California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 14, 1998

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 376-97 · Hearing Officer Kathleen Peterson

Los Angeles Unified must fund Landmark West School after its one-period resource program offer was found to deny FAPE.

Split decision: student prevailed on 10 of 13 issuesVanaman German LLP represented the student

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 13-year-old with a specific learning disability (dyslexia and dysgraphia) filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. The boy had always attended private schools and had been at Landmark West School, a nonpublic school for students with dyslexia, since February 1996. In 1997 the District assessed him and offered regular education with one period a day of resource specialist program (RSP) support at Parkman Middle School.

Hearing Officer Kathleen Peterson found flaws in the assessment. No professional observed him in class, and some tests were given outside their norms or by an assessor not trained to score them. But the District still correctly identified his needs, so these flaws did not deny FAPE. The IEP was another matter. The District did not invite his Landmark teacher, as California law required. That seriously limited his mother's participation. The goals were also inappropriate: he had already substantially met the reading goal, there were no goals for spelling or writing, and the objectives had no measurable criteria. On substance, one RSP period would not give the all-day support and changes to lecture-style teaching he needed, and would give only de minimis benefit. Landmark gave him real benefit, and no equitable factors weighed against reimbursement. The District was ordered to reimburse Landmark costs from March 12, 1997 through 1997-98 and pay any unpaid 1997-98 costs.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This case shows how SEHO applied the California rule requiring a privately placed student's current teacher at the IEP meeting. It also shows that only services written into the IEP counted, not what the resource teacher said she would do. Goals the student had already met, or that lacked measurable criteria, supported both a procedural and a substantive denial of FAPE.

Issues and holdings

  1. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment

    Issue I. Did the District fail to provide a FAPE by failing to conduct the type of assessment required by law, including a full and complete assessment of the student's ability level so there can be a full understanding of his learning needs?

    No classroom observation by a team member other than a teacher, a report missing observation statements, and tests given off-norm or by an untrained assessor were procedural violations. But the District still identified the student's needs, so there was no denial of FAPE. Not using an IQ test was not itself improper.

  2. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue II.A. Did the District violate the IDEA in developing the March 12, 1997 IEP by failing to include the individuals required to be present for students with a learning disability in the IEP meeting?

    Education Code section 56341(b)(2) required the student's present Landmark teacher. The District did not invite one, and a credentialed program specialist could not substitute. This seriously infringed parent participation and denied FAPE.

  3. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue II.B. Did the District violate the IDEA by failing to include specific information about the student's current levels of educational performance within the classroom setting?

    The IEP had six paragraphs of present levels drawn from objective assessment data, which met the requirement.

  4. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue II.C.1. Did the IEP include only two generic goals and limited short-term objectives that contain no short-term objectives specific to the steps that must be taught to achieve the goals?

    The goals were inappropriate. The student had already substantially met the language arts goal, the vocational goal addressed no need, and the vocational objectives gave no way to achieve neatness. There were no goals for spelling or written expression.

  5. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue II.C.2. Do the goals and objectives provide no reference to the goals and objectives required to ensure that the student is able to function in academic and other classes throughout the school day?

    Goals were to be worked on only during one RSP period. The IEP lacked goals, objectives or modifications for the regular education teachers, even though the student's needs affected every class.

  6. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue II.C.3. Are the goals and objectives not specific as to the level and/or percentage of compliance anticipated?

    The objectives gave no measure of achievement, such as a percentage or a level like fully or partially achieved.

  7. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue II.C.4. Do the goals and objectives fail to specify the objective criteria to be utilized to determine whether the short-term objectives are being achieved?

    'Observation' and 'informal assessment' were not objective criteria, and there was no evidence of how they would be used. Together with the other goal defects, this caused educational loss and denied FAPE.

  8. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue II.D. Did the District fail to include a statement of the specific special education and related services to be provided and the extent to which the student will participate in the regular educational program?

    Leaving the services and the extent of regular education participation out of the written IEP was a procedural violation. It did not deny FAPE because everyone understood the offer to be one RSP period a day.

  9. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue III. To comply with the IDEA, must the student's IEP contain additional goals, short-term objectives, and classroom modifications?

    The IEP must contain additional appropriate goals, objectives, and classroom modifications beyond those in the March 12, 1997 IEP. Petitioner asked only for this finding, not for the Hearing Officer to write the goals.

  10. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue IV. Does a resource specialist program (RSP) on a regular high school [middle school] campus provide an educational program which can effectively address the appropriate goals and objectives for the student and provide him with a FAPE?

    One RSP period a day, with no all-day support, no teaching-method modifications, and no small-group instruction in the IEP, did not meet the student's unique needs and would give only de minimis benefit. FAPE was denied for 1996-97 and 1997-98.

  11. Issue V. Did the student require placement in a nonpublic school setting from the time of the IEP meeting on March 12, 1997, and must the placement continue for the 1997-98 school year?

    Landmark West was appropriate under Rowley and Burlington for March 12, 1997 through 1997-98 because it gave educational benefit. The 1997 amendments' prior-notice rule did not apply.

  12. Issue VI. Is the District required to reimburse the family for the full costs of the Landmark West School from March 12, 1997, through the end of the 1996-97 school year?

    No equitable considerations weighed against reimbursement. The parent's goal of funding, the siblings' attendance at Landmark, and the parent's late awareness of her rights did not bar full reimbursement.

  13. Issue VII. Is the District required to pay the actual and full costs of the student's attendance at the Landmark West School for the 1997-98 school year?

    Treated as a reimbursement claim. The District must reimburse 1997-98 costs already paid and pay the rest of the 1997-98 costs.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 60 days of receiving receipts, the District must reimburse the parents for the full costs of Landmark West School from March 12, 1997 through the end of the 1996-97 school year.
  • Reimbursement. Within 60 days of receiving receipts, the District must reimburse the parents for the full costs of Landmark West School for the 1997-98 school year, to the extent the parents have already paid.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. To the extent the parents have not already paid, the District must assume the full costs of Landmark West School for the rest of the 1997-98 school year.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. Texas Board of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Larry P. v. Riles; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16; M.C. v. Central Regional School District; Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1st Cir. 1984); Landgraf v. USI Film Products

People named in the decision

  • Terri Veasman, District school psychologist (assessor), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Paul Carr, Coordinator of psychological services, West Valley special education unit (District representative at hearing), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Richelle Skerczak, RSP teacher, Parkman Middle School, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Dan Saborio, Program specialist; teacher designee at IEP meeting, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Holly Seery, School nurse (health assessment), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Leah Ellenberg, Clinical neuropsychologist; private evaluator and expert witness for Student, Private practice
  • Nita (Nina) Ferjo, Educational psychologist; private evaluator and expert witness for Student, Private practice, Westwood
  • Benjamin Shifrin, Headmaster, witness for Student, Landmark West School
  • Andrew Yellen, Private assessor (1994 evaluation), Private
  • Heidi Yellen, Private assessor (1994 evaluation), Private
  • Peter Lippert, World cultures teacher (provided report for assessment), Landmark West School
  • Kathy Teeter, Physical education teacher (provided report for assessment), Landmark West School
  • Karen Dzyak, Mathematics teacher (provided report for assessment), Landmark West School
  • Gisele Hayek, English teacher (provided report for assessment), Landmark West School
  • Elizabeth Anderson, Home economics teacher (provided report for assessment), Landmark West School
  • Landmark West School, Nonpublic school (parental placement)
  • Meadow Oaks, Private school previously attended

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Kathleen Peterson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Reseda, California, on August 7 and 8, 1997.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Jodi F. Ossen. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, Ms. PARENT. In addition to Ms. Ossen, attorney Valerie Vanaman was present on STUDENT’s behalf for part of the day on August 8, 1997.

Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (hereafter District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Howard Fulfrost. Also present on the District’s behalf was Paul Carr, coordinator of psychological services for the District’s West Valley special education unit.

The following witnesses were called by the Petitioner to testify: Terri Veasman, District school psychologist; Ms. PARENT; STUDENT; Dr. Nita Ferjo, educational psychologist; Benjamin Shifrin, Landmark West School headmaster; and Dr. Leah Ellenberg, clinical neuropsychologist.

The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Ms. Veasman; Dr. Richelle Skerczak, District resource specialist program (RSP) teacher; and Dan Saborio, District program specialist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. On September 15, 1997, the Hearing Office received the closing arguments, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

I. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to conduct the type of assessment required by law, including a full and complete assessment of STUDENT’s ability level so that there can be a full understanding of his learning needs?

II. Did the District violate the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) in developing the individualized educational program (IEP) for STUDENT on March 12, 1997, by: A. Failing to include the individuals required to be present for students with a learning disability in the IEP meeting; B. Failing to include specific information about STUDENT’s current levels of educational performance within the classroom setting; C. Including only two goals and limited short-term objectives which are generic in nature and which: 1. Contain no short-term objectives specific to the steps that must be taught to achieve the goals; 2. Provide no reference to the goals and objectives required to ensure that STUDENT is able to function in academic and other classes throughout the day; 3. Are not specific as to the level and/or percentage of compliance anticipated; and 4. Fail to specify the objective criteria to be utilized to determine whether or not the short-term objectives are being achieved; and D. Failing to include a statement of the specific special education and related services to be provided to STUDENT and the extent to which he will be participating in the regular educational program?

III. To comply with the IDEA, must STUDENT’s IEP contain additional goals, short-term objectives, and classroom modifications?

IV. Does a resource specialist program (RSP) on a regular high school campus provide an educational program which can effectively address the appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT and provide him with a FAPE?

V. Did STUDENT require placement in a nonpublic school setting from the time of the IEP meeting on March 12, 1997, and must the placement continue for the 1997-98 school year?

VI. Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT’s family for the full costs of the Landmark West School from March 12, 1997, through the end of the 1996-97 school year?

VII. Is the District required to pay the actual and full costs of STUDENT’s attendance at the Landmark West School for the 1997-98 school year?

BACKGROUND

STUDENT is a 13-year-old boy who is eligible for special education services because of a specific learning disability. STUDENT currently attends Landmark West School, a certified nonpublic school for dyslexic students, along with several of his siblings.

STUDENT has never attended a public school. For the first six years of his education, STUDENT attended Meadow Oaks, a private school. STUDENT had difficulties with reading and, in early 1994 (fourth grade), STUDENT’s parents paid for an assessment by Andrew and Heidi Yellen, in order to determine the nature of the processing difficulties that were causing him to struggle in school. The assessors administered several tests to STUDENT, including the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III), and they observed him at Meadow Oaks. The Yellens concluded that STUDENT was suffering from a learning disability that included dyslexia and dysgraphia. The Yellens made several recommendations for STUDENT while he continued at Meadow Oaks. Thereafter, Meadow Oaks began providing help to STUDENT through that school’s own “resource program,” as well as through after-school assistance. STUDENT’s parents also provided educational therapy for STUDENT. Despite this extra help, STUDENT continued to experience difficulties with reading and writing.

In January 1996 (sixth grade), STUDENT’s parents had him evaluated by a neuropsychologist to further clarify his diagnosis. Dr. Leah Ellenberg, Ph.D., conducted the neuropsychological evaluation. Dr. Ellenberg administered a number of tests and concluded that STUDENT had superior abilities in nonverbal and visual areas, and that his problem areas included a severe deficit in phonetically-based linguistic retrieval, a moderate to severe deficit in verbal memory, and a moderate to severe deficit in reading. Dr. Ellenberg recommended that STUDENT attend Landmark West School, which she described as a private school designed for bright children who are dyslexic. In February 1996, STUDENT’s parents moved him to Landmark West School.

In December 1996, STUDENT’s parents requested that the District conduct an initial assessment of STUDENT and convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of offering him an appropriate placement. In January 1997, the District obtained parental consent for the assessment plan, and school psychologist Terri Veasman conducted the evaluation of STUDENT. The District has a policy against administering intellectual ability tests to its students; therefore, Ms. Veasman did not use any standardized intelligence testing instruments, such as the WISC-III, in her testing of STUDENT. Instead, Ms. Veasman used alternative test instruments to estimate STUDENT’s cognitive ability. She concluded that STUDENT suffered from a deficit between ability and achievement, which qualified him for special education services because of a specific learning disability. On March 12, 1997, the District convened STUDENT’s first IEP meeting, at which the team agreed that he was eligible for special education services because of his specific learning disability. None of STUDENT’s Landmark teachers was present at the IEP meeting. The District offered to place STUDENT in one period of RSP at a District school, Parkman Middle School. STUDENT’s mother disagreed with the placement offered by the District in the IEP. STUDENT’s parents decided to keep him at Landmark, which he currently attends.

On April 2, 1997, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from attorney Jodi F. Ossen on behalf of STUDENT. The matter was taken off calendar by agreement of the parties so that the parties could participate in mediation. The parties were unable to resolve their disagreement informally, and the matter was scheduled for hearing on dates selected by the parties and approved by the Hearing Office. The day before the hearing convened, another private assessment of STUDENT was conducted by Dr. Nina Ferjo, educational psychologist. Dr. Ferjo concluded that STUDENT has a specific learning disability, specifically, a dyslexic protocol with secondary dysgraphia.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

I. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to conduct the type of assessment required by law, including a full and complete assessment of STUDENT’s ability level so that there can be a full understanding of his learning needs?

The Petitioner contends that the District failed to conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in January 1997 because the District failed to use a multidisciplinary evaluation team that included STUDENT’s regular teacher from Landmark. The Petitioner further contends that the District’s sole assessor, school psychologist Terri Veasman, failed to observe STUDENT in his educational setting at Landmark. The Petitioner asserts that the District failed to assess STUDENT’s ability because of its policy of refusing to administer standardized intelligence testing. The Petitioner further asserts that the test instruments used to estimate STUDENT’s ability were inadequate or administered improperly and that, therefore, the District could not have had a full understanding of his abilities and learning needs. The Petitioner also contends that the written report of the assessment results failed to contain statements of whether STUDENT has a specific learning disability and the basis for that determination, his relevant behavior noted during the observation, and the relationship of his behavior to his academic functioning.

The District contends that it utilized a multidisciplinary evaluation team that included several of STUDENT’s Landmark teachers because Ms. Veasman considered observation reports by those teachers in her report. The District further contends that STUDENT’s mother was a member of the multidisciplinary evaluation team and that her observation report contained in a parent questionnaire fulfills the requirement of having an evaluation team member observe STUDENT’s academic performance in the classroom. The District asserts that Ms. Veasman reviewed STUDENT’s record, which contained reports of previously administered evaluations that had utilized intellectual testing, and that, based on the assessment and review of records, Ms. Veasman obtained a full understanding of STUDENT’s needs. The District also contends that the written report of the assessment includes all required statements.

Multidisciplinary Evaluation Team

Under federal regulations that interpret the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA(Footnote 2)), an initial evaluation of a child who is suspected of requiring special education services must assess all areas of suspected disability. (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(f); California Education Code § 56320(f).) The school district must ensure that the evaluation is done by a multidisciplinary team that includes at least one teacher or specialist with knowledge in the area in which the student is suspected of having a disability. (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(e).) When a child is suspected of having a specific learning disability, the multidisciplinary evaluation team “shall” include the child’s regular teacher or a teacher qualified to teach a child of similar age, and at least one person who is qualified to conduct individual diagnostic evaluations of children, such as a school psychologist. (34 C.F.R. § 300.540.)

On the one hand, the Petitioner contends that the District did not utilize a multidisciplinary evaluation team because it used only one assessor, District school psychologist Terri Veasman, to evaluate STUDENT. (There is no dispute that the school nurse, Holly Seery, R.N., conducted a health assessment of STUDENT as part of his District evaluation; therefore, Ms. Seery was also part of STUDENT’s evaluation team.) On the other hand, the District contends that the multidisciplinary evaluation team for STUDENT included not only Ms. Veasman and Ms. Seery, but also Dr. Leah Ellenberg and Andrew and Heidi Yellen, by virtue of the fact that Ms. Veasman reviewed private assessments previously conducted by Dr. Ellenberg and the Yellens. The District’s concept of the “multidisciplinary team” is mistaken. A review of previously conducted assessments does not necessarily cause the authors of those assessments to become part of the multidisciplinary evaluation team. Perhaps if the private assessors were given an opportunity to discuss with Ms. Veasman the results of their testing and their recommendations, and the assessments were current, they could be deemed to be part of the team currently evaluating STUDENT. There is no evidence that there was any discussion between Ms. Veasman and either Dr. Ellenberg or the Yellens or that their assessments were done as part of, or concurrently with, the District’s assessment. In fact, the assessment by the Yellens was conducted during the first three months of 1994, fully three years prior to the evaluation being done for STUDENT by the District in 1997. What Ms. Veasman did was review the records of other professionals’ reports -- something which should be done -- however, her review of their reports did not transform these past assessors into members of the present multidisciplinary evaluation team. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s multidisciplinary evaluation team did not include either Dr. Leah Ellenberg or Andrew and Heidi Yellen.

The District also contends that several of STUDENT’s Landmark teachers were part of his multidisciplinary evaluation team. As part of the District’s assessment process, reports were also collected from several of STUDENT’s current Landmark teachers, including Peter Lippert (world cultures), Kathy Teeter (physical education), Karen Dzyak (mathematics), Gisele Hayek (English), and Elizabeth Anderson (home economics). (Dist. Exh. 10, 11, 12, 13, and 14(Footnote 3); testimony of Ms. Veasman.) The District asserts that these teachers were, therefore, also part of STUDENT’s multidisciplinary evaluation team. Although greater involvement in the evaluation team by STUDENT’s regular teacher at Landmark may have been ideal (since STUDENT has never been involved in a District school), there is no requirement in the law to have the multidisciplinary team meet face-to-face (as there is for the IEP team) in order to complete the evaluation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Landmark teachers whose reports were solicited and considered as part of the District’s assessment were part of STUDENT’s multidisciplinary evaluation team. The Hearing Officer also finds that because STUDENT had more than one teacher at Landmark and, hence, had no one “regular” teacher, the inclusion of the numerous reports from his Landmark teachers fulfills the requirement of having his “regular” teacher as a member of the evaluation team.

Observation of STUDENT

At least one member of the multidisciplinary team, other than the student’s regular teacher, “shall” observe the student’s academic performance in the regular classroom setting when a student is suspected of having a specific learning disability. (34 C.F.R. § 300.542(a).) STUDENT was suspected of having a specific learning disability in reading. Although the reports by STUDENT’s Landmark teachers contain important information that should be considered, the observation required as part of the initial evaluation for a student suspected of having a specific learning disability must be conducted by someone other than the student’s teacher. Therefore, any observation reports by STUDENT’s Landmark teachers will not fulfill this requirement.

The District asserts that STUDENT’s mother was a member of the multidisciplinary evaluation team and that her parent questionnaire, which provided information regarding her observation of STUDENT in his regular classroom setting, fulfills the requirement of a team member observation. Unlike the regulations regarding the makeup of an IEP team, which explicitly call for the participation of parents of children with disabilities, the regulations regarding the makeup of a multidisciplinary evaluation team do not similarly explicitly include parents. (34 C.F.R. §§ 300.344, 300.532(e), and 300.540.) If Congress had meant for the multidisciplinary evaluation team to include the child’s parent, it could have stated so, as it did with the IEP team, but it did not so state. Therefore, the logical conclusion is that Congress did not intend for parents to be a formal part of the evaluation team. Furthermore, the purpose of the evaluation team is to gather together specialists with knowledge of the child’s suspected disability, such as teachers, school psychologists, and speech and language pathologists. (34 C.F.R. §§ 300.532(e) and 300.540.) In other words, the team is made up of professionals whose business it is to evaluate, using sophisticated testing materials and instruments, as well as their professional experience. The fact that STUDENT’s mother filled out a parent questionnaire does not fulfill the District’s obligation to have a professional multidisciplinary evaluation team member (other than his teacher) observe him in his regular classroom. The purpose of having a professional, other than the student’s regular teacher, observe the student in class is to gain a firsthand professional understanding of how the student interacts in the classroom environment. In fact, Ms. Veasman testified that 95% of the time, she observes students as part of her assessments, but that she did not observe STUDENT because she felt she had enough information. The District did not claim that any other evaluation team member observed STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to have a member of the multidisciplinary evaluation team (other than his teacher) observe STUDENT as part of his initial District assessment.

Standardized Intelligence Testing

The District has a policy against administering standardized intelligence tests to any of its students, in response to the decision in Larry P. v. Riles, 495 F.Supp. 926 (N.D. CA 1979), aff’d in part, rev’d in part, 793 F.2d 969 (9th Cir. 1984), and resulting settlement which prohibits the use of such testing instruments with students of African-American descent. STUDENT is not African-American, but because of the District’s policy, Ms. Veasman did not use a standardized intelligence test with him. The purpose of using standardized intelligence tests is to estimate a student’s cognitive ability. No test is perfect. Although the use of standardized intelligence tests may be a simpler and more direct way of estimating cognitive ability, it is by no means the only acceptable way of doing so. If administered properly, other tests can give an assessor an understanding of a student’s cognitive ability.

District school psychologist Terri Veasman has a master’s degree in school psychology, a lifetime elementary school teaching credential, and a pupil personnel services credential, and has completed a one-year internship at the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute. She has worked as a school psychologist for the District since 1981. To estimate STUDENT’s cognitive ability and achievement level, Ms. Veasman used several measures of assessment, including the Matrix Analogies Test (MAT), the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), the Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised (PIAT-R), the Bender-Gestalt for Young Children, the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills-Upper Level (TAPS), the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test-Upper Extension, the Sentence Completion test, the Draw-A-Person test, the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scales (observation forms completed by teachers), other teacher reports, reports of observations, and work and language samples. (Pet. Exh. 12, at p. 110(Footnote 4); testimony of Ms. Veasman.) Primarily relying upon the results obtained on the MAT and the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test (tests she used as alternative measures of cognitive ability), Ms. Veasman concluded that STUDENT’s general ability was “within the above average range.” (Pet. Exh. 12, at p. 110; testimony of Ms. Veasman.)

Also available to Ms. Veasman were results from previous testing of STUDENT by Andrew and Heidi Yellen and Dr. Leah Ellenberg, which included standardized intelligence testing. (Pet. Exh. 2 and 3.) The District’s policy against administering standardized intelligence testing did not forbid Ms. Veasman from considering the results of such “I.Q.” testing by other entities. (Testimony of Ms. Veasman.) Ms. Veasman considered the results of the tests administered by the Yellens and Dr. Ellenberg in her evaluation of STUDENT. (Pet. Exh. 12, at p. 109; testimony of Ms. Veasman.)

Ms. Veasman noted that, in her own testing, STUDENT scored in the above average range for nonverbal reasoning and visual processing, and that he scored in the low average range for auditory memory. (Pet. Exh. 12, at p. 111.) Ms. Veasman concluded that a significant discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s cognitive ability and his achievement in reading (using the test results of the PIAT-R) that qualified him for special education services on the basis of a specific learning disability.(Footnote 5) (Id.) Ms. Veasman testified that STUDENT’s specific learning disability was in auditory processing -- particularly, auditory memory. In her report, Ms. Veasman recommended that STUDENT receive small group and individualized instruction in reading and written language and that distractions be minimized. (Pet. Exh. 12, at p. 111; testimony of Ms. Veasman.)

Dr. Leah Ellenberg is a clinical neuropsychologist who has a private practice that specializes in child neuropsychology. She has a Ph.D., is a licensed psychologist, and has authored several articles concerning child neuropsychology and learning disabilities. Dr. Ellenberg is on the evaluation referral list for several private schools, including Landmark. (Testimony of Ms. Veasman.) Dr. Ellenberg expressed concerns in her testimony about the MAT’s norming and scoring. She also indicated that the MAT is not heavily used and that the WISC-III provides more information regarding dyslexics than the MAT. Ms. Veasman acknowledged that the MAT tests nonverbal reasoning and does not strictly correlate to any of the subtests on the WISC-III. Although the Petitioner contends that Ms. Veasman’s reliance on the MAT as an estimate of STUDENT’s cognitive ability and the District’s failure to use standardized intelligence testing doomed the results of the District’s assessment, the Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Veasman’s conclusion regarding cognitive ability was identical to Dr. Ellenberg’s. Dr. Ellenberg concluded (based on results from the WISC-III) that STUDENT’s cognitive ability was in the above average range, just as Ms. Veasman had estimated using the MAT. Therefore, Dr. Ellenberg’s concerns about the MAT’s norming and scoring are unpersuasive.

Although both Dr. Ellenberg’s and Ms. Veasman’s conclusions regarding STUDENT’s cognitive ability indicate a drop in that ability since the time of the Yellens’ evaluation done in 1994, Dr. Ellenberg explained the reason for the change in her report. She said that STUDENT’s lowered performance IQ scores were due to drops in subtests which require “considerably more rapid performance to achieve high scores at age 11 that [sic] they do at age 9.” (Pet. Exh. 3, at p. 46.) Therefore, Ms. Veasman’s estimate of STUDENT’s cognitive ability is consistent with previous results. Furthermore, Ms. Veasman’s consideration of STUDENT’s previous standardized intelligence testing increases the credibility of her estimate of his cognitive ability. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to use standardized intelligence testing to estimate STUDENT’s cognitive ability in its own assessment did not in itself cause his assessment to be inappropriate.

The District’s Use of Particular Tests to Determine STUDENT’s Abilities and Learning Needs

The law requires that school districts assess children in all areas of suspected disability. (34 C.F.R. § 300.5323(f); California Education Code § 56320(f).) The District assessed STUDENT in his area of suspected disability -- a specific learning disability in the area of reading. Tests are to be validated for the specific purpose for which they are utilized and administered by trained personnel in conformance with the test producer’s instructions. (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(a)(2) and (3); California Education Code § 56320(a)(2)(3).) Here, the Petitioner contends that the tests Ms. Veasman used to determine STUDENT’s cognitive ability and achievement level were not administered in accordance with their instructions and that Ms. Veasman was not trained in using one of the subtests administered.

The Petitioner presented evidence of instances in which Ms. Veasman failed to administer testing instruments in accordance with their instructions. Dr. Ellenberg pointed out Ms. Veasman had noted STUDENT’s age on the MAT protocol as eight years old, when he was actually four years older. Ms. Veasman stated that this was simply a clerical error. Dr. Ellenberg noted that the MAT is administered to children up to age 17, and that it seemed to her that the upper end of the scores were excluded by the way the test was normed because STUDENT received all correct scores on “Serial Reasoning,” yet he received a standard score of only 12 for that area. Ms. Veasman testified that this score was correct, according to the way the test is normed.

Ms. Veasman acknowledged that she administered a form of the Bender Gestalt to STUDENT even though this test was normed for children up to ages 11 years, 11 months, and STUDENT was already 12 years, 8 months, at the time of his testing. She noted in her report that he scored no errors on this test, and she concluded that he had no visual-motor coordination problems. (Pet. Exh. 12, at p. 109.)

Ms. Veasman also acknowledged that she did not follow “to the letter” the instructions for the One-Word Expressive Vocabulary Test-Upper Extension, which she administered to assist her in estimating STUDENT’s cognitive ability. Ms. Veasman failed to include all of STUDENT’s responses on the protocol, even though the test producer instructs the administrator to do so. (Pet. Exh. 19, at p. 145; testimony of Ms. Veasman.)

The Petitioner also presented evidence of Ms. Veasman’s lack of training to administer one of the subtests she used with STUDENT. To support Ms. Veasman’s conclusion that STUDENT exhibited a discrepancy between ability and achievement, she relied upon the results of the PIAT-R. Ms. Veasman acknowledged that she had never before administered the written expression subtest of the PIAT-R and that she had not been trained in its complete scoring, but that she attempted to administer it to STUDENT anyway. Ms. Veasman testified that because this subtest was new to her, she did not finish scoring it; despite this fact, she assigned STUDENT a raw score of 39 and a stanine of 6 on the subtest.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the Bender Gestalt for Young Children and the One-Word Expressive Vocabulary Test-Upper Extension were not administered in conformance with the instructions provided by their producer and that the written expression subtest of the PIAT-R was administered by someone without the proper training. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District violated evaluation procedure requirements.

However, as far as actually identifying STUDENT’s abilities and needs, there is substantial credible evidence in the assessment and testimony of Ms. Veasman that, despite any procedural problems with the assessment, the District identified STUDENT’s areas of suspected disability, abilities, and needs. Ms. Veasman noted in her assessment report that the Yellens concluded that STUDENT had a language-based learning disability -- specifically, dyslexia and dysgraphia. (Pet. Exh. 12, at p. 109.) She also indicated that Dr. Ellenberg found that STUDENT had superior abilities in nonverbal problem-solving and visual spatial analysis, average to above-average general language skills, and neuropsychological deficits in phonetically-based linguistic retrieval, verbal memory, and academic achievement in reading. (Id.)

After Ms. Veasman conducted her own testing, she concluded that STUDENT scored in the “low average” range in auditory memory. (Pet. Exh. 12, at p. 111.) She also noted relative strengths in STUDENT’s nonverbal reasoning, visual motor coordination, and expressive vocabulary, and relative weaknesses in his auditory processing and reading recognition. (Pet. Exh. 12, at p. 110; testimony of Ms. Veasman.) Ms. Veasman found that STUDENT scored above average in mathematical computation and she noted that previous testing also indicated that this was an area of strength for him. (Pet. Exh. 12, at p. 110.)

The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Veasman and Dr. Ellenberg (as well as the Yellens) similarly identified STUDENT as suffering from a specific learning disability in reading. Ms. Veasman identified auditory memory as an area of weakness for STUDENT, as did Dr. Ellenberg. Ms. Veasman identified nonverbal reasoning/problem-solving, visual motor integration, and mathematical computation as areas of strength for STUDENT, as did Dr. Ellenberg. Ms. Veasman testified that she agreed with essentially all of Dr. Ellenberg’s conclusions about STUDENT in her summary. The Petitioner is concerned that certain abilities were not recognized in STUDENT because the District failed to use the WISC-III, with its many subtests. Although Dr. Ellenberg expressed preferences for certain tests over others, the Petitioner provided no evidence that any instruments used by the District were inherently unreliable. Despite the procedural problems associated with the District’s evaluation, its conclusions are nearly identical in content to Dr. Ellenberg’s. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that despite certain procedural violations in the administration of the District’s assessment, the District was able to gain a full understanding of STUDENT’s abilities and needs.

Written Evaluation Report

With students suspected of having a specific learning disability, once the evaluation is conducted, the multidisciplinary team is to prepare a written report which must contain certain specific statements regarding the student, including the following:

(1) Whether the child has a specific learning disability;

(2) The basis for making the determination;

(3) The relevant behavior noted during the observation of the child; (4) The relationship of that behavior to the child’s academic functioning; (5) The educationally relevant medical findings, if any;

(6) Whether there is a severe discrepancy between achievement and ability that is not correctable without special education and related services; and (7) The determination of the team concerning the effects of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage.

(34 C.F.R. § 300.543(b).)

Here, the Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s evaluation report written by Ms. Veasman fails to contain the first four items listed above. Ms. Veasman’s evaluation report indicates her belief that STUDENT meets the criteria for special education eligibility as learning disabled. (Pet. Exh. 12, at p. 111.) As the basis for her determination, Ms. Veasman states in her summary that she found a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of reading and that this discrepancy could not be corrected through services within the regular instructional program. (Id.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s written evaluation report states whether STUDENT suffers from a specific learning disability and the basis for that determination.

However, as to the requirement of stating the relevant behavior noted during the observation of STUDENT and the relationship of that behavior to his academic functioning, it is impossible for the written evaluation to contain such statements because neither Ms. Veasman nor any other formal, professional member of the evaluation team made any such observation of STUDENT. Although Ms. Veasman indicates her observations of STUDENT made during the testing (indicating his willingness to cooperate and his pleasant attitude), this is not the “observation” to which the statement is to refer. The “observation” referred to here is the one that should have been made by an evaluation team member (other than STUDENT’s teacher) of STUDENT’s classroom performance; it does not refer to just the psychologist’s observations of the student’s behavior during testing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s written evaluation report fails to state STUDENT’s relative behavior noted during his observation and the relationship of that behavior to his academic functioning. In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District utilized a multidisciplinary evaluation team, including STUDENT’s Landmark teachers, to assess him; the District failed to have an evaluation team member, other than his teacher, conduct an observation of STUDENT in his classroom environment; the District’s failure to use standardized intelligence testing did not, in itself, cause STUDENT’s evaluation to be inappropriate; despite procedural violations during the evaluation, the District was able to gain a full understanding of STUDENT’s abilities and needs; and the District’s written evaluation report failed to state STUDENT’s relative behavior noted during his observation and the relationship of that behavior to his academic functioning.

The Petitioner’s purpose in putting forth its contentions regarding the District’s assessment was to support a finding of a denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE). Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and federal regulations implementing the IDEA. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300 et seq.) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP.” (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205-206, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982).) Procedural violations which result in a “loss of educational opportunity” or which “seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE.” (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).) Procedural violations which do not result in such educational loss for the student or an infringement upon parental participation in the IEP process are insufficient to support a finding that the student has been denied a FAPE.

The Hearing Officer finds that even viewing together the procedural violations surrounding the assessment, there is no evidence that they resulted in educational loss for STUDENT or that they infringed upon his parents’ participation in the IEP process. Though the evaluation was imperfect, the District ultimately achieved the general purpose of a special education evaluation -- identifying a student’s abilities and needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE on the basis of the District’s failure to have a multidisciplinary evaluation team member observe him in class and its failure to state in the evaluation report STUDENT’s relative behavior noted during his observation and the relationship of that behavior to his academic functioning.

II. Did the District violate the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) in developing the IEP for STUDENT on March 12, 1997, by: A. Failing to include the individuals required to be present for students with a learning disability in the IEP meeting; B. Failing to include specific information about STUDENT’s current levels of educational performance within the classroom setting; C. Including only two goals and limited short-term objectives which are generic in nature and which: 1. Contain no short-term objectives specific to the steps that must be taught to achieve the goals; 2. Provide no reference to the goals and objectives required to ensure that STUDENT is able to function in academic and other classes throughout the school day; 3. Are not specific as to the level and/or percentage of compliance anticipated; and 4. Fail to specify the objective criteria to be utilized to determine whether or not the short-term objectives are being achieved; and D. Failing to include a statement of the specific special education and related services to be provided to STUDENT and the extent to which he will be participating in the regular educational program?

Once the evaluation report is generated by the multidisciplinary evaluation team, an individualized education program (IEP) team meeting is to be convened to discuss the evaluation report, make recommendations for the student’s program and placement, and discuss the reasons for those recommendations. (34 C.F.R. § 300.343; California Education Code § 56329(a).)

Need for STUDENT’s Teacher at his IEP Team Meeting

For a child who has been evaluated for the first time, federal regulations state that the IEP team (as opposed to the multidisciplinary evaluation team) “shall” include the following: a school district representative who is qualified to provide or supervise the provision of special education (other than the child’s teacher); the child’s teacher; one or both of the child’s parents; the child (if appropriate); and a member of the multidisciplinary evaluation team or someone who is knowledgeable about the evaluation procedures used with the child and familiar with the evaluation results. (34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(1)-(4) and (b).)

The Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s March 12, 1997 IEP team meeting failed to include the personnel required by law for a student with a learning disability because the District failed to ensure that STUDENT’s teacher from Landmark was present. The District contends that the teacher designee at the IEP meeting was program specialist Dan Saborio, who is also a credentialed special education teacher, and that his presence fulfilled the requirement of having a teacher present. The District does not contend that any of STUDENT’s Landmark teachers were present at his IEP team meeting.

The District contends that a note addendum to the federal regulations allows Mr. Saborio to fulfill the requirement of having STUDENT’s teacher present. The District cites this note for the proposition that the District may choose to have at the IEP meeting a “teacher qualified to provide education in the type of program in which the child may be placed,” instead of the child’s regular teacher. (Note 1 to 34 C.F.R. § 300.344.) Mr. Saborio testified that he has a learning handicapped credential to teach students of STUDENT’s age. Mr. Saborio stated that the District compiles an IEP team which includes a school psychologist and holds up to six IEP meetings during one day for students who are not enrolled in District schools, and acknowledged that the only person at STUDENT’s IEP meeting who had ever seen him (other than his mother) was the school psychologist who had conducted his assessment.

The Hearing Officer notes that unlike the note addendum to the federal regulations, state law does not similarly provide such leeway to school districts regarding the participation of the student’s teacher at IEP meetings. Under California law, the IEP team must include:

. . .

(2) The pupil’s present teacher. If the pupil does not presently have a teacher, this representative shall be the teacher with the most recent and complete knowledge of the pupil who has also observed the pupil’s educational performance in an appropriate setting. If no teacher is available, this representative shall be a regular classroom teacher referring the pupil, or a special education teacher qualified to teach a pupil of his or her age.

. . .

(California Education Code § 56341(b)(2).)

From the language, it is clear that the authors of the state law wanted to have the student’s current teacher at the IEP meeting, and that if (and only if) the student did not presently have a teacher, they required the presence of the teacher who had the most contact with the student. Furthermore, it is clear that only when “no” teacher who has complete knowledge of the student is available should a teacher qualified to teach children of the student’s age attend the IEP meeting instead. Courts have recognized that states may adopt substantive and procedural standards that are higher than those provided for by federal special education law. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982); Town of Burlington v. Department of Education for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, 736 F.2d 773 (1st Cir. 1984), aff’d, 471 U.S. 359, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985).) Therefore, because the California provision provides more protection for the student in this case, it will control the resolution of this issue. Furthermore, there is no indication that “teacher” does not include private school teachers.

Here, STUDENT had a “present” teacher (at Landmark); therefore, his Landmark teacher should have been part of the IEP team. There is no evidence that his Landmark teacher was not “available.” The District states that it has no control over private school teachers at Landmark, presumably to “force” one to attend an IEP meeting. Whether the District has such power is not the issue, because there was no evidence that the District even invited any of STUDENT’s Landmark teachers to the IEP meeting. (Testimony of Mr. Shifrin.) The importance of the presence of STUDENT’s Landmark teacher at his very first IEP meeting with the District in this case is heightened because of the limitation of his teachers’ involvement during the assessment phase. In STUDENT’s assessment, teacher reports were given to school psychologist Terri Veasman, but she made no contact with his Landmark teachers. Furthermore, neither Ms. Veasman nor any other professional member of the evaluation team observed STUDENT in his Landmark class. Additionally, STUDENT was not attending a District school; therefore, the participation of his own teacher became more important than for a student who was simply going from a District regular education class into special education. These facts highlight the need to have one of STUDENT’s Landmark teachers present at his IEP meeting. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s use of a program specialist who also happens to be credentialed as a teacher did not fulfill the requirement of having STUDENT’s teacher at his IEP meeting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District violated the IDEA by failing to ensure that STUDENT’s teacher from Landmark participated in the IEP team meeting.

Current Levels of Educational Performance

The Petitioner contends that the District created a deficient IEP for STUDENT because it fails to include specific information regarding his current levels of educational performance in the classroom setting. The District contends that STUDENT’s IEP contains all statements required by law.

An IEP must contain a statement of the student’s present levels of educational performance. (34 C.F.R. § 300.346; California Education Code § 56345(a)(1).) The Hearing Officer notes that section 300.346 is interpreted in the appendix following Part 300 of the federal regulations and specifically refers to evaluation data as a “good source of such information,” because the statement of present levels of educational performance should be in “objective measurable terms.” (34 C.F.R. Appendix C to Part 300, Question 36.)

On Section D of STUDENT’s IEP (denoted “PRESENT LEVEL OF PERFORMANCE”), is the first of six separate numbered paragraphs delineating STUDENT’s current levels of educational performance, as found by his assessment. The first paragraph deals with his health assessment (including objective data regarding his physical attributes); the second paragraph (located on page two) concerns cognitive information (including the finding that STUDENT’s general ability is in the high average range); the third paragraph (also located on page two) lists his academic achievement scores on the WRAT-III and the PIAT-R, and some of his strengths and weaknesses, based on those objective criteria; the fourth paragraph (located on page three) notes his social-emotional status, including findings based on the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scale; the fifth paragraph (also located on page three) states his speech/language abilities, based on scores from the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills; and the sixth paragraph (also located on page three) describes his motor skills, based on findings of the Bender-Gestalt. (Pet. Exh. 14, at pp. 113-115.) Therefore, based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP dated March 12, 1997, contains a statement of his present levels of educational performance.

Goals and Objectives

The Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s IEP includes only two goals and limited short-term objectives, which are generic in nature. The Petitioner contends that the IEP is also deficient because it (1) contains no short-term objectives specific to the steps that must be taught to achieve the goals; (2) provides no reference to the goals and objectives required to ensure that STUDENT is able to function in academic and other classes throughout the school day; (3) is not specific as to the level and/or percentage of compliance anticipated; and (4) fails to specify the objective criteria to be utilized to determine whether or not the short-term objectives are being achieved.

There are two goals listed on STUDENT’s IEP dated March 12, 1997. (Pet. Exh. 14, at p. 116.) One goal is in the area of language arts and the other is in the area of vocational education. The language arts goal is stated as follows: “Will read teacher-selected materials with fluency & comprehension at 6th grade level.” The vocational education goal is stated as follows: “Will demonstrate work/study habits appropriate to the general education classroom setting.” For each of these goals, the special education teacher was to be the person responsible for implementing the goal.

There are two short-term objectives written for each goal on STUDENT’s IEP. The two short-term objectives written for his language arts goal are as follows: (a) “Will read unfamiliar words from low 5th grade vocabulary using a variety of decoding strategies including phonics, sight memory, context clues & analysis”, and (b) “Will read unfamiliar words from high 5th/low 6th grade vocabulary using a variety of decoding strategies including phonics, sight memory, context clues & analysis.” The two short-term objectives written for STUDENT’s vocational education goal are as follows: (a) “Will make full use of allocated time to complete assignments neatly”, and (b) “Will organize materials to be used.” The evaluation criteria to be used for all four of STUDENT’s short-term objectives are “observation” and “informal assessment.”

Ms. Veasman testified that writing goals and objectives on IEPs was not one of her functions, but she acknowledged that she had identified a need in written expression and that there was no goal written for STUDENT in this area. She also agreed that, based on one subtest of the WRAT-III she administered, spelling was also an area of need for STUDENT and that, although a goal in language arts was written, no goal was written specifically for spelling.

First, based on unrefuted testimony that STUDENT has needs in spelling and written expression, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to propose goals in areas of need for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer also finds that, as to the goals that were proposed, STUDENT’s vocational education goal is inappropriate because there was no evidence that he did not demonstrate work or study habits that were inappropriate to the general education setting. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the short-term objectives for this goal are inappropriate because, considering STUDENT’s written expression deficits, the objectives do not give any method of obtaining “neatness,” other than by “making full use of time,” which is not STUDENT’s problem.

Regarding the language arts goal, Mr. Shifrin indicated that STUDENT was already ahead of fifth grade vocabulary in December 1996 and was working on sixth grade vocabulary by March 1997, so that by the time of the IEP meeting on March 12, 1997, he had already substantially met this goal. There was no evidence contradicting Mr. Shifrin’s statement; therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s language arts goal was inappropriate for him. Further, federal regulations and state law require that the IEP contain appropriate objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, on at least an annual basis, whether those short-term instructional objectives are being achieved. (34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(5); California Education Code § 56345(a)(6).) There is no indication of how the short-term objectives for either goal would be objectively judged for achievement -- for example, by a percentage of achievement, fully, substantially, or partially achieved -- or even how they would be measured. No evidence was presented to show how the District planned to use “observation” or “informal assessment” to find out whether STUDENT was making progress on these objectives. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the short-term objectives written for both of STUDENT’s goals do not contain objective criteria for deciding whether he would have achieved the objectives.(Footnote 6)

The Petitioner contends that STUDENT needs goals and objectives that must be worked on all day long, in each of his classes (including regular education classes), because his reading, spelling, and written expression needs cause him problems in every class, not just in his RSP class. Testimony and other evidence established that STUDENT’s goals and objectives were to be worked on during his one period a day of RSP services. (Pet. Exh. 14, at p. 116; testimony of Mr. Saborio.) One of STUDENT’s weakest areas is auditory memory. In junior high school, regular education classes are generally taught through lecture, requiring a student to use auditory skills to take notes of lectures, assignments, tests, and other information. The Hearing Officer finds that, based on unrefuted testimony, STUDENT needs to have information repeated several times and in different ways in order to benefit from his education.

STUDENT, who testified on his own behalf, has not allowed his learning disabilities to significantly affect his self-esteem in his current environment. (Pet. Exh. 12; testimony of STUDENT.) However, faced with typical lecture teaching methods in his regular education classes (since no goals or modifications for regular education teachers are on his IEP), STUDENT could easily become frustrated and lose the positive attitude that he has today. A statement that differential proficiency standards applied (in which STUDENT would be allowed shortened assignments and extended time to complete assignments) is the only modification included on STUDENT’s IEP. (Pet. Exh. 14, at p. 113.) Based on the findings above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not include necessary goals and objectives and/or modifications to be implemented by STUDENT’s proposed regular education teachers on his IEP.

In summary, regarding STUDENT’s goals and objectives on his IEP dated March 12, 1997, the Hearing Officer finds that his vocational education goal is inappropriate because there was no evidence that he did not demonstrate work or study habits that were inappropriate to the general education setting; STUDENT’s language arts goal itself was inappropriate for him because by the time of the IEP meeting, he had substantially met this goal; the short-term objectives for STUDENT’s vocational education goal are inappropriate because, considering STUDENT’s written expression deficits, the objectives do not give any method of obtaining “neatness,” other than by “making full use of time,” which is not STUDENT’s problem; STUDENT’s short-term objectives for both his goals fail to contain objective criteria for deciding whether he would have achieved the objectives; and the District did not include necessary goals and objectives and/or modifications to be implemented by STUDENT’s proposed regular education teachers.

Statement of Extent in Regular Education

The Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s IEP contains no statement of the services to be provided or the extent to which he would be participating in regular education. The District contends that when a student is placed in RSP, the accepted implication is that the student is mainstreamed for the remainder of the day and that, therefore, STUDENT’s parents understood how much of the day he would be in regular education.

The Hearing Officer notes that nowhere on the IEP does the District indicate exactly how much of the day STUDENT was to participate in regular education or even the number of periods of RSP he was offered, except by inference from the goals and objectives. (Dist. Exh. 25.) Federal regulations and state law require a statement of the specific special education services to be provided and the extent to which the student will be able to participate in regular education. (34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(3); California Education Code § 56345(a)(3) and (4).) The IEP team members understood the District’s offer as one period per day of RSP (and the Petitioner’s arguments are based on that understanding). However, the Ninth Circuit has stated that one of the reasons for requiring school districts to put their placement offers in writing on students’ IEP documents was to avoid later disputes over what was actually offered at the IEP meeting. (Smith v. Union School District, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994).) For this reason, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed a procedural violation by failing to include a statement of the specific special education services to be provided and the amount of time STUDENT would be able to participate in regular education.

Summary

In summary, regarding Issue II, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed several procedural violations, including failing (1) to include STUDENT’s teacher in the IEP meeting held March 12, 1997, (2) to propose appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT, and (3) to include a statement of the specific special education services to be provided and the amount of time STUDENT would be able to participate in regular education in his IEP.

The issue now becomes whether these violations of the IDEA denied STUDENT a FAPE because it either resulted in educational loss for him or seriously infringed upon his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. (W.G., 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).) The Hearing Officer finds that the failure to include a statement of the specific services to be provided and the extent to which STUDENT would be able to participate in regular education did not result in educational loss for STUDENT or prevent his parents from participating in the IEP process, because the parties understood the District’s offer to be one period a day of RSP.

However, by failing to include STUDENT’s teacher in his IEP meeting, the District prevented the IEP team (including STUDENT’s mother) from being able to consider information that his teacher could provide regarding his performance in class and the appropriateness of Landmark as a possible placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that this procedural violation seriously infringed upon STUDENT’s parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. An individualized educational program of services is to be based upon appropriate goals and objectives. (34 C.F.R. § 300.346 and Appendix C to Part 300, Question 37.) By failing to propose appropriate goals and objectives, the District has nearly ruled out any chance of being able to offer STUDENT an appropriate program and placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the failure to propose appropriate goals and objectives resulted in educational loss for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concludes that the procedural violations of failing to include STUDENT’s Landmark teacher in his IEP meeting and its failure to propose appropriate goals and objectives denied him a FAPE.(Footnote 7)

The dates marked for the annual review of services and the duration of the goals on STUDENT’s IEP indicate that the District’s offer was for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year and the 1997-98 school year. (Pet. Exh. 14, at pp. 113 and 116.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that based on procedural violations, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years.

III. To comply with the IDEA, must STUDENT’s IEP contain additional goals, short-term objectives, and classroom modifications?

As found above, the goals and objectives written in STUDENT’s IEP dated March 12, 1997, were inappropriate for him. The evidence shows that STUDENT needed further goals which encompassed his work in classes other than just RSP, and that he required classroom modifications to the typical lecture-style teaching method. At the hearing, the Petitioner indicated that he was not requesting the Hearing Officer to create any needed goals but simply to make a finding on this issue. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that to comply with the IDEA, STUDENT’s IEP must contain additional appropriate goals, objectives, and classroom modifications beyond that included in his IEP dated March 12, 1997.

IV. Does a resource specialist program (RSP) on a regular high school campus provide an educational program which can effectively address the appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT and provide him with a FAPE?(Footnote 8)

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and federal regulations, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(c); 34 C.F.R. § 300.1(a).) Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.1; California Education Code § 56000.) Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards and are provided at public expense and in conformity with an appropriate individualized education program (IEP). (34 C.F.R. § 300.8.) “Related services” includes supportive services that are required to assist a student with a disability to benefit from special education. (34 C.F.R. § 300.16(a).) In California, related services are known as “designated instruction and services” (DIS). (California Education Code § 56363.)

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the Supreme Court decided the appropriate level of instruction and services that must be provided to students with disabilities in order to satisfy the IDEA. The Court held that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200.)

The analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to first decide whether procedural steps have been followed, and to then decide whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207.) The preceding issues have encompassed procedural aspects of this case. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will proceed to the substantive issue presented under Issue IV.

The standard for determining whether the District substantively proposed an appropriate placement for STUDENT involves four factors, as follows:

1. Whether the District’s placement was designed to meet the student’s unique needs; 2. Whether the District’s placement was designed to provide educational benefit to the student; 3. Whether the District’s placement conformed to the student’s IEP; and 4. Whether the District’s placement was designed to provide the student with an education in the least restrictive environment.

(20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)

STUDENT’s Unique Needs

As noted above, STUDENT’s strengths include his nonverbal reasoning skills, his mathematics reasoning ability, and his general overall cognitive ability. STUDENT’s weaknesses in reading include auditory memory (especially), written expression, and spelling. Based on the overwhelming preponderance of evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs include the following: special accommodations and alternative teaching styles, instead of the use of typical lecture-oriented teaching; strategies throughout the day that will allow him to tap into his very useful strengths -- e.g., using context to give him clues as to the meaning of words and the use of visual information over textual; a computer to help with his written expression problems, with a spell checker to help with his spelling needs; support throughout the day because he is in junior high school, encountering several classes a day; participation methods that allow him to do hands-on work instead of written reports, due to his written expression problems; receiving instructions several times; receiving copies of overheads and lecture notes to help him “get” what is said in class; small group and individualized instruction when it is necessary for STUDENT to encounter those tasks which stretch his abilities to the limit -- e.g., reading and written expression. In junior high school, these tasks arise all day long in history, English, and social studies classes. They also arise in mathematics and science classes, when either word problems or other reading is involved. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs to have special education teachers for his academic classes or there must be support for him in classes taught by regular education teachers, such as an aide or a program designed for his needs.

What the District Proposed in STUDENT’s IEP

In STUDENT’s IEP dated March 12, 1997, the District proposed regular education with RSP support for one period per day at Parkman Middle School for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year and the 1997-98 school year. (Pet. Exh. 14; testimony of Ms. PARENT.) Parkman is STUDENT’s home school. (Pet. Exh. 14, at p. 113.) At the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s mother disagreed with the program and placement offered and signed that she objected to the “instructional setting.” (Id. at p. 117.) Ms. PARENT testified that one of the reasons she would not consent to the program offered by the District at this IEP meeting was that the District was not offering even the same level of services that STUDENT had received in his previous private school (Meadow Oaks), in which he had been unsuccessful. She stated that the resource program at Meadow Oaks involved 1:1 work much of the time (and never more than 3:1). Ms. PARENT also had concerns about the safety of the Parkman Middle School campus because when considering the school for an older sibling of STUDENT’s, she had talked to office staff who told her that if she could send her child to private school she should do so, because conditions were “dangerous” at Parkman.

Dr. Richelle Skerczak, District RSP teacher at Parkman, testified as to what STUDENT’s proposed program and placement would have entailed. She has been an RSP teacher for eight years and was a special day class teacher for ten years prior to that. Dr. Skerczak has learning handicapped and severely handicapped teaching credentials and a doctorate in education. She has never met STUDENT and was not present at his IEP meeting. Dr. Skerczak stated that at Parkman, RSP is not a pull-out program but, instead, involves one period of RSP support in a separate class. Dr. Skerczak stated that because STUDENT is such a highly intelligent student, she would have implemented his language arts goal through her study skills class and utilized notebook “checks” (in which she goes through students’ backpacks to make sure they have all the necessary items to organize their work). Dr. Skerczak stated that during the 1997-98 school year, she would be assisted by another credentialed teacher and would have three students in her RSP class. Dr. Skerczak said the maximum number of students she ever has in her class is six. She stated that computers were just added to her RSP room and that most of her students have written expression deficits. Dr. Skerczak added that STUDENT’s vocational education goal would have been worked on daily in her class since study skills are addressed every day. She said that she sees her job as encouraging students to get their homework done for other classes.

Dr. Skerczak testified that other modifications she could have made for STUDENT included shortening or modifying assignments, providing simplified versions of literature (e.g., Cliff’s Notes), and providing a place for him to study for other teachers’ tests at any time of the day. She said that she “programs” students to teachers who are receptive to her RSP students’ needs. Dr. Skerczak testified that she works with teachers to get them to use alternative methods of teaching with her RSP students, including using a tape recorder instead of taking notes, getting overheads from the teachers, or allowing students to do hands-on work instead of writing reports. Dr. Skerczak stated that she communicates with these teachers through daily reports and that they give her their lesson plans and one week’s worth of homework. She also indicated that her aide sometimes goes with RSP students to their regular classes to “shadow” them and make sure they get the agenda copied correctly. Dr. Skerczak said that the regular education classes have 30-35 students and that lunch, nutrition, the DARE program, after-school tutoring, and extra-curricular activities are available to students at Parkman.

Dr. Skerczak stated that STUDENT would not have had trouble functioning in a regular education classroom because his scores on nationwide tests were within the average range, indicating his ability to keep up, although she acknowledged that transition might be an issue, since he has been in private school all his life. Dr. Skerczak indicated that her RSP class is sensitive to a student’s “newness,” and offers a nurturing environment. She said that she does not use the lecture style of teaching solely and that she incorporates hands-on work, role playing, peer interactions, and a wide variety of modalities.

A school district’s placement offer must be in writing on the IEP document in order to be considered at a due process hearing. (Smith v. Union School District, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994).) Therefore, because there was no other written offer of placement, the Hearing Officer notes that the only modifications or services that can be considered in this decision are those delineated in STUDENT’s IEP. Although the list of what Dr. Skerczak could have done for STUDENT, had he been in her class this year, included several commendable modifications, the focus must be on what was actually offered to STUDENT in his IEP. In that IEP, there is a statement that differential standards apply (allowing modified assignments and additional time) and the two goals that were found inappropriate above. Perhaps if the IEP team had included Dr. Skerczak (as his proposed RSP teacher) in the IEP meeting, she could have provided the information about what she could do for STUDENT, and that information could have been included in his IEP for his mother to consider. STUDENT has never been in a District school, and Dr. Skerczak was not present to answer any questions Ms. PARENT might have had about Parkman’s RSP program. Although the District argues that all of what Dr. Skerczak put forth is simply part of the RSP program at Parkman, each student must have different services and modifications in place (if necessary), and without some guarantee in STUDENT’s IEP about what “would” have been done to provide him with the services and modifications he needed, the Hearing Officer cannot consider what Dr. Skerczak “could” have done. Whether the District’s Placement Met STUDENT’s Unique Needs

The Hearing Officer concludes that the proposed program did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs for the following reasons: (1) RSP for one period a day would not provide the support STUDENT needs throughout the day, (2) no alternative teaching methods were included as modifications in his IEP, and (3) small group and individualized instruction was not included in his IEP. Dr. Nina Ferjo, educational psychologist, testified regarding the inappropriateness of what the District offered for STUDENT.(Footnote 9) Dr. Ferjo, who has observed RSP classes in District middle schools, said that RSP for one period a day for STUDENT would not meet his unique needs because of the severity of his disabilities. She stated that he would be in jeopardy in all his regular education classes. Dr. Ferjo said that STUDENT needs help in every class, except for mathematics, in which he only needs support for reading. Dr. Ferjo testified that the placement offered by the District in STUDENT’s IEP dated March 12, 1997, would not meet all his unique needs.

By offering RSP, the District did not offer special education teachers throughout the day and there is, therefore, no provision for support throughout the school day. Neither did the District offer an aide or other support in STUDENT’s regular education classes. No modifications regarding teaching methods were included in his IEP. The District failed to even offer in STUDENT’s IEP what its own assessor recommended: small group and individual instruction in reading and written expression. For all these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed placement did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Ability to Gain Some Benefit from District’s Proposed Placement

The District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT would gain some benefit from the District’s proposed placement. Dr. Skerczak testified that she believed that STUDENT would benefit from the RSP program at Parkman. However, her belief was based on the services and modifications that she said she was willing to put into place for STUDENT, not what was actually included on his IEP. Ms. Veasman testified that at the time of STUDENT’s IEP meeting in March 1997, she agreed that the placement offered by the District was appropriate for him and that he would gain some benefit from it. However, the Hearing Officer notes that the IEP team failed to include the recommendations Ms. Veasman herself made regarding STUDENT’s education, including small group and individualized instruction in reading and written expression, a fact that detracts from the persuasiveness of her testimony.

The Petitioner’s witnesses testified that STUDENT would gain no more than de minimis benefit from the District’s proposed placement. Dr. Ellenberg testified that STUDENT’s disabilities are so severe that he is unlikely to get much out of regular education classes. She stated that STUDENT is intelligent and has potential, but that there is no time in the District’s RSP program during one period a day to tap into his strengths and provide an individualized educational program. Dr. Ellenberg said that because STUDENT’s least efficient method of gaining information is verbal, he would be able to obtain very little information through the lecture-type style of presenting used in most regular education classes. Because STUDENT needs alternative methods of instruction throughout the school day, he would not benefit from this traditional teaching that would occur in the majority of his day in regular education classes.

Dr. Ferjo stated that STUDENT would receive at most, slight benefit from the District’s offered program of one period of RSP per day because, unlike some students who have other skills to compensate (self-help skills or good auditory skills), he has none of these skills. She doubted whether STUDENT could be independent enough to be in regular education classes the majority of his day. Dr. Ferjo said that children with auditory processing deficits are the “highest risk” children in regular education classes.

Mr. Shifrin, Landmark headmaster for the past four years, testified that STUDENT would not have gained more than de minimis benefit from the District’s proposed placement in RSP because of his need for support throughout the day.(Footnote 10) Mr. Shifrin pointed out that by three months before the IEP meeting, STUDENT had already substantially met the goals proposed for him at that meeting. Mr. Shifrin said that putting STUDENT in the mainstream and simply pulling him out for RSP for 55 minutes a day was inadequate for him to gain some benefit from his education.

As discussed earlier, STUDENT has already been in a resource program at Meadow Oaks and experienced difficulty, even with that level of support. The District argues that STUDENT’s difficulties in the resource program at Meadow Oaks were not severe because he received passing grades and the school itself was very competitive. The District points to STUDENT’s scores on a national test which indicate that he was performing at or near national averages in all academic areas except for mathematics, in which he was performing above the average. (Testimony of Mr. Saborio.) The Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s grades were modified at Meadow Oaks and that the fact that his scores on national standardized testing fell within the average range is irrelevant. The Hearing Officer notes that there is no basis in the law for using how STUDENT scored on a nationwide test as a basis for program or placement recommendations.(Footnote 11) It is very clear that the whole purpose of the “individualized” educational program, or IEP, is to achieve individual progress, not progress in relation to peers. (34 C.F.R. § 300.346.) Furthermore, there is evidence that Meadow Oaks modified STUDENT’s grades and that he continued to experience problems in reading and written expression even after resource services, after-school tutoring, and educational therapy were instituted at that school. (Pet. Exh. 3, 15, and 16.)

Based on the preponderance of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT would receive only de minimis benefit from the District’s proposed placement. De minimis benefit is insufficient to meet the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (M.C. ex rel. J.C. v. Central Regional School District 81 F.3d 389 (3d. Cir. 1996), cert. denied, 117 S.Ct. 176 (1996); Polk v. Central Susquehana Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171 (3d. Cir. 1988), cert. denied, 488 U.S. 1030, 109 S.Ct. 835 (1989).) Therefore, based on the findings that the District’s proposed placement would not have met STUDENT’s unique needs and that it would have provided no more than de minimis benefit to him, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years. Because the District’s placement is inappropriate, it is unnecessary to discuss the factors regarding whether that placement conformed to the student’s IEP and whether it was the placement in the least restrictive environment.

V. Did STUDENT require placement in a nonpublic school setting from the time of the IEP meeting on March 12, 1997, and which must continue for the 1997-98 school year?(Footnote 12)

The Petitioner contends that STUDENT required placement in a nonpublic school (NPS) from the time of his IEP meeting during the 1996-97 school year through the end of the 1997-98 school year because the District failed to provide an appropriate placement for those school years. The District contends that STUDENT did not require placement in an NPS for the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years because it provided an appropriate placement at Parkman Middle School and because his parents enrolled him at Landmark before they requested an assessment from the District.

The Hearing Officer notes that the District provided no authority for its contention that STUDENT’s parents should have requested an assessment from the District before they enrolled him at Landmark. The Hearing Officer notes that under the amended IDEA, there is a requirement for parents to inform a school district before enrolling a student in a private school for which they seek reimbursement, which limits the amount of reimbursement that may be awarded, if the parents do not do so. (20 U.S.C.A. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii).) However, this provision applies only to situations in which the student was previously receiving special education services from a public agency. That is not the case here. Furthermore, at the time of the IEP meeting on March 12, 1997, the District knew that STUDENT was attending Landmark, as he had been for a year and one-half. Additionally, no one argued that anything other than the laws in existence before the amendments to the IDEA applied to this matter. Therefore, the District’s contention is without merit.

The standard under Rowley for a parentally provided placement, when a school district has failed to provide an appropriate placement and the parent is requesting reimbursement, is similar to the standard applicable to school districts, in that the placement must be designed to provide some educational benefit to the child. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176; Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington, Massachusetts, et al., v. Department of Education of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts et al., 471 U.S. 359, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985).

In this decision, the Petitioner requests reimbursement for STUDENT’s placement at Landmark for the 1996-97 school year under Issue VI. Under Issue VII, the Petitioner also requests a finding that the District must pay for STUDENT’s placement at Landmark for the 1997-98 school year, which had not begun at the time the hearing began. By the time the record closed in this matter, the 1997-98 school year had commenced and decisions about placement had to be made in order to avoid loss of educational opportunity. Therefore, for purposes of this decision, both requests will be dealt with as reimbursement requests and the standard for parental placements in Burlington will apply.

Mr. Shifrin indicated that even three periods a day of RSP would not be enough to allow STUDENT to benefit from his education because he needs help all day long. However, he acknowledged that STUDENT was “too advanced” for a typical District special day class. Mr. Shifrin testified that STUDENT was “ideally” placed at Landmark because he is a “classic” dyslexic/dysgraphic student, for which the Landmark program is specifically designed.

Mr. Shifrin testified that Landmark is accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges on a six-year cycle and that the school uses the state framework for curriculum and then adds to that framework. For example, Landmark requires four years of mathematics instead of the two the state requires. All classroom teachers have a regular teaching credential and either have a learning handicapped credential or are working on one. Class sizes range from eight to twelve students. The learning approach is strategy-based and focuses on the “how to” or organizational aspects of the subjects, including “how to” remember, “how to” organize, and “how to” do homework. The program is individualized for each student’s needs. Computers are utilized to help students with their particular problem areas. (Testimony of Mr. Shifrin.) There is an optional 1:1 program, in which a parent may choose to have a particular program, like Lindamood-Bell, used with a child; however, Mr. Shifrin said that this program was not necessary for STUDENT because he was able to gain significant benefit from the regular Landmark program.

Landmark develops goals and objectives for its students, based on their needs and classroom performance, which is included in the school’s own “in-house” IEP. (Pet. Exh. 5; testimony of Mr. Shifrin.) Classroom modifications are documented, along with the student’s needs and the results of testing. (Pet. Exh. 5 and 6.)

Mr. Shifrin stated that when STUDENT first came to Landmark, he seemed almost depressed, but that now he is very happy. Academically, STUDENT’s grades during the first reporting period after he arrived at Landmark were two B-pluses, one A-minus, and four A’s (one A was in physical education). For the first semester of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT’s grades were two A-minuses and five A’s (one A-minus was in physical education). For the second semester of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT’s grades were one B, two A-minuses, and four A’s (one A was in physical education). The comments from his teachers were nearly all positive about STUDENT’s academic performance and his progress at Landmark.

Ms. PARENT testified that she chose to send STUDENT to Landmark following the assessment by Dr. Ellenberg, who highly recommended the school for him. Ms. PARENT also knew of the school because other children of hers had attended Landmark. She indicated that she did not consider other private schools because they did not like to accept children with learning disabilities. Ms. PARENT testified that she did not approach the District about assessing and/or placing STUDENT immediately because she was not familiar with her rights to do so.

Ms. PARENT stated that STUDENT was happy at Landmark and his self-esteem improved because he no longer felt like an “outsider,” as he had felt at Meadow Oaks, where his peers teased him about his reading and writing problems. Ms. PARENT said that Landmark was able to get STUDENT interested in his education again and that the teaching method allowed him to learn. She testified that STUDENT’s grades at Meadow Oaks had been C’s and D’s in academic classes during sixth grade, and that he had improved to A’s and B’s at Landmark. Ms. PARENT said that instead of always using books, the students may log onto the Internet to do research or go on field trips.

Dr. Ferjo testified that according to her recent evaluation, she believed that Landmark was an appropriate placement for STUDENT because he receives help for his disabilities in every class. She stated that children like STUDENT “survive” through about the fifth grade, at which point they simply cannot keep up with several things happening at once. Dr. Ferjo testified that every class at Landmark is sensitive to STUDENT’s needs, every student is given computer skills, and STUDENT has tutorial support in addition to his special classes. Dr. Ferjo indicated that Landmark’s expertise is with dyslexia and that STUDENT fits the protocol of students who go to the school.

Based on unrefuted testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has benefitted from his placement at Landmark. Although the District contends that it provided an appropriate placement for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer found above that the District failed to do so. The District also contends that Landmark is inappropriate because one of the Petitioner’s witnesses stated that Landmark’s goal was to optimize a student’s education. The District is correct in saying that the District need not optimize or maximize a student’s education, under Rowley; however, in this matter, the District failed to provide a FAPE to STUDENT and he is receiving benefit from Landmark. The fact that Dr. Ferjo testified to her belief that Landmark attempted to optimize a child’s functioning is not determinative of whether Landmark is otherwise appropriate for STUDENT, in light of the District’s failure to provide a FAPE. The Petitioner does not contend that the District must optimize STUDENT’s functioning, and Landmark’s provision of services beyond the District’s duty to provide a basic floor of opportunity does not doom this parentally provided placement.

Parents are not required to provide the “perfect” placement for their children when a school district has failed to provide a FAPE. (Alamo Heights Independent School District v. Texas Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).) The fifth circuit stated that the rationale behind the holding in Burlington is that parents who elect ro risk shouldering the costs of what they believe is a more appropriate placement, and whose judgment is either partly or wholly vindicated by a decision, should receive more than just an “empty victory.” If reasonable reimbursement is not allowed, the student’s right to a free appropriate public education, as well as the parents’ right to participate fully in the IEP process, would be “less than complete.” The court said that “the Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the interim placement chosen by the parent is found to be the exact proper placement required under the Act.” Therefore, even if Landmark were a less than “perfect” placement for STUDENT, Alamo would allow reimbursement for that placement.

The Hearing Officer notes that according to STUDENT’s needs, STUDENT needs support throughout his day, in all classes. Although he might be able to work with just an aide in mathematics to help with any reading, he otherwise needs the support of a special education teacher or a program designed for his needs that can provide alternative teaching methods throughout the day. STUDENT is too intelligent for special day classes available; therefore, STUDENT cannot be educated in an environment less restrictive than one with support throughout the day. The only alternative to a special day class is a setting like Landmark, in which STUDENT can receive the support he needs. Although once the District has defaulted in its obligation to provide a FAPE, the issue of least restrictive environment is irrelevant for a parental placement, in any case, the Hearing Officer finds that Landmark is a placement in the least restrictive environment.

According to the standard in the Rowley and Burlington, the Hearing Officer finds that Landmark, an NPS, is an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the portion of the 1996-97 school year following the IEP meeting on March 12, 1997, through the end of the 1996-97 school year, because it provides educational benefit to him. No different information beyond that discussed for the 1996-97 school year was presented -- no IEP meeting other than the one held March 12, 1997, was convened, and no other placement was offered by the District. There is no indication from the evidence that STUDENT’s needs changed for the 1997-98 school year, considering that a brief evaluation was done on August 6, 1997, confirming the continuation of those needs. Nor is there any indication that STUDENT’s placement at Landmark has not continued to meet his needs. Therefore, for all the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that Landmark is an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year.

VI. Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT’s family for the full costs of the Landmark West School from March 12, 1997, through the end of the 1996-97 school year?

The Petitioner contends that the District is required to reimburse STUDENT’s family for the full costs of his placement at Landmark from the time of the IEP meeting on March 12, 1997, through the end of the 1996-97 school year because the District failed to provide him a FAPE and because Landmark was an appropriate placement. The District contends that reimbursement is not warranted because STUDENT’s parents approached the District solely to have Landmark funded.

Under Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington, Massachusetts, et al., v. Department of Education of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts et al., 471 U.S. 359, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985), the Supreme Court held that if a school district failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE), the child’s parents may seek reimbursement for an appropriate private placement.

The Hearing Officer found above that the District failed to provide a FAPE to STUDENT. STUDENT’s parents have paid for his education at Landmark, which the Hearing Officer found above was an appropriate placement for him. The District contends that the entire purpose of asking the District to assess STUDENT was to attempt to get funding for Landmark from the District, because STUDENT had been placed there by his parents for a year and one-half before they approached the District. The District contends that several of STUDENT’s siblings attend Landmark and that this is one reason Ms. PARENT placed him there and later sought reimbursement.

The Hearing Officer notes that equitable considerations and the actions of the parties are to be considered when a parent provides a placement because a school district has failed to provide a FAPE. (Burlington, 471 U.S. 359, 374, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985); W.G., 960 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).) The District has an obligation to provide a FAPE to students who reside within its boundaries. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(c); 34 C.F.R. § 300.1(a); California Education Code § 56000 and 56170.) Although Ms. PARENT’s goal may have been to seek District funding of STUDENT’s placement at Landmark, she testified that she wanted to see what the District had to offer to STUDENT. The fact that one or more of STUDENT’s siblings currently or previously attended Landmark does not lessen the District’s duty to provide a FAPE to STUDENT; ultimately, his siblings’ education is irrelevant to this proceeding. Ms. PARENT testified that after STUDENT was placed at Landmark, she first learned of her rights regarding a free appropriate public education for STUDENT and that only then did she approach the District. It is not unusual for parents to be unaware of their rights regarding disabled students. The Hearing Officer finds no evidence of equitable considerations that weigh against reimbursement. Therefore, for all the reasons above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s family is entitled to reimbursement for the full costs of his placement at Landmark, from the time after the IEP meeting of March 12, 1997, through the end of the 1996-97 school year.

VII. Is the District required to pay the actual and full costs of STUDENT’s attendance at the Landmark West School for the 1997-98 school year?

As noted earlier, this issue will be treated as one requesting reimbursement because the record closed after the 1997-98 school year began. The Hearing Officer found above that the District did not provide a FAPE to STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year and that Landmark was an appropriate placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s family is entitled to reimbursement for the full costs of his placement at Landmark for the 1997-98 school year, to the extent that those costs have already been paid. To the extent that STUDENT’s family has not already paid for his placement at Landmark for the entire year, the District must assume the remainder of the full costs of STUDENT’s placement at Landmark through the end of the 1997-98 school year.

ORDER

1. Within sixty days of receiving receipts documenting the following expenses, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for:

A. The full costs of STUDENT’s placement at Landmark for the period between March 12, 1997, and the end of the 1996-97 school year; and B. The full costs of STUDENT’s placement at Landmark for the 1997-98 school year, to the extent that his parents have already paid for his placement for that school year.

2. To the extent that STUDENT’s parents have not already paid for his placement at Landmark for the 1997-98 school year, the District shall assume the full costs of his placement there for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year.

3. All of the Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

I. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to conduct the type of assessment required by law, including a full and complete assessment of STUDENT’s ability level so that there can be a full understanding of his learning needs? The District substantially prevailed on this issue.

II. Did the District violate the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) in developing the IEP for STUDENT on March 12, 1997, by: A. Failing to include the individuals required to be present for students with a learning disability in the IEP meeting; B. Failing to include specific information about STUDENT’s current levels of educational performance within the classroom setting; C. Including only two goals and limited short-term objectives which are generic in nature and which: 1. Contain no short-term objectives specific to the steps that must be taught to achieve the goals; 2. Provide no reference to the goals and objectives required to ensure that STUDENT is able to function in academic and other classes throughout the school day; 3. Are not specific as to the level and/or percentage of compliance anticipated; and 4. Fail to specify the objective criteria to be utilized to determine whether or not the short-term objectives are being achieved; and D. Failing to include a statement of the specific special education and related services to be provided to STUDENT and the extent to which he will be participating in the regular educational program? The Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.

III. To comply with the IDEA, must STUDENT’s IEP contain additional goals, short-term objectives, and classroom modifications? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

IV. Does a resource specialist program (RSP) on a regular high school campus provide an educational program which can effectively address the appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT and provide him with a FAPE? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

V. Did STUDENT require placement in a nonpublic school setting from the time of the IEP meeting on March 12, 1997, and which must continue for the 1997-98 school year? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

VI. Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT’s family for the full costs of the Landmark West School from March 12, 1997, through the end of the 1996-97 school year? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

VII. Is the District required to pay the actual and full costs of STUDENT’s attendance at the Landmark West School for the 1997-98 school year? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: January 14, 1998 ____________________________________ Kathleen Peterson Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1.The Petitioner’s statement of issues was organized slightly differently from those presented here; however, for the purpose of writing this decision, the Hearing Officer has grouped necessarily related issues under subcategories to be dealt with together. 2.Amendments to the IDEA were signed into law on June 4, 1997. The request for this hearing was received before any of the 1997 Amendments to the IDEA became effective and the parties made no argument that the amendments apply here. Additionally, according the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Landgraf v. USI Film Products, 511 U.S. 244 (1994), retroactive application of such amendments is not favored. For all these reasons, the Hearing Officer will apply the law as it stood at the time of the hearing request. 3."Dist. Exh.” refers to the District’s exhibits, numbered 1 through 27, admitted into evidence. 4.Pet. Exh.” refers to the Petitioner’s Exhibits, numbered 1 through 27, admitted into evidence. 5.Ms. Veasman noted that using the achievement results of the WRAT-III, STUDENT did not exhibit a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement. However, she recommended eligibility based on the PIAT-R results. 6.Had a teacher from Landmark been invited to the IEP team meeting, perhaps the team would have been able to create more appropriate goals and objectives, because it would have had current information regarding STUDENT’s classroom performance available from that teacher. 7.It is possible that a school district may fail to provide a FAPE solely because of procedural violations, even though the district otherwise offered a substantively appropriate placement. In other situations, a school district may commit no procedural violations, yet fail to offer a substantively appropriate placement. Here, the cumulative effect of the District’s procedural violations was to deny STUDENT a FAPE procedurally and, as found below, the District also substantively failed to offer an appropriate placement, denying him a FAPE substantively as well. 8.Although the Petitioner’s issue statement refers to whether RSP on a regular “high” school campus is appropriate, the Hearing Officer concludes that this is a clerical error because the placement offered to STUDENT was at a regular “middle” school campus, and there is no argument elsewhere regarding a high school campus. 9.Dr. Ferjo has a private practice in Westwood, is on the faculty of Cedars-Sinai Hospital, has eight teaching credentials, and has a doctorate in education from UCLA. She has been in private practice for 15-20 years and has assessed “thousands” of children with learning disabilities. (Testimony of Dr. Ferjo.) 10.Benjamin Shifrin has a master’s degree in special education from Temple University, and is certified as a learning handicapped teacher in Pennsylvania. Mr. Shifrin has assessed 150-200 children as part of his degree requirements. He was an RSP teacher in a Philadelphia school and then came to work for the District. Mr. Shifrin first worked as a learning handicapped/learning disabilities teacher at Hamilton High School in the District, and then as a program specialist for the District for several years before he went to Landmark to became the headmaster of that school. Mr. Shifrin has personal experience with RSP at the District, since he was both a special education teacher and a program specialist for the District before becoming the headmaster at Landmark. 11.Additionally, eligibility criteria reflect that the whole purpose of special education is individual progress and achievement. (34 C.F.R. § 300.541.) 12.This issue is included as submitted by the Petitioner; however, the Hearing Officer notes that the appropriate standard is not whether STUDENT “required placement in a nonpublic school”, but whether the District provided an appropriate placement and, if not, whether the parent has provided an appropriate placement instead. (Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington, Massachusetts, et al. v. Department of Education of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, et al., 471 U.S. 359, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985).)