California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 8, 1996

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 290-96 · Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel

Los Angeles Unified must provide two make-up physical therapy sessions with transportation; parents' request to replace the student's aide denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 13-year-old with cerebral palsy filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District and represented her themselves. She attended regular classes in the gifted magnet program at John Burroughs Middle School with a one-to-one aide. Under a settlement with California Children's Services (CCS), a private provider, Corporesano Physical Therapy, gave her physical therapy (PT) three times a week. Her IEP made the District responsible for driving her to those sessions.

On the first issue, the parents said the District failed to transport her to five PT sessions. The Hearing Officer found that the District missed four of them. On the fifth date, the District did bring her, and the evidence did not show the District caused the missed session. Out of about 150 scheduled sessions, she missed only four. The District had made good-faith efforts, and each miss involved unusual circumstances, such as the first day of school or a schedule change the parents made. Weighing these equities, the Hearing Officer ordered two compensatory PT sessions, with transportation, during 1996-97.

On the second issue, the parents asked for a different aide. The Hearing Officer held that choosing staff is part of the District's methodology and is entitled to deference. The student had done well with the aide for two years, and the evidence did not show the aide harmed her safety or physical performance. The request was denied. The parents withdrew a separate compensatory education claim.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated compensatory education as an equitable remedy rather than a session-for-session make-up. It also shows that a parent's wish to replace a particular aide was not enough to override the district's choice of staff when the student was benefiting from the aide's help.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partImplementation

    Issue 1. Did the District fail to provide Student with transportation to five physical therapy sessions during the 1995-96 school year, and, if so, what is the appropriate remedy?

    The District failed to transport Student to four of the five claimed PT sessions. Weighing the equities, including the District's good-faith efforts and unusual circumstances, the Hearing Officer awarded two compensatory PT sessions with transportation.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Must the District provide Student with a one-to-one aide other than Stephanie Ingram in order for her to receive a free, appropriate education?

    Choosing staff is part of the District's methodology and gets deference. Student did well with this aide, and the evidence did not show any harm to her safety or physical ability, so the request to replace the aide was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Compensatory education. The District shall provide two compensatory physical therapy sessions, including transportation, during the 1996-97 school year (sessions under the IEP were 45 minutes each).

Total: 1.5 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Students of California School for the Blind v. Honig; Board of Education of Community Consolidated School District No. 21 v. Illinois State Board of Education

People named in the decision

  • Shirley Brown, due process coordinator, District representative, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Dorothy Jackson, special education administrator, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Janet McElroy, special education administrator, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Wayne Curl, bus supervisor, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Carol Barker, bus driver, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Janice Paulk, bus driver, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Stephanie Ingram, 1:1 aide, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Laverne Patterson, gifted magnet program coordinator, John Burroughs Middle School
  • Carol Greer, replacement 1:1 aide, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Ms. Davidson, social studies teacher, John Burroughs Middle School
  • Kris Harnden, manager, private physical therapy provider, Corporesano Physical Therapy of Beverly Hills
  • Corporesano Physical Therapy of Beverly Hills, private physical therapy provider (CCS contractor)
  • California Children's Services, agency providing physical therapy under settlement agreement
  • Anna Terean, Russian interpreter
  • Andrei Nazarian, Russian interpreter

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Los Angeles, California, on May 9, June 10, and August 5, 1996.

Petitioner STUDENT attended portions of the hearing and was represented throughout the hearing by her parents, PARENTS. Anna Terean, Russian interpreter, was present on May 9 and June 10 to assist the PARENTS. Andrei Nazarian, Russian interpreter, was present on August 5 to assist the PARENTS.

Respondent was represented by Shirley Brown, due process coordinator. Also present on behalf of Respondent during portions of the hearing were Dorothy Jackson and Janet McElroy, special education administrators.

The following witnesses were called by Petitioner: STUDENT;

Mr. and PARENT; Ms. McElroy; Wayne Curl, bus supervisor; Carol Barker, bus driver; and Janice Paulk, bus driver. The following witnesses were called by Respondent: Stephanie Ingram, one-to-one aide; and Laverne Patterson, gifted magnet program coordinator, John Burroughs Middle School.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with transportation to five (5) physical therapy sessions during the 1995-96 school year, and, if so, what is the appropriate remedy?

2. Must the District provide STUDENT with a one-to-one aide other than Stephanie Ingram in order for her to receive a free, appropriate education?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

1. Chronological Summary

Rulings regarding numerous prehearing motions are contained in the Orders dated April 10, 25, and 30 and May 6, 1996. On the first day of hearing, May 9, testimony was taken regarding the transportation issue. The parties agreed to continue the hearing to June 10 to allow the District time to conduct an assistive technology assessment relevant to an issue involving STUDENT's use of a computer. On June 10, the hearing reconvened and testimony regarding the transportation issue was completed. The parties then agreed to meet on June 20 to attempt to resolve the computer and aide issues. Subsequent to June 20 Petitioner advised the Hearing Office that further hearing time was requested. A telephone conference was held with the parties on June 27. Petitioner indicated that remaining unresolved issues were those involving the aide and compensatory education. It was then determined that the parties would meet by July 5 to attempt to resolve those issues. Subsequent correspondence received by the Hearing Office from the parties indicated that they had not been able to resolve the aide and compensatory education issues. A third day of hearing was scheduled for August 5. On July 16, the Hearing Office received a request from Petitioner to hold the third day of hearing by no later than July 22. On July 31, the Hearing Office advised the parties that the hearing remained scheduled for August 5.

At the outset of the hearing on August 5, Petitioner withdrew the compensatory education issue. STUDENT and PARENT testified regarding Petitioner's request to replace STUDENT's one-to-one aide, Ms. Ingram. When it was time for Ms. Ingram to testify, Petitioner moved to bar her testimony on the grounds that the District had not disclosed her as a potential witness at least five days before the hearing pursuant to Education Code Section 56505(E)(7). The Hearing Officer ruled that he would permit Ms. Ingram to testify. Given that the issue at hand was whether Ms. Ingram would continue to be the District staff member who worked most closely with STUDENT on a daily basis, the Hearing Officer needed to hear from Ms. Ingram in order to render an appropriate decision. Further, Petitioner should not have been surprised by or unprepared for Ms. Ingram's testimony in that Petitioner had raised the issue of replacing Ms. Ingram, who had been STUDENT's aide for the past two years, and the District had indicated that it believed Ms. Ingram should remain in that position.

When informed that Ms. Ingram would be permitted to testify, the PARENTS left the hearing and indicated that they would not return. The PARENTS were advised that the hearing would continue in their absence. At that time Ms. Ingram and Laverne Patterson, gifted magnet program coordinator for John Burroughs Middle School, testified, and the record was closed.

2. Issues for Hearing

During the course of the hearing process, the Hearing Officer had discussions with the parties, on the record, in an attempt to clarify the issues for hearing and the parties' proposed resolutions to those issues. One of the issues proposed by Petitioner was whether the District had provided STUDENT with educational opportunities equal to those provided to nondisabled students attending STUDENT's regular education classes. Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), the District must provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate education (FAPE) which emphasizes special education and related services individually designed to meet her unique needs. 20 U.S.C.

§1400(c); §§1401(a)(16-18). However, the Supreme Court has specifically held that IDEA does not require that disabled students receive educational opportunities equal to those provided to other non-disabled children. Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 198-199 (1982).(FOOTNOTE 1) Therefore, the Hearing Officer found that this specific issue was not an appropriate one for the hearing. See, e.g., Order dated April 30, 1996 at pg. 6.

Petitioner also proposed an issue involving its assertion that the District had failed to provide STUDENT with the services of a one-to-one aide on certain dates, thus preventing her from completing certain classwork which resulted in lowering her grade. The Hearing Officer noted that (1) Education Code Section 49066 sets forth specific procedures regarding grade changes, (2) those procedures apply to all students (disabled and nondisabled) and are separate from special education due process hearings, and, (3) it did not appear that the Hearing Officer had authority to order an increase in a child's grade as "appropriate relief" in a due process hearing.

Petitioner then indicated that the remedy it sought was "compensatory education." Petitioner indicated that it did not necessarily want more aide time to assist STUDENT with completing missed assignments. Rather, Petitioner requested that the District be ordered to accept the missed assignments should STUDENT choose to complete them. The Hearing Officer expressed concern as to whether, assuming Petitioner's allegations were to be proved, he could order such a remedy for several reasons: (1) It did not appear that Petitioner was in fact seeking compensatory education, in that it was not requesting that the District provide STUDENT with any additional educational services, (2) the Hearing Officer could not order STUDENT to complete the assignments, and (3) the net effect of Petitioner's request appeared to be simply to require the District to re-evaluate STUDENT's grade should she choose to submit more assignments. At no time did the Hearing Officer indicate that he would not hear the issue of whether the District had failed to provide STUDENT with the services of an aide on certain dates. As noted above, on August 5, Petitioner withdrew its "compensatory education" issue. That day, the issue of whether STUDENT's aide should be replaced was heard. Evidence was received regarding the appropriateness of the services provided by the aide, Ms. Ingram.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE

STUDENT is thirteen years old and recently completed the seventh grade in the gifted magnet program at John Burroughs Middle School in the District. STUDENT is eligible for special education by reason of cerebral palsy. She attends regular education classes and receives certain related services pursuant to her Individualized Education Plan (IEP).

1. Transportation to physical therapy

According to a document submitted during the course of prehearing motions, on June 23, 1995, a settlement agreement was entered into between the PARENTS and California Children's Services (CCS) in Case No. CV 94-0386, United States District Court for the Central District of California. Pursuant to that agreement, CCS agreed to provide STUDENT with physical therapy (PT) services for a minimum of two and a maximum of three forty-five (45) minute sessions per week for a minimum of two years, beginning no later than September 1, 1995. (Agreement, §7A) The Agreement stated:

[CCS] assumes no responsibility for transporting STUDENT to her therapy sessions or arranging the transport of STUDENT to her therapy sessions. (§7B)(footnote 2)

The Agreement noted that CCS would provide the PT service by contracting with a private vendor (§7A(1)), but that such arrangement "shall not affect the status of STUDENT's physical therapy as an educationally related service." (§9) CCS subsequently contracted with Corporesano Physical Therapy of Beverly Hills for provision of PT to STUDENT.

According to STUDENT's IEP document dated July 19, 1995:

Transportation will be provided per June 23, 1995 agreement between LAUSD (Los Angeles Unified School District) and the PARENTS to and from physical therapy year round . . . STUDENT will receive physical therapy through CCS (California Children's Services) as part of [her] education three (3) times a week for forty-five (45) minute sessions year round.

At or about the beginning of the school year, the parents arranged the following schedule with Corporesano for three weekly PT sessions: Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays from 4:00 p.m. to 4:45 p.m. During this time period it was agreed among the parents, Corporesano, and the District that, for each session, PARENT would have responsibility for meeting the District bus at Corporesano, helping STUDENT get off the bus, and then helping her get back on when the session was over. On Wednesday, September 6, 1996, the first day of school -- and apparently the first day on which the District was scheduled to begin transporting STUDENT to PT -- the District failed to transport her there and she missed her scheduled PT session. On that day, the District apparently simply failed to make the necessary arrangements in a timely manner. The District began providing STUDENT with transportation to her PT sessions on Friday, September 8.

On September 11, the parents arranged with Corporesano to change the Wednesday sessions to Thursdays from 3:00 to 3:45 p.m., effective Thursday, September 21, because STUDENT had a shortened day of classes on Thursdays. On September 12, the parents informed the District of the change. On Thursday, September 21, the District transported STUDENT to Corporesano. Ms. Barker, the bus driver, testified that when she arrived at Corporesano, PARENT was not there to take STUDENT off the bus. (She did not testify as to what time she arrived at Corporesano that day.) Ms. Barker testified that the physical therapist came out and stated that PARENT had told her that her husband could not make it that day.

PARENT testified that, on September 21, he arrived at Corporesano at 3:00 p.m. He testified that when the bus had not arrived by 3:40 p.m., he left. He testified that there was a day when he was unable to meet the bus, but that that occurred in October.

Petitioner submitted into evidence a letter dated September 28 from Kris Harnden, Corporesano manager, stating: "This letter is being written to confirm that Miss STUDENT was not brought to our facility at her scheduled time at 3:00 p.m. on September 21, 1995." The letter did not state what time STUDENT was brought to the facility that day. Ms. Harnden did not testify. The evidence showed that, on September 21, no one took STUDENT off the bus, and Corporesano did not provide her with PT.

The next week, District staff told the parents that, for District scheduling reasons, it would be difficult for the District to transport STUDENT to Corporesano on Thursdays by 3:00 p.m.

However, the District did not inform the parents that it would not attempt to do so. On Thursday, September 28, the District failed to provide STUDENT with transportation and she missed her scheduled PT session.

The next day, the District requested that the parents change STUDENT's Thursday sessions back to Wednesdays, but the parents stated that they would not. Then the District requested that the parents change the Thursday sessions to 4:00 p.m. The parents agreed to do so, effective Thursday, October 5.

In early December, Corporesano informed the parents that STUDENT's therapist's schedule was changing and that she was no longer available on Thursdays at 4:00 p.m. The parents arranged with Corporesano to change the Thursday sessions to Wednesdays at 4:00 p.m., effective Wednesday, December 20. On Friday, December 15 -- the last day of school before winter vacation -- the parents informed the District of the change. On Wednesday, December 20, during the first week of winter vacation, the District provided STUDENT with timely transportation to her scheduled PT session. However, on Wednesday, December 27, during the second week of winter vacation, the District failed to provide STUDENT with transportation to PT. On the afternoon of Thursday, December 28, a District bus arrived at STUDENT's home for the purpose of transporting her to Corporesano; however, no PT session was scheduled for that day.

From Thursday, February 29 through Tuesday, March 5, 1996, STUDENT missed school due to illness. On Tuesday, March 5, the parents informed District staff that STUDENT would return to school on Wednesday, March 6. (This was in accord with the District policy that when a child is absent for two or more days in a row, the parent must call the school the day before the child will return in order to ensure resumption of bus service.) On the morning of Wednesday, March 6, a District bus brought STUDENT to school. However, the District did not transport STUDENT to PT that afternoon. Transportation staff later indicated that they believed, mistakenly, that STUDENT was not in school that day, and that, by the time they discovered that she was there, it was too late to transport her to Corporesano in time for her scheduled session.

2. One-to-One Aide

With the exception of January and February, 1996, STUDENT's aide for the past two years has been Stephanie Ingram. These were STUDENT's sixth grade (1994-95) and seventh grade (1995-96) years at John Burroughs Middle School. (STUDENT enters eighth grade, her final year at Burroughs, this fall.) Ms. Ingram has assisted STUDENT in the classroom as well as with toileting and eating.

a. Petitioner's Witnesses

1. Testimony of STUDENT

Petitioner STUDENT testified that she liked Ms. Ingram during the 1994-95 school year. Even though Ms. Ingram was strict -- that is, she did not tolerate misbehavior -- she was fair.

During the 1995-96 school year, however, according to STUDENT, Ms. Ingram became cold and harsh. On certain occasions Ms. Ingram refused to write or take notes for her, and instead stated, "Type it yourself." Because STUDENT could not type fast enough, at times she did not complete her work by the end of class. At times Ms. Ingram would tell her to "hurry up" in typing her worksheets. (On the other hand, Ms. Ingram did always write down STUDENT's assignments for her in her "agenda" book.)

STUDENT waited until November 1995 to complain to her parents about Ms. Ingram because she was afraid of Ms. Ingram's possible reaction. Ms. Ingram seemed to get upset when she received notes from the parents. She chose not to complain to District administrators at that time because she had heard that Ms. Ingram would be leaving the District shortly. In January, Ms. Ingram began a leave of absence. She was replaced as STUDENT's aide by Carol Greer. STUDENT liked Ms. Greer. On March 6, Ms. Ingram returned.

On March 6, Ms. Ingram told STUDENT that Ms. Greer was being replaced because Ms. Greer had not been strict enough and had not helped STUDENT with adapted physical education. In late March, STUDENT had a conversation with Ms. Greer. Ms. Ingram was upset about this and demanded to know what the conversation had been about. STUDENT declined to answer, and Ms. Ingram threatened to report her to the principal. Also, Ms. Greer wanted to give STUDENT her home phone number, but did not do so because, STUDENT believes, Ms. Ingram advised Ms. Greer not to get involved with the family.

After Ms. Ingram returned, STUDENT was uncomfortable being around her. When they were together, it was harder to control her muscles, and her arms jerked more. She no longer likes Ms. Ingram.

2. Testimony of MOTHER

PARENT, STUDENT's mother, testified that on March 29, 1996, she wrote a letter to the principal complaining about Ms. Ingram. She believes this letter made Ms. Ingram angry. On a later occasion, she was told that Ms. Ingram was supposed to have placed a letter from Ms. Davidson, STUDENT's social studies teacher, in STUDENT's backpack. However, the parents did not receive the letter.

STUDENT has told the parents that when she is around Ms.

Ingram, she is nervous and therefore it is harder to control her arm movements. PARENT believes this makes it harder for STUDENT to type.

b. District's Witnesses

1. Testimony of Stephanie Ingram

Ms. Ingram testified that when she first met STUDENT during sixth grade (1994-95), STUDENT called her "hey lady," stated that she was used to having her own way, and stated that she believed Ms. Ingram was there to work for her. At that time, Ms. Ingram told STUDENT that this behavior was unacceptable, that she must show respect, and that she (Ms. Ingram) was there to assist STUDENT, not to work for her. Since that conversation, there have been no problems in this regard, except for one occasion when Ms. Ingram was talking to another adult and STUDENT told Ms. Ingram to "shut up."

STUDENT has told Ms. Ingram that she liked her, and has never told her that she did not like her. On occasion, they joke and laugh together. The parents gave Ms. Ingram a gift at Christmas. STUDENT has only complained to Ms. Ingram once. That involved an incident when STUDENT and her classmates were making fun of a substitute teacher and STUDENT called the substitute a "stupid woman." Ms. Ingram warned STUDENT to stop criticizing the substitute but she continued. Ms. Ingram wheeled STUDENT to the vice principal's office. Soon after, the vice principal spoke to the entire class, reprimanding them for their behavior.

In class, Ms. Ingram writes down the assignments and puts paper in the typewriter for STUDENT; then STUDENT types her responses to the assignments. STUDENT also types notes from the board, although, in some cases, teachers hand her a sheet of pre-prepared notes. For multiple choice tests, STUDENT makes the sign for the letters "A", "B" or "C" for her answers and Ms. Ingram shades the appropriate "bubble" on the test answer sheet. If STUDENT does not complete her work in class, typically her teachers allow her to make it up the next day.

When STUDENT is drowsy or has not had her medication, Ms.

Ingram will take notes and/or write her responses to assignments for her. On the other hand, STUDENT often brings books from home to read during class that are unrelated to the class subject matter. On some of these occasions, STUDENT will ask Ms. Ingram to take notes for her. If Ms. Ingram feels STUDENT is capable of taking the notes and would simply prefer to read her book, Ms. Ingram will decline to take the notes and tell STUDENT that she must do it herself.

Ms. Ingram did not tell STUDENT that Ms. Greer was replaced for any reason having to do with the manner in which Ms. Greer interacted with STUDENT. Ms. Ingram did hear from another student that Ms. Greer did not make STUDENT do her exercises in adapted physical education. There was an incident in which Ms. Greer was considering giving her phone number to STUDENT and going on social outings with her. Ms. Ingram advised Ms. Greer that it would be appropriate to get permission from the principal and the parents before doing so. Ms. Ingram does recall placing a letter from STUDENT's social studies teacher, Ms. Davidson, in STUDENT's backpack, and has no knowledge as to whether the parents received it.

Ms. Ingram noted there was one incident when she snapped at STUDENT. On that occasion, STUDENT rolled over Ms. Ingram's feet with her wheelchair and laughed. Ms. Ingram became upset because she believed that it was intentional.

Ms. Ingram stated that she has no ill feelings toward STUDENT or her parents. She feels she has done a good job and that she can continue to provide appropriate assistance to STUDENT during her upcoming, final year at John Burroughs Middle School. She has not observed that STUDENT exhibits more jerky arm movements than usual in her presence. In fact, upon Ms. Ingram's return in March, 1996, STUDENT stated that she was happy to see her.

2. Testimony of Laverne Patterson

Ms. Patterson is the gifted magnet program coordinator at John Burroughs Middle School. She testified that neither STUDENT nor any of her teachers has complained to her (Ms. Patterson) about Ms. Ingram during the two years that Ms. Ingram has assisted STUDENT. The parents have complained to Ms. Patterson that Ms. Ingram is too demanding and asks STUDENT to do things of which they believe she is not capable.

Although Ms. Ingram did a good job when she was present, there was some concern regarding absences on her part. On some occasions when Ms. Ingram was absent, it was difficult to obtain a substitute aide to assist STUDENT. Eventually it was determined that when Ms. Ingram was absent, another special education aide would assist

STUDENT.

STUDENT is doing well in the gifted magnet program. She is attending class and getting her work done. When Ms. Patterson has observed STUDENT and Ms. Ingram together, they appear to converse, and STUDENT does not seem nervous around or afraid of Ms. Ingram.

DISCUSSION

1. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with transportation to five physical therapy sessions during the 1995-96 school year? If so, what is the appropriate remedy?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities are entitled to receive a free, appropriate education (FAPE) which emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. 20 U.S.C. §1400(c); §1401(a)(18); California Education Code §56000. Related services are those required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(17); Education Code §56363. Related services include physical therapy and transportation. 34 C.F.R. §300.16(b)(7),(14); Education Code §56363(b)(6). In California, the Government Code establishes interagency responsibilities for the provision of certain services to disabled students. Government Code §7575(a)(1) states that California Children's Services (CCS) shall provide "medically necessary" PT when contained in the child's IEP. Section 7575(a)(2) states that PT not determined to be medically necessary, but which the IEP team determines is a necessary related service to assist a child to benefit from special education, shall be provided by the school district.

In this case, the Settlement Agreement of June 23, 1995 between CCS and the parents indicated that CCS would provide PT to STUDENT through a private vendor, but that CCS would not be responsible for transportation. The IEP document of July 19, 1995 stated that STUDENT would receive PT from CCS and that the District would provide transportation to the PT sessions. Petitioner asserts that the District failed to provide transportation to five scheduled PT sessions during the 1995-96 school year and that, as a result, STUDENT missed those sessions. Petitioner requests that, as a remedy, the District be required to fund and provide transportation to five compensatory PT sessions.

The evidence showed that the District failed to provide STUDENT with transportation to PT on four of the five occasions at issue: September 6 and 28, and December 27, 1995, and March 6, 1996. With respect to September 21, the first day on which a schedule change took effect, the District did transport STUDENT to PT. While Corporesano did not provide PT that day, the evidence was insufficient to support a conclusion that this was attributable to the District.

With respect to the four sessions noted above, in fairness to the District, a number of points must be noted. First, STUDENT is scheduled to receive PT three times weekly, year-round. Thus, while the evidence suggests that STUDENT has been scheduled for approximately 150 PT sessions during the past year -- that is, between September 6, 1995 and the present -- she has missed just four sessions because of transportation problems.

Second, the evidence showed that the District made a good faith effort to provide transportation to STUDENT and to work with the parents, and that, on each of the missed days, there were unusual circumstances. September 6 was the first day of school -- typically a hectic day -- and also the first day on which the District was scheduled to transport STUDENT to PT. Subsequently, the parents changed the PT schedule. The District did inform the parents prior to Thursday, September 28 that it would be difficult for the District to transport STUDENT to Corporesano on Thursdays in time for a 3:00 p.m. session. However, the September 28 session was missed before the District and parents could agree, on September 29, to change to 4:00 p.m. on Thursdays.

The parents next informed the District of another schedule change -- from Thursdays to Wednesdays -- on Friday, December 15, the last day of school before winter vacation. The District did transport STUDENT to PT on Wednesday, December 20, during the first week of vacation. However, there was apparently confusion among District staff regarding the scheduling change during the second week of winter vacation. No ride was provided on Wednesday, December 27, and the District bus arrived at STUDENT's house on Thursday, December 28, erroneously.

Finally, with respect to Wednesday, March 6, 1996, STUDENT had missed the several previous days of school, and there was apparently confusion among District staff as to whether she had returned to school that day.

Under the IDEA, decision-makers have authority to award "appropriate" relief for violations of FAPE. 20 U.S.C.

§1415(e)(2); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v.

Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1984). Appropriate relief may, under some circumstances, include compensatory education. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496-1497 (9th Cir. 1994). However, the Ninth Circuit has noted that there is no obligation to provide a day-for-day, or session-for-session, compensation for time missed. Rather, appropriate relief is relief "designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA." Id. at 1497. Further, because compensatory education is an equitable remedy, equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief. Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. at 374; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992); Parents of Student W., supra, 31 F.3d at 1496.

Based on all the circumstances and balancing the equities, the Hearing Officer finds that the appropriate number of compensatory PT sessions is two. No evidence was presented that STUDENT requires mores than that to meet her PT needs, and there are equitable factors to be cited in the District's favor with respect to the four sessions missed because of transportation problems.

2. Must the District provide STUDENT with a one-to-one aide other than Stephanie Ingram in order to provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate education?

The parties agree that STUDENT is entitled to the services of a one-to-one aide as a supplementary aid or service necessary to enable her to successfully participate in her regular education classes. 20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B); 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix Part C, q. 48; Education Code §56364. There does not appear to be any dispute that Ms. Ingram is qualified to perform this function.(footnote 3)

The choice of personnel who will provide special education services to a child is typically within the District's discretion. Selection of personnel is part of the District's methodology of delivering the services. The U.S. Supreme Court has noted that, so long as the school district's choice of educational methodology is reasonably calculated to provide the child with educational benefit, that choice is entitled to deference. Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 207-208 (1982); see also Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987) (District need not accommodate parental preference so long as its proposed program is adequate).

In this case, the evidence showed that STUDENT has performed well in all regular education classes during the two years that Ms. Ingram has served as her aide. Thus, the evidence showed that Ms. Ingram has provided STUDENT with appropriate assistance necessary to enable her to successfully participate in such classes. 20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B); 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix Part C, q. 48; Education Code §56364. Because the District's designation of Ms. Ingram has enabled STUDENT to receive educational benefit, that designation is entitled to deference.

The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT testified that she is now uncomfortable around Ms. Ingram and believes that, for this reason, her muscle movements have become more difficult to control when Ms. Ingram is present. However, (1) Ms. Ingram testified persuasively that she has not observed this, (2) no other witness who has observed Ms. Ingram and STUDENT together testified that they have observed it, (3) although this was, in general, a heavily documented case, there was no contemporaneous documentation of this occurring at any time, and (4) the Hearing Officer did not observe it during the brief period when Ms. Ingram and STUDENT were present in the hearing room together. Certainly one element of a FAPE is the right to physical safety in the school setting. Students of California School for the Blind v. Honig, 736 F.2d 538, 545-546 (9th Cir. 1984). However, the evidence did not support a conclusion that being assisted by Ms. Ingram compromises STUDENT's physical safety. Nor did the evidence support a conclusion that being assisted by Ms. Ingram affects STUDENT's physical ability to perform school tasks. Finally, although STUDENT testified at the hearing that she now does not like Ms. Ingram, Ms. Ingram testified persuasively that the two of them have had a generally positive and effective relationship for the past two years.

The Hearing Officer also notes that the parents are resistant to having Ms. Ingram assist STUDENT. The Seventh Circuit has found that parental hostility to a school district's proposed program for a disabled student is a factor to be considered in determining whether the proposed program is appropriate. Board of Education of Community Consolidated School District No. 21 v. Illinois State Board of Education, 938 F.2d 712 (7th Cir. 1991). In that case, the parents made derogatory comments about school staff members in the child's presence and continually second-guessed the disciplinary efforts of the educators. Id. at 714. The parents' mindset was likened to a "siege mentality". It was concluded that the school's placement had been "poisoned" in the child's mind by his parents and that this was likely to doom the proposed placement. More specifically, it was held that the child "would not be able to satisfactorily obtain the required educational benefits from the District's proposed placement" in light of the child's and the parents' relationship with the District. Id. at 715-716.

The Hearing Officer finds that the present case is factually distinguishable from Illinois State Board. The evidence demonstrated that despite disagreements between Ms. Ingram and the PARENTS regarding responsibility for notetaking and other matters, STUDENT has continued to obtain educational benefit during the two years that she has been assisted by Ms. Ingram.

In any event, the Hearing Officer finds the reasoning of the dissent in Illinois State Board more persuasive than that of the majority, and rejects the majority's reasoning. The dissent argued that the proposed placement was appropriate, i.e. it was reasonably calculated to enable the child to receive educational benefits, and therefore, the district should have been given the opportunity to implement it despite the parents' objections. Illinois State Board, supra, 938 F.2d at 718-719 (Wood, J., dissenting). Instead, the dissent noted, the majority opinion had accorded the parent an "absolute veto" over the District's proposed educational program. Id.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District's designation of Ms. Ingram as STUDENT's one-to-one aide is appropriate. For that reason, the District need not select another aide to assist STUDENT. Petitioner's request to replace Ms. Ingram is denied.

ORDER

The District shall provide STUDENT with two compensatory physical therapy sessions, including transportation, during the 1996-97 school year.

Each of Petitioner's remaining requests for relief is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Petitioner substantially prevailed on Issue #1 relating to transportation to physical therapy to the extent that two compensatory PT sessions were awarded. Respondent prevailed on Issue #2 relating to the one-to-one aide.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).

Dated: August 8, 1996 ___________________ Leonard Garfinkel Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1. The Court noted that "to speak in terms of "equal" services in one instance gives less than what is required by the Act and in another instance more." Id. at 199. 2. The Agreement does provide that up to an additional eight (8) weeks of services shall be added to the last year of the Agreement to cover "gaps in services that may arise as a result of the loss of physical therapy services beyond [the PARENTS'] control." See Section 7(a)(2). 3. IDEA leaves the qualifications of persons providing special education services to the states. 34 C.F.R. 300.15; .153. California defines "qualified" generally, Title 5 California Code of Regulations, Section 3001(x), but does not set forth any particular qualifications for classroom aides.