California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 30, 2002

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 374-02 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary

Los Angeles Unified denied FAPE by transferring a ventilator-dependent student under an unwritten nurse policy; IEP team must create compensatory plan.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of an 8-year-old student eligible for special education under other health impairment filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. The student uses a mechanical ventilator, and a licensed vocational nurse (LVN) attends him all day. He did well in kindergarten at his neighborhood school, Fries Avenue Elementary. The district then cut the school nurse at Fries to three and a half days a week. Under an unwritten policy that ventilator-dependent students attend campuses with a full-time nurse, it moved him to Harbor City Elementary.

The Hearing Officer found the August 2001 IEP meeting procedurally flawed. There was no prior written notice. No teacher who knew the student attended. The parents consented without enough information about the bus schedule or school-year track. The Hearing Officer found the Spanish interpretation adequate. Relying on the treating physician, Dr. Irene Gilgoff, the Hearing Officer found the student did not need a full-time school nurse. The Harbor placement did not meet two of his needs: staying off track in winter, when respiratory illness is a greater risk, and keeping friendships with classmates who were also his neighbors. Bus ride length alone did not deny FAPE. The Hearing Officer would not order a return to Fries because 2002-2003 placement was not at issue, and denied in-home tutoring. The district must hold an IEP meeting within 20 days to develop a compensatory education plan with academic and social-emotional parts.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a placement change driven by a blanket district policy instead of the student's individual needs. It also shows that consent given without notice or key details can be found to curtail parent participation. The Hearing Officer treated social and emotional development as part of educational benefit.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1. Did the District commit procedural violations in connection with the August 2001 IEP meeting that caused prejudice to the Petitioner's education?

    No prior written notice, an IEP team with no teacher who knew the student, and inadequate information on transportation and track seriously curtailed parent participation and prejudiced the student's education; the interpreter claim was rejected.

  2. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Did the August 2001 IEP for the 2001-2002 school year result in an inappropriate placement and deny the Petitioner a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?

    The Harbor placement, made under an unwritten full-time-nurse policy, failed to meet the student's needs to be off track in winter and to socialize with classroom and neighborhood peers, and was not reasonably calculated to provide benefit; bus ride length alone was not a denial, and LRE was not reached.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the order, District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop the 2002-2003 IEP (if not already done), consider the student's need for social and academic compensatory education, and develop a compensatory education plan consistent with the decision.
  • Compensatory education. Amount and type to be set by the IEP team; plan must include social/emotional and academic components, be comprehensive, be fully integrated into the 2002-2003 IEP, and account for the student's limited physical endurance.
  • Requests for an order returning the student to track A at Fries for 2002-2003 and for in-home tutoring during off-track time were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Burlington; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Irene Gilgoff, Student's treating physician; expert witness for Student, Rancho Los Amigos National Rehabilitation Center; USC School of Medicine
  • Victoria Ikwueme (also spelled Ikwaeme), Student's attending LVN during kindergarten, Private nursing agency (Medi-Cal funded)
  • Joe Goodwin, Program specialist, local district K, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Delia Hayes, Former principal, Fries Avenue Elementary School, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Patricio Muñoz, General education teacher at Fries; interpreter at August 2001 IEP meeting, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Gertrude Ihenechor, School nurse, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Karen Maiorca, Director of nursing services, local district K, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Dr. Helen DuPlessis, Former director of student medical services, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Milica Mladinich, Assistant principal, Harbor City Elementary School, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Kelly Graves, First grade teacher at Harbor City Elementary, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Linda Michel, Special education coordinator, local district K, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Sue Talesnick, Due process coordinator, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Brigette Ammons, Educational advocate for Student, Protection & Advocacy, Inc.

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Gardena, California, on July 9, 10 and 23, 2002.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorneys Marilyn Holle and Anahid Hoonanian and educational advocate Brigette Ammons, all of Protection & Advocacy, Inc. STUDENT’s father, Mr. PARENT, was also present during the entire hearing. STUDENT’s mother, Ms. PARENT, was present during part of the hearing. Various law clerks from Protection & Advocacy, Inc. were also present at times.

Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by Wesley B. Parsons from the Office of the General Counsel for the District. Also present for the District at various times were Linda Michel, special education coordinator for local district K, a subdivision of the District, and Sue Talesnick, due process coordinator for the District.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Mr. and Ms. PARENT; Dr. Irene Gilgoff, STUDENT’s treating physician; Victoria Ikwueme, STUDENT’s primary attending L.V.N. during his kindergarten year; Joe Goodwin, a program specialist for local district K; Delia Hayes, former principal at Fries Avenue Elementary School (Fries); Patricio Muñoz, a general education teacher at Fries; Gertrude Ihenechor, a District school nurse; Karen Maiorca, director of nursing services for local district K; Dr. Helen DuPlessis, former director of student medical services for the District; Milica Mladinich, assistant principal at Harbor City Elementary School (Harbor); Kelly Graves, STUDENT’s first grade teacher at Harbor; Linda Michel; and Sue Talesnick. The District put on its case through the testimony of witnesses called by the Petitioner.

Oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. The parties’ closing arguments were heard on August 20, 2002, and the record was closed as of that date.

ISSUES

1. Did the District commit procedural violations in connection with the August 2001 IEP meeting that caused prejudice to the Petitioner’s education?

2. Did the August 2001 IEP for the 2001-2002 school year result in an inappropriate placement and deny the Petitioner a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

STUDENT alleges that the District violated his parents’ right to fully participate in the IEP process and that the violations constituted procedural denials of a FAPE. STUDENT alleges, generally, that the purpose of the IEP meeting on August 20, 2001, was not to consider appropriate placement options for STUDENT, but simply to obtain ratification from STUDENT’s parents of the decision already made by the District to transfer STUDENT from Fries to Harbor. More specifically, STUDENT contends that the IEP meeting of August 20, 2001, was not properly noticed, that an interpreter was not provided for that meeting as required by law, that the District did not take necessary action to ensure that STUDENT’s parents understood the proceedings, and that the IEP team did not include required personnel who were knowledgeable about STUDENT and his unique needs. The District denies the Petitioner’s claims that there was a procedural denial of a FAPE.

STUDENT also contends that because of his medical condition, he needs a placement that will not require an excessively long bus ride, one that will allow him to be off track during the cold and wet winter months when respiratory illnesses are more prevalent, and one that will allow him to participate more easily in extracurricular activities and otherwise build on the social relationships with his neighbors who attend Fries. He alleges that his transfer was for one reason: to comply with the District’s unwritten policy that requires children on mechanical ventilators to be placed on a campus with a guaranteed full-time school nurse. STUDENT asserts that the transfer was accomplished without the required consideration of his unique needs and that the Fries placement would have continued to provide a FAPE to him by meeting these needs in the least restrictive environment, while the Harbor placement did not. The District alleges that the placement at Harbor was designed to meet STUDENT’s need for full-time attendant care by medically trained personnel and was also in compliance with State and District guidelines for ventilator-dependent students.

As a remedy for the alleged denial of a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT seeks a determination by the Hearing Officer that the change of placement was in error and an order that he be allowed to return to his class at Fries for the 2002-2003 school year. In addition, STUDENT seeks compensatory education in the form of an in-home tutor during the time that he is off track during the 2002-2003 school year. The District requests that all of the Petitioner’s claims to relief be denied.

BACKGROUND

STUDENT is eight years old. He lives with his older brother and parents. His mother speaks mostly Spanish, and his father is bilingual. The family lives within the geographical boundaries of the District. STUDENT is eligible for special education under the category of “other health impairment” (OHI). STUDENT’s neighborhood elementary school is Fries Avenue Elementary School, which is just a few hundred feet from his home. He last attended school at Harbor on October 23, 2001. He has been receiving home schooling since that time.

STUDENT has been diagnosed with nemaline rod myopathy, a genetic disorder that causes extreme weakness of the muscles. The disease has left him with total body weakness. STUDENT is dependent upon a mechanical ventilator and tracheostomy to breathe, except for short periods of time (up to fifteen to twenty minutes). He uses an electric wheelchair for mobility and requires a body brace to maintain a comfortable posture that will not interfere with his breathing. He also has weakness in his upper extremities that make it difficult to use his hands. Nemaline rod myopathy does not directly affect basic intelligence or personality. STUDENT is a bright and alert child who is motivated to learn. He is shy but quite capable of overcoming his shyness and interacting well with teachers and peers.

STUDENT has been medically stable since his recovery from the tracheotomy in approximately July 1999. He is seen regularly by Dr. Gilgoff. The State Department of Health Services (Medi-Cal) provides a licensed vocational nurse (LVN) to care for STUDENT throughout the day. Such care includes monitoring of his overall condition and of the effective operation of his mechanical ventilation system and the administration of medication. If STUDENT has difficulty breathing due to the buildup of secretions, he may require mechanical suction of these secretions to clear his airway. STUDENT can simply request suction if he wants it or feels that he needs it. Due to the weakness of the muscles used for chewing and swallowing, STUDENT is on a special diet and requires some assistance with feeding. STUDENT’s parents are also trained and qualified to attend to his physical needs.

STUDENT requires little regular medical maintenance other than assistance in maintaining an open airway and administering his medication. The ventilator plugs into a standard power source, and there is a backup battery for the ventilator that can be used in the event of a power failure. There is also a manual ventilation device (“ambu bag”) available as an additional backup. It requires no power source. The parents have a backup ventilator and additional backup batteries at their home.

STUDENT’s parents participated in an IEP meeting on March 22, 2000. According to the notice, the purpose of the meeting was to discuss changes to STUDENT’s IEP. Mr. PARENT notified the District that he would attend the meeting. He did not request an interpreter, although he could have checked a box on the notice form to do so. Nevertheless, both parents attended the meeting and a translator was provided.

At the IEP meeting on March 22, 2000, the District members of the team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a general education kindergarten class on an adapted campus with a full-time nurse. An adapted campus is one that is fully accessible to handicapped students. It may also have guaranteed coverage of a full-time school nurse. According to the testimony, the reason for the recommendation, although not noted on the IEP document, was the District’s unwritten policy that required that ventilator-dependent students be placed on campuses with guaranteed full-time coverage by a school nurse. The IEP document states that the nature of an adapted campus, including accessibility and its full-time nurse, was discussed in detail at the meeting. The parents disagreed with the placement recommendation.

The PARENTs wanted STUDENT to attend their neighborhood school, Fries. Fries is not an adapted campus, although there are some accessible classrooms and other areas. A full-time nurse was assigned to the campus for the 2000-2001 school year, but, unlike an adapted campus, school nurse coverage was not guaranteed. If the assigned nurse was sick or otherwise unavailable, a replacement was not assured. Mr. and Ms. PARENT requested an informal meeting to attempt to resolve the dispute. A mediation took place and the parties agreed that STUDENT could attend a regular kindergarten class at Fries for the 2000-2001 school year.

Although it can take as long as three hours to get STUDENT ready for school each morning, STUDENT managed to maintain an excellent attendance record during kindergarten, missing only three days. His attending LVN that year was Victoria Ikwueme. Either she or one of STUDENT’s parents would accompany him to school each day to attend to his physical needs, including whatever physical support or assistance he required for academic tasks. In the beginning of the year, STUDENT was taken each morning to see the school nurse, who would check his general condition and the operation of his ventilator. However, this check-in procedure was eliminated early in the year. Thereafter, STUDENT had infrequent contact with a school nurse at Fries. There were no medical emergencies. STUDENT’s caregivers never became incapacitated while on the job, and never required the assistance of the school nurse. STUDENT achieved good grades and had a successful year. By all accounts, STUDENT received substantial benefit from his education at Fries.

Between the end of the 2000-2001 school year and the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, the District changed the school nurse assignment for the Fries campus because of budgetary constraints. The nurse was to be present for only three and one-half days per week. Because of the change in school nurse coverage, the District decided that STUDENT would have to be transferred to a campus with a full-time nurse.

An IEP meeting was convened on August 20, 2001, to present to STUDENT’s parents the District’s decision to transfer STUDENT to a general education first grade class on an adapted campus with a full-time nurse. There was no prior written notice of this meeting. None of STUDENT’s teachers attended. Other than Delia Hayes, who had observed STUDENT on the Fries campus while she was the principal there during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT’s parents were the only persons present who were knowledgeable regarding STUDENT’s needs.

At the August 2001 meeting, the District explained to STUDENT’s parents that he would have to attend a general education class on an adapted campus with a full-time nurse. The campus was not identified in the IEP document, but it is agreed that at that meeting, or shortly thereafter, the IEP meeting STUDENT was offered placement at Harbor City Elementary School (Harbor). Home-to-school transportation was to be provided by lift bus, but the details of the transportation, such as pick-up and drop-off times, were not discussed. There was also no information in the IEP documents regarding what track STUDENT would be on at this year-round school, though this was an important element of the placement for STUDENT’s physical, social, and emotional health.

STUDENT’s parents were reluctant to agree to a transfer of STUDENT from Fries. Among other concerns, they did not want him to separated from his neighborhood and classroom peers with whom he was developing friendships. Ultimately, however, they did agree, and STUDENT began attending Harbor shortly thereafter on September 4, 2001. Contrary to his parents’ wish that STUDENT be assigned to track A, he was assigned to track C. The track assignment meant that he joined the class two months after the term had begun. It meant that he would be required to attend classes in the cold and wet winter months when respiratory infections were most common. It also meant that his school breaks would be different from those of his neighborhood and former class peers.

There were problems with STUDENT’s attendance at Harbor. His parents had difficulty getting him ready in time to be picked up by the bus, which at first arrived at 6:00 to 6:30 a.m. Mr. PARENT drove STUDENT to school to avoid difficulties with transportation. Mr. and Ms. PARENT also objected to STUDENT’s assignment to track C. The class had already completed half of the alphabet in the Open Court reading program by the time STUDENT joined them. He was separated from his friends at Fries and less accessible to neighborhood peers. On September 16, 2001, Mr. PARENT wrote to the school asking that an IEP meeting be scheduled to discuss the transportation schedule and track assignment.

An IEP team meeting was convened at Harbor on October 4 and 8, 2001. The meeting was called to address Mr. PARENT’s concerns, but it was also treated as an annual review meeting. STUDENT’s parents expressed their concern that track A was not available when STUDENT began attending Harbor and that the bus ride, although shorter than originally scheduled, was still too long. Mr. PARENT said he wanted STUDENT to be returned to Fries. The team agreed to reconvene on October 8, 2001, to discuss track, transportation and placement.

The IEP team reconvened on October 8, 2001. The parents were informed that only track C was available at Harbor. The District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT continue to attend Harbor on track C. The IEP document does not memorialize any further discussion regarding transportation. STUDENT’s parents did not agree. According to the IEP documents, they wanted track A and pick-up and drop-off times of 7:30 a.m. and 3:30 p.m., respectively. Mr. and Ms. PARENT noted on the IEP document that they agreed with the IEP except with respect to placement.

Mr. and Ms. PARENT were dissatisfied with the response to their complaints about the move to Harbor. They withdrew STUDENT from Harbor on last day of that fall term on October 23, 2001. STUDENT did not return to the campus in early January following the fall/winter break, and he has not returned to school since. According to his mother, STUDENT has been receiving one to one and one-half hours of home schooling twice per week. While being schooled at home, he has continued to build on his friendships with neighborhood and former classroom peers from Fries.

Protection & Advocacy, Inc. filed a request for due process on STUDENT’s behalf on February 20, 2002.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Under both state special education law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free, appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Calif. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free, appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the state educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed education, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Calif. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist the child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22).

The United States Supreme Court has held that a FAPE consists of educational instruction specially designed to meet the unique needs of the disabled child, supported by such services as are necessary to permit the child “to benefit” from the instruction. Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et .al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 188-189. It is not necessary for the child’s program to maximize the educational opportunities or put them on a par with the opportunities provided to typically developing students. What is required is that the disabled student be provided with access to a FAPE which is “sufficient to confer some educational benefit upon the handicapped child.” Id. at 200-201. Pursuant to Rowley, a proposed placement must meet three requirements in order to constitute an appropriate educational program. It must (1) have been designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) have been reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit; and (3) comported with the student’s IEP. All of these conditions must have been met in a placement that constituted the least restrictive environment.

Rowley also recognized that the IDEA reflects the desire of Congress to ensure that there are procedural protections afforded the student and parents which will allow for effective participation in the IEP process. The Court notes that parents can be the most ardent advocates for their children, and that their full participation can be the best way to ensure that all appropriate services are being offered to the handicapped child. The analysis must be two-pronged. First, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA which are designed to allow and encourage the full participation of the parents. Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of a FAPE. A procedural flaw must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process to result in the denial of a FAPE. Second, the Hearing Officer must look at the IEP and placement offer which were a result of those procedures to determine whether they meet the substantive requirement for a FAPE, including the requirement that they meet the unique needs of the child. Rowley, 458 U.S., at 206-207; See also: W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484. The District has the burden of proof on both prongs of the analysis. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, (9th Cir. 1994) 35 F.3d 1396, 1398.

Issue No. 1: Did the District commit procedural violations in connection with the August 2001 IEP meeting that caused prejudice to the Petitioner’s education?

Prior Written Notice

Districts are required to give written prior notice to the parents of the child whenever they propose to initiate or change, or refuse to initiate or change, the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child, or the provision of a free appropriate public education to the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). That notice generally must include a description of the proposed or refused action, an explanation of the reasons, a description of any other options considered, a description of each evaluation procedure, test, record, or report relied upon, a description of any other factors that are relevant, and information regarding procedural safeguards and sources for assistance in understanding the provisions of this part. 34 C.F.R. § 300.503. Such notice provides the parents with information that can help them to make informed decisions about their child’s education. The notice is also important in that it helps ensure that there is a clear record of what placement, services and assistance were offered to the student and when they were offered. This information might be required years after the fact if there is a dispute, as there is here, about compliance with the special education laws. Union School Dist. v. B. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F. 3d 1519, 1526.

There was no prior written notice regarding the scheduling and purpose of the August 2001 meeting. Nor was there evidence offered by the District regarding why there was no such notice. Mr. Goodwin testified that he contacted STUDENT’s parents at the request of the principal, Ms. Hayes, to invite them to the meeting and that he “believed” that he told them the meeting was to discuss a change of placement. It was the Hearing Officer’s impression that Mr. Goodwin was not certain that he had told Mr. PARENT why the meeting was being held, and there was no writing to confirm that such notice had been given. Mr. PARENT testified that his first notice that the District planned to change STUDENT’s placement to Harbor was at the IEP meeting on August 20, 2001, and that he was surprised by the proposal. The Hearing Officer found the testimony of STUDENT’s parents to be persuasive on this issue and finds that STUDENT’s parents did not know the District was planning to announce its intention to move STUDENT from his home school until that plan was presented at the August 2001 meeting. Calculated or not, the lack of prior notice effectively prevented Mr. and Ms. PARENT from considering their position, obtaining effective counsel, and preparing their response in advance of the meeting.

The flow of information to STUDENT’s parents did not improve during the August 2001 IEP meeting. According to Mr. PARENT’s testimony, he and his wife were concerned about the transportation schedule, particularly because it took so long to get STUDENT ready for school and because he tired so easily. They also were concerned about the track that STUDENT would be on in his new placement. They didn’t want him to be moved away from his neighborhood friends at his home school because they knew how difficult it was for him to make friends, and they wanted to make sure that he was off track during the winter months when he was at the greatest risk of respiratory infection. Mr. PARENT said that he expressed these concerns to the other team members and that he and Ms. PARENT agreed to the placement only after they were assured by the District that it would “take care of” these matters and that STUDENT could come back to Fries if things did not work out at the new placement.

The IEP documents did nothing to clarify matters. Other than stating that STUDENT would be placed on a District nonresidence, adapted campus, the IEP documents mention nothing about the specifics of the placement, the transportation, or the track. It states that Mr. Goodwin was to follow up on placement and transportation by August 29, 2001.

The District witnesses agreed that neither of STUDENT’s parents was at first inclined to accept the change of placement and that they wanted STUDENT to remain at his neighborhood school. They denied that the PARENTs were told that STUDENT could simply return to Fries if things didn’t work out to their satisfaction at Harbor. They testified that STUDENT’s parents were told that they could request another IEP meeting to reconsider the placement. No witness testified that the PARENTs were informed regarding the effect that their consent would have on STUDENT’s right to stay put at Fries, and none denied that the PARENTs were led to believe that their concerns regarding track and transportation would be properly addressed.

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the PARENTs were told that they could simply ask that STUDENT be returned to Fries if they were unhappy with the Harbor placement. However, the Hearing Officer is convinced that the District did not fulfill its obligation to give STUDENT’s parents adequate information regarding important details of the proposed change of placement in the course of the IEP meeting. The evidence supports the Petitioner’s contention that his parents gave their written consent to the change of placement in the reasonable belief that the details of transportation and track assignment would be handled to their satisfaction.

Mr. Goodwin testified that he planned a visit to the Harbor campus with Mr. PARENT for the day following the IEP meeting. He said that he was surprised to find out at the time of that visit that the PARENTs had already singed the IEP and consented to the placement. While Mr. Goodwin recalled no discussion of track assignment at the IEP meeting, he heard Mr. PARENT tell the Harbor representative during their visit that STUDENT needed to be on Track A. According to Mr. Goodwin, the representative responded that she believed the school could do that.

Although there was a dispute regarding whether Mr. PARENT was told that the bus would pick up STUDENT up at 6:00 a.m., two hours before the start of class, or at 6:30 a.m., it is clear that there was never an adequate understanding, much less an agreement, concerning the transportation schedule. According to Mr. PARENT, transportation was not arranged by early September, so he took STUDENT to school in the beginning. The parties agree that there were several adjustments to the schedule, the most recent one proposed by the District after STUDENT’s parents withdrew him from Harbor, but none that was acceptable to STUDENT’s parents.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the information provided to STUDENT’s parents about the District’s proposal to change STUDENT’s placement was not sufficient to allow them to make an informed and timely decision regarding the appropriateness of that change. The Hearing Officer is convinced by the testimony of STUDENT’s parents that they would not have consented to the change of placement had they been aware that their concerns about track assignment and transportation would not be satisfactorily addressed. As a result, the right of STUDENT’s parents to fully participate in the IEP process was seriously curtailed. In addition, STUDENT lost his opportunity to remain at Fries pending a determination by the Hearing Office regarding the appropriateness of the change of placement to Harbor.

Interpreter

It is the District’s obligation to ensure that the parents understand what is said at the IEP meeting. That includes the obligation to arrange for an interpreter for parents whose native language is other than English. Calif. Educ. Code § 56341.5(h).

Interpreters had been provided for the PARENTs, at least for Ms. PARENT, at six of the seven IEP meeting for which documents are in evidence. An interpreter was also provided at the subject meeting on August 20, 2001. While there were suggestions in the course of the hearing that the District’s use of the regular education teacher, Mr. Muñoz, as the interpreter was not adequate compliance with the law, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the translation services were adequate. Mr. PARENT has a good command of the English language and he understood what was said that day. The Hearing Officer is also convinced that Mr. and Ms. PARENT used the services of Mr. Muñoz to the extent they determined necessary. Mr. Muñoz testified that Mr. PARENT translated Ms. PARENT’s comments. The Hearing Officer is satisfied that Mr. PARENT was attentive to potential problems with the translations provided to his wife at the meeting and that any misunderstanding would have been raised by him and addressed appropriately at that time.

Inappropriately Composed IEP Team

A meeting to develop, review or revise an IEP must be conducted by a team that includesone or both parents or their representative, at least one of the student’s regular education teachers if the student is to be participating in the regular education environment, at least one of the student’s special education teachers, a representative of the district, the persons who conducted assessments, and, when appropriate, the student. Calif. Educ. Code § 56341; 34 C.F.R. § 300.344.

The IEP team that met on August 20, 2001, did not include STUDENT’s regular education teacher from the prior year. Nor did the IEP team include any teacher that knew anything at all about STUDENT and his needs. The evidence showed clearly that the team, other than Mr. and Ms. PARENT, was composed of District employees who knew little or nothing about STUDENT’s needs. The evidence clearly established that the August 2001 IEP meeting was not intended by the District to provide an opportunity to IEP team members to use their particular knowledge of STUDENT to review and revise STUDENT’s IEP as necessary to meet his unique needs or to take them into account in selecting an appropriate placement for him. Regardless of the District’s agenda for the meeting, the Hearing Officer agrees with the Petitioner that the IEP team that met on August 20, 2001, did not include the required members and was therefore procedurally deficient.

The faulty composition of the IEP team was just one more indication that the purpose of the meeting was as argued by the Petitioner: to obtain the consent of STUDENT’s parents to a transfer mandated by the District’s unwritten policy, regardless of STUDENT’s unique needs. Although it could be argued that the District’s recommendation would not have been any different had the team included all appropriate members, it is clear that the absence of important participants prevented any of the meaningful dialogue regarding the child’s needs that the law demands. A meaningful dialogue concerning the potential impact of the move on STUDENT’s social and emotional needs might have resulted in a recommendation that he stay at Fries, that he remain on track A, or at least that a plan for the transition be developed to assist with STUDENT’s socialization into the new class. A discussion with the teacher from Harbor would certainly have revealed that STUDENT would be far behind the class reading plan and that he might have a particularly difficult time making friends because relationships had already been established and social groups formed. The failure by the District to consider these matters was a clear denial of a procedural safeguard that is likely to have prejudiced STUDENT’s education.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District committed procedural violations in connection with the August 2001 IEP meeting that caused prejudice to the Petitioner’s education. The logical and predictable outcome of a process so prejudicial to STUDENT’s interests would be a placement that fails to address his unique needs and has the potential to cause damage to his physical, social and emotional health, as discussed below.

Issue No. 2: Did the August 2001 IEP for the 2001-2002 school year result in an inappropriate placement and deny the Petitioner a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment?

The Hearing Officer must determine whether the Harbor placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. In addition, the Hearing Officer must decide whether or not the proposed placement offered a FAPE to STUDENT in the least restrictive environment.

Was the Harbor Placement Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

The primary dispute was whether or not STUDENT needed to have a school nurse present on the campus to which he was assigned during the 2001-2002 school year. There was a dispute about whether or not STUDENT’s physical condition required that he be on a school schedule that was off track during the wet and cold winter months. There was a dispute regarding whether or not STUDENT’s social and emotional needs required that he be on a track that provided him with significant opportunities for social interaction with classroom and neighborhood peers. Finally, there was an issue regarding whether the length of STUDENT’s bus ride would have been detrimental to his health or alertness.

Full-time School Nurse

Dr. Irene Gilgoff has been STUDENT’s primary treating pediatrician since 1999. She is chairperson of the department of pediatrics at Rancho Los Amigos National Rehabilitation Center (Rancho Los Amigos) and a member of the faculty of the University of Southern California School of Medicine. In addition to STUDENT, the doctor follows about one hundred fifty pediatric patients with neuromuscular disease, some of whom are ventilator-dependent. Dr. Gilgoff was clearly the witness most knowledgeable concerning STUDENT’s medical and related needs.

Dr. Gilgoff confirmed that because STUDENT has total body weakness and a tracheostomy and is ventilator dependent, he requires full-time attendance by someone who is trained to provide for his physical needs. In the doctor’s opinion, STUDENT’s parents and his LVN are all well- qualified to fulfill these needs and have, in fact, fulfilled them in stellar fashion.

Dr. Gilgoff acknowledged that one of her recommended safety measures was that STUDENT never be left unattended, but explained she would qualify that by indicating that STUDENT should not be left alone for more than five minutes. Much of the District’s questioning on the issue focused on the possibility of an equipment failure or the sudden and unexpected incapacitation of the LVN. The doctor responded by explaining that STUDENT’s medical condition is stable and that the likelihood of an emergency that would require the physical assistance of a school nurse was so remote as to be, in Dr. Gilgoff’s words, “irrelevant.” She noted that the ventilator has a backup battery in the event of a power failure. There is the ambu bag that could be used by the LVN or parent to maintain STUDENT’s respirations, for hours if necessary. STUDENT could also be safely off the ventilator for short intervals of up to approximately fifteen minutes. Dr. Gilgoff considered all these factors in concluding that STUDENT did not need to be on a campus where a school nurse was always present.

The testimony of Victoria Ikwaeme, STUDENT’s LVN during his kindergarten year (2000-2001) at Fries, also supported the Petitioner’s position. Ms. Ikwaeme testified that she and STUDENT had contact with the school nurse infrequently during the 2000-2001 school year. She said that the daily check-in at the nurse’s office ended at the request of Fries personnel early in the year and there were no emergencies that required any contact with the school nurse. If there had been a medical emergency, Ms. Ikwaeme had a cellular telephone to call her supervising RN at her agency. She also confirmed that she had an ambu bag and said that STUDENT had gone off the ventilator for several hours on occasion. Ms. Ikwaeme had the telephone number for the ventilator service company in the event of an equipment failure. Her standard protocol for an emergency was to call “911" if she did not feel she could handle it on her own or with the advice of her supervisor. According to Mr. PARENT, emergency medical personnel were available at the fire station approximately five blocks from Fries.

The District offered no persuasive evidence to establish that STUDENT required a school nurse on campus. Ms. Hayes, the former principal at Fries, testified that she was concerned about STUDENT’s safety in view of an impending reduction in school nurse hours at Fries. Ms. Michel testified that because of the reduction in the nursing assignment, Ms. Hayes’ primary concerns were medical and related to STUDENT’s possible need for increased school nursing services, because he would be attending school for a full day. According to Mr. Goodwin, Ms. Hayes initiated the process that resulted in the August 2001 IEP because she was concerned that STUDENT’s LVN was not a District employee and should be supervised by a school nurse. Ms. Michel testified that the change of placement was pursuant to the District’s unwritten policy that all ventilator-dependent students be on campuses where a school nurse is always present.

There was little effort by the District to explain why its unwritten policy should be given more consideration than the needs of the student. Although there was some testimony regarding the annual cost of providing a school nurse, there was no real effort by the District to justify its unwritten policy on the basis of cost. The District argued that its unwritten policy was justified as a reasonable effort to conform its practices to a specific body of law, but its references to the District’s written guidelines and the guidelines and procedures published by the California Department of Education (CDE) were not persuasive. The only medical personnel who testified that STUDENT needed to be on a campus with a full-time school nurse was Karen Maiorca, the director of nursing services for district K. She testified that the unwritten policy of the District, which tries to adhere to the CDE guidelines, has been to place ventilator-dependent students on campuses with a full-time school nurse. However, she also said that exceptions have been allowed based upon specific recommendations to the contrary that were the result of an appropriate IEP process with input from knowledgeable personnel. Ms. Maiorca did not even attempt to show how STUDENT’s individual needs required a placement with a full-time school nurse.

It was clear from the evidence that the District did little to determine whether STUDENT actually needed to have a school nurse available to participate in his care. Dr. Gilgoff confirmed that no one from the District asked her about STUDENT’s needs or whether Harbor was more or less likely than Fries to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. There was no evidence that the District sought any current medical information regarding STUDENT’s needs from any source. The District had no current medical data of its own to support its claim that STUDENT needed to have a school nurse available at all times. The only medical person present at the August 2001 IEP was an “IEP Nurse” who had no knowledge of STUDENT’s individual needs.

The evidence showed that STUDENT needed to be attended at all times by someone who was qualified to provide for his physical needs. STUDENT’s LVN or either of his parents filled that need. The District asserts that Harbor was the appropriate placement for STUDENT because it had a full-time nurse. Considerable time was spent at the hearing on evidence regarding this claimed need. However, although placement of STUDENT on a campus with a full-time nurse would have not been to his detriment, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded that STUDENT has a unique need to be placed on a campus with a full-time school nurse. Moreover, the question is whether or not the Harbor placement appropriately addressed STUDENT’s unique needs, as discussed below.

Off Track In Winter

Dr. Gilgoff testified that STUDENT should be on a track that allowed him to remain at home during the cold and wet winter months of January and February due to his increased susceptibility to respiratory infections. She explained that STUDENT’s condition not only makes him more susceptible to respiratory infection, but because he does not have the ability to cough to clear his lungs, the potential consequences of such infection are severe for STUDENT. He is at increased risk of pneumonia. Although, as the District pointed out, Ms. Ikwaeme testified that the risk of respiratory infection in children decreases after age five or six, she did not contradict Dr. Gilgoff’s statements regarding STUDENT’s susceptibility and the potentially dire consequences to him of a respiratory infection. The Hearing Officer found the testimony Dr. Gilgoff persuasive on this issue. The District offered no other evidence to contradict the testimony of Dr. Gilgoff.

The Hearing Officer finds that one of STUDENT’s unique needs is that he be on a school schedule that will allow him to remain in the more protective environment of his home during the winter months. Although all children are at increased risk of respiratory infection during the winter months, STUDENT’s physical condition makes him particularly susceptible to such infection and more likely to suffer dire consequences as a result. The District neither identified nor made any effort to address this need in the August 2001 IEP and the resulting placement. STUDENT was placed on a track (track C) that required that he attend school in January and February. Other evidence established that only track A, the track specifically requested by Mr. PARENT, would fulfill this need. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Harbor placement was not designed to meet this individual need and thus failed to provide a FAPE in this respect.

Opportunities for Social Interaction with Classroom and Neighborhood Peers

Dr. Gilgoff’s testimony revealed that another important benefit to STUDENT of an assignment to track A would be that STUDENT would be off track at the same time as potential playmates in his neighborhood. The doctor expressed her serious concern that STUDENT’s educational placement not limit his opportunities to socialize with classroom peers who were also his neighbors. She explained that typically developing peers will usually not recognize a child like STUDENT, with his electric wheelchair, tracheostomy, and ventilator, as a potential playmate and friend. Because of this common perception, Dr. Gilgoff believed that STUDENT’s placement should make him readily accessible to potential playmates who attended Fries and lived near STUDENT. She feared that without thus ensuring STUDENT’s availability for social interaction, he would be at substantial risk of becoming socially and emotionally isolated.

Ms. Ikwaeme and STUDENT’s parents confirmed that STUDENT is shy and can have some difficulty warming up to and establishing friendships with others, adults and peers. He eventually made friends with classmates at Fries. At least some of these friends were also neighbors who would come over after school and on weekends to play with STUDENT. Some of these opportunities to visit with neighborhood friends in his home have continued while STUDENT has remained home from school. Ms. Graves also noted STUDENT’s shyness in her class at Harbor. It was clear from her testimony that she was concerned about STUDENT’s socialization within her classroom. She pointed out that by the time STUDENT arrived in her class, the other students had already had two months to establish relationships and form social groups. She observed that only two students seemed to reach out to STUDENT, who remained very shy and clearly isolated.

The Hearing Officer found the testimony of Dr. Gilgoff to be persuasive. Her opinions were validated by testimony regarding STUDENT’s experience during his attendance at Harbor. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs during the 2001-2002 school year included the need for an educational placement that would provide him with significant opportunities to establish and nurture social relationships with classroom and neighborhood peers. It is clear that this was another need that was neither identified nor addressed by the August 2001 IEP team. Moreover, there was no consideration given to a plan for an effective social transition into Ms. Graves’ class. For example, there was no plan to introduce STUDENT to the class or to explain STUDENT’s disability and needs to the other children. Although the Hearing Officer recognizes that Ms. Graves was aware of the problem and probably did her best to help STUDENT adjust socially to his new surroundings, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District’s efforts were not adequate. As a direct result, the August 2001 IEP and resulting placement at Harbor was not designed to meet this unique need.

Transportation Schedule

There was conflicting evidence regarding STUDENT’s tolerance for bus rides longer than fifteen to twenty minutes and also regarding the District’s ability to meet a transportation schedule that would fulfill STUDENT’s needs. Within the parameters of the schedules discussed, the evidence did not persuade the Hearing Officer that the length of the bus rides alone would support a finding that the the District’s offer did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

In summary, the Harbor placement did not meet STUDENT’s need to be at home during the months that he was at greatest risk of respiratory infection. Nor did the Harbor placement meet STUDENT’s unique need for social interaction with classroom and neighborhood peers. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the August 2001 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Was the Harbor Placement Reasonably Calculated to Provide an Educational Benefit?

The Petitioner argued that the Harbor placement was not reasonably calculated to confer an educational benefit on him because the transportation schedule was likely to cause him to be unnecessarily fatigued and thus less able to learn. For the reasons already discussed, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded by the evidence that this was the case. The Petitioner also argued that Harbor was not reasonably calculated to provide an educational benefit to him because he was two months behind the class when he joined it. The Hearing Officer did not conclude that this admitted fact alone established that Harbor denied STUDENT an educational benefit, but it was another indication of the District’s disregard for Harbor’s ability to meet STUDENT’s needs.

The District did not establish that the Harbor placement was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT in terms of his social and emotional needs. Social and emotional growth and development are part of the educational process for STUDENT. Healthy social development requires that the student have adequate opportunities to initiate and nurture social relationships. With particularly shy students, like STUDENT, consideration must be given to ways to facilitate the socialization process. That might include one-on-one introductions to peers, assignment of a “buddy” to help the student move within or between social groups, guidance to the typically developing peers about the nature of the child’s disability, and structured social opportunities. There was no effort by the District to provide this kind of educational benefit to STUDENT in the August 2001 IEP.

The August 2001 IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.

Did the Harbor Placement Offer STUDENT a FAPE in the Least Restrictive Environment?

There was much said in the course of the hearing about least restrictive environment. The Petitioner urges the Hearing Officer to conclude that the LRE doctrine should give rise to a presumption in favor of placement in the neighborhood school. In this case, however, the Hearing Officer found that the August 2001 IEP that resulted in the change of placement to Harbor was inappropriate because the District failed to provide adequate procedural safeguards during the development and implementation of the IEP. The Hearing Officer also found that the August 2001 IEP and Harbor placement did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs or provide him with social and emotional educational benefit. Under the circumstances, there is no need to determine whether or not Harbor was the least restrictive environment.

The Hearing Officer finds that the August IEP for the 2001-2002 school year resulted in an inappropriate placement at Harbor that denied STUDENT a FAPE.

REMEDY

Return to Fries

The Petitioner has requested several remedies. He has asked the Hearing Officer to enter an order compelling the District to place him on track A at Fries for the 2002-2003 school year. That relief is beyond the scope of the issues submitted for decision. The Petitioner submitted issues regarding the placement at Harbor for the 2001-2002 school year. There was no evidence at the hearing that STUDENT had yet been offered a placement for the 2002-2003 school year. Nor was there sufficient evidence upon which to base a determination regarding what STUDENT’s placement for the 2002-2003 school year would be. Accessibility of the Fries campus could be a factor in determining STUDENT’s placement during the 2002-2003 and subsequent school years. District staff stated that changes would have to be made for STUDENT to access a second grade classroom. There is also ongoing construction on the campus that may affect accessibility issues.

The Hearing Officer found that the District’s decision to change STUDENT’s placement from Fries to Harbor was flawed, in part, because it was not based upon STUDENT’s unique needs. The District’s offer of a placement to STUDENT for the current or later years must be based on his individual needs as discussed above and not simply on the District’s unwritten policy which assumes that all ventilator-dependent students need to have a school nurse present whenever they are on the campus. However, in spite of the Hearing Officer’s determination that the Harbor placement did not meet STUDENT’s needs for the 2001-2002 school year, prospective placement was not properly put at issue by the parties. The Hearing Officer is unable to order the District to allow STUDENT to return to Fries.

Compensatory Education

The Petitioner requests an award of compensatory education in the form of in-home tutoring at the District’s expense to be delivered during the time that he is off track during the 2002-2003 school year.

When a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 374, 105 S. Ct. 1996; see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). With reference to the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. The purpose of compensatory education is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Id.

STUDENT has been out of school for almost a year. During some of that time, he has received two to three hours per week of home schooling. He would have been in school for approximately thirty-five hours per week, including lunch and recesses, if the District had provided an appropriate placement. That time in school would have provided far more educational opportunity than STUDENT received at home. In addition, although STUDENT’s home schooling made him more readily available to neighborhood peers during off track and after school, it also deprived him of the opportunity to socialize with peers in the school setting.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents did not act unreasonably when they withdrew him from Harbor. They were rightfully concerned about STUDENT’s social and emotional isolation at Harbor. It was not clear from the evidence whether they recognized that STUDENT would likely suffer some academic loss as another result of the withdrawal. Regardless, given the options made available to them by the District, it was not unreasonable for them to believe that the withdrawal would allow him continued opportunities for social and emotional development through contact with neighborhood friends, and this alone justified their actions.

When STUDENT last attended at Harbor, he was behind the class, at least in the reading program. There was no specific evidence offered by the Petitioner regarding STUDENT’s current levels of achievement or the extent to which he has been damaged by the denial of a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year. Nevertheless, it was undisputed that STUDENT has been receiving only two to three hours per week instruction at home and no opportunities to socialize with peers on a school campus for almost a year. That evidence persuaded the Hearing Officer that STUDENT did sustain some loss, both academically and socially. Because of the lack of evidence to guide the Hearing Officer in the crafting of a plan for compensatory damage, the details of that plan are best left to the IEP team.

The IEP team will be responsible for determining the amount and type of the compensatory education, but it shall include social/emotional and academic components. The plan for compensatory education shall be comprehensive and fully integrated into STUDENT’s IEP for the 2002-2003 school year. That IEP and the process through which it is developed must comply with the IDEA and be consistent with this Decision, including the requirement that the placement and program appropriately address STUDENT’s needs as identified herein. The IEP team shall also consider STUDENT’s limited physical endurance and take reasonable care to ensure that the demands of the 2002-2003 IEP do not overburden him, alienate him from the educational process, or socially isolate him from his peers.

ORDER

1. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this order, the District shall convene an IEP meeting. The purpose of the meeting shall be to develop an IEP for the 2002-2003 school year, if that has not already been done, to consider STUDENT’s need for social and academic compensatory education, and to develop a compensatory education plan consistent with this Decision.

2. Other relief prayed for by the Petitioner is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

The Petitioner prevailed on both issues.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).

Dated: September 30, 2002 Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The issues were defined during a prehearing telephone conference conducted by the presiding Hearing Officer on July 5, 2002.

2. There was no dispute that the Fries placement provided a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year. The only basis for the District’s claim that the fries placement would not have provided a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year was the lack of full-time school nurse coverage on the campus.

3. Although there was testimony regarding wheelchair access (accessibility) to the various parts of the Fries campus, the parties focused their efforts on issues other than accessibility. The District did not argue that lack of accessibility warranted STUDENT’s transfer to Harbor or that it should prevent his return to Fries. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer feels compelled to discuss accessibility at Fries and will do so in the context of the discussion of the Petitioner’s remedy, below.

4. Ms. PARENT required the assistance of an interpreter at the hearing. Mr. PARENT did not.

5. It was not clear from the testimony that all adapted campuses had a guaranteed full-time school nurse.

6. There were later adjustments to the bus schedule.

7. The school day at Harbor began at 8:00 a.m. and ended at 2:54 p.m.

8. The 1997 amendments to the Act added other elements to the definition of what constitutes a FAPE, among them that the proposed placement must provide the child with reasonable access to the regular curriculum. These other elements were not issues in STUDENT’s case.

9. There had been written notice in advance of the several prior IEP meetings.

10. Mr. Goodwin testified that he had only Harbor in mind when he attended the IEP.

11. By consenting to the change of placement, STUDENT’s parents arguably waived their son’s right to invoke stay put at Fries.

12. In the course of the hearing, Petitioner’s counsel raised Mr. PARENT’s concern about the accuracy of the translation for Ms. PARENT. The event is indicative of Mr. PARENT’s attention to and concern for his wife’s understanding of what is said concerning STUDENT.

13. According to Delia Hayes, that teacher had retired. No further explanation of the omission of the teacher from the team was offered. Ms. Hayes was also retired at the time of her testimony.

14. STUDENT did not allege that the placement or program at Harbor did not comport with his IEP, allow him to access the general curriculum, or otherwise comply with the requirements of the IDEA as amended in 1997.

15. Several witnesses testified about the accessibility issue. But there was no real dispute regarding accessibility for the school year at issue (2001-2002).

16. It was clear from the testimony of Ms. Maiorca that the school nurse was not responsible for supervising STUDENT’s LVN.

17. It was pneumonia and respiratory distress that resulted in STUDENT’s hospitalization in 1999.

18. It was explained by Ms. Michel that at Fries, a “Concept 6" school, children who lived in the same neighborhood would generally be assigned to the same track.

19. There is no Ninth Circuit case on point, but most circuit courts that have decided the issue have held that the IEP team is required to consider the geographical proximity of the placement as just one of the factors upon which the placement decision should be based. The overriding rule is that placement decisions must be based upon the individual needs of the student.

20. In its closing argument, the District stated that it was prepared to offer STUDENT a placement on the A track at Harbor. That information does not constitute an offer to the Petitioner.

21. According to the testimony, changes might have to be made to the schedules for teachers and students in as many as six classrooms to accommodate STUDENT’s attendance in second grade.

22. The home schooling did not begin until some time after January 9, 2001.

23. The District had a continuing obligation to provide an appropriate education STUDENT. It learned in January that STUDENT had been withdrawn. It eventually began to provide limited home schooling, but there was no evidence that it did anything more to fulfill its obligation to educate STUDENT.