California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 6, 1997

Student v. Hollister School District

SEHO Case No. SN 385-96 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Hollister School District must reimburse a private neuropsychological evaluation; residential placement and emotional disturbance eligibility claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 31 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes that the Student sought a federal court order (U.S. District Court, Northern District of California) to stop the hearing in October 1996. The parties then agreed to continue the hearing. No later history is stated.

Summary

A seventh grader's parents filed for a hearing against Hollister School District. He was eligible for special education because of a traumatic brain injury and communication deficits. He attended general education classes with speech-language therapy and earned mostly A's and B's, but he had many discipline referrals for disruptive behavior. In August 1996, his parents placed him at Paradise Cove, a residential behavior-modification program in Western Samoa. They asked the District to repay those costs and years of private therapy and evaluations.

Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found that he did not qualify as seriously emotionally disturbed. Teachers described friendships and manageable behavior, his grades stayed high, and depression was found only during a brief hospitalization. Because he did well without services, he was not owed special education in 1993-1995. He also did not need psychotherapy or occupational therapy (OT) to benefit from school in 1995-1996. The District's 1995-1996 program and its spring 1996 IEP with a behavioral intervention plan were appropriate. So a residential placement was not required, and Paradise Cove costs were denied. Private speech, OT, and therapy costs were denied too.

However, the District's June 1995 assessment skipped motor and perceptual skills and did not adequately assess social, emotional, and behavioral needs. The District must repay Dr. Peter Karzmark's October 1995 neuropsychological evaluation. It must also hold an IEP meeting within 20 days to set how often counseling will be provided.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley's "some educational benefit" standard. Strong grades in general education defeated claims for emotional disturbance eligibility, private therapies, and an out-of-country residential placement. A district assessment that missed areas of suspected disability still led to repayment of a private evaluation the district later relied on.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Does STUDENT meet special education eligibility criteria as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?

    Student had some satisfactory relationships, his behavior was neither pervasive nor harmful to his educational performance, and depression appeared only during hospitalization, so he did not meet SED criteria.

  2. District prevailedChild find

    Issue 2. Was STUDENT entitled to special education services during the 1993-1994 and 1994-1995 school years?

    Student was properly exited in 1991 after assessment, no referral was warranted, and his strong grades showed he did not need speech or OT to benefit from instruction.

  3. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue 3. Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in June 1995?

    The assessment failed to assess motor/perceptual skills, relied on a test not normed for his age, and inadequately assessed social, emotional, and behavioral functioning.

  4. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 4. Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in March 1996?

    Given its limited purpose and the functional analysis assessment that followed, the March 1996 assessment was appropriate.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. Did STUDENT require psychological therapy during the 1995-1996 school year to benefit from his education?

    Student was benefiting from his education with good grades and achievement, so psychotherapy was not required.

  6. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 6. Did STUDENT require occupational therapy (OT) during the 1995-1996 school year to benefit from his education?

    The private OT assessment lacked school observation and relied on tests not normed for his age; the evidence did not show an educational need for OT.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 7. Did the District provide STUDENT with an appropriate education during the 1995-1996 school year?

    General education with language therapy met his needs, gave educational benefit under Rowley, and conformed to his IEP.

  8. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 8. Is STUDENT's current IEP, which was developed in March and April 1996 and includes the behavioral intervention plan, designed to meet his unique and individual needs?

    The IEP and behavioral intervention plan were thorough and appropriate, but they needed more detail on how often counseling would be provided.

  9. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9a. Shall STUDENT's current IEP be amended to include goals and objectives in conflict resolution?

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  10. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9b. Goals and objectives in anger control

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  11. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9c. Goals and objectives in denial of responsibility

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  12. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9d. Goals and objectives in accountability for actions

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  13. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9e. Goals and objectives in inappropriate inhibitions

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  14. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9f. Goals and objectives in provocation of others

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  15. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9g. Goals and objectives in derogatory remarks toward others

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  16. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9h. Goals and objectives in disrespect for authority figures and peers

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  17. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9i. Goals and objectives in self-respect

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  18. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9j. Goals and objectives in self-esteem

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  19. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9k. Goals and objectives in positive self-concept

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  20. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9l. Goals and objectives in development of appropriate relationships with peers and adults

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  21. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 9m. Goals and objectives in development of internal behavioral control

    The behavioral intervention plan already addresses this area, so no amendment was needed.

  22. Issue 10. Does STUDENT require a residential placement to receive a free appropriate public education?

    Student did well in general education. The evidence did not show that only a residential placement could meet his needs or that the placement was made for educational reasons.

  23. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 11. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1996-1997 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

    General education with language therapy and the behavioral intervention plan was appropriate. Even if failing to reconvene the August 1996 IEP meeting was a procedural violation, it caused no loss of educational opportunity and did not seriously limit parent participation.

  24. District prevailedResponsible agency

    Issue 12. Was the District required to refer STUDENT to Community Mental Health?

    Under Government Code section 7576, a referral would have been premature: no emotional condition impeded his educational benefit, and counseling had been offered through the behavioral intervention plan.

  25. Issue 13. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's placement at Paradise Cove, including residential, psychological, educational, and transportation costs?

    Because Student did not require a residential placement, Paradise Cove costs were not reimbursable.

  26. Issue 14. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent speech and language services provided by the Bay Area Speech and Language Services from September 1993 through January 1994?

    Student did not need speech-language services to benefit from his education in 1993-1994.

  27. Issue 15. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent OT provided by Donna Jackson from November 1993 to the present?

    Ms. Jackson's assessment was deficient and was not obtained because the parents disagreed with the District's assessment. No evidence showed an educational need for OT.

  28. Issue 16a. Reimbursement for independent psychological therapy provided by Deborah Kelley, Ph.D., from September through November 1995

    The services evaluated the student rather than treated him and addressed behavior at home, so reimbursement was denied.

  29. Issue 16b. Reimbursement for independent psychological therapy provided by Brian Lippincott, Ph.D., from March 1993 through September 1993

    Student was not then in special education, and there was no showing that the therapy was educationally related or necessary.

  30. Issue 16c. Reimbursement for independent psychological therapy provided by Richard Delmonico, Ph.D., from December 1995 through August 1996

    Student did not require psychological therapy to benefit from his education, and the therapy was not shown to address educational needs.

  31. Issue 17. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for an independent neuropsychological evaluation conducted by Peter Karzmark, Ph.D., in October 1995?

    Because the June 1995 District assessment was deficient and the District later relied on Dr. Karzmark's evaluation, the District must reimburse its cost.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to determine the frequency and duration of counseling to be provided as part of the behavioral intervention plan.
  • Reimbursement. In its Issue 17 conclusions, the decision requires the District to reimburse the parents for the cost of Dr. Peter Karzmark's October 1995 independent neuropsychological evaluation. No dollar amount is stated.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Capistrano Unified School Dist. v. Wartenberg; Burke County Board of Education v. Denton; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Hall v. Vance County Board of Education; 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9); Education Code § 56329(b); Government Code § 7576

People named in the decision

  • Carol Lankford, coordinator/director of special education, Hollister School District
  • Marie Lamb, school psychologist (June 1995 assessment), Hollister School District
  • Cheryl Rios, speech and language pathologist (1995 assessment), Hollister School District
  • Debra Hanson, resource specialist (1995 achievement testing), Hollister School District
  • Becky Steele, school psychologist (March 1996 assessment), Hollister School District
  • Tami Barnes, speech and language pathologist providing therapy, Hollister School District
  • Diane Sampson, resource specialist (1996 academic assessment), Hollister School District
  • Karen Ann Breslow, program specialist/behavior management specialist; conducted functional analysis assessment, San Benito County Office of Education
  • Nicki Sargeant (also spelled Sergeant), counselor identified to implement behavioral intervention plan; former private therapist
  • Donna M. Barry, fourth-grade teacher, Hollister School District
  • Stephanie Ann Mires, fifth-grade teacher, Hollister School District
  • Jan Boehme, sixth-grade teacher; vice principal, R.O. Hardin Elementary School
  • Mr. Tognetti, seventh-grade math teacher, Rancho San Justo (as written 'Rancho San Husto')
  • Phil Boehme, sixth-grade teacher and basketball coach, Hollister School District
  • Ms. Bogari, seventh-grade teacher, Hollister School District
  • Ms. Beckett, seventh-grade teacher, Hollister School District
  • Mr. Webb, seventh-grade science teacher, Hollister School District
  • Katie Merchant, Ed.D., former program specialist and SELPA director; expert witness for District
  • Margaret A. (Peg) Bledsoe, occupational therapist; expert witness for District
  • Richard Lawrence Delmonico, Ph.D., clinical neuropsychologist; witness for Student (testified by telephone), Santa Clara Valley Medical Center
  • Donna Jackson, private occupational therapist, Children's Therapy Center
  • Jennifer Hollibaugh, private speech-language pathologist
  • Bay Area Speech and Language Services, private speech-language provider
  • Brian Lippincott, Ph.D., private psychologist
  • Dr. Preston, private psychiatrist
  • Deborah Kelley (Kelly), private marriage, family, and child counselor
  • Peter Karzmark, Ph.D., psychologist; independent neuropsychological evaluator
  • Benjamin Mandac, M.D., student's physician
  • Fred Haruda, M.D., neurological evaluator (1990)
  • Marcel C. Chappuis, Ph.D., psychologist; director of psychology; witness for Student, Brightway Adolescent Hospital
  • Delbert T. Goates, M.D., psychiatrist; witness for Student, Brightway Adolescent Hospital
  • Sonia Fullwood, stateside coordinator; witness for Student, Paradise Cove
  • Barbara Hine, educational coordinator, Paradise Cove
  • Paradise Cove, residential program (Western Samoa), unilateral parent placement
  • F. Richard Ruderman, Student's prior attorney

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Hollister, California, on October 17, and November 14 and 15, 1996, January 8, 9, and 10, and February 3 and 4, 1997.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathryn E. Dobel. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his parents, FATHER and MOTHER. Respondent Hollister School District (District) was represented by attorneys Laurie E. Reynolds and Ivette Peña. Also present on behalf of the District was Carol Lankford, coordinator of special education.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open to allow the parties to submit written closing briefs. Closing briefs were received on February 25, 1997. The case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) Does STUDENT meet special education eligibility criteria as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?

(2) Was STUDENT entitled to special education services during the 1993-1994 and 1994-1995 school years?

(3) Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in June 1995?

(4) Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in March 1996?

(5) Did STUDENT require psychological therapy during the 1995-1996 school year to benefit from his education?

(6) Did STUDENT require occupational therapy (OT) during the 1995-1996 school year to benefit from his education?

(7) Did the District provide STUDENT with an appropriate education during the 1995-1996 school year?

(8) Is STUDENT's current IEP, which was developed in March and April 1996 and includes the behavioral intervention plan, designed to meet his unique and individual needs?

(9) Shall STUDENT's current IEP be amended to include goals and objectives in the following areas?

(a) conflict resolution;

(b) anger control;

(c) denial of responsibility:

(d) accountability for actions;

(e) inappropriate inhibitions;

(f) provocation of others;

(g) derogatory remarks toward others;

(h) disrespect for authority figures and peers;

(i) self-respect;

(j) self-esteem;

(k) positive self-concept;

(l) development of appropriate relationships with peers and adults; and (m) development of internal behavioral control.

(10) Does STUDENT require a residential placement?

(11) Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1996-1997 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

(12) Was the District required to refer STUDENT to Community Mental Health?

(13) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's placement at Paradise Cove, including residential, psychological, educational, and transportation costs?

(14) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent speech and language services provided by the Bay Area Speech and Language Services from September 1993 through January 1994?

(15) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent OT provided by Donna Jackson from November 1993 to the present?

(16) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent psychological therapy provided by (a) Deborah Kelley, Ph.D., from September through November 1995; (b) Brian Lippincott, Ph.D., from March 1993 through September 1993; (c) Richard Delmonico, Ph.D., from December 1995 through August 1996?

(17) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for an independent neuropsychological evaluation conducted by Peter Karzmark, Ph.D., in October 1995?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Scheduling of Hearing

On April 23, 1996, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing from attorney F. Richard Ruderman on behalf of STUDENT. The hearing was set for May 21 and 22, 1996. The parties agreed to three continuances and two additional continuances were granted over the objection of the District. On September 18, 1996, Mr. Ruderman informed the Hearing office that the PARENT's were seeking new legal counsel. Mr. PARENT followed up with a letter requesting a continuance of the hearing until January 1997. The Hearing Office found good cause for continuance but denied the request to continue the matter until January. The hearing was then set for October 17 and 18, 1996. Petitioner requested a further continuance of the hearing, which was opposed by the District. The Hearing Office denied the continuance. On October 17, 1996, the Hearing Officer and District representatives appeared at the time and place for hearing. The District made a motion to dismiss the due process hearing based on the failure of Petitioner to appear. The Hearing Officer took the request to dismiss the case under consideration, pending the results of Petitioner's request before the United States District Court, Northern District of California, to enjoin the hearing from proceeding, which was also set to be heard on October 17, 1996. The Hearing Office was informed later that day that the parties had agreed to continue the hearing to November 14 and 15, 1996.

Telephone Testimony

Petitioner requested that Richard Lawrence Delmonico, Ph.D., clinical neuropsychologist, be allowed to testify by telephone. The District objected and requested that the Hearing Officer to compel Dr. Delmonico to appear at the hearing. Dr. Delmonico is a neuropsychologist at the Santa Clara Valley Medical Center in San Jose, California. He also has a part time private practice in Los Altos, California. Dr. Delmonico testified that on the days scheduled for hearing, he was unable to leave the Medical Center because he was the only person with the appropriate credentials to see the patients and to supervise interns at the center. Dr. Delmonico has met with STUDENT and his parents a number of times to develop a plan to address STUDENT's behavioral problems at home. He also met with school personnel to provide them with information regarding traumatic brain injury (TBI) and to help them plan STUDENT's educational program.

California Education Code § 56505(e)(3) provides parties to a special education due process hearing the right to "confront, cross-examine, and compel the attendance of witnesses." (See also Title 5, California Code of Regulations § 3082(c)(1).) Neither California nor federal special education law specifies circumstances under which testimony may be taken by telephone. The U.S. Department of Education, Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP), has stated that the decision whether to allow telephone testimony is left to the discretion of the Hearing Officer in light of the relevant facts and circumstances of the case. 23 IDELR 1073 (OSEP 1995).

The Hearing Officer determined that the nature of Dr. Delmonico's practice and the distance of his place of employment from the hearing, the fact that the District was familiar with Dr. Delmonico, and the importance of obtaining relevant information from Dr. Delmonico regarding STUDENT, outweighed the need to have Dr. Delmonico present at the hearing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer allowed Dr. Delmonico to testify by telephone.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is eligible for special education because of communication deficits and a traumatic brain injury (TBI). By history, STUDENT had meningococcal meningitis at age six months.(FOOTNOTE 1) STUDENT suffered several other traumas to the head.(FOOTNOTE 2) STUDENT has been diagnosed with an attention deficit disorder (ADD) for which Tegretol is prescribed. He wears corrective lenses for diplopia (double vision). Following a brief hospitalization in Utah in August 1996, STUDENT's parents placed him in Paradise Cove, a residential program located in Western Samoa. STUDENT continues to participate in the Paradise Cove program.

During the 1987-88 school year, STUDENT entered the District for kindergarten. He repeated the first grade at the request of his parents. Fred Haruda, M.D., completed a neurological assessment of STUDENT in February 1990. Dr. Haruda found that STUDENT demonstrated several features of minimal brain dysfunction, including an attention deficit disorder, visual perceptual problems, and hypotonia. He attributed these problems to the meningoccal sepsis. Dr. Haruda prescribed Cylert for attentional problems. (Petitioner's Exhibit 21) The Cylert proved ineffective and Dr. Haruda then prescribed Clonidine.

During the 1989-1990 school year, while in the first grade for the second time, STUDENT was referred for a special education assessment. STUDENT's teacher reported that STUDENT had difficulty with paper and pencil tasks, exhibited low self-esteem, and functioned better when provided with consistency and a set routine. On measures of cognitive abilities STUDENT functioned in the high average range on the verbal scale and in the average range on the performance and full scales. STUDENT demonstrated weaknesses in attention, short-term auditory memory, visual motor skills, and written processing of information. Areas of strength included auditory learning, math, and science. On the Woodcock-STUDENTson Psycho-Educational Battery, administered on April 17, 1990, STUDENT received the following standard scores:

reading cluster - 87 knowledge - 86 math cluster - 102 skills - 91 written language - 93 (Petitioner's Exhibit 3, p. 19)

STUDENT's motor skills were also assessed by the adaptive physical education teacher. She determined that STUDENT functioned above average or within the average range of development in all areas except eye tracking.

The report of the assessment states that in social/emotional areas, STUDENT appeared much younger than his chronological age. (Petitioners' Exhibit 4, pp. 25 - 26) The assessment report includes the following additional comments regarding STUDENT:

STUDENT is a unique youngster in part because he appears so capable physically and verbally and yet is so emotionally young. His neurological background which contributes to impulsivity, fine motor difficulties and potential sequencing difficulties, has combined negatively with health, intellectual, language, and physical development. The challenge will be too see through STUDENT's negative behaviors, and to help him succeed when he does not feel in control.

(Petitioner's Exhibit 12, p. 67)

Based on tests results establishing a significant discrepancy between STUDENT's cognitive potential and academic performance in the area of reading, the IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education on the basis of a significant learning disability (SLD). STUDENT's IEP included one goal "to improve his reading and writing skills as they relate to reading/language arts curriculum area." The sole objective on the IEP reads as follows: Given a story at the 2.5 grd. level, STUDENT will read it at a rate of ___ words per minute with 3 or less errors by April 1991. The IEP team agreed to provide STUDENT with direct instruction from the resource specialist (RSP) teacher, as needed, for a time not to exceed 60 minutes per session, four times per week. The IEP also calls for weekly consultation between STUDENT's regular classroom teacher and the RSP teacher.

In preparation for STUDENT's annual IEP at the end of the second grade, the District administered the Woodcock-STUDENTson Psycho-Education Battery on April 26, 1991. STUDENT obtained the following standard scores:

reading cluster - 107 knowledge - 104 math cluster - 123 skills - 108 written language - 119 (Petitioner's Exhibit 3, p. 19)

On May 1, 1991, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT no longer required RSP services because he had demonstrated good progress in reading and there was no longer a discrepancy between his ability and achievement. STUDENT's parents attended the meeting and concurred with STUDENT's dismissal from special education. (Petitioner's Exhibit 3, p. 18)

STUDENT was enrolled in regular education for the third and fourth grades (1991-1992 and 1992-1993 school years) and did not receive any special education services. STUDENT's pediatrician referred him to Donna Jackson, registered occupational therapist (OTR), for a sensory motor evaluation. Following an extensive assessment in September 1992, Ms. Jackson found deficits in STUDENT's ability to process sensory information that was interfering with his ability to motor plan efficiently and effectively and to develop fine motor coordination and dexterity. Ms. Jackson also identified delays in lower neurodevelopmental areas, such as equilibrium/balance responses, shoulder stability, and muscular cocontraction, that was interfering with the higher skilled functions necessary to function safely, efficiently, and effectively. Ms. Jackson concluded that STUDENT was having difficulty processing vestibular, proprioceptive, and tactile information, that was affecting his body awareness, motor planning, and sequencing. (Petitioner's Exhibit 16) Thereafter, the PARENTs provided STUDENT with thrice weekly OT with Ms. Jackson.

In February 1993, Jennifer Hollibaugh, speech and language pathologist in private practice, assessed STUDENT. Ms. Jackson, OTR, had referred STUDENT to Ms. Hollibaugh. Ms. Hollibaugh was not able to complete an initial assessment because STUDENT was only able to tolerate twenty to thirty minutes of testing. Ms. Hollibaugh identified deficits in STUDENT's expressive and receptive language and in cognitive skills. Specifically, he exhibited deficits in processing oral directions, formulating sentences, recalling verbal information, expansion of word meaning, spatial and temporal relationships, word recall and word finding skills, interpreting information presented auditorially, and processing speed. Ms. Hollibaugh described STUDENT's attention as "selective." She did note that STUDENT exhibited strengths in using visual cues. The parents provided for one session per week of speech and language therapy, which replaced one of STUDENT's weekly OT sessions with Ms. Jackson. (Petitioner's Exhibit 17)

For a period during 1993, STUDENT and his parents received therapy from Brian Lippincott, psychologist, to help deal with STUDENT's anger, frustration, and out-of-control behavior. Dr. Lippincott referred STUDENT for a neurological examination. Several medications were prescribed and treatment with Dr. Preston, a psychiatrist, was begun. Neither proved effective.

STUDENT continued in regular education classes for the fifth and sixth grades (1993-1994 and 1994-1995 school years) and he did not receive any special education services. On June 12, 1995, at the request of Ms. PARENT, the District assessed STUDENT. Ms. PARENT had cited concerns regarding STUDENT's behavioral difficulties. Marie Lamb, school psychologist, completed the psycho-educational portion of the assessment. On testing, STUDENT's cognitive abilities fells within the average range and his academic achievement was within the expected range for his grade level. The assessor described STUDENT's social/emotional skills as "underdeveloped." Cheryl Rios, speech and language specialist, completed a speech and language assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Rios found that STUDENT exhibited weaknesses in single word vocabulary, expressive language, and pragmatics. His most significant weakness was in understanding and analyzing information from social situations and sources. (Petitioner's Exhibit 10)

On June 14, 1995, the IEP team met and found that STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education because of communication deficits and TBI. Ms. PARENT attended the meeting and concurred with the proposed goals, objectives, services, and placement for STUDENT. STUDENT received twice weekly speech and language therapy of 30 minutes each session to improve word knowledge and pragmatic skills. The IEP indicates that STUDENT's behavior needed to be addressed during the 1995-1996 school year. It also includes the following:

an area of concern continuously throughout the day: disrupting the work of other students, blaming others or materials for own failure or difficulty, making inappropriate noises, and engaging in excessive body movements. Daily at various times the following were areas of concern: difficulty attending to academic tasks, verbally or physically threatening others, facial expression of sadness or displeasure, failure to consider or disregard for consequences of own behavior, acting impulsively, need for immediate rewards or gratification, self-stimulating behavior, making derogatory or critical remarks about others, inappropriate physical or verbal responses to others attempts to interact, and use of obscene or profane language.

(Petitioner's Exhibit 2, p. 13 and 16)

The PARENTs arranged for therapy with Deborah Kelley, Ph.D., from September through November 1995. Sometime in the fall of 1995, Benjamin Mandac, M.D., STUDENT's physician, referred STUDENT to Peter Karzmark, Ph.D., psychologist, for an assessment of his "mental functioning." Dr. Karzmark administered the WISC-III, Seashore Rhythm, Underlining, Children's Auditory Verbal Learning, Benton Visual Retention, Trail Making, Wisconsin Card Sorting, Boston Naming, Benton Judgment of Line Orientation, and Grooved Pegboard tests. Dr. Karzmark reported that STUDENT performed in the "impaired range on tests of word finding, concentration, and mental efficiency." He performed in the normal range on tests of memory, visuospatial functioning, non-verbal reasoning, and verbal abstraction. Dr. Karzmark stated that STUDENT exhibited difficulty with disinhibited anger and that behavioral difficulties were "modestly" consistent with the effects of TBI. (Petitioner's Exhibit 19, pages 94-98)

Dr. Mandac also referred the PARENTs to Dr. Delmonico, clinical neuropsychologist, for help managing STUDENT's "aggressive behavior and verbal outbursts." Dr. Delmonico stated that "STUDENT's behavior is at least in part the result of the multiple blows to the head he has experienced as a child. His difficulties with impulse control, variable attention, information processing, modulating his emotions, and anger are very commonly seen in individuals who have experienced a brain injury." At that time, Dr. Delmonico recommended development of a comprehensive behavioral treatment plan that included strategies for use at school as well as home. (Petitioner's Exhibit 18, p. 92-93)

On February 21, 1996, the Student Study Team (SST) met to discuss concerns regarding STUDENT's behavior. Dr. Delmonico provided information regarding TBI. The team identified when STUDENT was having difficulty and developed strategies to improve his behavior. On February 28, 1996, Ms. PARENT consented to the District's proposed plan to assess STUDENT.(FOOTNOTE 3) She had requested that the District assess STUDENT because of her on-going concerns regarding the connection between TBI and STUDENT's behavioral difficulties. Becky Steele, school psychologist, completed the psycho-educational portion of the testing. Tami Barnes, language, speech, and hearing specialist, assessed STUDENT's speech and language, and Diane Sampson, RSP specialist, assessed STUDENT's academic achievement. On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, STUDENT obtained verbal, performance, and full scale scores in the average range. On the Woodcock STUDENTson Psycho-Educational Battery administered, STUDENT obtained the following standard scores:

reading - 102 skills - 115 mathematics - 123 knowledge - 102 written language - 105 (Petitioner's Exhibit 1, p. 5)

All of STUDENT's scores on the Woodcock-STUDENTson fell in the average or above-average range. Based on information from STUDENT's father and the results of social/emotional testing, which included administration of the Draw-A-Person and Robert's Apperception Test for Children, Ms. Steele concluded that STUDENT's social/emotional development was within the normal range. Ms. Steele made the following comments regarding STUDENT's behavior:

In a school day STUDENT can demonstrate excellent behavior or through [sic] verbal and physically disruptive behaviors. In a day there is a slow but consistent increase of physical motion so that at the beginning of the day STUDENT is seated and constantly working and by the end of the day he is literally may be found for periods of time, standing by his desk. STUDENT has been known to make instant and complete positive adaptive adjustments. Thus there appear to be situations under which STUDENT has control of his behaviors. Staff has found clear and consistent behavior management tied to clear consequences to be most effective.

(Petitioner's Exhibit 1, pp. 8-10; see also Petitioner's Exhibits 7, 8, and 9)

On March 19, 1996, the IEP team met and developed goals and objectives for STUDENT. To address STUDENT's deficits in cognitive-linguistic skills and pragmatics, the IEP team determined that STUDENT would be provided individual and small group speech and language services. Following the IEP meeting, the IEP document and all of STUDENT's psychological files were believed to have been lost by Ms. Steele.(Footnote 4) A second IEP meeting was scheduled; however, there was some misunderstanding about whether the meeting could be videotaped and the meeting was rescheduled.(Footnote 5) The IEP team reconvened on April 15, 1996. At that time, the team recreated the "lost" IEP and agreed that STUDENT would receive 75 to 120 minutes per week of speech and language services, which would be divided between direct treatment, observation, collaboration with STUDENT's teachers, and support to STUDENT and school staff. Ms. PARENT, who was present at the IEP meetings, concurred with the goals, objectives, services, and placement proposed by the IEP. She indicated on the IEP that STUDENT she believed STUDENT should be placed in a smaller class and that he needed a "psychologist to talk to maybe weekly." Another outcome of the IEP meeting was that the District proposed a functional assessment of STUDENT's behavior. Ms. PARENT consented to the District's proposed assessment. The IEP states that "once the assessment is completed, the Behavioral Intervention Team will meet to finalize STUDENT's Behavioral Intervention Plan." The IEP also states that the behavior management specialist would be available to consult with the behavioral intervention team to monitor and evaluate STUDENT's progress and to deliver services on an "as needed basis, with 30 to 180 minutes per month." (Petitioner's Exhibit 1, pp. 1-2)

Between April 15 and May 13, 1996, Karen Ann Breslow, program specialist for San Benito County Office of Education, conducted a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT. The assessment consisted of a review of STUDENT's educational records, interviews with each of STUDENT's teachers, interviews with STUDENT's parents, and observation of STUDENT on May 9, 1996. Ms. Breslow's initial report identifies target and replacement behaviors, goals, and strategies. The report also states that before the close of the 1995-1996 school year that STUDENT's behavioral intervention team would meet to review the assessment, to review the plan with STUDENT, to finalize the behavioral intervention plan and strategies for the remaining week of school, and to define strategies for the 1996-1997 school year. (Petitioner's Exhibit 5) The team met to review the findings on June 6, 1996.(Footnote 6) The team determined that STUDENT's eighth grade teachers should have input into the plan and training to implement the plan so an IEP meeting was scheduled for August 29, 1996, prior to the start of the school year.

On August 20, 1996, the PARENTs signed a contract for STUDENT's placement at Paradise Cove. (District's Exhibit 35) On August 22, 1996, the District convened a meeting with the parents and some members of the IEP team to determine the level of services necessary to implement STUDENT's behavioral intervention program (BIP). Nicki Sargeant, the person identified to provide services in relation to STUDENTs' behavioral intervention plan would not be available for the meeting set on August 29, 1997. At the meeting, the PARENTs requested that the District a residential placement for STUDENT. They informed the IEP team that during the summer STUDENT had run away from home and had altercations with his mother and that they would be leaving for Utah the following day.

On August 27, 1996, the PARENTs arrived at the Brightway Adolescent Hospital in St. George, Utah, where they had STUDENT admitted. Reports from Brightway state that STUDENT was admitted because of escalating acting out and "reactive behaviors, which have included physical assault on family members." (Petitioner's Exhibit 36, p. 158) The following day, Delbert T. Goates, M.D., conducted a psychiatric evaluation of STUDENT. He recommended that STUDENT be in a "structured, confined, contingency managed environment with assessment of the appropriate medications to allow him to continue in a less restricted environment, and for additional cognitive therapy to facilitate his return to a domestic environment." (Petitioner's Exhibit 40) On August 31, 1996, Marcel C. Chappuis, Ph.D., licensed clinical psychologist, assessed STUDENT's current level of psychological functioning and made recommendations for treatment and/or placement. Dr. Chappuis concluded:

Psychological testing completed identifies elements of problematic depression, difficulty in the area of interpersonal relationships and a general level of distrust of his own psychological functioning. He also acknowledges difficulty with enuresis, difficulty in his relationships with his parents and openly acknowledges the fact that his behaviors have escalated to the point of physical confrontations.

(Petitioner's Exhibit 36, p. 163) Dr. Chappuis gave STUDENT a diagnosis of "depression, NOS (W/Acting Out Features)." He also listed the following diagnostic impressions pursuant to the DSM-IV: diagnosed post-brain trauma; intermittent explosive disorder; ADHD; parent child problems; meningealcoccal encephalitis; four concussions; enuresis; and psychosocial, environmental, familial and academic stressors.

On September 16, 1996, STUDENT left Brightway and entered Paradise Cove, a residential program located in Western Samoa. Paradise Cove's Parent Manual describes the program as follows:

Paradise Cove is an effective program for boys ages 12 through 17. These boys have excellent potential but are headed for some serious problems. Typically, theses are teens who are determined to do their "own thing", regardless of who it hurts or how it may alter their futures.

Parents often realize that something must be done to change their son's present course. Behavior modification in a controlled environment is essential. Without a controlled environment, the parents' attempts to intervene are often thwarted by the influence of a negative peer group.

This Facility provides a balanced program that includes a structured daily schedule, behavior modification, intensive seminars, health and physical fitness programs, emotional growth and personal development courses, recreation, and individualized academic instruction.

(Petitioner's Exhibit 43)

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified how STUDENT's aggressive behavior began at eight months of age and that STUDENT required 100% more supervision than her other children because she feared he would hurt someone. She stated that STUDENT bit other children unprovoked and had an intense interest in fire. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT was unsuccessful in preschool when he was three years old; however, the following year, although STUDENT was aggressive and had poor social skills, he was able to attend a parochial nursery school. Ms. PARENT testified that the family sought assistance with STUDENT from their church social services, participated in a parenting class at the school district, and obtained private therapy from Nicki Sergeant for approximately four years.

Ms. PARENT testified that when STUDENT was in kindergarten, he cried every day, urinated all over the walls, and had poor social skills. Ms PARENT stated she was in constant contact with STUDENT's first grade teacher because of STUDENT's difficulty getting along with peers, and because of his verbal outbursts, shyness, and unhappiness. Ms. PARENT stated that she was concerned about STUDENT's behavior at home as well. He had trouble controlling his temper and feelings and was easily frustrated. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT did well during the second grade because he had a "wonderful" teacher; however, during the third grade, STUDENT had difficulty relating to other students and "exploded" when he came home. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT had very few friends in the fourth grade and was not allowed to go on field trips unless she accompanied him. STUDENT also had problems on the bus, which carried over to the fifth and sixth grades. Ms. PARENT testified that the sixth grade was very difficult for STUDENT. He could not control himself in the classroom, was rude, disrespectful, called other students names, made racial remarks, and got in fights. He also excessively passed gas and burped in class. Ms. PARENT testified that she received calls daily from the school regarding STUDENT's behavior and, although his grades were high enough to place him on the school's honor roll, his behavior kept him off except for one quarter.

Ms. PARENT testified that prior to the start of STUDENT's seventh grade school year, her attempts to meet with STUDENT's teachers were unsuccessful. Although Ms. PARENT offered to have Dr. Delmonico speak with STUDENT's teachers before school began, a meeting did not take place until February. Ms. PARENT stated that STUDENT did well in his English class and, for most of the year, also did well in Mr. Tognetti's math class; however, STUDENT had a "terrible" time in Ms. Bogari's class and both Ms. Bogari and Ms. Beckett refused to teach him the last three to six weeks of school and Mr. Webb, STUDENT's science teacher, "kicked" STUDENT out of his class two times a week. Ms. PARENT stated that she was at school "all of the time" because of STUDENT's many disciplinary referrals and suspensions. According to Ms. PARENT STUDENT exhibited "bizarre" behaviors in class that continued to include passing gas and letting chewed food run out of his mouth.

Ms. PARENT testified that during the summer of 1996, STUDENT's inappropriate behavior escalated. He was rude and disrespectful to family members, hurt his sister, punched the walls in his room, and ran away from home. Ms. PARENT noted that she checked with some of STUDENT's friends to locate him. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT yelled at her, called her names, and twice punched her in the face. STUDENT also told her that he hated his family and wanted to stab her through the heart with a knife. When she and Mr. PARENT decided to take STUDENT to Utah to be hospitalized, they planned a trip along the way and invited one of STUDENT's friends to travel with them.

Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT likes sports and Nintendo games. He played soccer from six to nine years old, played baseball from eight to fourteen years old, and played basketball in the seventh grade. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT worked one day per week during the summer for a friend of the family.

Ms. PARENT testified that, until speaking with her first attorney, she thought that special education was for children with physical disabilities and mental retardation. She also testified that she did not understand that she could make recommendations or changes to goals and objectives proposed by the District. She testified that she accepted the services offered by the District because she was glad to be getting any help and, in part, because she was not aware that the District could be responsible for providing other services. Ms. PARENT testified that the District's behavioral intervention plan would not be successful given the severity of STUDENT's behavior. Ms. PARENT testified that after she and Mr. PARENT discussed with the District their intent to hospitalize STUDENT and then to place him in a residential facility, the District did not make any other proposal for services, program, or placement for STUDENT.

Ms. PARENT testified that, based on weekly written correspondence from STUDENT and his therapist, she believes that STUDENT has made good progress since entering Paradise Cove. (Another therapist in the states contacts her monthly regarding STUDENT's progress.) Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT's goals at Paradise Cove are to recognize and be accountable for his behaviors; to work in a group; to communicate, share, and express his feelings; and to accept positive and negative feedback. She testified that STUDENT has been making progress toward these goals. STUDENT is now able to express his feelings. He told her that his behavior is "awesome," and that he is happy and feels as "light as a feather." Ms. PARENT testified that she spoke with another parent who saw STUDENT and reported that STUDENT appeared happy and healthy.

FATHER, STUDENT's father, is a financial planner and has served on the County Board of Education for 12 years. Mr. PARENT testified that STUDENT's grades are a misnomer and that he really is a "B" and "C" student. Mr. PARENT testified that STUDENT gets better grades by doing extra credit work and by showing improvement in his work. Mr. PARENT testified that STUDENT would work three to six hours at home on his school work. Mr. PARENT testified that the District never explained the possibility of an mental health referral or services. Mr. PARENT testified extensively about the billings for which he seeks reimbursement. In addition to the amounts detailed in Petitioner's Exhibit 45 and Respondent's Exhibit 44, Mr. PARENT testified that he has incurred the following: $1595 for roundtrip airfare; $175 for STUDENT's passport; and $2,100 per month for STUDENT's residential schooling at Paradise Cove.

Deborah Kelly, marriage, family, and child counselor (MFCC), is in private practice. Between September 22, 1995, and November 8, 1995, Ms. Kelly met with STUDENT four times and with his family two times. Ms. Kelly testified that the parents sought her assistance to deal with STUDENT's enuresis, difficulty getting along with peers, and aggressive and defiant behavior, including yelling and hitting. the sessions with STUDENT were for evaluative purposes. Ms. Kelly testified that STUDENT told her that achieving good grades was important to him. He also told her that he was angry much of the time and was preoccupied with revenging real or perceived wrongs. Ms. Kelly testified that STUDENT met DSM-IV criteria for an oppositional defiant disorder (ODD). At her last meeting with the PARENTs on November 8, 1995, Ms. Kelly made the following recommendations: provide STUDENT with a consistent and structured environment; implement a behavioral system with tangible rewards; include a physician on the team to evaluate and make treatment recommendations; reevaluate STUDENT's need for medication; and provide STUDENT with individual counseling oriented toward managing his anger and building self-esteem. Ms. Kelly stated that, at that time, she did not make a recommendation for residential treatment. She did, however, tell the PARENTs that they may want to consider the possibility of a residential placement.

Donna Jackson, OTR, is in private practice and is the owner/supervisor of Children's Therapy Center. Ms. Jackson testified that her role as an OT is to break down tasks and to modify tasks and/or the environment to allow the patient to be able to do the task. She also provides therapy to enhance sensory integration processing. Ms. Jackson assessed STUDENT on August 24, 1992, to determine whether any underlying sensory deficits were affecting STUDENT's behavior. (Petitioner's Exhibit 16) Ms. Jackson concluded that STUDENT was having difficulty processing sensory information which was interfering with his ability to motor plan efficiently and to develop fine motor coordination. She stated that STUDENT's difficulty processing vestibular, proprioceptive, and tactile information was also causing him to have difficulty interacting successfully with the external world and were impacting the amount of time he required to do his work. Ms. Jackson testified that because STUDENT functions at a high arousal level, interruptions result in his exploding. Ms. Jackson also found that STUDENT had poor penmanship. Ms. Jackson attended a meeting with the school principal, STUDENT's teacher, and Ms. PARENT to provide the results of her testing.

Ms. Jackson testified that the purpose of providing STUDENT with OT was to lessen his tactile defensiveness; improve his ability to process vestibular information; to teach him to weight shift to make movements easier; and to improve fine motor skills. Ms. Jackson found that STUDENT had additional needs and recommended a speech and language assessment for processing problems.

Ms. Jackson testified that STUDENT made the following progress as a result of OT: balance and equilibrium improved; he was better able to tolerate vestibular input; he was better able to express his needs in a small group setting; he improved his ability to tolerate frustration with his peers; his tactile defensiveness diminished; and he had more movement through the pelvis.

Ms. Jackson testified that she saw STUDENT for another assessment in July 1995. At that time, STUDENT had deficits in balance, weak automatic postural responses, poor ability to use muscles and to perform symmetrical and asymmetrical patterns of coordinated movement, and an inability to perform age-appropriate motor and cognitive tasks simultaneously. Ms. Jackson testified that STUDENT's TBI affects the following: modulating and inhibiting behavior; cognitive processing of new material; sensory modulating; vision; and auditory processing.Ms. Jackson recommended OT for two to three hours per week for six months. Ms. Jackson testified that STUDENT was dismissed form therapy in July 1995??? because he would not participate in OT activities and hit the therapist. Ms. Jackson testified that she then decided to shift the focus of therapy to psycho-social issues. Ms. Jackson testified that during the second period of time her office provided STUDENT's therapy, STUDENT made the following progress: he improved his ability to identify behavior and what affecting it; he started to verbalize his need for breaks; he improved his organization and sequencing skills; he improved cognitive and motor tasks; and, until April 1996, he exhibited less frustration.

Ms. Jackson testified that STUDENT presently needs a setting where immediate and appropriate intervention is provided for his behavior. She stated that STUDENT has the potential to cause danger to himself or others. She believed that STUDENT's behavior escalated to a point where he could not be controlled. For example, he hit his therapist one time and on other times slammed his fist and shoved chairs. Ms. Jackson testified that she attended meetings with the District in February and March 1996.

Jennifer Hollibaugh, speech and language pathologist, is in private practice. Ms. Hollibaugh testified that STUDENT was refereed to her by Donna Jackson. Ms. Hollibaugh testified that the PARENTs' insurance paid for her services for the period between September 1993 and January 1994 but not for the period from February 1993 and April 1993. Ms. Hollibaugh attempted to assess STUDENT in February 1993 but was only able to administer two tests due to STUDENT's lack of tolerance for testing. (Petitioner's Exhibit 17) She testified that STUDENT exhibits behavior consistent with a head injury and is impulsive. He also has attentional difficulties, is quick to anger, tired and fatigues easily, and is verbally explosive. Ms. Hollibaugh stated that STUDENT has difficulty finding appropriate words, and exhibits deficits in auditory processing skills including processing oral directions, formulating coherent discourse, and recalling information. He also is slow processing and attends selectively. Ms. Hollibaugh testified that STUDENT definitely would have qualified for special education services based on the above. Ms. Hollibaugh testified that STUDENT's language deficits affect his educational functioning in the following ways: he has difficulty sitting and listening to lengthy directions or teacher discourse; he has difficulty sitting in a large class without distraction; he has difficulty processing information; he is unorganized; and has trouble remembering to do assignments. Ms. Hollibaugh testified that STUDENT reacts very "strongly" or with anger when presented with too much information, overwhelmed by auditory information, or when presented with too much noise or when there were too many distractions in the classroom.

Richard Lawrence Delmonico, Ph.D., clinical neuropsychologist, is on the staff at Santa Clara Medical Center. He also has a small private practice and is an adjunct professor. Dr. Delmonico testified that his specialty is psychological treatment and behavior management of neurologically impaired individuals. He met STUDENT twice and with his parents five times to obtain information regarding STUDENT's behavioral problems and to develop strategies to address STUDENT's behavior at home. Dr. Delmonico also met with school officials to discuss the following: STUDENT's behavioral problems; approaches tried by the school; the manner in which STUDENT's brain injuries effect his behavior; and strategies to use at school. Dr. Delmonico testified that STUDENT's teachers concurred that, if they did not take some action regarding STUDENT, he would lose his motivation to perform well academically. Dr. Delmonico recalled that someone from the school stated that STUDENT could not be provided with counseling because he did not have any academic problems. From what the PARENTs told him, STUDENT was having outbursts in a number of environments.

Dr. Delmonico testified that the summary in Dr. Chappuis' report sounds like STUDENT; however, he testified that he saw STUDENT as frustrated and angry rather than depressed. Dr. Delmonico denied knowledge of STUDENT's enuresis. Dr. Delmonico disagreed with the diagnosis of intermittent explosive disorder and testified that it is typical for persons with TBI to have problems with anger, outbursts, and impulsivity. Disinhibition is also a common problem for persons with frontal lobe injuries. Dr. Delmonico testified that appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT address the following: conflict resolution; anger control; denial of responsibility; consequences; disinhibition of socially inappropriate behaviors; provocation of others; derogatory remarks; self-esteem; and peer relationships. Dr. Delmonico testified that without a consistent and comprehensive behavior plan, STUDENT's behavior will deteriorate. STUDENT also requires concrete examples of how to control his behavior and alternative strategies. Dr. Delmonico recommended that, at home, the PARENTs use positive reinforcers such as money or taking STUDENT to a sporting event. At school, Dr. Delmonico recommended allowing STUDENT to take breaks. Dr. Delmonico testified that he did not recommended hospitalizing STUDENT or placing him in a residential program.

Marcel C. Chappuis, Ph.D., is a psychologist in private practice and director of psychology for the Brightway Adolescent Hospital. Dr. Chappuis assessed STUDENT on August 31, 1996. (Petitioner's Exhibit 36) He stated that STUDENT presented as fidgety and impulsive but cooperative. Dr. Chappuis' assessment consisted of the a review of the records, a clinical interview, and administration of measures of personality. Dr. Chappuis administered the Minnesota Multi Phasic Inventory, the Beck Depression Inventory, the Suicide Probability Scale, the Rotter Incomplete Sentence Blank, and the Achenbach Youth Self Report. He did not administer measures of cognitive ability or achievement because of the District's recent assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Chappuis testified that STUDENT met diagnostic criteria for depression. He has inappropriate relations with peers and adults and behaves impulsively. Dr. Chappuis testified that STUDENT has some awareness of his problems but is unable to effectively deal with them. Dr. Chappuis testified that he recommended a residential placement for STUDENT because previous outpatient therapeutic and academic interventions had not been successful and STUDENT's aggressive behavior appeared to be escalating. Dr. Chappuis testified that the District's BIP does not take into consideration the problems that STUDENT was experiencing at home and in the community. On cross-examination, Dr. Chappuis testified that Brightway and Paradise Cove have the same "parent company." He stated that he recommends placement at Paradise Cove for 50% or fewer of the 20 to 25 students he assesses monthly at Brightway.

Delbert T. Goates, M.D., psychiatrist, assessed STUDENT and worked with him three to four times per week while hospitalized at Brightway. Dr. Goates observed STUDENT while he was not medicated and then began a regime of medication until he was stabilized. Dr. Goates described STUDENT as extremely impulsive. He stated that STUDENT would overreact to a minor event and was generally offensive to peers and staff. Dr. Goates testified that STUDENT would benefit from a structured and consistent residential program because staff at a regular school program would not be able to handle STUDENT's escalating behavior and his home was also not sufficiently structured to meet his needs. Dr. Goates testified that Paradise Cove offers a consistent program that allows STUDENT to learn to control his impulses and to be personally responsible for his actions. On cross-examination, Dr. Goates testified that 90% of the population at Brightway uses marijuana and has some criminal background, whereas STUDENT does not. Dr. Goates concluded that STUDENT is seriously emotionally disturbed.

Sonia Fullwood is the stateside coordinator for Paradise Cove. Ms. Fullwood holds masters' degrees in counseling and secondary education. Ms. Fullwood described Paradise Cove generally as a behavior modification program that is based on a system of providing students with rewards and consequences for their behavior. There are 250 boys at Paradise Cove between the ages of 13 and 18 years old. Students are placed in families of approximately 10 students each. The students are referred to the program for a variety of reasons including defiant behavior, family breakdowns, and runaway behavior. Ms. Fullwood testified that her case load includes gang members, students with criminal records, substance abusers, and school drop outs. Paradise Cove has nine teachers. Ms. Fullwood was uncertain whether Paradise Cove is certified by the State of California as a nonpublic school (NPS). She also was not aware of the teachers' credentials or whether the services of speech and language or OT are available at Paradise Cove.

Ms. Fullwood testified that Paradise Cove employs a six level system which is clearly explained, along with the rules and responsibilities, to the boys upon their entrance into the program. Students receive positive points for positive behavior and negative points as consequences for poor behavior. Consequences in Levels I and II consist of writing a 100 word essay, listening to personal growth tapes, and completing 10 worksheets. They also receive as many as 40 demerits;however, they are given a clean slate weekly and do not carry over negative points. Ms. Fullwood testified that students are never denied food, sleep, or baths, and they are not verbally abused, ridiculed, or humiliated. Ms. Fullwood testified that students also are not locked in seclusion; however, they may be placed in seclusion in an observation area for dangerous behavior. Ms. Fullwood did not know what was meant by the statement contained in the Paradise Cove Handbook regarding adjusting students' diets when they are on observation. She testified that students may only be restrained by using handcuffs when they are out-of-control and pose a danger to self or others. The staff does not, however, use any disabling mechanisms such as pepper spray.

Ms. Fullwood testified that to move from Level I to Level II, students are expected to maintain appropriate behavior, attain an appropriate number of points, and be observed by staff to interact appropriately with peers. To move from Level II to Level III, students are expected to maintain appropriate behavior, demonstrate leadership qualities, and interact effectively with peers. At Level III, students can have phone contact with their parents. Students are expected to show more personal growth to move to Level IV. At Level IV, the plan to transition stateside is begun. When a child transitions stateside, the parent and child participate in a three day seminar to reintegrate the family and identify areas to work on during the transition. Over the next two months, the student has constant contact with the parents through phone calls and home visits. The parent and child participate in an exit seminar and, six days later, participate in a third seminar.

Ms. Fullwood testified that she met STUDENT two days after he entered the program and, thereafter, has continued to meet with him monthly for approximately 45 minutes each. Ms. Fullwood also communicates with the PARENTs to discuss STUDENT's problems and progress. Ms. Fullwood testified that when she first met STUDENT, he was anxious, had very low self-esteem and self-confidence, was frightened of everything around him, made only minimum eye contact, and was not able to identify the purpose for his being at Paradise Cove. Ms. Fullwood testified that three weeks later, STUDENT started to "come out" and was more self-confident. Ms. Fullwood testified that the fact that STUDENT has received few consequences indicates that he is learning to operate in the system and can control his behaviors. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was on Level I. She was not familiar with STUDENT's educational progress. Ms. Fullwood testified that all of the elements proposed by Petitioner are necessary for a behavioral intervention plan to address STUDENT's needs.

District Witnesses

Donna M. Barry, was STUDENT's fourth-grade teacher. Ms. Barry testified that STUDENT had some behavioral problems at the beginning of the school year; however, he made academic progress and earned "A" and "B" grades while in her class. STUDENT would pick his scabs, lick dittos, blurt out inappropriately, burp, and pass gas. STUDENT also tried to put blood on another student and "mooned" the class at recess. Ms. Barry was unaware of STUDENT's exhibiting behavior that was assaultive, sexual in nature, or intimidating. Ms. Barry believed STUDENT that was seeking attention from the other students. Ms. Barry testified that she employed positive behavioral techniques to change STUDENT's behavior and provided a structured classroom, defined boundaries and rules to STUDENT, and communicated weekly with his parents. Ms. Barry testified that she never considered referring STUDENT for special education. Ms. Barry stated she may have asked Ms. PARENT to go on a field trip with STUDENT because of her concerns about his behavior. Ms. Barry testified that STUDENT followed directions, turned in homework, had good organizational skills, and was respectful to her.

Stephanie Ann Mires, STUDENT's fifth-grade teacher, described her class as highly structured and stated that she sets high standards and expectations for her students. While in her class, STUDENT completed his assignments, listened to instructions, stayed in his seat during instruction, did well on tests, participated in groups, did above-average work, and generally earned "A" and "B" grades. Ms. Mires stated that STUDENT had some social problems at the beginning of the school year and had a personality conflict with another student. Ms. Mires stated she generally was able to talk through the problems with STUDENT and that she observed positive changes in STUDENT as the year progressed. He accepted more responsibility for his behavior and, by the middle of the school year, would only have problems when there was a substitute teacher. STUDENT qualified academically for the honor roll; however, his behavior on the playground kept him off of the honor roll for the first quarter. Examples of STUDENT's problems were that he called other students "stupid" and would do something to "gross them out," such as writing on his tongue with markers and picking at scabs and then pretending to put them on another student. Ms. Mires testified that she had a good relationship with STUDENT and he developed friendships with the students as the year progressed. Ms. Mires testified that she never considered referring STUDENT for special education and she did not consider his behavior indicative of an emotional disturbance. Ms. Mires testified that she liked having STUDENT in her class. She stated that he had a good sense of humor and was charismatic. Jan Boehme, vice principal at R.O. Hardin Elementary School, was STUDENT's sixth-grade teacher until February 1995. Ms. Boehme holds credentials authorizing her to teach students who are learning disabled and emotionally disturbed. She testified that, because STUDENT entered her class three days late, he missed information pertaining to the structure and procedures of the class. Ms. Boehme testified that STUDENT initially appeared resentful of being there, was disruptive, defiant, and could be aggressive with students he did not like. He sometimes made "low key" sexual innuendos to females and the class and inappropriate racial comments to provoke other students. If STUDENT sensed that someone was vulnerable, he would pursue them and, when there was a new student in the class, he would engage in a power struggle with the new student. Ms. Boehme testified that STUDENT had more difficulty in unstructured environments like the playground or in the library and, therefore, required clear structure and limit setting to be successful. In her opinion, STUDENT was seeking approval from his peers and, if she could address him with a sense of humor, he would stop the inappropriate behavior. At other times, Ms. Boehme sent him out of the class for two minutes and then spoke individually with him. Ms. Boehme stated that many of STUDENT's problems occurred following some incident on the playground. Ms. Boehme testified that STUDENT's inappropriate behaviors in class decreased, he made friends in the class, and was self-confident. Ms. Boehme testified that she did not see a need to refer STUDENT for special education.

STUDENT Tognetti, math teacher, Rancho San Husto, had STUDENT in his fourth period regular seventh grade math class during the 1995 - 1996 school year. Mr. Tognetti testified that there were about 22 to 23 students in the class. They were seated in seven rows of four students each. STUDENT sat in the front seat of the second row. Mr. Tognetti described his class as fairly structured. Mr. Tognetti testified that STUDENT was an excellent student and that he primarily earned "A" grades. On the algebra readiness test, STUDENT correctly completed 104 of 118 problems and scored in the top 10% of those taking the Stanford Aptitude Test. Mr. Tognetti testified that STUDENT sometimes required a little extra time to complete assignments and tests. STUDENT sometimes stayed in Mr. Tognetti's class during lunch to complete his work. Mr. Tognetti testified that STUDENT requested extra credit work because he liked to do well. Extra credit work could only affect STUDENT's grade one-half of a grade. For example, Mr. Tognetti stated that extra credit work could improve a "B" grade to a "B+." Mr. Tognetti testified that STUDENT had friends in the class. He also saw STUDENT with other students during lunch and after school; however, STUDENT did not work well in groups. Mr. Tognetti described STUDENT as a "Dennis the Menace" jokester in class. STUDENT pulled pranks on fellow students, had a tendency to "put them down," and used inappropriate racial remarks toward a student. He would also chew food and show it in his mouth to other students.

As for whether STUDENT required special education, Mr. Tognetti testified that he did not see signs of depression in STUDENT. He also did not have any reason to believe that STUDENT required OT. Mr. Tognetti stated that he did not notice that STUDENT had difficulty copying from the chalkboard or difficulty differentiating relevant from irrelevant information in his text book. Mr. Tognetti testified that he was able to control STUDENT's behavior by extensively monitoring him and by keeping him busy and on track. He was also responsive to redirection. Mr. Tognetti stated that STUDENT had some difficulty responding to direction during the fourth quarter of school, which resulted in several referrals to the office. He also was not allowed to attend an assembly or participate in a field trip. Mr. Tognetti recalled that STUDENT, as well as a number of other students, had the history teacher in tears.

Phil Boehme, sixth-grade teacher, was STUDENT's basketball coach when STUDENT was in the seventh grade. He has also been a substitute teacher in STUDENT's class. Mr. Boehme described STUDENT as athletic and coordinated and his dexterity as average to a little above average. Mr. Boehme testified STUDENT sometimes was "silly or goofy" and that he had some difficulty paying attention; however, STUDENT presented no more of a behavioral problem than any of the other students. He also did not require additional supervision.

Cheryl Rios, speech and language pathologist, assessed STUDENT in May 1995 at the request of Ms. PARENT. Ms. Rios testified that to be eligible for speech and language services, a student must score at or below the second percentile in two similar measures of speech and language or at the seventh percentile in one measure with a concurring language sample. Ms. Rios found that STUDENT scored below the second percentile in two measures she administered and, on this basis, she determined that STUDENT was entitled to speech and language services. Ms. Rios testified that STUDENT exhibited deficits in his ability to problem solve in certain social situations and in some areas of expressive language as measured by standardized testing. Ms. Rios testified that the goals and objectives included on STUDENT's IEP dated June 14, 1995, address STUDENT's deficits in language and are related to improving STUDENT's behavior, to improve his ability to interpret social situations from several perspectives, to be flexible in his thought processes, to develop techniques to think before responding impulsively, and to understand the implications of his interactions with others. Ms. Rios testified that two thirty minute sessions per week of therapy would initially be sufficient to address STUDENT's needs. Ms. Rios testified that STUDENT would not have qualified for speech and language services based on testing completed by Jennifer Hollibaugh in February 1993.

Tami Barnes, speech and language pathologist, provided twice weekly speech and language therapy to STUDENT during the 1995-1996 school year. Ms. Barnes testified that STUDENT performed well academically. Ms. Barnes offered the opinion that STUDENT's behavior could be improved by making some changes to his classroom environment. For example, Ms. Barnes observed that STUDENT did better in class when he was seated away from the other students and with teachers who provided him with positive feedback and from whom he knew what to expect. She also noted that STUDENT became more agitated toward the end of the day. Ms. Barnes testified that STUDENT did better when she worked one-to-one with him and that, when another student was present, he became distracted. Ms. Barnes testified that STUDENT does not inhibit his behavior as well as an average person. He quickly gets mad and "goes off." She did not, however, consider STUDENT uncontrollable. Ms. Barnes testified that STUDENT's problems were more intense at the end of the school year than they were initially.

Included in the techniques she recommended for STUDENT were teaching him to perform positive self-talking, role-playing with peers, and replaying play difficult peer and social interactions with her. Ms. Barnes testified that STUDENT met objectives to improve his word knowledge. Regarding objectives to improve his pragmatic skills, STUDENT met one objective and partially met two other objectives. One objective was not addressed and one was partially addressed. Ms. Barnes testified that STUDENT could not necessarily apply the skills he learned in therapy to other situations. (See Petitioner's Exhibit 24) Ms. Barnes testified that the IEP team agreed to new goals and objectives she drafted for STUDENT in March 1996. The objectives were designed to teach STUDENT to learn to do more than one thing at a time (parallel processing), to provide him strategies for interpreting written materials and social situations, to improve peer relationships, and to enhance his ability to focus in class. Ms. Barnes testified that team members, including the parents, were provided with an opportunity to comment on the proposed goals and objectives.

Marie Lamb is a credentialed school psychologist and also holds elementary and several special education teaching credentials. In June 1995, Ms. Lamb assessed STUDENT after Ms. PARENT expressed concerns regarding his ability to be successful in a large junior high school environment, his behavior at home and at school, and his difficultly adjusting to change. Ms. Lamb testified that she provided Ms. PARENT with a copy of the parents' rights when she obtained consent to conduct the assessment. Ms. Lamb testified that part of her assessment included speaking with STUDENT's teachers, who did not share Ms. PARENT's concerns. STUDENT's fourth and fifth grade teachers reported that STUDENT's behavior was manageable and did not interfere with his learning. Ms. Lamb testified that it is not surprising that STUDENT's sixth-grade year was more difficult for him given that his teacher left mid-year, which resulted in the class having a series of substitute teachers and then a teacher who was inexperienced and struggled with classroom management, as well as the fact that STUDENT has some difficulty with transitions.

Ms. Lamb testified that the scores STUDENT obtained on tests she administered were comparable with prior test results. STUDENT's cognitive abilities fell within the average range. His scores on measures of academic achievement were actually higher than expected given his cognitive scores. Ms. Lamb testified that she was aware that STUDENT had received OT for approximately three years; however, she did not find any evidence that an OT assessment was warranted not did the parents request an OT assessment at the time of her assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Lamb testified that STUDENT's scores fell in the low average range on the Bender Gestalt, which is a measure of perceptual-motor skills. Ms. Lamb noted that, although STUDENT is one year older than the age for which the Bender Gestalt is valid, she administered the test to him to have a measure of his strengths and weaknesses. Ms. Lamb testified that information in STUDENT's cumulative records and from his teachers also does not support that STUDENT has fine- or gross-motor deficits or perceptual difficulties. There also was no evidence that STUDENT had benefitted from or made any progress during his three years of OT.

Ms. Lamb testified that STUDENT does not meet SED criteria. He did not appear unhappy or depressed during testing and none of his teachers reported him to be depressed. Ms. Lamb testified that STUDENT had some difficulty with social situations; however, STUDENT's fourth and fifth grade teachers reported that he was able to form relationships with them, had a group of friends with whom he socialized during lunch, and played on sports teams with his peers. Ms. Lamb concluded that STUDENT would benefit from speech and language therapy to address deficits interpreting social situations.

Karen Ann Breslow, program specialist and licensed speech and language pathologist, serves as a behavior management specialist for San Benito County. Ms. Breslow testified that one of her responsibilities is to conduct Hughes Bill functional analysis assessments (FAA). Ms. Breslow testified that the intent of the Hughes Bill is to protect students with serious behavioral problems by providing systematic and positive ways to deal with their behavior until they are learn the tools that will allow them to better access school, the community, and employment. Ms. Breslow testified that she is qualified to conduct FAAs because of her background in functional analysis assessment and the 32 or more hours of specific training in functional analysis assessment. Ms. Breslow conducted a functional analysis assessment and developed the behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT that are consistent with the requirements of the Hughes Bill. Ms. Breslow testified that, in developing STUDENT's plan, she first met with Ms. PARENT and the speech and language pathologist. She also reviewed STUDENT's cumulative education file and reports from Ms. Jackson, Dr. Karzmark, and Dr. Delmonico prior to analyzing STUDENT's behavior. STUDENT's teachers, his speech and language pathologist, the PARENTs, Donna Jackson, and the vice principal completed questionnaires about STUDENT and Ms. Breslow followed up with interviews of the same persons and observations in all but one of STUDENT's classes. The vice principal and the speech pathologist expressed concerns about STUDENT's gross behavior, such as chewing with his mouth open, and disruptive behavior during classroom instruction. Ms. PARENT expressed concerns regarding STUDENT's disrespect for authority, rudeness, and use of foul language. Mr. PARENT expressed concern for STUDENT's disrespect for authority and for his "disrupting peaceful times at home."

Ms. Breslow testified that STUDENT's first period teacher declined to fill out the questionnaire and told her that STUDENT did not have any problems in the class. Ms. Breslow also did not observe any behavioral problems during her observation of the class. STUDENT's second period art teacher expressed concerns regarding STUDENT's disruptiveness and talking out in class, and his use of classroom materials to annoy other students. For example, STUDENT flicked paint on the clothing of another student and put a wet sponge on another student's art project. During Ms. Breslow's observation of the art class, STUDENT was a little more disruptive than other students. He poked at his neighbor and made comments to draw attention to himself. STUDENT's third period social studies teacher reported that STUDENT "put down" and was disrespectful to the teacher and other students. Ms. Breslow observed that, in third period, STUDENT became restless and had difficulty keeping in his seat. He also kept getting food out of his backpack. STUDENT's fourth period math teacher did not identify any particular behavior as problematic. Ms. Breslow described STUDENT's behavior during her observation of fourth period as disruptive. He also called the teacher and other students "stupid and lame." STUDENT's fifth period teacher said that STUDENT had been rude and verbally abusive until he found out that he might be transferred to a different class. Thereafter, the teacher reported that STUDENT's behavior was acceptable. STUDENT's sixth period science teacher did not complete the questionnaire and did not identify any problems with STUDENT during Ms. Breslow's interview with him. Ms. Breslow testified that, when she made her observation of the sixth period class, there had been a substitute teacher for two weeks and the class was very rowdy. Ms. Breslow stated that STUDENT initially had difficulty staying in his seat when he came into the room; however, he later worked 20 minutes on a worksheet and was oblivious to all of the activities going on around him. Ms. Breslow testified that following her observations, the teachers confirmed that her observations had been typical. Ms. Breslow testified that STUDENT had "quite a collection of friends."

Ms. Breslow testified that the time lines were extended for completing the assessment because the parents were out of town. (Respondent's Exhibit 48)xx Ms. Breslow testified that, on June 6, 1996, she met with school staff and Ms. PARENT to review the data she had collected regarding STUDENT's behavior. Ms. Breslow testified that STUDENT had the most difficulty with his behavior during transitions, when he was learning new materials, and when he was in a less structured or unstructured activity. STUDENT had the least difficulty during the morning and in highly structured and quieter classrooms. Ms. Breslow testified that they determined that STUDENT's behavior plan would target disruptive behaviors, such as talking out and clowning around in class, putting down and mocking peers and adults, passing gas, gross chewing of food, and defacing other students' property. The plan also would target "mock" assaults where STUDENT appeared as if he were going to swing at or strike someone but actually did not. The plan identified consequences for inappropriate behavior, including referrals, verbal redirection, and ignoring. Positive consequences included verbal praise and acknowledgment of STUDENT's ideas. Ms. Breslow testified that she would evaluate the success of the plan weekly to determine if the target behaviors were being reduced and that the entire plan would be re-evaluated and modified, as appropriate, in December 1996.

Ms. Breslow testified that Ms. PARENT and her attorney at the time, Mr. Ruderman, expressed agreement with the plan and did not make any suggestions to change the plan. (See Respondent's Exhibit 27) Ms. Breslow testified, however, that STUDENT's current teachers were concerned about the lack of input from the teachers STUDENT would have for the 8th grade, since the 8th grade teachers would actually be implementing the plan. Ms. Breslow stated, that for this reason, the section of the plan regarding consequences was not completed and the team agreed to meet on August 28, 1996, to finalize the plan with STUDENT's 8th grade teachers.

Carol Lankford, director of special education, testified that STUDENT had significant behavioral problems during the seventh grade. The school convened a SST to address how to meet STUDENT's needs, conducted a behavioral assessment, and drew up a behavioral intervention plan. Ms. Lankford testified that the only concerns the parents expressed regarding the IEP dated April 15, 1996, was STUDENT's need for a smaller class size and additional speech and language. Ms. Lankford testified that the team could not agree whether STUDENT required counseling; however, she offered to provide counseling services. The District also agreed to conduct an OT assessment but the parents later decided that they would not consent to the District's offer. Ms. Lankford testified that the District agreed to have Dr. Delmonico review the behavioral intervention plan and that Nicki Sergeant would implement part of the plan. Ms. Lankford testified that the District planned to convene an IEP meeting on August 28, 1996, which is during the first week of school, so that STUDENT's teachers for the 1996-1997 school year would be able to participate; however, because Ms. Sergeant was not available then, the PARENTs, District representatives, and their counsel met with her on August 8, 1996. Ms. Lankford testified that before the meeting could begin, Mr. Ruderman informed the District that the parents were going to hospitalize STUDENT the following day and the parents shared the contract they had signed to that effect. Ms. Lankford testified that she was shocked because the parents had not previously mentioned that they were considering a residential placement for STUDENT. Also, the parties had been working to develop a plan and getting services in place for the fall. Ms. Lankford testified that the parents requested that the District fund STUDENT's residential placement; however, the District was not prepared to make that decision, particularly because of the need to convene a complete IEP team. Ms. Lankford testified that Mr. Ruderman was going to inform her of the parents' availability on their return from placing STUDENT. Ms. Lankford testified that she sent a letter to the parents after the August 8th meeting to ask them to contact her to discuss setting an IEP meeting and to address other options for STUDENT, such as AB3632 services or placement in a class for emotionally disturbed students. Ms. Lankford did not send a notice for an IEP meeting because she believed the parents had already made up their minds about STUDENT's placement and the dates had already been set for the due process hearing.

Ms. Lankford testified that she spoke with Barbara Hine, the educational coordinator from Paradise Cove, who told her that the students work independently on educational modules. Ms. Hine also informed her that Paradise Cove does not have any special education teachers or speech pathologists and that the majority of the students have drug or substance abuse problems, a number of the students have criminal records, and others have severe behavioral problems. Ms. Lankford testified that Ms. Hine did not recommend Paradise Cove for a student with TBI because there are no specialists in TBI in Western Samoa and she would not know what behavioral methods would be appropriate to employ.

Ms. Lankford testified that Paradise Cove is not a certified by the state of California as a nonpublic school or agency. Ms. Lankford testified that Paradise Cove is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the following reasons: STUDENT has made educational progress and was doing well academically in the District; a behavioral intervention plan has been drafted to address his behavioral problems; there is no justification to move STUDENT from placement in a regular education program with some special education services to a highly restrictive residential placement without first trying less restrictive interventions; and Paradise Cove employs behavioral interventions that are not in accordance with the requirements of the Hughes Bill. Ms. Lankford testified that in placing STUDENT, STUDENT's parents signed a waiver agreeing to the use of restraint and pepper spray. Ms. Lankford testified that the appropriate way to change STUDENT's behavior is to teach him replacement behaviors and to teach him in a concrete way. Ms. Lankford testified that the appropriate placement for STUDENT is in regular education with speech and language therapy and a behavioral intervention plan. Ms. Lankford testified that her recommendations regarding STUDENT's placement are supported by the fact that STUDENT has demonstrated good academic progress and has met many of his goals and objectives. Ms. Lankford testified that the District did not offer to place STUDENT in a residential program in California because the District does not believe that STUDENT requires a residential placement.

Katie Merchant, Ed.D., served as a program specialist and SELPA director and has recently relocated out-of-state. Dr. Merchant reviewed STUDENT's records before testifying. She has not met STUDENT. Dr. Merchant analyzed the educational criteria for SED and drew the following conclusions: STUDENT does not meet the first criteria as SED because his good grades demonstrate that he is able to learn; STUDENT does not meet the second criteria as SED because his behaviors that include rudeness, belching, passing gas, and impulsivity, are not the result of emotional problems; STUDENT does not meet the third criteria as SED because he has peers with whom he interacts and instructors he likes; and STUDENT does not meet the fourth criteria for SED because the only report of STUDENT exhibiting depression was while hospitalized in Utah. To satisfy the fourth criteria, STUDENT must have exhibited depression or other mood disorders that are pervasive, to a marked degree, and for a long period of time. The depression must also have affected his educational performance. Dr. Merchant testified that STUDENT has been assessed several times and none of the prior reports, including those by his treating physicians, have ever diagnosed STUDENT with depression. Dr. Merchant stated that, at the time of the Brightway assessment, STUDENT was aware that he would be leaving his family for a residential placement, and any depression STUDENT may have exhibited was directly related to the fact that he was hospitalized and was aware that he shortly would be going to a residential placement far away from home. Dr. Merchant testified that, under the circumstances, the fact that STUDENT was tearful and anxious was "rather a typical response" to the situation.

Dr. Merchant testified that the assessments conducted while STUDENT was hospitalized at Brightway do not indicate that STUDENT meets SED criteria for special education. They also are not helpful in determining STUDENT's placement because they do not include any educational or behavioral recommendations that would assist in planning an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. On cross-examination, Dr. Merchant testified that withdrawing, shyness, and lethargy may be signs of depression in a teenager. They also may be related to TBI. Dr. Merchant testified that impulsivity, distractibility, irritability, and silliness may be related to TBI. Dr. Merchant testified that STUDENT's behavior is not so severe as to merit residential placement. She concluded that an appropriate placement for STUDENT is in a regular public school setting with counseling, speech and language, and implementation of the District's behavioral intervention plan. Dr. Merchant testified that Paradise Cove's use of aversives and behavioral controls that are punitive violates the Hughes Bill, which allows only the use of positive behavioral intervention. For example, STUDENT's records from Paradise Cove speak of his not having any shoes, of being isolated from his peers, of taking away his silverware, of changing his diet, and of publicly humiliating him by hanging signs around his neck.

Margaret A. (Peg) Bledsoe is a board certified occupational therapist in private practice. Ms. Bledsoe testified that the following elements need to be assessed to determine whether a student would benefit from OT: signs and symptoms; cognition; vision and vision-perception; and self-help skills. Ms. Bledsoe testified that students with TBI do not benefit from sensory integration therapy because changes cannot be made to their neurological make up; however, OT to improve balance and body awareness, and to strengthen muscles may be beneficial.

Ms. Bledsoe testified regarding the assessment of STUDENT administered by Donna Jackson on August 24, 1992. (Respondent's Exhibit 37) She stated that it was not appropriate to report scores STUDENT obtained on the Sensory Integration and Praxis Test (SIPT) because STUDENT is beyond the age range for which the test is valid. The SIPT also is not appropriate because of the fact that STUDENT's TBI affects the validity of the test results and the test itself is very old. Ms. Bledsoe testified that STUDENT's deficits on the Visual Spatial Test were not supported by further assessment results. Ms. Bledsoe also found the assessment deficient because it did not include a writing sample, a hand function test, or observations of STUDENT in his school environment. Ms. Bledsoe testified that the report is vague. For example, Ms. Jackson's report states that STUDENT inappropriately used phasic muscle groups but the report fails to identify which area is affected. Ms. Bledsoe testified that the treatment goals and objectives developed by Ms. Jackson are not related to STUDENT's school performance. There also are no short-term measurable outcomes. Ms. Bledsoe testified that STUDENT did not require direct OT services to benefit from his education. She also commented that STUDENT OT will not bring about a change in STUDENT's condition.

Ms. Bledsoe testified regarding Ms. Jackson's assessment in July 1995. Ms. Bledsoe testified that the Ross Test of Higher Cognitive Processes is not included by the occupational therapist licensing board among the tests occupational therapists are qualified to administer. Therefore, as an occupational therapist, Ms. Jackson is not qualified to administer the Ross Test of Higher Cognitive Processes, unless she also is a psychologist. Ms. Bledsoe testified that the assessment is also deficient in the following ways: STUDENT does not fall in the appropriate age range for the Test of Visual Motor Skills; the assessment lacks a classroom observation, which is important to verify the child's functioning level in other than a clinical setting; Ms. Jackson is "out of her league" interpreting and making recommendations based on cognitive information since she is an occupational therapist rather than a psychologist; the report does not include short-term objectives and does not describe methodology to employ to meet treatment goals. Ms. Bledsoe testified that the goals for therapy, which she described as vague, are not related to educational outcomes. Ms. Bledsoe testified that STUDENT does not currently have any educational needs for which he requires OT.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Does STUDENT meet special education eligibility criteria as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA), children with disabilities are entitled to a free, appropriate education. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c); California Education Code § 56000. "Children with disabilities" includes children who, because of a serious emotional disturbance, require special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(1)(A); California Education Code § 56026(a-b). The federal regulations implementing IDEA set forth at 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9) the criteria that must be met to satisfy eligibility for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed:

(i) The term means a condition exhibiting one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affects a child's educational performance-- (A) An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors;

(B) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers;

(C) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances;

(D) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; or (E) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal of school problems.

(ii) The term includes children who are schizophrenic. The term does not apply to children who are socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that they have a serious emotional disturbance.(Footnote 7)

California regulations add that any inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances must be "exhibited in several situations." Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3030(i).

Petitioner contends that he meets eligibility criteria for SED because of an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances, and because of a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Petitioner asserts that his condition has existed for a long period of time and that he has exhibited aggressive and inappropriate behavior since infancy. The District contends that Petitioner does not meet special education criteria as SED.

Does Petitioner exhibit an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers?

Petitioner asserts that because he has no friends and has not gotten along with teachers, he satisfies the criteria of an "inability to build or maintain satisfactory relations with peers and teachers." 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9)(i)(B) The District contends that STUDENT had friends at school, has had good relationships with some of his teachers, and has made friends at Paradise Cove.

Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT has always had difficulty making friends and does not have any close friends. The fact that STUDENT has difficulty with interpersonal relationships was acknowledged by witnesses called on behalf of the District; however, the District witnesses disputed that STUDENT exhibits an inability to build satisfactory relationships with peers and teachers. STUDENT's teachers from fourth through seventh grade and his basketball coach testified credibly that STUDENT has made friends in his classes and with teammates. The teachers also reported having observed STUDENT associating with peers during lunch and on other occasions at school. Although Ms. PARENT asserted that STUDENT does not have friends, she testified that when she was concerned during the summer of 1996 that STUDENT had run away, she contacted some of his friends in an attempt to locate his whereabouts. Moreover, Ms. PARENT testified that one of STUDENT's friends was invited to accompany him on the trip to Utah in the summer of 1996, which, by design, culminated in STUDENT's hospitalization. In the report of an independent neuropsychological assessment of STUDENT on October 30, 1995, it is stated that Ms. PARENT reported to the assessor that STUDENT's "difficulty [making and keeping friends] appears to have improved recently." (District's Exhibit 32) STUDENT's writings from Paradise Cove also speak of his making friends. STUDENT described to his parents how his "best friend" from Brightway was at Paradise Cove and how he made a new friend from Kansas. STUDENT also wrote about trips with friends that he had made before leaving home to the Boardwalk and Great America, as well as the trip with his friend enroute to his hospitalization. (Respondent's Exhibit 41, pp. 5-6, 10) The testimony of STUDENT's teachers as well as the testimony of Ms. PARENT, establish that STUDENT has established positive relationships with some teachers. Several teachers reported that they liked STUDENT and enjoyed his sense of humor. His basketball coach also testified that he got along well with STUDENT. Additionally, on some occasions when STUDENT was having difficulty in a class when there was a substitute teacher, he was allowed to return to a former teacher's class because of their good relationship.

The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has established some satisfactory relationships with peers and teachers and, therefore, does not meet the SED criteria of an inability to build or maintain satisfactory relationships with peers and teachers.

Does Petitioner exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances?

Petitioner asserts that he meets the criteria of "inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances" because of disinhibited anger and behavior that is uncharacteristic of an honor student, including having food hanging out of his mouth, excessively passing gas in class, and "grossing out" his classmates. 4 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9)(i)(C) The District contends that STUDENT does not suffer from psychotic or overtly bizarre behavior nor is he is likely to harm himself or others and, therefore, does not satisfy this criteria as SED.

Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT physically assaulted her during the summer of 1996. He also has been aggressive toward a sibling. Ms. Jackson reported that STUDENT had struck another occupational therapist that had been working with him. The therapist did not testify and there is no information regarding the actual incident. STUDENT also engaged in one fight in each of the sixth and seventh grades. The fights were apparently provoked by an exchange of words between STUDENT and another student. Based on Ms. PARENT's responses on the Connors Parent Rating Scale, Dr. Karzmark concluded that STUDENT had a great deal of disinhibited anger.

Comments by teachers on STUDENT's sixth and seventh grade report cards describe STUDENT's conduct as "unsatisfactory." The testimony of STUDENT's teachers testified that during the sixth and seventh grades, STUDENT engaged in undesirable, distracting, and annoying behavior at school, such as eating with his mouth open, allowing food to dribble from his mouth, picking at scabs, flatulating in class, and blurting out information. He has also damaged other students' work, verbally "put down" other students and called them "stupid," and has used racial slurs and inappropriate language. The list of 34 disciplinary incidents from the seventh grade most often were related to rude and disruptive behavior. Other reports list swearing, obscenities, defiance, or insubordinate behavior as the reason for the referral. There are two incidents related to fighting. (Petitioner's Exhibits 21 and 22) Disciplinary reports from the sixth grade involve similar infractions. (Petitioner's Exhibit 2

However, none of the teachers, or for that matter, any of the assessors described STUDENT's behavior as bizarre or psychotic. All of the teachers that testified, as well as STUDENT's basketball coach, concluded that STUDENT's behavior was manageable. As to whether STUDENT's inappropriate behavior at school was unusual under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of STUDENT's teachers establishes that a majority of STUDENT's inappropriate behavior at school was intended to attract the attention of his peers and sometimes teachers as well, which is not entirely unusual for a junior high school student. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of STUDENT's teachers is more reliable regarding STUDENT's behavior at school than the testimony of other witnesses who were not were present and, therefore, did not directly observe STUDENT's behavior at school. Additionally, STUDENT did not demonstrate psychological problems on measures of social/emotional functioning. In Ms. Steele's report of STUDENT's scores on the Robert's Apperception Test for Children administered in March of 1996, she stated that STUDENT did not exhibit a "global pattern of psychological or behavioral disfunction." (District's Exhibit 22) School psychologist Ms. Lamb also did not find evidence of an emotional disturbance. Moreover, many of the persons who have assessed STUDENT at the request of his parents described his behavior as consistent with a TBI rather than an emotional disturbance. Dr. Karzmark, Ms. Hollibaugh, and Dr. Delmonico testified that STUDENT's attentional problems, anger, verbal explosiveness, outbursts, impulsiveness and anger are consistent with a head injury. Other assessors found STUDENT's behavior more consistent with a conduct disorder rather than an emotional disturbance. For example, Ms. Kelly diagnosed an oppositional defiant disorder.

To satisfy SED criteria, STUDENT's aggressive behavior must be inappropriate under the circumstances and also must be pervasive and adversely affect his educational performance. 34 C.F.R. 300.7 (b)(9)(i). There is no persuasive evidence that STUDENT engaged in behavior in the community that would be considered unusual under the circumstances. It is noted that STUDENT was employed by a family friend at a sandwich shop. The aggression directed against his mother and sibling is unfortunate; however, the Hearing Officer does not find that these incidents at home constitute pervasive inappropriate behavior.

Even if the limited incidents of aggressive behavior are construed as pervasive, the Hearing Officer does not find persuasive evidence that STUDENT's aggressive behavior has adversely affected his educational performance. Petitioner asserts that his behavior has negatively affected his education because it has kept him from having his name placed on the school's honor roll for some quarters that he would otherwise be eligible. Taking the fact that STUDENT has always been mainstreamed in regular education classes and has consistently received better than passing grades, the Hearing Officer does not find Petitioner's assertion persuasive. During the seventh grade, STUDENT received two "A's," one "A-", one "B," and a "C+" in physical education. STUDENT's grades in the sixth grade ranged from "B" to "A." In the fifth grade, STUDENT received only one "C" with the rest of the grades "B's" and "A's." During the fourth reporting period for both the fifth and sixth grades, STUDENT received all "A's." (Petitioner's Exhibit 24) Moreover, STUDENT's scores on measures of academic achievement show growth as well. Therefore, because STUDENT's behavior is neither pervasive nor does it adversely affect his educational performance, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not meet SED criteria based on inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances.

Does Petitioner exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression?

Petitioner asserts that, in August 1996, Dr. Chappuis and Dr. Goates diagnosed him with depression, which satisfies the SED criteria of a "general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression." 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9)(i)(D) Their finding of depression represents the only time that STUDENT has ever been diagnosed as depressed. The significance of the diagnosis of depression by Drs. Chappuis and Goates is when it was made. They assessed STUDENT when he was hospitalized in a psychiatric facility and was aware of his impending placement in a residential facility in Western Samoa, far from his family, friends, and community in California.

Even if STUDENT suffered from situational depression at the time of his hospitalization, his depression must also be found to be pervasive to meet SED criteria. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9)(i). This requirement means that the depressive mood or unhappiness must be exhibited in major areas of STUDENT's life, including school, community, and home. Neither Dr. Delmonico, Petitioner's witness, nor District testing in June 1995 or in March 1996 found that STUDENT was depressed. On testing administered by Ms. Steele in March 1996, STUDENT's scores on the Clinical Scale of Robert's Apperception Test for Children, fell within the normal range of anxiety, aggression, depression and rejection. (District's Exhibit 22) At the hearing, STUDENT's teachers from the fourth through seventh grades testified and none of them described STUDENT as depressed. Even Ms. PARENT reported to Dr. Karzmark in October 1995 that STUDENT "does not appear sad, tearful, or listless at this time." (District's Exhibit 32)

There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT suffered from a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression at any time other than at the time of his hospitalization at Brightway. Therefore, even if STUDENT were clinically depressed at the time of his hospitalization, the evidence does not establish that he was depressed for a long period of time or that any depression he may have experienced was pervasive. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not meet SED criteria because of a general pervasive mood of depression or unhappiness.

Petitioner did not assert that he meets SED criteria on any other basis nor was there evidence that he exhibits an inability to learn or has a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal of school problems. The Hearing Officer is mindful of the justifiable concerns of STUDENT's parents in regard to his well-being, as well as their concerns for STUDENT's ability to function within the family. However, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not meet educational criteria for a serious emotional disturbance.

ISSUE NO. 2: Was STUDENT entitled to special education services during the 1993-1994 and 1994-1995 school years?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). According to the United States Supreme Court, the student's placement must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The school district is required to provide the student with a "basic floor of opportunity" and is not required to provide the student with the best educational available. Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176. Thus, under IDEA and Rowley, the program offered by the school district is appropriate when it is designed to meet the student's unique needs, provides the student with some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP.

The term "related services" includes transportation and other services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services.

Petitioner's parents seek reimbursement for OT and speech and language services they provided for STUDENT during the 1993-1994 and 1994-1995 school years; however, STUDENT was not then eligible for special education, since the IEP team had exited him from special education at the end of the 1990-1991 school year. Therefore, unless it can now be determined that STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education during the time period at issue, he would not have been entitled to OT, speech and language therapy, or any other special education services. Petitioner contends that he was improperly exited from special education, that the District failed to assess him before he was dismissed from special education, and that he should have continued to be eligible to receive services from the District. Petitioner did not set forth any particular basis on which a redetermination of eligibility for special education should be found.

During the 1990-1991 school year, STUDENT was eligible for special education because of a discrepancy between his ability and achievement. Petitioner's assertion that the District did not assess him prior to exiting him from special education is without merit since the results of the District's testing of STUDENT is recorded in Petitioner's Exhibit 3. STUDENT's scores on academic achievement tests administered in April 1991 showed that he had made good progress and that there no longer was a discrepancy between his ability and achievement. The IEP team determined that STUDENT no longer met eligibility criteria for special education because of a learning disability or on any other basis. There is no evidence that STUDENT later met eligibility for special education because of a learning disability.

There also is no evidence that the District should have conducted further assessments prior to exiting STUDENT from special education. Petitioner presented no evidence of concerns or deficits in the areas of speech and language, or regarding the need for OT prior to the end of the 1990-1991 school year. There were no referrals by parents or teachers for further assessment of STUDENT. He also was not referred to the SST. STUDENT's teacher described STUDENT as a "good worker" and stated that he had "terrific concentration." STUDENT received good marks on all of his report cards. (Respondent's Exhibit 28) There also is no evidence that the District was aware of any therapy or other assistance that the PARENTs may have been providing STUDENT during the 1990-1991 school year.

Nothing in the evidence suggests that STUDENT's educational needs had changed or that he exhibited deficits at school that would have triggered the need for an OT assessment or services when the PARENTs initiated OT for STUDENT with Ms. Jackson in August 1992. There also was no evidence that STUDENT's school performance had changed during the first semester of the 1992-1993 school year, triggering a referral for assessment of STUDENT's speech and language needs. STUDENT's teachers during the periods in question all testified that they never considered referring STUDENT for special education and that he performed well academically in their classes. There also was no evidence that the parents requested an assessment. Therefore, there is no persuasive evidence that a referral for special education or an assessment were warranted during the 1991-1992, 1992-1993, and 1993-1994, school years.

Turning to whether STUDENT may have been entitled to speech and language therapy because he qualified for special education as a student with a speech and language disorder at the time the parents obtained the services of Ms. Hollibaugh in February 1993 or at some other time thereafter, special education law states that to be eligible, the student must demonstrate "difficulty understanding or using spoken language to such an extent that it adversely affects his or her educational performance and cannot be corrected without special education and related services." Education Code § 56333. The difficulty may result from a number of disorders, including "inappropriate or inadequate acquisition, comprehension, or expression of spoken language such that the pupil's language performance level of his or her peers." Education Code § 56333(d).(FOOTNOTE 8) Pursuant to 5 CCR § 3030(c)(4), to qualify as having a language disorder the student must meet one of the following criteria:

(A) The pupil scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean, or below the 7th percentile, for his or her chronological age or developmental level on two or more standardized tests in one or more or the following areas of language development: morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics. When standardized tests are considered to be invalid for the specific pupil, the expected language performance level shall be determined by alternate means as specified ont he assessment plan, or (B) The pupil scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean or the score is below the 7th percentile for his or her chronological age or developmental level on one or more standardized tests in one of the areas listed in subsection (A) and displays inappropriate or inadequate usage of expressive or receptive language as measured by a representative spontaneous or elicited language sample of a minimum of fifty utterances.

In asserting the District should have provided him with speech and language services, Petitioner relies on the testimony of Jennifer Hollibaugh, a speech and language pathologist that saw STUDENT for private therapy, and the results of her assessment in February 1993. (Petitioner's Exhibit 17) Ms. Hollibaugh testified that STUDENT would have qualified for speech and language services in 1993 because of difficulty finding appropriate words and deficits in auditory processing skills, processing oral directions, formulating coherent discourse and recalling information. Ms. Hollibaugh based her conclusions on clinical observations and administration of the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-Revised (CELF-R) and Tests of Cognitive Ability-Woodcock/STUDENTson.(FOOTNOTE 9) On the CELF-R, STUDENT's standard score on the measure of receptive language was 80 and his standard score on the measure of expressive language was 59. The age equivalent score was 7 years. According to Ms. Rios, District speech and language pathologist, the testing completed by Ms. Hollibaugh was insufficient to qualify STUDENT for services because she only obtained scores on one measure of language and did not support her results with a language sample. No additional testing was presented to establish that STUDENT met special education eligibility criteria because of a speech and language disability under 5 CCR § 3030(c)(4).

Ms. Barnes, who provided therapy to STUDENT for the District, testified that because of his TBI, it is likely that STUDENT has had language deficits for a long period of time. However, Ms. Barnes did not assess or observe STUDENT during the 1993-1994 or 1994-1995 school years and could not offer any specific information regarding STUDENT's strengths, weaknesses, or needs at that time. No one else testified that STUDENT had deficits in language during the 1992-1993, 1993-1994 or 1994-1995 school years, and neither STUDENT's teachers nor his parents referred STUDENT for a special education assessment for speech and language, OT, or any other basis. Moreover, even if STUDENT had some language deficits, there is no evidence to substantiate that the deficits were sufficiently severe to either qualify him for special education or to require therapy to benefit from his education.

Petitioner also contends that he required OT to address sensory-motor deficits. Petitioner asserts that the District had knowledge of his deficits since 1990 and also was aware that he had been receiving OT from Donna Jackson since 1992.

Occupational therapy includes:

(i) Improving, developing or restoring functions impaired or lost through illness, injury or deprivation;

(ii) Improving ability to perform tasks for independent functioning when functions are impaired or lost; and (iii) Preventing, through early intervention, initial or further impairment or loss of function.

34 C.F.R. 300.16(b)(5).

Petitioner relies on information provided by Ms. Jackson during testimony and contained in her assessments and reports to support his need for OT. In September 1992, Ms. Jackson recommended OT to address deficits in processing of sensory information that were interfering with STUDENT's ability to motor plan efficiently and effectively, to develop fine motor coordination and dexterity, and to function appropriately, safely, effectively, and independently for his age, to interact successfully with the external world, and to develop age appropriate social skills.

An assessment of STUDENT's motor skills by a District APE teacher in 1990 had found him functioning in the average to above average range of development. The assessment at the same time by the school psychologist did not reveal that STUDENT had any significant processing problems. STUDENT's teachers testified that STUDENT did not exhibit motor, postural, or coordination problems in class. None of STUDENT's teachers recommend him for an OT assessment and none of the teachers supported the contention that OT was necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education. Ms. Jackson did not observe STUDENT at school and she also did not discuss STUDENT with his teachers to determine whether OT was necessary to address educationally-related needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not find Ms. Jackson's testimony persuasive regarding STUDENT's educational need for OT. Moreover, the goals of the therapy do not appear to support his need for OT to benefit from his instruction. (See Petitioner's Exhibit 16)

Even if during the 1993-1994 and 1994-1995 school years, STUDENT exhibited some deficits in language or in motor or processing skills, the District was only required to provide him with language therapy or OT if either was necessary for him to benefit educationally from his instructional program. Education Code § 56363(a). All of STUDENT's scores on measures of academic achievement administered by the District at the end of the 1990-1991 school year fall within the average or above-average range. All of these scores are higher than scores achieved on similar measures the prior school year and the increase in standard scores ranges from 17 to 24 points. (Petitioner's Exhibit 3, p. 19) STUDENT's marks during the 1990-1991 school year were all satisfactory or better and a majority of the grades were "S+" (better than satisfactory) or "E" (excellent). STUDENT's marks during the 1991-1992 school year were also satisfactory or above except. The only areas marked slightly lower were in relating to peers and following school rules. STUDENT's grades during the 1992-1993 school year are all "A's" and "B's" except for "C's" the first two quarters in one class, science/health. STUDENT's grades in the sixth grade were even better and he only had one "less than expected" mark, which was for playground behavior. It goes without saying that STUDENT passed successfully from grade to grade. (District's Exhibit 28)

An argument could be made that STUDENT would not have been able to make academic progress without the support services provided by his parents. The nature of the OT STUDENT received from Ms. Jackson--weight shifting, developing balance and equilibrium and mature automatic postural responses, increasing strength and endurance of musculature, coordination and planning normalizing somatosensory processing, decreasing gravitational insecurity, and decreasing touch defensiveness--cannot reasonably explain STUDENT's exceptional academic achievement. Nor does the limited amount of services STUDENT received from Ms. Hollibaugh during the 1993-1994 school year. Moreover, STUDENT has demonstrated the ability to make good academic progress and to receive good marks on his report card when he has not received special education or other parentally provided assistance. STUDENT received his best grades in academic subjects and his best marks in behavior when he was not receiving services from either Ms. Jackson or Ms. Hollibaugh. STUDENT did not receive OT or speech and language services during the 1991-1992 school year and did not begin receiving speech and language therapy until midway through the 1992-1993 school year. He did not receive either OT or speech and language after January 1994.(FOOTNOTE 10)

Therefore, based on STUDENT's ability to receive commendable grades in the absence of special education services, except during the first grade, the ability to show progress on measures of academic achievement, and to pass successfully from grade to grade, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT did not require language therapy or OT to benefit educationally from his instructional program during the 1993-1994 and 1994-1995 school years.

ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in June 1995?

In order for the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Additionally, individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. Assessment and testing materials must also not measure the student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless that is what the test purports to measure.

Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. Pursuant to subsection (g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Education Code § 56324(a) and (b).

The District assessed STUDENT in June 1995 following the PARENTs' request for an assessment. The report of the assessment is contained in Petitioner's Exhibit 11. Marie Lamb, school psychologist, assessed STUDENT's personal, social, emotional, and cognitive, and visual/motor perceptual functioning. In personal, social, and emotional areas, Ms. Lamb administered the Behavior Evaluation Scale-2 to STUDENT's teacher, and interviewed the teacher and Ms. PARENT. To assess STUDENT's cognitive abilities, Ms. Lamb administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - III (WISC-III). To assess STUDENT's visual/motor perceptual functioning, Ms. Lamb administered the Bender Gestalt. Ms. Lamb's report also includes background information, summaries of speech and language and academic functioning, recommendations for special education services, and suggestions for working with STUDENT. The report refers to an assessment report dated April 18, 1990, for additional background information. The District's speech and language assessment was conducted by Cheryl L. Rios, M.A., CCC-SP, speech and language specialist. The assessment by Ms. Rios included the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-L, the Word Test-Adolescent, the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-R (CLEF-R) and the Test of Problem Solving (TOPS). Ms. Rios' report includes recommendations for services based on STUDENT's scoring below the 7th percentile on the Word and TOPS tests. (Petitioner's Exhibit 10) Resource Specialist Debra Hanson administered the Woodcock-STUDENTson Revised Test of Achievement. (District's Exhibit 15)

There was no evidence that the District's assessment instruments or the way in which they were administered were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. STUDENT's primary language is English and the tests were administered in English. The tests were administered by trained personnel--a school psychologist, resource teacher, and speech and language pathologist. There were no assertions that the tests were administered other than in conformance with test instructions or that the tests were invalid for the specific purpose for which they were used, except for the Bender, on which STUDENT exceeded the age on which the test was normed.

Petitioner contends that the District failed to assess all areas of his suspected disabilities. He asserts that the District has never conducted an occupational therapy assessment even though the District had been aware that Petitioner had received OT from Ms. Jackson for some period of time. The District contends that there was no indication that an OT assessment was necessary.

The last time that the District had assessed STUDENT's motor development and perceptual skills was in 1990. The 1995 assessment included the Bender Gestalt Test to measure STUDENT's visual motor perception; however, this assessment is normed only through age 11 years 11 months and, at the time of the assessment, STUDENT was 13 years old. STUDENT's teachers and District personnel who assessed STUDENT testified that they had not observed signs that would warrant an OT assessment. However, because neither the teachers nor the assessors are occupational therapists or adaptive physical education teachers, they would not necessarily have the expertise to made such a determination. Ms. Bledsoe, an occupational therapist who testified on behalf of the District, also had not observed or assessed STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concludes that given the nature of STUDENT's disability, the fact that STUDENT has received OT for a number of years, and because the District was aware of these facts, there was sufficient information to have put the District on notice that perceptual and motor skills are areas of suspected disability for STUDENT.

Petitioner also asserts that the District did not adequately assess his social, emotional, and behavioral needs. The District asserts that its assessment included measures of STUDENT's social and emotional functioning. Listed as the "reason for assessment" was the parent's concern about STUDENT's behavioral difficulties at school and at home. The District did not dispute that STUDENT had behavioral problems at school during the sixth grade. The record shows that STUDENT was referred for discipline numerous times during the school year. (Petitioner's Exhibit 23) Information obtained from Ms. PARENT describes her concerns regarding STUDENT's behavior. For example, Ms. PARENT reported to the assessor that STUDENT has exhibited consistent behavioral patterns and problems for the past 12 years for which he had received counseling. Information from STUDENT's teacher also identified some increasing social and behavioral concerns. Ms. Lamb described STUDENT as having underdeveloped social and emotional skills, and stated that STUDENT disrupts other students, acts impulsively, and inappropriately communicates with peers. The assessment report also notes that STUDENT's TBI and other meningoccal sepsis "apparently are factors in STUDENT's delays and that further medical information "is sought." (District's Exhibit 14) Based on the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that social, emotional, and behavioral skills were areas of suspected disability.

The only measure of STUDENT's social and emotional needs included in the District's assessment was the Behavior Elevation Scale-2, which was completed by STUDENT's classroom teacher. The District did not administer any projective instruments to STUDENT, did not administer any measures of adaptive behavior, and there is no evidence that the school psychologist or some other qualified person observed STUDENT's behavior in his classroom. Ms. PARENT also authorized the District to contact the persons who had assessed and provided STUDENT with therapy; however, there is no evidence that information from these persons was considered by the District. The Hearing Officer finds that the District's assessment of STUDENT's social, emotional, and behavioral functioning was deficient. The report of the assessment also states "Further medical information is sought." (Petitioner's Exhibit 11, p. 56) However, there was no further assessment by the District nor was there evidence that the District had consulted with STUDENT's pediatrician or other medical doctor that had seen him.

Because the District's assessment of STUDENT did not assess all areas of suspected disability, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in June 1995.

ISSUE NO. 4: Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in March 1996?

In March 1996, the District undertook an assessment of STUDENT at the request of his parents, who expressed continued concerns regarding STUDENT's behavioral difficulties at school and the effect of TBI on his behavior. Petitioner asserts that the resulting assessment by the District was deficient because it did not include a functional behavioral analysis, which the parents had requested during the 1994-1995 school year, did not assess Petitioner's functioning levels at home and in the community, and did not assess Petitioner's sensory motor skills. The District's assessment included: compilation of health and school histories; observations of STUDENT's behavior in all of his classes and at lunch; measurement of speech and language skills, cognitive skills, and academic achievement; an interview with Mr. PARENT; and measurement of STUDENT's social/emotional status by administering Robert's Apperception Test for Children and the Draw-A-Person test to STUDENT.

The original assessment plan prepared by the District on March 13, 1996, states that the reason for the proposed assessment was to "evaluate behavioral effects/social emotional effects of TBI." Given that STUDENT had been assessed less than one year earlier and the somewhat limited scope of this assessment. (Petitioner's Exhibit 27, p. 124) The assessment does include several measures of STUDENT's social and emotional status, as well as extensive observations of his behavior. There was no evidence that the assessment instruments utilized in its assessment of STUDENT in March 1996 or the way in which the assessments was administered were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. The way in which the assessment instruments were administered also was not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Testing was done in English. The tests were administered by trained personnel--a school psychologist, resource teacher, and speech and language pathologist. There were no assertions that the tests were administered other than in conformance with test instructions or that the tests were invalid for the specific purpose for which they were used.

The District also undertook a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT's behavior in April and May 1996. The FAA included observations of STUDENT in his classes, a review of STUDENT's educational history, and interviews with each of STUDENT's teachers and parents. Information was also obtained from Ms. Jackson and several of STUDENT's previous teachers. The data obtained from the observations and interviews was then analyzed to determine problem areas, the source of problems, and so forth. Given the fact that STUDENT had been assessed less than one year earlier, and the somewhat limited purpose of this assessment, the Hearing Officer finds that the District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT, particularly when the March 1996 assessment is taken into consideration in conjunction with the District's FAA.

ISSUE NO. 5: Did STUDENT require psychological therapy during the 1995-1996 school year to benefit from his education?

As discussed above, the IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education in June 1995. Therefore, as a special education student, STUDENT was entitled to related services during the 1995-1996 school year that were necessary to allow him to benefit from his education. The IEP team determined to meet STUDENT's needs by providing him with language therapy to address deficits in social language and word skills. Petitioner contends that he required the additional service of psychological therapy.

Petitioner asserts that Ms. Lamb's assessment supports his need for psychological therapy. (Petitioner's Exhibit 11) Ms. Lamb's report identifies some areas of concern regarding STUDENT's behavior and social skills. Ms. Lamb testified, however, that she did not recommend psychological therapy for STUDENT and that she concurred with the IEP team decision that STUDENT's needs could be addressed through language therapy designed to improve his ability to interpret social situations and to improve word knowledge. Ms. PARENT also concurred with the IEP team decision at the time it was made and did not then request any additional services. Dr. Delmonico testified that, when he met with the SST in February 1996, he suggested that STUDENT be provided with individual psychotherapy "because he was becoming discouraged at school and at home." (Testimony of Dr. Delmonico and Petitioner's Exhibit 18) Ms. Kelly, who evaluated STUDENT at the request of his parents in the fall of 1995, recommended that STUDENT be provided counseling to manage his anger and to build self-esteem.

The testimony of Dr. Delmonico and Ms. Kelly did not establish that their recommendations for psychotherapy were based on STUDENT's behavioral needs at school. It is noted that Dr. Delmonico and Ms. Kelly were contacted by the parents to help them with STUDENT's behavior at home. There was no evidence that Ms. Kelly consulted with STUDENT's teachers or observed him at school prior to making her recommendations. The evidence does not substantiate that individual psychotherapy is the only way to address the concerns expressed by Dr. Delmonico and Ms. Kelly. For example, counseling with the school counselor or school psychologist are other services that could be used to address STUDENT's needs. Moreover, to be entitled to psychological therapy, it must be a service that is necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his instruction.

It is conceded that STUDENT's behavior at home and school was less than exemplary. A review of the disciplinary records reveals that STUDENT's behavior resulted is being suspended from school six days during the 1995-1996 school year. None of STUDENT's behavior resulted in an expulsion. (Petitioner's Exhibit 22) During the 1995-1996 school year, STUDENT's grades continued to be very good. On measures of academic achievement, STUDENT scored in the average or above average range and his scores were consistent with expectations given his cognitive abilities. STUDENT passed all of his classes and was moving to the eighth grade. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was benefitting from his education and, therefore, did not require psychotherapy to benefit from his education.

As to whether the services provided by STUDENT's parents affected STUDENT's ability to benefit from instruction, Ms. Kelly testified that her services were evaluative in nature and that she did not treat STUDENT. Dr. Delmonico met with the family approximately five times in December 1995 and January 1996; however, the goal of his therapy was to help the PARENTs deal with STUDENT's behavior and it was unclear what services Dr. Delmonico provided directly to STUDENT and in what specific way the services may have been designed to meet STUDENT's educational needs. The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner did not establish that the services his parents provided were responsible for his ability to achieve at school. Therefore, because STUDENT was benefitting from his instruction, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require psychological therapy during the 1995-1996 school year.

ISSUE NO. 6: Did STUDENT require occupational therapy (OT) during the 1995-1996 school year to benefit from his education?

Petitioner contends that OT services provided by Ms. Jackson were necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education during the 1995-1996 school year. Ms. Jackson's testimony and the report of her assessment of STUDENT in July 1995 (Petitioner's Exhibit 15), support STUDENT's need for OT because of deficits in balance, weak automatic postural responses, poor ability to use muscles and to perform symmetrical and asymmetrical patterns of coordinated movement, and an inability to perform age-appropriate motor and cognitive tasks simultaneously.

Peg Bledsoe, who is also an occupational therapist, testified on behalf of the District. She stated that Ms. Jackson's assessment was lacking several essential components for determining whether OT was necessary for STUDENT for educational purposes. The most significant component missing from Ms. Jackson's assessment is an observation of STUDENT in an educational environment. Ms. Bledsoe also found Ms. Jackson's assessment deficient because she improperly relied on the results of the SIPT and the Test of Visual Motor Skills, which are not normed for students of STUDENT's age. Although Ms. Bledsoe has not provided OT to STUDENT or observed him in his educational setting, she is an experienced OT and has worked with students with TBI. Ms. Bledsoe's testimony was supported by STUDENT's teacher and other District assessors who did not observe STUDENT to have deficits that would require OT to allow him benefit from his education.

The fact that STUDENT, or any other special education student, receives independent OT does not automatically require a school district to provide the student with OT. A school district is only required to provide special education students with the services the student requires to benefit from his or her education. In this case, Ms. Jackson did not have information regarding STUDENT's educational needs either from direct observation of STUDENT at school or from information provided by his teachers. The evidence also does not establish that the goals and objectives of the OT provided were related to STUDENT's educational needs. Some of the needs Ms. Jackson stated could affect STUDENT's education, such as having difficulty copying from the chalkboard, were not supported by the testimony of STUDENT's teachers. Moreover, as discussed more fully above, STUDENT was benefitting from his education and the benefit he was receiving is not attributable to OT provided to address the areas described above. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not support finding that STUDENT required OT during the 1995-1996 school year to benefit from his instruction.

ISSUE NO. 7: Did the District provide STUDENT with an appropriate education during the 1995-1996 school year?

Under IDEA and Rowley, to be appropriate the program offered by the school district must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and comport with the IEP.

Turning to the first requirement that an appropriate placement must be designed to meet the unique and individual needs of the student, there was one primary area of need that emerged from the testing and the testimony of a number of witnesses. Teachers, parents, and the assessor all agreed that STUDENT had difficulty in social situations and the ways in which he attempted to interact with peers. Ms. Steele's assessment described STUDENT's behavior as falling within the "broad range of normal." Areas of concern included disrupting other students, making inappropriate noises, attentional problems, acting impulsively, making derogatory remarks and using obscene or profane language. STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives are designed to address specific deficits in vocabulary and in pragmatic language skills. At the beginning of the 1995-1996 school year, STUDENT received two thirty minute session per week of individual or small group language therapy to improve his word knowledge and pragmatic skills. Ms. Barnes testified that she addressed STUDENT's needs by providing him with skills to utilize in social situations, engaged STUDENT in role play of difficult social situations, and then had him replay the strategies with her. STUDENT has average cognitive potential and requires instruction in the core curriculum presented in regular education classes. The Hearing Officer finds that placement in a regular education classroom with language therapy to improve his social skills was designed to meet STUDENT's needs.

Additionally, during the 1995-1996 school year, the District responded to the PARENTs' requests for assistance with STUDENT's behavior by convening an SST with STUDENT's teachers, other District staff, Dr. Delmonico, and Ms. Jackson. A second assessment was undertaken in March 1996. Behavioral and language needs were identified and new objectives were developed to improve STUDENT's cognitive-linguistic skills and pragmatics, and language therapy sessions were increased. Dr. Delmonico stated that the SST recommended an assessment of STUDENT's behavior at school and identification of behavioral management techniques. The District prepared a plan to conduct a functional analysis assessment, obtained parental consent to conduct the FAA, and conducted the FAA in April and May 1996. A draft of a behavioral intervention plan had been completed and members of the IEP team were meeting during the summer of 1996 to review and revise the plan so that it could be implemented in the fall.

The second requirement of an appropriate placement is that it must be designed to allow the student to receive educational benefit. According to Ms. Barnes, STUDENT was making progress toward meeting his language goals and objectives. By March 1996, STUDENT had fully met four objectives and had met two other objectives approximately 60% of the time. The final two objectives had not been addressed. STUDENT's academic achievement was commensurate with his potential according to testing conducted in March 1996. STUDENT's grades during the seventh grade were generally "A's" and "B's." STUDENT has always been educated in regular education classes with his peers. For special education student's who primarily receive instruction in regular education classes, "Academic success is a helpful guidepost in determining the appropriateness of an educational setting in meeting a student's unique needs." Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenberg (9th Cir. 1995) 59 F.3d 884, 896. Based on STUDENT's academic achievement, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was benefitting from his placement. STUDENT's placement also satisfies the third requirement of an appropriate placement. STUDENT's placement in regular education classes with the special education service of language therapy conforms to his IEP. Therefore, because STUDENT's placement offered instruction designed to meet his unique and individual needs, allowed him to benefit from his instruction, and conformed with his IEP, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District provided STUDENT with an appropriate placement during the 1995-1996 school year.

ISSUE NO. 8: Is STUDENT's IEP current IEP, which was developed in March and April 1996 and includes the behavioral intervention plan, designed to meet his unique and individual needs?

Petitioner contends that his IEP is not appropriate because it does not include goals and objectives to address areas of conflict resolution, anger control, denial of responsibility, accountability for actions, inappropriate disinhibitions, provocation of others, derogatory remarks toward others, disrespect for authority figures and peers, self-respect, self-esteem, positive self-concept, development of appropriate relationships with peers and adults, and development of internal behavioral control. Petitioner asserts that the IEP also does not address his need for implementation of the behavioral treatment plan across all settings or parent training to implement a home component of the behavioral intervention plan.

The testimony of STUDENT's teachers, Dr. Delmonico, STUDENT's parents, and Ms. Jackson, as well as the results of the District's assessment of STUDENT in March 1996 and the FAA completed in May 1996, establish that STUDENT needs to develop cognitive strategies and pragmatic language skills to address deficits in social skills and to address inappropriate behavior. STUDENT's IEP includes goals and objectives to meet these needs. Additionally, Dr. Delmonico and the parents identified the importance of a comprehensive behavioral program that is implemented consistently at home as well as at school. The results of the FAA set forth STUDENT's behavioral needs in two major areas. One group of behaviors is identified as "disruptive" and includes talking out in class, "clowning," burping, chewing food with his mouth open, pushing the food out with his tongue, passing gas loudly and in close physical proximity to a peer, "putting down" peers, making sexual remarks, mocking his teachers, and making defiant or oppositional comments to adults. The second set of behaviors includes mock assaults, posturing, threatening assault, and actual assaults.

To meet these identified behavioral needs, a transitional behavioral intervention plan (BIP) for the first semester of the 1996-1997 school year was drafted. The overall goal of the BIP is to replace the behaviors set out above. Specific areas that would be addressed by the counselor include: teaching STUDENT to learn to deal with anger and providing him with strategies to ask for help; helping STUDENT to recognize the targeted behaviors, what triggers the behaviors, and devising strategies for him to deal with difficult situations; and teaching STUDENT strategies for receiving extra positive attention from peers; and providing STUDENT with constructive criticism. Specific areas to be addressed by the parents include the following: infusing cognitive strategies taught by the language specialist into homework and social situations; helping STUDENT to learn to recognize target behaviors; using script to follow in handing target behaviors; helping STUDENT to use strategies to receive peer attention; providing constructive criticism; and providing opportunities for STUDENT to participate in community events, earn privileges at home, and earn desired objects to reinforce reduction of targeted behaviors. The BIP calls for the behavioral specialist and the language therapist to develop a "script" for teachers and parents to follow when dealing with some of STUDENT's behaviors. (District's Exhibit 27 and testimony of Ms. Breslow.) The BIP also describes similar techniques that would be employed by the teachers. The language specialist would continue to provide services to STUDENT to meet the goals and objectives in STUDENT's IEP and the BIP.

The BIP is thorough and addresses the ways in which STUDENT's behavior will be addressed by STUDENT's teachers, parents, and language therapist. It calls for a counselor to work with STUDENT and to also work with the BIP team to develop strategies for working with STUDENT, as well as strategies for STUDENT to employ to improve his behavior. The BIP describes the way in which the plan will be monitored weekly by the behavior management specialist until the targeted behavior is reduced by 50%, states that the members of the behavioral intervention team will meet monthly, identifies the form on which data will be collected, and sets December 1997 as the date for review. It seems that the only thing not identified with sufficient specificity is the amount of time that the counselor would work with STUDENT. From the testimony regarding the sequence of events, the Hearing Officer understands that further meetings were scheduled to complete the BIP. These meetings were interrupted by the PARENTs taking STUDENT to Utah and enrolling him in the program in Western Samoa. The fact that the PARENTs have removed STUDENT from the District and disputes the appropriateness of the program proposed by the District does not relieve the District of its obligation to prepare an IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that with additional specificity regarding the frequency of counseling, the IEP is designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs.

ISSUE NO. 9: Shall STUDENT's current IEP be amended to include goals and objectives in the following areas: conflict resolution, anger control, denial of responsibility, accountability of actions, inappropriate inhibitions, provocation of others, derogatory remarks toward others, disrespect for authority figures and peers, self-respect, self-esteem, positive self-concept, development of appropriate relationships with peers and adults, and development of internal behavioral control? Petitioner contends that an appropriate IEP that is designed to address his unique and individual needs must include goals and objectives in the areas identified above. Because reduction in these inappropriate behaviors and replacement with appropriate behaviors is the goal of the BIP, which covers the above areas, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP already addresses these areas. For this reason, it is unnecessary to amend STUDENT's IEP to include the areas proposed above by Petitioner.

ISSUE NO. 10: Does STUDENT require a residential placement to receive a free appropriate public education?

According to Rowley, a school district is not required to provide services to maximize a student's benefit from special education. A district also is not required to provide a residential placement that is not educationally necessary. As has been discussed above, STUDENT has always been educated in regular education classrooms and he has received good grades, has made educational progress as demonstrated on standardized assessment instruments, and has passed from grade to grade. STUDENT's behavior apparently took a turn for the worse at home during the summer of 1996; however, the evidence is not persuasive that STUDENT's needs can only be met through a residential placement or that the placement was made for educational reasons. Moreover, STUDENT's needs are different than the population served by Paradise Cove. STUDENT has a TBI and several professionals treating him concluded that many of his behavioral problems were related to TBI rather than to an emotional problem. The majority of the students at Paradise Cove have substance abuse problems and have engaged in juvenile criminal activity. Paradise Cove does not offer any special education services for STUDENT and from information in the literature provided by Paradise Cove, it appears that some of the behavioral interventions employed at Paradise Cove violate the requirements of the Hughes Bill.

The Hearing Officer acknowledges the concerns the PARENTs have for STUDENT and the sincerity of their belief that they have chosen a placement that will be to STUDENT's benefit; however, after carefully weighing the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is not SED and he does not require a residential placement to allow him to benefit from his education.

ISSUE NO. 11: Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1996-1997 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

As to whether the program proposed by the District for STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year satisfies the three requirements of a free appropriate public education under IDEA and Rowley, the appropriateness of STUDENT's IEP and BIP was thoroughly addressed above. There was no evidence that STUDENT's academic needs have changed and the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continues to require instruction in the regular education curriculum with special education support to address language deficits and inappropriate behavior. The District proposes to continue STUDENT in regular education classes at the middle school. STUDENT's IEP calls for therapy from the language therapist to address deficits in social pragmatics. The BIP calls for the services of a counselor to facilitate implementation of the BIP and to provide individual counseling with STUDENT to help STUDENT develop strategies for dealing with frustrations and breakdowns.

The PARENTs expressed concerns about whether the District would implement the BIP at the beginning of the school year and asserted that STUDENT's needs had changed so much over the summer that the BIP was insufficient to address his needs. There simply is no credible evidence that, because STUDENT experienced some increased behavioral problems at home during the summer, regular school placement with support services such as he received and benefitted tremendously from in the past would suddenly become inappropriate and unable to meet his needs. The Hearing Officer reiterates that STUDENT has always done well in school and has received better than average grades without exception. The FAA revealed that one of STUDENT's strengths is the fact that he seeks to do well academically.(FOOTNOTE 11) Moreover, the BIP was in place for the beginning of the school year to provide STUDENT with additional support and monitoring. None of the witnesses found specific provisions of the BIP to be deficient. The fact that the counselor is someone with whom STUDENT and his parents have familiarity will also be beneficial, since in the past STUDENT has taken some time to adjust to new teachers or other persons who provide him services. Based on the above and the discussion regarding goals and objectives and the BIP above in prior issues, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program offered to STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year is appropriate under the standards set forth in IDEA and under Rowley.

Petitioner additionally contends that the District violated certain procedural safeguards that resulted in the denial of a free appropriate public education to him. In addition to the requirements of an appropriate education, Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the appropriate public education to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the child's educational program. The procedural rights extended to parents include in part: the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child's IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the right to a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415.

In Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of compliance with the procedural provisions of the IDEA. The Court stated: It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every state of the administrative process, see, e.g., Sections 1415(a)-(d), as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard. We think that the Congressional emphasis upon full participation of concerned parties throughout the development of the IEP, as well as the requirements that state and local plans be submitted to the Commissioner for approval, demonstrate the legislative conviction that adequate compliance with the procedures prescribed would in most cases assure much if not all of what Congress wished in the way of substantive content in an IEP.

458 U.S. 175, 205-206.

In summary, the Court concluded that the inquiry in suits brought under §1415(e)(2) is twofold--whether the district complied with procedural safeguards and whether it offered an appropriate educational placement. 458 U.S. 205-7.

Based on the reasoning in Rowley, several federal circuit courts have found that under certain circumstances procedural violations of the IDEA can result in the denial of a free appropriate public education. In W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, the Ninth Circuit held that procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe upon the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process "clearly result in the denial of FAPE." See Burke County Board of Education v. Denton (4th Cir. 1990) 895 F.2d 973; Rowland Md. v. Concord School Committee (1st Cir. 1990) 910 F.2d 983; Hall v. Vance County Board of Education (4th Cir. 1990) 774 F.2d 629.

Petitioner contends that the District has made procedural violations since STUDENT entered the District.(FOOTNOTE 12) Petitioner asserts that the District failed to do the following:

(1) Seek and serve pursuant to requirements of 34 C.F.R. § 300.128; California Education Code §§ 56301 and 56302.

This issues was addressed above and it was concluded that following STUDENT's initial dismissal from special education, the District was not obligated to further assess or provide services to STUDENT.

(2) Fully evaluate prior to discharging Petitioner from special education in 1991 as required by Education Code §§ 56301, 56302, and 56320(f).

It has already been determined above that the District assessed STUDENT before convening an IEP team meeting that resulted in his dismissal from special education.

(3) Timely conduct IEP meetings as required by 34 C.F. R. §§ 330.343 and 330.346 and Education Code §§ 56344 and 56345.

Petitioner asserts that the District failed to complete the IEP process during the summer of 1996 to fully incorporate the provisions of the BIP into the IEP developed in March and April 1996. According to the testimony of Ms. Lankford and others, an IEP meeting was set for August 28, 1996, to finalize the BIP and to allow STUDENT's teachers to have input into the BIP since they would be implementing it. Even without their input, the BIP is quite extensive. Prior to the beginning of the school year; however, the August IEP meeting was canceled. The District offered and was willing to convene an IEP meeting but was waiting for a response from Petitioner's counsel as to his availability. Thereafter, the District's position was that the pending hearing and the fact that STUDENT was placed in a residential facility by his parents relieved them of the obligation to complete the BIP as scheduled with STUDENT's eighth grade teachers.

The fact that parents made the decision to place their child in a school other than one run by the District does not relieve the District of its obligation to continue with the IEP process and to make a written offer of placement. Union v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519. Even if the District's failure to reconvene an IEP meeting prior to the beginning of the 1996-1997 school year, there is no denial of a free appropriate public education unless the procedural violation resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT or seriously infringed on the parents' participation in the IEP process. STUDENT would not have entered the 1996-1997 school year without a current IEP. The IEP drafted in March and April 1996 identifies the next review date as April 1997. The IEP calls for STUDENT to continue in regular education for the eighth grade with language therapy and includes updated goals and objectives which the language therapist was addressing with STUDENT. The FAA had been completed prior to the end of the school year and the BIP was drafted. During the summer 1996, several meetings with the PARENTs, their counsel, and District personnel had been held to discuss and revise the BIP, and another meeting was scheduled in August, prior to the beginning of school, with STUDENT's teachers for the 1997-1998 school year. A therapist, with whom STUDENT and his parents were familiar, had been identified to provide counseling to STUDENT and a meeting with her was set. The District has not disputed its obligation to provide STUDENT with the services set out in the IEP and the BIP and the parent is well aware of the program proposed by the District. It is the adequacy of the program proposed by the District that has been at issue in this hearing and not whether the District proposed a program for Petitioner. Because there was an appropriate program in place for STUDENT at the beginning of the school year and the parents had participated in its development at all steps along the way, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT nor was the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process seriously infringed upon.

ISSUE NO. 12: Was the District required to refer STUDENT to Community Mental Health?

Petitioner asserts that the District should have referred STUDENT to Community Mental Health following the April 25, 1990, IEP meeting. At that meeting, the IEP team discussed Dr. Haruda's evaluation which reported STUDENT's aggressive, biting, and kicking behavior, the parent's report of inappropriate behavior, and the school psychologist's report recommending careful behavior management. Petitioner asserts that the District should have made a referral to Community Mental Health following the June 14, 1995, IEP meeting at which it was noted that STUDENT had received private counseling since age five years and that his behavior needed to be addressed for the next school year. Petitioner asserts that a referral to Mental Health was called for throughout the 1995-1996 school year and thereafter.

Chapter 26.5 of Government Code sets forth interagency responsibilities for providing mental health services to special education students. Pursuant to § 7576(b), an IEP team may refer a student who is eligible for special education who is "suspected of needing mental health services," to a community mental health when the student meets all of the following:

(1) The pupil has been assessed by school personnel in accordance with Article 2 (commencing with Section 565320) of Chapter 4 of Part 30 of the Education Code.

(2) The local education agency has obtained written parental consent....

(3) The pupil has emotional or behavioral characteristics that: (A) Are observed by qualified educational staff in educational and other settings, as appropriate. (B) Impede the pupil from benefiting from educational services. (C) Are significant as indicated by their rate of occurrence and intensity. (D) Are associated with a condition that cannot be described solely as a social maladjustment or a temporary adjustment problem, and cannot be resolved with short-term counseling.

(4) As determined using educational assessments, the pupil's functioning, including cognitive functioning, is at a level sufficient to enable the pupil to benefit form mental health services.

(5) The local education agency has provided counseling, psychological, or guidance services to the pupil pursuant to Section 56363 of the Education Code, and the individualized education program team has determined that the services do not meet the pupil's educational needs, or, in cases where these services are clearly inappropriate, the individualized education program team has documented which of these services were considered and why they were determined to be inappropriate.

The procedures set forth in chapter 26.5 are not designed for responding to psychiatric emergencies of other situations requiring immediate response. Government Code § 7576(f).

In several of the issues above, STUDENT's ability to benefit from instruction has been thoroughly discussed and it has been concluded that STUDENT's ability to derive educational benefit from the instruction provided by the District was not impeded because of an emotional disturbance. It has also not been shown that STUDENT requires more intensive services than counseling, which has been offered as a part of the BIP. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer determines that it would have been premature to refer STUDENT to mental health and the District was not required to do so.

ISSUE NO. 13: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's placement at Paradise Cove, including residential, psychological, educational, and transportation costs?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the placement they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parent was appropriate. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education 471 U.S. 359 (1985).

Petitioner contends that in August 1996, he required a 24 hour residential center placement with an emphasis on behavioral intervention programming as an emergency basis. Because the parents could not wait for the lengthy IEP process and the District had not offered services to address his social, emotional, and behavioral needs, they are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his placement at Paradise Cove. Petitioner asserts that he is benefitting from his placement at Paradise Cove.

It was determined above that STUDENT does not require a residential placement. Therefore, STUDENT's parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at Paradise Cove.

ISSUE NO. 14: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent speech and language services provided by the Bay Area Speech and Language Services from September 1993 through January 1994?

The evidence failed to establish that STUDENT required speech and language services to benefit from his education during the 1993-1994 school year. Therefore, STUDENT's parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of speech and language therapy.

ISSUE NO. 15: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent occupational therapy provided by Donna Jackson from November 1993 to the present?

It was determined above that the District's assessment in 1995 was deficient because it did not include an OT assessment. In August 1995, Ms. Jackson assessed STUDENT. (Respondent's Exhibit 15) Ms. Jackson's assessment included the Ross Test of Higher Cognitive Processes, which Ms. Jackson stated assesses higher level cognitive skills. Ms. Jackson used the Damato Multifixation Campimeter to screen for visual field deficits. She found that STUDENT was within "functioning" limits but also stated that he had difficulty with the "use of monocular vision." Ms. Jackson also administered the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills to assess STUDENT's auditory processing skills and the Test of Visual-Motor Skills. Ms. Jackson indicated that these tests are standardized up to the age of twelve years. At the time of testing, STUDENT was 13 years old. She also analyzed WISC-III testing. Thus, Ms. Jackson relied on the results of tests that were either not normed for STUDENT's age or, according to the undisputed testimony of Ms. Bledsoe, that were not approved for use by occupational therapists. Ms. Jackson's report also includes recommendations which she clarified with the following statement, "It is important to understand that these recommendations are very general and have not been specifically designed for STUDENT." As discussed earlier, Ms. Jackson's assessment is also deficient in that it does not include any information or observations related to STUDENT's classroom performance. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Jackson's assessment is deficient and cannot be relied upon to determine whether STUDENT required OT to address educational needs. Furthermore, there is no evidence that the PARENTs obtained an assessment from Ms. Jackson because of their disagreement with the District's assessment. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer denies the request for reimbursement. Neither the information from Ms. Jackson's assessment nor any other evidence established STUDENT's need for OT. Therefore, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the private OT they provided.

ISSUE NO. 16: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent psychological therapy?

(a) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent psychological therapy provided by Deborah Kelley, Ph.D., from September through November 1995?

Petitioner contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent psychological therapy provided by Deborah Kelley, Ph.D., because the District failed to assess, draft goals and objectives, offer services, or make a referral to Mental Health to address his social, emotional, and behavioral needs. Petitioner asserts that these needs were well know to the District as early as 1990.

Deborah Kelley testified that her services were obtained by the PARENTs to evaluate STUDENT and to make recommendations to them regarding ways to address his behavior at home. Because the nature of the services were to evaluate rather than to treat STUDENT and because the Petitioner failed to establish that he required special education services during the period in question, the Hearing Officer denies the request for reimbursement.

(b) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent psychological therapy provided by Brian Lippincott, Ph.D., from March 1993 to September 1993?

Petitioner contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent psychological therapy provided by Brian Lippincott, Ph.D., because the District failed to assess, draft goals and objectives, offer services, or make a referral to Mental Health to address his social, emotional, and behavioral needs. Petitioner asserts that these needs were well know to the District as early as 1990. Dr. Lippincott provided 10 sessions of therapy to STUDENT over a six month period.

STUDENT was not a special education student during the period Dr. Lippincott provided therapy to STUDENT and Petitioner did not establish that therapy was necessary for him to benefit from his education. Additionally, Petitioner provided insufficient evidence regarding the nature of the therapy provided by Dr. Lippincott to allow a finding that the therapy was educationally related. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer denies the request for reimbursement.

(c) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent psychological therapy provided by Richard Delmonico, Ph.D., from December 1995 through August 1996?

It was determined above that Petitioner did not require psychological therapy to benefit from his education. From the testimony, it also cannot be concluded that the therapy provided by Dr. Delmonico was to address STUDENT's educational needs. For these reasons, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Delmonico's services.

ISSUE NO. 17: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for an independent neuropsychological evaluation conducted by Peter Karzmark, Ph.D., in October 1995?

A parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. Education Code § 56329(b).

Petitioner contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for an assessment conducted by Peter Karzmark, Ph.D., in October 1995 because the District failed to assess Petitioner's social, emotional, and behavioral needs. Petitioner asserts that Dr. Karzmark, as well as Dr. Delmonico, were the first to evaluate the impact of STUDENT's TBI on his education, including his social, emotional, and behavioral development.

It was determined above that the District's assessment in June 1995 was deficient. The report of the assessment also indicates the need for additional medical information. Dr. Karzmark's neuropsychological assessment is contained in Petitioner's Exhibit 19. The report states that the purpose of the assessment was to provide further information regarding STUDENT's current mental functioning. Dr. Karzmark's assessment includes a number of measures to assess concentration, learning, memory, problem solving, reasoning, language, academic, visuospatial, motor, and intellectual abilities. The report also includes a discussion of the findings and recommendations. Dr. Karzmark's assessment provided information in certain skill areas that was not assessed y the District. Moreover, the District included information from Dr. Karzmark's assessment in its subsequent assessment and IEP in 1997. Therefore, because the District's assessment was deficient and Dr. Karzmark's assessment provided additional information that the District relied on, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District is required to reimburse the parents for the costs of his independent assessment.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

(1) Does STUDENT meet special education eligibility criteria as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(2) Was STUDENT entitled to special education services during the 1993-1994 and 1994-1995 school years?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(3) Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in June 1995?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(4) Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in March 1996?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(5) Did STUDENT require psychological therapy during the 1995-1996 school year to benefit from his education?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(6) Did STUDENT require occupational therapy (OT) during the 1995-1996 school year to benefit from his education?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(7) Did the District provide STUDENT with an appropriate education during the 1995-1996 school year?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(8) Is STUDENT's current IEP, which was developed in March and April 1996 and includes the behavioral intervention plan, designed to meet his unique and individual needs?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(9) Shall STUDENT's current IEP be amended to include goals and objectives in the following areas?

(a) conflict resolution;

(b) anger control;

(c) denial of responsibility:

(d) accountability for actions;

(e) inappropriate inhibitions;

(f) provocation of others;

(g) derogatory remarks toward others;

(h) disrespect for authority figures and peers;

(i) self-respect;

(j) self-esteem;

(k) positive self-concept;

(l) development of appropriate relationships with peers and adults; and (m) development of internal behavioral control.

The District substantially prevailed on this issue.

(10) Does STUDENT require a residential placement?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(11) Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1996-1997 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(12) Was the District required to refer STUDENT to Community Mental Health?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(13) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's placement at Paradise Cove, including residential, psychological, educational, and transportation costs?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(14) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent speech and language services provided by the Bay Area Speech and Language Services from September 1993 through January 1994?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(15) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent OT provided by Donna Jackson from November 1993 to the present?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(16) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of independent psychological therapy provided by (a) Deborah Kelley, Ph.D., from September through November 1995; (b) Brian Lippincott, Ph.D., from March 1993 through September 1993; (c) Richard Delmonico, Ph.D., from December 1995 through August 1996?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(17) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for an independent neuropsychological evaluation conducted by Peter Karzmark, Ph.D., in October 1995?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

ORDER

(1) Within 20 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to determine the frequency and duration of counseling to be provided to STUDENT as a part of the behavioral intervention plan.

(2) All of Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.

DATED: June 6, 1997 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES 1. Meningococcal meningitis is an acute infectious disease, which often is fatal, involving inflammation of the membranes of the brain and spinal cord. Stedman's Medical Dictionary (1990) 25th Edition. 2. STUDENT's mother reports that he fell out of a car onto his head at age two years, fell off of a bicycle onto his face at age seven, and fell 15 feet from a batting cage. 3. STUDENT's eligibility designation later changed to TBI and communication disordered. 4. A note on the assessment plan states that the original plan was believed to be lost and was recreated and resigned by FATHER on March 13, 1996. There is another assessment plan signed by MOTHER on April 15, 1996, which states that "original signed 3/13/96. File lost. Form re-signed 4-13-96." (Petitioner's Exhibits 27 and 29) 5. It was initially thought that the school psychologist had left STUDENT's special education file at a laundromat. The parents expressed concern about the breach of confidentiality and the delay to STUDENT's receipt of services. According to the District, the psychologist eventually located the file in the school psychologist's office and STUDENT's IEP continued to be implemented. 6. Apparently the PARENTs had obtained permission to tape the meeting; however, when they arrived with a video recorder, Ms. Steele would not allow them to videotape the meeting. MOTHER then would not participate in the meeting and it was rescheduled. The PARENTs requested that Ms. Steele have no further involvement with STUDENT. The District complied with their request. 7. On April 23, 1996, the Hearing Office received the PARENTs request for a due process hearing. 8. MOTHER had authorized an extension of the time lines for completion of the report. 9. The teachers were unavailable to meet on August 22, 1996. Therefore, the August 29, 1996, date for an IEP meeting was maintained so that STUDENT's eighth grade teachers would have an opportunity to have input into the implementation of STUDENT's BIP. The August 29, 1996, IEP did not take place. 10. STUDENT had received special education services because of a learning disability. 11. Petitioner does not assert that he meets speech and language eligibility criteria because of articulation, abnormal voice, or fluency disorders. For this reason, only the criteria for a language disorder is addressed. 12. Ms. Hollibaugh was unable to complete the assessment because STUDENT became agitated and angry after 20 to 30 minutes of testing. 13. STUDENT resumed OT at a later date. 14. Even when STUDENT was suspended, he made certain that he knew his assignments and completed them before returning to school. (District's Exhibit 27) 15. Additional claims by Petitioner of procedural violations were substantive in nature, including the adequacy of services and are addressed earlier in the decision. 16. Nicki Sergeant was selected to serve as the counselor identified in the BIP. 17. Generally parents are entitled to reimbursement for only one assessment. In this case, Ms. Jackson and Dr. Karzmark assessed entirely different areas. For this reason, they are both reimbursable.