California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 30, 1999
Student v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 29-99 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown
Manhattan Beach Unified must provide compensatory education for summer 1997, summer 1998 and 1997-98 FAPE denials; reimbursement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Parents filed for due process for their 11-year-old son, a fifth grader at Pacific Elementary School in Manhattan Beach Unified School District. He was eligible for special education based on autism, a learning disability, and speech and language deficits. During 1997-98 he moved from a special day class into general education with an aide, curriculum modifications, and speech therapy. The parents challenged his program from June 1997 through October 1999 and sought reimbursement for Fast ForWord programs and private Reading Center tutoring.
The Hearing Officer found four denials of FAPE. The District placed him in a special day class for summer 1997 rather than his least restrictive environment. It offered only brief speech-therapist modeling to teach social skills in 1997-98. It provided no extended school year services in summer 1998, although his October 1997 IEP called for them. And his 1997-98 program produced no meaningful progress in reading comprehension, listening comprehension, and oral expression. Claims about the inclusion specialist's qualifications, curriculum modifications, and progress reports failed. The fall 1998 IEP, offering pull-out resource specialist reading instruction during the school day, provided FAPE; the District did not have to offer reading help outside school hours. Reimbursement was denied because the private services did not target the denied areas, predated the denial, or lacked proof of appropriateness or benefit. The District must hold an IEP meeting within 30 days to set compensatory education for 1999-2000, including social skills and remedial academic instruction.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied the Rachel H. factors both to find a special day class summer placement too restrictive and to uphold short daily pull-out reading instruction. It also shows a Hearing Officer denying reimbursement for unproven private services while leaving the form of compensatory education to the IEP team.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE from June 1997 to October 1998?
FAPE denied by special day class placement for summer 1997 (not LRE), inadequate social skills instruction in 1997-98, failure to provide ESY in summer 1998, and no meaningful progress in reading comprehension, listening comprehension and oral expression; claims about inclusion specialist qualifications, curriculum modifications, progress reports, summer reading programs, unspecified aide time, and ending collaboration meetings were rejected; pre-June 1997 LRE notice claim was outside the period at issue.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE from October 1998 to October 1999?
The October/November 1998 IEP offering pull-out resource specialist reading instruction (about 4 hours 20 minutes weekly) during the school day offered FAPE in the LRE; refusing to attach the parents' 'What STUDENT Needs' document to the IEP did not deny FAPE, and the District need not provide reading services outside school hours.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for Fast ForWord training during summer 1997, Fast ForWord 2 training in winter 1999, and reading tutoring at the Reading Center from October 1997 through May 1998?
Reimbursement denied: the private services did not address the socialization denials, summer 1997 Fast ForWord came before the denial period, Reading Center tutoring was not shown appropriate, and Fast ForWord 2 benefit was not shown; compensatory education awarded instead.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4a. If the District did not propose an appropriate placement for STUDENT at the October and November 1998 IEP meetings, does provision of an appropriate placement include tutoring services at the Reading Center?
Because the October/November 1998 IEP was appropriate, the request for prospective Reading Center tutoring was not considered.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4b. If the District did not propose an appropriate placement for STUDENT at the October and November 1998 IEP meetings, does provision of an appropriate placement include District reading services provided outside of school hours?
Because the October/November 1998 IEP was appropriate, the request for prospective District reading services outside school hours was not considered.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 30 calendar days of the decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to determine the appropriate form of compensatory education for the denials of FAPE in summer 1997, summer 1998, and the 1997-98 school year.
- Compensatory education. Compensatory education to supplement STUDENT's 1999-2000 program; the IEP team (including parents) shall include social skills instruction and/or modeling and remedial instruction in areas of academic deficit, determine the nature and extent of services, and decide whether to provide them during the school day or during nonschool hours. No hours specified.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H.; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Burlington; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Alamo Heights v. State Board of Education
People named in the decision
- Marianne O'Brien-Gordon, private speech-language pathologist; witness for Student, The Reading Center
- Dr. Christine Norvell, principal, Pacific School, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Jennifer Czechowski, inclusion assistant, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Julie Powell, school psychologist; triennial assessor, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Robert Schramm, special education teacher/inclusion specialist; case carrier, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Ray Uhls, inclusion assistant/1:1 aide, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Carole Hoesterey, resource specialist; case carrier (spelled Hoestery elsewhere in decision), Manhattan Beach Unified
- Kristy Mulhaupt, fourth grade general education teacher, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Emily Gantner, school psychologist, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Liana Neyer, fifth grade general education teacher, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Anne Schwing, speech and language specialist, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Sharon Grandinette, coordinator of special education, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Linda Jones, director of pupil personnel services, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Linda Pollard, program specialist, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Tami Simmons, school nurse; triennial assessor, Manhattan Beach Unified
- Josie Chan, SELPA inclusion facilitator/mentor, SELPA (Meadows)
- Jean Perbix, SELPA collaboration specialist, SELPA
- Dr. B.J. Freeman, private evaluator who diagnosed autism, UCLA School of Medicine
- Carol Dygean, private educational consultant (social skills training)
- Harbor Regional Center, regional center that funded part of social skills training
- The Reading Center, private provider of Fast ForWord and reading tutoring
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 29-99 Case Year: 1999 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Individual Education Program Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 19-75333 District: Manhattan Beach Unified Disability Type: Autism Specific Learning Disability Speech or Language Impairment
Case Details This matter was heard before Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, on March 11 and 12, April 20 and 21, and May 12, 1999, in Manhattan Beach, California.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by his parents, FATHER and MOTHER. Respondent Manhattan Beach Unified School District (hereinafter referred to as District) was represented by attorney Andrew Arcyznski. Also present on the District's behalf was Linda Jones, director of pupil personnel services for the District.
Several District employees and friends of the PARENTS also observed portions of the hearing. (Footnote 1) Observers included Eunice Kramer, Susan Viker, Leonard Schapira, Marilyn Barazza, Marcia Whistler, Robert Schramm, Darlene Goury, Julie Powell and Susan Terry-Gage.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Marianne O'Brien-Gordon, speech pathologist, and MOTHER, STUDENT's mother.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Dr. Christine Norvell, principal of Pacific School; Jennifer Czechowski, District inclusion assistant; Julie Powell, District school psychologist; Robert Schramm, District special education teacher/inclusion specialist; Ray Uhls, District inclusion assistant; Carole Hoesterey, District resource specialist; Kristy Mulhaupt, District teacher; Emily Gantner, District school psychologist; Liana Neyer, District teacher; Anne Schwing, District speech and language specialist; and Sharon Grandinette, District coordinator of special education.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments only. Upon receipt of the parties' closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 2)
(1) Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE from June 1997 to October 1998?
(2) Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE from October 1998 to October 1999?
(3) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for Fast ForWord training during summer 1997, Fast ForWord 2 training in winter 1999, and reading tutoring at the Reading Center from October 1997 through May 1998?
(4) If the District did not propose an appropriate placement for STUDENT at the October and November 1998 IEP meetings, does provision of an appropriate placement include the following?
(a) tutoring services at the Reading Center;
(b) District reading services provided outside of school hours.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is 11 years old and lives in Manhattan Beach, California, with his parents, FATHER and MOTHER, and his younger brother. During the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT was in the fifth grade at Pacific Elementary School, in the Manhattan Beach Unified School District. STUDENT is eligible for special education due to a diagnosis of autism, a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement, and deficits in auditory processing, speech and language, and receptive and expressive language.
STUDENT was initially found eligible for special education when he was three years old, based on a diagnosis of speech and language deficiency. In 1991, STUDENT transferred into the District and began receiving speech and language therapy in the District. (Petitioner's Exh. Y.) During the 1992-93 school year, STUDENT attended the pre-elementary program (PEP) at the District's Pacific School, and also received speech and language services. While STUDENT was in PEP, the District conducted an assessment that expanded his diagnosis to include a learning disability and deficits in auditory processing, speech, language and articulation, and sensory motor integration. (Petitioner's Exh. B-3.) In February 1993, while still a preschooler, STUDENT began attending a Pacific special day class. From kindergarten until fourth grade, STUDENT spent the majority of his school day in a special day class, and also continued to receive speech and language therapy.
Pursuant to STUDENT's IEP dated December 10, 1996, STUDENT attended a special day class and received transportation services, extended school year services, and speech and language therapy for thirty minutes a session, three times a week. In March 1997, STUDENT's parents took him to UCLA School of Medicine to be assessed by Dr. B.J. Freeman, who diagnosed STUDENT with autism. (Petitioner's Exhs. B-13 and C.) Dr. Freeman provided PARENTS with a referral to educational consultant Carol Dygean. (Petitioner's Exh. U.) From June 1997 to August 1998, STUDENT received social skills training from Ms. Dygean. (Ibid.; testimony of MOTHER.)
In May 1997, STUDENT's parents took him for an assessment by Marianne O'Brien-Gordon, a licensed speech pathologist at the Reading Center. (Testimony of Ms. O'Brien-Gordon.) For eight weeks during the summer of 1997, STUDENT received the Fast ForWord program. (Ibid.) Thereafter, he received tutoring at the Reading Center during the 1997-98 school year.
For summer 1997, STUDENT attended the District's extended school year, continuing his placement in a special day class. In a letter to the District dated July 31, 1997, STUDENT's parents inquired about moving STUDENT from his special day class into a regular education class. (Petitioner's Exh. B-10.) In the fall of 1997, STUDENT began transitioning from his special day class to a regular education fourth grade class. As specified in his IEP dated October 9, 1997, STUDENT spent only part of his day in a special day class, and spent the majority of his day in a regular education fourth grade class taught by Ms. Mulhaupt. While in his general education classroom, STUDENT received some assistance from a teacher's aide, Ray Uhls. STUDENT also continued to receive speech and language therapy. The IEP team met again on December 9, 1997, to consult regarding STUDENT's progress as he transitioned into regular education. In January 1998, STUDENT completed his transition into regular education, and thereafter was fully included in regular education for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year.
In October 1997, as STUDENT was beginning his transition into general education fourth grade, his IEP team met to discuss the transition process. (Petitioner's Exh. B-13.) At the meeting, the team agreed to PARENTS' request that a SELPA inclusion team be assigned to assist in coordinating STUDENT's transition. Team members included Ms. Mulhaupt, District resource specialist Carole Hoestery, and SELPA inclusion facilitator Josie Chan. The inclusion team initially met every week or two, but the meetings gradually became less frequent after STUDENT completed his transition in January 1998. (Testimony of Robert Schramm, Ms. Hoestery, Ms. Mulhaupt.) The final inclusion team meeting occurred on April 2, 1998, and included STUDENT's parents. (See testimony of Ms. Mulhaupt.)
From January to June 1998, Ms. Hoestery served as STUDENT's case carrier and was the person in charge of overseeing his transition into general education. (Testimony of Ms. Hoestery.) However, Mr. Schramm also became involved in STUDENT's case after he started working in the District in December 1997. (Testimony of Mr. Schramm.) Mr. Schramm took over as STUDENT's case carrier at the beginning of the 1997-98 school year; his responsibilities included modifying the curriculum to accommodate STUDENT's strengths and weaknesses. (Ibid.)
During the summer of 1998, STUDENT attended general education summer school, without the assistance of an aide or similar supports. (Testimony of MOTHER.) In August 1998, prior to the start of the new school year, the District held an articulation meeting to allow STUDENT's parents to meet his new teachers and allow STUDENT's new teachers to gain information and insight from his parents and previous teachers. At that meeting, the participants discussed how, during fourth grade, STUDENT's aide and teacher utilized a communication log to inform STUDENT's parents about how STUDENT was doing in school each day. Their discussion also covered the role of STUDENT's aide and the appropriate level of curriculum modification.
For the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT was in Ms. Neyer's fifth grade class. He was fully included in the general education class and did not spend any part of his day in a special day class. He continued to receive support services, including speech and language therapy, and support from his aide, Ray Uhls. Mr. Uhls worked with STUDENT for approximately two to three hours each school day. Mr. Uhls met with Mr. Schramm once a week to discuss curriculum modification and other issues related to STUDENT's program in Ms. Neyer's class. (Testimony of Mr. Uhls, Mr. Schramm.) In September and October 1998, Mr. Schramm, Ms. Powell and the school nurse, Tami Simmons, conducted STUDENT's triennial assessment. (District's Exh. 16; testimony of Ms. Powell.) The assessment results showed that STUDENT had significant weaknesses in visual-motor integration and auditory processing. While STUDENT demonstrated weaknesses in language, his computation skills had improved since his last assessment.
Once the results of the triennial assessment were available, the District scheduled an IEP meeting, and both PARENTS attended. At the IEP meeting on October 30, 1998, the team members agreed that STUDENT had reading deficiencies and needed additional work on his reading. To address those deficiencies, the District offered STUDENT resource specialist program (RSP) services on a "pull- out" basis during the school day. PARENTS would not agree to RSP pull-out because they felt that the pull-out would negatively affect STUDENT's socialization with the other students. PARENTS instead wanted STUDENT to receive one-on-one reading instruction before or after school.
The participants at the October 30 meeting ran out of time before they resolved these matters, so the team scheduled another meeting for November 17, 1998. At that meeting, MOTHER submitted a document entitled "What STUDENT Needs." She asked that the document be attached to the IEP, but the District did not agree to attach the document. (Petitioner's Exh. B-21.) PARENTS and the District failed to reach agreement at the November 17 meeting, and PARENTS did not sign the IEP. On January 4, 1999, PARENTS requested a due process hearing.
Throughout the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT remained a fully-included student in Ms. Neyer's fifth grade class. He continued to receive speech and language therapy three times a week from the District speech pathologist, Anne Schwing, but he did not receive RSP services. In January and February 1999, in addition to attending fifth grade during the day, STUDENT also went through the Fast ForWord 2 program during after-school hours. STUDENT's parents provided the program to him at home, with monitoring by Ms. O'Brien-Gordon. In February 1999, the District notified PARENTS and other parents at Pacific Elementary that students could join the Rad Reading Club, which would meet one morning per week before the school day began. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT began participating in the reading club.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
(1) Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE from June 1997 to October 1998?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA µ97) and state law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code § 56000.) Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; California Education Code § 56000.) "FAPE" is defined as special education and related services that are available at no charge, meet state educational standards, and conform to the student's IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)
"Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term "related services" includes transportation and other services that may be required to allow a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(17).) California Education Code section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program."
The analysis of whether or not the District offered a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the required procedural steps were followed and whether the student's placement was substantively appropriate. (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 207-208.)
A. Procedural Appropriateness
Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that "Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation" at every step "as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP." (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205-206.) Procedural violations which result in a "loss of educational opportunity" or which "seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE." (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).)
Petitioner's original issue statement did not indicate that any period prior to June 1997 was at issue, and Petitioner agreed during discussions at the start of the hearing that the period prior to June 1997 was not at issue. Nevertheless, Petitioner appears to raise the issue that the District failed to inform his parents of the possibility that general education with supports and services could be his least restrictive environment (LRE). In light of the parties' agreement at the start of the hearing that the period prior to June 1997 was not at issue, evidence regarding discussions at IEP meetings prior to June 1997 was not admitted at the hearing. Given that the District began transitioning STUDENT into general education at the beginning of the 1997-98 school year, in reality any failure of the District to inform STUDENT's parents about LRE occurred prior to June 1997. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that any procedural violations on this issue occurred prior to the time period at issue in this proceeding and that, therefore, the Hearing Officer has no jurisdiction to rule on this issue.
Petitioner also alleges that the District failed to inform his parents about particular programs, such as summer reading programs for the 1997 and 1998 summers. Notably, there was no evidence offered at hearing to establish that STUDENT needed such a program. The Hearing Officer is unaware of any requirement under IDEA µ97 or state law that a local educational agency must inform parents of every potential placement and every potential designated instructional service. Thus, the District's failure to inform STUDENT's parents of the existence of the District's summer reading programs does not constitute a procedural violation resulting in a denial of FAPE.
Additionally, Petitioner asserts that the February 1998 IEP failed to specify how much time he would have each day with the teacher's aide/instructional assistant. Significantly, Mr. Uhls testified that he spends two to three hours each day with STUDENT. There was no evidence offered at hearing to establish that STUDENT has not been receiving adequate time from his aide. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that, to the extent that the failure to specify aide time constituted a violation of the IDEA or state law, such violation did not constitute an actual denial of FAPE.
B. Substantive Appropriateness
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that a school district must provide to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA µ97). The Court determined that a student's IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200.)
To determine whether or not the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, one must focus on the adequacy of the District's program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.) If the District's program reflected STUDENT's needs, would have provided some educational benefit, and comported with STUDENT's IEP, the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, even if STUDENT's parents preferred another program, and even if the parents' preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley at 207-208; Gregory K. at 1314.) A school district is not required to provide the best education available or to maximize educational benefits. The school district must provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)
September 1997- October 1998
Was the District's placement designed to address STUDENT's unique needs?
The first step in this analysis is to determine what STUDENT's unique needs were during the time period at issue. STUDENT was diagnosed as autistic and demonstrated a significant weakness in auditory processing. (Petitioner's Exh. C; Respondent's Exhs. 5, 6 and 18.) STUDENT's auditory processing difficulties are evidenced by his score in the fourth percentile on the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills and by his below-average scores on the Recalling Sentences and Oral Expressions subtests of the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals - Revised. (Id.) Similarly, Marianne O'Brien-Gordon, the speech pathologist who worked with STUDENT at the Reading Center, testified that STUDENT had strong visual abilities but weak auditory skills. Additionally, STUDENT demonstrated a weakness in visual-motor integration, as evidenced by his low score on the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration. (Respondent's Exh. 18.)
STUDENT also exhibited deficits in listening comprehension and language. (Respondent's Exhs. 5 and 6.) As a second-grader, STUDENT scored at a kindergarten level on both the listening comprehension section and the language composite of the WIAT. (Respondent's Exh. 18.) The results of his fall 1995 speech and language assessment indicated weakness in language processing. (Respondent's Exh. 18.) Accordingly, STUDENT's IEPs dated October 9 and December 9, 1997, state that STUDENT has a speech and language disorder in the area of expressive and receptive language. (Respondent's Exhs. 4 and 5.) Similarly, Ms. O'Brien-Gordon testified that STUDENT had delays in expressive and receptive language, and Dr. B.J. Freeman's April 1997 evaluation concluded that STUDENT had severe language processing problems. (Petitioner's Exh. C.)
It is undisputed that, due to his deficits in auditory processing, visual-motor integration, listening comprehension and language, STUDENT required supports and services to assist him in his general education classroom. (Respondent's Exhs. 4, 5 and 6.) Foremost, it is undisputed that STUDENT's deficits impacted his ability to learn and to comprehend regular fourth-grade and fifth- grade schoolwork and that, as a result, STUDENT required modification of the general education curriculum. (See testimony of MOTHER, Mr. Schramm, Ms. O'Brien-Gordon.) It is further undisputed that STUDENT also required speech and language therapy to address speech and language deficits. (See testimony of MOTHER; Respondent's Exhs. 4, 5, 6 and 18.)
Regarding reading comprehension, the agreed-upon IEPs during the time period in question do not include weakness in reading as part of STUDENT's special education ability statement. STUDENT's fall 1995 scores on the reading comprehension subtests of the WIAT and Woodcock-Johnson Revised were not significantly below average. (Respondent's Exh. 18.) STUDENT's fourth grade teacher testified that STUDENT could decode what he was reading, although he had some difficulty with discussing reading comprehension questions. Similarly, Dr. Freeman's report noted that while STUDENT, then a fourth- grader, was reading at a third grade level, he did demonstrate some difficulty with reading comprehension. (Petitioner's Exh. C.) Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had some difficulty with reading comprehension.
Finally, in part because of his autism and in part because of his transition from a special day class to regular education, STUDENT had unique needs in facilitating his transition to regular education and unique socialization needs. Regarding his transition to regular education, it is undisputed that additional oversight of STUDENT's program was necessary to facilitate a smooth transition and allow STUDENT to learn how to behave in a regular education classroom. (See testimony of Ms. Mulhaupt, Sharon Grandinette, MOTHER; Respondent's Exhs. 4 and 5.) Such necessary oversight included communication among staff involved in STUDENT's program to address issues arising during STUDENT's transition period. (See testimony of Mr. Schramm, Ms. Grandinette; Respondent's Exh. 4.)
Regarding STUDENT's socialization needs, MOTHER testified that STUDENT had delays in social skills and did not know how to interact with other children. As noted in the IEP document dated October 9, 1997, STUDENT exhibited "difficulty initiating and sustaining reciprocal communication and difficulty developing peer relationships." (Respondent's Exhs. 4 and 5.) Anne Schwing, STUDENT's speech therapist since July 1998, testified that STUDENT had difficulty with social skills, including making eye contact and asking appropriate questions. STUDENT's fourth grade teacher testified that when STUDENT initially entered her regular education fourth grade class in September 1997, he did not have a close connection with the other students, although they knew him and talked to him. However, Ms. Mulhaupt noted that beginning in January 1998, when STUDENT was fully included in her class, he began developing closer relationships with the other fourth-grade children. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the evidence discussed herein that STUDENT had some delays in his social skills and that STUDENT needed social skills addressed as part of his educational program. No persuasive testimony or documents were received into evidence to prove that STUDENT needed additional services to address these delays in order to receive a FAPE from September 1997 to October 1998. (Footnote 3)
Having determined STUDENT's unique needs during the period from September 1997 to October 1998, the Hearing Officer next evaluates whether the District offered STUDENT a program that addressed those needs. The District's offer included collaboration meetings for District personnel to discuss issues arising during STUDENT's transition, an additional set of textbooks for STUDENT to use at home, daily communication between STUDENT's instructors and his parents, speech and language therapy, assistance from a teacher's aide/ inclusion assistant during the school day, consultation with a SELPA inclusion team, curriculum modification and accommodations made by STUDENT's teacher, including extended time on tests and assignments. (Respondent's Exh. 5; testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Mulhaupt.) At the IEP meeting on December 9, 1997, the District also offered consultation by the resource specialist program (RSP) teacher for twenty minutes a week, and the services of an inclusion specialist to provide additional support with curriculum modifications and other inclusion issues. The District noted the availability of social skills curriculum if appropriate to address STUDENT's socialization needs and facilitate inclusion. At the IEP meeting on February 10, 1998, the District also modified STUDENT's goals and objectives, and specified additional accommodations, including "tests read aloud, answers dictated as needed," and "may use word processor for written work."
Additionally, the IEP dated October 9, 1997, offers extended school year services on the grounds that such services are required "to maintain skills." However, the IEPs from December 1997 and February 1998 do not specify whether or not extended school year services are offered. The February 1998 IEP merely states that summer school personnel will be included in the articulation meetings for STUDENT's teachers "if Gen. Ed. summer school is opted by parents."
Petitioner makes numerous assertions about how the District's program failed to address STUDENT's needs; however, most of these assertions were not supported by the evidence. Those allegations included the following:
a. Qualifications of staff
Petitioner asserts that District inclusion specialist Robert Schramm was not qualified to be Petitioner's inclusion specialist. Mr. Schramm testified that he has a bachelor's degree from Southern Illinois University, with a major in physical education and a minor in drama. He previously worked as a substitute teacher, but did not have any prior experience working in special education or inclusion. (Id.) In fall 1997, the District hired Mr. Schramm as an inclusion specialist. (Id.) Mr. Schramm read manuals and other materials on inclusion, attended seminars and conferences, and received training for his position from Sharon Grandinette and District program specialist Linda Pollard. (Testimony of Mr. Schramm, Ms. Grandinette.) Mr. Schramm initially became involved in STUDENT's case in December 1997, but, officially, Carole Hoestery was STUDENT's "case carrier." (Testimony of Mr. Schramm, Ms. Hoestery.) Mr. Schramm officially became STUDENT's case carrier at the beginning of the 1998-99 school year. (Testimony of Mr. Schramm.) Mr. Schramm often consulted about STUDENT's case with Ms. Grandinette and with SELPA inclusion mentor Josie Chan. (Id.)
Petitioner argues that Mr. Schramm was not qualified to act as the inclusion specialist, but has not offered any relevant evidence as to what qualifications were required. Petitioner's argument that Mr. Schramm was less experienced than other inclusion personnel is not persuasive. Petitioner also points to evidence that Mr. Uhls and Mr. Schramm continually asked STUDENT's parents how they thought various assignments should be modified. (Petitioner's Exh. Y.) Petitioner argues that such practice indicates that Mr. Uhls and Mr. Schramm did not know how to do the modifications themselves. However, since the evidence clearly demonstrates that PARENTS were very involved in STUDENT's education, and had expressed strong opinions about how modifications should be made, it is logical that inclusion personnel would have sought PARENTS' input. Therefore, Petitioner's argument is without merit. (Footnote 4)
The only persuasive evidence presented on the issue of Mr. Schramm's qualifications was the testimony of Ms. Grandinette, who stated that Mr. Schramm was qualified for the position. Ms. Grandinette explained that Mr. Schramm learned about inclusion "on the job," which is the same way that Ms. Grandinette herself learned about inclusion, and the same way that many other individuals have learned about it. Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Schramm was adequately qualified to perform duties as STUDENT's inclusion specialist, and the District's use of Mr. Schramm as STUDENT's inclusion specialist did not constitute a failure to address STUDENT's needs.
b. Adequacy of curriculum modifications
Related to Petitioner's argument regarding Mr. Schramm's qualifications, Petitioner argues that Petitioner's curriculum modification was inappropriate and failed to address his needs. Initially, STUDENT's fourth grade teacher and his special day teacher made the curriculum modifications, but Mr. Schramm, with the assistance of Mr. Uhls, took over primary responsibility after December 1997. (Petitioner's Exh. B-16; testimony of Mr. Schramm, Ms. Mulhaupt.) Mr. Schramm testified regarding various means he used to modify STUDENT's curriculum, including reducing the quantity of work, rewriting instructions so that STUDENT would better understand them, and converting story problems into computational problems. Mr. Uhls explained how he modified STUDENT's tests, assignments and other curriculum in consultation with Mr. Schramm. (Testimony of Mr. Uhls.) Mr. Schramm stated that he often consulted with Ms. Grandinette regarding STUDENT's modifications.
Petitioner disputes the appropriateness and the timeliness of the curriculum modifications, but the weight of the evidence does not support these claims. For example, Petitioner alleges that the District should have modified his textbooks. However, no evidence was admitted to establish that modification of textbooks was necessary or appropriate to address STUDENT's unique needs. (See Petitioner's Exhs. B-16, O, P and Q.)
Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's curriculum modification met STUDENT's needs.
c. Progress reports
Petitioner also argues that the District failed to address his needs in that the District failed to agree to PARENTS's request that the February 1998 IEP include provision of regular progress reports. (Footnote 5) (See Petitioner's Exh. B-15.) PARENTS already had, and the IEP already provided for, daily communication from STUDENT's aide and teacher via a communication journal that STUDENT's aide updated each day. (Testimony of Mr. Uhls, Ms. Mulhaupt, Ms. Neyer; Petitioner's Exh. B-16.) While any parent would find regular progress reports useful, Petitioner has not offered evidence to establish why STUDENT needed progress reports other than those he received in general education and from the daily communication journal. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds no denial of FAPE.
d. Access to summer "reading competency" programs
Petitioner asserts that the District failed to offer him summer "reading competency" program for the 1997 and 1998 summers. District students in other grades attended such programs during the summers. (Testimony of MOTHER; Petitioner's Exh. MM.) However, no evidence was admitted establishing that STUDENT needed such programs, or even that, during the time period in question, STUDENT needed additional reading services beyond the supports and services specified in his IEPs. As long as a school district provides an appropriate education, methodology is left up to the district's discretion. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 208.)
e. Socialization needs
Petitioner argues that the District's program failed to address STUDENT's socialization needs. PARENTS submitted to the District proposed goals and objectives in social skills, such as maintaining eye contact and asking appropriate questions. (Petitioner's Exh. B-15.) Petitioner argues that instead of offering the requested services, the District offered to address those skills via five to ten minutes of modeling by STUDENT's speech therapist. (See Petitioner's Exh. B-16, p. 10 of 12.) Socialization goals and objectives also included the goal that STUDENT would initiate verbal interaction with a peer once a day, with STUDENT's teacher and aide/inclusion assistant assigned the responsibility of implementing this goal. (Petitioner's Exh. B-16, p. 5 of 12.) The IEP identifies STUDENT's teacher and instructional assistants as the persons responsible for implementing this goal.
While STUDENT's educational program provided other avenues for socialization, such as appropriate peer models, there was no evidence that STUDENT could learn to maintain eye contact, ask appropriate questions, and other social skills simply from peer modeling. The Hearing Officer finds that the District's offer of minimal modeling time by the speech therapist was inadequate to address STUDENT's need to learn those particular social skills. Thus, the District's offer failed to meet STUDENT's needs.
f. Weekly collaboration meetings ceased
Petitioner asserts that the District's program failed to address STUDENT's needs because District personnel ended their weekly collaboration meetings regarding STUDENT's inclusion. District personnel testified that the meetings gradually became less frequent the longer that STUDENT was fully included in general education. (Testimony of Ms. Hoestery, Ms. Mulhaupt, Mr. Schramm.) The meetings began in fall 1997, shortly after STUDENT began his transition, and the last meeting occurred on April 2, 1998. (Id.; testimony of MOTHER.)
While the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT needed oversight of his transition program to ensure that difficulties with the transition would be addressed, no evidence demonstrated that the collaboration meetings continued to be necessary. The only evidence regarding whether or not continuation of the meetings was needed was the testimony of District witnesses, who explained that they stopped meeting weekly because there was not enough to discuss once STUDENT had been fully included for a few months. (Testimony of Mr. Schramm, Ms. Mulhaupt.) Mr. Schramm also testified that he continued to consult with SELPA inclusion mentor Josie Chan regarding STUDENT's inclusion. Given that there was no persuasive evidence to the contrary, the Hearing Officer finds that the termination of the weekly collaboration meetings did not constitute a failure to address STUDENT's needs.
g. Failure to offer 1998 extended school year
Finally, Petitioner identifies 1998 summer school as another area in which the District's offer failed to address STUDENT's needs. California special education law provides for extended school year services where the child has a disability likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period and interruption in the student's program may cause regression. (Title 5 CCR § 3043.) The need for extended school year services is determined by the IEP team and included in the student's IEP. (California Education Code § 56345(b)(5); Title 5 CCR §§ 3043(b)(2), 3043(f).)
During summer 1998, STUDENT attended general education summer school without the special education supports and services he ordinarily received during the school year. The December 1997 and February1998 IEPs do not indicate whether or not STUDENT was entitled to extended year services for summer 1998; both the "yes" and "no" boxes on the forms were left blank. (Petitioner's Exh. B-16.) However, STUDENT's IEP dated October 9, 1997, does indicate that he was entitled to extended year services for summer 1998, with the justification that such services were necessary "to maintain skills." (Petitioner's Exh. B-14.) Notably, STUDENT had qualified for extended year services for summer 1997 and for every prior year he was enrolled at the District. (Petitioner's Exhs. B-14, B-8, B-6, B-5, B-4.) No evidence admitted at hearing indicated that STUDENT's needs had changed such that he no longer required extended school year services to maintain his skills.
Based on the evidence of STUDENT's needs, including his diagnosis of autism, his deficits in auditory processing, listening comprehension, speech and language and socialization, and his previously identified need for extended school year services, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needed extended school year services to maintain his skills during summer 1998, and that failure to provide those services was a violation of Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3043.
Overall, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's placement addressed STUDENT's needs from September 1997 to October 1998, with the notable exceptions of the failure to provide adequate social skills instruction and failure to offer extended year services for summer 1998. The District's offer included necessary curriculum modifications to allow STUDENT to benefit from his instruction. The District's offer included not only a transition into regular education, but also monitoring of that transition and needed accommodations for STUDENT's full inclusion.
Was the District's offer reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?
STUDENT's test scores from his September 1998 assessment showed progress in some areas and lack of progress in other areas. (Respondent's Exhs. B-16, B-18.) Compared with his November and December 1995 assessment results, STUDENT showed some improvement on the WIAT. (Footnote 6) For example, his score on the reading composite improved from a 2.1 grade equivalent to a 3.7 grade equivalent and his score on the math composite improved from a 2.1 grade equivalent to a 3.2 grade equivalent. However, his score on the WIAT's language composite showed little improvement, increasing only from a pre-kindgergarten grade level equivalent (age equivalent of 5 years, 3 months) to a mid- kindergarten grade level equivalent (age equivalent of 5 years, 9 months). In particular, STUDENT showed only slight improvement on the reading comprehension and listening comprehension subtests, and showed regression on the oral expression subtest.
Regarding socialization, Petitioner does not appear to dispute that he has made progress in social skills since he transitioned into regular education. As noted in STUDENT's October 1998 IEP, he was "using more eye contact, initiating conversation and taking turns." (Petitioner's Exh. 19.) STUDENT's fourth grade teacher, Ms. Mulhaupt, testified that she observed him progress in his social skills and organizational skills. Ms. Mulhaupt also explained that STUDENT got used to a regular education fourth grade classroom, learned a lot of the fourth grade curriculum, and appeared to feel happy and successful because he knew he could do regular fourth grade work. Ms. Mulhaupt further stated that she observed STUDENT improve in his writing, reading, history and math.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT failed to make progress in the areas of reading comprehension, listening comprehension and oral expression. However, the evidence also establishes that STUDENT made progress in most areas, including math, basic reading, and socialization. Thus, except for reading comprehension, listening comprehension and oral expression, overall STUDENT received educational benefit from September 1997 to September 1998.
Did the placement conform to STUDENT's IEPs?
Petitioner argues that the placement failed to conform to STUDENT's IEP because District personnel ceased meeting regarding STUDENT's inclusion. SELPA collaboration specialist Jean Perbix prepared a document entitled "Observations and Recommendations for STUDENT." That document, attached to STUDENT's December 1997 IEP, reads in part: "Collaboration. The Special Education team (including Josie Chan from Meadows) meets weekly to address areas of concern." Subsequently, STUDENT's February 1998 IEP specified a "recommended accommodation" that "RSP teachers, inclusion specialist, inclusion assistant and inclusion mentor will collaborate with the general education teachers as needed to make modifications and accommodations." (Petitioner's Exh. B-16.) District personnel testified that the meetings gradually became less frequent, and ended altogether after the final meeting on April 2, 1998. (Testimony of Ms. Mulhaupt, Ms. Hoestery.) The District argues that the phrase "as needed" meant that the IEP did not specifically require ongoing meetings if District personnel determined that the meetings were no longer needed. STUDENT's parents argue that they understood that the meetings would continue weekly, and that they would not have agreed to the February 1998 provision if they had known that the District interpreted "as needed" to mean that the meetings were not necessarily required.
The Hearing Officer finds that, in the context of STUDENT's inclusion into regular education, the use of the term "as needed" conveyed that the weekly meetings might no longer be needed once STUDENT had been included for some time and that inclusion was proceeding smoothly.
Overall, the Hearing Officer finds that, from September 1997 to October 1998, the District's program met STUDENT's needs, with the exceptions of the failure to address STUDENT's socialization needs and the failure to provide needed extended school year services. The District's program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, except for STUDENT's failure to make any meaningful progress in reading comprehension, listening comprehension and oral expression. The District's program also conformed to STUDENT's IEP. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that, except for socialization needs, extended school year services, and lack of educational benefit in reading comprehension and language, the District provided STUDENT a FAPE.
Summer 1997
Only limited evidence was received regarding the program STUDENT received during summer 1997. At the IEP meeting on December 10, 1996, the team determined that STUDENT needed extended school year services to maintain his skills. (Petitioner's Exh. B-8; Respondent's Exh. 6.) It is undisputed that STUDENT attended a special day class during the extended school year, pursuant to his IEP. STUDENT's summer teacher did not testify at the hearing.
As discussed in previous sections, the evidence established that STUDENT had deficits in auditory processing, listening comprehension, speech and language, and socialization. It is undisputed that STUDENT needed extended school year services during summer 1997. The Hearing Officer finds that the District's offer of extended school year services was designed to address STUDENT's needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and conformed to STUDENT's IEP.
However, the evidence indicates that the extended school year services were not provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE). Special education law requires that a student must be educated in the least restrictive environment, such that removal from the regular education environment shall occur only when the nature or severity of the student's disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services can not be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Education Code § 56031.) The law's preference for education in regular classes rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption. (Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir.1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45.)
In the present case, the District argues that the special day class was STUDENT's least restrictive environment until he was transitioned to regular education with supports and services. Petitioner argues that STUDENT's transition should have occurred earlier, and at the very least he should have been transitioning into a regular education class with supports and services during summer 1997.
In determining whether disabled children should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental services, the courts have considered four factors: (1) the educational benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled; (3) the effect of the disabled student's presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom; and (4) the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom. (Sacramento Unified School District v. Rachel H. (1994) 14 F.3d 1398.)
In the present case, the evidence indicates that being in the regular education classroom has allowed STUDENT the opportunity to learn a regular education curriculum and perform work at grade level. (See testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Mulhaupt.) The District did not offer any evidence of the educational benefits available to STUDENT in the special day class. Moreover, STUDENT receives significant benefit from interacting with nondisabled children; since becoming fully included, he has improved his social skills and is better able to interact with the nondisabled children in his class. (See testimony of Ms. Mulhaupt; MOTHER.) There has been no allegation that STUDENT has any negative effect on the teacher or other students in a regular education classroom; STUDENT is liked by his classmates and teachers. (Testimony of Ms. Mulhaupt, Ms. Neyer; Petitioner's Exh. B-16.) There has also been no allegation that the cost of STUDENT's full inclusion is in any way prohibitive.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not placed in his least restrictive environment during summer 1997. In light of the extensive evidence presented regarding the negative impact special day class placement had on STUDENT's socialization skills, the Hearing Officer finds that the failure to educate in the LRE was a denial of FAPE for summer 1997.
(2) Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE from October 1998 to October 1999?
A. Procedural Appropriateness
Both parties agree that at the IEP meeting on November 17, 1999, MOTHER submitted to the IEP team members a document entitled "What STUDENT Needs." MOTHER indicated that she and her husband had prepared this document, and she requested that the document be attached in its entirety to the IEP document. The IEP team members reviewed and discussed the document to some extent. However, the District refused to attach the document to the IEP.
Petitioner argues that the District's failure to attach the parents' document to the IEP constituted a procedural violation which caused a denial of FAPE. While federal and state laws require the other IEP team members to consider all information provided by STUDENT's parents, the Hearing Officer is unaware of any authority requiring the IEP team to attach documents provided by the parents. (Footnote 7) Moreover, the failure to attach the document did not cause any actual denial of FAPE and did not prevent STUDENT's parents from submitting the document as evidence at the due process proceeding.
B. Substantive Appropriateness
Again, the standard for determining whether the District's offer substantively provided a FAPE for STUDENT involves three factors: whether the offer was designed to address STUDENT's unique needs; whether the offered services would provide educational benefit to him; whether the services conform to his IEP, and whether they are provided in the least restrictive environment. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)
Overall, the evidence establishes that STUDENT's current needs are similar to his needs from September 1997 to October 1998. STUDENT continues to have deficits in auditory processing, listening comprehension, speech and language. (Respondent's Exh. 16; Petitioner's Exhs. B-19, B-20, B-24, B-26.) STUDENT's social skills have improved as he has spent more time included in general education, but some difficulties with social skills remain. (Id.) However, the 1998 assessment results establish that STUDENT has significant needs in reading comprehension. (Petitioner's Exh. B-26.)
The parties do not dispute that STUDENT has demonstrated difficulty with reading comprehension. Numerous witnesses testified that STUDENT's reading comprehension is below average for his age. (Testimony of Ms. O'Brien-Gordon, MOTHER, Ms. Powell.) STUDENT's October and November 1998 IEP states: "STUDENT has difficulty with comprehension and vocabulary...His reading comprehension skills are at the 2.9 grade level and he has difficulty recalling information." (Footnote 8) (Petitioner's Exh. B-24.)
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continues to have deficits in auditory processing, listening comprehension, speech and language, and socialization, and additionally has a significant need in reading comprehension.
Since the District has offered many of the same services offered previously(Footnote 9), Petitioner continues to dispute the appropriateness of those services for October 1998-1999, including the use of Robert Schramm as STUDENT's inclusion specialist and the curriculum modifications. Previously the Hearing Officer found that Mr. Schramm's role as inclusion specialist met STUDENT's needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and conformed to STUDENT's IEP. Given the evidence presented regarding the District's most recent offer, the Hearing Officer again finds that the District's use of Mr. Schramm as STUDENT's inclusion specialist addresses STUDENT's needs, is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit and conforms to STUDENT's IEP.
Regarding the curriculum modifications offered in the October and November 1998 IEP, the Hearing Officer notes that the District's offer includes accommodations such as assistive technology, textbooks for STUDENT to use at home, increased time for assignments and tests, notetaking support, seating near a strong peer, and modified assignments. (Testimony of Ms. Neyer; Petitioner's Exh. B-19.) Previously, the Hearing Officer found that the curriculum modification addressed STUDENT's needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit and conformed to the IEP. In light of the District's most recent offer of accommodations, the Hearing Officer again finds that the offer was designed to address STUDENT's unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Conformity to the IEP is not at issue.
The key dispute arising out of the District's recent offer concerns remedial reading instruction. The parties do not dispute that STUDENT should receive remedial reading instruction to address his needs. Instead, the parties dispute the type of services to be provided. The District has offered "pull-out" services by the RSP teacher, whereby STUDENT would leave his regular classroom to receive individual and/or small-group reading instruction. STUDENT would attend RSP in thirty or forty-five minute blocks, totaling approximately four hours and twenty minutes per week. (Petitioner's Exh. FF.) Petitioner does not want STUDENT to be removed from class and, instead, wants STUDENT to receive his reading instruction before or after school.
Petitioner argues that being pulled out of class would make him feel different from the other children, and could cause him to be stigmatized because he leaves class when the other children do not. However, numerous District witnesses testified that no stigma exists for students pulled out of class to attend RSP or receive other services. Witnesses explained that "pull-out" is unexceptional at Pacific Elementary, because so many students are pulled out of class for various reasons, such as attendance at speech therapy, RSP, counseling, or English as a Second Language. (See testimony of Carole Hoestery, Dr. Christine Norvelle, Julie Powell, Ray Uhls, Emily Gantner, Sharon Grandinette.) STUDENT's inclusion assistant testified that the other children in class do not seem to notice when STUDENT leaves class to attend speech therapy. Moreover, the proposed RSP schedule is arranged so that most of his RSP sessions would be either first thing in the morning or immediately after lunch; in both instances, STUDENT would not have to leave in the middle of class. (Petitioner's Exh. FF.)
Petitioner argues that RSP pull-out would not address STUDENT's needs because he needs maximum time in his regular education classroom to keep up with the curriculum. However, based on the proposed RSP schedule and the testimony of District witnesses, the Hearing Officer concludes that RSP pull- out will not significantly interfere with STUDENT's keeping up with the curriculum. Three of the proposed seven RSP blocks would be during the class's silent sustained reading (SSR) time; missing this time would not put STUDENT behind in his curriculum, because SSR simply involves each student silently reading material of his or her own choosing. Moreover, STUDENT's fifth grade teacher testified that STUDENT is usually not productive during SSR time; he will have a book to read or a workbook to work on, but he may not actually do any reading or work. (Testimony of Liana Neyer.) The remaining proposed RSP blocks are during the class's language arts period, which generally involves reading. (Testimony of Ms. Hoestery.) Therefore, STUDENT would be working on reading in RSP while his classmates work on reading in class.
Petitioner does not dispute that RSP pull-out would provide him with educational benefit, and no issue exists as to conformity with the IEP. However, Petitioner argues that, because of his socialization needs, he requires maximum time in his LRE -- the general education classroom -- to learn social skills. Thus, the Hearing Officer will compare the educational benefits available in STUDENT's regular classroom with those available in RSP, and the nonacademic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled. (Sacramento Unified School District v. Rachel H. (1994) 14 F.3d 1398.) Notably, in this instance, no issues exist regarding the effect of STUDENT's presence in the classroom or the cost of mainstreaming.
In her testimony, STUDENT's principal acknowledged that STUDENT needs socialization with nondisabled peers, but explained that the benefits of attending RSP outweigh any detriment of missing half an hour or so of class each day. (Testimony of Dr. Norvelle.) The RSP teacher testified regarding the reading instruction available in RSP, and Petitioner has not disputed that STUDENT would benefit from that instruction. The Hearing Officer concludes that the educational benefits available to
STUDENT in RSP a few hours a week outweigh the educational benefits available to STUDENT during those same few hours in his regular classroom. STUDENT has extensive opportunity during the remainder of the school day to receive the benefits of attending class with nondisabled peers. Missing class to attend RSP for one short period each day will address STUDENT's reading needs without any significant impact on his socialization.
Petitioner argues that, to avoid pulling him out of class, he should receive his reading instruction after school instead of during the school day. The Hearing Officer is unaware of any authority requiring school districts to provide services outside of the school day when comparable services during the school day will address the student's needs and provide educational benefit. Methodology is a matter left to the discretion of the District. (See Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 at 208.)
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that RSP pull-out is designed to address STUDENT's unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. No issue exists regarding conformity with the IEP. The offer of RSP pull-out also offers STUDENT an education in his LRE, in accordance with the LRE mandate.
Overall, the Hearing Officer finds that the October and November 1998 IEP is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit; naturally, no issue exists as to the IEP's conformity with itself. Thus, the District's most recent IEP offered STUDENT a FAPE for October 1998 to October 1999.
(3) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for Fast ForWord training during summer 1997, Fast ForWord 2 training in winter 1999, and reading tutoring at the Reading Center from October 1997 through May 1998?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.) Parents need not provide the exact proper placement or services required under IDEA, but rather must only provide a placement or services that address the student's needs and provides the student with educational benefit. (Florence County School District Four v. Carter (1993) 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.)
In the present case, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during summer 1997 because it failed to place him in the least restrictive environment. In light of the extensive evidence regarding STUDENT's socialization needs, the Hearing Officer finds that this denial of FAPE may have negatively affected STUDENT's socialization. However, the evidence regarding Fast ForWord trainings and Reading Center tutoring indicates that these educational services were designed primarily to address STUDENT's reading, speech and language needs, not socialization needs. (See testimony of Marianne O'Brien-Gordon; Petitioner's Exhs. D, E and F.) Therefore, these private educational services did not redress that component of FAPE denied during summer 1997, and the Hearing Officer will not order reimbursement on the basis of the summer 1997 denial of LRE. While documentary evidence indicates that STUDENT received social skills training from educational consultant Carol Dygean from June 1997 through August 1998, Petitioner has not requested reimbursement for any portion of this training. (Footnote 10) (See Petitioner's Exh. U.)
The District also failed to address STUDENT's socialization needs from September 1997 to October 1998, due to its failure to offer appropriate social skills modeling or instruction. However, again the evidence presented at hearing demonstrates that the private educational services provided by STUDENT's parents were not designed to address his socialization needs. Thus, the Hearing Officer will not order reimbursement on the basis of this denial of FAPE.
The Hearing Officer also found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to offer extended school year with appropriate supports and services during summer 1998. Based on the undisputed allegations and extensive evidence that STUDENT needed supports and services in a general education classroom, the Hearing Officer finds that this denial of FAPE most likely had a negative effect on STUDENT's academic progress. Additionally, the Hearing Officer found that the District's program was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in reading comprehension, listening comprehension and oral expression.
However, the Hearing Officer is unable to award reimbursement for Fast ForWord training, Reading Center tutoring or Fast ForWord 2 training, for the reasons that follow.
Regarding the Fast ForWord training in summer 1997, the Hearing Officer finds that reimbursement for that training is not appropriate because the training occurred prior to the denial of FAPE beginning in September 1997.
Regarding tutoring STUDENT received at the Reading Center, the Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient evidence upon which to base an award of reimbursement. Petitioner's only evidence regarding the appropriateness of this tutoring was a letter from the director of the Reading Center, and very brief testimony from STUDENT's mother and Ms. O'Brien-Gordon. (See Petitioner's Exh. D; testimony of MOTHER, Ms. O'Brien-Gordon.) The Hearing Officer finds that this evidence alone is not sufficient to support a finding that the tutoring at the Reading Center was appropriate.
Regarding the Fast ForWord 2 training STUDENT received in January and February 1999, the evidence is insufficient to establish that STUDENT received educational benefit from the training. No test results or other persuasive evidence of STUDENT's progress was presented.
Thus, in light of the Hearing Officer's findings that reimbursement is not an appropriate remedy for the District's denials of FAPE, the Hearing Officer next considers awarding relief in the form of compensatory education. Compensatory education is an equitable remedy which may be available when the school district has denied the student a FAPE. (Puyallup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489.) Because compensatory education is an equitable remedy, equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief. (Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374.)
The District failed to provide STUDENT with an education in his LRE during summer and failed to provide him with appropriate supports and services during summer 1998. During the 1997-98 school year, the District also failed to provide STUDENT with appropriate social skills modeling and failed to offer a program reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in reading comprehension, listening comprehension and oral expression . These failures constituted significant denials of FAPE which impeded STUDENT's progress in academics and socialization. Given that reimbursement is not available, and given STUDENT's limited progress in particular academic and social areas, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the compensatory education shall be provided over the course of the 1999-2000 school year. The record is not sufficiently clear to fashion the form of compensatory education that would adequately compensate STUDENT for the denials of FAPE. The Hearing Officer finds that a determination of the appropriate form of compensation shall be left to the IEP team members, including STUDENT's parents. As to appropriate forms of compensation, the IEP team shall include social skills instruction and/or modeling, and remedial instruction in areas of academic deficit. The IEP team shall determine the nature of these services and the extent to which they will be necessary to effectuate the purpose of compensating STUDENT for the previous denials of FAPE. The IEP team shall also consider that the right to compensatory education does not create an obligation to automatically provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for the opportunities missed. (Puyallup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489.)
Additionally, the IEP team shall determine whether it would be more effective to remediate STUDENT's areas of weakness during the school day or during nonschool hours, and shall determine provision of services accordingly. Given STUDENT's current needs, the IEP team may likely determine that provision of services during nonschool hours will be necessary to meet current needs while compensating for past denials. While the Hearing Officer previously determined that the District was not required to provide after-school services as a provision of FAPE, that determination does not necessarily apply to the provision of compensatory education.
(4) If the District did not propose an appropriate placement for STUDENT at the October and November 1998 IEP meetings, does provision of an appropriate placement include the following?
(a) tutoring services at the Reading Center;
(b) District reading services provided outside of school hours.
Because the District proposed an appropriate placement at the October and November 1998 IEP, the Hearing Officer will not consider these requests for prospective relief.
ORDER
1. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to determine the appropriate form of compensatory education to which STUDENT is entitled for the denials of FAPE which occurred during summer 1997, summer 1998, and the 1997-98 school year. The compensatory education program shall supplement the program STUDENT attends during the 1999-2000 school year.
As to appropriate forms of compensation, the IEP team shall include social skills instruction and/or modeling, and remedial instruction in areas of academic deficit. The IEP team shall determine the nature of these services and the extent to which they will be necessary to effectuate the purpose of compensating STUDENT for the previous denials of FAPE. Additionally, the IEP team shall determine whether it would be more effective to remediate STUDENT's areas of weakness during the school day or during nonschool hours, and shall determine provision of services accordingly.
2. All of Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
1) Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE from June 1997 to October 1998?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that the Hearing Officer found denials of particular elements of FAPE. The District prevailed on the remainder of this issue.
(2) Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE from October 1998 to October 1999?
The District prevailed on this issue.
(3) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for Fast ForWord training during summer 1997, Fast ForWord 2 training in winter 1999, and reading tutoring at the Reading Center from October 1997 through May 1998?
Petitioner prevailed to the extent that he received an award of compensatory education. The District prevailed on the remainder of this issue.
(4) If the District did not propose an appropriate placement for STUDENT at October and November 1998 IEP meetings, does provision of an appropriate placement include the following?
(a) tutoring services at the Reading Center;
(b) District reading services provided outside of school hours.
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: June 30, 1999 ___________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes 1. Nonparty witnesses testifying at the hearing were permitted to observe the hearing only after they had finished testifying. 2. Petitioner originally submitted a lengthy explanation of Petitioner's issues and proposed resolutions. On the first day of hearing, in consultation and agreement with the parties, the Hearing Officer revised Petitioner's original statement of issues. The Hearing Officer also subsequently reorganized and clarified the issues to facilitate better organization of the Decision. 3. While documentary evidence indicates that STUDENT received social skills training from educational consultant Carol Dygean, Petitioner has not submitted any evidence regarding the necessity of this training. (See Petitioner's Exh. U.) 4. A finding consistent with Petitioner's claim would also serve to penalize District employees for seeking any detailed input from PARENTS when determining how to provide STUDENT's education. 5. IDEA µrequires that IEP documents include a statement of how the pupil's parents will be regularly informed of the pupil's progress toward annual goals and informed of the extent to which that progress is sufficient to enable the pupil to achieve those goals by the end of the year. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(vii).) However, this provision did not take effect until July 1, 1998, subsequent to the IEP meeting on February 1, 1998. (See 20 U.S.C., Chapter 33, Miscellaneous Provisions.) The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT's October and November 1998 IEP states the frequency with which STUDENT's parents will receive progress reports. 6. The Hearing Officer takes into account that the comparison of the 1995 and 1998 assessment results reflects progress or lack thereof made during time periods other than those at issue in this proceeding. 7. While "What STUDENT Needs" likely should have been kept in STUDENT's special education file as a record of the parents' position, the contents of the special education file are not at issue in this proceeding. 8. The 1998 multidisciplinary assessment report reflects that STUDENT scored at the 2.9 grade level equivalent on the reading comprehension subtest of the WIAT. 9. The District has also offered additional services, such as extended school year and an occupational therapy evaluation. (Petitioner's Exh. B-19.) Petitioner has not indicated any dispute regarding the offer of those services. 10. Ms. Dygean's letter indicates that a portion of the social skills training was funded by Harbor Regional Center. (Petitioner's Exh. U.)
