California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 12, 1996

Student v. Fountain Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 298-96 · Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel

Fountain Valley Unified must fund weekly oral-motor and assistive technology services and partly reimburse parents; private clinic speech therapy denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 6 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 9-year-old boy with multiple disabilities filed for due process over his speech therapy. The boy was fully included in a third-grade general education class at Newland Elementary in Fountain Valley Unified School District, with a full-time aide. He could not speak words and relied mainly on a picture exchange system to communicate. The parents asked for 10 hours per week of speech therapy from private therapist Cheryl Cates at her clinic and reimbursement for her assessment. They also wanted the District to fund oral-motor therapy from private therapist Miche' Lano of Speech Pathology Associates and to repay their costs.

Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel applied Rowley. He found that the District's two hours per week of on-site speech therapy gave the student some educational benefit, given his severe disabilities. It improved his behavior and helped him take part in class. He denied the Cates request but ordered 60 minutes per week of assistive technology services. He denied reimbursement for the Cates assessment because the parents did not challenge any District assessment. He found the student needed 30 minutes per week of oral-motor therapy from a speech therapist, not the 60 requested, and that a District therapist could provide it. The District's speech assessment had wrongly rejected this therapy, and the District held the IEP meeting on its assessments nine months late. He therefore ordered reimbursement for the Speech Pathology Associates assessment and 50% of the parents' therapy costs.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley's "some educational benefit" standard to a student with severe, multiple disabilities. Slow progress was found reasonable, and the parents' preferred private providers were not required. The decision also ordered a related service despite a guarded prognosis. Reimbursement for an independent assessment depended on finding a District assessment inappropriate.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Must STUDENT receive his speech therapy program for two hours per day, five days per week, from Cheryl Cates, a private speech therapist, at her clinic?

    Under Rowley, the District's two hours per week of on-site speech therapy gave the student some educational benefit given his severe disabilities, so private clinic therapy was denied; the Hearing Officer did add 60 minutes per week of assistive technology services to the IEP.

  2. Issue 2. Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of an independent speech therapy assessment performed by Ms. Cates?

    Reimbursement was denied because the parents identified no District assessment they disagreed with, and the Cates assessment was similar to earlier District assessments.

  3. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Does STUDENT require oral-motor therapy provided by a speech therapist for sixty minutes per week?

    The student needs oral-motor therapy from a speech therapist to work toward word approximations, but only 30 minutes per week, with five minutes of each session used for parent training.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. If so, must the oral-motor therapy be provided by Miche' Lano, a private speech therapist with Speech Pathology Associates?

    District speech therapists, including Ms. Rausch, are qualified to provide oral-motor therapy, so the parents' preferred private provider is not required.

  5. Issue 5. Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of an independent oral-motor assessment performed by Speech Pathology Associates?

    The District held the IEP meeting on its oral-motor assessments about nine months late, which violated Education Code section 56344. Its speech assessment wrongly rejected therapy that the independent assessment correctly recommended, so the District must reimburse the parents for the independent assessment.

  6. Issue 6. Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of oral-motor therapy provided by Ms. Lano?

    Since December 1995, the District should have provided 30 minutes per week of oral-motor therapy, half of the 60 minutes the parents paid for, so it must reimburse 50% of the parents' costs.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • IEE at public expense. Within 20 days of receiving proof, reimburse the parents for the December 1995 assessment by Barbara Moore of Speech Pathology Associates.
  • Reimbursement. Within 20 days of receiving proof, reimburse the parents for 50% of the cost of oral-motor therapy provided by Miche' Lano through the date of the decision.
  • Order to provide or change services. Provide 30 minutes per week of oral-motor therapy from a speech therapist to help the student approximate speech, with the last five minutes of each session used for parent training. Also provide 60 minutes per week of assistive technology services. Both are in addition to the speech therapy in the current IEP.
  • Order to provide or change services. Continue occupational therapy at the current IEP level, with part of each session devoted to oral-motor therapy for self-feeding. The speech therapist and occupational therapist must consult and collaborate.
  • Within 20 days of the decision, conform the student's IEP to the decision.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982); Timothy W. v. Rochester, New Hampshire School District, 875 F.2d 954 (1st Cir. 1989); Education Code §56344; Education Code §56329(b); 34 C.F.R. §300.503; 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(25)-(26)

People named in the decision

  • Gina Nimmo, director of special education, Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Jim Hemsley, SELPA director, SELPA
  • Dr. Kim Huynen, psychologist; behavioral consultant contacted by parents; witness for Student
  • Cheryl Cates, private speech-language pathologist; independent assessor; witness for Student, Sky Pediatric Therapy
  • Miche' Lano, private speech-language pathologist providing oral-motor therapy; witness for Student, Speech Pathology Associates
  • Barbara Moore, private speech-language pathologist and director; independent oral-motor assessor; witness for Student, Speech Pathology Associates
  • Speech Pathology Associates, state-certified nonpublic agency
  • Sky Pediatric Therapy, private therapy provider
  • Betty Romero, private occupational therapist providing OT for the District; oral-motor assessor, Contracted by Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Rosemary Eadie, school principal, Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Sonya Daniels, District speech-language pathologist, Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Carmen Noble, 1:1 aide, Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Cynthia Cottier, District speech-language pathologist; AAC specialist, Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Jeff Atkinson, general education third-grade teacher, Newland Elementary School
  • Kathleen Rausch, District speech-language pathologist; oral-motor assessor, Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Nancy Lough, full inclusion specialist, Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Lana Tinsman, full inclusion specialist, Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Lynn Ruthenbeck, District speech-language pathologist; assessor, Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Judy Montgomery, District speech-language pathologist; assessor, Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Darlene Hanson, private speech-language pathologist; assessor and consultant
  • Sally Dashiell, District speech-language pathologist; AAC specialist consultant, Fountain Valley Unified School District
  • Dr. Ron Leaf, behavioral consultant

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Huntington Beach, California, on May 2 and 3, and June 4 and 5, 1996.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by Jessie Cabrera, advocate. Also present on behalf of Petitioner were his parents, PARENTS.

Respondent Fountain Valley Unified School District (the District) was represented by G. Robert Roice, educational consultant. Also present on behalf of the District were Gina Nimmo, director of special education, and Jim Hemsley, SELPA director.

The following witnesses were called by Petitioner: Mr. and PARENT; Dr. Kim Huynen, psychologist; Cheryl Cates, speech therapist; Miche' Lano, speech therapist; Barbara Moore, speech therapist; and Betty Romero, occupational therapist.

The following witnesses were called by the District: Mr. Hemsley; Rosemary Eadie, school principal; Sonya Daniels, speech therapist; Carmen Noble, one-to-one aide; Cynthia Cottier, speech therapist; Jeff Atkinson, teacher; Kathleen Rausch, speech therapist; and Nancy Lough and Lana Tinsman, full inclusion specialists.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until June 17, 1996 for the receipt of closing briefs. At that time the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

Issue #1: Must STUDENT receive his speech therapy program for two hours per day, five days per week, from Cheryl Cates, a private speech therapist, at her clinic?

Issue #2: Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of an independent speech therapy assessment performed by Ms. Cates?

Issue #3: Does STUDENT require oral-motor therapy provided by a speech therapist for sixty minutes per week?

Issue #4: If so, must the oral-motor therapy be provided by Miche' Lano, a private speech therapist with Speech Pathology Associates?

Issue #5: Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of an independent oral-motor assessment performed by Speech Pathology Associates?

Issue #6: Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of oral-motor therapy provided by Ms. Lano?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner asserts that, although District speech therapists have been working on STUDENT's expressive communication skills for years, he remains unable to communicate even his most basic needs. Petitioner requests, therefore, that STUDENT's speech therapy program be provided by Cheryl Cates, a private speech therapist, and that the parents be reimbursed for the cost of Ms. Cates' assessment.

Petitioner further asserts that STUDENT could benefit from oral-motor therapy (OMT) from a speech therapist in that it could assist him in making word approximations. Petitioner requests that (1) STUDENT receive OMT from Miche' Lano, a private speech therapist, (2) the parents be reimbursed for the cost of an assessment by Speech Pathology Associates (SPA), Ms. Lano's employer, and (3) the parents be reimbursed for the cost of oral-motor therapy provided by Ms. Lano thus far.

The District asserts that STUDENT has made some progress in expressive communication skills, but that the amount of progress has been limited by STUDENT's severe disabilities. The District asserts that it can provide an appropriate speech therapy program for STUDENT, and therefore there is no need for speech therapy to be provided by the private therapist, Ms. Cates.

The District further asserts that, because of STUDENT's severe disabilities, OMT from a speech therapist would not significantly benefit him. Therefore, the District asserts, Petitioner's request for OMT from a speech therapist should be denied. Finally, the District asserts that, in the event it is determined that STUDENT does require OMT from a speech therapist, District speech therapists are qualified to provide such service. Therefore, there is no need for OMT to be provided by the private therapist, Ms. Lano.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE

A. Introduction

STUDENT is nine years old and recently completed third grade at Newland Elementary School within the District. STUDENT experienced oxygen deprivation at birth and, as a result, has multiple disabilities. He has significant cognitive deficits secondary to brain damage. He walks with a walker. He can make sounds but cannot articulate words. He has, at times, exhibited maladaptive behaviors -- including loud vocalizations and outbursts -- attributable in significant part to frustration at inability to communicate.

Throughout elementary school, STUDENT has been "fully included" in regular education classes. He has been assisted by a full-time, one-to-one aide, and has received a variety of special services, including speech therapy, adapted physical education, physical therapy, occupational therapy, and hydrotherapy. This case concerns only speech therapy.

B. The efforts of District speech therapists to address STUDENT's expressive communication needs

Sonya Daniels, District speech therapist, began providing speech therapy to STUDENT when he was in kindergarten, during the 1992-93 school year. She provided therapy for approximately two hours per week, some within class, some on an individual "pullout" basis. She tried a number of approaches, all of which met with limited success in improving STUDENT's ability to communicate effectively and accurately. The approaches included (1) sign language -- particularly difficult for STUDENT because of fine motor deficits, although he did develop his own signs for "please" and "yes", (2) vocalizations, (3) gestures, (4) green and red cards to signify "yes" and "no" responses, and (5) black and white line drawings of objects for making choices of desired objects. That year Dr. Kim Huynen, a psychologist contacted by the parents, provided consulting to the District regarding STUDENT's disruptive behaviors and developing a gesture for "please."

In the spring of 1993, an assessment by District speech therapists Lynn Ruthenbeck, Judy Montgomery and Ms. Daniels recommended exploration of augmentative/alternative communication (AAC) devices. (R 43) The District experimented with a variety of AAC devices, including an Intertalker, Powerpad, and Muppet Keyboard. However, none of these was used frequently enough to allow STUDENT to master the device. Some of the factors complicating communication progress that year included behavioral noncompliance -- loud vocalizations, temper tantrums and outbursts which at times required STUDENT's removal from class -- and fatigue in the afternoon because of the long school day.

In first grade (1993-94), speech therapy was provided exclusively on a "pullout" basis. That year, in addition to the approaches previously attempted, Ms. Daniels used a communication board with photographs of actual objects attached. Again, STUDENT made limited progress in his ability to communicate effectively and accurately. Again, Ms. Daniels believed that behavioral noncompliance and fatigue were complicating communication progress. A spring 1994 assessment by private speech therapist Darlene Hanson recommended continued use of a variety of communication methods such as line drawings. (R 42)(Footnote 1)

In second grade (1994-95), in addition to the approaches previously attempted, Ms. Daniels used photographs of actual objects, now placed on STUDENT's desk rather than attached to a communication board. Again, STUDENT experienced limited success. That year District speech therapist Sally Dashiell, an AAC specialist, provided some consulting. She recommended the continuing involvement of an AAC specialist and the use of a variety of methods such as a picture communication system.

In the fall of 1994 the parties agreed to solicit the input of behavioral consultant Dr. Ron Leaf. Dr. Leaf determined that STUDENT's behavioral noncompliance was a result of frustrated attempts at communication, and also that STUDENT could not make progress in communication until his behavior was brought under control. Some early attempts at behavior modification in class were largely unsuccessful. In March, 1995, the parties reluctantly agreed to remove STUDENT from class and to temporarily place him in a program of "discrete trials" (DT) for his entire six-hour school day. (R 5) The parties agreed to temporarily suspend other goals and objectives in STUDENT's IEP in order to accomplish this. Speech therapy was not provided during this time.

The DT consisted of numerous repetitions of drills requiring STUDENT to distinguish between a cup and a spoon. STUDENT was given positive reinforcement for correct answers. The purpose of the drills was to improve STUDENT's behavioral compliance so that his communication needs could be more effectively addressed. Although STUDENT was not particularly accurate at distinguishing between cup and spoon, his behavioral compliance nevertheless increased dramatically.

By May, 1995, concerned about STUDENT's lack of interaction with his peers, the parties agreed to return STUDENT to class for 15 minutes of every hour. At an IEP meeting in May, the IEP team addressed communication goals in the areas of toileting, eating, drinking, socialization, and classroom activities. (R 13) The DT continued during the summer at home. At the end of the summer the parents wrote to the District indicating they were pleased with STUDENT's progress in vocalization, expressive communication and picture communication during the summer DT program. (P 11)

In third grade (1995-96) STUDENT attended his full inclusion class and continued to attend DT for a small portion of each day. Speech therapy was provided for two hours per day. That year, the primary approach used by Ms. Daniels was a "Picture EXchange" system, or PEX. In PEX, color photographs of classroom activities, peers and staff were placed on STUDENT's desk (P 45). He was instructed to make choices regarding activities he wished to engage in and peers with whom he wished to interact. Also that year, in late fall, PARENT brought in a device known as Cheap Talk, which included photos of objects and provided auditory feedback.(Footnote 2) Mrs. Daniels did not feel the device was effective.

Several District witnesses described STUDENT's communication progress they observed in Mr. Atkinson's class during third grade (1995-96). Ms. Daniels, the speech therapist, testified that STUDENT's accuracy in making choices with PEX increased somewhat. She believed PEX was the most successful communication system used with STUDENT thus far. He used his own sign for "yes" (touching his chest) and either pushed undesired items away or turned his head to indicate "no." He showed a somewhat improved ability to attend and follow directions. His classroom aides understood his gestures and were able to attend to his needs.

Ms. Noble, STUDENT's one-to-one aide, noted an increased use of PEX to communicate. STUDENT selected pictures to request a particular activity (a book for reading, a ball cart at recess). He also selected pictures of peers with whom he wished to interact as "reading buddies". His accuracy improved in this area. STUDENT rarely rejected the peer whose picture he had selected, indicating that he was in fact choosing pictures of desired peers. Ms. Noble noted STUDENT's daily progress for the parents in a home-school communication book. (P 47)

Jeff Atkinson, the teacher, found that STUDENT's behavior was much improved, and he rarely had to be removed from the class. As a result, his ability to follow and participate in the class routine with his peers increased. He was able to communicate "yes" and "no". He initiated choices of pictures for desired activities, peers, play equipment, and toileting. He was more attentive, although he still tired in the afternoon.

Lana Tinsman, full inclusion specialist, observed progress in making choices with pictures, attention/focus, understanding and following the class routine with fewer prompts, and amount of interaction with peers. She described his progress as slow but significant given his multiple disabilities.

During third grade District personnel kept extensive charts documenting STUDENT's daily progress on a variety of IEP goals and objectives. One such goal was to increase STUDENT's ability to independently indicate his need to go to the bathroom by selecting the toilet picture in the PEX system. The District's data showed inconsistent progress. According to the District, STUDENT's success rate was 62% during the first month (October) and 84% during the last month (May), but the average for all months was 62%.

Petitioner pointed out that the District's data did not account for the fact that, as District witnesses testified, STUDENT was taken to the bathroom at certain regular intervals regardless of whether he indicated the need to go at those times. Petitioner also pointed out that the District's data did not include three occasions when STUDENT wet himself in class without communicating the need to go to the bathroom. According to Petitioner, when taking these factors into account, STUDENT's success rate was 26% in October, 38% in May, and the average for all months was 26%.

At an IEP meeting on February 8, 1996, the parents indicated that they wished to discontinue the District's provision of speech therapy to STUDENT. (R 8-11) On February 27, the parents took STUDENT to Cheryl Cates, a private speech therapist associated with Sky Pediatric Therapy, for an independent assessment. Ms. Cates found that STUDENT demonstrated some willingness and ability to use both PEX and Cheap Talk to make choices; however, she found his accuracy to be inconsistent. At times, he selected pictures of objects but then rejected the actual object when it was presented to him. He did not show interest in an Intellikeys adapted keyboard. (P 4)

On March 5 and March 14, Ms. Cates observed STUDENT in school. STUDENT was more involved on the latter day. He participated somewhat in the class routine, interacted somewhat with peers and staff, and made some appropriate use of PEX -- for example, indicating that he wished to have responsibility for the ball cart on the playground at recess.

In her written report dated March 15, Ms. Cates recommended that STUDENT receive two hours of speech therapy, five days per week, in order to "more fully establish a communication system that is functional for his needs." She concluded that a portion of his speech therapy program should include trials with various AAC devices to determine the appropriate device for STUDENT. At the hearing, Ms. Cates testified that the greatest amount of weekly speech therapy she has provided for a student in the past is one hour, two days per week.

C. Oral-Motor Therapy

At an IEP meeting on May 8, 1995, the District agreed that both a speech therapist and an occupational therapist would conduct an assessment of STUDENT to determine whether or not he required a particular type of therapy known as oral-motor therapy (OMT). (P 48, pg. 30)

On May 9, Betty Romero, a private occupational therapist who has provided O.T. services to STUDENT on behalf of the District for several years, conducted an oral-motor assessment on behalf of the District. Ms. Romero examined whether OMT might improve STUDENT's self-feeding skills. Ms. Romero did not prepare a written report at that time. (R 44)(Footnote 3)

On May 18, District speech therapist Kathleen Rausch conducted her oral-motor assessment on behalf of the District. Ms. Rausch examined whether OMT might improve the functioning of STUDENT's oral mechanism for the purpose of producing speech. Ms. Rausch's written report dated May 19 included the following statements under the heading "clinical impressions":

Imitative abilities for speech and non-speech movements could not be elicited. Prognostic indicators for the development of sequenced articulating movements appears to be poor. (R 40)

Beginning on July 6, Ms. Romero devoted a portion of each O.T. session with STUDENT to OMT designed to enhance self-feeding skills. (R 44)(Footnote 4) On October 16, Ms. Romero prepared a written report describing both her May assessment and STUDENT's subsequent progress in OMT. (R 44) According to the report, STUDENT had made some progress in terms of decreased oral tactile defensiveness, improved use of the jaw and improved use of the tongue -- all of which might contribute to improved self-feeding skills. Id. She recommended continuing the practice of devoting a portion of each O.T. session to OMT for the purpose of improving self-feeding skills. She also noted that the OMT she was providing also afforded STUDENT an "excellent opportunity . . . to increase communication skills." Id.

On December 18, the parents obtained an independent assessment of STUDENT's need for OMT from Barbara Moore, a private speech therapist and director of Speech Pathology Associates (SPA). (P 52)(Footnote 5) In her written report dated December 28, Ms. Moore concluded:

Based on the fact that STUDENT has never received intensive OMT, it is recommended that he be enrolled in individual therapy for two sessions per week with a therapist who demonstrates expertise in the areas of oral motor skills and feeding. (P 52)

Beginning on December 21, the parents paid for STUDENT to receive OMT from speech therapist Miche' Lano at SPA, twice weekly for thirty minutes per session. On February 2, 1996, in preparation for an upcoming IEP meeting, Ms. Lano prepared a brief progress report. The report indicated some progress in terms of decreased oral tactile defensiveness, improved use of the jaw and improved use of the tongue. (P 6) Ms. Lano wrote, "Minimal progress has occurred only given six sessions in the last four weeks." Ms. Lano devoted the last five minutes of each session to giving suggestions to the parents regarding following through on OMT activities at home.

At an IEP meeting on February 8, 1996, Ms. Romero, Ms. Rausch, and Ms. Lano all made presentations regarding the issue of OMT. (P 48, pg. 9) The parents requested that, in addition to the OMT being provided by occupational therapist Ms. Romero, the District fund OMT for STUDENT with speech therapist Ms. Lano. Id., pg. 20. The District recommended that OMT issues continue to be addressed by Ms. Romero in her O.T. sessions (Id., pg. 13-14), but did not agree to fund additional OMT by Ms. Lano. The parents continued to pay for STUDENT to see Ms. Lano.

In a written progress report dated February 23, Ms. Lano noted that "the primary focus of STUDENT's OMT has been addressed [by me] through a feeding program. The muscles used in feeding are the same muscles used in speaking. Feeding therapy addresses the specific muscles that are deficient and necessary for the production of speech . . . " (P 5, pg. 1)

In the February 23 report, Ms. Lano again noted, as she had in her February 2 report, that STUDENT had made some progress in terms of decreased oral tactile defensiveness, improved use of the jaw and improved use of the tongue. She noted that some of this improvement might be attributable to OMT performed by Ms. Romero. Id., pg. 1-3. She noted, in agreement with the conclusion reached by District speech therapist Ms. Rausch in her May, 1995 assessment, that STUDENT "has not demonstrated the ability to imitate oral motor imitative movements." Id., pg. 4. She noted, however, that STUDENT had decreased his use of grunts and whines, increased his use of syllables, and shown a limited ability to spontaneously produce syllables that somewhat approximated single words. Id.

In her February 23 report, Ms. Lano recommended that STUDENT continue to receive two sessions per week of OMT, for thirty minutes per session. Id. One of her recommended goals was to "increase vocalizations and verbalizations during feeding and oral motor therapy to enhance STUDENT's communicative effectiveness." Id., pg. 6. One sub-goal was "model appropriate single word utterances." Id.

At the hearing in May, Ms. Lano testified that STUDENT has made minimal progress, and that, in general, her students' OMT progress tends to be very slow and hard to judge. She acknowledged that there is substantial overlap between the OMT activities that she and Ms. Romero perform with STUDENT. However, she noted that there is some difference in focus. More specifically, one of her goals is to improve the functioning of STUDENT's oral mechanism for the purpose of approximating speech. She stated that STUDENT's prognosis is "guarded", and that negative factors in this prognosis include his age, cognitive deficits and behavioral noncompliance. She testified, however, that she believes any student with oral-motor difficulties can benefit from OMT from a speech therapist, and that it is important to try.

Also at the hearing, Ms. Rausch testified that, while OMT from a speech therapist might lead to small gains in STUDENT's ability to approximate some words, it will never make him a verbal child. She believes that the District should continue to provide OMT to enhance STUDENT's self-feeding skills in O.T. sessions with Ms. Romero, and that a secondary benefit of such service might be some gains in vocalization. She testified, however, that should the Hearing Officer determine that STUDENT requires OMT from a speech therapist, she would be able to provide such service. She stated that she has provided OMT to many students in the past.

Finally, at the hearing, Ms. Romero testified that, while there is some overlap between the activities performed by her and Ms. Lano, unlike Ms. Lano she does not focus on speech production. Ms. Romero believes it is valuable for an occupational therapist and a speech therapist who are both providing OMT to a student to collaborate. More specifically, she testified that on one recent occasion, she used a suggestion from Ms. Lano regarding how to have STUDENT drink from a straw.

DISCUSSION

A. Must STUDENT receive his speech therapy program for two hours per day, five days per week, from Cheryl Cates, a private speech therapist, at her clinic?

Under federal and state law, disabled students are entitled to a free, appropriate education (FAPE) which emphasizes special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. §1400(c); Education Code §56000. Special education means specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(16). Related services are those required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(17). Related services include speech therapy. 34 C.F.R. §300.16(b)(13); Education Code §56363(b)(1).

In Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the Supreme Court addressed the substantive level of educational benefit that must be achieved in order for a disabled child to receive FAPE. The Court found that a school district is not required to provide the best possible education or to maximize educational benefits to the child, but rather to provide a "basic floor of opportunity." Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 200. The Court concluded that IDEA requires that the child receive "some" educational benefit. Id. at 200-201. The Court noted that because the Act requires states to educate a wide spectrum of children with disabilities, the question of whether a particular child has received sufficient educational benefit must be decided on a case-by-case basis. Id. at 202. The Court stated:

The benefits obtainable by children at one end of the spectrum will differ dramatically from those obtainable by children at the other end . . . [some children] may encounter great difficulty in acquiring even the most basic of self-maintenance skills.

Id at 202.

In this case, Petitioner acknowledges that STUDENT has made progress in various aspects of his education, including certain therapies and behavioral compliance. Petitioner asserts, however, that despite years of speech therapy, STUDENT has made unsatisfactory progress in expressive communication.(Footnote 6) In order to determine if STUDENT has received appropriate speech therapy, one must examine both STUDENT's progress in expressive communication skills and the extent to which speech therapy has assisted STUDENT to benefit from his special education program.

There is no dispute that the District speech therapists who have served STUDENT (1) possess appropriate qualifications (34 C.F.R. 300.15, .153; Title 5, California Code of Regulations Section 3001(x)), (2) have developed extensive and appropriate goals and objectives relating to communication for inclusion in STUDENT's annual Individualized Education Plans (IEPs), and (3) have attempted a variety of different approaches and methodologies in their efforts to assist STUDENT in meeting these communication goals and objectives. It is equally undisputed, however, that STUDENT has for the most part not met his annual IEP goals and objectives relating to expressive communication, and that his overall progress in this area has been relatively limited.

District witnesses who personally observed STUDENT in Mr. Atkinson's third grade class (Ms. Daniels, Mr. Atkinson, Ms. Noble and Ms. Tinsman) testified credibly that STUDENT experienced some success in using PEX to express choices of desired activities and peers with whom he wished to interact. These witnesses' testimony established that Ms. Daniels' speech therapy service assisted STUDENT to benefit from special education in a number of ways: his behavior improved significantly (presumably to some extent because of decreased frustration regarding communication), he no longer had to be removed from class, his attention and focus improved, his interaction with peers increased, he was better able to follow and participate in the class routine, he needed fewer prompts, and he was better able to get his classroom aides to understand his needs. Applying the Rowley standard (458 U.S. at 200-202) to the facts of this case, and particularly given STUDENT's severe, multiple disabilities, the Hearing Officer finds that he has received appropriate speech therapy services from the District. Those services have allowed him to make "some" progress in the area of expressive communication skills -- particularly during the just-completed 1995-96 year. While STUDENT's progress in communication has, at times over the years, been characterized variously as "slow" and/or "limited", given STUDENT's severe, multiple disabilities, it has been reasonable. Importantly, the related service of speech therapy has "assisted him in benefiting from special education" in that it enabled him to become a full member of the third grade regular education class. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(17).

Because the evidence showed that District speech therapists can provide appropriate speech therapy services to STUDENT in two hours of weekly therapy on the public school site, the District is not required to provide for STUDENT to receive speech therapy from Ms. Cates for ten hours per week at her clinic.

One further point requires discussion here. The parties agree, and the evidence was undisputed, that STUDENT requires ongoing experimentation with assistive technology devices in order to ascertain an appropriate communication device for use in the classroom. Under IDEA, an "assistive technology device" is defined as "any item, piece of equipment, or product system, whether acquired commercially off the shelf, modified or customized that is used to increase, maintain, or improve functional capabilities of individuals with disabilities." 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(25).(Footnote 7) In addition, IDEA defines "assistive technology services" as "any service that directly assists an individual with a disability in the . . . use of an assistive technology device." 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(26). No particular device has yet been identified as an appropriate device for STUDENT.

Cynthia Cottier, a District speech therapist with expertise in augmentative/alternative communication (AAC), testified that she is available to provide AAC consultation services to STUDENT. Because Ms. Cottier is qualified to provide such service, the District need not provide for the private speech therapist, Ms. Cates, to provide AAC consultation. The Hearing Officer notes that although (1) STUDENT has received some AAC services from various District speech therapists, and (2) the parties agree that one element of an appropriate speech therapy program for STUDENT must be continuing experimentation with communication devices, his present IEP does not specifically call for such services.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's IEP must be amended to provide for STUDENT to receive sixty minutes per week of assistive technology services. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(26). This service is in addition to (1) the two hours per week of speech therapy presently called for in STUDENT's IEP; and (2) the thirty minutes per week of OMT from a speech therapist that is ordered herein.

B. Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of an independent assessment performed by Ms. Cates?

A parent is entitled to be reimbursed for an independent assessment if it is determined at a due process hearing that a District assessment was inappropriate and that the independent assessment is appropriate. 34 C.F.R. 300.503; Education Code §56329(b). In this case Petitioner did not identify any District assessment corresponding to Ms. Cates' assessment with which it disagreed. The evidence showed that Ms. Cates' assessment was similar in content and recommendations to previous assessments performed by District speech therapists.(Footnote 8) (For example, she recommended ongoing experimentation with a variety of communication devices, as had District assessors before her.) Because it has not been determined that any District assessment was inappropriate, reimbursement for Ms. Cates' assessment is denied.

C. Does STUDENT require oral-motor therapy provided by a speech therapist?

As noted above, related services are those required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 34 C.F.R. §300.16; Education Code §56363. Related services include speech therapy and occupational therapy. 34 C.F.R. §300.16(b)(13); Education Code §56363(b). The parties agree that STUDENT requires speech therapy and occupational therapy in order to assist him to benefit from special education. They also agree that it is appropriate for Ms. Romero to continue to devote a portion of her O.T. sessions to OMT designed to enhance self-feeding skills. They disagree, however, as to whether it is necessary for STUDENT to also receive OMT from a speech therapist for the purpose of assisting him in making word approximations.

In Timothy W. v. Rochester, New Hampshire School District, 875 F.2d 954 (1st Cir. 1989), cert. denied, 493 U.S. 983 (1989), the court held that a severely and multiply disabled child could not be found ineligible for special education and related services on the theory that he could not benefit from them. The court noted that, in fact, severely disabled children are given priority under the IDEA. 20 U.S.C. §§1412, 1414. While Timothy W. concerned the threshold question of eligibility for special education, rather than whether a student eligible for special education required a particular related service in order to assist him to benefit from special education, it is nevertheless instructive here.

The provision of special education is not guaranteed to produce any particular outcome for the child. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix Part C, q. 59. Ms. Lano testified that STUDENT has made minimal progress under her OMT tutelage and that his prognosis for approximating speech is "guarded." Ms. Rausch testified that OMT from a speech therapist might lead to small gains in STUDENT's ability to approximate some words. The evidence showed that progress in the overall area of expressive communication skills for STUDENT, who has multiple, significant disabilities, has always been relatively limited. Expressive communication remains a priority for STUDENT. OMT from a speech therapist has value to the extent that OMT may improve his ability to express himself and make himself understood. For that reason, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT presently requires OMT from a speech therapist in order to assist him to benefit from special education.

The evidence showed that STUDENT currently receives OMT from both a speech therapist, Ms. Lano, and an occupational therapist, Ms. Romero. The evidence showed that there is substantial overlap between the OMT activities performed by Ms. Lano and Ms. Romero, and that they are consulting and collaborating with each other. Ms. Lano provides OMT twice weekly for thirty minutes per session, and Ms. Romero provides OMT for a portion of each of her O.T. sessions, which occur twice weekly for fifty minutes per session. There is a different focus to some of the OMT activities performed by Ms. Lano and Ms. Romero. One of Ms. Lano's goals is to achieve speech approximations, while Ms. Romero's goal is to improve self-feeding -- although a secondary benefit of her OMT service may be improved vocalization.

The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires only thirty minutes per week of OMT from a speech therapist, rather than the sixty minutes currently being provided by the private therapist. The last five minutes of each session should be devoted to parent training.

The Hearing Officer further concludes that STUDENT shall continue to receive the amount of occupational therapy called for in his current IEP, and that a portion of each O.T. session shall continue to be devoted to OMT designed to enhance self-feeding skills. The speech therapist and occupational therapist who provide OMT to STUDENT shall consult and collaborate with eachother to ensure the provision of efficient and effective service.

D. Must the oral-motor therapy be provided by Miche' Lano, a private speech therapist?

The evidence showed that District speech therapists including Ms. Daniels and Ms. Rausch are qualified to provide OMT designed to improve oral functioning for the purpose of improving vocalization. They are credentialed speech therapists. There are no special requirements in the law for a speech therapist to provide OMT; in any event, Ms. Daniels and, in particular, Ms. Rausch have received training in providing OMT and have provided it to other students. While it is true that Ms. Rausch testified she believes STUDENT does not require OMT from a speech therapist, at the hearing she agreed that he could receive some benefit from it. She stated that she would be willing to provide OMT to STUDENT should the Hearing Officer determine that he requires it. Petitioner asserts that STUDENT has now received OMT from Ms. Lano for six months and that it would be inappropriate to switch to a service provider such as Ms. Rausch who is perhaps less enthusiastic about STUDENT's prognosis than Ms. Lano is. Notwithstanding the parent's preference for Ms. Lano, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT can receive appropriate OMT from Ms. Rausch. Therefore, it is concluded that oral-motor therapy need not be provided by Ms. Lano.

E. Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of an independent assessment by Speech Pathology Associates?

On May 8, 1995, the District agreed that a speech therapist and an occupational therapist would conduct oral-motor assessments. The occupational therapist, Ms. Romero, conducted her assessment on May 9 but did not prepare a written report until October 16. (In July she began devoting a portion of each O.T. session to OMT designed to improve self-feeding skills.) The speech therapist, Ms. Rausch, conducted her assessment on May 18 and prepared a written report the next day. The report did not recommend that STUDENT receive OMT from a speech therapist.

The District did not conduct an IEP meeting for the purpose of discussing the results of Ms. Rausch's and Ms. Romero's OMT assessments until February 8, 1996, approximately nine months after the assessments were completed. The law requires that within fifty days (adjusted for certain school breaks) of receiving the parent's written consent to assess the District must conduct an IEP meeting to consider the results of the assessment. Education Code §56344. Although the District asserts that PARENT orally sanctioned some portion of the delay here, the timing requirement applies "unless the parent agrees, in writing, to an extension." Id.

The parents sought an independent assessment of STUDENT's OMT needs from SPA in December, 1995. This was after the date by which the District should have conducted an IEP meeting to discuss Ms. Rausch's and Ms. Romero's assessments, and two months prior to the date on which the District finally did conduct such a meeting. Therefore, lacking a definitive answer from the IEP team as to whether the District would provide OMT from a speech therapist, the parents obtained their own assessment.

The evidence showed that many of the conclusions reached by Ms. Rausch and SPA were very similar. However, Ms. Rausch concluded that OMT from a speech therapist would not benefit STUDENT significantly, while SPA concluded that it might. It has been determined above that SPA's recommendation that STUDENT receive OMT from a speech therapist was appropriate, and that Ms. Rausch's recommendation was not appropriate. 34 C.F.R. §300.503; Education Code §56329(b). For this reason, reimbursement for SPA's December, 1995 assessment is granted.(Footnote 9)

F. Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of oral-motor therapy provided by Ms. Lano?

The Hearing Officer has authority to award "appropriate" relief for instances of denial of a free, appropriate education. 20 U.S.C. §1415(e)(2). Appropriate relief may include requiring the District to reimburse parents for educational expenses the District should have borne in the first place. It has been determined herein that, as of December, 1995, when private speech therapist Ms. Lano began providing sixty minutes per week of OMT to STUDENT, the District should have been providing STUDENT with thirty minutes per week of OMT from a speech therapist. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must reimburse the parents for fifty percent (50%) of their out-of-pocket costs relating to OMT provided by Ms. Lano since December, 1995.

ORDER

1. Within twenty (20) days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the cost of the December, 1995 assessment performed by Barbara Moore of Speech Pathology Associates.

2. Within twenty (20) days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for fifty percent (50%) of the cost of oral-motor therapy provided by Miche' Lano through the date of this Decision.

3. The District shall provide STUDENT with (a) thirty minutes per week of oral-motor therapy from a speech therapist designed to assist STUDENT in approximating speech and (b) sixty minutes per week of assistive technology services. Such service shall be in addition to the level of speech therapy service provided for in STUDENT's current IEP.

4. The District shall continue to provide STUDENT with the level of occupational therapy service provided for in his current IEP. A portion of each O.T. session shall continue to be devoted to oral-motor therapy designed to enhance self-feeding skills. The speech therapist and occupational therapist who provide oral-motor therapy to STUDENT shall consult and collaborate with each other to ensure the provision of efficient and effective service.

5. Within twenty (20) days of the date of this Decision, the District shall conform STUDENT' IEP to this Decision.

All of Petitioner's remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

Issue #1: Must STUDENT receive his speech therapy program for two hours per day from Cheryl Cates, a private speech therapist, at her clinic?

Respondent substantially prevailed on this issue.

Issue #2: Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of an independent assessment performed by Ms. Cates?

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

Issue #3: Does STUDENT require oral-motor therapy provided by a speech therapist for sixty minutes per week?

Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue in that it was ordered that he must receive such therapy from a speech therapist for thirty minutes per week.

Issue #4: If so, must the oral-motor therapy be provided by Miche' Lano, a private speech therapist with Speech Pathology Associates?

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

Issue #5: Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of an independent assessment performed by Speech Pathology Associates?

Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.

Issue #6: Must the District reimburse the parents for the cost of oral-motor therapy provided by Ms. Lano?

Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue in that it was determined that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for fifty percent of such costs.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).

Dated: July 12, 1996 _____________________ Leonard Garfinkel Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Ms, Hanson, who was originally contacted by the parents and later provided consulting to the District, experimented with a method known as "facilitated communication" in which the therapist provides physical support to guide the student's hand over an expressive communication device. She employed the method only briefly with STUDENT, without success; Ms. Daniels, the District speech therapist, did not use the method.

2. More specifically, each picture in Cheap Talk included a corresponding recorded message which played when the button for that picture was pushed. (P 46)

3. Ms. Romero's written report was not prepared until October 19.

4. This apparently occurred without the agreement of an IEP team meeting.

5. Speech Pathology Associates is a state certified, non public agency.

6. Petitioner appears to acknowledge, and the evidence demonstrates, that STUDENT has also made progress in the area of receptive communication.

7. Depending on the circumstances, assistive technology devices may be special education, related services, or supplementary aids and services. See 34 C.F.R. §300.308.

8. Ms. Cates' recommendations as to the amount and location of speech therapy services did differ from those of District speech therapists.

9. Ms. Lano testified that she considered all of her first six sessions with STUDENT between December 1995 and February 1996 to be part of an ongoing assessment period. For purposes of reimbursement, the Hearing Officer finds that only Ms. Moore's initial evaluation in December, 1995 was an "assessment", and that all subsequent sessions with Ms. Lano constituted ongoing OMT service.