California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 20, 2000

Student v. Alameda County Mental Health

SEHO Case No. SN 385-00 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard

Alameda County Mental Health made a valid AB 3632 outpatient therapy offer; parent's private therapy reimbursement claim denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The student's father filed for a hearing against Alameda County Mental Health. The student turned 18 before the hearing and gave him written authorization to proceed for her. She was eligible for special education under the category of serious emotional disturbance and attended Pleasanton Unified School District. A 1998 AB 3632 mental health assessment recommended day treatment, but the family declined it. At a February 17, 1999 IEP meeting, county representative Carolyn Novosel offered outpatient therapy at the county's Valley Mental Health clinic in Pleasanton. The father rejected the offer and said the family wanted a private therapist. Starting in November 1999, the student saw that therapist weekly, and the family asked to be repaid about $1,700. At the hearing, the father said he had confused Valley Mental Health with a different local agency staffed by interns. Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard found the written offer valid and clear. The father had signed the IEP that named the clinic, and he never told the team why he objected. Testimony from clinic supervisor Gerome Miller showed the clinic was appropriate for the student, and the father agreed. The Hearing Officer also ruled that AB 3632 regulations let the county choose the provider except in emergencies. She denied both repayment and future funding of the private therapist. She noted that the therapist could still apply to join the county's provider network.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith to an AB 3632 mental health offer. A signed IEP naming the service and the provider was enough. A parent who rejects an offer without stating any objection weakens a later reimbursement claim. The county, not the parent, chose outpatient therapy providers outside emergencies.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did Alameda County Mental Health make a valid offer of appropriate mental health services to the student under AB 3632 from January 1999 to the present?

    The February 17, 1999 IEP contained a clear, valid written offer of outpatient therapy at Valley Mental Health. The parent signed it and gave no reason for rejecting it, and the services were appropriate. Any failure to list frequency, location, and duration caused no prejudice.

  2. Issue 2. If a valid offer was not made, is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for private therapy services the student received during this period?

    Because a valid offer was made and declined, reimbursement and prospective funding of the private therapist were denied. AB 3632 regulations leave the choice of provider to the county except in emergencies.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Petitioner's requests for relief, including reimbursement of about $1,700 for private therapy and prospective funding of the private therapist, were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Gov. Code § 7570 et seq. (AB 3632); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 2, § 60020; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 2, § 60040(e); Ed. Code § 56041.5

People named in the decision

  • Carolyn Novosel, Chief of Children's Specialized Services (AB 3632); county representative at IEP meetings; witness, Alameda County Mental Health
  • Gerome Miller, Chief psychiatric social worker and clinic supervisor; witness, Alameda County Mental Health, Valley Children's Services / Valley Mental Health
  • Audrey Sable, Licensed clinical social worker; children's therapist offered to student, Valley Children's Services / Valley Mental Health
  • Ms. Young, Licensed clinical social worker; AB 3632 mental health assessor, Alameda County Mental Health
  • Hugh Bain, School psychologist; assessor, Pleasanton Unified School District
  • Ken Ensroth, Child and adolescent psychiatrist; private evaluator, Menninger Institute, Topeka, Kansas
  • Dr. Stewart, Private therapist, Private practice
  • Discovery Academy, Private residential placement in Utah
  • Valley Mental Health, County outpatient mental health clinic offered, Alameda County Mental Health

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Oakland, California, on March 30, 2000.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by her father, MR. PARENT. STUDENT was not present at the hearing.

Respondent Alameda County Mental Health (Mental Health) was represented at the hearing by Willie Lott, Jr., Deputy County Counsel. Also present for the Respondent was Carolyn Novosel.

Petitioner’s only witness was her father, Mr. PARENT. Respondent called the following witnesses: Ms. Novosel, chief of Children’s Specialized Services, which includes AB 3632 services, and Mr. Gerome Miller, chief psychiatric social worker and supervisor of Valley Children’s Services.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and an oral closing argument was made by the parties. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the outset of the hearing, the Hearing Officer noted that, although Mr. PARENT had filed the request for a due process hearing on March 7, 2000, STUDENT had turned eighteen years of age on March 20, 2000. Under California Education Code § 56041.5, at age eighteen, “all other rights accorded to a parent under this part shall transfer to the individual with exceptional needs.” (Footnote 1) The hearing recessed to allow Mr. PARENT to meet with STUDENT and obtain a written authorization from her to proceed on her behalf. STUDENT’s written authorization was obtained and entered into evidence. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 1). (Footnote 2)

Prior to this recess, Respondent made a motion to dismiss the case based on the Petitioner’s failure to provide a written statement of issues ten days in advance of the hearing and to provide a list of witnesses and a copy of documents to be introduced five business days before the hearing as required by Education Code §§ 56505(e) (6) and (e)(7). This motion was denied. Respondent was given an opportunity to request a continuance if it believed additional time was required to prepare for hearing. After discussion of the issues, Respondent agreed to proceed with its case.

ISSUES

1. Did Alameda County Mental Health make a valid offer of appropriate mental health services to STUDENT under AB 3632 from January 1999 to the present?

2. If a valid offer was not made, is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for private therapy services STUDENT received during this period?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The offer of AB 3632 mental health services, which is the subject of dispute in this matter, was made by Respondent at STUDENT’s individualized educational program (IEP) meeting at the Pleasanton Unified School District on February 17, 2000. The offer was for outpatient therapy at Valley Mental Health, one of Respondent’s six outpatient mental health clinics.

Petitioner contends that Mental Health’s offer was not valid because Mr. PARENT misunderstood it. When he heard the reference to “Valley Mental Health,” he believed the offer was for services at an agency which had been called “The Center” and which, according to Mr. PARENT, was later called “Valley Community Mental Health Center.” STUDENT had received outpatient therapeutic services at this agency. Based on this experience, Mr. PARENT believed it to be inappropriate for STUDENT because it was staffed by interns without experience with adolescents. Both “Valley Mental Health” and “The Center/Valley Community Mental Health Center” are located in Pleasanton, California. Mr. PARENT asserted that these names are commonly confused. Once the confusion about the agency at which the services were offered was clarified, Petitioner conceded that the qualifications of the therapists offered by Mental Health were sufficient. Petitioner asserts, however, that at this juncture it would be detrimental to STUDENT to change an established relationship with her private therapist.

Respondent contends that the offer contained in the February 17, 1999 IEP was a valid offer which Mr. PARENT flatly rejected because he wanted STUDENT to see a private therapist. In its view, the Petitioner’s current assertion that Mr. PARENT misunderstood the offer is a “smoke screen” or false issue and his goal all along was to obtain private therapy. Respondent alleges that the only articulated reason for rejection of the offer at the IEP was a desire for private therapy. Any alleged confusion about the agency being offered would have been erased in February 1999 had Mr. PARENT indicated the basis for his rejection.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Testimony Relating to Chronology of Events

Mr. PARENT testified that STUDENT was identified as having dyslexia while she was in the third grade in the San Francisco Unified School District (San Francisco). Her initial eligibility for special education was due to her specific learning disability. San Francisco placed her in a resource specialist program (RSP), with tutoring and counseling. She also was qualified for mental health services under AB 3632. At the time she was determined eligible for mental health services, STUDENT was already seeing a private therapist. San Francisco agreed to pay for her private counseling and did so for approximately two years.

In 1992, the PARENT family moved to the Pleasanton Unified School District (the District) in Alameda County. According to Mr. PARENT, the family decided not to pursue AB 3632 services at that time because they wanted to help STUDENT mainstream and avoid the stigma of receiving mental health services. When STUDENT reached age 13 or 14, however, she began to exhibit out- of-control behaviors. In early 1997, the family had her evaluated by Ken Ensroth, a child and adolescent psychiatrist at the Menninger Institute in Topeka, Kansas. His diagnosis indicated that STUDENT had a depressive disorder not otherwise specified, with features of dysthymia and oppositional-defiant disorder. His report also indicated that STUDENT exhibited histrionic, narcissistic and borderline traits and that she was experiencing acute stress and conflicts with her parents, who had recently divorced. At some point, she threatened suicide and was hospitalized. The family realized that STUDENT needed more help.

Mr. PARENT testified that the family placed STUDENT at the Discovery Academy, a residential placement in Utah, without contacting the District. Instead, the family used educational consultants, placed STUDENT in Discovery, and then went through the process of trying to work with the District. (Footnote 3) STUDENT was in residence at the Discovery Academy for twenty months.

In February 1998, while at the Discovery program, STUDENT was assessed by District psychologist Hugh Bain. Based upon this assessment, she was determined to be eligible for special education as an individual with a serious emotional disturbance. (Footnote 4)

On June 15, 1998, STUDENT was assessed for AB 3632 mental health services by Ms. Young, a licensed clinical social worker (LCSW). (Respondent’s Exhibit C). She was determined to be eligible for services. Ms. Young indicated that “day treatment is recommended to facilitate her return home and to the community, and to support the gains she has made thus far. As part of that program, STUDENT should have a medication evaluation and, should medication be indicated, follow-up medication monitoring is recommended.” Mental health goals and objectives for STUDENT were attached to the assessment report, which was provided to the parents. On July 3, 1998, STUDENT’s mother signed the assessment report giving consent for STUDENT to receive treatment. Mr. PARENT testified that, after this assessment, he contacted a woman from Mental Health to “find out what day treatments centers were in the area...and to get some literature on those.”

On November 18, 1998, an IEP meeting was convened at the District to “establish eligibility for AB 3632 services and to discuss placement options for STUDENT” on her return from Discovery in December 1998. (Respondent’s Exhibit G). Carolyn Novosel, chief of Children’s Specialized Services, was present for Mental Health. The IEP Team Summary/Addendum indicates that STUDENT’s treating therapist at Discovery recommended that she return to a school with a small class size. A “therapeutic” school was not recommended for her. Ms. Novosel testified that she first learned that the parents were no longer interested in day treatment services for STUDENT at this IEP meeting. According to Ms. Novosel, they briefly talked about day treatment but the family was not inclined to accept those services as they wanted a more normal environment for her, “possibly with outpatient support.” (Respondent’s Exhibit F). Ms. Novosel told the parents about the range of services Mental Health could offer STUDENT. As indicated on IEP Team Summary/Addendum dated November 18, 1998, she offered STUDENT “outpatient mental health services 2 - 4 x per month, as well as psychiatric services as needed.” (Respondent’s Exhibit G). This IEP Addendum was not signed by the parents.

STUDENT’s most recent IEP meeting was held on February 17, 1999. (Footnote 5) The parties agreed that most of the time at this lengthy (2.5 to 3 hour) IEP meeting was spent addressing STUDENT’s educational program. (Footnote 6) Carolyn Novosel again participated in the IEP meeting for Mental Health. Ms. Novosel testified that at this IEP meeting she made an offer of outpatient therapy services for STUDENT at Respondent’s Valley Mental Health outpatient clinic. While Ms. Novosel testified that she did not recall the exact name she used to describe the facility being offered, both the IEP document and her contemporaneously typed notes from this meeting indicate that the offer was for services at “Valley Mental Health.” (Respondent’s Exhibits A & D). Ms. Novosel did not recall that she ever used the name “The Center.” The IEP Summary/Addendum of this date stated: “An IEP meeting was conducted to review STUDENT’s academic program and discuss AB 3632 services....A discussion centering on out-patient services was initiated with STUDENT’s parents. Outpatient services at Valley Mental Health were offered to STUDENT by County Mental Health. STUDENT’s parents are interested in counseling services with a private therapist. STUDENT’s parents will pursue due process mediation to resolve the issues regarding out-patient services.” (Respondent’s Exhibit A). Both the IEP and the IEP Summary/Addendum were signed by Mr. PARENT.

Ms. Novosel testified that, in response to the offer, Mr. PARENT advised her that he was not interested and that they had chosen to seek out counseling services for STUDENT from an independent therapist, Dr. Stewart. Mr. PARENT did not explain why he was not interested, other than to say that STUDENT had “unique and special needs.” She asked what they were, but there was no further discussion about it. Ms. Novosel testified that the subject of private therapy in San Francisco came up at this IEP meeting. Mr. PARENT specifically advised her that San Francisco County paid for STUDENT’s private therapy and asked why Alameda County would not pay for it. Ms. Novosel explained that Alameda was a managed care county which has a provider network that included the community mental health clinics. She advised Mr. PARENT that, if STUDENT’s private therapist was a member of the provider network or if she was interested in becoming one, “we could try and work that out.” She testified that when she asked whether this therapist would be interested in becoming a member of the provider network in Alameda County, Mr. PARENT did not give much response and may have said he would think about it. (Footnote 7) Ms. Novosel’s contemporaneously typed notes from the February 17, 1999 IEP meeting are consistent with this testimony. (Respondent’s Exhibit D).

Mr. PARENT testified that he rejected the offer at the February 17, 1999 IEP meeting because, based on his understanding of what was being offered, it was not appropriate. Mr. PARENT acknowledged that the IEP Addendum/Summary document, which he signed, indicated that the offer of services was at “Valley Mental Health.” He denied that the Addendum was a verbatim transcript. When asked whether he explained to Ms. Novosel or to anyone else at the meeting why he believed those services were not appropriate, he answered, “No, the question was not asked.” When asked whether he explained that STUDENT had been to a place called “The Center” on previous occasions and, based on that experience, he felt that the services provided there were not appropriate, he answered, “No, she did not ask.” Mr. PARENT testified that he did not offer any explanation for his reasons for objecting to the services “because nobody challenged our refusal.” The rejection of outpatient services was “based on our experience with the place that we thought she was offering.”

Mr. PARENT testified that he was referred to Dr. Stewart in December 1998. STUDENT saw her two times in January 1999, once with her parents present. Because STUDENT was resistant to continuing therapy, she then took a break from therapy until November 1999. This therapeutic hiatus was based solely on Mr. PARENT’s perception of STUDENT’s needs and was not attributable to Mental Health’s offer.

In November 1999, STUDENT returned to therapy with Dr. Stewart. Mr. PARENT did not contact Mental Health prior to restarting this therapy “in a nutshell because we were very enamored with Dr. Stewart’s qualifications and capability and assessment of STUDENT and her interaction with her for the two times that she did go to see her.” Mr. PARENT described STUDENT as an individual with a very forceful personality who is very good at controlling and manipulating people, particularly professional people who are used to dealing with children. He believed that STUDENT had been able to “run over” the therapists she had seen at “The Center.” Mr. PARENT testified that STUDENT received therapy at “The Center” in 1996, and again in the spring of 1997 after the name had been changed to “Valley Community Mental Health Center.” The last time STUDENT received therapy at this location was the first quarter of 1997, before she left for Discovery Academy. Since November, STUDENT has seen Dr. Stewart once a week with few exceptions. Her sessions are $90.00 each. Mr. PARENT's insurance pays $25 per session. Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the balance, which is currently about $1,700.00.

Both Mr. PARENT and Ms. Novosel testified that the confusion about the location of the offered outpatient treatment was clarified at the mediation in late January 2000. Ms. Novosel heard Mr. PARENT use various names for the outpatient clinic and became aware that Mr. PARENT interpreted “Valley Mental Health” clinic as being “The Center.” She then looked up the actual address of the Valley Mental Health and provided it to Mr. PARENT. She gave Mr. PARENT the name and phone number for Gerome Miller, the supervisor of Valley Mental Health/Valley Children’s Services. (Footnote 8) She also sent Mr. Miller a referral packet of information on STUDENT consisting of her AB 3632 assessment and IEP.

Mr. Miller testified that, after reviewing her referral packet, he concluded that Valley Children’s Service was an appropriate outpatient clinic for STUDENT. Her issues seemed very similar to cases they have involving adolescents facing issues of depression, agitated depression with acting out, or ADHD behaviors which may develop into bipolar. (Footnote 9) He also concluded that a referral to Audrey Sable, one of their full-time children’s therapists, was appropriate for STUDENT for several reasons. Ms. Sable is an LCSW with experience working with seriously mentally disturbed adolescents and young adults. She had an opening at the time. Mr. Miller was also aware that STUDENT was close to age eighteen and was probably experiencing transitional young adult issues. He believed she would relate better with a female therapist.

Mr. Miller spoke to Mr. PARENT one time by telephone and arranged for him to speak to Ms. Sable. During this call, Mr. Miller had the impression that Mr. PARENT was more interested in checking staff qualifications than seeking services for STUDENT. Thereafter, Mr. Miller had only brief contact with Ms. Sable about her conversation with Mr. PARENT. The week before the hearing, Ms. Sable put a letter in his box which she had received from Mr. PARENT. Mr. Miller did not recall the contents of the letter other than that Mr. PARENT had asked her to confirm some statements she had allegedly made during their conversation. (Footnote 10)

Mr. PARENT testified that Ms. Sable called and offered STUDENT a therapy appointment. Mr. PARENT told her STUDENT already had a therapeutic relationship with Dr. Stewart and had no desire to change therapists.

Ms. Novosel testified that Mental Health is still prepared to offer outpatient mental health treatment services to STUDENT at Valley Mental Health in Pleasanton.

Testimony Relating to Valley Mental Health and Valley Community Health Care Center

Mr. Miller testified that “Valley Mental Health” is the umbrella organization for the combined operation of adult and children outpatient mental health services in Pleasanton. Valley Children Services is the children’s mental health clinic. It has also been known in the past as Valley Children and Youth Services and as Valley Children’s Outpatient (VCO). They became Valley Children Services about two years ago. (Footnote 11) Valley Mental Health has used the same name at the same location on Hopyard Road in Pleasanton since the mid-1970s. All telephone calls received at this Pleasanton site, for both the children and the adult services, are answered by the name Valley Mental Health.

Mr. Miller testified that a wide range of outpatient mental health services are provided at Valley Children’s Services/Valley Mental Health, including individual, family, group, and play therapy. A good percentage of their clients are seen for disorders related to depression and ADHD. They have always served children with the most severe emotional and behavioral mental health problems. These children, known as specialty mental health Level I designated clients, are children coming out of residential placements, day treatment, and psychiatric hospitalizations. Valley Mental Health is level I facility with 5150 capacity. (Footnote 12) It works closely with hospitals, receives notification when their clients are hospitalized, and has a system of care approach. Children with less severe mental illnesses are referred out. Valley Children’s Services receives many AB 3632 referrals and, in general, works closely with the schools. (Footnote 13)

Mr. Miller testified that he was familiar with “The Center.” This agency was later subsumed in and is now part of “Valley Community Health Care Center.” Neither entity was ever called a “Mental Health” center. By contrast, Valley Mental Health has always been the mental health clinic in Pleasanton. He testified that Valley Community Health Center is the medically indigent (MIA) program under contract with the county. (Footnote 14) Although it offered psychotherapy to children, adolescents and adults, Valley Community Health Care Center did not provide services comparable to Valley Children’s because it is a Level 3 provider, serving people with situational adjustment problems, lesser depression problems and those who are not suicidal. One component of its program was staffed by interns; there was also a private practice component. Mr. Miller testified that he would classify STUDENT as a Level I client. In his opinion, sending STUDENT to Valley Community Health Care Center would not be an appropriate level of care for her.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Education Code § 5600. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997).

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). Education Code § 56363 (a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of possible related services are psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, parent counseling and training, health and nursing services, specially designed vocational education and career development, and counseling and guidance. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (22) (1997); California Educ. Code § 56363 (b) (1987).

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. At 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415 (b) (1997). Parents also have the right not to consent to all or part of a recommended IEP. “No pupil shall be required to participate in all or part of any special education program unless the parent...consents, in writing, to all or part of the” IEP. Education Code §56346 (a). If the parent does not consent and the district determines that the program is necessary to provide the student with a FAPE, it must institute a due process hearing. Education Code §56346 (b).

Offer of Mental Health Services

AB 3632 Mental Health Services

Assembly Bill (AB) 3632/882, which is codified at California Government Code §§ 7570 - 7588, Chapter 26.5, describes interagency responsibilities for providing services, including mental health services, to children with disabilities. (Footnote 15) Pursuant to that Act, “ensuring maximum utilization of all state and federal resources available to provide a child with a disability... with a free appropriate public education, the provision of related services...and designated instruction and services...shall be the joint responsibility of the Superintendent of Public Instruction and the Secretary of Health and Welfare.” (Gov. Code § 7570). The State Department of Mental Health, or any community mental health service, “shall be responsible for the provision of mental health services, as defined in regulations by the State Department of Mental Health, developed in consultation with the State Department of Education, when required in the pupil’s individualized education program.” Gov. Code § 7576(a).

The regulations which implement Chapter 26.5 are expressly applicable to, inter alia, the State Departments of Mental Health and their designated local agencies. (Title 2 California Code of Regulations § 6000). (Footnote 16) Their expressed intent “is to assure conformity with the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act or IDEA, Sections 1400 et. seq. of Title 20 of the United States Code, and its implementing regulations.... Thus, provisions of this chapter shall be construed as supplemental to, and in the context of, federal and state laws and regulations relating to interagency responsibilities for providing services to pupils with disabilities.” 2 Calif. Code Regs. § 6000. The regulations provide that “special education instruction, designated instruction and services, related services, and residential placements are to be provided at no cost to the parent.” 2 Cal. Code. Reg.§ 60200 (b).

A review of the Chapter 26.5 and its implementing regulations reveals a three-stage process for obtaining mental health services: the initial referral for assessment, the actual assessment of a student for mental health services and the development of the IEP to offer appropriate services. The assessment report is the basic document for determining eligibility for mental health services. If the pupil is determined eligible for mental health services, the assessment report also provides treatment recommendations, which Alameda County calls a “recommended mode of service.” The written assessment report of June 15, 1998 concluded that STUDENT was eligible for AB 3632 mental health services. The recommended mode of service was identified as day treatment services with medication evaluation and monitoring. The parent gave written permission for Respondent to provide these services to STUDENT.

In this case, there is no dispute that STUDENT was appropriately referred to and assessed by Mental Health as eligible for mental health services. After the Petitioner declined day treatment services, the written assessment report was not amended to reflect the change in the recommended mode of service from day treatment to outpatient therapy. There is nothing in the definition of “assessment,” however, to support the notion that Mental Health was obligated to prepare another written assessment formally changing its recommendation of the type of services offered. A “mental health assessment” is defined as a “service designed to provide formal, documented evaluation or analysis of the nature of the pupil’s emotional or behavioral disorder” which is conducted in accordance with the assessment procedures under Education Code §§ 56320 through 56329 and Title 9 Calif. Code Regs. § 543(b). 2 Calif. Code Regs. § 60020(g). Assessment services are “limited to an intake examination, mental health evaluation, physical examination, and laboratory testing necessary for the evaluation and treatment of the patient’s mental health needs.” Title 9 Calif. Code Regs. § 543(b). Ms. Novosel testified that, once the assessment recommendation is made and the parents sign it, they can change their mind about the type of treatment, for example, by declining day treatment and asking for outpatient therapy. In such cases, the change in recommended mental health services will be documented at the IEP meeting and the IEP summary/addendum will document if there has been discussion about what is being offered.

The evidence established that, after Mental Health was made aware that the Petitioner declined day treatment services, Ms. Novosel made a general offer of outpatient mental health services for two to four times a month at the IEP meeting in November 1998. She also made a specific offer for outpatient therapy at Valley Mental Health at the IEP meeting of February 1999. As discussed below, the Hearing Officer concludes that Mental Health made a valid offer of appropriate outpatient mental health services to STUDENT, which is contained in the February 17, 1999 IEP.

Procedural Validity of the Offer of Mental Health Services “Mental health services” are defined to mean “mental health assessments and the following services when delineated on an IEP in accordance with Section 7572(d) of the Government Code: psychotherapy...provided to the pupil individually or in a group, collateral services, medication monitoring, intensive day treatment, day rehabilitation, and case management....” Title 2 Calif. Code Regs. § 60020 (i). Government Code § 7572 (d) provides that “a related service or designated instruction and service shall only be added to the child’s individualized education program by the individualized education program team...if a formal assessment has been conducted pursuant to this section, and a qualified person conducting the assessment recommended the service in order for the child to benefit from special education.”

Under the AB 3632 statute and its implementing regulations, the offer of mental health services is made by the IEP team. Government Code § 7572. The assessment report by Mental Health is reviewed by the IEP team. If the parent disagrees with the assessment report, the parent may request that the person who conducted the assessment attend the meeting to discuss the recommendation. Gov. Code § 7572(d)(1). (Footnote 17) “Whenever a related [mental health] service... is to be considered for inclusion in the child’s individualized educational program, the local education agency shall invite the responsible public agency representative to meet with the individualized education program team to determine the need for the service and participate in developing the individualized education program.” Government Code § 7572(e). If the representative cannot meet with the team, “conference calls, together with written recommendations, are acceptable forms of participation.” Government Code § 7572(e).

In this case, Mental Health’s participation at the IEP team meetings in November 1998 and February 1999 culminated in an offer by Ms. Novosel of outpatient service for STUDENT at Valley Mental Health. The offer reflected an attempt by Respondent to find a placement which would be acceptable to the parents and which would incorporate the parents’ desire for a less restrictive therapeutic placement for STUDENT. As such, Mental Health’s offer of services was consistent with the legislative intent of the statute. In determining appropriate mental health services under the Act, “it is the intent of the Legislature that the local education agency and the community mental health service vigorously attempt to develop a mutually satisfactory placement that is acceptable to the parent and addresses the pupil’s educational and mental health treatment needs in a manner that is cost-effective for both public agencies, subject to the requirements of state and federal special education law, including the requirement that the placement be appropriate and in the least restrictive environment.” Government Code § 7576 (a).

Once a mental health service is determined to be necessary by the IEP team, the mental health portion of the IEP must contain a description of the present levels of social and emotional performance; the goals and objectives of the mental health services with objective criteria and evaluation procedures to determine whether they are being achieved; a description of the types of the mental health services to be provided; and the initiation, duration and frequency of the mental health services. Title 2 Calif. Code Regs. § 60050 (a). Respondent included its mental health goals and objectives for STUDENT in its assessment report which was given to the IEP team. Ms. Novosel testified that the actual IEP document is drafted by a person from the school district. (Footnote 18)

The IDEA also provides guidance regarding the procedural appropriateness of offers of related services. “The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child. See 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1)(C).” Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S. Ct. 428 (1994). In Union, the Ninth Circuit noted that the requirement of a formal, specific offer serves important purposes. “The requirement of a formal, written offer creates a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when educational placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement. Furthermore, a formal, specific offer from a school district will greatly assist parents in “presenting complaints with respect to any matter relating to the...educational placement of the child.” 20 U.S.C. 1415(b)(1)(E).” A formal offer would also have alerted the parents “of the need to seriously consider whether the offer was an appropriate placement under the IDEA.” The court determined that this requirement is “not merely technical” and “should be enforced rigorously.” Id.

The Hearing Officer concludes that a valid written offer for outpatient mental health services at Valley Mental Health clinic was made to Petitioner at the IEP meeting of February 17, 1999 which covered the relevant time period. (Footnote 19) This offer was contained in the IEP document signed by Mr. PARENT on February 17, 1999 and it was clearly written on the IEP Summary/Addendum sheet on which his signature again appears. The offer clearly identified the nature of the services offered and the service provider. Although Mr. PARENT testified that the summary was “not a verbatim transcript” of the meeting, it must be presumed that he read the document which he signed. To the extent Petitioner is contending that a different clinic was verbally offered during the course of the IEP meeting, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer was for services at Valley Mental Health. This is further supported by Ms. Novosel’s contemporaneous notes of this IEP meeting, which indicate the offer was for services at Valley Mental Health. (Respondent’s Exhibit D).

The Hearing Officer also finds that it was unreasonable for Mr. PARENT to have rejected Mental Health’s offer without providing any basis for doing so when he now contends that, at the time, he had a strong objection to its adequacy as a treatment resource for STUDENT. As noted by the Court in Union v. Smith, the purpose of a formal, specific offer is to alert the parent “of the need to seriously consider whether the offer was an appropriate placement...” (Id. at 1526, emphasis added.) Based on the evidence presented, it does not appear that Petitioner seriously considered this offer, because Petitioner failed to make known Mr. PARENT’s serious objections about the qualifications of the therapists at the agency he believed was being offered. As discussed below, several facts point to the unreasonableness of this rejection.

First, the Hearing Officer finds that Mr. PARENT is a sophisticated consumer of services who has fought for educational placements and services he believed were appropriate for STUDENT. If he were genuinely seeking services for STUDENT through the community mental health outpatient clinics, it is likely that he would have made his objections to the offered agency known. It is noteworthy that, when Petitioner was interested in day treatment service, Mr. PARENT sought out information from Mental Health. Second, at the time the offer was made, Mr. PARENT’s only articulated reason for his rejection of outpatient services was a desire to pursue counseling services with a private therapist. The evidence indicated that the PARENT family had met with Dr. Stewart prior to the February 1999 IEP meeting and were pleased with her abilities and qualifications. Although Mr. PARENT contends that STUDENT has an established relationship with Dr. Stewart, at the time the offer was rejected she had only seen Dr. Stewart on two occasions. Third, at the time the offer was made, Mr. PARENT specifically advised Ms. Novosel that San Francisco County had paid for STUDENT’s private therapy and asked why Alameda County would not pay for it. He advised the IEP team that he would pursue due process mediation to resolve this issue. Fourth, according to Mr. Miller’s testimony, neither The Center nor Valley Community Health Care has ever used the term “Mental Health” in its title. The Hearing Officer finds Mr. Miller’s testimony highly credible based on his knowledge of the Pleasanton community and his experience in the mental health field. Fifth, according to Mr. PARENT’s testimony, STUDENT had not gone to The Center/Valley Community Health Care for therapy since the first quarter of 1997. By the time of Mental Health’s offer, nearly two years had elapsed. Even if the offer had been for therapy at this agency, it is unreasonable to assume that the qualifications of the providing therapists would be identical two years later. Sixth, by failing to alert Mental Health of these strong objections, Mr. PARENT denied Respondent an opportunity to determine if there was a legitimate basis for his concern and to cure the problem, if necessary.

The Hearing Officer also concludes that Respondent was under no obligation to pursue Petitioner with its offer after Petitioner rejected the offer of services in February 1999. First, there was no showing that Respondent had a policy to pursue a parent who “flatly rejected” an offer of services at an IEP meeting. Ms. Novosel’s testimony indicated that there is no follow up where a parent flatly rejects mental health services after a mental health assessment has been completed. (Footnote 20) Second, there is nothing in the statute or regulations to suggest such an obligation. In contrast, there are repeated references to the necessity for parental consent for mental health services. Once mental health services are included in the IEP, the regulations require “parental approval for the provision of mental health services. This signed consent for treatment is in addition to the signed IEP.” Title 2 Calif. Code Regs. § 60050 (a), emphasis added. This underscores Ms. Novosel’s testimony that community mental health services are essentially voluntary services.

Substantive Validity of the Offer of Mental Health Services

Through the testimony of Mr. Miller, Respondent amply demonstrated that the qualifications of its therapists and the services it offered to STUDENT at Valley Children’s Services/Valley Mental Health were appropriate to treat her unique mental health needs. Mr. PARENT does not dispute this; in fact, he agreed that these services would be appropriate if he was looking for a therapist for STUDENT at this time. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondent’s offer of mental health services provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the relevant time period. Reimbursement for Private Therapy Services

Because Respondent made a valid offer of mental health services, which Petitioner declined, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for costs of private therapy. During closing argument, Petitioner also requested an order that private therapy with her current therapist be funded prospectively. This request is also denied.

There is no authority under AB 3632 for a parent to decline outpatient mental health services at a community mental health clinic in favor of a private therapist. The regulations clearly provide that mental health services, including psychotherapy, “shall be provided directly or by contract at the discretion of the community mental health service of the county of origin.” 2 Calif. Code Regs. § 60020(i). The only exception in the regulations which specifically allows a parent to “seek services from other public programs or private providers” is “in responding to psychiatric emergencies or other situations requiring immediate response.” 2 Calif. Code Regs. § 60040(e). There was no such emergency involved in this case. Moreover, Ms. Novosel provided Petitioner with information about how STUDENT’s private therapist, Dr. Stewart, might be funded through Alameda County: i.e., by voluntarily joining the managed care provider network. Petitioner expressed no interest and there was no follow up. According to Ms. Novosel, this option is still available to Petitioner prospectively, if Dr. Stewart is willing to complete an application for membership. Petitioner is encouraged to explore this funding avenue if interested.

ORDER

Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. On the first issue, the Respondent prevailed.

2. On the second issue, the Respondent prevailed.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: April 20, 2000 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. The code provides an exception for those individuals who have been determined to be incompetent under state law. Mr. PARENT indicated that STUDENT is not under conservatorship.

2. Prior to introducing the authorization, Mr. PARENT was placed under oath and testified that STUDENT had signed the authorization form.

3. Mr. PARENT testified that “rather than to go to the district, which one might assume would be our first course of action, we had just come from several years experience with the San Francisco School District of having to find out what STUDENT was entitled to, request those services, have them be denied and have to go through a due process hearing or mediation hearing to get those. So our experience was that if we need help, it certainly isn’t through the district unless we have time to take legal action.”

4. When the federal IDEA was amended in 1997, the term “serious emotional disturbance” was changed to “emotional disturbance,” and the federal regulations embody this change. See: 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4). The California special education regulation still uses the term “serious emotional disturbance” (See: Calif. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(i)) and that term will be used in this decision.

5. All parties agree that this IEP was the most recent one. Even though the IEP indicates on its face that an annual review was scheduled for September 1999, Mr. PARENT stated this has not occurred and they have been working through the resource specialist on STUDENT’s academic program at the District.

6. The IEP indicated that STUDENT’s recommended program is regular education with RSP services and 1 to 2 courses of independent study. Fifty percent of her time is not in general education because “STUDENT can’t have a full day schedule because of her mental health needs.” Modifications indicated are “use of calculator on computational type math problems; additional time needed for SAT/ACT/College Placement Tests.” The IEP does not contain any goals or objectives related to STUDENT’s mental health needs. The IEP does not list mental health services under Recommended Program or designated instructional services (DIS), California’s term for related services.

7. According to Ms. Novosel, “becoming a member” means that the private therapist must submit a resume, agree to have some insurance, agree to take a limited number of referrals and sign a contract. This is a voluntary process that Dr Stewart would have to undertake. It was not done in this case because there was no expressed interest or further discussion. It would be possible to fund STUDENT’s private therapist in the future if the therapist was interested in following up.

8. Mr. Miller is the chief psychiatric social worker and supervisor of two of Respondent’s mental health outpatient clinics for children: Eden Children’s Services in San Leandro and Valley Children’s Services in Pleasanton. He has also been responsible for setting up two school-based day-treatment programs. He has been a licensed clinical social worker since 1969.

9. Dr. Stewart described STUDENT as suffering “a significant personality disorder with impulsivity, poor judgment, depression and intermittent rages.” (Respondents Exhibit I). Mr. Miller agreed that this description is a typical description of the adolescents Valley Children’s Services sees.

10. On cross-examination, Mr. Miller verified that a letter from Mr. PARENT to Ms. Sable, dated March 15, 2000, was the one which Ms. Sable placed in his box. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 2). The Hearing Officer concludes that this letter is entitled to little weight. It contains hearsay statements allegedly made by Ms. Sable during her conversation with Mr. PARENT. Although Mr. PARENT had asked Ms. Sable to initial these statements “as being substantially correct,” the letter is not signed or initialed by Ms. Sable, who was not called as a witness.

11. Mr. Miller testified that Valley Community Support Services, the adult outpatient side, used to be called Valley Adult Outpatient (VAO).

12. Welfare and Institutions Code § 5150 authorizes a 72-hour detention of any person who, as a result of a mental disorder, is a danger to others or to himself or herself, or who is gravely disabled.

13. Mr. Miller also testified about the composition and qualifications of the staff at Valley Children’s Services/Valley Mental Health. Because Mr. PARENT conceded that the qualifications of the staff were not an issue for him once the confusion about where the services were being offered was clarified, this testimony will not be addressed.

14. Mr. Miller testified that the only misconception in names of clinics over the years he was aware of is with between the medical clinics, Valley Public Health Office and Valley Community Health Care. There was never any confusion with the mental health clinics. He indicated that, when there is a 5150, the police come there. “It is like the community knows we are there...”

15. Legislation enacted in 1996 (AB 2726) amended or enacted provisions of this chapter. The commonly used term “AB 3632" will be used to refer to mental health services under this chapter.

16. The “Joint Regulations for Pupils with Disabilities, Interagency Responsibilities for Providing Services to Pupils with Disabilities,” contained in Title 2 California Code of Regulations § 6000, et seq., were issued as emergency regulations to implement the provisions of Chapter 26.5, pending enactment of final regulations. These emergency regulations were in effect at the time of the offer of mental health services in this case. All references to these regulations are to the emergency regulations. The final regulations went into effect on August 9, 1999. (Barclays California Code of Regulations, Title 2 § 6000 et seq. (8-13-99)).

17. Petitioner initially agreed to the assessment’s recommendation. At the hearing, no evidence was presented that Petitioner ever expressed a desire to have the assessor present at the IEP meeting.

18. The IDEA requires that the IEP include the “anticipated frequency, location, and duration of those services.” 20 U.S.C.1414 (D)(1)(A)(iv). Mental Health is responsible for complying with the terms of both IDEA and the mental health regulations. It must include this information in its offer or ensure that the District includes this information in the IEP. In this case, Petitioner was made aware of the frequency of therapy, 2 to 4 times per month, from the November 1998 IEP offer of services. Despite the confusion about the agency offered, the location requirement refers to whether the services were to be provided at the school site or at an agency off-site. It was clear that services were offered at the off-site mental health clinic. The offer was of an open-ended duration which is appropriate given STUDENT’s history. California follows the Ninth Circuit rule that procedural violations of IDEA do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE unless there is a showing of prejudice; i.e. a loss of educational opportunity or a serious infringement on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, supra, 960 F.2d 1479. In this case, there was no showing that Petitioner suffered prejudice from the failure to itemize these components in its offer.

19. Although the formal offer of mental health services was made on February 17, 1999, Petitioner was aware that Respondent was offering outpatient therapy to STUDENT as of November 1998.

20. Ms. Novosel testified that there is a tickler system in place if the parent does not sign an assessment report because, without the parent’s consent, there is no basis on which to convene an IEP meeting or to discuss the recommendations of Mental Health. The assessment report is the prelude to the IEP for mental health services. In these cases, 30 and 60 day tickler files are set up and notices are sent to the parent. By contrast, when mental health services are rejected by the parent at the IEP meeting, there is not a tickler system. Efforts are made to try to remedy the issue if it is made known. This is done in the discussion at the IEP meeting. If there is a flat rejection of services by the parent, there is not any follow up. Because in this case Ms. Novosel was told at the IEP meeting that due process was likely, she put it in a file and called mediator after receiving the mediation notice.