California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 28, 2005
Student v. Fallbrook Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 383-05 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait
Fallbrook Union High School District correctly found that a student's planned fight was not a manifestation of his disability.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
This decision covers only the bifurcated manifestation determination issue. The student's remaining issues, including a planned claim for compensatory education for an alleged stay put violation, were taken off calendar, and either party may ask to put them back on calendar.
Summary
A 16-year-old tenth grader at Fallbrook High School challenged Fallbrook Union High School District's finding that his role in a January 19, 2005 fight was not a manifestation of his disability. He had received special education since first grade for a specific learning disability. At the January 27, 2005 manifestation meeting, the IEP team found he no longer qualified in that category. It reclassified him as other health impaired because of mild attention deficit disorder (ADD). The parties agreed to split the case, so this decision covers only the manifestation determination. The student's other claims were taken off calendar, and his attorney withdrew a stay put motion.
The Hearing Officer rejected all four of the student's arguments. First, the mother had declined another copy of the procedural safeguards notice and showed no harm. Second, the law did not require a new assessment for the manifestation review. Whether the triennial assessment was adequate was left for the second hearing. Third, the IEP was not inappropriate for lacking behavior goals, a behavior plan or counseling. Most of his discipline entries were for truancy and missed detentions, he earned mostly A's and B's, and the school had used a conduct agreement and an anger management referral. The student's two experts were not persuasive because they had not observed him at school or talked with his teachers. Fourth, no evidence linked his disability to the fight, which he planned in advance. The District may discipline him as it would a nondisabled student.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the 1997 IDEA manifestation standards. It held that no new assessment was required. It looked at whether the student's discipline record was connected to the fight and to his disability. It treated planned conduct and good behavior in some classes as evidence that the fight was not caused by his disability.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1. Should the District's manifestation determination be voided because the District failed to provide a notice of procedural safeguards to Student's parents during the manifestation determination IEP meeting?
The mother waived a new copy of the procedural safeguards notice and showed no prejudice, so the Hearing Officer did not void the determination.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2. Did the District fail to develop an adequate assessment to use in making the manifestation determination?
The law did not require a new assessment for a manifestation determination. Whether the triennial assessment was adequate was left for the second phase of the bifurcated hearing.
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue 3. At the time of Student's alleged misbehavior on January 19, 2005, was his IEP inappropriate because it did not have behavioral goals, a behavior support plan, or counseling services to help Student manage his anger?
His discipline record, made up mostly of truancy and missed detentions, did not significantly impede his education, and the school's conduct agreement and anger management referral were adequate, so the IEP was not inappropriate in relation to the fight.
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue 4. In relation to the January 19, 2005 fight, did Student's disability impair his ability to control his behavior?
No evidence linked his mild learning disability or mild ADD to an inability to control his behavior. The fight was planned in advance, not impulsive, so it was not a manifestation of his disability.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of the student's claims were denied. The District may proceed with its proposed discipline of the student under the laws that govern discipline of nondisabled students.
Key authorities
34 CFR § 300.523; 34 CFR § 300.525; 34 CFR § 300.346; Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5; Cal. Educ. Code § 56301
People named in the decision
- Sallie Hunt, special education director, Fallbrook Union High School District
- Peggy D. Martineau, school psychologist (triennial assessor), Fallbrook Union High School District
- Marty Camacho, case manager (conducted achievement testing and classroom observation), Fallbrook High School
- Lutz Zastrow, general education world history teacher, Fallbrook High School
- Sarah Carling-Guera, RSP English teacher, Fallbrook High School
- Mike West, RSP algebra teacher, Fallbrook High School
- Fred Marasco, expert witness for Student; former school psychologist working as a parent advocate
- Sara Frampton, expert witness for Student; educational psychologist
- Palomar Family Counseling, private provider of an anger management program
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard on March 8 and 9, 2005, in Fallbrook, California, by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Ellen Dowd. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother, MOTHER.
Respondent Fallbrook Union High School District (District) was represented by attorney Sharon Watt. Also present on behalf of District was the District’s special education director, Sallie Hunt.
Evidence was received, the record was closed, and the matter submitted for decision on March 9, 2005.
ISSUE
Was STUDENT’s behavior of engaging in a fight with another student on January 19, 2005, a manifestation of his disability?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The day before the hearing, the District made a motion to bifurcate the hearing. It proposed that the issue concerning the manifestation determination be heard first and the other issues raised by STUDENT be heard after there has been a decision concerning the manifestation determination. STUDENT’s attorney agreed to bifurcate the hearing. Therefore, this Decision will address only the issue of whether STUDENT’s behavior was a manifestation of his disability. The parties agreed to take the hearing relating to the other issues off calendar until after this Decision is rendered. Either party may request that the matter be put back on calendar.
During the second day of the hearing, STUDENT’s attorney made a motion for stay put. After some discussion concerning this motion, STUDENT’s attorney withdrew her motion and stated that she would address the District’s failure to comply with stay put in the second hearing and would ask for compensatory education in relation to that failure. Therefore, the issue of stay put will not be discussed in this Decision.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The District claims that it made an appropriate determination that STUDENT’s conduct on January 19, 2005, of fighting with another student was not a manifestation of his disability.
STUDENT contends that the District improperly concluded that his conduct was not a manifestation of his disability for the following reasons:
1. The District’s manifestation determination should be voided because the District failed to provide a Notice of Procedural Safeguards to STUDENT’s parents during the manifestation determination meeting.
2. The assessment performed by school psychologist Peggy D. Martineau and used by the IEP team during the manifestation determination meeting was not adequate.
3. STUDENT’s IEP at the time of the incident was not appropriate because it did not have behavioral goals, a behavior support plan, or counseling services to help STUDENT manage his anger.
4. Because of his disability, STUDENT was not able to control his behavior. (Footnote 1)
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a sixteen-year-old student who is in the tenth grade at Fallbrook High School. He has been receiving special education services since the first grade. He was diagnosed as having a specific learning disability that causes delays in auditory short-term memory and abstract visual processing.
On March 7, 2003, while STUDENT was in the eighth grade, his IEP team met to address his misbehavior in relation to an incident in which keys were stolen and locks removed from lockers. The team notes indicate that the IEP would be amended to include a behavior support plan and performance contract. A part of the contract appeared to address the incident that caused the contract to be written, including a provision that STUDENT not associate with certain other students. Other provisions of the contract addressed his overall academic performance, including a provision requiring him to attend classes, arrive on time, keep track of and complete assignments and attend tutorials.
On March 20, 2003, a transitional IEP was conducted to prepare STUDENT for his enrollment at Fallbrook High School the following fall. His IEP reflects that he would enroll in Resource Specialist Program (RSP) English and RSP algebra or pre-algebra for one period each. STUDENT attended this IEP meeting and was informed of the school rules he would be expected to obey while at Fallbrook High.
The IEP team met on January 29, 2004, to review STUDENT’s IEP and make any necessary changes for the coming year. Goals and objectives in math and English were drafted and the IEP team determined that STUDENT would continue with two periods of RSP support in English and math. During this IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents stated a concern about his behavior and his being “strong willed.” The IEP team concluded that STUDENT’s behavior did not impede his learning or the learning of others. STUDENT’s mother signed the IEP and initialed that she agreed with the placement, program, and services provided in the IEP.
During the fall of 2004, STUDENT was enrolled in the regular world history class taught by Lutz Zastrow. From the beginning of the class, there was friction between STUDENT and Mr. Zastrow. STUDENT’s misbehavior in Mr. Zastrow’s class included excessive talking during instruction time, sitting sideways in his chair, arguing, refusing to sign a detention slip, being tardy, and other conduct that demonstrated disrespect for Mr. Zastrow. In the latter part of November, Mr. Zastrow attempted to contact STUDENT’s parents to try to address STUDENT’s misbehavior in class. STUDENT’s mother contacted school administrators about the problems in Mr. Zastrow’s class and a parent conference was scheduled. A Conduct Agreement was prepared relating to STUDENT’s conduct in Mr. Zastrow’s class and STUDENT and his mother signed it.
On December 9, 2004, STUDENT was suspended for five days for threatening physical injury to another student. He is alleged to have threatened to “kick his ass.” It was recommended to STUDENT’s parents that STUDENT be enrolled in an anger management class. They were specifically recommended to the program conducted by Palomar Family Counseling. His parents were also told that if he enrolled in the class, his suspension would be reduced to three days. STUDENT did enroll in the Palomar anger management class and was allowed to return to school early.
On the afternoon of January 19, 2005, STUDENT attended his first anger management class. That evening he attended a school basketball game and became involved in a verbal altercation with another student. STUDENT and the other student agreed to meet after the basketball game to fight. After the basketball game, STUDENT returned home to change clothes and then proceeded to a nearby sports field where he and the other student engaged in a fight. Another student made a videotape of the fight and turned the tape over to District authorities. STUDENT was suspended for five days for his involvement in the fight and was recommended for expulsion.
An IEP meeting was scheduled for January 21, 2005, for two purposes: to determine whether STUDENT’s conduct was a manifestation of his disability and to review his triennial assessment and make necessary modifications to his IEP. It was determined that the triennial assessment would be performed in advance of the manifestation determination meeting. The triennial assessment had already been underway at the time of the January 19 fight. Achievement testing had been performed on January 10, 2005, by STUDENT’s case manager, Mr. Camacho, who had also performed one classroom observation on January 6, 2005.
After the January 19, 2005 incident, school psychologist Peggy D. Martineau performed an evaluation of STUDENT. Her evaluation included a review of school records and interviews with STUDENT’s teachers, his parents, and STUDENT. Ms. Martineau also administered the California Verbal Learning Test-II and the Beery Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration. Ms. Martineau also administered the student questionnaire portion of the Conner’s Attention Deficit Scale. She asked STUDENT’s mother to complete the parent’s questionnaire, but STUDENT’s mother refused. In the area of social emotional, Ms. Martineau concluded that “when STUDENT believes he is right, he has difficulty backing down. Therefore, he finds himself in trouble for disrespecting a teacher or finds himself fighting.”
The IEP team met on January 27, 2005, and first addressed the manifestation determination. The team reviewed STUDENT’s prior IEPs, all of which concluded that STUDENT’s behavior did not impede his learning or the learning of others. The IEP team also reviewed STUDENT’s grades at the time of the January 19, 2005 incident. At that time, he was receiving As in Learning Strategies and Boys Soccer, Bs in English, World History and Algebra, and a D in Woodshop.
The IEP team also reviewed STUDENT’s disciplinary history. Since entering high school, STUDENT had accumulated forty-five entries in his disciplinary record, including the incident on January 19, 2005. Of those entries, seven were for truancy. There were thirty-two entries for failure to serve detentions, most of which were assigned because of truancies or other failures to serve detentions. There were two entries related to disrupting a class. One entry related to the behavior contract for his world history class. One entry was related to the December 9, 2004 threat of physical injury and one related to the January 19, 2005 fight.
The IEP team also considered the academic testing done by Mr. Camacho and the testing done by Ms Martineau. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT’s performance scores now indicated that he was no longer eligible for special education as having a specific learning disability. In reliance on some of the testing done by Ms. Martineau and the parents’ statement that a physician had diagnosed STUDENT as having an attention deficit disorder (ADD), the IEP team agreed to reclassify him as eligible for special education services as “other health impaired” because of mild ADD.
The IEP team concluded that, in relation to the alleged misbehavior, STUDENT’s placement, program, and services were appropriate. They also concluded that STUDENT’s disability did not affect his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior and that his disability did not prevent him from being able to control his behavior. The team also concluded that STUDENT’s conduct on January 19, 2005, was not a manifestation of his disability.
STUDENT filed a request for hearing on February 15, 2005, to challenge the manifestation determination.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
The issue in this case is whether the District appropriately concluded that STUDENT’s disciplinary conduct was not a manifestation of his disability.
Both federal and State law provide procedures and standards for imposing discipline on disabled students. State law now conforms with federal law in this area. California Education Code § 48915.5.
Federal law provides that a disabled student may be disciplined in the same way as a nondisabled student if it is concluded that the behavior which is the subject of the discipline was not a manifestation of his/her disability. 34 CFR § 300.523 - 300.528. The law requires the IEP team to meet to review the behavior subject to disciplinary action and all other relevant information. 34 CFR § 300.523(c). To conclude that the behavior was not a manifestation of the child’s disability the IEP team must determine that:
(i) In relationship to the behavior subject to disciplinary action, the child’s IEP and placement were appropriate and the special education services, supplementary aids and services, and behavior intervention strategies were provided consistent with the child’s IEP and placement; (ii) The child’s disability did not impair the ability of the child to understand the impact and consequences of the behavior subject to disciplinary action; and (iii) The child’s disability did not impair the ability of the child to control the behavior subject to disciplinary action. 34 CFR § 300.523(c)(2).
If the IEP team determines that any of the standards set out above were not met, it must consider the behavior to be a manifestation of the child’s disability. 34 CFR § 300.523(d). If the parent of the child disagrees with the manifestation determination, he/she may request a hearing and the hearing authority is required to provide an expedited hearing to review the manifestation determination. 34 CFR § 300.525.
In this case, STUDENT contends that the conclusion that his conduct involving the January 19, 2005 fight was not a manifestation of his disability was inappropriate for a number of reasons, each of which will be addressed below.
1. Should the District’s manifestation determination be voided because the District failed to provide a notice of procedural safeguards to STUDENT’s parents during the manifestation determination IEP meeting?
California Education Code section 56301 provides in part that:
Parents shall be given a copy of their rights and procedural safeguards upon initial referral for assessment, upon notice of an individualized education program meeting or reassessment, upon filing a complaint, and upon filing for a prehearing mediation conference pursuant to Section 56500.3 or a due process hearing request pursuant to Section 56502.
In this case, the IEP dated Jauary 27, 2005, has a box that was checked and signed by STUDENT’s mother that indicated that she did not need another copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards at that time.
The special education director, Ms. Sallie Hunt, testified that when asked if she needed a copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards during the January 27, 2005 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s mother laughed and said she already had a stack of them.
STUDENT’s mother testified that she just routinely signed that form saying she did not need another copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards. Nevertheless, she did not testify that she did not know her rights at the time of the meeting, nor did she assert that the failure to receive the Notice of Procedural Safeguards prejudiced her in any way during the meeting.
It is concluded that STUDENT’s mother waived her right to receive a copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards. Moreover, there was no showing of how STUDENT was prejudiced by her failure to receive the Notice. Even if there was prejudice, the proper remedy would be to have the IEP team meet to redo the manifestation determination after providing STUDENT’s mother with the Notice of Procedural Safeguards. During the hearing, STUDENT’s attorney stated that she did not seek an order to require that the IEP team meet to reconsider the issue. Rather, she wanted the hearing officer to determine whether STUDENT’s conduct was a manifestation of his disability. Therefore, it is concluded that the District’s manifestation determination should not be voided because the District failed to provide a Notice of Procedural Safeguards to STUDENT’s parents at the time of the manifestation determination IEP meeting.
2. Did the District fail to develop an adequate assessment to use in making the manifestation determination?
Federal law requires that, in making the manifestation determination the IEP team is to:
(1) First consider, in terms of the behavior subject to disciplinary action, all relevant information, including— (i) Evaluation and diagnostic results, including the results or other relevant information supplied by the parents of the child; (ii) Observations of the child; and (iii) the child’s IEP and placement;..
34 CFR § 300.523(c)(1)
Federal law does not require that there be a new assessment of the child prior to the manifestation determination IEP team meeting. State law previously required that a pre-expulsion assessment be performed prior to making the manifestation determination. That law was amended and the requirement of a separate assessment was deleted. California Education Code § 48915.5. Therefore, there was no requirement that any separate assessment be performed for the manifestation determination. In this case, however, the District was in the midst of performing its triennial evaluation of STUDENT and decided to complete that assessment prior to the manifestation determination IEP meeting.
STUDENT’s attorney argues that since the District did an assessment, that assessment had to consider all areas of suspected disability including behavior and possible emotional disturbance. She further argued that because the assessment failed to adequately assess in those areas, it was deficient and that, therefore, its consideration when making the manifestation determination was inappropriate.
As indicated above, the law does not require any new assessment for the manifestation determination. The assessment done by Ms. Martineau provided additional, valuable information that was considered by the IEP team in making the manifestation determination. Such an assessment goes further than is required by law for a manifestation determination. Whether the assessment done by Ms. Martineau complies with the requirements for a triennial assessment is a matter to be decided in the second part of this bifurcated hearing. Therefore, STUDENT’s contention that the District’s manifestation determination should be overturned because of an inadequate assessment fails.
3. At the time of STUDENT’s alleged misbehavior on January 19, 2005, was his IEP inappropriate because it did not have behavioral goals, a behavior support plan, or counseling services to help STUDENT manage his anger?
STUDENT’s attorney asserts that STUDENT’s conduct must be found to have been a manifestation of his disability because his IEP at the time of the alleged conduct did not contain behavioral goals, a behavior plan or counseling services.
Federal law provides that the IEP team must conclude that the misbehavior of a student with disabilities is a manifestation of his disability if it fails to find that “in relationship to the behavior subject to disciplinary action, the child’s IEP and placement were appropriate and the special education services, supplementary aid and services, and behavior intervention strategies were provided consistent with the child’s IEP and placement (emphasis added).” 34 CFR § 300.523(c)(2)(i).
In this case, STUDENT is not contending that the District failed to provide the services in STUDENT’s IEP, but rather that the IEP itself was inappropriate because it did not contain behavior goals and services.
Federal law states that when developing a child’s IEP, the IEP team will:
In the case of a child whose behavior impedes his or her learning or that of others, consider, if appropriate, strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, strategies, and supports to address that behavior. 34 CFR § 300.346.
District witnesses, including psychologist Peggy Martineau, special education director Sallie Hunt, STUDENT’s case manager, Marty Camacho, and STUDENT’s RSP teachers Sarah Carling-Guera and Mike West, testified that they believed STUDENT’s IEP was appropriate at the time of the January 19, 2005 fight. They did not believe that there was a need for goals and objectives relating to behavior, a behavior plan, or counseling services.
Mr. West testified that STUDENT did not exhibit behavior problems in his class. In fact, Mr. West made STUDENT a leader of group studies. Mr. West testified that he was “doing great” in his algebra class prior to being suspended. He was one of the top two or three students in the class. He would have had a grade of A had he not failed to turn in some assignments.
Ms. Carling-Guera testified that STUDENT was doing fine in her RSP English class. He did not exhibit any behavior problems. At times he would become distracted, but he was easy to redirect. STUDENT had good interaction with the other students in the class and was receiving better than a B in her class.
STUDENT’s case manager, Mr. Camacho, testified that prior to the January 19, 2005 fight, he did not believe that behavior goals, a management plan or counseling were needed elements of STUDENT’s IEP. He said that most of STUDENT’s problems were outside the classroom.
STUDENT produced two witnesses who testified that his IEP should have contained behavior goals and services. The first witness was Fred Marasco, who had a long career as a school psychologist, but who now works as a parent advocate. He reviewed STUDENT’s educational records and interviewed STUDENT and his parents. He testified that based on this information, and especially on STUDENT’s discipline record, STUDENT’s IEP should have included some behavior goals and services.
Although the Hearing Officer will address STUDENT’s disciplinary record in more detail later in this Decision, the Hearing Officer finds here that the testimony of Mr. Marasco was not persuasive. He had not conducted any testing of STUDENT and did not interview STUDENT’s teachers or the school psychologist. He did not view the videotape of the fight and he did not observe STUDENT in a school setting. Mr. Marasco also said that he was not testifying as an impartial psychologist, but, rather, as STUDENT’s advocate.
The other witness called by STUDENT’s attorney to support the need for behavior goals and services in STUDENT’s IEP was Sara Frampton, an educational psychologist with many years of experience. She testified that she interviewed STUDENT and did some testing of him. She also reviewed some of his educational records and interviewed STUDENT’s parents. The primary recommendation made by Ms. Frampton was that there needed to be additional, impartial testing. She did say that based upon her limited testing, her interviews with STUDENT and his parents and her review of his records, including his disciplinary records, she believed that STUDENT’s IEP should have contained behavior support plan, a referral to mental health, and counseling services. She also testified that there was some evidence that STUDENT might be emotionally disturbed and that he may even have a seizure disorder. But she admitted the data she based these opinions on were not conclusive.
Although the Hearing Officer has great regard for Ms. Frampton’s dedication to the needs of disabled children, her opinions in this case were not persuasive. Although she did some testing, she did not provide the actual results of the testing, the protocols or any reports from the testing. She did not interview STUDENT’s teachers or the school psychologist. She did not observe STUDENT in a school setting. Like Mr. Marasco, Ms. Frampton admitted that she was STUDENT’s advocate, not an impartial assessor.
STUDENT’s attorney points to STUDENT’s disciplinary record as the primary reason his IEP team should have instituted a behavior plan, including behavior goals and counseling services.
STUDENT had a behavior plan in his eighth-grade IEP. This behavior plan was a result of a specific incident in which STUDENT and other students stole keys and opened the locker of some other student. The behavior plan addressed this problem as well as general behavior problems such as attendance, arriving at class on time, keeping track of school work, and attending tutorials. It does not appear that this behavior plan was continued when STUDENT entered high school. There is no evidence of any repeat of behavior similar to the conduct that triggered the creation of the behavior plan. STUDENT’s IEP team met on January 29, 2004, during his first year in high school. The team concluded that STUDENT’s behavior did not impede his learning or that of other students. There are no disciplinary entries for STUDENT during this time at Fallbrook High School that in any way resemble the incident that had triggered the creation of the behavior plan in junior high school. Therefore, the fact that there was a need for a behavior plan in junior high school does not mean that such a plan was needed while he was in high school.
STUDENT’s attorney also argues that the extensive number of entries in STUDENT’s disciplinary file should have caused the IEP team to include behavioral interventions in his IEP. A closer look at those entries does not support such a conclusion. There were forty-five disciplinary entries during STUDENT’s time at Fallbrook High School. Of those, seven were for truancy. In some cases, the truancy was for one or more periods, and in two cases it was for full days. These instances of truancy resulted in STUDENT’s either being counseled or being assigned to periods of detention. Thirty-two of the disciplinary entries were for STUDENT’s failure to serve periods of detention. The normal penalty for such an offense was another prescribed period of detention. One disciplinary entry related to his using a vending machine during a detention. Therefore, of the forty-five disciplinary entries, forty were related to truancy and the failure to serve the detentions that were the discipline for those truancies. There is no evidence that the truancies or failures to serve detentions significantly impeded his education. At the time of the December 19, 2005 fight, STUDENT was receiving As and Bs in classes except his woodshop class. Even if these incidents of truancy and failure to serve detentions should have been addressed in his IEP, the failure to do so would not appear to be connected to the conduct that is the subject of discipline, that is to say, fighting.
The other entries in STUDENT’s disciplinary record include two cases of disruption of class. There was no evidence presented relating to these incidents. One was handled by counseling STUDENT and asking his parents to call the teacher. The other incident was marked “for record only” and apparently did not result in any discipline. Of the remaining three disciplinary entries, one relates to the fight that is the subject of this hearing. The other two entries deserve additional discussion.
One of the two entries relates to problems that STUDENT was having in Mr. Zastrow’s world history class. Mr. Zastrow testified that from the very beginning of the class in the fall of 2004, STUDENT was disrespectful to him, which included talking with other students during instructional time, sitting sideways in his seat, being tardy, and refusing to sign and tearing up a detention slip. Eventually, Mr. Zastrow attempted to communicate with STUDENT’s parents in an effort to address STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior. STUDENT’s mother contacted school administrators and asked for a meeting. The result of the meeting was a Conduct Agreement that was signed by STUDENT and his mother on December 1, 2004. It required STUDENT to comply with the requirements of the class and to be respectful to the teacher and other students. The agreement set out progressive disciplinary penalties for failure to abide by the agreement.
STUDENT’s case manager, Mr. Camacho, testified that STUDENT came to him shortly after the agreement was signed and complained about the unfairness of the agreement. Mr. Camacho counseled STUDENT to abide by the agreement or he would suffer the consequences, including possible failure of the class. Mr. Camacho, Mr. Zastrow and STUDENT testified that his behavior in world history class improved as a result of the agreement. At the time of the January 19, 2005 fight, STUDENT was receiving a B. While STUDENT’s behavior in Mr. Zastrow’s class was disruptive, it did not interfere with STUDENT’s education. The conduct was addressed with a behavior agreement and the result was that STUDENT changed his behavior in that class. It does not appear that there was anything more needed in relation to that conduct. In fact, the conduct agreement was a behavioral intervention that appeared to be working. Therefore, it was not necessary to include any further behavioral interventions in STUDENT’s IEP.
The most serious incident recorded in STUDENT’s disciplinary record prior to the January fight occurred on December 9, 2004. The entry in the record states that “STUDENT was involved in a verbal altercation with another student on 12/9/04, and threatened to ‘kick his ass.’” STUDENT was suspended for five days and referred to an anger management program. He and his parents were told that if he enrolled in the anger management class he would have two days cut from the suspension. STUDENT enrolled in the anger management class and was able to return to school early.
It is difficult to determine the seriousness of this event. There was no evidence concerning the facts surrounding this event, except the testimony of STUDENT. STUDENT testified that the other student had been staring at him, and when STUDENT was changing his shirt in the bathroom the other student bumped into him. He claimed that he told the other student to “watch where he was going.” He denied telling the other student that he would “kick his ass.” He said it was not a big deal. It is hard to reconcile STUDENT’s version of the December 9, 2004 incident with his contention that the incident should have caused his IEP team to meet and develop behavioral goals, a behavior plan, and counseling services. In fact, if one accepts STUDENT’s version of the event, there would seem to have been no basis for the discipline that was given. However, even if the event was as described in the disciplinary entry, it would appear that the action taken by the school in referring STUDENT to anger management was an appropriate response. The school encouraged him to enroll by promising to reduce the days of suspension. There is also no evidence that his conduct in December 9, 2004, impeded his education or the education of other students, except for the fact that he missed a few days of class. The event happened outside of class. His grades were still As and Bs over a month later when the January fight occurred. For the reasons stated above, it is concluded that the December 9, 2004 incident did not necessitate a change in STUDENT’s IEP by the inclusion of behavioral interventions beyond those taken by the school under its normal disciplinary procedures.
The disciplinary incidents described above do not individually or collectively establish that STUDENT’s IEP was lacking at the time of the January 19, 2005 fight. They did not significantly impede his ability to benefit from his education and they had little or nothing to do with his disability. The District addressed the problems appropriately and instituted behavior interventions including behavior contracts and referral to an anger management class. It is concluded that in relation to the alleged disciplinary conduct, STUDENT’s IEP and placement at the time of the January 19, 2005 fight was not inappropriate because it lacked behavior goals, a behavior plan, or counseling.
4. In relation to the January 19, 2005 fight, did STUDENT’s disability impair his ability to control his behavior?
It is difficult to determine whether STUDENT’s attorney was really contending that STUDENT’s disability impaired his ability to control his behavior. On the first day of the hearing, STUDENT’s attorney conceded that STUDENT’s disability did not prevent him from controlling his behavior. On the second day of the hearing, she appeared to change her position and claimed that his disability may have been a factor in his inability to control his behavior.
There was no evidence of any disability that would interfere with STUDENT’s ability to control his behavior. He was receiving special education at the time of the incident because of a mild learning disability. There was no evidence that such a disability would impact STUDENT’s ability to control his behavior.
At the time of the manifestation determination, the IEP team members concluded that he might not still have a learning disability. The IEP team decided that there was some limited evidence of mild attention deficit disorder (ADD). The school psychologist, Ms. Martineau, observed incidents of distraction during testing that could be attributed to ADD. STUDENT’s mother also told school authorities that a doctor had diagnosed STUDENT as having ADD. There was no evidence connecting STUDENT’s mild ADD to an inability to control his behavior.
There was some testimony that impulsiveness may have been a problem with STUDENT, but no testing or other objective evidence supported such a conclusion. Moreover, even if STUDENT was impulsive, the facts surrounding the fight do not reflect impulsive behavior. He agreed during a basketball game to meet the other student for a fight after the game. He returned home to put on looser clothing that would be better for fighting and then returned to the scene of the preplanned fight. These facts do not reflect an impulsive act.
STUDENT’s testimony concerning this and the other disciplinary events do not reflect behavior caused by a disability. He said that he behaved badly in his world history class and his wood shop class because he did not like the teachers. In the classes of the teachers he liked, he behaved well and had no behavior problems. This selective behavior would be inconsistent with behavior caused by a disability. STUDENT’s testimony concerning the January 19, 2005 fight persuaded the Hearing Officer that STUDENT’s conduct was a result of delinquency, not disability. He seemed to enjoy describing the details of the fight and his ultimate victory. Although he was coached by his mother and counsel to say he was sorry, his demeanor did not reflect true contrition.
There is no evidence that STUDENT’s disabilities interfered with his ability to control his behavior in relation to the January 19, 2005 fight. Therefore, it is concluded that the IEP team correctly concluded that STUDENT’s conduct of fighting with another student on January 19, 2005, was not a manifestation of his disability.
ORDER
1. All of Petitioners claims are denied.
2. The District may proceed with its proposed discipline of STUDENT consistent with laws governing discipline of nondisabled students.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the only issues heard and decided in this decision.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this Decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: March 28, 2005 Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Haring Office
1. At the beginning of the hearing, STUDENT’s attorney stated that she was not claiming that STUDENT could not control his behavior. However, later in the hearing STUDENT’s attorney appeared to change her position and claimed that because of his disability and the District’s failure to address STUDENT’s behavior problems in his IEP, he might not have been able to control his behavior. STUDENT himself testified that he believed his fighting with the other student was a manifestation of his disability. Therefore, this contention will be addressed in the Decision.
