California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 26, 2005
Student v. San Francisco Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 3035-04, SN-3035-04 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
San Francisco Unified wins eligibility case for ADHD student; Hearing Officer finds only a failure to give notice of refusal to reassess.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions a prior due process matter between the same parties (SN02-00757) that was resolved through mediation in August 2002.
Summary
A 10-year-old fifth grader at Claire Lilienthal Elementary School in San Francisco Unified School District filed for due process. The District had found her ineligible for special education in 2002. Her mother argued she qualified under specific learning disability (SLD) or other health impairment (OHI). The claimed grounds were attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)-related symptoms, morning fatigue, and suspected auditory processing deficits. The claims covered three school years, 2002 through 2005. She sought reimbursement for a private evaluation by Dr. Theresita Solomon, 300 hours of tutoring, and weekly counseling and social skills therapy.
The Hearing Officer found that the District met its child find duty in 2002-2003. It observed her in class, assessed her speech and language, and held an IEP meeting. Its testing adequately covered auditory processing and social skills. Teachers testified that she performed at or above grade level with classroom accommodations. That meant there was no severe gap between ability and achievement, and her attention issues did not require special education. In 2003-2004, the District did not have to reassess just because the mother and a resource teacher asked. But it broke the law by not giving the mother written notice of its refusal and the reasons. In 2004-2005, the District did not have to hold an IEP meeting after receiving the private report, because the mother had not asked for one. Auditory processing and occupational therapy assessments were also unnecessary. The District's assessments were appropriate and the student was not eligible, so reimbursement and compensatory education were denied. No relief was ordered.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled an ADHD diagnosis under the eligibility rules of the time. A diagnosis alone did not establish OHI eligibility when regular classroom accommodations met the student's needs. It also shows that a district could refuse a requested reassessment but still had to give the parent prior written notice explaining why.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedChild find
Issue 1A. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny a FAPE by failing to meet its child find obligations to identify and assess Student's exceptional needs?
The District met child find by doing behavioral observations and a speech-language assessment, reviewing prior reports, and holding a November 2002 IEP meeting.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1B. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny a FAPE by failing to assess Student in all areas of suspected disability?
District cognitive, achievement, and speech-language testing adequately assessed auditory processing, and its observations and BASC adequately assessed social skills; no further testing was needed.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1C. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny a FAPE by failing to identify Student as eligible under specific learning disability and other health impaired?
No severe ability-achievement discrepancy existed, and attention issues were addressed with regular classroom accommodations, so Student met neither SLD nor OHI criteria.
- Student prevailed in partChild find
Issue 2A. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny a FAPE by failing to meet its child find obligations to identify and assess Student's exceptional needs?
The District did not have to reassess just because one was requested, but it failed to give the parent written notice of its refusal to reassess and an explanation.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 2B. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny a FAPE by failing to identify Student as eligible under specific learning disability and other health impaired?
With accommodations, Student met grade-level standards; there was no severe discrepancy, and ADHD did not adversely affect performance enough to require special education.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3A. During the 2004-2005 school year, did the District deny a FAPE by failing to convene an IEP meeting after its receipt of an independent evaluation from Student's parent?
Without a parent request for an IEP meeting, the District could consider the independent report in mediation and was not required to convene an IEP team.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 3B. During the 2004-2005 school year, did the District deny a FAPE by failing to conduct auditory processing and occupational therapy assessments?
One low memory subtest and one discrepant visual-motor score in the private report were outweighed by other testing and classroom observations; neither assessment was required.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 3C. During the 2004-2005 school year, did the District deny a FAPE by failing to identify Student as eligible under specific learning disability and other health impaired?
A single low math subtest was not corroborated, and teachers credibly testified that attention did not limit Student's alertness at school enough to require special education.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the June 1, 2004 independent assessment conducted by Theresita Solomon?
Because the District's assessments were appropriate, the parent was not entitled to reimbursement for the independent evaluation.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5A. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education of 300 hours of one-to-one tutorial instruction in all core academic areas?
Because Student was not eligible for special education, she was not entitled to compensatory services.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5B. Is Petitioner entitled to 2 hours per week of one-to-one individual counseling to address anxiety disorder and socialization/relationship issues?
Because Student was not eligible for special education, she was not entitled to compensatory counseling.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5C. Is Petitioner entitled to 2 hours per week of social skills group therapy?
Because Student was not eligible for special education, she was not entitled to compensatory social skills therapy.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's claims for relief were denied. No remedy was ordered for the prior written notice violation found on Issue 2A.
Key authorities
School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489; Todd v. Andrews (11th Cir. 1991) 933 F.2d 1576; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; Cal. Educ. Code § 56339; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329; Cal. Educ. Code § 56343; 5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3030(f), (j); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9); 34 C.F.R. § 300.503
People named in the decision
- Kimberley Thomas Rapp, attorney for Student, Adams ESQ
- Inga Sanders, attorney for Student, Adams ESQ
- Lenore Silverman, attorney for District, associate general counsel, School and College Legal Services of California
- Joseph Kinkade, attorney present for District
- William Hack, assistant principal, Claire Lilienthal Elementary School
- Linda Lee, content specialist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Katharine Macauley, SELPA director for special education, San Francisco Unified School District
- Pamela Macy, head speech pathologist and administrator; speech-language assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
- Mary Richards, principal, Claire Lilienthal Elementary School
- Scottie Smith, educational advocate, witness for Student
- Patricia Weiss, private neuropsychologist, expert witness for Student, McCauley Institute
- Theresita Solomon, private clinical psychologist who conducted the independent psychoeducational evaluation
- Sheila Meneely, school psychologist who conducted behavioral observations, San Francisco Unified School District
- Vicki Adams-Romero, private educational consultant, witness for District
- Robert Atkinson, third-grade teacher, William Cobb Elementary School
- Pamela Mills, administrator of psychological services, school psychologist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Kristen DeAndreis, administrative intern providing class assistance, San Francisco Unified School District
- Aaron Molinari, fifth-grade science teacher, Claire Lilienthal Elementary School
- Samantha Lucas, second-grade teacher, William Cobb Elementary School
- Hilary Poon, fourth-grade teacher, Claire Lilienthal Elementary School
- Mitch Reif, fifth-grade teacher, Claire Lilienthal Elementary School
- Christine Shields, school psychologist, 2001-2002 psychoeducational assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
- Kathleen Peters, educational psychologist, 1999 independent evaluator, Lucile Packard Children's Health Services, UCSF
- Elizabeth Dray, 1999 evaluator, Lucile Packard Children's Health Services, UCSF
- Erica Buhrmann, behavioral and developmental pediatrician, private provider
- Anlee Kuo, private physician/therapist
- Marcie Hall-Mennes, private psychiatrist
- Alice Hill, resource teacher, Claire Lilienthal Elementary School
- Ken Redpath, pupil services administrator, San Francisco Unified School District
- Golden Gate Regional Center, regional center that provided early intervention services
- Parents' Place, private provider of therapeutic playgroup
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Francisco, California, on January 19, 20, 21, 25, 26, and 27, 2005.
STUDENT (hereafter STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Kimberley Thomas Rapp of the firm Adams ESQ. Also present on behalf of Petitioner was attorney Inga Sanders of Adams ESQ and STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER. San Francisco Unified School District (hereafter District or Respondent) was represented at the hearing by attorney Lenore Silverman, associate general counsel with School and College Legal Services of California. Also present on behalf of the District on various days of the hearing were attorney Joseph Kinkade; William Hack, assistant principal at Claire Lilienthal Elementary School; Linda Lee, content specialist for the District; Katharine Macauley, SELPA director for special education; Pamela Macy, head speech pathologist and administrator for the District; and Mary Richards, principal of Claire Lilienthal Elementary School (Lilienthal).
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: MOTHER; STUDENT; Scottie Smith, educational advocate; Patricia Weiss, private neuropsychologist; Theresita Solomon, private clinical psychologist; and Sheila Meneely, school psychologist for the District.
The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: William Hack; Vicki Adams-Romero, private educational consultant; Robert Atkinson, STUDENT’s third-grade teacher at William Cobb Elementary School (Cobb); Pamela Macy; Pamela Mills, administrator of psychological services for the District; Kristen DeAndreis, administrative intern for the District; Aaron Molinari, STUDENT’s current fifth-grade science teacher; Samantha Lucas, STUDENT’s second-grade teacher at Cobb; Hilary Poon, STUDENT’s fourth-grade teacher at Lilienthal; Mitch Reif, STUDENT’s current fifth-grade teacher at Lilienthal; and Mary Richards.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of the parties’ written closing arguments, which were timely postmarked. Following receipt of the parties’ closing arguments, the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to identify and assess STUDENT’s exceptional needs; B. assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability; and C. identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
2. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to identify and assess STUDENT’s exceptional needs and B. identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
3. During the 2004-2005 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. convene an IEP meeting after its receipt of an independent evaluation from STUDENT’s parent; B. conduct auditory processing and occupational therapy assessments; and C. identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the June 1, 2004 independent assessment conducted by Theresita Solomon?
5. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education and services consisting of: A. 300 hours of one-to-one tutorial instruction in all core academic areas; B. 2 hours per week of one-to-one individual counseling to address anxiety disorder and socialization/relationship issues; and C. 2 hours per week of social skills group therapy?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District denied her a FAPE by failing to fulfill its “child find” responsibilities to promptly identify, evaluate, and address her unique needs. According to Petitioner, her parent repeatedly alerted the District that STUDENT was a child with special needs, but the District failed to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and failed to appropriately address her unique needs. Petitioner contends that as a child with a disability, she qualifies for special education and services beyond modification of her regular education program. Petitioner contends that she satisfies the elements of both specific learning disability (SLD) and other health impaired (OHI) eligibility.
The District argues that at all times it met its child-find obligations, that appropriate assessments were conducted in all areas of suspected disability, and that Petitioner did not qualify for special education services under the categories of SLD and OHI. According to the District, although homework completion and tardies continued to be a concern for Petitioner, a review of Petitioner’s overall performance based on assessments, observation, teacher report, and report card indicate that Petitioner is meeting and exceeding grade level standards and has been successful in school. Additionally, the District does not dispute that STUDENT had problems at birth and that she exhibits elements of ADHD. However, it argues that those difficulties do not at all affect her ability to access the regular education curriculum and, therefore, she does not need special education services.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a ten-year-old student who resides with her mother, MOTHER, in San Francisco, California. STUDENT is currently enrolled in a regular education fifth-grade class at Claire Lilienthal Elementary School in the San Francisco Unified School District. STUDENT has not been found eligible to receive special education and related services.
STUDENT was born with a condition known as anoxia. She was born blue, limp, and lacking any spontaneous movement, and stopped breathing for ten minutes immediately after birth. STUDENT was intubated, ventilated, pump-fed oxygen, and given a dose of Narean to resusitate her. After resuscitation, STUDENT had a normal physical examination and a normal neurological exam. However, STUDENT also suffered from seizures until the age of one, and it was reported that prior to the age of 5, STUDENT had a history of hyperactive, aggressive behavior and sleep difficulties.
In June 1999, when STUDENT was four years old, educational psychologist Dr. Kathleen Peters and Elizabeth Dray of the Lucile Packard Children’s Health Services at the University of California, San Francisco, conducted an independent psychological evaluation of her and noted early problems with fine and gross motor skills and delays in language development, social interaction, and daily living skills. Dr. Peters found that STUDENT had strong cognitive skills and performed well above the average range in the area of verbal reasoning and “excelled on the Comprehension subtest,” with relative weaknesses in short-term visual memory. At that time, Dr. Peters noted significant weakness in the area of social and daily living skills. Behavior rating scales indicated that STUDENT was struggling with paying attention, hyperactivity, impulsivity, and conduct problems. Dr. Peters believed that STUDENT best fit the criteria for a regulatory disorder, type 2, hyposensitive. STUDENT received early intervention services from the Golden Gate Regional Center for at-risk children.
During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT attended kindergarten at Golden Gate Academy in the District. In April 2000, a student success team (SST) meeting was held to discuss STUDENT’s difficulties with social interaction, conflict resolution, and violent behavior. Various modifications/accommodations were recommended, along with a referral to the school psychologist to determine whether there was a need for professional support. By the end of the school year, STUDENT’s teacher noted that she had shown improvement in the academic skills, but needed to improve her social skills.
During the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT attended first grade at Dr. William Cobb Elementary School (Cobb) in the District. STUDENT’s first-grade teacher reported that she was an excellent reader and writer and that she understood the math concepts introduced in class. The teacher also commented that she was concerned about STUDENT’s not turning in her homework everyday and her reading log each week. By the end of the school year, however, STUDENT’s teacher indicated that she had become a “star student.”
According to a report dated August 9, 2001, by behavioral and developmental pediatrician Dr. Erica Buhrmann, STUDENT began play therapy with Dr. Buhrmann in April 2000. (Footnote 1) Beginning in September 2000, STUDENT attended a weekly therapeutic playgroup at Parents’ Place, which ended in June. According to MOTHER and Dr. Buhrmann’s report, STUDENT had previously started taking Clonidine in January 2000 for aggressive and impulsive behavior and sleep problems. According to the report, STUDENT also had a trial of imipramine in 1999, which resulted in her seeing and batting at “gnats” that were not there.
During the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT was in the second grade and placed in Ms. Lucas’s regular education class at Cobb. In November and December 2001, the District conducted its initial psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT. MOTHER requested the evaluation due to concerns she had about STUDENT’s behavior, including her attention span and difficulty making friends. The District’s school psychologist, Christine Shields, noted in her report that at the time of testing, STUDENT was taking catepres for a sleep disorder and symptoms associated with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). After conducting testing, Ms. Shields concluded that STUDENT had average to superior cognitive ability and that her achievement in all areas fell within the average to above average range of functioning. According to Ms. Shields, STUDENT’s academic achievement in all areas was commensurate with her measured cognitive ability and no significant processing deficits were evident. Ms. Shields opined that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for special education under the category of SLD. Additionally, although STUDENT was experiencing some behavioral difficulties within the home and school setting, Ms. Shields believed that her behaviors did not appear to be significantly impacting her ability to learn within the school setting. Ms. Shields also noted that there were no indications of an emotional disturbance. Ms. Shields’ report included additional interventions and recommendations that she believed could help support STUDENT.
On January 16, 2002, the individualized education program (IEP) team met to discuss Ms. Shields’ evaluation report and health concerns. The District members of the IEP team agreed that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services; however, MOTHER disagreed with the determination of STUDENT’s ineligibility. Although STUDENT was found ineligible for special education services, the IEP team, without the parent’s agreement, recommended various supports and modifications to assist STUDENT in attaining goals and progressing in the general curriculum. According to STUDENT’s second-grade teacher, Samantha Lucas, various strategies and modifications were in fact implemented in her classroom for STUDENT, including preferential seating, encouragement, working one-to-one with her to monitor her work, giving STUDENT less intensive academics after lunch, and reminding STUDENT to use her words to communicate.
By letter dated January 17, 2002, Dr. Anlee Kuo, MD, who had been seeing STUDENT for individual therapy and medication management, drafted a letter to confirm STUDENT’s diagnosis of a mental disorder due to neurological insult at birth (anoxia), resulting in ADHD-like symptoms (hyperactivity, impulsivity, and distractibility). According to MOTHER, this written confirmation was provided to the District.
By the end of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT’s teacher noted that STUDENT had struggled with paying attention to lessons and assignments during the year, but that she was very bright and did well when she was able to focus. Ms. Lucas also noted that STUDENT was an excellent reader. STUDENT’s progress report indicated that she was able to demonstrate all academic skills introduced during the school year; however, tardies were a great problem. STUDENT attended summer school at Cobb during the summer of 2002 and per written report of one of her summer school teachers, STUDENT was intelligent and showed high potential in an academic setting, but her progress was curtailed by her difficulty in maintaining focus.
At the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, MOTHER expressed concerns to STUDENT’s third-grade teacher, Robert Atkinson, that she wanted STUDENT identified as eligible for special education services and that STUDENT needed accommodations in class. In response to MOTHER’s ongoing concerns, MOTHER and the District agreed through mediation (pursuant to another due process hearing) that in order to explore MOTHER’s concerns regarding attention and focus, the District would conduct a behavioral observation and review the District’s January 2002 psychoeducational report, notes from a summer school teacher, and reports/letters submitted by the mother. Additionally, the District agreed to conduct a speech and language evaluation, which had been recommended by Ms. Shields in her January 2002 report.
School psychologist Sheila Meneely conducted her classroom observations of STUDENT on three separate days in September 2002. According to her report, Ms. Meneely’s observations, along with consultation with STUDENT’s teacher, did not indicate any significant behavioral difficulties in class at that time. Ms. Meneely reported that inattention issues appeared to be manageable with teacher reminders to attend.
A speech and language evaluation was conducted over two days in October 2002 by District speech pathologist Pam Macy. According to Ms. Macy, STUDENT did not experience difficulty understanding and using basic language concepts and vocabulary skills necessary for interpretation and use of contextually appropriate and meaningful information. Additionally, Ms. Macy reported that STUDENT’s speech skills appeared to be at age level expectancy with 100 percent intelligibility noted during connected-discourse. Ms. Macy opined that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria as a speech/language impaired student as defined by the IDEA.
On November 6, 2002, another IEP meeting was held to follow-up with parent concerns and to review the recent District behavioral observation and speech and language reports. The District members of the IEP team again determined that STUDENT was not eligible to receive special education services. MOTHER disagreed. By the second quarter of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s teacher, Mr. Atkinson, commented on her progress report that STUDENT had improved in many areas since the beginning of the year and that she was becoming more organized and completing her home work. STUDENT was self-monitoring her listening and was getting more class work done; however, excessive tardies continued to be a serious concern. By the end of the school year, Mr. Atkinson graded STUDENT as competent or better in all academic and personal responsibility areas.
During the 2003-2004 school year, in spite of STUDENT’s difficulty getting to school on time, STUDENT’s parent transferred her to Lilienthal, which started an hour earlier than Cobb. According to MOTHER, she changed STUDENT’s school because she believed STUDENT may have been bored at Cobb and needed more of a challenge. Additionally, MOTHER took issue with Mr. Atkinson’s teaching style and the quality of education that STUDENT was receiving at Cobb. STUDENT was placed in Hilary Poon’s regular education fourth-grade classroom at Lilienthal. After the first quarter, Ms. Poon noted on STUDENT’s progress report that she needed to work on doing her assignments quickly in class by keeping focused. Ms. Poon also noted that STUDENT needed to complete her homework and promptly turn it in.
On November 6, 2003, an SST meeting was held to address the parent’s concerns regarding STUDENT’s educational performance. The SST also discussed whether MOTHER needed to be in Ms. Poon’s classroom so much. The SST decided STUDENT’s mother would sign her book and homework each night, a Section 504 Plan would be requested, past reports would be reviewed, and STUDENT would be provided with assistance through peer partners and the resource program.
On November 13, 2003, the school and the parent initiated a request for a Section 504 Plan. (Footnote 2) MOTHER had provided Mr. Hack with a letter from a doctor regarding STUDENT’s neurological issues, sleeping problems, and the medications she was taking. According to Mr. Hack, the 504 team believed that STUDENT’s taking medication warranted a Section 504 Plan referral. The District’s Section 504 committee, however, did not approve the request for a Section 504 Plan, reasoning that STUDENT did not require door-to-door transportation in order to get to school on time, and a “substantial limitation” was not substantiated with the documentation that had been submitted. By letter dated February 18, 2004, from Mr. Hack to the District’s pupil services administrator Mr. Ken Redpath, additional information was provided to the District’s Section 504 committee regarding the request for a Section 504 Plan, but to no avail. MOTHER testified that she wanted to first try a Section 504 Plan and also wanted STUDENT to go through screening and assessment again. The District never assessed STUDENT again and no other IEP meeting was convened.
By letter dated March 16, 2004, Ms. Poon reported that STUDENT had moments of attentiveness and that she seemed to have the most difficulty in the first hour of class, as she seemed very tired and sleepy. Once she was more energized, she was able to pay attention, participate in class, and do her assignments. Ms. Poon also reported that the quality of STUDENT’s work was not yet on grade level, but that STUDENT was making a satisfactory effort to do what work she was given. A number of accommodations and modifications were put in place in the classroom and throughout the school day for STUDENT, including assistance from the school’s resource teacher on an as-needed basis, extra time to complete school and home assignments, and a quiet work space whenever necessary. According to STUDENT’s progress report, by the end of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT demonstrated competent performance in all academic and personal responsibility areas except communicating mathematical thinking, computing accurately, and completing her homework and class work in a timely manner. Ms. Poon noted that STUDENT was capable when she put total effort into her work and that she needed to work on being on time to keep herself caught up in class and school. STUDENT was promoted to the fifth grade.
Still concerned about STUDENT’s academic performance and behavioral problems in the classroom, MOTHER obtained an independent psychoeducational evaluation from Dr. Theresita Solomon in order to determine STUDENT’s level of cognition, academic, and emotional functioning. According to Dr. Solomon’s June 1, 2004 report, although STUDENT was intelligent, she had uneven cognitive abilities, a significant deficit in her immediate auditory processing skills and processing speed, and a relative weakness in the area of visual motor integration. Dr. Solomon also found that STUDENT demonstrated clinically significant attentional problems and lacked organizational skills, which hindered her ability to perform her classroom assignments in a prompt and efficient manner. Dr. Solomon opined that STUDENT needed resource specialist services during the school day to help her learn and that she was also at great risk of failing academically and developing severe mental health issues. According to the District, it was provided a copy of Dr. Solomon’s report during the summer, after the completion of the 2003-2004 school year. Thereafter, the District reviewed Dr. Solomon’s assessment report with MOTHER during a mediation.
At the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year, STUDENT began attending Mitch Reif’s fifth-grade class at Lilienthal. Mr. Reif provides STUDENT various accommodations and modifications in class and STUDENT also occasionally receives assistance in completing assignments or reinforcing skills from the resource teacher or seventh- and eighth-grade students during recess or class time. Assistance from the resource teacher during open resource time is available to everyone and is not required. According to Mr. Reif, STUDENT is tardy to class at least three to four times each week because she gets to school at about 8:15 a.m. and school starts at 7:40 a.m. By the end of the first quarter of the school year, Mr. Reif noted on STUDENT’s progress report that she needed to improve in various areas in written language, reading, listening and speaking, history/social science, mathematics, and personal responsibility. Mr. Reif also noted that STUDENT needed to work on her organizational skills, which he believed were preventing her from making as much progress as she should have been making.
On December 27, 2004, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing, alleging that the District denied her a FAPE by failing to fulfill its child find obligations and refusing to find her eligible for special education. Petitioner also requested an award of compensatory education and reimbursement for an independent educational evaluation. The matter then proceeded to hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to identify and assess STUDENT’s exceptional needs; B. assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability; and C. identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
A. Child Find Obligations
Petitioner contends that the District failed to fulfill its child obligations to identify, evaluate, and address her unique needs during the 2002-2003 school year. According to Petitioner, her parent repeatedly alerted the District that she was a child with special needs; however, the District only assessed her for a specific learning disability and failed to assess her in all areas of suspected disability. Petitioner argues that the District did not consider her eligibility for special education services under the category of other health impaired (OHI). Petitioner argues that the District ignored evidence of her health challenges and her unique needs resulting from those challenges. Petitioner believes that her auditory processing deficits, ADHD-like symptoms, and sleep challenges interfered with her alertness and vitality in the academic setting to a point which should have triggered the District’s obligation to identify and assess her for purposes of eligibility for special education services under the category of OHI.
The District argues that in response to MOTHER’s ongoing concerns, the parties agreed in mediation that the District would conduct a speech and language assessment and a behavioral observation. Results of the speech and language assessment found all language functions to be in the average range and that there were no indicators of a verbal/auditory processing disorder. Results of the behavioral observation did not reveal any significant behavioral difficulties in class and inattention issues appeared manageable with teacher reminders to attend. The District contends that it met its child find obligations because the assessments were completed in a timely manner and the findings presented at an IEP meeting held on November 6, 2002.
The federal Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) and State law impose upon each school district the duty to actively and systematically identify and assess all children with disabilities who require special education and related services. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300, 56301.) Identification procedures must include utilization of referrals of students by teachers, parents, agencies, professional persons, and members of the public. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56302.) The obligation set forth in this statutory scheme is often referred to as the “child-find” obligation. (Footnote 3)
Petitioner challenges the District’s response to what she alleges were repeated instances of her parent alerting the District that she was a child with special needs. The Hearing Officer will examine whether the District properly responded to the parent’s concerns and met its child find obligations to identify and assess STUDENT.
MOTHER testified that during the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s third-grade teacher, Robert Atkinson, informed her that STUDENT was demonstrating inattention in class and not focusing. According to MOTHER, various accommodations were implemented to help STUDENT focus and Mr. Atkinson provided MOTHER with daily documentation about what STUDENT’s day was like. According to MOTHER, Mr. Atkinson told her that STUDENT’s behaviors could affect her performance in class. MOTHER also stated that both she and Mr. Atkinson had expressed concerns regarding STUDENT’s social skills.
Mr. Atkinson, however, testified somewhat differently, stating that although MOTHER expressed to him that she wanted STUDENT to receive special education services and that STUDENT needed accommodations such as sitting close to the front of the classroom, he never expressed any concerns to MOTHER regarding STUDENT’s need for special education because he believed STUDENT was gifted and did not need such services. The evidence indicates that sometime in August 2002, the parties participated in a mediation, unrelated to the current case, the result of which included the parties agreeing that the District would conduct a behavioral observation of STUDENT between September 9 and 27, 2002, and a speech and language assessment. (Footnote 4) (Dist.’s Exh. 25, pg.1.) District school psychologist Sheila Meneely conducted behavioral observations on three separate occasions in September 2002, and District speech language pathologist Pamela Macy conducted a speech and language assessment in October 2002.
On November 6, 2002, an IEP meeting was convened. (Dist.’s Exh. 19.) Ms. Meneely testified that during the IEP meeting, the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s learning abilities, both assessment reports that had been written, and the attention, medication, and sleeping concerns raised by MOTHER. According to Ms. Meneely, the IEP team also discussed the criteria for eligibility with ADD under OHI and the need for the IEP team to make a finding regarding whether or not inattention was adversely affecting STUDENT educationally. The District members of the IEP team did not find STUDENT eligible for special education services. MOTHER dissented to the District members of the IEP team’s decision.
The evidence showed that the District properly responded to MOTHER’s concerns regarding STUDENT’s educational performance and her belief that STUDENT had special needs. STUDENT was referred for a special education assessment by her mother and the Hearing Officer finds that the District met its child find responsibilities by conducting behavioral observations and a speech and language assessment, reviewing prior testing and reports/letters submitted by MOTHER, and convening an IEP meeting to discuss the same and consider STUDENT’s eligibility for special education services. Whether or not the District conducted an appropriate assessment or properly determined STUDENT’s eligibility for special education will be discussed by the Hearing Officer in the sections below.
B. Assessment
In November and December 2001, the District conducted an initial psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT and a report summarizing the assessor’s findings was completed on January 10, 2002. (Dist.’s Exh. 30.) Additionally, as a result of the agreement reached between the parties through a mediation in August 2002 (not involving the current matter but involving the same parties), the District conducted behavioral observations and a speech and language assessment in September and October 2002, respectively. Petitioner contends that the District’s assessment was inappropriate because it did not cover all areas related to the suspected disability, specifically in the areas of receptive auditory processing and social skills.
The District contends that it conducted a full psychoeducational assessment, which met the statutory requirements and explored all areas of suspected disability. According to the District, the tests administered by school psychologist Christine M. Shields in November and December 2001 exceeded the parent’s concerns. Cognitive processing, academic performance, perceptual and motor skills, attention, socialization, and emotional disturbance were all areas that were tested by the District. The District also contends that results of the behavioral observations conducted in September 2002 did not reveal any significant difficulties in class and inattention issues appeared manageable with teacher reminders to attend. Additionally, the speech and language evaluation conducted in October 2002 found all of STUDENT’s language functions to be in the average range and no indicators of a verbal/auditory processing disorder.
To be appropriate, the District’s assessment must have met the statutory requirements set forth in California Education Code section 56320 et. seq., which provides, in pertinent part:
(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purposes of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially culturally, or sexually discriminatory. (b) Tests and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements: (1) Are provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language or other mode of communication . . . (2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (3) Are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist (c) Tests and other assessment materials include those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need and not merely those which are designed to provide a single general intelligence quotient. (d) Tests are selected and administered to best ensure that when a test administered to a pupil with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills produces test results that accurately reflect the pupil’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure. e) No single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. (f) The pupil is assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, including low vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. A developmental history is obtained, when appropriate. . . .
Petitioner’s only objection regarding the appropriateness of the District’s assessment is whether the requirements of Section 56320(f) were met. Petitioner contends that the District failed to assess her in all areas related to the suspected disability because it ignored extensive indications that she had a receptive auditory processing deficiency interfering with her classroom performance and that she required further assessment in the processing area. Petitioner also contends that the District failed to assess her social challenges. As there were no other challenges to the assessment, it is unnecessary to address the remaining requirements of an appropriate assessment. Therefore, the discussion below is limited to Petitioner’s specific allegations raised at the hearing and set forth above regarding auditory processing and social skills.
Auditory Processing Testing
Dr. Patricia Weiss, private neuropsychologist and clinical psychologist, testified regarding the appropriateness of the District’s assessments. After reviewing various assessment reports and documents pertaining to STUDENT’s health history, Dr. Weiss concluded that the District should have tested STUDENT for an auditory processing deficit because children who have suffered from anoxia (lack of oxygen) at birth tend to have problems in the area of the brain where auditory processing takes place. (Footnote 5) Because it is difficult to identify this deficit, Dr. Weiss opined that the District failed to administer specific subtests on the cognitive and achievement that would have tested receptive auditory processing. (Footnote 6)
Dr. Weiss testified that in a classroom, a receptive auditory processing deficit could cause some children to be inattentive and fall behind academically. In reviewing STUDENT’s educational records, Dr. Weiss saw that in almost every report STUDENT was noted as having difficulty with concentration and attention, and some reporters thought that she might have ADHD. Dr. Weiss opined that it was necessary for the District to conduct comprehensive testing to thoroughly explore STUDENT’s receptive auditory processing deficits and social challenges as it was possible that she was having trouble completing homework because she did not fully understand what was being said.
District school psychologist Christine M. Shields completed a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT in November and December 2001 and reported that she found no significant processing deficits that would indicate an underlying learning disability. (Dist.’s Exh. 30.) District supervisor/program administrator and school psychologist Pamela Mills testified that STUDENT’s scores on Ms. Shield’s administration of the Cognitive Assessment System (CAS) and the Woodcock Johnson Tests of Achievement – Third Edition (WJ-III) showed that she had good processing speed and that there was no suggestion of a need for further testing in that area. (Footnote 7) (Dist.’s Exh. 30.) Dr. Mills testified that the CAS is a processing assessment and that auditory processing is best assessed on the Successive subtest of that measure. STUDENT received a standard score of 120 on the Successive subtest, which is in the 91st percentile. Dr. Mills stated that the Understanding Directions subtest on the WJ-III also provides information about receptive auditory processing skills because it takes those skills to be successful on that subtest, and STUDENT received a standard score of 109. Additionally, according to Dr. Mills, the Letter-Word Identification subtest on the WJ-III deals with how one hears the sounds of words, which also is related to receptive auditory processing, and STUDENT scored 122, which is substantially above the mean of 100.
The Hearing Officer finds persuasive both Ms. Shields’ psychoeducational report and Dr. Mills’ testimony regarding tests the District used to assess STUDENT’s receptive auditory processing skills. Both showed Dr. Weiss’s assertions to be unfounded. Additional testimony from the District’s head speech pathologist, Pamela Macy, further supports the validity of the District’s auditory processing testing.
Petitioner argued that in the District’s speech and language assessment conducted in October 2002, STUDENT underperformed on two tests measuring receptive auditory processing - the Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test (ROWPVT) and the Grammatic Understanding (ability to understand grammatical forms) subtest on the Test of Language Development-Primary (TOLD-P). (Dist.’s Exh. 26.) Ms. Macy testified that her testing results revealed no auditory processing weaknesses and that nothing led her to believe that further auditory processing testing was necessary. (Footnote 8) According to Ms. Macy, because STUDENT did not score very well on the ROWPVT, she administered another subtest on the TOLD-P, the Picture Vocabulary subtest, which assesses the same skill (the ability to understand the meaning of individual spoken words), to determine if the results would be similar. STUDENT earned a standard score of 13 and a percentile score of 84 on the Picture Vocabulary subtest, demonstrating vocabulary skills above age level expectancy. (Dist.’s Exh. 26, pg. 93.)
Ms. Macy also testified that STUDENT’s relatively low score on the Grammatic Understanding subtest was offset by her demonstrated abilities on the Grammatic Completion subtest of the TOLD-P and her speech and language sample, on which she showed that she could understand grammatical forms very successfully. According to Ms. Macy, STUDENT would not have been successful on the Grammatic Completion subtest, which assesses the ability to complete a partially formed sentence by supplying a final word that has proper morphological form, if she had not understood the grammatical form. Ms. Macy also did not find significant STUDENT’s low score on the Grammatic Understanding subtest because that subtest was administered during the last 20 minutes of a 65-minute testing session and STUDENT had become restless and was distracted by playing with her rings and lying off and on her chair. (Footnote 9) Moreover, STUDENT’s above average score on the Formulated Sentences subtest of the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF-3) also demonstrated that she had solid grammatical understanding skills. (Testimony of P. Macy.) According to Ms. Macy, these test results support her conclusion that STUDENT had no auditory processing deficits and did not require further testing in that area.
STUDENT’s auditory processing skills were additionally tested using the Word Discrimination and Phonemic Analysis subtests on the TOLD-P, which are screening devices for an auditory processing disorder. (Testimony of P. Macy.) According to Ms. Macy, typically, a student with auditory processing weaknesses will demonstrate difficulties with reading, oral language, and the rapid connection of phonemes to graphemes; but she saw none of these difficulties with STUDENT. In her report, Ms. Macy surmised that her test results indicated that STUDENT did not have attentional/listening difficulties in the absence of fatigue. She also reported that repetition of instructions and subtest stimuli were not necessary and that STUDENT did not appear to be experiencing any difficulty processing the material presented in increasing volume and was able to retain information for accuracy of response. (Dist.’s Exh. 26, pg. 96.)
The Hearing Officer was persuaded by Ms. Macy’s testimony that based on the totality of testing, no further assessment of STUDENT’s auditory processing skills was warranted. Ms. Macy testified persuasively about the thoroughness of the tests she conducted and the follow-up testing she performed to confirm the level of STUDENT’s auditory processing skills. Additionally, Dr. Mills provided testimony regarding how the cognitive and achievement testing conducted by the District in November and December 2001 provided further assessment of STUDENT’s auditory processing speed and skills. The Hearing Officer finds that the District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT’s auditory processing skills as evidenced in its November and December 2001 cognitive and achievement testing and its October 12, 2002 speech and language evaluation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that no further testing of STUDENT’s auditory processing skills was warranted during the 2002-2003 school year.
Testing of Social Skills
Petitioner contends that the District was aware of her social challenges, yet failed to assess her behavior in spite of evidence indicating a need for specialized instruction in the social arena. The District argues that in response to MOTHER’s concerns regarding STUDENT’s inattention issues and off-task or acting-out behaviors, the District agreed through mediation to conduct behavioral observations in September 2002 to determine whether STUDENT exhibited ADHD-like behaviors in the classroom. Thereafter, the IEP team reviewed the results of the behavior observations to consider whether STUDENT’s inattention issues had an adverse effect on her educational performance for purposes of eligibility under the category of OHI. (Footnote 10)
According to Dr. Weiss, every report that she reviewed indicated that STUDENT was extremely anxious, including a 2001 report by Dr. Erica Burhman, in which she diagnosed STUDENT with a Generalized Anxiety Disorder. (See Dist.’s Exhs. 25 and 30.) Dr. Weiss testified that STUDENT’s anxiety manifested itself by her inability to focus at school. Dr. Weiss also stated that children who are anxious often display a lot of withdrawal and depression and that therefore, she believed additional testing in emotional, psychological, and mood disorders should have been conducted to determine if STUDENT needed to be placed in a special day class. Dr. Weiss believed that the District should have administered the Rorschach and Thematic Apperception Tests (TAT) to STUDENT to determine whether she had a mood disorder, since anxiety and depression might be the reason that STUDENT had trouble focusing.
Dr. Mills, who is both an educational psychologist and clinical psychologist, testified that there was no need to administer the Rorschach or the TAT to STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year. According to Dr. Mills, the Rorschach is a projective test instrument often used by clinical psychologists in clinical practices to ferret out underlying themes of how one perceives the world. For instance, such tests would be used to determine if someone’s depression is motivated by some psychotic thinking, such as suicidality or schizophrenia. The Rorschach is not given to determine whether someone has anxiety or depression, but would be given to people who are going to be in long-term analytic-type therapy. Dr. Mills stated the TAT is similar to the Sentence Completion subtest on the Test of Language Development-Primary, which was administered to STUDENT by the District’s speech pathologist in October 2002. According to Dr. Mills, the TAT is also a projective of emotions that assesses one’s adaptive, social/emotional behavior. Dr. Mills stated that there were no indicators that would lead one to gather more information through the Rorschach or the TAT. (Footnote 11) Additionally, the fact that STUDENT witnessed a murder in 2002 would not change her opinion in that regard because those tests do not measure post-traumatic stress disorder, which is what one would examine under such circumstances. (Testimony of P. Mills.)
Dr. Mills also testified that Christine Shields’ December 2001 administration of the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC) assessed STUDENT’s adaptive behaviors and emotions. (Dist.’s Exh. 30, pgs. 105-106.) In her January 2002 report, Ms. Shields concluded that STUDENT had some behavioral difficulties within the home and school setting, but that the behaviors did not appear to be significantly affecting her ability to learn within the school setting as evidenced by her academic achievement scores. According to Ms. Shields’ report, there were no indications that STUDENT had an emotional disturbance, but Ms. Shields believed that STUDENT might benefit from a behavior modification plan to help her stay on task, complete her work, and improve appropriate behaviors. Neither party presented evidence as to whether the District implemented this suggestion. However, private doctor reports indicated that STUDENT had been referred for behavior management and play therapy, in which she did participate. (Dist.’s Exhs. 27 and 28.)
Additional evidence of the District’s assessing STUDENT’s social skills was found in the District’s behavioral observations. Pursuant to a mediation agreement completed on August 19, 2002, school psychologist Sheila Meneely conducted behavioral observations of STUDENT in Mr. Atkinson’s third-grade class on three separate occasions in September 2002 and also consulted with STUDENT’s third-grade teacher, Robert Atkinson. Ms. Meneely’s observation also included a review of the District’s January 10, 2002 psychoeducational report, notes from STUDENT’s summer school teacher, and reports/letters submitted by MOTHER. (Dist.’s Exh. 25.) Ms. Meneely testified that the purpose of her observations was to determine whether STUDENT had an attention disorder and whether STUDENT exhibited any off-task or aberrant behaviors. According to Ms. Meneely, her three observations, along with consultation with Mr. Atkinson, did not indicate any significant behavioral difficulties in class at that time. Rather, consistent with the findings from the District’s December 2001 assessment of STUDENT’s social/emotional and behavior skills, inattention issues were manageable during the 2002-2003 school year with teacher reminders to attend. Ms. Meneely testified that there was no indicator that further testing in the areas of attention, social skills, and emotional skills was necessary. (Footnote 12) According to Ms. Meneely, STUDENT showed no hypersensitivity when the teacher asked her questions to which she did not know the answers and there were no markers shown in any area indicating that her educational performance was not at the level that it should be.
In her written report, Ms. Meneely noted that the IEP team would need to consider the medical diagnosis of ADHD-like symptoms and keep in mind the eligibility criteria for special education services under OHI. (Dist.’s Exh. 25, pg. 89.) Ms. Meneely testified that the assessment of STUDENT’s attention issues was a major reason why she attended the November 6, 2002 IEP meeting. According to Ms. Meneely, during that IEP meeting, the IEP team discussed the criteria for special education eligibility with ADD and Ms. Meneely gave her opinion as to whether she believed STUDENT’s attention issues affected her educationally.
STUDENT’s teacher, Robert Atkinson, also testified that there was nothing that led him to believe that STUDENT had difficulty with social interactions with peers or adults. According to Mr. Atkinson, STUDENT related normally to her peers, had friends, and demonstrated that she understood the rules of the games in which she participated. Although her alertness was situational, it was within the range of a typical third-grade student in that she had no more difficulty focusing on her work than other children did. Mr. Atkinson stated that STUDENT simply needed to work on self-monitoring and her tardiness.
Although the District’s January 2002 psychoeducational report indicated STUDENT was experiencing some behavioral difficulties within the home and school setting at that time, her behaviors and attention issues were manageable and not significantly affecting her ability to learn. Ms. Meneely’s observation results and reports from STUDENT’s third-grade teacher indicated no significant behavioral or attention difficulties affecting STUDENT’s studies during the 2002-2003 school year such that the District should have conducted further assessment in these areas. The evidence above establishes that the District conducted a sufficient examination of STUDENT’s social skills, including attention and behavior, to determine the relationship of her behavior to her academic and social functioning. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT did not require additional testing in the area of social skills during the 2002-2003 school year.
C. Eligibility Under SLD and OHI
Petitioner contends that during the 2002-2003 school year, she qualified for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) or other health impairments (OHI) because she needed special education and related services due to said conditions. According to Petitioner, she required special education and services beyond modification of the general education classroom. The District contends that STUDENT did not meet the eligibility criteria for special education as a student with an SLD or OHI during the 2002-2003 school year. The District argues that it presented consistent evidence over a period of time demonstrating that Petitioner continued to make progress. The District asserts that while homework completion and tardies continued to be a concern during the 2002-2003 school year, Petitioner’s overall performance based on assessments, observation, teacher report, and report card indicate that Petitioner was meeting and exceeding grade level standards in all academic areas and was being successful at school.
Specific Learning Disability
The IDEA defines “specific learning disability” as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” (20 U.S.C. § 1401(26).) Basic psychological processes include “attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expression.” (5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3030(j)(1).) California Education Code section 56337 states that the following three requirements must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability:
(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievements in one or more of the following academic areas: (1) Oral expression;
(2) Listening comprehension;
(3) Written expression;
(4) Basic reading skills;
(5) Reading comprehension;
(6) Mathematics calculation;
(7) Mathematics reasoning.
(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. (c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.
Intellectual ability includes both acquired learning and learning potential and must be determined by a systematic assessment of intellectual functioning. The level of achievement includes the student’s level of competence in materials and subject matter explicitly taught in school and must be measured by standardized achievement tests. (5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3030(j)(2), (3).)
A severe discrepancy can be established through a formula using standardized tests, by alternative means when standardized tests are considered to be invalid, or by a finding of the IEP team that a severe discrepancy exists. (5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3030(j)(4)(A), (B), (C).)
Petitioner argues that she qualified for special education services under the category of SLD due to a disorder in one of the basic psychological processes - auditory processing - leading to a severe discrepancy between her ability and achievement in math.
The District contends that Petitioner did not present any evidence she required special education services to progress in the general education curriculum, that classroom accommodations provided sufficient support to allow Petitioner to make progress, and that there was no evidence to refute Ms. Shields’ findings in 2002 that a discrepancy did not exist between Petitioner’s ability and achievement. Additionally, the District contends that there was no evidence of Petitioner exhibiting signs of an auditory processing disorder.
At the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, the only test data available to compare STUDENT’s cognitive ability to her achievement was that obtained by school psychologist Christine Shields and recorded in the January 2002 psychoeducational report. (Dist.’s Exh. 30.) (Footnote 13) The District’s January 2002 psychoeducational report indicated that STUDENT obtained a full-scale score of 114 on the Cognitive Assessment Test (CAS), which classifies her as functioning in the average/superior range. (Footnote 14) STUDENT’s relevant standard achievement scores ranged from 107 to 122, indicating STUDENT’s achievement in all areas to be within the average to above average range. (Dist.’s Exh. 30, pg. 104.) Ms. Shields reported that STUDENT’s achievement in all areas was commensurate with her cognitive ability. (Id. at pg. 104.)
When standardized tests are considered valid for a student, the method of determining whether a severe discrepancy exists involves comparing STUDENT’s scores on standardized measures of intellectual ability with her scores on standardized academic achievement tests. The calculation of this formula has commonly involved interpreting the required difference for a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement standard scores to be at least 22.5 points (1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of 15), adjusted by 4 points, which is one standard error of measurement. This computed difference constitutes a severe discrepancy when “such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments and work samples, as appropriate.” (Id.)
Using only the cognitive and achievement scores from the District’s January 2002 psychoeducational report, District psychologist Pamela Mills testified that there was less than a 22-point difference between any of STUDENT’s cognitive and achievement scores. Therefore, there were no areas in which a severe discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s ability and achievement in any of the categories set forth in California Education Code section 56337. (5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3030(j)(4)(A).)
Since there was no standardized cognitive or achievement testing conducted during the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer turns then to other information regarding STUDENT’s skills that was available during the period at issue. (5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3030(j)(4)(C).) STUDENT’s first quarter progress report for the third grade indicated that she read at the fourth-grade level and was functioning well in an advanced math class. Her writing was typical of a third-grade student and she had some difficulty getting all of her homework in on time. Mr. Atkinson reported that STUDENT was often tardy to class in the morning and that she needed to work on organization, neatness, and monitoring her on-task behavior in class. (Pet.’s Exh. 20.) By the end of the school year, however, STUDENT had improved in every area noted by her teacher during the first quarter; but tardies continued to be a serious concern. (Id.)
Additionally, STUDENT’s class performance (measured by progress reports and teacher report) was commensurate with her above-average cognitive ability. Mr. Atkinson reported at the November 6, 2002 IEP meeting that STUDENT was at grade level or above in academic skills. She performed at the fifth-grade level in reading (decoding and comprehension) and at the fourth-grade level in math. (Dist.’s Exh. 19, pg. 44.) In writing, Mr. Atkinson testified that STUDENT performed within the instructional range and passed the State writing standard. According to Mr. Atkinson, although STUDENT demonstrated difficulty communicating mathematical thinking in writing, she was able to verbally explain how she ascertained her answers. Furthermore, Mr. Atkinson testified that he provided STUDENT accommodations such as redirection, individual instruction, repeating instructions, using manipulatives, and having STUDENT work with others in class, all of which helped STUDENT demonstrate competency with the curriculum.
In light of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the evidence demonstrates that there was no severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s intellectual ability and academic achievement in one or more of the academic areas identified in Education Code Section 56337(a). (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j).) Therefore, STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for SLD during the 2002-2003 school year. Other Health Impaired
To meet federal eligibility criteria for special education as OHI, the student must have “limited strength, vitality or alertness, including a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli, that results in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment,” because of chronic or acute health problems, such as attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, which adversely affects a child’s educational performance. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9).) Under state law, OHI eligibility for special education is set forth at Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3030(f) as follows:
A pupil has limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems, including but not limited to a heart condition, cancer, leukemia, rheumatic fever, chronic kidney disease, cystic fibrosis, severe asthma, epilepsy, lead poisoning, diabetes, tuberculosis and other communicable infections diseases, and hematological disorders such as sickle cell anemia and hemophilia which adversely affects a pupil’s educational performance… such physical disabilities shall not be temporary in nature
OHI eligibility for special education can be established with a diagnosis of ADD or ADHD if the disorder adversely affects the pupil’s educational performance, the pupil otherwise meets the eligibility requirements for OHI, and because of the disability, the student requires instruction, services, or both, which cannot be met by modification of the regular school program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56339(a); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9).)
Petitioner argues that she was tired and lacked attention and focus, exhibiting limited strength, vitality or alertness in the classroom and in assessment environments. According to Petitioner, this limited strength, vitality, and alertness was due to chronic health problems, including anoxia (breathing difficulty at birth), her difficulty sleeping at night, the effects of prescribed medications, and ADHD-like symptoms. Petitioner contends that her medical challenges and resulting attention difficulties were far from temporary, having been diagnosed and persistent for at least three years before the 2002-2003 school year. Petitioner argues that her limited alertness due to her chronic medical condition adversely affected her educational performance in that she had difficulty staying on task and at times did not complete her class work.
The District does not dispute that Petitioner was diagnosed with ADHD; however, the District argues that Petitioner’s diagnosis of ADHD and the fact that she takes medication, alone, do not establish that she has a health condition that would qualify her under the category of OHI. Although Petitioner was often late to school and did not complete homework, the District argues that there was no evidence or testimony presented at hearing that the reason for her tardies and failure to do homework was health-related.
Additionally, the District contends that STUDENT made significant growth in the social emotional domain during the 2002-2003 school year and the results of the behavioral observation did not reveal any significant behavioral difficulties. Petitioner’s inattention issues appeared manageable with teacher reminders to attend, and classroom accommodations provided STUDENT sufficient support to allow her to continue to make progress. According to the District, Petitioner did not present any evidence that she required special education services to progress in the general education curriculum.
Dr. Patricia Weiss testified that she believed STUDENT qualified for special education services under the category of OHI because of symptoms she exhibited that may have been the result of her original insult to the brain at birth (anoxia). According to Dr. Weiss, the District’s assessment was not comprehensive enough to make a determination regarding STUDENT’s eligibility under OHI. The Hearing Officer is hesitant to rely on Dr. Weiss’s interpretation of the District’s January 2002 psychoeducational report and its September and October 2002 behavioral observations and speech and language assessment, however, for several reasons.
Dr. Weiss did not assess STUDENT, nor did she observe her in the classroom or any other setting. Additionally, on the one hand, Dr. Weiss states that the District’s assessment was not comprehensive enough for it to make OHI eligibility determinations. However, on the other hand, she seems to believe she reviewed sufficient information to determine that STUDENT should have qualified for services as OHI. Dr. Weiss did not testify as to how rendering an opinion regarding STUDENT’s eligibility under OHI based on alleged noncomprehensive assessment data was possible in her case, but not possible in the District’s case. Because Dr. Weiss rendered an opinion on STUDENT’s eligibility under OHI after having not assessed or observed STUDENT herself and making a recommendation for additional testing, the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Weiss’s opinion unpersuasive. Moreover, Dr. Weiss appeared to base many of her opinions on Dr. Solomon’s June 1, 2004 assessment report, which was conducted after the 2002-2003 school year, more than one and one-half years after the District’s September and October 2002 assessments, and over two years after the District’s January 2002 psychoeducational assessment.
Mr. Atkinson testified that STUDENT had difficulty getting to school on time (possibly due to sleep problems and/or effects of her medication) and that she had to be redirected in class to help her stay on task. However, according to Mr. Atkinson, STUDENT’s alertness was situational and her need for redirection was no greater than that of any other average student. Mr. Atkinson and Ms. Meneely, who conducted three behavioral observations of STUDENT in September 2002, both testified that STUDENT was able to listen and respond to oral statements in class, and although she sometimes appeared not to be listening, on most occasions when asked a question, she would answer appropriately and demonstrate understanding. Mr. Atkinson did not believe that STUDENT required focused remedial instruction, but believed that STUDENT needed to work on self-monitoring and tardiness. According to Mr. Atkinson, there was no indication that STUDENT’s tardiness or ADHD-like symptoms negatively affected her ability to reach grade-level academic standards or that she was unable to make sufficient progress in the general education curriculum.
Ms. Meneely testified that over the course of her three classroom observations, STUDENT was typically on task throughout the day and did not need any reminders to stay in her seat. Ms. Meneely testified that STUDENT followed all of the teacher’s directions, responded appropriately to the teacher, and acted appropriately. According to Ms. Meneely, STUDENT had no problems communicating with other children in the class and she saw no issues of distractibility. (Dist.’s Exh. 25.)
The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony of STUDENT’s teacher regarding STUDENT’s ability to be redirected when off-task and how STUDENT demonstrated understanding of materials orally presented in class. Ms. Meneely also provided credible testimony confirming STUDENT had no significant behavioral difficulties in class at that time and that inattention issues appeared manageable by the teacher. Although there was evidence that STUDENT exhibited some limited alertness in the afternoons and that this may have been due to a chronic or acute health problem, (Testimony of R. Atkinson.), STUDENT’s educational challenges were addressed in the regular education environment with sufficient accommodations provided by the teacher.
On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner did not meet the eligibility criteria for OHI during the 2002-2003 school year.
2. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to identify and assess STUDENT’s exceptional needs and B. identify her as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
A. Child Find
As stated earlier in this Decision, each district must actively and systematically seek out and assess all individuals with exceptional needs who may require special education and related services. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300, 56301.)
Petitioner contends that that there were numerous communications through STUDENT’s teachers that STUDENT’s lack of focus, incomplete tasks, and her hyperactivity/impulsivity interfered with her class performance, and acknowledged and documented requests from the parent to screen and reassess STUDENT. However, the District refused to conduct any assessment during the 2003-2004 school year to reconsider her eligibility for special education and failed to provide her parent prior written notice of its refusal to do so.
The District argues that Petitioner did not exhibit any behaviors or academic performance that required reevaluation for special education during the 2003-02004 school year. STUDENT’s fourth-grade teacher, Hilary Poon, the principal at Claire Lilienthal School (Lilienthal), Mary Richards, and the assistant principal at Lilienthal, William Hack, all requested that MOTHER provide them with medical documentation to verify her concerns regarding the effects of STUDENT’s medication. According to the District, MOTHER produced only one doctor’s letter, which confirmed STUDENT had ADHD and that she was taking medications for inattention. (Pet.’s Exh. 21.) However, there were no behaviors that indicated a problem that needed monitoring and no problems that required further assessment for special education.
STUDENT’s mother transferred STUDENT to Lilienthal for the 2003-2004 school year. In September 2003, STUDENT was placed in Hilary Poon’s regular education fourth-grade classroom. MOTHER testified that when she enrolled STUDENT at Lilienthal, she purposefully did not alert the school about any of her concerns or provide it with any historical information because she did not want the school to “label” STUDENT. Instead, MOTHER wanted the school staff to see for themselves the educational difficulties that STUDENT was having.
When STUDENT started arriving at school late, MOTHER then informed the assistant principal, William Hack, that STUDENT had a sleeping disorder and provided him with medical documentation to that effect. MOTHER also then started spending more time in STUDENT’s classroom to monitor her response to the medications she was taking. A student success team (SST) meeting was subsequently convened on November 6, 2003, to address MOTHER’s concerns regarding STUDENT’s performance. The SST discussed STUDENT’s medical issues and the medications she was taking, whether STUDENT should be assessed again, whether she required bus transportation to get to school on time, and whether MOTHER needed to be in Ms. Poon’s classroom so often. (Pet.’s Exh. 25; testimony of W. Hack.) Mr. Hack testified that based on the doctor’s letter provided by MOTHER describing STUDENT’s neurological issues, sleeping problems, and the medications she was taking, the SST decided to request a Section 504 Plan for STUDENT.
The school and the parent initiated the Section 504 process on November 13, 2003, and used information from the doctor’s letter in developing the Section 504 request. (Dist.’s Exh. 22.) The Section 504 request form confirms that MOTHER wanted STUDENT to have a Section 504 plan, have close monitoring, and again go through screening and assessment for special education eligibility. (Id.; testimony of W. Hack.) MOTHER testified that she told the District that she first wanted to try a Section 504 plan before requesting an IEP because she was concerned that STUDENT would not qualify for special education services, since she had previously been found ineligible. The Section 504 plan request form also states that resource specialist Alice Hill recommended STUDENT be screened and assessed because she believed STUDENT would benefit from special education strategies in and out of the classroom. (Dist.’s Exh. 22, pg. 64.)
Although the District members of the SST and the parent believed that medications and doctors’ reports pointed to a legitimate concern, the District’s 504 school committee denied the 504 plan request. The committee reasoned that STUDENT did not need door-to-door bus transportation just because she was constantly tardy, and that three prior assessments done at Cobb and other IEP teams had determined that she was not eligible to receive special education services. (Dist.’s Exhs. 19, 20, 25, 26, and 30.)
In response to the denial, by letter dated February 18, 2004, Mr. Hack provided the 504 committee with additional information that it had indicated it needed and stated in his letter that he hoped a 504 plan would be recommended that would include STUDENT’s working with a resource teacher and receiving extended time. The additional information included a February 6, 2004 letter from STUDENT’s psychiatrist, Marcie Hall-Mennes, MD, stating that STUDENT had been under her care for the past seven months and that she met the criteria for ADHD and had features suggestive of generalized anxiety disorder, which contributed to STUDENT’s impulsivity, distractibility, inattention, and disorganization. (Pet.’s Exh. 21.)
The 504 plan request was eventually denied. The request for 504 services does indicate both MOTHER’s desire and Ms. Hill’s recommendation that STUDENT go through screening and assessment again. (Dist.’s Exh. 22, pg. 64). However, this does not necessarily mean that, under its child find obligations, the District was required to perform another assessment. The District’s child find obligation was to actively and systematically seek out and assess all individuals with exceptional needs who may require special education and related services. In STUDENT’s case, the District had already done so through the 20022003 school year. In the 20032004 school year, the diagnosis of ADHD in the February 6, 2004 letter from Dr. HallMennes was a diagnosis of a condition, ADHD, that the District had already been aware of through prior assessment. Regarding Ms. Hill’s recommendation for screening and assessment, that recommendation was made on the form requesting Section 504 services, and Ms. Hill stated no new circumstances to explain why reassessment for special education would be necessary. The same applies to MOTHER’s request. Neither State nor federal law mandate that a new assessment be performed whenever one is requested. If such were the case, a party could require reassessments with unlimited frequency. Under these circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not, pursuant to its child find obligations, required to conduct a reassessment in the 20032004 school year.
However, the District was required, under federal law, to provide MOTHER with notice of its refusal to reassess, with an explanation. Specifically, Federal law requires districts to provide parents with prior written notice a reasonable time before the district proposes or refuses to change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of a student or the provision of a FAPE to a student. (20 U.S.C. §§ 1415(b)(3), (c); 34 C.F.R. § 300.503(a)(1)(iii).) The District provided no such notice or explanation to MOTHER. To that limited extent, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to meet its child find obligations by failing to provide MOTHER with notice of its refusal to reassess STUDENT and an explanation for that refusal.
B. Eligibility Under SLD and OHI
Specific Learning Disability
Petitioner asserts that she should have been found eligible for special education services under the category of SLD during the 2003-2004 school year. She contends that her work was not yet on grade level three months prior to the end of the school year and that she failed to perform at grade level despite an abundance of informal modifications provided by her teacher, Ms. Poon.
The District contends that Petitioner made appropriate educational progress and was functioning well within the average range in all academic areas. The District argues that various accommodations were provided to Petitioner in the general education program that met her needs. Although STUDENT worked slowly, this did not prevent her from achieving in her academic work.
The District conducted no standardized testing during the 2003-2004 school year. Petitioner obtained an independent psychoeducational assessment from Dr. Theresita Solomon in April 2004, who drafted a report based on the assessment on June 1, 2004. While clarifying the issues at the beginning of the hearing, Petitioner indicated that the parent provided Dr. Solomon’s report to the District during the summer of 2004. In its closing brief, the District confirms that the report was provided to the District during the summer of 2004. (Dist.’s closing brief, pg. 27.) Since there were no standard test scores provided during the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer cannot make a determination based on the formula using standardized test scores as to whether a severe discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s intellectual ability and achievement. (5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3030(j)(4)(A).)
Turning then to information regarding STUDENT’s skills that was available during the period at issue, her teacher and prior assessors consistently testified that STUDENT’s cognitive skills fell within the average to above average range. Their testimony is supported by STUDENT’s having consistently obtained average to above-average standard scores on measures of intelligence. On cognitive assessments administered by Dr. Kathleen Peters in 1999 and the District in November/December 2001, STUDENT’s composite and full-scale scores were 111 and 114, respectively. (Dist.’s Exhs. 30 and 32.) There is no evidence that STUDENT’s cognitive skills fell in other than the average to above average range during the 2003-2004 school year.
As to STUDENT’s achievement, the testimony established that there was no severe discrepancy between her ability and achievement during the 2003-2004 school year. Hilary Poon, STUDENT’s teacher during the 2003-2004 school year, testified that she provided STUDENT with various accommodations and modifications in the classroom, such as preferential seating, teaching her self-monitoring strategies and how to organize her work and put it away, providing her with shorter segments, orally reviewing instructions with her and providing her with examples to make sure she was on the right track, working one-to-one with STUDENT during class time, partnering her with a peer and working in small groups, and providing her with assistance from the resource specialist during the open resource period. (Footnote 15) (See Dist.’s Exhs. 16 and 17.) Ms. Poon testified that STUDENT benefited from these strategies because as the school year progressed, she showed more consistency in her work. Ms. Poon stated that STUDENT showed no consistent pattern of difficulty in any one subject, and when given a chance, she was able to stay focused. With the modifications and accommodations, STUDENT was able to do the work presented to her, perform within the instructional range, and demonstrate understanding of the class content. (Testimony of H. Poon.) Lilienthal principal Mary Richards testified that STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Poon, never expressed concerns regarding STUDENT’s learning ability or academic achievement. Ms. Richards reported that STUDENT’s teacher told her that STUDENT was capable of doing grade-level work or better, but the challenge was that STUDENT often did not complete homework assignments and was often late to class.
Additionally, although STUDENT had difficulty completing her assignments quickly, doing her homework, staying focused, and coming to class on time at the beginning of the school year, the evidence showed that she was able to meet grade level content standards. (See Dist.’s Exhs. 18 and 37.) The Hearing Officer relies on the testimony of STUDENT’s teacher that she was able to perform in class and learn academic content. There was no evidence to the contrary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the evidence established that during the 2003-2004 school year, there was no severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement, and therefore, STUDENT did not meet the criteria for eligibility on the basis of a specific learning disability. (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j).)
Other Health Impaired
To meet federal eligibility criteria for special education as OHI, a student must have “limited strength, vitality or alertness, including a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli, that results in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment,” because of chronic or acute health problems, such as attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, which adversely affects a child’s educational performance. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9).) OHI eligibility for special education can be established with a diagnosis of ADD or ADHD if the disorder adversely affects the pupil’s educational performance, the pupil otherwise meets the eligibility requirements of OHI, and because of the disability, the student requires instruction, services, or both, which cannot be met by modification of the regular school program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56339(a); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9).)
Petitioner contends that she continued to be eligible for special education services as a child with a disability under the category of OHI during the 2003-2004 school year. According to Petitioner, her teacher and mother continued to report her lack of focus, inability to complete tasks, and her hyperactivity/impulsivity interfering with her class work. Petitioner argues that her medical diagnosis of ADHD (inattention and hyperactivity) and diagnosis of a generalized anxiety disorder, which contributed to her sleep challenges, interfered with her alertness and vitality in the academic setting.
The District disagrees that STUDENT qualified for services under OHI and that she needs special education services. The District argues that not one teacher testified that Petitioner was impulsive or hyperactive at school and the inattention that was noted was not to a degree that negatively affected her educational performance. The District agrees that STUDENT required accommodations, but believes that the necessary accommodations have been and continue to be implemented in the general education program.
Dr. Theresita Solomon testified that she believed STUDENT qualified for special education under the category of OHI due to her neurological insult at birth, regulatory disorder, her attention deficit, and slow processing, which have affected her ability to perform academically. Dr. Solomon testified that her understanding of the IDEA and eligibility under OHI was that a student has to have either an attention problem or a neurological problem. According to Dr. Solomon, STUDENT needs special education because she requires modifications in the classroom that are consistent and formally monitored.
Although Dr. Solomon believed that STUDENT was a child with exceptional needs due to her ADHD and neurological problems, she also acknowledged that STUDENT “had good cognitive skills and had demonstrated the ability to perform well academically…” (Dist.’s Exh. 23, pg. 78.) Moreover, the fact that STUDENT has been diagnosed with ADHD or that she may have had neurological-related problems does not necessarily lead to a conclusion that she qualified as OHI. In order to be eligible for special education services under OHI, a student’s limited strength, vitality, or alertness must be found to adversely affect her educational performance to such a degree that modification of the regular education program is not sufficient. (5 C.C.R. § 3030(f); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9).) A review of the evidence in this matter indicates that STUDENT had brief periods of limited vitality in the mornings and instances of inattention. However, STUDENT’s ADHD did not adversely affect her educational performance to such a degree that she required special education.
Regarding her report of STUDENT’s “moments of attentiveness,” Ms. Poon explained that this statement in a March 16, 2004 letter to the school’s principal did not mean that STUDENT had inattentive moments that lasted all day. Ms. Poon testified that STUDENT was consistently tired during the first hour of class; however, once she got more energized, she was able to complete her work. (Dist.’s Exh. 18.) Ms. Poon stated that she was also concerned with STUDENT’s coming to school late because it resulted in her missing work. However, in spite of being late to class, Ms. Poon testified that STUDENT was still able to demonstrate competency in the curriculum and make progress. In addition, STUDENT’s punctuality did improve, which helped improve her performance and allowed her to get help in class as needed. (Testimony of H. Poon; see also Dist.’s Exhs. 17 and 18.)
According to Ms. Poon, STUDENT had the ability to stay focused and complete class work. Ms. Poon also testified that after STUDENT’s treating psychiatrist, Dr. Mennes-Hall, observed STUDENT in Ms. Poon’s classroom during the spring and consulted with Ms. Poon, Dr. Mennes-Hall stated that she was happy to see that STUDENT was focused on what she was doing and staying on task. Ms. Poon stated that STUDENT demonstrated knowledge of content standards in language arts and worked within the instructional range and demonstrated understanding in math. Ms. Poon believed that STUDENT did not need focused remedial instruction in math. Ms. Poon stated that with assistance through accommodations and modification, STUDENT was able to complete her work. Strategies that helped STUDENT included allowing her extra time to complete tasks, giving her shorter segments of material, providing preferential seating, and reviewing instructions orally with STUDENT. STUDENT also worked well with peer partners in small groups, and once every couple of weeks, Ms. Poon provided STUDENT a quiet environment where she could complete class work. In addition, Alice Hill, the school’s resource teacher, assisted STUDENT on an as-needed basis. (Dist.’s Exh. 17; testimony of H. Poon.)
The evidence establishes that STUDENT may have had times when she was tired and exhibited limited vitality during the first hour of class and instances when she was inattentive; however, STUDENT’s ADHD or medical challenges did not adversely affect her educational performance to such a degree that she required special education. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(b).) Various modifications and accommodations to STUDENTs’s educational program allowed her to improve her class performance and stay focused, complete her work, and ultimately meet grade level standards in academic subjects. (Dist.’s Exh. 16.)
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was not eligible as OHI during the 2003-2004 school year.
3. During the 2004-2005 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. convene an IEP meeting after its receipt of an independent evaluation from STUDENT’s parent; B. conduct auditory processing and occupational therapy assessments; and C. identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
A. Convening an IEP Meeting
Petitioner contends that when her parent provided the District a copy of the June 1, 2004 independent evaluation from Dr. Theresita Solomon, the District had a duty to convene an IEP team, find her eligible, and develop an appropriate program. According to Petitioner, the District has inappropriately refused to convene an IEP team meeting since November 6, 2002, to reconsider eligibility. Particularly in light of Dr. Solomon’s findings in June 2004 that she qualified as OHI, Petitioner argues that the District should have convened an IEP meeting and found her eligible.
The District contends that there is no requirement that an independent assessment be discussed at an IEP meeting, particularly since, in this case, Dr. Solomon’s independent assessment was reviewed and considered at a mediation following receipt of the report.
Education Code Section 56343 states that an IEP team must meet whenever any of the following occurs:
(a) A pupil has received an initial formal assessment. The team may meet when a pupil receives any subsequent formal assessment. (b) The pupil demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress.
(c) The parent or teacher requests a meeting to develop, review, or revise the individualized education program. (d) At least annually, … (Footnote 16)
(emphasis added)
MOTHER did not testify that she specifically requested an IEP team meeting during the 2004-2005 school year, nor was there any documentary evidence to that effect. Dr. Mills and Lilienthal principal Mary Richards testified that after Dr. Solomon’s report was received, the parties agreed to mediate and Dr. Solomon’s report was reviewed with the parent during the mediation. As indicated above, Dr. Solomon’s findings in the areas of ability and achievement were consistent with the District’s prior findings. Petitioner did not refute these facts. Although the District is required to at least consider the results of independent assessment reports in some manner, the District is not required to convene an IEP team when a student receives subsequent formal assessment, unless the parent specifically requests an IEP team meeting to develop, review, or revise an IEP. (Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343(c); 56329(c).) The evidence establishes that the District considered Dr. Solomon’s assessment report in mediation and absent a specific request by the parent to meet to develop an IEP, the District was not necessarily required to convene an IEP team meeting once it received Dr. Solomon’s independent assessment report from the parent.
In addition, in this case, there was no change in circumstances to trigger an obligation to convene an IEP meeting. STUDENT’s fourth- and fifth-grade teachers had reported that STUDENT was demonstrating consistent improvement and the accommodations were helping her to access the curriculum. Lastly, Ms. Romero and Dr. Mills, who both had observed STUDENT in the classroom this 2004-2005 school year, testified that STUDENT was able to attend in class similarly to her peers. Therefore, no other evidence required the District to convene an IEP meeting.
B. Assessment
Petitioner argues that the District was required to conduct auditory processing and occupational therapy assessments as recommended by Dr. Solomon in her June 1, 2004 report. The District contends that Petitioner did not exhibit any behaviors or academic performance that required reevaluation for special education.
Auditory Processing Assessment
Petitioner argues that she demonstrated deficits in auditory processing and that the District failed to assess her in this area. According to Petitioner, the District was provided a copy of Dr. Solomon’s June 1, 2004 independent psychoeducational report during the summer of 2004 and, at that point, it was on notice that it needed to assess her auditory processing skills.
The District contends that STUDENT did not require additional testing in the area of auditory processing and auditory memory because she did not exhibit the type of problems associated with auditory processing difficulties. Specifically, the District contends that STUDENT was able to attend in class as well as her peers, remember information presented orally, follow multiple-part oral instructions, and demonstrate good listening skills, and appropriate reading, writing, comprehension, spelling, and vocabulary skills.
Dr. Solomon testified that based on STUDENT’s extremely low score of 66 on the Verbal Immediate Memory subtest of the Children’s Memory Scale (CMS), STUDENT had an auditory processing problem. Dr. Solomon opined that based upon this finding and “STUDENT’s history of speech and language delays,” STUDENT needed a hearing evaluation to closely examine her central auditory processing and rule out a hearing deficit. (Pet.’s Exh. 17, pg. 15.) According to Dr. Solomon, a hearing deficit might manifest itself by STUDENT’s being unable to remember information presented orally.
District head speech pathologist Pamela Macy disagreed that Dr. Solomon’s testing indicated a need for further assessment. Ms. Macy testified that Dr. Solomon used one listening comprehension subtest on the CMS to make a finding that STUDENT had a deficit in her auditory memory. In addition, STUDENT’s score on the Listening Comprehension subtest of Dr. Solomon’s administration of the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test-Second Edition (WIAT-II) did not indicate an auditory processing problem. STUDENT obtained a standard score of 111 on that subtest, which placed her in the 77th percentile, at the 6.8 grade level. (Pet.’s Exh. 17, pg. 7.) According to Ms. Macy, children who have auditory processing deficits typically have difficulty with language-dependent subjects, such as reading, writing, and spelling, and that was not the case with STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Solomon states in her report that STUDENT had a history of speech and language delays. However, the results of Ms. Macy’s October 12, 2002 speech and language assessment indicated that STUDENT exhibited at or above age level expectancy in language content, form, and use skills. (Dist.’s Exh. 19, pg. 45.) Ms. Macy reported that during the evaluation, STUDENT did not appear to be experiencing difficulty processing material presented in increasing volume and was able to retain information for accuracy of response. (Dist.’s Exh. 26.)
Ms. Macy testified that she observed STUDENT in Mr. Reif’s fifth-grade class during the current school year on two separate occasions. According to Ms. Macy, when she approached STUDENT in a group of four students and asked the whole group to explain how they came to be placed in the group, STUDENT was very spontaneous in responding. STUDENT also volunteered to show Ms. Macy her paper so that Ms. Macy could see how she had underlined her lines in the play. Ms. Macy also spoke with Mr. Reif and he did not express any concerns regarding STUDENT’s ability to access the general education curriculum. According to Mr. Reif, STUDENT very well understands questions that he asks and is able to answer appropriately.
Dr. Mills also observed STUDENT’s social skills during the 2004-2005 school year in Mr. Reif’s class while the class was rehearsing for a play. Dr. Mills testified that STUDENT was following directions in a timely manner and that during the observation, she heard no redirection from the teacher. In addition, Dr. Mills testified that STUDENT’s one low score on the CMS needed to be substantiated for validity. When she pursued the score further by reviewing STUDENT’s grades and testing, Dr. Mills stated that she found the score was not indicative of STUDENT’s ability and therefore invalid.
The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimonies of Ms. Macy and Dr. Mills, who both observed STUDENT in her fifth-grade class this year. Ms. Macy conducted a speech and language evaluation that included measures that assessed STUDENT’s auditory processing skills and found no indications of auditory processing weaknesses. Dr. Mills reviewed STUDENT’s grades and testing and provided convincing testimony regarding STUDENT’s processing speed. Conversely, Dr. Solomon relied on only one subtest of the CMS and stated incorrectly that STUDENT had a history of speech and language delays. The Hearing Officer is therefore not persuaded by Dr. Solomon’s conclusion that STUDENT has an auditory processing deficit and that further testing is needed. Additionally, other persuasive evidence, as discussed above, showed that STUDENT did not demonstrate difficulties typically associated with an auditory processing disorder, but, in fact, demonstrated appropriate listening skills and lacked difficulty with language-dependent subjects. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that Petitioner did not require an auditory processing assessment during the 2004-2005 school year.
Occupational Therapy Assessment
Petitioner argues that based on Dr. Solomon’s assessment results, the District should have conducted an occupational therapy assessment. In response, the District argued that Dr. Solomon’s findings in this regard were not consistent with those of school psychologist Christine Shields and Dr. Peters. Moreover, STUDENT’s classroom teachers, Ms. Romero, and Dr. Mills all testified that Petitioner’s handwriting and visual motor skills were in the average range.
According to Dr. Solomon, given STUDENT’s standard score of 87 on the Beery-Buktenica Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI), STUDENT requires closer examination by an occupational therapist. (Pet.’s Exh. 17, pg. 15.) Dr. Solomon believed this score was weak given her review of STUDENT’s documented history of weak fine motor skills. According to Dr. Solomon, a student’s fine motor skill affects his or her ability to copy from the board. Dr. Solomon acknowledged that STUDENT’s scores on her administration of the VMI differed from both Dr. Peters’ and Ms. Shields’ previous administration of the test. Her scores showed regression, and, therefore, she made a recommendation for further evaluation.
Dr. Peters’ 1999 scores and Ms. Shields’ November/December 2001 scores were consistent and reflective of past and present teacher comments that STUDENT demonstrated average fine motor abilities. District consultant Vicki Adams-Romero, who had conducted an observation of STUDENT on January 12, 2005, in Mr. Reif’s classroom, testified that STUDENT demonstrated no difficulties with fine motor tasks in class and was observed copying from the board onto her paper. In reviewing STUDENT’s spacing and formation of letters on a recent essay that STUDENT had written, Dr. Mills opined that there were no red flags indicating a need for an occupational therapy referral. (Dist.’s Exh. 46.)
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require an occupational therapy assessment. There have been no recent reports of STUDENT’s having fine motor task difficulty and STUDENT’s scores on Dr. Solomon’s administration of the VMI were discrepant from other administrations of the test and not indicative of STUDENT’s current handwriting ability. Accordingly, the District was not required to conduct an occupational therapy assessment during the 2004-2005 school year. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).)
C. Eligibility Under SLD and OHI
Petitioner argues that she continues to be eligible under SLD and OHI and that she requires special education and services beyond modification to the general education classroom during the 2004-2005 school year.
The District contends that Petitioner is not entitled to special education and services under the categories of SLD and OHI and that her academic performance does not justify further reevaluation or reconsideration of eligibility.
Specific Learning Disability
Petitioner argues that she continues to qualify as SLD due to her brain injury, processing deficits, and particular difficulty performing commensurate with her ability in math. The District contends that STUDENT’s teacher confirmed that the accommodations currently being implemented allow her to participate and make progress in the general education curriculum and that she is demonstrating consistent improvement in academic skills. The District believes that STUDENT could be doing better if she completed her homework and was not tardy so often. According to STUDENT’s teachers, they believe she is capable of doing the class work and have never had the impression that STUDENT did not understand instructions or was having difficulty in class.
Although Dr. Solomon conducted cognitive testing in her 2004 psychoeducational evaluation, she did not report STUDENT’s scores on her administration of the WISC-IV; however, she did provide STUDENT’s achievement test scores from her administration of the WIAT-II, the Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests-Revised (WRMT-R), and the Wide Range Achievement Test-Third Edition (WRAT-3). (Footnote 17) (Pet.’s Exh. 17, pgs. 17-18.) In her evaluation, Dr. Solomon found that STUDENT’s cognitive and achievement test results were consistent with those of previous testing done by Dr. Peters in 1999 and Christine Shields in 2002. According to District psychologist Pamela Mills, the cognitive ability score of 114 reported by Ms. Shields in her January 10, 2002 report, the score of 111 reported by Dr. Peters in 1999, and achievement scores obtained by Dr. Solomon in 2004, indicated no discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement.
The Hearing Officer notes, however, that STUDENT received one low standard score of 86 on the Numerical Operations subtest of the WIAT-II. Dr. Solomon’s report indicates that the Numerical Operations subtest involves simple addition and subtraction. According to Dr. Mills, the Arithmetic subtest on the Wide Range Achievement Test-Third Edition (WRAT-3), which was also administered by Dr. Solomon, is the exact same basic pencil and paper math test as Numerical Operations. STUDENT received a standard score of 109 on the WRAT-3 Arithmetic subtest. (Pet.’s Exh. 17, pg. 17.) Dr. Mills testified that STUDENT’s higher score on another test, which assesses the same skills, demonstrates that she has the ability to do math calculations. Moreover, according to Dr. Solomon, STUDENT’s lower score in Numerical Operations appeared to be due to careless errors STUDENT made in computing simple addition and subtraction problems. Dr. Solomon noted that STUDENT did not use visual cancellation methods and she did not check her work. (Pet.’s Exh. 17, pg. 7.)
STUDENT’s current teacher, Mr. Reif, indicated on her first quarter progress report that STUDENT’s organizational skills prevented her from making as much progress as she should be making. However, the second quarter report indicated that she was demonstrating competent performance in all academic areas, except for some areas of math. (Dist.’s Exh. 49.) Nevertheless, Mr. Reif testified that STUDENT was able to demonstrate her knowledge of the academic subjects in class. Specifically, STUDENT demonstrates understanding of math concepts and is able to work independently in the classroom, but would benefit from additional practice because she makes many “sloppy” mistakes. According to Mr. Reif, STUDENT misses a lot of the math instruction because she comes to school late.
The evidence showed that the one low Numerical Operations subtest score was not corroborated by other assessment data, and in fact, was contradicted by other evidence, including other testing and STUDENT’s class performance. (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A).) No single score or product of scores can be used as the sole criterion in determining the existence of a severe discrepancy. (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4).) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year to the present, STUDENT was not eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability.
Other Health Impaired
As discussed earlier, OHI eligibility for special education can be established with a diagnosis of ADD or ADHD if the disorder adversely affects the pupil’s educational performance, the pupil otherwise meets the eligibility requirements of OHI, and because of the disability, the student requires instruction, services, or both, which cannot be met by modification of the regular school program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56339(a); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9); 5 C.C.R. § 3030(f).)
Petitioner contends that she continues to have limited strength, vitality and alertness, due to her long history of medical and attentional issues that adversely affect her educational performance pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code § 56339(a), 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9), and 5 C.C.R. § 3030(f). According to Petitioner, she meets the criteria for ADHD and has features suggestive of Generalized Anxiety Disorder. Consequently, she continues to be tired or lacks attention and focus in the classroom and in assessment environments. Petitioner contends that she takes medication nightly to address her sleeping issues; however, the medicine does not always work.
The District does not dispute that STUDENT has been diagnosed with ADHD; however, it contends that the ADHD diagnosis alone does not support a finding that special education is required to remedy any alleged poor performance. According to the District, Petitioner exhibits the ability to attend equivalent to that of her peers.
Petitioner argues that she has limited alertness because she continues to be tired or lack attention in the classroom. STUDENT testified that she sometimes has a hard time paying attention in class and does not always understand what to do. STUDENT also stated that she is often late to school, but does not really know why. According to STUDENT, she has a hard time going to sleep at night and sometimes it is easy for her to wake up in the morning and, at other times, it is not because she goes to bed late or can’t sleep. STUDENT stated that she takes medicine every night to help her sleep.
With respect to alertness, MOTHER testified that all of STUDENT’s teachers have consistently told her that STUDENT needs to be redirected everyday. According to MOTHER, even volunteers have expressed to her that when they are sitting with and helping STUDENT in the hallway, they have to help her refocus on her work. MOTHER also testified that STUDENT’s teachers have expressed to her that despite being redirected, STUDENT is unable to stay focused in the classroom. According to MOTHER, STUDENT’s therapist, Dr. Kuo, diagnosed STUDENT with ADHD. Although MOTHER testified that STUDENT also has a sleep disorder, an April 1998 evaluation at the UCSF-Stanford Health Care Sleep Disorders Clinic in San Francisco, California, concluded that STUDENT had normal distribution of sleep stages throughout the night. Currently, however, STUDENT takes medication for insomnia related to anxiety. (Pet.’s Exh. 17, pg. 4.)
Dr. Solomon testified that STUDENT qualifies for special education services under the category of OHI because at the time she conducted her evaluation in April 2004, STUDENT still had neurologically based difficulties manifested by inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity.
All of the District witnesses, including several teachers, testified that despite STUDENT’s diagnosis of ADHD, she has not exhibited signs of ADHD in the educational environment during the current school year that rise to the level of satisfying eligibility for special education as OHI. Dr. Mills testified that STUDENT’s diagnosis of ADHD did not necessarily mean that she met the eligibility criteria for special education. According to Dr. Mills, many children with ADD do not meet eligibility criteria because they can be accommodated within the general education classroom with strategies such as being provided extended time and redirection. The only clinically significant test score related to attention was MOTHER’s rating on the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC), which was included in Dr. Solomon’s June 1, 2004 assessment report. (Pet.’s Exh. 17, pg. 19.) Dr. Mills concluded that Petitioner did not meet OHI criteria because the only notable report of attention difficulties was at home and was contrary to testing or observations of teachers in the educational environment. Moreover, having observed STUDENT this school year in Mr. Reif’s class, Dr. Mills testified that she observed no distractibility with STUDENT. She observed STUDENT doing very well following directions and in a timely manner and saw no need for redirection. District speech pathologist Pamela Macy, who also observed STUDENT this year in Mr. Reif’s class, concurred with Dr. Mills’ findings that STUDENT showed no signs that attention was affecting her academic performance.
Other District witnesses, including Mr. Reif, STUDENT’s current science teacher Mr. Molinari, and Kristen DeAndreis, the administrative intern who provides STUDENT additional assistance with class projects, testified that STUDENT does not exhibit attentional problems in the educational environment that would satisfy eligibility for special education services. Mr. Reif testified that although STUDENT is inattentive at times in class, he is able to either signal STUDENT or redirect her to focus, and she complies. According to Mr. Reif, STUDENT understands his questions and is able to answer and do what is expected of her. Mr. Reif stated that at times, STUDENT has difficulty starting an assignment; however, once she is given directions she is able to get herself organized and started. Mr. Reif stated that at times STUDENT appears to be unfocused, but when he calls on her she is able to answer the question.
Regarding vitality, Mr. Molinari testified that STUDENT is very engaged in class and appears excited about science. She volunteers in class, enjoys conducting experiments, and understands the directions that he gives. According to Mr. Molinari STUDENT is no more inattentive than other students in the class; she follows multi-step directions, completes her assignments and has no difficulty turning in work on time. Occasionally, STUDENT appeared tired after lunch; however, Mr. Molinari testified that it did not concern him because other students are also tired after lunch and this has not interfered with STUDENT’s ability to access the curriculum.
Kristen DeAndreis testified that she discussed STUDENT with both Mr. Reif and Mr. Molinari because she provides STUDENT assistance on her written work, social studies, and sometimes math one to two times each week. According to Ms. DeAndreis, STUDENT has not appeared tired or withdrawn and she has noticed nothing that would lead her to believe that STUDENT requires resource services as a special education student, academic remedial instruction, or assistance with social skills or emotional issues. Ms. DeAndreis also testified that STUDENT is attentive, follows directions, and completes the work that she is assigned.
Reports from most of STUDENT’s teachers over the years consistently indicate that STUDENT could be doing better if she came to school on time and completed her assignments that are to be done at home. (Dist.’s Exhs. 37-40 and 49.) District assessors and Dr. Solomon testified that they did not observe STUDENT exhibiting attentional problems during testing. Speech pathologist Pamela Macy was the only assessor who noted that fatigue was observed as affecting STUDENT’s attention/listening; however, Ms. Macy testified that the fatigue/inattention only occurred during the last 20 minutes of a 65-minute testing session. (Dist.’s Exh. 26.)
In weighing the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers regarding her alertness and vitality in class. The teachers have an opportunity to observe STUDENT whenever she is present in class and are in the best position to comment on her attention in the educational environment. Additionally, the testimony of the teachers at the hearing is supported by comments of other teachers on progress reports, by assessors, and by the results of testing. Dr. Solomon did not observe STUDENT in the educational environment. Although MOTHER testified that she had observed STUDENT in class during previous school years and once this year, she did not indicate that she observed STUDENT being inattentive in class on those occasions. Moreover, MOTHER’s high rating of STUDENT on attentional factors was based on her observations of her at home and is not determinative as to her actual performance in the educational environment.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s diagnoses of ADHD or other medical conditions do not cause her to suffer from limited alertness or vitality in the educational environment to such a degree that she requires special education. Therefore, from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year to the present, STUDENT did not satisfy requirements for OHI eligibility. (Footnote 18)
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the June 1, 2004 independent assessment conducted by Theresita Solomon?
California Education Code Section 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. However, if the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. (Id.) Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the assessment conducted by Dr. Theresita Solomon.
MOTHER testified that she obtained Dr. Solomon’s independent evaluation because she disagreed with the District’s assessment and the District’s determination that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services. However, under Education Code Section 56329(b) and (c), the parent is entitled to reimbursement for an independent educational assessment only where it is shown at a due process hearing that the District’s assessment is not appropriate.
As to the specific concerns raised by Petitioner, the Hearing Officer found above that the District’s 2002 psychoeducational assessment, speech and language evaluation, and behavioral observation were appropriate and complied with the law. Specifically, the Hearing Officer found that the District assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and was at no time required to conduct additional testing. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the parent obtained the independent assessment because she disagreed with the appropriateness of the above assessments and not because the District failed to provide written notice of its refusal to reassess. Petitioner is therefore not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessment.
5. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education and services consisting of: A. 300 hours of one-to-one tutorial instruction in all core academic areas; B. 2 hours per week of one-to-one individual counseling to address anxiety disorder and socialization/relationship issues; and C. 2 hours per week of social skills group therapy?
Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11 Cir. 1991).) Because it was found above that STUDENT was not eligible for special education during any of the school years at issue, she was not entitled to special education and related services during that time. Accordingly, STUDENT also is not entitled to compensatory education services.
ORDER
All of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement.
1. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to identify and assess STUDENT’s exceptional needs; B. assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability; and C. identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
The District prevailed on this issue.
2. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to identify and assess STUDENT’s exceptional needs and B. identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
Petitioner prevailed on issue 2.A. to the limited extent that the District failed to provide the parent with written notice of its refusal to reassess and an explanation for that refusal. The District prevailed on issue 2.A. to the extent that it was not, pursuant to its child find obligations, required to conduct a reassessment in the 2003-2004 school year. The District prevailed on issue 2.B.
3. During the 2004-2005 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. convene an IEP meeting after its receipt of an independent evaluation from STUDENT’s parent; B. conduct auditory processing and occupational therapy assessments; and C. identify STUDENT’s as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
The District prevailed on this issue.
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the June 1, 2004 independent assessment conducted by Theresita Solomon?
The District prevailed on this issue.
5. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education and services consisting of: A. 300 hours of one-to-one tutorial instruction in all core academic areas; B. 2 hours per week of one-to-one individual counseling to address anxiety disorder and socialization/relationship issues; and C. 2 hours per week of social skills group therapy?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: February 26, 2005 ____________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
The Hearing Officer notes that this “summary report” is not on letterhead and is not signed by the apparent author, Erica Buhrmann, MD.
2 Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, 29 U.S.C. §§ 794, et seq., is designed to afford accommodations to pupils who have a physical or mental impairment which substantially limits a major life activity that may not qualify as a recognized category for special education services under the federal Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. §§ 1400 et seq.
3 It is also referred to as the “search and serve” obligation.
4 The District had sought to have documentation regarding said mediation submitted into evidence; however, Petitioner objected to admission of any documents relating to that confidential mediation and this Hearing Officer sustained the objection, excluding the documents from the record in the instant matter. According to the District’s closing argument, in the previous due process matter, SN02-00757, Petitioner also alleged that the District failed to identify her for special education services. (Dist.’s closing brief, pg. 12.)
5 Dr. Weiss testified that she reviewed a letter from Dr. Anlee D. Kuo, MD, the District’s January 1, 2002 psychoeducational evaluation report, and its 2002 speech and language evaluation and behavioral observation reports. Dr. Weiss also reviewed Dr. Theresita Solomon’s June 1, 2004 independent psychoeducational evaluation report.
6 Dr. Weiss testified that she has a Ph.D. in clinical psychology and that she been a California-licensed clinical psychologist since February 2002. Dr. Weiss stated that she completed two years of postdoctoral work in neuropsychology and currently works as a neuropsychologist and psychologist at the McCauley Institute, where she has been employed for the last ten years. Her current work includes providing individual therapy to children who have attempted suicide or homicide, conducting family meetings with social workers, and conducting follow-up treatment. Dr. Weiss also testified that she works as an independent contractor with the San Francisco Mental Health Department, Kaiser, and with juvenile hall in San Francisco.
7 Dr. Mills testified that she has two master’s degrees in education and counseling, two doctoral degrees in counseling psychology and clinical psychology, California credentials in administrative services, teaching, counseling, and school psychology, and a certificate in neuropsychological assessment. For the past five years, she has overseen psychological services and all special education assessments in the District and conducted approximately 200 assessments each year. She previously served as the lead psychologist in the District and currently has a private clinical psychology practice in which she specializes in adolescents. (See Dist.’s Exh. 48.)
8 Ms. Macy testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in speech pathology and audiology, master’s degrees in speech pathology and education, an administrative credential, and an American Speech and Hearing certificate of clinical competence. She is a licensed speech pathologist in the State of California and has worked in the educational setting for over 15 years and been practicing for 20 years. Ms. Macy testified that she currently is the head speech pathologist for the District and supervises a staff of speech pathologists in the assessment and identification of children and adults with communication disorders.
9 The Sentence Imitation subtest was also administered during the last 20 minutes of the testing session, but STUDENT scored above age level expectancy on it. Ms. Macy explained that STUDENT likely performed better on this subtest during the last 20 minutes because, unlike the Grammatic Understanding subtest, it has no visual stimulus and does not require the examinee to look at anything in order to complete the task.
10 A student whose educational performance is adversely affected by a suspected or diagnosed attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting eligibility criteria for the category of OHI is entitled to special education and related services. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56339(a).)
11 Private clinical psychologist, Dr. Theresita Solomon, who was hired by STUDENT’s parent to conduct an independent psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT in April 2004, also testified that she saw no reason to administer the Rorschach or TAT as part of her assessment, because there was no evidence of STUDENT having thought disturbances in class and no evidence of severe behavior or emotional problems. According to Dr. Solomon, these tests are typically used with children who have severe emotional problems and STUDENT did not fall into that category.
12 Ms. Meneely testified that she has two master’s degrees in counseling and in special education. She has learning handicapped and severely handicapped credentials, and a pupil personnel services credential for psychology and school counseling. Ms. Meneely also stated that she is a licensed education psychologist and is credentialed to teach kindergarten through twelfth grade in a self-contained classroom. She is currently employed as a school psychologist for the District and, in that capacity, she has conducted more than 700 assessments in all psychological areas.
13 Although STUDENT took the California Standards Test in the spring of 2003 and scored “below basic” in math, the scores were scaled and not converted into common standard scores. (Pet.’s Exh. 19.)
14 This cognitive score was consistent with STUDENT’s Stanford-Binet composite cognitive score of 111 reported by Dr. Peters in 1999. (Dist.’s Exh. 32.)
15 According to principal Mary Richard, many of the accommodations provided to STUDENT in Ms. Poon’s classroom were the result of a mediation between the parties. (Dist.’s Exh. 16.)
16 The Hearing Officer notes that the requirement that the IEP team meet at least annually refers to reviewing the progress and the IEP of students already determined to be eligible for special education services. 17 Dr. Solomon testified that she did not list STUDENT’s WISC-IV scores on the version of her report provided to the District because it was her understanding that the District did not accept intelligence test information for African American students per the Larry P. v. Riles (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489) case.
18 This finding negates the need to reach the questions of whether limited alertness or vitality is due to chronic or acute health problems and adversely affects STUDENT’s educational performance.
