California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 22, 2001
Student v. Oceanside Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 312-01 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait
Oceanside Unified may proceed with expulsion; Hearing Officer finds windshield-smashing incident was not a manifestation of student's learning disability.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The student was a 17-year-old senior in the Oceanside Unified School District. He was eligible for special education under specific learning disability, based on auditory and visual processing deficits that affected math and writing, and he received resource specialist services. In January 2001 he threw a trash can through the windshield of another student's car on campus, and the District recommended expulsion. After meetings in which his mother took part, the IEP team found the conduct was not a manifestation of his disability. His mother, representing him herself, requested a hearing.
The mother did not challenge the District's procedures or his IEP and placement. She argued that he had a medical condition affecting anger control, which he had stopped taking medication for more than a year earlier, and that it kept him from controlling his behavior. Hearing Officer Glenn Fait disagreed. The learning disability had no connection to the act. The student admitted he knew the conduct broke school rules. His teachers testified that he followed rules and had no behavior problems. A clinical psychologist testified that the student did not meet the diagnostic criteria for the claimed disorder. The student testified that he acted to send a message after a threat, and he walked 20 to 30 feet to get the trash can. The Hearing Officer found this was a calculated response, not an uncontrollable outburst. The District may proceed with expulsion. In a footnote, the Hearing Officer criticized the school psychologist for not interviewing the student but did not require a new assessment.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the 1997 IDEA manifestation test when a parent argued that an unidentified condition made a student unable to control his behavior. The Hearing Officer relied on the student's own account and on whether the act was deliberate. The footnote stresses interviewing the student during a preexpulsion assessment.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue 1. Was STUDENT's conduct on January 22, 2001, of throwing a garbage can through the windshield of a car a manifestation of his disability?
The conduct was not a manifestation of the student's learning disability; he understood the conduct was wrong, and the evidence showed a deliberate response to a threat, not an uncontrollable outburst caused by a claimed anger-control condition.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's claims denied; the District may proceed with the expulsion hearing and may order discipline consistent with what would be appropriate for a nondisabled student.
Key authorities
34 CFR 300.523(c); 34 CFR 300.346; Education Code section 48915.5
People named in the decision
- Gregory J. Armstrong, school psychologist (triennial reevaluation and preexpulsion manifestation determination report), Oceanside Unified School District
- Virginia Serna, coordinator of Pupil Services/Special Education, Oceanside Unified School District
- Joe Sepulveda, police school resource officer, Oceanside Police Department
- Patricia Randolph, student's counselor (wrote letter supporting parent's position), Not stated
- Dr. Michael Bobik, clinical psychologist, witness, Not stated
- Mickey Sanders, teacher, witness, Oceanside Unified School District
- Connie Strause, teacher, witness, Oceanside Unified School District
- Tom Sprink, teacher, witness, Oceanside Unified School District
- Malinda Van Hooser, teacher, witness, Oceanside Unified School District
- Summit School, placement recommended by IEP team after manifestation determination, Not stated
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This case was heard on March 6 and 7, 2001, in Oceanside, California, by Hearing Officer Glenn Fait for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.
STUDENT was present at the hearing and was represented by his mother, MOTHER.
Respondent Oceanside Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Dina O. Harris and Maria E. Gless. Also present on behalf of Respondent was Virginia Serna, coordinator of Pupil Services/Special Education.
Documentary evidence and witness testimony was received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision on March 7, 2001.
ISSUE
Was STUDENT’s conduct on January 22, 2001, of throwing a garbage can through the windshield of a car a manifestation of his disability?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seventeen year old senior at High School. He was determined to be eligible for special education services in March 1997 because of a specific learning disability consisting of deficits in auditory and visual processing which impede his ability in math and written language. He has received special education support in the form of resource specialist services throughout high school.
During the first two years of high school, STUDENT took the drug Tygretol as part of his treatment for impulse control problems, temper outbursts and mood swings, and a possible seizure disorder. During the summer of 1999, following his sophomore year, STUDENT decided to stop taking Tygretol.
In March 2000, a three-year reevaluation of STUDENT was conducted. In his report of his reevaluation of STUDENT’s school psychologist Gregory J. Armstrong stated:
STUDENT is a quiet and often cooperative student. He gets along well with his teachers and his peers. In the past STUDENT has had difficulty with anger outbursts. He has kept out of trouble until recently. At the beginning of the semester, he was not attending school. He indicated that he was depressed and felt that he could not live up to the expectations that coaches had of him. When he returned to school, he was not totally cooperative in some of his classes. He has had some referrals due to intimidation and defiance. These occurred toward the end of the school year. He has a desire to continue to play football and possibly play at a 4 year university.
The IEP team concluded that STUDENT remained eligible for special education services because of his learning disability and determined that he should continue to receive resource specialist services to assist him with English and study skills. With respect to his social/emotional development, the IEP dated March 21, 2000, stated:
STUDENT is well liked by both peers and adults. Stress can cause emotions to fluctuate. Recent loss of focus on academics necessitated class changes.
STUDENT’s disciplinary records reveal that he was suspended for five days on April 19, 2000, for “mutual combat, verbal only” and was suspended five days on May 31, 2000, for “attempted/threatened injury, gang related.”
During his senior year (2000-01), STUDENT continued to receive resource specialist services. The only incident of discipline preceding the incident that is the subject of this hearing was a five day suspension on December 12, 2000, for “possession and use of alcohol on campus.”
Although STUDENT was not a documented member of a gang, he had a number of close friends who were members of the Samoan Bloods. The owner of the car that was damaged by STUDENT on July 22, 2001, was a member of the rival Crips gang. In the week prior to the disciplinary incident, STUDENT and his friends had a confrontation with the owner of the car in the boy’s bathroom. During the confrontation, the owner of the car said that he could “whip the asses” of STUDENT and his friends. This incident consisted of verbal exchanges but no actual physical violence.
On January 22, 2001, STUDENT and a friend were sitting in a car owned by another friend, waiting for the owner of the car to finish classes and drive them home. After the owner of the car and another friend got into the car, STUDENT got out of the car and walked about 20 to 30 feet to a trash can. He picked up the trash can and walked to the rival gang members car which was nearby and smashed the windshield of the car. He then returned to his friend’s car. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT’s friend also got out of the car and picked up the same trash can and smashed the windshield again. STUDENT and his friends then left the scene. The incident was witnessed by a bus driver who reported it to school authorities.
After a preliminary investigation, STUDENT was identified as one of the two students who had committed the offense. On January 24, 2001, Officer Joe Sepulveda, an Oceanside police officer assigned as a resource officer to the District interviewed STUDENT after reading him his Miranda rights. STUDENT agreed to give a statement. He admitted smashing the windshield of the rival gang member’s car with a trash can. When asked why he had committed the act, STUDENT said that he did not like the owner of the car because he had been talking about being able to “kick everyone’s ass.”
During the hearing, STUDENT testified that when his friends came to the car they said that the rival gang member had just told them that he was going the shoot the members of the Samoan gang. He said that this threat made him mad, so he got the trash can and smashed the rival gang member’s windshield because he wanted to send him a sign that he should not mess with them. This version of what occurred is supported by Officer Sepulveda’s report of his interview with the friend of STUDENT who also smashed the windshield with the trash can. His friend is quoted as saying that he smashed the windshield because the rival gang member had once threatened to shoot him and his friends.
On January 25, 2001, the District notified STUDENT that he was suspended for five days because of the incident and that it was recommending that he be expelled.
School psychologist Gregory J. Armstrong completed a “Manisfestation Determination Report” concerning the incident. He consulted with STUDENT’s special education teachers and with administrators who were recommending expulsion. He also reviewed special education and disciplinary records. He concluded as follows:
According to the administrative investigation of the incidents, STUDENT has a history of dislike of the student whose windshield he broke. STUDENT stated that his reason for his behavior was that he did not like the other student. It does not appear to be an impulsive act of destruction. STUDENT’s placement in the RSP program has been a result of difficulty with auditory processing and visual memory. Although he has had more significant behavioral difficulties when he was enrolled in middle school, he has not displayed frequent behavioral difficulties during his enrollment at ECHS. STUDENT has admitted that he understands school rules and the great majority of time follows both classroom and school rules. It is therefore concluded that there is not a linkage between his handicapping condition and his property destruction behavior.
On January 29, 2001, the IEP team met to make a manifestation determination. Neither STUDENT nor his mother attended the meeting. The team concluded that STUDENT’s actions were not a manifestation of his learning disability and that his placement was appropriate at the time of the incident. The team recommended placement at the Summit School. After this meeting, it was discovered that STUDENT and his mother had not realized that the meeting was scheduled, so the District continued the meeting to the next day. On January 30, 2001, STUDENT and his mother attended the IEP meeting and mentioned that STUDENT had a medical condition that might have caused his behavior and asked for time to obtain a letter from his doctor. The IEP team agreed to continue the IEP team meeting to February 2, 200l. During the meeting on February 2, STUDENT’s mother provided a note from his doctor which stated that “the patient stopped taking his medication and would result in loss of temper.” The doctor listed his diagnosis as “temper reactions, possible seizures.” The IEP team reviewed the information from STUDENT’s doctor, but the District members of the IEP team concluded that “STUDENT’s actions were premeditated and not a result of a fit of anger.” The IEP team agreed with STUDENT’s mother to place STUDENT in home/hospital instruction pending the expulsion hearing.
On February 15, 2001, the District notified STUDENT’s mother that an expulsion hearing would be conducted on February 26, 2001. Also on February 15, STUDENT’s mother filed a request for a hearing with the California Special Education Hearing Office. The District then postponed the expulsion hearing pending resolution of the hearing request.
A letter was written by Patricia Randolph, STUDENT’s counselor, on March 1, 2001 in which she states that STUDENT “has clinical symptoms of depression and behaviors of aggressive episodes that are grossly out of proportion to any psychological stressors. These behaviors are congruent with Intermittent Explosive Disorder, Code 312.14 DSM. IV and is treated with Tygretol medication.” Ms. Randolph inferred that the incident of throwing the trash can through the windshield of the car was an episode of impulsive, aggressive behavior.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
Both federal and State law provide that before a student with a disability can be expelled from school, the IEP team must determine that the conduct for which the student is being recommended for expulsion was not a manifestation of his disability.
Pursuant to 34 CFR 300.523(c), the IEP team and other qualified personnel may only determine that the conduct was not a manifestation of the child’s disability if they:
(1) First consider, in terms of the behavior subject to disciplinary action, all relevant information, including— (i) Evaluation and diagnostic results, including the results or other relevant information supplied by the parents of the child; (ii) Observations of the child; and (iii) The child’s IEP and placement; and (2) Then determine that— (i) In relationship to the behavior subject to disciplinary action, the child’s IEP and placement were appropriate and the special education services, supplementary aids and services, and behavior intervention strategies were provided consistent with the child’s IEP and placement; (ii) The child’s disability did not impair the ability of the child to understand the impact and consequences of the behavior subject to disciplinary action; and (iii) The child’s disability did not impair the ability of the child to control the behavior subject to disciplinary action.
California law is similar to the federal law; however, the wording is slightly different. California Education Code Section 48915.5(a) provides that a child with previously identified exceptional needs who is receiving special education services may only be expelled if the following conditions are met:
(1) An individualized education program team meeting is held and conducted....
(2) The team determines that the misconduct was not caused by, or was not a direct manifestation of, the pupil’s identified disability.
(3) The team determines that the pupil had been appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred.
California law also provides that there must be a preexpulsion assessment upon which the IEP team will base its manifestation determination. Education Code Section 48915.5(e) provides that the preexplusion assessment must include “a review of the appropriateness of the pupil’s placement at the time of the alleged misconduct, and a determination of the relationship, if any, between the pupil’s behavior and his or her disability.”
In this case, the petitioner did not contend that the District failed to follow proper procedures in making the manifestation determination.(Footnote 1) STUDENT’s mother also stated during the hearing that she was not challenging the appropriateness of STUDENT’s special education program or placement at the time of his conduct that resulted in the proposed expulsion.
There was no evidence that STUDENT did not understand the impact and consequences of his actions. In fact, he admitted that he knew his conduct was a violation of school rules. He did say that he did not think his conduct would result in a proposed expulsion, but he fully understood that what he was doing was wrong and would subject him to some form of discipline if his act was discovered.
The only issue raised by STUDENT was whether his disability impaired his ability to control his behavior.
There was no evidence presented that provided any support for the conclusion that his learning disability impaired his ability to control his actions. He had an identified learning disability that consisted of deficits in visual and auditory memory which impede his ability in math and written language. These deficits had no nexus to the act of throwing a trash can through the windshield of another student’s car.
STUDENT’s mother argued that STUDENT had an identified physical condition that caused him to have sudden, uncontrollable outbursts of anger when he was not taking his medication. She contended that this condition caused his act of throwing the trash can through the windshield of the other student’s car.
Federal law provides that when a child with a disability engages in behavior which impedes his or her learning or that of others, the IEP team must consider, if appropriate, “strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, strategies, and supports to address that behavior.” 34 CFR 300.346.
The District had knowledge that in junior high school STUDENT had experienced problems with controlling his anger, but had no information that this was a current problem for STUDENT. His teachers, including Mickey Sanders, Connie Strause, Tom Sprink, and Malinda Van Hooser all testified that STUDENT understood and complied with school rules. He was not a behavior problem. He did not exhibit any behavior issues which interfered with his education.
At the beginning of his senior year, STUDENT’s mother completed a health status form which asked whether STUDENT had any medical problems. STUDENT’s mother stated that he did not have any medical problems or physical limitations.
STUDENT did have two instances of discipline in his junior year, but there was no evidence that either incident was caused by an uncontrollable outburst of anger. During his senior year, prior to the windshield smashing incident he had only been disciplined once for possession and use of alcohol, an offense which would not appear to be related to his ability to control his anger.
There was no reason for the District to believe that STUDENT suffered from an inability to control his anger. And there is no evidence that if he had such a condition, it impeded his learning or the learning of others.
Therefore, the District was correct in concluding that his conduct of throwing a trash can through the windshield of another student’s car was not a manifestation of any identified disability.
There is also little evidence to support the fact that STUDENT suffers from a condition which limits his ability to control his anger. STUDENT’s counselor, Ms. Randolph, stated that STUDENT’s conduct in throwing the trash can through the windshield of the car was congruent with Intermittent Explosive Disorder as described in Code 312.14 of the DSM. VI. Clinical psychologist Dr. Michael Bobik testified at the hearing that he does not believe that STUDENT meets the diagnostic criteria for Intermittent Explosive Disorder. The DSM VI sets out the following diagnostic criteria for the disorder:
A. Several discrete episodes of failure to resist aggressive impulses that result in serious assaultive acts or destruction of property.
B. The degree of aggressiveness expressed during the episodes is grossly out of proportion to any precipitating psychosocial stressors.
C. The aggressive episodes are not better accounted for by another mental disorder (e.g., Antisocial Personality Disorder, Borderline Personality Disorder, a Psychotic Disorder, a Manic Episode, Conduct Disorder, or Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder) and are not due to the direct physiological effects of a substance (e.g., a drug of abuse, a medication) or a general medical condition (e.g., head trauma, Alzheimer’s disease).
Dr. Bobik testified that if STUDENT had suffered from this disorder, there would have been other instances of explosions of anger within the last year. There was no evidence of any other instances within the last year of such uncontrolled outbursts of anger. This is especially significant in light of the fact that STUDENT had been not been taking his prescribed medication for over a year and a half before this incident occurred.
The Hearing Officer is of the opinion that STUDENT’s conduct in smashing the windshield with a trash can did not fit diagnostic criteria B in that it was not grossly out of proportion to the conduct that precipitated the action. While STUDENT’s conduct was a violation of school rules and a crime, it was in reaction to a death threat made by a rival gang member. STUDENT admitted that his reason for taking the action was to send a sign to the rival gang member that he should not mess with him or his friends. It cannot be concluded that this action was out of proportion to the threat that had been made. It was more a measured and calculated response to a serious threat than an uncontrollable fit of anger. STUDENT admitted that he did not like the student whose car he damaged, that he was reacting to a specific threat. He walked from 20 to 30 feet to get a trash can and returned with it and smashed it through the windshield of the other student’s car. The time that it took to commit the offense is further evidence that the act was not a sudden outburst of anger, but a calculated response to a threat.
It is concluded that the District was correct in concluding the STUDENT’s actions were not a manifestation of his identified disability. The District was also correct in concluding that the act was not the result of a sudden uncontrollable outburst of anger.
ORDER
1. All of Petitioner’s claims are denied.
2. The District may proceed with the expulsion hearing and may order discipline consistent with that which would be appropriate for a nondisabled student.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(i).
Dated:
Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: The Hearing Officer is concerned about the thoroughness of the preexpulsion assessment performed by school psychologist Gregory Armstrong. He based his assessment exclusively on interviews with STUDENT’s special education teachers and District administrators and a review of STUDENT’s special education and disciplinary records. Of course, he did have prior knowledge of STUDENT from having assessed him during the previous year. But he did not interview or test STUDENT as part of his preexplusion assessment. In a disciplinary matter, it is important to understand the student’s motivations and his version of what happened. It is also important to interview the student in order to help determine whether the student understood that what he was doing was inappropriate. During the hearing, STUDENT’s testimony provided some of the most useful information needed by the Hearing Officer to determine whether his conduct was a manifestation of his disability and whether he understood what he was doing was wrong. Such information might have been equally illuminating to Mr. Armstrong. This weakness in the assessment is not serious enough to require a remand for further assessment by the District, because the missing information was provided to the Hearing Officer during the hearing.
