California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 31, 2005

Student v. Capistrano Unified School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 2832-02 · Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour

Capistrano Unified prevails on every claim; Hearing Officer finds resource and literacy services gave learning-disabled student educational benefit.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 12-year-old seventh grader in Capistrano Unified filed for due process in December 2002. Their daughter has been eligible for special education under specific learning disability since June 2001. They argued she should have qualified starting in March 2000. They also claimed the district denied her a FAPE every school year from 2001-2002 through 2004-2005. They asked for compensatory education in an intensive program and for reimbursement of private evaluations by Dr. Kate Stuhr Mack and Lindamood-Bell.

Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour ruled for the district on every issue. Before June 2001, classroom supports in general education were closing the student's reading and math gap, so she did not meet all eligibility requirements. The written offer of the SAIL summer reading program was clear enough. No speech-language reassessment was needed in 2001-2002. Each procedural claim failed, including prior written notice and a June 2003 IEP meeting held without the parents. The district had documented its efforts to reach them and then held a full second meeting they attended. Grades, district tests, goal progress and teacher testimony showed real progress each year. The Hearing Officer gave this evidence more weight than homework struggles at home or a single Lindamood-Bell test. The district's 2000 assessments were appropriate, so no reimbursement was ordered. All relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard. Teacher testimony, report cards, and district progress testing outweighed parents' reports of homework struggles and a one-time private test with no foundation. It also shows that the "cannot be corrected in regular education" part of the old learning disability test could defeat eligibility.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Was Student eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability from March 2000 to June 2001?

    The severe discrepancy was being closed within the regular program with modifications, as shown by satisfactory grades and teacher reports, so Student did not meet the SLD criteria before June 2001.

  2. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to recommend a specific program for the 2001 extended school year at an IEP meeting in June 2001?

    The IEP and the principal's letter described the SAIL summer program in enough detail to be a formal written offer under Union v. Smith, and the parents understood it.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 3. Did the District fail to assess Student in the area of speech and language during the 2001-2002 school year?

    There was no persuasive evidence of speech-language deficits in 2001-2002 that would have triggered a reassessment.

  4. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 4a. 2001-2002 (procedural): Did the District fail to give prior written notice of its proposal to increase RSP services in January 2002?

    Notice given at the IEP meeting at the same time the District sought parental consent was sufficient.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 4b. 2001-2002 (procedural): Did the District fail to ensure the participation of Orange County Mental Health personnel at the June 13, 2002 IEP meeting?

    Mental health staff were not required team members. The therapist was invited but could not attend, and the services were continued without dispute.

  6. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4c. 2001-2002 (substantive): Did the June 2001 IEP lack proper present levels of performance in reading, and were the RSP services inappropriate to meet Student's needs in reading, written language, and math?

    Present levels included measurable data. The individual and small-group RSP instruction with multisensory and Lindamood-Bell strategies was reasonably calculated to provide benefit and did provide meaningful benefit.

  7. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 5a. 2002-2003 (procedural): Did the District fail to give prior written notice of its denial of the parents' requests for a Lindamood-Bell clinic program and a functional analysis assessment in November 2002?

    The IEP documents and the January 10, 2003 letter gave sufficient and timely notice of both refusals.

  8. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 5b. 2002-2003 (procedural): Did the District fail to convene an IEP meeting when it allegedly noted regression in January 2003?

    The January 2003 letter only summarized the prior meeting and stated that Student was progressing, so no lack of anticipated progress triggered a meeting.

  9. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 5c. 2002-2003 (procedural): Did the District improperly convene the June 3, 2003 IEP meeting without the parents and fail to permit their participation at the June 17, 2003 meeting?

    The District documented its efforts to secure attendance and then held a full second meeting that the parents attended and actively participated in, so participation was not seriously infringed.

  10. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 5d. 2002-2003 (procedural): Did the District fail to give prior written notice of its proposal to discontinue mental health counseling services in June 2003?

    The District proposed the change in the IEP documents and sought consent at the same time, which satisfied the notice requirement.

  11. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5e. 2002-2003 (substantive): Did the June 2002 IEP lack proper present levels of performance, and were the RSP services insufficiently intensive for reading, written language, and math?

    Present levels were adequate, and 90 minutes of daily RSP produced progress shown by grades, CORE scores, goal attainment, and teacher testimony.

  12. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 6a. 2003-2004 (procedural): Did the District fail to convene an IEP meeting in April 2004 after identifying Student as at risk of not passing the California High School Exit Exam and/or being retained?

    The letter was a standard form letter, not evidence of a lack of anticipated progress, and Student was progressing on her goals.

  13. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 6b. 2003-2004 (procedural): Did the District fail to give prior written notice of its refusal to provide Lindamood-Bell clinic services at the June 2004 IEP meeting?

    The IEP documented the refusal and the reasons, and the parents received a copy, which was timely notice.

  14. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 6c. 2003-2004 (substantive): Did the June 2003 IEP lack proper present levels of performance and measurable written language goals, and were the RSP services insufficient?

    Present levels and written language goals were measurable, and the sixth-grade RSP English and math classes produced significant progress.

  15. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 7a. 2004-2005 (procedural): Did the District fail to discuss instructional strategies with the parents at IEP meetings?

    At the June 2004 meeting, the literacy specialist described the Lindamood-Bell strategies she would use. Methodology is left to the District.

  16. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 7b. 2004-2005 (procedural): Did the District fail to timely convene an IEP meeting to consider the House Ear Institute auditory processing assessment?

    The meeting came more than 50 days after the October 16, 2004 report, but there was no prejudice because the assessor recommended no direct services. The Hearing Officer found no procedural violation.

  17. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 7c. 2004-2005 (procedural): Did the District fail to give prior written notice in January 2005 of its intent to provide direct speech and language services?

    The proposal was made when consent was requested, which was sufficient notice.

  18. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 7d. 2004-2005 (substantive): Did the June 2004 IEP lack proper present levels of performance in writing, word meanings, math, behavior/attention, reading, and spelling?

    Present levels, read together with the attached assessments by Dr. Owen and Ms. Dews, gave enough information to write appropriate goals.

  19. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 7e. 2004-2005 (substantive): Did the District fail to offer direct speech and language services and speech-language goals after the May 2004 assessment?

    The assessor recommended only consultation, which the District offered, and no evidence showed a need for direct services or goals.

  20. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 7f. 2004-2005 (substantive): Were the RSP, intensive literacy intervention, and related services appropriate to address Student's deficits in reading, written language, and math?

    Teacher reports, grades, and informal reading inventories showed satisfactory progress. A one-time Lindamood-Bell test without foundation for its validity was given less weight.

  21. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 8. If the District failed to provide Student with a FAPE during any time period from March 2000 through the present, is she entitled to compensatory education in an intensive educational therapy program?

    Because FAPE was not denied in any year, no compensatory education was awarded.

  22. Issue 9. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations by Kate Stuhr Mack, Ph.D., and Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes?

    The District's 2000 psychoeducational assessments, including the nonverbal CTONI, were appropriate. The Lindamood-Bell testing was not based on disagreement with any District assessment.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's claims for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Burlington; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified Sch. Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Christopher Russell, advocate for Student (non-attorney); witness
  • G. Robert Roice, educational consultant representing District, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Kim Gaither, District legal specialist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Barbara Smith, District mediation and compliance officer, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Jill Dews, private speech-language pathologist who assessed Student for the District
  • Ann Madrid, District intensive literacy intervention specialist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • James Blinn, District program specialist and speech-language pathologist (literacy program), Capistrano Unified School District
  • Val Parkin, District learning support specialist; assistant principal at Ambuehl Elementary, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Jeffrey Owen, Ph.D., clinical psychologist who did the psychoeducational assessment for the District
  • Kimberly Zakaryan, associate clinic director, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
  • Dagmar Shumate, District literacy intervention specialist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Lianne Pfister, District speech-language therapist; assessor, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Pamela Poteet, school psychologist (retired) who assessed Student, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Chrisamy Anderson, fourth-grade teacher, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Carolyn Noyes, elementary resource specialist (RSP) teacher, Ambuehl Elementary School
  • Kathleen (Kate) Stuhr Mack, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; independent evaluator for parents
  • Laura Smith, fifth-grade teacher, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Cheri Detola, sixth-grade RSP English teacher, Marco Forster Middle School
  • Eileen Mulcahy, sixth-grade RSP math teacher, Marco Forster Middle School
  • Debra Romero, seventh-grade RSP English teacher, Marco Forster Middle School
  • Eric O'Toner, seventh- and eighth-grade RSP math teacher, Marco Forster Middle School
  • Lynne Shelley, second-grade teacher, Ambuehl Elementary School
  • Marilee Carroll, third-grade teacher, Ambuehl Elementary School
  • Maria Abramson, audiologist who assessed Student
  • Mike Hardos, District RSP teacher; academic assessor, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Nancy Frank, principal, Ambuehl Elementary School
  • Carrie Bertini, principal, Marco Forster Middle School
  • Carlen Jurey, auditory processing assessor, House Ear Institute Care Center
  • Western Youth Services, mental health assessment and counseling provider (vendor of Orange County Mental Health), Orange County Mental Health
  • Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes, private reading clinic; conducted January 2005 assessment

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Juan Capistrano, California, on February 3, 4, 8, 9, 10, 11, and 15, 2005.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Tania L. Whiteleather and advocate Christopher Russell. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were her parents, FATHER and MOTHER. (Footnote 1) Respondent Capistrano Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by educational consultant G. Robert Roice. Also present on the District’s behalf was Kim Gaither, District legal specialist. (Footnote 2) No one appeared on behalf of Respondent South Orange County Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA).

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: FATHER, her father; Christopher Russell, her advocate; Jill Dews, speech and language therapist; Ann Madrid, District intensive literacy intervention specialist; James Blinn, District program specialist; Val Parkin, District learning support specialist; Jeffrey Owen, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; Kimberly Zakaryan, associate clinic director of Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes; Dagmar Shumate, District literacy intervention specialist; Lianne Pfister, District speech and language therapist; Pamela Poteet, retired District school psychologist; Chrisamy Anderson, District fourth-grade teacher; Carolyn Noyes, District elementary school resource specialist; MOTHER, her mother; and Kathleen Stuhr Mack, Ph.D., clinical psychologist.

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Laura Smith, District fifth-grade teacher; Cheri Detola, District sixth-grade resource specialist; Eileen Mulcahy, District sixth-grade resource specialist; Debra Romero, District seventh-grade resource specialist; and Eric O’Toner, District seventh- and eighth-grade resource specialist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the briefs, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 3)

1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability from March 2000 to June 2001?

2. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to recommend a specific program for the 2001 extended school year at an IEP meeting in June 2001?

3. Did the District fail to assess STUDENT in the area of speech and language during the 2001- 2002 school year?

4. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?

5. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?

6. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?

7. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?

8. If the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any time period from March 2000 through the present, is she entitled to compensatory education in an intensive educational therapy program?

9. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations by Kate Stuhr Mack, Ph.D., and Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a twelve-year-old girl who resides with her parents and older sister within the boundaries of the District. She has been eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) since June 2001, when she was in third grade. She currently attends a regular education seventh-grade classroom at the District’s Marco Forster Middle School (Marco Forster) and receives related services of resource specialist program (RSP) support in English and math, intensive literacy intervention, and speech and language services.

On January 25, 2000, when STUDENT was in the second grade at the District’s Ambuehl Elementary School (Ambuehl), FATHER wrote a letter to the principal to request that STUDENT be assessed for special education. As a result, on February 17, 2000, the District convened a student study team meeting. STUDENT’S father, teachers, and assistant principal attended the meeting and discussed the concerns raised by her father that STUDENT was easily distracted, had difficulty staying focused, and exhibited below-grade-level academic skills.

In March 2000, pursuant to an assessment plan signed by STUDENT’s parents, District school psychologist Pamela Poteet conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Poteet concluded that STUDENT had low average to average overall intellectual development. According to Ms. Poteet, STUDENT functioned academically from late first-grade level through beginning third-grade level in reading, written language, and math. Ms. Poteet also found that STUDENT exhibited difficulties with attention.

At the same time, Carolyn Noyes, District RSP teacher, conducted a phonological awareness assessment of STUDENT and found her to function in the average range phonologically. A speech and language assessment by Lianne Pfister found STUDENT to have normal skills in expressive and receptive language, no auditory processing difficulties related to language, and difficulties with distractibility and attention.

On May 2, 2000, following these assessments, the District convened an initial individualized education program (IEP) meeting for STUDENT. At the meeting, Lynne Shelley, STUDENT’s second-grade teacher, discussed her concerns regarding STUDENT’s lack of attention in completing school tasks. In addition, Ms. Poteet, Ms. Pfister, and Ms. Noyes all completed a multidisciplinary team assessment report in which they indicated that STUDENT had difficulty with attention. They also noted that, despite her deficit, STUDENT achieved at or above age expectation in all academic areas. STUDENT’s parents, however, disagreed with these assessments and requested that the District conduct additional assessments in the areas of central auditory processing and nonverbal intelligence. The District agreed to do so.

In May 2000, audiologist Maria Abramson assessed STUDENT in the area of hearing and auditory processing. However, because of STUDENT’s lack of attention during the assessment, Ms. Abramson concluded that she could not adequately assess her. In addition, in June 2000, Ms. Poteet conducted an assessment of STUDENT’s nonverbal cognitive abilities. On the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (CTONI), STUDENT achieved a nonverbal intelligence score that was twenty-nine points higher than her full scale intelligence score in her earlier testing on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III).

On June 8, 2000, the IEP team reconvened to review the recent assessments. At this meeting, Ms. Poteet, Ms. Abramson, Ms. Pfister, and Ms. Noyes completed another multidisciplinary team assessment report, indicating that STUDENT was not consistently cooperative, needed to be prompted to sit appropriately, and had an inability to attend. However, they also indicated that STUDENT’s achievement level was within the average range of regular education. The team thus agreed to reconvene at the beginning of the following school year to review STUDENT’s progress in her regular education classroom after the new school year began.

On September 26, 2000, at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, the IEP team met to discuss STUDENT’s initial progress in third grade at Ambuehl. Although Marilee Carroll, STUDENT’s third-grade teacher, reported that STUDENT was making progress in school, her parents advised the team that they intended to obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) of STUDENT. The team thus agreed to meet again following the completion of the IEE.

In October and November 2000, Dr. Kate Stuhr Mack, a clinical psychologist, assessed STUDENT at the request of her parents. Dr. Mack concluded that STUDENT had average abilities in intellectual functioning and verbal and nonverbal reasoning abilities. In academic areas, STUDENT performed in the average range in reading, math, language, and spelling. Dr. Mack also concluded that STUDENT met all of the criteria for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). In addition, STUDENT scored in the very high range on an anxiety disorder index.

On June 5, 2001, the IEP team met again to discuss Dr. Mack’s report and STUDENT’s academic progress during the third grade. (Footnote 4) At this meeting, Ms. Carroll reported that STUDENT needed extra help in reading and that she had not made the amount of progress expected of a third-grade student. According to Ms. Carroll, STUDENT also experienced low self-esteem because of her academic difficulties.

On June 8, 2001, the IEP team met once more and agreed that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services on the basis of a specific learning disability (SLD) due to a severe discrepancy between her intelligence and achievement levels on the basis of her CTONI nonverbal intelligence score from June 2000 and her academic achievement scores in reading and math on District standardized tests. The team then agreed to place STUDENT in a fourth-grade regular education classroom at Ambuehl for the 2001-2002 school year with RSP services of fifty minutes per day and goals and objectives in reading and written language and an ESY program for reading assistance. The team also agreed to refer STUDENT to Orange County Mental Health (OCMH) to assess any social/emotional issues.

In August 2001, Western Youth Services (WYS), a vendor of OCMH, completed the OCMH assessment of STUDENT and concluded that STUDENT had difficulties with anxiety, low self-esteem, distractibility, and attention. WYS recommended mental health counseling sessions for STUDENT as well as treatment goals and objectives to reduce her anxiety and distractibility and increase her self-esteem. On October 23, 2001, the IEP team met to discuss the WYS assessment and agreed to add bi-monthly counseling, monthly mental health consultation, and mental health goals and objectives to STUDENT’s IEP.

On January 24, 2002, the IEP team met again to discuss concerns raised by STUDENT’s parents related to STUDENT’s difficulty with her homework and academic skills. At this meeting, the IEP team agreed to increase STUDENT’s RSP time from fifty to ninety minutes per day and to add goals and objectives in the area of math to her IEP. The District also agreed to conduct an additional assessment in the area of math. On March 5, 2002, the team met to review the math assessment and add an additional math goal and objective to STUDENT’s IEP.

On June 13, 2002, the District convened an annual IEP meeting to discuss a placement and program for STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year. The team agreed to place STUDENT in a fifth-grade regular education program at Ambuehl with related services of RSP support of ninety minutes per day and bi-monthly OCMH counseling. The team also agreed to place STUDENT in a reading program for ESY. The District also proposed goals and objectives in the areas of reading, math, and written language. Because the parents expressed disagreement with the goals and objectives, the IEP team met on June 21, 2002, to further discuss the proposed goals and objectives. At this meeting, although the parents continued to disagree with the goals and objectives, they consented to the IEP.

On November 5, 2002, District RSP teacher Mike Hardos conducted an updated assessment of STUDENT’s academic achievement. Mr. Hardos concluded that STUDENT scored in the low-average range in reading, the average range in math, and the low range in written language. On November 8, 2002, the IEP team met to discuss this assessment and to review STUDENT’s progress in school at that time. At this meeting, the parties agreed to continue the same placement and program for STUDENT. On December 19, 2002, because the parents were concerned with STUDENT’s test scores on Mr. Hardos’ assessment and because they disagreed with District reports that STUDENT was making progress in school, they filed a request for due process hearing with the Hearing Office.

On June 3, 2003, the District convened an annual IEP meeting to discuss STUDENT’s placement and program for the 2003-2004 school year, when STUDENT would begin sixth grade at Marco Forster. The District convened the meeting without the parents in attendance because of its concern that it was required to convene STUDENT’s annual IEP by June 3, 2003. At the meeting, the District and OCMH proposed to discontinue mental health services because STUDENT had allegedly met all of her social/emotional goals and objectives during the prior school year. The District members of the team also proposed an ESY reading program and placement for the 2003-2004 school year in a regular education sixth-grade classroom with ninety minutes per day of RSP services in English and math. The District further proposed goals and objectives in the areas of written language, reading, math, maintaining attention/focus, and improving organizational skills.

On June 17, 2003, the IEP team, including STUDENT’s parents, met to further review the proposed program and placement for the 2003-2004 school year. The District proposed the same placement and program as it had at the IEP meeting on June 3, 2003. STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the proposal to discontinue mental health services, the proposed goals and objectives, and an ESY reading program proposed at that meeting. However, despite their disagreement, they consented to the IEP and to discontinuing mental health services. Because of their disagreement regarding the ESY program, STUDENT did not attend that program. In May 2004, Jill Dews, a private speech and language pathologist, assessed STUDENT on behalf of the District in preparation for her triennial IEP meeting in June 2004. Ms. Dews found STUDENT to have mild receptive language delays, moderate expressive language delays, significant language memory delays, and a mild auditory processing delay. She recommended consultation services between the District’s speech and language pathologist and STUDENT’s teachers, small-group academic instruction, and an audiological evaluation to assess STUDENT in central auditory processing.

In May 2004, Dr. Jeffrey Owen, a clinical psychologist, conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT on behalf of the District in preparation for her triennial IEP meeting. On this assessment, STUDENT scored in the low-average range in cognitive functioning but exhibited attention problems. In academic areas, STUDENT scored at the fourth/fifth-grade level in math, the second/third-grade level in reading, the third-grade level in spelling, and the second-grade level in listening comprehension.

On June 3, 2004, the IEP team met for STUDENT’s triennial IEP and to discuss her program and placement for the 2004-2005 school year. In light of the recent assessments, the District proposed a seventh-grade regular education classroom, two periods per day of RSP services in English and math, one period per day of small-group intensive literacy intervention, and monthly speech and language consultation. The District also proposed goals and objectives in the areas of written language, math, behavior/attention, reading, spelling, and word meanings. Although the parents disagreed with the proposed services and goals and objectives, they consented to the IEP and agreed to an assessment of STUDENT in the area of central auditory processing.

Thereafter, in October 2004, Carlen Jurey of the House Ear Institute Care Center (House Ear Institute) conducted an auditory processing assessment of STUDENT on behalf of the District. Ms. Jurey concluded that STUDENT may have an auditory processing disorder in the areas of decoding and tolerance fading memory. On January 13, 2005, following this assessment, the IEP team met and agreed to add direct speech and language services and goals and objectives in the areas of speech and language and auditory processing to STUDENT’s IEP. Although the parents continued to disagree with the services and goals and objectives in the IEP, they agreed to the District’s offer to provide STUDENT with one hour per week of direct speech and language services on an interim basis pending the resolution of the due process hearing.

The parties proceeded to hearing on February 3, 2005.

CONTENTIONS

Petitioner contends that the District improperly failed to find her eligible for special education and related services during the 1999-2000 school year when her parents first requested by letter dated January 25, 2000, that she be assessed. She further contends that after the District ultimately found her eligible for special education and related services in June 2001, it failed to offer her appropriate services during every school year thereafter, including the ESYs, until the present time. In essence, Petitioner contends that the District committed both procedural and substantive violations of special education law and thus denied her a FAPE during every school year. As a result, Petitioner contends that she is entitled to compensatory education in an intensive educational therapy program and that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations.

The District contends that STUDENT was not eligible for special education and related services prior to June 2001, that it provided STUDENT with a FAPE for all time periods in question, that it committed no procedural violations, and that STUDENT and her parents are not entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Was STUDENT eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability from March 2000 to June 2001?

Under California special education law, an individual with exceptional needs is one who meets the definition of a child with a disability, as set forth in the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i), and, as a result of the impairment, requires instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a) and (b). The disabilities identified in the IDEA are mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech or language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, and specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i); see Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(a)-(j).

A specific learning disability (SLD) is defined as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26)(A); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j). Basic psychological processes include “attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expression.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(1).

For a child to qualify for special education as SLD, he or she must meet all three of the specified requirements. First, there must be a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in the areas of oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, or mathematics reasoning. 34 C.F.R. § 300.541(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(a). Second, the severe discrepancy must be due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using spoken or written language, and must not be primarily the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.541(b)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(b). A final requirement is that the discrepancy cannot be ameliorated through “other regular or categorical services” offered within the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(c); see 34 C.F.R. § 300.543(a)(6).

A review of the evidence reveals that in June 2001, STUDENT’s IEP team found her eligible for special education and related services under the category of SLD on the basis of a severe discrepancy between her intelligence score of 113 on the CTONI obtained in June 2000, and her academic achievement scores on the District’s Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) scores from March 2000. However, Petitioner contends that the District should have determined that she was eligible as a student with an SLD beginning in March 2000, when the District first assessed her eligibility for special education and related services.

The parties do not dispute that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy between her intelligence score of 113 on the CTONI administered in June 2000 and her academic achievement scores of 94 in reading comprehension on the WIAT, 90 in broad math on the Woodcock-Johnson-Revised (Woodcock-Johnson), and 85 in math reasoning on the Woodcock-Johnson in March 2000. (Footnote 5) They also do not dispute that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy was due to a disorder in the basic psychological processes involved in understanding written language, and that her severe discrepancy was not primarily the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26)(A); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j).

Instead, the parties dispute whether or not STUDENT’s discrepancy was ameliorated through “other regular or categorical services” offered within the regular instructional program. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(c). Petitioner contends that the District’s regular education program with classroom modifications during second and third grades did not ameliorate her severe discrepancy in the areas of reading and math. The District contends that STUDENT performed in the average range academically in these areas and thus did not require special education services during this time. The Hearing Officer will thus address the sole issue in dispute of whether the District’s regular education program for STUDENT during the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years ameliorated her severe discrepancies in reading and math.

A review of STUDENT’s second-grade report card and IEP reveals that STUDENT was in Lynne Shelley’s second-grade regular education classroom with modifications during the 1999-2000 school year. These modifications included after-school tutoring, modified spelling and seat work, specialized reading intervention with a District reading specialist, seating near the teacher, and peer tutor assistance. With regard to STUDENT’s academic achievements during this school year, Ms. Shelley, school psychologist Ms. Poteet, and RSP teacher Ms. Noyes completed a multidisciplinary team assessment report at the IEP meeting on May 2, 2000, stating that STUDENT achieved at or above age expectations in all academic areas. At the June 8, 2000 IEP meeting, Ms. Poteet, Ms. Noyes, audiologist Maria Abramson, and speech and language pathologist Lianne Pfister completed a similar report, noting that STUDENT’s achievement was “within range of regular education.” In addition, on STUDENT’s second-grade report card, she received grades of satisfactory in reading, writing, speaking/listening, and math achievement during the latter two-thirds of the school year. Ms. Shelley’s comments on the report card indicated that STUDENT struggled with reading during the first trimester but had improved in reading during the second trimester. Ms. Shelley noted that by the end of the school year, STUDENT had made slow and steady progress in reading and had become very motivated in math.

A further review of the evidence indicates that STUDENT was in Marilee Carroll’s regular education third-grade classroom with modifications during the 2000-2001 school year. These modifications included one-to-one assistance from the teacher, specialized reading intervention with a District reading specialist, and small-group work. On STUDENT’s first trimester report card, Ms. Carroll commented that STUDENT read simple books but needed extra work in math. During the second trimester, Ms. Carroll noted that STUDENT was slowly acquiring the skills to become an independent reader but needed help with increasingly difficult multiplication tables in math. However, despite her difficulties, STUDENT received grades of C’s in reading, writing, spelling, and math achievement throughout each of the trimesters of the third grade.

In contrast to STUDENT’s teachers, her parents do not believe that STUDENT was achieving within the average range academically during the second and third grades. FATHER testified that he read with STUDENT at home during second grade and that she was “not quite getting it.” He also testified that he did not believe that STUDENT was doing well in school because she had “meltdowns” at home and arguments with her mother when she did her homework. MOTHER also testified that she helped STUDENT with her homework during second and third grades, and STUDENT did not understand the work and became frustrated.

Although STUDENT had some difficulties with reading and math during the second and third grades, she was able to achieve academically in a regular education classroom within the average range with classroom modifications and extra assistance from teachers and peer tutors. According to her report cards, STUDENT received average and satisfactory grades in all academic areas during both school years. Her second- and third-grade teachers both noted improvement in reading skills during those years, and she did not begin to have difficulty with math until the end of third grade. However, despite her math difficulties, she received grades of C in math throughout third grade. Although STUDENT’s parents testified credibly that STUDENT had difficulties with her homework during second and third grades, the evidence indicates that she made satisfactory progress in school and achieved satisfactory grades in reading and math despite these difficulties.

Therefore, on the basis of the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy was ameliorated through “other regular or categorical services” offered within the regular instructional program between March 2000 and June 2001, and that STUDENT therefore did not meet one of the three factors required for eligibility as a student with an SLD. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that STUDENT was not eligible for special education and related services under the category of SLD from March 2000 to June 2001. (Footnote 6)

ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to recommend a specific program for the 2001 extended school year at an IEP meeting in June 2001?

Under both the federal IDEA and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a student free of charge, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(2).

A claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both procedural and substantive questions. Among the IDEA’s procedural mandates is the requirement that the process for the development of the IEP allow the parents to meaningfully participate in it. Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207 (1982). Not every procedural flaw is critical, but one that results in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringes on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

A procedural violation that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). As the Ninth Circuit stated in Union, “this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe that it should be enforced rigorously.”

The Court further explained that, under the facts of Union, a formal, written offer would have alerted the parents “to the need to consider seriously” whether the particular placement was appropriate under the IDEA, would have allowed the parents to decide whether to oppose the placement or to “accept it with the supplement of additional education services,” and would have helped the district to better prepare to introduce sufficient relevant evidence regarding the appropriateness of the placement at hearing. Id. at 1526.

Petitioner contends that the District did not comply with the requirements of Union by failing to offer her a specific ESY program at the IEP meeting on June 8, 2001, for the 2001 ESY.

California Education Code section 56345(b)(3) provides that an IEP shall include ESY services “when needed, as determined by the individualized education program team.” ESY programming is defined as special education and related services provided to a child with a disability beyond the normal school year of the public agency in accordance with the child’s IEP at no cost to the parents. 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b); Cal. Code of Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. Furthermore, California Code of Regulations, Title 5, section 3043 provides that a student is eligible for ESY services if interruption of the educational programming could cause regression that, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, would render it impossible or unlikely that the student would attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of the child’s handicapping condition.

The evidence reveals that on May 24, 2001, Nancy Frank, principal of Ambuehl, sent STUDENT’s parents a letter describing the Summer Academy for Intensive Learning (SAIL) program at Ambuehl for the summer of 2001. The letter stated that the program would begin on June 27, 2001, would last four-and-one-half-hours per day, and would provide STUDENT with “the opportunity to receive intensive remedial reading instruction balanced with work in basic mathematics.” Attached to the letter was a detailed description of the SAIL instructional day, which included specific times for opening reading activities, reading aloud time, fluency activities, small-group instruction, expository reading and writing, and math activities.

Thereafter, on June 8, 2001, the IEP team met to discuss, among other things, a proposed placement for STUDENT for the 2001 ESY. The IEP document states that the District offered STUDENT placement in the SAIL program for the 2001 ESY. The document further states, “Parents were informed that the school team recommends the SAIL 2001 summer school program, an intensive reading program balanced with math instruction. School will provide Virginia Russell with specific information about this program.”

FATHER testified that STUDENT had attended the SAIL program during the 2000 ESY and that he understood that the program was a specialized reading program for children who needed extra help with reading. He also testified that he understood the offer for ESY 2001 to be the same program that STUDENT had attended in ESY 2000.

The IEP document, the letter from Ms. Frank, and the testimony of FATHER demonstrate that STUDENT’s parents understood that for the 2001 ESY, the District was offering STUDENT placement in its SAIL program, an intensive reading and math program. Petitioner’s argument that the District’s offer was improper because it lacked specific details regarding the program is not supported by the evidence. Although the District agreed to provide Ms. Russell with specific information about the program after the meeting, the evidence reveals that the District had already provided the parents with specific information regarding the location of the program, the time of the program, the type of program, and the specific activities to be included during the school day.

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District met the Union court’s requirement that a formal written offer of placement be communicated to the parents. The District formally offered STUDENT a placement in the SAIL program and put its proposed placement in writing, as required by Union. As is evident from the testimony of STUDENT’s father, the parents fully understood what the District was offering STUDENT for the 2001 ESY. At the time of the proposal, the offer fully described the placement so that STUDENT’s parents could seriously consider whether the proposed placement was appropriate under the IDEA, and whether to oppose the placement or to “accept it with the supplement of additional education services.” In addition, the offer was sufficiently detailed to allow the District to introduce sufficient relevant evidence regarding the appropriateness of the placement at hearing. Union, 15 F.3d at 1526. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not commit a procedural violation and thus did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to make a specific program offer for the 2001 ESY.

ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District fail to assess STUDENT in the area of speech and language during the 2001-2002 school year?

Federal and State special education law provide that, before any action can be taken with regard to the placement of a child in special education, an assessment of the student’s educational needs shall be conducted. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. Furthermore, a district has an obligation to reassess a child at least every three years, or more frequently if conditions warrant reassessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). Petitioner contends that the District should have assessed her in the area of speech and language during the 2001-2002 school year because she began to exhibit deficits in this area during that school year. Districts are required to assess students in all areas related to the child’s suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).

A review of the evidence reveals that the District initially assessed STUDENT in the area of speech and language in March 2000 to determine whether she qualified for special education and related services on the basis of speech and language deficits at that time. Petitioner does not dispute the appropriateness of this assessment in which the speech and language pathologist found her to score within the normal range in speech and language abilities.

Several witnesses testified regarding possible indicators that a child may have speech and language difficulties. Ms. Pfister, who assessed STUDENT in speech and language for the District in March 2000, testified that indicators that a child should be reassessed in speech and language include difficulty following directions, difficulty answering questions, difficulty focusing, and low scores in language areas on standardized tests. James Blinn, District program specialist and speech and language pathologist, testified that indicators of speech and language difficulties may include an inability to communicate ideas coherently, to express oneself verbally, to follow directions, to use appropriate syntax and semantics, and to articulate appropriately. Jill Dews, the private speech and language pathologist who later assessed STUDENT on behalf of the District in May 2004, testified that indicators of speech and language deficits may include difficulty following directions, understanding verbal instructions, and difficulties with reading and writing.

The evidence reveals that neither party conducted an assessment of STUDENT’s speech and language abilities during the 2001-2002 school year. The only assessment of STUDENT’s speech and language abilities during the prior school year was Dr. Mack’s psychoeducational assessment in October and November 2000, on behalf of STUDENT’s parents, that included a speech and language component. On this measure of speech and language abilities, STUDENT scored in the average range. Dr. Mack noted in her report that STUDENT’s language abilities, although a weakness when compared with her memory score, were “in the average range and above those of approximately 32% of [her] peers.”

With regard to her classroom performance during the 2001-2002 school year, Chrisamy Anderson, STUDENT’s fourth-grade teacher, completed an annual review document in June 2002 in which she noted that STUDENT needed information in “small chunks with repetition” but was able to follow group instructions. Ms. Anderson also testified that STUDENT was able to follow directions in class because of seating at the front of the classroom. The evidence also reveals that on STUDENT’s report card throughout fourth grade, she received average or above-average grades in reading, writing, and math achievement.

Although Petitioner contends that she exhibited many of the indicators of a need for a speech and language assessment during the 2001-2002 school year, there was no persuasive evidence that she exhibited these factors or that she had a speech and language deficit. The document completed by Ms. Anderson does not indicate that STUDENT had speech and language deficits. It merely indicates that she needed some classroom modifications that enabled her to follow group instructions. None of the people most familiar with STUDENT during fourth grade, including her regular education teacher, her RSP teacher, or her parents, testified that STUDENT exhibited any speech and language deficits during that time.

On the basis of the weight of evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not improperly fail to assess STUDENT in the area of speech and language during the 2001-2002 school year.

ISSUE NO. 4: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?

As discussed above, children with disabilities are entitled to a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. As further discussed above, a claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both procedural and substantive questions. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 206-207. However, only those procedural flaws that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of FAPE. Target Range, supra, 960 F.2d at 1483-1484.

Substantively, the determination of a FAPE is based upon the appropriateness of the educational program offered or provided by the local education agency (LEA) to the student with a disability. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Rowley, the United States Supreme Court stated that the LEA is not required to provide a student with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. Rather, the Court held that an LEA is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to meet the student’s needs, reasonably calculated to provide him or her with some educational benefit, and that comport with the student’s IEP. Id. at 201. While this requires an LEA to provide a child with a disability with meaningful access to education, it does not require the LEA to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1997).

When taken together, the IDEA and the Supreme Court’s Rowley decision thus require that an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet the unique needs of the student, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, and (3) conform to the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 188. (Footnote 7)

Petitioner alleges that the District committed both procedural and substantive violations that denied her a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year. Procedurally, she contends that the District (1) failed to provide her parents with prior written notice of its proposal to increase her RSP services in January 2002, and (2) failed to ensure the participation of OCMH personnel at an IEP meeting in June 2002. (Footnote 8) Substantively, she contends that the District (1) failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives, and (2) failed to offer her appropriate services.

Procedural FAPE

1. Prior Written Notice of an Increase in RSP Hours

A district is required to provide parents of a child with a disability with prior written notice whenever it proposes or refuses to initiate or change the educational placement of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). However, when the action proposed by the school district requires parental consent for implementation, the school district may provide the written notice at the same time that it requests parental consent. 34 C.F.R. § 300.503(a)(2). Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide her parents with timely written notice of its proposal to increase her RSP services from fifty to ninety minutes daily in January 2002. (Footnote 9)

A review of the evidence reveals that on January 24, 2002, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss the concerns of STUDENT’s parents that she was not making progress in school and was having difficulty with homework. Both of STUDENT’s parents and her advocate attended this meeting. At the meeting, the District proposed an increase in STUDENT’s RSP hours from fifty minutes to ninety minutes daily for additional time to address her deficits in math. Both parents signed the IEP, and STUDENT’s mother initialed the portion of the IEP that stated, “I consent to the above changes in the IEP.”

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District timely provided written notice to STUDENT’s parents at the time that it requested their consent to the proposed increase in RSP hours at the IEP meeting in January 2002. The District convened an IEP meeting in January 2002, informed the parents at the meeting of its proposal to increase STUDENT’s RSP hours, and requested the parents’ consent to this proposal. The Hearing Officer thus concludes the District acted appropriately in providing written notice to STUDENT’s parents in January 2002 and did not commit any procedural violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE on this basis.

2. Ensuring the Participation of OCMH Personnel at an IEP Meeting in June 2002

An IEP team must include the following individuals: one or both parents, at least one regular education teacher, at least one special education teacher, a district representative, an individual who conducted an assessment of the child or is knowledgeable about assessment procedures, and the student, if appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b). In addition, at the discretion of the parents or the district, an IEP team may include other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the student, including related service personnel, as appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b). Petitioner contends that the District committed a procedural violation by failing to ensure the attendance of an individual from OCMH at the IEP meeting on June 13, 2002.

A review of the evidence reveals that on October 23, 2001, following an assessment by OCMH, the IEP team agreed to add mental health counseling services to STUDENT’s IEP. The District then convened an annual IEP meeting on June 13, 2002, to discuss STUDENT’s placement and program for the upcoming school year. STUDENT’s parents and advocate, the Ambuehl assistant principal, STUDENT’s RSP teacher, STUDENT’s literacy specialist, STUDENT’s regular education teacher, and a District special education coordinator attended the meeting. However, although a mental health therapist had attended the meeting in October 2001 and was invited to the June meeting, she was unable to attend the meeting. At the meeting, the IEP team, including the parents, agreed to continue STUDENT’s mental health services. The parents do not contend that the mental health services were inappropriate and had no dispute with the provision of these services at the time of this meeting or at any time thereafter while STUDENT received these services.

Although Petitioner contends that the District had an obligation to ensure that an individual from OCMH attend the IEP meeting in June 2002, she cites no legal authority for her contention. In fact, as discussed above, a district may invite related services personnel to a meeting, if appropriate. In this case, the District actually invited the OCMH therapist to the meeting, but she was unable to attend. Although the District could have rescheduled the meeting to ensure the attendance of the therapist, it had no obligation to do so. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b). An expanded IEP team, including a representative of the community mental health service is required only when a child is placed in a residential facility because of an emotional disturbance. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2 §§ 60020(c), 60100(b)(1). Moreover, there was no dispute regarding mental health services at the meeting as the entire team, including the parents, agreed to continue services exactly as they had been provided since October 2001. Furthermore, STUDENT’s parents do not contend that she required any change in the provision of these services. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District committed no procedural violation by failing to ensure the attendance of OCMH personnel at the IEP meeting on June 13, 2002.

In sum, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not commit any procedural violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.

Substantive FAPE

As discussed above, in addition to procedural protections under special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a substantive FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. As further discussed above, the determination of a FAPE is based upon the appropriateness of the educational program offered or provided by the LEA to the student. Gregory K., supra, 811 F.2d at 1314.

A review of the evidence reveals that the District proposed placement of STUDENT in a regular education classroom with related services of RSP support for fifty minutes per day for the 2001-2002 school year. RSP support increased to ninety minutes per day in January 2002. Petitioner does not dispute the placement in a regular education classroom. However, she contends that the proposed RSP services did not offer her a FAPE because she required more intensive services to address her needs in reading, written language, and math. She also contends that the District failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives for her in the area of reading.

What Were STUDENT’s Unique Needs in June 2001?

To determine whether the program that the District offered STUDENT in June 2001 offered her a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, it is first necessary to identify her unique needs at that time. The parties generally do not dispute that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of reading, written language, and math in June 2001. The parties also do not dispute that the needs described above required specialized individual and small-group instruction to address her deficits. Their dispute centers on the intensity of instruction required to address her needs.

The evidence reveals that on the Capistrano Objectives for Reaching Excellence (CORE) testing in the spring of 2001, STUDENT scored at the 17th percentile in reading, the 8th percentile in written language, and the 19th percentile in math. (Footnote 10) In addition, her third-grade report card in June 2001 notes that she was below grade level in reading, math, and written language achievement. Moreover, at the IEP meeting on June 5, 2001, Ms. Carroll, STUDENT’s third-grade teacher, reported that STUDENT had required interventions during third grade that included one-to-one assistance from the teacher, specialized reading instruction, reading intervention with a reading specialist, and small-group work in the areas of reading and written expression.

Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that in June 2001, STUDENT had deficits in the areas of reading, written language, and math. The Hearing Officer further concludes that STUDENT’s unique needs in these areas required specialized individual and small-group instruction in reading, written language, and math to address her deficits.

Was the Proposed Placement Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

The Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas identified above for the 2001-2002 school year. Petitioner has two areas of dispute with the proposed program. She contends that (1) her IEP in June 2001 did not contain proper present levels of performance, and (2) the proposed RSP services were not appropriate to meet her unique needs in the areas of reading, written language, and math.

1. Present Levels of Performance

An IEP must include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, to meet a student’s needs that result from the student’s disability to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and to meet the student’s other educational needs that result from the student’s disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2). An IEP must also include present levels of performance to inform the IEP team members of the student’s current level of functioning so that the team can develop appropriate goals and objectives that track progress in a child’s area of need. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(1)(A). Petitioner contends that the District’s proposed goals and objectives in her IEP in June 2001 in the area of reading were inappropriate as they lacked present levels of performance to determine her skill level in reading.

The present levels of performance in the IEP of June 8, 2001, state:

STUDENT demonstrates deficits in auditory conceptualization as well as having a high anxiety toward academic performance. This deficit significantly affects STUDENT’s ability to progress in the general curriculum within the content area of Reading and Written Language. STUDENT’s reading is slow and laborious and interferes with her comprehension.

CORE Testing Results:

Fall Spring Reading 170 18%ile 176 17%ile Math 174 17%ile 187 19%ile Lang. 175 21%ile 172 8%ile STUDENT presently reads orally at a rate of 51 words per minute from the CUSD reading series (Harcourt).

Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance contains no baseline of her skills in reading. However, the evidence indicates otherwise. Although the present levels of performance section includes a general statement about STUDENT’s deficits, the section also includes quantifiable measurements of her reading rate and her comprehension based upon the results of her CORE tests and fluency assessments. In addition, Ms. Noyes, STUDENT’s RSP teacher, testified regarding the results of her CORE tests and STUDENT’s level of reading in June 2001. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that these statements comply with the requirement that present levels of performance must inform the IEP team members of the student’s current level of functioning so as to enable them to develop measurable goals and objectives. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the present levels of performance in the area of reading in June 2001 were appropriate for STUDENT.

2. Appropriateness of Program

Ms. Noyes, STUDENT’s elementary school RSP teacher, testified that she has been an RSP teacher with the District for seven years and that she has a regular education teaching credential, a master’s degree in special education, and RSP certification. She also testified that she has been trained to teach reading to special education students by both Lindamood-Bell (LMB) and the District.

Ms. Noyes further testified that she and an aide provided small-group instruction in groups of two to four students, in addition to individual, RSP services to STUDENT in the areas of reading, written language, and math during the 2001-2002 school year. She further testified that these services included strategies, Earobics, a phonics program, the Write Program, and the Read Naturally program. (Footnote 11) In addition, she explained that the LMB programs that she utilized included the Lindamood Phonemic Sequencing (LiPS) program, the Seeing Stars program, and the Visualizing and Verbalizing program. (Footnote 12) In addition to these strategies, Ms. Noyes testified that she and the aide worked on STUDENT’s goals and objectives in her areas of need. Ms. Noyes also described games, vowel circles, math stories, reteaching math concepts, rewards, and computer programs that she used with STUDENT. In Ms. Noyes’ opinion, all of these programs worked well together to address STUDENT’s needs.

As discussed above, on her third-grade report card, STUDENT had received below grade-level grades in the areas of reading, written language, and math. She had also scored below expected levels in these areas on the District’s CORE testing in the spring of 2001. Furthermore, her third-grade teacher described a variety of interventions that STUDENT had required during that school year for assistance in these academic areas. The evidence thus reveals that the District’s small-group and individual RSP services, variety of teaching strategies, and work on STUDENT’s goals and objectives were designed to address her unique needs in the areas of reading, written language, and math.

Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of RSP services in June 2001 was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in reading, written language, and math for the 2001-2002 school year.

Was the Proposed Placement Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit to STUDENT?

The Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s proposed RSP services were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit in June 2001. The Hearing Officer found above that the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of reading, written expression, and math, her areas of deficit. Additionally, as noted above, the program provided STUDENT with opportunities for small group and individualized instruction in her areas of difficulty, multisensory approaches to instruction, individualized specialized instruction through a credentialed special education teacher trained to work with deficits such as STUDENT’s. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Furthermore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT actually obtained meaningful benefit from the program.

Ms. Noyes testified that by the end of the 2001-2002 school year, as a result of her work with STUDENT, STUDENT had matured, was able to complete her schoolwork, saw herself as a good student, and made a great deal of growth. She also testified that STUDENT had made progress on her goals and objectives. Ms. Anderson, STUDENT’s fourth-grade teacher, also testified that STUDENT showed improvement in her skills in reading, written language, and math during the 2001-2002 school year.

Ms. Noyes and Ms. Anderson also testified that STUDENT’s scores on the District’s CORE testing demonstrated improvement from the beginning to the end of the school year. STUDENT achieved scores of 180 in elementary reading, 177 in language usage, and 171 in elementary math on the District’s CORE testing in the fall of 2001. Her scores in the spring of 2002 had increased to 193 in elementary reading, 188 in language usage, and 200 in elementary math. Ms. Noyes and Ms. Anderson both testified that even though STUDENT remained below grade level in these areas, her increased CORE scores showed improvement, especially in math.

In addition, on the Burns and Roe Informal Reading Inventory (Burns and Roe) administered to STUDENT by Ms. Noyes at the end of fourth grade, STUDENT read at a 95 percent word recognition level and a 90 percent reading comprehension level on a fourth-grade reading passage. According to Ms. Noyes’ report in June 2002, STUDENT’s reading fluency was at a comfortable mid-third-grade level although she read at a much slower rate when reading fourth-grade material. She also described STUDENT as making good growth in word decoding and being able to self-correct when a word did not make sense in a sentence. She described STUDENT’s reading comprehension as good although slowed by concentrating on decoding words.

On her fourth-grade report card, although STUDENT remained below grade level in reading, writing, and math achievement, she achieved grades within the B and C range in all areas. Ms. Anderson’s comments on her report card noted that STUDENT was making sufficient progress toward meeting all of her IEP goals, Ms. Anderson was pleased with STUDENT’s progress, and STUDENT did well with modified homework. Ms. Noyes also noted on the report card that STUDENT was developing good spelling, word attack, and comprehension strategies and was retaining and applying math concepts. Ms. Anderson also described STUDENT as demonstrating growth in all academic areas on a fourth-grade annual review report completed in June 2002.

The evidence further reveals that when the IEP team met on January 24, 2002, Ms. Noyes informed the team that STUDENT had met five of seven of her reading short-term objectives. When the IEP team met on June 13, 2002, she informed them that STUDENT had met her two remaining short-term objectives in reading. She also informed the team that STUDENT had met all of her written language goals and objectives and was making progress on her math goals and objectives.

In contrast to the testimony of Ms. Anderson and Ms. Noyes, FATHER believes that STUDENT regressed during the 2001-2002 school year. He was concerned because STUDENT’s report card and CORE scores indicated that she was below grade level in reading, writing, and math. He further testified that he believed that STUDENT required more intensive LMB services so that she could function at grade level. FATHER testified that the parents did not believe that STUDENT had made progress on her goals and objectives because they observed that she was not able to complete the work independently at home. At home, according to her father, STUDENT had “meltdowns,” cried, and told her parents that she could not do the work.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the evidence that the District’s offer of RSP services for the 2001-2002 school year was not only calculated to provide educational benefit but actually provided educational benefit to STUDENT in the areas of reading, written language, and math. Although Petitioner contends that she did not progress in these areas, the evidence indicates otherwise. Both Ms. Noyes and Ms. Anderson testified credibly that STUDENT made progress in all of these areas during fourth grade as demonstrated by her school work, progress on her IEP goals and objectives, and improved CORE test scores. (Footnote 13) While it is undisputed that STUDENT was not functioning at grade level in these areas, the overwhelming evidence demonstrates that she progressed as a result of RSP services in reading, written language, and math and that both of her teachers were pleased with her progress that year.

Although STUDENT’s parents do not believe that STUDENT progressed sufficiently on her goals and objectives, they did not present persuasive evidence in support of their contention other than STUDENT’s difficulties with homework. The parents testified credibly that STUDENT had difficulties at home with her homework; however, they did not present evidence to dispute her academic progress at school. Although STUDENT’s mother testified credibly that she visited STUDENT’s fourth-grade classroom to observe her program throughout the year, the Hearing Officer gives greater weight regarding functioning at school to the credible testimony of the teachers who regularly worked with STUDENT at school during that school year and to STUDENT’s report cards and test results. (Footnote 14)

Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of RSP services and present levels of performance in reading in June 2001 were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.

Did the Placement Conform to STUDENT’s IEP?

There is no dispute that the District provided the placement, services, and implementation of goals and objectives specified in the IEP of June 2001.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.

ISSUE NO. 5: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?

Petitioner alleges that the District committed both procedural and substantive violations of the IDEA during the 2002-2003 school year. Procedurally, she contends that the District (1) failed to provide her parents with prior written notice of the District’s denial of their request for LMB services and a functional analysis assessment (FAA) in November 2002; (2) failed to convene an IEP meeting when the District noted regression in January 2003; (3) convened an IEP meeting without her parents on June 3, 2003, and failed to permit her parents to participate in a subsequent IEP meeting on June 17, 2003; and (4) failed to provide her parents with prior written notice of the District’s proposal to discontinue OCMH services in June 2003. (Footnote 15) Substantively, she contends that the District (1) failed to develop appropriate present levels of performance in the areas of reading, written language, and math in her IEP in June 2003, and (2) failed to offer her appropriate services to address her deficits in reading, written language, and math.

Procedural FAPE

1. Prior Written Notice Regarding the Parents’ Request for Services and Assessment in November 2002

As discussed above, a school district is required to provide parents with prior written notice whenever it proposes or refuses to change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). Petitioner contends that at an IEP meeting in November 2002, the District failed to provide timely prior written notice of its decision to deny her parents’ request for an LMB program and an FAA.

A review of the evidence reveals that beginning in January 2002, STUDENT’s parents repeatedly requested that the District provide her with an intensive program at the LMB clinic in Newport Beach and that the District declined each request. At the IEP meeting on June 13, 2002, the parents requested this program for the 2002 ESY, and the District declined this request. The IEP document states that the District members considered the request for the LMB program and instead decided to offer STUDENT a District-based LMB program. At the meeting on November 8, 2002, the IEP document notes that the parents again requested the LMB program for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year and that the District instead proposed that LMB strategies be used by the RSP teacher.

A review of the evidence also reveals that in their written dissent at the IEP meeting on November 8, 2002, STUDENT’s parents requested that the District conduct an FAA “due to some behavioral concerns & emotionality and the relationship between STUDENT and the RSP Instructional Aide.” (Footnote 16) The District did not respond in writing to this request until January 10, 2003, when Val Parkin, assistant principal at Ambuehl, sent a letter to the parents denying their request for both the LMB program and the FAA.

According to the evidence, the District and the parents discussed the parents’ request for an LMB program at the LMB clinic during the IEP meetings in January, June, and November 2002. In both the June and November IEP documents, the District documented its refusal to provide STUDENT with this program. It is undisputed that the parents received copies of both documents and were aware of the reasons for the District’s denial from the discussion at all three of the IEP meetings in 2002. Furthermore, these discussions were followed by the written notice sent by Mr. Parking on January 10, 2005. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District provided the parents with sufficient prior written notice of its decision not to provide STUDENT with a program at the LMB clinic.

With regard to the request for an FAA, the evidence reveals that the parents made this request in their written dissent at the IEP meeting in November 2002. (Footnote 17) Both Mr. Parkin and Mr. Russell testified that the parties did not discuss the request for an FAA at the meeting in November 2002. Furthermore, Mr. Parkin testified that the District was not aware of the FAA request until it reviewed the parents’ written dissent following the meeting. Thereafter, according to his testimony, he discussed the request with District members of the IEP team and on January 10, 2003, sent his letter denying the request.

The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District provided timely written notice to the parents of its decision not to conduct an FAA of STUDENT. Although STUDENT’s parents requested this assessment in their written dissent in November 2002, they did not make the request during the meeting. When the District became aware of the request following the meeting, it issued a written notice denying the request. Moreover, the parents were aware of the District’s reasons for denying the request as Mr. Parkin’s letter d iscussed his conversations with STUDENT’s teachers regarding her classroom behavior. (Footnote 18)

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not commit any procedural violations with regard to her parents’ request for an LMB program or an FAA during the 2002-2003 school year.

2. Convening an IEP Meeting in January 2003

An IEP team shall meet whenever a student demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(b). Petitioner contends that the District should have convened an IEP meeting following a letter from Mr. Parkin to her parents in January 2003 discussing her alleged regression.

A review of the evidence reveals that on January 10, 2003, Mr. Parkin wrote a letter to the parents in which he confirmed events that had occurred at the IEP meeting on November 8, 2002. As part of that letter, he discussed the parents’ concerns expressed at that meeting that STUDENT had regressed in reading and written language. In his letter, Mr. Parkin further confirmed the discussion at the meeting regarding a decline in STUDENT’s CORE test scores in the fall of 2002 and the discussion at the meeting that this decline may have been “indicative of regression over the summer break.” Mr. Parkin further noted in his letter that STUDENT’s CORE scores appeared to be inconsistent with “other testing data, portfolio samples, recorded reading samples, and observations.” He then expressed his opinion that STUDENT was “making progress overall.”

Although an IEP team must meet whenever a student demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress, that is not the case here. Mr. Parkin’s letter does not indicate that STUDENT was experiencing regression in January 2003. In fact, in his opinion, STUDENT was progressing and not regressing at that time. Mr. Parkin wrote the letter to confirm the discussion about regression with the parents at the IEP meeting held in November 2002. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not commit any procedural violations by failing to convene an IEP meeting in January 2003.

3. Parental Participation in IEP Meetings in June 2003

California Education Code section 56342.5 provides that school districts shall ensure that “the parent of each individual with exceptional needs is a member of any group that makes decisions on the educational placement of the individual with exceptional needs.” Moreover, when a district convenes an IEP meeting, it shall “take steps to ensure that one or both of the parents of the individual with exceptional needs are present at each [IEP] meeting or are afforded the opportunity to participate.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a). Furthermore, the parents shall be notified of the meeting “early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend,” and the meeting “shall be scheduled at a mutually agreed upon time and place.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(b), (c). Finally, a district may convene an IEP meeting without the parents in attendance if the district is unable to convince the parents that they should attend. In this event, the district shall maintain a record of its attempts to arrange a mutually agreed-upon time for the meeting. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g).

Petitioner contends that the District improperly convened an IEP meeting on June 3, 2003, without her parents. She further contends that at an IEP meeting on June 17, 2003, the District failed to allow her parents the opportunity to participate and provide input into the development of the IEP that it had created on June 3, 2003.

It is undisputed that STUDENT’s parents did not attend an annual IEP meeting held on June 3, 2003. However, the District contends that the parents permitted the District to proceed without them. STUDENT’s parents dispute this contention.

A review of the evidence reveals that on May 6, 2003, the District mailed a notice of an IEP meeting to the parents, informing them that the District had scheduled an IEP meeting for June 3, 2003. A notation on the notice states, “5/6/03 called Dad to inform of meeting.” On May 19, 2003, the District again mailed the parents a notice of IEP meeting, informing them of the meeting on June 3, 2003. This notice contained a notation indicating that on May 29, 2003, someone from the District had called the parents, and “parent will let me know if they are attending meeting.” An additional notation on the notice states, “Called June 2, 2003 from home in the evening. Mother canceled 6/3/03 meeting.”

The IEP document from the meeting on June 3, 2003, states that in addition to the two notices sent to the parents, the District made four telephone calls informing the parents of the meeting date. The document further states, “Parents were unable to attend mtg.; In order to meet annual timelines; parents agreed to have team proceed w/mtg. in their absence.” The document also states, “Parent notified case worker From Western Youth Service prior to this mtg. date that they would be @ mtg scheduled for today. However, RSPT called last evening to confirm, parents indicated that they would not be able to attend today. As per phone conversation this am, parents agreed to allow CUSD team members to proceed & reschedule to review at a later date.”

Ms. Noyes testified regarding the District’s attempts to ensure parental attendance at the meeting and testified that the District proceeded with the meeting on June 3, 2003, to comply with time lines regarding STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting. She further testified that on May 6, 2003, she called STUDENT’s father to inform him of the meeting and later called STUDENT’s mother but could not recall that conversation. According to Ms. Noyes, the District had rescheduled several prior meetings in which the parents advised her that they were unavailable after agreeing to a particular date. She also testified that the District was required to proceed with the meeting because of timelines and that the parents had allowed them to proceed.

FATHER testified that he did not believe that he had advised the District to proceed without him. He also could not recall receiving the notices of the meeting. In addition, MOTHER testified that she did not give the District permission to proceed with the meeting without her because one or both parents attended all meetings. She also stated, however, that her husband sometimes did not want her to attend IEP meetings because she became too emotional.

The evidence further reveals that the District proceeded with the meeting without the parents. At the meeting, the District proposed a regular education placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year with related services of ninety minutes per day of RSP support in English, math, and learning strategies. The District also proposed discontinuing STUDENT’s OCMH mental health counseling services because STUDENT had “met goals in this area as per treatment plan.” At the meeting, the District further proposed goals and objectives in the areas of written language, reading, math, and attention.

Additionally, the evidence reveals that on June 17, 2003, the District convened another IEP meeting. Both of STUDENT’s parents and her advocate attended this meeting. At the meeting, the District proposed the same placement and program as it had proposed as the meeting on June 3, 2003. The IEP document states, “Marco Forster RSP reviewed RSP program.” At this meeting, the parents expressed their opinion that STUDENT had not met her OCMH goals and objectives.

It is undisputed that the District held an annual IEP meeting on June 3, 2003, without STUDENT’s parents. However, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District was entitled to proceed without the parents because it attempted to obtain the parents’ presence at the meeting and documented its efforts to do so. Moreover, the District convened a subsequent IEP meeting for the exact same purpose, i.e., to discuss STUDENT’s progress and unique needs, discuss her goals and objectives, discuss its proposal to discontinue her mental health services, obtain parental input, and propose a placement and program for the following school year. (Footnote 19)

Although the parents contend that they were not allowed to participate in the second meeting, it is undisputed that both parents attended the meeting with an advocate, prepared a written dissent to the IEP, and were aware of the District’s proposal for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year. In the parents’ written dissent, they stated that they disagreed with the proposed IEP, the District’s statements that STUDENT had met her goals from the prior year, the District’s statements that STUDENT had made two years’ growth in reading, the proposed goals for the following school year, the proposed ESY program, and the proposal to discontinue OCMH services.

The evidence in this matter thus reveals that the parents were members of the IEP team and active participants in all program and placement discussions regarding STUDENT in June 2003. Their written dissent indicates that they were knowledgeable about the IEP and were familiar with the proposed program and goals and objectives for the upcoming school year. Moreover, they indicated their disagreement with various portions of the IEP, further indicating their familiarity with the District’s offer.

In sum, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the above evidence that the parents’ participation in the IEP process was not seriously infringed upon, nor did the actions of the District result in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT as a result of the parental participation at IEP meetings held in June 2003. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit any procedural violations on this basis during the 2002-2003 school year.

4. Prior Written Notice of the District’s Proposal to Discontinue OCMH Services in June 2003

As discussed above, a district is required to provide parents of a child with a disability with prior written notice whenever it proposes or refuses to initiate or change the educational placement of the child unless it provides this notice at the same time that it requires parental consent for implementation. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3); 34 C.F.R. § 300.503(a)(2). Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide her parents with prior written notice of its proposal to discontinue her OCMH counseling services in June 2003.

As discussed above, the District convened two IEP meetings in June 2003 to propose a placement and program for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year. At these meetings, the District proposed discontinuing STUDENT’s counseling services. The District documented this proposal in both IEP documents, and STUDENT’s parents wrote a dissenting statement indicating that they disagreed with the proposal.

It is undisputed that the District requested the parents’ consent to discontinuing mental health services at the same time that it informed them of its proposal to discontinue mental health services. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District provided the parents with prior written notice of its proposal to discontinue mental health counseling services for STUDENT in June 2003 and thus did not commit any procedural violations on this basis. (Footnote 20)

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit any procedural violations during the 2002-2003 school year.

Substantive FAPE

A review of the evidence reveals that the District proposed placement of STUDENT in a regular education classroom with related services of RSP support for ninety minutes per day and OCMH counseling for the 2002-2003 school year. Petitioner does not dispute the District’s proposed placement in a regular education classroom or the provision of OCMH counseling. However, she contends that the offer was not appropriate because the District failed to develop proper present levels of performance in the areas of reading, written language, and math in her IEP of June 2002. She also contends that the proposed services did not offer her a FAPE because she required more intensive services to address her needs in reading, written language, and math.

What Were STUDENT’s Unique Needs in June 2002?

To determine whether the RSP support that the District offered STUDENT in June 2002 for the 2002-2003 school year provided her with a FAPE, it is first necessary to identify her unique needs at that time.

It is undisputed that STUDENT continued to have unique needs in the areas of reading, written expression, and math in June 2002. It is further undisputed that STUDENT continued to require individual and small-group specialized instruction in these areas to address her unique needs.

As discussed above, STUDENT’s fourth-grade report card in June 2002 found her to be below grade level in reading, written language, and math. In addition, her CORE scores in the spring of 2002 were in the very low/low range in language usage, the low range in elementary reading, and the low/low average range in elementary math. Ms. Noyes also credibly testified that STUDENT continued to require individual and small-group RSP services in June 2002.

Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that in June 2002, STUDENT had deficits in the areas of reading, written language, and math. The Hearing Officer further concludes that STUDENT’s unique needs in these areas required specialized individual and small-group instruction in reading, written language, and math to address her deficits.

Was the Proposed Placement Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

1. Present Levels of Performance

As discussed above, an IEP must include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, and present levels of performance to inform the IEP team members of the student’s current level of functioning. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2), (a)(1)(A). Petitioner contends that the goals and objectives in her IEP of June 13, 2002, in the areas of reading, written language, and math lacked present levels of performance. (Footnote 21)

The IEP of June 13, 2002, contains the following description of present levels of performance in the area of reading:

Reading a fourth grade level passage on the Burns and Roe Reading Inventory, STUDENT is able to identify different sounds in words and is able to identify the number of syllables in a word with assistance. She knows the sounds of letter combinations, but is inconsistent in application. She does not always recognize root words in unknown words, however she knows most of the prefixes and suffixes. STUDENT continues to make improvement in reading oral fluency when she is reading. STUDENT reads approximately 80 words a minute on a cold timing and increase[s] to an average of 106 after 3 timed readings. She scored 90% in Comprehension on the fourth grade passage independently looking back in the story for information.

Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance contains no baseline of her skills in reading. However, the evidence indicates that the present levels of performance contain quantifiable information by which the IEP team could develop goals and objectives. These present levels of performance include the results of STUDENT’s performance on the Burns and Roe, an oral fluency assessment, and a comprehension assessment. The section also contains information regarding STUDENT’s ability to identify sounds, syllables, letter combinations, root words, and prefixes and suffixes. It also contains information regarding her oral fluency level and her comprehension ability. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District properly identified STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the area of reading in the IEP of June 2002.

The IEP of June 13, 2002, contains the following statement of present levels of performance in the area of written language:

STUDENT’s writing samples show that she is having difficulty writing a multi-paragraph composition including facts, details, and explanations. She is becoming more aware of punctuation’s [sic] and has indicated a desire to learn more of the punctuation rules for writing. STUDENT needs to use a dictionary or spell check every time she writes to emphasize spelling accuracy.

Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance contains no baseline of her skills in written language. However, the evidence indicates that the present levels of performance included information pertaining to her ability to write a composition, her knowledge of punctuation, and her ability to spell accurately. These levels thus contain quantifiable information to allow the IEP team to develop appropriate goals and objectives that address STUDENT’s deficits. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District properly identified STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the area of written language in the IEP of June 2002.

The IEP of June 13, 2002, contains the following statement of present levels of performance in the area of math:

When number[s] are dictated to STUDENT she can recognize numbers to 999,999. She can write numbers dictated to her to 999. STUDENT recognizes fractional numerals and parts with denominators of 8. STUDENT understands the concept of adding and subtracting single digit to multiple digit numbers with renaming in addition and subtraction problems, she sometimes hurries through the problems causing errors, however, she can correct the errors independently when the problems are marked incorrect. She understand[s] the concept of multiplication and can complete the facts through 10 on a timed test. STUDENT understand[s] the concept of division. She has most of the division facts memorized. STUDENT can name and understand the value of money and coins. She knows the relationship of the coins. STUDENT can tell time to five minutes. She knows the days, seasons, and months of the year. STUDENT can measure with a ruler to the ½ inch. In geometry, she can recognize two dimensional shapes, read a diagram, compute the perimeter of a square and triangle.

Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance contains no baseline of her skills in math. However, the evidence indicates that these levels contain quantifiable information regarding STUDENT’s knowledge of dictated numbers, addition and subtraction, multiplication, division, money, time, measurement, and geometrical shapes. These levels thus contain information to allow the IEP team to develop appropriate goals and objectives that address STUDENT’s deficits in the area of math. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District properly identified STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the area of math in the IEP of June 2002.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s statements of present levels of performance in June 2002 were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of reading, written language, and math.

2. Appropriateness of Program

Ms. Noyes testified that as with the prior school year, she and an aide provided individual and small-group RSP services to STUDENT and used similar multi-sensory approaches as during the prior school year to teach STUDENT reading, written language, and math skills. Ms. Noyes testified that, the small group again consisted of two to four students, and the teaching strategies included LMB techniques, work on individual goals and objectives, games, vowel circles, math stories, reteaching math concepts, rewards, and computer programs.

As discussed above, on her fourth-grade report card, STUDENT had received below grade-level grades in the areas of reading, written language, and math. She had also scored in the low and very low ranges in these areas on the District’s CORE testing in the spring of 2002. Furthermore, her fourth-grade teacher described STUDENT’s difficulties at that time with multiplication tables, phonemic awareness, and written language. The evidence thus reveals that the District’s small-group and individual RSP services, variety of teaching strategies, and work on STUDENT’s goals and objectives were designed to address her unique needs in the areas of reading, written language, and math. Additionally, as discussed above, a similar program during the 2001-2002 school year provided STUDENT meaningful educational benefit.

Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of RSP services for the 2002-2003 school year was again designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in reading, written language, and math.

Was the Proposed Placement Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit to STUDENT?

The Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s offer for the 2002-2003 school year was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer found above that the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of reading, written expression, and math, her areas of deficit. Additionally, as noted above, the program provided STUDENT with opportunities for small group and individualized instruction in her areas of difficulty, multisensory approaches to instruction, individualized specialized instruction through a credentialed special education teacher trained to work with deficits such as STUDENT’s. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Furthermore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT actually obtained meaningful benefit from the program.

Laura Smith, STUDENT’s fifth-grade teacher, testified that STUDENT made progress over the course of the year in all academic areas. In Ms. Smith’s opinion, ninety minutes per day of RSP services was adequate for STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year because of the growth that she observed both academically and socially.

In May 2003, Ms. Noyes completed an annual review of STUDENT. She described STUDENT as reading with 95 percent word recognition and 80 percent comprehension at a fifth-grade level and at an 80 percent instructional level on a fifth-grade word list. She also described STUDENT as making very good growth in reading and math and having made progress in written language during the school year. Ms. Noyes’ areas of concern for STUDENT at the end of the year were that her written language continued to be below grade level in paragraph development and format and was characterized by errors in spelling and punctuation.

Despite these areas of concern, Ms. Noyes believed that STUDENT had made progress on her goals and objectives in all areas during the 2002-2003 school year. She described STUDENT as a “slow learner” who put in more effort than others but who could do the work. She further described STUDENT as having a “wonderful year,” being very receptive to assignments, improving immensely, and wanting to be a good student. In addition, Ms. Noyes reported at the IEP meeting in June 2003 that STUDENT had met all of her fifth-grade goals and objectives in reading and math with 80 percent accuracy and all of her goals and objectives in written language with 70 percent accuracy. Ms. Smith also completed an annual review in June 2003, noting that STUDENT had developed strong math skills and made a lot of growth in reading comprehension and fluency although she also believed that STUDENT continued to need to put more effort into her writing.

On the District’s Standardized Testing and Reporting (STAR) testing in the spring of 2003, STUDENT’s English-language arts score was 277, which was below basic, and her math score was 236, which was far below basic. On CORE testing, however, STUDENT’s scores had increased from 172 in reading and 190 in math in the fall of 2002 to 189 in reading and 203 in math in the spring of 2003. STUDENT’s CORE language arts score remained the same at 189 in both the fall of 2002 and the spring of 2003. Ms. Smith testified credibly that STUDENT did not perform as well on STAR testing as she did on CORE testing because STAR testing is timed and STUDENT was a very slow worker. According to both Ms. Smith and Ms. Noyes, these CORE scores showed progress, as reflected by STUDENT’s seventeen-point increase in reading and thirteen-point increase in math between fall and spring.

Finally, on her fifth-grade report card, STUDENT achieved grades in reading, writing, and math in the B and C range throughout the year although she remained below grade level in word recognition, vocabulary, grammar/mechanics, writing content, and written expression. However, she had achieved grade-level ability in oral fluency, oral expression, reading comprehension, and all areas of math. On STUDENT’s report card, Ms. Smith described STUDENT as “showing slow but steady progress, especially in math and spelling” during the first trimester, continuing to show growth in most areas during the second trimester, and making “significant growth” by the end of the school year, especially in reading and math.

In contrast to STUDENT’s teachers, Christopher Russell, STUDENT’s advocate, testified that he did not believe that STUDENT had met her goals and objectives as reported by the District. According to Mr. Russell, STUDENT’s parents reported to him that she had the same reading struggles and difficulty with homework as during the previous school year. In addition, both Mr. Russell and FATHER testified that STUDENT had not made progress because her test scores had regressed, and she could not work independently.

Mr. Russell and FATHER based their opinions in part upon an academic assessment in November 2002 in reading, math, and written language conducted by Mike Hardos, a District RSP teacher. On this assessment, STUDENT achieved standard scores of 82 in broad reading, 96 in broad math, and 83 in broad written language on the Woodcock-Johnson. Mr. Russell and FATHER compared these scores to those that STUDENT had obtained on the WIAT administered by Ms. Poteet in March 2000, wherein STUDENT achieved standard scores of 97 in basic reading, 94 in reading comprehension, 98 in mathematic reasoning, 118 in numerical operations, and 101 in spelling and stated that these scores represented a regression in STUDENT’s skills. However, there was no other persuasive evidence to support these statements. Moreover, Ms. Smith testified persuasively that standardized test scores are not the only indicators of a student’s progress.

Although Petitioner contends that the discrepancy in standardized test scores between 2000 and 2002 indicate that she did not make progress during the 2002-2003 school year, the evidence does not support her contention. In fact, the overwhelming evidence indicates that STUDENT made satisfactory progress in reading, written language, and math during that year as evidenced by her report card, her CORE scores, progress on her goals and objectives, and the reports of her teachers. In addition, as discussed previously, although the Hearing Officer finds credible the testimony of STUDENT’s parents that she had difficulties with homework at home, there was no persuasive evidence to contradict the District’s evidence that she made progress in school.

With regard to homework, Ms. Smith testified that STUDENT did not do most of her homework during the 2002-2003 school year and came to school with notes from her parents indicating that she could not do her homework. According to Ms. Smith, STUDENT often acted as if she were “helpless” and frequently stated that she did not want to or could not do assignments. However, the evidence established that if Ms. Smith sat with her individually, STUDENT often could do the work in question. Ms. Smith believed that this behavior may have impacted STUDENT’s ability to complete her homework.

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed RSP program and present levels of performance in reading, written language, and math were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year.

Did the Placement Conform to STUDENT’s IEP?

There is no dispute that the District provided the placement, services, and implementation of goals and objectives specified in the IEP of June 2002.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year.

ISSUE NO 6: Did the District commit procedural and substantive violations of the IDEA that resulted in a denial of FAPE for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year?

Petitioner alleges that the District committed both procedural and substantive violations of FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year. Procedurally, she contends that the District (1) failed to convene an IEP meeting in April 2004 when it identified her as at-risk of not passing the California High School Exit Exam, and (2) failed to provide her parents with prior written notice of its decision not to provide her with LMB services in June 2004. (Footnote 22) Substantively, she contends that the District (1) failed to appropriately identify present levels of performance in the areas of writing, word meanings, math, behavior/attention, reading, and spelling; and (2) failed to offer appropriate services to address her deficits in reading, written language, and math.

Procedural FAPE

1. High School Exit Exam

As discussed above, an IEP team shall meet whenever a student demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(b). Petitioner contends that the District should have convened an IEP meeting in April 2004 when the District identified her as a student who was at-risk of not passing the California High School Exit Exam and/or of being retained.

The evidence reveals that on April 30, 2004, when STUDENT was in sixth grade, Carrie Bertini, principal of Marco Forster, sent a letter to STUDENT’s parents stating, “Your child has been identified as a student who is ‘at-risk’ of not passing California’s High School Exit Exam and/or being retained.” The letter further describes District policy regarding opportunities for remedial instruction and summer school for children recommended for retention. Cheri Detola, STUDENT’s sixth-grade RSP English teacher, testified that students begin to take the high school exit exam in the tenth grade and that a standard letter is sent prior to that time if a child’s grades indicate that he or she may not pass the exit exam. In addition, FATHER testified that he called Ms. Bertini after receiving the letter, and she apologized for having sent the letter.

Although a District is required to convene an IEP meeting when a student demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress, Petitioner does not specifically assert in what manner the letter sent to her parents in April 2004 indicates a lack of anticipated progress. According to Ms. Detola, high school students do not take the exit examination until tenth grade, and STUDENT was in sixth grade at the time. The letter appears to be a form letter addressed to “Dear Parents” with STUDENT’s name inserted rather than an indication regarding her actual or anticipated progress on her goals and objectives during the school year. In fact, as will be discussed below, STUDENT made significant progress on her goals and objectives and was in no danger of being retained in sixth grade.

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not commit a procedural violation by failing to convene an IEP meeting in April 2004.

2. Prior Written Notice Regarding LMB Services

As discussed above, a school district is required to provide parents with prior written notice whenever it proposes or refuses to change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide timely prior written notice of its decision to deny her parents’ request for an LMB program at an IEP meeting on June 3, 2004.

As discussed above, beginning in January 2002, STUDENT’s parents repeatedly requested that the District provide her with an intensive program at the LMB clinic in Newport Beach. At the IEP meeting on June 3, 2004, the parents again requested this program for the following school year, and the District again declined this request. The IEP document states that the District members considered the request for the LMB program and instead decided to offer STUDENT a District-based LMB program.

According to the evidence, the District and the parents discussed the parents’ request for an LMB program during the IEP meeting in June 2003. At this meeting, as it had done during prior years, the District documented its refusal to provide STUDENT with this program. It is undisputed that the parents received copies of the IEP and were aware of the reasons for the District’s denial from the discussion at the IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District provided the parents with timely prior written notice of its decision not to provide STUDENT with a program at the LMB clinic.

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not commit any procedural violations with regard to her parents’ request for an LMB program in June 2004.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit any procedural violations during the 2003-2004 school year.

Substantive FAPE

A review of the evidence reveals that the District proposed a placement for STUDENT in a regular education sixth-grade classroom with related services of RSP support in English and math in June 2003. Petitioner does not dispute the regular education placement but contends that the RSP services did not offer her a FAPE because she required more intensive services to address her needs in reading, written language, and math. (Footnote 23) She also contends that the offer of RSP services was not appropriate because the District failed to appropriately identify her present levels of performance in the areas of reading, written language, and math. She also contends that her written language goals and objectives were not objectively measurable.

What Were STUDENT’s Unique Needs in June 2003?

To determine whether the placement and program the District offered STUDENT in June 2003 provided her with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, it is first necessary to identify her unique needs at that time. The parties again do not dispute that STUDENT continued to have unique needs in the areas of reading, written language, and math that required specialized individual and group instruction to address her deficits in these areas.

As discussed above, at the end of fifth grade in June 2003, STUDENT remained below grade level in word recognition and vocabulary and in the written expression areas of grammar/mechanics, writing content, and written expression. In addition, Ms. Smith testified that at the end of fifth grade, although STUDENT had improved a great deal in math, she continued to have unique needs in that area. STUDENT’s test scores on the District’s CORE testing in the spring of 2003 indicated that she continued to exhibit below-average abilities in reading, math, and written language. Furthermore, Eileen Mulcahy, STUDENT’s sixth-grade RSP math teacher, testified that at the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT had difficulty with multi-digit subtraction. Ms. Mulcahy and Cheri Detola, STUDENT’s sixth-grade RSP English teacher, also testified credibly that STUDENT required specialized instruction to address her deficits in math and English.

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that in June 2003 STUDENT continued to have unique needs in the areas of reading, written language, and math. The Hearing Officer further concludes that STUDENT required specialized individual and small-group instruction to address her deficits in these areas.

Was the Proposed Placement Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

1. Goals and Objectives

As discussed above, an IEP must include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, and present levels of performance to inform the IEP team members of the student’s current level of functioning. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2), (a)(1)(A). Petitioner contends that the goals and objectives in her IEP of June 3, 2003, in the areas of reading, written language, and math lacked proper present levels of performance. She also contends that her written language goals were not objectively measurable.

a. Present Levels of Performance

The IEP of June 3, 2003, contains the following statement of present levels of performance in the area of reading:

STUDENT has made good growth in her reading skills. She can decode most words and can identify common prefixes and suffixes. On the CUSD CORE Testing, when compared to others at her grade level STUDENT scored in the low average in Reading. On the Burns and Roe Inventory Reading Test. Reading at a 5th grade level, STUDENT scored a 95% in word recognition and an 80% in reading comprehension. On 5th grade leveled fluency reading Inventory, STUDENT is reading an average of 100 words per minute. STUDENT can identify and interpret the 4th grade level reading vocabulary and is at a beginning 5th grade instructional level.

Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance in June 2003 contains no baseline of her skills in reading. However, the evidence indicates that these present levels of performance provide quantifiable information about STUDENT’s abilities in the areas of decoding, prefixes and suffixes, word recognition, reading comprehension, reading fluency, and reading vocabulary. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the IEP of June 2003 contains appropriate present levels of performance in reading.

The IEP of June 3, 2003, contains the following description of present levels of performance in the area of math:

STUDENT knows her basic addition, subtraction, and most of her multiplication and division facts. However, she needs to improve her math skills involving multiplication and division problems as well as her understanding of fractions and decimals.

Although the math present levels of performance section of the IEP contains a more generic description of STUDENT’s math abilities, the IEP document indicates in the meeting notes section that the team discussed STUDENT’s CORE scores in math. Furthermore, this description contains quantifiable information regarding STUDENT’s knowledge of addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, fractions, and decimals. As indicated in the IEP, on the basis of the description of STUDENT’s present levels of performance, the team was able to develop math goals and objectives in the areas of multi-step word problems, fractions, basic geometry, the order of operations, and basic algebraic equations. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the IEP of June 2003 contains appropriate present levels of performance in math.

The IEP of June 3, 2003, contains the following statement of present levels of performance in the area of written language:

STUDENT can write to the topic when given a writing-prompt and has shown improvement in organization of her writing. Although improved her written language is still below grade level. Her writing is characterized by errors in language mechanics i.e. capitalization and punctuation. She does not edit her work before turning in for credit. STUDENT[’s] writing samples show that she is having difficulty writing a multi-paragraph composition including facts, details, and explanations. She needs a checklist to self-edit.

Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance in June 2003 contains no baseline of her skills in written language. However, this description contains quantifiable measures by which the IEP team can determine appropriate goals and objectives, including her abilities in topic writing, language mechanics, editing, and writing a multi-paragraph composition. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the IEP of June 2003 contains appropriate present levels of performance in written language.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District properly identified STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the areas of reading, math, and written language in June 2003.

b. Measurable Goals in Written Language

Petitioner also contends that the written language goals in her IEP of June 2003 were not objectively measurable. A review of the IEP reveals that in the area of written language, the District proposed two annual goals. The first goal states, “By 6/04 will improve her application of specific punctuation and capitalization rules to 15 sentence exercises with 70%.” The second goal states, “By 6/04, STUDENT will compose and self-edit a multiple paragraph expository composition using a 4-5 sentence paragraph, using a topic sentence, supporting detailed sentences, and concluding sentence with 10 or fewer errors per paragraph.” Both were to be measured by tests, class work, assignments, journals, writing samples, and portfolios.

The Hearing Officer finds that these written language goals are quantifiable and able to measure STUDENT’s progress in the areas cited. The first goal indicates a specific level of sentence structure usage for STUDENT to achieve and a quantifiable way for the team to measure what progress she has achieved towards applying punctuation and capitalization rules. The second goal indicates a specific level of composition writing and a quantifiable way for the team to measure her progress in paragraph and sentence writing. Moreover, Ms. Detola testified that she was able to work with STUDENT on these goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District proposed measurable goals in the area of written language.

The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District appropriately identified STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the areas of reading, math, and written language and proposed objectively measurable goals in the area of written language in June 2003 that were designed to address her unique needs in these areas.

2. Appropriateness of Program

Ms. Detola, STUDENT’s RSP English teacher, testified that she has been an RSP teacher with the District for six years and worked with children with learning disabilities at a private school prior to that time. She further testified that she has a teaching credential, a special education credential, a master’s degree in special education, and training from the District in language acquisition. Ms. Detola described the English RSP classroom during the 2003-2004 school year as very structured with weekly spelling lists, homework, and vocabulary work. She testified that she utilized a variety of teaching strategies to teach written language skills, including scaffolding, charts, word banks, and definitions. She also taught writing process skills by using brainstorming activities and prewriting exercises and by teaching students to edit, proofread, and finalize their written work. She further stated that she used the same standards and literature books as the regular English classes but with modifications as well as working on STUDENT’s goals and objectives in reading and written language.

Ms. Mulcahy, STUDENT’s RSP math teacher, testified that she has a teaching credential, a special education credential, and a master’s degree in special education. She also testified that she has been an RSP teacher with the District for six years and has taught in special education for ten years. Ms. Mulcahy described her program as being very similar to the regular sixth-grade math curriculum. She testified that she taught her students math basics at each student’s pace while working on their IEP goals and objectives.

As discussed above, at the end of fifth grade in June 2003, STUDENT remained below grade level in word recognition and vocabulary and written expression and continued to require assistance in math. She also continued to score below grade-level on the District’s CORE tests in the areas of reading, math, and written language.

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District’s offer of RSP services in June 2003 was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of reading, written language, and math for the 2002-2003 school year.

Was the Proposed Placement Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit to STUDENT?

The Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s offer and placement was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit for the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer found above that the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of reading, written expression, and math, her areas of deficit. Additionally, as noted above, the program provided STUDENT with opportunities for small group and individualized instruction in her areas of difficulty, multisensory approaches to instruction, individualized specialized instruction through a credentialed special education teacher trained to work with deficits such as STUDENT’s. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Furthermore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT actually obtained meaningful benefit from the program.

Ms. Detola described STUDENT’s progress in her class during the 2003-2004 school year as “excellent.” Ms. Detola testified that STUDENT’s sixth-grade year was “fabulous” as she did very well in her class, matured, had no problems, and made “lots of growth.” According to Ms. Detola, STUDENT’s reading fluency rate was higher at the end of the year, increasing from 70 to 80 words per minute to 90 to 100 words per minute. In addition, by the end of the school year, STUDENT volunteered to read aloud and to answer comprehension questions, both areas in which she improved a great deal throughout the year. She stated that STUDENT’s decoding skills were “choppy” at first, but she became very good at breaking words apart by the end of the year. According to Ms. Detola, STUDENT also made good progress in spelling and grammar and had learned to recognize antonyms and suffixes. STUDENT’s IEP indicates that she progressed at a 60 percent level on her written language goals by the end of the year. In addition, the IEP indicates that STUDENT met her reading goals and objectives by the end of the year.

Ms. Mulcahy described STUDENT as an A student who required minimum support and made only a few simple errors in math. She testified that STUDENT made “fabulous growth” during the 2003-2004 school year. According to Ms. Mulcahy, STUDENT had difficulty with multi-digit subtraction at the beginning of the year, but by the end of the year, she performed this work with 90 percent accuracy and immediately recognized any errors that she made. In addition, Ms. Mulcahy testified that by the end of the year, STUDENT had met all of her math goals and objectives at 80 to 90 percent accuracy with the exception of learning multiplication tables, which she met at 70 percent accuracy.

MOTHER disputed the testimony of both teachers. She testified that STUDENT came home crying everyday during the first week of school because she did not like Ms. Mulcahy. MOTHER also testified that STUDENT told her that she did well on spelling tests in Ms. Detola’s class because Ms. Detola placed flash cards on a table where STUDENT could look at them during spelling tests and copy the correct answer. FATHER also testified that STUDENT continued to have difficulty with reading and writing in the sixth grade. He stated that even though her report cards indicated that she was doing well, STUDENT could not spell or read certain words and told him that she could not read.

The overwhelming evidence indicates that STUDENT made progress in reading, written language, and math during the 2003-2004 school year as a result of her RSP instruction. Both Ms. Mulcahy and Ms. Detola testified credibly regarding STUDENT’s progress in their RSP classrooms. Although MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not like Ms. Mulcahy at the beginning of the school year, she did not dispute Ms. Mulcahy’s testimony that STUDENT made progress in her classroom. The Hearing Officer gives little weight to MOTHER’s uncorroborated hearsay testimony that Ms. Detola allowed STUDENT to cheat on spelling tests. Hearsay evidence is not sufficient by itself to support a finding. Cal. Code of Regs. tit. 5, § 3082(b). In addition, although FATHER testified that STUDENT could not spell or read at home, there was no persuasive evidence to dispute the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers that she performed well in school and progressed on her IEP goals and objectives. As discussed above, although the Hearing Officer finds FATHER’s testimony credible regarding STUDENT’s behavior at home, she gives greater weight regarding STUDENT’s classroom performance to the testimony of the teachers who spent time with STUDENT in the classroom and who were credible and whose testimony was consistent with documents prepared at the time.

Therefore, on the basis of the above evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s RSP program, present levels of performance, and goals and objectives in reading, written language, and math in June 2003 were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.

Did the Placement Conform to STUDENT’s IEP?

There is no dispute that the District provided the placement, services, and implementation of goals and objectives specified in the IEP of June 2003.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit any procedural or substantive violations of the IDEA that resulted in a denial of FAPE for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year.

ISSUE NO. 7: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?

Petitioner alleges that the District committed both procedural and substantive violations of the IDEA during the 2004-2005 school year. Procedurally, she contends that the District failed to (1) discuss instructional strategies with her parents at IEP meetings, (2) timely consider an assessment report by the House Ear Institute at an IEP meeting, and (3) provide prior written notice to her parents in January 2005 of its intent to provide direct speech and language services. Substantively, she contends that the District failed to (1) offer her appropriate services to address her deficits in reading, written language, and math; (2) propose appropriate goals and objectives for her in the areas of writing, word meanings, math, behavior, reading, and spelling; and (3) propose appropriate services and goals and objectives in the area of speech and language.

Procedural FAPE

1. Discussing Instructional Strategies with STUDENT’s Parents at IEP Meetings

Petitioner contends that the District failed to discuss with her parents the instructional strategies that it intended to use to teach reading to her during the 2004-2005 school year. As indicated by the IEP document from June 3, 2004, and the testimony of the participants at that meeting, the District offered STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year intensive literacy intervention for one instructional period per day and the intensive literacy specialist described the LMB services to be provided to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District provided STUDENT’s parents with information regarding the instructional strategies to be used with STUDENT since it informed them that the literacy intervention specialist would use LMB strategies to teach reading to STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit any procedural violations on this basis in June 2004. (Footnote 24)

2. Consideration of an Assessment Report by the House Ear Institute at an IEP Meeting

A child shall be reassessed at least every three years, or more frequently if conditions warrant reassessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). In addition, a district is required to convene an IEP meeting following its completion of an assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(a). A district is also required to convene an IEP meeting within fifty days of the parents’ signed assessment plan, not counting school vacation days. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321. Petitioner contends that the District failed to timely convene an IEP meeting to consider an auditory processing assessment by the House Ear Institute conducted that had been funded by the District in October 2004.

Witnesses on behalf of both Petitioner and the District testified that in June 2004, the IEP team agreed to assess STUDENT in the area of auditory processing. As discussed previously, the parties had agreed in mediation that any assessments of STUDENT conducted prior to the commencement of the due process hearing would be conducted by non-District assessors. Thereafter, as indicated by the assessment report dated October 16, 2004, Carlen Jurey of the House Ear Institute conducted an auditory processing assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Jurey did not testify, and no one testified about her assessment, the date that she conducted the assessment, or the date that the District received the assessment. However, it is apparent from the date of the assessment report that the District did not convene a timely IEP meeting, as the report is dated October 16, 2004, and the IEP meeting did not occur until January 13, 2005, a time period of more than fifty days. However, the Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner suffered no prejudice as a result of this delay since Ms. Jurey did not recommend any direct speech and language services or any other direct services for STUDENT. (Footnote 25)

The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District did not commit any procedural violations with regard to consideration of the assessment report from the House Ear Institute.

3. Prior Written Notice of the District’s Intent to Provide Speech and Language Services

Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide her parents with prior written notice of its proposal at an IEP meeting in January 2005 to provide her with direct speech and language services. As discussed above, in October 2004, the House Ear Institute conducted an auditory processing assessment of STUDENT. Thereafter, on January 13, 2005, the District convened an IEP meeting and offered STUDENT direct speech and language services.

Although Petitioner contends that the District was required to provide her parents with prior written notice of its decision to provide speech and language services in January 2005, the evidence reveals that the District made this proposal at the same time that it requested her parents’ consent for these services. Therefore, as the District provided notice at the same time that it requested consent, this constituted sufficient prior written notice. See 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3); 34 C.F.R. § 300.503(a)(2). The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District did not commit a procedural violation on this basis.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit any procedural violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year.

Substantive FAPE

A review of the evidence reveals that in June 2004, the District offered STUDENT a regular education classroom with related services of RSP support in English and math, small-group intensive literacy intervention, and speech and language consultation. Petitioner does not dispute the offer of a regular education classroom. However, she contends that the District denied her a FAPE in June 2004, by failing to appropriately identify her present levels of performance, offer her any direct speech and language services, or offer her appropriately intensive services to address her needs in reading, written language, and math.

What Were STUDENT’s Unique Needs in June 2004?

To determine whether the placement and program the District offered STUDENT in June 2004 provides her with a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year, it is first necessary to identify her unique needs at that time. Again, the parties do not dispute that STUDENT continued to have deficits in the areas of reading, written language, and math that required individual and small-group specialized instruction to address her deficits. They also do not dispute that beginning in May 2004, she had additional deficits in the areas of speech and language, auditory processing, and attention. However, they again dispute the nature of services that STUDENT required to address these deficits.

A review of the evidence reveals that the District conducted additional testing of STUDENT in May 2004 in preparation for her triennial IEP in June 2004. Dr. Jeffrey Owen assessed STUDENT in the academic areas of reading, written expression, and math. On these assessments, STUDENT scored at the third/fourth-grade level in reading and written language and the fourth/fifth-grade level in math. In addition, according to Debra Romero, STUDENT’s seventh-grade RSP English teacher, STUDENT was approximately two levels below grade level in reading and at a third/fourth-grade level in written language and spelling at the beginning of the school year. Ms. Madrid, STUDENT’s literacy intervention specialist, corroborated these grade levels in reading in testing that she administered to STUDENT in the spring and summer of 2004.

A further review of the evidence reveals that Ms. Dews conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT in May 2004. Ms. Dews concluded that STUDENT exhibited mild receptive language delays, moderate expressive language delays, significant language memory delays, and a mild auditory processing delay. Ms. Dews recommended consultation services to address areas of following directions, remembering assignments, increasing vocabulary, taking notes, verbalizing a short story, writing a short narrative, describing events, interpreting relationships, and understanding stories.

In addition, Dr. Owen assessed STUDENT in May 2004 in the areas of attention and auditory processing and concluded that she also had a processing deficit in auditory reception and attention/concentration. Ms. Romero, Mr. O’Toner, STUDENT’s seventh-grade RSP math teacher, and Ms. Madrid also testified that STUDENT struggled with attention at the beginning of the seventh-grade year. Dr. Owen also recommended small-group instruction and varied instruction in the areas of fluency, decoding, comprehension, spelling, punctuation, vocabulary usage, and sentence structure to address her deficits.

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT had deficits in the areas of reading, written language, math, speech and language, attention, and auditory processing in June 2004. The Hearing Officer also concludes that STUDENT required specialized individual and small-group instruction to address these deficits.

Is the Proposed Placement Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

1. Present Levels of Performance

Petitioner contends that her IEP of June 3, 2004, lacks present levels of performance in the areas of written language, word meanings, math, behavior/attention, reading, and spelling.

The IEP of June 3, 2004, contains the following statement of STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the area of written language:

Due to auditory and attention processing disorder, STUDENT has gaps in written language skills. STUDENT is a creative writer with good ideas. With assistance, she is able to write a multi-paragraph essay. However, her written language contains errors in the mechanics of writing. STUDENT needs to improve in composing and self-editing a multiple paragraph.

Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance contains no baseline of her skills in written language. Although the present levels of performance section includes a general statement about STUDENT’s deficits, the section also contains specific deficits that STUDENT has in the area of mechanics and composition. Moreover, the IEP document indicates that the parties discussed the recent assessment of Dr. Owen, which was attached to the IEP, which found that STUDENT had deficits in the areas of spelling, punctuation, vocabulary usage, and sentence structure. Moreover, the District proposed goals in written language that included prewriting exercises, paragraph writing, use of correct punctuation, use of correct words, and spelling as recommended by Dr. Owen. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that these statements contain sufficient information to develop appropriate goals and objectives in written language and that the IEP of June 2004 therefore contains appropriate present levels of performance in written language.

The IEP of June 3, 2004, contains the following description of present levels of performance in the area of word meanings: “Due to STUDENT’s auditory and attention processing disorder, she struggles with the meanings of words.” Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance in June 2003 contains no baseline of her skills in the area of word meanings. Although the present levels of performance section includes only a general statement about STUDENT’s deficits in this area, the IEP also indicates that the team discussed the recent speech and language assessment by Ms. Dews, which was attached to the IEP, in which Ms. Dews found STUDENT to have difficulty with words in spoken conversation. In Ms. Dews’ assessment, STUDENT scored in the 37th percentile in word definitions and in the 1st percentile in understanding spoken paragraphs on the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF). Thus, the statement that she “struggles with the meanings of words,” derived from the CELF scores, coupled with Ms. Dews’ assessment data, gave the IEP team sufficient information about the deficit with which to develop a goal that involved matching words with their correct meanings. As a result, the IEP team developed a goal for STUDENT that involved using antonyms, synonyms, homophones, and homographs correctly in sentences as well as matching word meanings. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the IEP of June 2004 contains appropriate present levels of performance in word meanings.

The IEP of June 3, 2004, contains the following description of present levels of performance in the area of math:

Math skills tested 5/04. According to standardized testing. See Assessment Documentation. STUDENT knows her basic addition, subtraction, multiplication and division facts with some errors. STUDENT needs to improve her math calculation skills involving multidigit division as well as fractions and decimals. STUDENT also needs to continue to review and improve her understanding of math vocabulary. STUDENT can solve simple one step math word problems, however, she experiences some challenges when faced with multi-step math problems. STUDENT can identify coins and their value. She needs to continue to improve the application of money and its value. STUDENT consistently completes her homework and math recorrects. She needs to continue to complete her math homework, classwork and recorrects on a regular basis. STUDENT’s auditory processing and attention deficits requires specially designed instruction in math for STUDENT to succeed in mathematics.

Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance in June 2004 contains no baseline of her skills in math. However, the IEP provides quantifiable data, including standardized test results, regarding multi-digit division, money, word problems, fractions, and decimals. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the IEP of June 2004 contains appropriate present levels of performance in math.

The IEP of June 3, 2004, contains the following statement of present levels of performance in the area of behavior/attention:

Due to STUDENT’s auditory and attention processing disorder, she will require assistance with classroom notetaking and writing assignments. Currently, STUDENT is taking notes in class but rushes through some assignments often missing the main idea and details.

Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance contains no baseline of her skills in attention. However, the IEP contains quantifiable data, including the assessments of Dr. Owen and Ms Dews, attached to the IEP, in the area of behavior/attention. Ms. Dews recommended that STUDENT learn to take notes as a method to address her delays in receptive language. In addition, Dr. Owen recommended that STUDENT be given opportunities to transpose a verbal teaching task into a hands-on experience to encourage her retention of material and strengthen her auditory abilities. He also suggested visual prompts, such having her write down classroom assignments, to help her to ensure understanding. Moreover, as a result of this present level of performance, the IEP team was able to develop goals and objectives, as well as classroom accommodations and modifications, related to attending to classroom activities by taking notes, outlining, and summarizing.

The IEP of June 3, 2004, contains the following description of present levels of performance in the area of reading:

STUDENT demonstrates significant deficits in phonemic awareness and auditory conceptualization as measured by [LAC] Test: 69/100. This deficit significantly affects STUDENT’s ability to progress in the general curriculum within the content areas of reading and spelling. STUDENT’s oral reading is [s]low and laborious and interferes with her comprehension.

Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance contains no baseline of her skills in reading. Although this section contains very little information about STUDENT’s reading deficits, the IEP refers to the discussion at the meeting of Ms. Madrid’s and Dr. Owen’s recent assessments in the area of reading. In her assessment, reviewed at the IEP meeting, Ms. Madrid concluded that STUDENT had weak auditory conceptualization and decoding skills. Dr. Owen administered the GORT-4, attached to the IEP, and found STUDENT to have difficulties with reading speed, comprehension, and decoding. On the basis of these quantifiable measurements, the District proposed two reading goals and twelve short-term reading objectives, including decoding, reading fluency, functional reading, and contextual accuracy. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that these statements contain quantifiable measurements by which the IEP team developed goals and objectives to address her reading deficits and that the IEP of June 2004 contained appropriate present levels of performance in reading.

The IEP of June 3, 2004, contains the following statement of present levels of performance in the area of spelling:

STUDENT demonstrates significant deficits in phonemic awareness and auditory conceptualization as measured by LAC Test 69/100. This deficit significantly affects STUDENT’s ability to progress in the general curriculum in the area of spelling.

Petitioner contends that this description of her present levels of performance contains no baseline of her skills in spelling. However, as discussed above, the IEP team discussed Dr. Owen’s administration of the spelling subtest of the WIAT, attached to the IEP, that found STUDENT was spelling at a third-grade level. He also described her spelling as indicating that she may not be hearing some sounds. To compensate for this deficit, the District proposed a goal of applying phonemic awareness, spelling expectancies, and visual memory to the encoding process. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the team had sufficient quantifiable information regarding STUDENT’s spelling deficits to develop goal and objectives and that the IEP of June 2004 contains appropriate present levels of performance in spelling.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately described STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the areas of written language, meanings of words, math, reading, behavior/attention, and spelling in June 2004.

2. Speech and Language Services and Goals and Objectives

As discussed above, an IEP must include measurable goals and short-term objectives that meet the child’s educational needs resulting from his or her disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2). In addition, an IEP must include the specific special educational instruction and related services to be provided to the student so that the student will be able to advance appropriately towards attaining the annual goals. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3). Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer her direct speech and language services or to develop goals and objectives to address speech and language deficits following a speech and language assessment conducted in May 2004.

As discussed above, in May 2004, Ms. Dews conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT on the District’s behalf. Ms. Dews testified that she has a master’s degree in communication disorders and a speech pathology credential. She also testified that she has worked as a speech and language pathologist for five years. Ms. Dew assessed STUDENT with several instruments, including the CELF, the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills (TAPS), parent interview, and observations of STUDENT. Ms. Dews concluded that STUDENT had mild to significant receptive and expressive language delays. As a result, she recommended that STUDENT receive consultation services to assist her to follow directions, remember assignments, increase vocabulary, take notes, verbalize a short story, write short narratives, describe events and actions, interpret relationships presented verbally, and understand stories. Additionally, Ms. Dews recommended that the IEP team determine any further services for STUDENT after further assessments were conducted.

On June 3, 2004, following an additional psychoeducational assessment by Dr. Owen on the District’s behalf, the IEP team met for STUDENT’s triennial review. In the area of speech and language, pursuant to Ms. Dews’ assessment, the District proposed thirty-minutes per month of speech and language consultation between a speech and language pathologist and STUDENT’s teachers. The District proposed no goals and objectives in the area of speech and language.

Although Petitioner contends that the District should have provided her with direct speech and language services as a result of Ms. Dews’ assessment, there was no persuasive evidence that she needed such services. Ms. Dews recommended only consultation services, and the District proposed those services as recommended by Ms. Dews. There was no other speech and language assessment of STUDENT and no evidence that STUDENT required direct speech and language services or goals and objectives in the area of speech and language. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District did not improperly fail to provide STUDENT with direct speech and language services or goals and objectives.

3. Appropriateness of Services

Ms. Romero testified that she has been an RSP teacher with the District for thirteen years and that she previously taught children with severe disabilities. She also testified that she has a teaching credential, an RSP certificate, a credential to teach children with learning disabilities, and a master’s degree in special education. Ms. Romero described the RSP English program that she currently provides to STUDENT during the 2004-2005 school year. She testified that she uses the same basic curriculum as the regular education program with modifications that include a slower presentation of material, breaking comprehension into smaller components, and adding more detail. Reading strategies include small-group activities, listening to vocabulary words, making predictions based upon pictures, readings by the teacher, timed readings, answering comprehension questions, decoding strategies, and integration of vocabulary words into other lessons. With regard to written language, Ms. Romero testified that she teaches a modified seventh-grade grammar and written language curriculum with specific strategies geared to STUDENT’s needs in this area. Ms. Romero also testified that she works on STUDENT’s goals and objectives in the area of English.

Mr. O’Toner testified that he has taught RSP math with the District for five years. He also testified that he has master’s degree in teaching art, a social studies teaching credential, and a special education credential. He testified that although math is a relative strength for STUDENT, he assists her with areas of difficulty, particularly with multi-step word problems, and works on her math goals and objectives during the current school year.

With regard to intensive literacy instruction, Ms. Madrid testified that she has been an intensive literacy intervention specialist with the District for four years. She also testified that she has a teaching credential, a master’s degree in general and special education, an intern teaching credential, and a reading certificate from the District. In addition, according to Ms. Madrid, she received training in reading instruction from LMB when she was an employee at the clinic four years ago, as well as through many District workshops. Ms. Madrid testified that she provides STUDENT with various LMB strategies, either one-to-one or with one other student, including the Visualizing and Verbalizing program, the LiPS program, and the Seeing Stars program. In addition, she uses sight word practice, spelling tests, flash cards, and reading exercises with STUDENT. According to Ms. Madrid, she believes, on the basis of her training in reading instruction, that this instruction addresses STUDENT’s reading comprehension, higher order thinking, ability to read in context, symbol imagery, phonemic awareness, vowel circles, sound sequencing, and use of multi-syllabic words.

As discussed above, at the end of sixth grade, STUDENT scored below grade level in reading, written language, and math on assessments conducted by Dr. Owen and Ms. Madrid in the spring and summer of 2004. Dr. Owen and STUDENT’s teachers also found her to have a problem with attention and auditory processing deficits that required small-group instruction and specific instruction in reading and written language. In addition, Ms. Dews found STUDENT to have some speech and language deficits and recommended consultation to assist her with classroom activities. With regard to STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of reading, Ms. Romero and Ms. Madrid persuasively testified that they provide specific instruction in reading to STUDENT by using LMB and a variety of reading strategies. With regard to her unique needs in the area of written language, Ms. Romero testified that she provides a modified seventh-grade grammar curriculum with specific strategies to address her written language deficits. With regard to her unique needs in the area of math, Mr. O’Toner testified that he assists STUDENT with areas of difficulty, particularly with multi-step word problems. In addition, Ms. Romero and Ms. Madrid testified that they both provide STUDENT with slower presentation of material, breaking comprehension into smaller components, small-group activities, sight word practice, and vocabulary word lessons, which are areas of concern expressed by Ms. Dews and Dr. Owen in their assessment reports.

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District’s offer of RSP services in June 2003 was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of reading, written language, and math for the 2004-2005 school year.

Is the Proposed Placement Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit to STUDENT?

The Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s offer is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer found above that the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of reading, written expression, and math, her areas of deficit. Additionally, as noted above, the program provided STUDENT with opportunities for small group and individualized instruction in her areas of difficulty, multisensory approaches to instruction, individualized specialized instruction through a credentialed special education teacher trained to work with deficits such as STUDENT’s. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Furthermore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT actually obtained meaningful benefit from the program.

According to Ms. Romero, STUDENT currently reads ninety words-per-minute at a fifth-grade level, while her reading goal is one hundred words per minute. In addition, STUDENT functions at a fifth-grade level in reading comprehension and vocabulary although she has more difficulty with fluency. In the area of written language, Ms. Romero testified that STUDENT needs help with proofreading, revising her writing, and organizing her thoughts before writing. However, she testified that STUDENT has made progress in these areas and in her goals and objectives during the seventh grade.

Mr. O’Toner testified that STUDENT is doing “great” in his RSP math class, that she does above-average work, and that she is making progress on her goals and objectives. He testified that she can do multiplication tables in her head quickly although she has difficulty with common denominators and complex fractions, requiring the use of a calculator and the assistance of an aide.

STUDENT’s seventh-grade report card indicates that for the first quarter of seventh grade, she received all A’s and B’s with the exception of a C+ in RSP math. Her student summary reports for the first two quarters of the current school year indicate that she has received mostly passing grades in grammar, spelling, vocabulary, written language, and reading assignments.

In addition, in January 2005, Ms. Madrid assessed STUDENT’s progress in reading. On the Burns and Roe, STUDENT read a seventh-grade word list at an instructional level with ninety-eight percent accuracy. She also read and comprehended a seventh-grade reading passage independently at ninety percent. Ms. Madrid testified credibly that STUDENT’s progress in reading has included increased sight words, increased spelling ability, improved fluency, improved decoding, improved comprehension, progress in auditory comprehension, and improved phonemic and phonetic awareness. According to Ms. Madrid, STUDENT has made progress in reading on her goals and objectives since the beginning of the current school year.

James Blinn, District program specialist who is responsible for the literacy program, testified that he has a master’s degree in communication disorders, a speech and language credential, and an administrative credential. He also testified that he has been teaching reading to children in a private practice by using LMB strategies for the past seven years and has trained approximately one hundred teachers within the District regarding LMB strategies. He further testified that first received LMB training twenty-six years ago and has supervised many graduate students who teach reading to children by using LMB methodology.

Mr. Blinn testified that he has discussed STUDENT’s reading abilities with Ms. Madrid and has reviewed STUDENT’s test results. Mr. Blinn described STUDENT’s progress on the Burns and Roe as “steady improvement,” testifying that she has made “reasonable progress” from her work with Ms. Madrid. According to Mr. Blinn, STUDENT reads slowly but understands, is better at comprehension than decoding, and can read recreationally at a fourth/fifth-grade level.

STUDENT’s father and advocate dispute the testimony of the District witnesses regarding STUDENT’s progress in her current program. Although FATHER testified that STUDENT can read “easy” sentences and can identify and “sound out” certain words, in his opinion, she has not made appropriate progress because she cannot read a book or magazine at a seventh-grade level. Mr. Russell also testified that STUDENT continues to have the same reading and homework struggles at home as in prior years.

In addition, Petitioner contends that the results of an assessment administered by LMB on January 20, 2005, indicate that she has not made educational progress during the seventh grade. On that assessment, STUDENT scored at the third-grade level in reading rate, the second-grade level in reading accuracy and fluency, and the sixth-grade level in reading comprehension on the Gray Oral Reading Test-4 (GORT-4). On the Informal Tests of Writing, she achieved 28 of 32 in sound/symbol association, one of three in nonsense spelling, and 26 of 50 on the symbol imagery test.

It is undisputed that STUDENT continues to work below grade level in reading, written language, and math. However, no witness testified that STUDENT’s scores on standardized tests were the only way to assess her progress in school. Dr. Owen, the private assessor who conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT for the District in May 2004, testified that a student’s progress is determined by a variety of factors, including individual assessments, District-wide achievement tests, report cards, and informal perceptions of teachers and parents. Moreover, Kimberly Zakaryan, associate clinic director at LMB, testified that she did not personally administer the LMB assessments to STUDENT, does not know which personnel at LMB administered the tests, and was not present during the assessment. In addition, the LMB assessment document reports only scores without any explanation of the manner in which the testing was conducted, the length of time of the testing, or anything that may have affected the results during the course of the assessment. The validity of the LMB test results has thus not been established on the basis of the current record. Therefore, the Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the teachers who have worked directly with STUDENT throughout the current school year than to a one-time assessment without evidence to establish the validity of its results. As indicated by her teacher’s reports, her progress reports, informal assessments, and her report cards, STUDENT is making satisfactory progress towards her IEP goals and objectives in the areas of reading, written language, and math.

The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District’s proposed program in reading, written language, and math, present levels of performance, and speech and language services and goals and objectives in June 2004 is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year.

Does the Placement Conform to STUDENT’s IEP?

There is no dispute that the District is providing the placement, services, and implementation of goals and objectives specified in the IEP of June 2004, as amended in January 2005.

The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year.

ISSUE NO 8: If the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any time period from March 2000 through the present, is she entitled to compensatory education in an intensive educational therapy program?

Compensatory education is an equitable remedy which may be available when a school district has failed to provide a student with appropriate special education services. Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). The Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education does not involve an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. The purpose of compensatory education is “to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. at 1497. In crafting appropriate relief, a hearing officer has broad latitude. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Education of Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 359 (1985).

In light of the Hearing Officer’s conclusion above that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE during any of the years in question, she is not entitled to compensatory education.

ISSUE NO 9: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations by Kate Stuhr Mack, Ph.D. and LMB?

As discussed above, federal and State special education law provide that before any action can be taken with regard to the placement of a child in special education, an assessment of the student’s educational needs shall be conducted. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. Furthermore, a district has an obligation to reassess a child at least every three years, or more frequently if conditions warrant reassessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). When a parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency’s assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). For the educational agency’s assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code section 56320, which states that a district’s assessment must be administered by qualified personnel and utilize instruments that are not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. In addition, testing materials must be provided in the child’s primary language, have been validated for the purpose for which they are used, be administered by trained personnel in conformance with the test’s instructions, assess specific areas of educational need, accurately reflect the aptitude of a child with impaired sensory or speaking skills, and not utilize a single procedure as the sole criterion for determining eligibility for special education. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b), (c), (d), (e). In addition, California Education Code section 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas related to the child’s suspected disability. STUDENT’s parents request reimbursement for the independent assessments of Dr. Kate Stuhr Mack and LMB.

Dr. Mack’s Assessment

It is undisputed that STUDENT’s parents requested that Dr. Mack conduct a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT in October and November 2000 because they disagreed with the assessments conducted by school psychologist Ms. Poteet in March and June 2000. Therefore, to determine if the parents are entitled to reimbursement, the Hearing Officer must decide if the District’s assessments were appropriate. (Footnote 26)

As discussed above, Ms. Poteet assessed STUDENT in March 2000 in the areas of intelligence, academic achievement, visual motor integration, visual perception, and behavior. In June 2000, Ms. Poteet further assessed STUDENT in the area of nonverbal intelligence. It is undisputed that Ms. Poteet was a qualified school psychologist, she utilized instruments that were not discriminatory, testing materials were provided in STUDENT’s primary language, test instruments were validated for the purpose for which they were used, tests were administered by trained personnel in conformance with the test’s instructions, tests assessed specific areas of educational need, she did not utilize a single procedure as the sole criterion for determining STUDENT’s eligibility for special education, and she assessed STUDENT in all areas related to her suspected disability of SLD and attention.

The only dispute with the assessment by Ms. Poteet was that the WISC-III administered to STUDENT in March 2000 did not accurately reflect her intelligence because STUDENT allegedly should have been assessed with a nonverbal measurement of cognitive abilities due to her low verbal intelligence score. However, it is also undisputed that Ms. Poteet administered the CTONI to STUDENT in June 2000, which indicated a nonverbal intelligence score that was twenty-nine points higher than her verbal intelligence score. There was no dispute with the administration or results of the CTONI. Therefore, as the District assessed STUDENT with an instrument that accurately reflected her nonverbal aptitude, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District assessed STUDENT with an appropriate intelligence measure in June 2000 and conducted appropriate assessments in March and June 2000. Therefore, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the assessment of Dr. Mack.

LMB Assessment

Although STUDENT’s parents request reimbursement for the LMB assessment conducted in January 2005, there was no District assessment with which they could disagree at that time. STUDENT’s parents did not testify that they requested an assessment by LMB because they disagreed with any District assessments. In fact, Mr. Russell testified that the parents contacted LMB because they believed that its program would help STUDENT. Therefore, the evidence indicates that the LMB assessment was not a result of the parents’ disagreement with any District assessment. Nor is there any area in which Petitioner is alleging that the District failed to assess. Thus, reimbursement for the independent assessment by LMB is denied.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: March 31, 2005 ___________________________________ Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FATHER attended the hearing on February 3 and 4, 2005. MOTHER attended all of the remaining days of hearing.

2 Barbara Smith, District mediation and compliance officer, represented the District on the afternoons of February 8 and 15, 2005.

3Although the issues were discussed during a prehearing telephone conference with the parties and the Hearing Officer, the issues listed here differ slightly in wording and organization from the issues as stated by Petitioner. These differences were made for purposes of clarification and analysis only and include no substantive changes. 4Although Dr. Mack conducted her assessment of STUDENT in October and November 2000, she did not prepare a written report until May 23, 2001.

5 The calculation to determine the required difference for a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement standard scores has been interpreted to be 1.5 standard deviations multiplied by 15, adjusted by one standard error of measurement. That is, the computed difference must be at least 22.5 points, adjusted by the standard of error of measurement not to exceed four common standard points, or between 18.5 and 26.5 points. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A).

6 Petitioner set forth several alleged procedural violations regarding the District’s initial assessments of her in March and June 2000. However, in light of the Hearing Officer’s conclusion that STUDENT was not eligible for special education and related services at that time, there is no need to address those allegations because none of the alleged procedural violations, even if true, would alter the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy was ameliorated within the regular education program.

7 Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. ' 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56031. LRE is not at issue in this matter and thus will not be considered.

8 Petitioner also alleged in her issue statement that the District failed to convene an IEP meeting in June 2002 to discuss a decline in her grades. However, according to the evidence, the District convened IEP meetings on June 13, 2002, and June 21, 2002, attended by all of her teachers, to discuss STUDENT’s educational performance.

9 Petitioner also contends in her issue statement that the District failed to provide her parents with the test scores upon which it relied in proposing to increase her RSP hours. However, it is undisputed that the District increased STUDENT’s RSP time on the basis of her parents’ expressed concern that she was experiencing difficulty with math and not on the basis of any test scores. In fact, the District had not conducted any assessments of STUDENTat the time of the IEP meeting in January 2002.

10 According to a written description prepared by the District for parents, CORE tests measure a student’s academic progress over time and provide individual student growth scores.

11According to Ms. Noyes, Earobics is a computer-based program that helps students with reading and written language; the Write Program teaches capitalization, punctuation, and grammar; and Read Naturally is a reading fluency program.

12 According to a description from LMB, the LiPS program addresses auditory skills, the Seeing Stars program addresses symbol imagery, and the Visualizing and Verbalizing program addresses language usage.

13 MOTHER testified that STUDENT scored at higher levels than her ability level on CORE tests because STUDENT’s teachers helped her with the tests and sometimes gave her the answers. Although the Hearing Officer finds MOTHER’s testimony credible that STUDENT gave her this information, the Hearing Officer gives little weight to these uncorroborated hearsay statements that amount to allegations of seriously unethical behavior on the part of STUDENT’s teachers because they are based entirely upon STUDENT’s report to her mother.

14 Although STUDENT’s parents would like to see her function at grade level, there is no legal requirement that the District ensure that a student functions at grade level. The only legal requirement is that a student’s special education program be designed to enable the student to advance appropriately toward attaining his or her annual goals specified in the student’s IEP and that the student makes more than trivial advancement toward the goals. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., supra, 142 F.3d at 130.

15Petitioner also contends the District excessively charged her parents for a copy of an assessment report sometime in 2002. However, it is undisputed that the District provided her parents with copies of all assessment reports at IEP meetings following the assessments. While FATHER could not recall many details regarding this charge, it is possible that he requested copies of STUDENT’s educational records. Districts have the right to charge parents “no more than the actual cost” of providing copies of educational records. Cal. Educ. Code § 56504.

16 An FAA is an analysis of the causes of inappropriate behaviors for an individual with a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives in the individual’s IEP. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, §§ 3001(f), 3052(b)(2).

17 The evidence reveals that the parents submitted a one- to two-page handwritten dissent, prepared by Mr. Russell, at each IEP meeting. The District attached the dissents to the IEP documents.

18 No witness testified that STUDENT needed an FAA. In fact, STUDENT’s teachers all described her as sweet and well behaved. Her father described her as a “good girl” who just needed help in school. Furthermore, in the letter from Mr. Parkin, he mentions his belief that the request for an FAA was based on a single incident in which the RSP aide expected STUDENT to work on a lesson provided by the RSP teacher rather than on an alternate lesson that STUDENT wanted to pursue. There was no other evidence of STUDENT’s difficulties that would warrant an FAA.

19 The facts in this case are not the same as those in Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District No. 69, 317 F.3d 1072, 1078 (9th Cir. 2003), in which the court held that the district had improperly excluded the parents from the IEP process when it had merely mailed a copy of the IEP to them following the meeting. In this case, the District actually convened an entirely new IEP meeting, with the parents in attendance, for the same purpose as the meeting which the parents did not attend.

20 Although the parents disagreed with the proposal to discontinue mental health services, they permitted the District to no longer provide these services to STUDENT. However, Petitioner did not raise this termination of services as an issue at hearing and provided no evidence regarding her mental health needs after the cessation of services in June 2003.

21Petitioner also contends that the District failed to accurately identify her present levels of performance at the IEP meeting in November 2002. However, according to the evidence, the District did not propose new goals and objectives or discuss present levels of performance in November 2002 but merely attached to the IEP the present levels of performance and goals and objectives from the IEP meeting of June 2002. Moreover, the District had no obligation to identify present levels of performance at this meeting since it was not an annual IEP meeting, and STUDENT was continuing to work on her goals and objectives from her previous IEP.

22 Petitioner also contends that the District failed to allow her parents to choose their own assessors prior to STUDENT’s triennial assessment pursuant to an agreement between the parties reached during mediation discussions. However, there was insufficient evidence presented at hearing regarding the terms of the mediation agreement and therefore nothing in the record to establish that STUDENT’s parents were entitled to choose their own assessors.

23At the IEP meeting in June 2003, the District also proposed discontinuing STUDENT’s mental health counseling services through OCMH. Although the parents disagreed with this proposal, Petitioner did not raise this as an issue at hearing and presented no evidence regarding her mental health needs for the 2003-2004 school year.

24 Furthermore, courts have held that as long as a school district provides an appropriate education, questions of methodology are left to the discretion of the district. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 208. The issue of the appropriateness of the education provided during the 2004-2005 school year will be discussed below.

25 Although no assessor recommended direct speech and language services, at the IEP meeting on January 13, 2005, the parties agreed to provide STUDENT with one period per day of direct speech and language services and developed goals and objectives in the area of speech and language.

26The IEP of September 26, 2000, states that the parents also disagreed with the assessment by audiologist Maria Abramson. However, they did not pursue an independent audiology assessment and did not request an IEE at public expense through this hearing. Therefore, the appropriateness of Ms. Abramson’s assessment is not at i