California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 27, 2003
Student v. Bishop Union Elementary School District et al. (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2840-02 · Hearing Officer Joy Redmon
Bishop Union Elementary and Inyo County Office of Education must provide a total communication class for a deaf student after denying FAPE for three years.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted.
Summary
Bishop Union Elementary School District filed for hearing, and the student's mother filed a week later. The cases were consolidated against the district and the Inyo County Office of Education. The student, a six-year-old first grader with severe to profound hearing loss, got a cochlear implant in 2001. The Hearing Officer found a denial of FAPE in every period at issue. In 2000, the preschool program gave the mother no sign language instruction. Under Education Code section 56441.2, the Hearing Officer found that instruction essential to the child's language development. In 2000-2001, speech therapy was cut and the signing aide was dropped when she moved to a public preschool at Round Valley. The Hearing Officer rejected the claim that she was privately placed. After the implant, House Ear Institute consultant Kathleen Lehnert and speech pathologist Patricia Balthazor testified that she needed a total communication class with a deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) credentialed teacher and peers who sign. General education classes, a temporary "listening" aide, and weekly DHH consultation did not meet those needs. Her goals and five hours a week of speech therapy were appropriate. Within 20 days, the LEAs must provide a self-contained class using Signing Exact English (SEE Sign) with a DHH teacher and at least two DHH peers who sign. If they cannot, they must arrange a transfer or a nonpublic school and pay the related costs. Compensatory relief included that class through 2003-2004, family sign classes, two summers of camp, and $40.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO used Education Code section 56000.5's call for language-mode peers to require DHH signing classmates for a deaf child. It held that a rural location did not excuse the duty. It also treated sign language instruction for a preschooler's parent as a service the child needed and ordered compensatory placement and summer camp.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District and ICOE provide Student a FAPE from April 2000 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including the extended school year?
Goals, preschool placement, speech therapy and signing aides were appropriate, but the lack of sign language instruction for the mother, required for preschoolers' families under Education Code 56441.2, denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the LEAs provide Student with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 extended school year?
Student at the public Round Valley preschool was not a privately placed student; cutting speech therapy and dropping the signing aide based on placement rather than need, with no parent sign instruction, denied FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Did the LEAs provide Student with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, including the 2002 extended school year?
Goals and five hours weekly of speech therapy were appropriate, but placement without a total communication class, DHH teacher, DHH signing peers, a signing aide, or parent sign instruction denied FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 4. Did the LEAs offer Student a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the 2003 ESY, and if not does she require prospectively a total communication classroom with a DHH teacher, a proficient SEE Sign aide, DHH peers, aural habilitation, speech and language therapy, and staff training?
The June 2002 transition plan and December 19, 2002 IEP (general education class with weekly DHH consultation) denied FAPE; goals, therapy, SEE Sign aide and most supports were appropriate if paired with a proper placement.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 5. Is Student entitled to reasonable living expenses in another school district with two return trips to Bishop per month at the LEAs' expense?
Hearing Officer declined to order placement in a non-party district but ordered that if the LEAs cannot provide the program, they must secure an inter-district transfer or NPS and pay tuition, transportation and reasonable living expenses.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6a. Compensatory education: a fifty week program of two hours per week of auditory/verbal and speech and language therapy while school is in session and up to five hours per week when out of session.
Denied; Student's current five hours weekly of speech therapy is sufficient and additional therapy would not compensate for pre-implant losses.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6b. Compensatory education: two hours per week of SEE Sign instruction for Student, Mother, and other available family members for one year.
Granted; two hours weekly for one year, inclusive of the one hour already in the December 2002 IEP.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6c. Compensatory education: three workshops per year related to Student's deafness for Mother, including costs and fees.
Denied; no evidence Mother was denied workshop opportunities, and the LEAs had provided many.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6d. Compensatory education: a total communication summer camp including tuition, living expenses, and transportation for the 2003 and 2004 summers.
Granted for two summers; Hearing Officer also ordered the total communication class placement through 2003-2004 as compensatory education.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7. Is Mother entitled to reimbursement for a sign language class ($40.00) and a training class at House Ear Institute including travel, hotel, and expenses ($300.00)?
$40 sign language class reimbursed; House Ear Institute training denied because its connection to Student's educational needs was not shown.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 days, IEP team must meet to amend the December 19, 2002 IEP; all other IEP terms and program modifications remain the same.
- Placement ordered. Self-contained total communication class using SEE Sign with an emphasis on audition, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher, with a minimum of two DHH peers who use SEE Sign; amended IEP implemented within 20 days.
- If within 20 days the IEP team finds the LEAs cannot provide the program, the LEAs must immediately secure an inter-district transfer or enroll Student in a nonpublic school that can; for an out-of-county non-residential placement, the LEAs pay all reasonable costs including tuition, transportation and associated living expenses (Ojai v. Jackson).
- Compensatory education. Placement in a total communication class with a DHH credentialed teacher and at least two DHH peers who use SEE Sign through the 2003-2004 school year; plan due within 20 days.
- Compensatory education. Two hours per week for one year of SEE Sign instruction for Mother, which Student and other family members may attend (includes the one hour per week in the December 2002 IEP).
- Compensatory education. Total communication summer camp for the 2003 and 2004 summers, LEAs paying tuition, living expenses and transportation; IEP team to identify the camp by April 1, 2003, considering Student's age and whether Mother can attend.
- Reimbursement. $40.00 to Mother for a sign language class, within 20 days.
Total: $40 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; School Comm. of Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Ojai Unified School Dist. v. Jackson; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School Dist.; Education Code 56441.2; Education Code 56000.5(b)(4); 5 CCR 3065
People named in the decision
- Howard Lehwald, District director of special education, Bishop Union Elementary School District
- Al Sasuga (also spelled Alvin Sausuga), SELPA director, SELPA
- Mary Rohen, General education teacher with DHH credential; LEA witness, Bishop Union Elementary School District
- Lynne Andreyack-Clark (Lynne Clark), Speech-language therapist and special education preschool teacher, Inyo County Office of Education
- Kathleen (Kathy) Lehnert, Speech-language pathologist and educational consultant; expert witness, House Ear Institute
- Susan (Sue) Grant, Speech-language therapist, LEAs
- Jody Clover, Speech-language therapist, Bishop Union Elementary School District
- Dorothy Canfield, First grade general education teacher, Bishop Union Elementary School District
- Patricia Balthazor, Speech pathologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Brenda Ongley, Speech-language therapist, Bishop Union Elementary School District
- Martin (Marty) Hogue, Special education preschool teacher (Small Steps SDC), Inyo County Office of Education
- Terri Kelley, Kindergarten teacher, Bishop Union Elementary School District
- Suzanne Roepke, School psychologist, Bishop Union Elementary School District
- Donna Hogue, Infant development specialist, Inyo County Office of Education
- Heather King, 1:1 signing aide, Inyo County Office of Education
- Kathy Waasdorp, 1:1 signing aide, Inyo County Office of Education
- Ms. Turney, Preschool teacher (CCARE program), Round Valley Elementary School
- Ms. Aguilera, Preschool classroom aide, Round Valley Elementary School
- Linda Dye, Director of auditory-verbal program; staff trainer, Children's Choice for Hearing and Talking (CCHAT)
- Virginia Smith, 1:1 listening aide, Bishop Union Elementary School District
- Jennifer Still, Speech-language pathologist; post-implant evaluator, House Ear Institute
- John Schmidt, Consultant, AG Bell (Utah)
- Jenny Buchanan, ASL signing aide, Bishop Union Elementary School District
- Kit Niehans, 1:1 SEE Sign aide, Bishop Union Elementary School District
- Warren Easterbrooks, Presenter of training class, House Ear Institute
- House Ear Institute, Private medical/audiology and consultation provider
- Crown Valley Elementary School, Public total communication program considered for placement, Capistrano Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Joy Redmon, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific. The matter proceeded to hearing in Bishop, California, on January 14-17 and 21, 2003.
Bishop Union Elementary School District (District ) and Inyo County Office of Education (ICOE) were represented at hearing by attorney Lauri LaFoe. Also present on behalf of the District and ICOE (collectively LEAs) were Howard Lehwald, district director of special education, and Al Sasuga, director of the special education local plan area (SELPA).
STUDENT (Student) was represented at hearing by attorney Geralyn Clancy. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was her mother MOTHER.
The LEAs called the following witnesses: Mary Rohen, general education teacher with deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) teaching credential; and Alvin Sausuga, SELPA director.(Footnote 1)
STUDENT called the following witnesses: Lynne Andreyack-Clark, speech therapist; Kathleen Lehnert, educational consultant from House Ear Institute; Susan Grant, speech therapist; Jody Clover, speech therapist; MOTHER; Dorothy Canfield, first grade teacher; Patricia Balthazor, speech pathologist; Howard Lehwald; Brenda Ongley, speech therapist; Martin Hogue, special education pre-school teacher; Terri Kelley, kindergarten teacher; and Suzanne Roepke, school psychologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties submitted written closing briefs. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 2)
1. Did the District and ICOE (collectively LEAs) provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from April 2000 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including the extended school year?
2. Did the LEAs provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 extended school year?
3. Did the LEAs provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, including the 2002 extended school year?
4. Did the LEAs offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the 2003 extended school year, and if not does she require prospectively a total communication classroom with a DHH teacher, a proficient SEE Sign aide, DHH and general education peers, aural habilitation, speech and language therapy, and staff training to receive a FAPE?
5. Is STUDENT entitled to reasonable living expenses in another school district with two return trips to Bishop per month at the LEAs’ expense?
6. If the LEAs denied STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to the following as compensatory education:
(a) A fifty week program consisting of two hours per week of auditory/verbal therapy and speech and language therapy while school is in session and a maximum of five hours per week when school is out of session;
(b) Two hours per week of SEE Sign sign language instruction to be attended by STUDENT, MOTHER, and other available family members for one year;
(c) Three workshops related to STUDENT’s deafness per year for MOTHER, including costs and fees; and (d) A total communication summer camp for STUDENT including tuition, living expenses, and transportation for the 2003 and 2004 summers?
7. Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for a sign language class in the amount of $40.00, and for a training class at House Ear Institute, including travel, hotel, and expenses, in the amount of $300.00?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
STUDENT’s contentions are divided into two time periods, before and after her cochlear implant. Prior to the activation of her implant, STUDENT contends that the LEAs denied her a FAPE because they did not provide a one-to-one aide who was proficient in SEE Sign (signing exact English.) Additionally, STUDENT contends that she was not provided a sufficient amount of speech and language therapy to support her auditory and language needs. Finally, STUDENT contends that the LEAs were required to provide sign language training for her mother, MOTHER, so she could communicate with STUDENT. STUDENT contends that after her cochlear implant was activated, her needs intensified. In addition to the contentions above, STUDENT required aural habilitation, a placement that combined oral language and SEE Sign with an emphasis on audition, a DHH credentialed teacher, and DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign. STUDENT contends that prospectively she requires a total communication class, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher, containing both general education and DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign. Further, STUDENT asserts that such a placement cannot be provided in Inyo County. Therefore, she requests that the LEAs place her in another public school out of the County, pay for living expenses, and provide transportation expenses so that she and her mother can return to Bishop two times per month to visit family. STUDENT also contends that the LEAs committed procedural violations which resulted in a denial of FAPE by failing to provide MOTHER meaningful access during IEP meetings.(Footnote 3)
The LEAs contend that at all times STUDENT was entitled to a FAPE, the LEAs provided a FAPE. Additionally, the LEAs contend that while STUDENT attended Round Valley, she was a unilaterally privately placed student not entitled to a FAPE. The LEAs further contend that the IEP developed during the December 19, 2003, meeting constitutes its current offer of placement. The LEAs argue that this offer is a FAPE. However, the LEAs request that if the Hearing Officer finds that it is not a FAPE, that the LEAs be allowed to correct any defect in STUDENT’s program.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a six-year-old student who lives within the boundaries of the District. STUDENT contracted bacterial spinal meningitis at twenty-months of age. Thereafter, STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, began to notice changes in STUDENT, such as a decreased use of oral communication and difficulty balancing. STUDENT was referred to the House Ear Institute (HEI) in Los Angeles, by her pediatrician. In October of 1998, the HEI diagnosed STUDENT with a severe to profound sensorineural hearing loss resulting from meningitis. STUDENT’s cognitive abilities were within the superior to gifted range.
In September of 1998, STUDENT was found eligible for special education services under Part C of the IDEA because of her hearing impairment. STUDENT received services from the Inyo County Office of Education (ICOE) pursuant to an individual family services plan (IFSP). In STUDENT’s initial IFSP, dated October 16, 1998, Donna Hogue, the ICOE infant development specialist documented that “a total communication approach will be the focus of her program.” (Ex P-40).(Footnote 4)
In January of 1999, STUDENT received binaural hearing aides; however, they were not successful in enhancing her ability to hear. HEI then recommended that STUDENT learn sign language and that a strong emphasis should be placed on language and communication through exposure to sign. (Ex P-43, 43-A) STUDENT received services from the ICOE until approximately May of 1999.
STUDENT and her mother, MOTHER, moved to Las Vegas, Nevada in June of 1999. STUDENT continued to receive special education services while living in Nevada. As part of the program in Las Vegas, STUDENT was learning American Sign Language (ASL). Sign language was STUDENT’s primary language. The family returned to Bishop in March of 2000.
Upon her return to Bishop, STUDENT was enrolled in the ICOE’s special day class preschool program called Small Steps which was taught by Marty Hogue. Mr. Hogue is a credentialed special education teacher who possessed limited signing ability. STUDENT was assigned a one-to-one signing aide, Heather King. Mr. Hogue testified that he primarily relied upon Ms. King’s signing ability in communicating with STUDENT. STUDENT received two sixty-minute speech and language sessions per week provided by speech and language therapist (SLT) Sue Grant. During the 1999-2000 extended school year (ESY), STUDENT attended the ICOE’s special day class preschool program taught by Lynne Clark. Ms. Clark is an SLT and credentialed special education teacher. Ms. Clark testified that she was a beginning signer at that time. STUDENT was assigned Heather King as her signing aide for two weeks of the ESY program and Kathy Waasdorp, another signing aide, for the remaining two weeks of the ESY.
STUDENT began the 2000-2001 school year in the ICOE’s special day class (SDC) preschool program taught by Mr. Hogue. STUDENT continued with the same level of speech and language services as she had had the previous year. Although she was also offered a one-to-one signing aide, no one was available. Ms. King resigned from her position and had not yet been replaced. Mr. Hogue explained that the SDC preschool class contained approximately five or six special needs children and several general education children. STUDENT was the only hearing impaired child. MOTHER testified that she found the classroom to be “too noisy” and that the other children were very active. She also testified that transportation to and from the ICOE’s preschool was difficult because of her work schedule and day care needs.
MOTHER explained that in September of 2000, she attended an open house at Round Valley Elementary School. The preschool program at Round Valley is named the CCARE (catching children at risk early) program and is funded by the state. MOTHER spoke with the preschool teacher, Ms. Turney, and the classroom aide, Ms. Aguilera. According to MOTHER, both Ms. Turney and Ms. Aguilera told her that if STUDENT attended their program, they were willing to take sign language classes to communicate with STUDENT.
Thereafter, MOTHER stopped bringing STUDENT to Mr. Hogue’s class and requested that STUDENT’s placement be changed to Round Valley. An addendum IEP meeting was held on September 15, 2000, to consider MOTHER’s request to place STUDENT at Round Valley. The IEP team reiterated its offer of speech and language services at least two times per week. Regarding placement, the LEA members of the IEP team determined that STUDENT should remain in the “Bishop special education preschool with [a] signing aide on a daily basis to reinforce signing and speech skills.” (Ex-LEA 3) However, at the end of the meeting it was determined that STUDENT would attend Round Valley. The addendum was incorporated into STUDENT’s IEP, and MOTHER consented to it. STUDENT attended a public general education preschool class at Round Valley for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year. She received one thirty-minute session of speech and language therapy per week from Lynne Clark through December. When school commenced after winter break, STUDENT received an additional thirty-minute session per week from another SLT, Sue Grant, through the end of the regular school year. STUDENT did not have a one-to-one signing aide while at Round Valley.
Ms. Turney, Ms. Aguilera, and MOTHER enrolled in an evening ASL class to develop their signing skills. Ms. Clark requested signing instruction from the ICOE. Ms. Clark received three consultation sessions from STUDENT’s former signing aide, Ms. Waasdorp.
In the meantime, STUDENT was being evaluated by HEI to determine if she were a candidate for a cochlear implant.(Footnote 5) HEI determined that STUDENT was a candidate and California Children Services agreed to fund the procedure. An annual IEP meeting was held on April 25, 2001. The IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s progress. The team discussed the impending implantation, and drafted two annual goals in the area of language development, a receptive language goal and an expressive language goal. Each emphasized the use of sign language and total communication. The IEP team deferred finalizing STUDENT’s 2001-2002 IEP until after her surgery and agreed to reconvene prior to the commencement of the next school year.
On June 11, 2001, STUDENT underwent surgery for the cochlear implant. On July 10, 2001, STUDENT’s IEP team met to discuss her post implant needs. HEI recommended that post implant, STUDENT should have intensive therapy including five one-hour sessions per week of individual hearing therapy and speech and language therapy. HEI also recommended “total communication with strong auditory emphasis” (Ex P 107-111) The IEP team considered HEI’s recommendations and again deferred finalizing STUDENT’s IEP until after her cochlear implant had been activated.
On July 16, 2001, STUDENT’s implant was activated and she underwent her first mapping.(Footnote 6) Both Ms. Clark and Ms. Grant were present at HEI, at the LEAs’ expense, for the activation and to observe therapy sessions. STUDENT was in southern California for the majority of the 2000-2001 ESY and was therefore unable to attend the ESY program. On their own time, Ms. Clark and Ms. Grant provided therapy to STUDENT in her home, one hour per day, five days per week throughout the remainder of the summer.
A “review options” IEP meeting was held on August 23, 2001 to assess STUDENT’s needs with a cochlear implant and to finalize an IEP to address her placement and services for the 2001-2002 school year. At that time, the IEP team revised STUDENT’s goals pursuant to conversations between Ms. Clark, Ms. Grant, and Kathy Lehnert, a speech and language pathologist and educational consultant from HEI. The IEP team determined that STUDENT should be placed in the ICOE’s special day class preschool program in the morning and the District’s general education kindergarten program in the afternoon. Speech and language therapy was offered five days per week for one hour per day. At the suggestion of Ms. Lehnert, Ms. Clark requested that the LEAs purchase the WASP program (a post cochlear implant supplemental program) to be used during therapy sessions. The program was ordered pursuant to the IEP. STUDENT was also to be provided a signing aide during the kindergarten portion of her program in the District. The IEP states that STUDENT’s program would be total communication with an auditory-verbal emphasis. MOTHER consented to the IEP. The District began its search for a qualified signing aide using job postings and advertisements in the local newspaper.
During the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT was in Mr. Hogue’s class in the morning and in a general education kindergarten class taught by Terri Kelley in the afternoon. Ms. Kelly had minimal signing abilities. Ms. Grant provided therapy in the SDC two days per week and SLT Brenda Ongley provided STUDENT’s therapy at the District three days per week. Despite the LEAs’ efforts to hire a signing aide, no one applied for the position. STUDENT started the year without an aide.
The LEAs held various training sessions for staff working with STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year because STUDENT was the first student in the County with a cochlear implant. Before the school year began, the staff working with STUDENT viewed a video series entitled “Bringing Sounds to Life” to familiarize themselves with cochlear implants and the process of working with a child after implantation. On September 10, 2001, the County sponsored training by Linda Dye, the director of an auditory-verbal program, Children’s Choice for Hearing and Talking (CCHAT), which was attended by most of the staff working with STUDENT, including Mr. Hogue, Ms. Kelley, Ms. Grant, and Ms. Ongley. According to Ms. Grant, the attendees discussed the unavailability of a signing aide for STUDENT. Ms. Grant testified that Ms. Dye recommended utilizing a “listening aide” until a signing aide could be hired.
MOTHER was approached regarding a listening aide for STUDENT until a signing aide could be hired. On September 19, 2001, MOTHER consented to an addendum IEP which states, “due to no availability of a signing aide, the district will provide a ‘listening’ aide to support STUDENT in the class. This person will be taught some basic signs in case of an emergency.” In response to the addendum, the LEAs provided Virginia Smith (no relation to MOTHER) as STUDENT’s one-to-one aide on a temporary basis. Virginia Smith was only a beginning signer and utilized sign language books for assistance in communicating with STUDENT. The LEAs continued the search for a signing aide; however, at some point, Virginia Smith was hired as STUDENT’s aide and continued to work with STUDENT through the rest of the 2001-2002 school year.
The LEAs continued to provide training opportunities to the staff throughout the school year. On October 11, 2001, Ms. Lehnert from HEI traveled to Bishop and observed STUDENT in her school setting. Ms. Lehnert also provided a staff in-service for the individuals working with STUDENT.
On January 4, 2002, STUDENT underwent a six-month post-implant evaluation at HEI by Jennifer Still, SLT. Ms. Still suggested including supplemental aural habilitation in STUDENT’s program.(Footnote 7) After this evaluation, MOTHER prepared a list of concerns that she wanted to discuss with STUDENT’s IEP team.
A “communication meeting” was held on January 29, 2002, pursuant to MOTHER’s request. MOTHER was not able to attend; however, she requested that Ms. Clark (STUDENT’s former SLT) appear on her behalf and present MOTHER’s concerns. The District members in attendance believed that MOTHER should be present so the meeting was rescheduled for February 12, 2002.
The February 12, 2002, meeting was an addendum IEP meeting. MOTHER presented a list of ten concerns including requests for STUDENT’s class schedule, monthly meetings, a daily journal, signing books for the staff working with STUDENT, a signing aide, and access to videos for staff. MOTHER also requested that Virginia Smith utilize the auditory sandwich approach with STUDENT(Footnote 8). The meeting notes indicate that each concern was addressed individually. MOTHER consented to the addendum.
On March 18, 2002, John Schmidt, a consultant from AG Bell in Utah, traveled to Bishop to observe STUDENT and provide recommendations to the staff. Mr. Schmidt expressed concern that too much emphasis was placed on sign language for STUDENT and there was a lack of commitment to an auditory-oral approach. The following month, in April of 2002, Ms. Lehnert returned to Bishop to observe STUDENT again. She echoed the concerns of Mr. Schmidt. In her report Ms. Lehnert indicated that the goals and objectives drafted for STUDENT were “quite appropriate.” However, Ms. Lehnert went on to say that STUDENT required a self-contained total communication class with a strong emphasis on audition. Ms. Lehnert also recommended that the LEAs purchase an FM system for STUDENT’s classroom, which was purchased. Additionally, Ms. Lehnert suggested that the staff working with STUDENT visit DHH programs in the Los Angeles area to observe total communication classrooms with a strong emphasis on audition.
On June 4, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team met to develop her IEP for the 2002-2003 school year. According to Mr. Hogue and Ms. Kelley, STUDENT had met most of the kindergarten standards established by the State. The IEP team determined that STUDENT should move to first grade. The IEP team agreed to continue speech and language therapy five times per week. Ms. Grant drafted two goals and objectives for STUDENT in the area of listening and auditory oral skills. The team also agreed to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one aide, and the LEAs would continue to search for a person with proficient signing abilities. MOTHER consented to this IEP.
On June 27, 2002, the HEI conducted a one-year post-implant evaluation of STUDENT. Ms. Still determined that “STUDENT’s sign language skills have plateaued since her pre-CI evaluation...” Ms. Still also found that STUDENT had made minimal progress in her understanding of oral language. (Ex. P-88) HEI again recommended a self-contained total communication classroom with a strong emphasis on audition.
On August 22, 2002, MOTHER presented a list of eight requests to the LEAs to incorporate into STUDENT’s 2002-2003 IEP. On August 30, 2002, the IEP team met to address MOTHER’s requests. Each request was addressed individually. Additionally, the IEP team discussed a shift in the sign language being used with STUDENT. Up to this point, STUDENT, as well as the individuals working with her had been utilizing a combination of ASL and SEE Sign However, the recommendation from Ms. Lehnert was to shift from ASL to SEE Sign. Finally, Mr. Sausuga (SELPA director) suggested that members of STUDENT’s IEP team visit Crown Valley Elementary in Southern California to observe a total communication classroom.
During the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT is attending a regular education first grade class taught by Dorothy Canfield. She has received one hour per day, five days per week of speech and language therapy taught by SLT Jody Clover. From the beginning of the school year through the end of October, Virginia remained STUDENT’s aide. Virginia was replaced by Jenny Buchanan an ASL signing aide, but according to Ms. Canfield, STUDENT also had numerous substitute aides through winter break. In January, Kit Niehans was hired as STUDENT’s SEE Sign one-to-one aide.
During the fall of 2002, Mr. Lehwald (District director of special education) organized a visit to Crown Valley for staff members and MOTHER. According to Mr. Lehwald, the purpose of the visit was to observe the program and improve STUDENT’s program in the District. The visit took place on October 11, 2002.
Following the visit to Crown Valley, MOTHER sent a letter to STUDENT’s IEP team requesting that STUDENT be placed at Crown Valley, a public school in the Capistrano Unified School District. An IEP meeting was held on November 1, 2002, to consider MOTHER’s placement request. The LEA members of the IEP team rejected MOTHER’s request. The IEP team agreed to send Ms. Grant to HEI for further training. MOTHER disagreed with the team’s determination.
Later that day, Mr. Lehwald sent a letter to MOTHER documenting the reasons for rejecting her request to place STUDENT at Crown Valley. Mr. Lehwald indicated that the LEAs agreed to consult with Crown Valley to provide support for STUDENT’s program.
Ms. Clover, STUDENT’s SLT, consulted with Kathy Lehnert regarding STUDENT’s goals, objectives, and progress. Ms. Clover drafted new goals and objectives pursuant to Ms. Lehnert’s recommendations. In order to determine whether or not these goals could be incorporated into STUDENT’s IEP, a meeting was necessary. Mr. Lehwald testified that he scheduled an IEP meeting for December 19, 2002. One week prior, he sent MOTHER notice of the meeting. On December 18, 2002, he called MOTHER at work and asked if she would be attending the meeting. According to MOTHER, she told Mr. Lehwald that she had not received the notice of the meeting and was not available at the time it was scheduled because of work. Mr. Lehwald telephoned her later that day and asked if she could attend if the meeting were rescheduled until after her work hours. MOTHER told Mr. Lehwald that she would not attend the meeting without her attorney present and that she would not be able to have her attorney present the following day.
The IEP meeting proceeded without MOTHER on December 19, 2002.(Footnote 9) The goals and objectives drafted by Ms. Clover were incorporated into the IEP. Additionally, the IEP contains a page entitled Program Modification and Support.(Footnote 10) Mr. Lehwald sent a copy of the IEP to MOTHER.
MOTHER did not consent to the IEP. The District filed for a due process hearing. MOTHER filed for a due process hearing the following week. The matters were consolidated at the joint request of the parties.
Issue 1: Did the LEAs provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from April 2000 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including the extended school year?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the students at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the students’ individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (8). The student’s IEP must provide, among other things, for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other non-academic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities.
In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, the educational program must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, to provide the student with some educational benefit, prepare the student for employment and independent living, provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other non-academic activities, and the program must conform with the students’ IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176. Additionally, all of these conditions must have been met in a placement that constitutes the least restrictive environment. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Education Code § 56031.)
In this case regarding the denial of FAPE, Petitioner alleges that the programs provided did not meet her unique needs, and that the IEPs were not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in acquiring a language system. The other specific provisions of FAPE are not at issue in this case.
Unique Needs 1999-2000(Footnote 11)
To determine whether or not the LEAs’ program for the 1999-2000 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs it is first necessary to determine what those needs were. Generally, the parties are in agreement regarding STUDENT’s pre-implant needs. At that time, STUDENT was a three-year-old preschool student. The parties agree that STUDENT had a severe to profound hearing loss and that she relied upon sign language as her primary mode of communication. Further, the parties agree that STUDENT’s primary area of need was the development of a language system, including expressive and receptive language. In order to develop a language system, STUDENT needed interaction with other individuals with sign language capabilities above her own level to continue developing her sign language skills. Finally, the parties agree that as a preschool student, STUDENT needed to develop pre-academic or academic readiness skills. In addition to the needs described above, STUDENT asserts that her unique need to increase her signing ability also required sign language instruction for her mother. STUDENT alleged that her need to develop a language system required sign language instruction for MOTHER so they could engage in reciprocal conversation at home. Kathy Lehnert, a speech pathologist and educational consultant from HEI, testified regarding the need for MOTHER to develop sign language skills. Ms. Lehnert holds a masters degree in aural rehabilitation from the University of Maryland. She has worked with DHH and cochlear implanted students since approximately 1995. Ms. Lehnert is one of several professionals from HEI who has worked with STUDENT for several years. She was also hired by the LEAs to provide consultation services to the individuals working with STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Lehnert a credible witness who is knowledgeable regarding STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Lehnert explained that prior to her implant, STUDENT’s primary mode of communication was sign language. For STUDENT to develop language skills she needed to be surrounded by people she could communicate with both at school and at home. According to Ms. Lehnert, it was critical to meet this need that MOTHER, the person who spent the most time with STUDENT, needed to develop sign language skills. If MOTHER was not able to communicate with STUDENT, it would have significantly delayed STUDENT’s ability to acquire language. In light of the testimony of Ms. Lehnert, the Hearing Officer finds STUDENT’s needs included sign language instruction for MOTHER.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year were the development of a language system, including expressive and receptive language, the continued development of her sign language capabilities, and continued development of her pre-academic skills. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required speech and language therapy, a one-to-one proficient sign language aide, and sign language instruction for MOTHER.
Having identified STUDENT’s unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year, the Hearing Officer addresses whether or not the program provided by the District was designed to meet her unique needs.
Goals and objectives were drafted for STUDENT in the areas of expressive language, receptive language, and academic readiness skills. STUDENT’s first annual goals focused on improving receptive language skills for comprehension of sign. The benchmarks identified under this goal included increasing STUDENT’s ability to recognize signs for animals, body parts, clothing, school items, household objects, people, and holidays. Additionally, STUDENT was to comprehend yes, no, who, what, and where questions by giving the correct sign when prompted. The third benchmark developed to help STUDENT develop receptive language was following two to three step directions using signs that describe color, quantity, size, and spatial relationship. STUDENT’s second goal addressed improving her expressive language skills using total communication. The benchmarks for this goal included increasing STUDENT’s sign vocabulary by 75-100 words, developing STUDENT’s ability to express her wants in two-to-three word phrases (using sign), and developing her ability to orally create the production of vowel sounds.
Ms. Grant testified that these goals were designed to meet STUDENT’s speech and language needs as well as increase her sign language capabilities. Ms. Grant worked with STUDENT two times per week for sixty minutes per-session during that year. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Grant a credible witness who is knowledgeable about STUDENT’s needs. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique speech and language needs.
Additionally, a pre-academic goal was drafted for STUDENT. The pre-academic goal focused on STUDENT’s ability to identify textures, match geometric forms with pictures of shapes, and identify body parts. Mr. Hogue testified that these activities were appropriate for STUDENT as a preschooler and met her pre-academic needs. Mr. Hogue worked with STUDENT five days per week and observed her both in class and on the playground. The Hearing Officer finds Mr. Hogue a credible witness who is knowledgeable about STUDENT’s needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal and objectives regarding pre-academics were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives contained in STUDENT’s April 2000, IEP were designed to meet her unique speech and language and pre-academic needs.
STUDENT’s IEP called for placement in the ICOE’s special day class (SDC) preschool, Small Steps, to implement her pre-academic goal. Although this placement is described as an SDC, Mr. Hogue, the teacher, clarified the placement. Mr. Hogue explained that the program was a combination of general education and special education preschoolers. He had five to six SDC students (including STUDENT) and the remainder of the approximately twenty students were general education preschoolers. According to Mr. Hogue, this program gave him the opportunity to work in small groups and one-to-one with STUDENT on her pre-academic goal and it also gave STUDENT the opportunity to socialize and interact with numerous students to develop her emerging language and social skills. Mr. Hogue also clarified that this placement was appropriate because he was able to communicate with STUDENT through her one-to-one sign language aide. In light of the credible testimony of Mr. Hogue, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.
STUDENT’s IEP team also determined that she required certain designated instruction and services (DIS) to meet her needs. STUDENT’s IEP called for speech and language services two times per week, sixty-minutes per session. Additionally, STUDENT’s IEP provided for a signing aide.
STUDENT argued generally that two sixty-minute sessions of speech and language per week were not sufficient to meet her needs. The LEAs dispute this contention and argue that this was a sufficient amount of therapy to meet STUDENT’s needs at that time. Ms. Grant provided STUDENT’s speech and language therapy identified in her IEP. Ms. Grant credibly testified that two sixty-minute speech and language therapy sessions were a sufficient amount of time to implement STUDENT’s speech and language goals. STUDENT presented no evidence to the contrary.
The Hearing Officer has determined above that STUDENT’s speech and language goals and objectives were designed to meet her unique needs. In light of Ms. Grant’s testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the amount of time provided for STUDENT to implement those goals and objectives was also appropriate.
STUDENT’s IEP team also determined that STUDENT required a one-to-one signing aide. Heather King was assigned to STUDENT for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year and for two weeks of the ESY. Kathy Waasdorp was STUDENT’s signing aide for the second two weeks of the ESY. There is no dispute that both Ms. King and Ms. Waasdorp possessed sign language abilities above STUDENT’s ability level. (Testimony of Mr. Hogue, Ms. Grant, MOTHER, and Ms. Clark)
STUDENT argued in her closing brief that despite their ability level, they were not certified as required by law.(Footnote 12) During the hearing, however, STUDENT raised the issue of the aides’ proficiency rather than their credentials or certification as defined in the California Code of Regulations. The failure to raise the credential issue deprived the LEAs of the ability to respond during the hearing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not analyze the credential status of Ms. King and Ms. Waasdorp. However, even if Ms. King and Ms. Waasdorp did not possess the credentials required under the Code, that failure alone would not necessarily result in a denial of FAPE. The uncontested testimony was that both Ms. King and Ms. Waasdorp possessed signing abilities above STUDENT’s. Mr. Hogue testified that he relied upon Ms. King to translate between he and STUDENT. Ms. Clark, STUDENT’s teacher during the ESY testified that Ms. Waasdorp was a proficient signer who provided sign language instruction to Ms. Clark so she could improve her own ability to communicate with STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that even if Ms. King and Ms. Waasdorp were not credentialed, they met STUDENT’s need for a one-to-one sign language aide.
STUDENT also argued that her mother, MOTHER, required sign language instruction. The Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT’s unique needs required her mother to have sign language instruction for STUDENT to develop language. However, STUDENT’s IEP does not include sign language services for MOTHER. The LEAs argued generally that they were not required by law to provide services directly to MOTHER.
California Education Code section 56441.2 provides that special education programs for children between the ages of three and five “shall include specially designed services to meet the unique needs of preschool children and their families.” (emphasis added) The evidence established that a critical need of STUDENT’s was sign language instruction for MOTHER so STUDENT could develop a language system. The Hearing Officer finds that the LEAs failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs by not providing sign language instruction for MOTHER.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the program offered by the LEAs for the 1999-2000 school year was designed to meet some of STUDENT’s unique needs. However, a critical component of STUDENT’s program was missing. According to the testimony of Ms. Lehnert, STUDENT’s ability to acquire a language system was significantly delayed without the ability to communicate with her mother. Therefore, the program offered by the LEAs was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique need to communicate with her mom.
Educational Benefit
As determined above, STUDENT’s April 2000 IEP did not meet her unique needs because of the failure to provide sign language instruction to MOTHER. In order to provide a FAPE, the program that was implemented by the LEAs must also have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
The program implemented by the LEAs failed to address some of STUDENT’s unique needs. The evidence established that the ability for STUDENT to utilize sign in a reciprocal manner was critical to her development of a language system. MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, testified that she spent more time with STUDENT daily than STUDENT spent at preschool. MOTHER explained that she was frustrated with the lack of a reliable communication system between her and STUDENT. Ms. Lehnert credibly testified that the ability for STUDENT to develop language by communicating with her mother was critical. This critical component in STUDENT’s education as a preschooler was hindered by the lack of signing instruction for MOTHER. The Hearing Officer finds that this was a significant defect in her program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s April 2000 IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit in her most critical area of need.
Comport with her IEP
There was no allegation that the program implemented by the LEAs failed to comport with STUDENT’s April 2000 IEP. Accordingly, it will not be addressed by the Hearing Officer.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP for the 1999-2000 school year did not meet some of STUDENT’s unique needs. Further, because a critical component in STUDENT’s program was missing, it was not reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year.
Issue 2: Did the LEAs provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 extended school year?
The IEP drafted in April of 2000 was intended to remain in effect through April of 2001. STUDENT turned four years old in August of 2000, and her IEP team contemplated that she would remain in Mr. Hogue’s preschool class through at least April of 2001 (testimony of Mr. Hogue). However, in early September of 2000, MOTHER stopped bringing STUDENT to class and requested an IEP meeting to change her placement from Mr. Hogue’s class to a general education preschool class at Round Valley Elementary School, a public school.
STUDENT’s IEP team met on September 15, 2000. The meeting was identified as an “other review/program options” meeting. MOTHER testified that she attended an open house at Round Valley. MOTHER liked the program and wanted STUDENT to attend. Al Sasuga, SELPA director, testified regarding the meeting. He testified that during the meeting the IEP team discussed MOTHER’s request. The LEA members of the team believed STUDENT should remain in Mr. Hogue’s class. Mr. Sasuga testified that he explained to MOTHER that Round Valley’s preschool program was funded by the state and that fewer services would be available to STUDENT there. According to Mr. Sasuga, MOTHER informed the team that transportation to and from Round Valley was more convenient for her family and that she wanted STUDENT to attend the program.
At the conclusion of the meeting, it was determined that STUDENT would attend Round Valley. Her speech and language therapy would be reduced to one time per week for thirty minutes. The classroom was assigned an aide; however, STUDENT would not have a one-to-one aide at Round Valley. MOTHER signed an “addendum” IEP form agreeing to a reduction in services.
At hearing, the LEAs argued that Round Valley’s preschool program was funded by the State and the SELPA considers students that attend Round Valley to be private school students. The LEAs argued that STUDENT was a unilaterally privately placed student who was not entitled to a FAPE during the time she attended Round Valley. This argument is unpersuasive.
Round Valley is a public school located in the Round Valley Elementary School District. The school district is located in Bishop which is within the County. Even if the Hearing Officer were persuaded that MOTHER rejected the LEAs’ offer, STUDENT was not a private school student because Round Valley is a public school. At all times, the LEAs provided STUDENT services pursuant to an IEP. There is no indication in her IEP that STUDENT was considered a privately placed student. Even assuming, arguendo, that STUDENT were a privately placed student that the LEAs determined was entitled to some DIS services, those services would have been provided pursuant to a service plan as opposed to an IEP. Further, if the LEAs believed MOTHER was rejecting their offer, and they believed that the offer was a FAPE, the LEAs should have requested a due process hearing to make that determination. Instead, the LEAs continued to provide DIS services to STUDENT pursuant to an active IEP. For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer rejects the argument that STUDENT was a privately placed student for the 2000-2001 school year. Further, the LEAs undertook to provide STUDENT’s program during that year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the LEAs were required to provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
It has been determined above that the operative IEP from April 2000 through April 2001 did not constitute a FAPE. Additionally, the addendum IEP reduced the amount of speech therapy STUDENT was to receive and eliminated a one-to-one signing aide. This decision was not based upon STUDENT’s unique needs. Rather, the reduction in services was based upon her placement at Round Valley. It was determined above that the LEAs were responsible for providing STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the LEAs did not provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year.(Footnote 13)
Issue 3: Did the LEAs provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, including the 2002 extended school year?
Unique Needs (2001-2002)
Generally the parties agree upon several of STUDENT’s unique needs post-implant. As noted above, during the Summer of 2001, STUDENT received and had activated a cochlear implant. According to Ms. Lehnert, the cochlear implant allowed STUDENT to hear each sound in the English language; however, STUDENT was unable to attach meaning to the sounds she was now able to hear. Therefore, STUDENT’s most significant need was to develop a language system that included hearing, comprehending, and attaching meaning to what she heard.
HEI conducted an assessment of STUDENT prior to her implant to develop a base line regarding her expressive and receptive language skills. (Ex. LEA-34) Even utilizing sign language during her testing, STUDENT’s aural receptive language abilities as measured by the Reynell Developmental Language Scale (RDLS) were in the first percentile with an age equivalent of two years and two months (a two year and three month delay). The RDLS also revealed that STUDENT’s expressive language abilities were in the first percentile with an age equivalent of two years and four months (a two year and six month delay). The assessment also revealed that STUDENT had “significantly delayed speech production skills when compared to her same-aged, normally hearing peers.”
The parties agree that the above testing revealed STUDENT needed intensive auditory/verbal therapy post-implant for the development of a language system. Additionally, since STUDENT’s primary language was sign, she needed to continue developing those skills in order to have a language system. To facilitate this, the parties agree that STUDENT continued to need a one-to-one signing aide.
According to the credible testimony of Ms. Lehnert, after STUDENT’s implant was activated, she also needed to shift from ASL to SEE Sign. SEE Sign follows the syntax of the English language and facilitates the transition between signing and speaking.
In summary, STUDENT’s primary undisputed need for the 2001-2002 school year was to develop a language system including sign, aural, and oral language. Additionally, to accomplish this, STUDENT needed intensive therapy to improve her expressive and receptive language. STUDENT also needed to continue developing her sign language skills using SEE Sign with a one-to-one aide. The parties dispute the remainder of STUDENT’s needs.
STUDENT argues that to develop a language system, she needed a comprehensive program that was consistently implemented by all adults working with her. To provide the consistency STUDENT needed, she argues that she required a total communication class taught by a DHH credentialed teacher who was proficient in SEE Sign. A total communication class, argued STUDENT, would require all material (including curriculum and classroom directions) to be presented both orally and with SEE Sign. Additionally, STUDENT argues that her needs required other DHH peers who utilized SEE Sign. Finally, STUDENT argues that to meet her need to develop a language system, MOTHER required sign language instruction.
The LEAs argue that STUDENT needed a total communication approach rather than a total communication classroom. As such, according to the LEAs, STUDENT’s service providers (e.g. SLT and aide) needed to utilize total communication while providing services; the remainder of the time, STUDENT could function without total communication. The LEAs also argued that STUDENT did not require a DHH credentialed teacher. Further, the LEAs argued that STUDENT’s needs could be met without other DHH peers.
The Hearing Officer will analyze the parties’ contentions to identify whether or not they were STUDENT’s unique needs.
Several witnesses testified regarding STUDENT’s needs after she received her cochlear implant. Ms. Lehnert, educational consultant from HEI testified that the two years after a child receives a cochlear implant is critical in her ability to acquire language. This period is the “window of opportunity” after which language acquisition becomes more difficult. Ms. Lehnert’s testimony was also substantiated by Patricia Balthazor. Ms. Balthazor possesses a master’s degree in audiology and speech sciences from Purdue University. She is a speech pathologist who has provided extensive therapy to cochlear implanted students since 1994. Ms. Balthazor has independently assessed STUDENT and reviewed STUDENT’s school records and HEI records. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Balthazor a credible witness who is knowledgeable about children with cochlear implants and STUDENT specifically.
Ms. Balthazor and Ms. Lehnert both testified that one of STUDENT’s primary needs as a post-cochlear implanted student was to have a comprehensive program that was consistently implemented. As such, according to Ms. Balthazor and Ms. Lehnert, STUDENT needed everyone working with her to utilize the same communication format. Ms. Lehnert explained that STUDENT’s primary mode of communication was sign language. In order for STUDENT to attach meaning to the sounds she was hearing, she needed to have everything put into context. For example, STUDENT may have heard a bird chirp; however, she needed to have someone sign for her the word bird so she could comprehend and attach meaning to the sound. After STUDENT comprehended the sound, she needed to be prompted to say the word bird.
The communication format STUDENT needed, Ms. Balthazor testified, was the pairing of sign language and oral language which is referred to as total communication. However, since STUDENT was now able to hear sound, using total communication the emphasis must have been on audition. According to Ms. Balthazor and Ms. Lehnert, STUDENT required a total communication classroom where everything, from curriculum to directions, was presented orally, signed if needed, and repeated orally (the auditory sandwich). In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required a total communication classroom where all information was presented with the pairing of sign and oral language with an emphasis on audition.
To have a total communication environment where STUDENT’s program could be consistently implemented, according to Ms. Lehnert and Ms. Balthazor, it was essential that STUDENT had a DHH teacher. A general education teacher would not have been able to modify the curriculum, or to present information in the total communication format she needed.
Ms. Rohen disputes the assertion that STUDENT needed a DHH teacher. Mary Rohen is a DHH credentialed teacher; however, she has been employed by the District as a general education teacher for the last seven years. Ms. Rohen, however, conceded that she had very limited experience with cochlear implanted children. According to her testimony, the only experience Ms. Rohen had was working with one cochlear implanted child during one summer. Additionally, Ms. Rohen had not provided services to STUDENT. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer gives little weight to Ms. Rohen’s opinion regarding STUDENT’s needs.
As a result of the credible testimony of both Ms. Lehnert and Ms. Balthazor, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needed a DHH teacher who was proficient in SEE Sign.
STUDENT’s next assertion is that she needed some DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign. Ms. Balthazor testified that it was critical for STUDENT to learn that language, both sign and oral, is reciprocal. Ms. Balthazor and Ms. Lehnert both testified that one of the primary reasons STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills were so delayed, even utilizing sign, was that she had few people to interact with. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has been socially isolated because she has no peers to communicate with. Ms. Balthazor testified that even if STUDENT had a good relationship with her aide, that aide was not a “peer.” Ms. Roepke, District psychologist, testified that she observed STUDENT on the play ground. According to Ms. Roepke, STUDENT interacted with other children primarily, by pulling on their clothes, pointing, and using gestures. Mr. Hogue testified that STUDENT played with other children. However, he revealed that STUDENT would often wander out of class and seek out an older cousin and try to communicate. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needed some DHH peers who utilized SEE Sign to communicate with.
The next question becomes how many other DHH children must STUDENT have had in a class to have met her unique needs? Ms. Lehnert testified that STUDENT’s total communication class should have been co-enrolled with hearing children who sign, other DHH children, and children with cochlear implants. Ms. Balthazor provided an alternate opinion regarding STUDENT’s need for other language mode peers. Ms. Balthazor testified that the focus is not on whether or not the other children have cochlear implants. Rather, to meet STUDENT’s need, the focus is whether or not these DHH children utilize SEE Sign. According to Ms. Balthazor, one to two other children who rely on total communication and are proficient in SEE Sign would have constituted a “critical mass,” thereby meeting STUDENT’s needs and providing a basic floor of opportunity.
The program described by Ms. Lehnert would have been the ideal situation for STUDENT. However, it would be very difficult to create such a group in any area, but particularly in a geographically remote location where the LEAs are located. Moreover, the LEAs were not required to create such an ideal situation. Rather, they must have provided a basic floor of opportunity. In light of the critical need for STUDENT to communicate with her peers, and the frequency with which students are absent or away from school, the Hearing Officer finds that a minimum of two peers who utilize SEE Sign as opposed to only one would have been sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs.
STUDENT’s final contention is that MOTHER required sign language instruction. The Hearing Officer found above that one of STUDENT’s unique needs was to communicate with her mother. Since this need did not change, the Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER was entitled to sign language instruction.
In summary, STUDENT’s unique needs changed after she received her cochlear implant. STUDENT’s primary need for the 2001-2002 school year was to develop a language system. Additionally, STUDENT needed intensive therapy to improve her expressive and receptive language. STUDENT needed to continue using SEE Sign with a one-to-one aide. STUDENT also needed a total communication class, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher, with two other DHH peers who utilized SEE Sign. Additionally, STUDENT needed sign language instruction for MOTHER.
After having established STUDENT’s unique needs for the 2001-2002 school year, the Hearing Officer addresses whether or not the program provided by the District was designed to meet her unique needs.
STUDENT’s IEP developed on August 23, 2001, contains two goals. The first goal was to improve auditory listening skills for sound and the second was to attach meaning to words and sounds by discriminating and imitation sounds and words when listening. Ms. Grant, STUDENT’s SLT and Ms. Lehnert both explained that the goals and objectives for STUDENT were appropriate. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
To implement STUDENT’s goals and objectives her IEP called for placement in Mr. Hogue’s preschool class in the morning and a general education kindergarten class in the afternoon taught by Ms. Kelley. Neither Mr. Hogue nor Ms. Kelley possessed signing capabilities above STUDENT’s. Neither Mr. Hogue nor Ms. Kelley were credentialed DHH teachers. Without sign language capabilities it was impossible for either teacher to provide an appropriate total communication classroom to meet STUDENT’s needs. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement offered by the LEAs was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
STUDENT’s IEP team also determined that she required intensive auditory/verbal therapy. Accordingly, STUDENT’s IEP provided for five one-hour speech and language therapy sessions weekly. Additionally, STUDENT’s IEP indicates that her therapy sessions would be provided utilizing total communication. The Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language services identified in STUDENT’s IEP were designed to meet her unique needs.
STUDENT’s IEP also provides for a one-to-one signing aide. This was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. However, on September 19, 2001, an addendum was prepared stating, “due to no availability of a signing aide, the district will provide a ‘listening’ aide to support STUDENT in the class. This person will be taught some basic sign in case of an emergency.” The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs required a signing aide. The determination to replace a signing aide with a listening aide who does not sign was not based upon STUDENT’s needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the addendum IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Additionally, there is no provision in STUDENT’s IEP for DHH peers. The testimony at hearing was that STUDENT was the only DHH student in both Mr. Hogue’s and Ms. Kelley’s classes. Further, with the elimination of a signing aide, STUDENT was left with virtually no one to meaningfully communicate with. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP was not designed to meet her need for DHH peers.
The LEAs argued that even if STUDENT’s unique needs required DHH peers, they were not required to provide them because of the geographically remote location of the LEAs. The Hearing Officer disagrees.
California Education Code section 56000.5(b)(4) states that, “It is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children, like all children, have an education with a sufficient number of language mode peers with whom they can communicate directly and who are of the same, or approximately the same, age and ability level.” Not only has the Legislature expressed its intent that DHH children in general be educated with other language mode peers, the Hearing Officer has found that it is specifically one of STUDENT’s needs. The fact that Bishop may be geographically remote does not relieve the LEAs of their obligation to provide STUDENT with a program that meets her unique needs.
Finally, there is no provision in STUDENT’s IEP for sign language instruction for MOTHER. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s need in this regard.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s goals and objectives were designed to meet her unique needs. Additionally, the speech and language therapy identified in STUDENT’s IEP was appropriate. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement identified in STUDENT’s IEP was not designed to meet her needs. Further, the omission of a DHH credentialed teacher and two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the August 23, 2001 IEP and the September 19, 2001, addendum were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Educational Benefit
It has been determined above that the IEP for the 2001-2002 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Virtually every element of the placement failed to meet STUDENT’s needs. In light of the above, the IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Comport with her IEP
There was no allegation that the program implemented by the LEAs failed to comport with STUDENT’s August 2001 IEP. Accordingly, it will not be addressed by the Hearing Officer.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP for the 2001-2002 school year did not meet some of STUDENT’s unique needs. Further, because critical components in STUDENT’s program were missing, it was not reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year.
Issue 4: Did the LEAs offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the 2003 extended school year, and if not does she require prospectively a total communication classroom with a DHH teacher, a proficient SEE Sign aide, DHH peers, aural habilitation, speech and language therapy, and staff training to receive a FAPE?
On June 27, 2002, STUDENT received her one-year post-implant evaluation by HEI. STUDENT was five years and ten months old when tested. The RDLS was repeated both with and without sign language. On the receptive portion of the assessment, STUDENT was again in the first percentile with an age equivalent of one year and four months using auditory only and two years and four months when administered with both oral and sign language. On the expressive portion of the RDLS, STUDENT was again in the first percentile with an age equivalent of one year and nine months using auditory only and two years and four months using both oral and sign language. The report prepared by Jennifer Still, speech and language pathologist from HEI who performed the assessment, indicates that “STUDENT has demonstrated minimal linguistic progress in both oral and sign language...It appears that STUDENT’s language skills are not progressing at a rate that will support her academic needs.” (Ex. LEAs 41)
Ms. Lehnert testified convincingly that in light of STUDENT’s one-year post-implant evaluation, STUDENT’s unique needs remained the same as the year before. However, obtaining an appropriate educational program was even more critical because the “window of opportunity” for STUDENT to acquire a language system was closing rapidly.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs for the current school year are the same as during the 2001-2002 school year. To summarize, STUDENT’s greatest unique need for the 2002-2003 school year is to develop a language system. Additionally, STUDENT needs intensive therapy to improve her expressive and receptive language. STUDENT needs to continue using SEE Sign with a one-to-one aide. STUDENT also needs a total communication class, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher, with two other DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign. Finally, STUDENT needs sign language instruction for MOTHER.
After having established STUDENT’s unique needs for the current school year, the Hearing Officer now analyzes the LEAs’ program.
STUDENT’s IEP team met on June 4, 2002, to develop a plan to transition STUDENT from her combined preschool/kindergarten program to first grade. The team agreed to meet again after STUDENT’s transition to first grade to determine whether or not her needs would change. The result of the June 4, 2002, meeting was a transition plan that called for STUDENT to be placed in a general education first grade class taught by a general education teacher. The general education teacher, Dorothy Canfield, does not possess sign language skills at or above STUDENT’s. STUDENT would receive sign language instruction with a one-to-one aide proficient in SEE Sign. The plan also provided for five hours per week of speech and language therapy. MOTHER consented to this transition plan.
As determined above, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT requires a total communication class, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher, with two other DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign. The transition plan implemented by the LEAs fails to address some of STUDENT’s unique needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the transition plan was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
The IEP team met again on November 1, 2002, to draft STUDENT’s complete IEP for the 2002-2003 school year. MOTHER did not consent to this IEP so the transition plan remained operative. The IEP team met again on December 19, 2002, to revise STUDENT’s IEP. MOTHER was not in attendance. However, she testified that she received a copy of the IEP and does not consent to it. The LEAs explained at hearing that the December 19, 2002, IEP was their current offer of placement. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will analyze the December 19, 2002, IEP to determine if it is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs as opposed to the November 1, 2002, IEP because it was never operative and is not the LEAs’ offer of placement.
The December 19, 2002, IEP contains six goals and objectives focused on the acquisition of a language system, and developing STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language skills using total communication. Jody Clover, District SLT, testified that she drafted these goals. Ms. Clover explained that she consulted with Ms. Lehnert and developed these goals pursuant to Ms. Lehnert’s recommendations. Ms. Lehnert explained that the goals were appropriate for STUDENT. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds the goals and objectives contained in the December 19, 2002, IEP are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
To implement STUDENT’s goals and objectives, STUDENT’s IEP calls for continued placement in a general education first grade class. The IEP also indicates that the general education teacher would have weekly consultations with a DHH credentialed teacher. Ms. Lehnert and Ms. Balthazor both stressed the importance of having a DHH credentialed teacher for STUDENT. They convincingly testified that it would be impossible for a general education teacher who lacks proficient sign language abilities to create a total communication classroom that would meet STUDENT’s needs. In light of the discussion above regarding STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement offered by the LEAs is not designed to meet those needs. Weekly consultation with a DHH teacher is not sufficient. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires a total communication classroom, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher who is proficient in SEE Sign.
STUDENT’s IEP also provides for her speech and language therapy to continue five days per week, one hour per day. Ms. Balthazor testified that aural habilitation is the process of “teaching a child to listen so they can listen to learn.” Ms. Balthazor explained that the goals and objectives designed for STUDENT for speech and language encompass aural habilitation. In light of STUDENT’s intense aural habilitation and speech and language needs, the Hearing Officer finds that this amount of intense therapy meets her needs.
STUDENT’s IEP also includes other program modifications and support services. Those include the use of acoustic dividers in the classroom, California DHH guidelines for all staff working with STUDENT, ongoing consultation with LEA staff and Crown Valley staff including visitations, visitation for STUDENT’s SLT to meet and observe at HEI, one hour per week sign language instruction for MOTHER, participation at local workshops for MOTHER, daily interaction between SLT and signing aide, and daily interaction with general education teacher and signing aide.
In light of the testimony at hearing, and the foregoing discussion regarding STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer finds that if her placement is appropriate (total communication class, credentialed DHH teacher, two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign), then the proposed modifications and support services listed above are designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs with the exception of daily interaction with a general education teacher and signing aide. This modification was predicated on the belief that STUDENT’s needs could be met with a general education teacher as opposed to a DHH credentialed teacher. The Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT requires a DHH credentialed teacher. That finding renders the modification moot.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the December 19, 2002, IEP does meet STUDENT’s critical unique needs. The goals and objectives contained in the IEP are designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. The offered amount of speech and language therapy is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Providing STUDENT a one-to-one aide proficient in SEE Sign meets her needs. The following modifications and supports are also designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs if she is in an appropriate placement: acoustic dividers; DHH guidelines to staff; consultation and visitation with Crown Valley; visitation for SLT at HEI; sign language instruction for MOTHER; participation in local workshops; and daily interaction between SLT and signing aide to provide consistency. These modifications would not meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the placement offered in the December 19, 2002, IEP.
Despite the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP does not meet some of STUDENT’s unique needs. For STUDENT’s IEP to meet her unique needs and provide her a FAPE prospectively, the IEP must be amended. The Hearing Officer finds that the following modifications to STUDENT’s IEP must be made. STUDENT is entitled to placement in a total communication class, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher proficient in SEE Sign. Further, STUDENT requires two other DHH peers who use SEE Sign. The omission of the above components is a fatal flaw in STUDENT’s IEP and must be remedied to provide her with a FAPE.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s transition plan and proposed IEP for the 2002-2003 school year cannot meet some of STUDENT’s unique needs. Further, because critical components in STUDENT’s program are missing, it is not reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year up through the date of this Decision. STUDENT’s IEP must be modified to conform with the findings listed above.
Issue 5: Is STUDENT entitled to reasonable living expenses in another school district with two return trips to Bishop per month at the LEAs’ expense?
STUDENT argues that the District and County do not have a program that meets the criteria outlined above. Further, she argues that the LEAs cannot create a program with the components necessary to provide her a FAPE. Additionally, while not requesting a specific placement, STUDENT asserts that the only programs that meet the criteria outlined above to provide her a FAPE, are public school programs located in southern California. Therefore, STUDENT argues that the Hearing Officer should order the LEAs to relocate STUDENT, pay her moving expenses, pay rent to maintain her residence in a new city, pay travel expenses and lodging for STUDENT and MOTHER to return to Bishop two times per month to visit family still living in Bishop, and maintain responsibility for ensuring she receives a FAPE. The LEAs object to this as a proposed remedy arguing that if the Hearing Officer found a denial of FAPE, the LEAs should be given an opportunity to remedy any error.
The Hearing Officer has determined that the LEAs have failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE since April of 1999. This failure in STUDENT’s case has grave implications. What STUDENT has lost is not merely educational opportunity. Rather, as a result of the LEAs failure, STUDENT is at risk for losing the ability to acquire a language system. A language system, or the ability to communicate, is one of the most crucial components of living. Without the ability to communicate, receptively and expressively through sign or speech, STUDENT is at risk for becoming completely isolated from society. Resorting to gesturing, pulling on clothes, inadequate signing, and pointing, as STUDENT has, is not a language system. Ms. Balthazor’s uncontested testimony is that any child, including one without a hearing impairment, has a window of opportunity from birth to seven years of age to acquire language. After that time, the acquisition of language is very difficult. Moreover, according to Ms. Lehnert and Ms. Balthazor a child has a limited window of opportunity of only two years after a cochlear implant to acquire aural and oral language. Ms. Lehnert cautioned that if progress is not made during this essential time, the child may never receive the benefit of the cochlear implant. STUDENT is currently six years old and eighteen months past activation of her implant. Accordingly, STUDENT has essentially two windows of opportunity that are about to shut simultaneously. This cannot happen.
In this case, the LEAs seek an opportunity to amend STUDENT’s December 19, 2002, IEP to provide a program in conformity with this Decision. The Hearing Officer concludes that it is appropriate to give the LEAs a brief opportunity; it is ultimately better for STUDENT to receive a FAPE in the community where she currently lives. However, STUDENT’s windows of opportunity are closing, and the LEAs must now proceed swiftly to provide her an appropriate program. According to the testimony of Mr. Lehwald, district director of special education, the LEAs conducted a thorough search for a qualified signing aide for STUDENT for more than a year before securing an appropriate person. Mr. Lehwald explained that it is difficult to hire necessary staff given the remote location of the LEAs. While the Hearing Officer is sympathetic to the LEAs situation and believes the LEAs acted in good faith by bringing in consultants to try and design an appropriate program for STUDENT, ultimately, they failed.
The Hearing Officer recognizes that a rural community like Bishop may not possess all elements necessary to provide STUDENT a FAPE. Nevertheless, the overwhelming evidence clearly established STUDENT’s needs. Therefore, if the LEAs are not able to provide STUDENT a program that conforms to the criteria set forth in this Decision, they must immediately seek out a placement that will. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that if STUDENT’s IEP team determines it is not able to provide the program set forth in the order contained in this Decision, within the time period allowed, the team must expeditiously pursue alternate means. The Hearing Officer declines to order the specific relief requested by STUDENT because it is not appropriate to order STUDENT placed in a district that is not a party to this hearing and has no connection to STUDENT. However, the Hearing Officer finds that if the LEAs cannot provide an appropriate program, they must immediately attempt to secure an inter-district transfer to a district with an appropriate program or seek out a non-public school that can implement the program ordered in this Decision. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds that if STUDENT’s IEP team determines that placement outside of the LEAs is necessary, then the LEAs will be responsible for providing for all costs reasonably associated with that placement, including tuition, transportation, and reasonable living expenses.(Footnote 14)
Issue 6: If the LEAs denied STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to the following as compensatory education:
(a) A fifty week program consisting of two hours per week of auditory/verbal therapy and speech and language therapy while school is in session and a maximum of five hours per week when school is out of session;
(b) Two hours per week of SEE Sign sign language instruction to be attended by STUDENT, MOTHER, and other available family members for one year;
(c) Three workshops related to STUDENT’s deafness per year for MOTHER, including costs and fees; and (d) A total communication summer camp including tuition, living expenses, and transportation for the 2003 and 2004 summers?
Compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See: Parents of Petitioner W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). A hearing officer has broad authority to craft an appropriate equitable remedy. (See School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985)) Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. at 1497. However, equitable considerations are appropriate when fashioning compensatory remedies. An application of equitable principles requires that the actions of the parties themselves must be considered when evaluating the circumstances surrounding the child’s lost education opportunity and in creating an adequate remedy. Id. Thus, when considering a request for compensatory education, it is first necessary to determine whether an LEA failed to provide a FAPE. If that issue is answered affirmatively, the subsequent question is not what precise services were missed but, rather, what compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law.
The Hearing Officer had determined that the LEAs denied STUDENT a FAPE during all years at issue in this case. During the 1999-2000 school year, from April through the ESY, the LEAs denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide sign language instruction for MOTHER. During the 2000-2001 school year, the Hearing Officer determined that STUDENT was denied a FAPE when the LEAs reduced the amount of speech and language therapy she required from two sixty-minute sessions per week to one thirty-minute session from September through December, and two thirty-minute sessions from January through June. Additionally, the LEAs denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year by failing to provide a one-to-one signing aide, and sign language instruction for MOTHER. The LEAs denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year by failing to place STUDENT in a total communication classroom with a DHH credentialed teacher and at least two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign. Additionally, during the same school year, the LEAs denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide a one-to-one aide proficient in SEE Sign and sign language instruction for MOTHER. Finally, during the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT has been denied a FAPE because her placement does not conform to the criteria listed above.
The list of the individual failures identified above does not adequately reflect the loss STUDENT suffered when taken as a whole. The testimony of Ms. Roepke, district psychologist, established that STUDENT’s cognitive ability is within the superior to gifted range. However, despite her cognitive abilities, the evaluations conducted by HEI both six months and one year after STUDENT received her implant, revealed that she made virtually no notable progress in the development of her receptive and expressive language abilities, including sign language. This is a result of the LEAs failure to create and implement a cohesive program that addressed STUDENT’s needs in a comprehensive manner.
STUDENT seeks very specific remedies. However, the Hearing Officer finds that with the exception of summer camp, the requested remedies do not adequately address the educational opportunity that STUDENT lost. The critical components in STUDENT’s program that were missing were a total communication class, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher, attended by a minimum of two other DHH children who utilize SEE Sign. Ms. Lehnert, the consultant hired by the LEAs to assist in developing a program for STUDENT, has consistently recommended these elements following STUDENT’s surgery. The Hearing Officer has determined that the lack of these components, taken as a whole, have had a significant impact on STUDENT’s education and put at serious risk her ability to acquire a language system. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that given the critical nature of the loss, as well as the rapidly closing window of opportunity for STUDENT to develop a language system, providing a program to STUDENT that includes placement in a total communication class, with a DHH credentialed teacher, and at least two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign, through the remainder of the school year will not provide full compensation to which STUDENT is entitled. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that it is necessary to provide STUDENT with a total communication class, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher, attended by a minimum of two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign throughout the 2003-2004 school year as compensatory education.
(a) A fifty week program consisting of two hours per week of auditory/verbal therapy and speech and language therapy while school is in session and a maximum of five hours per week when school is out of session
As noted above, STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year regarding speech and language therapy.(Footnote 15) STUDENT’s needs as a deaf child during that period were drastically different then they are now as a child with a cochlear implant. Additional speech and language therapy sessions cannot compensate her for that loss. STUDENT’s current IEP provides for five hours per week of speech and language therapy. The Hearing Officer has determined that this is sufficient currently. Moreover, the Hearing Officer has determined above that STUDENT has received an adequate amount of speech and language therapy, driven by appropriate goals and objectives, since receiving her implant. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that additional speech and language therapy is not an appropriate remedy for STUDENT.
(b) Two hours per week of SEE Sign sign language instruction to be attended by STUDENT, MOTHER, and other available family members for one year.
The Hearing Officer determined that MOTHER has been entitled to sign language instruction since April of 2000. Ms. Balthazor testified that as a form of compensatory education, it would benefit STUDENT and other family members to participate in the sign language classes taken by MOTHER. This may expedite the acquisition of sign language for STUDENT and MOTHER as well as other family members that interact with STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that two hours per week of SEE Sign sign language instruction for a period of one year is appropriate. Additionally, the December 19, 2002, IEP provides for MOTHER to receive one hour per week of sign language instruction. That one hour will be included in the two hours ordered here and not in addition to.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the LEAs must provide two hours per week of sign language instruction for STUDENT, MOTHER, and other available family members for a period of one year.
(c) Three workshops related to STUDENT’s deafness per year for MOTHER, including costs and fees.
There was no testimony presented that MOTHER was denied the opportunity to attend workshops related to STUDENT’s deafness. In fact, the evidence established that the LEAs provided numerous opportunities for MOTHER to attend workshops, including paying for her to travel to Southern California to visit Crown Valley Elementary School. This request is denied because the Hearing Officer does not believe this is an appropriate remedy to compensate STUDENT for lost educational opportunity.
(d) A total communication summer camp including tuition, living expenses, and transportation for the 2003 and 2004 summers.
Ms. Balthazor and Ms. Lehnert both testified that emersion in a total communication summer program is the most appropriate way to compensate STUDENT for the education she lost. A total communication summer camp will provide exactly the educational opportunity that STUDENT lost. She will be enrolled in total communication camp where all people utilize sign and oral language to communicate. This will also provide her an opportunity to interact with several other children to communicate with. It is also important to remember that the “window of opportunity” for STUDENT to acquire language is rapidly closing.
Considering that since STUDENT received her cochlear implant she has required and not received a total communication class, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher, and attended by two other DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign, two summer camp programs are appropriate. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to attend a total communication summer camp including tuition, living expenses, and transportation for two summers. However, STUDENT is only in first grade and may have a difficult time being separated from MOTHER during a summer program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that in selecting her summer program, STUDENT’s IEP team must consider STUDENT’s emotional needs. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that rather than shortening the length of time STUDENT spends at summer camp, her IEP team should consider arranging for MOTHER to attend camp with STUDENT.
In summary, the Hearing Officer determines that as an equitable remedy, STUDENT must be placed in a total communication class, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher, with a minimum of two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign through the 2003-2004 school year. Additionally, STUDENT, MOTHER, and other available family members are entitled to SEE Sign sign language instruction for two hours per week for one year. Finally, STUDENT’s IEP team will select an appropriate total communication summer camp for her to attend during the summers of 2003 and 2004. Her IEP team must consider the length of program appropriate for STUDENT, and must also consider allowing MOTHER to attend camp. The LEAs will pay for tuition, living expenses, and transportation expenses associated with the summer camp. All of STUDENT’s other requests for compensatory education are denied.
Issue 7: Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for a sign language class in the amount of $40.00 and a training class at House Ear Institute including travel, hotel, and expenses in the amount of $300.00?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985); see also, 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. Equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA. Burlington, supra at 374.
MOTHER seeks reimbursement for a sign language class she took during the 2000-2001 school year. The Hearing Officer found above that MOTHER should have been provided with sign language classes at the LEAs expense. MOTHER testified that she derived some benefit from these classes and was better able to communicate with STUDENT after acquiring some signing ability. The Hearing Officer has also ordered sign language classes as a form of compensatory education and MOTHER is not entitled to be compensated for the same failure twice. However, the amount of sign language instruction ordered is not sufficient to compensate her for the total amount of instruction lost. Therefore, reimbursing MOTHER for the cost of the sign language classes is supplemental and not duplicative of the compensatory services ordered. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER is entitled to reimbursement in the amount of $40.00 for the sign language class she took.
MOTHER also seeks reimbursement for a training class she took at HEI put on by Warren Easterbrooks. MOTHER did not explain what type of presentation she participated in. Additionally, MOTHER failed to explain how this presentation related to STUDENT’s educational needs. Further, the LEAs provided several training classes for the individuals that participated with STUDENT and always invited MOTHER to attend, which she often did. Because MOTHER did not provide evidence of how this training class at HEI related to the LEAs’ denial of FAPE, the Hearing Officer denies the request for reimbursement.
In summary, the LEAs must reimburse MOTHER $40.00 for a sign language class she participated in. However, MOTHER is not entitled to reimbursement for a training class at HEI.
ORDER
1 Within twenty (20) days of the date of this Decision STUDENT’s IEP team must meet to amend her December 19, 2002 IEP as follows:
a. STUDENT must be placed in a self-contained total communication class utilizing SEE Sign with an emphasis on audition; b. the class must be taught by a DHH credentialed teacher;
c. STUDENT must have a minimum of two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign; d. All other aspects of STUDENT’s IEP, including program modifications identified in the December 19, 2002 IEP, are to remain the same.
2 Within twenty (20) days of the date of this Decision STUDENT’s amended IEP must be implemented.
3 If, within twenty (20) days of the date of this Decision, STUDENT’s IEP team determines that the LEAs are not able to provide a program that meets the criteria identified above, the LEAs must immediately secure an inter-district transfer to a district with an appropriate program or locate and enroll STUDENT in a non-public school that can implement the program.
4 If STUDENT is placed outside the county in a non-residential placement, then the LEAs will be responsible for providing all reasonable costs related to her placement including tuition, transportation, and associated living expenses.
5 Within twenty (20) days of the date of this decision STUDENT’s IEP team must meet to develop a plan for implementing the following compensatory education remedies and incorporate them into her IEP:
a. Placement in a total communication class, taught by a DHH credentialed teacher, with a minimum of two DHH peers who utilize SEE Sign through the 2003-2004 school year; b. Two hours per week for one year of SEE Sign sign language instruction for MOTHER that may be attended by STUDENT and other family members.
6 By April 1, 2003, STUDENT’s IEP team shall identify and incorporate into her IEP an appropriate total communication summer camp for STUDENT to attend during the 2003 and 2004 summers. In selecting a summer camp, the IEP team must keep in mind STUDENT’s age and consider arranging for MOTHER to attend the summer camp.
7 Within twenty (20) days of the date of this Decision, the LEAs will reimburse MOTHER in the amount of $40.00 for a sign language class.
8 All of STUDENT’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1 Did the LEAs provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from April 2000 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including the extended school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue to the extent that she was denied a FAPE because of the failure to include sign language instruction for MOTHER.
2 Did the LEAs provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 extended school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
3 Did the LEAs provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, including the 2002 extended school year? STUDENT substantially prevailed on this issue.
4 Did the LEAs offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the 2003 extended school year, and if not does she require prospectively a total communication classroom with a DHH teacher, a proficient SEE Sign aide, DHH and general education peers, aural habilitation, speech and language therapy, and staff training to receive a FAPE? STUDENT substantially prevailed on this issue.
5 Is STUDENT entitled to reasonable living expenses in another school district with two return trips to Bishop per month at the LEAs’ expense? STUDENT substantially prevailed on this issue to the extent that if the LEAs are unable to implement the order in this Decision, the LEAs must locate an appropriate placement and provide all costs associated with that placement including tuition, transportation, and reasonable living expenses.
6 If the LEAs denied STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to the following as compensatory education:
(a) A fifty week program consisting of two hours per week of auditory/verbal therapy and speech and language therapy while school is in session and a maximum of five hours per week when school is out of session;
(b) Two hours per week of SEE Sign sign language instruction to be attended by STUDENT, MOTHER, and other available family members for one year;
(c) Three workshops related to STUDENT’s deafness per year for MOTHER, including costs and fees; and (d) A total communication summer camp including tuition, living expenses, and transportation for the 2003 and 2004 summers?
-STUDENT substantially prevailed on this issue.
7 Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for a sign language class in the amount of $40.00 and a training class at House Ear Institute including travel, hotel, and expenses in the amount of $300.00? The LEAs substantially prevailed on this issue except that reimbursement in the amount of $40.00 was ordered.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: February 27, 2003 ____________________________________ Joy Redmon, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Several of the witnesses called by STUDENT were also requested by the LEAs. 2. Although a pre-hearing conference was held in this matter, these issues have been restated from the pre-hearing conference order to reflect the issues as clarified at the hearing. 3. STUDENT alleges that the LEAs committed procedural violations at all relevant time periods by denying MOTHER meaningful participation in the IEP process. As determined below, the Hearing Officer has found substantive denials of FAPE for each year at issue. Therefore, it is not necessary to determine if there were also procedural violations because even if proven, such denials would not affect the remedies in this case. 4. Several witnesses testified regarding the definition of “total communication.” While these definitions varied, total communication was consistently defined as the pairing of oral language with sign language and visual cues, such as lip reading, to assist a student to comprehend and attach meaning to language. 5. A cochlear implant is a “device for treating severe deafness that consists of one or more electrodes implanted by surgery inside or outside the cochlea (an organ in the inner ear that transforms sound vibrations into nerve impulses for transmission to the brain)...[As the electrodes are implanted], a miniature receiver is implanted under the skin, either behind the ear or in the lower part of the chest. A wire connecting the electrodes to the receiver is implanted at the same time. Directly over the implanted receiver, the patient wears an external transmitter, which is connected to a sound processor and a microphone.” Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified Sch. Dist. (9th Cir. 2003) citing American Medical Association, Encyclopedia of Medicine 286, (1989). 6. Mapping refers to the process of programing the cochlear implant to receive sound. A computer programs the pitch of the electrodes which gives the child a frequency range. A child must hear at a frequency that falls within the “speech banana,” as identified on an audiogram, to hear the sounds in the English language. The initial mapping is usually completed over a three day period with adjustments, if necessary, about one month later. Initially, the sound an implanted person hears is robotic or mechanical. 7. Aural habilitation was defined during the hearing as “teaching a child to listen so the child can listen to learn.” It was also described as an umbrella under which different types of therapy (e.g. auditory/verbal) fall. 8. Auditory sandwich is a total communication approach wherein a person orally speaks. If the receiver doesn’t understand then the oral command is signed, and repeated again orally (auditory, visual-if needed, auditory.) 9. The Hearing Officer is aware that failing to provide adequate notice of an IEP meeting may be a procedural violation resulting in a denial of FAPE; however, in this case because a substantive denial of FAPE is found below such a denial would not affect the remedies in this case. 10. The modifications are as follows: use of acoustic dividers in classroom; weekly consultation with DHH teacher and regular education teacher; all staff members on IEP have copy of DHH guidelines; consultation with Crown Valley including visitations; SLP to visit HEI; one hour per week of signing class for parent; parent afforded opportunity to participate in local workshops; consultation between District staff and Crown Valley staff; appropriate District staff will be invited to consult with DHH/CI students; daily interaction between SLT and signing aide; and daily interaction between regular education teacher and signing aide. 11. STUDENT did not return to Bishop until April of 2000. Therefore, the IEP was intended to be operative from April 2000 through April 2001. 12. Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations section 3065(t)(1),(3), and (4) state in relevant part: Specialized interpreting...services for pupils with low incidence disabilities shall be provided only by personnel who possess a certification issued by the Registry of Interpreters for the Deaf or the national Association for the Deaf or any of its affiliated organizations; or credential authorizing services for deaf and hard of hearing; or certificate or degree from a regionally accredited post-secondary institution affirming that the bearer has successfully completed a prescribed course of study in sign language interpreting. 13. STUDENT’s IEP team met on April 25, 2001 to develop her IEP for the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT was scheduled to receive a cochlear implant in June, which would be activated in July. STUDENT’s IEP team considered the fact that STUDENT’s unique needs would change dramatically after the implant and decided to defer creating her program for the 2001-2002 school year until after her implant was activated. The team met again on July 10, 2001, but agreed to meet in late August, prior to the commencement of the school year, but after STUDENT’s implant was activated. Accordingly, the IEP discussed above remained substantially in place through the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year including ESY. 14. If it should prove necessary for STUDENT to live outside of the county in a non-residential placement, provisions must be made for the additional expenses incurred by MOTHER in relocating with STUDENT to be borne by the LEAs consistent with the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Ojai Unified School District v. Jackson. (4 F.3d 1467 (9th cir. 1993)) 15. Although STUDENT identified auditory/verbal therapy and speech and language therapy separately, Ms. Balthazor testified that both fall under the umbrella of aural habilitation and can be provided in a speech and language therapy session. Since the services were identified as speech and language in STUDENT’s IEPs, the Hearing Officer will use the same label.
