California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 31, 2003
Student v. Kern High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 369-03, SN-369-03 · Hearing Officer Tracy L. Tibbals
Kern High School District must provide up to 100 hours of assistive technology training; diploma upheld and other IEP claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A Kern High School District student with a specific learning disability (auditory processing disorder and dyslexia) filed for due process in February 2003, during his senior year. He took general education and college preparatory classes with resource specialist program (RSP) support, a scribe, retesting, and notice to his parents of low grades. He challenged his IEPs for 10th through 12th grade over present levels, goals, how accommodations were described, and assistive technology. He also claimed the District gave him a diploma in June 2003 without notice.
The Hearing Officer found the 2000-2001 claims had been resolved by an earlier compliance complaint settlement. For 2001-2002 and 2002-2003, the IEPs had adequate present levels, measurable goals suited to general education classes, and clearly described accommodations. The assistive technology training failed, however. The District hired ARRC Technologies, the only vendor that responded, without checking whether it could teach a student with his disabilities. Laptops often broke, software was missing, and no training took place in his senior year. That denied FAPE in both years.
The diploma claim failed. For years the IEPs listed a June 2003 graduation and a college goal, and the family followed that plan. Teachers testified that he earned his grades. The District must hold an IEP meeting, have a qualified assessor evaluate his laptop skills, and provide up to 100 hours of training with loaned equipment. Reimbursement was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO awarded compensatory education after a student graduated. Assistive technology had been promised but was never usefully delivered. The Hearing Officer held that hiring a vendor without checking whether it fits the student's disability can deny FAPE. Notice of graduation was satisfied by years of IEPs stating the planned graduation date.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1A. Did the District deny FAPE because the IEPs lacked detailed goals and objectives, did not list present levels of performance, did not adequately describe accommodations or changes to them, and did not provide appropriate assistive technology for the 2000-2001 school year?
All 2000-2001 claims had already been resolved by the voluntary settlement of the parents' compliance complaint, and no persuasive evidence showed the agreed remedies were inadequate.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 1B. Same question for the 2001-2002 school year.
Present levels, measurable goals and accommodations were adequate, but the ARRC assistive technology training was not designed for his needs, was not reasonably calculated to provide benefit, and was not implemented as the IEPs required (broken laptops, missing software), so FAPE was denied as to assistive technology.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 1C. Same question for the 2002-2003 school year.
The rest of the program was appropriate, but assistive technology training stalled, no training was given, and a working laptop was not provided until after winter break, which denied FAPE as to assistive technology.
- District prevailedTransition
Issue 2. Did the District improperly award the Petitioner a high school diploma without notice to his parents as required by 34 C.F.R. section 300.503?
For four years the IEPs and transition plans gave written notice of a June 2003 graduation and college goal, the family acted on that plan, and he earned his grades, so the diploma was properly awarded; a stay put argument first raised in the closing brief was moot.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education as a remedy?
Compensatory assistive technology assessment and up to 100 hours of training were awarded even though he had graduated; reimbursement of out-of-pocket expenses was denied for lack of proof.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to locate and retain an appropriate assistive technology vendor or qualified District employee, taking into account the student's specific learning disabilities.
- Order to assess. The designated assessor must assess the student's proficiency and needs in using a laptop computer, finishing within 14 calendar days after being designated.
- Compensatory education. Assistive technology training in the hours the assessor sets, up to 100 hours, on the hardware and software that will help with community college coursework. The training must be finished within 120 calendar days of the decision unless the parties agree otherwise.
- The District must provide the hardware and software the assessor designates. The equipment, with software installed, is returned to the District when training ends.
- Reimbursement of out-of-pocket expenses was denied, as was rescinding the diploma. All other requests for relief were denied.
Total: 100 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Gregory K. v. Longview; Burlington; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Student W. v. Puyallup; 34 C.F.R. § 300.503; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345
People named in the decision
- Ron (Ronald) Sheppard, advocate for Student (witness)
- Linda P. Reither, private reading specialist/assessor (parent-chosen, witness for Student)
- Adie Geiser, technology specialist (witness for Student)
- Sharyn Eveland, psychologist (witness for Student)
- John Ferguson, special education administrator, Kern High School District
- Diane Galloway, school psychologist, Kern High School District
- Chad Provensal, U.S. history teacher, Kern High School District
- Steven Cabalka, health teacher, Kern High School District
- Carl Heasley, earth science teacher, Kern High School District
- Jim McCubbin, economics teacher, Kern High School District
- Jennifer Payne, government/English teacher, Kern High School District
- Ryan Geivert, biology teacher, Kern High School District
- David Ziegler, English teacher, Kern High School District
- Patricia Ford, English teacher, Kern High School District
- Megan Williams, English teacher, Kern High School District
- Elizabeth Landeros, resource aide, Kern High School District
- Tiffany Giffin, instructional aide / scribe, Kern High School District
- ARRC Technologies, assistive technology training vendor (nonpublic provider)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), of the University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Bakersfield, California, on September 9, 10, 11, 12, 16, 17, 18, 19, and 23, 2003.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Donnalee H. Huffman. Also present on the Petitioner’s behalf were his parents, FATHER (Footnote 1) and MOTHER. The Kern High School District (District or Respondent) was represented at the hearing by attorney Alan B. Harris. Also present on behalf of the District were John Ferguson, administrator for special education, and Diane Galloway, school psychologist.
Petitioner called as witnesses himself, his parents, advocate Ron Sheppard, reading specialist Linda P. Reither, technology specialist Adie Geiser, and psychologist Sharyn Eveland. The District called District special education administrator Ferguson, psychologist Galloway, U.S. history teacher Chad Provensal, health teacher Steven Cabalka, earth science teacher Carl Heasley, economics teacher Jim McCubbin, government teacher Jennifer Payne, biology teacher Ryan Geivert, English teachers David Ziegler, Patricia Ford, and Megan Williams, resource aide Elizabeth Landeros, and instructional aide Tiffany Giffin.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the receipt of written closing briefs. After receipt of the briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING (Footnote 2)
1 Did the Respondent fail to provide to the Petitioner a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) because of deficient individualized education programs (IEPs) that did not include detailed goals and objectives, that did not list present levels of performance, that did not adequately describe the Petitioner’s accommodations or changes to his accommodations, and that did not provide appropriate assistive technology:
A. For the 2000-2001 school year?
B. For the 2001-2002 school year?
B. For the 2002-2003 school year?
2. Did the Respondent District improperly award the Petitioner a high school diploma without notice to his parents as required by 34 C.F.R. section 300.503?
3. Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education as a remedy?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner is an eighteen-year-old adult residing with his parents and two siblings within the boundaries of the District. (Footnote 3) He received his high school diploma from the District during commencement ceremonies in June 2003. STUDENT enrolled at Taft Community College in August 2003.
STUDENT was first determined eligible for special education services in the first grade under the disabling condition of a specific learning disability. STUDENT has been diagnosed with an auditory processing disorder and dyslexia. As a result, he needs extra time to understand and process what he hears. He learns best if auditory lessons are reinforced with visual presentations. Sequencing is challenging for him, making multistep processes difficult. He can become fatigued and frustrated after extended studying. Because of his disabilities, STUDENT has deficits in the areas of mathematics, reading, spelling, and written language.
STUDENT was enrolled in the District for all four years of high school. The District participated in his transitional IEP meeting at the end of his eighth grade year in May 1999 (Petitioner’s Exhibit B). The IEP team noted that his cognitive ability tested well within the average range with a discrepancy between ability and achievement. The May 1999 IEP also reflected that STUDENT had a “positive attitude,” that he “actively” participated in class activities, that he turned in his work “on a regular basis,” and that his emotional and behavioral state did not significantly affect his academics or peer relationships. The May 1999 IEP team considered the assessment of Fresno reading specialist Linda P. Reither, whose services were requested by STUDENT’s parents. The District agreed to use her assessment (Respondent’s Exhibit 4) and paid for her services. The team also reviewed favorably the recommendations of both Ms. Reither and advocate Sheppard for an assistive technology assessment and consideration of a laptop computer and fundamental computer training to allow STUDENT to function in the regular education setting.
The first IEP team session convened by the District was on June 28, 1999 (Petitioner’s Exhibit C). The initial offer by the District for STUDENT’s ninth grade year included a special day class for math, language arts, and social skills. FATHER and MOTHER did not agree with this placement suggestion. At this meeting, MOTHER also requested that the District provide STUDENT a laptop computer for home and school use. At the August 18, 1999 follow-up IEP meeting (Petitioner’s Exhibit C), the team considered the parents’ disagreement with the special day class placement. The resulting offer, accepted by FATHER and MOTHER, placed STUDENT in the resource specialist program (RSP) for mathematics and for support of a combination of general education and college preparatory classes. The teachers were to notify the parents if STUDENT received a “D” on an assignment. For math, an area that was particularly challenging for STUDENT, instruction was to be in the RSP classroom. The District members of the team also assented to the parents’ request that STUDENT receive from the District a laptop computer with specific software to aid in written work, a tape recorder, calculator, books on tape, and expedited training on the computer software.
In anticipation of STUDENT’s sophomore year, the IEP team convened on June 5, 2000 (Petitioner’s Exhibit D). In addition to continuing with the RSP classes to provide for his math studies as well as to provide support for his regular program classes, the team approved a scribe, or note taker, for three hours each school day. A provision in this IEP also indicated that the parents “demand” to be notified of any grade below a “C.” This June 2000 IEP contained a handwritten entry of “2003, June” in the blank space after the preprinted text “anticipated graduation date.” Immediately following the date entered on this form was the preprinted sentence, “Upon graduation with a regular high school diploma, no further services will be offered by the Kern High School District.” The IEP referred to math goals that would be drafted and sent home to the parents by August 18, 2000. STUDENT’s parents declined to sign the June 2000 IEP until the goals were completed. The copy of this IEP in evidence has math goals dated September 7, 2000, attached but does not include a signature page.
The IEP team reconvened on November 29, 2000 (Petitioner’s Exhibit E). The notation “wants to attend college” appears both in the “Student Strengths” and “Student Interests, Preferences and Needs” sections under the “parent and student provided data” heading. This notation reappears on most of the subsequent IEPs. At this meeting, the team increased the time STUDENT’s scribe was available to four hours per day. The IEP notes provided for computer training for STUDENT and the scribe on Dragon Dictate, Inspiration, and Mavis Beacon Learns to Type. These notes also restated that the parents would be contacted by telephone or email if STUDENT received a grade below “C” on a test or assignment. Testing or retesting was to be completed within forty-eight hours. The IEP team agreed to meet again in January 2001 to complete present performance levels, goals, objectives, and transition needs.
At the January 9, 2001 IEP meeting, the team reviewed STUDENT’s scores on the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTEA) administered four days before (Petitioner’s Exhibit F). His composite scores reflected grade equivalents of 4.0 in mathematics, 7.1 in reading, and 2.9 in spelling. The reading scores making up the composite were a grade equivalent of 5.1 in decoding and a level of 9.7 in comprehension.
Toward the end of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT’s parents filed a compliance complaint against the District contesting the adequacy of goals and objectives, parental notification of below “C” grades, retesting procedures, and the extent of the assistive technology provided (Petitioner’s Exhibit Z). In an addendum to the January 2001 IEP, dated May 1, 2001 (Petitioner’s Exhibit G), the notes documented the compliance complaint issues as “parent concerns regarding implementation of IEP,” including the following: (1) Failure to retest after every test, (2) Failure of notification to parent of test scores below C, (3) Failure to notify parent of computer literacy training program, (4) Failure to provide goals and objectives specific to scribe responsibilities, regular teacher communications procedures and accommodations, (5) Technical assistance promised in previous IEP not implemented per parent satisfaction. The “Transition Planning Data” form attached to the May 1, 2001 IEP identifies STUDENT’s current course of study to be “College Prep” and “General Education.” Checked under “Projected Adult Living and Working Environments” were “Competitive Employment,” “College University,” “Community College,” and “Vocational Training.”
At the June 18, 2001 IEP meeting (Petitioner’s Exhibit H), the team considered STUDENT’s program for his junior year and the terms of the settlement of the compliance complaint. The transition data attached to the IEP modified the previous entries. Only “College Prep” was checked as his current course of study and “Vocational Training” was no longer indicated but check marks still appeared next to “College University” and “ Community College.” Also noted on this transition planning form was that “STUDENT wants to attend college,” that no need exists for designated instructional services or daily living skills training, and that STUDENT would “take classes leading to graduation.” The June 18, 2001 IEP also included goals and objectives for developing his computer skills.
The seven pages of notes attached to this IEP dealt with a wide range of topics. Biology teacher Ryan Geivet described to the IEP team STUDENT’s progress in his class during the previous year. Mr. Geivet described STUDENT’s performance on his “very hard essay tests.” Mr. Geivet used them to find out what the student had learned and to see “their thought process.” He determined from STUDENT’s performance on the tests that he knew the concepts but that he was not good in writing down the information in this format. Mr. Geivet told the IEP team, however, that STUDENT’s ability to write showed a “tremendous increase” during the previous school year. Mr. Geivet found that STUDENT was prepared, worked hard, was able to do well in his class, benefitted from the assignments, and that “It was obvious he studied.”
The June 2001 IEP meeting considered the compliance complaint issue of testing. After discussions of testing and grading procedures, the team prescribed retesting for grades of “D” or “F” and return of grades on work within five school days and notice to the parents within seven school days by telephone, email, or mail. The meeting notes also indicated the parents’ concern that with respect to assistive technology “two years have been lost.” The notes also show that during this meeting the parties resolved the assistive technology aspect of the parents’ compliance complaint against the District. The District arranged for computer training for STUDENT through an outside vendor, ARRC Technologies (ARRC), as compensatory education.
The IEP team met again on August 24, 2001 (Petitioner’s Exhibit I), to deal with STUDENT’s placement for the 2001-2002 school year and the remaining compliance complaint matters such as goals and objectives and related issues deferred from the June 2001 session. Included in this IEP was the written monitoring procedure for parent notification of grades less than “C” and provisions for retesting that placed the responsibility on STUDENT to make arrangements for the retest. Following up on the assistive technology program approved at the prior IEP meeting, the team contemplated that after the ARRC training was completed, “Periodic review” will continue “until expected graduation” to see if “STUDENT has reached a functional level of competency.” The IEP team also approved as part of STUDENT’s class schedule two days a week off-campus for the ARRC computer training as “compensatory services for the freshman and sophomore years.”
The IEP team reconvened on April 11, 2002, for the annual review to consider STUDENT’s schedule for his senior year, concerns about incorporating the assistive technology into his class work, and goals (Petitioner’s Exhibit K). A representative from the computer training vendor ARRC attended the meeting along with STUDENT’s U.S. history teacher, Mr. Chad Provensal. The team also reviewed STUDENT’s present levels of performance, as shown on a recent KTEA administration, and draft goals and objectives.
The April 11 meeting continued on April 19, 2002, with STUDENT present to discuss the transition plan and receive the notice of transfer of educational rights on his eighteenth birthday in May 2003 (Petitioner’s Exhibit L). Also attending this session were STUDENT’s U.S. history teacher Mr. Provensal, English teacher, Mr. David Ziegler, and science teacher, Mr. Carl Heasley. The team considered goals and objectives. STUDENT and MOTHER indicated disagreement next to their signatures to this IEP. MOTHER indicated that this was because of the claimed inadequacy of the goals and objectives.
At the October 14, 2002 IEP meeting, a further continuation of the annual review from the preceding April meetings, MOTHER discussed STUDENT’s transition to community college (Petitioner’s Exhibit M). During this session, STUDENT’s English teacher, Ms. Jennifer Payne, and his scribe, Ms. Tiffany Giffin, attended to provide progress updates. Ms. Payne reported that he was doing well in her class and discussed her course of study, which included Hamlet, Brave New World, Pygmalion, and Pride and Prejudice. The team also received updated levels of performance in mathematics, reading, and writing from teacher observations. This IEP included mathematics, English, and economics goals. These were accepted by the team, including MOTHER.
MOTHER told the IEP team on December 18, 2002, about problems STUDENT was having with the laptop and the software (Petitioner’s Exhibit N). The District offered a new laptop, to be available after the holidays. MOTHER acknowledged that ARRC had been originally authorized 144 hours, but stated that the results were not satisfactory. She requested one hundred additional hours. During this team meeting, advocate Sheppard described the Bakersfield College and De Anza College computer centers for training after graduation. MOTHER requested reinitiation of test/retest procedure for grades below a “C,” reporting that there had been a lack of notification when this situation arose, contrary to the procedures adopted at the August 2001 IEP meeting.
A recurrent theme during STUDENT’s high school years was his reluctance to “stand out.” Although several of his teachers indicated that they would have had no objection to STUDENT’s bringing his laptop to class, STUDENT chose not to do so. STUDENT’s scribes always sat away from him in class and never interacted with him in front of his classmates. STUDENT had a record of up to two tardies per week to his RSP class. Ms. Giffin, STUDENT’s scribe, explained that this was so that his peers would not see him going into a special education classroom.
The Petitioner filed this request for due process hearing in February 2003 alleging that the District did not provide the computer training compensatory education as planned and did not follow the agreed parent notification and retesting provisions. Efforts to mediate the disputes were unsuccessful and the matter went to hearing in September 2003.
In the meantime, STUDENT completed the requirements for his high school diploma in June 2003. In August 2003, he enrolled at Taft Community College. He is now pursuing a program with accommodations and modifications similar to those provided by the District.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide a FAPE for his tenth, eleventh and twelfth grade years. He alleges that present levels of performance were not adequately recorded. The Petitioner claims deficient goals and objectives in his IEPs, which he claims are vague, general, and not specific as to him. The Petitioner also alleges that accommodations such as providing a scribe and retesting are not specific enough and were changed without documentation. The Petitioner further asserts that the assistive technology program was inadequate and that the District did not provide the computer equipment and training during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years called for in the settlement of the Petitioner’s compliance complaint to the California Department of Education. The Petitioner is seeking compensatory education for these alleged deficiencies as well as out-of-pocket expenses paid prior to the due process hearing.
The District asserts that the IEPs adequately outlined the Petitioner’s program of general education and college preparatory classes. This was done through goals and objectives and supporting data with RSP support and accommodations that met his unique needs and provided educational benefit. The District further claims that it went beyond the terms of the settlement of the compliance complaint with regard to computer equipment and training. The District maintains that the Petitioner successfully completed his high school program and that no compensatory education is necessary.
The Petitioner further asserts that the District did not notify his parents of his impending high school graduation in June 2003 in violation of the legal requirements that parents must know in advance of a change in placement of a special education student. Additionally, the Petitioner now contends that the award of his diploma was a change of placement in violation of the automatic stay put provisions of the law as the due process request predates the graduation. The Petitioner is seeking to have his diploma rescinded.
The District counters that the Petitioner was on a graduation and college preparatory track since his entry into the District in his freshman year and that the goal of high school graduation and pursuit of college afterwards was repeatedly documented on his IEPs starting before the beginning of his freshman year.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue Number 1: Did the Respondent fail to provide to the Petitioner a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) because of deficient individualized education programs (IEPs) that did not include detailed goals and objectives, that did not list present levels of performance, that did not adequately describe the Petitioner’s accommodations or changes to his accommodations, and that did not provide appropriate assistive technology:
A. For the 2000-2001 school year?
B. For the 2001-2002 school year?
C. For the 2002-2003 school year?
The District is obligated to provide a FAPE to STUDENT to meet his unique needs under the provisions of the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law. 20 U.S.C. §1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §56000.
This free and appropriate education includes special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency, including appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)
“Special education” is specially designed instruction without cost to parents that meets the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” include transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a student to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z). State law provides for similar services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).
The IEP setting forth the special education program must contain, inter alia:
(1) Present levels of the pupil’s educational performance;
(2) Measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, directed toward “meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability;”
(3) The specific special educational instruction and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided;
(4) The anticipated frequency, location, and duration of those services;
(5) Appropriate objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, on at least an annual basis, whether the annual goals are being achieved;
(6) A statement how the pupil’s progress toward the annual goals will be measured;
(7) A statement how the pupil’s parents will be regularly informed, at least as frequently as parents are informed of their nondisabled pupil’s progress, the pupil’s progress toward the annual goals and the extent to which that progress is sufficient to enable the pupil to achieve the goals by the end of the year.
Cal. Educ. Code § 56345 (a)(1); (2)(A),(B); (3); (6); (7); (9); (10)(A),(B).
Parent involvement in the IEP process is more that a mere formality. It is a vital aspect of the process. The IDEA at 20 U.S.C. Section 1415(b)(1) confers on parents the right “to participate in meetings with respect to the identification, evaluation, and educational placement of the child, and the provision of a free appropriate public education.” The importance of these procedural safeguards “cannot be gainsaid.” Parents are to have a “large measure of participation” at every step. Board of Educ. Of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205-206. The case law and statutory mandate for parental involvement is to ensure that the interests of the child are protected. The IDEA contemplates that following procedural requirements would assure in most cases what the act prescribed for the substantive content of the IEP. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205-208. Every procedural misstep, however, does not necessarily result in a denial of FAPE. It requires serious infringement of the parent’s opportunity to participate on the IEP team or loss of educational opportunity to the pupil. W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 , 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).
The standard which the District’s instruction and services must meet to provide STUDENT a FAPE, his IEP must be designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 198-200. This United States Supreme Court decision does not require the District to provide to the student the best education available or to provide instruction that maximizes his abilities. STUDENT is entitled to have access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet his unique needs and to provide educational benefit as a “basic floor of opportunity.”
An appropriate public education does not require the absolute best or a “potential maximizing” program for the student. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F. 3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). The standard for the school district is whether the proposed placement is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student, not whether the student may obtain a greater benefit from a placement preferred by the parents. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). De minimis benefit or trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to meet the Rowley mandate of “some benefit.” Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998). The student’s academic progress must also be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his disability and must be gauged in relation to the student’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).
The Petitioner has challenged the sufficiency of the IEPs for each of his last three years in the District. The Petitioner’s expressed concerns are limited to the goals and objectives, the documenting of performance levels, description of his accommodations, and assistive technology.
A. 2000-2001 school year.
Before analyzing the District’s IEPs, STUDENT’s needs must be determined. What are STUDENT’s unique needs?
STUDENT came into the District as previously qualifying for special education services with a specific learning disability. The parties agree that because of an auditory processing disorder and dyslexia, he needs additional time to comprehend what he hears. Further impacts of these conditions are difficulty with multistep processes, sequencing, and retrieving information. His documented deficiencies in mathematics, reading, and writing result from these specific learning disabilities. Without controversy in this proceeding, STUDENT’s needs include additional time to do assignments including retaking tests when not meeting a minimum standard, individualized work in mathematics, assistance in note taking, and technology to ease the burden of reading and writing and reduce fatigue and frustration. STUDENT’s needs remained constant during the years in question.
The 2000-2001 school year
STUDENT was in the tenth grade during the 2000-2001 school year. Petitioner’s Exhibit Z includes the terms of the settlement of his compliance complaint with the District filed toward the end of that school year. This exhibit includes the letter of October 24, 2001, from the District to the California Department of Education. It states that the parties settled on what would be “Required Corrective Actions.” The five “actions” listed deal with clarifying goals and objectives, providing computer training and software, a monitoring procedure for notice to Petitioner’s parents of grades less that a “C,” a monitoring procedure for allowing retests in instances when the Petitioner obtains below a “C” on the original test, and a District in-service training “emphasizing the importance of the IEP implementation.” The evidence establishes that this was the agreement reached between the District and the Petitioner to settle the issues raised in his compliance complaint filed during the 2000-2001 school year. The issues asserted in the compliance complaint were addressed at the May 1, 2001 IEP meeting (Petitioner’s Exhibit G). Goals and objectives were reviewed at the June 18, 2001 IEP meeting (Petitioner’s Exhibit H). Specific “Monitoring Procedures for STUDENT ” dealing with parent notification and retesting procedures were accepted and signed off by the District and MOTHER at the August 24, 2001 IEP meeting along with the clarified goals and objectives (Petitioner’s Exhibit I). The ARRC training was expressly compensatory education for both the 1999-2000 and the 2000-2001 school years. The parties have already addressed the Petitioner’s issues with regard to the 2000-2001 school year and have reached an accord that the evidence indicates was voluntary, freely entered into, and discussed between the parties at several IEP meetings with the assistance of an advocate and the Department of Education compliance officer. There was no persuasive evidence at the hearing that the agreed remedies were inadequate. The Hearing Officer finds all issues raised in this proceeding with respect to this year have been resolved. B. The 2001-2002 school year.
Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs
The record is clear that without controversy STUDENT’s needs remained constant into the 2001-2002 school year. The IEPs for the 2001-2002 school year provided RSP class time for mathematics, study skills, additional time to do work, retesting, and general support. The IEPs also included assistive technology including computer training. The IEPs placed STUDENT in three regular education classes per day with the RSP classes, computer training and accommodations to allow him to succeed in the general education and college preparatory curriculum. The first IEP meeting of the 2001-2002 school year was on August 24, 2001 (Petitioner’s Exhibit I). The scribe was to continue “in classes where needed.” STUDENT was also excused to leave school two days a week for the computer training through outside vendor ARRC in his home. Attached to this IEP were specific mathematics goals and objectives focusing on the Saxon program. (Footnote 4) Goals for use of the computer bearing dates of the June 2001 IEP were also included. Additional goals for passing the regular education classes and participating the Liberty High School “Accelerated Reader” program followed on January 23, 2002 (Petitioner’s Exhibit J).
The next IEP meeting for an annual review occurred on April 11, 2002 (Petitioner’s Exhibit K). This IEP included STUDENT’s present levels of performance from an April 2, 2002, administration of the brief form KTEA. At this time, STUDENT showed progress to a grade equivalent of 5.6 in mathematics, 9.4 in reading, and 3.7 in writing. Also attached were goals and objectives to pass the regular education classes and continue to participate in the Accelerated Reader program. The April 11 IEP meeting was continued on April 19, 2002, at which time additional goals and objectives were presented for STUDENT’s mathematics program and regular classes (Petitioner’s Exhibit L). STUDENT attended this session to discuss his transition plan.
First, the Petitioner alleged that present levels of performance were absent from the IEPs. STUDENT’s present levels of performance, however, are shown in the June 18, 2001 IEP (Petitioner’s Exhibit H), where the January 5, 2001 KTEA results are shown, and in the April 11, 2002 IEP (Petitioner’s Exhibit K) where the April 2002 KTEA results appear. Teacher observations also follow the KTEA results. Additionally, STUDENT’s teachers reported to the IEP team from time to time on his classroom performance. The Hearing Officer, therefore, concludes that the Petitioner’s present levels of performance are adequately disclosed in the IEPs for this school year.
Second, the Petitioner’s position during the hearing and in his written argument is that the goals and objectives were not individualized for STUDENT and were not capable of measurement. This argument overlooks that STUDENT was placed in regular education classes. It is common for students in general education classes to have the same or similar goals to meet the standards of the class. FATHER and MOTHER particularly requested general education classes for STUDENT. They had expressly asked that the originally suggested placement of STUDENT in a special day class in his freshman year be abandoned in favor of mainstreaming in the core academic classes with accommodations that would permit STUDENT to succeed. A review of the goals and objectives for this year establishes that they are straightforward and comprehensible. They also are capable of assessment. The goals and objectives contained in Petitioner Exhibit K set a standard (e.g. “By the end of the end of the 2001-2002 school year, given a list of vocabulary and culture words STUDENT will demonstrate mastery of spelling words and the definitions of given words”) and have a standard of measurement (e.g.“as measured by a minimum of 75% accuracy on vocabulary and spelling tests”). It is concluded that the goals and objectives were appropriate for STUDENT as a student in general education classes and the goals and objectives were measurable.
The Petitioner also faults the provisions in the IEPs for the accommodations. The accommodations, however, are spelled out in detail. For example, STUDENT is provided a scribe to assist in note taking “in classes where needed” (Petitioner’s Exhibit I). The Petitioner in his written argument decries the lack of goals for the scribe. The scribe, however, is an accommodation to aid STUDENT to meet his goals. The IEPs sufficiently define how and for how much time the scribe will function. As to the other accommodations and changes to them, “Monitoring Procedures” for notice to parents and retesting is set forth in detail and signed off by the District and STUDENT’s parents (Petitioner’s Exhibit I). The testimony from some of his teachers indicates that STUDENT did not always retake tests that he could have retaken and simply failed to turn in some assignments. This suggests some of the communication breakdown in the retesting program was between parents and son and not always between parent and District. Therefore, it is concluded that the IEPs provided for class work and accommodations that addressed STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the support of the RSP classes, and accommodations delineated in the IEPs clearly addressed STUDENT’s needs for extra time and assistance to process his class material in his combination of general education classes, college preparatory classes.
The Petitioner’s remaining contention relates to the assistive technology training that was to be provided as a result of the settlement of Petitioner’s compliance complaint. The Petitioner contends that the equipment he received from the District was often not working and that he did not get the software that he needed. He further alleges that there was no effective or consistent integration of the assistive technology into his class work. The Petitioner also argues that the ARRC instructors were not qualified as teachers and had no training in working with a student with a learning disability. The evidence indicates that during the August 2001 IEP meeting, Mr. Ferguson made the effort to locate an appropriate provider of assistive technology training to meet the settlement terms. He located and contacted three companies in the local area, but only ARRC responded. Although there is evidence that during STUDENT’s freshman year he did receive some training from a District teacher, as of August 2001, the District apparently did not choose to go with its own staff. The District contracted with ARRC to do the training. ARRC was to determine an appropriate regimen and came up with the proposal to provide 144 hours to STUDENT at home. A manifestation of STUDENT’s handicap is that he has difficulty in sequencing and multistep tasks. He, himself, said that he had “trouble remembering things.” District psychologist Diane Galloway testified that STUDENT’s problems with computers predictably followed those with mathematics or spelling where multistep tasks are encountered. There is no indication, however, that ARRC instructors had any particular qualifications to teach STUDENT, especially in light of his disabilities. The record suggests that ARRC was chosen as it was the only vendor available. There is no indication that ARRC’s qualifications received even a cursory review to determine how ARRC’s services could meet the needs of a young man with auditory processing difficulties that made multistep tasks such as operating a computer arduous. The background record, however, shows that assistive technology was a focus going back to the original IEP in April 1999. Assessor Linda Reither and advocate Ronald Sheppard stressed the importance of assistive technology to meet STUDENT’s needs from the very beginning to assist him in the regular curriculum and prepare him for college. The assistive technology was to aid STUDENT in the completion of his regular education program and prepare him to meet the demands of college. The record does not show how the ARRC program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in any respect. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the ARRC program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit?
STUDENT’s grades and standardized tests showed that he was continuing to make progress. Although he was receiving some educational benefit from his classes, the assistive technology component was problematic. The evidence shows STUDENT acquired only minimal computer skills. He could play video games, but the record indicates only on one or two occasions that he used his computer for his assignments. The record does include the statement in the April 19, 2002 IEP (Petitioner’s Exhibit L) that “STUDENT reports computer training from ARRC Technologies has been very helpful to him.” This statement, however, is without any explanation or context and is contrary to the testimony. The evidence is devoid of any objective validation or correlation to STUDENT’s educational progress. The District, however, allowed ARRC unilaterally to design a program that may not even be calculated to provide some educational benefit to a normally developing high school student, much less to STUDENT with his own particular needs. The Hearing Officer concludes that although STUDENT was progressing in his classes, the ARRC program was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit.
Conformed to STUDENT’s IEP?
During 2001-2002 there continued to be parental issues raised at IEP meetings with regard to the methods of notification to the parents of substandard test grades and the assistive technology. For this year as well the record shows regular communication between the District and the Petitioner’s parents (Petitioner’s Exhibit S; Respondent’s Exhibits 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, and 26). (Footnote 5) STUDENT remained in his RSP and general education classes with the indicated accommodations. These provisions provided by the District substantially conformed to the IEPs for the 2001-2002 school year. The IEPs do include the ARRC services. The record establishes that ARRC did provide the 144 hours of time with STUDENT that was a result of the settlement of the compliance complaint. The District does not offer any contrary evidence to the Petitioner’s assertions that the laptop was frequently not operating, or the specific software programs were not provided as indicated in the IEPs. MOTHER testified that much of the time STUDENT and ARRC instructors would spend was playing computer games, at least partially because the District-provided equipment was not working. She also testified to a continuing frustration not only with equipment failures, but such things as parental permission cards to allow internet access repeatedly misplaced by the District, missing or delayed delivery of necessary access codes for some of the programs, and software that was either not provided as agreed or not replaced when laptops were exchanged. Although it is concluded that STUDENT’s classes and accommodations conformed to the IEPs, the Hearing Officer finds that provisions for assistive technology did not.
Did STUDENT receive a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?
Most of STUDENT’s program was designed to meet his needs, was reasonably calculated to confer some educational benefit, and did conform to the IEPs. However, because of the extent the ARRC program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was not reasonably calculated to provide to him a benefit, and did not conform to his IEPs, the Hearing Officer finds that this compensatory education program provided by the District denied STUDENT a FAPE.
C. The 2002-2003 school year.
Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs
In his senior year, STUDENT’s needs remained the same, as did the District’s offer to meet those needs. The Petitioner contends for this year as well that the IEPs did not state present levels of performance, lacked specific goals and objectives, failed to specify the terms or changes in the accommodations, and did not provide adequate assistive technology compensatory education.
The first IEP meeting of his twelfth grade year took place on October 14, 2002 (Petitioner’s Exhibit M). His present levels of performance reported by teacher observations as of October 2002 are set forth. In reading, the performance level stated is that “given a passage, STUDENT can comprehend literal and inferential information presented at a 8th/9th grade level.” The teacher testimony is that his level of competency is sufficient to master the textbook materials in his classes. The notes record MOTHER expressing STUDENT’s desire to be more independent from his scribe and discussing transition to community college. STUDENT’s English teacher, Ms. Jennifer Payne, reported to the IEP team that STUDENT had scored eighty-seven per cent on a recent test and outlined the class projects and works that would be studied. The notes also report that the computer technician describes STUDENT’s computer as “up and running.”
The “parent request” IEP meeting of December 18, 2002, was the last held in STUDENT’s high school career (Petitioner’s Exhibit N). The December 2002 IEP included goals and objectives similar to previous ones, progress reports from some of his classes, and continuation of the RSP, regular classroom placements, and accommodations.
The two IEPs during his final year in the District restated STUDENT’s processing problem and noted his deficits. RSP classes, regular education classes including college preparatory classes, and accommodations such as a scribe, parental notice for grades less than “C,” and retesting were continued to meet these needs. The computer training, however, was stalled. The IEPs show that MOTHER was still raising concerns about equipment failure and the need for more instruction as STUDENT was still unable to use the assistive technology in his school work to any significant degree. Although there is documented in the IEPs for the 2002-2003 school year negotiations between the District and the parent for more ARRC training, no agreement arose and no more training occurred. Even if more ARRC training had been provided, however, there is no indication in the record that it would have had any more relevance to STUDENT’s unique needs than the training during the 2001-2002 school year. Consequently, the assistive technology component of STUDENT’s program was not designed to meet his unique needs.
Reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit?
The team saw no reason to vary the IEP program. STUDENT was on track for graduation and was passing all of his classes. The program was providing a benefit to STUDENT with the exception of the assistive technology component. MOTHER reported in the fall of 2002 that STUDENT still had not yet mastered the basic computer skills. She also stated that he did not get some of the software indicated originally. Furthermore, there was a recurring problem with computer malfunctioning. The record indicates that the District took until after the winter break to provide to STUDENT a working computer. Further training was at an impasse. MOTHER requested 100 additional hours from ARRC, whereas the District offered fifty. STUDENT received no additional training during the 2002-2003 school year. ARRC wrote MOTHER in December 2002 and the District in March 2003 documenting that the lack of continuous access to a working laptop during the past year “made progress and continued education almost impossible.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit T). As with the prior school year, most of STUDENT’s program was directed toward a benefit to STUDENT, but with regard to assistive technology, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEPs for the 2002-2003 school year were not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit.
Conformed to STUDENT’s IEP?
The same basic program with accommodations proceeded through STUDENT’s senior year. Regular communication continued between STUDENT’s parents and the District (Petitioner’s Exhibits Q and R; Respondent’s Exhibits 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, and 33). As to assistive technology, the same shortcomings persisted with training and lost time because of equipment malfunction. The Hearing Officer finds that the services provided by the District to the Petitioner during the 2002-2003 school year substantially conformed to the IEPs with the exception of assistive technology.
Did STUDENT receive a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?
The IEPs document the lack of assistive technology training and equipment to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The evidence further demonstrates that assistive technology equipment and training was not reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit, and did not conform to the IEPs. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not provide a FAPE to the Petitioner for the 2002-2003 school year.
Issue Number 2: Did the Respondent District improperly award the Petitioner a high school diploma without notice to his parents as required by 34 C.F.R. section 300.503?
Federal regulations obligate the District to provide to the parents of a special education student reasonable advanced notice of any intended initiation or change in identification, evaluation, or educational placement. 34 C.F.R. § 300.503 (a)(1)(i). State law further defines graduation from high school with a regular diploma as a change in placement. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.5.
The Petitioner received his regular high school diploma from the District during the annual commencement ceremonies in June 2003. The Petitioner argues that this graduation was without notice and that he got through with “inflated” grades, thereby not earning the diploma. The Petitioner also argues that unless his diploma is rescinded, he cannot receive further special education services.
STUDENT testified that he always was working throughout high school for the diploma so that he could go to college. He expressly said that he wanted to keep his diploma, “If I can.” Virtually all of the IEPs, in which one or both of STUDENT’s parents participated, list college as STUDENT’s goal after graduation. The college ambition after graduation also appears in the transition plans. His schedule shows the consistent inclusion of college preparatory classes starting in the ninth grade. FATHER and MOTHER actively participated in the IEP process with the District throughout STUDENT’s high school years. Demonstrating their close monitoring of STUDENT’s program and awareness of their rights, FATHER and MOTHER on more than one occasion challenged the District’s conduct and have gone to the Department of Education with compliance complaints. The gravamen of the original due process hearing request filed by MOTHER with the Hearing Office on February 25, 2003, alleges the District is “out of compliance” with respect to assistive technology and that STUDENT requires assistive technology “to assist him in preparing for his goal of college.” In this request for hearing, MOTHER further asserts that “we have been working with KHSD since the end of STUDENT’s 8th grade year, trying to prepare him for the transition into high school and ultimately equip him for college.” The language of the due process request directly states that high school graduation is a goal. Nothing in the due process request suggests that STUDENT should not or could not graduate with his class. STUDENT’s advocate since before enrolling in the District, Ronald Sheppard, emphatically testified that STUDENT could and should proceed to high school graduation and college. Although MOTHER later testified that Mr. Sheppard was “wrong” about grades and graduation being STUDENT’s goals, the Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Sheppard’s testimony is credible and consistent with the documentary evidence that charts a course toward graduation from before the ninth grade.
STUDENT was recalled as a witness three days after his initial testimony. His mother had testified that she had not spoken to STUDENT before his first stint as a witness, but discussed the matter with him before his second time. STUDENT’s second round of direct examination included general statements that he “did not deserve” the grades he received. He said that he did “everything it takes” to get a passing grade even if that meant “cheating” and “copying” to get by. MOTHER also testified that the talk about college was to humor STUDENT as he had “an inflated sense of achievement” and she “did not want him to be defeated.” She explained that she wanted him in the college preparatory classes only so that he would be around youngsters with better developed language skills to aid STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony unconvincing that STUDENT or his parents did not want him to graduate. The IEPs, the transition plans, and Mr. Sheppard’s testimony establish the intent of the family to proceed through a high school program with a diploma at the end so that he could attend college. The parents’ own chosen assessor, Linda Reither, also concluded that STUDENT was on track for graduation in her 2001 assessment (Petitioner’s P). The Petitioner did not raise any objection before, during, or after the graduation ceremonies in June 2003. The Petitioner, as a high school graduate, enrolled in a community college during the month before the hearing. None of this evidence suggests that the Petitioner’s parents were not fully on notice that STUDENT would receive a diploma last June. The conduct of the Petitioner and his family are to the contrary.
As to the assertion that his grades were inflated, STUDENT’s teachers consistently indicated otherwise. STUDENT’s tenth grade health teacher, Mr. Steven Cabalka, testified that STUDENT had worked in his class and had earned his grade. This observation was repeated by all of his teachers who testified. All students’ grades, including STUDENT’s, were determined by a computer program know as “Grade Quick.” Every teacher witness during the hearing testified to using this program and applying the District’s grading rubric (District Exhibit 55). Grade Quick records weighted entries from the daily assignments to the final examination and calculates a mathematical percentage. Mr. Cabalka and all of his teachers stated that STUDENT’s grade was a direct transfer of the computer-generated score. The program gives the student credit for a number of types of assignments in addition to traditional testing. The teacher testimony indicated that this approach gives a clearer picture of a student’s accomplishments and does not unduly penalize a student who may have a weakness in some area such as formal testing. The record shows that STUDENT did well in his program of regular education classes with RSP class support and accommodations. This is borne out by his grades (Respondent’s Exhibit 57) and his commendable class ranking of 170 out of 525 (District Exhibit 44) that reflects well on both STUDENT and the District.
The Hearing Officer finds that repeatedly over the course of four years, STUDENT’s parents were notified in writing that STUDENT was heading for graduation in June 2003, and that they acted consistently with this understanding. Therefore, there was no lack of notice that the District planned to give STUDENT a high school diploma in June 2003. The Hearing Officer further finds that STUDENT legitimately achieved the passing grades necessary to graduate. Although the Hearing Officer has found that the District denied the Petitioner a FAPE for his eleventh and twelfth grade years, the deficiencies were solely in the area of assistive technology. The record establishes that in spite of this deficiency and the occasional refusal of the Petitioner to complete assignments and take advantage of his retesting option, with his program and accommodations he succeeded in high school beyond the level of most of his classmates. STUDENT, therefore, will retain the high school diploma that he earned.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District properly awarded the Petitioner his high school diploma. (Footnote 6)
3. Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education as a remedy?
Although STUDENT graduated in June 2003, the denial of FAPE prior to that date allows the award to him of compensatory education. Puffer v. Reynolds, 761 F.Supp. 838 (D. Mass. 1988); Straube v. Florida Union Free School District, 801 F.Supp. 1164 (S.D.N.Y. 1992); Novato Unified School District, 22 IDELR 1056 (SEA Ca. 1995). The denial of FAPE gives a student an entitlement to “appropriate” relief in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359,369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985). The Burlington principle extend to compensatory education as a form of relief to students who have been denied a FAPE. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990). Compensatory education is an equitable remedy to replace lost educational services. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d. 1489, 1496-1497 (9th Cir. 1994).
The Petitioner is seeking compensatory education “in a college of Student’s choice and that included in that compensatory education is payment for all of the assistive technology tools and training to become independent with the equipment ordered by the Compliance Complaint Settlement.” The evidence, through the grade records and teacher testimony, convincingly establishes that STUDENT was able to complete high school and is capable of learning. The accommodations provided by the District appear to have contributed in no small measure to this accomplishment. STUDENT has matriculated at Taft Community College and is embarking on a program with the aid of college-provided accommodations that will hopefully be as helpful as those in high school. As to assistive technology, however, the District-provided program was not helpful. Throughout his four years, the IEPs make it clear that the assistive technology was to be incorporated in the curriculum and to prepare STUDENT for college. As described above, this did not occur although ARRC did provide the 144 hours of time with STUDENT as specified in the IEPs.
The District has suggested that now that STUDENT is enrolled at Taft Community College with many of the same accommodations that he had in the District, he can take advantage of computer training available there. These arguments are not persuasive. The record indicates that the computer offerings are limited and STUDENT may be required to pay a fee.
The Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner is entitled to compensatory education in the area of assistive technology to provide to him some benefit that he did not receive under the terms of the compliance complaint settlement during the 2001-2002 and the 2002-2003 school years. The Petitioner also is seeking reimbursement of out-of-pocket expenses prior to the hearing. The Hearing Officer declines to make any reimbursement order as the evidence does not support the amount or kind of expenses that were necessary to make up any obligation not fulfilled by the District.
ORDER
(1) Within twenty calendar days of date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting for the purposes of locating and retaining an appropriate assistive technology vendor, or qualified District employee, considering the Petitioner’s specific learning disabilities, to assess the Petitioner’s proficiency and needs in the use of a laptop computer. The designated assessor, after determining the Petitioner’s level of proficiency, shall state how many hours of training, not to exceed 100 hours, that the Petitioner requires to use specific computer hardware and software programs, as determined by the assessor, that will assist the Petitioner in meeting the requirements of his community college course work. The stated number of hours may be provided by the assessor, or another appropriate assistive technology vendor or District employee as the IEP team deems appropriate, taking into consideration the Petitioner’s special instructional needs. The District will also provide to the Petitioner the hardware and software designated by the assessor. The hardware with software installed shall be returned to the District at the completion of the training.
(2) The assessment provided for in paragraph (1), above, shall be completed no later than fourteen calendar days after the assessor is designated. The training provided for in paragraph (1) shall be completed within 120 calendar days of the date of this Decision unless the parties agree otherwise.
(3) All other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code §56507(d), the hearing Decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) Did the Respondent fail to provide to the Petitioner a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) because of deficient individualized education programs (IEPs) that did not include detailed goals and objectives, that did not list present levels of performance, that did not adequately describe the Petitioner’s accommodations or changes to his accommodations, and did not provide appropriate assistive technology: (1) For the 2000-2001 school year? (2) For the 2001-2002 school year? (3) For the 2002-2003 school year?- The Respondent prevailed for the 2000-2001 school year; the Respondent prevailed on all issues for the 2001-2002 school year and the 2002-2003 school year with the exception of assistive technology. The Petitioner prevailed on the issue of assistive technology for the 2001-2002 school year and the 2002-2003 school year.
(2) Did the Respondent District improperly award the Petitioner a high school diploma without notice to his parents as required by 34 C.F.R. section 300.503? - The Respondent prevailed on the second issue.
(3) Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education as a remedy?-The Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: October 31, 2003
Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. FATHER did not attend the hearing after September 12, 2003, due to a prior business commitment that required him to travel overseas.
2. FATHER did not attend the hearing after September 12, 2003, due to a prior business commitment that required him to travel overseas.
3. STUDENT presented a written assignment of his educational rights to his parents on the first day of the hearing.
4. The Saxon program is a series of books that proceeds through basic mathematics subject areas with a pattern of lessons, practice, and reinforcement of previously learned concepts. The evidence indicates that STUDENT used the Saxon books as his only mathematics program in the RSP class with one-on-one instruction from the teacher or aide for each of his years in the District.
5. Both FATHER and MOTHER testified that there was a short period of time that the District did not use the correct email address to reach them. In the context of the evidence, this appears to be only brief interruption in what was otherwise a substantial effort to keep the parents informed.
6. In his closing written argument, the Petitioner also argues for the first time that his graduation violated the stay put provisions of the law. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); 34 C.F.R. § 300.514; Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). This issue, however, was not raised prior to his well-noticed and anticipated graduation, was not raised in the original due process hearing request, and was not raised ten days prior to the hearing under Cal. Educ. Code section 56505(e)(6), in the “Petitioner’s Issues Resolutions.” The stay put issue was also not raised at the prehearing conference on September 8, 2003, nor during the evidence in the hearing that followed. This issue is moot in light of the Hearing Officer’s ruling that STUDENT is entitled to his diploma.
