California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 5, 2002
Student v. Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 31-02 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel
Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified denied FAPE for nearly two years after an improper expulsion; reimbursement and compensatory education ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes that a related federal court complaint filed August 23, 2000 was dismissed on October 23, 2000 for failure to exhaust administrative remedies, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed on March 4, 2002. The due process case was off calendar from November 1999 until it was returned in August 2001. The Hearing Officer recommended that any court deny fees for the advocates' services and strongly consider reducing or denying attorney's fees for Student's counsel. Compensatory education was sent back to an IEP team, with a review at the end of 2002-2003.
Summary
A parent filed for due process in October 1999 against Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District. Los Angeles County Mental Health (LACMH) was added later. The student, now a 12-year-old sixth grader, was eligible as emotionally disturbed. After an October 1999 incident, the District suspended her and moved her to home teaching. It did not do a preexpulsion assessment or hold a manifestation IEP meeting. In December 1999 it stopped home teaching. She then received no educational services for about 22 months, though LACMH counseling continued.
The Hearing Officer found that before the incident, the District followed her behavior plan and LACMH properly monitored her medication. The removal, however, was an expulsion without the required procedures and violated stay put. The District also held no annual IEP meeting, made no offer, and postponed an April 2001 meeting because the parent brought an advocate. At the August 2001 IEP meeting, it shut the parent out of the placement decision. FAPE was denied from October 13, 1999 to September 12, 2001. The September 2001 offer of Alan B. Shepard, a county office program, was a FAPE. She did not qualify as learning disabled or speech-language impaired. The District must repay activity-class tuition and mileage to classes and counseling. Claims for child care, advocate fees, Lindamood-Bell, private school tuition, and lost wages were denied. An IEP team must set compensatory tutoring and social skills training.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated an informal move to home teaching after a behavior incident as an expulsion that required a manifestation review. It also held that the duty to hold IEP meetings and make offers continues when parents disengage. A parent may bring an advocate to an IEP meeting without special notice.
Issues and holdings
Issue Preliminary. Whether Petitioner may raise the District's alleged failure to timely assess after the parent's December 1997 request, given the mediated resolution of prior case SN98-00665.
The 1997-1998 assessment claim was resolved by mediated agreements in the prior due process case and is barred.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1a. Did Respondents deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year (September 7 to October 13, 1999): whether the District failed to follow the behavior intervention plan in the IEP.
The teacher used all BIP strategies and kept the parent informed; the program conformed to the IEP.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b. Did LACMH fail to properly advise the parent of Zoloft side effects and fail to properly monitor the medication (September 7 to October 13, 1999)?
LACMH prescribed an appropriate medication, informed the parent of side effects, monitored it, and stopped it promptly; no denial of FAPE by LACMH.
- Student prevailedDiscipline
Issue 1c. Did the District deny a FAPE from October 13, 1999 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year by failing to follow IDEA procedural safeguards after the incident?
The removal was an expulsion done without a preexpulsion assessment or manifestation IEP; the District violated stay put and ended home teaching, a total denial of FAPE.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?
The District provided no services, held no annual IEP, made no offer, and postponed the April 2001 IEP because the parent brought an advocate, missing the 50-day timeline; FAPE denied (not as to LACMH).
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3a. 2001-2002 school year (September 4 to October 22, 2001): whether the District denied the parent participation at the August 15, 2001 IEP meeting and continued to fail to return Student to her placement.
The District dismissed the team without letting the parent take part in the placement decision; combined with no placement, this denied FAPE through September 12, 2001.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 3b. Did the District fail to identify STUDENT as having a specific learning disability at the September 12, 2001 IEP?
Testing showed no severe discrepancy between ability and achievement, so she did not qualify as learning disabled.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 3c. Did the District fail to find STUDENT eligible as a student with a speech or language impairment?
She scored below the 7th percentile on only one test (TOPS) and above average on the TOPL; she did not meet the speech or language criteria.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3d. Was the offer of placement at Alan B. Shepard designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs?
The September 12, 2001 IEP and Alan B. Shepard program, with LACMH counseling, met her needs; there was no evidence that she needed peers of a particular racial makeup.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4a. Reimbursement for child care ($20,400)
Child care is a parental need, not an educational service; denied.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4b. Reimbursement for the cost of an advocate (approximately $1,500)
The advocates' services were in the nature of attorney's services, not reimbursable educational services; denied.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4c. Reimbursement for activity classes ($3,700)
The classes met some social-emotional needs and gave educational benefit; reimbursement granted only for documented tuition.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4d. Reimbursement for Lindamood-Bell services ($6,335)
No evidence showed the services addressed her needs or gave benefit; denied.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4e. Reimbursement for placement at Coast Christian School (approximately $1,000)
Records showed the school did not meet her needs and she did not benefit; denied.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4f. Reimbursement for transportation costs to all of the above ($3,773.03)
Mileage reimbursed for the activity classes and for LACMH individual and family counseling sessions, to the extent not already paid; otherwise denied.
- District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 4g. Reimbursement for earnings MOTHER lost due to missed work ($12,672)
Lost wages are damages, which the Hearing Officer has no authority to award.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
She is entitled to academic tutoring and social skills training; because of little evidence on amounts, the issue was sent to an IEP team with specific guidelines.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days, District to reimburse the parent $1,151 for tuition for activity classes listed in Student's Exhibit KKK (jazz, gymnastics, Shoot-Sparks at South Bay Y, 2000 camp classes at South Bay Y, etiquette and swimming through Torrance Parks and Recreation). The body of the decision finds $1,515 in documented tuition.
- Reimbursement. Mileage for transporting Student to the activity classes. The parent must submit proof within 25 calendar days. The District must reimburse at its employee mileage rate within 30 calendar days of receiving the proof.
- Reimbursement. Mileage for transporting Student to LACMH individual and family counseling from October 13, 1999 through September 12, 2001. The parent must submit proof within 25 calendar days. The District must reimburse at its employee rate within 30 days of receiving the proof, less any amounts already paid.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days, District to convene an IEP meeting to decide the type and amount of compensatory academic tutoring and social skills training. The team must use curriculum-based measures (end of third grade and current), State standards for grades 4–5, LACMH input, the student's wishes, multi-year needs, and summer programs.
- Compensatory education. Compensatory academic tutoring and social skills training for the nearly two-year denial of FAPE; amount to be set by the IEP team.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. An IEP team meeting to be held at the conclusion of the 2002-2003 school year to review compensatory education.
Total: $1,151 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; School Committee of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; Florence County v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Board of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education; Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5; Cal. Educ. Code § 56344; Cal. Educ. Code § 56341
People named in the decision
- Roni Goodman, District program specialist, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Lynn Busia, Director of pupil services / special education, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Helen Sowell, Nonpublic school coordinator, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Susan Kenner, Special day class teacher (Montemalaga), Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Rochelle Espinoza, Assistant director of Kids' Corner after-school program, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Lindy Neal-Hughes, Former school psychologist; conducted functional behavior analysis and BIP, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Ms. Meyer, School psychologist (1998 assessment), Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Dr. Bonney (also spelled Bonnie), School psychologist; multidisciplinary team report 2001, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Ms. Roush, Speech-language pathologist (2001 evaluation), Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Sharon Watt, District attorney at August 15, 2001 IEP meeting, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Deborah Smith, Program head, Los Angeles County Mental Health
- Dolores Spielman, Supervisor of psychiatric social work, Los Angeles County Mental Health
- Michael Malkin, Psychiatrist; witness for LACMH, Los Angeles County Mental Health
- Dr. Roberts, Psychiatrist who prescribed medication, Los Angeles County Mental Health
- Amy Eisman, Counselor, Los Angeles County Mental Health
- Thelma Young, Staff member, Los Angeles County Mental Health
- Dr. Ahmadnia, Student's therapist, LACMH-contracted provider
- Michele Linden, Psychologist; former private counselor and later director of LACMH-contracted outpatient provider, Private provider
- Sheila Maddox, School psychologist, Los Angeles County Office of Education
- Adair Teller, Assistant principal / program administrator, Alan B. Shepard, Los Angeles County Office of Education
- Dena Sharp, Staff member who toured placements, Los Angeles County Office of Education
- Christopher Russell, Non-attorney advocate for parent
- Virginia Russell, Non-attorney advocate for parent
- Rodney Ford, Staff of student's counsel, Office of Tania Whiteleather
- Felicia Silva, Proposed witness (testimony not allowed), Lindamood-Bell
- Lindamood-Bell, Private reading/language remediation provider
- Coast Christian School, Private school (unilateral placement)
- Alan B. Shepard, LACOE special day class program, Los Angeles County Office of Education
- Rossier Park, Nonpublic school offered August 2001
- Switzer School, Nonpublic school considered
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Palos Verdes, California, on March 7 and 8, April 16 and 17, May 1, 2, and 3, and June 11, 12, 14, 18, and 19, 2002.
STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Tania Whiteleather. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was MOTHER, and Christopher Russell, her advocate (present on April 16, 17, May 1, 2, 3, and June 18), and Rodney Ford, from Ms. Whiteleather’s office (present on June 14 and 18 only). Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Andrew Arczynski. Also present on the District’s behalf was Roni Goodman, District program specialist. Los Angeles County Mental Health (LACMH) was added to this case after the hearing on March 8, and was present from April 16 through the conclusion of the hearing. LACMH was represented at the hearing by Paul McIver. Also present on LACMH’s behalf was Deborah Smith, program head.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Christopher Russell, advocate; MOTHER; Virginia Russell, advocate; Roni Goodman, program specialist; Michele Linden, psychologist; Lindy Neal-Hughes, former school psychologist; Lynn Busia, director of pupil services; Dolores Spielman, supervisor of psychiatric social work; GRANDMOTHER; and Sheila Maddox, Los Angeles County Office of Education school psychologist.
The District recalled Roni Goodman, and called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Helen Sowell, non-public school coordinator; Susan Kenner, teacher; Rochelle Espinoza, assistant director of Kids Corner; Adair Teller, Los Angeles County Office of
LACMH called only one witness to testify at the hearing: Michael Malkin, psychiatrist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the briefs on July 24, 2002, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Did Respondents deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year?
2. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?
3. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year for the time period September 4, 2001 through October 22, 2001?
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following expenses: Reimbursement for child care ($20,400)
Reimbursement for the cost of an advocate (approximately $1,500) Reimbursement for activity classes ($3,700)
Reimbursement for Lindamood-Bell services ($6,335)
Reimbursement for placement at Coast Christian School (approximately $1,000)
Reimbursement for transportation costs to all of the above ($3,773.03) Reimbursement for earnings MOTHER lost due to missed work ($12,672)?
5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
One of the issues originally raised by Petitioner was the District’s alleged failure to assess Petitioner in a timely manner following the parent’s request for an assessment in December 1997. The District argued that this issue was barred by the mediated resolution of a prior due process matter between these same parties. In 1998 Petitioner filed a request for a due process hearing (case number SN98-00665) alleging that the District had not properly assessed STUDENT following the parent’s December 1997 request for assessments. MOTHER was represented in that matter by Virginia Russell. In June 1998, the parties reached a mediated interim agreement, agreeing to hold an interim IEP team meeting, conduct additional assessments, and to hold another IEP team meeting following completion of the new assessments. The additional assessments were conducted and an IEP team meeting was held on September 30, 1998. At that meeting it was agreed to revise STUDENT’s eligibility statement, modify the goals and objectives, and to incorporate a behavior intervention plan into the IEP. A mediation was held following the IEP team meeting and a second interim agreement was reached. This agreement called for the implementation of the September 30, 1998 IEP and a District referral to LACMH for an AB3632 assessment. These actions were taken, and Petitioner, through her advocate, voluntarily withdrew due process case number SN98-00665.
California law requires the Hearing Office to encourage settlement of special education disputes by mediation. Ca. Educ. Code § 56500.3. For the parties to be willing to resolve these disputes by settlement, they must have a reasonable assurance that issues settled in mediation will not be raised again, and subject to litigation in the future. The issue relating to the 1997-1998 assessments raised in this matter is identical to the issue resolved in case number SN98-00665. The mediated agreements reached in the prior case dealt specifically with the issue of assessment. In particular, the second agreement, though labeled as an “interim agreement,” was actually a final partial agreement because it evidenced agreement on resolution of the assessment and eligibility issues. Virginia Russell testified that she withdrew the prior case because she believed that all issues relating to assessment had been resolved by the mediated agreements. On the basis of these facts, the Hearing Officer finds that the issue Petitioner seeks to raise in this matter relating to the 1997-1998 assessment of STUDENT was resolved by mediation in the prior matter, and therefore Petitioner is barred from raising that issue at this time.
RELEVANT BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a twelve-year-old sixth grader attending a Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE) program on the Miraleste campus in the Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District (District). STUDENT has been a resident of the District at all times relevant to this Decision. STUDENT was referred for assessment at the request of her mother in December 1997. The initial assessment plan, signed by MOTHER on March 3, 1998, called for STUDENT to be assessed in the areas of academic achievement, social/emotional development, motor ability, speech and language, general ability, audiology, and health and development. The speech language specialist found that STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills were within normal limits; however, STUDENT had articulation problems involving the production of the “r” phoneme in all linguistic contexts. The results of the other assessments indicated STUDENT had and IQ of 110, placing her in the high average range of intellectual functioning, and her achievement scores were in the average to high average range. Additional testing indicated that STUDENT had difficulty maintaining attention. During testing it was observed that STUDENT would try to take control of the situation and to change the direction of activities. It was noted that those types of inappropriate behavior had been seen in other settings. Ms. Meyer, the school psychologist, concluded that, although STUDENT exhibited serious behavior problems and some emotional maladjustments, she did not meet the statutory criteria for a “serious emotional disturbance.” An IEP team meeting was held on June 4, 1998. The IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a speech impairment, drafted goals and objectives, and offered speech therapy, counseling, and RSP placement.
MOTHER, believing that the District was not responding to STUDENT’s behavior problems, filed a request for a due process hearing. MOTHER retained the services of Virginia and Christopher Russell as her advocates to represent her in that matter. MOTHER testified that STUDENT had been having behavior problems since kindergarten (1995). STUDENT had been seeing Michele Linden, a psychologist, for counseling since 1996. Dr. Linden reported a history of anxiety, depression, attention problems, and aggression. Dr. Linden diagnosed STUDENT with major depression, moderate in degree, and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.
On June 30, 1998, MOTHER and the District reached an interim agreement in the due process matter. This agreement called for additional assessments in the areas of occupational therapy, social/emotional functioning, and a functional behavioral analysis.
Lindy Neal-Hughes, an educational psychologist, performed the functional behavior analysis and drafted a report dated September 25, 1998. Ms. Neal-Hughes reported that STUDENT had a history of having difficulty following school rules with aggressive behavior such as pushing, choking, hitting and kicking. There were also safety concerns due to STUDENT’s impulsivity and poor judgment (STUDENT had been found in the boy’s bathroom attempting to put a paperclip in the electrical socket.) Ms. Neal-Hughes charted STUDENT’s challenging behaviors over a two-day observation period with the following results:
Seeking validation from the teacher 16 events Off task behavior 8 events Impulsivity 6 events Talking at inappropriate times 3 events Aggression 2 events
Ms. Neal-Hughes concluded that STUDENT’s challenging behaviors were stress-induced and had communicative intent, but were disruptive in nature. She stated that many of STUDENT’s behaviors were an attempt to draw attention to herself, allay anxiety, and gain comfort. Based upon her analysis Ms. Neal-Hughes developed a positive behavioral intervention plan (BIP). Ms. Neal-Hughes testified that the basics of the plan called for the staff to give STUDENT frequent validation and to redirect her when she was engaging in challenging behaviors.
An IEP team meeting was held on September 30, 1998. New goals and objectives were drafted and the BIP recommended by Ms. Neal-Hughes was adopted. After the IEP team meeting, a mediation was held at which the parties reached a partial final agreement calling for the implementation of the September 30 IEP and calling for a referral to LACMH for an AB3632 assessment. On November 20, 1998, LACMH completed its assessment. Particular areas of concern included mood lability, depression, anxiety, low self esteem, low frustration tolerance, oppositional and defiant behaviors, and difficulty following directions. It was concluded that STUDENT qualified for LACMH services under AB3632. MOTHER and her advocate agreed to withdraw the due process matter.
At this time, STUDENT was also attending Kids’ Corner, an after-school day care program operated by the District. On September 25, 1998, Ms. Espinoza, the assistant director of Kids’ Corner, wrote to MOTHER about ongoing problems they had been having with STUDENT. STUDENT had been unable to control her anger and had actually hurt other children at times. Ms. Espinoza warned MOTHER that if there were any more incidents STUDENT would be removed from the program. On January 20, 1999, Ms. Espinoza again wrote to MOTHER, informing her that STUDENT was no longer allowed to go to Kids’ Corner. Ms. Espinoza stated that STUDENT had intentionally hurt three other children on January 15.
An IEP team meeting was held on February 11, 1999. The team changed STUDENT’s primary eligibility to “emotionally disturbed” and STUDENT’s placement was changed to a special day class at the Montemalaga campus (a District school). STUDENT was to receive individual counseling from LACMH once a week, family counseling once a week, and speech and language therapy twice a week.
On April 16, 1999, an IEP team meeting was held to review STUDENT’s transition to the special day class. Individual counseling was increased from once a week to twice a week. It was noted that STUDENT had had a few incidents of aggression since her transition, and it was agreed to add an aide from lunchtime through the end of the day. During the 1999 summer, STUDENT attended Ms. Kenner’s summer school class at Montemalaga. STUDENT was made a “peer tutor” that summer because Ms. Kenner believed that it would allow STUDENT to feel in control, while still getting her to participate in the program. STUDENT did very well with a minimum of behavior problems. At the end of the summer, on September 9, Dr. Roberts (a LACMH psychiatrist) prescribed Zoloft for STUDENT. The records indicate that Dr. Roberts discussed possible side effects with MOTHER. Due to some logistical problems, STUDENT did not actually start taking Zoloft until September 20.
On September 7, 1999, STUDENT began the fourth grade in Ms. Kenner’s special day class. School went very well at first, though STUDENT began displaying increasingly defiant behavior during the second week of school. STUDENT would refuse to follow directions and, at times, stop responding altogether. One of her most consistent problems was her refusal to go to her mainstream class after lunch. Ms. Kenner testified that she had to spend a great deal of time with STUDENT getting her to calm down and comply. STUDENT also began threatening to leave school and walk home. Ms. Kenner tried several tactics to work through STUDENT’s defiance. At one point, STUDENT hid with another student after recess. Ms. Kenner became very concerned, and she and other school staff spent 20 minutes searching for STUDENT and the other student before they were found. On another day, STUDENT actually left campus and was found standing on the other side of the school fence, refusing to come back. On another occasion, STUDENT became extremely upset when she was not allowed to play with one of her friends. STUDENT became so agitated that she pinched Ms. Kenner when Ms. Kenner was in the process of phoning STUDENT’s mother. Ms. Kenner kept MOTHER informed of all of STUDENT’s behavior problems through the use of a daily behavior report. On October 7, Ms. Kenner and other school staff met with MOTHER to discuss STUDENT’s growing behavior problems. The school staff informed MOTHER that if STUDENT left the campus the school would have to call the police. MOTHER was not happy with this plan and wanted a formal IEP meeting at which she could be accompanied by one of her advocates.
On October 13, 1999, there was a serious incident at school involving STUDENT. The incident started with STUDENT trying to pass a note to one of her friends in class. The other student was trying to do his work and wanted STUDENT to leave him alone. The incident escalated until both students were shouting. Ms. Kenner took both students out of class and left them at the principal’s office so that she could return to her class. When Ms. Kenner returned to the office, she found files on the floor and STUDENT outside with two police officers. The principal told Ms. Kenner that STUDENT had scratched her and showed Ms. Kenner her injury. The school principal reported to the police that STUDENT had become so upset that she and a teacher had tried to physically restrain her. It was during this restraint that STUDENT had scratched the principal. STUDENT was released into the custody of MOTHER, and suspended for three days (which was letter increased to five days). Later that day MOTHER contacted the Russells. On October 18, 1999, Christopher Russell filed this due process matter in which MOTHER stated that she thought that STUDENT would need a private school placement and that she was “not willing to submit STUDENT to anymore of their [the District’s] punishment.”
On October 13, after the incident, MOTHER spoke with Amy Eisman, STUDENT’s LACMH counselor. MOTHER told Ms. Eisman about the incident at school and that she thought STUDENT’s behavior might have been a reaction to the Zoloft. Ms. Eisman passed this information on to Dr. Roberts, and the records show that Dr. Roberts took STUDENT off Zoloft on the 14th. Also on October 14, MOTHER told Ms. Eisman that she did not want STUDENT to return to Montemalaga because she did not believe the staff were meeting STUDENT’s needs.
MOTHER testified that on the Monday following the incident (October 20) she received a call from a Montemalaga staff member who informed her that STUDENT could not return to Montemalaga. Both MOTHER and Ms. Kenner recalled that there was a meeting (though neither could remember exactly when the meeting occurred) at which it was agreed that STUDENT would be provided home schooling until a placement decision could be made. On October 18, 1999, Lynn Busia, the director of special education for the District, signed an order for STUDENT to begin receiving home teaching. Home teaching was provided at STUDENT’s grandmother’s house, in San Pedro, beginning on October 25, 1999.
Helen Sowell, the District’s nonpublic school (NPS) coordinator, was brought in to work with MOTHER in trying to identify an appropriate placement. Based upon the information she was given about STUDENT’s history, Ms. Sowell investigated special day class placements for a bright student with behavior problems who needed on-site counseling services. Ms. Sowell identified the Switzer School, an NPS in Torrance, and the Mark Twain, Carr, and Alan B. Shepard schools, all of which were operated by LACOE. Alan B. Shepard was the farthest away, involving a 30- to 45-minute bus ride each way.
On October 26, 1999, Ms. Sowell, MOTHER, Christopher Russell and Dena Sharp (from LACOE) visited these four schools. For various reasons, MOTHER did not like any of the schools. Mark Twain’s class was in a “portable” some distance away from the regular campus. MOTHER commented that it was in the middle of nowhere. The Carr school special day class was on the regular education campus. However, MOTHER felt that the students were too disruptive and that the academic level was too low. Ms. Sowell also recalled that MOTHER was concerned about the ethnic make-up of the class, that STUDENT would be the only white student there. Alan B. Shepard was a new program designed for higher functioning students with behavior problems, but MOTHER was concerned because the class got out at 1:30 p.m. and she was not sure what STUDENT would do until the end of the regular school day. Ms. Sharp and Ms. Sowell offered to try to work on this problem and develop an appropriate after-school plan for STUDENT. MOTHER recalled that the student population at Shepard was mostly black and Hispanic (similar to the Carr school), and she was afraid STUDENT would feel isolated. At the Switzer school, STUDENT would have been the only girl and most of the student population was much older, including students all the way up to the twelfth grade. MOTHER was concerned that STUDENT would feel isolated and intimidated. Ms. Sowell also referred MOTHER to the Rossier school in Buena Park, but did not accompany her on the visit to that school. At Rossier, MOTHER recalled witnessing a student being physically dragged across campus by school staff. MOTHER felt also that the campus looked like a prison.
On November 1, 1999, Christopher Russell, by letter to the District’s attorney, agreed to take this due process matter off calendar. The case was officially taken off calendar on November 8, 1999. An IEP team meeting was held on November 10, 1999. Christopher Russell and Virginia Russell accompanied MOTHER to this meeting. At the meeting, Ms. Kenner gave a lengthy review of STUDENT’s academic and behavioral progress. She recounted the events of October 13 in some detail. Ms. Kenner stated that she believed that STUDENT’s behavioral needs were more than she could handle at Montemalaga. Amy Eisman, STUDENT’s counselor, also reported on STUDENT’s progress in therapy. According to the IEP document, Ms. Eisman stated that she did not believe a return to Montemalaga would be appropriate. The team discussed the need for a special day class placement with appropriate clinical support available on campus. The IEP document indicates that MOTHER discussed the schools she had visited. MOTHER recalls stating the reasons she did not like any of those schools. The District offered placement at Alan B. Shepard, and it was agreed that MOTHER, accompanied by Ms. Kenner, would visit that campus again. MOTHER also stated that she wanted STUDENT seen by a different therapist. The team agreed that LACMH would facilitate this change. It was planned that the IEP team would reconvene on November 30 and that home schooling would continue until an appropriate placement could be found. It does not appear that a second visit to Alan B. Shepard actually took place.
The next IEP meeting took place on November 30, 1999. MOTHER was again accompanied by Virginia and Christopher Russell. Adair Teller, the assistant principal at Alan B. Shepard, presented information about the program at Alan B. Shepard. The IEP document indicates the MOTHER stated that she did not feel any of the campuses she had visited were appropriate for STUDENT. MOTHER was concerned that STUDENT would not have peers she could identify with at Alan B. Shepard. MOTHER was also concerned about the after-school arrangements. It was again agreed that MOTHER would visit Alan B. Shepard, this time accompanied by Ms. Teller. Ms. Sowell was to arrange for STUDENT’s transportation to LACMH counseling pending a decision on school placement. There was no further visit to Alan B. Shepard.
On December 6, 1999, the District stopped providing home teaching. Ms. Busia testified that she stopped the home teaching after she learned that the home teacher was having to travel outside the District to provide the instruction, contrary to District policy. Ms. Busia recalled having a phone conversation with MOTHER during which she explained the reasons for stopping the home schooling. From this time until September 2001, STUDENT did not receive any educational services from the District. STUDENT did continue to receive individual and family therapy from LACMH.
For the next 22 months, STUDENT spent the majority of her time in day care with either her grandmother or a friend of MOTHER. MOTHER also enrolled STUDENT in various classes, such as dance, gymnastics, tennis, basketball, art, drama, and reading and math. Throughout these 22 months, almost all communications with the District were handled directly by the Russells or Tania Whiteleather, MOTHER’s attorney.
Between December 1999 and February 2000, there was a series of letters between the Russells and the District. The Russells made it clear that MOTHER was rejecting Alan B. Shepard, and insisted that the District offer a placement in a District school. In August 2000, MOTHER had STUDENT assessed by Lindamood-Bell.
On August 23, 2000, Tania Whiteleather, on behalf of STUDENT and MOTHER, filed a complaint in Federal Court. The complaint asserted that the Court had jurisdiction under the IDEA and alleged negligence, intentional and negligent infliction of emotional distress, and civil rights violations, and sought punitive damages and injunctive relief. The complaint did not mention that an administrative due process matter had been filed and was still pending.
On August 24, 2000, MOTHER wrote the District requesting an IEP meeting and giving September 1, 5 and 6 as possible dates. There was testimony that District personnel tried to call MOTHER several times to set up the IEP meeting, and eventually sent her a letter dated September 6, along with a proposed assessment plan. Tania Whiteleather responded with a series of letters. Ms. Whiteleather accused the District of trying to hold an IEP meeting on short notice and without proper notice to her, MOTHER’s attorney. Ms. Whiteleather also accused the District of denying STUDENT “stay put” at Montemalaga School. In the final letter dated September 24, 2000, Ms. Whiteleather informed the District that MOTHER was placing STUDENT in a private school, and that there was no reason to hold an IEP meeting because there could be no good faith on the part of the District. In September 2000, MOTHER enrolled STUDENT at Coast Christian School, a placement which lasted until late November 2000.
In September 2000, MOTHER also tried to re-enroll STUDENT at Montemalaga. MOTHER was told that Montemalaga was no longer STUDENT’s school and that if she had questions she needed to contact Lynn Busia. In December 2000, MOTHER enrolled STUDENT in Lindamood-Bell for four weeks.
In February 2001, Thelma Young from LACMH contacted Roni Goodman at the District. Ms. Young was inquiring about getting an updated assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Goodman told Ms. Young that she was not sure if STUDENT still lived in the District because a certified letter had been returned as unclaimed. A series of phone calls and letters followed. Despite this confusion, STUDENT did not miss any LACMH services and the District did develop a new assessment plan, which MOTHER signed on March 12, 2001. MOTHER also consented to a re-evaluation by LACMH. The plan called for STUDENT to be assessed in the areas of academic achievement, social/emotional development, speech/language, general ability, and health and development.
An IEP team meeting was scheduled for April 27, 2001. Virginia Russell accompanied MOTHER to this meeting. Ms. Goodman testified that she was surprised when MOTHER appeared for the IEP meeting. Ms. Goodman stated that she thought that the meeting had been postponed because the assessments were not completed and believed that the school psychologist had contacted MOTHER about the postponement. Ms. Goodman managed to gather District staff and convened the meeting. At this point Ms. Goodman discovered that MOTHER had brought an advocate. Ms. Goodman stated that the District could not hold an IEP meeting under those conditions because they needed the opportunity to have their own advocate or attorney present. Some arguing ensued. The District insisted on postponing the meeting. MOTHER refused to sign an extension of the statutory time line, and Ms. Russell requested that home teaching be resumed until placement could be decided. The District took no action on this request.
Shortly following the attempted April IEP meeting, Dr. Bonney, the school psychologist, completed the first draft of his multidisciplinary team report. The speech/language evaluation was completed on May 19, 2001. On June 6, 2001, MOTHER wrote to the District, requesting that the IEP meeting be held on either June 14 or June 21. The District responded that June 14 was graduation, and staff would be gone by June 21, but that it would mark September as a priority for holding the IEP. MOTHER also wrote and requested copies of the assessment reports. It does not appear that the District responded to this request. LACMH completed its AB3632 re-assessment on June 29, 2001. Dr. Bonney issued a revised report on July 16, 2001. On July 27, 2001, the District sent out notices for an August 15, 2001 IEP team meeting.
The August 15, 2001 IEP team meeting was, by all accounts, a long and adversarial meeting. MOTHER was accompanied by Virginia Russell, Christopher Russell, and Tania Whiteleather. The District was represented by attorney Sharon Watt. MOTHER’s advocates objected to the District’s assessments and requested an independent evaluation. They also voiced objections to how the meeting was being run. In the end, the District offered placement at Rossier Park, an NPS in Buena Park. MOTHER stated that she did not like what she had observed at Rossier and said that she preferred Alan B. Shepard. District personnel indicated that they were not aware that Alan B. Shepard was still a possibility and agreed to contact LACOE to see if this placement was available. The District continued to offer Rossier Park while Alan B. Shepard was investigated. MOTHER refused this offer and requested a resumption of hometeaching. The District promised to respond to this request.
Ms. Whiteleather followed up the IEP meeting with three letters, stating that the District had not allowed MOTHER to fully participate in the August 15 IEP meeting and that the IEP document did not correctly reflect what had occurred at the IEP meeting. Ms. Whiteleather also stated that MOTHER did not believe that Alan B. Shepard was an appropriate placement, but would accept it in order to get STUDENT back into school. The District responded with a letter formally denying the request for an independent evaluation. On August 31, 2001, the District also sent a letter to MOTHER stating that home teaching would resume, but it never did.
On August 23, 2001, Ms. Whiteleather sent a letter to the Special Education Hearing Office requesting that the due process matter be placed back on calendar.
The next IEP team meeting occurred on September 12, 2001. The District’s offer of placement was changed from Rossier Park to Alan B. Shepard. MOTHER, through Christopher Russell, objected to the goals and objectives, arguing that STUDENT was also qualified for services as learning disabled, and qualified for speech/language services. However, placement at Alan B. Shepard was accepted pending completion of the due process proceedings.
An IEP team meeting was held on October 22, 2001, to review STUDENT’s progress at Alan B. Shepard. The Alan B. Shepard staff felt that STUDENT’s behavior was reasonably well controlled and that STUDENT could tolerate a less restrictive placement. Placement in a new LACOE program located on the Miraleste campus (a District school) was recommended. New goals and objectives were added in the areas of written language and prevocational skills. All parties agreed that this placement was an offer of FAPE and the offer was accepted by MOTHER.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did Respondents deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year?
For analysis purposes, the 1999-2000 school year is divided into two time periods, the beginning of the school year up to October 13 (the date of the incident involving the principal), and October 13, 1999, through the end of the year.
September 7, 1999, through October 13, 1999
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 (d). The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). The student’s IEP must provide, among other things, for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. §1414(d).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provided instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208.
In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley the proposed educational program must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, to provide the student with some educational benefit, prepare the student for employment and independent living, provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities, and the program must conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.
In this case, Petitioner has two contentions: that the program provided did not conform to STUDENT’s IEP, specifically that the District failed to follow the behavior intervention plan, and second, that LACMH failed to properly advise MOTHER of the potential side effects of Zoloft, and failed to properly monitor the medication, leading to STUDENT’s increasingly defiant and out-of-control behavior.
The September 30, 1998 IEP was the governing document at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year. This IEP incorporated the Functional Analysis Report and the Behavior Intervention plan prepared by Lindy Neal-Hughes on September 25, 1998. This plan identified STUDENT’s challenging behaviors and proposed an intervention plan that focused on helping STUDENT appropriately get the attention and comfort she needed and helping her develop social skills. The learning targets were for STUDENT to learn behavioral self-regulation, develop problem solving skills, learn social interactions skills, and increase self-esteem and confidence by learning how to deal with stress. The plan called for the following:
1. Direct instruction in social skills and problem solving.
2. A positive behavior reward document to be sent home twice a week. 3. Class teacher to develop signals for redirecting STUDENT that would avoid the stigma of verbal redirection. 4. Class teacher to use intermittent reinforcement by calling on STUDENT to repeat directions for new tasks or inform other students of what they should have been doing. 5. A referral to LACMH for an AB3632 assessment.
The plan also contained various reactive strategies to be used when STUDENT was aggressive or noncompliant. The educator was not to directly confront STUDENT and was not to use verbal feedback or threats. The educator was to keep calm, convey support, and redirect STUDENT, moving her away from the activity or situation and helping her think about appropriate problem solving and choice making. If STUDENT’s behavior became out of control she was to receive a 30 minute “time out” in the office and her mother was to be called to set up a meeting.
According to the testimony of Ms. Kenner, STUDENT’s teacher during the first weeks of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’s behavior had become increasingly noncompliant. For the most part, the problem behaviors occurred during transitions, after recess and lunch. Ms. Kenner was using all of the strategies set forth in the BIP in class, with good success. She was also sending home a daily behavior report that MOTHER had to sign and return the following day. When STUDENT did become noncompliant, Ms. Kenner would remain calm, and attempt to redirect STUDENT and help her work through whatever the particular problem was. In fact, as STUDENT’s behavior became increasingly defiant, Ms. Kenner testified that she was spending more and more time trying to help STUDENT work through her crisis, which was taking away from her time with the rest of her class. MOTHER was kept constantly informed of STUDENT’s difficulties, by both the daily reports and frequent phone calls from Ms. Kenner.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the District was following the BIP developed by Ms. Neal-Hughes and incorporated into STUDENT’s IEP. STUDENT’s program at the start of the 1999-2000 school year did conform to STUDENT’s IEP.
Petitioner also contends that LACMH failed to properly advise MOTHER of the potential side effects of Zoloft and failed to properly monitor the medication, leading to STUDENT’s increasingly defiant and out-of-control behavior.
LACMH was responsible for the provision of mental health services. Mental health services includes medication monitoring, which is defined as “all medication support services...[which] include prescribing, administering, dispensing and monitoring of psychiatric medications or biologicals necessary to alleviate the symptoms of mental illness.” 2 C.C.R. §60020.
In this case, Dr. Roberts prescribed the Zoloft on September 9, 1999. Dr. Malkin testified that Zoloft was an appropriate medication to prescribe to a child STUDENT’s age with her symptoms and diagnosis. Documentation shows that MOTHER was informed of the possible side effects at that time. LACMH Exhibit 17. Ms. Kenner testified that MOTHER informed her of STUDENT’s medication and spent some time discussing the possible side effects. MOTHER testified that no one ever informed her that increased agitation was a possible side effect of Zoloft until after October 13. This is not born out by the record. Amy Eisman’s notes from her conversation with MOTHER on October 13 states that MOTHER told Ms. Eisman that she believed that STUDENT’s escalating behavior problems were a reaction to the medication. LACMH Exhibit 16. This information was passed on to the psychiatrist, who discontinued the Zoloft on the following day. In addition, it does not appear that LACMH failed to properly monitor the medication. STUDENT was seen by Dr. Roberts on September 27, one week after STUDENT actually began taking the medication. Despite the fact that STUDENT’s behavior problems were increasing, Dr. Roberts was told that STUDENT was tolerating the Zoloft well with no side effects.
The Hearing Officer finds that LACMH provided appropriate medication monitoring services. Dr. Roberts prescribed an appropriate medication, informed MOTHER of the possible side effects, and took reasonable steps to monitor the use of the medication. Once it was suspected that STUDENT might have been suffering from side effects to the medication, it was immediately discontinued.
In conclusion, STUDENT was not denied a FAPE for the time period September 7 to October 13, 1999. STUDENT’s program was provided in accordance with her IEP, and LACMH provided appropriate medication monitoring services.
October 13, 1999 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year
Petitioner’s primary allegation is that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year by failing to follow the procedural safeguards set forth in the IDEA.
There was considerable testimony regarding what happened on October 13, 1999, a basic description of which is set forth in the Background Facts section of this Decision. This was a highly emotionally charged incident and was understandably extremely upsetting to MOTHER. However, for the purpose of this Decision and the required analysis, what actually happened on that single day is less important than what happened after.
The Supreme Court in Rowley recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated that when the elaborate and highly specific procedural safeguards embodied in the IDEA are contrasted with the general and somewhat imprecise substantive admonitions contained in the Act, the importance Congress attached to those procedural safeguards cannot be ignored. The Court concluded that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with the procedures set forth in the Act as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard. Rowley 458 U.S. at 205-206. Therefore, procedural violations of the IDEA can amount to a denial of a FAPE, making a substantive analysis of the actual program offered unnecessary.
The first official act of the District following the incident was to suspend STUDENT for three days (later extended to five days). During the week following the incident, there was a meeting at which it was decided that STUDENT would begin receiving home teaching. Petitioner contends that STUDENT was expelled. The District contends that there was a voluntary change of placement.
The IDEA uses the term “change of placement for disciplinary reasons” to describe the expulsion of a student who is eligible for special education. This “change of placement” is defined as the removal of a child from the child’s current educational placement if the removal is for more than 10 consecutive days and the removal is the result of behavior that violated any rule or code of conduct of the local educational agency. 34 C.F.R. §300.519, 300.523. These regulations describe STUDENT’s circumstances. The District permanently removed STUDENT from her then current educational placement as the result of her behavior that violated District rules. Regardless of the District’s characterization of the change of placement, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was expelled.
There are specific procedures that the District needed to follow to expel STUDENT. California Education Code Section 48915.5 provides, in part:
(a) In a matter involving a pupil with previously identified exceptional needs who is currently enrolled in a special education program, the governing board may order the pupil expelled ... only if all of the following conditions are met: (1) An individualized education program team meeting is held and conducted... (2) The team determines that the misconduct was not caused by, or was not a direct manifestation of, the pupil's identified disability. (3) The team determines that the pupil had been appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred.... (h) No expulsion hearing shall be conducted for an individual with exceptional needs until all of the following have occurred: (1) A preexpulsion assessment is conducted.
(2) The individualized education program team meets pursuant to subdivision (a). (3) Due process hearings and appeals, if initiated pursuant to Section 1415 of Title 20 of the United States Code, are completed.
Both state and Federal law requires that the District maintain the pupil in his or her present placement, unless the public agency and the parent agree otherwise, pending the completion of the above procedures, including the actual state level hearing. Cal. Educ. Code §56505; 34 C.F.R. §300.514. The District acknowledged that it did not conduct the required assessment or hold a manifestation determination IEP meeting. Unless the District, through the proper procedures, determined that expulsion was appropriate, the District’s duty was to return STUDENT to her prior placement in Montemalaga. In this case, the District failed to follow the required procedures and failed to return STUDENT to her placement at Montemalaga. The District contends that there was an agreement to change STUDENT’s placement to home instruction. However, there was no substantial evidence to support the District’s contention. Although it is clear that MOTHER permitted the change to home instruction, it is unclear whether she voluntarily agreed to this change. It is also unclear how long either party anticipated that the home instruction would last.
Although the District failed to follow any of the required procedures as set forth above, procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. However, procedural inadequacies that result in the loss of educational opportunity, or seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process, clearly result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No. 23, Missoula, Mont. 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (C.A.9 (Mont.),1992). In this case, the District’s failures resulted in both a loss of educational opportunity and infringed on MOTHER’s opportunity to participate in the process. The procedures required to expel a special education student are more than mere hoops for the District to jump through. They are designed to ensure that the parent is fully informed of his or her rights and that the behavior that led to the change of placement is fully examined in light of the student’s disability. Because the District failed to conduct a preexpulsion assessment, and failed to hold a manifestation determination IEP team meeting, MOTHER was denied any meaningful opportunity to participate in the process. Finally, when the District failed to return STUDENT to her placement at Montemalaga, and finally discontinued STUDENT’s home teaching in December 1999, the District denied STUDENT all educational opportunity. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to follow any of the procedures set forth above amounted to a denial of FAPE.
At the November 10, 1999 IEP team meeting, the District made an offer of placement at the Alan B. Shepard school. This offer was repeated at the November 30, 1999 IEP team meeting. MOTHER did not accept this offer at either IEP meeting. However, the District’s failure to follow any of the procedures set forth above, and its failure to return STUDENT to her placement at Montemalaga, makes analysis of these offers unnecessary. As stated earlier, the District’s procedural failures denied MOTHER any meaningful participation in the process, and eventually denied STUDENT all educational opportunity. Until these flaws were corrected, the District could not make an offer of a FAPE.
Beyond its duties in relation to the expulsion procedures, the District also failed to comply with its general “stay put” duty to maintain STUDENT in her current educational placement pending completion of the due process matter. As set forth above, the District failed to establish that MOTHER had agreed to home instruction as an interim placement. Even if it is assumed the home instruction became STUDENT’s current educational placement for “stay put” purposes, the District unilaterally discontinued this placement on December 6, 1999, less than one week after the November 30 IEP team meeting. The District contended that it was necessary to stop home instruction because the teacher was having to travel outside of the District boundaries to provide the instruction. Assuming the logic to the District’s argument, that there might be some geographic limit to the District’s obligation to provide home instruction, it would not apply to this case. First, the documents indicate that home instruction was, from the first day, always provided at the grandmother’s home in San Pedro. See Student Exhibit MMM. The District was aware of the location, agreed to the location, and there was no change that should have prompted the District to discontinue the instruction. Second, as set forth earlier, the grandmother’s house was less than 300 yards from the District boundary, hardly enough distance to place any hardship on the District.
The District had improperly expelled STUDENT, and eventually discontinued all educational services, all without following any of the required procedures. From December 6 through the end of the school year, the District did not provide STUDENT with any educational services. The District’s actions were such a complete violation of the procedural safeguards and substantive requirements contained in the IDEA that they amounted to a total denial of FAPE for the time period of October 13, 1999 to the end of the 1999-2000 school year. In contrast, LACMH continued to provide counseling services, pursuant to STUDENT’s IEP, for the entire year.
2. Did the Respondent’s deny Petitioner a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?
Petitioner’s allegation is that the District continued to deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year by failing to follow the procedural safeguards set forth in the IDEA.
During this school year, the District did nothing to correct the violations of the prior year. Furthermore, the District continued in its failure to return STUDENT to her placement at Montemalaga or even to provide her with home instruction.
In addition to its failure to correct its past failures, the District failed to meet any of its essential procedural or substantive obligations for this school year. In August 2000, MOTHER requested an IEP meeting. The District proceeded to try to set up the IEP using the suggested dates MOTHER had provided in her request. Ms. Whiteleather, apparently not realizing that the District was trying to accommodate her client’s request, wrote a series of letters objecting to the District’s trying to set up an IEP meeting on short notice, and finally telling the District not to bother with an IEP meeting. See Student Exhibit NNN. At this point, the District did just that - they stopped. However, the District had a duty to hold an IEP meeting for STUDENT at least annually. Cal. Educ. Code §56343. The fact that the parent had indicated that she would not attend did not change the District’s duty. The law provides that the District may hold an IEP team meeting without the parent in attendance if the District is unable to convince the parent that he or she should attend. Cal Educ. Code §56341.5. In this case, the last IEP was dated November 30, 1999. Therefore, the District had a duty to hold an annual IEP team meeting on or before November 30, 2000. The District did not even convene an IEP team meeting until April 2001.
Having failed to hold an IEP team meeting, the District also failed to make any offer of placement for the 2000-2001 school year. A school district cannot escape its obligation under the IDEA to offer formally an appropriate educational placement, even assuming that the child's parents would not accept that placement. Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (C.A.9 (Cal.),1994.)
In February 2001, LACMH personnel contacted the District about having STUDENT reassessed. This resulted in MOTHER signing an assessment plan on March 12, 2001. The law gave the District 50 days to conduct the agreed-upon assessments and convene an IEP team meeting. Cal. Educ. Code §56344. The District did set up an IEP team meeting for April 27, 2001. Although an IEP meeting began on that date, it was postponed at the District’s insistence, over the objections of MOTHER and her advocate. The District argued that, because MOTHER had brought an advocate, Virginia Russell, to the IEP without notice, the District had a right to postpone the IEP until it could also be represented by an attorney or advocate. This may have been the District’s policy, but it was contrary to the law. The law provides that the IEP team shall include one or both of the parents, a representative selected by the parent or both. Cal. Educ. Code §56341. This section contemplates that a parent may wish to bring a representative to an IEP team meeting. There is no provision requiring special notice to the District or giving the District the right to postpone the meeting until it can have an attorney or advocate present as well. Moreover, in this case, the District was on notice that an advocate would attend. One or both of the Russells had attended every IEP team meeting since September 1998. In addition, MOTHER refused to sign a waiver of the statutory 50-day time line for holding the IEP team meeting. By refusing to hold the IEP meeting on April 27, the District placed itself, within a few days, in violation of Section 56344. To compound the violation, the IEP team meeting did not reconvene until August 15, 2001.
During the 2000-2001 school year, the District failed to return STUDENT to her prior educational placement, failed to provide any educational services, failed to hold the required annual IEP team meeting, failed to make any offer of placement, and failed to hold an IEP meeting within 50 days of receiving MOTHER’s acceptance of the District’s assessment plan. The Hearing Officer finds that these substantive and procedural violations constituted a denial of FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year. Again, LACMH continued to provide STUDENT with her counseling services for the entire 2000-2001 school year.
3. Did the Respondent’s deny Petitioner a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year for the time period of September 4, 2001, through October 10, 2001?
As to the 2001-2002 school year, Petitioner contends that the District failed to properly assess in the area of speech and language, failed to allow the parent to participate in the August 15, 2001 IEP meeting, failed to provide the parent with copies of assessment reports, failed to properly draft the IEP document, failed to draft appropriate goals and objectives, and failed to offer an appropriate placement at either the August 15 or the September 12, 2001 IEP meetings and therefore failed to offer a FAPE from September 4 through October 22, when the parent agreed to the District’s offer.
The August 15, 2001 IEP team meeting.
At this time, the District’s prior procedural violations in relation to the expulsion had, for the most part, been made moot by the passage of time. Almost two years had passed since the expulsion occurred and any analysis of STUDENT’s behavior in October 1999 would not necessarily be relevant to the development of an appropriate program in 2001. However, the District did have a continuing duty to return STUDENT to her prior educational placement. Regardless of whether that placement was home instruction or Montemalaga, the District failed in relation to this duty. This failure was made more egregious by the parent’s requests during the April and August 2001 IEP team meetings that home instruction resume and the District’s failure to restart this service.
At the August 2001 IEP team meeting, the District offered placement at the Rossier Park school. Before the substantive appropriateness of this offer can be examined, the Hearing Officer must first address Petitioner’s claims of procedural violations during the August 15 IEP team meeting. As set forth earlier, procedural violations only amount to a denial of FAPE if they result in the loss of educational opportunity, or seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No. 23, Missoula, Mont. 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (C.A.9 (Mont.),1992).
In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s conduct at the IEP meeting did infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. It should be noted that this was an extremely contentious and adversarial IEP meeting. After listening to the tape of this meeting (Student Exhibit NNN), the Hearing Officer finds that, although both parties were to some degree at fault for the adversarial nature of the meeting, it was the conduct of Petitioner’s advocate and attorney that made the meeting particularly difficult. Despite both parties’ improper behavior, MOTHER was permitted a meaningful opportunity to participate in the meeting until the issue of placement arose. At that point in the meeting, the District did not allow MOTHER any participation. Ms. Goodman, the District program specialist, presented her observations about the program at Rossier Park, and stated that this was the District’s offer; the IEP team members, excluding MOTHER, were asked if they agreed, mumbled agreement was heard on the tape, and the team was immediately dismissed. Following this dismissal, MOTHER and her advocates objected to both the offer and the dismissal of the team members. MOTHER stated she had serious reservations about the program at Rossier Park and insisted that the team be called back to discuss this offer and other options. Although the District personnel remaining - Ms. Goodman and Ms. Watt (the District’s attorney) - were willing to discuss other options with MOTHER, they refused to call back the team and have any formal discussion of MOTHER’s concerns and desires. Although it was agreed that LACOE would be contacted about the possibility of placement at Alan B. Shepard, MOTHER’s stated preference, and that another IEP meeting would be convened to consider that placement, the District insisted that its offer of placement was at Rossier Park, and steadfastly refused to call back the IEP team members. These actions effectively prevented MOTHER from having any opportunity to participate in the placement decision. The Hearing Officer finds that these actions, combined with the District’s continued failure to return STUDENT to her educational placement, or provide any educational placement, amounted to a denial of FAPE.
The September 12, 2001 IEP team meeting.
As to this IEP meeting, Petitioner alleges that the District failed to identify STUDENT as having a specific learning disability and as qualified for special education as a student with a speech and language impairment. In addition, Petitioner alleges that Alan B. Shepard was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
1. A specific learning disability
For a student to be found eligible for special education based upon a specific learning disability, the student must demonstrate a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement. Cal. Educ. Code §56337. Dr. Bonnie prepared the multidisciplinary team report dated May 8, 2001 and revised on July 16, 2001. Student Exhibit SS. This report described the results of various assessments preformed in May 2001. STUDENT had been administered the Weschler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), the Wechsler Intelligence Test for Children-III (WISC III), the Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CTOPP), the Berry Visual Motor Integration Test (VMI), and the Achenback Child Behavior Checklist. The WISC III tested STUDENT’s intellectual ability. STUDENT received a verbal IQ of 108, a performance IQ of 107, and a full scale IQ of 108. These placed STUDENT in the average range. The WIAT was given to test STUDENT’s academic achievement. On the WIAT STUDENT scored in the average range on all subtests accept oral expression, on which she scored in the very superior range. On the basis of these tests, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not have a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement. Therefore, she does not qualify for special education as a student with a specific learning disability.
2. A speech or language disorder.
To qualify for special education as a student with a speech or language disorder, a student must have an expressive or receptive language disorder evidenced by scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean, or below the 7th percentile, for his or her chronological age or developmental level on two or more standardized tests in one or more of the following areas of language development: morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics. 5 C.C.R. § 3030(c)(4). Ms. Roush , a speech/language pathologist, performed a speech/language evaluation in May 2001. Student Exhibit TT. Ms. Roush administered the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-III (PPVT), the Expressive Vocabulary Test (EVT), the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF-3), the Tests of Problem solving (TOPS), the Test of Pragmatic Language (TOPL), and the Fischer-Logemann Test of Articulation Competence (FLTAC). STUDENT demonstrated age-appropriate speech and language skills on all tests accept the TOPS, a test of pragmatic language. STUDENT received very low scores on four out of five of the subtests, and an overall score in the first percentile. Because of these low scores, Ms. Roush administered a second test of pragmatic language, the TOPL. STUDENT scored in the above average range on this test. Ms. Roush concluded that the two tests read together did not demonstrate a problem in the area of pragmatic language. Ms. Roush believed that STUDENT’s low scores on the TOPS may have been evidence of problems is other areas, such as social judgment. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Roush’s conclusions are supported by the evidence. STUDENT did not meet the criteria set for in Section 3030(c) because she had a score below the seventh percentile on only one test, the TOPS. STUDENT’s history supports the conclusion that her low score on the TOPS was related to her emotional disturbance rather than a problem with pragmatic language. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not qualify for special education as a student with a speech or language disorder.
3. The offer of placement at Alan B. Shepard.
Petitioner’s contention regarding the offer of placement at Alan B. Shepard was that the offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, specifically that the racial make up of the Alan B. Shepard would make STUDENT feel isolated. To analyze this offer of placement it is necessary to first determine what STUDENT’s unique needs were.
STUDENT’s primary needs were in the area of social-emotional functioning. LACMH identified her needs as reducing symptoms of depression and anxiety, improving problem solving, improving self-esteem, developing appropriate ways to express her feelings, and improving her ability to maintain positive relationships with peers and adults. Student Exhibit VV. Academically, STUDENT had demonstrated an average to above average academic ability and needed a setting that would offer her an academically challenging curriculum. Because STUDENT had been out of school for so long, Dr. Ahmadnia, STUDENT’s therapist, believedthat STUDENT would extra need help adjusting to a new school. To meet these needs, STUDENT would need ongoing outpatient therapy, a consistent supportive placement with a program designed for students with behavior problems, a positive behavior intervention plan, on-site counseling services available on an as-needed basis, services to help her adjust to her new school, and an academically challenging curriculum.
The September 12, 2001 IEP carried forward the goals and objectives from the August 15, 2001 IEP. These goals addressed improving STUDENT’s ability to comply with adult authority and school rules, improving anger management, improving interpersonal relationships. The IEP also included a behavior intervention plan that incorporated the BIP developed in 1998 and added a need for a point and level system for rewarding appropriate behavior at school. The September 2001 IEP modified the BIP by adding additional types of defiant behavior as “identified challenging behavior” and included suggested ways of addressing those behaviors. There were also mental health goals drafted to decrease anxiety and depression. LACMH offered outpatient individual and family counseling, one session of each, once a week, and on-site counseling for thirty minutes each week.
At the hearing, Adair Teller, a program administrator with LACOE, testified about the program at Alan B. Shepard. The program at Alan B. Shepard is a special day class program operated by LACOE. The program is designed for higher functioning students with behavior problems. There are ten to twelve students per class, with a teacher and two assistants per class. The academic level of the students typically ranges from slightly below average to above average. Each class has a school psychologist assigned to it. The school uses a point/level system to track and reward behavior. In addition, each student has his or her own BIP. The general curriculum is individually designed to meet each student’s needs and to provide a challenging environment for those students who are high average to above average academically.
The Hearing Officer finds that the September 12, 2001 IEP contained goals and objectives to meet all of STUDENT’s unique needs. The small class size, the academic levels of the other students, and the individually designed curriculum would provide STUDENT with an academically challenging environment. Furthermore, the combination of LACMH outpatient counseling services and the behavior program at the Alan B. Shepard school would provide the services necessary to implement the goals and objectives and meet all of STUDENT’s needs. Petitioner argued that the racial demographics at Alan B. Shepard (primarily black and Hispanic) would have made STUDENT feel isolated and increased her depression. However, there was no evidence that STUDENT needed to be in group of any particular racial makeup. In fact, Dr. Michele Linden testified that she was familiar with the Alan B. Shepard school and felt that it was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that the September 12, 2001 IEP was an offer of FAPE.
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following expenses: Reimbursement for child care ($20,400)
Reimbursement for the cost of an advocate (approximately $1,500) Reimbursement for activity classes ($3,700)
Reimbursement for Lindamood-Bell services ($6,335)
Reimbursement for placement at Coast Christian School (approximately $1,000) Reimbursement for transportation costs to all of the above ($3,773.03) Reimbursement for earnings MOTHER lost due to missed work ($12,672)?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).) The Court in Burlington made a point of distinguishing the right to reimbursement from damages. Reimbursement merely requires the school district to belatedly pay expenses that it should have paid all along and would have borne in the first instance had it developed a proper IEP. (Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370-371) To qualify for reimbursement the District must first have denied the student a FAPE, and the placement or service provided by the parent must have met the child’s needs and provided educational benefit. (Florence v. Carter, supra; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.) Because the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from October 13, 1999 through September 12, 2001, MOTHER has satisfied the first part of the test for reimbursement.
Child Care
Child care is not a proper subject for reimbursement. It is not an educational service and is not the kind of expense the District would have incurred had it developed a proper IEP. Although it meets a need, to supervise the student while the parent is at work, this is a need of the parent, not the child, and there was no evidence that the child care provided any educational benefit to STUDENT related to her disability.
Cost of an advocate
In this case, the evidence established that the Russells represented MOTHER in her dealings with the District in relation to the two due process filings, accompanied her on school visits, advised her on strategy, and accompanied her to IEP meetings. These are the same services that an attorney would have provided and there was no evidence that the Russells provided any educational services to STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Russells’ services were in the nature of attorney’s services and are not reimbursable in this decision.
However, the Hearing Officer feels compelled to discuss the actions of Petitioner’s advocates in relation to STUDENT. Both of the Russells testified to extensive experience in special education and in due process matters in particular. Therefore, any failures cannot be attributed to ignorance. The Hearing Officer has concluded that the District failed in its duty to provide STUDENT with a FAPE and wrongfully discontinued all educational services to STUDENT. Given the seriousness of the District’s denial of services, the Hearing Officer can see no reason why this case was allowed to sit off calendar for almost two years, especially since STUDENT was just in day care, receiving no educational services. This situation was the direct result of the advocates’ handling of this matter. The letters in the record and the testimony of Christopher and Virginia Russell make it clear that no real negotiations were going on for most of the time STUDENT was out of school. Ms. Russell’s letters of January 5, 2000, and February 23, 2000, made it clear that she had no belief in the willingness of the District to negotiate in good faith. Despite this complete breakdown in negotiations, no effort was made to resolve the case by bringing this matter to hearing. It only required a letter to the Hearing Office to place the matter on the active calendar and proceed to hearing. Not only did the advocates choose not to take this step, they took affirmative steps to keep the case off calendar. During the hearing, the Hearing Officer questioned Ms. Russell about the length of time this case was left off calendar. She responded that they were hoping for success on the Federal Court case. However, that case was not filed until August 2000 and was dismissed just two months later. Ms. Russell also admitted that one reason they did not go to hearing was because they were afraid they would lose.
After reviewing all of the documentary evidence and the testimony in this case, the Hearing Officer concludes that this case was left unresolved, and STUDENT was left out of school, in large part because the advocates were more interested in winning their power struggle with the District than with STUDENT’s welfare. The District’s actions in this case are inexcusable; however, it was the Russells who made the decision to leave this case off calendar for almost two years while STUDENT sat in day care. It was only the continued LACMH services that prevented this case from becoming a major tragedy.
Should the Russell’s fees in this matter be the subject of any motion or future action in a state or federal court, including payment through a motion for attorney’s fees by Ms. Whiteleather, the Hearing Officer advises that no reimbursement for those services be awarded.
Activity Classes
At various times during the time period at issue, MOTHER enrolled STUDENT in activity classes, such as dance, gymnastics, basketball, swimming, science, music, and etiquette. MOTHER testified that she did this to afford STUDENT some socialization while she was not enrolled in school. As set forth earlier, STUDENT’s needs were to reduce symptoms of depression and anxiety, improve problem solving, improve self-esteem, develop appropriate ways to express her feelings, and improve her ability to maintain positive relationships with peers and adults. Participating in the activity classes did provide STUDENT with the opportunity to socialize with her peers and to help her develop her social skills. From the LACMH counseling notes, it appears that these classes helped to reduce STUDENT’s depression and increased her self esteem. There was also evidence that STUDENT benefitted from these classes. By the time STUDENT returned to school in September 2001, she was able to demonstrate a greatly improved ability to get along with peers and authority figures. Although much of this improvement is likely due to the ongoing therapy STUDENT received from LACMH, the importance of the activity classes cannot be discounted. The Hearing Officer finds that the activity classes met some of STUDENT’s unique needs and provided her with some educational benefit. Therefore, reimbursement for these classes is appropriate.
The cost of the classes is somewhat in questions. MOTHER testified to having spent $3,700 on these classes. Student Exhibit FFF. However, she only submit proof of $1,515 in tuition for these classes. Student Exhibit KKK. The Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER is entitled to reimbursement for $1,515 as the cost of tuition for the various activity classes. MOTHER is also entitled to reimbursement for travel expenses incurred in relation to these classes.
Lindamood-Bell Services
In December 2000 MOTHER enrolled STUDENT in Lindamood-Bell classes for four weeks. Lindamood-Bell provides intensive classes designed to remediate specific types of language deficits. The only evidence as to what STUDENT’s classes were designed to address was a progress report dated December 18, 2000. Student Exhibit LLL. This report indicated that STUDENT was working on isolated multi-syllable skills, decoding, and spelling. However, there was no evidence that STUDENT had any specific needs in these areas. Petitioner presented no evidence as to the nature of the services being provided, what needs they were addressing, or whether STUDENT received any benefit from these classes. The Lindamood-Bell classes are distinguishable from the activity classes or from a private school placement. The Lindamood-Bell classes are designed to provide intensive remediation for specific skill deficits, not general academic instruction or opportunities for social interaction. Petitioner has failed to show that the Lindamood-Bell classes addressed any of STUDENT’s needs, or that STUDENT received educational benefit. On the basis of these findings, the Hearing Officer denies reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell classes.
Coast Christian School
In September 2000, MOTHER enrolled STUDENT at the Coast Christian School. This placement lasted only three months. Petitioner did not submit any records from Coast Christian School and presented only limited testimony about the program. The only reliable records that relate to this placement are the LACMH counseling notes. Mental Health Exhibit 16. These records indicate that STUDENT had numerous behavior problems at Coast Christian and was eventually expelled. Absent any evidence to the contrary, these records indicated that the program at Coast Christian was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and that STUDENT did not benefit from this program. The Hearing Officer finds that reimbursement for the placement at Coast Christian is not appropriate.
Transportation
The IDEA defines “related services” as including transportation and other supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401 (22). For those services that are being reimbursed, associated transportation costs have already been dealt with. There is an issue relating to transportation to STUDENT’s LACMH counseling appointments. Not only is transportation to these appointments required under the IDEA, but the District specifically agreed to reimburse MOTHER for her transportation of STUDENT from the home to the counseling appointments. Student Exhibit GG. Transportation would include transportation to both family and individual counseling sessions. MOTHER testified that she was not reimbursed for this cost. To the extent that MOTHER was not reimbursed, she is entitled to reimbursement for the transportation costs associated with the LACMH individual and family counseling sessions.
Lost Wages
Lost wages are not a proper subject for reimbursement. Although these wages may relate to the District’s denial of FAPE, they are in the nature of damages, rather then reimbursement for educational services. The Hearing Officer does not have the authority to award damages.
5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Petitioner seeks compensatory education in the form of tutoring, social skills training, and additional Lindamood-Bell services.
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(it) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington also have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497.
In this case, STUDENT has not only been denied a FAPE, but also has been denied any educational services for approximately 23 months. However, STUDENT did continue to receive LACMH counseling for the entire time period at issue. In addition, when STUDENT returned to school, she was able to enroll in the sixth grade, keeping her on track with her same-age peers. Regardless of STUDENT’s ability to be in a sixth grade class during the 2001-2002 school year, the cost of missing two years of school cannot be ignored.
To determine the cost to STUDENT of the denial of FAPE, STUDENT’s unique needs and present levels of performance must be examined. As set forth earlier, STUDENT’s needs were to reduce symptoms of depression and anxiety, improve problem solving, improve self-esteem, develop appropriate ways to express her feelings, and improve her ability to maintain positive relationships with peers and adults. In addition, STUDENT was entitled to be involved and progress in the general curriculum. The LACMH counseling met many of STUDENT’s emotional needs, however, the counseling could not provide STUDENT the socialization opportunities that she needed to help improve her self esteem and improve her ability to maintain positive relationships. In addition, STUDENT was denied any opportunity to be involved and progress in the general curriculum. Based upon this analysis, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT will require compensatory education in the form of academic tutoring and social skills training to make up for the almost two year denial of a FAPE.
How much of each of these services STUDENT requires is harder to gauge. Petitioner offered no evidence to establish STUDENT’s current academic level, or what amount and type of social skills training she currently requires. Examination of the record offers little additional information. There is no record of any curriculum-based measures either before or after the denial of FAPE.
Because of the lack of evidence in the record with respect to STUDENT’s academic needs, the Hearing Officer is forced to remand the issue of compensatory education back to an IEP team. While it is unfortunate to have to remand this decision back to an IEP team, it would be unfair to STUDENT for the Hearing Officer to arbitrarily determine the type and amount of compensatory education she requires. However, the Hearing Officer can offer specific guidelines for the IEP team to consider. The IEP team shall consider the following:
1. STUDENT will require academic tutoring and social skills training to compensate her for the District’s denial of a FAPE. 2. To determine the amount and type of extra academic tutoring STUDENT requires the team must: • Use curriculum based measures to determine where STUDENT was functioning at the end of the third grade. • Use curriculum based measures to determine where STUDENT is currently functioning. • Use the State standards to determine what academic instruction STUDENT should have received in the fourth and fifth grades. • Consider that there is reason to believe that, based upon STUDENT’s intellectual ability, she could be functioning at or even above grade level. • Consider the likelihood that more than one year will be needed to adequately compensate STUDENT for her missed academics. • Consider STUDENT’s desires and willingness to spend a significant amount of her after-school time in extra instruction must be considered when deciding the manner of providing compensatory academic education. • Consider the possible need for summer school.
3. To determine the amount and type of social skills training STUDENT requires the team must: • Consider the input of LACMH staff to establish the most appropriate services to compensate STUDENT for her lost socialization opportunities as a result of her 23 month absence from school. • As in the area of academic tutoring, STUDENT’s desires and willingness to spend a significant amount of her after-school time in extra instruction must be considered when deciding the manner of providing compensatory social skills training. • Consider the likelihood that more than one year will be needed to fully compensate STUDENT for her missed socialization opportunities • Consider the need for summer programs as part of STUDENT’s compensatory education program.
1. An IEP team meeting shall be held at the conclusion of the 2002-2003 school year to review this issue.
CONCLUSION
The District denied STUDENT a FAPE from October 13, 1999, through September 12, 2001. As a result of the denial, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the various activity classes, including transportation, and the cost of transportation to all LACMH counseling appointments during this period of time. STUDENT is also entitled to compensatory education as set forth above.
ORDER
1.a. The District shall reimburse MOTHER for the cost, including transportation, of the activity classes evidenced in Student’s Exhibit KKK: Watt/Jazz, gymnastics at the Marina Gym/SPROCK, Shoot-Sparks at the South Bay Y, 2000 camp classes provided through the South Bay Y, and etiquette and swimming through the Torrance Parks and Recreation. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall reimburse MOTHER $1,151 as the cost of STUDENT’s tuition for the various activity classes listed above.
1.b. Within twenty-five calendar days of the date of this Decision, MOTHER shall submit to the District proof of the mileage for transporting STUDENT to each of the activity classes listed above. Proof shall consist of a calendar or schedules showing each session of each class and a map or maps showing round trip mileage from the STUDENT’S home to each class location. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse MOTHER for the cost of transportation at the rate the District reimburses its employees.
2. Within twenty-five calendar days of the date of this Decision, MOTHER shall submit to the District proof of the mileage for transporting STUDENT to her LACMH counseling appointments (individual and family) for the time period of October 13, 1999 through September 12, 2001. Proof shall consist of a calendar or schedule showing each session STUDENT attended and the location of those sessions. In addition, MOTHER shall submit a map showing round trip mileage from the STUDENT’S home to each counseling location. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse MOTHER for the cost of transportation at the rate the District reimburses its employees. The District may deduct the amount of any transportation costs already reimbursed for this time period.
3.a. Within 20 calendar days from the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting. The purpose of this meeting will be to decide on the type and amount of academic tutoring and social skills training that STUDENT will require to compensate her for her missed schooling and socialization opportunities that resulted from the District’s denial of a FAPE. To determine the amount and type of extra academic tutoring STUDENT requires the team must: • Use curriculum based measures to determine where STUDENT was functioning at the end of the third grade. • Use curriculum based measures to determine where STUDENT is currently functioning. • Use the State standards to determine what academic instruction STUDENT should have received in the fourth and fifth grades. • Consider that there is reason to believe that, based upon STUDENT’s intellectual ability, she could be functioning at or even above grade level. • Consider the likelihood that more than one year will be needed to adequately compensate STUDENT for her missed academics. • Consider STUDENT’s desires and willingness to spend a significant amount of her after-school time in extra instruction must be considered when deciding the manner of providing compensatory academic education. • Consider the possible need for summer school.
3.b. To determine the amount and type of social skills training STUDENT requires the team must: • Consider the input of LACMH staff to establish the most appropriate services to compensate STUDENT for her lost socialization opportunities as a result of her 23 month absence from school. • As in the area of academic tutoring, STUDENT’s desires and willingness to spend a significant amount of her after-school time in extra instruction must be considered when deciding the manner of providing compensatory social skills training. • Consider the likelihood that more than year will be needed to fully compensate STUDENT for her missed socialization opportunities • Consider the need for summer programs as part of STUDENT’s compensatory education program.
4. An IEP team meeting shall be held at the conclusion of the 2002-2003 school year to review this issue.
5. All of Student's other requests for relief are denied.
6. The Federal District Court dismissed this complaint on October 23, 2000, for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Ms. Whiteleather appealed this dismissal to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the dismissal on March 4, 2002.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
1. Did Respondents deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue as to the District, but not as to LACMH.
2. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue as to the District, but not as to LACMH.
3. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year for the time period of 9/4/01 through 10/22/01?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue as to the District, but not as to LACMH.
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following expenses: Reimbursement for child care ($20,400)
Reimbursement for the cost of an advocate (approximately $1,500) Reimbursement for activity classes ($3,700)
Reimbursement for Lindamood-Bell services ($6,335)
Reimbursement for placement at Coast Christian School (approximately $1,000)
Reimbursement for transportation costs to all of the above ($3,773.03) Reimbursement for earnings MOTHER lost due to missed work ($12,672)?
The District prevailed on this issue except as to the cost of the activity classes.
5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue, but presented no evidence as to the type or nature of compensatory education that should be awarded.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: August 5, 2002 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The Russells continued to represent MOTHER throughout the course of the case.
2. Later testimony would establish that stomachaches, fatigue, and increased agitation were all possible side effects.
3. The other student was also in Ms. Kenner’s SDC, and had his own behavior plan and his own issues, and was particularly vulnerable.
4. San Pedro is directly adjacent to the District. According to the Hearing Officer’s Microsoft Streets and Trips program, the Grandmother’s address is less than 300 yards from District boundaries.
5. Either Virginia or Christopher Russell had accompanied MOTHER to every IEP team meeting beginning with the September 30, 1998 meeting.
6. These classes were offered through the local Y, Parks and Recreation, and private gyms.
7. The Russells did not have a particular placement in mind.
8. The Federal District Court dismissed this complaint on October 23, 2000, for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Ms. Whiteleather appealed this dismissal to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the dismissal on March 4, 2002.
9. MOTHER testified that this placement lasted only one month and ended for financial reasons. However, the LACMH counseling records indicate that the placement lasted until approximately November 28, when STUDENT was expelled for fighting.
10. Lindamood-Bell recommended twelve weeks, but MOTHER could only afford four.
11. Ms. Goodman was referring to a letter returned in December 1999.
12. The District had 50 days from the date it received MOTHER’s assent to the assessment plan to complete the assessments and convene an IEP meeting. MOTHER signed the consent on March 12, giving the District until May 1 to hold an IEP meeting.
13. There were two addendums to this IEP, one on January 7, 1999, and one on April 16 1999.
14. Under federal and State special education law, this duty to maintain the student in his or her present educational placement pending completion of due process hearing procedures applies even if there was no expulsion. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). This provision is commonly referred to as "stay put" and applies automatically upon the filing of a due process complaint. This case has been pending since October 18, 1999. A student's "present educational placement" is generally the placement called for by the student's IEP which has been implemented prior to the dispute arising, unless the parties agree to an alternate placement. Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education (6th Cir. 1990) 918 F.2d 218. At the time of the incident, STUDENT’s “present educational placement” was in a special day class at the Montemalaga school. This would have been STUDENT’s “stay put” placement, unless there had been an agreement between the District and the parent to a different placement. Although STUDENT’s placement was changed to home instruction, the District failed to put forth any substantial evidence as to how this change came about.
15. At the August 15 IEP meeting, MOTHER stated that she wanted STUDENT to be placed at Alan B. Shepard. She explained that changes in her circumstances since November 1999, when Alan B. Shepard was first offered, had eliminated most the logistical problems that had concerned her in the past. After the IEP meeting, Ms. Whiteleather wrote to the District stating that, although MOTHER would accept placement at Alan B. Shepard, she did not believe it was appropriate for STUDENT.
16. These needs were undisputed by all parties.
17. Dr. Linden was STUDENT’s former counselor and, as of September 2001, the director of the institution providing outpatient counseling to STUDENT under contract with LACMH.
18. MOTHER testified that STUDENT attended six weeks of Lindamood-Bell. However, the billings she submitted only documented four weeks of classes at a cost of $4,160.
19. At the conclusion of Petitioner’s case-in-chief, counsel for the District moved to dismiss the issue of reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell services based upon a lack of evidence to support reimbursement. The Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion to dismiss the issue, noting that there was some evidence in the record that related to reimbursement for Lindamood-Bell services. On the next day of hearing, counsel for Petitioner moved to submit new documentary evidence, a Lindamood-Bell progress report, and to amend Petitioner’s witness list to add Felicia Silva, a Lindamood-Bell employee. The Hearing Officer admitted the progress report. As to the new witness, the Hearing Officer issued a written order, noting that Petitioner had had 10 days of hearing to present this evidence and had chosen not to. However, Petitioner was allowed a limited opportunity to present Ms. Silva’s testimony, requiring Ms. Silva to testify at 9:00 a.m. on Wednesday, June 19, 2002. The Hearing Officer reasoned that this would allow Petitioner every opportunity to present all the relevant evidence and still allow the District adequate time within the remaining hearing days to present rebuttal testimony. At the commencement of the hearing on June 19, counsel for Petitioner stated that she had misread the Hearing Officer’s order and was not prepared to present Ms. Silva’s testimony at that time. The Hearing Officer ruled that his order had been very specific as to when Ms. Silva’s testimony was to be presented, that Petitioner had already been afforded ample opportunity to present any relevant evidence, and that counsel had failed to present good cause to be allowed an additional extension of time within which to present Ms. Silva’s testimony. The Hearing Officer therefore denied Petitioner’s motion to present Ms. Silva’s testimony at a later time.
20. 20The purpose of determining a prevailing party is to provide information for courts to use in awarding attorney’s fees. The Hearing Officer has already stated his opinion regarding any attorney fee award that includes the cost of the Russells’ services. The Hearing Officer also has serious reservations about attorney Tania Whiteleather’s handling of this case. On the basis of Virginia Russell’s testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that it was on Ms. Whiteleather’s advice that the decision was made to proceed with a Federal Court action rather than to go forward with the due process matter. Given the well established principle of exhaustion of administrative remedies, the Hearing Officer is at a loss to understand this strategy and waste of resources. In addition, most of Petitioner’s claims for relief presented in this due process matter are not remedies available in a special education due process proceeding, a fact any experienced attorney should know. Furthermore, Ms. Whiteleather, in presenting her case, chose to present almost no evidence on those claims for relief on which she prevailed, leaving the Hearing Officer to try to fashion what relief he could. Thus while technically the petitioner prevailed, she suffered an almost total denial of educational services for two years, and received relatively little compensation as a result of her attorney’s conduct. Additionally, the Hearing Officer is at a loss to comprehend why, once she became involved, Ms. Whiteleather took no steps to bring this matter to hearing until August 2001, when she finally requested that the case be placed back on the active calendar. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer recommends that the court strongly consider reducing or denying any award of attorney’s fees requested by Ms. Whiteleather.
