California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 28, 2003
Student v. Encinitas Union School District
SEHO Case No. SN 363-02 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary
Encinitas Union School District prevails; high-achieving student with a 504 plan was not eligible for special education.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 10-year-old's parents filed for due process against Encinitas Union School District. At an October 2001 IEP meeting, the district had found her not eligible for special education. She had a Section 504 plan with classroom accommodations for organization, focus and finishing work. In March 2002, midway through fifth grade, her parents moved her to The Winston School, a private school for children with learning disabilities. They argued she qualified as a student with a specific learning disability because of large gaps between her high IQ and her achievement scores. They also argued she qualified under other health impairment because of attention problems and a possible seizure disorder. They sought tuition and mileage reimbursement, funding for Winston through the school year, and vision therapy.
The Hearing Officer measured her ability with her verbal IQ of 127. Even so, the district's achievement testing showed no severe discrepancy in the areas the law lists, except possibly math fluency, and no other evidence backed one up. The Hearing Officer also found that she did not need special education. Her grades were average or better, her statewide test scores were above national averages, and her teachers called her capable and at grade level. Accommodations in general education could meet her needs. The same reasoning defeated the other health impairment claim. Because she was not eligible, the Hearing Officer denied reimbursement, Winston funding and vision therapy. The District prevailed on all issues.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a bright student who had processing weaknesses but was making good progress in general education. The Hearing Officer held that eligibility also required a need for special education that general education accommodations could not meet. On that basis, the Hearing Officer denied all claims for private school costs and therapy.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Should the Petitioner have been found eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability?
Using verbal IQ of 127, no corroborated severe discrepancy existed in the statutory areas, and the student did not need special education because her needs were met through general education accommodations; the October 5, 2001 denial of eligibility was correct.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 2. Should the Petitioner have been found eligible for special education and related services as a student with an other health impairment?
Evidence did not establish that a seizure or attention disorder limited strength, vitality or alertness, and in any event the student did not require special education; accommodations in general education met her needs.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. Are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and mileage costs of Petitioner's attendance at The Winston School from March 2002 to the present?
Because the student was correctly found ineligible, parents are not entitled to tuition and mileage reimbursement.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Should the District be required to fund Petitioner's continued placement at The Winston School through the end of the current school year?
Because the student was not eligible, the District need not fund Winston for the rest of the school year.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Should the District be required to fund Petitioner's vision therapy?
Because the student was not eligible, the District need not fund vision therapy.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of the Petitioner's claims to relief are denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Student v. Long Beach U.S.D. (2000) SN99-00721; Student v. Bellflower U.S.D. (2000) SN00-00449; Student v. Orinda Union S.D. (1995) SN94-00681; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(b); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030
People named in the decision
- Beverly K. Barrett, Ed.D., Director of pupil personnel services, Encinitas Union School District
- Sara M. Frampton, Ph.D., Educational psychologist and student advocate, For Student
- Dr. Carl G. Hillier, Optometrist, independent evaluator, For Student
- Carol J. Atkins, Licensed audiologist, independent evaluator, For Student
- Nancy J. Lazerson, Private speech-language pathologist, independent evaluator, For Student
- Nancy Markel, Ph.D., Clinical neuropsychologist, expert witness for Student, For Student
- Patricia Hotz, Resource specialist, assessor, Encinitas Union School District
- Michelle Dennis, Fourth grade teacher, Park Dale Lane School
- Erica Loder, Speech and language specialist, assessor, Encinitas Union School District
- Leslie Harden, Former principal, Park Dale Lane School
- Susan Jordan, School psychologist, assessor, Encinitas Union School District
- Dennis Rota, Science teacher, Park Dale Lane School
- Sidney Sickels, Fifth grade teacher, Park Dale Lane School
- Dr. Joseph Gleeson, Physician (neurological evaluation), UCSD Medical Center
- The Winston School, Private school for children with learning disabilities (unilateral placement)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Encinitas, California, on February 25, 26, 27, and 28, 2003.
Petitioner, STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT), was represented by attorney Eric B. Freedus of the law firm Frank and Freedus. STUDENT’s mother, Ms. PARENT, was also present throughout the hearing. Respondent, Encinitas Union School District (Respondent or District), was represented at the hearing by advocate G. Robert Roice of G.R. Roice & Associates. The District’s director of pupil personnel services, Beverly K. Barrett, Ed.D. was also present.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: Beverly Barrett; Sara M. Frampton, Ph.D., an educational psychologist and student advocate; Dr. Carl G. Hillier, an optometrist; Carol J. Atkins, a licensed audiologist; Nancy J. Lazerson, a licensed speech and language pathologist; Nancy Markel, Ph.D., a clinical neuropsychologist; and Ms. PARENT.
The District called the following witness: Patricia Hotz, a District resource specialist; Michelle Dennis, Petitioner’s fourth grade teacher at her last District placement, Park Dale Lane School (PDL); Erica Loder, a District speech and language specialist; Leslie Harden, former principal at PDL; Susan Jordan, a District psychologist; Dennis Rota, Petitioner’s former science teacher at PDL; and Sidney Sickels, Petitioner’s fifth grade teacher at PDL.
Oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. Closing arguments were heard, closing briefs were filed, and the record was closed on March 10, 2003.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
1. Should the Petitioner have been found eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability?
2. Should the Petitioner have been found eligible for special education and related services as a student with an other health impairment?
3. Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and mileage costs of Petitioner’s attendance at The Winston School from March 2002 to the present?
4. Should the District be required to fund Petitioner’s continued placement at The Winston School through the end of the current school year?
5. Should the District be required to fund Petitioner’s vision therapy?
BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a bright and likeable ten-year-old child who lives with her parents and two older siblings within the geographical boundaries of the District. She is currently enrolled at The Winston School (Winston), a private school for children with learning disabilities.
STUDENT was the product of a difficult pregnancy, with two threatened spontaneous abortions, and has a medical history significant for multiple ear infections that required tube placement on two occasions. She has worn glasses since she was four years old to correct far sightedness and strabismus.
STUDENT attended two years of preschool. She completed kindergarten and first grade at the District’s Ocean Knoll School and began attending second grade at Park Dale Lane School (PDL) in the1998-1999 school year. STUDENT completed the second, third, fourth, and some of her fifth grades years at PDL. She was removed from that school by her parents and enrolled at Winston midway through her fifth grade year in early March 2002. STUDENT still attends Winston.
Overall, STUDENT has always been a consistently good student. She has put forth good to outstanding effort and continued to make progress in the general curriculum. Her first grade report cards show that she was progressing in all areas and highly proficient in some math problem solving and reading. Her effort and progress continued in the second grade, but there was an indication that STUDENT was not completing and returning homework as expected and was having some trouble with her organizational skills. Stanford Achievement Tests (SAT-9) scores from April 1999 were all above the fiftieth percentile.
STUDENT continued to make progress in the general curriculum during her third grade year, but there was a gradual decline in her citizenship grades, particularly in the areas of self-control, organization, following directions, completing class assignments on time, and completing and returning homework. With the exception of a low subtest score of twelve percent in math procedures, STUDENT’s other SAT-9 total and subtest scores from May 2000 were all above the fiftieth percentile. Some of her scores were well above average, with a language score of ninety-four percent, a vocabulary score of ninety-six percent, and a math problem solving score of ninety-eight percent. By the end of the third trimester, STUDENT’s teacher noted her excellent reading skills that were above grade level. However, she also recognized STUDENT’s difficulties with organization, work completion, and written expression.
STUDENT continued to make progress during her fourth grade year. However, she also continued to have difficulties completing and returning homework assignments. All of her grades except spelling remained above average.(Footnote 2) Her teacher reported in November that STUDENT needed help with organization skills and focusing in class and at home.
In January 2001, Dr. Joseph Gleeson of UCSD Medical Center evaluated STUDENT for a possible seizure disorder. According to his report, it was not clear that STUDENT was having seizures. Nevertheless, he prescribed anti-seizure medication, based principally on the reported family history. On a later visit in April 2001, Dr. Gleeson recommended that STUDENT be evaluated for a possible attention deficit disorder because of her reported difficulties staying on task and her increasing distractibility.(Footnote 3)
A copy of Dr. Gleeson’s initial report was sent directly to PDL. A student study team (SST) was organized to address concerns about STUDENT’s organizational skills, her ability to follow directions, and her timely completion and return of school assignments.(Footnote 4) These efforts resulted in an accommodation plan pursuant to § 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. The February 12, 2001 504 plan provided for accommodations that included the following:
1. preferential seating close to the teacher;
2. the use of a graphic organizer to help with data collection and note taking; 3. one-step directions;
4. chunked tasks/assignments to adjust quantity 5. established timelines;
6. the use of an Alphasmart keyboard to help with writing fluency; 7. frequent prompts and checks for understanding;
8. visual support for instruction and concepts;
9. daily teacher checks for homework assignments.
The SAT-9 scores from May 2001 showed that STUDENT performed above the national percentile averages in all subtest and total scores. Her reading and language subtest and total percentile rankings were above the ninetieth percentile. Her math problem solving, procedures, and total scores were at the fifty-second, seventy-first, and sixty-first percentile, respectively. STUDENT’s spelling was in the seventy-fifth percentile. These scores showed some relative weaknesses in math and spelling, but they also demonstrated that STUDENT continued to do well compared nationally with other children her age.(Footnote 5)
On May 15, 2001, the Petitioner’s advocate, Sara Frampton, wrote to the District to request a special education assessment. An assessment plan was prepared and sent to STUDENT’s parents for review and approval. Sara Frampton amended the assessment plan to request, in addition to the current versions of the tests proposed by the District, the Test of Written Language (TOWL), the Gray Oral Reading Test (GORT), and tests of visual processing. The District declined the request to administer these additional tests because it believed that the planned assessments were adequate to assess in those areas. STUDENT’s mother reported that STUDENT had difficulty in some areas, including study habits, handwriting, and homework. She also believed that STUDENT had difficulty learning and remembering details, and she was concerned about STUDENT’s low grades. She also indicated that STUDENT had great difficulty getting homework to and from class. STUDENT’s forth grade teacher agreed that STUDENT needed extra time and other strategies to help her to focus and to complete tasks.
The District’s psychoeducational assessment was done in August and September 2001 by Susan Jordan, school psychologist, and Patricia Hotz, resource specialist. The Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III) was used to measure STUDENT’s cognitive ability. It produced verbal, performance, and full scale I.Q. scores of 127, 110, and 121, respectively.(Footnote 6) STUDENT demonstrated relative strengths in the areas of categorical thinking, abstract verbal reasoning, generalizing, practical judgment and self-direction. Relative areas of weakness included auditory processing, visual perception of meaningful stimuli, freedom from distractibility, memory, and visual organization.(Footnote 7) The Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement, III (WJ-III) was administered by resource specialist Patricia Hotz to measure STUDENT’s levels of achievement. Of the eleven standard battery test scores, one (writing sample) was in the very superior range (141), eight were in the high average range, one (reading fluency) was in the average range (105), and one (math fluency) was in the low average range (84). On the standard battery clusters, all scores were high average or superior except broad calculation skills (104) and academic fluency (106). These assessors concluded that STUDENT did not qualify for special education because she was performing in at least the average range. They confirmed her continuing eligibility for a 504 plan.
Erica Loder, speech and language specialist, conducted the speech and language assessment on September 3, 2001. She administered the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals, Third Edition (CELF-III), the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills, Revised (TAPS-R), the Language Processing Test, Revised (LPT-R), and took a writing sample. On the CELF-III, STUDENT’s receptive language score of 108 put her in the seventieth percentile nationally. Her expressive language composite score of 135 put her in the ninety-ninth percentile. STUDENT’s total test score on the LPT-R of 101 put her in the forty-seventh percentile. On the TARS-R, three subtest scores were below average but others were in the high average and above average ranges. STUDENT’s auditory perceptual quotient was a standard score of 91 and a percentile ranking of 26. Ms. Loder concluded that STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills were in the average to above average range and that she demonstrated adequate auditory processing skills, but with some weakness in auditory memory.
A rather contentious Individualized Education Plan (IEP) meeting was convened on October 5, 2001. STUDENT’s mother attended with her advocate, Sara Frampton. The District’s assessment results were reviewed and the District’s IEP team members concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. The District’s determination was based principally on the information that showed that STUDENT was doing well academically and that, therefore, she did not need special education services to progress in the general curriculum. Ms. PARENT and her advocate disagreed. Dr. Frampton stated that STUDENT’s parents planned to obtain their own independent assessments. This plan was reiterated in a letter from Dr. Frampton to Ms. Barrett dated November 13, 2001.(Footnote 8)
The District changed its grading practice for the 2001-2002 school year. It switched from a more traditional letter grade system to a state standards based system that quantified the student’s performance as being below, approaching, meeting, or beyond the grade level standard specified by the California proficiency standards. The new grading practice also provided for a traditional letter grade as a measure of day-to-day performance and quality of effort. STUDENT’s November 29, 2001 progress report for the first trimester indicated that she was at or beyond the grade level standards in most areas. She was approaching grade level standards in problem solving/mathematical reasoning, geography, U.S. History, and earth/weather science. Her performance/quality grades were all C or C+. Most of STUDENT’s life skills and work habits were deemed “satisfactory” with the exception of timely completion of tasks, timely completion and return of homework, and organization of her belongings, all of which needed some improvement.
In mid December 2001 the District convened a second meeting to discuss accommodations to which STUDENT was entitled pursuant to § 504. Again acknowledging that STUDENT had a disability that adversely affected her organization and work production speed, the District essentially reiterated the accommodations offered in February 2001 and added one accommodation to deal with what STUDENT’s mother reported as a concern about STUDENT’s self-esteem.
In early February, STUDENT was kept home from school due to illness. Before she returned, her attorney notified the District that STUDENT’s parents were withdrawing her from the District’s school. The District responded to this notice in a February 14, 2002 letter to STUDENT’s parents requesting their consent to a further evaluation by the District’s assessors. Dr. Frampton advised the parents that the assessment would be a waste of time. The parents did not consent to the further assessment. STUDENT did not return to PDL. Her attorney requested this due process hearing on February 19, 2002. STUDENT was enrolled at Winston in early March 2002. She remains a student there.
Between December 20, 2001, and January 29, 2003, STUDENT underwent independent assessments by clinical neuropsychologist Nancy Markel, audiologist Carol J. Atkins, optometrist Dr. Carl Hillier, and speech and language pathologist Nancy J. Lazerson.
Dr. Markel first evaluated STUDENT on December 20, 2001 and February 20, 2002. She administered the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (CTONI) to arrive at a measure of STUDENT’s ability. That test produced a geometric I.Q. score of 136, a pictorial I.Q. score of 121 and a nonverbal I.Q. score of 131. Dr. Markel administered the WJ-III, the results of which were consistently lower than those of the District’s WJ-III.(Footnote 9) She also administered the NEPSY, a test of neuropsychological development, the California Verbal Learning Test – Children’s (CVLT-C), the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI), the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills, Revised (TVPS-R), The Beck Youth Inventories, and the Child Behavior Checklist. The doctor also reviewed the testing that was done by the District and found some scoring errors. The doctor is of the opinion that STUDENT has significant impairments in many academic areas and severe discrepancies between ability and achievement in math calculation, math reasoning, written expression, reading skills and reading comprehension.
Carol Atkins conducted her audiological evaluation of STUDENT on May 20, 2002. Her impression was that STUDENT suffered from both an auditory processing disorder and an attention deficit disorder. She diagnosed a central auditory processing disorder.
Dr. Hillier conducted his optometric examination of STUDENT on June 5, 2002. He determined that STUDENT has a micro-strabismus (slight turning in) of the left eye that contributes to the slightly reduced visual acuity in that eye (20/20 vs. 20/25). The doctor believed that these deficits, along with STUDENT’s difficulty with fine grapho-motor development, contribute to her problems with endurance and efficiency, particularly with respect to written work and reading comprehension, as reported by STUDENT. The doctor recommended that STUDENT undergo fifteen to twenty-five one-hour vision therapy sessions
Nancy Lazerson’s speech and language assessment was done on June 5 and 17, 2002. The focus of the assessment was auditory processing. Ms. Lazerson found little fault with the speech and language assessment that had been conducted by the District, except what she referred to as a lack of in-depth interpretation of STUDENT’s performance, which suggested possible auditory processing deficits. She administered the Oral and Written Language Scales (OWLS), the Comprehensive Assessment of Spoken Language (CASL), the Listening Test, and the Elementary Test of Problem Solving, Revised (TOPS-R). STUDENT scored above the fiftieth percentile in all subtests of the OWLS. There was wide scatter on five subtests of the CASL, with three of the scores being below the fiftieth percentile and one, pragmatic judgment, at the tenth percentile. Four of the five subtest scores on the Listening Test were below the fiftieth percentile, with two of those, reasoning and story comprehension, at the third and twelfth percentile, respectively. STUDENT’s performance on the TOPS was also very poor. Ms. Lazerson concluded that STUDENT suffered from a moderate language processing deficit that was most likely secondary to a central auditory processing disorder and variable attention. She recommended sixty minutes per week of individual speech and language therapy.(Footnote 10)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
The central issue in this case is whether the Petitioner should have been found eligible for special education and offered appropriate services during the 2001-2002 school year. The Petitioner contends that she was eligible as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD). She claims that she has a superior intellect and that there is a severe discrepancy between her high I.Q. and achievement scores on standardized tests in the areas of oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and mathematics calculation. She asserts that the discrepancy is due to auditory, visual, and cognitive processing disorders. She argues that her ability to make progress with her peers in the general education curriculum without the benefit of special education does not make her ineligible under the SLD category. She contends that the required comparison is only between her individual ability and achievement and not between her achievement and the achievement of her peers or some arbitrary grading standard. If a severe discrepancy is found to exist, and if that discrepancy is not correctable through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program, Petitioner claims that she must be found eligible for special education regardless of her ability to make some progress without it. The Petitioner also contends that she was eligible as a student with other health impairments (OHI), namely a seizure disorder and an attention disorder.
The Respondent contends that, although the Petitioner has areas of relative weakness, her needs are adequately addressed in the regular education environment as evidenced by the Petitioner’s overall progress in the general curriculum.
Issue No. 1: Should the Petitioner have been found eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability?
The IDEA defines “specific learning disability” as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in a imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26). Four requirements must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability. The first three requirements are set out in Cal. Educ. Code § 56337. First, there must be a severe discrepancy between the intellectual ability and achievement in oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, or mathematics reasoning. Second, the discrepancy must be due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. Basic psychological processes include attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, and conceptualization, and expression. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030 (j)(1). Third, the discrepancy must not be correctable through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. In addition to these, there is a fourth requirement, one that applies to all persons who seek special education services pursuant to the IDEA. To be eligible, it must be demonstrated that the student requires special education, as opposed to services that can be provided through modifications to or accommodations in the regular school program. Cal Educ. Code § 56026(b); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030.
A severe discrepancy can be established either through a formula using standardized test scores, by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid, or through a determination by an IEP team that such a discrepancy exists. 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A) – (C). The District chose to rely upon the formula using standardized test scores to determine whether or not there was a severe discrepancy. Using this measure, the IEP team compares the ability or I.Q. score with achievement test scores. When the required severe discrepancy between ability and achievement is to be established through valid, standardized tests, the comparison must be of common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of fifteen. A difference equal to or greater than one and one-half standard deviations, adjusted by one standard error of measurement, indicates a severe discrepancy when corroborated by other assessment data. That other assessment data may include other tests, scales, instruments, observations, and work samples. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(A). As indicated in the first paragraph of Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030, in determining eligibility, the IEP team “shall take into account all the relevant material which is available on the pupil. No single score or product of scores shall be used as the sole criterion for the decision . . .”
There was some dispute regarding the appropriate measure of STUDENT’s intellectual ability. The District used the WISC-III as a measuring tool and arrived at the corrected verbal, performance, and full scale I.Q. scores of 127, 110, and 121, respectively. The District psychologist, Susan Jordan, explained that she typically uses the full scale I.Q. score for comparison unless there is a significant discrepancy and a clear indication that there is a major processing disorder affecting one of the I.Q. scores.
Nancy Markel, Ph.D., STUDENT’s consulting neuropsychologist, argued for the use of the higher verbal I.Q. of 127 because, in her opinion, the testing protocols demonstrated a weakness that caused the significant discrepancy between the verbal and performance results.(Footnote 11) She believes that the WISC-III verbal I.Q. is a better measure of STUDENT’s potential. She also administered the CTONI because she believed that it would result in an even more accurate measure of STUDENT’s intellectual ability by screening out those factors weakened by her disability. This test produced a nonverbal I.Q. of 131, the measure that Dr. Markel and others of the Petitioner’s experts believed was the most appropriate measure of STUDENT’s ability.
The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony of Dr. Markel that the difference between STUDENT’s performance and verbal I.Q. scores on the WISC-III was significant enough to call into question the reliability of the WISC-III full scale I.Q. as a measure of STUDENT’s ability. However, he was not convinced that the District’s reliance on the WISC-III was unreasonable or that it should have used a test, such as the CTONI, that does not include timed tests or the use of motor skills. The Hearing Officer finds that the verbal I.Q. score of 127 was an appropriate measure of STUDENT’s ability for comparison purposes.
Dr. Markel was critical of the District’s failure to administer the extended battery of the WJ-III, but she did not disagree with the use of that test in general to measure STUDENT’s achievement.(Foonote 12) The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s WJ-III results provided an accurate snapshot of STUDENT’s levels of achievement at the time in question and that it was reasonable for the IEP team to rely on the results of this testing. A comparison of the scores from the WJ-III with STUDENT’s verbal I.Q. of 127 reveals no discrepancy equal to or greater that 1.5 standard deviations in any of the areas specifically identified by the statutes (oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, or mathematics reasoning). Although STUDENT’s math fluency (84) and broad math calculation skills (104) scores might arguably qualify as severely discrepant, the latter is a composite of the math calculation, reasoning and fluency scores. STUDENT scored 114, well within 1.5 standard deviations, on the two areas of math that are specifically referred to in the statutes: math calculation and math reasoning.(Footnote 13) It was really only the math fluency score that might qualify.(Footnote 14)
The regulation states that no single score or product of scores shall be used as the sole criterion and that a discrepancy equal to or greater than 1.5 standard deviations is considered a severe discrepancy only when corroborated by other assessment data. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(A). In this case, even if something more than a single score or product of scores was found to exceed 1.5 standard deviations, there was nothing else in the District’s assessment data to corrobate the existence of a severe discrepancy. On the contrary, taking STUDENT’s work samples, SAT-9 scores, and classroom observations into consideration, it would have been reasonable for the District members of the IEP team to conclude that no severe discrepancy existed. Given the totality of the evidence, the Hearing Officer would have agreed with that conclusion.
However, the District did not base its denial of eligibility on a finding that there was no discrepancy between ability and achievement scores equal to or greater than 1.5 standard deviations. Nor did it base the denial on a finding that STUDENT did not have a qualifying processing disorder that was causing discrepancies between ability and achievement.(Footnote15) Rather, it was the District’s position that STUDENT’s overall performance, including classroom achievement, grades and SAT-9 testing, not only failed to provide the necessary corroboration, but also demonstrated that she did not require special education.
Citing the language of Cal. Educ Code § 56337(c), the Petitioner’s experts testified that the discrepancies could not be corrected through services offered within the regular instructional program. The Hearing Officer was not convinced of that. The classroom accommodations must have been helping STUDENT to continue to make progress in the general curriculum. In any event, the Hearing Officer was persuaded that STUDENT’s impairment was not such that she required special education or related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(b).
It was virtually undisputed in this case that STUDENT has been progressing in the general curriculum along with her peers. Her progress reports from the first, second, third, and fourth grades show consistent progress with average or better grades, except for one D+ in spelling for the third trimester of the fourth grade. STUDENT continued to make progress at or above grade level in most areas in the first trimester of her fifth grade year and was approaching grade level in the other areas. Her fourth grade teacher, Michelle Dennis, credibly described STUDENT as a highly proficient student. She acknowledged that STUDENT needed to be refocused at times, would require extra time to copy notes and would not always complete and return her assignments. However, she was adamant that she would not have considered referring STUDENT for special education because she was working at or above grade level.
Sidney Sickels, STUDENT’s fifth grade teacher for about a month just before she left in February, and Dennis Rota, her science teacher that same year, agreed. Both described STUDENT as capable and generally producing work at grade level, but both noted that there were some problems with missing assignments, completing timely work and with organizational skills. Neither of them believed that STUDENT needed to be referred for special education. In addition, STUDENT’s scores on the SAT-9 tests near the end of the second, third, and fourth grades, show that STUDENT consistently ranked above national averages.(Footnote 16) All of this evidence showed STUDENT received far more than just “some benefit” from her education. Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200-201.
It appeared from the testimony of Petitioner’s experts that they focused on the standardized test scores that might demonstrate a discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and her achievement and with establishing the existence of processing disorders. None of the Petitioner’s experts seemed to be interested in the fact that STUDENT was clearly benefiting from her District placement. This focus was consistent with the Petitioner’s argument that her actual performance relative to her peers is of only minor significance, at best. However, the experts’ analyses, and the argument they were intended to support, ignored the fact that thus far the IDEA has been consistently interpreted by the Hearing Office to serve the students whose educational needs cannot be met by modification to the regular education program. The evidence persuaded the Hearing Officer that STUDENT was not such a student at the time in question.
The federal district court cases relied upon by the Petitioner are not binding on the Hearing Officer. Furthermore, neither case announces a rule of eligibility different than the one generally accepted. The rule is that the particular needs of each child must be examined to determine his or her eligibility, and there can be no bright-line rule that would automatically deny eligibility to all children who are passing from grade to grade. Rowley, supra, at 203, n. 25.
The Petitioner’s reliance on the prior decisions of the Hearing Office is also misplaced. None of the decisions supports her position. In Student v. Long Beach U.S.D. (2000) SN99- 00721, the Hearing Officer actually concluded that the student there was not eligible as a student with an SLD. Although she found a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement caused by a processing disorder, she also found that the student did not meet the requirement that the discrepancy could not be corrected in regular education. She found, instead, that the student’s ability to get good grades demonstrated that his educational needs could be met through accommodations in the District’s regular educational program. The Hearing Office decisions in Student v. Bellflower U.S.D. (2000) SN00-00449 and Student v. Orinda Union S.D. (1995) SN94-00681 followed a similar analysis and reached the same conclusion.(Footnote 17)
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s determination on October 5, 2001, that STUDENT was not eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability was correct.
The evidence showed that STUDENT did not require special education at the time of the October 2001 IEP meeting. However, the evidence should also put the parties on notice that STUDENT may need special education at some time in the future if modifications and accommodations in the regular education program prove less successful in enabling her to benefit. STUDENT’s difficulties with fluency, perhaps related to a slow processing speed, may require more careful consideration by all. Prompt, sustained and effective intervention through modifications of and accommodations in the regular classroom could insure that STUDENT will never need special education services to benefit from her education.
Issue No. 2: Should the Petitioner have been found eligible for special education and related services as a student with an other health impairment?
A child with attention deficit disorder is eligible for special education if the disorder adversely affects the child’s educational performance and the child otherwise meets the eligibility criteria for serious emotional disturbance (SED), OHI, or SLD. Cal. Educ. Code § 56339. A student qualifies for special education as OHI based on ADD if the disorder causes the student to have limited strength, vitality or alertness and adversely affects the student’s educational performance. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(f). As with all eligibility categories, the child’s impairment must require instruction, services, or both, which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Cal Educ. Code § 56026(b).
STUDENT’s fourth grade teacher, Ms. Dennis, testified that STUDENT at times needed to be refocused on her work. School psychologist Susan Jordan also described some attention issues that were evident from the assessment process, including some lack of focus and weak organizational skills. The science teacher, Mr. Rota, also noted some problems with organization. Ms. Atkins believed that an attention deficit could have at least been a factor contributing to STUDENT’s auditory perception problems. It was not clear from the evidence whether STUDENT’s difficulties with attention and organization were due to the seizure disorder, an attention deficit disorder, or something else. Nor could the Hearing Officer determine from the evidence whether the seizure disorder, the attention deficit disorder or a combination of the two actually caused STUDENT to have limited strength, vitality or alertness. However, as indicated in the discussion of issue one, above, the evidence persuaded the Hearing Officer that STUDENT did not require special education to meet her educational needs. Her needs could be met with appropriate accommodations in the regular education environment.
Issue No. 3: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and mileage costs of Petitioner’s attendance at The Winston School from March 2002 to the present?
The Hearing Officer has already found that the District correctly determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. Therefore, her parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and mileage costs of STUDENT’s attendance at Winston from March 2002 to the present.
Issue No. 4: Should the District be required to fund Petitioner’s continued placement at The Winston School through the end of the current school year?
The Hearing Officer has already found that the District correctly determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. Therefore, the District is not required to fund STUDENT’s attendance at Winston for the remainder of the current school year.
Issue No. 5: Should the District be required to fund Petitioner’s vision therapy?
The Hearing Officer has already found that the District correctly determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. Therefore, the District is not required to fund STUDENT’s vision therapy.
ORDER
All of the Petitioner’s claims to relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
The District prevailed on all issues.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: March 28, 2003 Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues are not listed specifically as stated on the first day of hearing. They have been organized by the Hearing Officer for the purposes of adjudication. 2. The progress report format changed slightly. Letter grades were given for general academic areas. STUDENT received A’s and B’s in all areas for all reporting periods, except a D+ in spelling for the third trimester only. 3. There was evidence that STUDENT eventually began medication, first Adderall and later Concerta, for the attention problem, but there was no evidence regarding the actual diagnosis. 4. There is a statement in the November 9, 2000 progress report to the effect that the SST process had actually begun by that date, long before Dr. Gleeson’s diagnosis.
5. All content clusters were average or above average except two math clusters (estimation and problem solving strategies). STUDENT performed in the average and above average range on those two math clusters the prior year. 6. Susan Jordan corrected the scores during her testimony because errors were found in the original scoring. 7. STUDENT’s scores in these areas of relative weakness were in the average and low average ranges. None were below average.
8. The Petitioner made it clear at the due process hearing that she was not seeking reimbursement for the independent assessments under Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). 9. Dr. Markel administered Form B of the WJ-III. The Hearing Officer does not know what form of the test the District had administered just a few months earlier. He would have expected the later scores to be at least comparable if the District had used Form A, and noticeably higher as a result of practice effect if it had used Form B. 10. The Petitioner has not received this service and seeks no prospective funding for it. 11. Dr. Markel testified that the corrected performance I.Q. from the District’s WISC-III should have been 108, which is nineteen points lower than the verbal I.Q. 12. Dr. Markel also used the WJ-III.
13. The “applied problems” subtest measures math reasoning skills. 14. The District’s assessment data suggests that fluency is a principal area of weakness for STUDENT.
15. The testimony of the Petitioner’s various expert witnesses identifying attention deficit, visual processing, and auditory processing disorders was essentially unchallenged by the District. 16. The only clear exception was STUDENT’s math procedures score at the twelfth percentile on the third grade SAT-9. But in the prior and subsequent years, she scored in the seventy-third percentile and the seventy-first percentile, respectively, in math procedures.
17. Both parties cited the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals opinion affirming, in relevant part, the Hearing Office decision in Student v. Orinda. Since that opinion is not published, the Hearing Officer referred to the underlying decision by the hearing officer.
