California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 26, 1996

Student v. Mt. Diablo Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 295-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson

Mt. Diablo Unified prevails: Hearing Officer finds 17-year-old student does not qualify for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 17-year-old student's family filed for due process against Mt. Diablo Unified School District. The student had received special education since preschool and qualified under "severe disorder of language." He also had cognitive delays, attention deficit disorder, and obsessive-compulsive disorder. He attended special day classes and general education electives at Concord High School. His mother asked that he also be found eligible as having a serious emotional disturbance (SED), and she sought a residential placement. The only issue was whether he met the SED criteria.

The student's private psychologist, Dr. Andrew Pojman, said he met several criteria, including depression and inappropriate behavior. Dr. Pojman had never observed the student at school or spoken with his teachers. District school psychologist Jerry Zimmerman, teachers Joan MacKellar and Geneva Henry, and other witnesses described a student who earned B's, made progress on his IEP goals, led classmates in group work, and had friends and good relationships with staff. Hearing Officer Mark Paxson reviewed each of the five SED characteristics. He found that any learning problems were explained by the student's cognitive and language disabilities. The student had difficulty with relationships but not an inability to form them. His behavior concerns occurred outside school and did not harm his educational performance. The depression scale was unreliable for this student. The Hearing Officer denied the claim, and the district prevailed.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the SED definition in 5 CCR § 3030(i). Each characteristic had to exist over a long period of time and to a marked degree, and it had to harm educational performance. Serious behavior at home or in the community did not establish SED when school grades, goal progress, and teacher reports showed the student was doing well.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education services as a result of a serious emotional disturbance (SED)?

    Student did not meet any of the five SED criteria in 5 CCR § 3030(i) over a long period of time, to a marked degree, and with an adverse effect on educational performance; his school grades, progress on goals, and positive peer and teacher relationships showed no such effect.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Petitioner's claim that he is eligible for special education as a result of a serious emotional disturbance is denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(i)

People named in the decision

  • Joan Alber, administrator of special education, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Diana Wells, director of special education, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Ivette Pena, attorney for District (part of hearing), Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Dr. Edward Stambaugh, private neuropsychologist (neuropsychological assessment and counseling), Rafa Counseling Associates
  • Dr. Greg MacDonald, pediatric neurologist (evaluation), Kaiser Permanente-Martinez
  • Therese Arcand, school psychologist (triennial reevaluation), Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • James (Jim) Long, vice principal, District witness, Concord High School
  • Joseph Shulik, placement coordinator, Regional Center of the East Bay
  • Jerry Zimmerman, school psychologist (SED assessment), District witness, Mt. Diablo Unified School District, Delta Center
  • Kathy Rice, interviewed for assessment (role not stated)
  • Dr. Martha Butler, chief of outpatient psychiatry (letter submitted; did not testify), Kaiser-Martinez
  • Dr. Andrew Pojman, private psychologist, expert witness for Student
  • David O'Grady, private counselor
  • Mary Beahoeffer, family counselor
  • Oasis Center, private counseling provider
  • Marianne Fellrath, Regional Center case manager, witness for Student, Regional Center of the East Bay
  • Joan MacKellar, general education home economics (Foods) teacher, District witness, Concord High School
  • Geneva Henry, special day class teacher and case manager, District witness, Concord High School
  • Jodi Couick, psychologist, records-review expert witness for District, West Contra Costa Unified School District
  • Anneliese Makely, school psychologist providing counseling, District witness, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Helen Borgan, supervisor, District witness, George Miller Center
  • George Miller Center, after-school social-recreational program for youth with developmental delays
  • Devereux, residential treatment facility (accepted the student)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Concord, California, on July 25 and 26, and August 1, 1996.

Petitioner Student was represented by attorney Deborah Duggan. Also present on behalf of Petitioner was his mother, Mother. Respondent Mt. Diablo Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Bridget Flanagan. Also present on behalf of the District was Joan Alber, administrator of special education and, for a portion of the hearing, attorney Ivette Pena and Diana Wells, director of special education.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until August 13, 1996, for the submission of closing briefs. At that time the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

Is STUDENT eligible for special education services as a result of a serious emotional disturbance (SED)?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old young man who has been diagnosed with multiple disabilities, including a speech and language impairment, cognitive delays, attention deficit disorder, and obsessive-compulsive disorder. He has received special education services since preschool. STUDENT has repeated two grades, third and eighth; and during the prior school year, 1995-96, he was enrolled in the ninth grade at Concord High School. His educational program at Concord High School consisted of special day classes in academic subjects and regular education courses in his elective courses, such as Foods and Physical Education.

In recent years, STUDENT has had several behavioral problems which have caused concern. In June 1994, he broke into two homes and stole some women's underwear. As a result of this incident, STUDENT was charged with two counts of burglary. At a later date, the charges against STUDENT were amended to include another count of burglary stemming from another incident on December 20, 1994. STUDENT was placed on probation.

In the fall of 1995, STUDENT again broke into a home. This time it was the home of a fellow student. STUDENT stole the student's personal phone book and clothing. He made phone calls to individuals listed in the phone book. This incident was also reported to the police and STUDENT has been charged with violation of his probation. As of the date of the hearing, there had been no resolution of the latest charge against STUDENT. In addition to stealing women's clothing, STUDENT has also engaged in other sexual acting out at home, such as wearing his mother's clothes and excessive masturbation. However, he has not engaged in any similar acting out at school.

STUDENT had referrals, detentions, or suspensions periodically throughout the 1992-1993 to 1994-1995 school years, including approximately five one-day suspensions for fighting-related behavior. He also had several detentions and referrals for disrupting class or failing to complete homework. However, he did not have any discipline referrals from October 1995 until he was suspended during the present summer school session for an incident in which he hit another student.

STUDENT has been on a series of medications, including Depacote, Tegretol, Prozac, Haldol, Cogenten, and Anafranil, to help him control his behaviors. He is currently taking only Tegretol.

On September 19, 1994, Dr. Edward Stambaugh of Rafa Counseling Associates, completed a neuropsychological assessment of STUDENT. At that time, STUDENT's mother noted an increase in the past two years of a variety of compulsive behaviors, including lying, stealing, fighting, disruptiveness, and infatuation with women's underwear. The reason for the referral to Dr. Stambaugh was a series of home break-ins in which STUDENT stole women's underwear.

Dr. Stambaugh administered a wide range of tests. On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III, STUDENT received a Full Scale IQ score of 73, which Dr. Stambaugh indicated fell in the borderline range of mental retardation. On the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), STUDENT's academic scores were at a similar level. His scores ranged from 67 on the Spelling subtest to 77 on the Reading Comprehension, Listening Comprehension, and Mathematical Reasoning subtests. Dr. Stambaugh concluded that the results on the WIAT suggested that STUDENT was making the "best use of his intellectual resources in the academic curriculum."

Dr. Stambaugh's diagnostic impression of STUDENT was "borderline mental retardation, likely secondary to cerebral infection or insult prenatally, with historical evidence of a seizure disorder currently untreated. Consistent evidence of a compulsive personality disorder with probable underlying obsessive features." Dr. Stambuagh also noted that STUDENT is persistent and has a strong need to please others, characteristics which might conceal from "the casual observer" the severity of his disabilities.

On February 1, 1995, Dr. Greg MacDonald with the pedi-neurology department at Kaiser Permanente-Martinez conducted an evaluation of STUDENT. Dr. MacDonald's impression of STUDENT at that time was that he has a "mild right hemiparesis" consistent with mild cerebral palsy and that his behavioral difficulties are "exaggerated normal behaviors for pre-adolescent." Dr. MacDonald also concluded that STUDENT has symptoms consistent with obsessive-compulsive disorder and attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity. Dr. MacDonald recommended a change in medication to treat his symptoms.

On March 8, 1995, Therese Arcand, school psychologist, completed a triennial reevaluation of STUDENT. Dr. Arcand concluded that

STUDENT presents the picture of an adolescent with multiple problems. His mother reports that he is brain damaged, has a seizure disorder, is cerebral palsied, has a learning disability, possesses an adaptive behavior level of a much younger child, has lower functioning mental ability, and has an assessed Obsessive-Compulsive disorder. The impact of multiple disorders necessitates continuation of special education as well as the restrictive environment of special day class. At school STUDENT usually requires supervision and patience. He continues to qualify for special education under the handicapping condition of severe disorder of language.

In March and May 1995, STUDENT's IEP team met several times to develop his IEP. On May 4, 1995, the IEP was completed. The IEP included several pages of goals and objectives covering social studies, language arts, math, use of a computer, asking for help, and social and behavioral areas. The social and behavioral goals included such things as working independently and following directions, completing homework, and working with others.

On December 4, 1995, after MOTHER expressed concerns regarding STUDENT's leaving campus during school hours to Jim Long, vice principal at Concord High School, Mr. Long sent a memo to his teachers instructing them to contact Student Services whenever STUDENT needed to be out of class. Student Services would sent a campus supervisor to accompany STUDENT.

In January 1996, STUDENT started at an extended day program at George Miller Center, an after-school program for disabled children. He has continued attending that program to the present.

Also in January 1996, MOTHER requested an IEP meeting to determine whether STUDENT meets the SED eligibility criteria. The IEP team agreed to conduct an assessment to address MOTHER's request.

On February 8, 1996, Joseph Shulik, placement coordinator for the Regional Center of the East Bay, prepared a letter recommending STUDENT for residential placement for SED children. According to Mr. Shulik, STUDENT is a higher functioning individual than the Regional Center usually serves in its residential facilities and he would "fit" into an SED residential facility.

On April 17, 1996, Jerry Zimmerman, school psychologist for the District, completed a psycho-educational assessment as required by the January 1996 IEP meeting. The purpose of the assessment was to determine whether STUDENT qualified as SED. Mr. Zimmerman based his assessment on a review of STUDENT's records and interviews with STUDENT, MOTHER, and Kathy Rice. Mr. Zimmerman did not conduct any additional testing of his own.

While Mr. Zimmerman did not doubt or question prior diagnoses of STUDENT, including obsessive-compulsive disorder, Mr. Zimmerman noted that STUDENT's school records did not reveal any obvious signs or behavioral symptoms related to obsessive-compulsive disorder, nor did STUDENT's IEP address obsessive thoughts or compulsive behaviors which interfered with academic functioning. Mr. Zimmerman interviewed STUDENT and noted that he had a rigid and repetitive style of functioning during the school day but that he believed that the rigidity and repetition could be an adaptive function to help him cope with the stimulation and choices at school.

Mr. Zimmerman stated that STUDENT "presented" as a high functioning educable mentally retarded student. Mr. Zimmerman was of the opinion that STUDENT's level of intellectual functioning has the most pervasive impact upon his education. Mr. Zimmerman stated that STUDENT's school records supported the conclusion that he also has subaverage adaptive behavior, delayed development, and subaverage educational performance.

Mr. Zimmerman reviewed STUDENT's behavior in relation to the criteria for SED eligibility. His conclusions were as follows:

(1) inability to learn - STUDENT is able to learn in the classroom with appropriate interventions and modifications. In addition, if STUDENT does have an inability to learn, STUDENT has other factors, including mental retardation, speech and language disorders, and multiple handicaps, which may explain that inability.

(2) interpersonal relationships - STUDENT is able to initiate and maintain satisfactory relationships with peers and teachers as evidenced by his friends at school and at the George Miller Center.

(3) inappropriate behavior - these behaviors have to be psychotic, overtly bizarre, or potentially harmful. STUDENT's behaviors, while potentially dangerous to himself, are only dangerous to himself because of the possible reactions of others. In addition, his behaviors are not interfering with his education.

(4) unhappiness or depression - while STUDENT may be unhappy because of teasing, over-stimulation, high expectations, or inappropriate curriculum, his grades have been good. STUDENT is not depressed.

(5) physical symptoms or fears - there is no report of physical symptoms or fears by STUDENT or his mother, and they are not evident in his school records.

Mr. Zimmerman also noted that the SED criteria require that the student's emotional disturbance have an adverse affect on the student's education. Mr. Zimmerman stated that STUDENT's school records do not indicate that he is a source of disruption or potential danger to himself or others. In addition, based on his current grades, he appeared to be learning. Finally, Mr. Zimmerman noted that the behaviors which were of concern were not documented to have occurred at school. Mr. Zimmerman was of the opinion that STUDENTdid not meet the SED eligibility criteria.

On May 21, 1996, Dr. Martha Butler, chief of the outpatient psychiatry department at Kaiser-Martinez, sent a letter regarding STUDENT to MOTHER. According to Dr. Butler, STUDENT has problems with obsessive compulsive symptoms and has been diagnosed with pervasive developmental disorder, not otherwise specified. Dr. Butler states that this diagnosis would qualify STUDENT as SED because of an inability to maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships and inappropriate types of behaviors or feelings under normal circumstances.

Beginning in March 1996, STUDENT's IEP team convened several times to discuss Mr. Zimmerman's assessment and STUDENT's placement for the 1996-97 school year. With the exception of MOTHER, the IEP team recommended continued placement in a special day class with speech and psychological services. MOTHER wanted a residential placement. At the time of the IEP meeting, STUDENT's most recent Woodcock Johnson achievement scores as recorded on May 1, 1996, were the following:(Footnote 1)

Test Standard Score

Broad Reading 81 Broad Math 84 Broad Written Language 70 Broad Knowledge 79 Skills 79

The IEP team again adopted a lengthy list of goals and objectives.

In May 1996, STUDENT's English teacher completed a "Summary of English Performance." This summary addressed whether STUDENT had met the language goals in his IEP. Of eight goals listed, STUDENT had met four goals and had made progress toward four goals, which were recommended by the teacher to be continued. As for STUDENT's other goals, he met some math goals and vocational education goals. However, the goals and objectives relating to social and behavioral issues were defined as "ongoing," apparently indicating that they would be continued to STUDENT's next IEP.

STUDENT's final grades for the 1995-96 school year were as follows:

Foods B Phys. Ed. B Math B English B Voc. Ed. B Science C

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Petitioner's Witnesses

Andrew Pojman

Dr. Andrew Pojman is a licensed psychologist and certified school psychologist who first provided counseling services to STUDENT on January 31, 1995. Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT exhibited poor personal hygiene at that time and that he was not very responsive. Between January 1995 and January 1996, STUDENThad 22 sessions with Dr. Pojman. The purpose of Dr. Pojman's counseling services was to clarify STUDENT's diagnosis, improve his social behaviors and interpersonal awareness, and decrease his acting out.

Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT's disabilities include a significant language impairment and a neurological impairment which is causing significant cognitive limitations. Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT may meet the criteria for educably mentally retarded. Dr. Pojman also indicated that STUDENT has features of an obsessive-compulsive disorder and exhibits inattention, lack of energy, and depression.

Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT meets the criteria for SED eligibility. Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT has the ability to learn but questioned whether his learning is consistent with his ability. Dr. Pojman also stated that he "assumed" STUDENT's sexual thoughts and obsessions would interfere with his ability to learn. According to Dr. Pojman, STUDENT has difficulty developing satisfactory relationships with his peers and teachers. Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT knows how to socialize appropriately (for example, smile and look at the face of the person he is talking with), but that he is unable to maintain appropriate socialization. Dr. Pojman also stated that STUDENT does not ask for help from others. Dr. Pojman based his opinion regarding STUDENT's inability to maintain satisfactory relationships on his review of STUDENT's records and his own observations of STUDENT.

In addition, Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT engages in inappropriate behavior under normal circumstances. As examples, Dr. Pojman cited incidents of STUDENT breaking into his mother's room and wearing her clothes, stealing from other kids, and his tendency to "go too far" when he likes somebody. Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT's behavior and feelings are inappropriate. Dr. Pojman also cited STUDENT's hearing voices as an example of his inappropriate behavior. Dr. Pojman testified that he suspects that the episodes of hearing voices interfered with his educational performance.

Finally, Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT is depressed and unhappy. Dr. Pojman testified that, in STUDENT's own mind, he is unhappy approximately eighty percent of the time. Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT's unhappiness exists in all environments. Dr. Pojman administered a depression scale (Reynolds Adaptive Depressive Scale) during one of his sessions with STUDENT. On that scale the benchmark raw score for depression is 72 or higher and STUDENT obtained a raw score of 77.

Dr. Pojman pointed to several factors in support of a diagnosis of depression for STUDENT. Those factors included STUDENT's isolation and the fact that he does not get out much, his depressed mood, sleep problems, unhappiness, difficulty concentrating and paying attention, and irritability. Dr. Pojman testified that some of these factors could be attributed to other problems, such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder or cognitive impairments.

Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT's SED has adversely affected his educational performance because he has been involved in several fights recently and he walks off campus.

Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT is not a good source for information about what is going on in his life because he does not tell the truth. Dr. Pojman also testified that STUDENT has only a vague sense of the consequences of his behaviors.

Dr. Pojman testified that he has never spoken with STUDENT's teachers or observed STUDENT at school or at home. Dr. Pojman noted that STUDENT appears to be frightened or fearful of other kids in Dr. Pojman's waiting room.

MOTHER

MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified that STUDENT was diagnosed at the age of three years as having brain damage. Throughout his schooling, STUDENT has had difficulty socializing.

MOTHER testified that prior to the beginning of STUDENT's eighth grade school year, he began to receive counseling from Mr. David O'Grady. The counseling lasted for two months and ended because STUDENT was not participating in the counseling. MOTHER then took STUDENT to Dr. Stambaugh. STUDENT saw Dr. Stambaugh once a week for three months in 1994. Following counseling with Dr. Stambaugh, STUDENT received family counseling from Mary Beahoeffer, and then he received counseling from the Oasis Center. STUDENT has also seen a psychiatrist at Kaiser for the purpose of medication monitoring.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT had several problems during the 1994-95 school year, which was STUDENT's second year in the eighth grade. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was caught off campus in the elementary school girl's bathroom. STUDENT was also suspended and taken to the office several times. MOTHER testified that STUDENT broke into several homes in December 1994 and also stole girl's underwear from backpacks at school. MOTHER testified that, during this time, STUDENT did not socialize with neighborhood peers, never brought school friends home, and was never invited out by other children.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT continued having problems with leaving campus during the past school year, 1995-96. According to MOTHER, STUDENT left campus and broke into a fellow student's home several times during school hours. STUDENT stole the student's personal phone book and used it to make phone calls. STUDENT also stole the student's clothing. MOTHER testified that she learned of this incident from the other student's mother, who found out about the phone calls and also observed STUDENT at her front door one day when she came home for lunch. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has not broken into any homes since this incident because of the medications he has been on and because he has been under constant supervision.

MOTHER also testified that STUDENT had several incidents of "hearing voices" in fall 1995 and that he was placed on Haldol and Cogenten for a short period of time as a result. STUDENT was taken off of Haldol and Cogenten because of the side effects.

According to MOTHER, STUDENT went to a school dance with a girl from his class. MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not talk to the girl on the ride to the dance and that at the dance the girl danced with her friends but did not dance with STUDENT. MOTHER also testified that at some point after the dance the girl invited STUDENTto a movie with some of her friends. MOTHER testified that the girl did not talk to STUDENT during the whole "event."

Regarding STUDENT's social-emotional status, MOTHER testified that STUDENT was suspended from summer school recently for hitting and swearing at another student; is more volatile; has discussed, but not attempted, suicide; has written letters regarding not having friends and being teased; is afraid of changing schools because of teasing; has low self-esteem; and is not happy. MOTHER testified that he is obsessed with sexual issues and women's clothing.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT has a good relationship with his older brother, who is nineteen years old. STUDENT and his brother play Nintendo and go swimming together. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has passed all of his classes and is on track for graduation.

Marianne Fellrath

Marianne Fellrath is STUDENT's case manager for the Regional Center of the East Bay. Ms. Fellrath testified that the Regional Center has tried to provide STUDENT with in-home and out-of-home respite care and that he is currently attending an extended day program at the George Miller Center. Ms. Fellrath testified that STUDENT does a lot of "caretaking" of some of the more behaviorally challenged students in the program. Ms. Fellrath testified that she has not heard of any problems with STUDENT at the George Miller Center.

District Witnesses

Joan MacKellar

Joan MacKellar is a home economics teacher at Concord High School and taught STUDENT's Foods class during the 1995-96 school year. Ms. MacKellar testified that the class is a regular education class consisting of approximately 33 students. The students work together on various projects, including cooking and food preparation.

Ms. MacKellar testified that STUDENT's behavior in her class was normal to above average. He had good attendance, knew when things needed to be done, and was a leader with his group of students when working on projects. Ms. MacKellar testified that other students in his group, which consisted of two regular education students and two special education students, accepted his leadership. Ms. MacKellar testified that none of the students in STUDENT's group ever complained about his behavior and that the group was successful as a team. Ms. MacKellar also testified that STUDENT liked to help her and that oftentimes he came to class early to help her set up supplies.

Specifically regarding STUDENT's relationships with his peers, Ms. MacKellar testified that he was teased at the beginning of the year because of his impairment. However, as soon as she found out about the teasing, Ms. MacKellar testified that she put a stop to it and STUDENT did not have any further problems with his peers. Ms. MacKellar testified that STUDENT's behavior was excellent. Ms. MacKellar testified that STUDENT was usually playful, fun, and upbeat.

Jerry Zimmerman

Jerry Zimmerman is a school psychologist employed by the District at the Delta Center, a special site for students with behavioral and emotional difficulties. In March 1996, Mr. Zimmerman conducted an assessment, consisting primarily of a review of his records and several sessions with STUDENT. Mr. Zimmerman did not conduct any formalized testing of STUDENT. Mr. Zimmerman testified that the purpose of his assessment was to determine whether STUDENT qualifies for special education as a result of an SED.

Mr. Zimmerman testified that STUDENT appeared overmedicated when he met with him because his affect was flat and his responses were slow. Mr. Zimmerman testified that he discussed school with STUDENT and that STUDENT was more positive about school than he expected. Mr. Zimmerman testified that STUDENT was "socially uncomfortable" and that the teasing STUDENT received at school was hurtful. Mr. Zimmerman testified that learning was not a problem for STUDENT but that STUDENT was concerned about his mom's expectations.

A week after his meeting with STUDENT, Mr. Zimmerman met with MOTHER and Kathy Rice. Mr. Zimmerman testified that they discussed STUDENT's problems in the community, MOTHER's concerns that STUDENT's educational needs were not being met, and whether a residential placement would be appropriate.

Mr. Zimmerman testified that STUDENT had a very rigid style or routine of doing things but that STUDENT was happy with the routine. Mr. Zimmerman also testified that STUDENT was happy at the George Miller Center.

Mr. Zimmerman reviewed the triennial assessment completed by Dr. Arcand in March 1995 and testified that there was nothing in that assessment that indicates the possibility of SED eligibility. Mr. Zimmerman also reviewed a form that Dr. Pojman filled out and submitted for an AB 3632 referral and testified that there was nothing in Dr. Pojman's information that supported SED eligibility. Specifically, although Dr. Pojman listed some behavioral problems that STUDENT was having, there was nothing in that information which indicated that STUDENT's behavioral problems were interfering significantly with his education. Mr. Zimmerman also testified that the sexual problems that STUDENT is having are not happening in the classroom or interfering with his education.

Regarding STUDENT's ability to learn, Mr. Zimmerman testified that STUDENT's teachers have said that he is doing well in his classes. Mr. Zimmerman testified that, based on the teachers' reports, STUDENTis doing better than he would expect based on STUDENT's cognitive impairments.

Regarding STUDENT's relationships with peers and teachers, Mr. Zimmerman testified that this SED criterion refers to students who have "disturbed" relationships and who are withdrawn and incapable of seeking help. Mr. Zimmerman testified that STUDENT has several friends and that he responds well to teachers, both at school and at the George Miller Center. Again, Mr. Zimmerman testified that although STUDENT is socially awkward, his awkwardness does not interfere with his education. Mr. Zimmerman testified that there was no evidence of disturbed relationships.

Regarding inappropriate behavior under normal circumstances, Mr. Zimmerman testified that to meet the SED criterion the behavior has to be bizarre or a very extreme response that does not relate to the circumstances. Mr. Zimmerman testified that there was no evidence of extreme behaviors that were interfering with STUDENT's education.

Regarding depression or unhappiness, Mr. Zimmerman testified that the depression or unhappiness has to be pervasive, or exist in all settings in the individual's life. Mr. Zimmerman also described this criterion as requiring a student who has no pleasure in anything or is so depressed that he or she is not able to take care of him or herself. Mr. Zimmerman testified that STUDENT is unhappy at times about being teased or being in trouble, but that his unhappiness is a natural and appropriate reaction to what is happening in his life. In addition, Mr. Zimmerman testified that STUDENT's unhappiness is not pervasive. He is happy at George Miller Center and at home and enjoys school.

Mr. Zimmerman testified that all of the information he received, including STUDENT's school file, Dr. Pojman's report, and other reports completed by professionals who have worked with Student, supports a diagnosis of developmental delays but not SED. Mr. Zimmerman testified that STUDENT has difficulties but those difficulties are not related to an emotional disturbance.

Geneva Henry

Geneva Henry was STUDENT's case manager and one of his special day class teachers during the 1995-96 school year. STUDENT was in her English and pre-vocational class. Ms. Henry testified that there were approximately 12-13 students in the English class, with one full-time aide.

Ms. Henry testified that STUDENT did very well in her class. He was always on time and prepared, a good note-taker, responsive during class activities, and cooperative. Ms. Henry testified that she never had any problems with STUDENT. Ms. Henry testified that STUDENT was a "leader" and tried to keep students in his group focused. Ms. Henry testified that, although STUDENT was teased somewhat at the beginning of the school year, he was accepted by the other students in the class. Ms. Henry also noted that he was friendly with several other students in her class. In addition, Ms. Henry testified that STUDENT was always friendly and appropriate with her. Ms. Henry testified that STUDENT was interested in learning and that if he did not understand something he would seek clarification.

Ms. Henry testified that there are approximately 11-12 students in her vocational education class. The class focuses on real-life math skills and real-life activities. Ms. Henry testified that STUDENT did well in the class and did not present any behavioral problems. Ms. Henry testified that STUDENT had friends in the class.

As STUDENT's case manager, Ms. Henry met weekly with all of his teachers. Ms. Henry testified that she was not aware of any problems that STUDENT's other teachers had with him. Ms. Henry testified that she never observed bizarre behaviors from STUDENT and that he knew how to communicate with others and interact appropriately.

Jodi Couick

Jodi Couick is a psychologist who works for the West Contra Costa Unified School District. Ms. Couick reviewed STUDENT's records, including reports from Kaiser, the Regional Center, Dr. Stambaugh, and STUDENT's school. Ms. Couick has not observed STUDENT in school or met with him.

Ms. Couick testified that SED requires that a student not be benefitting educationally due to an emotional disturbance. Ms. Couick testified that there was nothing in the records she reviewed to support eligibility for STUDENT as SED. Ms. Couick testified that STUDENT's behavioral problems are related to his cognitive delay and that his sexual identity issues are attributable to his age and cognitive delay.

With regards to the specific SED criteria, Ms. Couick testified that school records establish that STUDENT is learning and his standardized scores are increasing on a consistent basis. Therefore, he does not have an inability to learn.

Regarding peer relationships, Ms. Couick testified that STUDENT does have relationships with peers and adults both in the classroom and at George Miller. Ms. Couick also testified that STUDENT does not exhibit inappropriate behavior in several settings. Specifically, Ms. Couick noted that STUDENT does not engage in inappropriate conduct at school. As a result, any behavior problems that STUDENT has are not pervasive and are not affecting his education.

With regards to depression or unhappiness, Ms. Couick testified that STUDENT is not unhappy or depressed at school. Ms. Couick testified that he participates in classroom activities and appears to be happy at school. Other than being unhappy about being teased, STUDENT does not exhibit any significant signs of general unhappiness.

Ms. Couick testified that the depression scale administered by Dr. Pojman is not a valid measure for students with cognitive or language delays and that the measure is also not normed for children with developmental delays. Ms. Couick testified that the scale is not a reliable measure of STUDENT's depression. Ms. Couick also noted that STUDENT's own responses on the scale were contradictory and raised questions about the validity of the results.

James Long

James Long is the vice principal at Concord High School. During the 1995-96 school year, Mr. Long had responsibility for discipline for STUDENT. Mr. Long also observed STUDENT occasionally on the campus.

Mr. Long testified that STUDENT interacted with different students during lunch and breaks and was engaged in typical behavior. Mr. Long testified that STUDENT did not seem isolated from other kids. Mr. Long also testified that during class STUDENT participated and interacted with other kids.

With regard to STUDENT's relationships with adults, Mr. Long testified that he always had a good relationship with STUDENT and that STUDENT would acknowledge him when they saw each other. Mr. Long also testified that STUDENT had positive relationships with his teachers.

Anneliese Makely

Anneliese Makely is a school psychologist for the District who began providing counseling to STUDENT at the beginning of July 1996. Ms. Makely has seen STUDENT once per week since the counseling began. Ms. Makely testified that she is working with STUDENT on increasing his self-esteem and friendship building. Ms. Makely testified that she has a good rapport with STUDENT and that he is very friendly and involved in conversations during the counseling sessions.

Ms. Makely testified that she does not believe STUDENT is an SED student. Ms. Makely testified that he is doing well in his summer school classes, that his affect is good, and that she has not observed any bizarre behaviors. Ms. Makely also pointed to the positive relationship she has developed with STUDENT and the fact that he has told her he would be comfortable with her serving as a "support person" to talk to when problems arise during the school year.

Helen Borgan

Helen Borgan is a supervisor at the George Miller Center. Ms. Borgan described the George Miller Center as a social-recreational program for 11- to 22-year-olds with developmental delays. The emphasis of the program is to teach the students how to interact with each other and how to interact within the community. The program includes on-site activities, such as computers, board games, and art, and off-site activities, such as bowling, roller skating, and going to the movies.

Ms. Borgan testified that STUDENT's involvement at the George Miller Center has been very positive. STUDENT interacts well with all the children and helps those children who are functioning at a lower level then he is. Ms. Borgan testified that STUDENT acts sometimes as a mentor for other students who are having behavior problems. Ms. Borgan testified that STUDENT has not engaged in any disruptive behavior at the George Miller Center and that he participates willingly in all activities.

DISCUSSION

California Code of Regulations, Title 5, § 3030(i) provides that a student qualifies for special education services if

[b]ecause of a serious emotional disturbance, a pupil exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance:

(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

The Hearing Officer notes that § 3030(i) requires that only one of the five characteristics be evident in order to qualify a student for special education. In addition, any such characteristic must be present for "a long period of time and to a marked degree" and also must adversely affect educational performance. Each of the five criteria is analyzed below.

(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors.

The only evidence submitted that STUDENT has an inability to learn was the testimony of Dr. Pojman, who testified that STUDENT's level of learning may not be consistent with his ability to learn. Dr. Pojman also testified that he assumed that STUDENT's sexual thoughts and obsessions interfere with his ability to learn. On the other hand, the District submitted documentary evidence which establishes that STUDENT has done well in his courses over the past year and has made progress on his goals and objectives. In addition, several of STUDENT's teachers testified that he does well in his classes and enjoys school and learning, and, ultimately, does have the ability to learn.

Dr. Stambaugh expressed in his report of September 19, 1994, that STUDENT was making the "best use of his intellectual resources in the academic curriculum." Dr. Stambaugh's statement was based on a comparison of STUDENT's ability test scores with his achievement test scores. In the two years since Dr. Stambaugh assessed Student, STUDENT's achievement test scores have continued to rise, demonstrating that he is continuing to learn.

The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT has multiple disabilities. Even assuming that STUDENT has an inability to learn, there was no evidence presented that such an inability to learn is significantly the result of a serious emotional disturbance rather than his cognitive, speech and language, and other impairments. The Hearing Officer also notes that Dr. Pojman has not observed STUDENT in his classroom or spoken with any of STUDENT's teachers.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not have an inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors.

(2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.

Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT has difficulty developing satisfactory relationships with his peers and teachers. Dr. Pojman's opinion was based on a review of STUDENT's records and his own observations of STUDENT in the therapeutic setting. MOTHER testified that STUDENT does not have any friends. MOTHER also pointed to STUDENT's unsatisfactory experience in going to a dance with a fellow student as an example of his inability to develop friendships with his peers.(Footnote 2)

On the other hand, the District presented testimony from STUDENT's teachers that he has developed satisfactory relationships with his teachers and peers. STUDENT's Foods teacher, Joan MacKellar, provided credible testimony that STUDENT has worked well within a class structure that required him to work with the same group of students for the entire school year. According to Ms. MacKellar, STUDENT not only worked well within his group but was actually the group leader and was accepted as the leader by the other students. Ms. MacKellar also stated that she had a positive relationship with STUDENT and that he would oftentimes come early to class to assist her in setting up the materials for the upcoming class session. The District provided testimony from other District personnel and staff from George Miller that was consistent with Ms. MacKellar's.

The Hearing Officer notes that §3030(i) requires that a student have an inability to build or maintain satisfactory relationships, not a difficulty, as described by Dr. Pojman. While it may be difficult for STUDENT to build or maintain satisfactory relationships due to his cognitive impairments and speech and language difficulties, the evidence does not support a finding that he has an inability to build or maintain satisfactory relationships as a result of a serious emotional disturbance. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not have an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.

(3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations.

Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT's lawbreaking, wearing of women's clothing, stealing from other students, and his tendency to "go too far" were examples of inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. While many of the incidents Dr. Pojman referred to are inappropriate, there is no evidence that any of these incidents adversely affected STUDENT's educational performance. There was no evidence that any of STUDENT's inappropriate behavior has occurred at school in any significant amount.

While there was evidence presented that STUDENT may have left the school site during school hours several times during fall 1995, there was no evidence presented that he has continued to leave during school hours. Furthermore, even assuming that STUDENT left the school site several times during fall 1995, there is no evidence that supports a finding that this behavior adversely affected his educational performance. Instead, the evidence presented by the District, in the form of the testimony of STUDENT's teachers and his grades for the 1995-96 school year, demonstrate that STUDENT continued to benefit from his education throughout the school year and by the end of the year was receiving B's in five of his classes and a C in one class.

The Hearing Officer also notes that there was no evidence that STUDENT engages in any acting out or sexually inappropriate behavior at school. Instead, District personnel testified that STUDENT was not a behavior problem at school or in his classes. Finally, STUDENT has not had any discipline or behavior referrals since October 1995.

Dr. Pojman also testified that STUDENT's hearing voices was an example of inappropriate behavior. Dr. Pojman stated that he "suspected" that the episodes of hearing voices interfered with his educational performance. However, there is no evidence that STUDENT has heard voices since fall 1995 and there also is no evidence, beyond Dr. Pojman's suspicion, that these incidents had any impact on STUDENT's educational performance.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances that are exhibited in several situations to a marked degree or which have an adverse effect on his educational performance.

(4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT is depressed and unhappy and that his unhappiness exists in all environments. Dr. Pojman also administered the Reynolds Adaptive Depressive Scale, which produced results showing that STUDENT is depressed. Dr. Pojman also pointed to STUDENT's isolation, sleep problems, unhappiness, irritability, and difficulty concentrating as factors to support a conclusion that STUDENT is depressed.

On the other hand, District personnel testified that STUDENT enjoys school and only exhibited unhappiness when he discussed the possibility that he would not be returning to Concord High School for the 1996-97 school year.(Footnote 3) There was, ultimately, little, if any, evidence presented demonstrating that STUDENT exhibits any symptoms of unhappiness or depression at school.

The Hearing Officer also gives little weight to Dr. Pojman's testimony on this factor for two reasons. First, Dr. Pojman testified that STUDENT is not a good source of information about himself. Yet, much of Dr. Pojman's testimony relies on information he obtained from STUDENT during counseling sessions. Second, the depression scale administered by Dr. Pojman does not provide credible evidence of depression in STUDENT. Not only is it not normed for disabled children but STUDENT's own answers provide reason to believe that the results are not accurate. For example, while STUDENT said that he feels happy most of the time, he also said that he feels sad most of the time.

Finally, it is necessary again to look at STUDENT's school performance. Even assuming that STUDENT is unhappy or depressed, there is no evidence that such unhappiness or depression is adversely affecting his school performance. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression which adversely affects his educational performance.

(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

Petitioner does not contend and no evidence was submitted that STUDENThas a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not meet this criterion.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not qualify for special education as a result of a serious emotional disturbance as defined by California Code of Regulations, Title 5, § 3030(i).

ORDER

Petitioner's claim that he is eligible for special education as a result of a serious emotional disturbance is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 565057(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: August 26, 1996 _____________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES:

1. The same test administered on February 22, 1995, produced the following results: Broad Reading, Standard Score 84; Broad Math, Standard Score 84; Broad Written Language, Standard Score 78; Broad Knowledge, Standard Score 70; Skills, Standard Score 76.

2. Petitioner also submitted a document from Dr. Butler in which Dr. Butler states her opinion that STUDENT has an inability to maintain satisfactory relationships and exhibits inappropriate behavior. However, Dr. Butler did not testify and her letter does not explain the basis for her opinion.

3. STUDENT has been accepted by Devereux, a residential treatment facility.