California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 21, 2005

Student v. Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 2944-04, SN-2944-04, SN04-02995 · Hearing Officer Michael B. Arkin

Acton-Agua Dulce Unified's special day class offer met the student's needs but must be revised to add mainstreaming time.

Student prevailed in part

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a second grader eligible for special education as speech and language impaired, and the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District, each filed for a hearing, and the cases were consolidated. The student attended a general education class at Meadowlark Elementary, his home school. He had a one-to-one aide, resource specialist support, speech-language therapy and occupational therapy. In December 2004 the District offered a speech and language-based special day class (SDC) at Agua Dulce Elementary, with transportation. The parents wanted the existing program to continue.

The Hearing Officer relied on the student's teachers, speech pathologist Mark Lytle, school psychologist Misty Cervantes and aide Becky Carrubba, who had worked in the proposed class. Their testimony showed the student made only about two to three months of progress a year and kept falling further behind. The Hearing Officer found he was not getting "some educational benefit" under the existing IEP. The SDC offer met his needs and was reasonably calculated to provide benefit. However, applying the Rachel H. factors, the Hearing Officer found the student gained significant social benefit from nondisabled peers. The offer left his time with general education students unspecified beyond lunches, recesses and assemblies, so the District did not prove it offered the least restrictive environment. The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within 20 days and spell out specific mainstreaming times and activities. Motions to exclude evidence were mostly denied, and the District's request for sanctions was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO could approve a move to a more restrictive class and still find the offer fell short on least restrictive environment. The offer did not spell out when the student would be with nondisabled peers. It also shows the Hearing Officer giving weight to classroom staff over parents' observations at home when judging the student's progress.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Did the District's offer of an educational program and placement at Agua Dulce Elementary School, contained in the IEP of December 9, 2004, offer the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2004-2005 school year?

    The SDC offer met the Student's unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, but the District did not prove it offered the LRE because mainstreaming time was unspecified and limited to lunches, recesses and assemblies.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to revise the December 9, 2004 IEP. The revised IEP must include a comprehensive plan giving the Student appropriate and adequate opportunities to interact with general education students at Agua Dulce. It must specifically identify the times and/or activities for general education participation, including, if appropriate, assemblies, lunches, recesses, physical education and extracurricular activities.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Oberti v. Board of Educ.; Adams v. State of Oregon; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range; Murray v. Montrose Co. Sch. Dist.; Flour Bluff Indep. Sch. Dist. v. Katherine M.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Gellerman v. Calaveras Unified School Dist.; Norton v. Orinda Union Sch. Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Brian Allen, educational advocate for Student (also called as District witness)
  • Philip Rosell, principal and director of curriculum, Meadowlark Elementary School
  • Elda Fessler, first grade teacher, Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District
  • Lori Hickman, second grade teacher, Meadowlark Elementary School
  • Misty Cervantes, school psychologist, Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District
  • Jessica Hawley, occupational therapist, Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District
  • Mark Lytle, speech pathologist, Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District
  • Steve Lorenze, director of special education and principal; District representative, Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District / Agua Dulce Elementary School
  • Becky Carrubba, one-to-one classroom instructional aide (witness called by Hearing Officer), Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District
  • R. Isaacs, school psychologist (2002 psychoeducational assessment), Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District
  • John Beck, M.D., psychiatrist; letters offered by Student, not called to testify

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard in Acton, California, on February 10 and 11, 2005, before Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law.

Petitioner and Cross-Respondent, the Student (Student), was represented at the hearing by attorney David Burkenroad and educational advocate Brian Allen. (Footnote 1) Student’s father and his mother also attended the hearing on his behalf. Respondent and Cross-Petitioner Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by Steve Lorenze, director of special education and principal of Agua Dulce Elementary School (Agua Dulce).

The District, which bore the burden of going forward, (Footnote 2)called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Brian Allen, educational advocate; Philip Rosell, principal at Meadowlark Elementary School (Meadowlark); Elda Fessler, first grade teacher; Lori Hickman, second grade teacher; Misty Cervantes, school psychologist; Jessica Hawley, occupational therapist; and Mark Lytle, speech pathologist.

The Student called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Student’s parents and Steve Lorenze, director of special education.

The Hearing Officer called Becky Carrubba, the Student’s classroom aide, as a witness.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties made closing arguments, and the record was then closed and the matter submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

1. District’s Motion to Exclude Student’s Documentary Evidence.

Prior to the taking of testimony and at the beginning of the hearing, the District objected to the introduction of all of Student’s exhibits because they were not delivered to the District five days prior to the hearing as required by California Education Code section 56505(e)(7). Additionally, the District objected to the admission into evidence of Student’s exhibits 4, 7, and 9 on the grounds that they contained hearsay and that there was no foundation provided to corroborate the hearsay statements.

Education Code section 56505(e)(7) provides that the parties to a due process hearing have the right to receive from the other parties, at least five business days prior to the hearing, a copy of all documents that the parties intend to present at the hearing. Education Code section 56505(e)(8) provides that the aggrieved party has the right to prohibit the introduction of any evidence that has not been disclosed to that party at least five business days prior to the hearing. See also, 34 C.F.R. § 300.509. In the present matter, Student did not provide copies of his exhibits to the District until the due process hearing commenced.

However, the Hearing Officer determined that a violation of the Education Code and federal regulations had not occurred as to exhibits 1-3, 5, 6, 8, 10, and 11 because the District acknowledged that it had seen and examined those exhibits and was either relying upon, or had seen and considered, those documents in the preparation of its case prior to the hearing. Thus, the documents had been “disclosed” prior to the deadline. In addition, even if a technical violation had occurred because the Student had failed to “provide” copies of those documents to the District, the Hearing Officer generally inquires as to whether the failure to deliver the evidence in a timely manner prejudiced the District’s preparation for the hearing. In response to the Hearing Officer’s question in that regard, the District acknowledged that it was not surprised by the offer of exhibits 1-3, 5, 6, 8, 10, and 11 and that it did not need a continuance to review those documents. Because there was no surprise and no prejudice to the District, the Hearing Officer concluded that the violation of section 56505(e)(7), if any, was merely technical. Thus, the motion to exclude the evidence was denied as to exhibits 1-3, 5, 6, 8, 10, and 11.

The remaining exhibits, exhibits 4, 7, and 9, were letters written on the stationery of John Beck, M.D., a psychiatrist who was listed as a witness by the Student, but was not called to testify at the hearing. The District objected to the admission of the exhibits on the grounds of hearsay, as well as due to an alleged violation of section 56505(e)(7). The District contended that it would be prejudiced by the admission of the exhibits because it had not seen the exhibits beforehand, did not know prior to the hearing what Dr. Beck’s credentials were and what his opinion relating to the Student’s educational program or needs would be, and therefore could not prepare a response. At the hearing, the Hearing Officer overruled the District’s hearsay objection because there is no prohibition excluding hearsay from admission in administrative proceedings. See Cal. Code Regs. Title 5, § 3082(b).

In the present matter, the Hearing Officer gives little, if any, weight to the substance of those letters for the following reasons: the hearsay statements attributed to the doctor were not corroborated by any other testimony or documentary evidence; the letters were not delivered to the District or the Hearing Officer until the day the hearing commenced; the doctor was not called to testify and was not subject to cross-examination; and there was no evidence introduced to qualify the doctor as an expert witness on matters relating to special education. Therefore, the District’s objection to the admission of Student’s exhibits 4, 7, and 9 was sustained.

2. Student’s Motion to Exclude District’s Witnesses and Documentary Evidence.

The Student moved to exclude the District’s witnesses and documentary evidence, contending that the time for the production of documents and identification of the witnesses expected to testify for the District in the District-filed case (SN04-02995) had passed. Student relied on language in the Prehearing Conference Order issued in this case as the supporting ground for his motion. The language relied upon was as follows:

The time for the notice of issues pursuant to California Education Code section 56505(e)(6) and for the identification of witnesses and the production of documentary evidence pursuant to California Education Code section 56505(e)(7) has passed.

The Student did not make reference, however, to the following language, also contained in the Prehearing Conference Order:

....The parties were advised that their agreement [on February 8, 2005] to the consolidation and to a hearing of the consolidated matter on February 10, 2005, could be viewed as inconsistent with a claim that they did not have reasonable notice....

The presiding Hearing Officer determined that the prehearing conference hearing officer intended, by the language cited above, to caution the parties that a hearing officer could find that each party had, by consenting to the consolidation and hearing date, waived any objection they may otherwise have had on the grounds so specified. At the hearing, this Hearing Officer accepted the exhibits proffered and permitted the testimony of the witnesses who testified, not only on the ground of waiver, but also upon a finding that there was no surprise and no prejudice to either party as it appeared that both parties were relying on the testimony of the same witnesses and the same documents, with a few anticipated and logical exceptions. Thus the Student’s motion was denied.

3. District’s Request for Sanctions.

In this matter the District expressed frustration in its dealings with the counsel and advocate for the Student and requested that sanctions be imposed for failure to follow the rules of procedure set forth in California Education Code section 56505 et seq. The District contended that the Student’s failure to comply with those provisions was intended to place the District at a disadvantage and gain surprise. The Student contended that the request for sanctions reflected a personal vendetta by the District against his representatives.

Sanctions are authorized in special education due process hearings by section 3088(a) of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations. Section 3088(a) provides that a presiding officer may order one party to reimburse the other party for expenses, including reasonable attorneys fees which result from “bad faith actions or tactics that are frivolous or solely intended to cause unnecessary delay” as defined in section 128.5 of the California Code of Civil Procedure.

While there were allegations made and inferences attempted, no direct evidence was introduced to show that the actions complained of were done in bad faith. The Student did not gain any advantage by failing to deliver documentary evidence to the District five days prior to the hearing and there were no surprise witnesses called by the Student. Further, no contention was made by the District that the acts complained of were made solely to cause delay or that they were frivolous.

The remedy of sanctions is to be used sparingly, reserved for matters that clearly fall within the parameters of the federal regulations, the California Education Code, the California Code of Regulations, and, where applicable, the California Code of Civil Procedure. In this matter, the burden of proof was not met. The Hearing Officer therefore denied the District’s motion for sanctions.

ISSUE

Did the District’s offer to the Student of an educational program and placement at Agua Dulce Elementary School, contained in the individualized education program (IEP) of December 9, 2004, offer him a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2004-2005 school year?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Student contended that the District’s offer of December 9, 2004, was not an offer of a FAPE for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year. He contended that he requires the following placement and program to address his unique needs and receive a meaningful benefit from his educational program: placement in a general education second-grade classroom at Meadowlark, his home school; provision of a one-to-one instructional aide from 8:30 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. on each school day; pull-out small-group speech and language services twice weekly for twenty-five minutes per session; pull-out small-group resource specialist program (RSP) services four times weekly for twenty-five minutes each session; and small-group occupational therapy (OT) services once per week for thirty minutes delivered in the classroom or, at the therapist’s option, on a pull-out basis. The Student contended that the placement and program offered to him at the IEP meeting of May 7, 2004, was appropriate to meet his needs and provide him meaningful educational benefit and should be continued.

The District contended that because the Student was not making sufficient progress in a general education class with academic support and special education services at Meadowlark, it designed and offered a more comprehensive program at the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting and it is that offer that constitutes a FAPE for the Student for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year. The District contended that while its December 9, 2004 offer included pull-out speech and language services and occupational therapy services as requested by the Student, the Student requires more intensive academic support and additional focus on speech and language difficulties. Additionally, the District contended that the Student requires instruction in a smaller class setting. Finally, the District contends that Student’s needs can be met in the SDC at Agua Dulce, but not in a general education placement at Meadowlark.

BACKGROUND FACTS

The Student is almost eight years old and is a second grade student at Meadowlark Elementary School. The Student lives with his parents and a sibling within the boundaries of the District. He is eligible for special education and related services under the category speech and language impaired.

His eligibility for special education was first evaluated in March 2002, when District speech pathologist Mark Lytle assessed the Student at the request of his parents prior to his entry into kindergarten at Meadowlark. The Student’s parents were concerned about what they perceived as his slow development.

At that time the Student was in preschool and he was four years ten months old. His relevant health history included recent episodes of chronic middle ear infection (otitis media). The recurring infections were sufficient to cause the Student’s pediatrician to order pressure equalizing (PE) tube placement. Mr. Lytle observed, during his assessment of the Student’s speech and language skills, that the Student was making errors in speech articulation and frequent grammatical errors. Mr. Lytle also observed that the Student’s speech and language difficulties were accompanied by an overlay of attentional difficulties. Mr. Lytle administered two standardized preschool language scale tests, collected a language sample, and completed an oral-motor screening. The results validated the conclusion that the Student was challenged in the area of speech and language, as evidenced by very low performance scores—at the 2nd percentile in auditory comprehension, the 2nd percentile in picture selection, and the 1st percentile in expressive communication.

According to Mr. Lytle, the Student exhibited mild to moderate articulation and phonological disorders and some voicing errors. Mr. Lytle’s overall impression was that the Student’s speech and language performance was at the borderline level of developmental dysfluency. The Student’s attentional issues at this time, according to Mr. Lytle, included an inability to sit quietly, difficulty attending, and a propensity to provide impulsive responses to questions.

District school psychologist R. Isaacs administered the Student’s first psychoeducational assessment in March 2002, as the Student was completing preschool. The principal significant conclusion from this evaluation was a finding that the Student fell in the average to below average range in cognitive functioning and academic performance.

On the basis of the Student’s delays in both receptive and expressive speech and language skills, his level of cognitive functioning, and his attentional issues, the IEP team, on June 18, 2002, established the Student’s eligibility for special education and related services and agreed to provide him pull-out speech and language therapy in a small-group setting twice weekly for periods of thirty minutes each. His placement continued to be in a general education class at Meadowlark, his home school. However, due to his increasing academic delays, the District added a peer tutor and a home tutor to his IEP.

By the time of his next annual IEP on May 7, 2003, the Student’s teacher reported that he was receiving medication for his attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), but that he was “still struggling” with attentional issues. His eligibility category remained speech and language impaired. Mark Lytle, the speech pathologist, reported that the Student had made only intermittent progress with his communicative issues due to inconsistent attendance and his attentional issues. The attendance issues were resolved by agreement between the District and the Student’s parents. Additional speech and language therapy time was not recommended because, as the report of the IEP meeting shows, the speech pathologist reported that the Student’s progress would increase as his attendance at the scheduled therapy sessions increased and his attention became more focused. The IEP team also recommended an extended school year (ESY) session for the Student for summer 2003.

The Student’s next IEP review meeting took place on October 3, 2003. The speech pathologist’s written report stated that even though the Student continued to miss key grammatical markers such as the article “the,” he had made “substantial progress.” However, during the discussion at the IEP meeting, the IEP team found that while it was true that he had progressed in some areas of articulation, he was not making adequate progress, particularly in receptive language, and because he did not understand instructions and multi-step directions, he was falling behind in all of his academic areas. A peer tutor and home tutor had been provided by the District but, due to insufficient results, the IEP team recommended additional services delivered through the resource specialist program (RSP). The IEP team agreed that an RSP teacher would provide academic support to the Student four times weekly in forty-five minute sessions.

In December 2003, Misty Cervantes, the current District school psychologist, found that the Student was experiencing even greater academic difficulties when she conducted a follow-up psychoeducational assessment at the request of the Student’s parents. Utilizing the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test - Second Edition (WIAT-II), she found that the Student’s overall mathematics skills were in the 8th percentile, his overall reading skills were in the 6th percentile, and his overall written expression skills were in the 4th percentile, all well within the below average range. She noted that the results of the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (CTONI) indicated that the Student’s cognitive abilities were falling more solidly into the below average range. She also found, using the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills - Revised (TAPS-R), the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills - Revised (TVPS-R), and the Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI), that his visual-perceptual skills and psychomotor skills were weakening. She concluded that his attentional issues were worsening and his speech and language difficulties were not improving at a rate commensurate with his age. Ms. Cervantes also concluded that the Student had continuing needs for pull-out speech and language therapy and accommodations in the classroom to help him with his attentional issues.

The Student’s next IEP meeting took place on February 19, 2004, at his parents’ request. He continued to make progress, characterized by District members of the IEP team as “slow, steady progress,” but he was performing below grade level in all academic areas. The parents continued to express their concern that he was not functioning at grade level. The Student was then in first grade and continuing to exhibit severe deficits in receptive and expressive language. His attentional issues appeared more prominently mentioned in the IEP. His eligibility criteria remained speech and language impaired. An occupational therapy (OT) assessment was in progress at the time of the IEP meeting.

At that IEP meeting, because of the Student’s difficulties with receptive language, his parents requested that he be provided an auditory trainer (a device to screen out background noise), a one-to-one aide, and goals and objectives designed to bring him up to grade level in all academic areas. The District members of the IEP team agreed to provide an auditory trainer, and increase his RSP support to seventy-five minute sessions, four times per week. Speech and language therapy was continued at essentially the same level: twice weekly, with pull-out small-group sessions of twenty-five minutes each. A one-to-one aide was not offered because the District members of the IEP team believed that an in-classroom aide would interfere with the benefits of the auditory training device. In addition, at this IEP meeting, goals and objectives for speech and language and the core curriculum were written and adopted. An ESY program was also offered. Accommodations were developed to assist him with his attentional difficulties—specifically, the provision of modified worksheets, manipulatives, prior notice of tests, rephrasing questions and directions, extra time, preferential seating, a study partner, visual cues, immediate feedback, checking work in progress, monitoring assignments, concrete examples, visual reminders, and a multi-sensory approach and having the Student read aloud and repeat information and instructions.

An OT assessment report was delivered to the IEP team shortly after the February 19, 2004 IEP meeting. The Student’s parents had requested this assessment. The District OT assessor found that the Student had successfully passed vision and hearing screenings. However, her assessment concluded additionally that he had a nineteen-month developmental deficit in fine motor/upper limb dexterity, a seven-month developmental deficit in upper limb coordination, a four-month developmental deficit in visual motor coordination, an unspecified auditory processing deficit, a deficit in visual/motor perceptual skills to a minimal amount, and “very minimal poor organization of behavior” (showing attentional difficulties interfering with task completion).

At the May 7, 2004 IEP meeting, because the Student’s OT assessment indicated that he had developmental difficulties in OT areas, the IEP team added one thirty-minute session per week of OT. The Student’s progress with speech and language issues and with attentional issues was once again described by District members of the IEP team as slow and steady. The IEP team added a classroom instructional aide to the Student’s program for four hours per day. His classroom seating and related attentional accommodations, as listed above, were continued and he was also provided the additional accommodation of extra time to complete homework assignments. His placement continued to be in a general education class seventy-seven percent of the time at Meadowlark, his home school. Finally, because the IEP team was concerned about the Student’s failure to improve significantly, an IEP review was scheduled for December 2004 to evaluate his progress. (Footnote 3)

The IEP review took place as scheduled on December 9, 2004. Mr. Lytle told the IEP team that it would not be effective to increase the Student’s individual speech therapy. Instead, he suggested placement in a language-rich environment with speech therapy continuing at the present levels. The District members of the IEP team concluded that they had provided to the Student the full range of services available to meet his needs in a general education setting and that to make progress he required a more restrictive placement in a class with fewer students, more instructors, and with more emphasis on speech and language issues.

The District IEP team members then determined that a change of placement to an SDC was required for the Student to receive a FAPE and made an offer reflecting this determination at the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting. The offer was for placement in the SDC setting at Agua Dulce, a comprehensive general education elementary school some distance from Meadowlark but within the boundaries of the District. According to District IEP team members, the SDC setting would provide the Student academic instruction in a small-group setting. Further, it would provide an opportunity for social interaction with general education students with whom he would interact at assemblies, lunches, recesses, and after-school sports programs. The District also offered to assign the Student a credentialed special education teacher as a case manager. Because the school is located approximately fifteen minutes away from his present school, the offer also contained a provision for door-to-door transportation. The offer also provides for continuation of his two twenty-five minute sessions per week of speech and language therapy and one thirty-minute session per week of OT services.

The Student’s parents disagreed with the District’s offer, contending that it does not offer him a FAPE in the LRE.

The Hearing Office received the present requests by the Student and by the District for a due process proceeding on December 13 and 17, 2004, respectively. The matters were then consolidated and the due process hearing commenced on February 10, 2005.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE: Did the District’s offer to the Student of an educational program and placement at Agua Dulce Elementary School, contained in the individualized education program (IEP) of December 9, 2004, offer him a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2004-2005 school year?

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17). California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

To determine whether the District substantively offered the student a FAPE, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized education program must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). Federal and State law also require that districts educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment, with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301.

To summarize, under the IDEA and the United States Supreme Court decision in Rowley, supra, the District’s proposed program must be designed to meet the student’s unique and individual needs, be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, and comport with the IEP. The offer must also provide an education in the least restrictive environment.

The right to a FAPE also includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G, supra, 960 F.2d at 1483. In Rowley, supra, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. 458 U.S. at 205. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., supra, 960 F.2d at 1479; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

Accordingly, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural requirements have been followed and whether the proposed program is substantively appropriate. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 206﷓208. In the present matter, the Student made no claim of errors by the District in following the procedures required by IDEA or the California Education Code. Thus, the Hearing Officer will turn directly to an examination of the substantive appropriateness of the District’s offer.

Student contended that the District’s offer of December 9, 2004, is not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit. He also contended that the offer of an SDC was not an offer of FAPE in the LRE. He contended at the hearing that a FAPE was offered by the District’s offer of May 7, 2004, and it is that program that should continue to be provided to him.

The District contended that on the basis of the available information, the offer of December 9, 2004, will provide Petitioner a FAPE for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year and that the District’s experience with the Student as of December 9, 2004, shows that the offer of May 7, 2004, was not appropriate.

(1) What Are the Student’s Unique Needs?

Federal and State law describe the types of disabilities that may qualify a child for special education and related services, but the child’s unique needs arising from his or her disability are the fundamental determinant of an appropriate program for the child. As stated in federal law, “The services and placement needed by each child with a disability to receive a free appropriate public education must be based on the child’s unique needs and not on the child’s disability.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.300(a)(3)(ii).

The appropriateness of the District’s offer must be viewed in light of the information that the IEP team had or should have had at the time the offer was made. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141 (9th Cir. 1999). Therefore, the Hearing Officer now turns to a determination of the Student’s unique needs at the time of the IEP meeting of December 9, 2004.

Both parties agreed that at the time of the IEP meeting on December 9, 2004, the Student had needs in the areas of speech and language, attention, academic instruction, and social interaction. The disagreement was about the severity of those needs and the placement where those needs could be appropriately addressed.

The District contended that the Student’s needs had increased as evidenced by the fact that he continued to lose ground in academics in comparison to his typical peers. District witnesses testified that each year he was getting farther behind his peers. The Student contended that the program set forth in his May 7, 2004 IEP met his needs and that he progressed satisfactorily from the time that program was offered until the present time. Student’s father testified that the most significant addition was the full-time aide, Ms. Carrubba, who was provided as a result of the May 7, 2004 IEP.

The District provided evidence that the Student’s deficits had increased over the past two and half years of his educational experience at Meadowlark. At the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting, the Student’s classroom teacher stated that the Student is not doing passing work at his grade level in any academic subject and that he is not able to complete his work at any level without his aide. (Footnote 4) She also stated that he is becoming frustrated in the general education class and is frequently “tuning out” and lying down on the floor during classroom instruction time. Mark Lytle, the speech pathologist, testified that he communicated to the IEP team that the Student’s phonology had improved but that other areas of speech difficulty had not. Mr. Lytle stated that second grade work is above the Student’s ability and that, in Mr. Lytle’s opinion, the Student is acting out his frustration by exhibiting dramatic negative behaviors (kicking and screaming on the floor, banging his head against the wall, etc., when Mr. Lytle is working with him). Mr. Lytle reported at the IEP meeting that the Student’s academic advancement is hampered by what has become a severe expressive and receptive language difficulty, an inability to remember sequences, an inability to perform calculations, and poor spelling skills.

District witnesses testified at the hearing that the Student’s difficulties “worsened” with the passage of time despite the provision of special education services by the District. When Mr. Lytle conducted a supplemental speech and language assessment in March 2002, he found that the Student continued to have severe delays in both receptive and expressive speech. At the due process hearing, Mr. Lytle testified that even with the Student’s slow but steady progress, his speech and language development actually worsened over time, “as compared to the development of his same-age peers.” That is, during the period from the 2000-2001 school year to the 2004-2005 school year, the same time that the Student was making “slow but steady” progress, his peers were making typical progress. The difficulty the Student was experiencing in receptive and expressive language had a negative effect on his ability to absorb academic information. Thus, while on an annual basis, his peers generally made a year’s academic progress, the Student’s academic progress was considerably less and, according to these witnesses, the Student continued to fall farther and farther behind.

Mr. Lytle testified that the Student was frustrated by his failure to keep up with his class and that one consequence was that during the 2004-2005 school year the Student began exhibiting compensating negative behaviors, presumably during speech therapy sessions which is the context in which the Student and Mr. Lytle had contact. According to Mr. Lytle, the Student’s compensating negative behaviors included banging his head against the wall or lying on the floor kicking in frustration. Mr. Lytle opined that the Student’s increased level of frustration demonstrated the Student had reached a point at which he could no longer benefit from a general education setting. Mr. Lytle testified that because of the Student’s present speech and language skill level, by the time the Student reaches third grade in the 2005-2006 school year, he will not be able to comprehend the academic information coming to him. Mr. Lytle testified that the Student needs more intense work than just the two sessions per week of speech therapy he has been receiving. According to Mr. Lytle, the Student needs supplementary speech and language practice in a smaller, more restrictive classroom, such as a speech and language based SDC. Mr. Lytle was well qualified to offer the opinions and the observations he provided. He has a master of arts degree (M.A.) in speech therapy, has been providing speech pathology services to school districts for the past eight years, and has been the Student’s speech pathologist since kindergarten. (Footnote 5)

Philip Rosell, the principal at Meadowlark, testified that he took an interest in the Student’s progress and therefore observed him often in the classroom and in playground situations. The principal characterized the Student’s progress by saying, “I see it as a decline. As time passes, he falls more and more behind his class.” In a year’s time, the Student progressed perhaps only two or three months according to the testimony of Mr. Rosell. (Footnote 6)

District school psychologist R. Isaacs administered the Student’s first psychoeducational testing in March 2002. The Student placed in the average to below average range in cognitive functioning and academic performance. Misty Cervantes, the current District school psychologist, found that the Student was experiencing greater academic difficulties when she conducted a follow-up psychoeducational assessment in December 2003 at the request of the Student’s parents. Utilizing the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test - Second Edition (WIAT-II), she found that the Student’s overall mathematics skills were in the 8th percentile, his overall reading skills were in the 6th percentile, and his overall written expression skills were in the 4th percentile, all well within the below average range. She also noted that the Student’s scores on the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (CTONI), indicated that his cognitive abilities were also falling more solidly into the below average range. Additionally, she found, using the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills - Revised (TAPS-R), the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills - Revised (TVPS-R), and the Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI) that his visual-perceptual skills and psychomotor skills were falling. She concluded at that time that his attentional issues were worsening and his speech and language difficulties were not improving at a rate commensurate with his age.

Ms. Cervantes, the District school psychologist, concluded at the time of her testing in December 2003 that the Student had continuing needs for pull-out speech and language therapy and accommodations in the classroom to help him with his attentional issues. She continued to recommend at the May 7, 2004 IEP meeting that he be provided more intensive speech and language services. Further, as she testified at the due process hearing, at the time of the next IEP meeting, the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting, the discussion of the Student’s needs was extensive because all the District members of the IEP team concluded that the Student still was not making meaningful progress. She testified that throughout the course of his schooling, because the Student was not making progress and was not meeting his goals and objectives, the IEP team continued to add services to his program: first the RSP program, then the auditory trainer, then OT, and then an aide. But, because the Student continues to achieve below acceptable levels, she and the District members of the IEP team concluded that he needs an environment that will provide him with a more intense speech and language focus. In short, Ms. Cervantes testified that for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year, the Student needs the smaller class setting that can be provided through an SDC and a class with a speech and language focus, as well as formal speech therapy, OT services, and continuing opportunities for social interaction. (Footnote 7)

Elda Fessler, the Student’s first grade teacher, testified that due to his limited receptive and expressive language growth, he has continued to fall more and more behind in all academic areas. “He [did] not get a year’s growth out of a year.” She testified that he did not work at grade level in any academic area and met only a few of his IEP goals and objectives. She also testified that in her professional opinion he needs an SDC environment that has a considerably smaller class size in order to make progress.

Lori Hickman, the Student’s second grade teacher at Meadowlark, also testified that the Student continues to have difficulty with speech and language, that his attentional problems are worsening, in her opinion due to his frustration, that he is not performing at grade level in any academic subject, and that he needs to be in a class that is smaller, is more specialized, and provides more focus on speech and language and a remedial academic curriculum. Ms. Hickman stated that since Ms. Carrubba began working as the Student’s instructional aide, Ms. Hickman has not had to devote as much of her own attention to the Student during class time.

In short, the witnesses for both parties testified that the Student continues to have a need for direct speech and language therapy in a small group, that he needs accommodations in the classroom to assist in dealing with his attentional issues, and that he needs occupational therapy services once weekly. The District witnesses also testified that in their collective opinion, the Student needs instruction in a classroom environment where there are fewer students and more instructors. The Student’s parents’ disagreed with this recommendation, as is stated below.

Student’s mother testified that the Student’s speech and language, OT, and academic needs are being met at Meadowlark. She stated that she is very satisfied with the May 7, 2004 IEP, which provides the present program, and that she feels that the Student’s one-to-one aide, Ms. Carrubba, is an essential addition to the Student’s educational program. She stated that he is making significant progress and is also concerned that his social needs will suffer if transferred to Agua Dulce.

The Student’s father agreed that the Student has attentional needs and needs for speech and language, OT, academic instruction, and social interaction. In addition, Student father testified that the Student’s needs are being met under the May 7, 2004 IEP. He stated that the Student has social friends with whom he plays sports at Meadowlark and if he were to transfer to Agua Dulce his needs for social interaction with peers would not be met. Student’s father also stated that in his opinion the Student is making adequate academic progress and “doing very well” in his present program and that the addition of the one-to-one aide to deal with his attentional needs was all that was required to fully meet the Student’s unique needs.

Ms. Carrubba testified that she told the December 9, 2004 IEP team that the Student would not be able to function in class without her. She stated at the hearing that because of the Student’s speech deficits, it is very difficult for the other students to understand what the Student is saying to them. Mr. Lytle testified “ the Student clearly demonstrates language comprehension and expression difficulties to a severe degree, with speech difficulties relating to imprecise articulation and phonemic output. In language comprehension the Student is challenged by multi-step, complex directions and often doesn’t tune in to the listener’s message, resulting in output not necessarily related to the subject matter at hand...” This summary statement by Mr. Lytle was consistent with Ms. Carrubba’s testimony to the effect that in the classroom she acts as the Student’s translator, repeating input from the teacher or reading written instructions to him, and then helping him to express himself or expressing for him what he wishes to communicate. Ms. Carrubba also testified that the Student is having difficulty performing at the second grade level. She stated, “Second grade is above him.” (Footnote 8) He has educational needs in reading and receptive and expressive language and is able to function, she testified, “because I am there to read to him. Without me he would be lost.” She testified that in her opinion, as a person who has worked for seven years as an instructional aide in the District, the Student has a need for a smaller class size, such as an SDC environment where he could work at his own level with more professionals present and be successful.

Ms. Carrubba testified that for several years she had been an instructional aide in the Agua Dulce SDC being offered to the Student and that she was very familiar with the program and routine of that class. She stated that from her experience she believed that the smaller class size of an SDC environment would provide the Student with regular contact with his teacher, the academic aides and RSP instructors who assist in the SDC, the OT provider, and the speech and language provider, all of which he needs to make meaningful progress. She also observed that the Student would fit in socially at Agua Dulce and that his needs for social interaction would be met. She testified that the Student is a motivated and well-behaved student who is very likable, makes friends easily, and “would fit in anywhere.”

The Student’s RSP teacher also expressed concern that the Student was not making sufficient progress and that even with the help he had been provided, he continues to fall more and more behind his grade level. His progress report indicated satisfactory performance, but the District witnesses testified that the report was scaled down and could not be used to demonstrate proficiency in middle-school work.

The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of Ms. Carrubba, Ms. Hickman, Ms. Fessler, Ms. Cervantes, and Mr. Lytle. All are educators who are well acquainted with the Student over the course of his school career, and their assessments of his unique needs and descriptions of his progress were consistent, both on direct and cross-examination. Ms. Carrubba was particularly persuasive in that she had loyalties to the family, but she was also an observer who had experience with the Student in his present program, as well as experience assisting in the SDC proposed by the District in the December 9, 2004 IEP. (Footnote 9)

The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence was sufficient to establish that at the time of the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting, the Student had unique needs for speech and language therapy in a small-group setting, OT therapy services, academic instruction provided in a small-group setting, academic tutors, and opportunities for social interaction.

(2) Is the District’s Offer Designed to Meet the Student’s Unique Needs?

The Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s offer is designed to meet the Student’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer must view the appropriateness of the District’s offer in light of the information that the IEP team had or should have had at the time the offer was made. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141 (9th Cir. 1999). As stated earlier, the District’s offer must be designed to meet the student’s needs. Moreover, as long as a school district provides an appropriate education, choices of methodology are left to the school district’s discretion. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., supra, 811 F.2d at 1314.

The District’s offer was made at the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting. The offer is for placement in the speech and language based SDC at Agua Dulce, a class that is located at a comprehensive general education elementary school in the District. According to the testimony of Steve Lorenze, the special education director and principal of Agua Dulce, and Mr. Lytle, the proposed SDC would provide the Student academic instruction with seven other students, all of whom have speech and language impairments and none of whom have physical disabilities, in a small-group setting and opportunities for social interaction with the students in the Student’s peer group, as well as with general education students during assemblies, recesses, and lunches. A credentialed special education teacher teaches the offered SDC with the assistance of an experienced instructional aide. Mr. Lorenze described the SDC as a “structured, small-group setting, with a higher adult to student ratio, and an overall focus on speech and language impairment.” The offer includes a credentialed special education teacher assigned as a case manager for the Student. Because the school is located approximately fifteen minutes from his present school, the offer contains a provision for door-to-door transportation. Finally, the District’s offer continues to provide the Student with two twenty-five minute sessions per week of speech and language therapy and one thirty-minute session per week of OT services.

The SDC at Agua Dulce, Ms. Cervantes testified, is speech and language based. The class size is smaller than at Meadowlark and the teacher/adult to student ratio is much lower. Ms. Fessler testified that the class size in the District’s SDC usually is five to seven students as compared to twenty students in the general education class. She explained, “It [the SDC] will give him an opportunity to move more at his own pace. At Meadowlark [the general education class], he will feel more stressed. He can’t keep up with his class. Eventually he will see himself as lesser than others and his self-esteem will suffer,” she testified.

Thus, the testimony established that the SDC setting would address the Student’s need for academic instruction in a small-group setting. It also would provide him opportunities for social interaction with speech and language impaired students in his peer group, as well as with general education students with whom he would have interacted during assemblies, lunches, recesses, and sports programs.

The offer also would provide the Student with the continuation of two twenty-five minute sessions per week of speech and language therapy to meet his need for improvement in speech and language skills. And he would be provided one thirty-minute session per week of OT services to continue to meet his OT needs. Ms. Carrubba testified that she believed that the Student would do well in the Agua Dulce SDC because the class size, structure, and focus would meet the Student’s unique needs in those areas. Ms. Carrubba had seven years experience as an instructional aide. Her years of experience as the instructional aide in the speech and language based SDC at Agua Dulce provided even more weight to her testimony in this regard.

The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District’s offer of December 9, 2004, was designed to meet each of the Student’s unique needs, namely small-group instruction in a speech and language focused SDC setting taught by a credentialed special education teacher with the assistance of an experienced instructional aide, small-group speech and language therapy, continuing OT services, and opportunities for social interaction with the general education population. Additionally, the offer was designed to meet the Student’s transportation needs that were occasioned by the proposed change of placement.

(3) Is the Offer Described in the IEP of December 9, 2004, Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit to the Student?

The Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s offer is reasonably calculated to provide the Student with educational benefit. Gregory K., supra, 811 F.2d at 1314. In Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The notion of “some” educational benefit may be characterized as more than a modicum, but less than the maximum possible, provided the amount of benefit is meaningful. The concept of “some” benefit is discussed in Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998), which held that providing meaningful educational benefit to a special education student requires a school district to provide meaningful access to education, but does not require a school district to guarantee successful results. As the Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit enunciated in M.C. ex rel. J.C. v. Central Regional School District, 81 F.3d 389 (3rd Cir. 1996), cert. denied, 117 S.Ct. 176 (1996), and Polk v. Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171 (3rd Cir. 1988), cert. denied, 488 U.S. 1030 (1989), the benefit conferred must be more than trivial or de minimis. What is required is a “basic floor of opportunity” that provides access to specialized instruction and related services individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. See Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 201; Cronkite v. Long Beach Unified School District, 176 F.3d 482 (9th Cir. 1999).

The parties disagreed on this issue. Student contended that he is receiving sufficient educational benefit from the program in place pursuant to the May 7, 2004 IEP. The District members of the December 9, 2004 IEP team acknowledged that the Student is receiving a modicum of benefit from the May 7, 2004 program, but contended that an analysis of his progress by December 9, 2004, showed that he was not receiving meaningful educational benefit as required by the IDEA.

The principal at Meadowlark, Phillip Rosell, testified that he was personally familiar with the Student’s progress. He observed the Student in class on occasion, at recess, and at lunch and he had taken an interest in the Student during the past three years. Mr. Rosell stated that any progress that may be attributed to the program provided by the May 7, 2004 IEP was “illusory.” He stated that as principal at the school, he was sufficiently familiar with the Student to observe that while it was true that the Student progressed, he made only approximately two to three months’ progress in the curriculum in a period of twelve months. “I see this as a net decline,” the principal testified. Conversely, he stated, the program proposed for the Student at the December 9, 2004 IEP is reasonably calculated to support the Student more completely and thus to provide sufficient “educational benefit” under IDEA.

Misty Cervantes, the District school psychologist, testified persuasively that the Student’s progress under the May 7, 2004 IEP has not been significant and that, because of this, the District developed the December 9, 2004 program, a program with more support in the Student’s areas of needs and thus reasonably calculated to provide him with sufficient educational benefit.

Steve Lorenze testified that at the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting, the Student’s declining skill levels were of concern. Mr. Lorenze testified that he told the IEP team “since the Student is not making adequate progress and is falling further behind his peers, we need to offer a more appropriate program that will provide him meaningful progress in the curriculum.” According to Mr. Lorenze, the IEP team then designed the December 9, 2004 program and offered it with the expectation that this program would provide the Student “some educational benefit.”

The Student’s father contended that pursuant to the May 7, 2004 IEP, the Student was making sufficient progress and that his progress constituted “some educational benefit.” The evidence offered in support of that contention was parental observation, gathered primarily at home and thus outside of the school environment. The Student’s parents testified that they observed some progress, but they also acknowledged that they were not aware of his frustration at school, his compensating behaviors at school, and his progress as compared to that of his peers.

The term “some educational benefit” connotes more than a modicum of progress. As the court stated in Gellerman v. Calaveras Unified School District, 34 IDELR 33 (E.D. Ca. 2000), “While the term does not require maximizing a child’s educational potential, it does require that the program offered be calculated to confer a meaningful educational benefit on the child.” (Citing Adams, supra, 195 F.3d at 1150.)

The Hearing Officer finds on the basis of the testimony of all of the witnesses that the Student made only a modicum of progress under the May 7, 2004 IEP. However, the Student continued to fall behind because he was able to make only three months of progress per year. The Hearing Officer finds therefore that the Student was not receiving “some educational benefit” under the May 7, 2004 IEP. The Hearing Officer concludes on the basis of the credible testimony of the District staff that it is the IEP of December 9, 2004, with its additional supports, including the SDC placement that is reasonably calculated to provide the Student educational benefit.

(4) Does the Proposed Program Conform to Petitioner’s IEP?

There is no dispute that the District was willing and able, and remains willing and able, to provide the program specified in the Student’s IEP of December 9, 2004. No issue exists as to conformity at the present time as the Student has not attended Agua Dulce pursuant to the District’s offer of December 9, 2004.

(5) Would the District’s Offer Provide an Education in the Least Restrictive Environment?

The final step is to determine whether the District’s proposed program would provide the Student with an education in the least restrictive environment (LRE). The Student contends that the District’s proposed program would not provide him an education in the LRE because it does not provide for interaction with typical peers or placement in his neighborhood school.

Special education law requires that a child with disabilities be educated in the least restrictive environment. Specifically, the IDEA provides that state and local educational agencies must ensure:

(1) That to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities ... are educated with children who are not disabled; and (2) That special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only if the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

Consistent with the mandate of LRE, school districts are required to ensure that a child’s placement “is as close as possible to the child’s home.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.552(b)(3). School districts are also required to ensure that “[u]nless the IEP of a child with a disability requires some other arrangement, the child is educated in the school that he or she would attend if nondisabled.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.552(c). However, the case law points out that these regulatory provisions create at most a preference for education in the school that the child would attend if not disabled (i.e., the neighborhood school). See, e.g., Murray v. Montrose Co. Sch. Dist. RE-1J, 51 F.3d 921, 929 (10th Cir. 1995). As the Court stated in Murray, supra:

A natural and logical reading of these two regulations is that a disabled child should be educated in the school he or she would attend if not disabled (i.e., the neighborhood school) unless the child’s IEP requires placement elsewhere. If the IEP requires placement elsewhere, then in deciding where the appropriate placement is, geographical proximity to home is relevant, and the child should be placed as close to home as possible. [Citations omitted.]

Id. (italics in original).

The proximity preference is merely one of many factors for a district to take into consideration in determining a student’s proper placement and does not rise to the level of a presumption that a disabled student should attend his or her neighborhood school. Flour Bluff Independent Sch. Dist. v. Katherine M., 91 F.3d 689, 693-694 (5th Cir. 1996). Therefore, for example, when a school district has an obligation to provide a disabled child with a school placement that includes a full-time nurse on duty, it is not required to change the district’s placement of nurses when care is readily available at another easily accessible school. Kevin G. v. Cranston Sch. Committee, 130 F.3d 481, 482 (1st Cir. 1997).

In Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994), the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals adopted a four-factor balancing test to determine whether a child should be placed in a regular education classroom with supplemental services. The Court found that the following four criteria should be considered: (1) the educational benefits of placement in a regular education class, (2) the nonacademic benefits of such a placement, (3) the effect the disabled child will have on the teacher and children in the regular class, and (4) the costs of mainstreaming the disabled child. Id. at 1404.

Further, in making an LRE determination, the Hearing Officer is guided by the Court’s admonition in Oberti v. Board of Educ. of the Borough of Clementon Sch. Dist., 995 F.2d 1204, 1216 (3rd Cir. 1993), which stated that a reviewing body must pay “special attention” to those unique benefits a disabled child may obtain from integration in a regular classroom which cannot be achieved in a segregated environment, such as the development of social and communication skills from interaction with nondisabled peers. Therefore, even a determination that a child with disabilities might make greater academic progress in a segregated special education class may not warrant excluding that child from a regular classroom environment. Oberti, supra, 995 F.2d at 1217.

Turning now to an examination of the factors discussed above, with regard to the first factor, the evidence established that the Student is not receiving much, if any, educational benefit from placement in the general education class and that his ability to receive educational benefit in that setting was diminishing as time passed. Specifically, according to the testimony of the Student’s second grade teacher and his one-to-one aide, because of the Student’s receptive language impairments and his attentional difficulties, he is experiencing difficulty with the second grade curriculum to a marked degree in that he is unable to understand instructions and unable to follow directions without the assistance of his full time one-to-one instructional aide. The teacher and aide each testified that looking to next year, because the third grade curriculum is so much more difficult than second grade, they believed that when the Student reaches third grade, he would be unable to understand what is taking place in a general education classroom. Thus, they stated that although he benefits minimally with the assistance of a full-time aide at the present time, his skill levels have been progressively falling and it would not be long before he is unable to benefit from any educational opportunities in a general education class.

The Student’s parents disagreed. They testified that the Student is benefiting from the general education class at the present time. However, as the record reflects, the District members of the IEP team each persuasively testified that the educational program at Meadowlark is not working for the Student. Instead, they stated that he is falling farther behind. Further, by the time of the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting, the District had continued to deliver the Student’s special education programs and services at his home school, keeping him in a general education class, while attempting to meet his educational needs by increasing the special education services and programs discussed previously in this Decision. When asked by the Hearing Officer whether the District considered other options—for example, any additional supplementary aids or service options—Mr. Lytle testified that adding more minutes of speech therapy would not be of benefit to the Student, stating that what the Student needs is “immersion in an SDC that is language based.” The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the nature and severity of the Student’s present disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. In comparison, the evidence establishes that the speech and language based SDC is designed to provide the Student with an amount of educational benefit that the general education setting is unable to.

As to the second factor, the nonacademic benefits available to the Student in a general education classroom, the Hearing Officer notes that the Student’s parents expressed a desire for him to stay at Meadowlark in a general education class with aids and services because of the nonacademic benefits of that placement, and contended that the more restrictive SDC for students with speech and language impairments at Agua Dulce would be harmful because of restricted social opportunities with nondisabled children. Further, they testified that his present friendships were centered at his home school, that his friends came over to his house to play after school, and that his school friends were the ones with whom he played after school organized sports, such as soccer. (Footnote 10) As stated earlier in this Decision, a hearing officer must pay “special attention” to those unique benefits a disabled child may obtain from integration in a regular classroom, such as the development of social and communication skills from interaction with nondisabled peers. Oberti, supra, 995 F.2d at 1217.

The testimony of all of the District witnesses who had contact with the Student at school established him to be a delightful and gregarious student, who “would have no trouble making friends anywhere.” The Hearing Officer is persuaded by that testimony and finds that the Student is able to obtain nonacademic benefits from interactions with his general education peers in terms of developing his social and communication skills. The December 9, 2004 IEP provides that the Student would spend twenty-three percent of his school day in the general education population at Agua Dulce but does not specifically reference how that will be accomplished other than during assemblies, lunches, and recesses. Taking into account that the Student is presently in a general education classroom at his home school, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence fails to establish that the December 9, 2004 IEP contains sufficient mainstreaming opportunities for the Student. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District failed to offer the Student an education in the LRE to the extent that its offer failed to provide specific and adequate time for the Student in the general education program at Agua Dulce during times such as physical education class, intramural sports programs, and other times as may be appropriate for the Student at Agua Dulce.

Additionally, as to the third factor, the effect the Student would have on the teachers and other students in the regular class, the Hearing Officer observes that no evidence was produced to suggest that the Student has a negative impact on the teacher and/or children in a regular education classroom. The testimony of all those who have worked with the Student most recently established that he is a well-behaved and well-liked individual, both by his teachers and his typical peers. There is no history of disruptive or aggressive behaviors in the classroom, and he is assisted by a one-to-one instructional assistant while in the classroom so that his need for individualized attention does not encroach upon those of his classmates. There was testimony suggesting that the Student’s current acting-out behaviors during speech therapy sessions would be disruptive if carried over into the general education class. However, that situation had not occurred as of the time of the hearing in this matter.

Similarly, with regard to the fourth factor, no evidence was offered to show that the cost of placing the Student in a regular education classroom would be significantly more expensive than an SDC placement. At one point in the proceeding, the special education director commented that the per-pupil cost of the SDC would be greater than the per-pupil cost of educating the Student in a general education classroom. However, nothing more specific was mentioned relative to comparative costs. (Footnote 11)

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student receives limited academic benefits from placement in a general education classroom, but obtains significant nonacademic benefits from placement in a general education classroom. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student does not have a negative effect on the teacher and other students in a general education classroom, or that the cost of a regular education placement weighs in favor of a more restrictive setting. The Student’s present educational program is described in his May 7, 2004 IEP as delivered seventy-seven percent of the school day in a general education setting at his home school. The proposed program would be delivered primarily in a special education SDC at a school other than his home school and to which the Student has to be transported. The proposed program is clearly designed to meet the Student’s educational needs and reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit. As noted earlier, the evidence presented at the hearing supports a finding that the substantial leap from the present program to the proposed program is required to provide the Student a FAPE. However, to the extent that the Student’s time with the general education students at Agua Dulce is unspecified and presently limited to an offer of mainstreaming during lunches, recesses, and assemblies, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence presented in this matter is insufficient to prove that the program offered to the Student by the December 9, 2004 IEP would provide him an education in the least restrictive environment.

(6) Conclusion.

The Hearing Officer has found that the IEP team correctly identified the Student’s unique educational needs and that the program offered in the December 9, 2004 IEP is designed to meet those needs and is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the Student. However, because the District failed to prove that the program offered would provide the Student adequate interaction with his nondisabled peers, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not offered the Student an education in the least restrictive environment. Thus, in conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to prove that its offer to the Student of an educational program and placement at Agua Dulce Elementary School, as contained in the IEP of December 9, 2004, is an offer of a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year. The District shall, within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of discussing, developing, and offering an appropriate educational program for the Student in the LRE. Specifically, the District shall consider additional mainstreaming opportunities for the Student to interact with his nondisabled peers at Agua Dulce and specifically describe those opportunities in the IEP.

ORDER

1. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of discussing and revising the December 9, 2004 IEP so that it offers the Student an appropriate educational program at Agua Dulce Elementary School. The District shall revise the educational program offered to the Student on December 9, 2004, to include a comprehensive plan that will provide the Student appropriate and adequate opportunities to interact with the general education population at Agua Dulce. The District shall specifically identify in the IEP the times and/or activities for participation in the general education program, including, if appropriate, assemblies, lunches, recesses, physical education class, and extra-curricular activities.

2. Any and all other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

The District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided to the extent that it proved that its offer of December 9, 2004, was designed to meet the Student’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. There was no challenge with regard to whether the program would have comported with the IEP. The Student prevailed on the only issue heard and decided to the extent that he established that the District’s offer of December 9, 2004, did not offer him an education in the LRE. The Student failed to prove, however, that his desired program constitutes an offer of a FAPE in the LRE.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: April 21, 2005 ___________________________________ Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Mr. Burkenroad did not attend the second day of the hearing. On that day, educational advocate Brian Allen appeared for the Student, examined the witnesses, and delivered the closing argument on the Student’s behalf.

2 At the prehearing conference in this matter on February 8, 2005, the parties stipulated that the District would bear the burden of going forward in this matter consistent with the general rule that the party seeking to change the status quo bears the burden of going forward. See Burger v. Murray County Sch. Dist., 612 F.Supp. 434 (N.D. Ga. 1984); Norton v. Orinda Union Sch. Dist., 168 F.3d 500 (9th Cir. 1999) (holding that at the administrative hearing, “[t]he school district bears the burden of proving that its evaluation and proposed student placement complied with the IDEA requirements....”).

3 Following the May 7, 2004 IEP meeting, the District received correspondence from the California Department of Education indicating that a compliance complaint had been filed on behalf of the Student, alleging that the District was not holding IEP meetings as required by his educational difficulties. Special education director Steve Lorenze testified at the hearing that he understood this to mean that the Student’s parents were not satisfied with the program offered by the District. Subsequently, Student’s father testified at the hearing that the program of special education and related services adopted at the May 7, 2004 IEP meeting was perfectly acceptable.

4 She did state that he was working at the second grade level in the area of math with his aide’s assistance.

5 Mr. Lytle is a graduate of the University of California at Santa Barbara and Pepperdine School of Law. After practicing law for a period of years, specializing in personal injury where he developed an interest in human anatomy and medicine, he returned to California State College at Hayward and received an M.A. in speech pathology in 1996. A certified speech pathologist, he provides speech and language services to individuals privately and through school districts.

6 Mr. Rosell has fifteen years experience in education. He is a graduate of California State College at Fullerton, from which he obtained a bachelor of arts degree and a clear teaching credential, and of California State College at Bakersfield, where he received his M.A. and an administrative credential. He has been principal and director of curriculum at Meadowlark throughout the period of the Student’s attendance at that school.

7 Misty Cervantes had been working in the education field as an elementary school teacher and school psychologist for seven years by the time of the hearing. She has been the District’s school psychologist for a period of four years.

8 Student’s Exhibit 11 was a progress report dated January 27, 2005, which indicated that the Student was doing very well and was making progress with “Ms. Becky’s help.” Ms. Carrubba testified that the report did not reflect that the Student was performing any work at grade level and was simply intended to encourage the continuation of his “slow and steady progress.”

9 The Hearing Officer observed that Ms. Carrubba was uncomfortable testifying because she was fond of the family and her testimony contradicted their position in this matter.

10 Student’s mother stated that she observed an SDC at Agua Dulce and observed autistic children, severely handicapped children, and children unable to control their bodily functions. In her opinion, placing the Student in a class with children so severely disabled would be harmful to his self-esteem and would create barriers to his progress. Student’s mother’s concerns were dispelled when Mr. Lorenze testified that there were two SDCs at Agua Dulce, one of which had more severely disabled students in it. However, he stated, that was not the SDC intended for the Student. The Student’s proposed SDC consists only of speech and language impaired students.

11 However, it should be noted that the comment referenced was volunteered and was not in response to a pending question during the testimony of the special education director. In that context, it was not evident whether the cost of the one-to-one aide was factored into Mr. Lorenze’s com