California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 2, 1996
Student v. San Francisco Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 286-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
San Francisco Unified did not deny an appropriate education through late large-print materials; Hearing Officer links failing grades to absences.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
An 18-year-old student filed this case on his own behalf. He was eligible for special education because of a vision impairment. His IEP at Abraham Lincoln High School in San Francisco Unified School District included special day classes, vision services, orientation and mobility services, preferential seating, and enlarged materials. He said staff often failed to enlarge assignments, tests, and textbooks on time. He said he lost class time tracking down copies and failed many courses as a result. He asked for compensatory education.
Hearing Officer Mark Paxson agreed that the student needed enlarged materials and that the IEP required them. However, the student described only isolated incidents. He did not show a pattern of failure that affected his ability to benefit from his education. District witnesses, assistant principal Grace King and resource specialist Virginia Giamo, testified that the enlargement process had problems in his first year but improved quickly. They said textbooks were ordered early in later years. School records showed he earned his best grades in his freshman year, when the materials problems were worst. His grades fell in his junior year, when his absences rose sharply. The student admitted he attended only two classes during his senior year. The Hearing Officer found that the failing grades came from absences and missing work, not from the District. He found no denial of an appropriate education under Rowley and did not decide the compensatory education claim. All relief was denied.
Why it matters
The case shows how SEHO handled a claim that a district failed to implement an IEP accommodation. The Hearing Officer looked for a pattern of failures that affected educational benefit, not isolated lapses. He also weighed attendance and grade records to decide what actually caused the student's poor performance.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1. Did San Francisco Unified School District fail to provide Student with an appropriate education by failing to provide him with enlarged educational materials in a timely manner?
Student showed only isolated delays in enlarged materials, not a pattern of failure affecting educational benefit; his failing grades resulted from absences and missing work, so there was no denial of an appropriate education under Rowley.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. If the District failed to provide Student with an appropriate education, is he entitled to compensatory education?
Not reached because no denial of an appropriate education was found on Issue 1.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's requested claim for relief denied.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175; 20 USC § 1401; Education Code § 56000 et seq.; Education Code § 56505
People named in the decision
- Sylvia Mollick, vision services provider, San Francisco Unified School District
- Grace King, assistant principal for curriculum and instruction; District witness, Abraham Lincoln High School, San Francisco Unified School District
- Virginia Giamo, resource specialist and student's counselor; District witness, Abraham Lincoln High School, San Francisco Unified School District
- Katharine Fleury, compliance officer for special education; District representative, San Francisco Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer with the Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, on April 18, 1996, in San Francisco, California.
Petitioner STUDENT represented himself at the hearing. Respondent San Francisco Unified School District (District) was represented by Katharine Fleury, compliance officer for special education for the District.
Evidence was received, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Did San Francisco Unified School District fail to provide STUDENT with an appropriate education by failing to provide him with enlarged educational materials in a timely manner?
(2) If the District failed to provide STUDENT with an appropriate education, is he entitled to compensatory education?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an 18-year-old young man eligible for special education as a result of a vision impairment. He was born with congenital cataracts and was also diagnosed with glaucoma in the summer of 1995. As a result of his vision impairment, STUDENT has lost 90% of the vision in his left eye.
In the fall of 1992, STUDENT enrolled at Abraham Lincoln High School in the District. At that time, he was enrolled in several special day classes, and received vision services and orientation and mobility services. Among the modifications implemented were preferential seating and large-print answer sheets and assignments. This arrangement -- special day classes, vision services, orientation and mobility services, preferential seating and enlarged materials -- has continued to the present.
On October 24, 1994, Sylvia Mollick, STUDENT's vision services provider, submitted a memo to school personnel regarding the process for enlarging materials for STUDENT. According to Ms. Mollick, the following was to occur:
1. Materials to be enlarged will be dropped off by student messenger to a designated box in Mrs. King's office.(Footnote 1) 2. Materials will be retrieved and enlarged by Main Office copy service. 3. Enlargement specifications will be posted above copy machine. 4. A memo outlining this procedure will be sent to each of STUDENT's classroom teachers. 5. As my schedule permits, I will continue enlarging ongoing projects (U.S. History text and selected other materials) at the Special Education Resource Center.
Additionally, materials that needed to be enlarged within 24 hours were to be processed by the Main Office. Materials that did not need to be completed immediately were to be dropped off in Sylvia Mollick's box by Tuesday to be returned by Wednesday of the following week.
During STUDENT's freshman year, he primarily received passing grades, except for "F's" in Modern World 2 and Advanced Drawing. During STUDENT's sophomore year, he again received primarily passing grades except for an "F" in Ethnic Literature 2. STUDENT's other grades for the first two years were primarily "C's" and "D's." In his third year at Abraham Lincoln High School, STUDENT's performance worsened and he received six "F's" in American Literature 1 and 2, U.S. History 1 and 2, Photography 1, and General Math 2.
In December 1994, STUDENT was involved in an accident in which his leg was seriously injured. As a result of the injury, STUDENT did not return to school until April 1995. During his absence he received home instruction.
During Summer 1995, STUDENT moved from San Francisco to Oakland. However, he continued attending Abraham Lincoln High School through an interdistrict transfer agreement. When he enrolled in fall of 1995 for his senior year, school personnel insisted that he enroll in four junior-level classes to make up for failing grades he received in those classes the previous year. In addition to those four junior-level classes, STUDENT was enrolled in two senior classes -- English and French. During fall 1995, STUDENT attended only the senior-level classes.
On November 8, 1995, Grace King, assistant principal at STUDENT's school, requested that the interdistrict transfer agreement be revoked as a result of STUDENT's poor attendance. This request was granted on November 28, 1995. At the time of the revocation, STUDENT was failing all of his courses. According to a progress report dated December 6, 1995, his failing grades in five out of his six classes were attributable to lack of attendance.
STUDENT returned to the District after the transfer was revoked, but has not returned to school. Once STUDENT returned to the District, he was offered a placement at George Washington High School which has a full-time vision specialist on staff and a special copier that can enlarge texts. STUDENT rejected this placement. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT had not returned to school.
As of the date of the hearing, STUDENT requires the following classes to graduate: Art 1, U.S. History 1 and 2, American Democracy, Ethnic Literature 2, American Literature 1 and 2, European Literature 1 and 2, and one year of foreign language or differential standard. In addition, STUDENT needs to pass the proficiency tests in composition and math or have differential standards applied.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Petitioner's Witnesses
STUDENT testified on his own behalf. STUDENT testified that the enlargement services required by his IEP were not provided by school staff in a timely manner. In addition, STUDENT stated that he was expected to seek help in getting materials enlarged when he got to class and work had not been enlarged. As a result, he lost a significant amount of class time looking for staff who could enlarge the work. STUDENT testified that, although he lost a lot of time trying to get materials enlarged, his teachers held him responsible for the work and expected him to turn in his assignments on time.
STUDENT testified that he also had difficulties getting enlarged textbooks in time for him to do classwork. STUDENT testified that there were times when he was going to the principal's office twice a day to get assignments enlarged.
STUDENT provided several examples of his inability to do work because of his vision problem. In his Home Economics class, he could not read the dials on the kitchen equipment or read information on food boxes. He asked Sylvia Mollick, the vision services provider, for assistance, but did not receive any. STUDENT also testified that he had problems in his Photography class during his junior year. Although Ms. Mollick was expected to work with the teacher, STUDENT oftentimes had to take work to the main office to get it enlarged. Finally, STUDENT testified that he was unable to take a test in one of his classes because the Scantron answer sheet was not enlarged on time. Instead of taking the test the rest of the class took, STUDENT was asked questions based on other material.
STUDENT testified that he asked if he could use the enlarging equipment rather than waiting for Ms. Mollick or other school personnel to do the enlargements. However, he was told that it was against school policy for students to use the equipment.
Regarding his accident in December 1994, STUDENT testified that he and his mother decided that he should not return to school until his leg had healed because the combination of his vision impairment and leg injury would have made it difficult for him to get around the school campus. When he did return to school, STUDENT requested a key to the elevator so that he would not have to use the stairs to get from class to class. He was advised that it was against school policy to allow students to have a key to the elevator. Instead, he was allowed to leave class five minutes early and a hall monitor would let him on the elevator. STUDENT testified that, as a result of this arrangement, he was late to a number of classes.
District's Witnesses
Grace King is the assistant principal for curriculum and instruction at Abraham Lincoln High School. Ms. King testified that the system for enlarging materials for STUDENT was successful. Ms. King testified that school personnel did everything they could to make STUDENT's education a success and to provide materials in a timely manner. Ms. King testified that teachers were supposed to put assignments in a box for the vision services teacher to copy. Regarding textbooks, Ms. King testified that some textbooks were late STUDENT's first year. However, after STUDENT's first year, school personnel ordered his enlarged textbooks early enough for him to have the books when school started in the fall. For example, Ms. King testified that she began ordering STUDENT's senior year textbooks around April 1995. As a result, when STUDENT came to school in September 1995, all of his textbooks were available. The only book that was not available was a supplementary grammar book which Ms. Mollick enlarged a chapter at a time once school started.
Regarding the Photography course during STUDENT's junior year, Ms. King attributed his failing grade to the fact that STUDENT was expected to take and develop two rolls of film while he was on home teaching. Ms. King testified that STUDENT did not turn in the film and, as a result, did not pass the class. Ms. King testified that STUDENT was failing his courses during his senior year because he was not doing the necessary work.
Ms. King testified that when STUDENT returned to school in April 1995, his class schedule was changed so he would not have to use the elevators as much. In addition, STUDENT spent several periods each day in the main library, where aides would bring him his assignments.
Virginia Giamo is a resource specialist at Abraham Lincoln High School and is STUDENT's counsellor. Ms. Giamo testified that STUDENT's primary need is enlarged materials. Ms. Giamo testified that when STUDENT first enrolled at Abraham Lincoln High School, there was an occasional delay in getting enlarged materials to STUDENT. However, Ms. Giamo testified that the system improved and, except for last-minute assignments, school personnel were successful in getting the materials to STUDENT in a timely manner. In addition, Ms. Giamo testified that STUDENT was given extra time when materials were not provided to him in a timely manner.
Ms. Giamo attributed STUDENT's failing grades throughout his years at Abraham Lincoln High School to his poor attendance. For example, Ms. Giamo testified that Modern World 2 is a class that has almost no materials that need enlarging and the textbook was available to STUDENT in large print. Ms. Giamo attributed STUDENT's grade of "F" in that class to his absences. Ms. Giamo testified that STUDENT was not required to do assignments he missed due to excused absences such as for doctor's appointments or for therapy. However, his absences began to increase significantly and affect his grades. Ms. Giamo also noted that STUDENT received his best grades during his freshman year, when there were the most difficulties with getting materials to him. Once the system was in place, STUDENT's absences went up and his performance went down.
DISCUSSION
(1) Did San Francisco Unified School District fail to provide STUDENT with an appropriate education by failing to provide him with enlarged educational materials in a timely manner?
State and federal law requires that students with disabilities receive a free appropriate public education. (California Education Code § 56000 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 USC 1400 et seq.) Pursuant to 20 USC § 1401(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child, including classroom instruction, instruction in physical education, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institutions." 20 USC § 1401(16). "Related services" is defined as "transportation, and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services ... as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education..." 20 USC § 1401(17).
In addition to the specific language of the IDEA, the U.S. Supreme Court has interpreted the IDEA as requiring that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, 200. The Supreme Court stated in Rowley that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential.
The IDEA and the Rowley Court's interpretation of the IDEA establish a three factor test to determine whether a student's placement is appropriate. Those three factors are:
1) Is the placement designed to meet the student's unique needs? 2) Does the placement conform to the student's IEP?
3) Is the placement designed to provide the student with educational benefit?
In the present case, Petitioner contends that the District was required by his IEP to provide him with enlarged educational materials for him to benefit from his education. Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide him with such materials and that that failure caused him to fail numerous courses. Ultimately, if Petitioner's contentions are true, the District's placement would fail all three factors of the Rowley standard.
The witnesses were in agreement that STUDENT needs enlarged materials to benefit from his education. STUDENT's IEP calls for him to have enlarged materials. If the District failed to provide enlarged materials to STUDENT, the placement did not meet STUDENT's needs, did not conform to his IEP, and did not provide him with educational benefit.
However, Petitioner did not present evidence of a pattern of failure on the part of the District which affected his ability to benefit from his education. While Petitioner testified to specific instances of the District's failure to provide him with the necessary materials, these were isolated incidents which do not establish a pattern of failure on the part of the District that impacted STUDENT's ability to benefit from his education. In addition, while Petitioner testified that he never got his materials on time during the current school year, he did not provide any supporting evidence and acknowledged that he attended only two of his classes during the current school year.
The evidence presented by the District establishes that there were problems with the enlargement process when STUDENT first enrolled at Abraham Lincoln High School. However, these problems were dealt with quickly and school staff subsequently had a high success rate of getting materials to STUDENT on time.
The evidence also establishes that STUDENT did his best when there were the most problems with the enlargement process. During STUDENT's freshman year, when his textbooks did not arrive on time and materials were not produced on time, STUDENT passed almost all of his courses. During the next two years, other than isolated incidents, there were no significant problems with getting materials to STUDENT. During his sophomore year, STUDENT again passed almost all of his courses. However, in his junior year, STUDENT failed a significant number of courses although the textbooks had arrived on time and the enlargement process was working successfully.
What changed over the course of STUDENT's education was the number of absences. STUDENT's Scholarship Record establishes that during his freshman year, STUDENT had a significant number of absences during the second semester. He also had a drop in his grades in that semester from the first semester. STUDENT's attendance during his sophomore year remained relatively consistent with his freshman year. During STUDENT's junior year, however, STUDENT's absences increased significantly over the prior two years and he failed three classes each semester. The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence presented by the Scholarship Record and the testimony of Ms. King and Ms. Giamo is persuasive that STUDENT's failing grades are attributable not to the District's failure to provide materials, but instead are attributable to STUDENT's failure to attend class on a regular basis and turn in classwork.
In response to the District's contention that Petitioner's absences were the cause of his failing grades, Petitioner testified that many of his absences were attributable to his leaving class to get materials enlarged. However, Petitioner did not present any supporting evidence that this was the case. Instead, the evidence establishes that STUDENT's absences were at their lowest at the time he should have had the most absences. When the system was not working perfectly, during STUDENT's freshman year and STUDENT may have needed to leave class to get materials, his absences were not as high as during his junior year when the system was working. The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT testified that he did not attend any of his junior-level courses during the current year and only attended his two senior-level courses. STUDENT did not attribute these absences to a lack of materials.
While Petitioner identified isolated incidents related to the District's failure to provide enlarged materials, he did not establish a pattern of failure that significantly impacted his ability to benefit from his education. Instead, the evidence establishes that STUDENT's grades were attributable to his absences and failure to turn in assigned work. Pursuant to the Rowley standard, Petitioner did not establish that the District failed to provide an appropriate education.
(2) If the District failed to provide STUDENT with an appropriate education, is he entitled to compensatory education?
Based on the finding in Issue 1, the Hearing Officer does not reach Issue 2.
ORDER
Petitioner's requested claim for relief is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56505(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: May 2, 1996 ______________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: Ms. King is the assistant principal at Abraham Lincoln High School.
