California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 16, 1999
Student v. Colton Joint Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 324-99 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Colton Joint Unified must reimburse parents $500 for a private assessment after inadequate and delayed speech and OT evaluations.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 12-year-old fourth grader filed for due process against Colton Joint Unified School District. The student qualified for special education under specific learning disability and was also designated orthopedically impaired. Before the hearing, the parties settled disputes over access to records and a word processor. That left one question: should the parents be reimbursed $500 for a private assessment done in early 1998 at Big Springs School by educational therapist Regina Richards and speech-language pathologist Dindy Wheelock?
The District argued that its own assessments were adequate. It also said it never saw the Big Springs report until the hearing and that the parents had asked only to be reimbursed for services from Trusedale (Truesdale) Center. The Hearing Officer found the parents credible. The notes from the January and February 1999 IEP meetings showed a separate request to pay for the outside evaluation. On the main question, the District's December 1997 speech-language assessment was mostly a fill-in form focused on speech production. It barely addressed the auditory processing deficits that the school psychologist had already found, so it did not assess all areas of suspected disability. The District also waited until June 1998 to do an occupational therapy assessment and until September 1998 to do a full speech assessment. It did not hold an IEP meeting on those results until January 1999, 13 months after the first IEP meeting following the student's return. The District was ordered to pay the parents $500 within 30 days.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a claim to be reimbursed for a private evaluation. The district's speech assessment ignored auditory processing problems its own psychologist had already found. The Hearing Officer also treated a 13-month delay in assessing all suspected areas, and in meeting on the results, as a reason to reimburse the evaluation the parents obtained.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment jointly conducted by Regina Richards, M.A., and Dindy Wheelock, M.S. (Big Springs)?
The District's December 1997 speech assessment did not address known auditory processing deficits, and the District took 13 months to assess all suspected areas and hold an IEP meeting on the results, so parents were entitled to $500 reimbursement for the Big Springs assessment.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within thirty days of the decision, District shall reimburse the parents $500.00 for the independent evaluation conducted by Big Springs.
Total: $500 ordered
Key authorities
Cal. Educ. Code 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code 56320 (cited as 36320); Cal. Educ. Code 56327; Cal. Educ. Code 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer (observer), Special Education Hearing Office
- Russell Rankin, Non-attorney advocate assisting parents, Developmental Disabilities Area Board XII
- Gail Lindberg, District representative, East Valley SELPA
- Bonnie Russell-Hunt, Director of pupil services, Colton Joint Unified School District
- Richard (Rick) Pesqueira, School psychologist, Colton Joint Unified School District
- Jacqueline Pridgeon, SELPA speech therapist (December 1997 assessment), East Valley SELPA
- Gale (Gayle) Wray, Occupational therapist, East Valley SELPA
- Kaye Sheffield, Speech therapist (September 1998 assessment), Colton Joint Unified School District
- Regina Richards, Educational therapist and director; independent assessor, Richards Educational Therapy Center/Big Springs School
- Dindy Wheelock, Private speech-language pathologist; independent assessor, Richards Educational Therapy Center/Big Springs School
- Richards Educational Therapy Center/Big Springs School, Private assessment provider
- Trusedale (Truesdale) Center, Private assessment, tutoring, and speech therapy provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Bloomington, California, on May 4 and 5, 1999. Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda attended as an observer. Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter Petitioner or STUDENT) appeared through his parents, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT. Russell Rankin from the Developmental Disabilities Area Board XII provided assistance to the parents throughout the hearing. Respondent Colton Joint Unified School District (hereinafter Colton or District) was represented by Gail Lindberg of the East Valley Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA). Also present on Respondent's behalf was Bonnie Russell-Hunt, director of pupil services for Colton. The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: Mrs. PARENT, mother of Petitioner; Mr. PARENT, father of Petitioner; and Gale Wray, occupational therapist. (Footnote 1) The Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: Bonnie Russell-Hunt, Colton's director of pupil services; and Richard Pesqueira, school psychologist. Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. The Hearing Office received the written closing arguments, the record was closed and the issue was submitted for a decision. PROCEDURAL MATTERS Prior to the presentation of evidence, the parties resolved the issue of parental access to STUDENT's educational records. Before the second day of the hearing began, the parties also settled the issue of the availability of a word processor. Consequently, these issues will not be addressed by the Hearing Officer. The hearing continued on the issue of reimbursement for a private assessment. ISSUE Are Mr. and Mrs. PARENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment jointly conducted by Regina Richards, M.A., and Dindy Wheelock, M.S.? CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES The Petitioner contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for an independent educational and speech assessment conducted at Richards Educational Therapy Center/Big Springs School (hereinafter Big Springs). The Petitioner argues that because the District's speech and educational evaluations were insufficient, it was necessary to obtain this information privately to assist in determining the appropriate placement and services for STUDENT. The District maintains that its assessments were adequate. In addition, it claims that the Big Springs report was never furnished to it until shortly before this hearing. Therefore, the information contained therein did not provide any additional benefit when drafting STUDENT's individual educational program (IEP), or goals and objectives. Moreover, it is the District's position that the parents requested reimbursement for an evaluation done by Trusedale Center (hereinafter Trusedale) but that they never sought repayment for the Big Springs evaluation. Colton argues that, as a result, the Petitioner cannot seek reimbursement for an assessment conducted by Big Springs. BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT is twelve years old and currently a fourth-grade student after repeating two grade levels. He qualifies for special education because of a specific learning disability. He is further designated as orthopedically impaired. STUDENT's parents state that he has leg perthys, fine motor delays, and an attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity (ADHD). He takes medication for the ADHD, as well as for depression. According to Mrs. PARENT, STUDENT also exhibits outbursts of anger. STUDENT and his family have resided within the Colton School District's geographical boundaries throughout his educational years. Before he reached school age, STUDENT was placed by the District in a special education preschool program at San Salvador School. As a kindergartner, he was enrolled as a special education student at Reche Canyon Elementary School (hereinafter Reche), his home school. His parents removed him from Reche following kindergarten and placed him at Calvary Chapel (hereinafter Calvary), a private school. Although the District continued to serve STUDENT's siblings, and thus was aware that the family remained within the District, it did not provide STUDENT with any services while he attended Calvary, nor did it conduct IEP meetings. (Footnote 2) STUDENT returned to the District in October 1997. Because he did not have a current IEP, he was initially placed by the District in a general education class at Reche without special education support. To update its information regarding STUDENT, the District had its psychologist, Rick Pesqueira, conduct a psychoeducational evaluation in October and November 1997. Mr. Pesqueira reported that STUDENT's nonverbal problem -solving skills, which require perceptual organization, were above average. In marked contrast, his verbal associative concepts, social judgement and math reasoning were within the low average range. He also displayed low average abilities in verbal conceptual skills and freedom from distractability in tasks requiring short-term attention and memory. STUDENT's reading level was at an early second grade level when tested using the Woodcock Reading Mastery and WIAT assessment tools. His math abilities were equivalent to the level of the third month of the third grade. His grade equivalence in spelling was 2.8. Mr. Pesqueira did not note problems with social adjustment; however, STUDENT did have difficulties in the areas of task attention and completion. Test results revealed that he had long-term memory abilities within average limits. However, he displayed pronounced deficiencies with short-term attention and memory. In skills involving rote memory for numerical sequences, sentences, interpreting directions, and word units, STUDENT scored below the tenth percentile. Mr. Penqueira also found a severe discrepancy between STUDENT's nonverbal abilities and his academic performance, especially in the areas of reading and written language. Mr. Pesqueira concluded that STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education due to a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement with auditory processing concerns and a weakness in verbal abilities. He recommended that STUDENT be provided with strategies for addressing his auditory processing weakness and a structured reading program which emphasized a multi-sensory approach. On behalf of the District, Jacqueline Pridgeon, a SELPA speech therapist, administered one test to STUDENT on November 24, 1997, and three additional tests on December 5 and 9, 1997. (Footnote 3) She determined that STUDENT's test results were within the normal range and that he did not qualify for special education as speech and language impaired. On December 10, 1997, an IEP meeting was convened. The District offered placement in the general education fourth-grade class with resource specialist support (RSP) sixty to ninety minutes per day, five days per week. Proposed goals were to improve STUDENT's reading skills, written work and auditory processing abilities. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT declined to sign this IEP document. They requested placement in a "language-based" class and decided to visit special day classes (SDC) within the District. As a result of depression, in January 1998, STUDENT was placed on a home/hospital study program for three months pursuant to a physician's orders. The District claims that STUDENT was not provided with special education services while on home study because he did not have a signed IEP. Again, the Hearing Officer was provided with very little information about the reason home study was necessary, the dates of the home study program, or any education STUDENT received during this period. Between the dates of January 22 to February 24, 1998, STUDENT's parents obtained an independent assessment at Big Springs. This testing was jointly performed by Regina Richards, M.A., an educational therapist and the director of Big Springs, and Dindy Wheelock, M.S., a speech and language pathologist. Ms. Richards and Ms. Wheelock reported STUDENT's visual perceptual skills and math as areas of strength for him. He was also found to have a strong knowledge of general information and a good understanding of vocabulary. His area of weakness was described as a language-based, auditory learning disability which affected his reading, writing and verbal expression. In addition, STUDENT had difficulty with organizing verbal expression and poor semantic flexibility. As language became more complex, his basic language skills decreased. His reading and spelling were characterized by significant gaps in phonological awareness. Ms. Richards and Ms. Wheelock prioritized the following recommendations: 1. Placement in a classroom environment where his areas of strength can be utilized; 2. Initiation of classroom modifications to help STUDENT learn more efficiently and successfully. Examples provided were: a. Establish a consistent signal when instructions are to be given; b. Preferential seating; c. Restate information provided orally; d. Use a reduced rate of speed, shorter sentences, and frequent pauses; e. Visual props for auditory information; f. Before new oral information is given, provide cues for listening for important facts; g. Provide assistance to organize and formulate what STUDENT wants to say or write; h. Compensate for visual skill deficiencies by reducing chalkboard copying and providing paper with substantial white areas and clarity of print; i. Other modifications included a reduction in the quantity of assignments, do not reduce grades for misspelling, provide extra time, provide tasks incrementally, prioritize task components for complex activities, use technology such as a computer and a Franklin Speller; 3. Develop study skill strategies that use strength in visual processing; 4. Develop phonetically logical spelling, then use an electronic speller to check his accuracy; 5. Two hours per week of direct speech therapy; 6. Provide a multi-sensory remedial assistance in reading, spelling, comprehension and writing; 7. Develop strategies to help STUDENT visually track his place on a written page; and 8. Continue using a word processor. Another IEP meeting was held on May 19, 1998. This meeting occurred at the parent's request to discuss STUDENT's school placement upon his return from home study. At the meeting, the District's placement offer was ninety to three hundred minutes per day, five days per week of RSP and special day class (SDC) assistance. STUDENT was also offered thirty-minute sessions of on-site counseling one to two times a week. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT presented an independent evaluation from Trusedale at this IEP meeting. (Footnote 4) They expressed a need for socially acceptable behavior from STUDENT. They also requested assessments by a speech pathologist and an occupational therapy (OT) fine motor evaluation. The parents further wanted STUDENT excused from physical education and placed in a SELPA county program with an emphasis on language. On June 11, 1998, another psychoeducational evaluation was conducted by Rick Pesqueira. (Footnote 5) Tests indicated that STUDENT continued to require special education assistance in the areas of reading and written language. His basic reading skills were determined to be at a 3.4 grade level with reading comprehension at a 2.9 grade level. Written language was found to be STUDENT's weakest area with spelling abilities at a second -grade level and writing skills at a readiness level. Poor grammar and punctuation were also noted. STUDENT's math skills were his main area of strength, with test scores at a mid-fourth-grade level. Deficits in organization and attention-related concerns were noted. Although STUDENT had difficulty with visual organization, his other visual skills appeared age appropriate. Mr. Pesqueira concluded that STUDENT continued to require special education support that included visual cues to assist with teacher instruction and a multi-sensory approach to address academic weaknesses. An OT assessment was conducted on June 12, 1998, by Gayle Wray, an OT with the East Valley Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA). The purpose of her evaluation was to determine the appropriate intervention for fine motor/handwriting skills. Ms. Wray found that STUDENT demonstrated difficulty with writing endurance and that his production of written work was extremely slow. She recommended limiting pencil tasks through the use of a word processor and stated that a word processor with a spell checker was necessary to ensure STUDENT's success on school assignments. The parties met for another IEP meeting on August 18, 1998 to discuss STUDENT's placement following receipt of the above evaluations. Although the District stated that it believed STUDENT's needs could be met at his home school, it agreed to make a referral for placement at a county program pursuant to the parents request. It further agreed to reconvene the IEP meeting when the speech therapist's evaluation was completed. A speech and language assessment was conducted by Kaye Sheffield, a Colton speech therapist, on September 30, 1998. Ms. Sheffield's examination revealed deficits in auditory processing, short-term memory, homonyms, and difficulties with grammar. She wrote that STUDENT would benefit from "extra help, encouragement, and suggestions provided to aid in auditory processing of information." An IEP meeting held on January 11, 1999, was indicated in the IEP document to be a continuation of the May 19, 1998 and August 18, 1998 IEP meetings. Its purpose was to review the speech assessment of September 1998. By the time of this meeting, STUDENT had been placed in a communicatively handicapped special day class at Mariposa School (hereinafter Mariposa), a county program, where he continues to date. The IEP team agreed to continue STUDENT's present goals and objectives until the team met with the county staff to determine his current needs. At this meeting, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT requested reimbursement for "outside testing; a word processor; outside tutoring in addition to CH/SDC placement - TRUSEDALE." On February 16, 1999, another IEP meeting was held to review the outside assessments obtained by Mr. and Mrs. PARENT, in addition to those conducted by the District and the SELPA. It was determined that these assessments supported an ongoing need for auditory processing assistance with goals continuing to address STUDENT's auditory processing deficits, reading recognition, comprehension and math computations. The team also reviewed STUDENT's progress and discussed his goals for the following year. It agreed that after editing his work, STUDENT should have access to a word processor during prolonged writing assignments. The parents raised concerns about the independent evaluations, reimbursement for these evaluations, and LST (learning severely handicapped) services provided by Trusedale. Mrs. PARENT indicated that they would no longer pursue reimbursement for the Trusedale services. ISSUE Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for an independent assessment? It is the District's position that the Petitioner requested reimbursement for tutoring and an evaluation conducted by Truesdale. However, according to Ms. Russell-Hunt, Colton's director of pupil services, the District was unaware of the Big Springs assessment and never received the report until a copy was provided by the Petitioner in his evidence packet for hearing. Ms. Russell-Hunt maintained that, as a result, the Big Springs assessment did not contribute to STUDENT's IEPs. Ms. Russell-Hunt further claimed that the District would not have conducted its own speech evaluation in September 1998 had it had the Big Springs report. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT disagree that their reimbursement request for "outside testing" was for the independent evaluation from Truesdale. They claim to have initially sought reimbursement for tutoring provided by Truesdale, and for the independent assessment conducted by Big Springs. Both parents testified that they provided the District office with a copy of the Big Springs bill and requested reimbursement in February and March 1998. They also testified that they provided the District with a copy of the Big Springs report and requested reimbursement for it during the January and February 1999 IEP meetings. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of Mr. and Mrs. PARENT is credible and that the documentary evidence supports their position. The IEP of January 11, 1999, states: "Parent requesting reimbursement for outside testing; a word processor; outside tutoring in addition to CH/SDC placement- TRUESDALE." The Hearing Officer concludes that this statement refers to four separate issues: (1) repayment for an independent evaluation,(2) a word processor, (3) placement in the county's SDC, and (4) reimbursement for private tutoring by Truesdale. The contents of the IEP of February 1999 further support the Petitioner's position. Contained in this document is the statement "1/11/99 IEP addressed additional concerns around outside evaluation, reimbursement and LST services at Truesdale." The use of the word "and" between a reimbursement request for an outside evaluation and LST services at Truesdale, indicates that two separate issues are being addressed. The February 1999 IEP also is consistent with the PARENTs testimony that they withdrew their request for repayment of the Truesdale services. The IEP states: "Mrs. PARENT indicates that the family is not pursuing reimbursement for Truesdale services." It does not state that the parents have also withdrawn their demand for reimbursement of the "outside evaluation." The separation in each document of reimbursement and Truesdale services indicates that different issues were being raised. This is consistent with the Petitioner's assertion that they were requesting reimbursement for the independent assessment from Big Springs and for additional services from Truesdale. Moreover, it is illogical that the parents would repeatedly request reimbursement for tutoring services and an independent evaluation from Truesdale, withdraw that request, then file for a due process hearing seeking the lessor monetary sum of $500.00 as repayment for the Big Springs assessment. The Hearing Officer therefore makes a factual finding that the District received notice of the parents' request for reimbursement for the independent assessment conducted by Big Springs. There is no disagreement between the parties that the Petitioner repeatedly sought reimbursement for an independent assessment. The District was therefore on notice of a repayment demand. A parent is entitled to reimbursement for an independent evaluation if the District's assessment was inadequate. The Hearing Officer therefore turns to the more general questions of (1) whether the speech and language assessment conducted by the District on December 9, 1997, was adequate and (2) whether the District complied with its obligation to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability in a timely manner. California Education Code 56329(b) provides: A parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists . . . if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, the public education agency may initiate a due process hearing . . . to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the final decision resulting from the due process hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense. For a district's assessment to be appropriate, it must satisfy the following requirements: (1) the assessment must be conducted by a qualified person who possesses the requisite state and federal certifications in the area in which they are assessing, (2) the testing materials cannot be racially, culturally or sexually biased, (3) the tests must be provided in the student's primary language or method of communication, (4) the test given must be validated for the specific purpose for which it is being used, (5) the assessor must be trained in and administer the test in conformance with the test's instructions, (6) intellectual or psychological tests must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist, (7) the pupil must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability, and (8) the assessor must be knowledgeable of the student's disability. California Education Code 36320(e). At the conclusion of the evaluation, the assessor must provide a written report containing the results of the assessment. California Education Code 56327. The speech and language assessment and resulting report of December 9, 1997 from Ms. Pridgeon, primarily assesses STUDENT's communication and speech production skills. The report concluded that STUDENT exhibited "age appropriate articulation, voice, fluency, receptive and expressive language skills" and did not qualify for special education as speech and language impaired. The Hearing Officer first notes that the report appears to be a "form" report in which the assessor merely filled in responses to prewritten categories or checked a box from multiple choices. It does not contain much individual information pertaining specifically to STUDENT. In addition, the District was aware that STUDENT had exhibited an auditory processing deficit since preschool, yet the focus of the speech evaluation is primarily on STUDENT's speaking abilities. The District's psychoeducational report by Mr. Penqueira was done in November 1997. Thus, it was available for the speech assessor to review as part of her evaluation. Mr. Penqueira's test results specifically found "pronounced deficiencies" in short-term memory and attention. STUDENT scored below the tenth percentile in areas involving memory for sequencing and understanding directions, sentences and word units. Mr. Penqueira concluded that STUDENT had auditory processing difficulties and weak verbal skills. He recommended that STUDENT be provided with a multi-sensory teaching method and strategies for responding to his auditory processing difficulties. Despite the availability of this information about STUDENT's processing problems, only one sentence in Ms. Pridgeon's entire report referenced STUDENT's auditory processing issues. She states that STUDENT "exhibited significant weaknesses in the areas of sentence imitation indicative of difficulty in the area of short term auditory memory." Auditory processing issues are within the domain of a speech pathologist. However, Ms. Pridgeon did no further investigation of her own, or of Mr. Penqueira's, findings, nor did she offer "strategies for responding to his auditory processing weakness." The Hearing Officer finds that the speech evaluation conducted by the District on December 9, 1997, was insufficient and violates the requirements of California Education Code 56329(b). It did not adequately address STUDENT's auditory processing deficiencies and ,consequently, it failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. Because the Hearing Officer has found that the speech evaluation of December 9, 1997, did not adequately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, it is next necessary to determine whether the District provided another evaluation that did assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability in a timely manner. The first re-enrollment IEP meeting to discuss the assessment results and determine placement and services was held on December 10, 1997. At that meeting, the parents specifically requested placement in a "language-based class." Despite Mr. and Mrs. PARENT's request for a language program, the psychologist's confirmation of an auditory processing disorder, and the speech therapist's reference to short-term memory problems, Colton did not have a speech pathologist conduct testing of STUDENT in these areas until September 30, 1998, one year after STUDENT returned to the District. (Footnote 6) This subsequent speech evaluator did find STUDENT eligible for special education as a result of her testing. STUDENT also has a medical diagnosis of leg perthys and issues relating to fine motor development. He has a second special education designation as orthopedically impaired. Following his return to the District in October 1997, Colton did not conduct an OT assessment until June 1998, eight months later. The occupational therapist found that STUDENT had handwriting difficulties that necessitated a word processor. The IEP meeting to discuss the results of the speech and OT evaluations was not held until January 11, 1999, approximately seven months after the OT assessment and three and a half months after the speech assessment. A total of thirteen months had elapsed between the first IEP meeting following STUDENT's return to the District and the IEP meeting to consider the results of the District's OT and speech and language reports. At the first IEP meeting of December 10, 1997, the parents raised STUDENT's ADHD and fine motor delays, and sought placement in a language program. At that same meeting, the school psychologist verified a processing disorder. STUDENT was also a returning student who had been known to the District as a special education student since preschool. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that a lapse of thirteen months between STUDENT's re-enrollment in the District and the convening of an IEP meeting to discuss assessment results constitutes a failure by Colton to perform timely evaluations in all areas of suspected disability. The parents sought their independent evaluation from Big Springs in January and February 1998, following the IEP meeting in which the District failed to present an assessment plan to conduct complete OT and speech assessments. The independent assessment obtained by the parents was conducted jointly by an educational consultant and a speech therapist. It confirmed that STUDENT had a language-based, auditory processing disability. In addition to enumerating specific modifications needed by STUDENT, the independent evaluators recommended that STUDENT receive two hours per week of one-on-one speech therapy. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT maintained that the assessment supported their repeated request that STUDENT be placed in the County's communicatively handicapped SDC, as he ultimately was. CONCLUSION The evidence establishes that Colton's initial speech and language evaluation was inadequate and that it did not thereafter conduct a timely assessment of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. The Hearing Officer finds that a delay in excess of one year to properly assess in areas of disability to which the District was alerted, and to convene an IEP meeting to consider the results of such assessments, violates 36320 of the California Education Code. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement in the sum of $500.00 for the independent assessment conducted by Big Springs. ORDER 1. Within thirty days of the date of this decision, the District shall reimburse Mr. and Mrs. PARENT the sum of $500.00 for the independent evaluation conducted by Big Springs. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code 56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The Petitioner prevailed on the only issue heard and decided. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(i).Dated:_________________________ _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
1. The testimony of Ms. Wray pertained only to the Petitioner's need for a word processor. Following her testimony, but before the case was submitted for a decision, the parties settled the issue of a word processor. Ms. Wray's testimony will therefore not be discussed in this decision.2. The parties provided no documentary evidence and very little testimony concerning STUDENT's educational background prior to his return to the District in October of 1997. The Hearing Officer has therefore attempted to compile an accurate chronology with limited information.3. Neither party introduced this report into evidence at the hearing, nor did either party discuss it during testimony. The Hearing Officer issued an order reopening the record to admit this report and required the parties to provide a written response addressing whether the Hearing Officer should consider the report and discussing its significance to the issue of reimbursement for the independent assessment. Following receipt of the responses, the Hearing Officer determined that the December 9, 1997 speech report would be considered.4. At some point, STUDENT's parents also had him assessed by Trusedale. Neither testimony nor a report from this evaluation was introduced into evidence, so the Hearing Officer is unaware of the findings or recommendations from this agency. Parent testimony indicates that the Petitioner also received private speech and communication therapy at Trusedale from 1996 through 1998. 5. The IEP document of May 19, 1998, states: "Team met at the request of the family to discuss STUDENT's placement upon return from Home and Hospital teaching." Mr. Pesqueira's report states that the evaluation he conducted on June 11, 1998, was done while STUDENT remained on home study. The Hearing Officer therefore assumes that the initial three months of home study prescribed by the physician in January 1998 was extended at some point.6. The District argued that it would not have conducted this speech assessment if it had known of the Big Springs assessment. The Hearing Officer notes that the District's speech assessment was conducted eight months after the Big Springs assessment.
