California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 15, 2005

Student v. Redwood City Elementary School District

SEHO Case No. SN 3002-04 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski

Redwood City Elementary must provide 25 hours of tutoring for a late special education referral; its IEP offers were upheld.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 10 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a seven-year-old second grader at Redwood City Elementary School District's Orion Alternative Elementary School filed for due process in December 2004. At a December 9, 2004 IEP meeting, the student had been found eligible for special education with a specific learning disability in reading and writing (mild dyslexia). The parents claimed the District should have identified him years earlier and that its offers were inadequate. They also sought reimbursement and a private placement.

The Hearing Officer dismissed claims arising before December 20, 2001 under the three-year statute of limitations. The District's child-find outreach to private preschools was adequate. The student's kindergarten attention and writing issues were typical for his age and were addressed through student study team meetings. But by May 12, 2004, when his first-grade teacher wrote a letter supporting private testing, the District had reason to suspect a disability. It should have held an IEP meeting by September 28, 2004. As a result, it denied FAPE from that date until December 9, 2004.

The District's offers of resource specialist pull-out services, later changed to push-in services, used a multisensory approach and offered FAPE. So did its consultative occupational therapy offer. The parents' procedural claims failed. Reimbursement for the private evaluation, preschool tuition, and two private programs was denied. The District must provide 25 hours of one-to-one reading and writing tutoring within one year.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO set a "reason to suspect" date from a teacher's letter supporting testing. It then counted the assessment-plan and IEP deadlines forward across summer break to find a limited denial of FAPE. It also shows that SEHO denied reimbursement for a private evaluation completed before the district's IEP deadline.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue Preliminary. District's oral motion to dismiss claims, including child-find claims back to July 2000, that accrued more than three years before the December 20, 2004 filing (Ed. Code 56505(j)).

    Because the parents knew of the student's deficits from age three on, claims that arose before December 20, 2001 were dismissed as outside the three-year limitations period.

  2. District prevailedChild find

    Issue 1. Did the District violate its child-find obligation by failing to search, locate, and serve STUDENT as a student with a suspected disability during the period December 20, 2001, to August 2002?

    The District's and SELPA's child-find outreach (letters to private preschools, media notices, referral procedures) was adequate, and the preschooler's focus and fine motor issues were being addressed and did not call for a referral.

  3. District prevailedChild find

    Issue 2a. Did the District fail to assess STUDENT as a student with a suspected disability during the period September 2002 to August 2004?

    Kindergarten attention and writing issues were developmentally typical and were handled through student study team meetings. By May 12, 2004, however, the District had reason to suspect a disability, which started the assessment and IEP timelines (IEP due by September 28, 2004).

  4. Student prevailedChild find

    Issue 2b. Did the District fail to assess STUDENT as a student with a suspected disability during the period September 2004 to December 2004?

    Because the District did not hold an IEP meeting until December 9, 2004, it denied FAPE from September 28, 2004 to December 9, 2004.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3 (Dec. 9 and 14, 2004 – procedure). Did the District commit procedural violations by providing pull-out services before an IEP meeting, predetermining the RSP offer at the December 9 meeting, and failing to have a psychologist at the December 14 meeting?

    The short-term pull-out services were general education support given with parent consent. The parents, with counsel and their private psychologist present, had a fair chance to discuss the RSP recommendation. No psychologist was required on December 14 because both assessors had already presented on December 9.

  6. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3 (Dec. 9 and 14, 2004 – substance). Was the District's program and placement offer made at the December 9 and 14, 2004 IEP meetings designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit?

    General education with RSP pull-out (four 40-minute sessions per week) using a systematic multisensory approach drawn from several programs offered FAPE. One-to-one Slingerland/Lindamood-Bell services were not required, and deferring the ESY decision until regression-recoupment data existed was reasonable.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3 (Jan. 31, 2005). Was the District's offer of OT consultative services made at the January 31, 2005 IEP meeting designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit; did the District miss the 50-day timeline or lack a special education teacher at the meeting?

    The OT assessment timeline began when the parents requested OT on December 9, so the January 31 meeting was timely. The co-director's attendance met the special education teacher requirement, and four to six consultative in-class OT sessions using the ALERT program were appropriate.

  8. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3 (Feb. 28, 2005). Was the District's revised offer of push-in RSP services made at the February 28, 2005 IEP meeting designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit; was it a violation not to have a psychologist and a special education teacher present?

    Push-in RSP services (four 45-minute sessions per week) with a qualified resource specialist offered FAPE. No procedural violation occurred because the co-director with a special education credential attended and no psychologist was required.

  9. Issue 4. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of assessments and/or services privately obtained?

    Reimbursement was denied for the private psychoeducational evaluation (completed before the District's IEP deadline), preschool tuition (no child-find violation), BrightStar (no notice, no proof of cost or benefit) and Great Leaps (no evidence).

  10. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services?

    For the denial of FAPE lasting about two and a half months, the Hearing Officer awarded 25 hours of one-to-one tutoring but denied prospective nonpublic school placement.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Compensatory education. District to provide 25 hours of one-on-one tutoring services to address the student's needs in written language and reading, to be provided within one year of the date of the Decision.
  • IEP team directed to attach the OT goals and objectives to the January 31, 2005 addendum IEP.

Total: 25 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23; Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Dept. of Education, State of Hawaii v. Cari Rae S.; Cal. Educ. Code 56505(j); Cal. Educ. Code 56301; Cal. Educ. Code 56344

People named in the decision

  • John T. Brentar, Ph.D., private consulting psychologist; independent assessor and witness for Student, Morrissey/Compton Educational Center, Inc.
  • Anne Varney, educational specialist, private assessor, Morrissey/Compton Educational Center, Inc.
  • Renee Lamborn, co-director of special education; school psychologist, Redwood City Elementary School District
  • Carla Crenshaw-Preising, co-director of special education, Redwood City Elementary School District
  • Tina Prozell, owner-teacher, private preschool; witness for Student, San Mateo Montessori Preschool
  • Anne DeBattista, program manager and pediatric nurse practitioner; witness for Student, Lucile Packard Children's Hospital at Stanford
  • Martha Monetti, Ph.D., school psychologist, Redwood City Elementary School District
  • Melissa Musch, second grade general education teacher, Orion Alternative Elementary School
  • Rebecca Jackson, former kindergarten teacher, Orion Alternative Elementary School
  • Chris Selberg, resource specialist teacher, Redwood City Elementary School District
  • Amy Cooper, occupational therapist, Associated Learning and Language Specialists (ALLS)
  • Lorien Chambers, first grade teacher, Orion Alternative Elementary School
  • Sue Shalvey, former principal, Orion Alternative Elementary School
  • Cathy Okubo, principal, Orion Alternative Elementary School
  • Trudy Weber, resource specialist, Orion Alternative Elementary School
  • Dr. Schlumpberger, student's pediatrician (private provider)
  • Dr. Cheyette, neurologist (private provider)
  • Mr. Fletcher, role not stated (not called as witness)
  • BrightStar, private biofeedback program
  • Great Leaps, private reading program

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law, in Redwood City, California, on March 8-9 and March 15-18, 2005.

STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Susan Foley. Also present on STUDENT=s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. FATHER, STUDENT=s father, was present during the morning of March 15 and briefly on March 17. Redwood City Elementary School District (District or Respondent) was represented at the hearing by deputy county counsel Judith A. Holiber, of the County Counsel=s office of San Mateo County. Carla Crenshaw-Preising and Renee Lamborn, co-directors of special education, were also present on behalf of the District.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: John T. Brentar, Ph.D., consulting psychologist with Morrissey/Compton Educational Center, Inc.; Renee Lamborn, co-director of special education; Carla Crenshaw-Preising, co-director of special education; MOTHER, STUDENT=s mother; Tina Prozell, owner-teacher, San Mateo Montessori Preschool; Anne DeBattista, program manager for the Muriel Johnson behavioral unit of Lucille Packard Children=s Hospital at Stanford University and pediatric nurse practitioner at the hospital.

Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: Martha Monetti, Ph.D., school psychologist; Melissa Musch, second grade teacher at Orion alternative elementary school; Rebecca Jackson, former kindergarten teacher at Orion; Chris Selberg, a District resource specialist teacher; and Amy Cooper, an occupational therapist with Associated Learning and Language Specialists (ALLS).

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Petitioner first asserted that the District failed to satisfy its child-find obligations back to July 2000, when he attained age three. The District made an oral motion to dismiss and asserted that because Petitioner filed for due process on December 20, 2004, he was precluded by California=s three-year statute of limitations from raising any issues for hearing that accrued prior to December 20, 2001.

California Education Code section 56505(j) provides that A[a]ny request for a due process hearing arising under subdivision (a) of section 56501 shall be filed within three years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for the request. During oral argument, Petitioner=s attorney acknowledged that Petitioner=s parents knew of STUDENT=s deficits from age three to the present. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer granted the District=s motion and dismissed Petitioner=s claims that accrued prior to December 20, 2001. Moreover, in subsequent testimony, MOTHER acknowledged that she knew of STUDENT=s fine motor deficits and focusing issues during the entire period that STUDENT attended the Montessori preschool.

During the due process hearing, Petitioner moved into evidence a copy of a March 2, 2005 letter prepared by Dr. Brentar at the request of MOTHER. Within the letter, Dr. Brentar recommended that STUDENT receive a Acomprehensive full-day program that will focus on developing his reading and writing skills using a multisensory, well-researched, and scientifically based program designed for dyslexic students@ and that the instruction Ashould occur in a structured classroom with a low teacher-student ratio with children with comparable needs.@ The Hearing Officer sustained the District=s objection on the basis of relevance, because Dr. Brentar had not presented this recommendation at the IEP team meeting that he attended on December 9, 2004, nor was the recommendation presented at any of the IEP meetings held for STUDENT during the 2004-2005 school year. However, the Hearing Officer admitted the letter for a limited purpose: as evidence relating to Petitioner=s request for a prospective placement in a program with the characteristics set forth within Dr. Brentar=s March 2, 2005 letter. (Pet. Exh. G-12.)

After the hearing, Petitioner=s attorney, Ms. Susan Foley, submitted Petitioner=s request that the Hearing Officer take administrative notice of the District=s Atraditional school calendars@ for the 2003-2004 and 2004-2005 school years. (Pet. Exh. X and Y.) The request, received by the Hearing Office on March 29, 2005, indicates that a copy of the request was served by fax and by mail on Ms. Judith Holiber, the attorney for the District.

The Hearing Office did not receive a response from the District to Petitioner=s request, nor did the District refer to Petitioner=s request within the District=s written brief that was received by the Hearing Office several days after receipt of Petitioner=s application for administrative notice.

Special education law does not specifically provide for taking administrative notice. Thus, the Hearing Officer looks to the California Evidence Code for guidance. Section 452(h) of the Evidence Code provides that judicial (administrative) notice may be taken of Afacts and propositions that are not reasonably subject to dispute and are capable of immediate and accurate determination by resort to sources of reasonably indisputable accuracy.@ The Hearing Officer finds that the District=s traditional school calendars meet the criteria for section 452(h), because the school district publishes the school calendars and can thus determine the accuracy of its own calendars with Areasonably indisputable accuracy.@

Additionally, section 453(a) of the Evidence Code provides that a party who requests such notice must give Aeach adverse party sufficient notice of the request through the pleadings or otherwise, to enable such adverse party to prepare to meet the request.@ The District had an opportunity to respond to Petitioner=s request for administrative notice within its written closing brief but did not object within its closing brief to Petitioner=s request. The Hearing Officer finds that because the District had an opportunity to respond to Petitioner=s request within the District=s closing brief, section 453(a)=s notice requirement was satisfied.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer grants Petitioner=s request that the Hearing Officer take administrative notice of the District=s traditional school calendars for the 2003-2004 and 2004-2005 school years. The Hearing Officer takes administrative notice of the District=s school calendars at Petitioner=s Exhibits. X and Y.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

1. Did the District violate its Achild-find@ obligation by failing to search, locate, and serve STUDENT as a student with a suspected disability during the period December 20, 2001, to August 2002?

2. Did the District fail to assess STUDENT as a student with a suspected disability a. during the period September 2002 to August 2004?

b. during the period September 2004 to December 2004?

3. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE within its December 9 and 14, 2004 individualized education program (IEP) offer, and as supplemented by the January 31, and February 28, 2005 revised IEP offers?

4. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for any or all of the above-mentioned periods, are STUDENT=s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of assessments and/or services privately obtained?

5. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for any or all of the above-mentioned periods, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that the District failed to fulfill its child-find obligation by failing to implement systematically appropriate child-find procedures that should have identified him as student with a disability from December 20, 2001 until December 9, 2004, when an IEP team first found him eligible for special education and related services. Petitioner acknowledges that although it would be Aspeculative@ to determine under which disability category he would have qualified prior to his enrollment in a District kindergarten at age five, Petitioner asserts prior to his enrollment in kindergarten he attended the San Mateo Montessori Preschool for two years. Petitioner asserts that he had processing issues that were Aclearly@ identifiable, and that the Montessori preschool used a Amultisensory methodology@ that addressed his Aprocessing issues, focusing issues, distractibility, and fine motor deficits.@

Petitioner further contends that the District committed procedural violations that led to a serious infringement of parental participation in the IEP process that resulted in a denial of a FAPE procedurally during the 2004-2005 school year as follows: (1) by providing him with a resource Apull-out@ placement prior to holding an IEP team meeting; (2) by making a Apredetermined@ placement offer at the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting; (3) by failing to have a psychologist in attendance at the December 14, 2004 IEP meeting; (4) by failing to comply with the 50-day timeline from the date his parent signed the assessment plan, November 18, 2004, until the date the IEP team met to consider the District=s occupational therapy evaluation, January 31, 2005; (5) by failing to have a special education teacher in attendance at the January 31, 2005 IEP meeting; (6) and by failing to have a special education teacher and a psychologist in attendance at that February 28, 2005 IEP meeting.

Additionally, Petitioner contends that the District=s initial IEP offer made on December 7 and 14, 2004, was not a FAPE because the offer did not include the services of a resource specialist trained in a Amultisensory@ teaching methodology to address his dyslexia, because the offer of pull-out RSP services was not appropriate for him, and because the offer did not include extended school year (ESY) services. Petitioner also contends that the offer did not meet his fine motor needs.

Petitioner also contends that the District=s offer of OT services at the January 31, 2005 IEP meeting did not address his fine motor concerns (regarding snapping, zipping, and shoe tying). Additionally, Petitioner contends that the District=s revised February 28, 2005 IEP offer of push-in services did not meet his needs.

Petitioner seeks reimbursement for educational services privately obtained at the Montessori preschool from December 20, 2001, until July 2002. Petitioner also seeks reimbursement for an independent psycho-educational evaluation conducted by Dr. Brentar and Ms. Varney of Morrissey-Compton, Educational Center, Inc. (Morrissey/Compton), and for the costs of educational services privately obtained from the BrightStar program in November and December 2004 as well as for the Great Leaps program. Petitioner seeks as compensatory education services, prospective placement at a school with the characteristics outlined within Dr. Brentar=s March 2, 2005 letter.

The District asserts it implemented at all relevant times, appropriate child-find procedures to identify children with a disability. The District also asserts that STUDENT was performing within the Anormal@ developmental range for his age during preschool, kindergarten and first grade, and so there was no reason to refer him for special education services during the period STUDENT attended preschool, kindergarten, and first grade.

The District asserts that it complied with the legal requirements that govern IEP meetings and properly convened IEP meetings held on December 9 and 14, 2004, and on January 31 and February 28, 2005. The District further asserts that it offered STUDENT a substantive FAPE at the December 9 and 14, 2004 IEP meetings, and as supplemented by revised offers made at the January 31 and February 28, 2005 IEP meetings. The District contends that Petitioner=s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Brentar=s psycho-educational assessment because it was not made out of disagreement with a District assessment. The District also asserts that because it satisfied the legal requirements for child find, and because each offer it made in December 2004, January 2005, and February 2005, was a FAPE, STUDENT=s parents and STUDENT are not entitled to reimbursement of the costs of privately obtained assessments and/or educational services or compensatory education services.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seven-year-old who resides with his parents, FATHER and MOTHER, within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Redwood City Elementary School District (District). (Footnote 2) STUDENT, who is his parents= only child, has resided within the District his entire life. At present, STUDENT attends second grade at the District=s Orion Alternative Elementary School (Orion). The regular education class is taught by Ms. Melissa Musch.

STUDENT first became eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) (in reading and writing) at an individualized education program (IEP) team meeting held on December 9, 2004. STUDENT appears to have a mild form of dyslexia and also a very superior verbal aptitude. (Test. of Dr. Brentar and Ms. Selberg.)

Preschool B 2001-2002 school year

When STUDENT turned age three in July 2000, STUDENT was enrolled by his parents in a private preschool, the San Mateo Montessori Preschoool (Montessori preschool). STUDENT attended the private preschool from age three until age five (July 2002). The Montessori preschool operates year-round, and STUDENT received assistance with fine motor development. STUDENT developed the strength and dexterity to hold a pencil and to write. At completion of preschool, STUDENT was able to print numbers and his first name. Neither STUDENT=s parents nor Montessori school staff members referred STUDENT to the District for a special education assessment. (Test. of Ms. Prozell and MOTHER.)

Kindergarten B 2002-2003 school year

In September 2002, STUDENT started kindergarten at Orion and was taught by Ms. Rebecca Jackson. (Footnote 3) During the fall parent-teacher conference in mid-November, MOTHER requested that STUDENT be tested for Ainattention problems,@ and because the quality of his school work had Adeclined.@ MOTHER did not request that STUDENT be referred for an assessment to determine his eligibility for special education and related services. In response, Ms. Jackson requested that a student study team (SST) meeting be scheduled. (Test. of Ms. Jackson and MOTHER.)

The SST meeting was held on December 11, 2002. STUDENT=s parents, Ms. Jackson, school psychologist Martha Monetti, Ph.D. (Dr. Monetti), school principal Sue Shalvey, and resource specialist Trudy Weber attended the meeting. According to the team notes and testimony, the primary concern addressed by the team was STUDENT=s lack of focus and attention in kindergarten. STUDENT had difficulty sitting during calendar time. The SST team agreed to the following: that STUDENT sit in front of the classroom, and that Ms. Weber, a resource specialist, conduct an observation of STUDENT. Neither the District nor STUDENT=s parents requested a referral for a special education assessment. Ms. Jackson stated that the team agreed to check back within a month in a follow-up SST meeting to see how things were going. (Dist. Exh. 27-28; Test. of Ms. Jackson, MOTHER, and Dr. Monetti.)

Prior to the follow-up meeting, Ms. Weber observed STUDENT for thirty minutes and did not see anything Aabnormal.@ Additionally, Dr. Monetti observed STUDENT on the playground and while STUDENT interacted with other students. (Test. of Ms. Jackson and Dr. Monetti.)

A follow-up SST meeting was held on January 15, 2003. STUDENT=s parents, Ms. Jackson, Dr. Monetti, and Ms. Weber attended the meeting. Ms. Jackson testified that during the interval, she had observed improvements in STUDENT=s focus and attention and found that sitting in the front next to girls or friends who were less distracting to him Areally helped@ STUDENT. Nevertheless, the SST team decided to have Ms. Jackson implement a behavioral plan that included stamping STUDENT=s hand several times a day. Ms. Jackson stated that the goal was that if STUDENT was showing his Abest work to the best of his ability,@ for Aless liked@ activities such as journal writing, he would get a little smiley face stamp on his hand. Ms. Jackson would come over to STUDENT periodically and stamp his hand and compliment him for trying his best and for doing great work. The purpose was to give STUDENT a visual and physical reward, because kindergarten students like getting stamps on their hands. Ms. Jackson stated that the behavioral plan did help STUDENT, because he seemed to be more aware of what is appropriate, more engaged, and happier after the plan was implemented. (Test. of Ms. Jackson.)

A third SST meeting was not requested, and STUDENT completed kindergarten in Ms. Jackson=s class. STUDENT=s academic grades (a trimester system with three grading periods) throughout kindergarten were generally in the proficient range. In a teacher comment for grading period three, Ms. Jackson noted in June that STUDENT is Acompetent with letter sounds,@ and Ahas been working independently more often,@ but could use practice Asounding out and spelling all parts of words, especially endings.@ Ms. Jackson did not note additional problems with focusing and noted that STUDENT was ready for first grade. (Test. of Ms. Jackson; Pet. Exh. A.)

First grade B 2003-2004 school year

STUDENT returned to Orion in the fall as a regular education first grade student within a first and second grade Acombo@ class taught by Ms. Lorien Chambers. (Footnote 4) (Test. of Ms. Musch.) MOTHER described Ms. Chambers as a Avery caring and proficient@ teacher who had Aspectacular reviews even before she got to Orion,@ and that Aall of the talk from all of the parents@ had noted what an Aexceptional teacher@ she was. (Test. of MOTHER.)

Throughout the year, MOTHER testified that she expressed concerns about STUDENT=s focus issues, and his issues with reading and handwriting to Ms. Chambers and asked that STUDENT be tested but did not specifically request a special education assessment. MOTHER also raised the same concerns with the school principal, Sue Shalvey. Ms. Chambers did not refer STUDENT for a special education evaluation, nor did anyone else. No one, including STUDENT=s parents, ever requested an SST meeting during the first grade.

Prior to the end of first grade, during the late spring 2004, MOTHER asked Ms. Chambers to write a letter for her to provide to an insurance company to cover the costs of testing to evaluate STUDENT=s Adevelopment,@ because STUDENT=s pediatrician had told her that if she got the letter, he would try to get testing covered by insurance. Ms. Chambers prepared and signed a ATo Whom It May Concern@ letter dated May 12, 2004, and gave it to MOTHER. The letter recommended that STUDENT undergo testing Ato further investigate his development.@ MOTHER submitted the letter to the Lucille Packard Clinic but was told that her insurance would only cover a one-hour consultation. (Test. of MOTHER.) STUDENT completed the first grade, and Ms. Chambers recommended that STUDENT attend second grade.

MOTHER was referred to Morrissey/Compton Educational Center, Inc. (Morrissey/Compton) for an assessment. On July 30, 2004, MOTHER met with Dr. John Brentar, a consulting psychologist with Morrissey/Compton, and Anne DeBattista, a pediatric nurse practitioner. MOTHER said that STUDENT was not present for the appointment and that she brought STUDENT=s work samples with her and provided them to Dr. Brentar. (Test. of MOTHER and Ms. DeBattista.) Dr. Brentar and an educational specialist, Anne Varney, then assessed STUDENT on August 27 and 28, and on September 10, 2004. Dr. Brentar conducted standardized aptitude tests and Ms. Varney conducted achievement tests and eventually completed a joint report, but a written report was not completed at that time. (Footnote 5) MOTHER was not present during the assessments but said that each of the three appointments lasted Aone and one-half hours.@

Second grade B 2004-2005 school year

Just prior to the beginning of the second grade school year, Ms. Melissa Musch, STUDENT=s current second grade teacher, spoke with Ms. Chambers about STUDENT. Ms. Chambers described STUDENT as a Agreat kid,@ and Avery bright,@ and that he had been working with another parent on reading skills. Ms. Chambers told Ms. Musch that if she had STUDENT in her class, it would be a Agood thing@ to continue parent help on reading and also a good thing to hold an SST meeting because of MOTHER=s concerns Alast year@ about reading, if Ms. Musch also had concerns in the beginning of second grade. (Test. of Ms. Musch.)

Thereafter, STUDENT was re-enrolled at Orion and was assigned to Ms. Musch=s general education second grade class. During the first and second weeks of September, Ms. Musch assessed all of her students to determine their functioning levels. Ms. Musch concluded that she had a Afew concerns@ about STUDENT=s writing and reading fluency that necessitated holding an SST meeting. When Ms. Musch approached MOTHER about holding an SST, MOTHER told her that STUDENT was already being tested privately and that she did not want to hold an SST but wanted to wait for the results of the private testing. MOTHER would then share the test results with her. Ms. Musch reported the conversation with Orion=s principal, Cathy Okubo, who told her to wait a few weeks before holding an SST. (Test. of Ms. Musch.)

On November 2, 2004, MOTHER sent a letter to Ms. Okubo that discussed the private assessment and enclosed a copy of a four-page summary of Dr. Brentar=s assessment. MOTHER=s letter noted that STUDENT=s score in the 99.7 percentile in Vocabulary and the fifth percentile score on the Gray Oral Reading Test (GORT) represented a Asignificant@ difference that obligated the school to address STUDENT=s Alikely dyslexia.@ The letter further requested that STUDENT be given pull-out services by a reading specialist certified in the ASlingerland or Lindamood Bell techniques@ for a minimum of three times per week Aas quickly as possible,@ and Aat least by the end of November, 2004.@ MOTHER=s letter also indicated that Aour doctor@ said that STUDENT should stay at Orion and not be Aswitched@ to a different school. The letter also requested that the District forego any further testing Aif possible.@ (Dist. Exhs. 30 and 151 through 154; Test. of MOTHER.)

On November 15, 2004, Dr. Monetti telephoned MOTHER to discuss MOTHER=s letter and the assessment results. Dr. Monetti asked MOTHER if she was seeking a special education referral and then explained the special education process. MOTHER told Dr. Monetti that she preferred that STUDENT not be tested any more. Dr. Monetti said that because Dr. Brentar=s evaluation was Avery thorough@ and that she had already spoken with Renee Lamborn, Aa psychologist as well as the co-director of special education,@ that Aperhaps@ the District would not need to do a full assessment since one was recently done. (Test. of Dr. Monetti.)

Dr. Monetti also described what services might Alook like@ for STUDENT and told her about a pull-out program at Orion with a resource specialist teacher. Dr. Monetti also mentioned that the District had an SDC program at another school site that employed the Slingerland method (a teaching methodology for dyslexic students). (Footnote 6) MOTHER told Dr. Monetti that she did not want STUDENT to be pulled from Orion and that she was not interested in and Adid not want that@ [Ford program], and that Dr. Brentar felt that it would be Aadverse@ for STUDENT to change schools. (Test. of Dr. Monetti.)

Dr. Monetti told MOTHER that STUDENT would Amost likely@ qualify (for special education), but the District had to do at least some other assessments and that she would also need to speak with his teacher and do at least a brief classroom observation and an assessment in social-emotional functioning because Dr. Brentar=s assessment did not include STUDENT=s Asocial-emotional@ functioning, an area necessary for determining eligibility. (Test. of Dr. Monetti.)

Dr. Monetti also told MOTHER that if the District did see something either in the observation or after talking with the teacher that did not Afit with@ what Dr. Brentar had seen, the District would then like to be able to assess in those areas, and that is why Aif needed@ was typed beside several areas of the District=s proposed assessment plan. Dr. Monetti prepared an assessment plan for STUDENT and scheduled a one-on-one meeting with MOTHER for November 24 to gather additional information.

On November 15, Dr. Monetti sent to STUDENT=s parents a ANotice of Intent to Refer [STUDENT] for Special Education Assessment,@ and a separate explanatory letter that included the assessment plan. MOTHER acknowledged receipt of the assessment plan. The plan provided for testing, Aas needed,@ in the areas of academic achievement, intellectual development, and psychomotor development. The plan also provided for testing in social/adaptive behavior. On November 18, STUDENT=s father, FATHER, signed the assessment plan. The District received the signed assessment plan on November 22, 2004. (Dist. Exhs. 31, 32, 33; Test. of MOTHER, Ms. Lamborn, and Dr. Monetti.)

Meanwhile, MOTHER had spoken by telephone with Ms. Lamborn regarding her request for services (as expressed within November 2 letter to the District), and Ms. Lamborn agreed to set something up with Ms. Selberg, and MOTHER agreed to begin pull-put services. Ms. Lamborn also converted the scheduled meeting with Dr. Monetti into an SST meeting. (Test. of MOTHER and Ms. Lamborn.)

On November 22, 2004, STUDENT began pull-out services in forty-minute sessions. The sessions occurred four days per week, Monday through Thursday, and ended on December 9, 2004, the date of the initial IEP team meeting. STUDENT received a total of seven pull-out sessions that were held with Athree to four@ students in the LA (language arts) group. The sessions were held during the first afternoon period after lunch at the recommendation of Ms. Musch, so that STUDENT would not miss classes held in the morning that he Areally loved,@ and because STUDENT was not reading Acompletely by himself@ when engaged in independent silent reading during the reading workshop class held after lunch. Dr. Monetti testified that the pull-out services could be done as part of a regular education function by Ms. Selberg who provided support to Orion students. (Test. of Ms. Selberg, MOTHER, and Ms. Musch.)

An SST meeting was held on November 24. STUDENT=s parents, Dr. Monetti, Ms. Musch, and Ms. Okubo attended the SST meeting. The team discussed the special education referral, obtained updated information on STUDENT, and agreed that Dr. Monetti and Ms. Selberg would conduct observations and that MOTHER and Ms. Musch would complete behavior rating scales. (Test. of Dr. Monetti.)

The SST meeting notes prioritize the following concerns: Areading, writing (can=t read what he wrote B reversals of letters), abstract visual memory issues, doesn=t produce best work, when reading has problems with comp.[rehension] because struggles with decoding.@ The meeting notes also indicate that the parties agreed to hold an IEP team meeting on December 9 and that MOTHER would arrange Dr. Brentar=s attendance at one meeting to present his assessment report. The parties agreed that the District would conduct a behavioral observation, and STUDENT=s parents were given forms to complete for the assessment. The meeting notes also indicate that STUDENT was three weeks into the ABrightStar@ program (a six-week Abiofeedback@ program). (Test. of Dr. Monetti, MOTHER; Dist. Exh. 29.)

In a December 8, 2004 assessment report, Dr. Monetti noted that on the Behavior Assessment Scale for Children (BASC) (parent and teacher scales) STUDENT did not demonstrate any significant behavioral or social emotional indicators and that on both scales, STUDENT was seen as Avery adaptable@ overall, with Avery little emergence of problem behaviors.@ Dr. Monetti=s report also noted that STUDENT has a Asevere discrepancy between intellectual ability and classroom performance@ due to processing difficulties in perceptual reasoning, working memory, processing speed, rapid retrieval on information, visual attention to detail, and visual motor integration. Dr. Monetti also noted that Aat this time,@ STUDENT meets special eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability (SLD). Dr. Monetti recommended that STUDENT be placed in the resource specialist program (RSP) at Orion forty minutes per day, three days per week. (Test. of Dr. Monetti; Dist. Exh. 36-38.)

On December 9, 2004, the IEP team met for the first time to consider the assessment reports of Dr. Brentar and Dr. Monetti. Dr. Brentar presented his assessment findings to the IEP team. Dr. Brentar reported that STUDENT has Amild dyslexia.@ (Footnote 7) (Test. of Dr. Brentar; Pet. Exh. G-1 through G-11.) After the IEP team discussed eligibility, the team decided that STUDENT qualified for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD). (Footnote 8)

Dr. Monetti presented her behavioral assessment report and as team members followed along with their copies, Ms. Selberg read to the team three goals that she had written (goals in reading, written language goal, and handwriting). The IEP team then collaborated on a writing applications goal, and the four goals were Aadopted@ by the IEP team. The IEP notes indicate the team discussed how the District will update and modify the goals and objectives if STUDENT met them prior to one year. (Test. of Dr. Monetti and Ms. Selberg; Dist. Exh. 47.)

After the team discussed placement and services, the District offered STUDENT placement in an RSP forty minutes per day, four days per week. The District also offered STUDENT a detailed transition plan and accommodations. The parties agreed to continue the IEP meeting to December 14 because the parties did not reach agreement on services, and because Ms. Lamborn did not want to proceed further without an attorney. (Test. of Ms. Lamborn.)

The IEP meeting reconvened on December 14, 2004. MOTHER testified that she consented to implementation of the accommodations recommended by Dr. Brentar (listed in narrative at page 11 of 13 of the IEP that she read into the record) at the meeting. The IEP team discussed extended school year (ESY) services. The District wanted to conduct a regression recoupment analysis before deciding on the appropriateness of ESY services. (Test. of Ms. Lamborn.) Petitioner requested an occupational therapy assessment and the IEP team agreed to one and MOTHER signed an assessment plan. The team agreed to meet again to consider the OT assessment. The District=s program and placement offer remained the same as the District=s offer made at the December 9 IEP meeting.

On December 20, 2004, Petitioner filed his request for a due process hearing with the Hearing Office.

On January 14, 2005, Amy Cooper, an occupational therapist with Associated Learning and Language Specialists (ALLS), assessed STUDENT at school after school hours to accommodate MOTHER=s request. The assessment included one-on-one testing and some standardized testing. Ms. Cooper also interviewed Ms. Musch and MOTHER and observed STUDENT in the classroom. Ms. Cooper noted that STUDENT demonstrated Afluctuating writing performance@ for line usage, letter sizing and formation, and concluded that the performance may be due to Aincreased distractibility@ in the classroom because when Ms. Cooper worked with STUDENT one-on-one, he was able to have the Adesired quality of output@ for writing assignments. Ms. Cooper also observed that at times, STUDENT had letter reversals. Ms. Cooper characterized the reversals as Atypical until the age of eight,@ according to the developmental standard taught within the OT curriculum, and consistent with her OT experiences with children who do letter reversals Aup to age eight.@ (Test. of Ms. Cooper; Dist. Exh. 86.)

Ms. Cooper also had STUDENT complete drawings to test his imagination and his ability to get his ideas out on papers. STUDENT drew a character that he made up that he named the Amuscle man@ and also drew a dragon next to it. STUDENT drew a picture of himself that Ms. Cooper asked him to draw and printed his name, correctly and legibly, on his own. (Dist. Exh. 87A and 87B.) Ms. Cooper prepared an assessment report dated January 19, 2005, and recommended that STUDENT receive four to six forty-five minute consultative OT sessions within the classroom once per week to explore strategies for providing sensory input throughout the school day in order to improve focus and decrease fidgeting for more effective classroom performance. Ms. Cooper also recommended a home program for STUDENT to carry over successful sensory strategies from the classroom and that further recommendations would be made upon completion of the consultative sessions. (Test. of Ms. Cooper; Dist. Exh. 82-87.)

On January 31, 2005, the IEP team met for a third time to consider Ms. Cooper=s OT assessment report. Ms. Cooper presented her report and recommendations, and, after a team discussion, the District made an offer of OT consultative services. However, because MOTHER for the first time raised a concern with the IEP team that STUDENT experienced difficulties with fastening his clothing (zipping and buttoning), the District agreed to evaluate STUDENT further in OT. Additionally, toward the end of the IEP meeting, MOTHER also for the first time provided two letters to the IEP team, one by Dr. Schlumpberger, STUDENT=s pediatrician, and one by Dr. Cheyette, a neurologist. Both letters discussed headaches STUDENT had been experiencing, and both letters recommended that because MOTHER attributed STUDENT=s headaches to the previous pull-out services provided by Ms. Selberg, that STUDENT not be pulled out of class during the day and that the RSP sessions be conducted after school. The IEP team agreed to meet again so that Ms. Cooper could explore the fine motor issues raised by MOTHER, and to give the District time to consider the new information contained within the doctor=s letters. (Dist. Exh. 99-106; Test. of Ms. Cooper and Ms. Lamborn.)

On February 28, 2005, the IEP team met for a fourth time. The District revised its December offer to provide STUDENT with push-in, not pull-out, RSP services in forty-five minute sessions, four days per week, to accommodate MOTHER=s concerns about STUDENT=s headaches. However, MOTHER now would not consent to the District=s revised offer of push-in services because she requested one-on-one instructional services for STUDENT that she believed Dr. Brentar had recommended. The District also revised its January OT offer to include three forty-five minute sessions of OT services for the occupational therapist to train STUDENT=s class and teacher on the ALERT program to increase each student=s personal awareness of distractibility issues. Additionally, the District offered six individual OT sessions to address STUDENT=s handwriting and pencil grip (and motor issues in general), as well as to address the snapping and zipping concerns raised at the January IEP meeting. MOTHER consented to implementation of the occupational therapy services offered by the District, and Ms. Cooper testified that she had begun implementing OT services.

As discussed previously, on March 2, 2005, after consulting with MOTHER in anticipation for hearing, Dr. Brentar wrote a letter to Petitioner=s parents that made a program recommendation that had not been presented at any of the IEP team meetings held for STUDENT.

This matter convened for hearing on March 8, 2005.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District violate its Achild-find@ obligation by failing to search, locate, and serve STUDENT as a student with a suspected disability during the period December 20, 2001 to August 2002?

Under State and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). Cal. Educ. Code ' 56000; 20 U.S.C. ' 1400(d). California school districts are required to establish policies and procedures to locate, identify, and evaluate children within their boundaries who are eligible for special education. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56300 et seq. This responsibility, commonly referred to as Achild find,@ rests with school districts, special education local plan areas (SELPAs), and applicable county offices. See also 20 U.S.C. ' 1412(a)(3).

Section 56301 of the California Education Code provides that all individuals with disabilities residing in California, including students enrolled in public or private schools, including parochial schools, Aregardless of the severity of their disabilities, and who are in need of special education and related services, shall be identified, located and assessed@ in accordance with Section 1412 of Title 20 of the United States Code. Section 56301 also provides that each district, SELPA, or county office Ashall establish written policies and procedures for a continuous child-find system which addresses the relationships among identification, screening, referral, assessment, planning, implementation, review, and the triennial assessment. The policies and procedures shall include, but need not be limited to, written notification of all parents of their rights under this chapter, and the procedure for initiating a referral for assessment to identify individuals with exceptional needs.@

Section 56302 of the California Education Code provides that each district, SELPA, or county office provides that child-find identification activities Ashall include systematic methods of utilizing referrals of pupils from teachers, parents, agencies, appropriate professional persons, and from other members of the public@ and that such procedures Ashall be coordinated with school site procedures for referral of pupils with needs that cannot be met with modification of the regular instructional program.@

Section 56530 of the Education Code provides that a Apupil shall be referred for special educational instruction and services only after the resources of the regular education program have been considered and, where appropriate, utilized.@ [emphasis added.] Section 56029 of the Education Code defines Areferral for assessment@ as Aany written request for assessment to identify an individual with exceptional needs made by a parent, teacher, or other service provider.@

December 20, 2001, to August 2002

Petitioner contends that while he attended the San Mateo Montessori Preschool, the District violated its child-find obligations by failing to implement appropriate, systematic search and find procedures to identify, locate, and evaluate him as a student with a suspected disability. The District contends that it implemented appropriate, systematic search and find procedures and asserts that it did not initiate or receive a referral for a special education evaluation from anyone, including STUDENT=s parents or the Montessori preschool. Additionally, the District asserts that it did not have reason to suspect that STUDENT was a student with a disability that warranted a referral for a special education assessment at the time he attended the Montessori preschool.

It is undisputed that at no time either prior to or while STUDENT attended the Montessori preschool did anyone, including STUDENT=s parents or Ms. Prozell or Montessori preschool staff members refer STUDENT to the District for a special education assessment. It is also undisputed that no one with the District, SELPA, or county office of education referred STUDENT for a special education evaluation. (Test. of MOTHER and Ms. Prozell.)

Ms. Carla Crenshaw-Preising, the District=s co-director of special education who has been with the District (in various roles) for fourteen years, described the District=s child-find activities that included activities implemented by the San Mateo County SELPA (SELPA) and by the District, as well as activities implemented by the county office of education. (Footnote 9)

The SELPA sends an identical child-find letter to private school directors and nonpublic school directors that includes a list of contact persons for special education, the county office of education, and early childhood education. (Footnote 10) The letter includes each district=s telephone numbers and expressly states that it is the official notice to the educational agency that school districts are obligated under federal and State law to identify, locate and evaluate students suspected of having a disability. [emphasis added]. The letter includes the following language:

AIf you suspect a student in your school has a disability, please contact the student=s district of residence. [emphasis added.] However, prior to referral, modifications/accommodations should be made to the student=s regular education curriculum.@ [expressly citing Cal. Educ. Code ' 56303.]

(Test. of Ms. Crenshaw-Preising; Pet. Exh. M-2.)

At the start of each school year, the District sends or gives out a child-find form letter to private community preschools in Redwood City, State preschools, Child Development Centers, Acertain@ Redwood City doctor=s offices, Head Start agencies, private agencies serving children (from birth to age three), as well as to District individual school sites (e.g., to outreach specialists, school principals, special education staff members, and to all kindergarten teachers). The form letter, addressed ADear Parents@ (in Spanish and in English), requests a written response from parents (by letter to the director of special education) and a detailed description of the parents= concerns and significant health concerns, including the child=s identifying information. The form letter is provided to the above-referenced agencies referenced for parents concerned about their child=s speech and language development and/or learning and who would like their children to be evaluated. The letter also requests copies of assessments of the child that the parents may have. (Test. of Ms. Crenshaw-Preising.)

Ms. Crenshaw-Preising stated that the agencies are told to give a copy of the letter to parents so that they know the referral procedure to the Redwood City School District. Although Ms. Crenshaw said that she was unaware of whether written instructions accompanied the form letters sent to the agencies (as to what they are Asupposed to do@ with the letter), she explained that the agencies listed are ones that the District has worked with for a number of years, and that no one has ever asked, Awhat am I supposed to do with this [letter]?@

Additionally, the San Mateo County Office of Education (Office of Education) also provides to numerous news agencies, television stations, and radio stations a request for the Aimmediate release@ for publication of the District=s (SELPA) child-find notice. (Dis. Exh. 115-116; Test. of Ms. Crenshaw-Preising.)

Petitioner argues that the District cannot establish that child-find notices were published and that because of a potential confidentiality issue, the District or SELPA should not expect a private school director (e.g., Ms. Tina Prozell, the owner-teacher of the San Mateo Montessori Preschool) to contact a district directly if a student was suspected of having a disability without first obtaining parental consent. Petitioner also argues that the child-find letter did not set forth the qualifying criteria for special education so that a school director would know whether a preschool student might have a special education disability. Additionally, Petitioner asserts that the District=s child-find form letter does not explain to private school directors how a parent can Aself refer@ (i.e., contact the district of residence directly). Petitioner=s challenges to the District=s child-find activities fail.

Although the District did not establish the extent to which the SELPA child-find notice was published in the media, Ms. Crenshaw-Preising stated that the District provides child-find notices to numerous media outlets and that the District or SELPA Aroutinely purchases@ space in the newspaper for this purpose. Ms. Crenshaw-Preising=s testimony was unrebutted. Additionally, Petitioner provides no persuasive authority that the District must engage in a particular level of publication in local media in order to establish that it met its child-find obligation, particularly where, as in this case, the District has shown that media outlets were sent child-find notices with a request for immediate release and has shown that it routinely purchases space in the newspaper to publicize child-find. Also, the Hearing Officer notes that the child-find notices for media distribution represented just one of several child-find activities engaged in by the District (and SELPA) and county office of education. (Test. of Ms. Crenshaw-Preising; Dist Exh.115-116.)

Ms. Prozell also questioned the adequacy of the child-find form letter sent to private schools because the letter does not Atell you what to look for@ or give a more specific list of Aidentifiers.@

The Hearing Officer first notes Ms. Prozell=s acknowledgement that she has previously suspected Montessori preschool students of having a disability by seeing signs of the student=s inability to recognize letters and numbers, or inability to rhyme. (Test. of Ms. Prozell.) Thus, Ms. Prozell had an understanding of Awhat to look for.@ Additionally, a private or nonpublic school director would not be expected to conduct an assessment of a preschool student prior to making a referral for a special education assessment. However, the Hearing Officer finds that a private or nonpublic school director could reasonably be expected (if indeed a director suspected that a preschool student has a disability) to advise the parents of any concerns about a suspected disability, and then refer the parents directly to the district of residence for further questions (by calling, visiting, writing, or emailing the district) for questions or to request an evaluation. Or, a director could obtain a written authorization from the parents prior to making a direct referral to the district of residence for an evaluation.

Petitioner provides no persuasive authority that the District must set forth a more specific list of special education identifiers within its child-find form letter in order to satisfy the legal requirements of child find. Moreover, Ms. Prozell acknowledged that when she returned to the Montessori preschool from a four-month maternity leave, she learned that a child-find letter had been received from the SELPA in October 2001. (Footnote 11) Ms. Prozell=s testimony supports the District=s position that it sends out child-find letters each year. Moreover, the staff member who filed the child-find letter during Ms. Prozell=s absence obviously understood the significance of the letter and kept it on file because the letter contained useful contact information for referring a student to a district of residence for an evaluation. (Footnote 12)

As discussed above, the child-find form letter includes a directory with the names and telephone numbers of school districts and their special education departments. Additionally, Ms. Crenshaw-Preising testified that she has received telephone calls from parents of preschool age children who have been referred by their schools to call the District, and that the District is averaging seven preschool referrals per week from multiple sources, and sometimes from parents by direct email. Parents can also walk into any school within the District and ask to speak with someone, including the principal, about special education services. Parents can also call the District, even on the general number, and ask to speak with someone about special education services. (Test. of Ms. Crenshaw-Preising.)

Petitioner does not provide persuasive authority that the District was obligated to provide additional information on its child-find form letters, or that the District must establish that it gave notice to a particular preschool each year, in order to satisfy the legal requirements of child-find.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District adequately complied with its child find obligation and that the District engaged in a variety of appropriate methods to publicize child-find notices during the time that STUDENT attended the Montessori preschool.

Petitioner further asserts that he was a student with a suspected disability. In support of this contention, MOTHER testified that STUDENT experienced frustrations if he was unable to Aget out and play@ and that she and her husband had noted that STUDENT seemed to be dazed, Alost in space,@ and Anot with us@ they referred to as a Afocus@ issue. However, Ms. Prozell stated that STUDENT=s ability to stay on task and to stay focused was not unusual and that Amaybe@ fifty to seventy-five percent of boys during preschool years also have that same difficulty. (Footnote 13) Thus, what Petitioner=s parents referred to as a focus issue was a trait that STUDENT shared with most preschool-age boys.

MOTHER also said that STUDENT had, between the ages of three and five, fine motor needs and a Acomponent@ of large motor. Ms. Prozell testified that STUDENT had fine motor issues relating to writing and that his fine motor skills were Adefinitely immature@ for a typical preschooler. (Footnote 14)

Although STUDENT had some initial difficulties holding a pencil, MOTHER and Ms. Prozell both stated that he was printing numbers and printing his first name at the conclusion of preschool in July 2002. MOTHER said that STUDENT made Asignificant@ progress in fine motor at preschool, and that when STUDENT=s fine motor skills were strengthened and when his hands were strong, the preschool introduced Amore letter writing and phonics kinds of activities.@ (Test. of MOTHER.) Ms. Prozell testified that by the time STUDENT left preschool for kindergarten, STUDENT had progressed from not being able to hold a pencil, to writing numbers and letters Afairly accurately@ and with a Apretty good@ degree of independence, and that he had made progress in fine motor.

Ms. Prozell stated that she had made Afive or six@ occupational therapy assessment referrals in the past but had not done so with STUDENT because his parents already knew about fine motor issues when he started preschool and that the preschool was working on them. Ms. Prozell further stated that the Alast two@ written parent-teacher conferences indicate that Agood progress continues to be made with fine motor skills...and at that point, he was writing letters and numbers...@ The Hearing Officer finds that the preschool=s accommodations and modifications were working for STUDENT and that he was making progress and thus did not demonstrate the need for special education services to progress with his fine motor development.

Ms. Prozell testified that working independently is a goal the preschool helps students work towards in preparation for kindergarten. Ms. Prozell acknowledged that the preschool did see some progress in this area for STUDENT, but that Asome concerns@ (about STUDENT=s ability to work independently) were Abrought to the attention of the parents.@

The Hearing Officer also notes MOTHER=s testimony that STUDENT was Atotally@ stimulated and interested in the world at preschool and that he would come home regularly with reports of Apretty complex@ things and told his parents about South America and all of the continents.

The credible evidence establishes that STUDENT was not a preschool student who required a referral for a special education assessment. After reviewing the District=s (SELPA) child-find letter that states that Aprior to referral, modifications/accommodations should be made to the student=s regular curriculum [Cal. Educ. Code ' 56303], Ms. Prozell testified as follows: AThat is exactly what we did. We [knew] that he need[ed] assistance with fine motor skills, and that=s what we provided him, and we knew he needed extra help with learning how to stay on task and learning the letters and numbers like all of the children do, and that=s what we provided him...@ [emphasis added.]

In summary, the credible evidence establishes that the District=s child-find activities were adequate and satisfied the legal requirements, and that there was no evidence to suggest that STUDENT required a referral for a special education assessment.

ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District fail to assess STUDENT as a student with a suspected disability a. during the period September 2002 to August 2004?

b. during the period September 2004 to December 2004?

September 2002 to August 2004

Petitioner contends that from September 2002 through August 2004, while he was a kindergarten and first grade student, the District should have assessed him as a student with a suspected specific learning disability. (Footnote 15) The District contends that it had no reason to suspect that STUDENT was a student with a disability in kindergarten or in first grade.

As discussed above, a district is obligated to identify, locate, and evaluate all children residing within the district who are suspected of being a child with a disability under section 300.7, regardless of the severity of their disability and who are in need of special education and related services, even though they are advancing from grade to grade. 34 C.F.R. ' ' 300.125, et seq.

Pupils shall be referred for special educational instruction and services Aonly after the resources of the regular education program have been considered and, where appropriate, utilized.@ [emphasis added.] A referral for assessment is Aany written request for assessment to identify an individual with exceptional needs made by a parent, teacher, or other service provider.@ Cal. Educ. Code ' 56029.

All referrals for special education shall initiate the assessment process and shall be documented. When a verbal referral is made, District, SELPA, or county staff members shall offer assistance to the individual in making a request in writing and shall assist an individual who requests such assistance. School staff referrals shall be written and include a brief reason for the referral and documentation of the resources of the regular education program that have been considered, modified, and when appropriate, the results of intervention. 5 C.C.R. ' 3021.

The District did not receive or initiate a referral for STUDENT to determine if he was eligible for special education and related services during the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years while he was a kindergarten and first grade student at Orion. The Hearing Officer must determine whether, and if so, when, the District should have assessed STUDENT for special education eligibility during this time period.

2002-2003 school year – Kindergarten STUDENT attended Rebecca Jackson=s kindergarten class at Orion alternative elementary school during the 2002-2003 school year. (Footnote 16)

Petitioner asserts that his deficits in reading and writing and his distractibility should have triggered a referral by the District for a special education assessment during kindergarten. The District contends that it did not have a reason to suspect a disability that warranted a referral for an assessment because STUDENT=s work in kindergarten was generally proficient and because STUDENT=s attention and performance were within the normal developmental range for kindergarten students.

It is undisputed that MOTHER did not request that STUDENT be evaluated for special education eligibility during the 2002-2003 school year and that the District did not refer STUDENT for a special education evaluation.

Ms. Jackson recalled speaking with MOTHER during a parent-teacher conference held in mid-November 2002 about MOTHER=s concerns over STUDENT=s Afocus@ issues and her belief that the quality of his school work had declined (from his work the prior year at the Montessori preschool). (Footnote 17) MOTHER spoke about testing STUDENT but did not request a special education assessment. Ms. Jackson told MOTHER that a Student Study Team (SST) would convene to discuss her concerns. (Test. of Ms. Jackson and MOTHER.)

An SST meeting convened on December 11, 2002. The team addressed STUDENT=s attention and focus during carpet times as the primary concern. Ms. Jackson testified that she had made modifications to address that problem prior to the meeting after speaking informally with MOTHER and that MOTHER had agreed to having STUDENT sit in the front and next to girls who typically are less distracting to the other children. Dr. Monetti testified that she and Ms. Weber, who attended the meeting, were going to observe STUDENT. Dr. Monetti described the seating modification as an intervention to help STUDENT focus better in class. The SST notes indicate that Ms. Jackson=s assessments of STUDENT in Areading/sounds@ and math are Aon target@ and Aa little above average@ and that the SST team would meet again, and, if needed, refer STUDENT for a speech and language assessment. (Dist. Exh. 27.)

A follow-up SST meeting was held on January 15, 2003. The SST notes indicate that a change in seating had Areally helped with attending@ and that STUDENT Aseems to be more aware of what is appropriate...more engaged, happy, interested,@ and that Amany kids also cannot sit.@ Ms. Weber reported that she did not see anything abnormal when she observed STUDENT for thirty minutes. The SST notes indicate further that STUDENT Ahas to get used to different structure@ at Orion, which is Aless structured@ than Montessori, and that he Aseems to be improving and adapting.@ (Footnote 18) The SST team agreed to implement a behavior plan, described by Dr. Monetti as a type of intervention that provided STUDENT with stamps on his hand as a reward for doing his best. The SST team did not refer STUDENT for a speech and language assessment and did not schedule a follow-up meeting, but agreed to hold one Aif needed.@ (Test. of Ms. Jackson; Dist. Exh. 28.)

Dr. Monetti testified that in her professional opinion as an experienced, licensed clinical psychologist and school psychologist, it is not uncommon for a kindergarten student to have attention or focus issues and that such issues are within the normal developmental range for kindergarten. Dr. Monetti further stated that there was nothing discussed at the two SST meetings that would trigger a referral for an assessment, and that she did not have any information that would cause her to suspect STUDENT was a child with a disability at that time.

Petitioner asserts that he was in danger of retention because of difficulties in writing his full name and that Ms. Jackson Afudged@ a language arts grade. Ms. Jackson explained that she gave STUDENT partial credit for printing his last name based on the rubric used by the District in scoring the language arts assessment form, and that she had previously explained the rubric to MOTHER. (Footnote 19) Ms. Jackson also stated that STUDENT was not in danger of retention, and that a kindergarten student=s difficulty with a single benchmark is not a basis for retention. Ms. Jackson stated that a Agood@ kindergarten teacher looks at more than just a single benchmark to determine how a student is performing in kindergarten, and that STUDENT=s periodic difficulties writing his full name, while noteworthy, were still developmentally within the expected range for a kindergarten student. Ms. Jackson=s testimony was unrebutted. (Test. of Ms. Jackson.)

Ms. Jackson further stated that based upon her professional opinion and five years of experience as a kindergarten teacher, there was Anothing@ in STUDENT=s scores or about STUDENT that warranted a referral for special education testing. In unrebutted testimony, Ms. Jackson and Ms. Lamborn, an experienced school psychologist, testified that reading and writing skills are not taught until the first grade.

A review of STUDENT=s grades in kindergarten reveals that most of STUDENT=s academic grades (three grading periods on a trimester system) were in the proficient range (a grade of three) in language arts, social studies, science, and mathematics. STUDENT also received several grades of four (advanced) in four language arts areas and in two mathematics areas. STUDENT received a grade of two (Aneeds to work on@) in language arts subjects once in the first semester for reciting short poems, rhymes and songs (under listening and speaking) which improved to a grade of three in the second and third trimesters. STUDENT received a grade of two in the second trimester and a two plus in the third trimester for writing his first name and last name, and he received a grade of two plus for writing uppercase and lowercase letters legibly in the third trimester. (Dist. Exh. 11; Test. of Ms. Jackson.) The Hearing Officer concludes that the grades indicate that STUDENT=s kindergarten performance was generally proficient, and that he needed to work on writing uppercase and lowercase letters legibly and writing his first name and last name.

Ms. Jackson acknowledged that because there is such a wide range of developmental norms in kindergarten, it is generally Atoo early to tell@ if a concern is Adevelopmental@ B something that a kindergarten student will eventually Agrow out of@ -- or something more. Ms. Jackson testified that it is not uncommon for kindergarten students to have reversals. Ms. Jackson=s testimony was unrebutted.

Ms. Jackson also stated that she spoke with STUDENT=s parents and Orion resource teacher Trudy Webber to develop strategies to help STUDENT and that she monitored STUDENT=s behavior. Ms. Jackson testified further that STUDENT showed steady improvement in attention and in writing and that if he had not, she would have held another SST meeting. At the end of the school year, Ms. Jackson decided that STUDENT was ready for first grade. In the comments section for grading period three, Ms. Jackson recommended practice on Asounding out and words and spelling parts of words, especially the endings of words.@ Ms. Jackson testified that this was not an unusual area of need for a kindergartner. (Dist. Exh. 11.)

The Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately held SST meetings to address the concerns expressed by MOTHER and that it implemented appropriate accommodations to address those concerns, in accordance with the requirement under the Education Code that a pupil shall be referred for special educational instruction and services only after the resources of the regular education program have been considered and, where appropriate, utilized. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56303.

The Hearing Officer places great weight on the generally consistent testimony of Ms. Jackson (who worked with STUDENT daily), Dr. Monetti, and Ms. Lamborn, all experienced educational professionals, and less weight on the testimony of MOTHER, who acknowledged that she has not had any formal education or training in teaching or in psychology. Dr. Brentar did not express an opinion on when STUDENT=s mild dyslexia first manifested or when the District first should have suspected that STUDENT had a learning disability, or whether STUDENT was a student with a suspected disability in kindergarten.

Dr. Monetti and Ms. Jackson stated that STUDENT=s attention and focus issues were within the developmentally expected range for a kindergarten student. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT=s attention and focus issues were not unusual for his age and that his difficulties in writing his full name, while an appropriate concern for kindergarten, did not signify a suspected disability in writing because in this regard, STUDENT was performing within the normal range of development as a kindergarten student.

In support of his position, Petitioner in his brief emphasizes the importance of a reported federal district court (not appellate court) of Hawaii case that is readily distinguishable. (Footnote 20)

The weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District did not have reason to suspect that STUDENT was a student with a disability during kindergarten to trigger a referral for a special education assessment.

2003-2004 B First Grade

STUDENT attended first grade in Lorien Chambers= first and second grade combo class at Orion during the 2003-2004 school year.

It is undisputed that MOTHER did not request that STUDENT be evaluated for special education during the 2003-2004 school year and that the District did not refer STUDENT for a special education evaluation. Additionally, it is undisputed that an SST team meeting was not convened during the first grade.

Petitioner continues to assert that his deficits in reading and writing and his distractibility should have triggered a referral by the District for a special education assessment during first grade. The District continues to contend that during first grade, it did not have a reason to suspect that STUDENT was a student with a disability that warranted a referral for a special education assessment because STUDENT=s attention and performance in first grade were within the normal developmental range for a first grade student.

MOTHER testified that she spoke Aconstantly@ with Ms. Chambers and with Sue Shalvey, the then-principal of Orion about her concerns for STUDENT. MOTHER said that STUDENT had a Afocus@ issue, one that she and her husband Awere not sure what it was, but we thought there may be something going on there.@ MOTHER said that she spoke with Ms. Shalvey in the school=s hallway at the beginning of the school year and told Ms. Shalvey that she continued to have all of the same concerns that she had at both SSTs in kindergarten and that she really wanted STUDENT to be tested. MOTHER testified that she asked Ms. Shalvey how Awe@ could get STUDENT tested and that Ms. Shalvey replied that Awe@ should start another SST. MOTHER stated that soon after the conversation, Ms. Shalvey sustained a serious injury and never returned to the school. (Footnote 21)

A review of STUDENT=s grades as a first grade student in Ms. Chamber=s class reveals generally proficient performance in mathematics and science, but in language arts, STUDENT needed to improve on in several areas of reading and writing and was struggling. (Dist. Exh. 13.)

Additionally, a review of STUDENT=s AFirst Grade Language Arts Assessment Form for Report Card@ reveals that STUDENT received a few below basic scores. However, Ms. Musch testified that a few below basic scores is not unusual and would not trigger a referral for an assessment. Ms. Lamborn testified that STUDENT=s first grade report card and language arts assessment indicate that STUDENT was making progress and that the difference in scores between kindergarten and first grade would not trigger a referral for a special education assessment. (Footnote 22)

The evidence further reveals that in the late spring 2004, MOTHER requested that Ms. Chambers write her a letter to provide to her insurance company to fund testing to evaluate STUDENT=s development, and that Ms. Chambers= provided MOTHER with a letter dated May 12, 2004, to that effect. (Footnote 23)

The Hearing Officer finds that at the time that MOTHER requested a letter from Ms. Chambers about testing STUDENT, the District was aware of MOTHER=s ongoing concerns about STUDENT=s focus and his difficulties with reading and writing, and that MOTHER had expressed those concerns consistently beginning with kindergarten. The context of MOTHER=s request for a letter from Ms. Chambers thus included STUDENT=s acknowledged, continued difficulties in reading and in writing and ongoing concerns about STUDENT=s attention and focus, that had begun in kindergarten. Moreover, MOTHER=s testimony that she had asked Ms. Shalvey that STUDENT be tested and had asked Ms. Shalvey how the testing could be done was unrebutted.

The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT=s grades throughout the first grade in math and science were proficient. By comparison, several of his language arts scores in reading, writing, and written/oral conventions for the third trimester were either two=s, (needs to work on), or two minus. Because of the apparent discrepancy by the end of the first grade between STUDENT=s sustained proficient performance level in math and science, and his continuing difficulties in reading and writing, and because MOTHER=s unrebutted testimony establishes that she had requested that STUDENT be tested earlier in the first grade, the Hearing Officer finds that the District had reason to know, in the late spring 2004, that STUDENT had a suspected disability and that it needed to refer him for a special education evaluation. Thus, the Hearing Officer designates the Atrigger@ date as the date of Ms. Chambers= letter, May 12, 2004, that Ms. Chambers provided to MOTHER to pursue private testing. Accordingly, May 12, 2004, marks the start of the District=s obligation to develop an assessment plan and its obligation to conduct a special education assessment of STUDENT.

Therefore the District, as of May 12, 2004, had fifteen calendar days to develop a written proposed assessment plan. Counting fifteen calendar days forward, the District should have provided STUDENT=s parents with an assessment plan by May 27, 2004. STUDENT=s parents would have had at least fifteen days from receipt of the proposed assessment plan to arrive at a decision about the plan. See Cal. Educ. Code '' 56043 and 56321. The 2003-2004 school year was scheduled to end on June 16, 2004. (Pet. Exh. X.) However, because the Hearing Officer has determined that the referral should have been made by May 27, 2004, twenty days from the end of the regular school year (June 16), the District would have had thirty days after commencement of the 2004-2005 school year to assess STUDENT and to convene an IEP team meeting. (Pet. Exh. X.) See Cal. Educ. Code ' 56344.

Because the 2004-2005 school year commenced on August 30, 2004, the District would have had until September 28, 2004, to convene an IEP team meeting.

The credible evidence establishes that as of May 12, 2004, the District had reason to suspect that STUDENT had a disability and that the District should have convened an IEP team meeting by September 28, 2004, to consider the assessment results.

August 2004 to December 2004 - Second Grade

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has found that the District should have referred STUDENT for a special education assessment of STUDENT on May 12, 2004, and that it had until May 27 to develop an assessment plan. The Hearing Officer also found that the District had until September 28, 2004, to convene an IEP team meeting. Because the District did not convene an IEP team meeting until December 9, 2004, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the period September 28, 2004, until December 9, 2004.

ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE within its December 9 and 14, 2004 individualized education program (IEP) offer, and as supplemented by revised IEP offers made on January 31 and February 28, 2005?

Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. ' 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56000. The term Afree appropriate public education@ means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student=s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(8). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student=s IEP must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but the district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child=s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a Abasic floor of opportunity@ consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean that the absolute best or Apotential-maximizing@ education must be provided for the student. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965 (1994). However, a de minimis benefit of only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of Asome@ benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997).

Additionally, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. ' 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

The IDEA also extends to parents important procedural rights that include the right to participate in the development of their child=s IEP and the right to have specified individuals present at an IEP meeting. Procedural flaws or violations of the IDEA do not automatically result in a denial of a FAPE, unless the procedural violation results in a loss of educational opportunity for a student or a serious infringement on the parent=s right to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District=s proposed program must meet the following substantive requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs, and (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; (3) comport with STUDENT=s IEP; and (4) be in the LRE. (Footnote 24)

Petitioner raises procedural and substantive allegations regarding each of the four IEP meetings held during the 2004-2005 school year. The Hearing Officer will address the contentions within the analysis of each meeting.

December 9, 2004 IEP meeting

Was the District=s program and placement offer made at the December 9 and 14, 2004 IEP meetings designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit?

Procedural appropriateness

Petitioner contends that the District improperly provided him with pull-out services prior to making an eligibility determination at the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting and that this was a significant procedural violation that resulted in a serious infringement on his parents= right to participate in the IEP process. Petitioner also contends that the District made a Apredetermined offer@ (Dr. Monetti=s placement recommendation within her assessment report) of an RSP program at the December 9, IEP meeting. Petitioner asserts that this was a significant procedural violation that resulted in a serious infringement on his parents= right to participate in the IEP process.

The District asserts that STUDENT was provided short-term pull-out services to support him in the general education curriculum, and not as a special education student. The District also asserts that it did not make a predetermined offer at the December 9 IEP meeting. The District contends that the offer resulted from a collaborative discussion that occurred during a lengthy meeting (two and one half hours). The District asserts that the offer was not predetermined and that Petitioner=s parents, with counsel, had a fair opportunity to discuss placement with Dr. Brentar and Dr. Monetti.

1. Pull-out services

Section 56320 of the California Education Code provides that A[b]efore any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs in special education instruction, an individual assessment shall be conducted...by qualified persons...@

As discussed above, STUDENT=s parents were eager to have STUDENT receive pull-out services after receiving Dr. Brentar=s assessment in early November, when MOTHER informed the District by letter that she wanted STUDENT to receive pull-out services no later than the end of November. The District was aware that MOTHER was very concerned and wanted to provide STUDENT with some additional services right away. District resource specialist Chris Selberg was asked to start working with STUDENT as a general education student and to provide pull-out services. (Test. of Ms. Selberg and Ms. Lamborn.)

It is undisputed that MOTHER consented to the pull-out services, and that the services were provided from November 22, 2004, until the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting. (Footnote 25) It is undisputed that at the time that Ms. Selberg provided pull-out services to STUDENT, an IEP team had not yet determined his eligibility to qualify for special education and related services and that Dr. Monetti had not yet completed her social/adaptive behavior assessment of STUDENT.

The credible evidence establishes that the pull-out services were provided over a two-week period to support the general education curriculum, not special education. Experienced educational professionals, Dr. Monetti, Ms. Selberg, Ms. Crenshaw-Preising, and Ms. Lamborn, provided unrebutted testimony that the services were provided to STUDENT as a general education student. Moreover, Ms. Selberg has a general education teaching credential (multiple subject). The Hearing Officer finds that the District committed no procedural violation that resulted in a serious infringement of the right of Petitioner=s parents to participate in the IEP process because the services were provided to STUDENT as a general education student, and because an IEP meeting was held (December 9) only a few weeks after the start of pull-out services on November 22, 2004.

2. Predetermined offer

Petitioner contends that the District made a predetermined offer at the December 9 IEP meeting when it offered the RSP placement recommended by Dr. Monetti that was also contained in her report.

The District asserts that the offer it made at the December 9 IEP meeting was not predetermined because STUDENT=s parents, with counsel present, had a fair opportunity to discuss the District=s placement recommendation at the December 9 IEP meeting.

It is undisputed that MOTHER participated in the IEP team meeting discussions held on December 9 and was represented by counsel. Moreover, Dr. Brentar attended the IEP meeting, presented his assessment and recommendations and participated in the placement discussions. Ms. Lamborn testified that the IEP meeting was lengthy and lasted from two and one half to three hours. As discussed previously, Dr. Monetti also attended the meeting and discussed her recommendation of an RSP placement. Ms. Selberg also attended the meeting and discussed goals and objectives and her experience with STUDENT during pull-out sessions.

Petitioner provides no persuasive authority that a district cannot make a placement recommendation within an assessment report prior to an IEP team meeting.

The credible evidence establishes that Petitioner was given a fair opportunity to discuss the RSP placement recommendation at the December 9 IEP meeting. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation in this respect.

Substantive appropriateness

STUDENT=s unique needs

Before determining whether the District=s program and placement offer of December 9, 2004, was designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs, it is necessary to identify his needs based upon the information available to IEP team members in December.

It is undisputed that following the presentation of the reports by Dr. Brentar and Dr. Monetti, the IEP team discussed and agreed-upon STUDENT=s areas of need as follows: reading/phonics, writing/spelling, retrieval of information, visual-motor integration, attention to detail, and organizational skills. (Footnote 26) (Test. of Dr. Brentar, Dr. Monetti, Ms. Musch, Ms. Selberg, and Ms. Lamborn; Dist. Exh. 45.) The first page of the IEP notes also include fine motor as an area of need to be addressed with goals and objectives for STUDENT to receive educational benefit. Dr. Brentar stated that STUDENT needed strengthening of his fine motor skills to improve his writing. (Dist. Exh. 39; Test. of Dr. Brentar.)

Dr. Brentar also testified that STUDENT needed to develop self-esteem because of his dyslexia. However, Dr. Brentar did not assess STUDENT for social/emotional functioning and did not observe STUDENT in the classroom setting. Moreover, Dr. Monetti determined from the results of the teacher and parent scales of the Behavior Assessment Scale for Children (BASC) that STUDENT did not demonstrate any significant behavioral or social emotional indicators. STUDENT was seen on both scales as being Avery adaptable@ overall, with very little indication of emergence of problem behaviors. (Test. of Dr. Monetti; Dist. Exh. 36-38.) The credible evidence establishes that self-esteem was not an area of unique need for STUDENT.

Dr. Brentar also testified that STUDENT needed a systematic multisensory teaching methodology because of his dyslexia. (Footnote 27) It is undisputed that STUDENT needs multisensory teaching because of his dyslexia.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has needs in the following areas: reading (phonics), writing/spelling, retrieval of information, visual-motor integration, attention to detail, organizational skills, fine motor, and a multisensory teaching methodology. STUDENT had not yet been assessed in occupational therapy in December. It is undisputed that STUDENT also needs accommodations and modifications at Orion. The Hearing Officer will examine more fully STUDENT=s fine motor needs within the discussion about the District=s revised offers made at the January 31and February 28, 2005 IEP meetings.

The District=s program and placement offer

At the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting, the District offered STUDENT placement in a general education second grade classroom with resource specialist program (RSP) pull-out services four days per week, in four, forty-minute sessions.

The offer included four agreed-upon goals and objectives in reading, written language (spelling), writing strategies, and writing applications. Additionally, the IEP team offered the following accommodations: that STUDENT will receive additional time and breaks as necessary, and that directions will be read to him, with the exception of reading assessment. MOTHER testified that she consented to implementation of the accommodations. As discussed above, Petitioner does not dispute the appropriateness of the goals and objectives and did not assert that he needed additional goals and objectives.

Petitioner contends that the District=s offer of pull-out RSP services was not appropriate because he associates headaches with the pull-out sessions that Ms. Selberg previously provided. Petitioner also contends that the offer was deficient because it did not provide for occupational therapy services to meet his fine motor needs and did not provide for his need for extended school year services (ESY). Additionally, Petitioner contends that he needed a single, multisensory teaching methodology approach such as Slingerland or Lindamood-Bell provided three days per week in sixty minute one-on-one educational therapy sessions. Petitioner further contends that Ms. Selberg is not adequately trained in multisensory to meet his needs.

Petitioner asserts that the offer of pull-out services was not appropriate because of headaches he associated with the services provided by Ms. Selberg. The Hearing Officer notes that Petitioner=s parents did not raise concerns at the December 9 IEP meeting that the pull-out services previously provided by Ms. Selberg had caused him headaches. Ms. Lamborn recalled a single reference to headaches made by MOTHER at the December 9 meeting when MOTHER said that STUDENT had just started wearing eye glasses. MOTHER did not raise the issue in earnest until the end of the January 31, 2004 IEP meeting when she provided two doctor=s letters to the IEP team. The December IEP notes do not indicate a parental concern over headaches. Moreover, the persuasive testimony of Ms. Musch and Ms. Selberg establishes that STUDENT did not show any signs of anxiety and did not report headaches to either Ms. Musch or to Ms. Selberg at any time when pull-out services were provided.

MOTHER acknowledged that in December, Dr. Brentar did not know Athe progression of STUDENT=s headaches and [that] the status with that changed and he did not receive updates or know about the experiences with Chris Selberg.@ MOTHER=s testimony establishes that she did not inform Dr. Brentar of her concerns even though she had consulted with Dr. Brentar and had arranged for Dr. Brentar to present his assessment report to the IEP team on December 9. The Hearing Officer finds that at that timethere was no credible evidence of a connection between the pull-out services previously provided by Ms. Selberg and STUDENT=s headaches. Because MOTHER had no additional issues regarding pull-out services, the Hearing Officer finds that the District=s December 9 offer of pull-out services was appropriate for STUDENT. (Footnote 28)

With regard to STUDENT=s need for occupational therapy services to address fine motor, the parties dispute whether the fifty-day timeline for completing the OT assessment was triggered on November 22, 2004, when the District received its proposed assessment plan signed by FATHER on November 18, 2004, or when MOTHER signed a second assessment plan on December 14, 2004, authorizing the District to assess STUDENT in OT. Because an OT assessment was not due as of the December 9 or December 14 IEP meeting (fifty days had not yet elapsed from November 22, 2004), the District was not obligated to provide an OT assessment at the December 9 or December 14 IEP meetings and therefore was not prepared to address whether STUDENT had needed OT in December.

Petitioner also asserts that the District failed to offer him ESY services. The Hearing Officer finds that because the District had had no previous experience working with STUDENT under an IEP, it would have been speculative to decide, in December, that STUDENT needed ESY services during the summer of 2005. The more reasonable approach, expressed by Ms. Lamborn, was that the District would first obtain regression recoupment data while STUDENT worked under an IEP, and then reconvene the IEP team in the late spring to determine whether STUDENT needed ESY services. Because Petitioner did not accept any of the District=s placement offers, the District has not yet had an opportunity to collect valid regression recoupment data while STUDENT is being served under an IEP.

Petitioner asserts that he needed one-on-one educational therapy three days per week in sixty-minute sessions in after school sessions. Petitioner also asserts that he needs a Slingerland, Lindamood-Bell, or another single, systematic multisensory approach. Petitioner also asserts that Ms. Selberg lacks the training to employ a multisensory teaching approach. The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner=s contentions fail.

First, Dr. Brentar did not recommend one-on-one therapy within his assessment report, and there is no credible evidence that he recommended one-on-one therapy to the IEP team on December 9. Dr. Brentar=s assessment report refers to an individualized program. Additionally, Dr. Brentar testified that STUDENT would receive benefit from either one-on-one services or services within a small group setting with two or three students. Dr. Brentar did not specifically recommend a frequency of services and acknowledged that this was a matter best left to the school district. Additionally, Dr. Brentar described a one-on-one program as the Aideal@ and Abest@ program for STUDENT. Districts are not required to maximize a student=s performance or to offer or provide the best program.

Under cross-examination, MOTHER acknowledged that her interest in one-on-one services for STUDENT was expressed to her verbally by Dr. Brentar and that the District was not privy to conversations she had with Dr. Brentar and that Dr. Brentar=s report does not reflect those conversations. Furthermore, MOTHER did not remember whether Dr. Brentar was present at the December 9 IEP meeting when she made the request for one-on-one services, including the frequency and manner of services, or whether Dr. Brentar even commented at all at the IEP meeting about when, how long, and where the services for STUDENT should be implemented.

The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Brentar did not recommend one-on-one therapy services at the December 9 IEP meeting and that STUDENT did not need one-on-one therapy services in December to meet his unique needs.

Petitioner asserts that he needed a Slingerland, Lindamood-Bell, or other single, systematic multisensory methodology.

Dr. Brentar testified that STUDENT needs a single, multisensory approach because he will make greater progress with a single approach that is systematically followed. Although Dr. Brentar testified that the scientific evidence shows that a single multisensory approach followed systematically has been shown to provide greater academic gains than a multisensory approach drawn from several sources, there is no persuasive evidence that drawing from multisensory approaches cannot meet STUDENT=s unique needs and provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Ms. Selberg persuasively testified that the multisensory approach she uses will meet STUDENT=s needs. (Test. of Dr. Brentar and Ms. Selberg.)

Ms. Selberg testified that she employs a multisensory approach from a variety of methods, including a Sounds for Signs phonemic program and the Working with Words program that teaches phonemic awareness. Ms. Selberg=s testimony was detailed and was illustrated by exhibits on how the teaching methodologies employ a student=s use of sight, sound and tactile (i.e., multisensory). Ms. Selberg stated that the programs are systematic and build on each lesson. Moreover, MOTHER acknowledged that during the December 9 IEP meeting, Dr. Brentar was shown a document by Ms. Selberg and that Dr. Brentar confirmed that it Alooks like@ a multisensory approach. MOTHER also stated that the District was not obligated, under an IEP, to set forth the methodologies it intended to use. (Footnote 29)

The Hearing Officer finds that the systematic multisensory teaching methodology Ms. Selberg uses from a variety of sources meets STUDENT=s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

Petitioner contends that Ms. Selberg is not properly trained to use a multisensory teaching methodology.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Selberg is an experienced resource specialist with appropriate California teaching credentials and provided credible and detailed testimony concerning her teaching experience and training. (Footnote 30) Ms. Selberg credibly testified that she uses multisensory teaching methodologies and has the appropriate educational training and experience to determine teaching methods for students in the RSP. MOTHER testified that Ms. Selberg told her that she uses the Reading Recovery program for dyslexic students and that after reviewing the information about the Reading Recovery program at its website on the internet, MOTHER determined that the Reading Recovery program would not be appropriate for STUDENT because it is not designed for dyslexic students. MOTHER=s concerns are unfounded. Ms. Selberg testified that she has not employed the Reading Recovery program since the year 2000 and that she did not tell MOTHER that she would be using the Reading Recovery program to address dyslexia.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Selberg has the necessary credentials, training, and experience to meet the needs of STUDENT. The Hearing Officer also finds that the systematic multisensory teaching methodology Ms. Selberg uses from a variety of sources meets STUDENT=s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

Petitioner attempted to show through STUDENT=s work samples that STUDENT was not mildly dyslexic but severely dyslexic and that he has even greater needs in writing and in reading. It is undisputed that the parties agreed at the December 9 IEP meeting that STUDENT qualifies for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer need not determine whether STUDENT suffers from a mild or a severe form of dyslexia. The District=s program must be based on STUDENT=s unique needs, not on his disability. 34 C.F.R. ' 300.300 (a)(3)(iii)

The Hearing Officer finds that the District=s IEP offer of December 9 was designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs in reading/phonics, writing/spelling, retrieval of information, visual motor integration, attention to detail, organization skills, and a multisensory teaching methodology, with appropriate modifications and supports. The Hearing Officer notes that the District, at the time of hearing, had not yet had an opportunity to work with STUDENT under an IEP under an RSP. The credible evidence establishes that the RSP program offer was designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs as set forth above, and was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. (Test. of Ms. Selberg, Dr. Monetti, Ms. Lamborn, Ms. Musch.)

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District=s program and placement offer made at the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting was a FAPE.

December 14, 2004 IEP meeting

The IEP team reconvened to discuss services. It is undisputed that the District did not change its December 9 placement offer at the December 14 IEP meeting.

Procedural appropriateness

No psychologist in attendance at December 14 IEP meeting

Petitioner asserts that the District should have had a psychologist in attendance at the December 14, 2004 IEP meeting but did not. Petitioner further asserts that this omission is a procedural violation that resulted in a significant infringement on the right of STUDENT=s parents to participate in the IEP process. The District contends that because Dr. Brentar and Dr. Monetti attended the December 9 IEP meeting and had presented their assessment reports, discussed their findings and recommendations, and participated in team meeting discussions, and because STUDENT=s parents had a fair opportunity, with counsel, to participate in the IEP discussion on December 9, the District did not commit a procedural error.

It is undisputed that both Dr. Brentar and Dr. Monetti attended the December 9 IEP meeting and that both completed their presentations of their assessment reports and findings and participated in team meeting discussions. It is also undisputed that MOTHER made arrangements for Dr. Brentar to attend the meeting, and that the District accepted the test results conducted by Dr. Brentar and Ms. Varney (although the District did not accept all of Dr. Brentar=s recommendations). (Footnote 31)

Petitioner contends that his mother had additional questions to ask Dr. Brentar and that he left the meeting prior to its conclusion. MOTHER testified that she believed that Dr. Brentar=s recommendation for individualized services meant that Dr. Brentar was recommending one-on-one services and that the District disputed this interpretation of his assessment report. MOTHER asserts that because of the dispute over Dr. Brentar=s placement recommendation, it was the District=s obligation to either invite Dr. Brentar back to another IEP meeting to discuss the issue further, or to bring a District psychologist to the December 14 meeting to answer MOTHER=s additional questions.

The IDEA provides procedural safeguards to ensure that appropriate individuals attend IEP meetings so that the IEP team can make decisions about a disabled child=s programming. In general, an IEP team must include the child=s parents, at least one regular education teacher, at least one special education teacher, or where appropriate, at least one special education provider of the child, a representative of the local educational agency, an individual who can interpret the instructional implications of evaluation results...or, at the discretion of the parent or the agency, other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the child, including related service personnel as appropriate, and whenever appropriate, the child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(B) [emphasis added]; See also 34 C.F.R. ' 300.344(a) and Cal. Educ. Code ' 56341(5).

The Hearing Officer notes that the statute does not require that a psychologist be present at every IEP meeting. Furthermore, it is undisputed that both psychologists in attendance at the December 9 IEP meeting, Dr. Brentar and Dr. Monetti, had presented their assessment reports and findings to the IEP team on December 9. Moreover, Ms. Lamborn, in unrebutted testimony, stated that she asked MOTHER during a telephone conversation held to reschedule the IEP meeting if she wanted to invite Dr. Brentar to the December 14 IEP meeting and that MOTHER had replied that his recommendations were already in writing. The Hearing Officer finds that it was reasonable for the District to rely on MOTHER=s statement. The Hearing Officer further notes that Petitioner had already rejected the District=s offer of placement and services at the December 9 IEP meeting and that, as discussed within, the District=s offer did not change its offer of placement at the December 14 IEP meeting.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the absence of Dr. Brentar or Dr. Monetti from the December 14 IEP meeting did not result in a significant infringement on Petitioner=s parent=s right to participate in the IEP process because Dr. Brentar and Dr. Monetti had already presented their assessment reports, because Petitioner=s parents, with counsel, were given a fair opportunity to discuss the assessors= findings and instructional implications of the evaluation results, and because of MOTHER=s conversation with Ms. Lamborn.

Substantive appropriateness

Because the District did not change its December 9 IEP offer at the December 14 IEP meeting, and because the Hearing Officer has already addressed the substantive appropriateness of the December 9 IEP offer, it remained appropriate.

January 31, 2005 IEP meeting

Was the District=s offer of OT consultative services made at the January 31, 2005 IEP meeting designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit?

Procedural appropriateness

Petitioner first asserts that by holding the IEP team meeting on January 31, 2005, to consider Ms. Cooper=s OT assessment report, the District failed to meet the fifty-day timeline for convening the meeting. The District denies that it missed the fifty-day timeline because the District did not have reason to suspect a disability in fine motor until the matter was discussed at the December 9 IEP meeting. In the alternative, the District argues that even if the first assessment plan signed on November 18 and received by the District on November 22, triggered the timeline, the District missed the deadline by only a few days that included a weekend, and that Petitioner=s parents did not suffer a serious infringement of their right to participate in the IEP process.

Petitioner also asserts that the District failed to have a special education teacher in attendance at the January 31 IEP meeting, which resulted in a serious infringement on the right of parental participation at that meeting.

1. Fifty-day timeline

Section 56344(a) of the California Education Code provides that A...[a]n individualized education program required as a result of an assessment of a pupil shall be developed within a total time not to exceed 50 days, not counting days between the pupil=s regular school sessions, terms, or days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays, from the date of receipt of the parent=s written consent for assessment, unless the parent agrees, in writing, to an extension.@

Petitioner asserts that the assessment plan signed by FATHER included consent for a psychomotor assessment and that an OT assissment should have been conducted and presented to the IEP team within 50 days. Petitioner contends that Ms. Cooper=s occupational therapy assessment was not presented to the IEP team until January 31, 2005, a date past the fifty-day timeline.

The District first contends that it was not placed on notice of a need to conduct an OT evaluation until Petitioner=s parents requested an OT evaluation at the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting. The District argues that the fifty-day timeline was triggered on December 9 and that it met the timeline when it convened the IEP meeting on January 31, 2005 to consider Ms. Cooper=s OT assessment. The District also argues that even if the Hearing Officer finds that its obligation to conduct an OT assessment was triggered on November 22, 2004, when it received the first signed assessment plan, the District missed the deadline by four days (two business days) and that the delay resulted in a minor procedural violation and did not result in a serious infringement on the right of Petitioner=s parents to participate in the IEP process.

The Hearing Officer first addresses the District=s position that it was not obligated to proceed with an OT assessment until the matter was raised at the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting, and that therefore, the District met the fifty-day timeline.

It is undisputed that STUDENT=s father, FATHER, signed an assessment plan on November 18, 2004, and that the District did not receive the plan until November 22, 2004. (Dist. Exh. 33.) Although the plan FATHER consented to included testing in the area of psychomotor development, the plan included the typewritten expression, Aas needed,@ in the event that testing was not indicated. Additionally, the assessment plan does not specifically provide for an occupational therapy assessment. Moreover, Dr. Brentar did not recommend, within his four-page summary provided to the District in early November (enclosed with MOTHER=s November 2, 2004 letter), that an OT evaluation be conducted. The summary simply lists test scores. Additionally, Dr. Monetti and Ms. Lamborn testified that the VMI test score (for visual motor integration) identified in Dr. Brentar=s summary was in the average range, and therefore the score did not indicate a need for an OT assessment. Ms. Lamborn testified that Dr. Brentar=s four-page summary did not raise any Ared flags@ that would trigger the need for an occupational therapy assessment. (Test. of Dr. Monetti and Ms. Lamborn.) The testimony of Dr. Monetti and Ms. Lamborn was unrebutted. In any event, once the IEP team met on December 9 and the matter about an OT evaluation was raised by STUDENT=s parents, the District agreed at that meeting to conduct an OT assessment. At the IEP meeting held on December 14, MOTHER signed a new assessment plan that gave her consent to the District=s proposed occupational therapy assessment.

The Hearing Officer finds that because STUDENT=s VMI score was within the average range (and did not indicate a need for an OT assessment), and because the District provided an assessment form that indicated Aas needed@ next to psychomotor development, the Hearing Officer finds that the timeline for an OT assessment did not begin to run until Petitioner=s parents requested an OT assessment at the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting. Thus, the District=s obligation to begin the OT assessment process was not triggered until the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting. (Footnote 32)

2. Failure to have a special education teacher in attendance

It is undisputed that Ms. Selberg did not attend the January 31 IEP meeting and that a special education teacher is required to be present at an IEP meeting. Additionally, it is undisputed that the IEP team met on January 31 to consider Ms. Cooper=s OT assessment of STUDENT, and not to consider the District=s December RSP placement offer. Additionally, it is also undisputed that Ms. Crenshaw-Preising was present at the meeting, that Ms. Crenshaw-Preising has a severely handicapped teaching credential, has previously taught an SDC class, and was available to answer questions about the proposed special education services.

The Hearing Officer finds that because Ms. Crenshaw-Preising was present at the January 31 IEP meeting, and because the IEP meeting was held to consider Ms. Cooper=s OT assessment and not to consider the RSP placement offer previously made, the District did not commit a procedural error in holding the January 31 IEP meeting. Thus, the holding of the meeting did not result in a serious infringement on the rights of Petitioner=s parents to participate in the IEP process.

Substantive appropriateness

The IEP team convened on January 31, 2005, according to the addendum, to review Ms. Cooper=s OT assessment results and to consider OT therapy services. (Dist. Exhs. 89-92.)

Petitioner contends that the District=s offer of four to six OT consultative services does not meet his needs for one-on-one OT services. The District asserts that the offer was appropriate based upon the information available to the District at the time Ms. Cooper conducted her OT assessment.

Ms. Cooper presented her OT assessment report to the IEP team. (Dist. Exhs. 93-98.) Ms. Cooper testified that she brought with her three written proposed goals and objectives, but acknowledged that neither the January 31 nor the February 28, 2005 IEP has OT goals and objectives attached to the IEPs. (Footnote 33) Ms. Cooper read the following proposed, classroom-based OT goals out loud to the IEP team: that STUDENT participate in adult-directed sensory activities in the classroom with verbal cues, that STUDENT demonstrate improved focus and decreased fidgeting following sensory-based activities, and that STUDENT independently follow a school-based sensory program for optimal participation in classroom activities. The IEP team reached consensus on the goals. (Test. of Ms. Cooper.)

Ms. Cooper presented her recommendation that STUDENT receive four to six OT sessions in forty-five minute sessions within the classroom, one time per week to explore strategies for providing sensory input throughout the school day in order to improve focus and decrease fidgeting for more effective classroom performance. (Footnote 34) (Test. of Ms. Cooper.) Ms. Cooper testified that she intended to introduce the ALERT program in the classroom. The program helps students to decrease fidgeting and restlessness. (Footnote 35)

Ms. Cooper=s second recommendation, that a home program be provided for STUDENT to carry over successful sensory strategies from the classroom to the home, is usually produced within a few sessions of getting to know a child and what a child=s particular needs are, and that once strategies are found that work in the classroom for the student, then Ms. Cooper would come up with a written home program to help support what is going on in school. (Test. of Ms. Cooper.) Additionally, Ms. Cooper=s report indicates that further recommendations would be made after completion of the four to six consultative sessions. Ms. Cooper stated that she made this recommendation in the event the proposed OT goals were not completely met during the consultative sessions. (Test. of Ms. Cooper.)

MOTHER said that the OT report sounded like a Apretty good@ representation of STUDENT and how she saw him and added a couple of Astipulations@ added to that. (Test. of Ms. Cooper.) The IEP notes indicate that MOTHER said that the OT=s report is Afairly close@ to how she sees STUDENT, that she concurred with Ms. Cooper=s observations, but had added that STUDENT has a Aclothes/texture sensitivity and problems with snapping his pants and manipulating game pieces/cards.@ Ms. Cooper stated that this was the first time she had heard about the concerns expressed by MOTHER at the IEP meeting. (Dist. Exh. 91.)

It is generally undisputed that MOTHER had disclosed to the IEP team for the first time on January 31 that STUDENT had difficulties in snapping and zipping his trousers. Because of the new information, the District team members decided to have Ms. Cooper conduct a further assessment of STUDENT=s fine motor needs.

It is undisputed that Ms. Cooper conducted one-on-one testing of STUDENT at school, administered standardized testing, conducted a classroom observation of STUDENT, and interviewed Ms. Musch and MOTHER. Petitioner did not challenge the adequacy of Ms. Cooper=s assessment. (Footnote 36)

A review of the OT history questionnaire and sensory profile completed by STUDENT=s parents in mid January 2005, reveals that STUDENT=s parents did not raise concerns about STUDENT=s ability to fasten clothes (snapping, zipping, tying shoes) that would have alerted Ms. Cooper to fine motor issues in that regard. In response to the question, Adoes your child currently have problems with self-care,@ STUDENT=s father answered, ANo, I consider him normal in this area.@ The Hearing Officer finds that the response that STUDENT is Asometimes clumsy@ in small motor, in response to a question about STUDENT=s Aoverall movement patterns@ to have adequately alerted the District that STUDENT did not have fine motor issues relating to fastening his clothing and tying his shoes. (Dist. Exh. 72-81.) Moreover, MOTHER acknowledged that STUDENT was not wearing clothing to school that required snapping or zipping, or shoes that required tying laces, that would have alerted school staff to potential problems over fastening clothing and tying shoes. Additionally, Ms. Musch testified that she did not observe STUDENT having difficulties with fastening clothing. (Test. of MOTHER and Ms. Musch.) Thus, the credible evidence establishes that the District reasonably relied on the parents= completed questionnaire, that did not reveal STUDENT=s alleged difficulties with fastening clothing and tying shoes. Moreover, the classroom teacher had not noted difficulties in the classroom.

The Hearing Officer considers Petitioner=s contention that he needed one-on-one OT therapy sessions, and not consultative sessions in the classroom. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT had not yet been served under an IEP. Additionally, Ms. Cooper=s OT assessment was thorough, and although testimony provided by Ms. Cooper suggests that STUDENT would benefit from one-on-one OT sessions because he shows fewer signs of distractibility during one-on-one sessions, the Hearing Officer finds that it was appropriate and reasonable for the District to first address STUDENT=s underlying focusing and fidgeting issues by implementing the ALERT program in the classroom setting. Ms. Cooper=s testimony regarding the appropriateness of her OT recommendations was largely unrebutted.

The credible evidence establishes that the District=s offer of four to six consultative forty-five minute OT sessions in the classroom and the home program was appropriate at the time the offer was made at the January 31 IEP meeting based upon the information available to the District at the time. The offer was designed to meet STUDENT=s need to develop an awareness of, and strategies for dealing with his fidgeting and attention difficulties in the classroom. The offer was also reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit -- strategies learned from the ALERT program that would help STUDENT focus better in class and to improve his classroom performance.

February 28, 2005 IEP meeting

Was the District=s revised offer of Apush-in@ RSP services made at the February 28, 2005, IEP meeting designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit?

Procedural appropriateness

Petitioner asserts that the District=s failure to ensure that a psychologist attend the February 28, 2005 IEP meeting led to a procedural violation and a serious infringement on his parent=s right to participate in the IEP process. The District contends that it was not required to have a psychologist present at the meeting.

As discussed above, it is undisputed that Dr. Brentar and Dr. Monetti had already presented their assessment reports at the December 9, 2004 IEP meeting. Thus, the fact that a psychologist was not present at the February 28 IEP meeting did not result in a procedural error and did not result in a serious infringement on the parents= right to participate in the February 28 IEP meeting because the February 28 IEP meeting addressed STUDENT=s OT needs and RSP push-in services. Thus, the District did not commit a procedural violation in this regard.

Petitioner also asserts that the District=s failure to ensure that a special education teacher attend the February 28 IEP meeting also was a procedural error that resulted in a serious infringement on the right of his parents to participate in the IEP process. The District contends that because Petitioner requested that the meeting be held on the very day that the District had just returned from a one-week break, the District did not have sufficient time to find a substitute for Ms. Selberg.

It is undisputed that Ms. Selberg, the resource specialist, did not attend the February 28 IEP meeting. However, Ms. Crenshaw-Preising attended the IEP meeting. It is undisputed that Ms. Crenshaw-Preising has a severely handicapped teaching credential and has experience teaching a special day class. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Crenshaw-Preising was available to answer questions about the District=s revised offer of push-in services. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation. Additionally, the Hearing Officer notes that the due process hearing convene within ten days of the IEP meeting to address Petitioner=s issues regarding each of the District=s placement offers.

Substantive appropriateness

The IEP team met again on February 28, 2005. In addition to discussing a revised offer of OT services (consented to by Petitioner), the District revised its offer of pull-out services and offered STUDENT push-in services. The District offered STUDENT RSP push-in services four days per week, in forty-five minute sessions.

Petitioner generally contends that the District=s revised offer of push-in services is not appropriate for STUDENT because Ms. Selberg lacks the qualifications necessary to employ a single multisensory teaching methodology that he needs. Petitioner asserts that he needs one-on-one services.

As discussed previously, at the end of the January 31, 2005 IEP team meeting, MOTHER provided the team with two doctor=s letters to establish that pull-out services were not appropriate for STUDENT because she believed that pull-out services increased STUDENT=s headaches. The District maintains that it revised its offer of pull-out services to push-in services to accommodate MOTHER=s concerns about STUDENT=s headaches.

The Hearing Officer briefly reviews the two doctor=s letters submitted to the IEP team regarding STUDENT=s headaches. According to a report by Dr. Schlumpberger, STUDENT=s pediatrician, on January 10, 2005, STUDENT told the doctor during an appointment that he had been having Aone headache per week that tended to occur after school or when stressed or frustrated.@ In a letter dated January 13, 2005, Dr. Schlumberger noted that Aapparently,@ STUDENT=s mother felt that Athe stress of [STUDENT] being pulled out of class caused a marked increase in STUDENT=s headaches.@ As a result of MOTHER=s concerns, Dr. Schlumberger recommended Asome sort of program to address STUDENT=s dyslexia ...which would allow him to continue to stay in his usual classes during the day.@(Dist. 15.)

Additionally, Dr. Cheyette, a neurologist, noted in a January 25, 2005, letter that Asince pullouts are potentially very stressful for STUDENT, it could help his headache frequency to do the extra work after school if possible.@ (Dist. Exh. 103.)

Taken together, the letters by Dr. Schlumberger and Dr. Cheyette support the District=s position that providing services in the classroom, rather than pull-out services, is appropriate for STUDENT because of an apparent association between additional stress STUDENT experienced as a result of pull-out services, and STUDENT=s headaches.

As discussed previously, the Hearing Officer found that Ms. Selberg possesses the necessary training and experience to meet STUDENT=s need for a multisensory teaching methodology. Moreover, Ms. Selberg testified that she is able to provide RSP services on a push-in basis. Additionally, as discussed previously, the Hearing Officer has found that Dr. Brentar did not recommend one-on-one services for STUDENT.

Accordingly, the credible evidence establishes that the District=s offer of push-in services made at the February 28 IEP meeting is designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

In summary, the credible evidence establishes that the District=s program offer was an offer of FAPE.

ISSUE NO. 4: If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any of the above-mentioned periods, are STUDENT=s parents entitled to reimbursement for costs of assessments and/or services privately obtained?

Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the privately obtained assessment of Dr. Brentar and Ms. Varney in the amount of $3,527.00. (Pet. Exhs. U and V.) Petitioner also seeks reimbursement for his tuition costs incurred at San Mateo Montessori Preschool for the period December 2001 through July 2002 in the amount of $6,330.00 (Pet. Exh. N.) Additionally, Petitioner seeks reimbursement in the amount of $2,250.00 for the BrightStar program he attended from October 28 to December 12, 2004, as well as reimbursement for the Great Leaps program recommended in Dr. Brentar=s evaluation. (Footnote 37)

The District argues that reimbursement for Dr. Brentar=s evaluation is not warranted because Petitioner did not obtain the assessment out of disagreement with a District assessment. The District further argues that if the Hearing Officer awards reimbursement, the amount should be reduced for various reasons that will be addressed in the analysis. The District contends that because it conducted child-find in accordance with the legal requirements for all relevant times, and because it offered STUDENT a FAPE at the December, January, and February IEP meetings, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement of compensatory education services.

Dr. Brentar=s independent educational evaluation

Section 56329(b) provides that a Aparent or guardian has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists...if the parent or guardian disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency, in accordance with Section 300.502 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.

It is undisputed that the District did not conduct an assessment of STUDENT for special education eligibility. It is also undisputed that MOTHER obtained a letter dated May 12, 2004, from STUDENT=s first grade teacher, Lorien Chambers, to enable STUDENT=s parents to seek insurance company funding for testing STUDENT. In substance, Ms. Chambers= letter recommended that STUDENT undergo testing Ato further investigate his development@ because he Astruggles with a variety of activities including reading and writing.@ (Pet. Exh. D.)

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has previously found that as of May 12, 2004, the District had reason to suspect that STUDENT was a student with a disability and that the need for a referral for a special education assessment of STUDENT. At that point, the District was obligated to begin the referral process, including preparation of an assessment plan and obtaining consent from Petitioner=s parents for the assessment. The Hearing Officer has also found that the District was first obligated to convene an IEP meeting on September 28, 2004.

Because the District was not obligated to convene an IEP meeting until after Dr. Brentar and Ms. Varney had completed their assessment of STUDENT prior to September 28, 2004, the District is not obligated to reimburse Petitioner for the costs of the assessment privately obtained by the Petitioner. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of Dr. Brentar=s and Ms. Varney=s assessment.

Reimbursement of tuition costs incurred at the San Mateo Montessori preschool

As previously discussed, the Hearing Officer found that the District met its child-find obligations during the time that STUDENT was enrolled at the San Mateo Montessori preschool and that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for that period. Thus, there is no basis for reimbursement of the tuition costs of placement at the Montessori preschool. Moreover, Petitioner=s parents did not, in any event, notify the District of their intention to place STUDENT at the Montessori preschool. Nor did Petitioner provide any credible evidence that he ever sought a District placement prior to enrolling in Orion for kindergarten in September 2002. Thus, Petitioner=s request for reimbursement of his tuition costs for his enrollment at the San Mateo Montessori Preschool is denied.

Reimbursement of costs for the Great Leaps program

Petitioner provided no evidence on the Great Leaps program. It is unclear whether Petitioner ever attended the Great Leaps program. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denies Petitioner=s request to be reimbursed for the costs of the Great Leaps program.

Reimbursement of costs for the BrightStar program

As previously discussed, the Hearing Officer found that the District, by not referring STUDENT for a special education assessment by May 27, 2004, resulted in a denial of a FAPE for the period September 28, 2004 to December 9, 2004.

Petitioner=s parents did not give any written notice to the District that they intended to enroll STUDENT in the BrightStar program. Under 34 C.F.R. ' 304.403, reimbursement would be appropriate if Petitioner had enrolled in BrightStar after disagreement with a District offer and after providing appropriate notice of an intent to enroll. However, the BrightStar services were provided almost entirely before the District made its first IEP program offer on December 9, 2004.

The Hearing Officer also notes that no one from BrightStar testified about the appropriateness or reliability of its program. Nor did Petitioner=s parents provide any testimony about the cost of services and did not submit a bill for the services rendered. The Hearing Officer also notes the consistent testimony of witnesses who discussed the six-week BrightStar program: each witness acknowledged that there is no known scientific evidence of BrightStar=s validity or reliability to either Acure@ dyslexia or to provide an educational benefit beyond the six-week course that could be reasonably discernable in the classroom. (Test. of Dr. Brentar, Ms. Preising, Ms. Lamborn, Ms. Musch. ) Ms. Musch persuasively testified that she did not notice a marked improvement in STUDENT=s classroom performance while STUDENT was enrolled in BrightStar. Moreover, MOTHER acknowledged that the biofeedback program may have triggered STUDENT=s headaches.

For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement of the costs for the BrightStar program.

ISSUE NO. 5: If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any of the above-mentioned periods, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services? Compensatory education is an equitable remedy to compensate a student for lost educational opportunity when the District has failed to provide the student with appropriate special education services. 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii). ACompensatory education is not a contractual remedy but an equitable remedy, part of the Court=s resources in crafting appropriate relief...designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.@ Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1496, 1497 (9th Cir. 1994).

Petitioner seeks as a remedy, a finding that the District has denied him a FAPE, compensatory education services in the form of a prospective placement that comports with the characteristics set forth in Dr. Brentar=s March 2, 2005 letter. (Pet. Exh. G-12.)

As discussed previously, the Hearing Officer found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the period September 28, 2004, to December 9, 2004, because it did not convene an IEP team meeting to determine his eligibility for special education and related services. The Hearing Officer finds that the denial of FAPE resulted in the loss of educational services to STUDENT to address his unique needs, primarily in written language and reading.

Because the District=s denial of FAPE is limited to a relatively short period of time, two and one-half months, the Hearing Officer declines to award Petitioner prospective placement in a non-public school.

The Hearing Officer weighs the conduct of the parties and STUDENT=s relatively significant needs in written language and in reading, and taking into consideration Petitioner=s interest in one-on-one tutoring services, the Hearing Officer finds that an award of one-on-one tutoring services will address STUDENT=s needs in written language and reading. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer awards STUDENT twenty-five (25) hours of one-to-one tutoring services to be provided by the District to address STUDENT=s writing and reading needs. The District is directed to provide the services within one year of the date of this Decision.

ORDER

1. The IEP team is directed to attach the OT goals and objectives to the January 31, 2005 addendum IEP.

2. The District is ordered to provide STUDENT with twenty-five hours of one-on-one tutoring services to address STUDENT=s needs in written language and reading to be provided by the District within one year of the date of the Decision.

3. All of Petitioner=s other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

In accordance with California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with the statute: The District prevailed on each issue heard and decided except to the extent that Petitioner prevailed on the denial of FAPE issue for the period September 2004 through December 2004, and to the extent that Petitioner was awarded compensatory education services.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety calendar days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).

Dated: June 15, 2005 ____________________________________ Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1 On the first hearing day, the Hearing Officer engaged the parties in a detailed discussion of the parties= issues and contentions. The issues have been re-framed to facilitate analysis and reflect the issues and contentions identified by Petitioner during the clarification of issues prior to testimony.

2 MOTHER testified that she gave birth to STUDENT by emergency C-section. STUDENT was then transferred to Stanford Children=s Hospital and was treated within the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) for twenty-one days. MOTHER stated that STUDENT had Aa lot of@ medical issues during his first three years, and that he was followed during that time by the Lucille Packard Children=s Hospital Developmental Clinic.

3 Orion is a magnet school. Families of Orion students are required to volunteer eighty hours per year in Aany kind of work@ that benefits Orion. (Test. of MOTHER.)

4 Ms. Chambers did not testify at hearing because she was out of the country on a one-year sabbatical, funded by a grant, to learn how children acquire a second language.

5 Dr. Brentar, a licensed consulting psychologist, holds a master=s and doctorate degrees in clinical psychology. Dr. Brentar performs contract work for Morrissey/Compton. (Test. of Dr. Brentar; Student Exh. T.)

6 The Henry Ford elementary school includes two SDCs, one for the first through fifth grades, and a middle school level class. The teachers are trained in and employ the Slingerland methodology for dyslexic students. (Test. of Ms. Crenshaw-Preising.)

7 Dr. Brentar described dyslexia as a Atype of learning disability caused by problems in phonological processing that impact an individual=s ability to read and other activities, including writing and spelling problems as well as difficulties with other subject areas because of some of the processing difficulties associated with dyslexia.@ There is no DSM-IV diagnosis for dyslexia. (Test. of Dr. Brentar.)

8 AThe term >specific learning disability= means a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations...such term includes such conditions as perceptual disabilities, brain injury, minimal brain dysfunction, dyslexia, and developmental aphasia. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(26)(A) and (B).

9 Ms. Crenshaw-Preising holds a bachelor=s degree in psychology and a master=s degree in educational administration. Ms. Crenshaw-Preising also holds the following credentials: severely handicapped, multiple subjects, bilingual cross-cultural, a preliminary administrative credential, and a clear credential for administration. Ms. Crenshaw-Preising has experience as an SDC teacher, as a full inclusion specialist, and as a program specialist. (Test. of Ms. Crenshaw-Preising.)

10 The San Mateo special education local plannning area (SELPA) includes the Redwood City School District as well as various other districts identified on the bottom of the SELPA=s letter addressed to private school directors. The SELPA, not the District, sends out the letter to the private schools. (Test. of Ms. Crenshaw-Preising; Dist. Exh. 111 through 114.)

11 Ms. Prozell said that the child-find form letter at Petitioner Exhibit M-2 is Aalmost identical@ to the one she saw in her file, other than the date and the name of the superintendent.

12 Ms. Prozell said that she has given a copy of the letter to parents of a Montessori preschool student.

13 Ms. Crenshaw-Preising stated that preschools work on fine motor issues and that work on fine motor in preschool does not indicate a deficit but is, rather, a necessary part of the developmental stage for every preschool child.

14 Ms. Prozell has a Montessori certificate and an early childhood education teaching credential for preschool. Ms. Prozell has been teaching at a Montessori preschool for eighteen years and has owned the San Mateo Montessori Preschool for the last five years. Ms. Prozell taught STUDENT during the two years, except when she was on maternity leave, and the student-teacher ratio was seven to one. (Test. of Ms. Prozell.)

15 Petitioner=s attorney initially stated during issues clarification that it was too Aspeculative@ to identify STUDENT=s suspected disability, but on the second hearing day, Petitioner=s attorney stated that the District should have suspected that STUDENT had a specific learning disability when he was a kindergarten student.

16 Ms. Jackson is a kindergarten teacher at San Francisco Day School. Ms. Jackson previously taught kindergarten, first grade and a K-1 multi-age class at Orion for five years. Ms. Jackson earned her teaching credential in 1998 at Santa Clara University and her BA degree from the University of Oregon, with a double major in linguistics and psychology. Ms. Jackson has a master=s degree in interdisciplinary education from Santa Clara with a focus in language arts and literacy. Ms. Jackson started out as a first grade teacher in San Jose.

17 MOTHER testified that her business office was located just two blocks from Orion and that she visited the school or spoke with Ms. Jackson frequently.

18 The student-adult ratio at the San Mateo Montessori Preschool was seven to one. (Test. of Ms. Prozell.)

19 Ms. Jackson stated that the Kindergarten Language Arts Assessment form for Report Card contained the actual numbers that STUDENT scored on District assessments, and that his scores were Avery good@ and within the normal range for a kindergarten student.

20 Department of Education, State of Hawaii v. Cari Rae S., 158 Fed.Suppl.2d 1190 (D. Hawaii 2001). In Rae, the district court cited with approval a hearing officer=s distinction that the correct inquiry is not whether a student actually qualified for services, but whether the student should be referred for an evaluation. However, the facts in Rae that led to its ultimate finding, that the LEA should have suspected a disability earlier, are far different from the facts in this case. The student in Rae was in high school and had been absent from school numerous times and had engaged in very disturbing behaviors. The student was ranked near the bottom of her class with cumulative grade point averages of 1.5 or lower over a three-year period.

21 Neither party called Ms. Shalvey or Mr. Fletcher to testify at the hearing.

22 Ms. Lamborn is a school psychologist and has conducted approximately 400 to 450 special education assessments.

23 The letter states the following: AI have been STUDENT=s first grade teacher for the 2003-2004 school year. During this time I have closely observed STUDENT=s growth and I recommend that he undergo testing to further investigate his development. STUDENT is an active and social first grade boy who has made some visible academic growth over the course of the year, however, he continues to struggle with a variety of activities, including reading and writing. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.@ (Pet. Exh. D.)

24 Because Petitioner did not accept the District=s program offers, and because Petitioner did not raise as an issue whether the District=s offers were in the LRE, the Hearing Officer does not address either requirement.

25 The pull-out services occurred from 1:00 p.m. to 1:40 p.m., Monday through Thursday. Ms. Selberg testified that the services went Avery well,@ and that STUDENT was not bored and completed his work.

26 The Hearing Officer does not identify Agiftedness@ and Abroad academic needs@ as areas of need for STUDENT, because goals and objectives are written to address areas of need, not areas of strength or broad academic subjects. Moreover, Dr. Brentar testified that he believed that STUDENT would be challenged intellectually within the regular education curriculum at Orion. (Test. of Dr. Brentar.)

27 Dr. Brentar testified that a multisensory technique includes a teaching methodology that involves Aauditory, visual and kinesthetic (touching) pathways.@

28 Ms. Selberg persuasively testified that pull-out services were not offered five days per week so that STUDENT would have an opportunity to use the skills (on Friday) that he had been working on outside of the classroom (in pull-out sessions) the other days of the week.

29 MOTHER also acknowledged that she had counsel, Ms. Foley, present at each of the four IEP team meetings convened in this matter.

30 Ms. Chris Selberg has twelve years of experience as a resource specialist teacher. Ms. Selberg has a multiple subject teaching credential, a learning handicapped credential and a resource specialist certificate, a reading specialist certificate, a California Language Development (CLAD) (the credential or certificate for teachers to work with students who are English language learners) and a secondary credential. Ms. Selberg has served over 300 students as a resource specialist and stated that 85% of the students have had a reading disorder, or dyslexia. (Test. Of Ms. Selberg; Dist. Exhs. 127 through 146.)

31 Also present were STUDENT=s parents and attorney (Ms. Foley), school principal Cathy Okubo, co-director of special education Renee Lamborn, STUDENT=s current teacher (Ms. Musch), Ms. Selberg, Dr. Brentar (private assessor), and Dr. Monetti, school psychologist.

32 Additionally, even if the Hearing Officer had found that the timeline was triggered on the date (November 22, 2004) the District received the first assessment plan signed by FATHER on November 18, 2004, the District would have missed the fifty-day timeline by just three or four calendar days (and by just one or two business days). Such a minor error would not have resulted in a significant infringement on the parents= right to participate in the IEP process.

33 As discussed previously, Petitioner did not raise any issues regarding goals and objectives and did not specifically raise issues over OT goals and objectives during the issues clarification.

34 At hearing, the parties entered into the following stipulation: that at the January 31, 2005, IEP meeting, the District offered Afour to six individual and consultative@ OT sessions Awhich included three sessions in class to implement the ALERT program@ and that all of the services were to provided during school hours.

35 The ALERT program gives children a language for Ahow they are feeling inside and how they are functioning in a particular moment@ and offers strategies for when the engine is too high or too low. Ms. Cooper stated that although the program can benefit the whole class, it definitely was offered with STUDENT in mind to help STUDENT Atake some strategies with him to help him function.@ (Test. of Ms. Cooper.)

36 The assessment was deficient in one respect. Ms. Cooper administered the VMI within one year of Dr. Brentar=s administration of the VMI. Thus, the VMI test results obtained by Ms. Cooper are invalid. However, Ms. Cooper testified that she also relied on the Bruininks-Oseresky Test of Motor Proficiency assessment results that address the same areas that led to her OT recommendations. (Test. of Ms. Cooper.) Because Petitioner did not challenge the adequacy of Ms. Cooper=s assessment, the Hearing Officer does not determine, ultimately, the appropriateness of Ms. Cooper=s OT assessment.

37 Petitioner provided no evidence regarding the Great Leaps program and no evidence concerning a reimbursement claim for the Great Leaps program.