California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 22, 2004

Student v. Murrieta Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 328-04 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown

Murrieta Valley Unified must reimburse 114 hours of private CARD therapy for a late preschool IEP offer; other claims mostly denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 4 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parent of a four-year-old boy with autism filed for due process against Murrieta Valley Unified School District. The parent sought reimbursement for a 35-hour-per-week home discrete trial therapy (DTT) program from the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), and prospective CARD placement. The boy moved from Inland Regional Center services to the District when he turned three in July 2002. The District did not give the parent an assessment plan until mid-June, and the first IEP meeting was not held until October 16, 2002. The Hearing Officer found that the District caused the delay, not the parent, because the law gave her at least 15 days to review the plan. The delay broke the rule that an IEP be in place by age three, cost the student educational opportunity, and denied him FAPE from mid-August to mid-October 2002. Claims about missing IEP team members failed. The District's program was a preschool special day class, home DTT, speech therapy, and occupational therapy (OT). The Hearing Officer found it met the student's needs, and he made meaningful progress. The District missed some OT sessions in 2002-2003 and four speech sessions in fall 2003. The November 2003 offer provided FAPE, so prospective CARD placement was denied. The District must reimburse the first 114 hours of CARD services and offer makeup OT and 80 minutes of speech therapy.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the rule that a district have an IEP in place by a toddler's third birthday. The Hearing Officer would not blame the delay on a parent who used her full review period for the assessment plan. The decision also shows how lost hours were counted and paid back by reimbursing part of a private program.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partIEP procedure

    Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

    The District's late assessment plan and October 16, 2002 IEP meeting violated the Part C-to-Part B rule to have an IEP by age three, which denied FAPE from mid-August to mid-October 2002, and the District missed three hours of OT. The team-member claims failed, and the program was otherwise appropriate and provided benefit.

  2. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

    The program from August to November 2003 and the November/December 2003 offer of an SDC with an inclusion program, DTT, speech, and OT provided FAPE. The only violation was four missed speech-language sessions (80 minutes).

  3. Issue 3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement for the costs of the program provided by Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)?

    The parents get reimbursement for the first 114 hours of CARD services to make up for services lost from August 14 to October 16, 2002, plus makeup OT and 80 minutes of speech therapy. Further reimbursement was denied.

  4. Issue 4. Is STUDENT entitled to prospective placement with the CARD program for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year?

    Because the District's November 2003 offer was appropriate, there was no basis to order prospective placement at CARD.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Parents must give the District proof of expenses (invoices and receipts) for the first 114 hours of CARD services starting in November 2003. The District must reimburse the amount paid to CARD for those hours within 30 calendar days of receiving the proof.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 calendar days of the decision, the District must send written notice of an IEP meeting to all team members. The meeting must convene within 30 calendar days of the decision.
  • Compensatory education. At that IEP meeting, the District must offer an additional four hours of OT and 80 minutes of speech-language services as compensation for missed sessions, on top of the existing offer. The findings identify three hours of missed OT.

Total: 5.33 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District No. 69; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Johnson v. Special Education Hearing Office; Adams v. State of Oregon; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Alamo Heights v. State Board of Education; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District; Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S.; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 17, § 52112(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56344(a)

People named in the decision

  • Zhanna Preston, District special education director, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Moussa Sabarra, District program specialist, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Theresa Contreras, CARD supervisor; witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Dr. Betty Bostani, CARD psychologist; assessed student January 2004; witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, CARD clinical director; witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Dr. Sebastien Bosch, CARD director of research and development; witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Linda Lucas, school psychologist, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Joanne Abrassart, speech-language pathologist, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Melissa Gidley, speech-language pathologist, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Betsy Baird, inclusion support teacher, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Estela Dominguez, preschool special education (SDC) teacher, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Amy Brennan, occupational therapist, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Audrey Lindemulder, occupational therapist, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Jeanine Johnson, speech-language pathologist, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Dr. Kathleen Kitlowski, psychologist; supervised in-home DTT through nonpublic agency; witness for District, ACCESS (nonpublic agency)
  • Melissa LaMothe, special education teacher (assessor), Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Gail Hansen, adaptive physical education teacher, Murrieta Valley Unified School District
  • Barbara Lopez, early intervention teacher, VIP Tots
  • Dr. Thomas Gross, licensed psychologist; Regional Center psychological assessment, Inland Regional Center referral
  • Patricia Brown, independent speech-language pathologist, Private
  • ACCESS, nonpublic agency providing in-home DTT
  • Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), private ABA/DTT provider
  • VIP Tots, early intervention provider
  • Inland Regional Center, Part C regional center

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard in Murrieta, California, on April 20-23, April 29, and May 4-7, 2004, before Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law. (Footnote 1) Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter referred to as Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Shelli Lewis. Present on Petitioner’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Attorney Don Gonzales also represented Petitioner on some hearing days. Paralegal Stephen Gonzales was present to assist Ms. Lewis on some hearing days, and attorney Patricia Cromer assisted on one hearing day. Respondent Murrieta Valley Unified School District (hereinafter referred to as District) was represented by attorney Maria Gless of the law firm of Best, Best & Krieger. Present on the District’s behalf was District special education director Zhanna Preston. District program specialist Moussa Sabarra attended the hearing on two days in place of Ms. Preston. Additionally, attorneys Haviva Shane and Rick Eggers each attended brief portions of the hearing on behalf of the District. Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Theresa Contreras, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) supervisor; Dr. Betty Bostani, CARD psychologist; Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, CARD clinical director; MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; and Dr. Sebastien Bosch, director of research and development for CARD.

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Linda Lucas, District school psychologist; Joanne Abrassart, District speech-language pathologist; Melissa Gidley, District speech-language pathologist; Betsy Baird, District inclusion support teacher; Estela Dominguez, District special education teacher; Amy Brennan, District occupational therapist; Audrey Lindemulder, District occupational therapist; Jeanine Johnson, District speech-language pathologist; and Dr. Kathleen Kitlowski, psychologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. Upon receipt of closing briefs on May 25, 2004, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 2)

(1 Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

(2) Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

(3) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement for the costs of the program provided by Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)?

(4) Is STUDENT entitled to prospective placement with the CARD program for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that the District failed to make a timely offer of FAPE by his third birthday and that, as a result, he did not begin receiving his educational program until several months after his third birthday. Petitioner argues that the District also procedurally denied him a FAPE by failing to include the necessary participants at the IEP meetings. Additionally, Petitioner contends that his initial IEP of October/November 2002 misidentified his then-present levels of performance by stating lower levels than he had actually achieved, and thus wrote goals for tasks and behaviors he could already perform. Petitioner further asserts that he failed to make progress in his District placement, and that the District failed to document any progress he made during that time period. Petitioner also argues that the District failed to provide the amounts of occupational therapy, speech-language therapy and in-home discrete trial therapy specified in his IEP.

The District alleges that it made a timely offer of FAPE and that STUDENT’s initial offer of FAPE was delayed only because his parents delayed in consenting to the initial evaluation. The District contends that all of the necessary participants attended STUDENT’s IEP meetings and no procedural denial of FAPE occurred. The District further argues that it conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT which resulted in accurate present levels of performance and appropriate goals and objectives drafted for the IEP. The District contends that it offered an appropriate placement and services that constituted a FAPE, and that STUDENT made progress during the time he attended the District program. The District states that it provided all of STUDENT’s designated instruction and services (DIS) in conformity with his IEP. Additionally, the District argues that the CARD placement was not appropriate for STUDENT.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT is a four-year ten-month-old boy who is eligible for special education services based on a diagnosis of autism. STUDENT lives within the boundaries of the District with his parents and four siblings.

In February 2002, when he was two and a half years old, the Inland Regional Center (Regional Center) held an individual family services plan (IFSP) meeting for STUDENT and determined that he was eligible for services from the Regional Center due to speech and language delays. Initially STUDENT’s services consisted of two hours of one-to-one early intervention services per week provided by teacher Barbara Lopez of VIP Tots. Pursuant to the PARENTS’ request, the Regional Center increased STUDENT’s services to three hours per week in May 2002, and finally to four hours per week in June 2002.

On April 11, 2002, STUDENT’s Regional Center providers and caseworkers met with STUDENT’s parents and District speech-language pathologist Joanne Abrassart to discuss the transition of STUDENT’s educational services from the Regional Center to the District upon his third birthday. Because STUDENT’s third birthday would occur in July 2002, the participants agreed that the Regional Center would continue to provide STUDENT’s services until the new school year began on August 14, 2002. (Exh. 51; testimony of MOTHER, Joanne Abrassart.) At the meeting on April 11, Ms. Abrassart scheduled STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting for August 12, 2002, and obtained MOTHER’s verbal agreement to a waiver of the legal timelines for conducting the District’s assessment and initial IEP meeting. However, after the April 11 meeting, the District’s special education director rescheduled the initial IEP meeting to June 14, 2002, with the goal of completing the assessments of STUDENT before the end of the 2002-2003 school year.

STUDENT’s initial IEP team meeting convened on June 14, 2002, with MOTHER and her mother both in attendance. (Footnote 3) (Exh. 4.) At that meeting, District members of the IEP team presented MOTHER with an assessment plan and indicated that they wished to begin assessing STUDENT immediately after the meeting. MOTHER requested that the initial assessment include a neuropsychological evaluation. (Footnote 4) MOTHER did not sign the assessment plan at the initial IEP meeting, and therefore the District’s assessors did not begin their assessments that day.

On June 26, 2002, STUDENT received an occupational therapy (OT) evaluation pursuant to a referral from the Regional Center. The OT evaluator recommended that STUDENT receive OT services to increase his self-feeding and fine motor skills. In July 2002, licensed psychologist Dr. Thomas Gross conducted a psychological assessment of STUDENT pursuant to a referral from the Regional Center. Dr. Gross diagnosed STUDENT with mild mental retardation with significant deficits in communication, learning, self-direction, and self-care. Dr. Gross concluded that STUDENT did not qualify as autistic but appeared to have a pervasive developmental disorder, not otherwise specified (PDD-NOS).

MOTHER signed the District’s assessment plan and mailed it back to the District in mid-July 2002. (Footnote 5) (Exh. 6.) In August 2002, the District agreed to include a neuropsychological assessment as part of STUDENT’s initial assessment. (Footnote 6) In September and early October 2002, special education teacher Estela Dominguez, school psychologist Linda Lucas, special education teacher Melissa LaMothe, and District speech-language pathologists Melissa Gidley and Joanne Abrassart conducted their assessments of STUDENT in the FAMILY home and at the District’s Avaxat Elementary School. The school psychologist concluded that STUDENT met the criteria for special education eligibility due to autism. The assessment report indicated that STUDENT had delays in communication, social skills, adaptive skills, fine motor and cognition. The speech-language pathologists determined that STUDENT was eligible to receive services in receptive and expressive language. The occupational therapist found that STUDENT had difficulties with fine motor skills, visual motor skills, sensory input and organizational skills, and that STUDENT was eligible to receive OT services to address those needs.

There was no IEP in place for STUDENT in mid-August 2002, so as a result the Regional Center reportedly agreed to continue providing STUDENT’s services through the end of September 2002. (See testimony of Ms. Abrassart; Exh. 3, p. 18.) The District was responsible for providing STUDENT’s education once he turned three, and so in early October 2002 it took over STUDENT’s program from the Regional Center. Because STUDENT still did not have an operative IEP at that time, the District provided STUDENT an interim placement pursuant to the terms of his IFSP. (Footnote 7) That interim placement consisted of one-to-one early intervention services provided to STUDENT by preschool special education teacher Estela Dominguez and inclusion specialist Betsy Baird for a total of four hours per week, and OT provided by occupational therapist Audrey Lindemulder for two hours per week. (Footnote 8) In September and October 2002, the PARENTS obtained an independent speech-language evaluation of STUDENT by speech-language pathologist Patricia Brown. In October 2002, clinical psychologist Dr. Kathleen Kitlowski conducted a behavioral and educational assessment of STUDENT on behalf of the District.

On October 16, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team convened to review the results of the initial assessments. The team members did not complete all of the discussions during the time allotted that day, and therefore the meeting was continued until October 28, 2002. The team also ran out of time at the October 28 meeting and the meeting eventually concluded on November 19, 2002. The IEP team drafted goals and objectives in the following areas: expressive language, receptive language, speech intelligibility, fine and visual motor skills, classroom participation, social interactions, behavior/self-regulation, self-help/toileting, attending to an activity, counting and matching.

During the October and November 2002 IEP meetings, the District offered STUDENT placement in the preschool special day class (SDC) taught by Ms. Dominguez at the District’s Buchanan Elementary School (Buchanan). The District’s offer included the following services: (1) individual speech-language therapy for twenty minutes per week, group speech-language therapy for twenty minutes per week, and speech-language consultation services for up to one hour per month; (2) individual occupational therapy for two sessions per week, thirty minutes per session, and an occupational therapy training for STUDENT’s parents and District staff who work with him; and (3) discrete trial therapy (DTT) consisting of behavior tutoring for ten hours per week in the family’s home, bimonthly clinic meetings for up to four hours per month, and consultation by the autism consultant for six hours per month. The IEP also provided for extended school year (ESY) services and transportation. (Exh. 25.)

MOTHER agreed to the District’s offer and signed her consent to the IEP at the meeting on November 19, 2002. Thereafter STUDENT began receiving the OT and speech-language therapy pursuant to his IEP. On December 9, 2002, STUDENT began receiving the in-home DTT program, supervised by Dr. Kitlowski, pursuant to his IEP; the District provided the DTT program through ACCESS, a non-public agency (NPA) operated by Dr. Kitlowski and her husband. On December 10, 2002, the IEP team convened again to review how STUDENT was doing in his program. The IEP team agreed to increase his in-home DTT to sixteen hours per week through the end of January 2003.

In January 2003, STUDENT began attending his preschool SDC placement at Buchanan four days per week for approximately an hour and a half each day. (Exh. 26.) The SDC consisted of one special education teacher, three aides, and ten to twelve students aged three to five years old, including one or two typically developing peers. An adaptive physical education (APE) teacher visited the class twice a week to work on gross motor activities in a group setting. To provide reverse mainstreaming, non-disabled third- and fourth-graders often visited the SDC to work and interact with the preschoolers. STUDENT was the only autistic student in the SDC; the disabilities of the other children included speech-language impairment, orthopedic impairment, Down’s Syndrome and attention deficit disorder (ADD). The curriculum and structure of the SDC incorporated several methodologies used for teaching autistic children, including Treatment of Autism and related Communication Handicapped Children (TEACCH), Social Stories, Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS), applied behavioral analysis (ABA) and floor time.

Because STUDENT had problems with both tantrum behaviors and sensory issues, initially the school staff tried to avoid tantrums by placing very few demands on STUDENT while he attended school. During his initial days of school in January 2003, occupational therapist Audrey Lindemulder frequently took STUDENT out of class to do sensory activities, such as swinging on swings and being brushed with a surgical scrub brush, to relieve STUDENT’s sensory overload and avoid his tantrum behaviors. Gradually the SDC teacher and aides increased the demands placed on STUDENT in the SDC as he adjusted to being in a classroom.

On January 27, 2003, the IEP team reconvened to review STUDENT’s progress in the program. The IEP notes reflect that STUDENT had not received all of his tutoring hours from the DTT program in December, and therefore the missed hours would be made up. MOTHER requested that STUDENT’s in-home DTT hours be increased to 35 hours per week, but the other members of the IEP team did not agree to this increase.

For the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT continued to attend the Buchanan preschool SDC, continued to receive his OT and speech-language therapy each week, and continued in the in-home DTT program for sixteen hours per week. In May 2003, the IEP team convened and agreed to increase the length of STUDENT’s school day by 45 minutes, so that he would attend school for approximately two and a half hours each school day. (Exh. 30.) On June 11, 2003, MOTHER, the SDC teacher and a District administrator convened for another IEP meeting to discuss STUDENT’s classroom placement for fall 2003; they agreed to change STUDENT’s placement from Buchanan to Murrieta Elementary School. (Exh. 31.) Despite the change of school, Ms. Dominguez would continue to be STUDENT’s teacher and would operate the SDC in the same general manner as she had at Buchanan. (Testimony of Ms. Dominguez.)

For the 2003 summer, STUDENT attended ESY in a preschool class. (Testimony of MOTHER.) He continued with the in-home DTT program during the summer. (Exhs. 62, 68.) On August 22, 2003, at the beginning of the new school year, STUDENT’s IEP team convened and agreed to continue his in-home DTT program for sixteen hours per week until his annual IEP review in October/November 2003. As to STUDENT’s classroom placement for the new school year, STUDENT returned to Ms. Dominguez’s preschool SDC although the location of the SDC was now at Murrieta Elementary School. For the first few days of school, STUDENT was the only student in the class. Another student returned from summer vacation a few days later, and other students joined the class in the following weeks; by October 2003, there were approximately five students in the class.

In early October 2003, the PARENTS took STUDENT for an evaluation by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD). The CARD assessors agreed that STUDENT had autism and recommended a forty-hour-per-week program of one-to-one DTT in the home. In a letter dated October 22, 2003, the PARENTS notified the District that they were placing STUDENT in a DTT program operated by CARD and that they intended to seek reimbursement from the District. (Exh. 35.) On November 10, 2003, STUDENT began receiving thirty-five hours per week of in-home DTT from CARD. STUDENT no longer attended the Buchanan SDC, no longer received DTT from ACCESS, and no longer attended speech therapy or OT sessions.

The IEP team convened for STUDENT’s annual review on November 17, 2003. The meeting did not conclude on that date, so the team reconvened to complete the review on December 1, 2003. During the two meetings, the team reviewed and discussed Dr. Kitlowski’s final progress report regarding the in-home DTT program the District had provided. The District again offered speech-language therapy, OT, SDC placement, and Dr. Kitlowski’s DTT program for 16 hours per week of tutoring and eight hours per month of consultation/supervision. Regarding the SDC, the District offered that STUDENT’s placement would be modified to include his participation in an “inclusion program,” wherein typically developing peers would attend STUDENT’s SDC for a significant portion of the school day. (Exh. 41; testimony of Ms. Dominguez, Ms. Preston.) MOTHER did not consent to the District’s offer.

STUDENT has remained in the CARD program, receiving thirty-five hours of in-home tutoring per week. He has not been receiving any services from the District and has not been attending any type of preschool class. In January 2004, CARD psychologist Dr. Betty Bostani conducted a psychological assessment of STUDENT. On February 13, 2004, the Hearing Office received a due process request on STUDENT’s behalf regarding the present case.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

(1) Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and state law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code § 56000.) Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; California Education Code § 56000.) “FAPE” is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards, include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and that are provided at public expense and in conformity with an IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to allow a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(17).) California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

The determination of whether a student has been offered a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate. (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200.)

A. Procedural Requirements

The IDEA provides procedural protections to children with disabilities and their parents. The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP.” ( Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 205-206.)

While procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE, procedural violations which result in a “loss of educational opportunity” or which “seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE.” (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).) Thus, the courts have created a two-prong test for determining if a procedural violation resulted in a denial of FAPE for a student: (1) whether a procedural protection has been violated and (2) whether the procedural violation resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringed on the parents’ participation in the IEP process.

Delay in Implementing STUDENT’s Program After His Third Birthday

Petitioner raises the procedural claim that the District failed to make a timely offer of FAPE upon his third birthday and that, as a result, he did not begin receiving his educational program until several months after his third birthday. In response, the District argues that STUDENT’s initial offer of FAPE was delayed only because his parents delayed in consenting to the initial evaluation. The District further contends that any delay in the offer of STUDENT’s program did not cause him to lose educational opportunity because he was receiving appropriate services in the interim placement from September to November 2002.

For a student transitioning from Part C to Part B of the IDEA upon the student’s third birthday, the law requires that the receiving local educational agency (LEA) assess the student and, if the student is eligible, offer a FAPE by the child’s third birthday. California Code of Regulations, Title 17, section 52112(a) states that “LEAs shall provide special education and related services to eligible children at age three.” Section 52112(a) further provides that, for a toddler who may be eligible for preschool programs under Part B of the IDEA, an LEA shall participate in the transition planning before the toddler is two years and nine months old, or at the discretion of all parties up to six months before the child turns three “to ensure that an IEP has been developed and is implemented by the toddler’s third birthday.”

Before any action is taken with respect to the initial special education placement of a student, the student must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. (Cal. Education Code § 56320.) The process for assessment begins with a written referral for assessment by the parent, teacher, school personnel, or other appropriate agency or person. (Cal. Education Code §§ 56302, 56321(a); 5 C.C.R. § 3021.) Within 15 days of referral, the parent must be given a written assessment plan which explains the types of assessments to be conducted. (Cal. Education Code § 56321.) Upon receiving the assessment plan, the parent “shall have at least 15 days from the receipt of the proposed assessment plan to arrive at a decision.” (Cal. Education Code § 56321.) The LEA has fifty (50) days from the date it receives the parent’s written consent for assessment, excluding vacation and days when school is not in session, to complete the assessments and develop an initial IEP, unless the parent agrees in writing to an extension. (Cal. Education Code § 56344(a).) When a referral for assessment has been made twenty (20) days or less prior to the end of the regular school year, the resulting IEP shall be developed within thirty (30) days after the commencement of the subsequent regular school year. (Id.)

In the present case, STUDENT’s third birthday was on July 20, 2002, but the IEP had not been developed by that date. The transition team meeting of the Regional Center and the District took place on April 11, 2002. STUDENT’s initial IEP team meeting convened on June 14, 2002, with MOTHER and her mother both in attendance. (Exh. 4.) At that meeting, District members of the IEP team presented MOTHER with an assessment plan. MOTHER did not sign the plan at the meeting. In mid-July 2002, during the District’s summer break, the District received the signed assessment plan with MOTHER’s signature dated July 10, 2002; however, MOTHER inadvertently did not make a check mark in the box indicating consent to the proposed assessments. (Exh. 6; testimony of Zhanna Preston, MOTHER.) At the District’s request, MOTHER subsequently checked the correct box on the form.

On August 19, 2002, the District special education director sent a letter by electronic mail (E-mail) to PARENTS regarding scheduling dates for the assessments. Ms. Preston proposed dates of August 23, August 28 and September 6, 2002. (Exh. 3, p. 20.) Similarly, on August 21 and 22, District speech-language pathologist Melissa Gidley and District school psychologist Linda Lucas each sent their own E-mail letters to PARENTS regarding scheduling assessment dates for August 27 and 28, 2002. (Exh. 3, pgs. 27-28.) On August 22, 2002, MOTHER replied by E-mail and requested that the assessments be scheduled after September 16, 2002, due to conflicts with several other appointments she had scheduled for her children. (Testimony of MOTHER; Exh. 3, p. 25.) The assessments finally took place in September and October 2002, and the IEP meeting convened on October 16, 2002. Because development of the IEP took several hours to complete, the IEP team needed to meet three times; as a result, the final meeting and agreement upon the offer did not occur until November 19, 2002.

As noted above, when a referral for assessment has been made twenty (20) days or less prior to the end of the regular school year, the resulting IEP shall be developed within thirty (30) days after the commencement of the subsequent regular school year. (Cal. Education Code § 56344(a).) Given that a school district must present a proposed assessment plan within fifteen days of receiving a written referral, the District’s presentation of the assessment plan on the last day of school in June indicates that section 56344's thirty-day timeline for developing the IEP was applicable. Because the District received the parent’s signed consent form during summer vacation, the timeline was tolled during that period. (Cal. Education Code § 56344(a).) The District’s 2002-2003 school year began again on August 14, 2002, so the District had thirty days from August 14, 2002, to conduct the assessment and convene the IEP meeting. (Exh. 61.) The IEP meeting actually convened on October 16, 2002, approximately sixty-three days after the timeline began to run. (Footnote 9) While the parent did not sign a written consent to extend the timeline, the evidence established that the District staff delayed conducting the assessments for approximately three weeks pursuant to a request by the parent. (Exh. 3, p. 25; testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Abrassart.) Therefore, the IEP meeting convened almost five weeks after the thirty-day timeline had run, although part of the delay can be attributed to the District’s attempts to accommodate the parent’s scheduling requests. The question remains regarding why the District did not present the assessment plan earlier, so that the assessments could have been conducted prior to the summer break to ensure that the IEP was developed and the program implemented prior to STUDENT’s third birthday. (See Cal. Code of Regs., Tit. 17, § 52112(a).) The District’s special education director initially testified that the District would have had a program in place by STUDENT’s third birthday if MOTHER had signed the assessment plan when it was presented to her at the IEP meeting on June 14, 2002. Upon questioning by the Hearing Officer regarding the minimum 15-day period the parent has to consider an assessment plan, Ms. Preston testified that the District staff would have been able to conduct the assessments in summer 2002 had the parent returned the signed assessment plan within 15 days of receiving it. This argument is not persuasive because Education Code section 56344(a) gives a parent at least fifteen days to consider the assessment plan. Hence, MOTHER’s return of the signed assessment plan approximately four weeks after receiving it was not the cause of the delay in STUDENT’s initial evaluation. Rather, it appears that the District’s scheduling of the June 14 IEP meeting did not consider the minimum 15-day time period for the parent to review and sign the assessment plan. As a result of presenting the proposed assessment plan in mid-June, the District received the signed assessment plan during the summer break and thus did not conduct the assessments of STUDENT until after the new school year began, which was after STUDENT had turned three years old. This delay occurred even though the District had known at least since April 2002 that it would need to assess STUDENT and convene an IEP team meeting prior to the start of the 2002-2003 school year.

Thus, the District’s decision to wait until June 14, 2002, to provide the parent with the assessment plan foreseeably resulted in STUDENT’s program not being implemented once the new school year began in August 2002, in violation of California Code of Regulations, Title 17, section 52112(a). This delay was not minor. Because of the resulting delays in conducting the assessments and convening the IEP meetings, STUDENT did not receive an offer of FAPE until mid-October 2002, approximately two months into the school year. The delay caused STUDENT a loss of educational opportunity because during his interim placement he received only six hours of educational services pursuant to his IFSP, instead of the more extensive program he received once the parties agreed upon his educational program on November 19, 2002.

The District argues that STUDENT received a FAPE during the interim placement and therefore suffered no loss of educational opportunity. Based upon STUDENT’s needs prior to turning three, the interim placement consisted of four hours per week of one-on-one instructional services by a preschool teacher and two hours per week of OT services. In contrast, STUDENT’s IEP dated November 19, 2002 offered him a preschool SDC four days a week, two hours per day, a DTT program including behavior tutoring for ten hours per week, plus speech-language therapy and OT. There is no question that the delay in receiving the more extensive program designed to address his then-current needs caused a loss of educational opportunity.

Moreover, the evidence did not establish to what extent STUDENT received interim services in September 2002. Ms. Abrassart testified that the Regional Center had agreed to continue to provide STUDENT’s services pursuant to his IFSP through the end of September 2002, and an E-mail Ms. Abrassart sent in August 2002 likewise states this. (Exh. 3., p. 18.) However, MOTHER testified that there was a three or four-week gap between when the Regional Center stopped providing STUDENT’s services and when the District began providing the interim placement in early October 2002. The hearing evidence did not include any Regional Center documents verifying the extension of services, any testimony from individuals who provided services to STUDENT in September 2002, or any other evidence establishing that STUDENT received services from the Regional Center in September 2002.

Accordingly, the delay in conducting STUDENT’s assessment and convening his IEP meeting created loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT. It is well-established that for several weeks he received only six hours per week of services pursuant to the interim placement, instead of the ten to sixteen hours per week later implemented under his IEP. Additionally, there is indication of a period in September 2002 during which STUDENT did not receive any services pursuant to his IFSP.

Finally, the IEP team’s need for three meetings spanning the course of one month may have occurred regardless of whether the meetings took place in October or August 2002. Thus, in determining the extent of the procedural violation discussed herein, the Hearing Officer will only consider the delay leading up to the first IEP meeting on October 16, 2002. (Footnote 10) That meeting occurred approximately two months after the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year. While STUDENT received some services during that two-month period pursuant to the interim placement, he was denied the educational opportunity he would have received had the extensive program designed to address his then-current needs been in place as specified in California Code of Education, Title 17, section 52112(a). This violation therefore constitutes a procedural denial of FAPE.

Attendance of Required IEP Team Members

Petitioner argues that the District failed to include necessary individuals at several of his IEP meetings during the 2002-2003 school year. California Education Code section 56341(b) identifies the necessary members of the IEP team, including: (1) one or both parents, (2) at least one a regular education teacher of the pupil, if the pupil is or may be participating in the regular education environment; (3) at least one special education teacher of the pupil or, if appropriate, at least one special education provider of the pupil; (4) a representative of the responsible local educational agency (LEA), and (5) an individual who conducted an assessment of the student, or who is knowledgeable about the assessment procedures used to assess the student and is familiar with the assessment results or recommendations. (See also 34 CFR § 300.344(a).) Additionally, at the discretion of the parent or the LEA, the IEP team may include “other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil, including related services personnel, as appropriate.” (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(6); 34 CFR § 300.344(a).)

For the 2002-2003 school year, Petitioner alleges that the District failed to include the required participants at three IEP meetings. (Footnote 11) Petitioner alleged that necessary IEP team members were absent from the IEP meetings as follows: (1) a speech-language pathologist on January 17, May 9 and June 11, 2003, (2) an occupational therapist on June 11, 2003, (3) a regular education teacher on January 17, May 9, and June 11, 2003, and (4) a provider from the ACCESS NPA on June 11, 2003. Petitioner has not asserted how the alleged violations resulted in a loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement on parental participation in the IEP process.

(a) Speech-language pathologist

Regarding the attendance of a speech-language pathologist, California Education Code section 56341(b) requires the attendance of related service personnel when the individual has conducted an assessment of the student; beyond that requirement, section 56341(b)(5) states only that related service personnel may attend “when appropriate.” (See 34 CFR § 300.344(a)(5).) In the present case, speech-language pathologist Melissa Gidley testified that she did not attend the January 2003 IEP because that meeting concerned STUDENT’s DTT and transition to the SDC, and did not concern any speech issues. The notes of that IEP meeting and witness testimony concur that the primary topics of that meeting were the DTT program, particularly the number of DTT hours, and STUDENT’s transition to the SDC. (Exh. 28; testimony of Ms. Dominguez.) Ms. Gidley also indicated that she did not attend the May 2003 IEP because speech was not at issue and, instead, that meeting concerned an increase in STUDENT’s classroom time. The notes of that IEP meeting reflect discussion about STUDENT’s behaviors in the home, his progress in the SDC, and a proposed increase in his SDC time. (Exh. 30; see also testimony of Ms. Dominguez.) Regarding the IEP meeting of June 11, 2003, the participants agreed to change STUDENT’s elementary school for fall 2003, although he would continue with the same teacher in a preschool SDC and would otherwise receive the same program and services with the same SDC teacher. (Exh. 31.)

None of these three meetings concerned STUDENT’s speech-language assessment, speech-language services or speech-language goals. There is nothing in the law to indicate that related services personnel are required to attend every IEP meeting for a child who receives that related service. (See 64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12585.) Moreover, Petitioner has not alleged what loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement of parental participation resulted from the speech-language pathologist’s absence, and the evidence does not indicate any such harm. In light of all evidence, the District’s failure to include the speech-language pathologist at the January, May and June 2003 IEP meetings did not constitute a procedural denial of FAPE.

(b) Occupational therapist

As discussed above, section 56341(b) requires the attendance of related service personnel only “when the individual has conducted an assessment of the student,” and otherwise states that related service personnel may attend the IEP meeting “when appropriate.” Petitioner notes that the only attendees at the June 11, 2003 IEP meeting were STUDENT’s mother, STUDENT’s SDC teacher, and a District administrator. At that meeting, the three participants agreed to change STUDENT’s elementary school location for fall 2003, although his program and services otherwise did not change. (Exh. 31.)

Considering the IEP notes and Ms. Dominguez’s testimony about the June 2003 IEP meeting, it appears that the purpose of the meeting was to discuss and agree upon STUDENT’s change to a different elementary school. This meeting did not concern STUDENT’s OT assessment, OT services or OT goals. As stated above, there is nothing in the law to indicate that related services personnel are required to attend every one of a child’s IEP meetings. Thus, the occupational therapist’s absence was not necessarily a violation of section 56341(b). In any event, there is no indication of what loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement of parental participation resulted from the occupational therapist’s absence, particularly considering that Petitioner does not appear to dispute the change of placement agreed upon at the meeting. Therefore, the absence of the occupational therapist at the June 2003 IEP meeting did not constitute a procedural denial of FAPE.

(c) Regular education teacher

The list of individuals who should attend the student’s IEP meeting includes the regular education teacher of the student, if the student is or may be participating in the regular education environment. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(2); 34 CFR § 300.344(a)(2).) The purpose of attendance of the regular education teacher is to obtain that teacher’s input and participation so that the parents and other members of the IEP team will have accurate information upon which to base a decision, and an LEA’s failure to ensure this input seriously infringes on the parents’ participation in the IEP team meeting. (See Target Range School District No. 23, supra at 1484.)

In the present case, STUDENT had never attended a regular education placement and therefore did not have a regular education teacher. A regular education teacher attended STUDENT’s IEP meetings in October and November 2002, when the IEP was intially developed. At the time of the January, May and June 2003 IEP meetings, STUDENT’s parents were not requesting, nor was the IEP team considering, a regular education placement. Thus, at that time STUDENT was not a student who “may be participating in the regular education environment.” Moreover, Petitioner has not alleged what loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement of parental participation resulted from this absence, and the evidence does not indicate any such harm. Accordingly, the lack of participation of a regular education teacher did not constitute a procedural denial of FAPE.

(d) Provider from ACCESS NPA

The list of IEP attendees also includes “at least one special education teacher of the pupil, or if appropriate, at least one special education provider of the pupil.” (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(3); 34 CFR § 300.344(a).) Recently the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals addressed a similar topic in a case where the parents of a preschool child argued that the school district should have included at the meeting the child’s current preschool teacher of a program the child had attended for the past two school years. The court found that the failure to include the child’s teacher was a procedural violation that constituted a denial of FAPE. The opinion held in part that “for a child with a disability who is being considered for placement in special education, the teacher could be the child’s regular teacher, or a teacher qualified to provide education in the type of program in which the child may be placed, or both.” Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District No. 69, 317 F.3d 1072, 1077 (9th Cir. 2003).

In the present case, at the June 2003 IEP meeting the three participants agreed to change STUDENT’s elementary school location for fall 2003, although his program and services otherwise did not change. STUDENT’s SDC teacher attended the meeting, fulfilling section 56341's requirement of attendance of a special education teacher of the child. The meeting notes do not address STUDENT’s in-home DTT program, and no changes to that program were proposed or agreed upon at the meeting. (See Exh. 31; testimony of Ms. Dominguez.) Given that this was a brief, addendum IEP meeting unrelated to STUDENT’s DTT program, the attendance of the DTT provider was not required under State or federal law. Additionally, there is no indication of what loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement of parental participation resulted from this absence, particularly considering that Petitioner does not appear to dispute the change of placement agreed upon at the meeting. Therefore, the absence of a provider from the ACCESS NPA at the June 2003 IEP meeting did not constitute a procedural denial of FAPE.

B. Substantive Requirements

Under the IDEA and the decision of the U.S. Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to address the student’s unique needs, be reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and be in conformity with the student’s IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.) To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. (Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) The Rowley opinion explained that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student’s potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200.) Moreover, as long as a school district provides an appropriate education, methodology is left up to the school's discretion. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 208.)

Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (Footnote 12) (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Education Code § 56031.) The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming” or education in the LRE. The law demonstrates “a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” (Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir.1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45.)

Furthermore, the IDEA specifies additional requirements for the provision of a FAPE which are not in dispute in the present case, such as the obligation to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. (See, e.g., 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).)

To summarize, the IDEA and Supreme Court’s decision in Rowley require that an appropriate program: (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, (3) conform to the student’s IEP, and (4) be in the LRE. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 188.)

What Were STUDENT’s Unique Needs in 2002-2003?

To determine whether the program the District offered was appropriate for him during the 2002-2003 school year, this Decision must first consider what STUDENT’s unique needs were during that time period. This topic is an area of dispute between the parties; Petitioner contends that the District failed to properly assess him, and as a result failed to correctly identify his unique needs and then-present levels of performance. (Footnote 13) In contrast, the District contends that it accurately identified STUDENT’s needs and then-present levels of performance and designed an appropriate program based upon that information.

There is no dispute that STUDENT has a diagnosis of autism and needed a program including speech-language, OT and DTT. In October 2002, the District school psychologist and special education teacher evaluating STUDENT concluded that he had delays in the areas of communication, adaptive/self-help skills, social skills, fine motor skills and cognition. The assessment report also noted that STUDENT’s mother reported he had frequent tantrums. The initial assessment by the District’s autism specialist similarly determined that STUDENT had sensory needs and exhibited delays in communication, social skills, play skills, attention, adaptive living skills, behavior and compliance. The speech-language pathologists determined that STUDENT had deficits in receptive and expressive language. The occupational therapist found that STUDENT had difficulties with fine motor skills, visual motor skills, sensory processing and organizational skills. The occupational therapist determined that STUDENT’s gross motor skills were not delayed, and therefore did not recommend further evaluation or services in this area.

STUDENT argues that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability and failed to correctly identify his unique needs in the areas of gross motor skills, adaptive physical education (APE), sensory integration, self-help skills, behavior and speech-language. First, Petitioner argues that the District failed to identify his gross motor deficits and failed to conduct an APE assessment. District occupational therapist Amy Brennan testified that she did not observe any significant problems with STUDENT’s gross motor skills, and therefore did not refer him for an adaptive physical education (APE) evaluation. Similarly, STUDENT’s occupational therapist for the 2002-2003 school year testified that, when STUDENT participated in gross motor activities with her, she observed that his gross motor skills were excellent and age-appropriate. Nevertheless, the IEP team agreed to refer STUDENT for observation by the APE teacher, as indicated on a signed assessment plan dated October 28, 2002. (Exh. 22.) The observation by the APE teacher, Gail Hansen, did not generate a written report and Ms. Hansen did not testify at the hearing; Ms. Dominguez testified that Ms. Hansen had observed STUDENT in the SDC and discussed with Ms. Dominguez, who has a bachelor’s degree in APE, that STUDENT’s gross motor skills were within normal limits. STUDENT participated with the rest of the SDC students in gross motor activities, which were facilitated by the APE teacher in the SDC twice a week and by Ms. Dominguez the other two days of the SDC school week. (Testimony of Ms. Dominguez.)

Petitioner points to CARD’s observations of STUDENT’s abilities to perform various gross motor activities in November 2003 as evidence of gross motor deficits. (Exh. 47, section 14.) However, Ms. Brennan persuasively explained that the levels recorded in the CARD logbook did not necessarily reflect any deficits because there are many variables involved that affect at what age a child is expected to be able to perform an activity. For example, Ms. Brennan explained that the logbook’s notation that STUDENT could not “kick a ball” does not reflect the size of the ball, whether the ball was rolling or stationary, or whether he was trying to kick it while he was running. Ms. Brennan explained that, depending on such variables, STUDENT’s abilities may have been age-appropriate.

Notably, Regional Center and VIP Tots reports from summer 2002 found that STUDENT had developed many age-level gross motor skills. The Regional Center’s psychological evaluation of July 2002 reported that he was able to walk and run fairly well, was able to jump on two legs, walk up and down stairs, throw two-handed and catch a beach ball with variable accuracy, but was not able to hop on one leg or pedal a tricycle. (Exh. 10, p. 46; see also Exh. 15, p. 54.) Consistent with that evaluation, a June 2002 report by VIP Tots indicated that STUDENT could jump in place, jump forward six inches, jump over a rope, pedal a tricycle when prompted on the knees, catch and throw an eight-inch ball, and climb the hill in his backyard. (Exh. 9, p. 43.) These reports further support Ms. Brennan’s conclusion that gross motor skills and APE were not an area of suspected disability. While STUDENT’s parents and VIP Tots both reported that STUDENT’s tricycle riding was delayed, overall STUDENT did not demonstrate significant needs in gross motor skills or APE. Thus, the evidence does not establish that STUDENT had needs in gross motor skills or APE that the District failed to identify or assess.

Next, STUDENT contends that the District failed to correctly identify his self-help needs in the areas of dressing or feeding. Petitioner points to the June 2002 VIP Tots report for evidence of those areas of need, which reported that he had difficulty using a fork but could pour liquids from one container to another and could drink from a “sipper” cup. Regarding dressing, the report indicated that STUDENT could zip or unzip a jacket that was fastened at the bottom and could unzip small bags to remove the toys inside. (Exh. 9.) This report is not inconsistent with the District’s psychological assessment of October 2002, wherein the school psychologist administered the Battelle Developmental Inquiry in the area of adaptive living skills. That report indicated that STUDENT could eat bite-sized pieces of food with his hand or a spoon, had emerging skills using a fork, did not use a knife and used a combination of regular and sipper cups for drinking. The psychological report also recounted STUDENT’s dressing needs, noting that he needed assistance with dressing and undressing, but was learning to use velcro fasteners on his shoes. (Exh. 15, p. 55.) These levels were summarized in the present levels of performance of the October/November 2002 IEP. (Exh. 25, p. 84.) Thus, the evidence established that the District identified STUDENT’s deficits in the area of self-help and adaptive living skills.

Petitioner also argues that the District failed to assess and identify his unique needs in the area of sensory integration. On this point, Petitioner’s closing brief contends simply that “the VIP Tots Exit Report identified [STUDENT’s sensory integration] deficits but the district did not assess in [that] area.” However, the VIP Tots exit report states only that “STUDENT’s behavior does seem to be directly related to sensory needs.” (Exh. 9, p. 43.) Similarly, the District’s October 2002 OT assessment identified STUDENT’s sensory needs, describing how he had “poor registration of sensory input” and noting that his ability to attend to tasks improved once he was provided with sensory activities. (Exh. 18; testimony of Ms. Brennan.) District occupational therapist Audrey Lindemulder, who provided STUDENT’s OT during the 2002-2003 school year, testified regarding how STUDENT’s behavior and attention were affected by his sensory needs. There was no evidence presented establishing that STUDENT had sensory needs beyond those identified by the District and therefore the Hearing Officer finds that the District accurately identified STUDENT’s sensory needs.

STUDENT also contends that the District failed to identify his areas of deficit regarding his maladaptive and aggressive behaviors. He contends that his behaviors included spitting, hitting, kicking, and self-stimulatory behaviors such as masturbation, repetitive play and use of jargon. Regarding aggressive and tantrum behaviors, the District’s initial assessments note these behavioral issues as reported by STUDENT’s mother, such as frequent temper tantrums that included hitting, kicking and screaming. (Exh. 15, p. 54; Exh. 24, 78.) The IEP team noted these behavioral issues in STUDENT’s present levels of performance and also drafted a self-regulation goal to reduce the tantrums. (Exh. 15, pgs. 84, 90.)

Regarding self-stimulatory behaviors, STUDENT’s mother described her observations of STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors, including use of jargon and self-stimulatory masturbation behavior of rubbing against a trampoline. Ms. Contreras, who observed STUDENT beginning in October 2003, and Dr. Bostani, who assessed STUDENT in January 2004, both reported that STUDENT has some self-stimulatory behaviors in the way he plays with toys. (Exh. 64, p. 7-8; Exh. 34, p. 123.) However, neither of these CARD staffers indicated that STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors were frequent or pervasive; for example, Dr. Bostani’s assessment did not mention reduction of self-stimulatory behaviors within her recommendations for STUDENT’s program. (Exh. 64, p. 20-21.)

The District’s assessments did not initially identify self-stimulatory behaviors as an area of need. The District assessors reported that they did not observe STUDENT exhibiting any self-stimulatory behaviors. (Exh. 15; testimony of Ms. Dominguez, Ms. Lucas.) Ms. Dominguez acknowledged that STUDENT did speak in jargon but she concluded that he was using it to try to communicate, not as a self-stimulatory behavior. Similarly, neither the VIP Tots reports or other Regional Center assessments reported any observation of self-stimulatory behaviors. In his July 2002 psychological evaluation on behalf of the Regional Center, Dr. Gross wrote that “no odd, repetitive or stereotyped behavior was observed.” (Exh. 10, p. 45.) In the parent interviews conducted as part of the District and Regional Center assessments, MOTHER did not report any perseverative or other self-stimulatory behavior. However, MOTHER explained that initially she had not been aware that some of STUDENT’s behaviors were actually self-stimulatory, but she began noticing STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors after Dr. Gross mentioned what types of behaviors were in this category.

Hence, the above evidence established that while STUDENT was exhibiting some self-stimulatory behaviors during the 2002-2003 school year, these behaviors were not frequent or pervasive and were not observed by District assessors. Indeed, MOTHER did not report any self-stimulatory behaviors to the District assessors or the IEP team, and Dr. Gross did not observe any during his July 2002 assessment. Given that STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors were limited, were not observed by the assessors and were not reported by the parent, at the time the IEP was developed the District did not reasonably have reason to know that these behaviors were part of STUDENT’s needs. (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999) (citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. Of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3d Cir. 1993).) Hence, the failure to identify STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors as part of his unique needs did not constitute a denial of FAPE.

Petitioner further contends that the District failed to properly identify his speech and language needs. Petitioner argues that an independent speech-language evaluation conducted by speech-language pathologist Patricia Brown in September and October 2002 contains recommendations not identified in the District’s assessments or IEP. (Footnote 14) (Exh. 17.) On this point, Petitioner’s argument is not persuasive and not supported by the evidence. The District speech-language assessors, Ms. Gidley and Ms. Abrassart, found that STUDENT had needs in receptive language, expressive language, oral-motor and articulation. (Footnote 15) The IEP’s present levels of performance note delays in receptive and expressive vocabulary and oral motor issues, and the IEP included goals in receptive language, speech intelligibility and expressive language to address these needs. (Exh. 16.) Ms. Gidley and Ms. Abrassart testified credibly regarding their findings. Moreover, the findings and recommendations of the independent speech-language assessor, who did not testify, were not inconsistent with those of the District’s assessments. For example, STUDENT’s expressive language goal includes objectives designed to increase the length of his utterances, as the independent assessment recommended. Similarly, the independent assessment’s recommendation to increase STUDENT’s ability to follow directions is covered by the IEP’s receptive language goal and objectives, including an objective that he will “follow 1-step commands using 10 basic concepts.” (Exh. 25, p. 85; see testimony of Ms. Gidley.) Accordingly, the District did not fail to identify STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language.

Thus, the District correctly identified STUDENT’s deficits in the areas of communication, receptive language, expressive language, oral motor, articulation, social skills, play skills, adaptive/self-help skills, compliance, cognition, fine motor skills, visual motor skills, sensory processing, attention and behavior. In fall 2002, STUDENT had some limited expressive language and generally spoke in one-word sentences. He could parallel play but had difficulty interacting with peers. He was not toilet-trained. He did not have any significant deficits in gross motor skills. He had sensory needs and was extremely sensitive to sensory input. He had some self-stimulatory behaviors, although these were limited. He had temper tantrums and was often noncompliant, although his failure to follow instructions appeared partly due to his receptive language delays. As a result of these areas of need, no one disputed that STUDENT needed to learn in a small group setting with structure and routine, and therefore needed an SDC placement. There was also no dispute that, due to his deficits, STUDENT needed the intensive instruction of a DTT program, and also that he needed OT and speech-language therapy.

Was The Program Designed To Address STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

Having identified STUDENT’s unique needs, the next step is to determine whether the District offered a program that was designed to address those unique needs. During the October and November 2002 IEP meetings, the District offered STUDENT the following: (1) placement in the preschool SDC taught by Ms. Dominguez; (2) individual speech-language therapy for twenty minutes per week, group speech-language therapy for twenty minutes per week, and speech-language consultation services for up to one hour per month; (3) individual occupational therapy for two sessions per week, thirty minutes per session, and an occupational therapy training for STUDENT’s parents and District staff who work with him; and (4) DTT consisting of behavior tutoring for ten hours per week in the family’s home, bimonthly clinic meetings for up to four hours per month, and consultation by the autism consultant for six hours per month. The IEP also provided for extended school year (ESY) services and transportation. (Exh. 25.)

Petitioner raises several contentions about how the District’s program was inappropriate for STUDENT. First, Petitioner argues that the goals and objectives for the 2002-2003 school year were not appropriate because the October/November 2002 IEP “lacked goals and objectives to adequately address STUDENT’s weaknesses in the areas of behavior, speech and language, occupational therapy, visual processing, self-help and social and emotional needs.” A review of the October/November 2002 IEP indicates that the IEP contained goals in all of these areas, with emotional needs addressed within the self-regulation goal and visual processing and OT addressed by the two “fine motor/visual motor” goals. (Exh. 25.)

Petitioner further argues that the IEP goals and objectives were inappropriate because STUDENT had already achieved many of those goals and objectives. Petitioner points to the June 2002 exit report prepared by Barbara Lopez of VIP Tots. Ms. Lopez reported, in part, that STUDENT used more than fifty expressive labels, could sort by color and object, could draw an imitation of a straight line and a circle, could identify all capital letters of the alphabet, could count to ten although would sometimes forget how to do so, would obey two-part commands, would work on tasks for up to 45 minutes while seated in a tray chair, and could sometimes work for up to 30 or 35 minutes while seated on a rug. (Exh. 9.) While Ms. Lopez did not testify, MOTHER testified that she had observed STUDENT work with Ms. Lopez and agreed with Ms. Lopez’s exit report, with the sole exception that STUDENT did not understand prepositions as Ms. Lopez had reported. (See Exh. 9, p. 42.)

The reports of District assessors, however, were consistent and persuasive in their explanations that they did not observe STUDENT performing at these levels. (Testimony of Dr. Kitlowski, Ms. Lucas, Ms. Dominguez, Ms. Gidley.) As CARD supervisor Theresa Contreras explained, STUDENT behaves better for, and complies better with commands from, people he knows. As a result, his performance levels for a new individual are generally lower than his performance levels for people he knows. Similarly, Ms. Dominguez explained that while STUDENT may have demonstrated higher-level skills for Ms. Lopez, with whom he was familiar, he did not demonstrate those skills for the District assessors who were new and unknown to him. Hence, some of STUDENT’s 2002-2003 goals and objectives included tasks that Ms. Lopez reported STUDENT could already perform; for example, the IEP’s pre-academic goal included an objective of counting up to five, while the receptive language goal included objectives of “follow 1-step commands using 10 basic concepts” and “sort objects into 3-4 basic categories.” (Exh. 25.)

Assuming that STUDENT demonstrated the reported skill levels when he worked with Ms. Lopez in 2002, the absence of these skills during the District assessments nevertheless indicates that STUDENT had not retained and/or generalized these skills and would not demonstrate them for new observers. Regardless of whether STUDENT had those skills at one time, if he was not exhibiting those skills then he had not learned or generalized them, and inclusion of those skills in the goals and objectives was appropriate to address STUDENT’s unique needs. Thus, the District was not incorrect in drafting goals and objectives targeted to those skills.

Petitioner also raises the argument that the ACCESS DTT program did not address his unique needs because that program had no goals and objectives. The IEP team drafted STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives at the two IEP meetings in October 2002, while Dr. Kitlowski did not conduct her initial assessment until November 2002. Dr. Kitlowski testified that she did not draft any new goals or objectives for the home program and did not change any of the existing ones because she believed that the existing goals and objectives were consistent with the goals and objectives she recommended for the in-home DTT program. Dr. Kitlowski testified that the home program worked on all but two of STUDENT’s goals. The ACCESS progress reports, log notes and data sheets support this testimony. (Exhs. 27, 29, 32, 62, 68.) Thus, the ACCESS DTT program had goals and objectives, but simply did not have new goals and objectives separate from those already in STUDENT’s program.

Next, Petitioner argues that the District failed to address his behavioral needs because it failed to design appropriate behavioral interventions. The October/November 2002 IEP contained a specific behavioral goal of self-regulation, plus other goals related to behavior, such as classroom participation, attending, cooperative play and social interactions. The IEP indicated that the in-home DTT program, supervised by Dr. Kitlowski, would address STUDENT’s behavior issues. The DTT program tracked STUDENT’s behaviors in data sheets, Dr. Kitlowski’s log book and the progress reports Dr. Kitlowski wrote. (Exhs. 27, 32, 52; testimony of Dr. Kitlowski.) The IEP team also developed a behavior tracking sheet. (Exh. 25, p. 92.) The SDC teacher later switched to using a behavior tracking form that had a numbering system but that form was not working well; therefore, at the May 2003 IEP meeting the team agreed to switch to a different form that Dr. Kitlowski developed. (Exh. 57; testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Dominguez.) Additionally, STUDENT’s behaviors in the SDC were reported to the parents in his progress reports and in the communication log sent home to the parents each day. (Exh. 56.) Ms. Dominguez, Dr. Kitlowski and Ms. Lindemulder all described various ways that the staff used to avoid or address STUDENT’s behaviors, including sensory activities, reinforcers and time outs.

Thus, the District’s program included behavior interventions for both the SDC and the DTT settings and included components for tracking and addressing negative behaviors. Ms. Dominguez and Dr. Kitlowski reported improvements in STUDENT’s behaviors, including a reduction in tantrums during the 2002-2003 school year. (Exhs. 27, 32.) Considering all of the behavioral interventions, these measures were appropriate to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs and reduce his negative behaviors. Petitioner further contends that the District’s program failed to document his progress. It is well-established that frequent data collection is a key component of providing FAPE using a DTT program. Dr. Sebastien Bosch explained in his testimony that data collection allows the providers of a DTT program to modify the program according to the child’s progress. In the present case, the tutors and supervisor of the DTT program provided by ACCESS recorded the data on STUDENT’s behaviors and progress on the drills. Dr. Kitlowski used the data follow STUDENT’s progress, adjust the DTT program according to his progress, and report on his progress in quarterly progress reports. (Footnote 16) (Exhs. 27, 32, 52, 68; testimony of Dr. Kitlowski.) Dr. Kitlowski’s testimony on this topic was persuasive and supported by her progress reports and the DTT drill sheets. To the extent that data collection was part of providing the DTT program to address STUDENT’s unique needs, the evidence indicates that ACCESS sufficiently met that obligation. There is no indication that any failure in data collection caused a denial of FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year.

Thus, the evidence established that the District’s program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs for the 2002-2003 school year. While District staff did not observe STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors and therefore did not design his program to address that area of need, the program was designed to address his other areas of need, i.e., delays in the areas of communication, social skills, play skills, adaptive/self-help skills, attention, behavior, compliance, cognition, receptive language, expressive language, oral motor, articulation, fine motor skills, visual motor skills, and sensory processing.

Was The Program Reasonably Calculated To Provide Educational Benefit?

The District’s program consisted of appropriate components to address STUDENT’s unique needs, including a DTT program, preschool SDC, appropriate DIS and goals and objectives in his areas of deficit. Petitioner generally contends that the program was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. In light of the above discussion finding that the program components of preschool SDC, DTT, and DIS were appropriate for STUDENT, that the program contained appropriate goals and objectives, and that the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the evidence established that the program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

Moreover, because the program was implemented, the Hearing Officer is able to consider STUDENT’s actual progress in the program as evidence of whether the program was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. MOTHER testified that STUDENT made virtually no progress during the period he was in the District’s program, from December 2002 to November 2003. She explained that STUDENT’s only improvement in communication was that he learned to say “I want” regarding an item he wanted, although he had already learned to say the word “want” while in VIP Tots. She testified that, while in the District’s program, STUDENT continued to be non-compliant, which also interfered with him being toilet trained. She testified that STUDENT’s behaviors of tantrums, hitting and kicking continued during this time period. She described how she had difficulty taking STUDENT with her on shopping trips because he would have tantrums when she tried to take him inside a store. MOTHER stated that STUDENT would learn something in DTT, such as how to follow a command that contained a preposition, but then would not be able to generalize that skill when he was home with his family outside of instructional hours. MOTHER explained that the SDC and the DTT program both avoided putting demands on STUDENT to avoid his tantrums; she alleged that, as a result, he was not challenged and any time a demand was placed on him he would have a tantrum or use other avoidance behavior to escape having to do any work. In contrast, MOTHER described how STUDENT’s behaviors and expressive language had improved significantly after just a short time in the CARD program.

The findings of STUDENT’s initial assessment by CARD in October 2003 also offer some insight regarding STUDENT’s progress in the District’s program. (Footnote 17) Regarding STUDENT’s levels in October 2003, the CARD staff found in part that STUDENT could follow simple commands but had negative behaviors of noncompliance, frequent tantrums, and hitting. Regarding receptive language, the CARD supervisors found that STUDENT receptively understood colors, shapes, letters and other concrete items, but could not understand abstract concepts. Expressively, STUDENT could label colors, shapes, numbers, letters and other concrete items. The CARD clinic supervisors who assessed STUDENT generally concurred with the areas of need previously identified by the District, with the addition of self-stimulatory behavior as an area of need. (Exh. 34; testimony of Ms. Contreras.)

District witnesses described how STUDENT had made significant progress in numerous areas. Ms. Gidley, who was the speech-therapist for STUDENT’s SDC during the 2002-2003 school year, described how STUDENT’s attention, behaviors, communication and social interactions all improved during the period from January to June 2003. Ms. Gidley testified that during this period the amount of time STUDENT would work on speech therapy before losing attention increased from one or two minutes to twenty-five minutes. Ms. Gidley stated that STUDENT’s tantrums and other negative behaviors that she had observed in January 2003 decreased or disappeared by June 2003. She reported that in January 2003 STUDENT would not interact with the other children in the class, but by June 2003 he was participating in circle time and was at the beginning stages of communication with the other children. Regarding his speech-language goals, Ms. Gidley reported that STUDENT had met all of the objectives in his speech intelligibility goal, and had met some of the objectives in his receptive and expressive language goals. (See Exh. 25, p. 85-86.) This progress is reflected in STUDENT’s spring 2003 speech-language report cards/progress reports, which stated in part that STUDENT was “using 2-3 words to express his wants” and was “answering questions in class spontaneously.” (Exh. 68, p. 6.)

Occupational therapist Audrey Lindemulder also testified about STUDENT’s progress during the 2002-2003 school year. Ms. Lindemulder described how initially STUDENT had a very short attention span and had difficulty participating in classroom activities, but over time his attention span increased significantly and he was able to participate in activities with other children; when he lost attention to his task, Ms. Dominguez was able to redirect him back to task. Ms. Lindemulder also described how, when she first began working with STUDENT in October 2002, he would not listen to her directions, but after several weeks of sensory training, would follow her directions.

Ms. Dominguez similarly described the progress STUDENT made over the course of his attendance in her SDC from January to June 2003. Ms. Dominguez testified that STUDENT initially had significant difficulty transitioning between activities, would not interact with peers, would not participate in circle time, and required a lot of sensory activities before he was ready to work on very small tasks in the classroom. By June 2003, STUDENT was able to perform more demanding tasks, could transition between activities, could work in a small group setting at a table, and would enthusiastically participate in circle time. STUDENT developed more expressive and spontaneous language. STUDENT’s cooperative play improved, as he became able to play with other children and to do turn-taking for preferred activities. STUDENT’s academic progress is also reflected in his spring report card/progress reports, which report in part that he was making gains in sorting, could count with 1:1 correlation, was making gains in toilet training, and was learning to cooperate and share with peers. (Exh. 68, pgs. 7-9.)

Additionally, Dr. Kitlowski described the progress she observed during STUDENT’s attendance at the in-home DTT program she supervised. Dr. Kitlowski testified about how STUDENT’s attention, spontaneous language and social interactions increased, while his tantrum behaviors and sensitivity to sensory input decreased. Dr. Kitlowski’s written progress reports similarly reflect STUDENT’s progress. (Exhs. 27, 29, 32.) During her testimony, Dr. Kitlowski reviewed each of STUDENT’s IEP goals and described his progress on each, noting that each of the eleven goals worked on in the home program had been met or partially met by the time of STUDENT’s annual IEP review in November 2003.

As to the testimony of MOTHER and the four District witnesses described above, the Hearing Officer finds that all five of the witnesses were credible in their testimony. While taking into account some differences in perception, the Hearing Officer concludes that both MOTHER and the District witnesses were generally correct: STUDENT made meaningful progress at school and in DTT but did not exhibit any significant reduction of tantrums or noncompliance with his family outside of instructional hours. The evidence from the District witnesses and supporting documents established that STUDENT made significant progress on his IEP goals and objectives while he was in the SDC, DTT, OT and speech-language sessions. While his continued problem behaviors outside of instructional hours are not insignificant, overall his lack of progress at home does not negate the progress STUDENT made in nearly all areas of his program. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit during the 2002-2003 school year, and in fact STUDENT received educational benefit in that program.

Did The Program Comport With STUDENT’s IEP?

Petitioner alleges the District denied him a FAPE by failing to provide him the services specified in his October/November 2002 IEP. (Footnote 18) Petitioner alleges that he was denied services in the following areas:

(a) Occupational Therapy

Petitioner asserts that the District failed to provide him with OT services during the 2002-2003 school year in conformity with his IEP of October and November 2002. The October/November 2002 IEP indicated that STUDENT would receive individual occupational therapy for two sessions per week, thirty minutes per session. Ms. Lindemulder testified that she provided STUDENT with individual OT services twice a week for thirty minutes per session, and described some of the activities they did during those sessions. Ms. Lindemulder acknowledged that on a few occasions she was not able to see STUDENT at school, in part due to some modified (shortened) school days. Ms. Lindemulder’s OT log reflects that she provided one hour of individual OT services to STUDENT most weeks that school was in session, except for two occasions when she attended STUDENT’s IEP meetings instead of providing direct services to him. (Exh. 73.) Considering the modified school days and the days when Ms. Lindemulder missed sessions due to STUDENT’s IEP meetings, STUDENT missed a total of six (6) thirty-minute OT sessions.

STUDENT’s IEP did not specify an exception to provision of services due to IEP meetings. None of the missed sessions were made up. To the limited extent of three hours of OT services, this created a nonconformity with the IEP.

Petitioner also argues that his OT services failed to comport with his IEP because there is no evidence that he received any OT services during the 2003 ESY. STUDENT’s IEP provided that he would receive ESY services during summer 2003 in order to maintain his skills. (Exh. 25, p. 83.) Extended school year (ESY) services are provided to individuals with special needs who require special education services in excess of the regular academic year when interruption of their regular education program may cause regression. (5 C.C.R. § 3043(a).) Because the IEP did not specify OT services during ESY, the absence of OT services during ESY did not create a nonconformity with the IEP and did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on that basis. (Footnote 19)

Finally, Petitioner raises the issue of provision of a “sensory diet.” The IEP of December 10, 2002, states that “sensory integration training will be put in place by [the occupational therapist]” and the May 10, 2003 IEP states that “a sensory diet & sensory activities are implemented through-out the day.” (Exh. 26, p.102; Exh. 30, p.113.) Petitioner appears to be contending that the District failed to comply with this provision because no written sensory diet was ever developed. District occupational therapist Audrey Lindemulder testified that from October 2002 to June 2003, she had STUDENT participate in several sensory activities, including joint compression, brushing him with a plastic surgical brush and using the therapy ball. Dr. Kitlowski and Ms. Dominguez similarly described their observations of STUDENT’s sensory activities during OT sessions they observed. There was no evidence contrary to Ms. Lindemulder’s testimony. Moreover, Ms. Lindemulder testified in a particularly straightforward manner which was both credible and persuasive. Thus, the evidence established that Ms. Lindemulder implemented STUDENT’s sensory integration activities pursuant to the IEPs, and the absence of a written sensory diet was not a nonconformity with the IEP.

(b) Speech-Language Services

During clarification of Petitioner’s issues, Petitioner generally stated that the District had failed to provide speech-language services in conformity with the IEP for the 2002-2003 school year. However, subsequently Petitioner did not specify which speech-language sessions he contends were not provided. Rather, in his closing argument, Petitioner asserts that a nonconformity occurred because his speech-language therapist for the 2002-2003 school year failed to provide the following year’s speech-language therapist with documents created during his work on the Links to Language program.

The October/November IEP specified that STUDENT would receive individual speech-language therapy for twenty minutes per week, group speech-language therapy for twenty minutes per week, and speech-language consultation services for up to one hour per month. The IEP did not specify that the speech-language therapist would provide any particular documents to STUDENT’s subsequent speech-language therapist.

In any event, Petitioner’s allegation does not support a finding that STUDENT failed to receive his speech-language sessions pursuant to the IEP during the 2002-2003 school year. Ms. Gidley testified that, pursuant to the October/November 2002 IEP, she worked with STUDENT individually for twenty minutes per week and in a group for an additional twenty minutes per week. As discussed above, Ms. Gidley’s testimony described how STUDENT progressed during those sessions. In August 2003, Ms. Gidley spoke with STUDENT’s new speech therapist on the telephone and sent her an E-mail regarding STUDENT’s speech-language levels. (Testimony of Jeanine Johnson, Ms. Gidley; Exh. 74, p. 7.) Ms. Gidley was entirely credible in her testimony and there was no evidence contrary to her statements. Thus, there is no evidence of any failure to provide STUDENT’s speech-language services in conformity with the IEP, and Ms. Gidley’s failure to send documents to the next speech-language therapist is not evidence of any nonconformity.

Petitioner also argues that the District failed to provide him with speech-language therapy during the 2003 ESY and that the absence of those services failed to comport with the IEP. As discussed above, STUDENT’s IEP did not specify what type of services he would receive during the 2003 ESY. In any event, a written log sheet indicates that STUDENT received individual and group speech-language services during the 2003 ESY, and Ms. Johnson testified that this log was her record of the services she provided to STUDENT during the 2003 ESY. (Exh. 74, p. 9.) Hence, STUDENT’s speech-language services during the 2003 ESY were provided in conformity with the IEP.

(c) In-Home DTT

Petitioner argues that he did not receive all of the ten hours per week pursuant to his October/November 2002 IEP, and did not receive all of the sixteen hours per week of in-home DTT specified in his IEP dated January 27, 2003. Dr. Kitlowski testified that initially, in December 2002 and January 2003, STUDENT did not receive all of his DTT hours because of confusion regarding the scheduling and employment status of the DTT tutors. However, consistent with a chart of STUDENT’s hours during this period, Dr. Kitlowski explained that she scheduled and provided additional hours for February and March 2003 to make up for the missed hours. (Footnote 20) (Exh. 76.) The data sheets, time sheets of the tutors, and time sheets for the ACCESS program support the District’s position that STUDENT eventually received all the hours of his program. (Exhs. 62, 68, 76.) While the parties agree that some records of the DTT program from April to July 2003 are missing, the remaining records and the testimony of Dr. Kitlowski sufficiently establish that the DTT hours were provided in substantial conformity with the amounts specified in the IEPs during the 2002-2003 school year.

In summary, the only nonconformity with the IEP was the failure to provide three hours of OT sessions over the course of the 2002-2003 school year. Other than this limited nonconformity, the District provided STUDENT’s services in conformity with his IEPs for the 2002-2003 school year. No other substantive denials of FAPE occurred during the 2002-2003 school year and therefore overall the District substantively provided STUDENT with a FAPE that year. Regarding procedural claims, the District procedurally denied STUDENT a FAPE from mid-August to mid-October 2002 due to the failure to convene an IEP meeting and offer a program prior to October 16, 2002.

(2) Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year, including the ESY?

A. Procedural Requirements

The only procedural denial of FAPE claim for the 2003-2004 school year concerns the attendance of required team members at the IEP annual review meetings on November 17 and December 1, 2003. Petitioner argues that no occupational therapist, regular education teacher or CARD representative attended the meetings, in violation of California Education Code section 56341(b) and 34 C.F.R. section 300.344(a).

The attendance of related services personnel is appropriate for the IEP annual review meeting. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b), 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a).) Amy Brennan is the occupational therapist who provided OT services to STUDENT while he attended the District’s Murrieta Elementary School from August to November 2003. Ms. Brennan did not attend the November 17 IEP meeting, but attended the continuation of the meeting on December 1. The Hearing Officer considers that Ms. Brennan was thus available to discuss STUDENT’s OT services, offer input regarding his program, and answer questions posed by other team members. Given the occupational therapist’s attendance at the second portion of the IEP annual review, there does not appear to have been any loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement of parental participation, nor has Petitioner identified any such harm. Thus, the occupational therapist’s absence at the IEP meeting on November 17, 2003, did not constitute a procedural denial of FAPE.

No regular education teacher attended either the November 17 or December 1 IEP meetings. As discussed above, the regular education teacher of the student shall attend the student’s IEP meeting if the student is or may be participating in the regular education environment. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(2); 34 CFR § 300.344(a)(2).) At the time of the meetings, STUDENT’s parents had just removed him from the District’s program, which consisted of a preschool SDC, DIS of speech-language and OT, and an in-home DTT program operated by ACCESS. After leaving the District program, STUDENT began a 35-hour per week DTT program operated by CARD. Thus, at the time of these IEP meetings, STUDENT did not have a regular education teacher from either his previous program with the District or his current program with CARD.

The question remains whether STUDENT might have been participating in a regular education class for the period after November/December 2003, pursuant to the specifications of California Education Code section 56341(b)(2). At the November/December 2003 IEP meetings, the District was offering placement in an inclusion program, wherein several typically developing peers would attend the SDC, but STUDENT would remain in the SDC taught by Ms. Dominguez and would not have a regular education teacher. Regarding the program the PARENTS sought for STUDENT, the parents notified the District that STUDENT was switching to a CARD program but did not notify the District of their request for placement in a regular education class. (Exhs. 35, 41.) Because the District had no reason to believe that STUDENT might be participating in a regular education class during that time period, the attendance of a regular education teacher was not required. Considering also that there was no evidence of loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement of parental participation, such absence does not constitute a procedural denial of FAPE.

Petitioner’s final procedural claim for this school year concerns the absence of a CARD representative from the November/December 2003 IEP meetings. STUDENT had begun his thirty-five-hour per week CARD program on November 10, 2003, shortly before the IEP annual review meetings on November 17 and December 1, 2003. Ms. Dominguez, STUDENT’s special education teacher for the previous ten months, attended both meetings. As noted above, the IDEA and State law require the attendance of “at least one special education teacher of the pupil or, if appropriate, at least one special education provider of the pupil.” As discussed above, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has held that the teacher could be the child’s regular teacher, or a teacher qualified to provide education in the type of program in which the child may be placed, or both. (Shapiro v. Paradise Valley, supra, 317 F.3d at 1077.) Additionally, at the discretion of the parent or the LEA, the IEP team may include “other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil, including related services personnel, as appropriate.” (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(6); 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(6).)

The main purpose of the attendance of a CARD staff member would have been to offer input regarding STUDENT’s needs, but the CARD staff members had only worked with STUDENT for a few days. Unlike the child’s teacher in Shapiro, the CARD staff members had little time to acquire familiarity with STUDENT’s needs prior to the IEP meetings. Under the Education Code and the IDEA regulations, the parents had the discretion to invite a CARD representative or ask the District to invite a CARD representative to the meetings, but there was no evidence that they sought to do so.

Other attendees at the meeting had worked with STUDENT for months and had knowledge of his needs. STUDENT’s recent special education teacher’s attendance at the meetings fulfilled the requirements of Education Code section 56341(b)(3) and 34 C.F.R section 300.344(a)(3). In light of all the evidence, the absence of a CARD representative at the November and December 2003 IEP meetings did not constitute a procedural violation and did not deny STUDENT a FAPE. B. Substantive Requirements

What Were STUDENT’s Unique Needs in 2003-2004?

At the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT continued to have deficits in the same general areas as in 2002-2003, which were delays in communication, social skills, play skills, adaptive/self-help skills, attention, aggressive and self-stimulatory behaviors, compliance, cognition, speech, receptive language, expressive language, oral motor, articulation, fine motor skills, visual motor skills and sensory processing. Because he had made progress during the 2002-2003 school year, as detailed under Issue #1 of this Decision, his performance levels had risen in many areas. As discussed above, STUDENT’s skills and performance levels included transitioning between classroom activities using the SDC’s color-coded system, paying attention and working on a task in the classroom, and participating in classroom activities such as circle time. STUDENT was developing social and play skills such as turn-taking and sharing toys with peers. Through the efforts of both District staff and his parents, STUDENT had made gains in his toilet training. Behaviors such as tantrums, hitting and kicking had been reduced at school and in DTT, but persisted at home. STUDENT’s mother reported that he was often non-compliant with his family members, but his teachers reported that he would follow simple commands.

Because STUDENT’s initial IEP had convened in October and November 2002, his annual IEP was due to reconvene at the same time in 2003. Hence, the District’s program offer for August to November 2003 differed from its offer for November 2003 through the end of the 2003-2004 school year. For purposes of clarity, this Decision will therefore consider the two offers separately.

August - November 2003

At the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT was still receiving the services and placement pursuant to his October/November 2002 IEP, with amendments from IEP meetings on December 10, 2002, May 9, 2003, and June 11, 2003. In fall 2003, STUDENT’s program itself remained essentially the same as it was in the prior school year, with OT, speech-language, an in-home DTT program by the NPA ACCESS and a preschool SDC taught by Ms. Dominguez and three aides. While the location of the SDC changed to a different school, Ms. Dominguez otherwise ran the SDC similar to the prior year, except that the number of students in the SDC was half that of the previous year and therefore the teacher-to-student ratio had been doubled. The IEP goals and objectives remained the same; as discussed above, while the goals and objectives did not address STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors, overall they targeted STUDENT’s areas of need. Considering this Decision’s previous findings about the appropriateness of the program offered in the October/November 2002 IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that the program continued to be appropriate to address STUDENT’s unique needs and provide him with educational benefit from August to November 2003.

Evidence of STUDENT’s progress in fall 2003 supports the finding that the program was appropriate for STUDENT at that time. For example, Ms. Dominguez testified that during the period from August to November 2003 STUDENT made significant gains such as using more spontaneous language, improved social interactions with peers, learning to socially greet other people, and transitioning between activities more easily and with less supervision. Regarding his ability to transition, Ms. Dominguez explained that previously STUDENT had used a Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) schedule, but that in fall 2003 she set up a system using colored popsicle sticks as “classroom transition sticks.” Ms. Dominguez testified that STUDENT was able to follow verbal instructions and transition to the new activity designated by the colored stick.

Similarly, Dr. Kitlowski’s November 2003 progress report indicated that STUDENT had made gains in numerous areas including social interactions, play skills, behavior, spontaneous and expressive language, receptive language, verbal imitation, nonverbal imitation, and sorting items into categories. He knew the numbers 1 through 10, knew colors and shapes, and could copy a line or a circle. (Exh. 41; testimony of Dr. Kitlowski.) These gains were reported in the November/December 2003 IEP document, which indicates that STUDENT had met all of his IEP goals from the October/November 2002 IEP. (Exh. 41.) Moreover, as discussed in Issue #1, the October 2003 CARD evaluation reflected progress that STUDENT had made during this period. (Exh. 34; testimony of Ms. Contreras.) Thus, this evidence of progress supports the conclusion that the District’s program was appropriate for STUDENT for the period from August to November 2003.

The next question is whether the services STUDENT received comported with his operative IEPs. Petitioner points to two possible areas of nonconformity. Pursuant to the October/November 2002 IEP, STUDENT was supposed to receive individual speech-language therapy for twenty minutes per week and group speech-language therapy for twenty minutes per week. Petitioner argues that STUDENT missed four speech-language sessions from August to November 2003 because the speech-language therapist did not provide those sessions. Ms. Johnson testified that she missed a few individual sessions with STUDENT because she attended two trainings during this period and missed another session due to her illness. There is no question that she otherwise provided STUDENT with one individual session and one group session of speech-language therapy each week. (Exh. 74, pgs. 1-6.) While occasional, infrequent absences by related services personnel are probably unavoidable in any program, the missed sessions nevertheless constitute a nonconformity with the IEP if not replaced. Thus, to the limited extent that the District failed to provide STUDENT with four speech-language sessions from August to November 2003, those missed sessions constituted a nonconformity with the IEP.

The other area of alleged nonconformity concerns the in-home DTT. Petitioner alleges that there are no records for provision of any DTT services for the period from September 24 to October 8, 2003. (Exh. 68, pgs. 61, 78.) Dr. Kitlowski recalled that sometime around September 2003, the in-home program did not do STUDENT’s usual DTT drills so that they could focus exclusively on toilet training. Dr. Kitlowski described how the in-home program continued to provide services during that period, but those services consisted of play activities interrupted by taking STUDENT to the toilet every fifteen minutes. The daily log notes from the program are consistent with this explanation in that a note dated October 8, 2003 solely concerns STUDENT’s progress on toilet training. In light of all information, the evidence does not support any nonconformity denied STUDENT a FAPE from August to November 2003.

In summary, the only substantive denial of FAPE from August to November 2003 was the limited nonconformity caused by four missed speech-language sessions. Otherwise, the District provided STUDENT a FAPE from August to November 2003.

November 2003 to August 2004Petitioner argues that the District’s program continued to be inappropriate for STUDENT and that he instead needed a forty-hour per week program from CARD. At the November/December 2003 IEP meetings, the District offered to continue STUDENT in the same program and placement. The offer consisted of ESY, speech-language therapy, OT, Ms. Dominguez’s preschool SDC, and Dr. Kitlowski’s DTT program for 16 hours per week of tutoring and eight hours per month of consultation/supervision. Regarding the SDC, the District offered that STUDENT’s placement would be modified to include his participation in an “inclusion program,” wherein typically developing peers would attend STUDENT’s SDC for a significant portion of the school day. The inclusion program would be “reverse mainstreaming” for STUDENT; he would remain in the same classroom all day, while the typically developing peers would leave their class and attend the SDC for part of the day. (Footnote 21) They would replace half of the SDC students, who would move to the regular education classroom for that portion of the day. (Exh. 41; testimony of Ms. Dominguez, Ms. Preston.)

As discussed above, the District’s program of ESY, speech-language, OT, DTT and the preschool SDC overall was appropriate for STUDENT. Ms. Dominguez testified that STUDENT’s behavior and attention had improved so much that he would be able to handle the inclusion program. Moreover, because STUDENT’s imitation skills had improved, District staff believed that greater exposure to typically developing peers would now result in greater academic and non-academic benefit for STUDENT. Consistent with the findings discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the November/December 2003 IEP was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to result in educational benefit. Because the program was not actually provided, there are no allegations of nonconformity with the IEP. Therefore, the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year.

(3) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement for the costs of the program provided by Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).) However, parents are not required to have procured an exact proper placement under IDEA in order to be entitled to reimbursement. (Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 79 F.2d 1153, 1161.) In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting relief. (Burlington, supra; Student W. v. Puyallup School District, supra.)

This Decision found that STUDENT was procedurally denied a FAPE from mid-August to mid-October 2002. During those months, the District did not offer him a FAPE and therefore STUDENT received only the services pursuant to his IFSP. While those services were not inappropriate, they did not provide the educational opportunities, such as attendance at a preschool class, that the District later offered in the IEP. This Decision also found a minor nonconformity regarding the provision of OT services from November 2002 to June 2003, when STUDENT did not receive three hours of OT services pursuant to his IEP. Similarly, the Decision found a minor nonconformity regarding the provision of speech-language services from August to November 2003, when the District failed to provide STUDENT with eighty minutes of speech-language services as set forth in his IEP.

STUDENT is entitled to a remedy for the nonconformities with his IEPs, and for the loss of educational opportunity from mid-August to mid-October 2002 due to the failure to make a timely offer. The PARENTS seek reimbursement for their expenses providing STUDENT’s CARD program from November 2003 to the present.

Regarding the missed OT and speech-language sessions, STUDENT has not received any OT or speech-language services since he began the CARD program in November 2003. Thus, there is no causal relationship between the denial of FAPE and the remedy Petitioner seeks and reimbursement is therefore not an appropriate remedy for the missed OT and speech-language sessions. The Hearing Officer next considers awarding relief in the form of compensatory education. Compensatory education is an equitable remedy which may be available when the school district has denied the student a FAPE. (Puyallup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489.) The right to compensatory education does not create an obligation to automatically provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for the opportunities missed. (Id.) However, in the present case the replacement of the missed sessions is feasible and would remedy the harm. Thus, the District shall remedy the failure to provide the missed DIS sessions with replacement of the missed sessions. Accordingly, in addition to services the District has already offered STUDENT, the District shall offer STUDENT an additional three hours of OT and eighty minutes of speech-language services.

Next, the Hearing Officer will consider an appropriate remedy for the denial of FAPE from mid-August to mid-October 2002, a period of approximately nine weeks. As discussed previously in this Decision under Issue #1, it is unclear whether STUDENT received any services for a period of three to four weeks in September 2002. Ms. Abrassart reported that the Regional Center had promised to provide STUDENT’s services through September 2002, but MOTHER alleged that there was a period of three to four weeks when STUDENT received no services until the District’s services began in early October 2002. There was no evidence at hearing to establish that STUDENT actually received his services from the Regional Center in September 2002. Despite any promise from the Regional Center to continue services, in fall 2002 STUDENT was three years old and therefore the District remained the agency ultimately responsible for his education. Hence, any failure by the Regional Center to deliver STUDENT’s services during this time was nevertheless the responsibility of the District. Considering that the District bears the burden of proof at hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to establish that STUDENT receive his interim services for four weeks in September 2002. (See Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398; Seattle Sch. Dist., No. 1 v. B.S., et al., 82 F.3d 1493, 1498 (9th Cir.1996).) Thus, the District’s procedural denial of FAPE in fall 2002 denied STUDENT a total of sixteen (16) hours of services for four (4) weeks in September 2002, for a total of sixty-four (64) hours.

For the remaining five weeks in the nine-week period from August 14 to October 16, 2002, STUDENT received four hours per week of one-on-one early intervention services and two hours per week of OT. Given that this Decision found that SDC attendance and DIS totaling six hours per week plus DTT of ten hours per week met STUDENT’s needs, the District’s delay denied him a total of ten hours of services during the weeks when he received his six hours of interim services. Accodingly, during those five weeks, the procedural denial of FAPE caused STUDENT to lose ten hours per week, for a total of fifty (50) hours. Combined with the hours from September 2002, STUDENT lost a total of one hundred and fourteen (114) hours of services during the period from August 14 to October 16, 2002. Had the District offered STUDENT’s program by his third birthday and not created the procedural denial, STUDENT would have been able to receive those 114 hours in DTT and preschool classroom time, with OT for one hour per week and speech-language services for forty minutes per week.

To remedy this denial, Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the CARD program he began receiving in November 2003. The CARD program has been providing STUDENT with DTT services for thirty-five hours per week. The primary purpose of STUDENT’s CARD services has been to provide his educational program. However, considering that STUDENT was denied a FAPE for two months in 2002, a portion of the CARD program has operated to compensate him for that denial. Considering that DTT was a primary component of STUDENT’s program from the District, there is a causal relationship between the denial of FAPE in fall 2002 and the DTT program subsequently provided by CARD.

The evidence established that the CARD services were appropriate for STUDENT. CARD staff conducted assessments of STUDENT and identified his areas of need, including expressive language, receptive language, following instructions, aggressive behaviors, self-stimulatory behaviors, emotional functioning, self-regulation, turn-taking and other social interactions, play skills, and attention. (Exhs. 34, 64; testimony of Ms. Contreras, Dr. Bostani.) The CARD staff drafted goals and objectives to address those areas. (Exh. 69.) STUDENT has made progress in the CARD program. MOTHER described how STUDENT’s behavior, compliance, self-help skills and communication have all improved since he began the CARD program. Ms. Contreras described those gains and his academic progress.

It is notable that, while the CARD services alone have been appropriate for STUDENT, other components are required to provide STUDENT an appropriate program. STUDENT needs the socialization with peers available in a classroom. Petitioner does not dispute that classroom attendance would be appropriate, but his mother explained that financial limitations have prevented the parents from placing STUDENT in a private preschool classroom. Petitioner also acknowledges that STUDENT needs speech-language therapy and OT, which he has not received since he stopped attending a District program in early November 2003. Thus, the CARD services do not constitute the entirety of an appropriate program for him. However, given that that the CARD services addressed STUDENT’s unique needs and provided him with educational benefit, reimbursement for the services may still be awarded.

Given the amount of hours denied and STUDENT’s young age, awarding compensatory services would not be feasible because STUDENT already receives a full-time, intensive program. Moreover, the Hearing Officer considers that, by providing STUDENT with private DTT services from CARD, the PARENTS have already provided compensatory services replacing STUDENT’s lack of services from August 14 to October 16, 2002. Because STUDENT’s parents have already provided compensatory services, an additional award of compensatory services is not warranted. Rather, to reimburse for the compensatory services STUDENT’s parents already obtained, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the first one hundred and fourteen (114) hours of his CARD program in November and December of 2003.

(4) Is STUDENT entitled to prospective placement with the CARD program for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year?

The District’s most recent IEP offer was for the period from November 2003 to November 2004. As discussed in Issue #3, overall the program offered was appropriate for STUDENT. Accordingly, there is no basis to order STUDENT’s prospective placement at CARD.

ORDER

1. STUDENT’s parents shall provide the District with proof of their expenses, such as invoices and receipts, for the first one hundred and fourteen (114) hours of the CARD program STUDENT received beginning in November 2003. Within thirty (30) calendar days of the receiving such proof, the District shall reimburse the parents for the amount they paid to CARD for the first one hundred and fourteen (114) hours of services.

2. Within ten calendar days of the date of this Decision, Respondents shall send written notice of an IEP team meeting to all of STUDENT’s IEP team members pursuant to 34 C.F.R. section 300.345 and California Education Code section 56341.5. The meeting shall be scheduled to convene within thirty (30) calendar days of the date of this Decision. At the IEP meeting, the District shall offer STUDENT an additional four hours of occupational therapy and eighty (80) minutes of speech-language services, in addition to the existing offer of services, as compensation for the missed sessions identified in this Decision.

3. All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

(1) Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that the District denied him a FAPE from mid-August to mid-October 2002, due to a procedural violation, and also failed to provide him with three hours of occupational therapy (OT) services from November 2002 to June 2003 in conformity with his IEP. The District prevailed on the remainder of this issue.

(2) Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that the District failed to provide him with eighty (80) minutes of speech-language services in conformity with his IEP. The District prevailed on the remainder of this issue.

(3) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement for the costs of the program provided by Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that he is entitled to reimbursement for one hundred and fourteen (114) hours, of CARD services to remedy the denial of FAPE from mid-August to mid-October 2002. Additionally, Petitioner prevailed to the very limited extent that he is entitled to compensatory services of hours of OT and eighty (80) minutes of speech-language services. The District prevailed on the remainder of this issue.

(4) Is STUDENT entitled to prospective placement with the CARD program for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)

DATED: June 22, 2004 ___________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. On April 22, 23 and 29, the hearing convened only a portion of each day due to continuances requested and obtained by Petitioner’s attorney, Shelli Lewis. Each continuance was granted for good cause and the District did not oppose Petitioner’s requests for the continuances.

2. These issues were identified in the parties’ Joint Issue Statement and clarified during a prehearing telephone conference on April 19, 2004.

3. On June 12, 2002, the District sent a notice of an IEP meeting to convene on August 12, 2002, to review the results of the assessments that the District intended to conduct on June 14, 2002. Because the assessors did not have the opportunity to conduct the assessments by that date, that meeting did not take place. However, no one informed MOTHER that the meeting was canceled. On August 5, 2002, PARENTS sent an E-mail to Ms. Abrassart, copied to several other District staff members, inquiring about the assessments and the August 12 meeting. Ms. Abrassart replied by E-mail that the PARENTS needed to “deal with the district office” on the matter. On August 12, 2002, MOTHER arrived for the IEP meeting and learned that the meeting had been canceled.

4. In an E-mail sent two days prior to the IEP meeting, Mr. and MOTHER had notified the District staff about this concern and about their concern that the assessment plan indicated only the general areas of testing and not the specific tests that would be administered.

5. Initially MOTHER did not make a check mark in one of the necessary boxes on the form. She checked the correct box and again signed the document when District staff presented the Assessment Plan to her in August 2002.

6. Subsequently, the parties could not reach agreement regarding who would conduct the neuropsychological assessment and therefore that assessment did not occur.

7. For a student moving from Part C to Part B of the IDEA upon turning three years old, the student’s IFSP operates as the stay put placement when the student does not have an implemented and agreed-upon IEP. (See Johnson v. Special Education Hearing Office, 287 F.3d 1176 (9th Cir. 2002).)

8. Initially, the District’s special education director, Zhanna Preston, offered the interim placement services for a total of four hours per week, as specified in the February 2002 IFSP. However, in late August 2002, the District learned that the Regional Center had increased STUDENT’s services to six hours per week, and as a result Ms. Preston amended the proposed interim placement accordingly. (Exh. 3, p. 29.)

9. Even in the light most favorable to the District, the fifty-day timeline had also run by the time the October 16, 2002 IEP meeting convened.

10. Moreover, in other cases parents may not consent to the IEP, in which case the student’s IFSP remains the operative placement when the student does not have an implemented and agreed-upon IEP.

11. In the parties’ Joint Statement of Issues and the subsequent prehearing telephone conference in this matter, Petitioner’s initial issues identified specific IEP meetings in which the attendance of particular individuals was in dispute. However, Petitioner’s closing argument did not address several of his initial claims, and raised one new claim. This Decision will address only the allegations raised in both Petitioner’s stated issues and his written closing argument; issues abandoned or raised for the first time in a closing argument will not be addressed.

12. Because STUDENT’s LRE was not in dispute for any school year at issue, this Decision does not contain an LRE analysis. Petitioner’s request for prospective placement in a full-time CARD program and attendance in a regular education preschool with a one-on-one CARD aide is not a request for mainstreaming under Sacramento City School Dist. v. Holland, (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994).

13. Petitioner confirmed at the hearing that he does not dispute that the District’s assessments met the legal requirements contained in Education Code section 56320 et seq. Rather, Petitioner only disputes some of the findings of those assessments.

14. Neither Petitioner’s arguments at the hearing nor his closing brief specified which recommendations he refers to.

15. Dr. Kitlowski’s Behavioral and Education Assessment of November 2002 also identified similar deficits in STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language. (Exh. 24.)

16. Notably, the whereabouts of the logbook containing STUDENT’s data sheets from April to July 2003 are unknown; neither party could produce the logbook and each party accuses the other of misplacing the book. In any event, the production of data sheets as evidence in a due process hearing is separate from the question of whether the data collection denied the student a FAPE.

17. However, the evidence established that STUDENT behaved better and complied better with commands from people he knew; as a result, the performance levels he demonstrates for someone new are generally lower than his performance levels for people he knows. (Testimony of Ms. Contreras; cf. Exhs. 9, 15.) Therefore, to some degree the October 2003 CARD assessment report may have underestimated STUDENT’s performance levels.

18. Initially, the parties’ Joint Statement of Issues did not allege any failure to provide services in conformity with the IEPs. During a prehearing telephone conference, Petitioner’s attorney clarified that Petitioner was also alleging that the District denied a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year by failing to provide OT, DTT and speech-language services in conformity with the IEP. In his closing brief, Petitioner argues that the District also failed to provide services in conformity with the IFSP from August to November 2002. Because no IEP was in place during this time and because the issue was not clearly noticed, this Decision does not address whether the services from August to November 2002 were in conformity with the IEP. However, the discussion under Issue #1 of this Decision analyzes procedural violations resulting in a denial of FAPE during that time period.

19. Petitioner did not raise any procedural claims regarding whether the IEP provided a clear written offer concerning the ESY. (See Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519.) Accordingly, this Decision does not address that topic.

20. MOTHER testified that Dr. Kitlowski had stated that if missed hours were not made up within a two-week period, then the hours would not be made up at all. Dr. Kitlowski explained that actually she told MOTHER that the SELPA’s policy was that any missed hours should be made up within two weeks if possible, but that she assured MOTHER that any missed hours would eventually be made up regardless of whether more than two weeks had passed. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Kitlowski’s explanation of her statement was reasonable and plausible; in contrast, the statement MOTHER recalls would have been odd and inexplicable. While MOTHER was otherwise a credible witness, on this point it appears that she either misunderstood or incorrectly recalled Dr. Kitlowski’s statement.

21. While STUDENT’s SDC previously had some reverse mainstreaming due to the presence of one or two typically developing peers in the class, the inclusion program constituted an increase in mainstreaming because more typically developing peers were involved.