California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 23, 2004

Student v. Murrieta Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 296-04 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski

Murrieta Valley Unified must reimburse parents for in-home CARD program after denying a preschooler a FAPE; autism eligibility claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 12 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Parents of a preschooler filed against Murrieta Valley Unified School District. Their son entered the district at age three from Regional Center Early Start services, with significant speech and language delays. The district labeled him "developmentally delayed," a category the Hearing Officer said California had not adopted. The parents argued he should have been found eligible under "autistic-like behaviors" in both 2002 and 2003. The Hearing Officer rejected that claim both times. He gave more weight to staff who saw the child at preschool than to home reports and a clinical diagnosis.

The district did deny a FAPE. The parents' conditions on consent delayed the initial assessment, but the district still owed an interim placement from August 14, 2002. It provided nothing for six weeks and later missed occupational therapy (OT) sessions and instruction hours. The December 2002 IEP lacked clear baselines and measurable goals for receptive and expressive language, visual motor skills, and oral-motor feeding. The district also failed to prove its 2003 ESY program was appropriate. The October 2003 offer repeated the language and visual motor problems and cut speech and OT time. The Hearing Officer ordered full reimbursement for the in-home Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) program from November 10, 2003, through the end of the school year, less five days because the parents' notice was late. Claims about 2004 ESY and future CARD placement were not ripe, and additional compensatory education was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

Shows how SEHO handled a three-year-old's move from Regional Center services. Parents' conditions on assessment consent excused a late IEP but not the district's duty to provide an interim placement. The decision also shows reimbursement for an in-home ABA program based on vague language goals, even though autism eligibility was rejected.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Should the District have identified STUDENT as a child with autistic-like behaviors in October 2002?

    Student met only the oral-language criterion, not a combination of autistic-like criteria; the district's 'developmental delay' label was improper under California law, but the district still had to meet all his needs.

  2. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 2A. Did the District offer or provide a FAPE from August 14, 2002 to December 10, 2002 (interim placement period)?

    Parents' conditions on consent excused the late IEP, but the district still owed an interim placement from August 14, 2002; it gave no services for six weeks and later missed OT and in-home instruction under the interim plan.

  3. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue 2B. Was the December 10, 2002 IEP designed to meet unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide benefit, and implemented through the end of the 2002-2003 school year?

    SDC placement, peer interaction, attention, toileting and sensory supports were appropriate and no BIP was needed, but present levels and goals for receptive/expressive language, visual motor and oral-motor feeding were deficient, and 450 minutes of OT were not provided.

  4. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2C. Did the District offer or provide a FAPE for 2003 ESY?

    The district did not prove its 2003 ESY program was a FAPE or that it provided speech-language services during ESY.

  5. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 3. Should the District have identified STUDENT as a child with autistic-like behaviors during the period October 2003 through January 2004?

    Giving more weight to school staff who saw him over time than to home reports, a clinical autism diagnosis, and the CARD assessment, the Hearing Officer found Student did not meet the criteria beyond the oral-language criterion.

  6. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 4A. Procedural appropriateness of the October 10 and November 14, 2003 IEP meetings (absence of a regular education teacher, an OT, and a CARD representative)

    The missing team members did not cause a loss of educational opportunity or seriously limit parent participation; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley was distinguished.

  7. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4B. Did the District offer or provide a FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year, including the October 10, 2003 IEP offer?

    District failed to provide 360 minutes of OT and 2 hours of speech in fall 2003; the October offer lacked baselines for language goals, gave vague and reduced speech and OT time, and did not address visual motor needs. No BIP was needed.

  8. Not reachedIEP content

    Issue 4C. Did the District fail to offer a FAPE for the 2004 ESY?

    Not ripe, because the district must reassess Student before his transition to kindergarten and decide his ESY placement.

  9. Issue 5. If the District failed to offer or provide a FAPE, are the parents entitled to full reimbursement for the costs related to the CARD program?

    CARD met Student's language and fine motor needs and provided benefit; full reimbursement from November 10, 2003 through end of the regular school year, reduced by five days because notice was less than 10 business days.

  10. Issue 6. If the District failed to offer a FAPE, is Student entitled to prospective placement with the CARD program for the 2004-2005 school year?

    Not ripe; the IEP team must first reassess Student and consider his transition to kindergarten.

  11. Issue 7. If the District failed to offer or provide a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of CARD hours during 2004 ESY?

    Denied as inappropriate because the 2004 ESY placement was not ripe and needed assessment and IEP team review; neither party prevailed.

  12. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 8. If the District failed to offer or provide a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education for the loss of educational services?

    CARD reimbursement was an adequate remedy; the Hearing Officer denied additional compensatory education, noting that the parents had delayed the initial assessment.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving written receipts, district shall fully reimburse parents for CARD services provided from November 10, 2003 through the end of the regular school year, less five days.
  • All other requests for relief denied, including prospective CARD placement, CARD hours for 2004 ESY, and additional compensatory education.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup; Johnson v. Special Education Hearing Office; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley; Gregory K. v. Longview; Andress v. Cleveland ISD; Adams v. Oregon; Alamo Heights v. State Board of Education; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Polk v. Central Susquehanna

People named in the decision

  • Zhanna Preston, director of special education, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Moussa Sabbara, program specialist, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Linda Lucas, school psychologist, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Amy Brennan, occupational therapist (assessor), Murrieta Valley USD
  • Audrey Lindemulder, occupational therapist, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Tiffany Knudsen, occupational therapist, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Michelle Pullman, occupational therapist, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Betsy Baird, inclusion support teacher, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Melissa Lamothe, SDC preschool teacher, Murrieta Valley USD, Buchanan Elementary
  • Estela Dominguez, SDC teacher, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Karen McGinn, State preschool inclusion teacher, Buchanan Elementary
  • Melissa Gidley, speech-language pathologist; PIP program, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Lisa Piper, speech-language pathologist, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Joanne Abrassart, speech-language pathologist, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Gabriela DiGiovanni, school psychologist, Murrieta Valley USD
  • Kathleen Kitlowski, Ph.D., psychologist and autism consultant (district witness), A.C.C.E.S.S. (nonpublic agency)
  • Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., director of CARD; expert witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Betty Bostani, Psy.D., CARD assessor, CARD
  • Theresa Contreras, CARD clinical supervisor, CARD
  • Samantha Mouser, CARD therapist, CARD
  • Andrea Zarsadias, CARD intake assessor, CARD
  • Margaret Ticich, speech-language pathologist (Early Start assessor), VIP Tots
  • Barbara Lopez, early intervention teacher, VIP Tots (nonpublic agency)
  • Thomas F. Gross, Ph.D., licensed clinical psychologist (Regional Center assessor), Inland Regional Center
  • Julie Reeker, Ph.D., private psychologist (clinical autism diagnosis), Children's Hospital of Orange County (CHOC)
  • Dr. Maninder, private pediatric neurologist
  • Dr. Jeffrey Owen, proposed neuropsychological assessor (rejected by parent)
  • Rasco & Associates, private occupational therapy assessor
  • Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), private in-home ABA provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Murrieta, California, on March 11, 12, 16-19, 23, 24, and 26, 2004. (Footnote 1)

Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Shelli Lewis. Assisting Ms. Lewis at hearing was attorney Donald Gonzales. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf was his mother, PARENT. Respondent Murrieta Valley Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Maria Gless of Best, Best, & Krieger. Also present on some hearing days was attorney Jack Clarke. Appearing on the District’s behalf at most hearing days was the District’s director of special education, Zhanna Preston. Also present on some hearing days was program specialist Moussa Sabbara.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Linda Lucas, school psychologist; Amy Brennan, occupational therapist (OT); Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., director of the Center for Autism and Related Disorders, Inc. (CARD); PARENT, STUDENT’s mother; Betty Bostani, Psy.D. a CARD assessor; Theresa Contreras, clinical supervisor with CARD; Zhanna Preston, director of special education; and Samantha Mouser, CARD therapist.

The District called the following witnesses: Betsy Baird, inclusion support teacher; Melissa Lamothe, special day class teacher; Tiffany Knudsen, OT; Kathleen Kitlowski, Ph.D., psychologist and autism consultant; Melissa Gidley, speech-language pathologist; Lisa Piper, speech-language pathologist; Audrey Lindemulder, OT; Gabriela DiGiovanni, school psychologist; and Joanne Abrassart, speech-language pathologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of written closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 2)

1. Should the District have identified STUDENT as a child with autistic-like behaviors in October 2002?

2. Did the District offer or provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year (ESY)?

3. Should the District have identified STUDENT as a child with autistic-like behaviors during the period October 2003 through January 2004?

4. Did the District offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 ESY?

5. If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any periods at issue, are his parents entitled to full reimbursement for the costs related to the CARD program?

6. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement with the CARD program for the 2004-2005 school year?

7. If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any periods at issue, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of CARD hours during 2004 ESY?

8. If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any periods at issue, is he entitled to compensatory education for the loss of educational services?

CONTENTIONS

Petitioner contends that the District failed to identify him as a student who exhibits autistic-like behaviors, failed to identify all present levels of performance, failed to identify his unique needs -- particularly in the areas of communication and visual processing -- and failed to develop appropriate behavior interventions for him. Petitioner further contends that the District failed to draft appropriate goals and objectives that addressed his unique needs and failed to document progress toward his goals and objectives. Petitioner also generally contends that the District procedurally and substantively failed to provide him with a program to meet his special needs. In the discussions within, the Hearing Officer will delineate further Petitioner’s contentions as they relate to particular time periods.

The District contends that STUDENT is not eligible for special education as a student with autistic-like behaviors and that it offered STUDENT a FAPE for both school years. The District further contends that the CARD program is not appropriate for STUDENT and is too restrictive for him. The District asserts that the CARD program does not provide credentialed teachers for STUDENT and does not provide STUDENT with needed occupational therapy and speech-language therapy services by a qualified OT and by a credentialed and licensed speech-language therapist.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, at age four years and ten months, is a preschooler who resides with his parents and four siblings within the boundaries of the District. STUDENT has attended an in-home, forty-hour-per-week CARD program since November 10, 2003, after his parents removed him from a District preschool SDC class program at the end of October 2003. In October 2002, STUDENT, at age three years and two months, was initially found by the District to meet special education eligibility criteria as “developmentally delayed” and to require speech-language and occupational therapy.

STUDENT was initially referred to the Inland Regional Center (IRC) at age two years and seven months for speech and language delays. STUDENT was evaluated on February 11, 2002, at his home by the IRC and by VIP Tots, a nonpublic agency (NPA) that provides infant and toddler programming. On that date, STUDENT was qualified for early intervention services under the Early Start program, and his Individual Family Service Plan (IFSP) provided that he receive in-home preschool services twice a week for one hour taught by a VIP Tots preschool teacher to address speech and language delays. (Exh. 63 and Test. of PARENT.)

On March 5, 2002, speech-language pathologist Margaret Ticich assessed STUDENT for VIP Tots. Ms. Ticich found that STUDENT communicated with facial expressions, gestures, jargon, and a few rote phrases. STUDENT did not have basic sentence structure and had a limited vocabulary, although he had good imitation skills and imitated single words and phrases on request. STUDENT had significant difficulty following simple commands and attending to task. He often omitted consonant sounds in multisyllabic words, and when he attempted to combine words and the context was unknown, his intelligibility was significantly reduced. STUDENT demonstrated functional play skills and initiated interactions. Ms. Ticich did not recommend speech therapy but made recommendations for increasing STUDENT’s communication skills. (Exh.1.)

On April 11, 2002, a transition meeting was held because STUDENT was to turn three in July. Ms. Joanne Abrassart, a District speech-language pathologist, attended the meeting. The transition team agreed to increase STUDENT’s IFSP in-home preschool services to three times per week for one hour, scheduled an IEP meeting for August 12, 2002, and decided STUDENT was to receive home services from IRC until August 14 (the start of the District’s regular school year) (Exh. 62.) The IFSP was revised later in the spring so that STUDENT could receive in-home OT services for two hours per week and in-home preschool services four hours per week. (Test. of Ms. Preston and PARENT.)

By E-mail dated June 12, 2002, PARENT requested a neuropsychological assessment. Also on June 12, members of the District’s preschool assessment team (Melissa Lamothe, Linda Lucas and Joanne Abrassart) exchanged E-mails about assessing STUDENT on June 14. By E-mail dated June 13, Ms. Preston informed PARENT that the District would respond to her assessment request by letter or by assessment plan within fifteen days and that an assessment plan meeting would occur on June 14. (Exh. 4 and Test. of PARENT and Ms. Preston.)

The meeting was held on June 14 at the Buchanan Elementary School (Buchanan), but Ms. Abrassart did not attend because the meeting ended before she arrived. Ms. Abrassart did not recall a communication that it was an assessment planning meeting, and she went “with tests in hand”as she had done for “thirteen years” with the preschool team. Ms. Abrassart noted that assessment “usually began immediately,” and that she was surprised to learn that PARENT had not signed the plan. PARENT did not bring STUDENT to the meeting because her mother (a resource specialist in Vista) had told her that an assessment plan meeting was required prior to the assessment, and Ms. Preston’s June 13 E-mail referred to a meeting, not an assessment. (Test. of PARENT.)

At the meeting, PARENT requested that the District pay for a neuropsychological assessment because she wanted to know if STUDENT had autism. PARENT stated that she wanted the neuropsychological evaluations held before the District’s assessments, and that she would not sign the assessment plan unless the District agreed to conduct one. (Test. of PARENT and Exh. 6.) The District assured PARENT that it was capable of assessing STUDENT for placement and for eligibility under autism, but PARENT took the assessment plan home with her and would not sign it until she heard from Ms. Preston. (Footnote 3) (Test. of Ms. Gidley and Exh. 7.)

PARENT said that after the meeting she E-mailed Ms. Preston on July 2 regarding the assessment status but did not receive a reply. (Footnote 4) (Test. of PARENT and Exh. 4.) Meanwhile, PARENT took STUDENT to an audiologist to rule out hearing problems and to find out why he was having delays in speech and language. The audiologist found no hearing problems but gave PARENT a referral to a pediatric neurologist. The neurologist, Dr. Maninder, saw STUDENT and told PARENT “just to go with the school district and continue [with the] assessments.” Dr. Maninder did not make a diagnosis because he felt that STUDENT was too young and wanted to see him within a school setting before he could form a diagnosis. (Test. of PARENT.)

On June 14, the District notified Petitioner’s parents in writing of the August 12, 2002 IEP meeting “to initiate IEP” and to consider the various program alternatives. (Exh. 5.) (Footnote 5) On June 20, 2002, Barbara Lopez, a VIP Tots early intervention teacher, conducted an “early development exit profile assessment” and concluded that STUDENT, at 35 months, was functioning at the following age levels: cognitive/readiness skills - scattered, 24 to 30 months; receptive language skills - scattered, 21 to 27 months; expressive language skills - scattered, 21 to 33 months; gross motor skills at 30 months; fine motor skills at 24 to 27 months; social-emotional skills at 28 months; self-help feeding skills at 30 months; self-help dressing skills at 22 months; and self-help toileting skills at 15 months. (Exh. 66.) On June 26, STUDENT was assessed by an occupational therapist with Rasco & Associates. Finding fine motor delays and difficulties eating a variety of foods, the assessor recommended OT services for three months to develop fine motor skills and to increase STUDENT’s self-feeding skills. (Exh. 9.)

Meanwhile, Ms. Preston, and PARENT exchanged E-mails concerning the District’s pending assessment. The parties did not agree on who would conduct a neuropsychological assessment. The District was now on summer break and the parties had not reached agreement on who would conduct the neuropsychological assessment. The District had not begun its assessment of STUDENT. (Exh. 4. and Test. of PARENT and Ms. Preston.) On July 10, PARENT signed the June 14 assessment plan but at the time did not check the consent box to give her approval to the proposed assessments. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Preston, and Exh. 7.)

On July 25, 2002, Thomas F. Gross, Ph.D., a licensed clinical psychologist, conducted an assessment for the IRC to determine STUDENT’s continued eligibility for services after age three. (Test. of PARENT.) Dr. Gross concluded that on the Stanford Binet Intelligence Scale, STUDENT’s performance indicated average intellectual ability. On the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS), STUDENT obtained a score of 20.5 (scores above 29.5 indicate autism). Dr. Gross noted that during the evaluation, STUDENT was cooperative, tended to be a bit distractible and lost focus and attention easily, made and sustained good eye contact, initiated interactions and sought the attention of others, observed social courtesy and asked “are you okay?” when Dr. Gross dropped an object. Dr. Gross also noted that STUDENT did not engage in “odd, repetitive, or stereotyped behavior.” Dr. Gross noted that STUDENT’s speech was somewhat mis-articulated and, at times, difficult to understand, and that STUDENT had difficulty grasping novel questions asked of him. Under “impressions and recommendations,” in Dr. Gross’s opinion, STUDENT “does not experience autism or mental retardation.” However, Dr. Gross expressed concerns about STUDENT’s speech and language and noted that STUDENT exhibited some “mild sensory integration problems” (eg., hypersensitivity to some textures). Dr. Gross recommended that a district consider administering a speech-language assessment and an OT assessment relating to sensory integration. (Exh. 11.)

On August 12, 2002, PARENT attended the scheduled IEP meeting, but no one showed up, and she was told that staff members were attending an in-service training. By E-mail dated August 14 to Ms. Preston, PARENT noted the missed IEP meeting and stated that she had yet to receive confirmation of the neuropsychological evaluation. For the first time, PARENT requested an interim placement “until the IEP and assessments...take place.” (Footnote 6)By reply E-mail dated August 19, Ms. Preston informed PARENT that she would be receiving a plan for a neuropsychological assessment and an authorization for release of information and that she would inform her of assessment details “after...both forms are signed.” The assessments and observations were to occur in late August in the home and on September 6 at Buchanan and PARENT was to confirm the dates with the assessors. The E-mail also noted that the IEP “should not take place later than 50 days from August 14.” (Test. of PARENT and Exh. 4.)

By E-mail dated August 21 to PARENT, Ms. Gidley requested that she and SDC teacher Estela Dominguez observe STUDENT on August 27. By E-mail dated August 22 to PARENT, Linda Lucas requested that she and SDC preschool teacher Melissa Lamothe observe STUDENT at home on August 28 “when the home teachers are there working with...STUDENT.” By E-mail dated August 22, PARENT informed Ms. Abrassart that “any time after the 16th [of September] will work well for me.” Ms. Abrassart then E-mailed Ms. Preston indicating that PARENT wanted the September 6 assessment changed to the end of September. (Exh. 4.)

By E-mail dated August 26 to PARENT, the District offered the following interim placement for STUDENT: four hours per week of in-home preschool services by a District teacher and two hours of in-home OT services. The offer replicated the revised IFSP. An interim placement form dated August 27, 2002, was signed by Ms. Preston on August 29, and by PARENT on September 4, but the placement was not described on the form. (Exhs. 4 and 15 and Test. of Ms. Preston and PARENT.)

Also on September 4, PARENT signed an assessment plan dated August 27, 2002. The plan proposed assessing STUDENT using various test instruments. At the bottom of the page and under the “other” section, PARENT, or someone acting for her, added “see additional assessments recommended by parent.” PARENT’s initials appear next to assessment instruments apparently added by her. At the top of the page next to a checked box, PARENT initialed the following question to be answered by the assessment: Does my child have a communication disorder? (Exh. 13.) On September 5, 2002, PARENT signed a second assessment plan dated August 20, 2002, for a neuropsychological assessment. (Footnote 7) PARENT initialed, and apparently checked a box “to develop a Behavior Plan.” (Exh. 12) However, the parties did not reach agreement on who would conduct the neuropsychological assessment, and the District never did complete one. (Footnote 8) The District began its initial assessment of STUDENT in the fall of 2002, probably during the first week of October. PARENT recalled that the assessments began “at the end of September or the beginning of October.” Ms. Gidley could not recall when she assessed STUDENT for speech and language, but did recall that she went to STUDENT’s home with SDC teacher Estela Dominguez and also assessed him with Ms. Abrassart at Buchanan.

School psychologist Linda Lucas and SDC preschool teacher Melissa Lamothe assessed STUDENT in his home on October 2, 2002. Ms. Lucas had not seen the earlier assessment plans referred to above, but Ms. Lucas brought with her an assessment plan that she had prepared, and had PARENT sign it at her home on October 2. Ms. Lucas administered the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale (GARS) and the Battelle Developmental Inventory (Battelle). Ms. Lamothe administered the General Knowledge and Basic Math sections of the Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Early Development (Brigance). The assessors also interviewed PARENT and made observations of STUDENT. An October 3, 2002 psychological assessment report also relied on a health and developmental history completed by PARENT. (Test. of Ms. Lucas, Ms. Lamothe, PARENT and Exhs. 69, 70, 71, 73, and 16.) (Footnote 9)

At 38 months, STUDENT’s social and adaptive living skills on the Battelle were at the 20- and 23-month levels, respectively, both significantly below the expected level for his age; his general knowledge and comprehension skills on the Brigance were between the 12 and 63 month levels, with overall skills at the 33-month level and significant discrepancies between splintered skills; on the GARS, STUDENT’s communication and developmental subtest scores were within the above average and average range, respectively. STUDENT’s overall Autism Quotient was within the below average range, indicating a “borderline” probability of autism that did not qualify him for an educational eligibility of autism. Instead, STUDENT was found to qualify under the preschool educational eligibility of Developmental Delay because his developmental levels on the Battelle in social and adaptive living skills were both within the 51st to 75th percentiles.

In an October 7, 2002 speech-language assessment report signed by Ms. Abrassart (both Ms. Abrassart and Ms. Gidley contributed to the report), STUDENT was found to meet eligibility criteria in receptive and expressive language. The assessors recommended oral-motor stimulation and a language-based program that emphasized processing simple directions, understanding, using basic concepts, and expanding basic sentence use. (Exh. 17.)

Meanwhile, Audrey Lindemulder, OTR, had begun to provide STUDENT with OT services during the first week of October at Buchanan. Her records indicate that during the fall of 2002, some services were provided at Buchanan, some at home and some at “Avaxat,” STUDENT’s home school. (Exh. 83 and Test. of Ms. Lindemulder.) According to PARENT, STUDENT was provided with some sensory OT services at the elementary school behind his home (Avaxat), but STUDENT would “get upset and cry,” and so most of the OT services were provided to him in his room at home. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Lindemulder.)

Also in early October, District inclusion support teacher Betsy Baird was asked by Ms. Preston to extend STUDENT’s early intervention program (interim placement) “until the IEP could be held.” Ms. Baird testified that during October, she and Estela Dominguez worked together with STUDENT at Buchanan, but after October, Ms. Dominguez, and the classroom, were no longer available, so Ms. Baird worked with STUDENT at the FAMILY home during November. Ms. Baird implemented STUDENT’s three IFSP goals from the February IFSP – goals that were not updated -- and described the program as an “informal kind of play” directed by IFSP goals.

On October 14, 2002, District OTR Amy Brennan, assessed STUDENT for OT at Buchanan. Ms. Brennan administered the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales, fine motor. At 39 months, STUDENT had an age equivalent of 20 months for grasping and 31 months for visual motor. In sensory processing, STUDENT showed “several indicators” of poor registration and modulation of vestibular (sense of movement) and tactile (sense of touch) input. Additionally, STUDENT was resistant to handling different textured objects and movement “through space.” Ms. Brennan recommended OT services for fine motor and visual motor difficulties and to address “poor registration” on sensory input and poor organizational skills. (Exh. 18 and Test.of Ms. Brennan.)

STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting was held on October 16, 2002. Ms. Brennan participated by phone and reviewed her OT assessment. Ms. Lucas and Ms. Lamothe reviewed the psychological assessment, and Ms. Abrassart and Ms. Gidley reviewed the speech-language assessment. Ms. Lopez reviewed the VIP Tots exit report. Present levels of performance were discussed and drafted. The team also discussed eligibility and agreed “unanimously” that STUDENT qualified for special education and related services as a child with developmental delays. The team agreed to address delays in speech and language and fine motor with direct services. The IEP team also agreed that District autism consultant, Dr. Kathleen Kitlowski, would conduct a behavior assessment of home observations because PARENT had reported tantrumming in the home. (Test. of Ms. Brennan, Lucas, Lamothe, Abrassart, Gidley, and Baird and Exh. 25.)

The IEP team meeting reconvened on October 28 and the team reviewed and discussed present levels of performance. STUDENT’s parents and the VIP Tots teacher provided additional information for present levels. The team drafted several goals and objectives in the following areas: self-help, academic, fine motor, visual motor, pre-writing, receptive and expressive language, and behavior. PARENT signed an assessment plan that authorized Dr. Kitlowski’s behavior assessment, and Dr. Kitlowski subsequently observed STUDENT at his home on two occasions and prepared an assessment report dated December 9, 2002. (Exhs. 21 and 23.)

The IEP team meeting reconvened on December 10, 2002. Dr. Kitlowski presented her findings and behavior observation results and recommended that STUDENT participate in a preschool program that focused on improving attention and language because those were his greatest needs. Dr. Kitlowski also recommended that STUDENT participate in a structured preschool SDC program that was appropriate developmentally and provided a strong focus on communication and social skills, with independence of skills “across all domains.” The IEP team also reviewed STUDENT’s present levels and goals and discussed placement options. The District IEP team members recommended the following program: OT services two times per week in thirty-minute sessions outside the classroom; speech and language services two times per week in thirty-minute sessions (one individual and one small group); and placement in an SDC preschool classroom, four times per week, two hours and forty-five minutes each day. The team agreed to reconvene in April to determine progress and to reevaluate STUDENT’s placement. (Exh. 25.) STUDENT’s parents did not sign the IEP, but took it home for consideration.

On January 9, 2003, STUDENT’s mother signed the IEP, and on January 14 STUDENT started attending the Buchanan SDC preschool morning class taught by Ms. Lamothe. The IEP team did not meet in April 2003. However, in May or June 2003, PARENT, Ms. Abrassart and Ms. Lamothe met informally to discuss STUDENT’s program for the fall 2003. An IEP meeting was not held because STUDENT’s annual review of goals and objectives was not due until October, and the District was still working on his annual goals and objectives. The participants discussed STUDENT’s classroom performance, and PARENT testified that her biggest concern was that Ms. Lamothe was constantly comparing STUDENT with children in his SDC classroom instead of with typical children. PARENT stated that she also expressed concerns about STUDENT’s obsessive-compulsive behaviors and his preoccupation with flashlights but was told that there were no flashlights in the classroom and that STUDENT had not shown a preoccupation with flashlights at school. The parties agreed nonetheless that STUDENT was ready to enter Ms. Lamothe’s afternoon program (for older children) in the fall because of his overall progress and that the class would also enable STUDENT to attend the State preschool inclusion program. The combined program meant that STUDENT would attend the afternoon State inclusion preschool class twice a week and Ms. Lamothe’s afternoon class twice a week.

Meanwhile, STUDENT’s parents had STUDENT assessed at the Children’s Hospital of Orange County (CHOC) for autism by a licensed psychologist. In a June 9 assessment report, Julie Reeker, Ph.D., gave STUDENT, at age three years and ten months, a clinical diagnosis of autism. (Exh. 28.) STUDENT apparently attended Rail Ranch Elementary school (ESY 2003) in July for four weeks. The class was held in the mornings for two hours and forty-five minutes, five days per week. STUDENT received OT services two times per week. (Test. of Ms. Brennan and PARENT.) In the fall of 2003, PARENT informed District program specialist Moussa Sabbara of Dr. Reeker’s clinical diagnosis of autism and provided him with a copy of the CHOC report. The District agreed to assess STUDENT and to revisit eligibility under autism. On August 12, 2003, PARENT signed an assessment plan drafted by school psychologist Gabriela DiGiovanni. (Exh. 29) STUDENT attended Ms. Lamothe’s afternoon SDC preschool class, and he started attending the State preschool inclusion class. STUDENT also received speech-language therapy services and OT services twice a week in one-half hour sessions. (Test. of Ms. Piper and Ms. Knudsen.) Meanwhile, District school psychologist Gabriela DiGiovanni had begun to assess STUDENT in September and Ms. Lamothe completed the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (classroom edition) in preparation for STUDENT’s annual review. (Test. of Ms. Lamothe, Exh. 33.)

On October 1, STUDENT was given an evaluation and “intake assessment” by Theresa Contreras and Andrea Zarsadias at the San Diego office of CARD. CARD recommended that STUDENT receive 40 hours of DTT per week with “1:1 behavioral intervention” by therapists trained in Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) (Exh. 37 and Test. of Ms. Contreras.)

On October 10, 2003, the IEP team met for STUDENT’s annual review and “to share preliminary results of assessments conducted.” The team discussed the CHOC evaluation, STUDENT’s present levels of performance, and his progress on his initial goals and objectives. Gabriela DiGiovanni reviewed her preliminary observations from a partial report dated October 8, 2003. Her report was not yet completed because PARENT had not yet turned in all of her parent forms. (Exh. 41 and Test. of PARENT.) The team discussed and formulated goals and objectives, and PARENT participated in the discussions. The IEP team discussed significant differences between STUDENT’s behavior as seen by District staff members, and his behaviors as seen by his mother at home. The District’s offer of another behavior assessment by an autism consultant was rejected because PARENT stated that STUDENT “already had an autism diagnosis from CHOC.” PARENT would not sign the IEP, and the team agreed to continue STUDENT’s placement in his current program. The team summary notes indicated the District’s current offer: “SDC at Buchanan Elementary school, four times per week for sixty (60) minutes; speech language services two times per week in ‘twenty to thirty minute’ sessions; OT services one time per week in ‘twenty to thirty minute’ sessions; and attendance at an SDC inclusion State preschool class at Buchanan...four times per week for 125 minutes.” (Exh. 42.)

On October 12, 2003, school psychologist Gabriela DiGiovanni issued a final draft psycho-educational assessment report. Ms. DiGiovanni concluded that the IEP team “may consider” STUDENT’s eligibility under the category of speech/language impairment as a primary eligibility category, but not under the category of autism. (Exh. 43.)

By letter dated October 22, 2003, STUDENT’s parents informed the District, in accordance with California Education Code section 56176, that they intended to place STUDENT in a discrete trial program at CARD and to seek reimbursement for the costs related to the CARD program. (Exh. 44.) STUDENT continued to attend Buchanan until he was removed from school by his parents on or about October 29, 2003, and STUDENT has received no District services since then. On November 10, 2003, STUDENT’s initial clinic meeting marked the beginning of his CARD program, which included all one-on-one services in the home, and STUDENT continued to attend the CARD program throughout the hearing. (Footnote 10)

On November 14, 2003, the IEP team met for the last time prior to the due process hearing. The IEP notes indicate the following: “District offer of FAPE remains the IEP of 10/10/03.” The team reviewed Ms. DiGiovanni’s report and eligibility criteria. Ms. DiGiovanni had found a discrepancy between STUDENT’s behaviors at home and at school and concluded that STUDENT had “possible” pervasive development delay (PDD) based on history and parent report. (Exh. 47.) The team also considered the parents’ request for CARD services. The District team members recommended additional speech-language services in the form of a Preschool Intervention Program (PIP), an intensive group therapy program operated by a speech-language pathologist for preschool children with expressive and receptive language delays. PIP was to meet two times per week in 90-minute sessions at Curran Elementary school, a fifteen-minute drive from Buchanan. (Test. of Mrs. Lamothe and Ms. Gidley.) District team members also recommended fourteen hours of behavioral consultation to address parental concerns about STUDENT’s behaviors at home. (Footnote 11) PARENT did not consent to the November 14, 2003 IEP. The Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing on February 10, 2004, and the matter convened for hearing on March 11, 2004.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Should the District have identified STUDENT as a child with autistic-like behaviors in October 2002?

Petitioner asserts that he should have been found eligible for special education and related services as a child with autistic-like behaviors under California law. Petitioner argues that because he was not identified as a student with autism, his unique needs arising from the disability were not addressed. The District contends that Petitioner did not satisfy criteria for autistic-like behaviors, that it properly labeled STUDENT as “developmentally delayed,” and that it properly identified and met STUDENT’s needs. The District further argues that a child’s needs drive the program, not an eligibility label.

Autism is defined under federal regulations as “a developmental disability significantly affecting verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction, generally evident before age three, that adversely affects a child’s educational performance.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c). [emphasis added.] (Footnote 12)

California special education law provides that autistic-like behaviors may qualify a child for special education if the results of an assessment demonstrate that the degree of the child’s impairment requires special education. 5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3030(g) To meet eligibility criteria for “autistic-like behaviors,” California special education regulations provide that a Petitioner must exhibit any combination of the following: [to include but not limited to]:

(1) An inability to use oral language for appropriate communication. (2) A history of extreme withdrawal or relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction from infancy through early childhood. (3) An obsession to maintain sameness.

(4) Extreme preoccupation with objects or inappropriate use of objects or both. (5) Extreme resistance to controls.

(6) Displays peculiar motoric mannerisms and motility patterns. (7) Self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior.

5 C.C.R. § 3030(g)

Linda Lucas, school psychologist, testified that she assessed STUDENT on October 2, 2002, and that STUDENT did not qualify for an educational eligibility of autism. (Footnote 13) Ms. Lucas made her determination based on the GARS score (borderline for autism) and observations of STUDENT at his home. (Test. of Ms. Lucas) Ms. Lucas described the GARS as a questionnaire that assists in determining the likelihood that the behaviors a child exhibits are consistent with the behaviors of an autistic population. Ms. Lucas stated that STUDENT’s scores on the GARS placed him in the above average (borderline range for autism) on the communication subtest, within the average range on the developmental subtest, within the below average range on the social interaction subtest, and within the low average range on the stereotyped behaviors subtest. Ms. Lucas stated that below average and low average range scores were not consistent with those of an autistic population. Ms. Lucas concluded in her report that STUDENT’s autistic-like behaviors should be monitored and readdressed after STUDENT has had the opportunity to function and adjust to a preschool setting for a 6-month period. Ms. Lucas testified that she attended the IEP meetings on October 16, 2002, and October 28, 2002, and that she reviewed her assessment report at the October 16 meeting.

Ms. Lucas testified that at that time of her assessment of STUDENT in October 2002, there was not enough evidence to confirm autism, although there were certainly developmental delays -- areas of developmental concern -- that were “autistic-like” and needed monitoring to determine over a longer period of time “if indeed we did see autism or not.” Ms. Lucas further stated that at the time of her assessment it was unknown to what extent STUDENT could build on skills (eg., social and expressive language skills). Ms. Lucas noted that the most difficult part of determining autism is when language and communication is involved, because it is hard to determine whether a youngchild who has significant speech and language impairments also presents with autism. Ms. Lucas noted that some children very clearly meet the criteria for autism while others may present with some other possible eligibility or diagnosis. (Footnote 14) (Test. of Ms. Lucas.)

Although the parties referred to the federal definition for autism, Petitioner focused on the California eligibility criteria for autistic-like behaviors. Applying just the federal definition for autism, District witnesses uniformly testified that STUDENT primarily and effectively communicated by gesture, although he also used some words and one to two word sentences, in the fall of 2002. (Test. of Ms. Lucas, Ms. Lamothe, Ms. Abrassart, and Ms. Baird, Ms. Gidley, and Ms. Lindemulder.) Ms. Lucas testified that during her assessment, STUDENT was very effective in pointing and that he was very outgoing. The persuasive evidence establishes that STUDENT did not meet the federal criteria for autism in the fall of 2002 because he did not demonstrate a developmental disability that significantly affected verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction -- generally evident before age three -- that adversely affects his educational performance.

Regarding the State definition for autistic-like behaviors, Petitioner alleges, and the District agrees, that STUDENT met the first criterion – an inability to use oral language for appropriate communication. The abundant evidence establishes that STUDENT demonstrated an inability to use oral language for appropriate communication and that STUDENT used gestures and one to two word sentences. (Test. of PARENT.) Ms. Baird testified that although STUDENT was not age appropriate with oral language, he did have some functional language. Ms. Abrassart stated that STUDENT used jargon, which she described as unintelligible words used to fill up spaces and stated that, for her, jargon is an attempt “to fill the spaces that their delayed expressive language can’t come up with.” Ms. Abrassart stated that she tended to look at it from “somewhat of a favorable light,” because a child who uses jargon to fill the spaces is “ahead of [a child] who doesn’t have anything to put out verbally” and that it reflected communicative intent.

Petitioner also contends that he exhibited several other eligibility criteria for autistic-like behaviors: (2) “a history of extreme withdrawal or relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction from infancy through early childhood; (3) an obsession to maintain sameness; (4) extreme preoccupation with objects or inappropriate use of objects or both; (5) extreme resistance to controls; and (7) self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior.” Petitioner does not assert that he exhibited “peculiar motoric mannerisms and motility patterns,” under criterion (6), and therefore the Hearing Officer does not address criterion (6). The District contends that STUDENT did not meet autistic-like behavior criteria other than criterion (1) in October 2002. The District also contends that even if STUDENT met the criteria for autistic-like behaviors, its program offer for STUDENT in the fall of 2002 met all of STUDENT’s unique needs.

As discussed below, the evidence establishes that STUDENT, who was just entering the District for the first time as a three-year-old preschool student in October 2002, exhibited some behaviors that primarily related to his significant delays in receptive and expressive language. However, the evidence did not establish that STUDENT exhibited significant behaviors under autistic-like criteria (2), (3), (4), (5), and (7).

Under criterion (2), the abundant evidence establishes that STUDENT enjoyed interacting with adults and peers and that he related to people appropriately. Ms. Baird, a District inclusion teacher, testified that when she worked with STUDENT at Buchanan in October 2002, STUDENT enjoyed interacting with nondisabled children from the State preschool on the playground at Buchanan. (Footnote 15) Ms. Baird also did not observe delays in social interaction while working with STUDENT at home or at school. Moreover, Ms. Lucas and Ms. Lamothe did not observe impaired social interactions at his home when they assessed him in October 2002. Instead, they observed a preschool child who greeted them at the door and who interacted with his siblings. Ms. Lucas described STUDENT as very outgoing in a “nonverbal way”; he attempted to be social and his difficulty was in not having words to communicate. Ms. Lamothe noted that STUDENT was excited because there were two new people in his home. STUDENT gave limited eye contact and responded when his name was called. STUDENT tried to get her attention by showing her his bed and then wanting her to go outside with him. Ms. Lamothe described STUDENT’s behavior as typical for a three-year-old and that she was pleased at the response she did get. (Test. of Ms. Lucas and Ms. Lamothe.) Ms. Lucas noted in her assessment report that STUDENT was described by his mother as having a positive relationship with his parents and siblings, as a child who initiates play with his siblings and other children, and as a child who makes eye contact with others readily and approaches adults and peers without hesitation. Ms. Lucas noted that during the assessment, STUDENT approached the assessors and made eye contact frequently. (Exh. 16.)

Ms. Lindemulder, the occupational therapist who provided interim services to STUDENT in the fall of 2002, testified that when she went to STUDENT’s home to provide services, STUDENT usually greeted her in a kind of peel, “Audrey’s here, Audrey’s here” and noted that STUDENT was excited to see her. Ms. Gidley testified that she observed STUDENT interacting with siblings in the home and interacting with her and Ms. Dominguez during the assessment. Ms. Gidley also stated that STUDENT initiated interaction with her at his home by bringing her something from his room to show her. District witnesses uniformly testified that STUDENT was very social and demonstrated communicative intent by gesture and orally with jargon and a few words and with one- and two-word sentences.

Moreover, Dr. Gross, in a psychological assessment for the Regional Center (July 25, 2002), had concluded that STUDENT did not present with autism or mental retardation. Dr. Gross noted PARENT’s responses on the CARS that STUDENT engaged in shared attention, appeared sensitive to others’ emotional states, and would acknowledge another in distress and would tell a parent or attempt to comfort. Dr. Gross also noted PARENT’s responses on the Vineland that STUDENT regards his parents as significant others “and will seek their attention and regard” and that he initiates and sustains interactions with others, including peers. Dr. Gross observed STUDENT to make and sustain good eye contact, to observe social courtesy, and reported that STUDENT had asked him, “are you okay?” when Dr. Gross had dropped an object.

The Hearing Officer weighs the testimony of PARENT, who stated that she “overestimated” STUDENT’s developmental levels when she responded to District and Regional Center test protocols, with the testimony of various District witnesses and the assessments reports, including the report of Dr. Gross. The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the detailed testimony of experienced educational professionals, and less weight to the testimony of PARENT, whose responses on the CARS administered by Dr. Gross, and on the GARS administered by Ms. Lucas, did not reflect a history of extreme withdrawal or a history of relating to people inappropriately. The evidence establishes that STUDENT did not demonstrate a history of extreme withdrawal or a history of relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment “from infancy through early childhood” in the fall of 2002.

The evidence establishes that STUDENT did not meet criterion (3) in the fall of 2002. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT demonstrated an “obsession to maintain sameness.” Ms. Baird testified that when she worked with him in the fall of 2002, STUDENT was a “very busy boy” and that when she initially brought a certain number of activities for him, she had to double the amount of work she brought because he really needed a fast-paced activity. Ms. Baird stated that STUDENT worked with a lot of puzzles and books and stringing beads and coloring. Ms. Lindemulder also testified that STUDENT engaged in a variety of fine motor activities. Moreover, on the CARS administered by Dr. Gross, PARENT reported that STUDENT “appeared to accept change or variation in routines” and that he “played with a variety of toys in a symbolic and imaginative way.” Dr. Kitlowski noted during her assessment of STUDENT that he was easily able to imitate her in a variety of tasks and situations and “to orient to sound, track items, match colors, numbers, common items [and] complete basic puzzles.” STUDENT also demonstrated an interest in books and was able to make items with playdough and string large beads. (Test. of Dr. Kitlowski and Exh. 23.) The abundant evidence establishes that STUDENT enjoyed a variety of activities and did not exhibit an obsession to maintain sameness. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not demonstrate an obsession to maintain sameness in the fall of 2002.

The evidence establishes that STUDENT did not exhibit an extreme preoccupation with objects or an inappropriate use of objects to satisfy criterion (4) in the fall of 2002. PARENT reported to Dr. Gross that STUDENT tended “to want to mouth objects” and reported to Ms. Lucas that STUDENT put objects in his mouth. Ms. Lucas and PARENT both testified to STUDENT’s placing non-food items in his mouth at home. However, neither Ms. Baird nor Ms. Lindemulder testified that STUDENT put objects in his mouth during instructional and OT services, and Dr. Kitlowski did not observe STUDENT placing objects in his mouth during her assessment of STUDENT conducted on two occasions in the fall of 2002. The evidence established that STUDENT, at age three, put objects in his mouth at home, but there was no evidence to show that STUDENT engaged in such behavior while working with Ms. Baird or Ms. Lindemulder.

PARENT also testified to STUDENT’s preoccupation with umbrellas in the home, and Dr. Kitlowski testified that PARENT had reported STUDENT’s preoccupation with umbrellas in the home. However, Dr. Kitlowski did not observe STUDENT obsess on umbrellas during her two visits with STUDENT and while she engaged STUDENT in a variety of tasks and situations. PARENT also explained to Ms. Gidley that STUDENT would talk about umbrellas, but Ms. Gidley stated that STUDENT did not refer to umbrellas in her presence on the two occasions she assessed STUDENT at Buchanan and at his home, nor did she see him perseverate on any objects in her presence, either at Buchanan or at his home. (Test. of Ms. Gidley.) The Hearing Officer notes that the October 16, 2002 IEP present levels page indicated that STUDENT used umbrellas and hats as a “security object.” (Exh. 25.) The Hearing Officer further notes that PARENT reported on the CARS administered by Dr. Gross that STUDENT did not “repetitively manipulate object parts”and that he “showed no intense object regard.” (Exh. 11.) The Hearing Officer finds that although STUDENT apparently was preoccupied with umbrellas in the home, he did not refer to umbrellas while engaged in educational services in the fall of 2002. (Test. of Ms. Baird and Ms. Lindemulder.) Nor did STUDENT refer to umbrellas during the District assessments.

Ms. Baird and Ms. Lindemulder testified that STUDENT clung to toys at the beginning of instructional and OT sessions in the fall of 2002, but both District witnesses also testified that STUDENT was generally able to be redirected and would release control over the toys and engage in a variety of instructional, gross motor, and fine motor activities in the fall of 2002. Because STUDENT at age three was generally able to be redirected and was able to engage in a variety of activities in the educational setting, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s clinging to toys at Buchanan in October 2002 and his preoccupation with umbrellas or toys at home as reported by his mother was not extreme and did not result in the inappropriate use of objects to satisfy criterion (4).

The evidence establishes that STUDENT did not demonstrate an “extreme” resistance to controls (criterion 5) in the fall of 2002. Ms. Baird testified that she saw very little resistance to controls in October but did see some signs of resistance in the home that increased “somewhat” in November. Ms. Baird also stated that a typical three-year-old doesn’t always follow directions and might ignore them, or say “no,” or comply. The present levels of performance page for the October 16, 2002 IEP notes that “mom reports tantrums and aggressions several times a day [and that] teachers noticed only one tantrum in eight one-hour sessions of interim placement.” The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s behaviors with Ms. Baird did not demonstrate an “extreme resistance” to controls, because Ms. Baird testified credibly that she was able to engage STUDENT in a variety of fine motor and pre-academic activities when she worked with him. Occupational therapist Lindemulder indicated that STUDENT sometimes could not be redirected in the fall of 2002, but her testimony does not support a finding that STUDENT’s resistance was extreme. Ms. Lindemulder generally characterized STUDENT’s behaviors as developmentally appropriate for a three-year-old and noted that she was able to engage STUDENT in gross motor and fine motor activities in the fall of 2002. (Test. of Ms. Lindemulder.) On the Vineland and CARS administered by Dr. Gross, PARENT reported that STUDENT responded to simple commands, would help with a simple chore with ongoing prompting and direction, and that STUDENT accepted change or variation in routines. The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s behaviors in the educational setting did not demonstrate an “extreme resistance to controls” in the fall of 2002.

PARENT testified that STUDENT would engage “self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior” (criterion 7) through video talk and perseverative behaviors at home. However, in response to the CARS administered by Dr. Gross, PARENT did not report ritualistic or obsessive behavior, and PARENT reported on the CARS that when STUDENT used words, they were appropriate to context and purposeful.

Moreover, several District witnesses testified that they did not observe STUDENT engage in video talk, echolalia or perseverative or ritualistic behaviors during services or assessments in the fall of 2002. (Ms. Baird, Ms. Lindemulder, and Ms. Gidley.) During a two and one-half hour assessment at STUDENT’s home, Ms. Lucas testified that she did not observe STUDENT engage in video talk while he watched television and only heard him repeat, one time, the last word of a question raised by his mother. Ms. Gidley testified that she didn’t see any self-stimulating or ritualistic behaviors at Buchanan or at STUDENT’s home, either through behavior or language. Ms. Gidley testified that given the amount of time she spent with STUDENT on both occasions, the absence of such behaviors in her presence indicated to her that it was not a significant issue. Ms. Abrassart testified that she did not recall STUDENT repeating scripts or parts of scripts (delayed echolalia), and that although he sometimes repeated what she said, she did not recall him getting stuck on things by repeating things over and over. Dr. Kitlowski reported that STUDENT at times used jargon or echolalia when he was unsure how to respond in a situation. The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the testimony of several experienced educational professionals who observed STUDENT during assessments and during the delivery of educational services, and less weight to the testimony of PARENT, whose testimony related to STUDENT’s behavior at home (and not while Ms. Baird and Ms. Lindemulder were providing one-on-one services), and which was, sometimes, not consistent with protocol responses that she gave on the CARS in July and in the fall of 2002. The evidence establishes that STUDENT did not demonstrate significant “self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior” in the fall of 2002.

Although the parties agree that STUDENT exhibited an inability to use oral language for appropriate communication, the evidence establishes that STUDENT did not demonstrate significant autistic-like behaviors under the criteria discussed above in the fall of 2002. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT did not meet the requirement that he exhibit a combination (more than one criterion) of autistic-like behaviors in the fall of 2002.

Did the District misidentify STUDENT as “developmentally delayed?”

Petitioner argues that the District’s eligibility determination for STUDENT under the category “developmental delay” was improper because STUDENT was already age three at the time of the District’s initial assessments and eligibility determination in the fall of 2002.

Section 300.7(b) of the C.F.R. provides in pertinent part as follows: “The term child with a disability for children aged 3 through 9 may, at the discretion of the State and LEA and in accordance with Sec. 300.313, include a child– (1) Who is experiencing developmental delays, as defined by the State and as measured by appropriate diagnostic instruments and procedures, in one or more of the following areas: physical development, cognitive development, communication development, social or emotional development, or adaptive development; and (2) Who, by reason thereof, needs special education and related services.”

Section 300.313 (a) of the C.F.R. provides in pertinent part as follows:

(4) If a State does not adopt the term developmental delay [for children aged 3 through 9], an LEA may not independently use that term as a basis for establishing a child’s eligibility under this part.

It is undisputed that California has not adopted the term “developmental delay” in accordance with section 300.313. The Hearing Officer finds that the District incorrectly used the term “developmental delay” as the basis for STUDENT’s eligibility for special education and related services. Instead, section 56441.11 of the California Education Code, as noted above, sets forth the eligibility categories for children between the ages of three and five years.

Prior to STUDENT’s transition into the District at age three, STUDENT qualified for Regional Center services because of speech and language delays. Moreover, the IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education and related services in October 2002 (Test. of Ms. Lamothe.), albeit under the incorrect label “developmentally delayed.” Furthermore, once the District had established STUDENT’s eligibility for special education and related services, it was obligated to meet all of STUDENT’s needs, irrespective of the primary eligibility category designated by the IEP team. Dr. Kitlowski testified that the label did not dictate the services that STUDENT received, and that STUDENT’s unique needs did. (Footnote 16) The Hearing Officer will analyze below whether the District offered or provided STUDENT with a program that met his unique needs.

The Hearing Officer now examines Petitioner’s contentions regarding the District’s program offer for the 2002-2003 school year and ESY.

ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District offer or provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education(FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year and ESY?

Under the amended federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, that meets the standards of the State educational agency, including appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, that is provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP) 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) Related services means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z), special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A)

California special education law further provides that for children between the ages of three and five years, special education shall include “specially designed services to meet the unique needs of preschool children and their families. To meet this purpose, the program focus is on the young child and his or her family and shall include both individual and small group services which shall be available in a variety of typical age-appropriate environments for young children, including the home, and shall include opportunities for active parent involvement.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56441.2.

Special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability by means of an IEP. Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3rd Cir. 1988) The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] education delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345; Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305 (1988). The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, special education and related services, and program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to meet the child’s needs resulting from his or her disability to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and be educated and participate with nondisabled children to the maximum extent possible. Id.; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56343.

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 92nd Cir. 1997)

The IDEA and Rowley require that an appropriate placement (1) be designed to meet the unique needs of the Petitioner, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the Petitioner with some educational benefit, (3) conform with the Petitioner’s IEP, and (4) provide for education in the least restrictive environment (LRE) 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 188.

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. States are required to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each child with a disability receives a FAPE and that parents are involved in the formulation of the child’s educational placement. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in a loss of educational opportunity to the child or that seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

In finding whether a child has been provided a FAPE in the LRE, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the District followed procedural steps and whether the proposed placement was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.

Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer or provide him a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year and ESY.

The Hearing Officer will discuss three periods separately: (1) the period from August 14, 2002, to December 10, 2002; (2) the period December 10, 2002, through the end of the regular school year; and (3) the extended school year (ESY).

A. August 14, 2002 to December 10, 2002

Petitioner contends that the District did not have in place a program offer prior to the 2002-2003 school year (August 14, 2002) and that the District did not fully comply with the terms of the interim agreement entered into between the parties. The District contends that it was not obligated to provide STUDENT with a FAPE until December 10, 2002, when it made its complete IEP offer to Petitioner, because Petitioner’s parents delayed his initial assessment by not consenting to the District’s proposed initial assessment on June 14, 2002. (Footnote 17)

The Hearing Officer addresses two periods: from August 14, 2002, until the beginning of services to STUDENT by the District in October 2002; and the period of the first week of October 2002 to December 2002.

1. August 14, 2002, to October 2002

It is undisputed that STUDENT turned age three on July 20, 2002, and that the District’s fall school year program did not begin until August 14, 2002, when the District was obligated to begin providing preschool services to STUDENT. It is also undisputed that the District did not have in place a program offer prior to the start of the 2002-2003 school year. Moreover, STUDENT’s Regional Center services continued until August 9, 2002, because he had turned three during the summer when the District’s special education preschool program was not in session. But STUDENT received no Regional Center services after August 9. (Footnote 18) (Test. of PARENT.) It is also undisputed that STUDENT did not receive any services from the District during the period August 14, 2002, until the first week of October 2002 -- a delay of six weeks.

Under California Code of Regulations (C.C.R.) section 52112(a) (“Transition from Early Intervention Services”), LEAs “shall provide special education and related services to eligible children at age three.” Additionally, Title 34 Code of Federal Regulations, Section 303.344, provides that each LEA shall participate in the transition planning for toddlers served under the Early Intervention Services Act, Government Code Sections 95000-95030, who may be eligible for preschool programs under Part B of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, Title 20 United States Code Sections 1400-1420, before the toddler is two years nine months, or at the discretion of all parties up to six months before the child turns three to ensure that an IEP has been developed and is implemented by the toddler’s third birthday.

Although the District had an obligation to develop and implement an IEP for STUDENT by his third birthday on July 20, 2002 (and prior to the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year), as noted above, the District could not proceed with its assessment plan of June 14 because PARENT would not consent to the plan unless the District agreed to conduct and pay for a neuropsychological assessment before it proceeded with its assessments. PARENT did not sign the District’s assessment plan at the June 14, 2002 IEP meeting, but instead took the plan home. PARENT signed the assessment plan on July 10, 2002, but did not mark the box consenting to the assessment. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Preston.) Although PARENT had had at least fifteen days to consider the District’s assessment plan under California Education Code section 56321(a), at the time she signed the plan on July 10, she did not withdraw her demand that the District conduct and pay for a neuropsychological assessment before it proceeded with its assessments. The District was now on summer break and was not scheduled to resume regular classes until August 14, 2002. (Footnote 19)

Moreover, as noted above, PARENT would not agree with the District’s eventual choice made in August, Dr. Jeffrey Owen, as the “neuropsychologist” assessor because PARENT understood that Dr. Owen was not properly qualified as a neuropsychologist. (Footnote 20) Petitioner’s parents instead further conditioned their consent to the District’s assessment plan on the District’s agreeing to choose as the neuropsychologist assessor from a list of three individuals designated by Petitioner. (Test. of PARENT.)

A district must first be given the opportunity to conduct its own assessment before it is required to provide an independent evaluation assessment. Education Code § 56329(b). The evidence establishes that the District was ready to proceed with its initial assessment of STUDENT as early as June 14. (Test. of Ms. Gidley, Ms. Abrassart, Ms. Lucas, and Ms. Preston.) The Hearing Officer finds that the position of Petitioner’s parents improperly prevented the District from timely proceeding with its assessment plan of June 14, 2002.

Moreover, a district is not obligated to provide a FAPE if a parent does not make the child available for assessment. Therefore, the District was not obligated to have an IEP program in place by STUDENT’s third birthday, in accordance with section 52112(a), because Petitioner’s parents had, in effect, withheld consent.

Although Petitioner’s parents improperly prevented the District from proceeding with its assessment plan of June 14, 2002, the District was nevertheless obligated to offer Petitioner a thirty-day interim placement to begin on August 14, 2002. Section 56325(a) of the California Education Code provides in pertinent part as follows: “Whenever a pupil transfers into a school district from a school district not operating programs under the same local plan in which he or she was last enrolled in a special education program, the administrator of a local program...shall ensure that the pupil is immediately provided an interim placement for a period not to exceed 30 days. The interim placement must be in conformity with an [IEP], unless the parent or guardian agrees otherwise. The [IEP] implemented during the interim placement may be either the pupil’s existing [IEP], implemented to the extent possible within existing resources...or a new [IEP] developed pursuant to Section 56321.” The Hearing Office has analogized the interim placement requirement under section 56325 to the circumstance where a three-year-old preschooler is transitioning from a Regional Center program into a district. The position of the Hearing Office has been upheld by the 9th Circuit. (See Johnson v. Special Education Hearing Office, 287 F.3d 1176 (9th Cir. 2002.) (Footnote 21) Because the District failed to establish that it, or the Regional Center, provided STUDENT with any interim placement services for the period August 14, 2002, through September 30, 2002, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied Petitioner a FAPE for the six-week period.

It is undisputed that the parties eventually agreed, in early September 2002, that the District would provide STUDENT with the following interim placement: four hours per week of in-home direct instructional services and two hours per week of in-home occupational therapy services. The agreement was to replicate the nature and frequency of Regional Center services STUDENT received under his revised IFSP. (See Exh. 4 and Test. of Ms. Preston.) According to Ms. Lindemulder’s written record of OT services, OT services were first provided STUDENT on October 4, 2002. Ms. Lindemulder initially provided these services at Buchanan, although the IFSP called for in-home preschool services. (Footnote 22) It is undisputed that STUDENT did not receive any OT services during the period August14, 2002, to September 30, 2002. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with 15 OT sessions and at 120 minutes (two hours) per week, the District failed to provide STUDENT with a total of 900 minutes of OT during the initial six-week period. Moreover, Ms. Baird also testified that she first provided direct instructional services to STUDENT during the first week of October 2002. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to establish at hearing that it provided STUDENT with any direct instructional services during the initial six-week period in accordance with STUDENT’s revised IFSP placement. The Hearing Officer finds that at four hours per week of direct instructional services, the District failed to provide STUDENT with twenty-four hours of direct instructional services during the six-week period.

2. October 2002 to December 10, 2002

Meanwhile, as noted above, on September 4 and 5, 2002, PARENT signed two assessment plans, but the District did not yet proceed with its assessment. Additionally, on or about September 4, 2002, PARENT signed an interim placement form that gave her consent to an interim placement of STUDENT. (Exhs. 4 and 15. ) (Footnote 23)On October 2, 2002, PARENT signed a third assessment plan, the day that school psychologist Linda Lucas and SDC preschool teacher Melissa Lamothe made a home visit to assess STUDENT. Other assessments were conducted in early October, and IEP meetings were then held on October 16 and October 28. Dr. Kitlowski then conducted a behavioral assessment, and a final IEP meeting was held on December 10, when the IEP team reviewed Dr. Kitlowski’s findings and the District made its program offer.

Petitioner argues that the District failed to provide OT services under the interim placement during the period October 2002 through December 2002.

Ms. Lindemulder testified that she was scheduled to provide STUDENT with four 30-minute sessions of OT per week during the period October 4, 2002 until December 20, 2002 (the District was on Christmas break from December 21, 2002 through January 9, 2003). The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT sixteen 30-minute OT sessions during the months of October, November, and December. (Exh. 83.) This figure does not include the times that Ms. Lindemulder was told by PARENT that STUDENT was “too tired or ill” and could not be served and does not include two “short sessions” of fifteen minutes’ duration. (Test. of Ms. Lindemulder and PARENT). Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide 480 minutes of OT services (sixteen times 30 minutes for each session) during the remainder of the interim placement. Moreover, as noted above, Ms. Baird testified that she provided STUDENT with direct instructional services during October and November 2002 only. Therefore, the District did not establish that it provided STUDENT with any direct instructional services in December 2002. Thus, the District failed to establish that it provided STUDENT with twelve hours of direct instructional services during the first three weeks of December 2002 up to December 20, 2002, and the Christmas break.

Although the Hearing Officer has already found that the District was not obligated to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the time that it could not assess STUDENT, the District was obligated to provide STUDENT with interim placement services and to convene an IEP team meeting during the 30-day interim placement period to agree upon a program for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that because the parties could not agree upon a program for STUDENT at the October and December 10, 2002 IEP meetings, the District was obligated to continue to provide STUDENT with interim placement services until Petitioner’s parents consented to the IEP in January 2004.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District only partially comported with STUDENT’s revised IFSP during the period October 2002 through December 20, 2002. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to comport with STUDENT’s IFSP to the following extent: the District failed to provide 480 minutes of OT services, and the District also failed to provide twelve hours of direct instructional services. The effect will be addressed under the discussion concerning remedies.

B. December 10, 2002, through the end of the 2002-2003 School Year

1. Was the District’s December 10, 2002 IEP program offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique individual needs?

California Education Code section 56345 (a) provides, in pertinent part, as follows:

The individualized education program is a written statement determined in a meeting of the individualized education program team and shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following:

(1) The present levels of the pupil’s educational performance, including the following: (A) For a schoolage child, how the pupil’s disability affects the pupil’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum. (B) For a preschoolage child, as appropriate, how the disability affects the child’s participation in appropriate activities. [emphasis added.] (2) The measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to the following: (A) Meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. (B) Meeting each of the pupil’s other educational needs that result from the pupil’s disability.

Petitioner first contends that the District failed to delineate all present levels of performance and failed to identify his unique needs within various domains. (Footnote 24) Petitioner also contends that the District failed to develop a program to meet his unique needs and failed to document his progress toward goals and objectives.

The District contends that it determined Petitioner’s correct present levels of performance by assessing him appropriately in October 2002. The District asserts that it identified the following areas of need for STUDENT: speech and language (receptive and expressive), written expression, fine motor, sensory integration, visual motor, and daily living skills.

As noted above, the Hearing Officer addresses the District’s program for the period December 10, 2002, through October 2003, the date of his annual IEP.

STUDENT’s present levels of performance

During IEP meetings held in October 2002, the IEP team determined STUDENT’s present levels of performance (at age 38 months) after discussions among team members that included PARENT, District assessors, and other team members. Ms. Baird, STUDENT’s inclusion support teacher in October and November 2002, and PARENT both participated in each of the three IEP meetings held in October and December. Ms. Lamothe testified that she wrote some of the present levels at the October IEP meetings and that PARENT added to present levels and was “very vocal” in expressing her concerns. Ms. Lamothe stated that the IEP present levels “kind of went around the table,” as people with their expertise wrote in what their assessment of his levels were. (Footnote 25)

Petitioner argues that the District failed to identify on his October 2002 IEPs all of his present levels of performance as revealed by test protocols (the GARS, the Battelle, and the Brigance) that were produced during the hearing. The Hearing Officer addresses the relevant contentions made by Petitioner. (Footnote 26)

The form IEP page used by the District for STUDENT’s October and December IEPs includes the following headings for present levels of performance: Reading, Written Expression, Math, Communication, Fine/Gross Motor, Social/Emotional, Behavior, Daily Living Skills, Work Maturity Skills, Community Participation, and Student Learning Strengths/Preference. (Footnote 27) Under Reading, the IEP present levels page indicates that STUDENT “loves to look at books, will point and name pictures, turns pages one by one,” and that the VIP teacher and parent had reported that STUDENT “can name capital letters.” In the margin, the present levels also indicate that STUDENT “does not understand the concept of flow of story.” Petitioner contends that protocol responses indicated his lack of interest in “read-to-me” books, his inability to describe actions depicted in pictures, or to take part in reading by “filling in” words and phrases. On the Brigance, STUDENT turned pages individually and pointed to and named simple pictures. Ms. Baird stated that STUDENT would look at books and “you would orient a book to turn the page.” The Hearing Officer finds that the omission of an entry for his lack of interest in read-to-me books did not render the IEP deficient because the consistent testimony establishes that STUDENT demonstrated an interest in books. The last two protocol items (for describing actions and filling in pictures) have a grade equivalency of 3-0, with a next step of 4-0. The Hearing Officer finds that the omission of the two entries having a grade equivalency of 3-0, indicating a two-month delay was not significant and did not render the IEP deficient.

Under Math, the IEP present levels page indicates that STUDENT “can count to 10 and recognizes numerals 1-10 per teacher and parent and that STUDENT can demonstrate 1:1 correspondence and the concept “more” (per VIP Tots teacher, not parents and other[s].”. Petitioner asserted that on the Brigance, he could not count to ten. Ms. Lamothe stated that STUDENT could not “rote count” on the Brigance. However, STUDENT was able to read numerals up to ten -- described by Ms. Lamothe as a “splintered skill”-- but was unable to demonstrate an understanding of ordinal positions. (Footnote 28) Ms. Baird testified that she was surprised by how high STUDENT counted, but could not recall how high he counted. The Hearing Officer finds that the entries for math sufficiently stated STUDENT’s present levels for math in October 2002 and is persuaded by the testimony of Ms. Lamothe that STUDENT’s performance on the Brigance was likely the result of attentional issues or fatigue.

Petitioner argues that his present levels omitted information about his inability to match colors and to match shapes on the Brigance, thus making his present levels deficient. Ms. Lamothe testified that she was unsure whether STUDENT understood the word “match,” and that during testing STUDENT was showing signs of inattentiveness and fatigue. It is undisputed that STUDENT, at 38 months, had significant delays in receptive and expressive language and may not have understood the word “match.” Moreover, matching shapes has an age equivalence of 3-0, but matching colors has an age equivalence of 2-0. According to Ms. Lamothe, a two-month delay in matching shapes was not significant, but a fourteen-month delay in matching colors was significant. The Hearing Officer finds that the omission on the present levels regarding STUDENT’s inability to match colors was significant and rendered the present levels deficient in that respect.

Under STUDENT’s communication present level, it was noted that STUDENT understood the concept “more,” and that STUDENT had not shown this understanding to his parents and others. Petitioner asserts that he did not know “many/one,” only knew “big” but not “little,” and did not know “full and empty.” Petitioner also asserts that he did not demonstrate number concepts of “one more,” and “just one.” The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s present level for understanding quantitative concepts could not be uniformly determined for all settings and that the entry regarding his ability to understand “more” in one setting sufficiently identified STUDENT’s difficulty with understanding quantitative concepts. Moreover, as discussed within, the IEP team developed a preacademic goal for receptive understanding of quantitative concepts.

Petitioner also asserts that the omission of a reference to classifying (the ability to categorize items such as animals, toys, means of travel) rendered the IEP present levels deficient. Ms. Lamothe testified that she did not attempt the section on the Brigance because STUDENT was experiencing attentional issues. STUDENT’s present levels should have at least noted that an accurate present level could not be determined for classifying.

Under Fine/Gross Motor, the IEP present levels page has no entry for gross motor, and Petitioner asserts that the District failed to identify his present levels of performance for gross motor. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s present levels were deficient in this respect, by not identifying STUDENT’s developmental levels for gross motor functioning.

Petitioner asserts that the present levels do not refer to visual motor. The Hearing Officer finds that although Ms. Brennan identified visual motor needs within her OT assessment, the present levels do not identify present levels for visual motor.

Under Communication, the IEP present levels page notes the following: “Delays in receptive/expressive language; developmental artic[ulation] errors; no voice/dysfluency issues; oral-motor issues per VIP – in/out under in receptive language...uses 2-3 word sentences...[and] some social com.[munication] skills (greetings).

Petitioner contends that the present levels entry, “delays in receptive/expressive language” was deficient because the entry lacks specificity. The Hearing Officer finds that the entry lacks specificity which was not “cured” by the inclusion of three entries regarding “in/out” under receptive language, STUDENT’s use of 2-3 word sentences and some social greetings. The present levels simply do not provide enough information about STUDENT’s level of functioning in receptive and expressive language -- acknowledged by the parties to be two of his greatest areas of need. The IEP team’s development of two goals, one for receptive language and one for expressive also does not cure the lack of specificity because IEP goals depend upon adequate information from a child’s present levels to form a baseline for the goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer further notes, that under the heading “statement of need,” both goals simply repeat the generic categories “receptive language” and “expressive language” without any further information about STUDENT’s baseline functioning in those areas.

Regarding the entry “developmental articulation errors,” Ms. Gidley testified that she administered the Goldman-Fristoe Test of articulation to identify sound errors and that the errors STUDENT exhibited were developmental in nature that one would expect at that age and were not in need of remediation. Petitioner did not provide evidence that STUDENT’s articulation errors, in October 2002, were not developmental in nature and were in need of remediation, and the Hearing Officer therefore finds that the entry was sufficient for his present levels for articulation.

With regard to voice and dysfluency, speech-language therapists Abrassart and Gidley testified that, developmentally, STUDENT did not have deficits in voice and dysfluency. (Footnote 29) Petitioner presented no evidence that STUDENT had issues with voice and fluency, and the Hearing Officer finds that the present levels sufficiently expressed STUDENT’s present levels for voice and fluency.

Petitioner asserts that the IEP present levels do not adequately identify STUDENT’s present levels for oral motor. The Hearing Officer notes that the present levels page simply indicates, without more detail, that STUDENT had “oral motor issues.” Ms. Abrassart testified that she conducted an oral motor screening of STUDENT and that his mother told her that he has a limited food preference and preferred food that did not require a lot of chewing, and that he did not enjoy eating meat (his parents referred to him as a vegetarian). Ms. Abrassart found that STUDENT needed to strengthen his jaw to provide some sensory stimulation. However, none of this information was included under present levels. The Hearing Officer finds that the present levels reference to oral motor issues, without greater specificity, did not sufficiently identify STUDENT’s oral motor issues regarding food preferences.

With regard to “pragmatics,” the present levels indicate that STUDENT used 2- to 3-word sentences and that he used some social communication skills for social greetings. Petitioner asserts that he frequently echoed words verbally and with signs which should have been noted on the present levels. However, as discussed above, the District witnesses did not observe STUDENT engaging in echolalia in the fall of 2002. Moreover, Ms. Abrassart testified that echolalia is an indicator of communicative intent and is not uncommon for a preschooler. Furthermore, on the CARS administered by Dr. Gross, PARENT reported that when STUDENT used words, “they are appropriate to context and purposeful.” The Hearing Officer finds that the omission of a reference to echolalia on the present levels did not render the IEP deficient.

Under Social/Emotional, the IEP present levels page notes the following: “follows same age peers, likes to engage w[ith] adults and peers; generally happy; gives eye contact (limited eye contact).” Petitioner contended that the present levels did not note the following: “his inability to express his emotions and the emotions of others, that he did not learn from his peer or adult relationships, that he could not engage in or sustain positive interactions with personal relationships, that he did not have any ‘social reciprocity,’ and that he used ‘video talk’ as his way to compensate for his lack of appropriate language and social engagements.” As discussed above, none of the District staff members observed STUDENT engage in “video talk” in the fall of 2002 and District staff members testified to STUDENT’s ability to express his feelings. There was an insufficient showing that STUDENT “did not learn from his peer or adult relationships” (a single protocol response). Moreover, the District had had no prior programming experience with STUDENT, who was just three years old, to determine that he could not learn from peer or adult relationships. Additionally, there was no showing that STUDENT’s ability to express the feelings of others was below age-equivalence for a three-year-old. The VIP exit report noted that STUDENT “attempts to comfort others in distress,” and Dr. Gross noted PARENT’s protocol response that STUDENT appeared sensitive to the emotional states of others. PARENT testified that this was not accurate but explained that she had given STUDENT “the benefit of the doubt” and had overestimated his functioning levels in many areas. However, it is undisputed that PARENT actively participated in the discussion regarding present levels and eventually signed and consented to the IEP.

Ms. Lucas testified that the information under social/emotional was consistent with her assessment. All of the District witnesses observed STUDENT engaging with adults and peers and noted that he enjoyed social interaction. (Test. of Dr. Kitlowksi, Ms. Abrassart, Ms. Lamothe, Ms. Lindemulder, Ms. Baird). Although some District staff members noted that STUDENT avoided looking at the speaker when his name was called, others noted that STUDENT gives eye contact. The Hearing Officer finds that the present level item “gives eye contact (limited eye contact)” sufficiently expressed STUDENT’s present performance level for eye contact. The Hearing Officer finds that the present level entries under social/emotional were sufficient in October of 2002.

Under “Behavior,” the IEP present levels page notes that STUDENT “has a hard time following adult directives, can be non-compliant...mom reports tantrums and aggression several times a day. Teachers noticed only one tantrum in eight one hour sessions of interim placement; [and] has “security objects” (hat & umbrella).” Under “Work Maturity Skills,” the IEP present levels page notes that STUDENT has “short attention to activities (less than one minute per activity)[and that] one-step directions can be followed.” Petitioner contends that the present levels inadequately state his behaviors at the time of the initial assessment because he had many “maladaptive” behaviors, including preoccupations with objects, temper tantrums, [and] task avoidance behaviors, and that he also exhibited frustration with aggressive and self-stimulatory behaviors.

Ms. Baird testified that she observed some resistance, “maybe one or twice,” towards the end in November when STUDENT was more resistant to sitting down and working with her at his home. Ms. Baird recalled that PARENT brought up the subject at the IEP meeting on October 28 and asked whether they had seen it during the interim placement and noted that she was having difficulty with tantrumming at home. Ms. Baird stated that they had not seen that during the interim placement at school. Dr. Kitlowski and Ms. Abrassart noted that STUDENT was at times noncompliant and had attentional issues. Ms. Lindemulder testified that STUDENT experienced difficulties with her when she first started working with him in the fall of 2002, both at Buchanan and Avaxat and in the home. Ms. Lindemulder characterized the difficulties, including tantrumming, to be normal developmentally, given STUDENT’s age and his preference for social and gross motor activities and his dislike for fine motor activities (writing with pencils). Nevertheless, the evidence establishes that the District witnesses saw limited instances of resistance by STUDENT or tantrumming. The Hearing Officer finds that the present levels reference to one tantrum behavior in eight one-hour sessions sufficiently described the frequency of STUDENT’s tantrumming behaviors in the presence of District staff members in October 2002, and that the reference to the parent’s report of tantrumming and aggression “several times a day” reflected STUDENT’s behavior in the home as observed by his mother.

The Hearing Officer notes that test protocols can reveal significant areas of need for a child, as well as areas of strength, but test protocols are just one source of information to determine a child’s present levels of performance. Observations made of a child in all environments are also very important in the assessment of a child and play a vital role in determining present levels of performance. Regional Center records are also important for a preschooler. Most importantly, discussions held at IEP team meetings among the various members of the IEP team, including the parents, can reconcile differing observations and uncertain protocol information, and are far more likely to result in a balanced appraisal of a child’s present levels, than a strict reliance on information taken only from test protocols. A three-year-old child’s relative levels of attention and fatigue level must also be taken into consideration when interpreting test protocol responses. Moreover, Petitioner provides no persuasive authority that IEP present levels of performance must contain exhaustive inventories taken from test protocols relating to all domains in order to satisfy the IDEA. Present levels of performance should be accurate and specific descriptors of a child’s performance within significant domain areas, taking into account a child’s chronological age, maturity, and past experience with standardized testing. The IEP team must then make careful judgments, after a thorough discussion, to determine accurate present levels of performance and significant areas of need in order to formulate appropriate, measurable goals and objectives to address a child’s needs.

PARENT emphasized that she “overestimated” STUDENT’s developmental levels during the District’s initial assessment and even disputed the accuracy of many of the IFSP present levels that were based on information that she had provided in February 2002. (Test. of PARENT.) Obviously, accurate parental information is very important for establishing accurate present levels of performance of a three-year-old coming into a district for the first time. Inaccurate responses given by a parent either during interviews with assessors (eg., in response to standardized test instruments), or in written response on forms or assessment protocols can result in inaccurate present levels of performance. Notwithstanding the parent’s report of overestimating STUDENT’s developmental levels, the Hearing Officer notes that the observations of several District staff members in different settings and at different times, together with information provided by PARENT, were an adequate basis for determining STUDENT’s present levels in October 2002.

The weight of the evidence establishes that the present levels of performance were sufficient except for the following: there was no entry regarding STUDENT’s inability to match colors or for classifying items; the reference to oral motor needs lacked specificity regarding STUDENT’s feeding issues and STUDENT’s need to strengthen his jaw; there was no reference to gross motor levels of functioning or to visual motor; and the reference to delays in receptive and expressive language lacked specificity because it did not delineate STUDENT’s levels of functioning in those areas to provide a baseline. The effect of these deficiencies will be discussed below. The Hearing Officer first addresses STUDENT’s unique needs as determined in the fall of 2002.

STUDENT’s unique needs

To determine that the District’s program offer in December 2002 was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to determine STUDENT’s needs.

The parties do not dispute that STUDENT had unique needs in the following areas: receptive and expressive language, oral motor, fine motor, visual motor, sensory integration, self-help (including toilet training), development of peer interaction, behavior, and the need for structure and to develop attention to task and need for redirection. Petitioner asserted that he had additional areas of need not identified by the District.

Petitioner asserted that his communication deficits included articulation, his lack of age appropriate semantics (word meanings), morphology (grammar), syntax (word order), pragmatics (how language is used in relation to others), voice and fluency.

Ms. Gidley testified that she administered the Goldman-Fristoe Test of Articulation to identify sound errors and that the errors STUDENT exhibited were developmental in nature that one would expect at that age and were not in need of remediation. Ms. Gidley also stated that STUDENT had all of the “repertoire” of sounds. The testimony of Ms. Gidley was persuasive that STUDENT did not have needs in the area of articulation in the fall of 2002, and there was no evidence to the contrary.

Ms. Gidley also testified that as part of her informal assessment of voice and fluency, she listened for a “raspy-like” voice and for “stuttering-like” behaviors, but STUDENT did not exhibit any of those behaviors and that she found no deficits. Petitioner provided no evidence that voice and fluency were areas of need for him in October 2002. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have needs in the areas of voice and fluency in the fall of 2002.

Regarding semantics, grammar and syntax, Ms. Gidley testified that STUDENT’s verbal output at the time of the District’s initial assessment was very limited to some one and two-word phrases. Moreover, Ms. Abrassart testified that the District could not assess STUDENT for sentence structure and for grammatic completion in October 2002. The Hearing Officer finds that semantics, grammar, and syntax were not areas of need for STUDENT because of STUDENT’s very limited verbal output.

Petitioner asserted that the District failed to identify the following social-emotional needs: his ability to relate to people and his ability for social interaction. The Hearing Officer finds that the District identified STUDENT’s need for development of peer interaction, which encompasses the ability to relate to people and his ability for social interaction. Moreover, the District developed a goal and objectives for STUDENT to engage in appropriate peer interactions. (Exh. 25.)

Petitioner asserts that the District failed to identify his needs in visual motor. As noted above, the Hearing Officer has already found that the District failed to identify present levels for visual motor. (Footnote 30) Ms. Brennan testified that according to the Peabody assessment, STUDENT received a low average range score in visual motor (16%) and that the two fine motor goals and objectives addressed his visual motor needs. The evidence establishes that although the District identified STUDENT’s needs in visual motor by assessment and by developing goals and objectives, there was no showing that the District had a baseline for goals and objectives in visual motor.

Petitioner also asserts that he had gross motor needs and lacked balance and mobility in standing, walking, running, and hopping. The Hearing Officer examines the information available to the IEP team regarding STUDENT’s gross motor functioning in October 2002.

On STUDENT’s initial IFSP in February 2002, at age 31 months, STUDENT’s present levels of development for gross motor indicate the following: “walks [and] runs well; goes up/down stairs holding the rail using same step foot placement; kicks [and] throws balls; moves forward on a tricycle by pushing his feet along the ground.” (age level equivalency for [gross] motor - 20 to 30 months). The IFSP describes as a strength STUDENT’s “great gross motor skills.” In the early development exit profile assessment conducted on June 20, 2002, by VIP Tots, STUDENT, at nearly 35 months, performed gross motor skills at the 30-month level. (Exh. 66.) At the time of the exit profile, STUDENT had partially met a developmental goal for pedaling a bicycle forward six feet. STUDENT could physically pedal the bicycle forward six feet with adult prompting, but would not try to do it on his own. STUDENT met a second IFSP goal that he imitate several gross motor movements, and STUDENT was able to imitate “almost any” gross motor activity with his upper body and could stand on one foot momentarily, but could not hop. STUDENT also could balance on an “eight-inch wide” garden wall and jump over a rope “jiggled a few inches off the ground.” On July 25, 2002, PARENT reported to licensed psychologist Thomas F. Gross, Ph.D., on the Vineland that at 36 months, STUDENT could walk and run well, walk up and down stairs, jump on two legs, could not hop on one leg, did not pedal a tricycle, could throw (with direction) and kick a ball, and could catch a ball with variable accuracy. Dr. Gross did not recommend that the District assess STUDENT for gross motor issues.

District witnesses described STUDENT as demonstrating appropriate gross motor skills during his preschool assessments and when services were provided to him. Ms. Baird testified that while working with STUDENT at Buchanan in October, he enjoyed running around and that she remembered him “running around [on the playground] with the other kids [from the State preschool]” when no SDC preschool children were present, and that STUDENT was “able to keep up with them.” Ms. Baird also recalled that STUDENT enjoyed swinging on the swing set and taking rides on the wagon. Because STUDENT needed gross motor activities to address his attentional issues, Ms. Baird would alternate direct instruction with motor breaks.

Dr. Kitlowski noted that STUDENT was able to jump “really well” and that she observed STUDENT climb a “very, very” steep hill behind his home. Ms. Lamothe testified that when she assessed STUDENT at his home, she saw him running in the backyard, and while he was in her class, she saw him walking correctly and did not notice any problems with his gait or balance. STUDENT used a trampoline in her classroom without adult supervision. Ms. Lamothe also noted that STUDENT was able to skip and that she saw him kick and throw a ball outside “as did his peers.” Ms. Lamothe generally noted that she did not observe STUDENT exhibit any problems with gross motor skills or that gross motor issues prevented his access to the preschool environment. Ms. Lindemulder, OT, testified that she worked with STUDENT on a “lot of” ball and gross motor activities, including use of the trampoline at his home in the fall 2002, and did not note any gross motor deficits.

Preschool psychologist Linda Lucas noted in her assessment report that STUDENT’s mother had reported that STUDENT’s developmental milestones were met at a normal rate in the areas of sitting and walking and that STUDENT’s family were currently working with him on hopping and on working the pedals on a tricycle and that he had just recently begun hopping on two feet and working to achieve six pedal rotations. Under “adaptive living skills,” Ms. Lucas noted that STUDENT “frequently climbs, yet has not had any significant accidents from climbing.” Gross motor deficits were not noted in any of the initial assessment reports or on his initial IEP. There was no showing at hearing that STUDENT, at age 38 months, lacked balance and mobility in standing, walking, running, and hopping. (Footnote 31) The Hearing Officer finds that gross motor was not an area of need for STUDENT.

Petitioner also asserts that the District failed to identify his “adaptive needs” in that he exhibited the following maladaptive behaviors: temper tantrums, task avoidance behaviors, frustration with aggressive behaviors, and self-stimulatory behaviors. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT did not exhibit an extreme resistance to controls in the fall of 2002 because District staff members did not observe significant tantrumming, aggressive behaviors, or self-stimulatory behaviors. Dr. Kathleen Kitlowski testified that she conducted a behavioral assessment of STUDENT on two occasions and completed a consultation report dated December 9, 2002. (Footnote 32) (Exh. 23.). Dr. Kitlowski testified that she did not observe tantrum behaviors, but at the December 10, 2002 IEP team meeting, she recommended structure and limited choice “to improve” tantrums based upon the parental report of STUDENT’s tantrumming at home. (Exh. 25.) Although District staff members observed frustration, they attributed it toSTUDENT’s significant delays in communication. Moreover, as discussed above, District witnesses credibly testified that STUDENT could be redirected when he exhibited frustration. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District properly identified STUDENT’s need for structure, development of his attention to task, and for redirection, to address his deficits in behavior.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds in the fall of 2002, that STUDENT had deficits in the following areas: receptive and expressive language, oral motor, fine motor, visual motor, sensory integration, development of peer interaction, adapted behavior (toilet training), behavior, and development of attention to task and redirection. Moreover, Petitioner does not dispute that he needed a small, structured class that emphasized the development of expressive and receptive language, that developed peer interaction, attention to task, and learning to follow adult directives.

The Hearing Officer now determines whether the goals and objectives developed by the IEP team in the fall of 2002 were appropriate and designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.

Goals and Objectives (Footnote 33)

It is undisputed that the IEP team developed appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT in the following areas: self-help (for toilet training), preacademic (for developing an understanding of quantitative concepts), fine motor pre-writing (copying a line, circle, cross and square), fine motor for scissors skills (cutting with scissors), developing peer interactions, and increasing attention to task (for up to ten minutes). Petitioner contended that two goals and objectives in receptive and expressive language were not appropriate because they were not measurable and the receptive goal was unclear (and therefore vague).

Goal number 5 (receptive language) provides that by 10/03, STUDENT “will follow 2-step commands in the context of 20 clinician-selected basic concepts using objects/pictures/paper-pencil tasks w[ith] 80% acc[uracy].” Above the goal at the upper right part of the page, the following notation is indicated: “What 2-step...” and the rest is illegible to the Hearing Officer. Petitioner indicates in his brief that the IEP contains the written notes - “what two-step commands anywhere,” and Petitioner further asserted that the goal was not measurable and it was unclear what the basic concepts were.” It is undisputed that receptive language was a significant area of need for STUDENT. Ms. Baird testified that she would be able to work on the goal, with input from the speech-therapist clinician, and measure progress on it. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the goal is not sufficiently measurable because the goal does not explain what basic concepts are and does not explain which basic concepts would be addressed by the goal. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal was too vague and not measurable because the goal was not supported by a specific present level of performance, and an adequate baseline was not given for the goal. Thus, Goal number 5 was not an appropriate goal for STUDENT.

Goal number 6 (expressive language) provides that by 10/03, STUDENT “will use n[ouns] and v[erbs] and direct object[s] to express needs/wants w[ith] 80% accuracy.” Petitioner did not contend that this goal was vague or not measurable, but in his brief, Petitioner asserts that his parents “felt that the expressive language goal was not appropriate because [it] had actions, prepositions, pronouns, using objects with pictures” [that] “should have been broken down into separate goals.” It is noted that the goal contains the following objectives/benchmarks: that “[b]y 1/03, STUDENT will identify (by pointing) verb actions, prepositions, pronouns using objects [and] pictures with objects w[ith] verbal prompting w[ith] 80% accuracy”; that “[b]y 4/03, STUDENT will identify by repeating the model or naming action verbs, prepositions, pronouns using obj[ect]/pictures w[ith] 80% acc[uracy].” Ms. Baird testified that she would be able to work on the goal and measure progress on it. The Hearing Officer notes that the expressive language goal was broken down into separate objectives/benchmarks. It is undisputed that STUDENT was entering the District with a very limited verbal output. STUDENT was to be taught how to use expressive language by learning how to form grammatical sentences (nouns, verbs, prepositions, pronouns) so that he could express his needs and wants. Although the Hearing Officer finds that the expressive goal was “measurable,” the Hearing Officer finds that the expressive language goal was not supported sufficiently by a present level of performance, and an adequate baseline was not given for the goal. Accordingly, it is not clear whether the goal was an appropriate one for STUDENT.

Regarding Petitioner’s contention that he needed an IEP goal for “looking at books,” Ms. Lamothe testified persuasively that STUDENT did not need a goal for that because he seemed to engage and showed an interest in books during the assessment and that “looking at books” is a part of the daily curriculum and daily routine of her SDC preschool class. Ms. Lamothe further stated that STUDENT enjoyed story time and that her class had a reading center with a bean bag and book shelf where the children picked out their books and “read” them by pointing to pictures and talking about the story. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not need a goal for looking at books, and there was no evidence to the contrary.

Regarding creating a goal for the identification of body parts, Ms. Lamothe credibly testified that STUDENT did not need a goal for that because it is addressed daily in the preschool curriculum through “lots of songs and motions” and because she was waiting for improvement in his expressive language skills. Petitioner also contends that the IEP was deficient because it does not have a goal for counting and a goal for knowing the use of objects. Ms. Lamothe testified that goals for counting and for knowing the use of objects were unnecessary because they are a part of the daily SDC curriculum. The Hearing Officer finds that the absence of an IEP goal and objectives for looking at books, identifying body parts, for counting, and for knowing the use objects did not render the IEP deficient.

In summary, the Hearing Officer has found that the goal for receptive language was vague and not measurable and did not provide a baseline. Accordingly, the goal was not appropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer has also found that the goal for expressive language, while measurable, did not provide a baseline. Without an accurate baseline, it is not clear whether the expressive language goal was an appropriate one for him.

Placement and Services

The Hearing Officer has already determined that STUDENT had unique needs in the following areas: receptive and expressive language, oral motor, fine motor, visual motor, sensory integration, development of peer interaction, self-help (toilet training), and the need for structure and to develop attention to task and need for redirection. Moreover, as discussed above, Petitioner does not dispute that he needed a small, structured class that emphasized the development of expressive and receptive language, and that developed peer interaction, attentional skills, and the ability to follow adult directives. Additionally, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT did not have unique needs in gross motor.

Petitioner asserted generally that the District’s offer was substantively inadequate and did not address his unique needs and did not provide behavioral intervention. The Hearing Officer discusses the District’s program offer to determine whether it was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The IEP team offered the following program on December 10, 2002: attendance in an SDC preschool class four days per week for two hours and 45 minutes each day; a Community Friends program in which two typically developing four-year-old peers attend the SDC preschool class to be used as peer models; two speech-language therapy sessions per week in 30-minute sessions at school (one individual and one group); and two individual occupational therapy services per week in 30-minute sessions at home. The program also provided that STUDENT would receive “behavioral support” by a behavior specialist and that STUDENT’s progress would be measured six times per year “by progress report/report cards.” (Footnote 34) (Exh. 25.)

Ms. Lamothe described the morning preschool SDC classroom at Buchanan that STUDENT attended. There are no more than ten preschool children in the class, with two aides in the classroom. Two nondisabled peers attend the class under the Community Friends program (described as reverse mainstreaming). The classroom is set up in “fifteen minute-increments”: during the first fifteen minutes, the children enter the classroom, put away their backpacks, engage in social greetings, and play one-on-one with an aide or with peers; the second fifteen minutes is “opening circle,” during which children sit down on a letter as the class does opening welcoming songs, and then the calendar, during which she explains the day and does an introduction to the rotations. Ms. Lamothe then gives out colored cards to the children. Depending upon which colored card the child chooses, (red, blue, yellow, or green), he or she then goes to the table centers for fifteen minutes to do “table-top” activities and/or floor activities. Ms. Lamothe explained that each center represents a different modality of learning: the red table is for fine motor skills for a “lot of” cutting and coloring on the theme of the week; the blue table is for sensory integration, where children place their hands in rice and shaving cream daily; the yellow table is for math and cognitive development, where children do number recognitions – counting, puzzles, and “I see/I spy games”; and the green table is for language development, where oral motor skills are developed as well as reading and language arts. (Footnote 35)

Afterwards, the children have some open time/down time. The children then engage in the second circle time of the day – story time and singing. The children then have snack time and help prepare and set out snacks. Ms. Lamothe noted that some children come in with specific food issues and concerns and that if a child has an issue with food, everyone gets to try that (eg., apple sauce) taste and touch. Ms. Lamothe stated that learning taste and touch is taken in increments: first, the child successfully holds the spoon, then moves the spoon to the lips, and then to the tongue. Ms. Lamothe explained that a child is not expected to eat something that he or she has a high aversion to and that the child works up to it. The children learn to eat correctly and to sit longer than one and one-half seconds. The children sit and wait for friends to finish and, afterwards, the children line up on the black line and go outside. At that point, the children learn, “who’s first, who’s second.” A child can walk behind a friend. The children then go outside to work on gross motor skills, with everyone kicking the ball that day, and with everyone walking on the balance beam and getting to toss the ball. The children then return to the classroom for closing circle, at which time the day is reviewed, and the class has “sharing time.” The children then return home with a little homework to review with the parents, such as practicing saying sentences such as “I made this,” “my name is...,” and then the class says good-bye with a little song and the children return home by bus or their parents pick them up.

Ms. Lamothe stated that she consulted with an OT regarding the sensory integration program and that an OT is in her classroom “at least twice and sometimes three or four times per week.” Ms. Lamothe also stated that she works closely with the speech-language therapist and described the SDC preschool program as a “speech and language preschool enhancement program,” indicating that her classroom is set up to promote correct speech and social and communication skills and that, to some extent, the class works on oral motor daily, and on articulation daily, whether the speech therapist is present or not.

Dr. Kitlowski testified that STUDENT needed a structured program that was “language rich” and with speech services built into the class. Dr. Kitlowski also noted that Ms. Lamothe’s class gave STUDENT an opportunity for being social, and further stated that although STUDENT had the opportunity with four siblings at home, he really needed to be with peers in a social situation and to work on his attention so that he could do learn to do things independently without people having to structure him too much. None of the witnesses called by Petitioner addressed the appropriateness of Ms. Lamothe’s SDC preschool classroom for STUDENT or disputed the accuracy of Ms. Lamothe’s and Dr. Kitlowski’s description of the classroom.

The Hearing Officer notes that the classroom size was small, with no more than ten students. Moreover, Ms. Lamothe was assisted by two aides. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer met STUDENT’s unique needs for a small, structured SDC preschool classroom. Petitioner did not provide evidence that he needed a different classroom placement.

The Hearing Officer notes that the classroom gave STUDENT daily opportunities for social interaction with peers, including nondisabled peers who attended the class through the Community Friends program. Moreover, Ms. Lamothe and Dr. Kitlowski persuasively testified that the classroom met STUDENT’s needs to develop his social interaction skills. As noted above, the IEP team developed an appropriate goal for STUDENT to engage in appropriate peer interactions.

Ms. Lamothe and Dr. Kitlowksi persuasively testified that the small, structured classroom provided STUDENT with daily opportunities to develop his skill to attend to task and to learn to follow adult directives. As noted above, the IEP team developed an appropriate goal for STUDENT to develop his attention to task.

Ms. Lamothe testified that because there were behavior concerns mainly coming from PARENT, she determined that her goal as an educator was to bring STUDENT into the classroom and to try some behavior modifications and to extinguish behaviors and to give him socially accepted ways to handle his frustrations and his lack of communication. Ms. Lamothe also testified that Dr. Kitlowski consulted with her for techniques on dealing with behaviors should they arise in the classroom. Petitioner asserts that the program should have included a behavior intervention plan. However, STUDENT was just three years old and coming into a District program for the first time. It would not have been practicable to develop a behavior intervention plan because the plan required classroom observations and STUDENT had not attended class yet. Moreover, accommodations and modifications had not yet been tried and found wanting. (Footnote 36) Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the lack of a behavioral intervention plan did not make the District’s program offer deficient.

Occupational therapist Ms. Brennan persuasively testified that the program offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s fine motor needs. The program offer provided that STUDENT receive two 30-minute occupational therapy sessions each week. As discussed above, the IEP team developed two appropriate goals and objectives in fine motor. Petitioner did not dispute the amount of OT services offered. However, as discussed below, there was evidence that not all of the sessions were provided.

Ms. Brennan persuasively testified that the program was designed to address STUDENT’s needs in sensory integration. As discussed above, the sensory motor center within Ms. Lamothe’s classroom provided STUDENT with daily opportunities to work with a tactile bin, shaving cream, and rice to develop tactile discrimination and to work on sensory integration issues. Moreover, Ms. Lamothe persuasively testified that she consulted with an occupational therapist regarding sensory integration and that an occupational therapist was in the classroom two to four times per week.

As noted above, the program included a self-help goal for toilet-training. It is undisputed that STUDENT needed toilet-training, and Ms. Lamothe persuasively testified that toilet-training was implemented in the SDC classroom schedule. The program also included a preacademic goal and objectives for understanding basic quantitative concepts.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the structured SDC classroom and services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas discussed above. The Hearing Officer next addresses the areas in which deficiencies were found. The Hearing Officer previously found that the program offer did not contain present levels and goals and objectives for matching colors and for classifying items. However, the evidence establishes that matching colors was part of the daily curriculum in Ms. Lamothe’s classroom. For example, in Ms. Lamothe’s classroom, each child could choose to engage in four different table-top activities. The child chose the color code – red, blue, yellow or green -- for the activity. The District failed to establish present levels and goals and objectives for classifying items. Ms. Lamothe testified that she did not test for classifying items because STUDENT was experiencing attentional issues. Ms. Lamothe further stated that if she had been greatly concerned, she would have readdressed classifying items. The Hearing Officer finds that the absence of a goal and objectives for classifying items did not render the IEP deficient.

The Hearing Officer previously found that the District failed to provide present levels for visual motor. The Hearing Officer finds that the program was not appropriately designed to address STUDENT’s visual motor needs because the two fine/visual motor goals and objectives lacked a baseline to track STUDENT’s progress in visual motor.

The Hearing Officer previously found that the District failed to establish appropriate present levels in oral motor for feeding issues. The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Lamothe testified that oral motor issues were dealt with in the structure of the classroom through snack time as well as during speech therapy sessions. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer finds that the program was not appropriately designed to address STUDENT’s feeding issues in oral motor because the IEP team did not develop a goal and objective in oral motor for feeding issues and did not have a present level to establish a baseline to measure progress in oral motor.

The program offer provided STUDENT with two 30-minute speech-language therapy sessions per week at school. Petitioner did not dispute the amount of speech-language services. STUDENT’s greatest deficits were in receptive and expressive language. Therefore, it was of the utmost importance that the District establish sufficient present levels in receptive and expressive language so that baselines could be established and progress measured. However, as discussed in detail above, the Hearing Officer found that the District failed to establish appropriate present levels in receptive and expressive language. That failure led to the development of deficient goals and objectives for receptive and expressive language. Although the structure of the classroom provided daily opportunities for STUDENT to develop his communication skills and Mrs. Abrassart had assessed STUDENT and understood his needs, a critical feature of the IEP–measurable goals and objectives--was missing. Because the program design was deficient in this very important area of need for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer was not designed to meet his unique needs for the development of receptive and expressive language.

2. Was the District’s program offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit?

The appropriateness of an IEP team program offer is evaluated at the time it is made. (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999) (citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993))

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that the District’s offer was designed to meet his needs for a small, structured classroom environment and for developing social and adaptive skills, and increasing attention to task. The Hearing Officer finds that the offer was also reasonably calculated to provide benefit to STUDENT in those areas, and in fact, did provide some benefit. (Footnote 37) However, the Hearing Officer also found that the District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of visual motor, oral motor feeding issues, and in receptive and expressive language. The Hearing Officer finds that for the same reasons discussed above, the District’s offer also was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit in these areas.

The evidence establishes that the District’s program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit except in the areas of oral motor feeding issues, visual motor, and receptive and expressive language as discussed above. (Footnote 38)

3. Did the District program and services comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

Petitioner contends that during the 2002-2003 school year, the District failed to provide him with OT services in accordance with his IEP. Under his December 2002 IEP, STUDENT was to receive one hour of individual OT services in the home two times per week in 30-minute sessions. As noted above, Ms. Lindemulder could not recall when, where and for what length of time she was able to provide OT services to STUDENT during the spring of 2003. Petitioner argues in his brief that he missed 16 thirty-minute sessions during the spring of 2003. The evidence establishes that STUDENT failed to receive 15 thirty-minute sessions during the period January 14, 2003, to June 13, 2003 – for a total of 450 minutes. (Footnote 39) This determination is derived from the testimony of Ms. Lindemulder and Exhibit 83 which sets forth the dates of services, the duration of services, the location of services, and the reasons services were not provided.

Petitioner also contends that the District failed to document his progress as provided by his initial IEP. (Footnote 40)

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s documentation of STUDENT’s progress at Buchanan was adequate. Ms. Lamothe provided a report card/progress report each quarter. (Exh.26.) It is also undisputed that she sent a logbook home for review by PARENT each week although the logbook was discarded by Ms. Lamothe. Ms. Lamothe wrote in the notebook approximately once every two weeks. (Test. of PARENT.) PARENT acknowledged that she was in frequent telephone contact with Ms. Lamothe concerning STUDENT’s progress, and Ms. Lamothe credibly testified that she would phone PARENT whenever anything significant occurred in the classroom. (Test. of Ms. Lamothe and PARENT.)

With regard to OT services, the December 2002 IEP did not require that progress records be maintained. Nevertheless, Ms. Lindemulder did maintain records, brought with her to the hearing, and Ms. Lindemulder testified credibly and in detail about the services she provided to STUDENT. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer has already found that the District failed to establish that it comported with STUDENT’s IEP regarding the provision of OT services as discussed above. The Hearing Officer finds that the failure of the District to provide written OT progress records for STUDENT for the relevant periods did not result in a failure to comport with his IEP.

4. Was the District’s offer of placement in STUDENT’s least restrictive environment?

Petitioner did not raise as an issue for hearing whether the District’s offer of placement was in the LRE.

C. Did the District offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for 2003 ESY?

On the December 10, 2002 IEP, the box was checked for ESY, indicating that STUDENT would receive ESY services. The following notation is next to the box: “to maintain levels.” (Exh. 25.) However, the IEP did not provide additional details about the 2003 ESY placement or services and whether STUDENT would be provided with direct OT and speech-language services.

However, it is undisputed that STUDENT attended the 2003 ESY program for four weeks in July 2003. PARENT testified that STUDENT attended the program. Moreover, Ms. Brennan, OTR, testified that she provided STUDENT with OT services in a group setting two times per week during 2003 ESY and that she did not miss any OT sessions. PARENT also testified that STUDENT received OT services during 2003 ESY, but was not sure about speech and language services.

STUDENT’s preschool SDC teacher for 2003 ESY was not identified by document and the 2003 ESY teacher did not testify at the hearing. Ms. Lamothe testified that she did not teach the 2003 ESY program. Moreover, the District failed to provide evidence, either by testimony or by document, to show that the District provided STUDENT with direct speech and language services during 2003 ESY. Ms. Abrassart stated that she provided direct speech-language services to STUDENT at Buchanan preschool for the period January 2003 through June 2003 but not during 2003 ESY. Ms. Piper stated that she did not begin providing speech-language services to STUDENT until late August or early September 2003, when she first met him. Ms. Gidley participated in STUDENT’s initial speech-language assessment but did not say that she ever provided speech-language services to STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer finds that although limited evidence indicates that STUDENT attended an 2003 ESY program for four weeks in July and did receive OT services, the District failed to establish at hearing that the ESY program was a FAPE or that the District provided direct speech and language services to STUDENT. The nature and quality of the evidence presented at hearing simply lacked sufficient detail to establish that the 2003 ESY program was a FAPE. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for 2003 ESY.

In summary, as discussed above, the District’s program offered or provided to STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year and ESY was deficient for the following reasons: (1) The District failed to establish that it provided STUDENT with any direct instructional services during the first six weeks of the school year, from mid-August 2002 through September 2002. Moreover, during the six-week period, the District failed to provide STUDENT with 900 minutes of OT services and failed to provide STUDENT with twenty-four hours of direct instructional services in accordance with Petitioner’s IFSP. (2) The District’s program failed to comport with Petitioner’s IFSP during the period October 2002 through December 20, 2002, in that the District failed to provide STUDENT with 480 minutes of OT services and failed to provide STUDENT with twelve hours of direct instructional services. (3) The District’s program failed to comport with Petitioner’s IEP in the spring of 2003 in that the District failed to provide STUDENT with 450 minutes of OT services. (4) The District failed to design a program to meet Petitioner’s unique needs for oral and visual motor functioning and in receptive and expressive language for the 2002-2003 school year. (5) The District failed to establish that it provided STUDENT with a FAPE during ESY 2003. The Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year and ESY.

ISSUE NO. 3: Should the District have identified STUDENT as a child with autistic-like behaviors during the period October 2003 through January 2004?

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that Petitioner did not meet California eligibility criteria for exhibiting autistic-like behaviors in the fall of 2002. Because STUDENT was given a clinical diagnosis of autism by Dr. Reeker in June of 2003, the District re-evaluated him in the fall of 2003. After PARENT signed an assessment plan on August 12, 2003, school psychologist Gabriela DiGiovanni began her assessment of STUDENT in September and early October 2003. Ms. DiGiovanni reported her findings in a final draft report dated October 12, 2003. (Exh. 43.) Ms. DiGiovanni testified that she reviewed the District’s prior psychological assessment report of October 2002 as well as Dr. Reeker’s CHOC assessment. Ms. DiGiovanni also spoke with Ms. Lamothe before and during the assessment as well as with occupational therapist Tiffany Knudsen and speech-language therapist Lisa Piper. Ms. DiGiovanni also directly observed STUDENT for approximately four or five hours in his SDC classroom and at the State preschool. Ms. DiGiovanni also administered the following standardized test instruments: the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence (WPPSI), the Beery-Buktenica Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration, the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale (Vineland) -- Classroom and Interview editions, the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale (GARS) -- completed by Mrs. Lamothe and PARENT, and the Behavior Assessment Scale for Children (BASC), preschool edition, parent and teacher rating scales completed by Mrs. Lamothe and PARENT, respectively. PARENT also completed a checklist for sensory functioning. (Footnote 41)

Ms. DiGiovanni reported that STUDENT had made “continuous growth” in his educational program, that there were no longer any difficulties with compliance, and that his behavior hadimproved. STUDENT was found to be engaging “far more than previously noted.” However, the parent and teacher ratings on adaptive and behavioral measures were found to be “significantly discrepant.” Ms. DiGiovanni explained that the differences in reporting “may be attributed to the context” in which STUDENT is observed by the different raters and that STUDENT’s behaviors may be specific to the respective home and preschool environments. Ms. DiGiovanni concluded that STUDENT’s behaviors may suggest a pervasive developmental disorder (PDD), but also concluded that it was not significantly affecting STUDENT in the educational setting. Ms. DiGiovanni further noted that STUDENT appeared to be most affected by his continued language deficits, which appeared to affect his “global functioning,” and that the IEP team “may consider” STUDENT’s primary eligibility under the category of speech/language impairment, but not autism. (Test. of Ms. DiGiovanni and Exh. 43.)

As noted above, the parties are in agreement that STUDENT met criterion (1) in the fall of 2003, because he continued to exhibit an inability to use oral language for appropriate communication. The parties dispute whether STUDENT met criteria (2), (3), (4), (5), and (7) in the fall of 2003. Thus, the Hearing Officer again considers the criteria in dispute in light of the evidence related to the District’s program experience with STUDENT during the spring and fall of 2003 and Ms. DiGiovanni’s reassessment of STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer first considers criterion (2) – whether STUDENT exhibited a “history of extreme withdrawal or relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction from infancy through early childhood.” The evidence establishes that STUDENT was sociable and enjoyed social interactions with adults and peers as discussed below.

Ms. Abrassart, speech-language pathologist, worked with STUDENT throughout the spring of 2003. She testified that she quickly regretted and felt a little foolish over the IEP team decision to provide STUDENT with one-on-one speech-language services, because STUDENT responded so well to group sessions with peers and he progressed very rapidly in group. Ms. Abrassart stated that she had a caseload of autistic children who were identified as “overtly” autistic as well as a caseload for language-impaired kids and that STUDENT was in the language-impaired group. Ms. Abrassart described STUDENT as “light years ahead” of the autistic children. By way of comparison, she stated that she could not get her autistic kids to be “terribly interactive,” and that had she placed STUDENT with the autistic kids, he would have been “bored stiff” and she would have had trouble holding his attention. Ms. Abrassart testified that STUDENT’s peer interactions were appropriate to his level of language and that she did see, over the course of the year, improvement in his peer interactions. Ms. Piper, speech-language pathologist, testified that STUDENT performed better in small-group speech-language therapy sessions during the fall of 2003 because he was motivated by peers. Ms. Knudsen, occupational therapist, also believed that STUDENT was motivated by peer interaction during the fall of 2003 and recommended that OT sessions occur in a group and not a one-on-one setting.

Ms. DiGiovanni observed STUDENT several times for four to five hours in the fall of 2003 during her assessment. Ms. DiGiovanni noted that STUDENT greeted adults in the classroom (for example, STUDENT was observed saying, “Hi, Mr. Palmer” and “Hi Mr. Wally”) and that he smiled in response to reciprocal greetings. STUDENT was also observed to say “Look at me” to Mr. Palmer while playing with a toy car. Ms. DiGiovanni testified that STUDENT socialized well with adults and peers in the classroom and that he was actually one of the most “interactive” children when she observed him. Ms. DiGiovanni stated that STUDENT played appropriately with other kids, but noted that the difficulties he did experience with interactions were primarily because of his difficulty with communication skills, because he tended to not converse as much and engage as much as the other children. Ms. DiGiovanni stated that STUDENT greeted adults by name in the classroom and laughed and engaged appropriately and did not tantrum or engage in unusual behaviors. STUDENT did not demonstrate unusual emotional responses and responded well to her praise throughout a therapy session with that she observed. STUDENT initiated eye contact, but did not sustain eye contact, especially when there was a lot of conversation and language involved. STUDENT participated in circle time activities and transitioned very smoothly from one activity to the next, whether it was a planned activity or not. (Test. of Ms. DiGiovanni.) Based upon her observations conducted in the SDC classroom, in the State preschool, and on the playground, as well as STUDENT’s performance, and after consideration of teacher and parent reporting on the Vineland, Ms. DiGiovanni concluded that no significant behaviors were reported in the school setting, although significant behaviors were being reported in the home/community setting by PARENT. (Footnote 42)

Dr. Kitlowski testified that she observed STUDENT a couple of times in the SDC classroom during the school year and noted that he was able to initiate interactions with peers and play “the way three- and four-year-olds do” who go up and ask to enter play or who just gather and start playing. By comparison, Dr. Kitlowski noted that children who present with moderate or severe autism typically do not have the ability to interact with other children and that things have to be “pretty structured”’ for them to participate in activities with other children. Dr. Kitlowski described STUDENT as “more flexible” and noted that STUDENT seemed to want to be around other children and wanted to be part of circle time.

Ms. Lindemulder recalled that during the spring of 2003, STUDENT did not want to stop playing with his friends at preschool and would “strain” to get back to his group upon seeing her at the Buchanan preschool when she came for his pull-out OT sessions. On three occasions, Ms. Lindemulder did not provide pull-out services at Buchanan because of this. Ms. Lindemulder also stated that when she provided in-home OT services, STUDENT wanted to join his siblings in the living room rather than engage in fine motor activities in his bedroom.

STUDENT was interacting with peers and adults so well that he progressed from Ms. Lamothe’s preschool morning program in the spring of 2003 to the afternoon program for older children in the fall of 2003, to give him greater opportunities to interact with nondisabled peers in the State preschool class. STUDENT’s mother wanted and agreed to the change. (Test. of PARENT.) Additionally, STUDENT’s ability to interact well with adult aides was an important factor in Ms. Lamothe’s recommendation that STUDENT attend the State preschool inclusion class with older children. The Hearing Officer finds it implausible that a program change of this nature would have occurred had STUDENT been interacting inappropriately with people or exhibiting a continued significant impairment in social interactions. Ms. Knudsen, OTR, testified that when she “overlapped” with Ms. Pullman, OTR, in the fall of 2003, STUDENT was excited to see her and would greet Ms. Pullman by saying, “Miss Michelle, Miss Michelle.”

In summary, the persuasive and consistent evidence establishes that STUDENT did not exhibit extreme withdrawal in any environments. The evidence also establishes that STUDENT generally related to adults and peers appropriately at preschool and that the difficulties he experienced with interactions were primarily because of his difficulty with communication skills. The Hearing Officer finds that whatever difficulties he had interacting with others were a result of his delays in receptive and expressive language. The Hearing Officer finds that he did not meet criterion 2.

Regarding criterion (3), there is no evidence that STUDENT exhibited an obsession to maintain sameness during the spring of 2003 or during the fall of 2003. The evidence suggests otherwise -- an interest in variety and a high degree of activity. STUDENT did not exhibit an obsession to maintain sameness in Ms. Lamothe’s class: STUDENT engaged in the full range of activities offered within his SDC preschool classroom during the various circle times. (Test. of Ms. Lamothe, Dr. Kitlowski and Ms. DiGiovanni) Ms. Lindemulder testified that STUDENT engaged in a variety of fine motor activities. During a CARD assessment Dr. Bostani conducted of STUDENT on January 29, 2004, that lasted several hours, she noted both STUDENT’s restlessness and his ability to engage in different activities. (Footnote 43) Moreover, Dr. Bostani also observed that STUDENT generally demonstrated appropriate play throughout the session, played “spontaneously” with a car garage and airplane, and “required minimal prompting to vary his play.” There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT exhibited an “obsession to maintain sameness” in any environment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT did not meet criterion 3.

Regarding criterion (4), the evidence establishes that although STUDENT’s use of objects at home was sometimes inappropriate (putting items into his mouth, etc.), STUDENT did not demonstrate an inappropriate use of objects in the SDC classroom and during DIS services in the spring and fall of 2003. Moreover, Dr. Reeker reported in the CHOC assessment in June that STUDENT’s behavior of putting items into his mouth had improved since STUDENT started using a toothbrush (recommended by Ms. Abrassart). Ms. DiGiovanni testified that when she observed STUDENT in the fall of 2003, STUDENT played with toys appropriately -- for example, he used cars appropriately and constructed a ramp at one point. Ms. DiGiovanni further noted that STUDENT didn’t engage in anything that was repetitive and that he expanded on his play. Although STUDENT exhibited a preoccupation with umbrellas during the rainy season in early January 2003 when he was just starting in Ms. Lamothe’s classroom and on one occasion during a speech-language therapy session with Ms. Abrassart when she first started working with STUDENT, there was no showing thereafter that STUDENT used an umbrella inappropriately. (Test. of Ms. Lamothe and Ms. Abrassart.) The evidence establishes that on each occasion, District staff members were able to redirect STUDENT away from his preoccupation with umbrellas. The umbrella was simply removed from the SDC classroom and from Ms. Abrassart’s office, and STUDENT did not continue to perseverate about umbrellas. Moreover, STUDENT’s interest in umbrellas did not interfere with his education. Thus, there was no persuasive evidence to show that STUDENT’s preoccupation with umbrellas was extreme, and there was no showing that STUDENT exhibited an extreme preoccupation with any other objects, such as flashlights, while at Buchanan or during DIS services. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT did not meet criterion 4.

Regarding criterion 5, the evidence establishes that STUDENT did not exhibit extreme resistance to controls during the spring and fall of 2003. Ms. Melissa Lamothe, STUDENT’s SDC teacher during the period January 14, 2003, to June 11, 2003, and from August 2003 to October 29, 2003, testified that STUDENT did not exhibit autistic-like behaviors in her classroom and that tantrum behaviors that STUDENT exhibited in the early part of January 2003 (the first two weeks) were soon completely extinguished. Ms. Lamothe testified that she contacted PARENT regarding STUDENT’s behaviors and discussed them with Dr. Kitlowski who provided her with ideas and suggestions. Ms. Lamothe stated that by the end of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT exhibited no more tantrumming and that she gave him choices and prompted him on what was coming up next and that he adapted very well to the classroom setting. Ms. Lamothe also stated that she didn’t see tantrumming when he exited the program in the fall of 2003. District witnesses testified uniformly that STUDENT improved his ability to attend to tasks and to follow directions during the spring of 2003, although Ms. Abrassart acknowledged that STUDENT had some difficulties with frustration because he couldn’t communicate and his language skills were not what they should have been.

Ms. DiGiovanni testified that when she worked with him one-on-one during her assessment in the fall of 2003, STUDENT was “easily redirected” to task but required redirection throughout. Ms. DiGiovanni stated that she did not observe “externalized” behaviors such as aggression or tantrumming reported by PARENT, although she observed some attentional difficulties. Ms. DiGiovanni noted that STUDENT participated in circle time activities and to transition “very smoothly” from one activity to the next, whether or not it was a planned activity, and that STUDENT did not tantrum or engage in unusual behaviors. Ms. Knudsen testified that when she took over STUDENT’s OT therapy in early October 2003 from Michelle Pullman, STUDENT followed adult directives and did not demonstrate difficulty with the transition to her. Ms. Knudsen also stated that STUDENT did not engage in aggressive behavior or tantrum when she worked with him. Speech-language pathologist Lisa Piper stated that she worked with STUDENT in the fall of 2003 and that he was able to interact with her and was compliant, on task, and followed directions. Ms. Piper described STUDENT as “communicatively impaired” and stated that she didn’t witness any of the behaviors typically associated with autism.

CARD clinical supervisor Theresa Contreras testified that she did not observe STUDENT tantrum or display aggressive behaviors during the initial intake evaluation held on October 1, 2003. (Footnote 44) Dr. Bostani did not personally observe tantrumming during her January 29, 2004 CARD assessment and reported that STUDENT was generally cooperative throughout the session, that he separated from his mother and transitioned into the testing room smoothly, and that he provided “no resistance” to start the testing. Although Dr. Bostani noted that STUDENT showed “a great deal of impulsivity” while turning pages and by responding before instructions were completely given and often moved around in his seat, Dr. Bostani also reported that the behaviors were managed with a “system of social reinforcement (i.e., social praise, tickles), and the obtaining of desired foods and toys.” (Test. of Dr. Bostani and Exh. 50A.)

As discussed above, Ms. Lamothe noted that STUDENT did so well with social interaction that she recommended that STUDENT attend her afternoon SDC class for older students in the fall of 2003. Dr. Kitlowski concurred with Ms. Lamothe’s recommendation based upon observations she had made of STUDENT -- both at his home and in the classroom -- during the course of the school year. STUDENT could be easily redirected and his behaviors controlled. Dr. Kitlowski testified that when she observed STUDENT during the school year at his home while engaged in another matter, STUDENT responded well to time-outs administered by his father when he was being non-compliant. The evidence establishes that STUDENT did not exhibit an extreme resistance to controls. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT did not meet criterion 5.

Regarding criterion 7, all of the District staff members who either assessed STUDENT and/or worked with him testified that STUDENT did not engage in “self-stimulatory, ritualistic behaviors.” As discussed previously, Ms. Lamothe testified that when STUDENT started in her classroom in January 2003, he noticed an umbrella and STUDENT tantrummed and needed redirection -- but once the umbrella was removed from the classroom, STUDENT was able to focus on the program and the behavior did not reoccur. Ms. Joanne Abrassart, STUDENT’s speech-language pathologist for the period January 2003 to June 2003, testified that STUDENT did not demonstrate self-stimulatory, ritualistic behaviors except for a single incident involving an umbrella during a therapy session and that she dealt with it by removing the umbrella from her office. Ms. Abrassart characterized STUDENT’s behaviors as “fairly typical for his preschool age.” At no other time did Ms. Abrassart observe STUDENT obsess on any object during her speech therapy sessions with him, and Ms. Abrassart testified that she did not observe STUDENT engage in self-stimulatory, ritualistic behaviors.

As discussed above, Ms. Piper did not observe any behaviors typically associated with autism in the fall of 2003 and Ms. DiGiovanni testified that STUDENT did not use toys in a “self-stimulatory” or unusual manner and that STUDENT played with toys appropriately, using cars and constructing a ramp at one point and expanded on his play and did not engage in repetitive behavior. PARENT testified that STUDENT exhibited an obsession with flashlights, umbrellas and swords. Dr. Bostani testified that during her initial greeting with STUDENT, his first response was “I miss my flashlight” and that he perseverated on the topic of flashlights throughout her assessment. (Footnote 45) In her report, Dr. Bostani noted that STUDENT “spoke of and searched for flashlights on numerous occasions during free play breaks.” (Footnote 46) Dr. Granpeesheh testified that “the biggest area [of concern] is perseverative behaviors” on specific objects, and that “for awhile it was umbrellas, now it’s flashlights.” Dr. Granpeesheh characterized STUDENT’s interest in flashlights and umbrellas as an obsession and STUDENT’s behavior of repeatedly talking about flashlights as “self-stimulatory” and “perseverative.” Dr. Granpeesheh observed the flashlight behavior once during the January 29, 2004 assessment, three months after STUDENT had been removed from District programming. None of the District witnesses testified to STUDENT’s speaking of or searching for flashlights at any time. (Footnote 47) (Test. of Ms. Lamothe, Ms. Abrassart, Ms. Lindemulder, Ms. Piper, and Ms. Knudsen.)

Dr. Kitlowski observed STUDENT on two occasions at his home and also observed STUDENT in the SDC preschool classroom approximately two times per month while STUDENT attended the program in the spring and fall of 2003, and did not observe an inappropriate use of objects or umbrellas and did not observe STUDENT speak of flashlight or search for flashlights at any time. Dr. Kitlowski testified that when she observed STUDENT in the home on another matter, she noted that sometimes STUDENT would ask his mother about an umbrella and would tantrum. However, there was no evidence that STUDENT ever perseverated on flashlights or swords at Buchanan. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s preoccupation with umbrellas was not extreme in the educational setting because District staff members were able to redirect him, and, according to the testimony of Ms. Lamothe, the behavior was extinguished by the early spring of 2003 and did not reoccur in her classroom.

To the extent that STUDENT engaged in “jargon-like” speech, the conduct, according to the credible testimony of District witnesses, revealed a communicative intent and was appropriate in context. (Test. of Ms. Abrassart, Ms. Piper and Dr. Kitlowski.) The utterances reflected STUDENT’s significant delays in receptive and expressive language and his desire to communicate. The use of jargon was not “self-stimulatory,” or “ritualistic” but reflected STUDENT’s social nature. No one testified that STUDENT sat alone, repeating jargon or video talk.

The Hearing Officer gives less weight to the observations of Dr. Bostani, who only observed STUDENT once in a clinical setting on January 29, 2004, and to the observations of Dr. Granpeesheh, who saw STUDENT “for a few hours” on January 29 and a second time a week to ten days prior to testifying to prepare for the due process hearing. (Footnote 48) Neither Dr. Bostani nor Dr. Granpeesheh observed STUDENT at Buchanan preschool or at his home. Moreover, Dr. Bostani noted in her report that STUDENT “generally demonstrated” appropriate social interaction with the assessor and was “generally cooperative” during the lengthy (several hours) CARD assessment. Dr. Granpeesheh described STUDENT as a “good kid” and stated that he has “really reduced significantly his maladaptive behaviors” and that he’s “not really tantrumming or highly aggressive right now,” although Dr. Granpeesheh generally characterized STUDENT’s behaviors as “maladaptive.” However, Dr. Granpeesheh’s testimony lacked detail. Dr. Granpeesheh relied on memory to recall specific instances of STUDENT’s behavior on the two occasions she observed him and stated that she did not reduce her March 2004 observations of STUDENT to writing and said that she “just spent time with him” and reviewed the CARD assessment report and “checked the behaviors.” The Hearing Officer also gives less weight to test protocols completed by PARENT, either alone or by interview, during the District’s reassessment in the fall of 2003 and during the CARD assessment on January 29, 2004, because the protocols reflected PARENT’s observations in the home and community environments but not in the preschool environment. PARENT did not testify to any classroom observations that she made of STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the detailed testimony of STUDENT’s teachers, DIS providers, and assessors who worked with him in a preschool setting over prolonged periods of time -- Ms. Baird, Ms. Lamothe, Ms. Lindemulder, Dr. Kitlowski, Ms. Abrassart, Ms. DiGiovanni, Ms. Piper, and Ms. Knudsen – and less weight to protocol responses given by PARENT and to the CARD assessment that occurred on January 29, 2004, which did not include any observations made of STUDENT by Dr. Bostani or Dr. Granpeesheh, either at preschool (STUDENT was no longer attending preschool) or at his home.

Regarding Dr. Reeker’s clinical diagnosis of autism in June 2003, the Hearing Officer notes that DSM-IV criteria do not establish eligibility. The Hearing Officer must apply the criteria for autism from federal and State special education law.

Additionally, Dr. Reeker’s report does not refer to observations made either at home or at preschool, but in the clinical setting only. Nor did Dr. Reeker communicate with District staff members concerning STUDENT’s behaviors in preschool. Moreover, Dr. Reeker did not testify at the hearing, and so the Hearing Officer must give Dr. Reeker’s findings “due weight.” (Footnote 49) In summary, the evidence establishes that Petitioner did not engage in self-stimulatory, ritualistic behaviors in the fall of 2003.

Based on the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not meet special education eligibility criteria for autistic-like behaviors during the period October . 2003 through January 2004.

ISSUE NO. 4: Did the District offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 ESY?

A. 2003-2004 Regular School Year

As discussed above, for the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer found that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE. From the period August through September 2002, the District did not provide STUDENT with an interim 30-day placement. During the period October to December 10, the District’s program did not comport with STUDENT’s interim placement. Moreover, the IEP was deficient in several areas as discussed above and failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE. STUDENT entered the 2003-2004 regular school year under the same IEP of December 10, 2002, that was in effect until the end of the 2002-2003 school year. Since there was no evidence that STUDENT’s needs had changed as of the beginning of 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District continued to deny STUDENT a FAPE from the beginning of the school year until at least the October IEP of 2003.

In addition to the deficiencies in the IEP for this period, the District did not provide all the services required by the IEP. Regarding the period August 2003 to October 10, 2003, the Hearing Officer finds that although the District established that Ms. Knudsen, occupational therapist, provided STUDENT with OT services in late September and throughout October 2003, the District did not establish that OT service were provided in August or during most of September. Although Ms. Knudsen testified that she “overlapped” the OT services of Ms. Pullman, Ms. Pullman did not testify at hearing. Moreover, the District did not provide reliable documentary evidence that Ms. Pullman provided OT services to comport with STUDENT’s IEP during the months of August and September of 2003. PARENT testified that she was unaware that Ms. Pullman had provided OT services to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to establish that it provided STUDENT with six weeks of OT services during the period mid-August 2003 through September 2003, for a total of 12 thirty-minutes sessions (360 minutes of OT services).

The Hearing Officer also finds that the District failed to establish that STUDENT was provided with direct speech-language therapy services during the first two weeks of the school year in August 2003. Ms. Piper, STUDENT’s speech-language therapist in the fall of 2003, testified that she took over as a new speech-language therapist during the second or third week of the school year and that STUDENT to her knowledge had not received speech therapy services from any other speech therapist at the beginning of the school year. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEP because it did not establish that STUDENT received two hours of speech-language therapy services during the first two weeks of the 2003-2004 school year.

The Hearing Officer now addresses the District’s program offer made at the October 10, 2003 IEP meeting for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer will address the 2004 ESY separately.

1. Procedural appropriateness

The Ninth Circuit has held that procedural violations of the IDEA do not automatically result in a denial of a FAPE unless there is a showing of prejudice; i.e., a loss of educational opportunity or a serious infringement on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992).

Petitioner asserts that the District committed a procedural violation because it failed to invite a regular education teacher to the October 10, 2003 IEP meeting and failed to invite an occupational therapist and a CARD representative to the November 14, 2003 IEP meeting. The District asserts that its failure to have a regular education teacher in attendance at the October IEP meeting did not result in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT and did not result in a serious infringement of parental participation in the IEP process. The District contends that it wasn’t required to have an occupational therapist in attendance at the November meeting because the District did not conduct an OT assessment of STUDENT. The District also contends that it was not obligated to invite a CARD representative to the November meeting because Petitioner’s parents had placed him unilaterally in the CARD program.

California Education Code section 56341(b), in pertinent part, provides that the IEP team shall include all of the following: (2) At least one regular education teacher of the pupil, if the pupil is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment...(5) An individual who conducted an assessment of the pupil or who is knowledgeable about the assessment procedures used to assess the pupil, and is familiar with the assessment results or recommendations...(6) At the discretion of the parent...or the district...other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil, including related services personnel, as appropriate. The determination of whether the individual has knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil shall be made by the party who invites the individual to be a member of the IEP team.

The District acknowledges that a regular education teacher was not in attendance at the October 10, 2003 IEP meeting. However, the District argues that this omission was not a procedural violation because Ms. Lamothe, STUDENT’s SDC preschool teacher, attended the meeting, was already familiar with the regular education program, had a regular education credential, and had received information regarding STUDENT from the State preschool teacher, Ms. McGinn.

Ms. Lamothe’s unrebutted testimony establishes that she has a California professional clear multiple subject teaching credential which allows her to teach from preschool through high school and adult education classes. Further, Ms. Lamothe described the State preschool program in detailed testimony and stated that she has observed the program. Moreover, the evidence establishes that Ms. Lamothe received information about STUDENT from Ms. Karen McGinn prior to the October 10 IEP meeting, and that PARENT participated in the October 10 IEP meeting and was able to express her thoughts and concerns and to add to different portions of the IEP. Furthermore, STUDENT had already received his initial intake evaluation from CARD on October 1, and PARENT was not seeking regular education. PARENT did not sign the October 10 IEP.

Additionally, the District augmented its October 10, 2003 IEP offer for the 2003-2004 school year at the November 14, 2003 IEP meeting when Ms. McGinn was available to participate by telephone. The Hearing Officer also notes in PARENT’s testimony that she was able to speak with Ms. McGinn at that time and that she received an update on STUDENT’s behaviors during his attendance that fall in the State preschool program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the absence of Ms. McGinn from the October 10, 2003 IEP meeting did not result in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT and did not result in a serious infringement on the rights of his parents to participate in the IEP meeting. Accordingly, the District did not commit a procedural violation as a result of Ms. Karen McGinn’s nonattendance at the October 10, 2003 IEP meeting.

With regard to the November 14, 2003 IEP meeting, the District asserts that an occupational therapist is not required to participate at an IEP meeting unless the therapist has conducted an assessment that will be reviewed at the IEP meeting, citing section 56341(5) of the Education Code. Id. The Hearing Officer finds that the District was not obligated to have an occupational therapist present at the November 14 IEP meeting. It is undisputed that Ms. Knudsen, an occupational therapist, was present at the October 10, 2003 IEP meeting, when present levels of performance and goals and objectives were reviewed and proposed. The Hearing Officer finds that the absence of an occupational therapist at the subsequent IEP meeting on November 14, a meeting that did not involve a review of an OT assessment, did not result in the loss of an educational opportunity for STUDENT and did not result in a serious infringement on parental participation in the November 14, 2003 IEP meeting.

As to the participation of a CARD representative, the District contends that a provider of a unilateral placement (i.e., CARD) is not a required participant at an IEP meeting under Education Code section 56341(b)(6). The District asserts that it would have been at the parent’s discretion to invite someone from CARD to attend. Petitioner argues in his brief that a recent Ninth Circuit opinion holds otherwise, and cites Shapiro v. Paradise Valley U.S.D., 317 F.3d 1072 (9th Cir. 2003) The Hearing Officer does not find Petitioner’s reliance on Shapiro persuasive. (Footnote 50) First, in Shapiro, the parents of the student were not invited to attend the IEP meeting, but in this case, PARENT was invited to and did attend all IEP meetings held for STUDENT. Second, in Shapiro, the private school teacher who had the most experience working with the student was not invited to participate in that IEP meeting. In contrast, the teachers with the most experience working with STUDENT, Ms. Lamothe, who taught STUDENT in the spring and fall of 2003, and Ms. Ms. Karen McGinn, who taught STUDENT in the fall of 2003 at the State preschool, participated in the November 14 meeting. Both teachers were knowledgeable about STUDENT’s unique needs. See W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees, 960 F.2nd 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992) Moreover, STUDENT had started receiving CARD services on November 10, just a few days before the November 14 IEP meeting. Therefore, any CARD representative who might have participated in the November 14 IEP meeting would not have had the level of experience with STUDENT that Ms. Lamothe and Ms. Ms. Karen McGinn had. Moreover, PARENT testified that she discussed the CARD program at the November 14 IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer further notes that PARENT could have invited a CARD representative to participate in the IEP meeting but apparently did not do so. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to invite a CARD program representative to the November 14, 2003 IEP meeting did not result in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT and did not result in a serious infringement on parental participation in the November 14 IEP meeting.

B. Substantive appropriateness of the October 10, 2003 IEP program offer

Petitioner contends that the District failed to delineate all present levels of performance and failed to identify his unique needs, particularly in oral motor and visual motor. Petitioner also contends that the District’s October 10, 2003 program offer was not designed to meet his unique needs. In addition, Petitioner contends that he needed a behavioral intervention plan. As a proposed resolution, Petitioner seeks private placement in a CARD program of forty-hours per week of discrete trial training provided to him in one-on-one sessions at his home.

The District asserts that it designed a program to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and also asserts that STUDENT does not need a behavioral intervention plan and does not need a forty-hour per week CARD program. The District further contends that the CARD program is not necessary for STUDENT to receive an educational benefit and that its one-on-one format is too restrictive for him and deprives him of needed opportunities for social interaction with peers, including nondisabled peers.

The IEP team met on October 10, 2003, for STUDENT’s annual review IEP meeting. The IEP team members discussed STUDENT’s present levels of performance and reviewed his progress on goals and objectives. Goals and objectives were also developed for the following school year. The IEP team discussed the CHOC autism diagnosis, and the team notes indicate that District program specialist Moussa Sabbara had indicated that a clinical and educational diagnosis of autism may differ. The team notes further indicate that PARENT would not agree to continued assessments offered by the District in the areas of behavior and OT and that she “will consult with her lawyer on this at this time.” The District members of the IEP team then presented the District’s “current” program offer that is discussed further within. PARENT would not sign the IEP. Moreover, the IEP meeting concluded without an agreement to continue the IEP meeting.

On October 22, 2003, Petitioner’s parents provided the District with written notice that STUDENT would be removed from the District program for unilateral placement with CARD and that Petitioner would seek reimbursement for those services. (Exh. 44.) STUDENT attended Buchanan until October 29 and then began receiving CARD services on November 10, 2003. Meanwhile, the District requested another IEP team meeting to discuss Petitioner’s request for CARD services and to discuss Ms. DiGiovanni’s “final” psycho-educational report. The IEP meeting was held on November 14, 2003, after STUDENT had already begun to receive CARD services.

The Hearing Officer finds that the parties had not agreed to a continuance of the October 10, 2003 IEP meeting. Moreover, it is undisputed that the District, and not Petitioner’s parents, requested the IEP meeting that was held on November 14 after STUDENT had already been removed from Buchanan on October 29. The Hearing Officer also notes that the District indicated on the November IEP that the District’s offer of FAPE “remains the IEP of 10/10/03,” even though the District, at the November 14 IEP meeting, offered the PIP intensive language program and 14 hours of behavioral consultation services to address behaviors in the home. The Hearing Officer finds that the October IEP program offer is the offer Petitioner’s parents reasonably relied on when they notified the District on October 22 that they were removing STUDENT from the District program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer analyzes the appropriateness of the District’s October 10, 2003 IEP offer.

1. Was the District’s October 10, 2003 IEP program offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

To determine if the October IEP offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is first necessary to determine STUDENT’s unique needs in the fall of 2003. As discussed above, because Petitioner raised as contentions for hearing that the District failed to delineate all of his present levels of performance for both the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years, the Hearing Officer first addresses STUDENT’s present levels of performance as of October 2003.

STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the fall of 2003 (Footnote 51)As noted above, Petitioner contends that the District failed to identify all present levels of performance. Although the parties provided substantial testimony and documentation regarding the present levels of performance set forth within the fall of 2002 IEPs, the parties did not provide testimony that specifically addressed the present levels of performance page for the October 2003 IEP. Some District witnesses commented indirectly on STUDENT’s present levels but did not address the specific language of the present levels page. The Hearing Officer briefly considers the entries for the IEP present levels of performance page.

Regarding the entry for communication, STUDENT’s present levels indicate that STUDENT is using sentences with four words interspersed with jargon, that he has a limited vocabulary and is beginning to use some syntactical concepts appropriately, and that he has difficulty with “wh” questions. Ms. Piper testified that STUDENT could follow two-step commands receptively when they were terms he was familiar with, and that he had some difficulties with prepositions and pronouns. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to establish that the communication entry was sufficient because the District had had several months of progam experience with STUDENT and should have provided more specific information about STUDENT’s levels of functioning in receptive and expressive language. For example, the reference to a limited vocabulary is vague. By October, the District knew the extent of STUDENT’s vocabulary and should have provided that information to develop a baseline for increasing STUDENT’s vocabulary. The reference to “some” syntactical concepts is also vague. The entry does not indicate which syntactical concepts STUDENT was beginning to use. Although the entry for difficulties with “wh” questions is important, it does not describe the difficulties STUDENT was experiencing. Moreover, the entry does not include Ms. Piper’s reference to difficulties with prepositions and pronouns. Although the Hearing Officer has already noted above that the present levels page need not contain exhaustive inventories of protocol information, in this case, because it is undisputed that STUDENT’s deficits in receptive and expressive language are his greatest area of need, greater specificity in formulating present levels was warranted because STUDENT was now four years of age and was only able to engage in very limited conversation. STUDENT’s IEP needed more specific information regarding his deficits in receptive and expressive language to develop baselines so that measurable goals and objectives in specific areas could be drafted and progress tracked. With appropriately measurable goals and objectives, the IEP team could then make necessary adjustments during the school year.

Petitioner also asserts that the present levels page is deficient because it lacks information regarding his present levels for semantics, syntax, and morphology and for executive functioning based upon diagnostic information from the TOLD and BRIEF-P assessments administered by the CARD assessor, Dr. Bostani, on January 29, 2004. However, the Hearing Officer does not consider the CARD assessment results because the information was not available for consideration by the IEP team when it made its program offer in October.

As noted above in the discussion concerning STUDENT’s present levels in the fall of 2002, the Hearing Officer found that the present levels were deficient because they did not include oral motor and visual motor functioning information. This information was also lacking on the October 2003 IEP. Moreover, Ms. DiGiovanni reported in the fall of 2003 that STUDENT’s visual motor integration (VMI) scores were weak. The Hearing Officer finds that the present levels page was deficient with regard to oral motor and visual motor functioning.

Under Reading, the present levels page indicates that STUDENT recognizes name in print, knows lower and upper case letters, can retell short stories 8-12 pages, and recites the story book “Brown Bear, Brown Bear.” Under written expression, the present levels page indicates that STUDENT can draw a face and person and can use scissors, and that for math, STUDENT can rote count to 30, recognize #1-10, and understands 6 basic quantitative concepts. Under behavior, the present levels page indicates that STUDENT follows classroom routines, wants to be a part of the group, likes to help others, and follows adult directives. Under daily living skills, the present levels page indicates that STUDENT is toilet trained, helps with dressing, eats independently, helps clean up after himself, and volunteers to help others. Under fine motor, the present levels page indicates that STUDENT is able to copy a horizontal, vertical line, a circle and a cross and is also able to cut on a 3 inch line with 80% accuracy using fine motor skills. Under social/emotional, that STUDENT enjoys playing with peers, likes making friends, will engage in make-believe play, and is remorseful if he disobeys rules.

Except as discussed above regarding speech-language, oral motor and visual motor, Petitioner made a general allegation that STUDENT’s other present levels for the fall of 2003 were inadequate, but no persuasive evidence was presented at hearing that the present levels identified above were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s present levels were not appropriate in receptive and expressive language, oral motor and visual motor, but were appropriate in the other areas. STUDENT’s unique needs in the fall of 2003

It is undisputed that Petitioner continued to have significant receptive and expressive language deficits, as well as deficits in fine motor, visual motor, sensory integration, development of peer interaction, the need for structure and to develop attention to task and need for redirection. Ms. DiGiovanni’s assessment confirmed the fact that STUDENT continued to have the same needs he had in the fall of 2002. For example, Ms. DiGiovanni noted in her report that STUDENT’s attention to task was short when compared to same-age peers, although she also noted that STUDENT was easily redirected. Ms. DiGiovanni also reported that STUDENT engaged in limited spontaneous conversation and his comprehension difficulties were evident because he required repetition on questions such as “how old are you? and “what is your teacher’s name?” Ms. DiGiovanni found that, if anything, STUDENT’s needs had intensified in receptive and expressive language and in visual motor integration based on the low score VMI results.

Petitioner contended that he also has oral motor needs. The Hearing Officer notes that PARENT reported to the CHOC assessor in June that STUDENT “used to mouth objects all of the time, but this [has] improved since the parents have given him some oral stimulation as recommended by the OT via a vibrating toothbrush.” (Exh. 28) The Hearing Officer finds that in light of STUDENT’s acknowledged improvement in oral motor, oral motor was not an area of need for STUDENT in the fall of 2003.

Petitioner asserts that he also has behavioral needs relating to his maladaptive behaviors. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT did not exhibit extreme resistance to controls during the spring and fall of 2003. Moreover, Ms. Lamothe testified that STUDENT’s tantrumming behaviors at Buchanan had been extinguished in the spring of 2003 and that he had made progress in attending to task and in following adult directives. Ms. DiGiovanni also testified to and reported STUDENT’s improvement in behavior and noted that there were no longer difficulties in compliance.

The October 10, 2003 team summary notes indicate the following: “PARENT would like input from Ms. Caron (State preschool teacher). Some of STUDENT’s behaviors in that setting were reported. Mrs. Lamothe shared that he cried during his initial attendance to the State preschool. No significant difficulties have been reported.” (Footnote 52) PARENT testified that she spoke with Ms. Karen (McGinn) and was satisfied with the information she received about STUDENT’s functioning at the State preschool. Ms. McGinn informed her that STUDENT was doing well in the State preschool and that his transitions were “slowly but surely” getting better. In the beginning, STUDENT had troubles going to the State preschool, but once he started going it was okay. (Test. of PARENT). Moreover, Ms. DiGiovanni, by assessment and testimony, noted no behavioral difficulties other than the need for some redirection throughout his activities based upon observations she made of STUDENT at the State preschool.

CARD clinical supervisor Teresa Contreras testified that STUDENT had many maladaptive behaviors in October and November 2003. (Footnote 53) However, Ms. Contreras acknowledged in her testimony that she did not observe STUDENT tantrum during STUDENT’s October 1, 2003 intake assessment, nor did she recall aggressive behaviors by him at the time. Moreover, Ms. Contreras acknowledged that she had not observed STUDENT at preschool at any time and had never observed the State preschool or the Buchanan preschool. The Hearing Officer notes that the testimony of Ms. Contreras relied largely on CARD logbook entries made by CARD junior therapists. The entries by the therapists, including entries regarding maladaptive behaviors, were made at a time when stringent demands were being placed upon STUDENT during 2-4 hour therapy sessions, with even the breaks monitored by CARD therapists. STUDENT was receiving up to 81/2 hours per day of intensive one-to-one CARD therapy, a significant increase over the District’s preschool program of two hours and forty-five minutes per Ms. Contreras was able to recall only a few anecdotal observations about STUDENT’s CARD therapy sessions. Moreover, Ms. Contreras did not speak with District staff members concerning how STUDENT was performing in school. (Footnote 54) (Test. of Ms. Contreras.)

The CARD assessor, Dr. Bostani, and the CARD director, Dr. Granpeesheh, did not observe STUDENT at Buchanan or at his home or in the community. Dr. Bostani and Dr. Granpeesheh did not speak with District staff members about STUDENT’s behavior at Buchanan. Moreover, the CARD assessment on January 29, 2004, was conducted several months after the District’s offer in early October. (Test. of Dr. Bostani and Dr. Granpeesheh.) The Hearing Officer gives less weight to the observations of CARD witnesses, and greater weight to the detailed testimony of District staff members (as discussed above) who worked directly with STUDENT in the preschool setting over a significant period of time and who testified consistently that STUDENT could be redirected and that he did not engage in tantrumming behavior at the Buchanan preschool after the behaviors were extinguished in the spring of 2003. The Hearing Officer finds that behavior was not an area of need for STUDENT in the fall of 2003.

In summary, STUDENT had unique needs in the following areas: receptive and expressive language, fine motor, visual motor, sensory integration, pre-academic, development of peer interaction, the need for structure, and the need to develop attention to task and the need for redirection.

The abundant, credible evidence establishes that STUDENT continued to need services and a small structured classroom for sensory integration, for the development of his skills in receptive and expressive language, fine motor, preacademic and social skills. STUDENT also continued to need the opportunity to develop interaction skills with nondisabled peers.

Although Petitioner did not raise specific contentions regarding the appropriateness of any of the goals developed by the IEP team on October 10, the Hearing Officer briefly reviews the goals and objectives.

Goal and objectives

The IEP team developed the following goals and objectives: (1) STUDENT will engage in social interaction with adults and peers; (2) STUDENT will attend to task for 7-10 minutes with sensory input first, with verbal prompts 80% of the time; (3) STUDENT will be able to identify 8 quantitative concepts by pictures and objects 80% of the time with teacher records; (4) STUDENT will be able to identify 8 directional/positional vocabulary by pointing to pictures or using manipulatives with 80% accuracy, with teacher records; (5) STUDENT will be able to answer simple ‘wh’ questions about presented objects/items/pictures in 4/5 trials; (6) STUDENT will be able to use personal pronouns in structured tasks in 4/5 trials; (6) STUDENT will be able to identify/use 30 new vocabulary terms including nouns & verbs, in trials; (7) STUDENT will be able to cut a square with 80% accuracy; (8) STUDENT will be able to trace his name with 80% accuracy.

The Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives developed at the October 10, 2003 IEP team addressed STUDENT’s needs in developing social interaction, attention to task, preacademic, receptive and expressive language, and fine motor skills.

However, because the Hearing Officer has found that the District failed to develop sufficient present levels of performance in the areas of receptive and expressive language, the Hearing Officer finds that the three goals and objectives developed by the IEP team in the area of receptive and expressive language lacked the necessary baselines to measure progress.

Placement and Services

The District team members offered the following program, described as the District’s “current offer,” at the October 10, 2003 IEP meeting: placement in an SDC afternoon classroom sixty minutes per day, four days per week; placement in the State inclusion program classroom 125 minutes per day, four days per week; (Footnote 55) speech-language services twice per week for 20 to 30 minute sessions; occupational services one time per week for 20 to 30 minute sessions. The District also offered an assessment plan to include assessments by an autism consultant and an occupational therapist to address behavioral and sensory issues raised by PARENT. The Hearing Officer now addresses whether the components of the District’s offer meets STUDENT’s unique needs.

With regard to the District’s offer of placement, PARENT testified that she agreed with the State inclusion program, but did not agree to continued placement in Ms. Lamothe’s SDC classroom. The Hearing Officer finds that the State inclusion program met STUDENT’s needs for developing interactions with nondisabled peers. Regarding the SDC classroom, none of the witnesses called by Petitioner specifically addressed or challenged the appropriateness of the SDC classroom or disputed the accuracy of Ms. Lamothe’s and Dr. Kitlowski’s description of the classroom.

The SDC classroom provided STUDENT with daily opportunities for sensory integration within the sensory integration center. Moreover, the SDC classroom continued to provide inclusion opportunities through the Community Friends program. The class also continued to address needs for a small structured classroom environment that supported the development of peer relationships, greater attention to task, and providing him with opportunities to work on goals and objectives. As discussed above, STUDENT continued to have significant speech-language needs in the fall of 2003, and the Hearing Officer finds that the SDC classroom continued to address STUDENT’s speech-language needs within a “language-rich” environment. However, speech-language addressed within the SDC was not sufficient to overcome a lack of appropriate speech-language services.

As to speech-language services, it is undisputed that STUDENT’s primary area of need is receptive and expressive language. The Hearing Officer first finds that the District’s speech-language therapy offer is, on its face, inappropriate, because it does not provide a precise time per session, an omission characterized by Ms. Abrassart as “illegal.” Moreover, the District’s October offer of 20-30 minutes represented a reduction of receptive and expressive language services from the prior school year when STUDENT was receiving one hour of direct speech-language services per week to address two goals and objectives although the October 2003 IEP team had drafted three goals.

PARENT testified that the PIP intensive language program was appropriate for STUDENT, and District witnesses acknowledged that STUDENT needed the PIP program to address his receptive and expressive language need. The District did not offer PIP until November 16. So, although the District acknowledged that STUDENT required additional speech-language services, it offered less. (Footnote 56) (Test. of Dr. Kitlowski and Ms. DiGivoanni.) Even with the addition of the PIP program, the program offered in November remained deficient for the reasons stated above regarding the present levels and goals and objectives for communication developed at the October IEP meeting as well as for the reasons discussed within concerning OT and visual motor. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s October offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in receptive and expressive language.

The Hearing Officer next finds that the District failed to establish that the offer of occupational therapy services of 20-30 minutes, a reduction from the previous school year, was appropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District failed to provide a substantial amount of OT services to STUDENT during the previous school year. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s October offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in occupational therapy.

The Hearing Officer also finds that the District failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in visual motor. As discussed above, the District failed to set present levels of performance for visual motor although it recognized that visual motor was an area of need for STUDENT.

Petitioner asserts that he needed a behavioral intervention plan to address maladaptive behaviors. The persuasive testimony of Ms. Lamothe, Ms. DiGiovanni, and Dr. Kitlowski establishes that the District had used behavioral modification techniques which proved successful during the 2002-2003 school year. Thus, the evidence did not establish that accommodations and modifications were unsuccessful necessitating the development of a behavioral intervention plan for the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer finds that a behavioral intervention plan was not needed for STUDENT at Buchanan or at the State preschool. District witnesses testified persuasively that the small structured SDC classroom, with appropriate behavioral strategies for redirection implemented by trained staff that had proved successful during the 2002-2003 school year were appropriate behavioral support for STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year. Additionally, while STUDENT attended the State preschool classroom with other children participating in the inclusion program, an aide accompanied STUDENT and class members from the SDC classroom. As noted above, although STUDENT experienced difficulties initially transitioning into the State preschool classroom, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s behavior improved in that environment as well.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs except for the areas of receptive and expressive language, occupational therapy, and visual motor.

2. Was the District’s IEP offer on October 10, 2003, reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit?

For the same reasons discussed above regarding the design of STUDENT’s program, the evidence establishes that the District’s October 2003 program offer was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit for developing peer interactions both within the SDC classroom and within the State preschool. The program offer was also reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in improving his attention to task and need for redirection, with preacademics, and in providing him with sensory integration opportunities within the SDC classroom.

Nevertheless, as discussed above, the October program offer was not appropriate to address STUDENT’s very significant receptive and expressive language needs and his needs in occupational therapy and in visual motor.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit as discussed above, except in the areas of receptive and expressive language, occupational therapy, and visual motor.

3. Did the District comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

This item is not addressed because Petitioner’s parents would not consent to the District’s October 10, 2003 IEP offer, and Petitioner was removed from the District program by his parents on October 29, 2003.

4. Was the District’s offer of placement in STUDENT’s least restrictive environment?

Petitioner did not raise as an issue for hearing whether the District’s offer of placement was in the LRE.

As described above, the District failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEP from August to the October 10, 2003 IEP meeting. Moreover, because the District failed to offer a program and services to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in receptive and expressive language, occupational therapy, and visual motor, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s October 10, 2003 program offer failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year. (Footnote 57)

Did the District fail to offer a FAPE for the 2004 ESY? (Footnote 58)

In the parties’ joint issue statement, Petitioner asserted that the District had failed to offer him a FAPE for 2004 extended school year. The District argues that the issue is not ripe, that a denial of a FAPE for 2004 ESY has not occurred yet and that the District has yet to determine the exact 2004 ESY placement for Petitioner and that it needs to hold a transition IEP meeting to consider STUDENT’s transition from preschool to kindergarten (STUDENT turns five this summer). Petitioner argues that the issue is ripe because the IEP team had already made a program offer for the period October 2003 through October 2004, which includes 2004 ESY, at Petitioner’s annual IEP review meeting held on October 10, 2003. Petitioner further asserts that the District made its “standard” SDC offer for 2004 ESY by checking the ESY box on the IEP form.

California Education Code section 56445(a) provides that “prior to transitioning an individual with exceptional needs from a preschool program to kindergarten, or first grade as the case may be, an appropriate reassessment of the individual shall be conducted pursuant to Article 2 (commencing with Section 56320) of Chapter 4 to determine if the individual is still in need of special education and services.” [emphasis added.]. Although neither party contends that STUDENT is not still in need of special education and services, section 56445(a) expressly requires that an appropriate reassessment be conducted of a preschool child who is transitioning into kindergarten. Several witnesses who testified on behalf of Petitioner and District anticipated that STUDENT will be transitioning into kindergarten this fall as a five-year-old. (Test. of Ms. Lamothe, Ms. Preston, PARENT, and Dr. Granpeesheh)

Ms. Preston, director of special education, stated that during the period April to June, the Murrieta District customarily conducts “some kind of assessment” (not necessarily formal) for transitioning preschoolers and discusses the assessment results at an IEP meeting held at that time. The IEP team decides whether the preschooler participates in an ESY program with kindergartners or in a program with other preschoolers. (Test. of Ms. Preston.) The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team in October and November 2003 could not provide a specific 2004 ESY offer because it was not known then whether STUDENT would be transitioning into kindergarten in the fall of 2004. Moreover, the November 2003 IEP offer made by the District team members was not implemented because Petitioner was removed from his District placement and placed unilaterally by his parents in a forty-hour-per-week CARD program. CARD program witnesses described dramatic gains made by STUDENT in the CARD program, and therefore an IEP team would consider that information as well as any other information developed by assessment, formal or informal, to develop an appropriate 2004 ESY for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the FAPE issue for ESY 2004 is not ripe because the District has an obligation to assess STUDENT to determine the appropriate ESY placement for STUDENT, who is expected to transition into kindergarten in the fall of 2004.

ISSUE NO. 5: If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for any of the above-mentioned periods, are his parents entitled to full reimbursement for the costs related to the CARD program?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services incurred for their child when a school district has failed to offer or provide a student a FAPE. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994.). However, parents are not required to obtain a placement or services that is the exact, proper one required under the IDEA in order to receive reimbursement. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 79 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986) The parents are entitled to reimbursement if their placement or services met the student’s unique needs and provided the student with educational benefit. Id.

STUDENT’s parents seek full reimbursement for the costs related to the CARD program for the period November 10, 2003, through June 2004 (or date of Decision) As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year and ESY because the District’s program for the school year was deficient in the following ways: (1) the District failed to provide Petitioner with an interim placement during a six-week period, from August 14, 2002, through September 2002, and thus failed to provide STUDENT with 900 minutes of OT services and 24 hours of direct instructional services; (2) the District failed to comport with Petitioner’s IFSP during the period October 2002 through December 20, 2002, by failing to provide STUDENT with 480 minutes of OT services and 12 hours of direct instructional services during that period; (3) the District failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEP in the spring and fall of 2003 by not providing STUDENT with 810 minutes of OT services and two hours of speech-language services. (4) The District failed to design a program to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in oral motor, visual motor, and in receptive and expressive language; and (5) the District also denied STUDENT a FAPE for ESY 2003 for the reasons discussed above. The Hearing Officer also found that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year because the program offer was deficient by not meeting his unique needs in speech-language, occupational therapy, and visual motor.

In weighing the amount of reimbursement to be awarded, the Hearing Officer takes into consideration the behavior of Petitioner’s parents, who refused to consent to the District’s assessment on June 14, 2002, and refused to provide consent to a neuropsychological assessment the District was willing to undertake at District expense unless the District agreed to an assessor of their choosing. The Hearing Officer finds that the position taken by Petitioner’s parents improperly delayed the District’s assessment, which contributed to delays in services and delays in the initial IEP process. The two assessment plans signed by PARENT appear to include language added either by her or by her advocate. Petitioner appears to have changed the terms of the District’s assessment plans, and the Hearing Officer finds that this conduct also contributed to the District’s delays in assessing STUDENT and the scheduling of STUDENT’s initial IEP meetings. Moreover, the overall position of Petitioner’s parents appeared to relate more to the issue of labeling STUDENT autistic, and less on the issues of program and services for STUDENT in the fall of 2002.

Nevertheless, the District was under a legal obligation to provide a timely interim placement for STUDENT as an incoming preschooler with significant developmental delays and did not establish at hearing that it did so for a period of six weeks. As discussed above, the District failed to provide an immediate 30-day interim placement to STUDENT, and the District did not make its complete full program offer until December 10, 2002, just a few weeks prior to the start of the winter break (December 21, 2002.) Petitioner did not begin his full District programming until January 14, 2004.

The District argues that the CARD placement was not appropriate for STUDENT and did not meet his needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of CARD staff members establishes that the services provided by CARD were appropriate to address STUDENT’s language and fine motor deficits.

The District also argues that the CARD placement is too restrictive and that CARD staff members were not credentialed or licensed to provide speech-language and OT services. The Hearing Officer finds the argument unavailing because a parental placement may be found to be appropriate by a hearing officer even if it does not meet the State standards that apply to education provided by the SEA and LEA’s. See 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(c).

Although the CARD program is an ABA program that primarily addresses behavior, Dr. Granpeesheh testified that the CARD program includes a developed curriculum to address language needs. Ms. Contreras testified in detail concerning the discrete trial drills provided to STUDENT within many curriculum program areas developed by CARD as documented in the CARD logbook. STUDENT received daily language drills and fine motor drills. Examples of some of the CARD programs that CARD therapist implemented with are the following: conversational questions such as name?, how old? favorite color?, how are you? that are designed to elicit a verbal response; another is describe/guess, where the child is asked to show something; other program drills involve the use of prepositions, pronouns, receptive commands, “wh” rotations, and placing two-dimensional items in story sequence. (Test. of Ms. Contreras and Exh. 55.)

The evidence also establishes that the CARD program provided STUDENT with an educational benefit in language and in fine motor. The Hearing Officer notes the credible testimony of Ms. Contreras that STUDENT made progress in the CARD program and had met District goals and objectives.

The Hearing Officer also takes into consideration that because CARD does not provide direct OT services, there is no direct causal link between the failure of the District to provide OT services and the overall services provided under the CARD program. However, the evidence does show that CARD provided services in fine motor and worked with STUDENT on his coloring. Moreover, in determining that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY and did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs in receptive and expressive language, the Hearing Officer noted many deficiencies in the District’s programming for the period August 2002 through October 2003. OT services were a particularly important part of STUDENT’s interim programming during the period August 2002 through December 2002. The Hearing Officer finds that the nature and extent of the deficiencies as discussed above during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY and the deficiencies within the 2003-2004 school year’s offer, particularly in the area of communication, reasonably led to the decision by STUDENT’s parents to seek a different placement for STUDENT in the fall of 2003 to address significant deficiencies and to restore STUDENT to the level of functioning that he would have reached had the District provided all appropriate and needed services in a timely fashion.

California Education Code section 56176 provides in pertinent part that the cost of reimbursement may be reduced or denied in the event that a parent did not provide written notice of their intent to enroll the child in a private school to a District at least 10 business days prior to removal of that child from public school. Petitioner’s parents provided the requisite written notice to the District October 22, 2003, but removed STUDENT from Buchanan on or about October 29, 2003. (Test. of PARENT and Exh. 44.) Thus, Petitioner’s parents did not provide 10 days written notice. The Hearing Officer reduces the within reimbursement award by five days.

After weighing all of the relevant facts discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to full reimbursement for Petitioner’s CARD services from November 10, 2003, through the end of the regular school year, less five days. Because of the intensity of CARD services, CARD is an adequate remedy for the denial of FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year and ESY and for the 2003-2004 school year. Petitioner shall provide receipts for services provided during that period.

ISSUE NO. 6: If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY, is he entitled to prospective placement with the CARD program?

As noted above, the Hearing Officer has already found that the 2004 ESY FAPE issue is not ripe for determination. The District also argued at hearing and within its brief that Petitioner’s request for prospective placement with the CARD program (for the 2004-2005 school year) is also not ripe because the District has yet to reassess STUDENT as a preschooler who is transitioning in the fall 2004 into kindergarten, and the District has not had the opportunity to make an offer for kindergarten. See Education Code § 56445(a). Moreover, the District must also hold an IEP meeting to discuss whether STUDENT is ready to transition into kindergarten from the preschool or whether he will remain at the preschool level. (Test. of Ms. Preston.) (Footnote 59) The Hearing Officer finds that it would not be appropriate to place STUDENT prospectively in the CARD program for the 2004-2005 school year because the IEP team must meet to assess STUDENT and to consider whether STUDENT will attend kindergarten in the fall. The Hearing Officer finds that the issue is not ripe for determination.

ISSUE NO. 7: If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for any periods at issue, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of CARD hours during 2004 ESY?

When a school district denies a Petitioner a FAPE, the Petitioner is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997) Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, and the courts have stated that there is no obligation to provide a day-for-day compensation for time missed. Petitioner W. v. Puyallup School District, (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997). Appropriate compensatory education is relief designed to ensure that the Petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. Id. Thus, the question is not what was missed but what was required to provide the Petitioner with a FAPE.

The Hearing Officer has already awarded Petitioner reimbursement for the costs of the CARD. Because the Hearing Officer has determined that Petitioner’s placement for ESY 2004 is not ripe for determination and requires assessment and IEP team consideration, it would not be appropriate for the Hearing Officer to order that the District provide Petitioner with compensatory education in the form of CARD hours during ESY 2004.

ISSUE NO. 8: If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for any of the periods at issue, is he entitled to compensatory education for the loss of educational services?

Compensatory education is an equitable remedy available when a school district has failed to provide a student with appropriate educational services. Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994) The Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education is not a contractual remedy and does not require a district to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. The purpose of compensatory education is “to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Id. at 1497. A hearing officer has broad latitude in crafting appropriate compensatory education relief. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 359 (1985).

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has already awarded Petitioner full reimbursement of CARD program services provided during the period November 10, 2003 through the end of the regular school year. The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to receive additional compensatory education. In making this determination, the Hearing Officer weighs all of the circumstances, including the fact that Petitioner’s parents insisted on having the District conduct a neuropsychological assessment of STUDENT by an individual of Petitioner’s choosing, even though the District had yet to conduct its initial assessment of STUDENT, thereby delaying STUDENT’s assessment and preventing the District from first assessing STUDENT on June 14, 2002.

ORDER

1. Within thirty (30) calendar days of receipt of written receipts for CARD services provided to Petitioner during the period November 10, 2003, through the end of the regular school year, the District shall fully reimburse Petitioner’s parents for the amounts of those receipts, less five days.

2. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

In accordance with Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Should the District have identified STUDENT as a child with autistic-like behaviors in October 2002? The District prevailed on this issue.

2. Did the District offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

3. Should the District have identified STUDENT as a child with autistic-like behaviors during the period October 2003 through January 2004? The District prevailed on this issue.

4. Did the District offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 ESY? Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue. Neither party prevailed on whether a FAPE was offered for 2004 ESY because the issue is not ripe.

5. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, are his parents entitled to full reimbursement for the costs related to the CARD program? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

6. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement within the CARD program for the 2004-2005 school year? Neither party prevailed on this issue because the issue is not ripe.

7. If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any of the periods at issue, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of CARD services during 2004 ESY? Neither party prevailed on this issue.

8. If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any periods at issue, is he entitled to compensatory education for the loss of educational services? The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i)

Date: July 23, 2004 _________________________________________Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. This matter convened on March 11, 2004, but no evidence was admitted on that date because the parties spent most of the day discussing settlement off the record and outside the presence of the Hearing Officer.

2. The parties prepared a joint statement of issues and joint exhibit and witness lists for hearing. The Hearing Officer further clarified the issues and the parties’ contentions. The issues are revised to facilitate analysis. References within are to the joint exhibits.

3. Ms. Gidley testified that the preschool assessment is typically conducted right after the meeting and, had PARENT signed the assessment plan, the District was prepared to assess STUDENT on June 14.

4. At this time, PARENT authorized a special education advocate to communicate with the District for Petitioner. (Test. of PARENT.)

5. By E-mail dated June 20, PARENT requested that the District reschedule the IEP meeting a week earlier because the last day for VIP Tots services was to be August 9, 2002. (Exh. 4.)

6. PARENT stated she requested an interim placement because it looked as if it was going to take longer for STUDENT to be assessed, and because the Regional Center was going to fund only through August 12, 2002, she needed STUDENT placed “somewhere.” The Regional Center ended funding on August 12. (Test. of PARENT.)

7. PARENT initialed the following handwritten comment on the form: “A resume provided by evaluator failed to support professional competency in neuropsychology” and limited her consent to three named individuals.

8. PARENT would not agree on the District’s initial choice, Dr. Jeffrey Owen, because Dr. Owen “was not exactly a neuropsychologist.” (Test. of PARENT.)

9. PARENT and Ms. Lucas had exchanged E-mails to coordinate, ultimately, the October 2 meeting. Initially, Ms. Lucas had been asked to observe STUDENT with his in-home teacher (with Regional Center), but the teacher did not start working with STUDENT, so they scheduled the October 2 meeting to do observations and interviews at that time. (Test. of Ms. Lucas)

10. STUDENT received 30-35 hours of CARD services in November and December, 2003. The services were increased to 40 hours per week in January 2004. (Test. of Ms. Contreras and Dr. Granpeesheh.)

11. Dr. Kitlowski attended the IEP meeting and testified that the purpose of the behavioral consultation offer was to help the parties understand the discrepancy between behaviors reported at home and in the school setting and to assist STUDENT’s mother in identifying what behaviors were occurring and the function of the behaviors in order to “come up with” strategies to address those behaviors.

12. Section 56441.11(b) of the California Education Code provides that a preschool age child between the ages of three and five qualifies as a child who needs early childhood special education services if the child meets the following criteria (in pertinent part): (1) is identified as having one of the following disabling conditions, as defined in section 300.7 of title 34 of the [C.F.R.]...: (A) Autism...(K) Speech or language impairment in one or more of voice, fluency, language and articulation...” [and] (4) Meets eligibility criteria specified in section 3030 of Title 5 of the [C.C.R.].

13. Ms. Lucas is a licensed school psychologist, with seven and one-half years of experience, and is a certified BICM. Ms. Lucas conducts “90 to 140 assessments per year.” Ms. Lucas holds a master’s degree in Marriage Family and Child Counseling and a California pupil personnel services credential.

14. Ms. Lucas stated that the age at which a child is diagnosed with autism is a “very controversial issue,” and that some psychologists wait until age five or six before they make a diagnosis, while others feel that“the earlier the intervention the better,” and they will go ahead and establish autism as an eligibility. Ms. Lucas noted that some families are very fearful of the autism label.

15. Ms. Baird stated that she has an A.A. degree in child development and a master’s degree in special education, and holds multiple subject (regular education K through 6) and mild moderate (special education) California teaching credentials. Ms. Baird also has a level-three certificate for teaching preschool and is a certified behavior intervention case manager (BICM) Ms. Baird has worked for five years as an early intervention teacher with VIP Tots and has received training in autism, floortime, TEACCH, social stories, PECS, and SABAC- systematic applied behavioral analysis for discrete trial training (DTT) Ms. Baird described DTT as breaking down a task into smaller components and teaching those tasks using reinforcements. Ms. Baird noted that DTT relies heavily on assessment in determining where a child is and on a lot of individual instruction -- usually one-on-one -- and data collection -- and evaluating the data and building from there. (Test. of Ms. Baird.)

16. Section 56001(i) of the Education Code expresses the intent of the State legislature that the “unnecessary use of labels” be avoided in providing special education and related services. The Hearing Officer interprets that provision to mean that once eligibility for services is established, an IEP team’s focus should be to identify the needs of the child and to develop an appropriate program for the child, with less emphasis given on labeling the child.

17. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, in Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), has held that “if the parents want Gregory to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing.” See also Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995), in which the Fifth Circuit has stated that “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child....there is no exception to this rule.”

18. Section 52112(e) of the C.C.R. provides as follows: “Regional centers may continue providing or purchasing services for a preschooler who has been determined eligible for regional center services: (1) until the beginning of the next school term after the toddler’s third birthday during a period when the LEA special education preschool program is not in session; and, (2) when the multi-disciplinary team determines that services are necessary until the LEA special education program resumes.”

19. Petitioner did not raise as a contention for hearing that the District failed to develop an IEP within fifty days from the date of the parent’s written consent for assessment. (See Education Code section 56043(d))

20. hallenges to the appropriateness of an assessment and the qualifications of an assessor may be made after the assessment is conducted. (See Education Code section 56329)

21. ion 56325(b) provides that prior to expiration of the 30-day period, the interim placement “shall be reviewed by the [IEP] team and a final recommendation shall be made.” The IEP team did not meet for the first time until October 16, 2002.

22. NT did not know how many OT sessions were missed. Ms. Lindemulder could not recall when she first provided OT services to STUDENT and when she did not provide scheduled OT services to him. After Ms. Lindemulder testified, the District produced a document prepared by Ms. Lindemulder that purports to show when and where Ms. Lindemulder provided OT services to STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year. The parties stipulated to the admission into evidence of the exhibit and also stipulated that STUDENT’s first OT service was on October 4, 2002. (Test. of Ms. Lindemulder and Exh. 83.)

23. According to the form, the program and its location were described in an “attached letter.” However, the letter was not entered into evidence, and a District witness noted that the letter was missing. (Test. of Ms. Preston and Exh. 15.)

24. The Hearing Officer does not address those areas identified for the first time in Petitioner’s brief.

25. Ms. Lamothe is an SDC preschool teacher for the District at Buchanan. Ms. Lamothe holds a professional clear multiple subject (for preschool through high school and adult classes) and clear specialist in learning handicapped California teaching credentials. Ms. Lamothe has received training in PECS, DTT, TEACCH, social skills, social stories, and professional assault response training (PART) Ms. Lamothe has also received training in the SCERTS model, described as a systematic way to implement different modalities in the classroom for students with autism, including low- and high- functioning, and in Links to Language, described as another form of DTT for step-by-step learning in academic, social, and mainly communication skills. Ms. Lamothe has taught first grade for three years, has taught one year as a basic resource pull-out teacher, and one year as a general education fifth grade teacher. Ms. Lamothe was in her third year as a District SDC preschool teacher.

26. It is not relevant to show that STUDENT did not, at age 38 months, demonstrate behaviors or skills that would not be expected of a nondisabled child, developmentally, at age 38 months. Petitioner simply lists in his brief without argument or explanation many of the responses given by PARENT for the Battelle under the personal-social and adaptive domains (thirty-six bulleted items under personal-social and twenty-one bulleted items under the adaptive). Petitioner did not show the relevance of the items, and many were at age ranges well beyond STUDENT’s age. For example, the responses “would not ask for adult help when he needed it” (developmental age range of 72-83 months), “would not initiate contact with familiar adults” (age range of 60-71 month), and that he “could not dress and undress himself without supervision” (age range of 48-59 months) are not relevant to STUDENT’s present levels or needs in October 2002. Moreover, age ranges are imprecise, and therefore the assertion that STUDENT was developmentally behind his peers for not demonstrating skills or behaviors expected within the age range 36 to 47 months is not accurate, because STUDENT would still have had nine months to demonstrate the behavior or skill (eg., “could not serve food without assistance” and “did not demonstrate caution and avoid common dangers” each have a developmental age range of 36-47 months).

27. For the discussion concerning STUDENT’s present levels of performance, the Hearing Officer refers to Exh. 25A, and not Exh. 25, because the copy of Exh. 25 cut off language on the left margin of the page. The Hearing Officer addresses the entries for Written Expression within the Fine/Gross Motor discussion.

28. According to the Brigance, rote counting up to twenty, reading numerals, and understanding ordinal positions each have a grade equivalence of 5-3, well beyond STUDENT’s age of 3-2 at the time of the assessment.

29. Ms. Abrassart, a licensed speech-language pathologist, holds a bachelor’s and master’s degree in communicative disorders. Ms. Abrassart has 31 years of experience working as a speech-language pathologist and has worked in the public schools for at least fifteen years. Ms. Abrassart estimated that at one time she assessed between 55 and 85 kids per year and last year she assessed 150 children. Ms. Abrassart has taught as a clinical adjunct or associate professor for many years at the college or university level as follows: diagnostics at Whittier College for five years; language disorders, diagnosis, clinical supervision, and directed clinic and supervision of schools at Chapman University for four years; language studies and classes on stuttering, fluency and language at California State University at Fullerton for four years; and graduate-level courses in language disorder and articulation as a professor at Loma Linda University for six years.

Ms. Gidley is a licensed speech-language pathologist and holds a bachelor’s degree in communicative disorders and a master’s degree in speech and language pathology. Ms. Gidley has 14 years of experience working as a speech-language pathologist and has training in autism, DTT, social stories, and Links to Language.

30. During clarification of the issues, Petitioner used the terms visual processing and visual motor integration interchangeably. The Hearing Officer uses the term visual motor.

31. The Hearing Officer does not consider the testimony of CARD witnesses who observed or assessed STUDENT over one year later. The testimony lacked relevance as to time of observations and assessment. Moreover, the CARD information would not have been available for consideration by the IEP team in October 2002.

32. Dr. Kitlowski is a licensed clinical psychologist with a bachelor’s, master’s and doctorate degrees in psychology. Dr. Kitlowski is the director of A.C.C.E.S.S., an NPA, and provides consultative services to school districts and individuals, including parents, who work with students with autism. Dr. Kitlowski provided weekly trainings to District staff members and was typically in the preschool program about four hours per month. Additionally, Dr. Kitlowski provided general trainings four times a year. (Exh. 67.)

33. On the IEP, only the first two goals were given numbers. The parties agreed at hearing that the goals for fine motor/visual motor/pre-writing and “fine motor/visual motor/scissor skills, be designated goal numbers three and four, respectively, that the goals for receptive language and expressive language be designated goal numbers five and six, respectively, and that goals for peer interaction (named goal number 3 on the IEP), and for attending to task (named goal number 4 on the IEP), be designated goal numbers seven and eight, respectively.

34. Behavioral support involved consultations with District staff members regarding attentional issues and redirection. (Exh. 23 and Test. of Dr. Kitlowski.)

35. Ms. Brennan, OTR, described the classroom’s sensory motor center: children do tactile activities involving shaving cream or a tactile bin, and interact with rice and tactile discrimination; the children also engage in “movement activities” on the trampoline or therapy ball and, when it is pleasant outside, the children then go outside for water play and have playground time which incorporates movement and proprioceptive activities.

36. A child’s behavior is among the factors an IEP team must consider in developing the IEP. For a child whose behavior impedes his or her learning or that of other children, the IEP team must consider, when appropriate, strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, and supports to address the behavior...” 20 U.S.C. section 1414(d)(3)(B)(i); 34 C.R.R. section 300.346(a)(2)(1).

37. It is undisputed that STUDENT was successfully toilet-trained. Moreover, the consistent and persuasive testimony of District witnesses establishes that STUDENT developed social skills, was able to follow directions better, and was able to give greater attention to tasks. These developments led to the agreement by PARENT in the late spring of 2003 that STUDENT was ready to attend the State inclusion preschool program in the fall of 2003 to give him greater opportunities to interact with nondisabled peers. As of October 10, 2003, STUDENT had met goals in toilet training and in peer interaction, two goals in fine motor and had made substantial progress on goals for attending to task and in quantitative concepts. (Test. of Ms. Lamothe, Ms. Abrassart, Ms. Knudsen, and Dr. Kitlowski.)

38. The CARD initial intake evaluation report dated October 1, 2003, indicates that “after a series of evaluations [and intervention], STUDENT had made some progress but continued to present delays and difficulties. The report also noted that STUDENT demonstrated his receptive understanding of “colors, shapes, letters, numbers to 10, food items, and verbs.” (Exh. 37.)

39. The Hearing Officer does not include those sessions missed because STUDENT was ill, refused service, or was too tired.

40. Because the Hearing Officer has found that the District did not develop appropriate goals and objectives in receptive and expressive language for the reasons discussed above, the Hearing Officer does not address the contention that the District failed to document his progress in receptive and expressive language.

41. Ms. DiGiovanni administered the performance, but not verbal, subtest of the WPPSI because of STUDENT’s “previously identified” difficulties with language processing skills. (Exh. 43.) STUDENT obtained a performance IQ of 85, in the low average range, on the WPPSI-R. On the Beery, STUDENT obtained a standard score of 81 after looking at and copying “geometric designs of increasing difficulty.” STUDENT’s age-equivalent score of 3 years and 1 month meant that he had weak visual motor integration skills. On the Vineland, Mrs. Lamothe’s ratings placed STUDENT’s adaptive levels for communication and motor skills in the “moderately low” range and his socialization skills in the “adequate” range. Mrs. Lamothe did not complete the Daily Living skills protocol because they related more to STUDENT’s functioning in the home/community setting. On the Vineland, PARENT’s ratings placed STUDENT in the low range for Communication and Daily Living skills. PARENT did not complete the socialization or maladaptive behavior domains. On the BASC completed by Mrs. Lamothe on September 22, 2003, her ratings for STUDENT’s behaviors gave him an Adaptive Skills composite T-score of 56, in the average range. Mrs. Lamothe’s ratings for STUDENT on Externalizing Problems (including hyperactivity, aggression and conduct problems scales) and on Internalizing Problems (including anxiety, depression, and somatization scales) gave him T-scores of 43 and 41, respectively, both placing him in the average range compared to his age peers. STUDENT’s Adaptability and Social Skills also were within the average range. PARENT completed the parent scales of the BASC on October 7, 2003. PARENT’s ratings for the Behavior Symptoms Index and his Adaptive Skills were in the “clinically significant” range. PARENT’s ratings for Externalizing Problems and Internalizing Problems placed STUDENT in the average range for both composites. On the GARS, Mrs. Lamothe’s ratings indicated a “very low probability of autism,” while PARENT’s ratings indicated that STUDENT is “probably autistic.”

42. The Hearing Officer does not discuss in detail the rating scales PARENT completed for the Vineland and BASC in the fall 2003 because it is undisputed that the scores are clinically significant. Ms. DiGiovanni attributed the difference in the teacher and parent Vineland scores to a “difference in the environment” and that STUDENT’s behavior may be specific to the different environments, taking into consideration the environmental controls that are present and the way in which different adults interact with STUDENT. Ms. DiGiovanni stated that rating scales are one person’s opinion of another’s behavior. (Test. of Ms. DiGiovanni.)

43. Dr. Bostani is a CARD assessor who at the time of her assessment of STUDENT acted as a psychological intern under the supervision of Dr. Granpeesheh, the director of CARD. Dr. Bostani has a bachelor’s degree in psychology from UCLA, a master’s degree in psychology, and a doctorate degree in clinical psychology. (Exh. 54). Dr. Bostani worked for several years at the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention as an Institute Assessor, Case Supervisor, and Workshop Leader. (Test. of Dr. Bostani.)

44. Ms. Contreras stated that STUDENT began to exhibit many maladaptive behaviors when demands were placed upon him during CARD drills and after he was exposed to flashlights.

45. Ms. Abrassart testified that she did not recall STUDENT’s making spontaneous sentences like that and that she interpreted the statement differently, as STUDENT’s way of initiating, and that it is STUDENT’s way of bringing up a topic that means something to him. Ms. Abrassart noted that all child language is centered on themselves:“it’s all in the here and now.” Ms Abrassart stated that STUDENT never talked about flashlights when she worked with him. 46. Nevertheless, Dr. Bostani testified that STUDENT was able to complete all of her standardized assessments and that the assessment results were considered valid.

47. PARENT testified that she reported the behavior in the spring of 2003 to District staff members, who told her that they had not seen the behavior. Thus, the District was aware of PARENT’s concerns, but the behavior was not occurring in the preschool setting.

48. Dr. Granpeesheh, the founder and director of CARD, has a Ph.D. in professional psychology from UCLA and holds a California license in professional psychology and is a board-certified behavior analyst. CARD has developed program curriculums for the following areas: language, socialization, social cognition, play, executive functioning, fine and gross motor, self-help, and school integration. (Test. of Dr. Granpeesheh and Exh. 52.)

49. Nevertheless, Dr. Reeker recommended that STUDENT continue in a special education preschool class and continue work on language skills, attention, and social and play skills. Dr. Reeker also recommended that STUDENT receive OT two times per week and speech therapy two to three times per week -- services that the District was already implementing and that were not available through the CARD program.

50. The Shapiro holding relies on an interpretation of 20 U.S.C. section 1401(a)(20) which, according to the 9th Circuit’s reading, requires that “the” teacher, not “a” teacher, as argued by the District, needed to be in attendance at the IEP meeting. The Ninth Circuit in Shapiro looked to the section’s implementing regulation, 34 C.F.R. section 300.344, Note 1, which provides, in pertinent part, as follows: “In deciding which teacher will participate in meetings on a child’s IEP, the agency may wish to consider the following possibilities: (a) For a child with a disability who is receiving special education, the teacher could be the child’s special education teacher...”

51. The Hearing Officer incorporates by this reference the discussion concerning present levels for the fall of 2002 and only addresses those present levels in dispute for the fall of 2003

52. The State preschool teacher did not testify at the hearing. The IEP refers to Ms. Caron, but the parties’ joint exhibit list refers to Ms. Karen McGinn as the State preschool teacher. Hereafter, the Hearing Officer refers to “Ms. Caron” as Ms. Karen McGinn, the State preschool teacher who attended the November 14, 2003 IEP meeting.

53. Ms. Contreras, a clinical supervisor with CARD since December of 1999, received her training through CARD. Ms. Contreras has a bachelor’s degree but does not hold any licenses or teaching credentials. Ms. Contreras supervised two junior therapists who provided direct services to STUDENT. (Test. of Ms. Contreras and Exh. 76.).

54. As discussed earlier, the difference in environments may have accounted for the high level of tantrumming and resistant behaviors reported by PARENT in the home environment.

55. Ms. Lamothe testified that the State inclusion program operated in the afternoon from 12 to 3, two doors down from her SDC classroom. The State program sent 8 of its students with a trained aide into Ms. Lamothe’s classroom, and Ms. Lamothe sent half of her students to the State inclusion program classroom with a trained aide.

56. The District did not explain why the PIP program was offered at the November IEP meeting, and not offered one month earlier at the October IEP meeting. Ms. Gidley, a speech-language therapist who assessed STUDENT in the fall of 2002, testified that she operated the PIP program like a typical preschool program. Ms. Gidley. described the program as a “good fit” for STUDENT because it would have given him some peer models with higher language skills to interact with. The PIP class was scheduled to meet in ninety-minute sessions, two times per week.

57. The District did not explain why the PIP program was offered at the November IEP meeting, and not offered one month earlier at the October IEP meeting. Ms. Gidley, a speech-language therapist who assessed STUDENT in the fall of 2002, testified that she operated the PIP program like a typical preschool program. Ms. Gidley. described the program as a “good fit” for STUDENT because it would have given him some peer models with higher language skills to interact with. The PIP class was scheduled to meet in ninety-minute sessions, two times per week.

58. Although this Decision is issued during 2004 ESY, the determination that the issue is not ripe continues to apply because at the time of the hearing, the District had not yet had an opportunity to re-assess STUDENT.

59. Ms. Preston stated that if a child turns age five by December 1, the child can go to kindergarten that year. STUDENT turns age five this summer, on July 20, 2004.