California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 7, 1996
Student v. Plumas Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 289-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
Plumas Unified must reimburse a private speech assessment and 40% of private therapy costs; future therapy funding denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a six-year-old kindergartner filed for due process against Plumas Unified School District. Their son was eligible for special education because of a speech and language disorder. They asked the District to pay for three things: a private speech and language assessment, past private therapy from Kris Wilson, and future private therapy through October 1996.
The Hearing Officer found that the District broke Education Code section 56445. It did not reassess the student before he moved from a preschool special day class to regular kindergarten in August 1994, and an assessment from October 1993 did not meet that rule. By February 1996, conditions also called for a full reassessment under section 56381. District therapist Donna Pilgrim's one-word vocabulary tests and observations were only progress checks, not a full assessment. The District had to reimburse the private assessment by Speech Language Learning Associates.
The District owed nothing for therapy in summer 1994 because no evidence showed a need for extended school year services. The District's program met the student's needs and gave him educational benefit. But in 1994-95 he got therapy on only about 82% of the required days, and missed sessions were never made up, so the program did not follow his IEP. The Hearing Officer weighed the equities, including the parents' refusal of a third weekly session, and ordered the District to repay 40% of private therapy costs. The request for future private therapy was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied the preschool-to-kindergarten reassessment rule in Education Code section 56445 even though the child stayed in special education. It also shows a Hearing Officer reducing reimbursement on equitable grounds when a district missed about 20% of IEP sessions but still provided educational benefit.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for a private speech and language assessment obtained on February 2, 1996?
The District violated Education Code section 56445 by not reassessing the student before the preschool-to-kindergarten transition, and conditions warranted a comprehensive reassessment under section 56381 by February 1996; periodic progress checks did not count, so the private assessment must be reimbursed.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for private speech and language therapy received from 1994 to the date of this decision?
No reimbursement for summer 1994 because there was no evidence of ESY need. The District provided therapy on only about 82% of required days in 1994-95, so the program did not conform to the IEP. Weighing the equities, the Hearing Officer ordered 40% reimbursement of private therapy costs.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Is Plumas Unified School District required to pay for Petitioner's private speech and language therapy from the date of this decision through October 1996?
The current program was appropriate, there was no evidence of lingering deficits, and past reimbursement already compensated the student, so future private therapy was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- IEE at public expense. Upon proof presented by Petitioner, the District shall reimburse the cost of the independent speech and language assessment obtained in February 1996.
- Reimbursement. Upon proof presented by Petitioner, the District shall reimburse 40% of the costs of private speech and language therapy provided by Kris Wilson from April 1995 to the date of the decision. (The discussion section says August 1995 to the date of the decision.)
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Murphy v. Timberland Regional School District; Burr v. Ambach; Miener v. State of Missouri; Robert D. v. Andrews; Education Code § 56445; Education Code § 56381; Education Code § 56329; Education Code § 56366.3; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043
People named in the decision
- Kris Wilson, private speech-language pathologist; witness for Student, Private practice; former District resource specialist (August 1990 to February 1996)
- Donna Pilgrim, District speech and language specialist; witness for both parties, Plumas Unified School District
- Judy Broselle, preschool special day class teacher (1993-94), Plumas Unified School District
- Jim Grant, school psychologist and senior program specialist, Plumas Unified School District
- Janet McCoy, speech and language aide (1993-94), Plumas Unified School District
- Speech Language Learning Associates, private speech and language assessor (independent assessment), Yuba City
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Chester, California, on April 30 and May 1, 1996.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by his parents, MOTHER and FATHER. Kris Wilson, a private speech and language therapist, was also present on behalf of STUDENT during a portion of the hearing. Respondent Plumas Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Raymond Dunne. Also present on behalf of the District was Donna Pilgrim, speech and language therapist for the District.
ISSUES
1) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for a private speech and language assessment obtained on February 2, 1996?
2) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for private speech and language therapy received from 1994 to the date of this decision?
3) Is Plumas Unified School District required to pay for Petitioner's private speech and language therapy from the date of this decision through October 1996?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is six years old and currently in kindergarten. STUDENT was first found eligible for special education as a result of a speech and language disorder in October 1992, when he was in the Lodi Unified School District. At some point between October 1992 and October 1993, STUDENT's family moved to the Plumas Unified School District.
On October 2, 1993, Donna Pilgrim, the District's speech and language specialist, completed a speech and language assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Pilgrim used the Expressive and Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Tests, observations, and language samples to determine STUDENT's language abilities. STUDENT's scores on the One-Word tests were in the 5th percentile with a standard score of 75 on the expressive portion and in the 6th percentile with a standard score of 77 on the receptive portion. Based on her observations, Ms. Pilgrim stated that STUDENT's speech was approximately 5-10% intelligible but that it appeared STUDENT was trying to communicate. Ms. Pilgrim recommended a preschool placement and speech therapy for his language delays.
Following the assessment, an IEP meeting was convened. The IEP team placed STUDENT in a special day class preschool program at Chester Elementary School with speech and language services 2-3 times per week for 30 minutes per session. The IEP team also established goals and objectives to work on STUDENT's receptive and expressive language skills, language pragmatics, and articulation. Although the evidence is unclear as to when these goal were met, the IEP submitted into evidence indicates that all were met or partially met.
During the summer of 1994, STUDENT attended a private preschool program run by his mother and received private speech and language services from Kris Wilson, a private speech and language therapist, who also worked as a resource specialist for the District.
On August 31, 1994, an IEP meeting was convened. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT should enroll in a regular education kindergarten class because he would have more appropriate language role models. The IEP team also recommended that STUDENT receive resource specialist support services on an as needed basis. There was no evidence that STUDENT ever received or needed the resource specialist services.
In September 1994, Ms. Pilgrim again administered the Expressive and Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Tests to STUDENT. At that time, he scored in the 50th percentile with a standard score of 100 on the receptive test and in the 7th percentile with a standard score of 78 on the expressive test.
STUDENT's annual IEP, although due in October 1994, did not take place until December 1994 because of difficulties with schedules and an uncertainty as to who was STUDENT's case manager. On December 13, 1994, the IEP team convened and dismissed STUDENT from the resource specialist program. STUDENT's placement in the regular education kindergarten class was continued and STUDENT's speech and language services were continued twice a week for 30 minutes per session. The IEP also includes a note next to the "Number of Minutes of Special Education per day" which states "monitor, regular class observation 60 minutes per week." The IEP does not indicate the purpose of the observation or who was expected to carry it out.
The IEP team adopted a new set of goals and objectives to address STUDENT's expressive and receptive language and intelligibility. A notation on the IEP indicates that STUDENT's fluency was to be monitored. According to the IEP document submitted into evidence by the District, of the fifteen objectives, STUDENT had met twelve and three had to be continued. Again, it is unclear from the IEP document when the objectives were met.
Due to concerns raised by STUDENT's parents, another IEP meeting was convened on March 16, 1995. At that time, fluency and articulation were identified as concerns, and expressive language and on-task behaviors were identified as areas in which STUDENT was improving. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT's program should reinforce the kindergarten core curriculum and that communications between school and home should increase, including at-home activities for work on articulation. The IEP team agreed that Ms. Pilgrim would send home observation notes home every 2-3 weeks.
Also in March 1995, STUDENT returned to Ms. Wilson and began receiving private speech and language services in addition to those provided by the District. Ms. Wilson has continued providing private speech and language for STUDENT to the present. During the summer of 1995, STUDENT again participated in a private preschool program.
On April 10, 1995, the PARENTS met with Ms. Pilgrim. They agreed that STUDENT would continue twice a week sessions of speech and language therapy and that Ms. Pilgrim would provide a bi-weekly communications including progress STUDENT was making toward his objectives and specific methods used to support that progress.
For the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT re-enrolled in kindergarten, as was originally planned, to allow STUDENT to continue the progress he had made during the prior year. STUDENT also continue to receive two 30-minute sessions of speech and language services per week from Ms. Pilgrim.
On October 4, 1995, Ms. Pilgrim administered the Expressive One-Word test to STUDENT. At that time he scored in the 50th percentile. The copy of the test record form admitted into evidence does not indicate his standard score, although it does indicate that his raw score had increased to 53 from 12 in October 1993 and 22 in September 1994.
On February 1, 1996, Kris Wilson prepared a report that was provided to the private assessor, Speech Language Learning Associates in Yuba City, on February 2, 1996. According to Ms. Wilson's report, STUDENT's primary disability is in the are of his expressive language. Ms. Wilson stated that STUDENT was exhibiting delays in phonology, syntax, and morphology.
On February 2, 1996, Speech Language Learning Associates City conducted a speech and language evaluation at the request of STUDENT's parents. On the Goldman-Fristoe Test of Articulation, STUDENT scored in the fourth percentile and demonstrated substitution, deletion, and cluster reduction errors. On the Khan-Lewis Phonological Analysis, STUDENT had an age-equivalent score of 3-4. On the Test of Language Development-Primary, STUDENT received the following subtest scores:
Picture Vocabulary Oral Vocabulary Raw Score: 13 Raw Score: 10 Age Equiv: 6-3 Age Equiv: 6-9 Percentile: 50 Percentile: 50
Gram. Understanding Sentence Imitation Raw Score: 16 Raw Score: 3 Age Equiv: 6-7 Age Equiv: 3-1 Percentile: 63 Percentile: 5
Gram. Completion Work Discrimination Raw Score: 7 Raw Score: 1 Age Equiv: 3-6 Age Equiv: <3.3 Percentile: 9 Percentile: 2
Word Articulation Raw Score: 5 Age Equiv: <3-5 Percentile: 1
The assessor also stated that while STUDENT demonstrated articulation errors, he was understandable approximately 80% of the time. The assessor's initial diagnostic impression was that "STUDENT demonstrates moderated articulation deficits, although his speech production errors decrease with structure and modeling. His vocabulary skills are as strength; however, he demonstrated difficulty in other language skills, including syntax." The assessor recommended continued speech and language therapy that addresses articulation with an emphasis on phonological processes, increasing syntax, and increasing phonemic awareness including processing sound and sound changes.
On February 6, 1996, Ms. Pilgrim prepared an update, which was given to STUDENT's parents on March 12, 1996. According to that update, STUDENT's fluency continued to improve with his increase in language. Ms. Pilgrim recommended continued monitoring of fluency but did not recommend any fluency goals. With regards to articulation, Ms. Pilgrim identified specific sounds that STUDENT had mastered. The update also indicates that STUDENT's ability to answer questions had improved, along with his sentence length, attention, eye contact, vocabulary, and mean length of utterance.
On March 12, 1996,(Footnote 1) an IEP meeting was convened. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT continue with the same level of speech and language services and that he be reevaluated in September of 1996. The IEP team also recommended goals to continue addressing STUDENT's expressive language, sound discrimination, and sound change. STUDENT's parents did not agree with the goals and objectives and did not sign the IEP.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Petitioner's Witnesses
Kris Wilson, a private speech and language therapist, has provided speech and language therapy for STUDENT off and on since the summer of 1994. In addition to her private practice, Ms. Wilson was employed by the District from August 1990 until February 1996 when she resigned her position with the District.
Ms. Wilson testified that she provided speech and language therapy to STUDENT between his preschool and kindergarten programs because his parents wanted speech and language services to continue during the summer of 1994. Ms. Wilson testified that STUDENT also attended a private preschool program run by his mother during the summer of 1994. Ms. Wilson testified that, although STUDENT has a lot to say, much of what he did was unintelligible. Ms. Wilson testified that STUDENT had developed his own rules of simplification for producing speech. For instance, STUDENT deleted final consonants.
Ms. Wilson testified that her services ended when STUDENT enrolled in kindergarten in the fall of 1994 because he would be resuming speech and language therapy with the District. Ms. Wilson testified that the decision to enroll STUDENT in kindergarten was made because of the belief that a kindergarten program would be a language-rich environment in which STUDENT could develop his own language skills. Ms. Wilson testified that when STUDENT enrolled in kindergarten, his receptive language skills were at age level but his expressive language skills were very low.
Ms. Wilson began speech and language services again for STUDENT in March 1995 because his parents were concerned that STUDENT was not receiving speech and language services from the District as often as called for in his IEP. Ms. Wilson testified that when she started providing services again, she administered the Structured Photographic Expressive Language Test-Preschool (SPELT-P) to assess STUDENT's expressive language level. STUDENT scored below the first percentile and had only increased his "mean length of utterance" to 3.0 words from 2.5 words in August 1994. Ms. Wilson testified that STUDENT should have showed more progress than her test scores indicated.
Ms. Wilson testified that she has continued providing speech and language services one to two times per week since March 1995. Ms. Wilson testified that if the PARENTS had not obtained the private assessment in February, she would have conducted her own assessment to determine STUDENT's progress and what areas needed to be focused on.
Regarding the private assessment, Ms. Wilson testified that it shows that STUDENT's expressive language skills, as indicated by the TOLD, are still low. Ms. Wilson testified that what is significant about STUDENT's language abilities is that he is able to understand information provided to him but is not able to provide information of his own.
Ms. Wilson testified that STUDENT is a high functioning student who is succeeding in the classroom. Ms. Wilson testified that the only piece missing from STUDENT's language skills is his expressive language. Ms. Wilson testified that STUDENT should have intensive speech and language services -- 3-4 times per week-- to assist him in improving his intelligibility and expressive language. Ms. Wilson testified that STUDENT would receive some benefit from two speech and language sessions per week, but because of his age and intelligence, the therapy could and should be more intensive.
Judy Broselle was STUDENT's public preschool special day class teacher during the 1993-94 school year. Ms. Broselle testified that STUDENT had a few words that were understandable but, for the most part, his speech was unintelligible. Ms. Broselle also testified that STUDENT was unable to answer "yes or no" questions. Ms. Broselle used a language-based program with her students to prepare them for kindergarten.
Ms. Broselle testified that STUDENT was supposed to have speech and language services provided by the District on a pull-out basis twice a week for 25-30 minutes each session. Ms. Broselle testified that she did not recall STUDENT being pulled out of her classroom as often as the IEP required.
Ms. Broselle testified that in June 1994 when STUDENT completed the preschool year, he had the skills to go into kindergarten.
Jim Grant is a school psychologist and senior program specialist for the District. Mr. Grant testified that STUDENT was in another District when he was found eligible for special education. Mr. Grant testified that if he had known that STUDENT was going to be placed in kindergarten in the fall of 1994, he would have completed a reassessment. However, Mr. Grant did not know of STUDENT's kindergarten placement until the IEP meeting in August 1994 at which the decision was made. As a result, Mr. Grant testified that there was no time to conduct a transition assessment.
Mr. Grant testified that a majority of speech and language services provided to kindergartners is on a pull-out basis and that there is less pull-out speech and language therapy for preschoolers.
Janet McCoy worked as a speech and language aide during the 1993-94 school year and provided a significant amount of the speech and language services that STUDENT received during that school year. Ms. McCoy testified that most of the services were provided in the preschool classroom.
According to Ms. McCoy, she provided services under Donna Pilgrim's direct supervision and met with Ms. Pilgrim every day to review lesson plans and the progress the students were making. Ms. McCoy testified that Ms. Pilgrim also would occasionally observe STUDENT and conduct formal and informal testing to check on his progress.
Ms. McCoy testified that STUDENT made progress during the 1993-94 school year in the areas of eye contact (from little eye contact at the beginning to frequent eye contact at the end), using real words for objects, and trying to communicate with others. Ms. McCoy testified that although STUDENT had made progress during the school year, the October 1993 assessment was still an accurate reflection of STUDENT's abilities because he still needed a lot of work.
Petitioner/District Witness
Donna Pilgrim(Footnote 2) is the District's speech and language specialist responsible for providing services to STUDENT since he enrolled in the District. Ms. Pilgrim testified that pull-out speech and language services are not provided the first week or two of the school year because the teachers want the children to be comfortable in their classes first.
Ms. Pilgrim testified that she charts a student's progress through testing, language samples, observational notes, and the student's goals and objectives. Ms. Pilgrim testified that the last complete speech and language assessment was in October of 1993 but that she has administered the Expressive One-Word and Receptive One-Word tests to STUDENT and produced language samples to measure his progress. Regarding the need for a transition assessment, Ms. Pilgrim testified that such an assessment should be done in all areas of disability and that the October 1993 assessment was such an assessment and was still accurate in the fall of 1994.
Ms. Pilgrim testified that STUDENT's speech was approximately 5-10% intelligible in October 1993. Ms. Pilgrim testified that STUDENT knew very few words and rarely put two words together. At the time, Ms. Pilgrim believed that STUDENT's primary needs were in the areas of receptive and expressive language, articulation, pragmatics. Ms. Pilgrim also has noticed problems with disfluency (stuttering) but testified that disfluency is no longer an issue with STUDENT. Ms. Pilgrim testified that as STUDENT's vocabulary has increased his disfluency has decreased.
Ms. Pilgrim testified that during the 1993-94 school year, direct speech and language services were provided twice a week, primarily in the classroom. Ms. Pilgrim testified that these services were provided by Ms. McCoy with Ms. Pilgrim providing assistance with lesson plans, observations, and helping when STUDENT was pulled out of the classroom. Ms. Pilgrim also monitored STUDENT's progress on his goals and objectives.
Regarding STUDENT's progress, Ms. Pilgrim testified that by June 1994 STUDENT had improved his utterances from one word to three words; had increased his vocabulary with this receptive language up to the 50th percentile and his expressive language at the seventh percentile; had increased his attention span, eye contact, two-way conversation, and intelligibility; and was answering to his name and following directions. STUDENT's articulation had also improved to the point that he was using some final consonants and was able to pronounce "voiceless" consonants.
Ms. Pilgrim testified that STUDENT's needs during the 1994-95 school year consisted of continuing to work on his articulation and language, primarily his expressive language. During the 1994-95 school year, Ms. Pilgrim provided speech and language services twice a week, primarily on a pull-out basis. To determine progress, Ms. Pilgrim administered the Receptive and Expressive One-Word tests, observed STUDENT, and had STUDENT produce language samples.
Ms. Pilgrim testified that she proposed an additional session of speech and language in March 1995 so that STUDENT could take advantage of a new group of students that was forming to work on pragmatics and continue receiving the same amount of one-to-one work. Ms. Pilgrim testified that this proposal was rejected by STUDENT's parents during an IEP meeting on March 16, 1995. During that IEP meeting, the IEP team did agree to tie STUDENT's speech and language therapy to his kindergarten curriculum and increase school-to-home communications.
In April 1995, Ms. Pilgrim again raised the issue of a third day of services. Ms. Pilgrim testified that the parents again rejected the proposal because STUDENT was now receiving two days of private therapy. Ms. Pilgrim testified that during the spring of 1995 she was still monitoring STUDENT's progress through observations, progress on goals and objectives, and conversations with his teacher. Ms. Pilgrim testified that what STUDENT does in therapy and in the classroom provides a better measure than standardized testing and that she does not need to conduct standardized testing to determine his functioning level. By the spring of 1995, STUDENT was still increasing his vocabulary, understandability, and articulation. Ms. Pilgrim testified that, by the spring of 1995, STUDENT has met goals 1,2,3,4 (not including 4a), 5,6, and 8 (not including 8b) on his current IEP.
Regarding the independent assessment conducted in February 1996, Ms. Pilgrim testified that it was a valid assessment and provided a good picture of STUDENT. Ms. Pilgrim testified that the results are consistent with what she has observed in STUDENT, although she did testify that the Word Discrimination subtest was not an accurate measure because it does not test vocabulary with context and STUDENT's functional vocabulary is good when he can use context to figure words out. As to the recommendations contained in the assessment, Ms. Pilgrim testified that the District has already been addressing several of them and has started to work on the other recommendations since the IEP meeting in March 1996.
Ms. Pilgrim testified that STUDENT's goals and objectives should now focus on articulation and language areas including syntax and morphology. Ms. Pilgrim base her opinion regarding STUDENT's goals and objectives on how he has progressed in meeting previous goals and objectives, her observations of STUDENT, and the language samples he has produced.
According to Ms. Pilgrim, STUDENT received 47 days of speech and language services out of a possible 57 days during the 1994-95 school year, and for the 1995-96 school year through April 1996, STUDENT received 37 days of speech and language therapy and 8 observations for a total of 45 days of services. Most of the observations occurred between February 7, 1996 and April 1996.
DISCUSSION
1) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for a private speech and language assessment obtained on February 2, 1996?
Education Code § 56329 (b) provides that
[a] parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists… if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency.
However, the public education agency may initiate a due process hearing… to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the final decision resulting from the due process hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense.
Petitioner contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for the private speech and language assessment because of the District's failure to comply with several assessment-related provisions of state special education law. First, Petitioner contends that the District violated Education Code § 56445 by failing to conduct a transition assessment when STUDENT moved from preschool to kindergarten n August of 1994. Section 56445(a) provides that
[p]rior to transitioning an individual with exceptional needs from a preschool program to kindergarten… an appropriate reassessment of the individual shall be conducted… to determine if the individual is still in need of special education and services. The District contends that a transition reassessment was not necessary because the District was not proposing to move STUDENT out of special education. The District's contention is that statements of legislative intent contained elsewhere in § 56445 establish that the District was not required to conduct a transition reassessment because the District was considering removing STUDENT from special education. For instance, subsection (b) states that
[I]t is the intent of the Legislature that gains made in the special education program… are not lost by too rapid a removal of individualized programs and supports…
The District's argument, however, ignores the very clear language of subsection (a). A transition reassessment shall be conducted when a student with exceptional needs is considered for transition from preschool to kindergarten. While policy statements may explain the purpose behind such a requirement, the policy statements do not override the very clear language of subsection (a).
Furthermore, the District misreads subsection (b). The policy behind requiring transition reassessments is to prevent individual programs or services from being removed too soon, not just the removal of a child from special education. STUDENT's special education placement changed significantly from preschool to kindergarten. In preschool, STUDENT was enrolled in a special day class and received two sessions of speech and language services per week. When STUDENT enrolled in kindergarten in August 1994, his program changed to a regular education class with resource specialist monitoring and speech and language services.
While the District may not have considered moving STUDENT from his speech and language therapy, the transition did involve a significant change in STUDENT's overall special education placement. Section 56445 required that the District complete a transition reassessment when STUDENT was moved from preschool to kindergarten.The District argues that a transition reassessment was not necessary because a comprehensive assessment had been completed in October 1993. However, the District's argument again ignores the very clear language of § 56445 (a) and the policy behind that section. The policy behind requiring a transition reassessment is to record progress made by the child during his preschool program to ensure that he does not suffer a change in services too rapidly. An assessment completed ten months prior to the child's transition from preschool to kindergarten not only does not satisfy the clear language of subsection (a) but also does not serve to record the progress made by the child to satisfy the statement of legislative intent contained in subsection (b). It is important to note that STUDENT was, and is still, at an age where rapid progress could be made in a short period of time. Such progress may require reassessments to occur on a more frequent basis than every three years. Witnesses noted that STUDENT made progress during the 1993-94 school year. Such progress adds further reason to require the District to comply with the transition reassessment requirement contained in § 56445 (a).
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District had a statutory obligation to conduct a transition reassessment of STUDENT prior to his transition from preschool to kindergarten in August of 1994. Additionally, the assessment conducted in October 1993 did not constitute an assessment which satisfies that statutory obligation.
Petitioner's second contention regarding reimbursement for the private assessment is that the District should have conducted a comprehensive reassessment at some point during the past year and a half. The contention of Petitioner is that the District's failure to do so violates Education Code § 56381. Section 56381 provides that
[a] reassessment of the pupil… shall be conducted at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the pupil's parent or teacher requests a new assessment and a new individualized education program to be developed.(Footnote 3)
The District contends that a comprehensive reassessment has not been necessary because there has been no change in circumstances that warrants a reassessment.
Reassessments conducted pursuant to § 56381 must be done in conformance with the assessment provisions of state law, starting with § 56320. The assessment provisions require, among other things, that assessments include more than one procedure to determine the appropriate educational program for the student, and that the pupil be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. In addition, § 56321 requires that before an assessment is conducted, a proposed assessment plan must be developed and approved by the student's parents.
There are two issues to address. First, did conditions warrant conducting an assessment at any time since October 1993, when the District conducted its last assessment of STUDENT? Second, if the District did have such an obligation, was the obligation to assess fulfilled by Ms. Pilgrim?
The District was required to conduct a transition reassessment in August 1994 and did not do so. STUDENT is at an age when significant progress can be made in a short period of time. This potential for rapid change is recognized by the Legislature's requirement of a transition assessment to determine what progress, if any, has been made before moving a child from preschool to kindergarten. In addition, almost two more years have passed since the transition reassessment was due. Again, because of the potential for change, conditions warranted conducting an assessment to determine what progress STUDENT had made.
Considering the lack of a transition reassessment and the time that has lapsed since STUDENT's last assessment in October 1993, the Hearing Officer finds that by February 1996, when the private speech and language assessment was obtained, the District had an obligation to conduct a comprehensive speech and language assessment to determine STUDENT's progress and his needs.
The District contends that the Expressive and Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test administered by Ms. Pilgrim, the language samples obtained by Ms. Pilgrim, and Ms. Pilgrim's observations over the past several years were sufficient to record STUDENT's progress and determine his needs. While the Hearing Officer does not question Ms. Pilgrim's ability to record STUDENT's progress, the problem with the District's contention is that Ms. Pilgrim was not doing anything more than any special education teacher or therapist does during the course of the year. By requiring a comprehensive assessment, § 56320 requires more. Section 56320 requires an assessment which addresses all areas of a child's suspected disability and requires the assessor to use an array of procedures to conduct the assessment and determine the child's needs.
The only standardized testing used by Ms. Pilgrim since 1993 was the Expressive and Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Tests, which only assess a student's basic expressive and receptive language skills. On the other hand, the private speech and language assessment included three different standardized tests. These tests covered articulation, phonological process, picture vocabulary, oral vocabulary, grammar understanding, sentence imitation, grammar completion, word discrimination, word articulation. The results of the assessment provided concrete measures of STUDENT's strengths and weaknesses in articulation, phonological process, semantics, and syntax.
The private speech and language assessment conducted in February 1996 is the type of comprehensive assessment that STUDENT needed to determine what progress he had made. The ongoing "progress check" conducted by Ms. Pilgrim does not constitute the kind of assessment envisioned by § 56320 and required in this case because of STUDENT's age and potential for progress.
The District further contends that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the private assessment because it did not provide the District with any meaningful information that was not already known by the District. The District does not cite any legal authority for the position. Furthermore, there is no provision in the Education Code which limits reimbursement for an independent assessment to circumstances where the independent assessment provides new information.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District had an obligation to conduct a reassessment in August 1994. The District failed to fulfill that obligation and also failed to conduct a reassessment in compliance with § 56381. Therefore, pursuant to § 56329, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the private speech and language assessment obtained in February 1996.
2) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for private speech and language therapy received from 1994 to the present?
State and federal law requires that students with disabilities receive a free and appropriate public education. (California Education Code § 56000 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 USC § 1400 et seq.) Pursuant to 20 USC § 1401 (18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents or guardians, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings; and instruction in physical education." 20 USC § 1401 (16).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the ‘basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the child. 458 U.S. 175, 200.
The Rowley court also held that if a school district commits procedural violations, the violations could rise to the level of rendering a placement inappropriate. Petitioner contends that delays in conducting his IEPs are procedural violations which render his placement inappropriate. The Hearing Officer finds that the delay in STUDENT's IEPs did not prejudice STUDENT's ability to benefit from his education. Since August of 1994, STUDENT's level of speech and language services have remained the same. STUDENT's parents never proposed additional therapy and when Ms. Pilgrim suggested a third day of therapy per week, they rejected the proposal. Furthermore, the evidence establishes that the responsibility for the delayed IEP meetings does not rest entirely with the District. Several meetings were canceled or postponed at the PARENT's request.
The IDEA and the Rowley Court's interpretation of the IDEA provide three factors for analyzing whether a school district's education program is appropriate. Those three factors are as follows:
1. whether the program is designed to meet the student's unique needs; 2. whether the program is designed to provide educational benefit to the student; and 3. whether the program conforms with the student's IEP; and
Summer of 1994
During the summer of 1994, STUDENT did not participate in any District programs or speech and language therapy. Ms. Wilson testified that she provided private speech and language services during the summer of 1994 because STUDENT's parents wanted him to continue such services during that period.
California Code of Regulations § 3043 provides that
[e]xtended school year services shall be provided for each individual with exceptional needs who has unique needs and requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year. Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil's educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.
There was no evidence presented to support the notion that STUDENT is an individual who needs extended school year services. More specifically, no evidence was presented that STUDENT's speech and language impairment will continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period. Rather, the evidence presented establishes that STUDENT has made progress in many areas to the point that he has reached age appropriate levels already or will reach age-appropriate levels soon. In addition, no evidence was presented that STUDENT would experience regression or that he had limited recoupment capacity.
Based on the lack of evidence that STUDENT needed extended school year services, the Hearing Officer finds pursuant to § 3043 that the District was not obligated to provide extended school year services during the summer of 1994 and that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the speech and language services obtained during that time.
March 1995 to the Present
Using the Rowley three factor test, the first question to be asked is whether the District's program during this time period was designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs. The evidence establishes that STUDENT's only educational needs are in the speech and language area. All assessments and testing done from October 1993 to the present establish that STUDENT's primary disability is in the area of expressive language skills. STUDENT's receptive language skills have consistently been much better than his expressive language skills, and have reached age-appropriate levels. Therefore, STUDENT's needs include speech and language therapy which focuses on expressive language skills, including articulation, phonological process, syntax, and pragmatics.(Footnote 4)
Ms. Pilgrim testified that her speech and language therapy for STUDENT has focused on articulation and language, primarily his expressive language. In addition, STUDENT's IEP from December 1994 lists a series of goals and objectives aimed at increasing his expressive language skills. The objectives included such things as naming selected items and describing them to classmates or teachers; selecting vocabulary items; using descriptive terms to compare items; increasing intelligibility on an "utterance sample" by turning to the listener and articulating all syllables; increasing ability to lift and sustain lip; and increasing mean length of utterances through the understanding and consistent use of pronouns, the verb "is," and noun-verb agreement. The IEP proposed in March 1996, but not agreed to by STUDENT's parents, continue with goals and objectives in similar areas.
Ms. Pilgrim's testimony and the goals and objectives which she was working on establish that the speech and language services were designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs in the area of expressive language. Furthermore, the fact that 12 of the 15 goals were met establishes that the program was meeting STUDENT's needs.
With regards to whether the District's program provided STUDENT with educational benefit, it is important to note that Rowley does not require that a school district's program maximize a student's potential. Instead, Rowley only requires schools to provide some educational benefit to the student. In the present case, the analysis is made difficult by the fact that STUDENT was receiving private therapy twice a week for the time period in question. However, there are certain factors which establish that the program provided by the District was providing STUDENT with educational benefit.
While STUDENT was in preschool during the 1993-94 school year, he received a similar quantity and type of speech and language services from Ms. Pilgrim to the services Ms. Pilgrim provided while STUDENT also received private therapy. During that year, according to Ms. Broselle, his preschool teacher, he acquired the necessary skills to advance to kindergarten. In addition, Ms. Pilgrim testified that he increased his utterances from one word to three words; increased his vocabulary, eye contact, and two-way conversation; and had improved his intelligibility. STUDENT also met the goals and objectives contained in his IEP. During most of the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT continued to receive two days of speech therapy per week. Again, the record establishes that he was progressing in his language skills and was able to meet a significant number of the goals and objectives on his IEP. The Hearing Officer also notes that Ms. Wilson testified that STUDENT can receive benefit from two days of therapy per week.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's program of two days of speech therapy per day provided STUDENT with educational benefit during the 1993-94 school year and during that portion of the 1994-95 school year when he was not receiving private speech and language services. There is no evidence that STUDENT suddenly stopped receiving such benefit in April 1995.
Petitioner's primary contention is that the District's program of speech and language services did not conform to his IEP. Specifically, Petitioner points to the District's failure to provide him with two days of speech and language therapy each and every week. Ms. Pilgrim testified that STUDENT received 47 sessions of therapy during the 1994-95 school year and that during the 1995-96 school year he received 37 sessions of therapy and 8 observations through April 1996. The "Daily Speech Logs" introduced into evidence support Ms. Pilgrim's estimation of the number of sessions STUDENT received. The academic calendar for the 1994-95 school year establishes that there was approximately 57 days during which STUDENT should have received speech and language services.(Footnote 5) No effort was made to make up the ten days that were missed. The result is that STUDENT received speech and language therapy on approximately 82% of the days on which he should have during the 1994-95 school year.
For the current school year, Ms. Pilgrim testified that STUDENT had received 45 days of speech and language services by April 1996. The parties did not introduce into evidence an academic calendar for the current school year, so a determination could not be made regarding the number of days of services STUDENT should have received by April 1996.
The issue then is whether a program that provides speech and language services during 82% of the days STUDENT was to receive the services is in conformance with the his IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that such a program is not in conformance with STUDENT's IEP. Missing almost 20% of his speech and language sessions could result in a significant setback in his acquisition of the skills he needs to progress. Despite the benefit provided to STUDENT, the speech and language services provided by the District were not in compliance with STUDENT's IEP. Therefore, the program provided by the District during the 1994-95 school year was not appropriate as required by the IDEA and Rowley.
Since the academic calendar for the current school year was not introduced, insufficient evidence was presented to determine the exact level of service STUDENT has received this year. Based on the insufficient evidence, Petitioner failed to establish that the District's program for the current school year is not in conformance with the STUDENT's IEP. The Hearing Office notes that by April 1996 STUDENT had received almost as many sessions of services as he had received during the entire 1994-95 school year. Based on the number of sessions STUDENT has already received, it appears likely that STUDENT will received substantially more sessions of speech and language this year as compared to last year.
When a school district fails to provided an educational program which satisfies the three factor test, a student may be entitled to reimbursement for private special education services. See Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education, EHLR 556:389 (S. Ct. 1985). The Burlington Court was interpreting 20 USC § 1415 (e)(2), which provides that such relief as is deemed appropriate shall be granted. The Court concluded that § 1415 (e)(2) "means that equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief." Burlington, EHLR 556:389,396.
Although the District technically failed to provide an appropriate program for STUDENT during the 1994-95 school year, the District did substantially meet STUDENT's needs and provide him with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer finds that the District's provision of a substantially appropriate program is a mitigating factor which should be considered in determining the District's responsibility to reimburse Petitioner for the private therapy. Ultimately, the District did meet STUDENT's needs and provide him with education benefit. Furthermore, when Ms. Pilgrim offered to increase to increase speech and language services to three days per week, STUDENT's parents rejected this offer.
Weighing in favor of reimbursement is the fact that the District failed in its obligations to conduct a transition assessment in August 1994 or a reassessment at any time since October 1993, although the evidence establishes that a reassessment was warranted by the circumstances. The District's failure to assess may have affected the District's ability to meet STUDENT's needs. In addition, if the District had properly assessed STUDENT, some of the PARENTS' concerns may have been alleviated and they may not have found it necessary to obtain private speech and language services. Finally, although STUDENT missed almost 20% of his therapy sessions, no effort was made to make up these sessions.
Taking the above circumstances into account the Hearing Officer finds that the District's failure to provide a program in conformance with STUDENT's IEP during the 1994-95 school year should not result in the District's being held entirely responsible for the private speech and language provided from April 1995 to the present. The Hearing Officer finds that the District should reimburse Petitioner for 40% of the cost of the private speech and language therapy received by Petitioner from August 1995 to the date of this decision. This figure takes into account the approximately 20% of sessions that were missed during the 1994-95 school year and not made up, as well as the District's failure to properly assess STUDENT and the effect that failure may have had on the provision of services to STUDENT.
The District contended that Education Code § 56366.3 precludes the District from reimbursing Ms. Wilson for the speech and language services she provided to STUDENT. Section 56366.3(a) provides that
[n]o contract for special education and related services provided by a nonpublic, nonsectarian school or agency shall be reimbursed by the state pursuant to Sections 56740 and 56775 if the contract covers special education and related services, administration, or supervision by an individual who was an employee of a contracting district, special education local plan area, or county office within the last 365 days, unless the contract contains an addendum establishing that the individual was involuntarily terminated or laid off as part of necessary staff reductions from the district, special education local plan area, or county office.
The Hearing Officer notes that there are several reasons why this section does not apply to the present case. First, an order of reimbursement by a Hearing Officer is not reimbursement made pursuant to a contract between a district and former employee. Second, an order of reimbursement by a Hearing Officer is not made pursuant to Sections 56740 or 56775 but pursuant to Burlington. The Hearing Officer finds that § 56366.3 does not bar an order of reimbursement for a former employee of the District. 3) Is Plumas Unified School District required to pay for Petitioner's private speech and language therapy through October 1996?
The evidence presented establishes that the District's program for STUDENT can provide him with an appropriate level of services so long as he is provided with two sessions of therapy per week as called for the IEP. There is no evidence that the District's program for the time from now until October 1996 is inappropriate. Therefore, it appears that Petitioner is requesting prospective relief to make up for the District's failure to provide an appropriate program in the past.
Compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded if it is determined that a school district failed to provide an appropriate program for a disabled student which resulted in the student failing to advance at an appropriate rate. See Lester H. v. Gilhool (3rd Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Murphy v. Timberland Regional School District (1st Cir. 1992); Burr v. Ambach (2nd Cir. 1988) 863 F.2d 1071; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749; Robert D. v. Andrews (11th Cir. 1991) 933 F.2d 1576.
There is no evidence that the District's program during the current school year in inappropriate. There is also no evidence that Petitioner is exhibiting deficiencies that have resulted from the District's failure to provide an appropriate program during the 1994-95 school year. The evidence establishes that STUDENT has received more services than he needs to benefit from his education and that he is approaching age-appropriate levels in most speech and language areas. The services STUDENT has received have been in the form of both publicly and privately provided speech and language services.
The District has already been ordered to reimburse Petitioner for a significant portion of the private speech and language services. Petitioner has already been amply compensated for the District's failure to provide an appropriate program during the 1994-95 school year. As already noted, while the District did not comply with the technical requirements of the IEP, thereby rendering the program inappropriate under the IDEA and Rowley, the program did in fact substantially meet STUDENT's unique needs and provide him with educational benefit.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to an award for future speech and language services. The District is not required to compensate Petitioner for the cost of private speech and language services obtained between the date of this decision and October 1996.
ORDER
(1) Upon proof presented by Petitioner, Plumas Unified School District shall reimburse Petitioner for the cost of the independent assessment obtained in February 1996.
(2) Upon proof presented by Petitioner, Plumas Unified School District shall reimburse Petitioner for 40% of the costs of the private speech and language therapy provided by Kris Wilson from April 1995 to the date of this decision.
(3) Petitioner's other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56505(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Issue #1: Petitioner prevailed Issue #2: Petitioner prevailed in part, Respondent prevailed in part. Issue #3: Respondent prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505 (i).
DATED: June 7, 1996 ______________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: STUDENT's annual IEP was due in December 1995. However, it appears from the evidence submitted that his annual IEP meeting did not take place until February 7, 1996, again due to scheduling conflicts between the parties. For example, although an IEP meeting was scheduled for December 11, 1995 it was not held and another meeting was scheduled for December 14, 1995 at 4:00p.m. However, this IEP meeting was canceled because MOTHER was unable to attend. In addition, there was no document submitted into evidence constituting an IEP developed on that date. Instead, there is correspondence which makes reference to an IEP meeting on February 7, 1996, and an actual IEP dated March 12, 1996.
Footnote 2: Ms. Pilgrim was called by both parties and was the only witness called by the District.
Footnote 3: The District contends that the parents never requested a reassessment. Although there is some evidence that STUDENT's parents expressed dissatisfaction with the manner in which STUDENT's progress was being tracked, there is no evidence that STUDENT's parents made a specific request that a reassessmetn be conducted.
Footnote 4: Ms. Wilson described articulation as being "the way we talk," syntax as being "how we put sentences together," pragmatics as being the "appropriate use of language," and phonological process as "how we produce speech."
Footnote 5: This number excludes days that were not available because of scheduling conflicts, including holidays, in-service training, and requests by STUDENT's teacher that he not be taken out of the class on specific days.
