the evidence at hearing established that Ms. Pollard’s contract was still open after May 2000 and Ms. Pollard did not provide further services because MOTHER objected to Ms. Pollard’s qualifications to provide appropriate services to STUDENT. Further, by that time, MOTHER had requested that the District hire Dr. Norall to provide consultation and other services for STUDENT’s program and had filed a request for due process hearing to resolve this issue. Given the ongoing dispute regarding the appropriate provider and Ms. Rounsaville’s undisputed testimony that MOTHER had withdrawn her consent to Ms. Pollard, the Hearing Officer finds that the District fulfilled its obligation to provide STUDENT with the services of an autism/Asperger’s specialist to the extent required.

* * * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE when it improperly failed to provide STUDENT with the services of an inclusion specialist from late November 1998 to May 25, 1999, and the services of a Tourette’s specialist from September 1999 to the end of the second half of the 2000-2001 school year, except for the fourth quarter of the 1999-2000 school year. The consequences, if any, of the District’s failure to provide the foregoing services will be addressed in the next section regarding compensatory education.

ISSUE NO. 2: If the District failed to provide the required services, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

When a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); 20 U.S.C. § 1415. Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief which may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Compensatory education does not, however, necessarily involve an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity or time missed. Id. at 1497. The purpose of compensatory education is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id.

In Issue No. 1, the Hearing Officer concluded that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE because it failed to provide STUDENT with the services of an inclusion specialist from late November 1998 to May 25, 1999, and the services of a Tourette’s specialist from September 1999 to the end of the second half of the 2000-2001 school year, except for the fourth quarter of the 1999-2000 school year. To determine whether an award of compensatory education is warranted, it must first be determined whether compensatory education is necessary to make up for lost educational opportunity.

A. Failure To Provide Inclusion Specialist From November 1998 to May 25, 1999

On March 10, 1998, when STUDENT was in the first grade and placed in the general education program during five periods every school day, his IEP team determined that he required the twice monthly services of an inclusion specialist to benefit from his special education. In October 1999, when STUDENT was in the second grade and again placed in the general education program, the IEP team determined that STUDENT continued to require the services of an inclusion specialist and that he needed more services from the inclusion specialist. The team increased the frequency of the inclusion specialist’s services to three times per month. The IEP addendum developed in October 1998 stated that the inclusion specialist would develop, with the parent’s input, a behavior plan to be used in the classroom by the aide with specific strategies for redirection, the maintenance of on-task behavior, and the development of acceptable social behaviors. According to the IEP, the inclusion specialist would also develop, with the parent’s input, a behavior plan for use during recess and lunch time to address STUDENT’s need to practice age-appropriate social and recreational involvement with other children and adults. Additionally, the IEP stated that the inclusion specialist would train the one-on-one aide assigned to assist STUDENT in the regular classroom setting, as well as during lunch and unstructured outdoor activities.

Ms. Anesko testified that, in her role as an inclusion specialist, she observed STUDENT in the school setting and consulted with his teacher and aide regarding modifications and adaptations to the general education curriculum, as well as worked with other special education staff such as the speech and language therapist and school psychologist to coordinate STUDENT’s program. According to the testimony provided by Ms. Anesko and other District witnesses, Ms. Anesko stopped providing services to STUDENT in late November 1998, when she was reassigned to teach a preschool special class for autistic students, and no one was thereafter assigned to replace her as STUDENT’s inclusion specialist. According to MOTHER’s undisputed testimony, a new aide was assigned to STUDENT in December 1998 and, with Ms. Anesko reassigned to the preschool class, there was no one to train the new aide, as required by the IEP. Additionally, there was no evidence that a behavior plan was developed by an inclusion specialist during the second grade year, as required by STUDENT’s IEP. However, evidence was presented of the many behavior and social problems that STUDENT exhibited that year. For example, MOTHER, who was frequently on the Washington campus that year, testified that STUDENT frequently poured “slime water” on his head during recess and that there was no behavior plan in place to address these types of behaviors. Further, Ms. Anesko testified that STUDENT had difficulty in mathematics and a low frustration level. She testified that these were issues that had to be closely monitored for STUDENT in the educational setting. According to Ms. Anesko, STUDENT’s program had to be modified for him to be successful in the general education classroom. Despite the undisputed fact that STUDENT required the services on an inclusion specialist during the second half of his second-grade year, none were provided to him.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to provide the inclusion specialist services from late November 1998 to May 25, 1999, as required by STUDENT’s IEP, resulted in lost educational opportunity. To make up for the lost educational opportunity, the District must provide STUDENT with compensatory services. Because the District failed to provide STUDENT with the services of an inclusion specialist during approximately half a school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must provide STUDENT with the services of an inclusion specialist during the first half of the 2001-2002 school year. The inclusion specialist services must be provided three times per month for forty-five minutes each time, as it was intended to be provided through the IEP dated October 19, 1998. The inclusion specialist shall consult with the case manager/coordinator to determine the appropriate modifications and accommodations to provide STUDENT in the general education program, as well as attend the monthly case management meetings.

B. Failure To Provide Tourette’s Specialist From September 1999 To End Of Second Half Of 2000-2001 School Year (Except During Fourth Quarter Of 1999-2000 School Year)

On May 26, 1999, STUDENT’s IEP team determined that the staff working with him required the consultation services of a Tourette’s specialist in order for STUDENT to benefit from his education. According to the evidence, the Tourette’s specialist was included in STUDENT’s program to provide support and assistance in developing strategies for working with STUDENT’s symptoms arising out of Tourette’s syndrome. During the two times that Ms. Wang provided services to STUDENT (on May 8, 1999, and February 2, 2001), she provided support and assistance to STUDENT’s program through activities such as observing STUDENT in the educational setting, providing awareness training to staff working with him, and discussing with staff problems that they were experiencing in the school setting and advising them of her recommended solutions.

The testimony of witnesses such as Susan Krupnick, who has served as STUDENT’s paraeducator in the school setting since September 1999, and Ms. Wang established that STUDENT was exhibiting many vocal and motor tics in the educational setting during the 1999-2000 school year and the first half of the 2000-2001 school year. For example, STUDENT was banging a pencil on his desk frequently. A number of the tics, including the banging of the pencil, caused STUDENT’s classmates to become annoyed with him, thus adversely affecting his (already impaired) social functioning with his classmates. Ms. Wang testified that her observation in 1999 revealed that STUDENT had some complex tics that were affecting his performance in the classroom. Ms. Wang also testified that certain activities, such as math assignments, increased his anxiety level and thus increased the frequency and intensity of his tics. Based on her undisputed expertise in Tourette’s syndrome, Ms. Wang was able to provide suggestions to decrease STUDENT’s anxiety, thereby decreasing his tics, and offer recommendations with regard to ways to work around some of STUDENT’s tics so that they would not interfere with his ability to benefit from his instructional program or adversely affect his relationship with his peers. However, as discussed earlier, Ms. Wang’s consultation was not provided to the staff working with STUDENT until May 1999 and was provided only a second time in February 2000, despite the District’s obligation to provide such services from September 1999 onward.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to provide services as required by the IEPs resulted in lost educational opportunity. The District has an obligation to provide STUDENT with compensatory services to make up for the lost educational opportunity. To redress the failure to provide the services of a Tourette’s consultant for approximately five quarters, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must provide STUDENT with additional Tourette’s consultant services during the 2001-2002 school year. In addition to the level of Tourette’s consultant services already agreed to by the parent in the IEP dated November 20, 2000 (i.e., one time per quarter for up to two hours), the District must provide STUDENT with an additional one time per quarter for up to two hours during the 2001-2002 school year.

* * * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education services to make up for lost educational opportunity. The District shall provide STUDENT with the following services in addition to those already contained in his educational program: during the first half of the 2001-2002 school year, the services of an inclusion specialist three times per month for forty-five minutes each time, who shall consult with the case manager/coordinator to determine the appropriate modifications and accommodations to provide STUDENT in the general education program, as well as attend the monthly case management meetings; and during the 2001-2002 school year, in addition to the level of Tourette’s consultant services already agreed to by the parent in the IEP dated November 20, 2000 (i.e., one time per quarter for up to two hours), an additional one time per quarter for up to two hours.

ISSUE NO. 3: Does STUDENT require the services of a certified cognitive behaviorist with experience in applied behavior analysis, who is an educational psychologist with sufficient experience in diagnosing, assessing, and developing appropriate programs for students with Asperger’s syndrome?

In its IEP dated November 20, 2000, the District offered to provide STUDENT with a social cognition program implemented in a small group and on an individual basis in two thirty-minute sessions per week, and sixty to ninety minutes per month of case management/coordination services to conduct monthly case management meetings, among other things. The District proposed to have Ms. Anesko provide both the social cognition program and the case management/coordination services. Petitioner asserted at hearing that Ms. Anesko was not qualified to provide the social cognition program or the case management/coordination services for STUDENT. Petitioner contended that, in order to receive a “minimum educational benefit,” STUDENT requires the services of a certified cognitive behaviorist with experience in applied behavior analysis, who is an educational psychologist with sufficient experience in diagnosing, assessing, and developing appropriate programs for students with Asperger’s syndrome.

There is no dispute that Ms. Anesko does not meet the description set forth by Petitioner. Ms. Anesko is not a certified cognitive behaviorist or educational psychologist. She does not diagnose or assess children using formal evaluation measures, except in the area of academic achievement, because she is not a licensed psychologist nor a school psychologist. However, she has been working in the public schools as a teacher and in other positions since 1987, and as an inclusion and behavior specialist for the District since 1998. She has a bachelor of art’s degree in communicative disorders, a master of art’s degree in education with an emphasis in curriculum and instruction, a regular education teaching credential for grades kindergarten through sixth, a severely handicapped credential, and a learning handicapped credential. She has experience working with autistic children, including a number of high functioning autistic children and six children who have been diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome. She is also a certified behavior intervention case manager, which permits her to perform observational and functional behavior assessments in the school setting, as well as develop behavior plans. The District contended that Ms. Anesko is well qualified to provide the social cognition program and the case management and coordination services for STUDENT. The question, then, is whether the person providing the social cognition program and case management/coordination services for STUDENT needs to meet the requirements set forth by Petitioner in order for STUDENT to receive a FAPE.

Dr. Norall, who does meet the description set forth by Petitioner, testified that STUDENT requires the services of a cognitive behaviorist because the social understanding group that STUDENT requires is essentially cognitive behavior therapy. Additionally, according to Dr. Norall, an educational psychologist is necessary to provide the cognitive behavior therapy. Dr. Norall also testified that the person implementing the social skills program should have experience in applied behavior analysis because he or she needs to have an understanding of how to set up interventions based on the function of a behavior. Finally, she stated that the person providing services to STUDENT needs to have experience diagnosing and assessing children with Asperger’s syndrome, because he or she must know what to look for and what areas are deficits for STUDENT educationally. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the person providing the social skills program and case coordination/management services to STUDENT must be a certified cognitive behavior or licensed educational psychologist, or that the person must have experience in diagnosing and assessing children with Asperger’s syndrome in order to provide STUDENT with appropriate services.

There is no doubt that Dr. Norall’s work with children on the autism spectrum, especially in the last year and a half, is more extensive than that of the other witnesses because she has chosen to work exclusively with this population during that time. Further, Dr. Norall’s testimony established that, since February 2000, more than half of her nonpublic agency’s caseload has consisted of children diagnosed with high functioning autism and that she currently works with fifty to sixty children diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome. There is also little doubt that, were the District to provide STUDENT with the services of the person described by Dr. Norall, he would receive educational benefit. However, the evidence established that the District is not required to provide STUDENT with this level of services in order to provide him a FAPE. The IDEA and State special education law require only that a school district provide a child with a disability instruction and services that are necessary for the child to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a); 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). As the Supreme Court has made clear, the IDEA does not require a school district to provide a special education student with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 198-200. A school district is required to provide a child with a disability only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201.

While there is no dispute that STUDENT’s greatest area of deficit is in social development, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that STUDENT’s needs can only be addressed and he can only be reasonably calculated to obtain educational benefit if the District provides him with the services of a certified cognitive behaviorist with experience in applied behavior analysis, who is an educational psychologist with sufficient experience in diagnosing, assessing, and developing appropriate programs for students with Asperger’s syndrome. While such services may optimize STUDENT’s educational benefit, as discussed above, such maximization of educational benefit is not required by the IDEA.

As the testimony of school psychologist Vikki Nabozny and others establishes, the person implementing a social skills program in the public school for a child diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome need not necessarily be a certified cognitive behaviorist. Ms. Nabozny has been a school psychologist for the past nineteen years, is a licensed educational psychologist, has had extensive training in autism, and has experience providing social skills programs to children diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome, but is not a certified cognitive behaviorist. Yet Ms. Nabozny’s testimony made clear that she recognizes many of the social understanding needs that an Asperger’s child may have, which Dr. Norall spoke of, and that her social skills groups address these needs. Additionally, there is no evidence that a license in educational psychology is required to work appropriately with STUDENT in the public school setting. According to Dr. Norall’s testimony, an educational psychologist’s license is based on two or more years practicing as a school psychologist and the passage of an examination administered by the Board of Behavioral Sciences, as well as the submission of recommendations. Dr. Norall acknowledged that a license in educational psychology does not necessarily ensure that a person has experience working with children on the autism spectrum. Since a license in educational psychology is based on training and experience as a school psychologist, there appears no reason that a school psychologist would not have sufficient training to provide cognitive behavior therapy. Finally, Dr. Norall did not provide any persuasive reason that a person implementing the social skills program or providing case management/coordination services for STUDENT needs to be able to diagnose or formally assess a child with Asperger’s syndrome. The District already conducted a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT in October and November 2000, of which Dr. Norall was a part. There is no reason why a person providing the actual services to STUDENT cannot rely on the diagnostic and assessment information gathered from that assessment or from the assessors involved in the assessment in providing services to STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Anesko has sufficient training and experience in providing service to children on the autism spectrum to provide STUDENT with a social cognition program and case management/coordination services. Ms. Anesko’s resume and testimony established that she has fifteen years’ experience providing direct services to autistic children in special classes, as well as in social skills programs. Additionally, she has attended numerous trainings specifically focused on serving children on the autism spectrum and implements in her social skills programs many of the social cognition techniques suggested by Dr. Norall. However, Ms. Anesko does not have sufficient expertise in providing services specifically to children diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome to appropriately provide services without the regular and frequent (i.e., at least monthly) consultation of a psychologist with some expertise in providing services in the educational setting to children diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome and NLD, such as school psychologist Vikki Nabozny. While Ms. Anesko has worked with many high functioning autistic children, she has only worked with a few children diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome. Ms. Anesko would require the regular and frequent consultation of a psychologist familiar with the educational implications of diagnoses of Asperger’s syndrome and nonverbal learning disability to be aware of the issues unique to Asperger’s and NLD, such as the increased anxiety and possible depression that would arise were STUDENT to be taught social understanding in his regular education classroom with his nondisabled peers.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not required under the IDEA to provide STUDENT with the services of a certified cognitive behaviorist with experience in applied behavior analysis, who is an educational psychologist with sufficient experience in diagnosing, assessing, and developing appropriate programs for students with Asperger’s syndrome. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Anesko is sufficiently trained and experienced to provide the social cognition program and the case management/coordination services called for in STUDENT’s IEP but only with regular and frequent consultation of a psychologist with some expertise in providing services in the educational setting to children diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome and NLD, such as school psychologist Vikki Nabozny. The psychologist providing the consultation and input should be made a part of the team that participates in the monthly case management meetings.(Footnote 7)

ORDER

1. The District shall provide STUDENT with the services of an inclusion specialist during the first half of the 2001-2002 school year. The inclusion specialist services shall be provided three times per month for forty-five minutes each time. The inclusion specialist shall consult with the case manager/coordinator to determine the appropriate modifications and accommodations to provide STUDENT in the general education program, as well as attend the monthly case management meetings. The District shall amend STUDENT’s IEP to reflect the inclusion specialist services described in this paragraph.

2. The District shall provide STUDENT with additional Tourette’s specialist consultant services during the 2001-2002 school year. In addition to the level of consultant services by a Tourette’s specialist already agreed to by the parent in the IEP dated November 20, 2000 (i.e., one time per quarter for up to two hours), the District shall provide STUDENT with an additional one time per quarter for up to two hours during the 2001-2002 school year. The District shall amend STUDENT’s IEP to reflect the additional Tourette’s specialist consultation services described in this paragraph.

3. The District shall include in STUDENT’s IEP a provision for the regular and frequent (at least monthly) consultation of a psychologist with some expertise in providing services in the educational setting to children diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome and NLD, such as school psychologist Vikki Nabozny. The District shall include the aforementioned psychologist as part of the team that participates in the monthly case management meetings.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Did the District fail to provide services to STUDENT as required in his individualized education programs during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years and the first half of the 2000-2001 school year? ** Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.

2. If the District failed to provide the required services, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education? ** Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.

3. Does STUDENT require the services of a certified cognitive behaviorist with experience in applied behavior analysis, who is an educational psychologist with sufficient experience in diagnosing, assessing, and developing appropriate programs for students with Asperger’s syndrome? ** Respondent substantially prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date: May 15, 2001 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: The issues listed here differ slightly in wording from those noticed by Petitioner. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and to facilitate proper analysis, as well as to reflect the discussion held with the parties on the first day of hearing. For example, during the discussion of the issues, Petitioner withdrew three of the issues that had been noticed. Footnote 2: When asked during the discussion of issues on the first day of hearing, Petitioner specified that he was putting at issue the provision of services during a portion of the 1998-1999 school year to the “present.” As the first day of hearing was January 16, 2001, this decision will only adjudicate issues regarding the provision of services up to the first day of hearing, which fell roughly at the conclusion of the first half of the 2000-2001 school year. Footnote 3: Although Petitioner’s closing brief additionally alleges that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide social skills services and to train adequately the staff working with STUDENT, these issues were not properly raised in Petitioner’s issue statement or during the course of the hearing. In fact, the only issue Petitioner presented in his issue statement that related to whether the District denied STUDENT a FAPE in previous years stated, “Did the Desert Sands Unified School District fail to provide services to STUDENT through an NPA as required in his IEP?” While it was made clear during the discussion of issues on the first day of hearing and during a specific discussion regarding issues on February 22, 2001, that Petitioner was putting at issue the services of an inclusion specialist, Tourette’s consultant, and autism/Asperger’s NPA consultant, Petitioner did not specifically put at issue at any time during the course of the hearing the issues concerning social skills and staff training. Consequently, because these issues were not properly raised as issues at hearing, they will not be adjudicated in this Decision unless they relate to the issues properly raised by Petitioner at hearing that are cited above. Footnote 4: It is noted that there was some conflicting testimony offered by Carolyn Rounsaville that Ms. Anesko was the preschool teacher only until February 5, 1999. However, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Anesko’s testimony more reliable on the issue of the period during which she taught the preschool class. Footnote 5: According to the IEP document, the only service which was to be provided on an as-needed basis was the resource specialist program. Footnote 6: According to the testimony produced at hearing, Asperger’s syndrome was recognized as a disorder in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) only within the last several years, in the early 1990's. The testimony also established that there is some disagreement in the field regarding whether Asperger’s syndrome is a form of high functioning autism or constitutes a separate diagnosis. At the present, the DSM - Fourth Edition (DSM4) describes Asperger’s syndrome as a disorder on the pervasive developmental delay (PDD) continuum (i.e., the autism spectrum). Footnote 7: On a related issue, it is noted that another major dispute at hearing between the parties was the manner in which STUDENT’s social skills program should be implemented. The testimony provided at hearing established that STUDENT should be taught social understanding in a small group setting before being taught social skills with his nondisabled peers in the general education classroom. The Hearing Officer found persuasive the testimony of Ms. Nabozny and Dr. Norall that beginning a social skills program for STUDENT by teaching social understanding in a general education classroom would be inappropriate because of the degree to which social understanding concepts must be broken down for STUDENT. According to the testimony, the nondisabled students have already learned such concepts through their typical development or by “osmosis,” as stated by Dr. Norall. Providing such instruction to the general education classroom would prove inappropriate because the nondisabled students do not require the same instruction STUDENT requires and, because of STUDENT’s level of intelligence and heightened sensitivity to anxiety and feelings of being different, would likely cause increased anxiety and possible depression for STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer was not persuaded, however, that STUDENT requires a social understanding group with only other children with Asperger’s syndrome or high functioning autism. Ms. Nabozny established that she has found through her own experience working on social skills with children diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome that a small social skills or social understanding group consisting of three to four children would be appropriate to teach STUDENT social understanding. While the group may consist of one other child diagnosed with high functioning autism or Asperger’s syndrome, the group should also include nondisabled children with whom STUDENT feels comfortable or with whom he has developed friendships. According to Ms. Nabozny, because the Asperger’s child has average intelligence and normal language development, the Asperger’s child tends to learn the social understanding concepts rather quickly. Ms. Nabozny testified that the inclusion of the nondisabled peers provides the Asperger’s child with appropriate models, as well as opportunities to practice the social skills, and promotes generalization of the skills into the general education setting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not required to provide STUDENT with a social understanding group consisting solely of children diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome or high functioning autism. While Dr. Norall’s method may also be appropriate for STUDENT, the District has the discretion to determine issues of methodology as long as it is appropriate to meet the needs of the child and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207.