California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 14, 2003
Student v. East Side Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 308-03 · Hearing Officer Heather A. Hoyle
East Side Union High School District properly found student's alleged assault on an employee was not a manifestation of his language disorder.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The case was split from SN02-02565 (the non-expedited placement and services issues), which this decision did not address. The Hearing Office denied a stay put request on February 10, 2003, because the District had obtained a temporary restraining order on February 4, 2003, barring the student from the James Lick campus.
Summary
The father filed this expedited case for a 17-year-old student at James Lick High School in East Side Union High School District. The student was eligible for special education because of an expressive and receptive language disorder. He attended a special day class with some general education classes and had a one-to-one aide during academic periods only. In January 2003, the District suspended him and recommended expulsion. He allegedly hit a school employee on the head with a plastic water bottle during the brunch break. A manifestation determination team decided that his disability did not cause the conduct. The father challenged both the process and the result.
Hearing Officer Heather A. Hoyle ruled for the District. The father knew about the meeting and attended it. Team members did not have copies of the IEP and the three-year (triennial) assessment at the meeting, which was likely a procedural error. However, members had reviewed the documents beforehand, so it did not harm the student. The team met legal requirements. The student's therapist, his former case manager and a second teacher did not have to attend. On the merits, the school psychologist and other witnesses testified that the language disorder did not keep him from understanding the consequences of hitting an employee. It also did not keep him from controlling that behavior in a social setting. The student himself testified that he knew hitting a teacher was wrong. All relief was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO reviewed a manifestation determination under the 1997 IDEA regulations. The Hearing Officer called the missing document copies a likely procedural error but found no harm to the student. The Hearing Officer also separated conduct during social, non-academic time from earlier classroom incidents that had been found to be manifestations of the disability.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue 1a. Appropriateness of the manifestation determination meeting: whether the District gave proper notice, whether the team considered the proper information when copies of the IEP and triennial assessment were not at the meeting, and whether the team was properly composed (Petitioner contended a psychotherapist, former case manager and SDC teacher should have attended).
Father had actual notice and attended; not having document copies at the meeting was a probable procedural error but caused no prejudice because members had reviewed them beforehand; team composition met 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c) and Ed. Code § 56341, and the three named individuals were not required members.
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue 1b. Did the District appropriately determine that STUDENT's disability does not impair his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior that is subject to disciplinary action?
Credible testimony showed the student's language disorder did not keep him from understanding the consequences of allegedly striking a school employee during brunch; any joking atmosphere with staff did not change this.
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue 1c. Did the District appropriately determine that STUDENT's disability does not impair his ability to control his behavior that is the subject of disciplinary action?
The student's past behavior problems arose in academic situations, while this conduct occurred in a social, non-academic period. He had no history of violence, and evidence showed he could control the behavior.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- The District appropriately determined the conduct was not a manifestation of the disability; all requests for relief denied.
Key authorities
34 C.F.R. § 300.523; 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(b); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k); Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5; Cal. Educ. Code § 56341; Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5
People named in the decision
- Felton Owens, Director of special services, East Side Union High School District
- Carol Black, School psychologist; conducted triennial assessment and pre-expulsion review, East Side Union High School District (James Lick High School)
- Barbara Burton, Program specialist; special education department co-chair, James Lick High School, East Side Union High School District
- Linda Mora, Associate principal / District administrator, East Side Union High School District
- Victor Maestas, Associate principal, East Side Union High School District
- Steve Sellers, Former case manager / teacher, East Side Union High School District
- Ray Himenez, Special day class teacher, East Side Union High School District
- Susan Zaslow, School psychologist (witness for Student)
- Sasha Esposito, Psychotherapist, licensed marriage and family therapist (witness for Student), Pilot program for Mt. Pleasant SELPA
- Rosas, Case manager and teacher (attended manifestation meeting; first name redacted in text), East Side Union High School District
- Ray Martinez, Witness referenced as testifying that the student knows right from wrong (possibly a misnaming of Ray Himenez)
- Pinnacles, Nonpublic school recommended by District pending expulsion
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Heather A. Hoyle, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Jose, California, on February 18 and 19, 2003.
Petitioner (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by his father. Both STUDENT and his mother, were also present during portions of the hearing on behalf of STUDENT. East Side Union High School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Benjamin Nieberg from the law firm of Burke, Williams and Sorensen. Felton Owens, director of special services for the District was also present on behalf of Respondent.
The following witnesses were called to testify on behalf of the Petitioner: Steve Sellers, case manager; Sasha Esposito, psychotherapist; STUDENT, Petitioner; Ray Himenez, SDC teacher; and Susan Zaslow, school psychologist. The following witnesses were called to testify on behalf of the Respondent: Barbara Burton, program specialist and Linda Mora, associate principal.
Both parties called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Felton Owens, director of special services; Carol Black, school psychologist; and Victor Maestas, associate principal.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments on February 26, 2003, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING
Did the District appropriately determine that STUDENT’s behavior on January 15, 2003 was not a manifestation of his disability?
POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District failed to conduct an appropriate manifestation determination regarding STUDENT’s alleged conduct on January 15, 2003, and that STUDENT’s behavior subject to disciplinary action was a manifestation of his disability. Petitioner’s position is that due to the District’s failure to conduct the manifestation meeting properly and to provide him with adequate notice, he was not able to fully participate in the meeting. Petitioner alleges that the team members failed to consider the appropriate documents and in particular that the team members did not hand out copies of the Petitioner’s last agreed-upon IEP or evaluations at the meeting and some members did not have the documents physically present at the meeting. Petitioner asserts that the manifestation meeting did not include Sasha Esposito, Ray Himenez, and Steve Sellers as team members. In addition, Petitioner asserts that STUDENT’s disability impairs his ability to control his behavior and to know right from wrong.
The Respondent contends that the manifestation determination meeting held January 27, 2003, complied with applicable federal and State law. The manifestation team members determined that STUDENT’s alleged conduct on January 15, 2003, was not a manifestation of his disability. The Respondent’s position is that the composition of the manifestation team was appropriate. The Respondent further contends that after reviewing STUDENT’s placement, disability and the alleged conduct as well as hearing new information from the school psychologist, the team members appropriately determined that the alleged behavior was not a manifestation of STUDENT’s disability. The Respondent contends that it did give proper notice of the team meeting to Petitioner. In addition, the team members reviewed the appropriate information prior to making a determination regarding STUDENT’s disability and its effect on the conduct subject to discipline. In response to the Petitioner’s contention that team members did not have copies of the student’s IEP and evaluations passed out at the meeting, the District’s position is that copies of the documents are not necessarily required to be physically present during the manifestation team meeting.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old student who is currently eligible for special education services due to an expressive and receptive language disorder. No other areas of disability have been identified.
STUDENT first became eligible for special education services in 1992 as a first grader. At that time, STUDENT exhibited delays in speech and language. STUDENT has been placed in various special education settings over the years; however, for the majority of the time STUDENT has attended public school, he has been placed in a special day class setting with participation in regular education as determined appropriate. At times STUDENT has exhibited inappropriate behavior in the classroom, and behavior plans and strategies have been developed to address those behaviors. STUDENT’s high school educational placement has also been a combination of regular education classes as well as special day classes. Until STUDENT was suspended in January 2003, STUDENT attended James Lick High School. STUDENT has been assigned a one-to-one aide to assist him in academics within the classroom. STUDENT has not had an aide during passing periods or during lunch or other non-academic periods as the aide was to keep him on task academically.
In February 2000, the District conducted STUDENT’s most recent triennial assessment.(Footnote 1) As part of the triennial assessment, school psychologist Carol Black conducted a psychoeducational assessment and reviewed the results of other recent testing. Ms. Black’s assessment included use of the following tools: parent interview and review of development and medical history; review of school records; classroom observations; interview and observation of the student; teacher interviews and progress reports; General Assessment of Test Session Behavior (GATSB); Assessment of Mental Status and Basic Psychological Process, Minnesota Multi-Phasic Personality Test (MMPI) Adolescent; High School Personality Questionnaire, Sentence Completion; and the Slosson Oral Reading Test. Also reviewed by Ms. Black were previous psychological and speech assessments; Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC II); and the Woodcock-McGrew, Werder Mini Battery of Achievement. Based upon Ms. Black’s records review and assessments it was determined that a severe discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s intellectual ability and his achievement in the areas of reading and writing.
Additionally, Ms. Black’s triennial assessment included a review of STUDENT’s vision and hearing screening, as well as his social emotional functioning. His vision and hearing were within normal limits. Ms. Black also noted that it appears that STUDENT is unable to convert nonverbal cues socially, is easily distracted, and may have a difficult time waiting his turn. He may confuse similar sounds and has difficulty with phonetics in spelling and reading. Ms. Black also stated that based on the social-emotional tests administered, STUDENT suffers from anxiety, attention problems, a fear of failure, and a lack of understanding of the importance or value of school which results in some of the avoidance behaviors he exhibits in the classroom. STUDENT was also described having a competitive spirit, a good sense of humor, and as being creative and imaginative.
The parties have met numerous times over the last two school years to discuss STUDENT’s placement, and STUDENT’s most recent IEP was held on December 10, 2002. The parties were not in agreement regarding the services STUDENT requires, in particular the provision of one-to-one aide services, and Petitioner filed a due process hearing regarding that disagreement.(Footnote 2) STUDENT’s placement was not changed as a result of this IEP team meeting and his placement remained SDC with participation in regular education classes when appropriate.
On January 15, 2003, STUDENT allegedly assaulted a school employee during the brunch period of the school day. STUDENT allegedly hit the employee on the back of the head with a large plastic water bottle.(Footnote 3) The employee reported the incident to the school administration, and after STUDENT arrived at the school’s administrative office he was suspended and then arrested. STUDENT was initially suspended for five days and later was recommended for expulsion.
On January 27, 2003, the District convened an IEP team meeting to discuss whether STUDENT’s behavior, allegedly assaulting a school employee, was a manifestation of his disability. At the meeting Ms. Black reviewed the results of her investigation regarding the incident. The District team members then determined that STUDENT was appropriately placed at the time of the incident in relation to the behavior subject to discipline, and that his disability did not impair his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior or his ability to control his behavior that is the subject of disciplinary action and was not therefore a manifestation of his disability. The District IEP team members recommended placement at an NPS, Pinnacles, pending the expulsion process.
On January 27, 2003, STUDENT’s parents filed for a due process hearing because they disagreed with the District’s manifestation determination.(Footnote 4)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Did the District appropriately determine that STUDENT’s behavior on January15, 2003, was not a manifestation of his disability?
Both federal and State law provide that before a student with a disability can be expelled from school, the IEP team must determine that the conduct for which the student is being recommended for expulsion was not a manifestation of his or her disability.(Footnote 5) Pursuant to 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c)(Footnote 6) the IEP team and other qualified personnel may only determine that the conduct was not a manifestation of the child’s disability if they:
(1) First consider, in terms of the behavior subject to disciplinary action, all relevant information, including: (i) evaluation and diagnostic results, including the results of other relevant information supplied by the parents of the child; (ii) observations of the child; and (iii) the child’s IEP and placement; and (2) then determine that:
(i) in relationship to the behavior subject to disciplinary action, the child’s IEP and placement were appropriate and the special education services, supplementary aids and services, and behavior intervention strategies were provided consistent with the child’s IEP and placement; (ii) the child’s disability did not impair the ability of the child to understand the impact and consequences of the behavior subject to disciplinary action; and (iii) the child’s disability did not impair the ability of the child to control the behavior subject to disciplinary action
Appropriateness of manifestation determination meeting
Petitioner contends that the manifestation determination was procedurally inappropriate because he was not provided proper notice of the team meeting, Petitioner was not provided a copy of a “manifestation determination report” at the meeting, copies of the previous IEP and assessment were not provided to the team members at the meeting, and certain individuals were not invited to or present at the manifestation determination IEP team meeting held January 27, 2003.
Manifestation determination team meetings must be held within ten school days after the date the decision to take disciplinary action is made. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523 (a)(2). Generally, districts are required to provide reasonable notice to parents whenever an IEP team meeting is scheduled. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(b), Cal. Education Code § 56341.5. Typically notice of IEP team meetings are provided in writing and mailed to the parents’ home address. However, because manifestation determination meetings are subject to strict and short time limitations it may be necessary to provide that notice by telephone or otherwise, so long as it is reasonable and allows the parent the opportunity to participate. Felton Owens testified that he believes he told STUDENT’s father about the meeting on January 22, 2003, during a meeting between himself and STUDENT’s father regarding another student. (Footnote 7) Testimony of the District’s witnesses was that STUDENT’s father attended and participated in STUDENT’s manifestation determination meeting. Testimony of Ms. Black and Ms. Owens was that STUDENT’s father was aware of the upcoming manifestation determination meeting because he specifically requested Carol Black to conduct the review. Ms. Black visited STUDENT’s father and STUDENT at home to conduct an interview prior to the meeting. While it appears from testimony at hearing that there may have been rescheduling of the time of the manifestation determination meeting, STUDENT’s father was aware the meeting was approaching and did in fact attend the meeting. Mr. Owens testified credibly that STUDENT’s father was on notice of the meeting. STUDENT’s father did not testify at hearing and no evidence was presented establishing that he was not notified of the manifestation determination meeting. Based on the evidence presented, even if the District committed a procedural error regarding the provision of proper notice of the meeting, there was no prejudice to Petitioner. STUDENT’s father was able to attend and participate in the meeting.
Petitioner also contends that the IEP team members failed to consider the proper information at the manifestation determination meeting, that the team did not have copies of the documents the team reviewed, and that Ms. Black did not have copies of a “manifestation determination report.” While Petitioner alleges that the manifestation determination report was missing at the IEP team meeting, there is no legal requirement to develop a manifestation determination report to have at the team meeting. Ms. Black testified that she completed a “manifestation determination form” after the meeting on January 27, 2003, that reflects the team’s discussion and determination.
At the manifestation determination meeting, the IEP team is required to review all relevant information. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c)(1). In this case, STUDENT’s triennial evaluation was reviewed by Carol Black, who also completed an investigation and review of STUDENT’s records prior to the meeting.(Footnote 8) Ms Black testified that she went to Petitioner’s home and interviewed STUDENT and STUDENT’s parents, and also interviewed the school employee STUDENT allegedly assaulted. Ms. Black further testified that she reviewed the incident report completed by the District as well as STUDENT’s most recent pscyhoeducational report and IEP. (Footnote 9) Then, at the January 27, 2003 IEP meeting, Ms. Black reported to the team her observations which were based on the new information she obtained as a result of her interviews. Ms. Black and Mr. Owens also testified that the team discussed STUDENT and any effect his disability may have on his behavior based in part on a template school psychologists in the District use in manifestation determination meetings.(Footnote 10)
Testimony at hearing was that copies of the triennial assessment and the last agreed-upon IEP were not handed to each team member at the meeting and that the members did not all bring copies of those documents to the meeting. However, there was credible testimony by each of the District’s witnesses that they had reviewed STUDENT’s IEP and other documents prior to the meeting. No testimony was presented that STUDENT’s father did not review the documents or that he did not have them at the manifestation determination meeting. Actual possession of the previous IEP and assessment documents is not necessarily determinative of whether the IEP team members were able to meaningfully participate in the IEP meeting. By their very nature, IEP meetings involve a flow of information and verbal communication between the parties. The District IEP team members are all experienced teachers who had previously attended multiple IEP meetings, some of whom helped to develop the triennial IEP and were present when the assessment was first presented. Because an IEP meeting necessarily involves a continuous flow of information, all team members have the opportunity to voice their concerns or to question the outcome of a manifestation determination at any point in the meeting. In this case, no team member voiced any disagreement with the manifestation determination findings.
The failure to have copies of the documents at the meeting that the IEP team reviewed and relied on in making the manifestation determination regarding a student’s behavior likely constitutes a procedural error.(Footnote 11) However, in this case, it was not prejudicial to the Petitioner as the team members testified credibly that they were familiar with the documents and had reviewed them prior to the meeting. Furthermore, present at the manifestation meeting were members of STUDENT’s triennial IEP team where the assessment was first presented, and of his most recent IEP team which met on December 10, 2002. Moreover, no member of the manifestation determination team testified that having copies of these documents was necessary to reach a decision or would have altered their decision in STUDENT’s case. Whether or not the failure to have copies of the documents at the manifestation determination meeting reviewed in preparation for the manifestation determination meeting is a procedural violation, the Petitioner, in this matter, did not suffer any prejudice.(Footnote 12)
Federal law requires that a manifestation determination be conducted by “the IEP team and other qualified personnel in a meeting.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c). According to California Education Code section 56341, the IEP team consists of the pupil’s parents, at least one regular education teacher, at least one special education teacher, a representative of the district, individuals who conducted an assessment, and when appropriate the pupil. In this case, present at the January 27, 2003 IEP meeting were STUDENT’s father, Petitioner’s father, STUDENT Rosas, STUDENT’s case manager and teacher; Carol Black, the school psychologist; Barbara Burton, program specialist; Linda Mora, a District administrator; and Felton Owens, director of special services and also a credentialed regular education teacher. These individuals satisfy the legal requirements for the IEP team composition.(Footnote 13) The team members are knowledgeable about STUDENT’s needs and were involved in developing and determining his educational placement and services. Ms. Black had worked with STUDENT for approximately three years and she testified that, when STUDENT attended Oak Grove High School, she allowed STUDENT to come to her office whenever he felt he needed to, even during academic class periods. Ms. Black conducted STUDENT’s most recent triennial assessment and STUDENT’s father requested that she conduct the review for the manifestation determination meeting. Mr. Owens is the director of special services and he testified that he has known STUDENT for approximately three years. Mr. Owens testified that he has been at almost every one of STUDENT’s IEPs in the last three years and while he does not typically become involved in every student’s IEP team meeting he has a good relationship with Petitioner and in particular with STUDENT’s father who also represents other students in the District.(Footnote 14)
Petitioner alleges that Sasha Esposito, Steve Sellers, and Ray Himenez were not invited or present at the meeting and that they should have been in attendance. Sasha Esposito is a psychotherapist and first met STUDENT in October 2002. Ms. Esposito met with STUDENT approximately one time per week for approximately an hour.(Footnote 15) Ms. Esposito testified that she has not formally assessed STUDENT but is working to help him control his classroom behavior with academic strategies. Ms. Esposito testified that she does not necessarily consider herself a member of the IEP team. She sees her role as helping to determine STUDENT’s strengths and helping him to be successful academically. Steve Sellers is STUDENT’s former case manager.(Footnote 16) Mr. Sellers testified that he was not STUDENT’s current teacher or directly involved in STUDENT’s program or the alleged incident. Ray Himenez was one of STUDENT’s SDC teachers and did not attend the manifestation IEP team meeting.(Footnote 17) Mr. Himenez testified that he typically attends IEP team meetings but does not recall ever attending a manifestation determination meeting.
While all three individuals Petitioner alleges should have participated in the manifestation determination meeting do have experience with STUDENT, they are not necessary team members pursuant to 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c) and California Education Code section 56341. Moreover, Mr. Sellers is no longer STUDENT’s case manager. Ms. Espositio’s testimony indicates that she does not necessarily consider herself an IEP team member. Mr. Himenez was one STUDENT’s current teachers at the time of the meeting and could have been an IEP team member; however, it is not a legal requirement that all of a student’s teachers attend IEP team meetings. There was no evidence presented indicating that having these three individuals at the meeting would have changed the result of the manifestation determination. In fact all three individuals testified that based on their experience with STUDENT, he knows right from wrong and that they do not think that his disability affected his alleged behavior on January 15, 2003. As found above, the composition of the manifestation determination team meeting was appropriate and additionally, these individuals were not necessary team members. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c) and California Education Code section 56341.
The Hearing Officer finds that the manifestation determination meeting was appropriate despite the probable procedural error regarding the failure to provide copies of the documents at the meeting. That procedural flaw was not prejudicial to the Petitioner. The IEP team was comprised of appropriate team members knowledgeable about STUDENT, and the team considered the appropriate information including an oral presentation at the manifestation determination meeting by Ms. Black who conducted STUDENT’s most recent pscychoeducational assessment as well as a pre-expulsion review.
**** The Hearing Officer turns to the appropriateness of the manifestation determination. To determine whether STUDENT’s behavior was a manifestation of his disability, there are three factors to be considered: 1) whether STUDENT’s placement and services were provided appropriately in relation to the alleged conduct subject to discipline; 2) whether STUDENT’s disability impairs his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior subject to disciplinary action; and 3) whether STUDENT’s disability impairs his ability to control his behavior subject to disciplinary action. The first factor is not in contention as there is no dispute as to whether or not STUDENT was appropriately placed in relation to the alleged incident.(footnote 18) Thus, the Hearing Officer turns to the only two areas of contention: whether STUDENT’s disability impairs his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior subject to disciplinary action, and whether STUDENT’s disability impairs his ability to control his behavior subject to disciplinary action.
Did the District appropriately determine that STUDENT’s disability does not impair his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior that is subject to disciplinary action?
Petitioner’s position is that STUDENT’s disability affected his alleged conduct on January 15, 2003. In order for conduct subject to discipline to be found a manifestation of a student’s disability, the student’s disability must impair his ability to understand the impact and consequences the behavior subject to discipline. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c). STUDENT’s disability is identified as an expressive and receptive language disorder. Ms. Black testified that as STUDENT has grown older, he does not want to expose his disability in front of other students and he exhibited inappropriate behavior as a result. Testimony of Felton Owens, Victor Maestas and Steve Sellers all indicate that STUDENT is a popular well-liked student.(Footnote 19) STUDENT is very interested in music and has served as a disc jockey for school events and on the school campus. In particular Mr. Owens testified that STUDENT has worked for several years as an intern for a radio station in San Francisco. Mr. Sellers testified that while he has become frustrated with STUDENT and his failure to follow school rules, he likes STUDENT and “thinks he is a great kid.” The testimony of all of the District’s witnesses indicated that STUDENT is a likable student who participates socially with regular education students without intervention or accommodations.
Petitioner contends that the District’s employees fostered an atmosphere of joking around with STUDENT and that atmosphere, coupled with his disability, prevented STUDENT from understanding that his alleged behavior on January 15, 2003, was inappropriate. STUDENT testified that school staff would frequently “joke around” with him. STUDENT testified that for example, the staff would “rev” the engine of the golf carts the staff drives on the campus while headed toward him and tell him to get to class. STUDENT’s defense to his conduct on January 15, 2003, was that he was joking around and “tapped” the employee on the back of the head with the plastic water bottle to say “bye.” However, Ms. Black testified that STUDENT’s disability would not prevent him from understanding the consequences of his actions or from understanding what is appropriate behavior in a social setting such as the brunch period or from interacting appropriately in that setting with school employees. Ms. Black explained that an example of a joke that STUDENT may not understand due to his disability would be the “the lights are on but no one is home.” Ms. Black explained that STUDENT is very literal in his understanding of certain concepts and it would be harder for him to comprehend that statement. The Hearing Officer finds that even if the District staff did interact with STUDENT in a “joking” manner, no convincing evidence was presented that this atmosphere affected STUDENT’s ability to understand the consequences of behavior subject to disciplinary action.
Ms. Burton testified that she saw STUDENT on the school’s campus shortly after the alleged incident and that STUDENT appeared to be upset with his head down.(Footnote 20) Ms. Burton testified that she spoke to STUDENT, asking why he was not in class and he told her that he was in trouble and was on his way to the office, but he was just taking a minute to collect himself before going to the office. STUDENT’s testimony was similar and he indicated that when he saw Ms. Burton he was taking a “breather.” In addition, STUDENT testified that after the incident he tried to tell the employee he allegedly assaulted that he was sorry and later told Ms. Black that as well.(Footnote 21) STUDENT further testified that he liked this employee and had a good relationship with her. He also indicated that he knows the rules but when it comes down to it, it is difficult to him to remember about the rules. He stated that he does know right from wrong but “not in all things.” He testified that he thinks it is wrong to hit a teacher, and that to do so would “throw his whole career away.” Ms. Burton testified that based on her conversation with STUDENT shortly after the alleged incident he appeared to understand what he had done and know that there would be consequences to his actions. Ray Martinez, Steve Sellers, Barbara Burton, Carol Black and Victor Maestas all testified that STUDENT generally knows right from wrong and that he understands the consequences of his actions and in particular the consequences of assaulting a school employee.
Did the District appropriately determine that STUDENT’s disability does not impair his ability to control his behavior that is the subject of disciplinary action?
Petitioner also alleges that STUDENT’s disability impairs his ability to control his behavior subject to disciplinary action. As set forth above, in order for conduct subject to discipline to be found a manifestation of a student’s disability, the student’s disability must impair his ability to control his behavior subject to discipline. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c)
Testimony at hearing was that STUDENT has exhibited inappropriate behaviors in the past, but that the majority of those behaviors were “petty” and involved pushing the limits with teachers and other authority figures as well as not being prepared for class.(footnote 22) Ms. Black testified that she was involved with another manifestation determination review of STUDENT’s behavior while he was attending school in the District when he attended Oak Grove High School. In that case STUDENT’s behavior was found to be a manifestation of his disability because a teacher challenged him in an academic setting and then in an attempt to escape that situation STUDENT pushed another person while making his way toward the door. Ms. Black testified that the conduct currently subject to discipline occurred during the brunch period, a social nonacademic period and therefore the conduct on January 15, 2003, differed from the prior incident. Ms. Black further testified that STUDENT’s past behavior issues have stemmed from academic situations and that STUDENT has not exhibited difficulty with socialization or “fitting in” with regular education students or with adults in social settings. There was not testimony presented at hearing that STUDENT has a history of violent actions or of striking other individuals. STUDENT and his father requested, and the District concurred, that STUDENT did not require an aide during passing periods and lunch or brunch. STUDENT’s disability does not require aide services during non-academic periods because the aide’s role has been limited to help STUDENT focus on academic tasks in the classroom.
The District’s witnesses further testified that STUDENT does not always follow school rules such as being on time to class, or returning to class after being provided a restroom pass. They testified that STUDENT knows the rules but chooses not to follow them. A document titled “Accommodations and Strategies Agreement” dated November 14, 2001, states that “ [STUDENT] will assume responsibility for his behavior in the classroom and the resolution of problems using structures in place at school.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit H) Mr. Sellers, STUDENT’s former case manager testified that in his experience with STUDENT, he has found that STUDENT is capable of following the rules but he always has an excuse for why he does not do so.
The Hearing Officer finds that based on credible testimony and documentary evidence presented the District did appropriately determine that STUDENT’s alleged conduct subject to discipline was not a manifestation of his disability because STUDENT’s disability did not impair his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his actions subject to disciplinary action or impair his ability to control the behavior subject to disciplinary action.
***** To summarize, the District considered the appropriate factors related to STUDENT’s expulsion: 1) whether STUDENT’s placement and services were provided appropriately in relation to the alleged conduct subject to discipline; 2) whether STUDENT’s disability impairs his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior subject to disciplinary action; and 3) whether STUDENT’s disability impairs his ability to control his behavior subject to disciplinary action. In conducting the manifestation determination review of STUDENT’s conduct, the District convened an appropriate IEP team and that team considered the relevant information as required by the law. The team’s conclusion that STUDENT’s behavior subject to discipline was not a manifestation of his disability is supported by the evidence presented in this case, and was in conformance the legal requirements. Therefore, the District’s determination that STUDENT’s conduct of allegedly striking an employee was not a manifestation of his disability of expressive and receptive language disorder was proper.
ORDER
1. The District appropriately determined that Petitioner’s conduct was not a manifestation of his disability.
2. All requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 5607(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: Respondent prevailed on the issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: March 14, 2003 ______________________________ Heather A. Hoyle, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Ms. Black’s “Three-Year Evaluation/Progress Report” is dated February 28, 2000. Respondent’s Exhibit 4. 2. Petitioner’s initial request for a due process hearing regarding the disagreement between the parties as to the appropriate placement and services for STUDENT was identified as SN02-02565. Prior to the start of the hearing scheduled for case no SN02-02565 the Hearing Office became aware that the issues for hearing involved issues that were expedited hearing issues as well as those that were not expedited hearing issues. Therefore, the expedited hearing issue regarding the manifestation determination conducted by the District was identified as a separate due process hearing request and was assigned case number: SN3-00308. The remaining issues between the parties are the subject of case number SN02-02565 and will not be addressed in this Decision. 3. This Decision does not address whether or not the conduct on January 15, 2003, occurred and therefore will refer the to conduct subject to discipline as “alleged.” 4. Petitioner requested a stay put order from the Hearing Office on January 27, 2003. The order was denied on February 10, 2003, as the District had sought and been granted a temporary restraining order on February 4, 2003, which prevented STUDENT from returning to the James Lick High School campus. No testimony was offered regarding STUDENT’s placement at the time of the hearing; however, it appears that STUDENT was not then attending school. 5. This hearing is being held pursuant to expedited hearing procedures provided for the review of manifestation determinations pursuant to 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.523-300.528. The issues are limited to review of the procedures used in making that determination and the conclusions concerning whether the behavior in question was a manifestation of the Petitioner’s disability. It is not within the scope of this Decision to determine other issues such as whether the alleged conduct occurred or whether the proposed discipline is appropriate 6.. Effective January 1, 2003, California Education Code section 48915.5 was amended to incorporate federal law regarding discipline of special education students. The section now provides that: “An individual with exceptional needs, as defined in Section 56026, may be suspended or expelled from school in accordance with subsection (k) of Section 1415 of Title 20 of the United States Code, the discipline provisions contained in Sections 300.519 through 300.529 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, and other provisions of this part that do not conflict with federal law and regulations.” Thus federal and State laws are identical regarding the requirements for conducting a manifestation determination. 7. Mr. Owens testified that he has worked for thirty-two years in the District and has served for three yeas as the director of special services. Prior to that Mr. Owens has been a special day class teacher, a transition specialist, a principal as well as other positions within the District. 8. Ms. Black testified that she has been a school psychologist for thirteen years and has been a school psychologist at James Lick for the last five years. Prior to becoming a school psychologist, Ms. Black taught elementary school. 9. STUDENT’s last IEP team meeting prior to the incident was held December 10, 2002. 10. The manifestation determination template the District used is consistent with the legal requirements and applicable factors for a manifestation determination as they apply to this case. 11. In many instances busy teachers and school administrators cannot be expected to read and remember what may be complex information contained in the relevant documents that will be relied on in manifestation determination meetings. Having copies of the documents allows the team to share a common core of information that can be considered in reaching a manifestation determination. 12. The Hearing Officer notes that while in this specific case no prejudice was found based on the District’s failure to provide copies of documents at the meeting, districts should have copies of the documents at the meeting that are reviewed and relied on at manifestation determination meetings. 13. No issue was raised with respect to the composition of the IEP team, other than the three individuals Petitioner contends should have attended. 14. Mr. Owens testified that STUDENT’s father works to help other students in the District and therefore he meets with STUDENT’s father regularly. 15. Ms. Esposito is a licensed marriage and family therapist and specializes in behavior. Ms. Esposito has worked with children for approximately eight years and has been a licensed therapist for two years. Ms. Esposito is working in a pilot program for the Mt. Pleasant SELPA to provide support for at risk students 16. Mr. Sellers testified that he has been a teacher for the last nine years and has a clear teaching credential. 17. Mr. Himenez testified that he has taught for eighteen years as a special day class for the District. 18. State and federal law do not require a District to establish that a pupil’s program and placement were appropriate in all respects to meet his special education needs in order to discipline a disabled student, but rather require a review of the appropriateness of the program and placement as it relates to the specific conduct that may be subject to discipline. See 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4)(C)(ii)(I); Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5. If a program or placement is defective in some way, there must be a logical nexus between the defect and the misconduct in order to bar the District from taking disciplinary action. During the second day of hearing, the parties stipulated that while Petitioner does not agree with the placement STUDENT was in at the time of the incident, it was not an issue with regard to STUDENT’s alleged conduct on January 15, 2003. Therefore this factor of the manifestation determination will not be discussed further in this Decision. 19. Mr. Maestas testified that he has been an associate principal for the District for the last thirteen years. 20. Ms. Burton testified that she was worked with the District since 1993 and currently holds the position of department co-chair of special education at James Lick. 21. This indicates that STUDENT knew that he had done something wrong and that he clearly understood that his behavior on January 15, 2003, required that he apologize for his actions. 22.Mr. Maestas provided examples of this behavior including being late for class and failing to follow the school’s common dress policy.
