California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 8, 1998

Student v. Capistrano Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 305-97 · Hearing Officer Kathleen Peterson

CCS must reimburse part of 1997 private OT and Capistrano Unified must pay mileage; most other claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 6 of 22 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision describes prior SEHO matters between these parties: SN 462-94 (withdrawn October 27, 1994); SN 493-94 (District prevailed on assessing without consent, August 17, 1994); SN 1016-94 (withdrawn by the District); and SN 1096-94 (resolved in mediation January 11, 1995). It records no later history for this case.

Summary

The parents of a nine-year-old boy filed against Capistrano Unified School District and California Children's Services (CCS) over his occupational therapy (OT). Under a mediation agreement, he was eligible under other health impairment. He attended Prentice Day School, a nonpublic school, at District expense. He received OT for oral-motor, feeding and sensory-motor needs from CCS and from Irvine Therapy Services (ITS) under a District contract. The Hearing Officer applied a three-year statute of limitations, which barred claims before March 18, 1994. The rest of 1993-94 and all of 1994-95 were not reached. For 1995-96, the District never had ITS do the six-month reevaluation the IEP required. That left the student with consultation only when he still needed direct therapy. CCS cut its direct therapy to monthly consultation without telling the District, so no IEP meeting was held. Both agencies denied FAPE. For 1996-97, CCS stopped services without written notice when its therapist resigned, and the District held no IEP meeting. Services were otherwise appropriate. The Hearing Officer found ITS and CCS, not SKY Pediatric Therapy Services, to be the appropriate providers. CCS must reimburse SKY therapy costs from February 28, 1997 through the end of the 1996-97 school year and extended school year. The District must reimburse mileage for that period. The parents' claim for SKY in place of ITS was denied. So was their claim for transportation to Prentice, which they had waived in signed agreements.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated California Children's Services as a party bound by the IEP when its therapy was both medically and educationally necessary. CCS could set its own treatment goals. But it could not reduce or pause IEP services without notice that let the IEP team act. Reimbursement was also cut back on equitable grounds.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue I (1993-94). Regarding the provision of OT, did the Respondents provide a FAPE during the 1993-94 school year?

    Claims before March 18, 1994 were barred by the three-year limitations period; the rest of 1993-94 was not considered because no remedy was sought for it and an earlier hearing request had been withdrawn. No ruling on the merits.

  2. Issue I (1994-95). Regarding the provision of OT, did the Respondents provide a FAPE during the 1994-95 school year?

    Not considered: no remedy was sought for the year, and the earlier hearing request (SN 1096-94) was resolved by a January 1995 mediation agreement.

  3. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue I.A.3.a (1995-96). Did the District fail to give serious consideration to reports from the student's physicians?

    No evidence the District failed to consider the physicians' reports; the extensive OT agreed to suggests it did consider them.

  4. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue I.A.3.b (1995-96). Did the District fail to ensure IEP team decisions were based on information from a variety of sources, including parent-initiated evaluations?

    Asking to do its own assessment did not mean the District ignored independent information; no violation.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue I.A.3.c (1995-96). Did the District fail to ensure the participation of the student's OTRs from ITS and CCS at IEP meetings?

    Related-service providers were not required IEP team members under 34 C.F.R. § 300.344, even if parents asked for them; no violation.

  6. Student prevailed in partImplementation

    Issue I.A.3.d (1995-96). Did the District fail to ensure the monthly ITS OT consult and six-month reevaluation required by the May 22, 1995 IEP?

    Delays in the home program and consultation were partly caused by the parents and not charged to the District. However, the District's failure to obtain the required six-month reevaluation (also requested by CCS in December 1995) caused a lost educational opportunity and denied FAPE.

  7. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue I.A.3.e (1995-96). Did the District fail to give written notice that it would propose to change placement and transportation at the June 19, 1995 IEP meeting?

    Written notice rules do not require advance notice of what will be proposed at an IEP meeting; the IEP document served as notice.

  8. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue I.A.3.f (1995-96). Did the District fail to convene an IEP meeting with Dr. Huynen and CCS by July 14, 1995?

    A meeting held six days late without non-required personnel was not a violation that denied FAPE; there was no educational loss or harm to parent participation.

  9. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue I.A.3.g (1995-96). Did the District and CCS fail to provide appropriately trained personnel when the CCS therapist transferred in August 1995?

    The replacement CCS therapist had been trained in the Beckman technique by her predecessor and was appropriately trained; no violation by CCS.

  10. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue I.A.3.h (1995-96). Did CCS fail to develop goals and objectives with input from the parents, behavior therapist, ITS, or the IEP team?

    CCS's internal medical treatment goals were outside the IEP process and not subject to IEP team input requirements.

  11. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue I.A.3.i (1995-96). Did CCS fail to obtain written parental consent before testing progress toward goals?

    CCS's six-month treatment reevaluations were not IEP assessments, and the parents' annual service agreement gave consent; no violation.

  12. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue I.A.3.j (1995-96). Did CCS reduce OT services in January 1996 without an IEP team meeting?

    CCS is bound by the IEP when its therapy is also an IEP service. By cutting direct OT to monthly consultation without telling the District so the IEP team could meet, CCS caused about six months of lost OT and denied FAPE.

  13. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue I.A.4.a (1996-97). Did CCS fail to give notice of its therapist's resignation and the resulting interruption of services?

    Even a temporary halt in services triggered written notice. CCS gave no notice and did not inform the District, and the student missed OT, which denied FAPE.

  14. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue I.A.4.b (1996-97). Did the District fail to immediately convene an IEP meeting when it learned of the CCS staffing problem?

    The District knew of the staffing problem by January 13, 1997 and held no IEP meeting after June 19, 1996. The summary and conclusion find this denied FAPE, although one sentence in the analysis says the opposite.

  15. Not reachedIEP procedure

    Issue I.A.4.c (1996-97). Did the District fail to give written notice that it refused to fund the parents' chosen provider (SKY)?

    Not decided in detail because FAPE denial was already found; the Hearing Officer noted the District should have given written notice of its refusal to fund SKY.

  16. District prevailedRecords

    Issue I.A.4.d (1996-97). Did the District (through ITS) and CCS fail to adequately provide records?

    No evidence that any alleged records problem caused educational loss or impaired parent participation.

  17. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue I.B.1 (1995-96 substantive). Were the OT services in 1995-96 designed to meet unique needs, did they provide benefit, and did they conform to the IEP?

    The District's consultation-only ITS services did not meet the student's sensory-motor needs, gave no more than minimal benefit, and did not follow the IEP. CCS services met needs and gave benefit but did not follow the IEP. Both denied FAPE.

  18. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue I.B.2 (1996-97 substantive). Were the OT services in 1996-97 designed to meet unique needs, did they provide benefit, and did they conform to the IEP?

    ITS and CCS direct therapy met the student's needs, provided benefit, and followed the IEP; it was substantively appropriate.

  19. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue II. Currently, which agency is the appropriate OT provider for the student?

    ITS is the appropriate provider of educationally necessary OT and CCS of medically necessary OT. The request to designate SKY was denied; CCS may choose its own methodology.

  20. Issue III.A. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for OT provided by SKY Pediatric Therapy Services during 1997, including transportation to and from SKY?

    SKY services were appropriate. On equitable grounds, reimbursement was limited to OT replacing CCS services from February 28, 1997 through the end of the 1996-97 school year and ESY, plus mileage. Reimbursement for SKY replacing ITS was denied because the parents left an appropriate provider.

  21. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue III.B. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for transportation to and from Prentice Day School during the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years?

    The parents signed IEP agreements giving up transportation in exchange for District funding of Prentice; there was no basis to set those agreements aside.

  22. Dismissed / withdrawnFAPE: services offered

    Issue IV. Mileage rate to be used for parent reimbursement of transportation

    Resolved by the parties off the record during the hearing and not addressed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receiving receipts, CCS must reimburse the parents for SKY Pediatric Services costs of medically necessary OT from February 28, 1997 through the end of the 1996-97 school year, including extended school year services. Dollar amount not specified.
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receiving mileage documentation, the District must reimburse the parents for transportation to SKY from February 28, 1997 through the end of the 1996-97 school year (including extended school year), at the rate for parental transportation reimbursement.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District; Wilson v. Garcia; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Zvi D. v. Ambach; M.C. v. Central Regional School District; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16; Landgraf v. USI Film Products; Cal. Gov. Code § 7575; Cal. Gov. Code § 7586(c)

People named in the decision

  • Doreen Lohnes, District executive director of special education, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Robert White, SELPA director, South Orange County SELPA
  • Dwight Nelsen, counsel for CCS, California Department of Health Services
  • Cathy Babiak, chief therapist, Orange County California Children's Services
  • Denise Yota, CCS occupational therapist, California Children's Services
  • Carol Holtzman, CCS physical therapist, California Children's Services
  • Marti Hawkins-Gammon, CCS occupational therapist, Orange County California Children's Services
  • Lori Griffin, CCS occupational therapist / therapy consultant, Orange County California Children's Services
  • Carla Odwald, supervising therapist, Reilly Medical Therapy Unit, Orange County CCS
  • Kim B. Huynen, clinical psychologist / behaviorist, witness for Student, Behavior Change Associates
  • John Lutzker, behaviorist, Behavior Change Associates
  • Bethzaida (Betsy) Figueroa, private occupational therapist, SKY Pediatric Therapy Services
  • Nancy L. Press, pediatric occupational therapist, witness for Student
  • Betty Romero, occupational therapist, former owner, Irvine Therapy Services
  • Priya Mohan, occupational therapist, current owner and clinical director, Irvine Therapy Services
  • Julie Turner, occupational therapist, Irvine Therapy Services
  • Susan Perrine, occupational therapist, District assessor, Saddleback Pediatric Therapy Services
  • Michael Weiss, student's pediatrician
  • Ira Lott, director of child neurology, treating physician, University of California, Irvine
  • Corinne Parker, legal assistant for Student
  • Prentice Day School, nonpublic school
  • Irvine Therapy Services, private OT agency (District contractor)
  • SKY Pediatric Therapy Services, private OT provider
  • Behavior Change Associates, behavior consultation agency

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Kathleen Peterson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Juan Capistrano, California, on July 23, 24, and 25, September 25 and 26, October 24, and November 7, 1997.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Joan K. Honeycutt. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his mother, Ms. PARENT, and (for portions of days) his father, Mr. PARENT. Legal assistant Corinne Parker was also present on STUDENT’s behalf.

Respondent Capistrano Unified School District (hereafter District) was represented at the hearing by educational consultant G. Robert Roice. Also present on the District’s behalf were Doreen Lohnes, District executive director of special education, and Robert White, director of the South Orange County SELPA.

Respondent California Children’s Services (hereafter CCS) was represented at the hearing by attorney Dwight Nelsen, senior counsel for the California Department of Health Services. Also present on CCS’s behalf was Cathy Babiak, chief therapist for Orange County CCS.

The following seven witnesses were called by the Petitioner to testify: Denise Yota, CCS occupational therapist; Ms. Lohnes; Kim B. Huynen, clinical psychologist; Bethzaida (Betsy) Figueroa, Sky occupational therapist; Nancy L. Press, pediatric occupational therapist; Mrs. PARENT; and Mr. PARENT.

The following four witnesses were called by the District to testify: Betty Romero, occupational therapist and former owner of Irvine Therapy Services (ITS); Ms. Lohnes; Priya Mohan, current ITS owner and clinical director; and Julie Turner, ITS occupational therapist.

The following four witnesses were called by CCS to testify: Martha (Marti) Hawkins-Gammon, Orange County CCS occupational therapist; Lori Griffin, Orange County CCS occupational therapist; Carla Odwald, supervising therapist at the Reilly Medical Therapy Unit (MTU) for Orange County CCS; and Ms. Babiak.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. The Hearing Office received the closing arguments, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the beginning of the hearing, CCS moved to be dismissed as a party to this matter, based on its contention that CCS has not denied any services to STUDENT and has authorized maximum benefits for him. Special education due process hearing requests that involve multiple services by more than one state department are to be heard in one hearing with all the responsible state and local agencies joined as parties. (California Government Code § 7586(c).) The Hearing Officer denied the motion and found that CCS was a proper party to this hearing because the issues presented by the Petitioner included reimbursement regarding occupational therapy (OT) provided by CCS.

Before testimony began, the Petitioner indicated that the parties were in the process of resolving one of the issues originally submitted concerning the mileage rate to be used for parent reimbursement of transportation. (See “Issue IV” in the Petitioner’s last notice of issues statement.) During the course of the hearing, the mileage rate issue was resolved off the record and the parties did not present evidence regarding that issue; therefore, it will not be addressed in this decision. The remaining issues were clarified during discussions on the record. The issues stated below are those the Hearing Officer determined are appropriate for adjudication.

ISSUES

I. Regarding the provision of occupational therapy (OT), did the Respondents provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for STUDENT during the 1993-94, 1994-95, 1995-96, and 1996-97 school years?

II. Currently, which agency is the appropriate OT provider for STUDENT?

III. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following: A. The costs associated with the OT being provided by SKY Pediatric Therapy Services (SKY) to STUDENT during 1997, including transportation to and from SKY; and B. Transportation to and from Prentice Day School for STUDENT during the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a boy who turned ten years old in February 1998, and who is eligible for special education services under the category “other health impairment” (OHI) as the result of a mediation agreement. STUDENT had serious medical problems as an infant, including feeding problems and a diagnosis of “failure to thrive” syndrome.

There is a history of disputes between STUDENT’s parents, the District, and CCS. STUDENT’s parents first requested an assessment and services from the District in November 1990, when STUDENT was two years old. In December 1990 and January 1991, the District assessed STUDENT. The District’s speech and language pathologist concluded that STUDENT was experiencing expressive language and articulation delays of four to seven months, but indicated that his receptive language and auditory comprehension abilities were in the average range and there was no overt evidence of an oral-motor dysfunction, even though STUDENT’s private OT indicated that he had a slight oral-motor dysfunction. (Dist. Exh. 11, at pp. 1-4.(Footnote 1)) The District’s school psychologist concluded that STUDENT’s social-emotional skills were scattered between the 27-month to 33-month levels; that self-care areas (eating, dressing, and toileting) were the lowest scoring areas, according to parent reports; and that, at this point, STUDENT’s mother and feeding therapist reported that his feeding difficulties were primarily behavioral. (Dist. Exh. 11, at pp. 5-8.) In January 1991, just before STUDENT’s third birthday, the District found him ineligible for special education services.

In February 1993, when STUDENT turned five years old, his mother asked the District for help because his teacher was concerned that he was not staying focused on tasks and his time spent at snack time was interfering with his class time. The District’s school psychologist called a Student Study Team meeting, but concluded that STUDENT did not require another assessment.

In September and November 1993, STUDENT’s pediatrician, Dr. Michael Weiss, noted that he felt that therapy was necessary to deal with STUDENT’s oral and gross motor deficits, vestibular difficulties, intestinal motility and feeding problems, and resulting slow weight gain. By November 1993, STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher at his private school suggested that his parents request another District assessment. She was concerned about STUDENT’s sensory defensiveness and lack of maturation. The same month, 1993, Dr. Ira Lott, director of child neurology at the University of California at Irvine, noted that he had made a diagnosis of “probable” mitochondrial myopathy for STUDENT and recommended both physical therapy (PT) and OT for him.(Footnote 2) On November 12, 1993, STUDENT’s parents requested that the District assess STUDENT in all areas, including sensory motor and feeding areas. On January 23, 1994, STUDENT’s parents also requested that CCS assess STUDENT to determine his eligibility for medically necessary OT and/or PT services.

In February and March 1994, the District assessed STUDENT again. (Dist. Exh. 10.) The District’s speech and language therapist concluded that STUDENT scored within the average to above average ranges on the tests and noted that he had a high, narrow, hard palate and an overbite, but that his tongue thrust swallow did not hinder his speech. The District’s school psychologist concluded that STUDENT had high average intelligence and average or above average visual perception and visual-motor integration skills, but that there were conflicting accounts of his behavior in the areas of distractibility/attention, feeding, and frustration. The District’s adapted physical education (APE) and orthopedic impairment (OI) specialists concluded that STUDENT was functioning within age expectancy for both fine and gross motor skills.

In March 1994, Dr. Lott, U.C. Irvine director of child neurology, informed the District that his diagnosis of STUDENT now included dysautonomia, extreme stimulus sensitivity, and a feeding disorder.(Footnote 3) Dr. Lott indicated in his letter to the District that occupational and physical therapy were medically necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education.

On March 9, 1994, the District convened an individualized education program (IEP) team meeting and again found STUDENT ineligible for special education services. Later that month, STUDENT’s parents obtained a private assessment from Irvine Therapy Services (ITS). On March 22, 1994, Betty Romero (then the owner of ITS) conducted the assessment and found that STUDENT exhibited significant sensory-motor dysfunction involving the vestibular, tactile, oral motor, visual-motor, auditory processing, motor coordination, and motor planning systems. Ms. Romero recommended that STUDENT receive therapy twice weekly to remediate his sensory processing and motor deficits, to facilitate the acquisition of normal food movement patterns and functional skills, and to reduce the risk of injury that could result from swallowing problems.

On March 27, 29, and 30, 1994, the District’s school psychologist conducted additional testing of STUDENT, including assessments of STUDENT’s behavior and adaptive behavior, pursuant to a request by the PARENTs. The psychologist concluded that there continued to be conflicting accounts of STUDENT’s behavior and recommended a review of the assistance that had been provided to the PARENTs, as well as a behavioral program with well spelled-out consequences.

By May 1994, CCS had completed its own assessment of STUDENT’s OT needs. In a report dated May 4, 1994, Denise Yota, CCS OT, and Carol Holtzman, CCS PT, found that STUDENT showed dysfunction in the areas of vestibular, tactile, and proprioceptive processing, which impacted his fine motor and academic functioning. However, CCS concluded that no medically necessary therapy (OT or PT) was indicated because STUDENT’s areas of dysfunction were not neurologically or orthopedically based, nor did the areas of deficit appear to be related to muscle weakness.

On May 16, 1994, the District convened another IEP team meeting for STUDENT and the team considered the results of both the ITS and CCS assessments. At the meeting, District staff indicated that another OT assessment of STUDENT was needed, as well as an auditory processing assessment. STUDENT’s parents consented to the District’s assessment plan; however, after the IEP team meeting, they withdrew their consent for the assessment. On May 27, 1994, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from attorney Joan Honeycutt on STUDENT’s behalf (SN 462-94). On June 6, 1994, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from the District regarding whether the District could conduct the OT assessment of STUDENT without his parents’ consent (SN 493-94). By agreement of the parties, the District’s hearing on assessment was conducted prior to the parents’ hearing on eligibility. (Order, STUDENT v. Capistrano Unified School District and California Children’s Services, SN 462-94, p. 1 [October 3, 1994].(Footnote 4)) When the District’s hearing convened on August 4, 1994, no one appeared on STUDENT’s behalf, and the District prevailed on the issue of its right to do the OT assessment of STUDENT over his parents’ withdrawal of consent. (Decision, Capistrano Unified School District v. STUDENT, SN 493-94, pp. 1, 7 [August 17, 1994].)

On July 11, 1994, CCS issued a revised version of its evaluation report dated May 4, 1994. In this version, Ms. Yota found a CCS-eligible condition and changed her recommendation for STUDENT to include consultation services, quarterly checks, and a home/classroom program.

On July 13, 1994, ITS began providing OT to STUDENT in twice weekly sessions, paid for privately. On August 11, 1994, ITS owner Betty Romero prepared an OT progress report for STUDENT. Ms. Romero stated that after eight treatments, STUDENT was responding well to the treatment and showed early signs of improvement, including increased tolerance for sensory input and decreased muscle fatigue. However, Ms. Romero stated that STUDENT required OT for six more months to treat his sensory-motor deficits and work toward his continued treatment goals.

On September 26, 1994, Priya Mohan, ITS therapist, prepared an ITS OT progress report regarding STUDENT. Ms. Mohan said that STUDENT had been responding well to the twice weekly therapy program, working toward achieving the goals set out by Ms. Romero. Ms. Mohan said that STUDENT had made significant progress in his ability to calm himself and organize his behavior, and that he had evidenced increased tolerance for sensory input, improved motor coordination, decreased muscle fatigue, and increased visual-motor control. However, Ms. Mohan noted that STUDENT had difficulty with utensils and that he needed to work on preliminary hand control before he could become proficient at using a utensil. For these reasons, Ms. Mohan recommended that STUDENT finger-feed himself, which would also alleviate some of the mealtime stress for him. Ms. Mohan stated that STUDENT required therapy for six more months to address his needs and work toward his continued treatment goals.

On October 14, 1994, Ms. Yota completed an “Oral Motor Evaluation Worksheet” regarding STUDENT’s oral motor functioning as part of the quarterly checks by CCS. Ms. Yota found that STUDENT had low tone in his lips, minimal to no movement in his tongue in response to pressure, and low tone and decreased strength in his cheeks. She also found that he was not chewing consecutively enough times to swallow food without difficulty, he was chewing at the front of his mouth and using his fingers to push food to the back of his mouth, and he used an immature grip on utensils and brought his head down to the utensil instead of lifting it to his mouth. Ms. Yota concluded that STUDENT’s muscle tone was low and that his muscles appeared weak. She arranged for STUDENT to begin receiving direct therapy services twice a week, for thirty minute sessions, with the first session scheduled for October 28, 1994.

On October 21, 1994, the Hearing Office received a new request for a due process hearing from the District regarding STUDENT (SN 1016-94). On October 27, 1994, the Petitioner withdrew his case against the District and CCS in case number SN 462-94.

On October 31, 1994, Dr. Ira Lott signed a prescription for twice-weekly OT to allow CCS to treat STUDENT. On November 7, 1994, Ms. Yota began treating STUDENT at the Reilly MTU.

On November 28, 1994, Susan Perrine, OTR from Saddleback Pediatric Therapy Services conducted an assessment for the District. Ms. Perrine recommended that STUDENT receive a consultation by an OTR and said that an OTR with sensory integration expertise could prescribe a “sensory diet,” but she did not recommend any direct OT therapy services for him. On November 30, 1994, the District withdrew its case against STUDENT in case number SN 1016-94. On December 9, 1994, the Hearing Office received a new request for a due process hearing from Ms. Honeycutt on behalf of STUDENT against the District (SN 1096-94). On January 11, 1995, the District and STUDENT’s parents participated in mediation associated with case number SN 1096-94. As a result of this mediation, STUDENT’s special education eligibility was agreed to by his parents and the District, and case number SN 1096-94 was closed because the issues presented for hearing in that matter had been resolved by agreement of the parties.

On February 8, 1995, Ms. Mohan prepared an ITS OT progress report regarding STUDENT. Ms. Mohan found that it was too soon to readminister a test that had recently been given to STUDENT by the District (the Sensory Integration and Praxis Test, or SIPT). However, Ms. Mohan noted through other testing that STUDENT had made significant gains in therapy, including beginning to seek out vestibular information (seeking better modulation of the information), improving his balance, equilibrium, postural stability, motor planning, and organizing his behavior. Ms. Mohan continued his generalized treatment goals and recommended that he continue receiving ITS therapy for another six months because STUDENT continued to evidence areas of deficit.

On February 10, 1995, the District convened an IEP team meeting for STUDENT, and the team memorialized their mediation agreement resulting from the resolution of case number SN 1096-94 regarding STUDENT’s eligibility in an IEP. (Pet. Exh. 109.(Footnote 5)) The team agreed that STUDENT required OT to benefit from his education and that he was to receive medically necessary OT from CCS twice a week in thirty-minute sessions and educationally necessary OT from ITS (in the place of the District) twice a week in fifty-minute sessions until June 1995. The team also agreed (pursuant to their mediation agreement) that the District would fund STUDENT’s placement at the nonpublic school he was attending at this time, Prentice Day School.

On April 27, 1995, Ms. Yota completed another CCS Oral Motor Evaluation Worksheet regarding STUDENT. Ms. Yota found that STUDENT was able to activate his lips functionally for eating. Ms. Yota also found that STUDENT still had low tone in his cheeks, although he could activate these muscles in response to pressure and he had a significant increase in his ability to chew consecutively, with rotary chewing emerging. Ms. Yota concluded that STUDENT had achieved more than 50% of his goals (three out of four), with progress toward the fourth goal, and that his lip, cheek, tongue, and jaw strength had improved. Ms. Yota noted that self-feeding would not be a focus in treatment because STUDENT’s refusal/inability to feed himself did not appear to be a strength or fine motor issue, but may be a behavioral one. Ms. Yota created new goals for STUDENT, including increasing his ability to chew and swallow soft foods and to take appropriately-sized bites of food, which continued to be problematic. She recommended that STUDENT continue to receive OT from CCS twice a week through October 1995 to work on those goals.

On May 15, 1995, Ms. Mohan prepared another ITS OT progress report regarding STUDENT. Ms. Mohan administered the SIPT to gauge STUDENT’s progress in sensory integration and found that the test results and clinical observations suggested that his vestibular functioning had increased to a fairly average level. Ms. Mohan found that both motor coordination and motor planning were now within normal limits for STUDENT. Ms. Mohan noted that STUDENT’s mother reported that he used poor handwriting, although Ms. Mohan observed that he had dexterity with the hand he chooses for an activity, and that his handwriting would continue to improve with practice. Ms. Mohan also noted that STUDENT did not show signs of tactile defensiveness any longer, and that his test results supported this finding. However, Ms. Mohan stated that STUDENT’s parents continued to report that STUDENT avoided using utensils for feeding outside the clinic. Ms. Mohan said that because STUDENT had been able to use a spoon in the clinic, his difficulties with utensils were not related to any motor component problem, and that he needed to consistently work on using utensils during mealtime. Ms. Mohan noted that mealtimes were perceived as negative by STUDENT (as they had for years) and that behavioral intervention was indicated. Ms. Mohan found that for all these reasons, and because CCS was addressing oral motor issues, direct OT twice a week from ITS was no longer required for STUDENT. Ms. Mohan recommended that STUDENT receive OT consultations at his home during mealtimes to help him develop the ability to use utensils appropriately, and that he be reevaluated in six to eight months.

On May 22, 1995, the IEP team met again and agreed that the District would continue to fund STUDENT’s placement at Prentice and added extended school year services and transportation to Prentice. The team also noted that beginning on June 1, 1995, STUDENT’s ITS services would change to OT consultation services for one hour per month, with a reevaluation in six months. No one from either ITS or CCS was present at this meeting. On May 31, 1995, pursuant to the parties’ agreement, the IEP team convened by telephone and agreed to have STUDENT receive eight hours per month of behavior consultative services to address utensil use.

On June 19, 1995, the IEP team met again and reviewed goals and objectives proposed by Prentice for STUDENT. STUDENT’s father was present at the meeting. The District indicated that the transportation to and from Prentice was prohibitively expensive and that the District would continue to fund the placement at Prentice only if STUDENT’s parents would provide transportation. The team did not reach agreement during this meeting regarding the placement/transportation issue. On June 26, 1995, STUDENT’s attorney, Joan Honeycutt, suggested that STUDENT’s parents join a car pool to reduce the amount they would be reimbursed for transportation, in response to the District’s stance on the placement/transportation issue. The District rejected this suggestion, and on July 20, 1995, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT signed an IEP addendum stating that from August 1995 through June 1996, they would provide STUDENT’s transportation to Prentice and that the District would continue to fund his placement there.

On August 17, 1995, ITS OTR Priya Mohan sent to STUDENT’s parents a list of activities (dated June 12, 1995) for STUDENT’s use at home. Later in August 1995, CCS OTRs Denise Yota and Marti Gammon-Hawkins (then Gammon) consulted with STUDENT’s behaviorist from Behavior Change Associates (BCA), Dr. Kim Huynen. (Ms. Gammon was taking over as STUDENT’s therapist because Ms. Yota was transferring to a different CCS MTU.) The behavioral recommendations included focusing on fun activities (instead of the “negative” oral motor goal), allowing STUDENT to choose activities, negotiating to gain his cooperation, and structuring activities to allow him to be successful.

On September 12, 1995, Betty Romero began providing “home consultation services” to STUDENT, either meeting him at his home, her home, or the clinic, for an hour or two each month.

Beginning on October 31, 1995, Ms. Gammon completed a CCS OT reevaluation of STUDENT. On November 20, 1995 (before testing was completed for this reevaluation), Ms. Gammon met STUDENT and members of his family at a restaurant in order to observe him outside the clinic. STUDENT exhibited difficulties with using his utensils and Ms. Gammon stepped in to show him how to use them. STUDENT reacted negatively to Ms. Gammon’s actions. In Ms. Gammon’s report of the reevaluation, dated December 12, 1995, she found that STUDENT had met the goals set in his last evaluation, he had been cooperative in therapy, and his home oral motor program remained appropriate. Ms. Gammon found that STUDENT’s fine motor and perceptual skills were at normal or above age level, but that STUDENT continued to display difficulty handling utensils in daily living situations that include distractions (e.g., restaurants, home). Ms. Gammon noted the restaurant incident and stated that attempts to resolve the tension between her and STUDENT had been unsuccessful, even with help from his behaviorist. Ms. Gammon concluded that the difficulties with using utensils in daily living situations appeared to be more related to sensory/motor planning problems, rather than muscle weakness problems, taking them outside the scope of CCS, and she recommended further OT assessment of these areas by an outside consultant. Ms. Gammon created new goals for STUDENT (maintaining/increasing oral musculature and oral motor coordination), and recommended that he cease receiving direct OT and begin a program of once-a-month consultations for the next year.

On June 1, 1996, BCA behaviorists Dr. Huynen and Dr. John Lutzker completed a progress report regarding STUDENT. Drs. Huynen and Lutzker suggested several IEP goals for STUDENT to address noted deficits in utensil use, resistiveness during meals, the need for prompting during meals, and to decrease the overall amount of time he spent at meals, while increasing what he ate. The behaviorists noted that STUDENT was observed in class to be highly distractible and that he continued to display noncompliant behavior and tantrums at home weekly. Drs. Huynen and Lutzker recommended the following: a referral to the Child Development Center at U.C. Irvine to determine whether medication might reduce some of his challenging behavior and increase his appetite; behavior consultation by BCA for six hours a month, until STUDENT goes to the U.C. Irvine program; and continuing his structured school setting at Prentice.

On June 12, 1996, Ms. Gammon completed another reevaluation of STUDENT. She noted that STUDENT had been seen on a monthly “check” basis for the last six months. Ms. Gammon found that STUDENT could benefit from services during the summer break, including direct therapy for two to three times a week (depending on his parents’ schedule) and a home program, because his oral musculature remained weak. Ms. Gammon created new goals for STUDENT, including improving strength for adequate chewing.

On June 17, 1996, Ms. Romero prepared an ITS OT progress report. Ms. Romero noted that the District had contracted with ITS to provide thirteen hours of consultative services to STUDENT from September 1, 1995, through September 30, 1996. (Pet. Exh. 102, at p. 38.) During the approximately nine hours of services STUDENT had received from ITS as of the date of the report, Ms. Romero had observed him at his own home, her home, and the clinic. From her observation, Ms. Romero found that it appeared that STUDENT’s difficulties using utensils may be more related to physiological factors than behavioral issues. Ms. Romero noted that STUDENT performed better at the beginning of meals, before he became fatigued or lost concentration, and that his fatigue was probably related to weakness in jaw stability, low muscle tone in his cheeks and tongue, and dysrhythmia in his respiratory patterns required to consecutively breathe and swallow and to control his posture. Ms. Romero also noted that STUDENT’s handwriting had improved with practice, but that he still exhibited weakness in his hands. Ms. Romero concluded that STUDENT should resume clinical OT with ITS because he continued to display deficits in self-feeding and utensil use, he had not responded adequately to consultative services alone, and he had a history of responding well to clinical OT intervention.

On June 19, 1996, the IEP team convened by telephone. The team agreed to have the District continue to fund STUDENT’s placement at Prentice conditioned upon his parents providing transportation to Prentice and waiving travel reimbursement, except for transportation to OT (which would continue to be reimbursable). The team also agreed that STUDENT required OT from CCS three times a week through September 1996, and that he required OT from ITS two times a week through February 1997, to be provided either at school or at home, including eight sessions over the summer.

On September 9, 1996, Ms. Gammon completed an Oral Motor Evaluation Worksheet regarding STUDENT, and found that he had improved his chewing strength, but that he still had strength problems involving his cheek, jaw, and lip strength on the right side, and that he continued to require therapy to address these deficits. Ms. Gammon created new goals, including increasing right jaw, right cheek, and right lip strength to allow STUDENT to chew safely. Ms. Gammon recommended OT direct therapy twice a week. The prescription for this therapy was to last until May 30, 1997.

By letter dated December 11, 1996, Carla Odwald, supervising therapist at Reilly MTU, informed STUDENT’s parents that his current occupational therapist, Ms. Gammon, was resigning. Ms. Odwald indicated in her letter that she hoped to fill Ms. Gammon’s position by March 1997. STUDENT’s last OT session at CCS was on December 24, 1996.

STUDENT’s parents wanted to continue with therapy and asked CCS staff about vendoring the therapy through SKY. On December 30, 1996, CCS staff invited SKY occupational therapist Betsy Figueroa to apply for paneling status, because CCS requires vendors to be “CCS-paneled,” and no one at SKY was paneled. Ms. Figueroa did not qualify for CCS paneling. On January 20, 1997, STUDENT’s attorney informed the District that STUDENT’s parents would immediately initiate services at SKY and that the PARENTs expected to be reimbursed by the District for these services. On January 21, 1997, Ms. Lohnes informed Ms. Babiak at CCS that the District would contract for STUDENT’s therapy services at SKY, and that the District was formally requesting CCS to either fund those services directly, reimburse STUDENT’s parents, or reimburse the District. On January 23, 1997, CCS therapist Lori Griffin stated that CCS was unable to authorize SKY as an OT vendor, nor could it reimburse either the District or STUDENT’s parents for services there because no therapist at SKY was CCS-paneled. However, Ms. Griffin noted that it was not necessary to seek vendored services because CCS was able to provide STUDENT’s OT services, through a different time slot at Reilly MTU, the 4:30 p.m. time slot at another MTU (Dana), vendoring through Children’s Hospital of Orange County (CHOC), or waiting until late February for a 4:30 p.m. time slot at Reilly MTU. Ms. Babiak also stated that Reilly MTU would be fully staffed by March 3, 1997.On January 23, 1997, STUDENT began receiving services from an OTR from SKY, Betsy Figueroa, who conducted an initial evaluation of him that day. Ms. Figueroa noted in her report, dated January 23, 1997, that STUDENT was cooperative during the first assessment session, but that during a self-feeding session, he became upset. Ms. Figueroa stated that STUDENT required parental intervention and a change in approach from a strictly oral motor and feeding skills therapy approach to a sensory integrative approach. Ms. Figueroa administered the Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency and found that STUDENT was performing below age level in bilateral coordination, balance, upper limb coordination, visual-motor control, and upper limb speed and dexterity. Ms. Figueroa also found that STUDENT exhibited significant deficits in the areas of self-feeding, oral motor, and fine motor skills, and that the deficits were due to increased tactile hypersensitivity to his oral cavity and face, and decreased proprioceptive processing/visual motor coordination, in-hand manipulation skills/dexterity with tools, postural stability/motor planning, and visual perception skills. Ms. Figueroa recommended the following goals: increasing STUDENT’s independence with self-feeding by desensitizing his oral cavity and facial hypersensitivities, improving his chewing and tongue lateralization with crunchy foods, improving his safety awareness for food portions, increasing his breathing/swallowing coordination, improving upper extremity motor control, and ensuring his follow-through at home and in school through six home and school consultations. Ms. Figueroa recommended that STUDENT receive OT twice a week for thirty- to forty-five minute sessions for six months to work on those goals.

On February 1, 1997, Julie Turner, ITS OTR, prepared an OT progress report regarding STUDENT. Ms. Turner, who had taken over as STUDENT’s therapist, found that STUDENT had achieved his goal of being able to take consecutive swallows, and that he had partially met his goal of exhibiting socially acceptable utensil use while eating, because he did so in the clinic, although he still exhibited problems at home and in school. Ms. Turner found that STUDENT had also partially achieved his goal of improving his functional trunk, shoulder, arm, and hand control (for fine motor tasks and using utensils) because he was able to maintain an upright trunk during the first fifteen minutes of a meal for at least 50% of the time, although when a meal lasted longer than fifteen minutes, he did this less than 50% of the time. Ms. Turner added a goal for STUDENT (to demonstrate a more mature grasp pattern and better control with tools and utensils 50% of the time), and recommended that his current program of direct therapy be continued until June because his use of utensils was not yet an automatic motor activity for him and he showed improvement after returning to direct therapy. However, Ms. Turner noted that in June, she would consider discharging STUDENT from direct therapy.

On February 6, 1997, Ms. Babiak informed STUDENT’s parents that on Monday, February 10, 1997, OT services would be available at Reilly MTU on Mondays and Wednesdays at 4:30 p.m. (the days and time requested), and that CCS expected STUDENT to return for services on that date.

On February 25, 1997, the District informed STUDENT’s parents that it would no longer pay for STUDENT’s therapy provided by SKY as of February 28, 1997, because CCS was able to provide services at the times and on the days requested by the PARENTs. On March 17, 1997, STUDENT’s father asked the District to transfer the services provided by ITS to SKY, to allow for consolidation of services and transportation. On March 18, 1997, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing in this matter from Ms. Honeycutt on STUDENT’s behalf. On April 15, 1997, Ms. Turner last saw STUDENT at ITS. On April 23, 1997, STUDENT’s father informed Ms. Turner at ITS that beginning that day, STUDENT would receive all his OT services from SKY.

In the current due process hearing, the parties dispute whether since the 1993-94 school year, the District and/or CCS failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) regarding STUDENT’s OT services. Specifically, the parties dispute whether CCS denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide services in early 1997, after Ms. Gammon’s resignation. Further, the parties dispute to what extent since the 1993-94 school year STUDENT has had difficulties with eating, including using utensils, biting, chewing, and swallowing, and to what extent he has shown progress in these areas after receiving therapy from CCS and ITS. The parties dispute whether STUDENT’s parents should be reimbursed for the services they have paid for at SKY (including transportation) for the period after the District stopped funding those services, and whether SKY should continue to provide OT for STUDENT. The parties also dispute whether STUDENT’s parents should be reimbursed for their costs to transport STUDENT to and from Prentice, despite the agreement regarding this issue.

STUDENT currently attends Prentice Day School, a certified nonpublic school, which is paid for by the District according to the parties’ agreement that his parents would provide transportation. STUDENT currently receives both occupational and physical therapy from SKY, paid for privately. STUDENT’s parents have not returned to either CCS or ITS for his OT services. STUDENT’s parents pay for his transportation to and from SKY, as well as his transportation and to and from Prentice.

The parties participated in mediation, but were unable to resolve their disagreement informally, and the matter was scheduled for hearing.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

I. Regarding the provision of occupational therapy (OT), did the Respondents provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for STUDENT during the 1993-94, 1994-95, 1995-96, and 1996-97 school years?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA(Footnote 6)) and federal regulations, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(c); 34 C.F.R. § 300.1(a).) Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.1; California Education Code § 56000.) Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards and are provided at public expense and in conformity with an appropriate IEP. (34 C.F.R. § 300.8.) “Related services” includes supportive services that are required to assist a student with a disability to benefit from special education, such as occupational and physical therapy. (34 C.F.R. § 300.16(a).) In California, related services are known as “designated instruction and services” (DIS). (California Education Code § 56363.)

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the Supreme Court decided the appropriate level of instruction and services that must be provided to students with disabilities in order to satisfy the IDEA. The Court held that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200.)

As noted above in the Procedural Matters section of this Decision, CCS is a proper party to this matter. Furthermore, it is undisputed that CCS is a state agency that has been providing services under STUDENT’s IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that for purposes of this hearing, CCS is a public agency against whom special education state and federal laws apply, including the obligation to provide a FAPE. Although CCS is obligated to provide a FAPE, that obligation is limited to its role within the educational framework, i.e., providing medically necessary occupational or physical therapy. (California Government Code § 7575(a).)(Footnote 7)

The analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to first decide whether procedural steps have been followed, and to then decide whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 20-207.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer will first consider procedural appropriateness and then consider substantive appropriateness.

A. Procedural Appropriateness

Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and federal regulations implementing the IDEA. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300 et seq.) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP.” (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205-206.) Procedural violations which result in a “loss of educational opportunity” or which “seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE.” (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).)

The Petitioner contends that the Respondents committed numerous procedural violations during the 1993-94, 1994-95, 1995-96, and 1996-97 school years that resulted in the loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT and seriously infringed upon his parents’ right to effectively and meaningfully participate in the IEP process.(Footnote 8) The Hearing Officer will deal with the Petitioner’s specific contentions under each school year below.

1. The 1993-94 school year

One of the Petitioner’s contentions is that because the District failed to find STUDENT eligible during the 1993-94 school year, he suffered educational loss. Although neither the District nor CCS raise the issue that a statute of limitations might bar the Petitioner’s contentions regarding the 1993-94 school year, this issue must be addressed as a matter of the Hearing Office’s jurisdiction.

There is no statute of limitations contained in either state special education law or the federal IDEA; therefore, the courts adopt the statute of limitations for the state cause of action most analogous to an action under the IDEA. (Wilson v. Garcia, 471 U.S. 261, 266-267 (1985).)

According to the Ninth Circuit, the state cause of action that is most analogous to an action under the IDEA is contained within the California Code of Civil Procedure section 338(a) and, therefore, the Ninth Circuit adopted the three-year statute of limitations contained therein to claims brought under the IDEA in California. (Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District, 817 F.2d 551, 555 (9th Cir. 1987).) The Alexopulos court also stated that:

Congress’ desire to obtain timely and appropriate education for handicapped children by conferring substantial substantive and procedural rights on parents and guardians on behalf of their children clearly indicates that it did not intend to authorize filing of claims on behalf of or by the children many years after the alleged wrongdoing occurred. It is reasonable to assume that Congress expected and intended the child’s representative to file actions and apply for hearings on his behalf near the time the contested event occurred.

(Id. at p. 556.)

This case was filed with the Hearing Office on March 18, 1997; therefore, using the three-year statute of limitations contained in section 338(a), the Petitioner’s claims regarding time periods prior to March 18, 1994, are time-barred, and the Hearing Officer will not consider those claims. As of March 1994, STUDENT’s parents were initiating complaints regarding issues arising out of the 1993-94 school year and earlier; therefore, at that time, they knew they had claims. STUDENT’s parents were also well acquainted with the procedures for requesting a due process hearing and had done so twice before (SN 462-94 and SN 1096-94), and the statute of limitations would not toll under any applicable doctrine.

With regard to the Petitioner’s claims regarding STUDENT’s OT services from March 18, 1994, through the end of the 1993-94 school year, the Hearing Officer notes that the Petitioner does not seek any remedy for any procedural or substantive violations that allegedly occurred during the 1993-94 school year -- all of the Petitioner’s requested remedies concern reimbursement for OT services in the latter half of the 1996-97 school year and for transportation in the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years. The Hearing Officer cannot issue declarative opinions. Moreover, the Petitioner requested two separate due process hearings prior to the current hearing. One hearing was requested on May 27, 1994, during the 1993-94 school year (SN 462-94), which the Petitioner withdrew on October 27, 1994; therefore, the Petitioner had the opportunity in a prior due process hearing to contest the issues eligibility and FAPE. For all these reasons, the Hearing Officer will not consider the remainder of the 1993-94 school year.

2. The 1994-95 school year

As stated above, the Petitioner seeks remedies relevant only to the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school year. Furthermore, the Petitioner also requested a due process hearing on December 9, 1994 (SN 1096-94), which was resolved in mediation on January 11, 1995, resulting in the agreement that STUDENT was eligible for special education services. (Pet. Exh. 109.) For all these reasons, the Hearing Officer will not consider the 1994-95 school year.

3. The 1995-96 school year

The Petitioner contends that during the 1995-96 school year, the Respondents committed the following procedural violations: the District failed to give serious consideration to the reports from STUDENT’s physicians regarding his physical condition; the District failed to ensure that the decisions of the IEP team were based on information from a variety of sources (including parent-initiated evaluations); the District also failed to ensure the participation of STUDENT’s OTRs from ITS and CCS at his IEP team meetings; the District failed to ensure that STUDENT received the monthly OT consult and six-month reevaluation by ITS in accordance with the specifications of the IEP dated May 22, 1995; the District failed to provide written notice of the fact that it would propose to change STUDENT’s placement and the related service of transportation at the IEP team meeting on June 19, 1995; the District failed to ensure that all services were provided in accordance with STUDENT’s IEP dated June 19, 1995, when it failed to convene an IEP team meeting by July 14, 1995, for a discussion of OT with Dr. Huynen and CCS; the District and CCS failed to provide appropriately trained personnel to provide OT for STUDENT when Denise Yota transferred to another MTU in August 1995; CCS failed to develop goals and objectives with the input of STUDENT’s parents, his behavior therapist, his OTR at ITS, or the rest of the IEP team; CCS failed to obtain written consent from STUDENT’s parents before administering tests to determine his progress toward IEP goals; and CCS reduced the amount of OT provided to STUDENT in January 1996 without convening an IEP team meeting.

The District contends that any procedural violation which may have occurred during this year did not rise to the level of a denial of FAPE. The District contends that it gave the appropriate consideration to the reports from STUDENT’s physicians and that the IEP team made decisions based upon information from a variety of sources. The District and CCS contend that the participation of STUDENT’s OTRs at his IEP team meetings is not mandatory, and that when Ms. Yota transferred, CCS provided services from personnel who were adequately trained. CCS further contends that it creates medical treatment goals, not IEP goals, and that input from parents or the IEP team on those goals and objectives is not a legal requirement.

a. Consideration of STUDENT’s doctors’ reports

When a public agency interprets evaluation data to make a placement decision, it must follow certain procedures, including drawing upon information from a variety of sources and ensuring that the information obtained from those sources is documented and carefully considered. (34 C.F.R. § 300.533.)

STUDENT was receiving OT from two therapists (ITS and CCS) during the 1995-96 school year. (Pet. Exh. 111, 181.) Had the District failed to consider the doctors’ reports, it is likely that the IEP team would not have agreed that STUDENT needed such extensive OT services. The Petitioner presented no evidence that the District failed to consider the reports presented by STUDENT’s physicians regarding his physical condition. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to consider the physicians’ reports during the 1995-96 school year.

b. Basing the decisions of the IEP team on a variety of sources

Independent evaluations were presented to the IEP team. Prior to the agreement about eligibility, the District requested that it be allowed to conduct additional evaluations of its own. School districts have a right and obligation to assess children who are suspected of requiring special education before providing special education services. (34 C.F.R. § 300.531; California Education Code § 56320.) Simply requesting to further assess STUDENT does not mean that the District did not consider the Petitioner’s independent information. The Petitioner presented no evidence that the IEP team did not base its decisions on a variety of sources or that it did not carefully consider all such information. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to base the decisions of the IEP team on a variety of sources during the 1995-96 school year.

c. Attendance of CCS and/or ITS personnel at STUDENT’s IEP Meetings

The public agency shall ensure that the following people attend each IEP team meeting: a representative of the agency (other than the child’s teacher) who is qualified to provide or supervise the provision of special education; the child’s teacher; one or both of the child’s parents; the child (if appropriate); and other individuals at the discretion of the parent or agency. (34 C.F.R. § 300.344.) Therefore, personnel providing related services, such as OT, are not required to attend IEP team meetings, even if requested to do so by the parent, although it would not be inappropriate for them to either attend or be otherwise involved (by providing a written recommendation of the nature, frequency, and amount of services to provide to the student), if invited by the public agency or the parent. (Id.; and as interpreted in Appendix C to Part 300, question 23.)

There is no indication that anyone from ITS or CCS were present at the two IEP team meetings held during the 1995-96 school year. (Pet. Exh. 111, 181) Although the Petitioner contends that the District should have ensured the participation of both ITS and CCS personnel at STUDENT’s IEP team meetings, especially following the PARENTs’ requests for such participation by the OTRs, there is no requirement in the law that the District do so. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation by failing to ensure the participation of ITS and CCS personnel at all of STUDENT’s IEP team meetings during the 1995-96 school year. Although this contention is raised regarding the 1996-97 school year, it will not be addressed again.

d. ITS monthly consult/six-month reevaluation

The IEP dated May 22, 1995, contains the IEP team’s agreement that STUDENT would receive OT consult services for one hour each month, beginning on June 1, 1995, with a reevaluation in six months to see if that level of services continued to be appropriate. Priya Mohan, ITS OTR, met with STUDENT on approximately June 5, 1995, although it is unclear whether this was a direct therapy session or a consultative session. (Pet. Exh. 159, at p. 14.) In August 1995, Ms. Mohan sent a list of activities to STUDENT’s parents for use at home. (Pet. Exh. 102, at p. 38.) On September 12, 1995, Betty Romero, ITS OTR and owner, began providing services to STUDENT, either meeting him at his home, her own home, or the clinic. (Pet. Exh. 159, at p. 15.) From that point on, these services were provided each month for at least an hour. (Id. at pp. 15-16.) On June 17, 1996, Betty Romero, ITS OTR and owner, prepared an OT progress report regarding STUDENT and the consultation services he had received over the past year. (Pet. Exh. 102, p. 38.) Ms. Romero’s report indicates that the District contracted with ITS to provide a total of thirteen hours of consultation services between September 1, 1995, and September 30, 1996. Ms. Romero noted that STUDENT had received nine hours of consultation services from September 1, 1995, through the date of the report.

It was evident from the Petitioner’s contentions and the testimony by STUDENT’s parents at the hearing that they have an expectation that “home consultation services” requires that the OTR come to their home and provide direct therapy services there. However, the PARENTs’ understanding of “consultation services” is not a definition which comports with the definition provided by the OTRs who testified on this issue: that it is a service by which the OTR checks on the progress being made by the child in the program the parents are implementing at home. (Testimony of Ms. Gammon and Ms. Griffin.) The definition provided by the OTRs also comports with the common-sense understanding of “consultation” services.

The Petitioner contends that Ms. Mohan failed to come out to the PARENT home for the home “consultation” services because Ms. Mohan decided that it was too far to drive. Ms. Mohan acknowledged that this was true. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that failing to come to STUDENT’s home does not mean that ITS was failing to provide consultation services. Such services could be provided anywhere, unless testing requiring specific equipment is done, because it is simply a way for the OTR to check on how the parents are doing with the exercises they are to be implementing at home. (Testimony of Ms. Gammon and Ms. Griffin.) Further, Ms. Mohan also testified that Mr. PARENT called Ms. Romero, then-owner of ITS, and said that his wife (STUDENT’s mother) did not want Ms. Mohan to provide the consultative services to STUDENT. Ms. Mohan stated that she presumed that the reason for this telephone call was that Ms. Mohan had recently recommended consultation services for STUDENT, instead of direct therapy. Although Mr. PARENT testified that he never called Ms. Mohan to tell her that his wife did not want Ms. Mohan treating STUDENT, he did not say that he never called Ms. Romero regarding this issue. The Hearing Officer finds that the delay in providing the home program and consultation services related to that home program was at least partly caused by the PARENTs’ refusal to allow STUDENT’s ITS therapist to continue providing services. The Hearing Officer also finds Ms. Mohan’s testimony credible. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the delay in receiving the home program for STUDENT and the associated consultation services may not be imputed to the District.

On the other hand, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s IEP required an OT evaluation by ITS in six months to determine if consultation services continued to be appropriate; yet no ITS reevaluation was done until June 1996.(Footnote 9) As noted below under “Substantive Appropriateness,” CCS referred STUDENT to the District for further OT testing in sensory integration following a CCS report in December 1995. (CCS Exh. L, at p. 13.) The District had an obligation to get STUDENT reevaluated regarding his sensory integration issues for two reasons: the CCS referral and the requirement in STUDENT’s IEP. Even if CCS did not properly inform the District of the need to reassess STUDENT, the District should have been aware of the need for the reevaluation from his IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed a procedural violation by failing to ensure that STUDENT was reevaluated when such reevaluation was required -- within six months of his IEP or following the CCS referral in December 1995.

The question is whether this failure to reevaluate STUDENT denied him a FAPE. When ITS did its reevaluation of STUDENT in June 1996, Ms. Romero decided that STUDENT required direct therapy once again. (Pet. Exh. 102.) When CCS did its reevaluation of STUDENT in June 1996, Ms. Gammon decided that STUDENT could benefit from OT services two to three times a week, along with a home program over the summer. (CCS Exh. L, at p. 10.) By the end of the 1995-96 school year, ITS had provided no direct OT services for over a year, and both agencies decided that STUDENT needed direct therapy again. In fact, the IEP team’s recommendation for CCS therapy was increased from its previous twice-a-week level to three times a week. (Pet. Exh. 123.) For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT lost educational opportunity because of the District’s procedural violation; therefore, the District denied STUDENT services during the 1995-96 school year, to the extent that it failed to ensure that he was reevaluated according to his IEP.

e. Written notice of proposal to change STUDENT’s placement

Under federal regulations, a school district must provide prior written notice to parents a reasonable time before the district proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, placement, or the provision of a FAPE to a child. (34 C.F.R. § 300.504) This means that the District was required to give written notice to STUDENT’s parents when the District proposed to change the provision of his educational services. The IEP document itself fulfills this requirement.

However, the Petitioner is apparently arguing that the District was required to give notice before the IEP meeting held June 19, 1995, of what it would propose at that IEP meeting. Other than giving notice of when an IEP team meeting is to occur, the written notice requirements do not apply to IEP meetings themselves. (Letter to O’Connor, OSEP 1996, 26 IDELR 320.) Based on the evidence provided, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided the required written notice regarding the proposal at the IEP team meeting on June 19, 1995, and did not commit a procedural violation regarding that proposal.

f. IEP meeting by July 14, 1995

The IEP team noted on the IEP dated June 19, 1995, that the team would reconvene again by July 14, 1995, with Dr. Huynen and CCS. (Pet. Exh. 181.) An IEP addendum was signed on July 20, 1995, regarding the transportation issue, although there is no indication that Dr. Huynen or anyone from CCS was involved in that meeting. As noted above, related services personnel are not required to participate in IEP meetings. Further, the IEP team is only required to meet once a year to ensure that a current IEP is in place for a student at the beginning of the school year. (34 C.F.R. §§ 300.342 and 300.343.) Therefore, if more than one IEP team meeting is necessary to resolve the issues of program, services, and placement, the District may convene such an additional meeting, or it may request a due process hearing, as may the parents. (34 C.F.R. § 300.506.) However, the District is not required to convene an unending number of IEP team meetings, simply because the team cannot agree on what is appropriate for a child.

In this case, simply because an additional IEP team meeting did not occur until six days after the date set for it and personnel who are not required to participate in such a meeting did not attend it does not mean that the District committed a procedural violation. Had these circumstances constituted a procedural violation, there is no evidence that such a violation caused educational loss for STUDENT or prevented his parents from participating in the IEP process. STUDENT was receiving services from both ITS and CCS, the level of which had been determined at the IEP team meeting held on May 22, 1995. There is no reason that Dr. Huynen and STUDENT’s CCS OTR could not have discussed therapy together in a forum other than an additional IEP team meeting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that regarding the convening of an IEP team meeting by July 14, 1995, the District committed no procedural violation that denied STUDENT a FAPE.

g. Appropriately trained personnel

When Denise Yota transferred to another MTU in August 1995, Marti Gammon-Hawkins (then Gammon) took over as STUDENT’s OTR at CCS. Ms. Yota had been formally trained in the Deborah Beckman oral motor therapy techniques, but Ms. Gammon had not, and the Petitioner contests Ms. Gammon’s training was inadequate as of the time she took over as STUDENT’s OTR. Ms. Gammon did take the formal course in the Beckman technique some time after becoming STUDENT’s OTR. (Testimony of Ms. Gammon.) However, Ms. Gammon testified that she received training in the technique from Ms. Yota prior to the time Ms. Yota left and felt qualified to use that technique with STUDENT.

Curiously, the Petitioner also contends as an allegation of substantive inappropriateness that the use of the Beckman technique was inappropriate with STUDENT. However, with regard to whether Ms. Gammon was appropriately trained to administer the Beckman technique, Lori Griffin, CCS therapy consultant in charge of the continuing education of the therapists, stated that to use the Beckman technique, therapists must have either completed the course themselves or be taught by someone who has done so. No other evidence regarding the amount of formal training necessary to implement the Beckman technique was provided. There was no dispute that Ms. Gammon was trained by Ms. Yota in the Beckman technique before Ms. Gammon took over as STUDENT’s therapist in August 1995. Based on the evidence provided, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Gammon was appropriately trained to use the Beckman technique with STUDENT in August 1995, and that her provision of services to STUDENT was not a procedural violation by CCS.

h. Creation of CCS goals and objectives

State and federal special education law require that the IEP team create goals and objectives for a student in need of special education services, and that those goals and objectives are to direct what program (and placement) is necessary, in order to meet those criteria. (34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2); id. as interpreted in Appendix C to Part 300, question 43; California Education Code § 56345(a)(2).) IEP goals and objectives may not be changed except by the IEP team. (34 C.F.R. § 300.343; California Education Code § 56340.)

In this case, CCS also created goals and objectives for its own use in treating STUDENT. CCS does not contest that STUDENT’s parents, ITS, and the IEP team had no input into CCS’s treatment goals and objectives for STUDENT. However, CCS contends that its goals and objectives are “treatment” goals and objectives for medically necessary services that are determined by a medical prescription, not IEP goals and objectives and, that, therefore, CCS need not (and cannot) request input from anyone other than the physician writing the prescription for OT. Ms. Gammon-Hawkins also testified that CCS creates general goals that are changed to reflect the changes in the client’s status following the receipt of therapy services.

Both Priya Mohan, the current owner of ITS, and Betty Romero, the former owner of ITS, testified that OTRs set “generalized treatment goals” toward which they hope the client will make progress, but that the IEP team sets IEP goals that are more specific. Documents from ITS show the difference between treatment goals and IEP goals. (Pet. Exh. 25; Pet. Exh. 31.)

The Petitioner has not shown why CCS’s treatment goals and objectives, used for its internal provision of medical services to STUDENT, should be subject to the same procedural requirements to which IEP goals and objectives are subject. The IEP team sets the IEP goals and objectives for a student, and CCS could be involved in that process. However, CCS’s treatment goals and objectives were outside the IEP process and not subject to IEP team review. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that CCS did not commit a procedural violation by failing to allow STUDENT’s parents, ITS OTRs, or the rest of the IEP team to provide input into CCS’s treatment goals and objectives for STUDENT during the 1995-96 school year. Although this contention is raised regarding the 1996-97 school year, it will not be addressed again.

i. Consent for CCS evaluations

Under federal regulations, parental consent must be obtained before conducting a preplacement evaluation for special education services. (34 C.F.R. § 300.504(b)(i).) Under California statute, whenever an assessment for the development or revision of the IEP is to be conducted, a parent is to be given an assessment plan, and the public agency must obtain the consent of the parent for the assessment. (California Education Code §§ 56321(a) and 56321(c).)

Here, the “assessments” for which the Petitioner contends CCS should have obtained specific consent are the six-month treatment reevaluations that have been used internally by CCS to determine STUDENT’s progress on his treatment goals and to write his prescription for medically necessary OT. CCS’s testing was not done to create or revise STUDENT’s IEP. Therefore, the requirements that apply to the District regarding testing used to create or revise STUDENT’s IEP do not apply to CCS in its provision of medically necessary OT. Further, CCS had consent from the PARENTs to provide OT services and do necessary reevaluations of him as part of that provision of services, through the annual agreement for services signed by STUDENT’s parents. (CCS Exh. G.(Footnote 10)) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that CCS did not commit a procedural violation in the administration of its evaluations to STUDENT. The Petitioner raises this contention with regard to the 1996-97 school year, but it will not be addressed again.

j. Reduction of OT services by CCS in January 1996

A public agency must initiate and conduct an IEP team meeting at least once a year to review and, if necessary, revise a child’s IEP. (34 C.F.R. § 300.343(d).) As noted above, a public agency must provide written notice when the agency proposes to change the special education services being provided to a student. (34 C.F.R. § 300.504.)

Beginning in 1994, STUDENT began receiving medically necessary OT services from CCS. On February 10, 1995, the IEP team agreed that OT services from CCS twice a week in thirty-minute sessions were services that were also educationally necessary for STUDENT. (Pet. Exh. 109.) The IEP document, dated May 22, 1995, stated that the services from CCS were to continue. (Pet. Exh. 111.) The addendum of May 31, 1995, did not change the level of CCS services. (Pet. Exh. 195.) The IEP document, dated June 19, 1995, stated that STUDENT was to receive CCS services twice weekly. (Pet. Exh. 181.) The addendum, dated July 20, 1995, did not change the level of CCS services. (Pet. Exh. 183.) Therefore, STUDENT was to be receiving twice-weekly services from CCS at the time a prescription for OT consultation services was created for STUDENT and signed by his physician in December 1995. (CCS Exh. J, at p. 12.) This prescription, which was to last until December 1996 (one year), reduced the amount of services CCS would provide to STUDENT from twice-a-week, thirty-minute direct therapy sessions to once-a-month consultation sessions. No IEP team meeting was held from the time this prescription was signed until the meeting held on June 19, 1996. STUDENT received three direct therapy sessions in January 1996. (CCS Exh. T, at p. 5.) He then began receiving consultation services once a month from CCS from February 1996 until after the IEP team meeting in June 1996, at which the team agreed he needed OT from CCS three times a week through September 1996, when he was reevaluated by CCS. (CCS Exh. N, at p. 2; Pet. Exh. 123; testimony of Mrs. PARENT.) Although CCS has the power to decide whether OT services are medically necessary for a child, it does not act in a vacuum -- that is, CCS does not have the power to also decide unilaterally whether OT services are educationally necessary. (California Government Code § 7575(b).) The IEP team decides if services are educationally necessary. (34 C.F.R. §§ 300.343 and 300.346.) If a related service (such as OT) is not medically necessary, but is still educationally necessary, then the local educational agency must take over the provision of such services. (California Government Code § 7575(a)(2).) Therefore, when therapy services are provided by CCS and are also included on a child’s IEP as a related service, CCS is bound by that IEP to provide those services or must inform the school district of a change in service. (California Education Code § 56363; 34 C.F.R. § 300.504.)

In this case, no evidence was presented showing that CCS informed the District of the change in STUDENT’s prescription for OT services in December 1995 or January 1996, so that the District could convene an IEP team meeting. (CCS Exh. H, at pp. 5-6.) Ultimately, the burden of initiating an IEP team meeting is on the District, but without the knowledge that CCS was changing STUDENT’s prescription, the District cannot be held accountable for this procedural violation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that CCS committed a procedural violation when it failed to take the steps necessary to inform the District that it changed STUDENT’s prescription from the amount of services indicated on his IEP so that an IEP team meeting could be convened.

The question is now whether this procedural violation either resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT or prevented his parents from participating in the IEP process. In this instance, CCS stopped providing OT services that the IEP team might have decided were still educationally necessary in January 1996, and could have had another agency provide those services. In fact, when the IEP team did convene in June 1996, it decided that STUDENT did need educationally and medically necessary OT from CCS (a CCS representative was present at this meeting). For all these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT lost approximately six months of OT services and, therefore, was denied a FAPE during the 1995-96 school year by CCS’s failure to at least inform the District of the change in his prescription.

In summary, both the District and CCS denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1995-96 school year to the extent that the District failed to ensure that STUDENT was reassessed regarding his sensory integration problems and CCS failed to adequately notify STUDENT’s parents in writing of the reduction in CCS services, either directly or through the District.

4. The 1996-97 school year

The Petitioner contends that during the 1996-97 school year, CCS failed to notify the District regarding the resignation of Ms. Gammon, that the District failed to immediately convene an IEP team when it learned of the staffing problem, that the District failed to provide written notice that it was refusing to contract with the PARENTs’ chosen OT provider (SKY), and that both the District (through ITS) and CCS failed to provide records adequately.

a. Notice of Ms. Gammon’s resignation by CCS

As noted above, a public agency must provide prior written notice to parents a reasonable time before it proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, placement, or the provision of a FAPE to a child. (34 C.F.R. § 300.504) In this case, it is uncontroverted that unless the PARENTs had requested otherwise, CCS would have put STUDENT “on hold” for OT services until a replacement therapist was on staff in March 1997. Although simply changing therapists, times when therapy is provided, or even the location of the therapy would not have triggered a notice requirement, the Hearing Officer finds that the cessation of services -- albeit, temporary -- did, in fact, trigger such requirement. Therefore, CCS should have provided the type of written notice required in the federal regulations under sections 300.504-300.505, or it should have notified the District about the problem so that the District could provide such notice by convening an IEP team meeting and attempting to resolve the problem. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that CCS committed a procedural violation by failing to either provide the required written notice or to inform the District so that it could provide written notice in an IEP document of the staffing problem. STUDENT missed out on OT services during the period of time when the staffing problem occurred; therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that CCS denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year with regard to this notice problem.

b. Need for the District to convene an IEP team meeting

As mentioned above, the District is required to convene an IEP team meeting whenever a proposal to change a student’s provision of FAPE is made. (34 C.F.R. § 300.504.) In this case, the District learned of the staffing problem at CCS by January 13, 1997. (Pet. Exh. 28; testimony of Mr. PARENT.) At that time, the District had an opportunity to satisfy its legal obligations by immediately convening an IEP team meeting. There is no evidence showing that since June 19, 1996, through the end of this hearing, an IEP team meeting was convened for STUDENT. Although the District paid for SKY services while CCS was unable to provide services, STUDENT still lost services he should have received from CCS before his parents went to SKY on January 23, 1997. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to convene an IEP team meeting regarding the interruption of services by CCS.

c. Written notice of refusal to fund SKY

The Hearing Officer notes that it is unnecessary to address this issue in detail because there has already been a finding that both CCS and the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year because of the notice deficiency regarding the staffing problem and the failure to initiate an IEP team meeting. However, the Hearing Officer also notes that under federal regulations, the District should have provided written notice to STUDENT’s parents (in accordance with federal regulations) of the refusal to fund SKY. (34 C.F.R. § 300.504.)

d. Failure to adequately provide records

The Hearing Officer notes that it is also unnecessary to address this issue in detail. The Petitioner spent a great deal of time putting on evidence of how both ITS and CCS failed to provide records. The Hearing Officer simply notes that there was no evidence that any of the alleged procedural violations concerning records resulted in an educational loss to STUDENT or prevented his parents from participating in the IEP process.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that both CCS and the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year with regard to CCS’s failure to give notice of the temporary cessation of services and the District’s failure to initiate an IEP team meeting.

B. Substantive Appropriateness of OT services(Footnote 11)

For the same reasons stated above regarding procedural appropriateness, the Hearing Officer will not consider the 1993-94 and 1994-95 school years.

The standard for determining whether a local educational agency’s provision of services substantively provided a FAPE for STUDENT involves three factors: whether the services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; whether the services provided educational benefit to STUDENT; and whether the services conformed to STUDENT’s IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)

1. 1995-96 school year a. Whether the services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs

The Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s needs during the 1995-96 school year included the following: problems chewing hard and soft foods due to both a lowered tone in his mouth and a hypersensitivity to certain textures; an inability to chew an appropriate number of times (or with a rotary chew) to avoid choking problems resulting from swallowing food whole; a problem with seeking out vestibular information resulting from a sensory integration problem; and postural/strength problems which prevented him from being able to sit for very long at meals or properly use utensils.

The District and CCS contend that STUDENT’s needs had lessened due to the provision of OT from both ITS and CCS. The District contends that it became clear that utensil use problems were associated with behavioral issues and that services from a behaviorist were added to his IEP. CCS contends that it provided services at a quality and level consistent with the standard of the profession, and that STUDENT had low oral muscle tone, but he continued to improve his oral motor strength and to make progress on his goals.

The Hearing Officer notes that a great deal of testimony about the minute details of STUDENT’s abilities during each school year were presented. Based on a careful review of all the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs during the 1995-96 school year included the following: low oral motor tone; sensory-motor dysfunctions involving the motor planning, oral motor, visual motor, motor coordination, vestibular, and tactile systems; sensory defensiveness (including a hypersensitivity to soft foods) and related problems with swallowing foods (swallowing without chewing), overall strength, and endurance; difficulties using utensils; distractibility; and behavioral issues associated with all of the above, especially regarding utensil use.

In May 1995, based on STUDENT’s progress on his sensory integration problems, ITS recommended that he no longer receive direct therapy but instead should receive consultation services. (Pet. Exh. 102, at p. 34; testimony of Ms. Mohan.) The IEP team agreed with this suggestion and STUDENT’s IEP dated May 22, 1995, noted that as of June 1, 1995, he would begin receiving consultation services once a month from ITS. (Pet. Exh. 111.) Therefore, for the first half of the 1995-96 school year, the services designed by ITS for STUDENT consisted of consultation services and no direct therapy.

CCS continued to provide twice weekly direct therapy to STUDENT during the 1995-96 school year, until a six-month reevaluation was done by Marti Gammon in late October and early November 1995. CCS utilized the Beckman technique, consisting partly of a “quick stretch” of the oral muscles. The Hearing Officer finds that just as in the more “educational” arena of special education law, wherein school districts are allowed to choose the method of teaching, CCS had the prerogative of choosing the method by which to treat STUDENT, as long as it otherwise provided appropriate services. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 208.) Therefore, the particular method used by CCS will not be questioned if the services were otherwise appropriate.

A new prescription was issued on December 12, 1995, changing STUDENT’s CCS services to consultation services once a month, which began in February 1996. (CCS Exh. L, at p. 13; Testimony of Ms. Gammon; CCS Exh. T, at pp. 5-6.) Ms. Gammon indicated in her CCS evaluation of STUDENT that he had met his goals set in the last evaluation, and that his fine motor and perceptual skills were tested and were at or above age level. (CCS Exh. L, at p. 13.) Ms. Gammon noted that while STUDENT performed well in the clinic, after observing him in a restaurant (in which a negative incident between the two of them occurred), he still continued to experience difficulty with using utensils in a daily living situation. (Id.; testimony of Ms. Gammon.) Ms. Gammon concluded that because STUDENT was able to perform such skills in the clinic, but was unable to maintain these skills in distraction-filled environments (like the restaurant), the issues surrounding utensil use were more related to sensory/motor planning than strength, and she recommended further OT assessments by the District in that area. (Id.)

Direct therapy by ITS had already been reduced to consultation services by the time that CCS changed STUDENT’s prescription to consultation services. Therefore, during the latter half of the 1995-96 school year, both ITS and CCS had designed a program of services for STUDENT consisting solely of consultation services and no direct therapy.

STUDENT’s needs had lessened in the 1995-96 school year, as evidenced by the progress he had made in both clinical arenas, ITS and CCS. STUDENT’s parents indicated that his skills in the clinic had not generalized to daily living situations, and that his needs outside the clinic were just as great as they were before receiving treatment. Ms. Gammon recognized this phenomenon and recommended that the District seek further sensory-motor integration assessments. The Hearing Officer finds that as to actual strength, STUDENT’s needs had decreased such that, with proper follow-up by STUDENT in a home program, he did not need direct therapy from CCS. The therapy by CCS was limited to its role as the provider of medically necessary OT, related to his medically-eligible condition of low tone. CCS was not required to address other issues if they were not related to that condition and, instead, were related to a sensory-motor problem (e.g., utensil use). Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that CCS’s services were designed to address those deficits for which it was responsible. However, as to his sensory-motor integration problems being addressed by ITS, the Hearing Officer finds that although those problems decreased, STUDENT still required direct therapy (although not necessarily twice a week for fifty minutes) to address this area of deficit. This problem might have been averted, had the six-month evaluation been done, as required in STUDENT’s IEP dated May 22, 1995. Based on these facts, the Hearing Officer finds that during the 1995-96 school year, CCS’s services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, but that the District’s services were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

b. Whether the services provided benefit to STUDENT

The Petitioner contends that neither the District’s nor CCS’s services provided more than de minimis benefit to STUDENT during the 1995-96 school year. The District and CCS contend that STUDENT benefitted from their OT services during this year.

De minimis benefit is insufficient to meet the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (M.C. ex rel. J.C. v. Central Regional School District 81 F.3d 389 (3d. Cir. 1996), cert. denied, 117 S.Ct. 176 (1996); Polk v. Central Susquehana Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171 (3d. Cir. 1988), cert. denied, 488 U.S. 1030 (1989).) The Hearing Officer notes that, as a matter of common sense, because the District’s services (through ITS) during this school year were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is not likely that those services could provide “some” benefit to him. As to what benefit STUDENT actually received from the District’s services, the Hearing Officer finds that, based on the evidence presented, the program of consultation services provided by ITS during the 1995-96 school year provided no more than de minimis benefit, and that this amount is insufficient to satisfy Rowley. As to CCS’s services during the 1995-96 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT made progress toward his CCS goals and that he benefitted from the services provided. (CCS Exh. L, at p. 13; testimony of Ms. Gammon.).

c. Whether the services conformed to STUDENT’s IEP

The Petitioner contends that the services provided by CCS and ITS did not conform to STUDENT’s IEP for the 1995-96 school year. Neither the District nor CCS directly addressed this contention. STUDENT’s IEP for the 1995-96 school year, dated May 22, 1995, called for OT services from ITS in the form of consultation services until a six-month reevaluation was done. (Pet. Exh. 111.) ITS provided consultation services for the entire year and did not do a reevaluation until June 1996. (Pet. Exh. 102, at p. 38; testimony of Ms. Mohan.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s provision of services through ITS did not conform to STUDENT’s IEP.

That same IEP also called for OT services from CCS in the form of direct therapy twice a week for thirty minute sessions. (Pet. Exh. 111.) CCS provided such therapy until STUDENT’s prescription was changed. (CCS Exh. T, at pp. 4-7; testimony of Ms. Gammon.) The fact that CCS’s reduction to consultation services was designed to meet his unique needs does not take away from the District’s obligation to include such changes in an IEP. (34 C.F.R. § 300.504.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that CCS’s provision of services did not conform to STUDENT’s IEP.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that during the 1995-96 school year (1) the District’s services (through ITS) were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) the District’s services did not provide benefit to STUDENT, and (3) neither CCS’s nor the District’s services conformed to STUDENT’s IEP. Based on these findings, the Hearing Officer finds that both the District and CCS substantively denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1995-96 school year.

2. 1996-97 school year a. Whether the services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs

The Petitioner contends that by the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT was still unable to adequately feed himself using utensils and that he continued to have difficulty with chewing both hard and soft foods. The District contends that in this school year, STUDENT was functionally able to feed himself and that behavior was a factor in his eating problems. CCS contends that during this school year, STUDENT’s needs had continued to lessen with the years of services provided by CCS, but acknowledged that he still required direct OT services.

The Hearing Officer notes that before the beginning of the 1996-97 school year, both CCS and ITS recognized a need to reinstate direct therapy and on June 19, 1996, the IEP team agreed with that decision. (Pet. Exh. 123.) In June 1996, ITS retested STUDENT with the Sensory Integration and Praxis Test and found that he not only maintained the gains he had made in this area, but continued to increase those gains since the testing a year before. (Pet. Exh. 102, at p. 39.) Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs during the 1996-97 school year included a need to address his continuing (but lessening) sensory-motor dysfunctions (including sensory defensiveness), oral motor strength, and utensil use.

The services designed by CCS to treat his reemerging oral motor strength problems were direct therapy two to three times a week in thirty-minute sessions and a home program to use over the summer to maintain strength gains. (CCS Exh. L, at p. 10; testimony of Ms. Gammon.) The flexibility in number of sessions per week was for the convenience of STUDENT’s parents. (Testimony of Ms. Gammon.) CCS created goals to work on STUDENT’s oral motor strength. The Hearing Officer finds that based on the evidence presented, CCS’s services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, within the CCS framework of responsibility.

ITS created a program of services including direct therapy twice a week for at least six months to address his oral motor/respiratory coordination, utensil use, and self-feeding. The Hearing Officer finds that based on the evidence presented, ITS’s services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

b. Whether the services provided benefit to STUDENT

The Petitioner contends that the services from CCS and ITS were not designed to provide any more than de minimis benefit to STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year. The District and CCS contend that during this school year, STUDENT made progress and that the services of both ITS and CCS provided benefit to him.

Substantial evidence was presented showing that STUDENT had, in fact, benefitted from the OT services provided by both CCS and ITS. Ms. Gammon found that after receiving direct therapy from CCS during the summer months of 1996, STUDENT made gains in lip strength, cheek strength, and chewing. (CCS Exh. L, at p. 9; testimony of Ms. Gammon.) STUDENT’s prescription for therapy was reduced from two to three sessions of direct therapy a week to two sessions a week, effective in October 1996. (Id.) Julie Turner, who had taken over as STUDENT’s OTR at ITS, noted that he had also shown progress following direct therapy with her and had either achieved or partially achieved the treatment goals and objectives ITS had created for STUDENT. (Pet. Exh. 102, at p. 41; testimony of Ms. Turner.) STUDENT’s parents continued to express concern that he was unable to generalize his skills to situations outside the clinic; however, the Hearing Officer notes that the District provided a behaviorist to help assist with the problems associated with utensil use, and that STUDENT has the strength to do such tasks, but does not utilize his skills consistently. Therefore, for all these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that both ITS’s and CCS’s services during the 1996-97 school year provided benefit to STUDENT.

c. Whether the services conformed to STUDENT’s IEP

The Petitioner contends that the services provided by the District and CCS did not conform to STUDENT’s IEP for the 1996-97 school year. The District and CCS disagree.

STUDENT’s IEP for the 1996-97 school year, dated June 19, 1996, called for three sessions a week of direct OT services from CCS until September 1996. (Pet. Exh. 123.) CCS’s prescription for STUDENT for this period of time was for two to three sessions per week of OT services. (CCS Exh. L, at p. 10.) In fact, STUDENT was scheduled for three sessions per week. (CCS Exh. T, at p. 3.) The Petitioner contends that some of these scheduled sessions were “make-up” sessions for times when either STUDENT or the therapist could not make a regularly scheduled session and did not represent a schedule of three sessions per week. The Hearing Officer notes that before reinstating direct therapy in June 1996, STUDENT was receiving consultation services only, and that make-up sessions would not have been necessary. In terms of what was actually provided, of the approximately thirty sessions scheduled during the last week of June 1996 through the last week of August 1996 (the only time period addressed in STUDENT’s IEP), half were canceled -- nine by STUDENT’s parents and six by the therapist; therefore, fault cannot be laid solely upon CCS for missing sessions. (CCS Exh. T, at pp. 3-4.) Even though CCS’s prescription was flexible, it is clear that three sessions per week were scheduled during this period.

The Petitioner also asserts that STUDENT did not actually receive thirty minutes of direct therapy from CCS. The Petitioner asserts that STUDENT received services in an amount closer to twenty minutes, due to the fact that STUDENT would hide from his therapist because he did not like his therapy and considered it “torture.” (Testimony of Mrs. PARENT.) CCS contends that with children, the entire amount of therapy time is not applied directly to working on goals because the therapist needs to work on establishing and maintaining rapport with the child and encouraging the client to allow the therapy to continue because oral motor therapy is not comfortable.

The Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner’s assertion that CCS did not provide the full thirty minutes of therapy is unfounded for several reasons, including the fact that STUDENT’s mother acknowledged that she was often either late to CCS sessions or “just barely on time” to them. In reality, it would be impossible for a therapist to begin working on oral motor therapy at the moment the session is to begin, when the client is either not there yet, or has just walked in the door. Further, it is reasonable to expect that a therapist will take a short amount of time to acclimate a child before putting his or her hands in the child’s mouth. Therefore, for all the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that CCS’s provision of services conformed to STUDENT’s IEP.

STUDENT’s IEP for the 1996-97 school year also called for ITS to provide twice weekly sessions during the regular school year. (Pet. Exh. 123.) ITS provided services twice a week during the 1996-97 school year. (Pet. Exh. 159, at pp. 16-24; testimony of Ms. Turner.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that ITS’s provision of services conformed to STUDENT’s IEP.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that during the 1996-97 school year, both CCS’s and ITS’s services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the services provided benefit to him, and conformed to his IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that substantively, both CCS and the District provided a FAPE to STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year.

C. Conclusion regarding FAPE

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that both the District and CCS committed procedural and substantive violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE regarding appropriate OT services during the 1995-96 school year, and that both the District and CCS committed procedural violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year to the extent that CCS temporarily ceased to provide services and the District failed to convene an IEP team, although STUDENT’s OT services were substantively appropriate during the 1996-97 school year.

II. Currently, which agency is the appropriate OT provider for STUDENT?

The Petitioner contends that the appropriate OT provider for STUDENT is SKY because (1) neither the District nor CCS has provided an appropriate education for STUDENT, (2) he receives all his OT from SKY, and (3) that by combining the services in one provider, STUDENT is freed from traveling to two different providers, who sometimes provide overlapping services. The Petitioner also asserts that the therapy STUDENT is provided is not enjoyable, and to avoid unnecessary repetition of such therapy, SKY should assume all responsibilities as STUDENT’s OT provider.

The District contends that ITS is an appropriate provider of educationally necessary OT services for STUDENT and that there is no need for SKY to provide his OT services. CCS contends that CCS is the appropriate provider of medically necessary OT services for STUDENT. CCS further asserts that SKY cannot be STUDENT’s provider of OT because that agency is not approved to provide those services to him. CCS contends that STUDENT’s OT is provided pursuant to his medical prescription and that any outside vendor of the therapy must be CCS-paneled to provide it. CCS contends that because SKY has no CCS-paneled occupational therapists on staff, it is an inappropriate service provider of STUDENT’s medically necessary occupational therapy.

The Hearing Officer notes that ITS provided appropriate services to STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year, and that the finding that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE was based solely upon a procedural violation regarding the District’s failure to initiate a single IEP team meeting. Based on the evidence that ITS provided appropriate services to STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that ITS is currently the appropriate provider of educationally necessary OT services for STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer also notes that CCS provided appropriate services to STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year, and that the finding that CCS denied STUDENT a FAPE was based solely upon a procedural problem regarding notice. Furthermore, the bulk of the Petitioner’s arguments that CCS was not an appropriate provider of STUDENT’s medically necessary OT services centered upon methodology. As noted above, CCS may choose what methodology to use with a child as long as the services are otherwise appropriate. Therefore, the fact that CCS committed a procedural violation during the 1996-97 school year does not mean that CCS is not an appropriate provider of STUDENT’s educationally and medically necessary OT services. Based on the evidence that CCS provided appropriate substantive services to STUDENT during the 1996-97 school, and the fact that the procedural violation is not of a nature to suggest that CCS cannot or will not avoid repeating it in the future, the Hearing Officer finds that CCS is currently the appropriate provider of medically necessary OT services for STUDENT.

Because the Hearing Officer has found that both ITS and CCS are appropriate providers of STUDENT’s OT services, the Hearing Officer denies the Petitioner’s request for an order that SKY is currently the appropriate provider of OT services for STUDENT.

III. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following: A. The costs associated with the OT being provided by SKY Pediatric Therapy Services (SKY) to STUDENT during 1997, including transportation to and from SKY; and B. Transportation to and from Prentice Day School for STUDENT during the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years?

Under Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington, Massachusetts, et al., v. Department of Education of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts et al., 471 U.S. 359, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985), the Supreme Court held that if a school district failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE), the child’s parents may seek reimbursement for an appropriate private placement.

A. OT services by SKY and transportation to SKY

The Petitioner is requesting reimbursement for SKY services as a replacement for CCS services during the period of time beginning February 28, 1997, through the date of this Decision. STUDENT began receiving therapy services at SKY to replace the services from CCS on January 23, 1997. (Pet. Exh. 139, 140, and 180; testimony of Mrs. PARENT and Ms. Figueroa.) When the District was informed that CCS was having staffing problems, the District funded STUDENT’s therapy at SKY until after CCS informed the parties that it was once again able to provide services to STUDENT at the time and location requested by the PARENTs. The District informed the PARENTs that effective February 28, 1997, the District would no longer fund SKY. (Pet. Exh.143; testimony of Ms. Lohnes.)

The Petitioner is also requesting reimbursement for SKY services as a replacement for ITS services during the period of time beginning April 23, 1997, through the date of this Decision. STUDENT continued to receive OT services from ITS until April 23, 1997, at which time his father informed ITS that STUDENT would receive all his OT services from SKY. The District had paid for STUDENT’s therapy at ITS until his parents refused ITS services.

The Hearing Officer found above that both the District and CCS committed procedural violations which denied a FAPE for STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year (the year during which the services at issue were provided). Therefore, under Burlington, the Petitioner may be entitled to reimbursement for the services if it is shown that the parentally provided services were appropriate, i.e., the services must be designed to meet the child’s unique needs and provide some educational benefit. (Burlington, 471 U.S. 359 (1985).) The evidence showed that the OT services provided by SKY were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and that he received benefit from those services, based on his progress and gradual increase in skills with Ms. Figueroa -- similar to the gradual progress he had been making with both ITS and CCS. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the services provided by STUDENT’s parents through SKY were appropriate.

However, the Hearing Officer notes that equitable considerations and the actions of the parties are to be considered in awarding relief when a parent provides a placement because a school district has failed to provide a FAPE. (Burlington, 471 U.S. 359, 374, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985); W.G., 960 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).) In this case, although CCS ceased providing services, the cessation was temporary. Although the District failed to convene an IEP team following the cessation of services, once the District was informed of the staffing problem, it did provide funding at SKY so that STUDENT would not miss out on further OT sessions that CCS could not then provide at the time and place requested by the PARENTs.

Further, CCS provided numerous alternatives for STUDENT to receive therapy either at another time at Reilly MTU, at his regular time at another MTU, or to vendor with CHOC. (Pet. Exh. 138; testimony of Ms. Griffin and Ms. Babiak.) None of the alternatives offered was acceptable to the PARENTs for one reason or another. The Hearing Officer notes that if it was important to the PARENTs to make sure that STUDENT received his medically necessary OT services, then they could reasonably be expected to at least attempt to utilize one of the various alternatives provided by CCS.

It should also be noted that the temporary inability to provide OT services to STUDENT resulted from the resignation of a therapist, not from any act for which CCS can be faulted. Moreover, the finding that CCS denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year was not based upon any substantive failure of CCS to provide appropriate services -- it was solely based upon a limited procedural violation. As found above, despite the procedural concern, CCS is an appropriate provider of services. Furthermore, the procedural violation is relevant to the 1996-97 school year only. These considerations weigh toward limiting reimbursement for the Petitioner.

CCS indicated that it was able to provide STUDENT’s medically necessary OT services at the time and place requested by the PARENTs on Monday, February 10, 1997. (CCS Exhibit D; testimony of Ms. Babiak.) The District continued to fund SKY as a replacement for CCS services until February 28, 1997. (Pet. Exh. 43; testimony of Ms. Lohnes.) Therefore, except for the period of time when CCS ceased providing services until STUDENT began receiving SKY services on January 23, 1997, free appropriate public OT services were available to STUDENT at all times. However, STUDENT’s parents needed a predictable provider of OT services, in light of CCS’s changing availability. The Petitioner provided evidence that STUDENT was sensitive to transition, and special education law favors stability and maintaining the status quo. (Zvi D. v. Gordon Ambach, 694 F.2d 904 (2d Cir. 1982).) However, since decisions about placement and services are generally made on an annual basis, it would have been appropriate to consider a transition back to CCS at the end of the 1996-97 school year. (California Education Code § 56343(d).) STUDENT’s parents were, therefore, justified in staying with SKY for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year for his medically necessary OT services. For all these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that it would be equitable to limit reimbursement for medically necessary OT services provided by SKY (including transportation) in the place of CCS to the amount of time after February 28, 1997, until the end of the school year, including extended school year services and transportation.

The Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for SKY services as a replacement for the District’s services (through ITS) is based on the Petitioner’s contention that the District failed to provide an appropriate education. As found above, the finding that the District denied a FAPE was based solely upon a limited procedural violation, and otherwise, ITS was found to be an appropriate provider of STUDENT’s educationally necessary OT services. The Petitioner argued that having one provider for all of STUDENT’s OT services was necessary because of the nature of the services, the need to avoid overlapping services, and because STUDENT has difficulty with transition. However, there was no evidence that CCS and ITS used the same techniques with STUDENT, that the services overlapped significantly, or that the nature of the services were such that limiting them to one provider was necessary, other than for convenience of the PARENTs. Furthermore, the evidence showed that STUDENT was able to adapt to his therapist at SKY fairly quickly. (Testimony of Ms. Figueroa; Pet. Exh. 40 at p. 3.) The Hearing Officer also notes that if STUDENT’s parents had allowed him to continue receiving services at ITS, there would be no need to “transition” him back there now. Because the District offered appropriate services at ITS (and paid for SKY services while CCS was unavailable), and STUDENT’s parents changed the status quo regarding ITS services, the Hearing Officer finds that it would be equitable to deny reimbursement for educationally necessary OT services provided by SKY in the place of ITS.

B. Transportation to Prentice during the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years

The Hearing Officer finds that based on the uncontroverted evidence that the PARENTs signed agreements giving up transportation to Prentice for the District’s agreement that it would continue funding STUDENT’s placement there, there is no basis to set aside those agreements. (Pet. Exh. 183, 123.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer denies the Petitioner’s requests for reimbursement for transportation to Prentice for the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years.

ORDER

1. Within thirty days of receiving receipts for SKY Pediatric Services (SKY) documenting the costs for medically necessary occupational therapy (OT) for the period between February 28, 1997, and the end of the 1996-97 school year, including extended school year services, CCS must reimburse STUDENT’s parents for these costs.

2. Within thirty days of receiving documentation of the mileage incurred by the PARENTs’ provision of transportation to SKY for the period between February 28, 1997, and the end of the 1996-97 school year (including the extended school year), the District must reimburse STUDENT’s parents for these costs at the rate for parental transportation reimbursement.

3. All of the Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

I. Regarding the provision of OT, did the Respondents provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for STUDENT during the 1993-94, 1994-95, 1995-96, and 1996-97 school years? For the 1993-94 school year, the Hearing Officer made no ruling on the merits of this issue. For the 1994-95 school year, the Hearing Officer made no ruling on the merits of this issue. For the 1995-96 school year, the Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that he was denied appropriate OT services; however, the only remedy requested for that year was not awarded. For the 1996-97 school year, the Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

II. Currently, which agency is the appropriate OT provider for STUDENT? The District and CCS prevailed on this issue.

III. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following: A. The costs associated with the OT being provided by SKY Pediatric Therapy Services (SKY) to STUDENT during 1997, including transportation to and from SKY; and The Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that reimbursement was awarded, although reimbursement was reduced for equitable reasons. B. Transportation to and from Prentice Day School for STUDENT during the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years? The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: April 8, 1998 ____________________________________ Kathleen Peterson Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES:

1) "Dist. Exh.” refers to the District’s exhibits, numbered 1 through 11, admitted into evidence.

2) Mitochondrial myopathy is a cellular condition often characterized by muscle weakness. (Dorland’s Illustrated Medical Dictionary, 28th ed., p. 1074 (1994).)

3) Dysautonomia is a chromosomal condition often characterized by a weakening of the reflexes. (Dorland’s Illustrated Medical Dictionary, 28th ed., p. 514 (1994).)

4) SN 462-94 was subsequently withdrawn by the PARENTs in October 1994.

5) "Pet. Exh.” refers to the Petitioner’s exhibits, numbered 101 through 112, 114 through 116, 118 and 119, 121 through 123, 126 through 156, 158 through 164, 166 and 167, 169 and 170, 174 through 176, and 178 through 220.

6) Amendments to the IDEA were signed into law on June 4, 1997. The request for this hearing was received before any of the 1997 Amendments to the IDEA became effective and the parties made no argument that the amendments apply here. Additionally, according to the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Landgraf v. USI Film Products, 511 U.S. 244 (1994), retroactive application of such amendments are not favored. For all these reasons, the Hearing Officer will apply the law as it stood at the time of the hearing request.

7) When, as in this matter, services such as OT are both educationally and medically necessary, CCS must provide those services, which must be included in an IEP (California Government Code § 7575(a)(1); California Education Code § 56345.)

8) The Petitioner also contends that the District committed procedural violations prior to the 1993-94 school year. The Hearing Officer notes that due process hearing decisions are limited to resolving issues presented for hearing and noticed to the other parties. No issue regarding any year prior to the 1993-94 school year was noticed to the other parties; therefore, this Decision will not address contentions regarding years prior to 1993-94.

9) The Hearing Officer notes that this finding does not impugn the services provided by ITS, because, unlike the District, ITS is not a public agency responsible for providing a FAPE. Furthermore, ITS was not at the IEP team meeting in which it was agreed that a reevaluation should be done in six months, nor was it required to be there.

10) "CCS Exh.” refers to the exhibits of CCS, lettered A through X, admitted into evidence.

11) As with the procedural issues, the Petitioner’s substantive issues regarding STUDENT’s educational program solely addressed the provision of OT services, i.e., placement was not at issue.