California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 12, 2000
Student v. Conejo Valley Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 299-99 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Conejo Valley Unified must add weekly speech therapy for oral-motor and social skills; requests for clinic OT and PT are denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a six-year-old boy with autism filed for due process against Conejo Valley Unified School District. The boy also has a form of cerebral palsy and attended a regular education kindergarten. Before the hearing, the parties settled the claims for private speech therapy in summer 1997 and private OT in summer 1998. The District agreed to pay $600 for the OT.
The parents asked for more individual speech-language therapy, therapy sessions with typically developing peers, and clinic-based OT and PT. Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found that the District's speech therapist, Rebecca Singhal, covered most of the boy's language goals well. However, she never worked on his oral-motor deficits, even though his June 1998 IEP had an oral-motor goal. Staff and private providers also agreed that his social skills with peers were seriously limited. The Hearing Officer ordered one more 30-minute individual session each week and one 30-minute weekly session led by the speech therapist with typically developing classmates. She also ordered a new IEP meeting within 15 days to write oral-motor and social-language goals.
The parents' OT and PT requests were denied. Testimony from District occupational therapist Jennifer Kreitman, expert Nancy Bagatelle, and adapted PE teacher Catherine LaRuffa showed that school-based services met the boy's needs and that he was making progress. Because the District's OT was appropriate, the parents were not repaid $1,140 for private clinic OT.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley's "some educational benefit" standard to related services. A goal written into the IEP but never worked on supported ordering more services. Requests for clinic-based therapy failed when school-based services, using other equipment, produced documented progress.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1a. Does Student require one or two sessions per week of small-group speech and language therapy with typically developing peers and two or three sessions per week of individual speech and language sessions to meet his needs and receive a FAPE?
District therapy did not address the student's oral-motor deficits or social-language needs; he needs one more weekly individual session and one weekly facilitated session with typically developing peers.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b. Does Student require two sessions per week of clinic-based occupational therapy (OT)?
The District's school-based collaborative OT met the student's needs and produced progress; clinic equipment was not required under Rowley.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1c. Does Student require two sessions per week of clinic-based physical therapy (PT)?
Monthly PT consultation combined with APE met the student's motor needs, and he progressed and took part in regular PE.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of clinic-based occupational therapy they provided for Student during the 1998-1999 school year?
Because the District's OT was appropriate, the parents' $1,140 reimbursement request for private clinic OT was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days, convene an IEP meeting to develop goals and objectives for oral-motor deficits (diminished lip and tongue range of motion, decreased lip and cheek strength) and social-language skills, and to conform the IEP to the added speech-language services.
- Order to provide or change services. Within 20 calendar days, provide one 30-minute weekly individual session addressing oral-motor deficits and social-language instruction, plus one 30-minute weekly session facilitated by the speech-language pathologist in the classroom during small-group activities or on the playground with two or more typically developing peers.
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup School District
People named in the decision
- Jack Bannon, associate director of special education, Conejo Valley Unified School District
- Elisabeth Cheryl Fletcher, private speech-language pathologist, witness for Student
- Betty Jo (B.J.) Freeman, Ph.D., expert witness for Student; professor of medical psychology, UCLA Autism Clinic
- Linda Gomberg, special day class teacher (1997-1998), Conejo Valley Unified School District
- Rebecca "Becky" Singhal, school speech-language pathologist, Conejo Valley Unified School District
- Mary Vehrs, full inclusion facilitator, Conejo Valley Unified School District
- Susan Liebling, kindergarten teacher, Conejo Valley Unified School District
- Tanya Brustinov, private occupational therapist, witness for Student, Child Development Center, Simi Valley Hospital & Health Care Services
- Jennifer Kreitman, school occupational therapist, Conejo Valley Unified School District
- Nancy Bagatelle, expert witness for District; occupational therapist, Pediatric therapy clinic, University of Southern California
- Charmayne Beck, private physical therapist, witness for Student, Child Development Center, Simi Valley Hospital & Health Care Services
- Catherine LaRuffa, adapted physical education teacher, Conejo Valley Unified School District
- Ms. Hall, school physical therapist, Conejo Valley Unified School District
- Child Development Center, Simi Valley Hospital & Health Care Services, private assessment and therapy provider
- Tri-Counties Regional Center, regional center funding a home behaviorist and an additional speech session
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Thousand Oaks, California, on October 14 and 15, November 22, and December 6, 1999. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Jodi F. Ossen. Also present on behalf of Petitioner were his parents. Respondent Conejo Valley Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Cynthia A. Yount. Also present on behalf of the District was Jack Bannon, associate director of special education.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the beginning of the hearing, the parties engaged in settlement discussions outside the presence of the Hearing Officer. The parties indicated that they had resolved one of the issues initially presented for hearing related to reimbursement for the costs of independent speech and language therapy procured by the PARENTS for STUDENT during the summer of 1997. The parents also accepted the District's offer of reimbursement in the amount of $600.00 for the costs of independent occupational therapy provided during the summer of 1998. Therefore, this decision addresses only the remaining issues as set forth below.
ISSUES
(1) Does STUDENT require the following designated instructional services (DIS) to meet his needs and to provide him with a free appropriate public education (FAPE):
(a) one or two sessions per week of small-group speech and language therapy with typically developing peers and two or three sessions per week of individual speech and language sessions;
(b) two session per week of clinic-based occupational therapy (OT);
(c) two sessions per week of clinic-based physical therapy (PT)?
(2) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of clinic-based occupational therapy (OT) they provided for STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner STUDENT is a six-year-old student who is eligible for special education based on a diagnosis of autism. He also has been diagnosed with spastic diaphoresis, a form of cerebral palsy affecting leg, trunk, and oral-motor functioning. STUDENT has deficits in the areas of communication, sensory processing, fine- and gross-motor skills, socialization, and self-help skills. STUDENT attends a regular education kindergarten in the District. His individualized educational program (IEP) calls for him to receive the following services: speech and language therapy, occupational therapy (OT), physical therapy (PT), and adapted physical education (APE). Additionally, STUDENT receives support in the classroom from a full-time instructional assistant and a full-inclusion specialist who weekly observes STUDENT and consults with his teacher. A behaviorist provided by the Tri-Counties Regional Center works weekly with STUDENT at home on toilet training, developing social skills, and conforming to a routine. STUDENT's parents have supplemented the services provided by the District with clinic-based OT and PT, and the Regional Center has funded an additional session weekly of speech and language therapy.
When STUDENT was approximately 21 months old, his parents became concerned about his speech and language development. They observed that STUDENT's language development had regressed and he was using stereotypical phrases. He also was not interested in the same things as his peers. Because of their concerns and, on the recommendation of their pediatrician, the PARENTS referred STUDENT to the District for a special education assessment in the spring of 1997. The District undertook a speech and language assessment of STUDENT. In April 1997, the IEP team determined that STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education because of severe delays in language development. The IEP called for STUDENT to receive two sessions of speech and language therapy for up to 60 minutes weekly. The District provided STUDENT with speech and language therapy for the remainder of the regular school year; however, because the District did not provide STUDENT with speech and language therapy during the summer, his parents provided therapy privately. (Footnote 1)
When STUDENT was three years and nine months old, he was diagnosed with autism. In September 1997, MOTHER provided the District with a copy of the assessment report. In October 1997, the District undertook a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. The District also completed an APE assessment of STUDENT, which identified deficits in fine- and gross-motor skills. On October 16, 1997, the IEP team met and changed STUDENT's special education eligibility designation from speech and language to autism. The IEP team recommended placement in a special day class (SDC) for three hours daily, five days per week. The recommendation also was for an SDC employing a "speech and language" model. The IEP also called for STUDENT to receive speech and language services consistent with his previous IEP and collaborative APE services two times per week for a total of 40 minutes. The IEP called for STUDENT to integrate with regular education peers on the playground for 60 minutes daily, on monthly field trips, and on community outings for two hours each month. In December 1997, the parents obtained an independent OT assessment from the Child Development Center (CDC) of the Simi Valley Hospital & Health Care Services.
In March 1998, the District completed an OT assessment of STUDENT. (Footnote 2) The IEP team did not convene following the assessment; however, the District provided the parents with an IEP form recommending that STUDENT receive collaborative OT twice weekly for 30-minute sessions. The IEP did not contain OT goals and objectives. MOTHER gave her consent allowing the District to initiate OT services. She also requested the District convene an IEP to develop OT goals and objectives. On June 4, 1998, the IEP team reconvened to conduct its annual review of STUDENT's goals and objectives and placement. The IEP team recommended continued placement in the SDC with APE for two sessions weekly of 20 minutes each, collaborative OT for two sessions weekly of 30 minutes each, and collaborative speech and language therapy for three sessions weekly of 30 minutes each. Integration with regular education peers was recommended for 30 minutes daily on the playground and also during lunch.
Because STUDENT was not receiving APE during the summer of 1998, his parents provided private OT weekly for 50 to 60 minutes. In August 1998, the PARENTS obtained an independent evaluation of STUDENT from B. J. Freeman of the Autism Clinic at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA).
STUDENT returned to the SDC in the fall of 1998. In November 1998, MOTHER requested a PT assessment. On December 8, 1998, the IEP team convened to review reports of assessments obtained by the parents from the CDC and UCLA. On January 13, 1999, the IEP team met again. The IEP team did not reach consensus on STUDENT's need for clinic-based OT, individual speech and language therapy, clinic-based PT, or mainstreaming, which were requested by the parents. On February 17, 1999, the IEP team met for a third time. The resulting IEP calls for the following services: two weekly sessions of 20 minutes each of APE, two weekly sessions of 30 minutes each of collaborative OT, two weekly sessions of 30 minutes each of small-group speech and language therapy, and monthly PT consultation.
In March 1999, the parents obtained a PT assessment from the CDC because they did not believe the services offered by the District were sufficient to meet STUDENT's needs. Private PT was initiated and STUDENT received one 50- to 60-minute session weekly. In June 1999, the parents initiated private speech and language therapy to address STUDENT's oral-motor needs and, in July 1999, they increased STUDENT's private OT and PT to two sessions weekly.
As to the 1999-2000 school year, the parents concur with STUDENT's placement in a regular education kindergarten class. However, they continue to dispute the appropriateness of the level of speech and language, OT, and PT provided by the District. Petitioner contends that to meet his needs and to provide him with a FAPE, two hours weekly of speech and language therapy provided in two or three thirty-minute individual sessions, and one or two small-group sessions with two or three typically developing peers. Petitioner asserts that the sessions must address oral-motor and social-language deficits not presently addressed by the speech and language therapy provided by the District. Petitioner also contends that he requires a minimum of one hour weekly of clinic-based occupational therapy (OT) and one hour weekly of clinic-based physical therapy (PT). Petitioner asserts that he requires clinic-based OT and PT because the specific equipment he needs to address his needs is not available in the school setting.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Does STUDENT require the following designated instructional services (DIS) to meet his needs and to provide him with a free appropriate public education (FAPE):
(a) one or two sessions per week of small-group speech and language therapy with typically developing peers and two or three sessions per week of individual speech and language sessions;
(b) two session per week of clinic-based occupational therapy (OT);
(c) two sessions per week of clinic-based physical therapy (PT)?
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student's individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).)
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student's individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provided instruction or services that maximize the students' abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 207-208.)
In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.)
Speech and Language Therapy
Speech and language therapy is included in the list of related services available to the student. (Footnote 3) Thus, the District is required to provide STUDENT with speech and language therapy as a related service if speech and language therapy is necessary for STUDENT to benefit educationally from his instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363. Assessments in May and September 1999 by Elisabeth Cheryl Fletcher, C.C.C. (Certificate of Clinical Competence), STUDENT's private speech and language pathologist, provide information regarding STUDENT's speech and language deficits. (Petitioner's Exhibit 7) The assessments identified significant deficits in both receptive and expressive language. Ms. Fletcher found that, at age five years and five months, STUDENT's receptive language skills were at a two-year and seven-month level. STUDENT's expressive language skills fell at the two-year and nine- month level. Ms. Fletcher also identified auditory processing deficits, which affect STUDENT's ability to follow directions in class and respond to peers, and social-skills deficits. District assessors have also identified expressive, receptive, and social-language deficits. Thus, it is undisputed that STUDENT requires speech and language therapy to address receptive, expressive, and social language deficits. The District presently provides STUDENT one weekly individual speech and language therapy session and a second weekly session with a special education student whose language skills are higher than STUDENT's.
Petitioner contends that the present services he receives from the District are not appropriate, in part, because they do not address oral-motor deficits and do not sufficiently address deficits in social language. Petitioner asserts that to meet his needs and to provide him with a FAPE, he requires a minimum of two hours weekly of speech and language therapy provided in two or three, thirty-minute individual sessions, and one or two small-group sessions with two or three typically developing peers.
MOTHER, Ms. Fletcher, and Betty Jo ("B.J.") Freeman, Ph.D., professor of medical psychology at UCLA, testified about the adequacy of the District's speech and language therapy. Ms. Fletcher testified that STUDENT's speech and language goals and objectives generally are appropriate and address his primary areas of need; however, Ms. Fletcher also testified that STUDENT's IEP minimally addresses oral-motor deficits. Petitioner's witnesses testified that developing social skills is inadequately addressed by his IEP goals and objectives and that specific social skills should be taught by the speech pathologist. (Testimony of MOTHER and Ms. Fletcher.)
Dr. Freeman testified generally in support of STUDENT's need for additional services. (Footnote 4) Based on the lack of expected growth in communication skills, Dr. Freeman concluded that STUDENT must not be receiving proper services from the District. More specifically, Dr. Freeman attributed STUDENT's inadequate progress to the District's failure to provide individual speech and language therapy or social structuring.(Footnote 5) Dr. Freeman explained that, with proper intervention, STUDENT's verbal scores on intelligence testing should increase, given her conclusion that STUDENT has average intelligence, despite test scores showing below average intelligence. However, on both initial and follow-up administration of the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence - Revised, STUDENT obtained standard scores of 64 on verbal measures of intelligence. On the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, STUDENT showed some improvement in communication skills but not to the level expected by Dr. Freeman.
Turning to the contention that STUDENT has oral-motor needs that must be addressed by the District's speech and language therapy, Linda Gomberg, STUDENT's SDC teacher during the 1997-1998 school year, identified oral-motor deficits while STUDENT was in her class. For example, Ms. Gomberg noted that, in May 1998, STUDENT could not move his tongue in a number of different ways. She also stated that STUDENT's lips did not move symmetrically and his top lip remained stationary. (See Petitioner's Exhibit 24, pp. 141-143.) In May 1999, one year after Ms. Gomberg's assessment, Ms. Fletcher observed the following during her assessment of STUDENT: STUDENT's lip range of motion was diminished; his lip and cheek strength was decreased; his tongue did not move automatically; and, when he moved his tongue, his entire jaw moved as well. Ms. Fletcher testified that oral-motor deficits affect STUDENT's speech intelligibility and use of facial expression. Ms. Fletcher also testified the IEP goal to improve oral-motor skills was too general to implement. (Petitioner's Exhibit 16)
Rebecca "Becky" Singhal, C.C.C., testified on behalf of the District. Ms. Singhal has provided STUDENT's therapy at school since the 1998-1999 school year. As to STUDENT's oral-motor skills, Ms. Singhal stated that while STUDENT's bottom lip hangs, she has not observed that it affects his drinking, eating, or speaking. She also does not believe that STUDENT has difficulty using facial expressions to show emotions. He has a big grin when he is happy and tears when he is unhappy. Ms. Singhal testified that oral-motor therapy would be necessary only if STUDENT lacked the requisite oral-motor skills to produce comprehensible speech, keep food or liquids in his mouth, chew food, or breath. In summary, Ms. Singhal does not dispute that STUDENT has oral-motor deficits; however, she has not provided him with oral-motor therapy and concluded that STUDENT's deficits do not rise to the level of needing oral-motor therapy.
STUDENT's IEP dated June 4, 1998, includes the following goal: "STUDENT will improve his tongue, lip and jaw mobility by 6/99." Despite the IEP team's conclusion that STUDENT exhibited oral-motor deficits for which he required therapy, Ms. Singhal has not addressed oral-motor skills during the therapy she has been providing for STUDENT since 1998. There also is no evidence that STUDENT has met the IEP goal related to oral-motor skills. Ms. Fletcher's testimony establishes that STUDENT presently exhibits the same oral-motor deficits to the same extent as identified by Ms. Gomberg in 1998. Based on the above, it is concluded that STUDENT has oral-motor deficits that must be addressed through speech and language therapy.
Nearly all witnesses expressed concern about STUDENT's significant deficits in social skills. MOTHER testified that STUDENT's current IEP lacks goals and objectives related to socialization. In her opinion, STUDENT requires one to two small-group sessions weekly with typically developing peers to provide him with models of appropriate turn-taking and language, and to enhance opportunities for him to develop his social skills with peers.
Classroom staff also echoed concerns related to STUDENT's lack of interactions with peers. Mary Vehrs, full inclusion facilitator, testified that STUDENT is beginning to "check" with other students to see what they are doing when a novel activity is introduced; however, Ms. Vehrs described STUDENT's interactions with peers as "limited." Susan Liebling, STUDENT's kindergarten teacher, testified similarly. Despite Ms. Singhal's testimony that the therapy she provides STUDENT meets his needs, she shared Ms. Fletcher's concerns about STUDENT's substantial lack of social skills with peers and concurred that STUDENT would benefit from additional opportunities to develop social language through structured play or a social skills group with regular education peers.
STUDENT is eligible for special education because of the diagnosis of autism. Poor social and language skills are intrinsic to the diagnosis of autism. The evidence establishes that STUDENT's social skills with his regular education kindergarten peers is significantly impaired. His current therapy is either individual or with one other special education peer. Therefore, based on the substantial concerns by the District and private persons working with STUDENT, it is concluded that STUDENT needs additional therapy to develop social skills. The testimony establishes that speech and language therapy should play an important role in improving those skills by teaching STUDENT specific social-language skills, which can then be practiced with peers in a structured session under the direction of the speech and language pathologist. For these reasons, it is concluded that STUDENT should receive specific instruction in social language and an additional weekly session with the speech and language pathologist to provide him with opportunities to practice those skills with a small group of kindergarten peers. The speech and language pathologist shall provide these structured interactions during small-group activities in the classroom and on the playground.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District's therapy sufficiently addresses STUDENT's speech and language needs except as discussed above with respect to oral-motor and social skills. Ms. Singhal testified in great detail the ways she addresses goals and objectives related to increasing STUDENT's use of pronouns and possessives; learning basic concepts such as first, last, less, and more; increasing length of sentences; storytelling; and asking questions and making comments. Ms. Singhal also testified persuasively that STUDENT has made the following progress toward meeting speech and language goals and objectives. STUDENT partially met objectives related to pronouns. He knows the pronoun "I" and continues to have difficulty with "he" and "she." As to the objective related to following complex directions, STUDENT has mastered all but "few" and "top." STUDENT is able to answer simple questions three out of five times. STUDENT has met objectives related to understanding negatives, same, and different. Ms. Singhal works closely with STUDENT and testified specifically that the therapy she provides meets STUDENT's needs. On the other hand, Dr. Freeman's testimony was very general and she reached rather sweeping conclusions regarding the adequacy of therapy that she has never observed. Ms. Fletcher acknowledged that her conclusions were based primarily on her one-to-one work with STUDENT and a single observation of a speech and language session at school. In conclusion, the District's speech and language therapy adequately addresses STUDENT's needs except as to oral-motor deficits and developing social skills. To address these needs, it is concluded that STUDENT requires an additional weekly session of individual therapy to address oral-motor deficits and to instruct him in specific social-language skills to facilitate peer interactions. He also requires an additional weekly session of structured interactions with a small group of typically developing peers to practice social skills that he has learned during individual sessions.
Occupational Therapy
Occupational therapy is included in the list of related services available to the student. (Footnote 6) Thus, the District is required to provide STUDENT with OT as a related service if OT is necessary for STUDENT to benefit educationally from his instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363. Occupational therapy is provided to address:
(A) Improving, developing or restoring functions impaired or lost through illness, injury, or deprivation; (B) Improving ability to perform tasks for independent functioning if functions are impaired or lost; and (C) Preventing, through early intervention, initial or further impairment or loss of function.
34 C.F.R. 300.24(b)(5)(ii)(A) and (B).
The testimony of witnesses and the results of assessments establish that STUDENT has visual-motor, fine-motor, tactile, proprioceptive, vestibular, organizational, and sensory processing deficits which affect his functioning at school. (Footnote 7) For example, visual-motor deficits affect STUDENT's ability to color, draw, write, and process what he sees on paper. Fine-motor deficits affect his ability to turn pages and use a pencil. Tactile deficits may result in his needing a larger personal space than other children and touch may be painful or threatening. Tactile deficits may also affect STUDENT's interactions with peers. Proprioceptive deficits affect motor planning. Vestibular deficits affect planning and balance. Sensory processing deficits affect STUDENT's overall alertness and arousal, which need to be at an appropriate level for learning. (Testimony of Dr. Freeman, Tanya Brustinov, registered occupational therapist (OTR) who provides STUDENT private OT, and Petitioner's Exhibits 2, 5, and 9)The parties agree that for STUDENT to benefit from his special education, he requires the related service of OT. Accordingly, STUDENT's IEP includes OT as a related service. The District presently provides twice weekly OT. Petitioner contends that to meet his needs and to provide him with a FAPE, he requires a minimum of one hour weekly of clinic-based occupational therapy (OT) Petitioner further asserts that he requires clinic-based OT because the specific equipment he needs to address his needs is not available in the school setting.
MOTHER and Ms. Brustinov testified that STUDENT's current IEP goals and objectives and the OT services provided by the District are deficient because they do not address STUDENT's sensory- motor deficits. Their testimony of STUDENT's classroom teacher establishes that STUDENT has difficulty transitioning, paying attention to task, remaining seated, and following multi-step instruction. MOTHER and Ms. Brustinov attribute the above deficits to the failure of the District's program to meet STUDENT's sensory-motor needs. Ms. Brustinov provides STUDENT with a weekly session of OT at the CDC. She testified that it is necessary to provide STUDENT with multisensory experiences to get him to the appropriate level of arousal for learning to take place. Ms. Brustinov recommended use of a therapy ball, a ball pit and swings that move in different ways and in different planes to provide STUDENT with varying types of vestibular input. According to Ms. Brustinov, activities at the school provide only proprioceptive and tactile stimulation, which are insufficient to address STUDENT's moderate sensory deficits. Ms. Brustinov has worked with STUDENT and demonstrated an understanding of OT in general and of STUDENT's needs in particular. On the other hand, Jennifer Kreitman, OTR, also is familiar with STUDENT's needs. Ms. Kreitman provided STUDENT's OT at school from September 1998 to October 1999. (Footnote 8) Ms. Kreitman testified that the District is providing appropriate OT services for STUDENT. Her testimony establishes that STUDENT's needs are being addressed in the following manner. Vestibular needs are addressed by activities such as bouncing a ball and riding a scooter board. Proprioceptor needs are met by placing a weighted vest or blankets on STUDENT, by rolling a big therapy ball on top of STUDENT, by having him crawl through a tunnel, and by engaging in activities such as walking like a particular animal. Tactile needs are addressed by drawing on shaving cream and spreading glue with his fingers. To address goals and objectives related to writing, cutting, coloring, and self-help skills, Ms. Kreitman has STUDENT engage in activities she described as "power, precision, arch development and wrist stabilization activities." Specific activities are itemized in Respondent's Exhibit 19. For example, to build STUDENT's hand strength, Ms. Kreitman has STUDENT do activities with a Sparkle Brite toy. The activities involve putting in and pulling out colored pegs to make designs. She also uses slant boards and a vibrating pen. Ms. Kreitman also consults with the teacher to address ways to use playground equipment including, swings, slides, and climbing apparatus, and has provided the parents with activities for home.
Ms. Kreitman's testimony was supported by the testimony of Nancy Bagatelle, OTR. Ms. Bagatelle coordinates the pediatric therapy clinic at the University of Southern California. Ms. Bagatelle was asked by the District to review STUDENT's IEP and assessments, and to render an opinion regarding STUDENT's OT needs. (Footnote 9) Ms. Bagatelle concluded that neither assessments nor STUDENT's IEP indicates that he requires clinic-based OT. In fact, she stated that to effectively address STUDENT's needs, OT should be provided at his school. For example, Ms. Bagatelle testified that STUDENT requires a sensory diet every two to three hours to calm and organize himself. Because the benefits of a sensory diet last for a limited time period, provision of a sensory diet at weekly OT sessions outside of the school day would not carry over to the educational environment. On the other hand, a sensory diet of deep pressure and "heavy work" can be applied in STUDENT's class. Ms. Bagatelle testified that STUDENT can wear weighted vests and "get squished" in a bean bag chair. Activities to address STUDENT's fine-motor needs can also be provided in a classroom environment. For example, a kindergarten classroom generally has materials and activities involving cutting, pasting, writing, and coloring.
Ms. Bagatelle additionally testified that research "in the field" has shown that a collaborative/consultative model of OT in the educational environment is both appropriate and preferred. Ms. Bagatelle testified that studies have shown that developmentally delayed students receiving collaborative/consultative OT made better achievement toward their IEP goals and objectives than students receiving other types of OT such as clinic-based. They also were better able to carry over the skills they learned to different environments. Their success was attributed to the fact that the occupational therapist consulted with and trained classroom staff who were then able to provide activities during the course of the school day to support OT.
As to whether STUDENT is benefitting from the OT provided by the District, Ms. Bagatelle concluded that based on the information she gleaned from reviewing STUDENT's records, the model employed by the District to provide STUDENT with OT is meeting his needs and that he is progressing toward meeting IEP goals and objectives in OT. Ms. Kreitman testified that STUDENT has made slow but steady progress toward meeting his goals and objectives. She testified that STUDENT has demonstrated progress in writing his name, cutting simple shapes on a line, holding his pencil with the proper grip, and willingly participating in tactile activities.
The fact that Ms. Kreitman does not have all of the same equipment available to her at the school site that is available at the clinic is not dispositive, given Ms. Kreitman's credible testimony regarding the way she addresses STUDENT's needs and STUDENT's growth toward meeting IEP goals and objectives. As previously noted, the IDEA and Rowley do not require the District to provide the best education available to a student. Based on the testimony of Ms. Kreitman and Ms. Bagatelle, it is concluded that the District has provided OT that addresses STUDENT's needs and complies with the requirements of special education law set forth above. Therefore, Petitioner's request for clinic-based OT is denied.
Physical Therapy
Physical therapy (PT) is included in the list of related services available to the student. Thus, the District is required to provide STUDENT with PT as a related service if PT is necessary for STUDENT to benefit educationally from his instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363. There is no dispute that STUDENT has motor deficits and that he is entitled to PT as a required related service. Petitioner contends that, to meet his needs, he requires one hour weekly of clinic-based physical therapy (PT). Petitioner asserts that clinic-based therapy is necessary because of the equipment available at the clinic. The District contends that the combination of monthly PT consults and APE meet STUDENT's needs and that he is benefitting from those services. The physical therapist consults with the APE specialist who then provides the activities to address STUDENT's needs.
Charmayne Beck, who provides private PT to STUDENT testified on his behalf. Ms. Beck is a licensed physical therapist employed at the CDC. Ms. Beck's assessment of STUDENT on March 26, 1999, revealed that STUDENT's gross-motor skills were below age expectations. Ms. Beck testified that STUDENT had an awkward gait, impaired and weak bilateral coordination, and exhibited some tactile defensiveness. (Petitioner's Exhibit 6.) On Ms. Beck's reassessment on September 3, 1999, STUDENT continued to exhibit weaknesses in posture and balance. STUDENT cannot currently hold on to the "monkey bars" or access the playground equipment at his school. Ms. Beck stated that STUDENT's sensory processing and motor needs are educational in nature. For example, STUDENT requires good posture to participate in table top activities in his classroom. Because STUDENT cannot keep up with peers on the playground or access play equipment, his motor deficits additionally have a negative affect on his social skills development.
Ms. Beck testified that the District's program does not sufficiently address STUDENT's motor and sensory deficits. APE does not address the "quality" of movement or the neurological basis of STUDENT's motor deficits. APE also does not address STUDENT's sensory integration needs. Ms. Beck recommended that STUDENT receive one to two sessions weekly in a clinic setting to allow him access to equipment that will address these deficits.
Catherine LaRuffa, STUDENT's adapted physical education (APE) teacher for the past two school years, testified regarding the way APE services address STUDENT's gross-motor deficits. Ms. LaRuffa testified that during weekly sessions with STUDENT, she addresses goals and objectives to improve balance, strength, endurance, fitness, locomotion, and eye-hand and eye-foot coordination. Ms. LaRuffa provided the following examples of how she meets STUDENT's needs. She constructs an obstacle course to address balance, climbing, and motor-planning skills. She gives STUDENT multi-step directions to follow such as "gallop to the bucket and put the bean bag in the bucket." To address low muscle tone, Ms. LaRuffa has STUDENT pull and push arms and legs with another student while seated on the ground. To improve his trunk and shoulder muscles, Ms. LaRuffa engages STUDENT in activities using a parachute. To strengthen STUDENT's upper body, she has STUDENT hang from the "monkey bars." To address his range of motion, Ms. LaRuffa has STUDENT engage in moving to music with a hoop or ribbons. To improve STUDENT's gait, Ms. LaRuffa has STUDENT walk on lines and on a balance beam.
Ms. LaRuffa testified that she modifies activities, as necessary, and teaches STUDENT skills that he does not know so that he can participate in the regular PE curriculum. She also physically and verbally prompts him to engage in PE activities. Ms. LaRuffa testified that she consults with Ms. Hall, STUDENT's physical therapist. Ms. Hall has made suggestions to Ms. LaRuffa regarding specific ways in which to work with STUDENT.
As with OT, the Petitioner principally is seeking clinic-based services because of the equipment available at a clinic setting that may not be available at the school site. However, Ms. LaRuffa's testimony establishes that alternative equipment is available at the school site which she has used to implement STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives. According to Ms. LaRuffa, the school has the following equipment which can be used to address STUDENT's PT and APE goals and objectives: swings, balance beam, climbing apparatus, different size hurdles, a high wall, "monkey bars," climbing poles, and a three-foot bar for limbo activities.
As to whether APE addresses the underlying basis for STUDENT's deficits, Ms. LaRuffa testified persuasively that she consults with the physical therapist to determine activities to use with STUDENT to address his underlying deficits. Moreover, she is able to address STUDENT's needs individually and with his peers, which she finds motivating for STUDENT. Because Ms. LaRuffa consults with STUDENT's classroom teacher, follow-up activities addressing the same skills may be used in the classroom. As to STUDENT's progress, Ms. LaRuffa's testimony establishes that STUDENT has made adequate progress toward meeting his IEP goals and objectives to satisfy the requirements of IDEA and Rowley. STUDENT met his goal for catching. He also has made progress on goals and objectives related to locomotion, running, throwing, kicking, jumping, and balance. He is getting stronger and his balance is improving. Ms. LaRuffa described STUDENT's progress in balancing as "great." (See also Respondent's Exhibits11 and 12.) Ms. LaRuffa has worked with STUDENT for over a year and is able to appraise his progress in the school environment where STUDENT uses the skills he is learning. With the support he receives from APE and PT consultations, Ms. LaRuffa testified persuasively that STUDENT is participating successfully in the regular physical education program with his kindergarten peers. Therefore, based on Ms. LaRuffa's testimony, it is concluded that the District's combination of PT and APE services meets STUDENT's need. Accordingly, Petitioner's request for clinic-based PT is denied.
ISSUE NO. 2: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of occupational therapy (OT) they provided for STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.
Petitioner seeks reimbursement in the amount of $1,140 for clinic-based OT the parents provided for STUDENT. It has been determined above that the District provided appropriate OT for STUDENT. Therefore, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
ISSUE NO. 1: Does STUDENT require the following designated instructional services (DIS) to meet his needs and to provide him with a free appropriate public education (FAPE):
(a) one or two sessions per week of small-group speech and language therapy with typically developing peers and two or three sessions per week of individual speech and language sessions;
(b) two session per week of clinic-based occupational therapy (OT);
(c) two sessions per week of clinic-based physical therapy (PT)?
Petitioner prevailed as to speech and language therapy. The District prevailed as to clinic-based OT and PT.
ISSUE NO. 2: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of occupational therapy (OT) they provided for STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue.
ORDER
(1) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to:
(a) develop goals and objectives to address oral-motor deficits including diminished range of motion of the lips and tongue and decreased lip and cheek strength, and social-language skills; and (b) conform STUDENT's IEP to the decision regarding the provision of additional speech and language therapy as set forth in Order No. (2).
(2) Within 20 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall provide STUDENT with one 30-minute weekly session of individual therapy to address oral-motor deficits and to provide instruction in social-language skills, and one 30-minute weekly session facilitated by the speech and language pathologist in the classroom during small-group activities or on the playground to provide STUDENT opportunities to practice social skills with two or more typically developing peers.
(3) Petitioner's other requests for relief are denied.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: April 12, 2000 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. At the beginning of the hearing, the District agreed to reimburse the PARENTS for the costs of the speech and language therapy they procured for STUDENT during the summer of 1997.
2. The District's earlier APE assessment of STUDENT identified gross- and fine-motor deficits; however, because the assessment did not include an OT assessment, MOTHER then requested that the District undertake an OT assessment.
3. California's term for related services is "designated instruction and services" or "DIS."
4. Dr. Freeman first met STUDENT in August 1998 when he participated in an assessment at the Autism Clinic at UCLA. She also saw STUDENT for a follow-up assessment in September 1999.
5. Dr. Freeman also testified that STUDENT requires individual PT. The level of PT STUDENT requires is discussed below.
6. California's term for related services is "designated instruction and services" or "DIS."
7. Ms. Brustinov described "visual-motor" as eye-hand coordination; "fine-motor" as the ability to use small muscles of the hand to manipulate objects; "tactile" as the sense of touch; "proprioceptive" as the position of body parts in relation to motor planning; "vestibular" as where the body is in relation to space; and "organization" as following directions.
8. Ms. Kreitman is currently on maternity leave.
9. Ms. Bagatelle has never met STUDENT or spoken to any of his service providers.
