California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 28, 1997

Student v. Mt. Diablo Unified School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 387-96 · Hearing Officer Edwin Villmoare

Mt. Diablo Unified student with learning disability found not seriously emotionally disturbed; residential placement denied, but new IEP ordered.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 16-year-old tenth grader filed against Mt. Diablo Unified School District and Contra Costa County Mental Health. He was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability. He asked to be found seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) and to receive a residential placement. His independent psychologist, Dr. Vincent Nunno, and his therapist, Allan McTighe, testified that he had a long-standing depressive condition and trouble keeping relationships. District teachers, psychologists Dr. Bruce Heller and Dr. Jodi Couick, and Mental Health's program director disagreed. They said he showed no depression at school and got along well with teachers and peers.

Hearing Officer Edwin Villmoare found the student was not SED. Substance abuse better explained the anger, overeating and oversleeping offered as signs of depression. No depressed mood appeared across settings over a long period. Teachers, friends and his therapist showed he could form real relationships. Residential placement was also denied. His needs came from conduct problems, substance abuse and missed classes, not from his learning disability. For that reason, the "mixed causation" reasoning of Capistrano v. Wartenberg did not apply. However, the Hearing Officer found his recent IEPs lacked enough academic substance. Mental Health agreed he needed psychotherapy. The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within 30 days, with Mental Health present. The new IEP had to include appropriate academic coursework, mental health services and transition services.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO separated emotional disturbance from conduct problems and substance abuse when deciding SED eligibility and residential placement. It looked at whether symptoms were pervasive at school. Even though the parent lost on both main issues, the Hearing Officer still required a stronger IEP with mental health and transition services.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue I. s STUDENT seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?

    The Hearing Officer found the student was not SED. He showed no general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression and could build and maintain satisfactory relationships. His school difficulties came from substance abuse, misconduct and missed classes.

  2. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue II. Does STUDENT require a residential placement to receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

    Residential placement was denied because the student's needs came from conduct problems and substance abuse, not his learning disability. However, his recent IEPs lacked enough academic substance, so a new IEP with mental health and transition services was ordered.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. The District must schedule an IEP meeting within 30 days of receiving the decision, and a Mental Health representative must attend.
  • Order to provide or change services. At that meeting, the IEP team must develop an IEP that includes an appropriate level of academic course work, mental health services, and transition services.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175; Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884 (9th Cir. 1995); Sequoia Union High School District (N.D. Cal. 1987) 559 EHLR 133; 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1

People named in the decision

  • Kathleen Peterson, Hearing Officer (observing), California Special Education Hearing Office
  • Joan Alber, District special education administrator and administrator for special day classes and centers; District representative and witness, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Stephen Leanos, attorney present for District, Breon, O'Donnell, Miller, Brown & Dannis
  • Richard (Rich) Weisgal, AB3632 program coordinator/director; Mental Health representative and witness, Contra Costa County Mental Health
  • Dr. Vincent Nunno, clinical, educational and neuropsychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Private practice
  • Allan McTighe, private therapist (licensed marriage, family and child counselor); witness for Student, Private practice
  • Cathy Rice, special education program specialist, Mt. Diablo Unified School District (Concord High School)
  • Susan Elliott, resource specialist (RSP) teacher, seventh and eighth grade, Pine Hollow Middle School, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Sandra (Sandi) Harris, RSP teacher, Concord High School, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Ann Eliese Makely, school psychologist who attended the June 1996 IEP meeting; District witness, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Gary Barnes, home and hospital teacher, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Dr. Jodi Couick, clinical psychologist and school psychologist; expert witness for respondents (records review), West Contra Costa Unified School District (part-time school psychologist)
  • Dorothy Brown, American Sign Language teacher, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Dr. Bruce Heller, clinical psychologist; assessor at District request and witness for respondents, Private practice
  • Robert Siltanen, social studies teacher, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Carol Whiting, District school psychologist, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Dr. Lawrence H. Diller, private physician (ADD treatment and counseling), Private practice
  • Robin Heinschel, home and hospital teacher, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Walter Shugert, psychologist whose report was reviewed at the June 1996 IEP meeting
  • Ron Afdahl, probation department representative at the June 1996 IEP meeting, County probation department
  • Linda Leeper, probation officer, County probation department
  • Sherman House, therapeutic group home
  • Family Life Center, residential placement
  • Summit, alternative residential treatment program, Coordinated by Contra Costa County Mental Health
  • CEDU, private school represented by Student's counsel (subject of a District disqualification motion, which was denied)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Edwin Villmoare, Chief Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Mt. Diablo, California, on January 21 and 22, and March 6 and 7, 1997. Observing was Kathleen Peterson, also a Hearing Officer from the California Special Education Hearing Office.

Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Michael Zatopa. Ms. PARENT, STUDENT's mother, was also present.

Respondent Mt. Diablo Unified School District (hereafter District) was represented by Joan Alber, District administrator for special day classes and centers, and attorney Martha Buell Scott of Breon, O'Donnell, Miller, Brown & Dannis. Also present on the District's behalf was Stephen Leanos of Breon, O'Donnell, Miller, Brown & Dannis.

Respondent Contra Costa County Mental Health (hereafter Mental Health) was represented by Richard Weisgal, Mental Health AB3632 program coordinator.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of closing briefs. Closing briefs were received, the record was closed on March 28, 1997, and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the beginning of the first day of hearing, Mental Health made a motion to be dismissed as a party to this matter. After hearing argument from the parties, the Hearing Officer denied the motion on the ground that Petitioner's issues involve services from Mental Health. At the beginning of the third day of hearing, the District made a motion to have Mr. Zatopa disqualify himself from representing the Petitioner on the ground that he represents a school (CEDU) which he allegedly recommended to the Petitioner. The motion was denied because placement at CEDU was not being requested as a remedy in this matter.

ISSUES

I. Is STUDENT seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?

II. Does STUDENT require a residential placement to receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a 16-year-old male who is currently eligible for special education services due to a specific learning disability. He is in the tenth grade. STUDENT was born six weeks premature with a stillborn twin brother. His parents separated in 1983, when STUDENT was two and a half years of age. STUDENT stayed with his mother from the time of the separation until February 1994.

STUDENT attended school in the District at Silverwood Elementary School during first and second grade. He attended a Christian School during third and fourth grade and returned to the District for fifth grade (the 1991-92 school year). At the beginning of fifth grade, STUDENT was identified as learning disabled and was placed in the resource specialist program (RSP) at Silverwood. STUDENT has admitted that at age 11 he began using drugs and alcohol.

In seventh grade (the 1993-94 school year), STUDENT attended Pine Hollow Middle School. In approximately November 1993, STUDENT went to live with his father, with whom he stayed until about June 1995, and who apparently used drugs openly around STUDENT. By the end of the 1993-94 school year, District psychologist Carol Whiting recommended that STUDENT's parents consider a medical referral for evaluation for possible attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). STUDENT began private therapy and was prescribed Ritalin for ADHD, although there was some concern that he was selling the drug illicitly. During eighth grade (the 1994-95 school year), STUDENT was suspended several times for various incidents, including smoking, setting fire to paper, and possession of a bong that smelled of marijuana.

In about June 1995, STUDENT returned to live with his mother. At the beginning of the ninth grade (the 1995-96 school year), STUDENT attended RSP at Clayton Valley High School. After an Individualized Education Program (IEP) meeting was held October 9, 1995, STUDENT was transferred to Concord High School. On November 6, 1995, in an IEP meeting, and upon his mother's request, STUDENT was placed in the District's home and hospital program, which provided five hours a week of home instruction. Beginning that fall, STUDENT became involved in the juvenile justice system due to delinquent behavior. STUDENT was arrested four times during one five-week period beginning in November 1995. His offenses included possession of alcohol, associating with known gang members, vandalism, and carrying a deadly weapon (a tire iron). STUDENT was released to his mother's custody and was ultimately placed on probation.

On February 5, 1996, STUDENT was adjudicated a ward of the court. On February 7 and 26, and March 18, 1996, IEP team meetings were held in Ms. PARENT's absence. The IEP team members recommended that STUDENT's placement be changed from the home and hospital program back to RSP at Concord. On April 16, STUDENT was placed on probation and returned to his mother's custody. STUDENT returned to Concord in May 1996. At the end of May, STUDENT failed a drug test, which was a violation of his probation, and was returned to juvenile hall. On June 13, he was released to home supervision and spent the summer on house arrest with a monitoring bracelet. On June 21, 1996, an IEP meeting was held, during which Ms. PARENT requested a residential placement.

In August 9, 1996, STUDENT again failed a drug test and was detained by juvenile hall after admitting to having smoked "rock" cocaine. By juvenile court order dated August 27, STUDENT was placed by the probation department at Sherman House, a therapeutic group home. The Sherman House program included instruction by a home and hospital teacher provided by the District. On September 12, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT resume attending two RSP classes at Concord and two periods of "T.A." (teaching assistance) at Pine Hollow. Ms. PARENT was present but did not sign the IEP face sheet. STUDENT resumed the RSP program at Concord in October, while he continued to reside at Sherman House.

In mid-October 1996, STUDENT had an episode involving alcohol and on October 17, he was removed from Sherman House and ordered to juvenile hall. On October 17, the juvenile court ordered STUDENT detained with "authority to release to placement only." STUDENT's last day in the RSP program was October 31, 1996. On November 11, STUDENT was placed at another residential placement, Family Life Center, but he was returned to juvenile hall the next day when he failed to cooperate at the placement. STUDENT remained at juvenile hall until January 17, 1997, when he was placed at Summit in a six-month alternative residential treatment center program. The program was coordinated by Mental Health and located at the juvenile hall site. STUDENT is currently in the Summit program. The juvenile court will not release STUDENT without a special educational program that includes a residential component.

Summary of Relevant Testimony

A. Testimony for the Petitioner

1. Dr. Vincent Nunno

Dr. Nunno is a clinical educational psychologist and neuropsychologist. He has a bachelor's degree from Hunter College in New York, a master's degree from the New School for Social Research in New York, and a Ph.D. from the California School for Professional Psychology, then located in Berkeley. He was licensed as a marriage, family, and child counselor (M.F.C.C.) in 1976, as an educational psychologist in 1978, and as a clinical psychologist in 1980. Dr. Nunno teaches in the area of advanced psychological assessment techniques and is on the core faculty of the San Francisco School of Psychology. He has provided consultations for the District and other school districts. Dr. Nunno is also in private practice and spends approximately 80% of his time seeing patients for individual assessments. His focus is on diagnosis and diagnostic assessment, and he has published papers in the area of Rorschach tests.

On January 22 and 29, 1996, upon Ms. PARENT's request, Dr. Nunno saw STUDENT for the purpose of conducting an independent assessment. Dr. Nunno administered several tests, including (1) Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, third edition (WISC-III); (2) Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT-R); (3) Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (PPVT-R); (4) Wechsler Memory Scale; (5) Trailmaking (Adult Form); (6) Bender Gestalt with Immediate Memory; (7) Background Interference Procedure; (8) Aphasia Screening Test; (9) Projective Drawings; (10) Sentence Completion (High School and Group Forms); (11) Hand Test; (12) Thematic Apperception Test (TAT); and (13) Rorschach Inkblot Test.

Dr. Nunno reviewed several documents before conducting the assessment, including educational and psychological assessments conducted by the District. Dr. Nunno interviewed STUDENT before testing on January 22 and as part of his follow-up on February 12. He also interviewed STUDENT's mother.

In his report dated February 13, 1996, Dr. Nunno's full diagnosis of STUDENT is listed as follows: under Axis I, attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), combined type, dysthymic disorder (early onset, chronic), alcohol abuse, and cannabis abuse; and under Axis II, borderline personality disorder. (Pet. Exh. 5.)(Footnote 1) Dr. Nunno testified that "Axis I" diagnoses are the clinical symptoms or syndromes that are the focus of treatment and that "Axis II" refers to personality disorders. Dr. Nunno acknowledged that although STUDENT meets the criteria for a conduct disorder, he did not include that on his diagnosis, even though the DSM-IV requires the listing of all disorders.

Dr. Nunno based his conclusion that STUDENT meets the criteria for dysthymic disorder (a depressive disorder) on STUDENT's performance on the psychological tests (especially the Rorschach test) and his psychological history, as revealed through the documents, interviews, and consultations. Dr. Nunno stated that the issues of depression are "ubiquitous" in STUDENT's background, along with excessive fear, anxiety, and suicidal ideation and threats, although he acknowledged that STUDENT does not have "major" depression.

Dr. Nunno testified that STUDENT also meets the criteria for dysthymic disorder in the DSM-IV because of his periods of overeating, oversleeping, low self-esteem, and poor concentration. Every time Dr. Nunno saw STUDENT, he was eating, although STUDENT is not overweight. Dr. Nunno acknowledged that cannabis abuse could also cause overeating. STUDENT reported to Dr. Nunno that he slept a lot (estimated by Ms. PARENT at 15 hours a day), which Dr. Nunno acknowledged could also have been caused by cannabis abuse. Dr. Nunno also acknowledged that STUDENT's poor concentration and difficulty making decisions could also be related to substance abuse, but that STUDENT has a history of attention deficit problems from a very early age. Dr. Nunno testified that STUDENT's concentration and other educational problems are not caused by his cannabis abuse, but that his cannabis abuse is a symptom of his emotional problems.

Dr. Nunno indicated that STUDENT presents his depression in a way that is less visible to people who do not have extensive experience with depression in adolescents or who "over-rely" on self-reporting tests. STUDENT reported being depressed as long as he could remember, and Dr. Nunno stated that STUDENT's acting-out behaviors (drugs, alcohol, excessive anger, and defiance to authority) are attempts to distract himself from the depression.

According to Dr. Nunno, although STUDENT does not exhibit the classically "vegetative" symptoms that one usually associates with depression (i.e., sadness), he expresses anger, which often is a symptom of depression in adolescents. Dr. Nunno stated that depression is anger turned inward and that STUDENT's anger turned inward is exhibited in his low self-esteem, while his anger turned outward is exhibited in his socially problematic behavior and his drug use. He stated that STUDENT's depression is "pervasive." It is always there although others may not recognize it and STUDENT may not tell others that he is depressed. Dr. Nunno acknowledged that people with oppositional defiant disorder or conduct disorder also exhibit anger.

Dr. Nunno reported that STUDENT admitted using drugs to keep from worrying. Dr. Nunno described this habit as a sort of "self-medication" for depression. Dr. Nunno disagreed with Dr. Heller's conclusion that STUDENT is not SED, citing Dr. Heller's own language that STUDENT is "clearly significantly disturbed." (Pet. Exh. 1-C.) Dr. Nunno stated that a person who only has a conduct disorder is not disturbed -- others are disturbed by that person's conduct, but the person with the conduct disorder is not disturbed.

Dr. Nunno testified that STUDENT meets the legal criteria for "seriously emotionally disturbed" under the category of a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.(Footnote 2) Dr. Nunno stated that STUDENT does have an ability to learn, but that he cannot currently benefit from his education.

Dr. Nunno said that both he and Dr. Heller found a coping index deficit, which indicates an internal problem-solving inability, and that this is one reason why STUDENT needs to be in a structured residential placement. Regarding the Rorschach test, Dr. Nunno acknowledged that he received only 13 responses from STUDENT, while the accepted "Exner" method requires 14 responses for results to be considered valid.

Dr. Nunno said that STUDENT has a sublimation problem -- an inability to channel, control, and regulate his behavior such that he can concentrate on activities like going to school -- which prevents him from being able to benefit from his education. Dr. Nunno acknowledged that the abuse of some substances (such as alcohol or cocaine) could also produce such a problem. However, Dr. Nunno indicated that STUDENT's substance abuse is a symptom of his inability to channel and regulate his behavior.

Dr. Nunno said that STUDENT avoids the school environment because it forces him to deal with his internal conflicts. (STUDENT was refusing to go to school at the time Dr. Nunno saw him.) Dr. Nunno stated that without being in a structured, contained educational and treatment environment, STUDENT would not likely benefit from his education. Dr. Nunno said that, if asked, STUDENT would probably say he prefers school to a residential placement, but that he would not last in school for long. Dr. Nunno recommended a residential placement for three years.

Dr. Nunno stated that while some have recommended outpatient therapy and medication for STUDENT, he believes that STUDENT would not take the medication or attend the therapy unless he were in a residential placement. If STUDENT were released from Summit and returned to home and school, he would fall back into his old patterns. Dr. Nunno stated that STUDENT is at risk for suicide, not by "committing" suicide, but by putting himself in situations where he may get killed, e.g., a car crash or abusing drugs. Dr. Nunno acknowledged that a twelve-step substance abuse program would be appropriate for STUDENT.

2. Ms. PARENT

Ms. PARENT, STUDENT's mother, described his early years and her tumultuous relationship with STUDENT's father and stated that for a time after STUDENT's birth, his father drank and used drugs. STUDENT was two and a half when she and STUDENT's father separated. Ms. PARENT stated that STUDENT began having conduct problems in kindergarten. STUDENT went to live with his father for a short time after he remarried.

Ms. PARENT acknowledged that STUDENT had a "wonderful" relationship with his maternal grandfather who, unfortunately, passed away. STUDENT and his grandfather spent a great deal of time together, including an excursion to see a submarine similar to the type his grandfather spent time on during World War II. Ms. PARENT had taken STUDENT to a Christian counselor with whom STUDENT related well during this period, but the counselor passed away also. Ms. PARENT said that STUDENT responds very well to her present husband.

Ms. PARENT said that the only year she remembers STUDENT getting "good" grades was in sixth grade at Silverwood when he had a tutor. In about November 1993, STUDENT returned to live with his father and, after that, Ms. PARENT totally lost control of STUDENT's behavior, which included taking drugs. Ms. PARENT acknowledged that STUDENT's drug use probably exacerbated his school problems. During seventh grade at Pine Hollow, when he was about 13, STUDENT started to have a lot of behavior problems. STUDENT saw Dr. Lawrence H. Diller, M.D., for both his ADD problem and for counseling during junior high.

Ms. PARENT said that STUDENT "failed" eighth grade, but that the school officials said they would have to promote him to the next grade because of an age-appropriateness policy. She did not communicate with her ex-husband regarding STUDENT's schooling during this time and did not know whether he had refused to go to school during eighth grade. At the end of eighth grade, an IEP meeting was held at Pine Hollow to discuss STUDENT's going to high school at Clayton Valley.

During ninth grade, STUDENT began to get in trouble with the police, whom Ms. PARENT asked to talk to STUDENT to "scare" him. The police recommended moving STUDENT to Concord High School, away from his friends. STUDENT had "rough" friends at Clayton Valley High School and had associated with a "rough" crowd since junior high. The police suspected that some of the people STUDENT associated with at Clayton Valley were gang members. Even after moving to Concord, STUDENT still saw his old friends.

Ms. PARENT said that she asked school personnel at Concord to contact her if STUDENT failed to attend classes, but that he had skipped about 14 classes before she was notified. She was told that he never attended his last period class and often skipped his first period class. Ms. PARENT acknowledged that STUDENT did well in his T.A. class, which was designed to help the developmentally disabled, until he was thrown out of that class. During that time, STUDENT's drug use was increasing, and Ms. PARENT was not able to wake him up for school in the morning. When she called Sandra Harris, STUDENT's RSP teacher at Concord, to discuss STUDENT's failure to attend class, Ms. Harris suggested the home and hospital program in order to maintain his eligibility for RSP.(Footnote 3)

Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT did not show any progress in the home and hospital program, but that it was extended at the end of the calendar year because, at that time, STUDENT refused to go to school. Toward the end of December 1995, she decided STUDENT needed a residential placement and sent for information on private residential schools. However, since the schools considered her ex-husband's income (they have joint custody of STUDENT), she could not afford them because STUDENT's father would not contribute to STUDENT's schooling.

The following January, Ms. PARENT sought legal help from Mr. Zatopa and an independent assessment from Dr. Nunno. Ms. PARENT stated that once she contacted an attorney, she thought she did not need to attend IEP meetings, even though she received notices. She told Cathy Rice that any communication should go through Mr. Zatopa, her attorney. Ms. PARENT said that she did not attend the February 1996 meeting because it was her birthday and that she did not receive notice of a March 1996 IEP meeting.

Ms. PARENT said that STUDENT stayed in the home and hospital program until April 1996, after which it could not longer be extended. STUDENT then went back to the RSP program at Concord in May 1996, which he attended part days for three days a week. STUDENT did "alright" at first in this program, but by June, although he was going to class, he was not participating or doing homework. He would not come home until 6, 7, 8 p.m. or later, and then he would just "crash." STUDENT's smoking and alcohol and drug abuse were very upsetting to his mother. STUDENT became a ward of the court in her custody when he was put on house arrest in the summer of 1996.

Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT expressed his suicidal tendencies in subtle ways. When she would ask him how he was going to deal with his problems, he would answer, "Well, it doesn't matter -- I'm going to die anyway." STUDENT went through periods where he burned himself with cigarettes, and pierced his own nipple. Ms. PARENT testified that she felt he would place himself in a position where he would get killed by making inappropriate decisions and choices, e.g., hanging out with gang members. In Ms. PARENT's opinion, the message STUDENT's father gave him (by his lifestyle) was that you can drink and do drugs and still maintain your life, but "just don't get caught." STUDENT was back at juvenile hall for breaking probation (substance abuse) before going on house arrest, which prevented him from finishing out the spring 1996 semester.

Ms. PARENT testified that at the IEP meeting on June 21, 1996, there was discussion that STUDENT was able to function in school when he actually attended. To her, the idea was "laughable," because STUDENT never did any homework while in the home and hospital program, his report cards had D's and F's, and his IEPs were "never fulfilled." Ms. PARENT requested a residential placement at this IEP meeting. A representative from the probation department, Ron Afdahl, was present and said that the department would like to work with the District, but that its offer of an RSP at Concord was not appropriate.

During the summer, STUDENT registered for two classes -- driver's education and sign language. He never attended driver's education and was kicked out of sign language. That fall, STUDENT lived at Sherman House and attended school there at first. Later he attended school at Concord. Ms. PARENT said that STUDENT had a "hard time" with the teacher at Sherman House and that the teaching material was at the elementary school level. When STUDENT returned to Concord, he had a couple of mainstream classes, including sign language, and RSP classes. Ms. PARENT said that ultimately STUDENT was thrown out of Sherman House after being written up "too many times" for talking back, smoking, inappropriate sexual activity, and drinking.

After STUDENT was put in juvenile Hall, Ms. PARENT continued to believe STUDENT needed to be in a residential placement. Eventually, STUDENT was placed in Family Life Center. Ms. PARENT described this placement as a very structured program that has group and individual counseling and other mental health treatment. Four hours after arriving at Family Life Center, STUDENT was discharged for being excessively rude and abusive, and for making inappropriate sexual advances toward female staff. STUDENT was returned to juvenile hall that same day, October 11, 1996. Ms. PARENT said that STUDENT's probation officer, Linda Leeper, indicated that STUDENT would be detained in juvenile hall until an appropriate placement was made.

Ms. PARENT indicated that STUDENT is "getting better" in juvenile hall and that he has been seeing therapist Allan McTighe in juvenile hall since June of 1996. She pays for Mr. McTighe's therapy services. She stated that STUDENT and Mr. McTighe have "an incredible bond" and that STUDENT feels close to Mr. McTighe. STUDENT has been in the Summit program since mid-January 1997, and Ms. PARENT's understanding from probation is that STUDENT will be kept at Summit for six months, depending on how well he does. She noted that STUDENT has an interest in helping the disabled, and indicated that although he sometimes yells and gets angry with her, they actually have a very good relationship.

3. Allan McTighe

Mr. McTighe is a licensed marriage, family, and child counselor (M.F.C.C.). He has a master's degree in counseling psychology from California State University at Hayward. Mr. McTighe has been in private practice since 1980. Half of Mr. McTighe's practice is dedicated to adolescents, primarily those in trouble with the law, and most of his referrals come from juvenile courts and schools.

Prior to entering private practice, Mr. McTighe worked from 1972-1974 as a counselor in Contra Costa's County Juvenile Hall and from 1974-1980 as a deputy probation officer in the juvenile division, mostly in "placement diversion." In the latter position, Mr. McTighe read court reports of adolescents ordered into court-approved licensed institutions and called their parents to see if they would consider intense family counseling which might keep the child from being placed outside the home.

Mr. McTighe first met STUDENT June 17, 1996. He reviewed Dr. Nunno's psychological evaluation, the District's report, and the juvenile court records, and he interviewed Ms. PARENT. He has seen STUDENT for 50-minute sessions almost every week since June 17, in his office initially, and in juvenile hall recently.

Mr. McTighe testified that STUDENT is extremely confused, with very low self-esteem and very poor frustration tolerance and impulse control. He said that STUDENT has a desperate need for closeness with people, yet suddenly attacks when he's "too" close.

Mr. McTighe concurs with the diagnosis of borderline personality disorder, with a secondary diagnosis of depression. He testified that STUDENT also fits under the criteria for a conduct disorder, which he said was not unusual for people who have borderline personality disorders. Mr. McTighe said that borderline personality disorder is often marked by shifts in moods and STUDENT can be depressed one moment and panicked the next. He stated that STUDENT exhibits a pervasive (or "free floating") mood of unhappiness or depression, alternating with anxiety, except that the degree lessens in an atmosphere where he feels truly "safe." He said that adolescents, and STUDENT especially, can mislead "experts" by not exhibiting the typical hopelessness, helplessness, and sadness that most people associate with depression. Mr. McTighe said that adolescents often exhibit depression through irritability and agitation, and that depression is anger turned against the self. Mr. McTighe stated that STUDENT's anger is secondary to his depression.

Mr. McTighe did not think STUDENT was a gang member because he always denied it when asked. Mr. McTighe stated that STUDENT did not do things to "fit in," as do many kids who join gangs.

Mr. McTighe was not aware of any positive peer relationships STUDENT might have had prior to juvenile hall. STUDENT tended to associate with dangerous kids when he lived at home, yet, while at juvenile hall, he associated with the kids who were motivated to turn their lives around. Mr. McTighe said that STUDENT came in as a kind of swaggering street thug, but that his overall demeanor changed because he did not have the same kind of ambivalence toward making decisions at juvenile hall, where the consequences are swift. Mr. McTighe's primary breakthrough with STUDENT occurred when STUDENT was at juvenile hall, where he could not obtain illegal substances or act out in ways to avoid psychological pain. Mr. McTighe stated that if STUDENT is returned home and sent to any District placement Mr. McTighe knows of, STUDENT is "doomed" because he does not have what it takes to succeed in such an arrangement. Mr. McTighe said that Sherman House did not work because it did not provide the kind of "tough love" that STUDENT needs. He stated that STUDENT should complete the six-month program at Summit and that, even at that point, he would not be ready to return home.

Mr. McTighe acknowledged that substance abuse could affect STUDENT's performance in school, although he remarked that substance abuse is common to those with borderline personality disorder. He believed that STUDENT was clean and sober while in juvenile hall and that, even then, he exhibited the characteristics of a borderline personality disorder.(Footnote 4)

B. Testimony for the Respondents

1. Cathy Rice

Ms. Rice, a District program specialist for special education at Concord, first met STUDENT at a fall 1995 IEP meeting at which she served as a District representative.

Ms. Rice's first interaction with STUDENT was when he was put into the home and hospital program pursuant to the IEP meeting of November 6, 1995. The placement change was made because STUDENT did not like his science class (which he skipped) and was not getting along with the teacher with whom he worked in his teaching assistant class. Ms. Rice indicated that STUDENT had been doing "reasonably well" in two periods of RSP, but that because STUDENT had a job detailing cars, his mother asked for a schedule that would allow him to work. Ms. Rice said that the home and hospital program is used not only for medical problems, but also as a temporary placement when other placements are being considered. Ms. Rice stated that the placement was being implemented in response to STUDENT's problems with his science class and his elective class teacher and not for any other behavioral or academic performance concerns.

Ms. Rice stated that STUDENT's IEP was due in early 1996, so the District scheduled IEP meetings in January, February, and March 1996. Both STUDENT's RSP and home and hospital teachers had indicated to Ms. Rice that STUDENT was successful when he attended school. Therefore, on February 26, 1996, the District side of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT return to RSP at Concord with an elective class. Ms. PARENT did not attend either the February or March meeting, but Ms. Rice wrote to her asking if she agreed with the IEP team's recommendations. Ms. PARENT attended the IEP meeting of April 29, 1996. At that meeting, STUDENT was scheduled to drop home and hospital and start attending two RSP classes with Sandi Harris. An AB3632 referral was also made.

The two RSP classes comprised the total educational program offered to STUDENT at this IEP meeting. The program was scheduled to last through the final six weeks of school. Ms. Rice said that the reason for the 10 school hours per week was to provide more schooling than he received in the home and hospital program (five hours a week) and to put him in classes in which he had been successful (RSP with Sandi Harris). The goals and objectives from an earlier IEP were carried forward in this IEP. Ms. Rice testified that Sandi Harris, STUDENT's RSP teacher, and Robin Heinschel, STUDENT's home and hospital teacher, indicated to Ms. Rice on a teacher checklist that STUDENT did not exhibit behaviors (resistance to authority) which affected his educational performance during the time they each saw him. (Dist. Exh. 64.(Footnote 5))

Ms. Rice testified that at the IEP meeting held June 21, 1996, the team reviewed the reports of psychologist Walter Shugert and Dr. Nunno, and the referral for AB3632 services. The District offered an out-of-District assessment to determine eligibility as SED. No decision regarding SED eligibility was made. Ms. Rice said that the first referral for AB3632 services made in April was rejected by Mental Health because STUDENT was benefitting from his education; therefore, another referral was made at the IEP meeting held in June.

Ms. Rice stated that the purpose of the September IEP meeting was to review Dr. Heller's report and the referral for AB3632 services, and to discuss STUDENT's return to Concord RSP. STUDENT's program as of that meeting was two RSP classes (English and math), two regular classes (world civilization and science), and American Sign Language as an elective. The program included a tracking system to ensure that STUDENT attended class. No recommendation was made for AB3632 services pending action by Mental Health on the referral, although goals were set in that area.

Ms. Rice stated that the purpose for the IEP meeting of November 7, 1996, while STUDENT was in juvenile hall, was to meet with probation and to ensure that the District had a proper placement available upon STUDENT's release. Ms. PARENT did not attend this meeting.

Ms. Rice stated that Ms. PARENT talked about her concerns for STUDENT's emotional state, but that Ms. Rice did not remember Ms. PARENT mentioning STUDENT's inability to produce work. Ms. Rice observed STUDENT in his sign language and RSP math classes and never saw an inability to learn; nor did any teacher report to her that STUDENT had an inability to learn.

Moreover, Ms. Rice never received a report that STUDENT had an inability to build or maintain satisfactory relationships. She never received a report regarding inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances, except a call from a school bus driver who was concerned over STUDENT's behavior with a deaf girl. Ms. Rice said that a girl felt STUDENT was bothering her by talking about her body, but when STUDENT talked to Ms. Rice, he indicated he was just learning vocabulary.

Although Ms. PARENT had reported to Ms. Rice that STUDENT had a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, Ms. Rice never received a similar report from any of his teachers. She also never received a report from STUDENT's teachers regarding anxiety or panic, or physical symptoms or fears associated with school or personal problems.

2. Susan Elliott

Ms. Elliott is a District resource specialist at Pinehollow Middle School. She has been an RSP teacher for the last 12 or 13 years and, before that, was an SDC teacher. STUDENT was her student during his seventh and eighth grade years. She described STUDENT's attendance and participation in her class as good.

Ms. Elliott said that STUDENT seemed to have trouble with attention, but that STUDENT did not need a residential placement in seventh or eighth grade. STUDENT came up with astute insights when studying "the Diary of Anne Frank," and was one of Ms. Elliott's better students in math. However, he did not do the work when he was moved to a regular math class and was sent back to her resource math.

Ms. Elliott described STUDENT as caring and kind when he worked with the developmentally delayed students in his teaching assistant class. STUDENT achieved some progress on his goals and objectives by the time of the IEP meeting of June 6, 1997. Although he had been suspended for various incidents during this time, the incidents occurred outside her classroom. Ms. Elliott did not specifically recall STUDENT's having any unusual problem with attendance or completing homework, but indicated that STUDENT probably received poor grades because he failed to do homework.

Ms. Elliott said that it would not have been appropriate to retain STUDENT in eighth grade, because he had the ability to do the work and he was physically big and tall. She stated that he did not exhibit an inability to learn, depression, irritability, anxiety, sadness, or inappropriate behaviors to any degree greater than the average student. STUDENT appeared to be happy in her class and the girls liked him. He had friends who continued from seventh to eighth grade, and he "stuck up" for the developmentally disabled kids. Ms. Elliott did not see STUDENT ostracized or picked on by other kids. Although Ms. Elliott heard that STUDENT "hung out" with students who smoked, none of those students was in her class. Ms. Elliott said that she had a good relationship with STUDENT. She has two SED students this year and believes that STUDENT does not fit the profile of a typical SED student.

3. Sandra ("Sandi") Harris

Ms. Harris, a District RSP teacher, has taught at Concord for the 16 years. STUDENT has been her student off and on for the last year and a half in English and math. Ms. Harris acknowledged that she STUDENT was her student for only four weeks at a time, three separate times. She described him as very verbal with a good sense of humor, and as one of the more mature students in her class. She stated that he seemed to like school. His functioning was "very close to grade level," he did his homework, his attendance was good, and he was cooperative with her and other teachers.

Ms. Harris stated that STUDENT was in her class in fall 1995 for about four weeks. Ms. Harris said that STUDENT had a job and that Ms. PARENT was concerned about STUDENT not attending his science class and falling behind. For this reason, Ms. Harris was hopeful that if STUDENT could take a break between November and the end of the semester to get back on track, he would be able to come back to RSP the second semester. STUDENT did not return to RSP until late in the spring semester for only another three or four weeks.

Ms. Harris indicated that in addition to receiving good grades in fall 1995 (a B in resource math and a B in resource English), STUDENT put forth excellent effort. The grades partly represented his school work at Clayton Valley, since he was not present at Concord for the full nine-week grading period. Ms. Harris stated that she believed STUDENT had above-average cognitive abilities. His grades in the second semester were D's in her two classes because he was absent and in juvenile hall.

Ms. Harris did not know of any refusal by STUDENT to go to school. She stated that while STUDENT was at Sherman House and attending Concord, she did not believe he was absent or even tardy one day. She talked to STUDENT's other teachers, who remembered him "with pleasure," saying that he was a "terrific kid." Ms. Harris stated that STUDENT never caused his science teacher any problems -- he just announced that he hated science, could not do it, and was not going to go to that class. Ms. Harris asked that STUDENT's home and hospital teacher focus on science to catch him up in that subject.

Ms. Harris said that STUDENT maintained his friends from Clayton Valley that he "partied with" and that he was eager to go out to lunch with them. She stated that he also had friends in class, and that after he began the Summit program, he wrote her a letter in which he asked about the kids in the class. Ms. Harris testified that she and STUDENT had a good relationship and that he would tell her when he was upset.

Ms. Harris stated that STUDENT never appeared sad, depressed, anxious, or upset any more than any other adolescent boy. She never saw him panicked, but, occasionally, STUDENT would tell her he was angry with his mother. Ms. Harris said no other teachers told her they observed any of these negative characteristics.

Ms. Harris stated that STUDENT did not demonstrate an inability to learn and that his success was determined by whether or not he applied himself. STUDENT also did not exhibit inappropriate behaviors or feelings. Ms. Harris said that she has SED students in her classes and that she would not characterize STUDENT as SED. She said that she is sensitive to any display by students of suicidal behavior and that STUDENT never talked to her about suicide or exhibited such behavior. She acknowledged that she had never seen STUDENT outside of class. Ms. Harris testified that she believed STUDENT would succeed if he came back to Concord because he started out the 1996-97 school year very well.

4. Ann Eliese Makely

Ms. Makely has a B.S. in psychology from U.C. Davis and an M.S. from California State University at Hayward in school psychology and clinical child psychology. Her graduate program addressed SED assessments.

Ms. Makely attended the June 1996 IEP meeting because the school psychologist who had evaluated STUDENT had retired. She does not know STUDENT and has only read previous reports regarding him. Ms. Makely indicated that at the June IEP meeting, the team concluded that STUDENT was not SED because, although he had some emotional problems, these problems did not affect his educational performance. Ms. Makely reviewed the reports by Drs. Heller and Diller and found nothing to indicate that STUDENT is SED under the legal criteria. She also reviewed STUDENT's test scores and concluded that STUDENT had benefitted from his education. She found no indication that STUDENT had an inability to form relationships.

Ms. Makely stated that she has attended workshops by Dr. Nunno and believes that his approach does not really apply to educational issues. She also felt that he did not really follow the legal SED guidelines in the workshop.

Ms. Makely said that she did not believe that STUDENT needs a residential placement to benefit from his education and that a student's refusal to attend school is usually a matter of oppositional behavior, not an emotional disturbance. Ms. Makely acknowledged that if a student were SED, his or her refusal to attend school might be considered an adverse effect on his or her education.

Ms. Makely stated that if a student is seriously "working" an educational program, yet receives only D's and F's, she would consider that program inappropriate. However, she stated that if the low grades were a result of the student's failure to "work" the program, she would not consider that program inappropriate.

5. Rich Weisgal

Mr. Weisgal has been the AB3632 program director for Contra Costa County Mental Health for the last six and a half years. He received a B.A. from the University of Michigan and his master's in M.F.C.C. from the University of Santa Clara. Mr. Weisgal is a licensed M.F.C.C. in California and has spent a total of 20 years in that profession. He has attended IEP meetings and his job involves significant amounts of AB3632 work.

Mr. Weisgal has been involved with STUDENT's case since the referral for AB3632 services made in June 1996. He has been involved in the development of the Summit program, in conjunction with the juvenile court system. He recommended the Summit program for STUDENT and is familiar with his progress there.

Mr. Weisgal stated that he has seen nothing in STUDENT's charts or in his visits to Summit that would indicate an inability to learn or an inability to maintain satisfactory relationships. Mr. Weisgal stated that STUDENT has had excellent relations with the staff at Summit and good peer relations. He also stated that based on his review of the documents, he does not believe that STUDENT has a long-standing inability to establish relationships. In his opinion, the District provided an appropriate program and STUDENT's attendance problem was related to substance abuse or selling drugs.

Mr. Weisgal found no indication that STUDENT has engaged in inappropriate behavior while at Summit. His review of the records indicated anger, but no depression, on STUDENT's part. In the school within Summit, STUDENT is considered the top student. Mr. Weisgal stated that STUDENT's extreme turnaround while in juvenile hall and Summit indicates that STUDENT is not SED, because SED students cannot "get better" that quickly just because they are in a residential placement. Mr. Weisgal has placed approximately 150 SED students in residential placements over the years and stated that none of them has performed like STUDENT. Mr. Weisgal believes STUDENT does not suffer from even mild depression, that STUDENT's primary diagnosis is substance abuse, and that when STUDENT is not in situations with temptations, he "clears" and is able to apply himself. Mr. Weisgal said that Summit focuses on substance abuse and that it involves "reality-oriented" work, i.e., what STUDENT needs to do to have a clean and sober lifestyle.

Mr. Weisgal said that while at Summit, STUDENT spoke with him and indicated that he did not want to be put in another residential placement. STUDENT also exhibited an awareness of his substance abuse problem. Summit staff indicated to Mr. Weisgal that STUDENT is studying for an informal version of his bar mitzvah and that he believes STUDENT is sincere about this goal. Mr. Weisgal testified that he does not believe STUDENT needs a residential program and that if he were placed in such a program for SED students, STUDENT would be with people who are much worse off emotionally.

6. Gary Barnes

Mr. Barnes, a teacher in the District's home and hospital program, taught STUDENT at Sherman House. Prior to his current position, Mr. Barnes taught elementary school for 30 years. He does not have special education training.

Mr. Barnes stated that he gave grade-level work to STUDENT. He stated that STUDENT's attitude was very positive and that he would ask for more work. Mr. Barnes did not see an inability to learn in STUDENT. He said that there were two or three other students in the program and that STUDENT got along very well with them. Mr. Barnes also testified that STUDENT did not appear to be depressed, though he might have been a little bored. He also failed to see STUDENT exhibit any inappropriate or bizarre feelings or behaviors.

7. Joan Alber

Ms. Alber is the District's special education administrator and the administrator for special day classes and centers. She has been an educator for 27 years, with 15 years in general education. Ms. Alber received her bachelor's degree from U.C. Berkeley and her master's from California State University at Hayward. She has an administrative credential and lectures at several universities. Ms. Alber stated that her duties at the District involve investigating options available for special education students in nonpublic schools and special day classes. She meets with District program specialists weekly to problem-solve, and became involved with STUDENT's case after the IEP meeting held in November 1995, when she talked with program specialist Cathy Rice.

Ms. Alber stated that STUDENT's home and hospital program was a response to the undesirable friends STUDENT was associating with at that time. She stated that the program was not meant to be long term. Because it was difficult to get special teachers in the middle of a semester, they planned to obtain STUDENT's preferred teachers at the beginning of that next semester (spring 1996).

At the hearing, Ms. Alber interpreted some of the District's computer printouts of daily attendance logs regarding STUDENT. She indicated that STUDENT had a significant number of absences, not including suspensions. Ms. Alber stated that STUDENT was ranked 225 out of 250 at the time of his fourth quarter grades for 1994-95. She indicated that STUDENT is current on his high school credits and is on track for graduation, even after the limited RSP schedule, the home and hospital program, and his stays in juvenile hall.

8. Jodi Couick

Dr. Couick is a clinical psychologist, a licensed educational psychologist, and a school psychologist. Dr. Couick has a master's degree in clinical child school psychology, a doctorate in clinical child psychology and family therapy, and credentials in pupil personnel services and school psychology. Dr. Couick works part-time as a school psychologist for the West Contra Costa Unified School District, and is an adjunct professor at the schools of education at both California State University at Hayward and St. Mary's College. Dr. Couick teaches courses in assessment, counseling, and the SED credentialing program at St. Mary's, and assessment and counseling of special needs children at California State University at Hayward. She has extensive experience with the SED eligibility category under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.

Dr. Couick has not met STUDENT, but she has reviewed his educational and psychological records and stated that she did not see anything that supports SED eligibility for STUDENT. To her, it appeared STUDENT may have been situationally depressed; however, his records did not indicate any depression since the time of Dr. Nunno's diagnosis.

Dr. Couick stated that a truly SED student could not make the kind of quick turnaround that STUDENT has apparently made at Summit. She indicated that it is not characteristic of SED students to be able to maintain relationships and to disregard their own needs to sustain those relationships as STUDENT has done in several situations, such as his work with the developmentally disabled students in which he demonstrated significant empathy.

Dr. Couick testified that if a student's depression existed over a long period of time, teachers would see a lot of withdrawal, despondence, isolation, and nonparticipation. She acknowledged that STUDENT is not without problems, but stated that those problems stem from his substance abuse. She also acknowledged that anger can be correlated with depression, but asserted that anger can also be caused by substance abuse. Dr. Couick stated that the problems STUDENT has experienced for the past two years are those typically associated with a conduct disorder, not depression. The "pervasive" requirement for depression means that the symptoms of depression must show up more than occasionally at school, because the truly SED student does not have control over the depression. She stated that STUDENT, in contrast, seems to have control over his conduct and the feelings he exhibits.

With regard to peer relations, Dr. Couick said that just because adults may not "like" the peer group with whom a child associates, it does not mean the relationships are not "satisfactory."

9. Dorothy Brown

Ms. Brown is a District teacher of American Sign Language (ASL). STUDENT was in her ASL class in late September through October 1996. STUDENT participated to some degree in class and, although he missed some classes, he worked to catch up with the class. She said that STUDENT was tough and streetwise but was not withdrawn, depressed, or unhappy. She indicated that there was a group of girls who always wanted to be around STUDENT. Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT received a final grade of "D" because he did not bring his materials to class and did not exhibit much effort.

10. Bruce Heller

Dr. Heller is a clinical psychologist. He received his A.B. from U.C. Berkeley in 1975 and a Ph.D. from U.C. Davis in 1980. He has taken coursework in testing and measurement, and specific courses in the Rorschach test. He spends about 40% of his practice on psychological assessment and the other 60% on psychotherapy. Dr. Heller's practice consists of about 35% adults, 35% children, and 30% adolescents. He has completed over 500 assessments.

Dr. Heller met with STUDENT for a total of about six hours on August 21, 23, and 24, 1996, in response to a request by Ms. Alber. Dr. Heller also spoke with STUDENT's mother, his stepfather, and his therapist, and he reviewed STUDENT's records. Dr. Heller concluded that STUDENT is not SED under special education law. He also concluded that STUDENT does not require a residential placement to benefit from his special education. He based his conclusions on the fact that although STUDENT has a number of problems, some have to do with a conduct disorder, some with an identity disorder, some with his learning disability, and some with substance abuse.

Dr. Heller said that he did not think STUDENT was depressed and that, although a residential placement might raise STUDENT's self-esteem and provide needed structure, he did not think that it was educationally necessary. Dr. Heller indicated that STUDENT told him that he did not want a residential placement and that he acted out in ways to get himself removed from those placements. Dr. Heller stated that Dr. Nunno did not "cast a wide enough net" in his testing, because he did not use various kinds of measures to come up with his conclusion that STUDENT was SED. Dr. Heller said that it is not appropriate to find a student SED based on one piece of data, which, in Dr. Nunno's case, was the Rorschach. Dr. Heller stated that according to Dr. Nunno's own findings, STUDENT's validity indicator on the Rorschach showed that the results may not be valid. Dr. Heller testified that this indicator and the low number of responses (one less than the required 14) indicate that the Rorschach results should not be considered valid.

Dr. Heller stated that while anger could be associated with depression, STUDENT does not fulfill the criteria for clinical depression. Dr. Heller testified that he believes his conduct disorder influences STUDENT more than his other problems and that his conduct disorder does not arise out of his ADHD.

11. Robert Siltanen

Mr. Siltanen, a credentialed District social studies teacher, had STUDENT as a student in the fall of 1996 for three to four weeks. Mr. Siltanen stated that STUDENT attended all classes, had one tardy, and participated in class and offered comments in discussions.

Mr. Siltanen testified that STUDENT appeared no more depressed than other students and that, if anything, he was fidgety. STUDENT was not particularly disruptive, although at one point, he drew a large marijuana leaf on the board. Mr. Siltanen did not notice that STUDENT had an inability to learn.

DISCUSSION

I. Is STUDENT seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?

The federal criteria for finding a serious emotional disturbance are as follows:

(i) The term means a condition exhibiting one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affects a child's educational performance-- (A) An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors; (B) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers; (C) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances; (D) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression;

(E) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

(ii) The term includes schizophrenia. The term does not apply to children who are socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that they have a serious emotional disturbance.

34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9).

California regulations add that any inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances must be "exhibited in several situations." California Code of Regulations § 3030(i).

Here, the Petitioner contends that STUDENT is SED because he meets the criteria under category B -- an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers -- and category D -- a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Therefore, categories A, C, and E are not at issue in this matter.

A. A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression

Petitioner contends that he is SED because he has exhibited over a long period of time and to a marked degree a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression that has adversely affected his educational performance.

The District and Mental Health contend that STUDENT is not SED and that his educational difficulties are due to his conduct disorder(Footnote 6) (including his defiance of authority and his illegal behavior), his substance abuse, and his resulting entanglement with the juvenile justice system.

Petitioner's witness, Dr. Vincent Nunno, testified that STUDENT meets the criteria for SED. Dr. Nunno based his conclusion on his diagnosis of STUDENT as having dysthymic and borderline personality disorders. (Pet. Exh. 5.) Dr. Nunno testified that although he did not include it in his diagnosis, STUDENT also meets the criteria for a conduct disorder.(Footnote 7) The Hearing Officer notes that the diagnoses of dysthymia and borderline personality disorder are not dispositive of a finding of SED. A student must meet the criteria in the law to be eligible for special education services as SED.

Dysthymia (a milder form of major depressive disorder) is described as a "chronically depressed mood that occurs for most of the day more days than not for at least 2 years (Criterion A)." DSM-IV(Footnote 8), page 345. Eight criteria, listed from A to H, are required for this diagnosis. Criterion A recognizes a mood of irritability as evidence of dysthymia in children and adolescents and requires exhibition of the mood for one year instead of the two years for adults. Additionally, Criterion G indicates that the symptoms must not result from the physiological effects of substance abuse. DSM-IV, page 349.

Mr. McTighe, who is not a psychologist, concurred with the diagnosis of dysthymia. Dr. Couick, however, stated that while STUDENT may have had a situationally related depression at one time, it did not appear to amount to a pervasive depression and there was no indication of depression in his records since the time of Dr. Nunno's diagnosis. Dr. Heller specifically rejected dysthymia and instead found that STUDENT had a conduct disorder. (Dist. Exh. 78, p. 11.)

The typical depression involves withdrawal and isolation. (Testimony of Dr. Nunno.) Nowhere is this well-understood depressive behavior indicated with STUDENT. Rather, Dr. Nunno's diagnosis of depression is based on the following symptoms: anger, defiance of authority, use of drugs, overeating and oversleeping. Other witnesses testified that these same behaviors are symptoms of substance abuse rather than indicators of depression.

With respect to STUDENT's anger, Dr. Couick testified that while anger can be correlated with depression, it can also be caused by substance abuse. Dr. Heller testified that while anger could be associated with depression, in this case it is not, because STUDENT does not fulfill the criteria for clinical depression. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Couick's and Dr. Heller's interpretation that STUDENT's anger could be caused by his use and abuse of illicit substances to be more persuasive than the interpretation that his anger demonstrates depression. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's anger is not indicative of any depressive trait related to SED.

Dr. Nunno also cited overeating as a basis for his finding of dysthymia. Dr. Nunno said that STUDENT told him he eats a lot. However, Dr. Nunno indicated that STUDENT is not at all fat. In fact, STUDENT himself wrote "I am skinny" as part of Dr. Nunno's tests. (Pet. Exh. 5.) Dr. Nunno acknowledged that cannabis abuse could affect a person's appetite. The Hearing Officer notes that it is not unusual for a teenage boy to be hungry much of the time, especially one who has used marijuana. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's alleged "overeating" is not indicative of any depressive trait related to SED.

As to Dr. Nunno's indication of oversleeping as a basis for his diagnosis of dysthymia, Dr. Nunno said that STUDENT and his mother reported that he oversleeps. STUDENT's mother indicated that she had a problem getting STUDENT up in the morning. However, Dr. Nunno acknowledged that substance abuse could have an effect on STUDENT's sleeping habits. Ms. PARENT also indicated that when STUDENT was living at home, he often did not come home until late at night. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's "oversleeping" is not indicative of any depressive trait related to SED.

Dr. Nunno also diagnosed STUDENT as having a borderline personality disorder. (Pet. Exh. 5.) This disorder is described as "a pervasive pattern of instability of interpersonal relationships, self-image, and affects, and marked impulsivity beginning by early adulthood and present in a variety of contexts, as indicated by five (or more)" of nine specified categories. DSM-IV, page 654. Dr. Nunno stated that the five criteria STUDENT fulfills are (1) pattern of unstable and intense interpersonal relationships characterized by alternating between extremes of idealization and devaluation, (2) identity disturbance, marked and persistent unstable self-image or sense of self, (3) impulsivity in two areas that are potentially self-damaging (e.g., spending, sex, substance abuse, reckless driving, and binge eating), (4) recurrent suicidal behaviors, gestures, or threats, and (5) inappropriate intense anger or difficulty controlling anger, frequent displays of anger, constant anger, or recurrent physical fights. (Testimony of Dr. Nunno.)

The criteria for borderline personality disorder under the category of "recurrent suicidal behaviors, gestures, or threats" could meet the SED criteria under the category of "general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression" through the exhibition of suicidal tendencies. The DSM-IV indicates that major depressive disorder involves a "major depressive episode" within the last year (for adolescents). DSM-IV, pages 339 and 349. One of the qualifying episodes is "recurrent thoughts of death (not just fear of dying), recurrent suicidal ideation without a specific plan, or a suicide attempt or a specific plan for committing suicide." DSM-IV, page 327.

Dr. Nunno stated that STUDENT is suicidal in the sense that he puts himself in situations where he will get himself killed. Dr. Nunno said that by hanging out with suspected gang members, getting into fights, and exhibiting other dangerous behaviors, STUDENT is setting himself up to be killed. Dr. Nunno did not indicate that STUDENT had any specific plan to kill himself. Ms. PARENT indicated that she felt STUDENT was suicidal based on his statements that it didn't matter how he dealt with things because he was "going to die anyway." However, the Hearing Officer finds that the described statements and actions only indirectly hint at suicidal behavior, and therefore do not meet SED criteria under the category of general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's alleged suicidal tendencies are not sufficient to establish SED.

Even if a student experiences a general mood of unhappiness or depression, that mood must be found to be pervasive. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9). This requirement means that the depressive mood must be exhibited in all areas of life, including school and home. While Ms. PARENT testified that she felt STUDENT was depressed, many witnesses testified that they saw no such mood present when STUDENT was around them. (Testimony of Ms. Harris, Ms. Elliott, Ms. Makely, and Dr. Heller.) Another requirement is that this indicator of SED exist over a long period of time and to a marked degree. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9). There is credible evidence that STUDENT does not suffer from depression at all. Therefore, these requirements are not met in STUDENT's case.

Further, even if a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression is found, that mood must cause an adverse effect on educational performance. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9). As to STUDENT's cognitive abilities, in May 1994, District psychologist Carol Whiting noted that STUDENT's full-scale IQ, as measured by the WISC-R, given January 1987, was above-average (122). (Pet. Exh. 15.) In August 1996, Dr. Heller administered the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Cognitive Ability, which revealed that STUDENT's cognitive abilities were in the low average range (89), with a high in the area of reading comprehension. (Pet. Exh. 1-C.) In January 1996, Dr. Nunno found STUDENT's full-scale IQ, as measured by the WISC-R, was average (98). (Pet. Exh. 5.) Comparing the two WISC-R tests would seem to give the best picture of STUDENT's cognitive abilities. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's cognitive abilities are at least in the average range.

As to STUDENT's educational performance, although not all of his grades are poor, STUDENT has received several failing grades over quite a few years of schooling, particularly in junior high. In seventh grade, STUDENT's grades included one C (in physical education), four D's, and two F's, which his seventh grade RSP teacher indicated were probably a result of his not doing his work. (Testimony of Ms. Elliott and Pet. Exh. 10.) His grade point average (GPA) at the end of seventh grade was 1.48. By the second quarter of eighth grade, STUDENT's GPA had fallen to 1.43, and after receiving his third quarter grades, which consisted of three D's, three F's, and one A (in his teacher's aide class, in which STUDENT helped out with young developmentally disabled children), his GPA hovered at 1.45. STUDENT's attitude and effort in his T.A. class stands out from that in his other classes. (Pet. Exh. 10.) STUDENT's intellectual abilities are average or above average, yet he had failing and near-failing grades in seventh and eighth grades. The Hearing Officer notes that something was interfering with his performance in school, at least during seventh and eighth grade.

However, by the end of ninth grade, after participation in the home and hospital program and his return to Concord for the second semester, STUDENT had earned 54 out of a possible 60 credits; he had a 2.75 GPA and was on track for graduation. (Dist. Exh. 79 and testimony of Ms. Alber.) By ninth grade, STUDENT seemed to be achieving grades more commensurate with his abilities. (Testimony of Ms. Harris, Ms. Alber, and Pet. Exh. 10.) There is evidence that when STUDENT is present in class, he has the ability to do grade-level work. (Dist. Exh. 82.) During the first quarter of the 1995-96 year (ninth grade), STUDENT received as interim grades one A, two B's, one C, and one F (in science, which he often skipped). (Pet. Exh. 10 and Dist. Exh. 82.) STUDENT failed to attend some classes (science, especially) and, as a result, received poor grades. (Dist. Exh. 83.) Ms. Harris, STUDENT's RSP teacher at Concord, said that STUDENT did his homework and that his attendance was good. Ms. Harris indicated that STUDENT received a B in resource math and a B in resource English in fall 1995, and added that he had excellent effort and participation. Ms. Harris also said that STUDENT's grades in the second semester reflected his lack of attendance after he went back to juvenile hall.

While the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT's grades are still not reflective of a student without problems, the grades improved somewhat during the time when he was most in trouble with the law, and detained in juvenile hall. The Hearing Officer notes that the unavailability of drugs in juvenile hall may have played a role in STUDENT's increased performance during this time. Since enrolling in the Summit program, STUDENT has become the "star" student there. (Testimony of Mr. Weisgal.) However, in light of all the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has experienced an adverse effect on his educational experience. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT's poor educational performance is the result of his substance abuse, misconduct, and his failure to attend class. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's educational difficulties are not related to SED eligibility.

In conclusion, for the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not SED under the category of general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

B. An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers

Petitioner contends that he has an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers which causes him to be eligible for special education services as SED. The District and Mental Health contend that STUDENT has an ability to build and maintain such relationships.

Ms. PARENT described the very close and loving relationship STUDENT had with his maternal grandfather before he passed away. According to her testimony, STUDENT and his grandfather seemed to really enjoy each other's company and STUDENT apparently trusted and cherished his grandfather.

Ms. PARENT indicated that even though STUDENT sometimes yells at her and gets angry with her, they actually have a very good relationship. Although Ms. PARENT was fearful that STUDENT's friends from Clayton Valley High School were gang members, STUDENT maintained contact with these friends, even after moving to Concord High School. Although there is some question as to whether these relationships would be considered "satisfactory," the existence of these relationships indicates that STUDENT is able to make friends. Dr. Couick testified that an adult's perception that STUDENT's friendships with these kids was inappropriate would not obviate the fact that they could be "satisfactory" under the criteria. However, because there are sufficient other relationships to consider under this category, the Hearing Officer gives little weight to STUDENT's relationships with either suspected or known gang members.

Both Ms. PARENT and Susan Elliott, STUDENT's RSP teacher at Pinehollow during seventh and eighth grade, indicated that STUDENT had an affinity for dealing with the developmentally disabled. Ms. Elliott said that STUDENT was caring, kind, and compassionate with these children and that he "stuck up" for them if they were picked on by other children. Additionally, Ms. Elliott said that girls liked STUDENT and that he had friendships that endured from seventh to eighth grade. Ms. Elliott said that she had a good relationship with STUDENT.

Mr. McTighe, STUDENT's therapist since June 1996, testified that he believed STUDENT would consider their relationship very important, at least before he was placed in Summit. Mr. McTighe also said that although STUDENT tended to associate with dangerous kids when he lived at home, he associated with the kids who were motivated to turn their lives around when he was at juvenile hall. He said that the juvenile hall kids care for STUDENT and that he cares for them, because all he asks of them is trust. Again, this indicates an ability to build healthy new relationships. Although these friendships are with other kids who are incarcerated, STUDENT has chosen as friends those kids who aim to better themselves.

Sandi Harris, STUDENT's RSP teacher at Concord, said that STUDENT maintained his friends from Clayton Valley and that he was eager to go out to lunch with them. She stated that he had friends in class as well. Ms. Harris testified that she and STUDENT had a good relationship and, during the hearing, a letter dated February 2, 1997, from STUDENT to Ms. Harris was produced in which STUDENT indicated his affection for her:

I got your letter today. I do not know if my mom told you I just got out of Juvie & I am know [sic] in a program. The program is called Summit. Its a alright program. . . . You know Mrs. Harris, I miss your class. You really helped me out through all of this. I know you don't just go over to anyone's house to test them & kickit & chat with them. . . .

. . . .

I seriously wish I would have stuck to business instead of making a fool of myself. But I can't change that know [sic] can I. You wanta know something. I do not regret anything I've done. Its made me a stronger person. Out of all people I know you understand.

. . . .

I'm glad that you saw your mom over the holidays it must have been hella cool.

Love, STUDENT (Dist. Exh. 81.)

Considering all the evidence of friendships and relationships that STUDENT has created and maintained, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not suffer an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.(Footnote 9) Therefore, STUDENT is not seriously emotionally disturbed under the category of an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.

II. Does STUDENT require a residential placement to receive a free appropriate public education?

Both federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a free appropriate public education that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.1; California Education Code § 56000. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards and are provided at public expense and in conformity with an appropriate individualized education program (IEP). 34 C.F.R. § 300.8.

"Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability, whose educational needs cannot be met in a regular education program with modifications. 34 C.F.R. § 300.17(a)(1); California Education Code § 56031. This includes instruction at home or in hospitals and institutions. 34 C.F.R. § 300.17(a)(1).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the Supreme Court decided the appropriate level of instruction and services that must be provided to students with disabilities in order to satisfy the IDEA. The Court held that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." 458 U.S. 175, 200.

According to Rowley, the District need not provide such services as to maximize a student's benefit from special education. The Hearing Officer notes that a special education student may require a residential placement even if he is not seriously emotionally disturbed if there is another basis for finding that it is necessary. However, a school district is not required to provide a residential placement that is not educationally necessary. Sequoia Union High School District (N.D. Cal. 1987) 559 EHLR 133.

STUDENT is not entitled to a residential placement because his apparent need for one is unrelated to his disability (a learning disability probably brought on by ADHD). His residence needs arise from an oppositional defiant disorder or a conduct disorder, substance abuse, and related truancy -- problems special education does not purport to remedy. STUDENT is clearly troubled, but the trouble does not arise from his qualifying learning disability or from any cause intertwined with that disability. Therefore, this is not a case of mixed causation -- of a learning disability and conduct disorder that cannot be separated. For this reason, Capistrano Unified School District v. Jeremy Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884 (9th Cir. 1995), is distinguishable from the instant case. While in Wartenberg the Hearing Officer found that Jeremy's qualifying disabilities caused his conduct disorder and, therefore, could not be separated, here STUDENT's behavioral problems have not been shown to have been caused by his learning disability. They are separate. The District need not address problems caused almost entirely by behavioral problems, and is not required to provide a residential placement.(Footnote 10)

However, STUDENT's recent IEPs do not satisfy the standards set forth in IDEA and Rowley. They contain insufficient course work and academic substance. Additionally, while opposing a residential program on legal grounds and on the ground that such a program is not in STUDENT's best interests, Mental Health did acknowledge during the hearing that STUDENT needs psychotherapy as part of his special education. Mental Health also indicated that it stands willing to provide such services. The Hearing Officer defers to Mental Health's position. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires some mental health services, even though STUDENT is not SED and is not entitled to a residential placement. Ms. PARENT paid for Mr. McTighe's counseling services, and although no request for reimbursement for those services has been made, the Hearing Officer concludes that the respondents should arrange for those services to be offered to STUDENT in order to provide him with a free appropriate public education. STUDENT's recent IEPs do not contain mental health services because the District and Mental Health await STUDENT's release from the juvenile authorities. However, STUDENT is entitled to have a complete, current IEP.

Therefore, for the reasons set forth above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District and Mental Health must develop an IEP for STUDENT that contains sufficient academic substance and mental health services. Moreover, because STUDENT is 16 years old, the IEP must include a statement of needed transition services for STUDENT's transition from high school to post-secondary education or the work world. California Education Code § 56345.1.

The Hearing Officer is not unmindful of the worry and anxiety that STUDENT's mother has suffered over STUDENT's experiences with the juvenile justice system and the financial hardship of providing services to STUDENT. On the other hand, the Hearing Officer recognizes that the special education system is not responsible for providing all the mental health needs of students. The Hearing Officer applauds STUDENT's efforts at becoming free of drugs and alcohol, while noting that the special education system is not generally responsible for remediating substance abuse problems. After carefully weighing all of the relevant evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is not SED under the federal and state regulations and that he does not require a residential placement in order to benefit from his special education.

ORDER

1. STUDENT is not eligible for special education services as seriously emotionally disturbed.

2. STUDENT does not require a residential placement in order to benefit from his education.

3. The District shall schedule an IEP meeting within 30 days of receiving this decision. A representative of Mental Health shall attend this meeting. At the meeting, the IEP team shall develop an IEP for STUDENT that includes an appropriate level of academic course work, mental health services, and transition services.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

I. Is STUDENT seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?

As to this issue, the Respondents prevailed.

II. Does STUDENT require a residential placement to receive a free appropriate public education?

As to this issue, the Respondents substantially prevailed; however, Petitioner succeeded in establishing that STUDENT requires a new IEP.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: April 28, 1997 _________________________________ Edwin Villmoare Chief Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. "Pet. Exh." refers to Petitioner's Exhibits, marked 1-18.

2.Dr. Nunno stated in his report that STUDENT "may also meet the criteria for SED because of an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, as well as the development of fears associated with personal and school problems," but he added that he did not have enough information to fully justify this conclusion. 3.STUDENT had indicated a desire to do independent study, but this would require dropping him from RSP eligibility. 4.Mr. McTighe testified that STUDENT meets all nine criteria for borderline personality disorder. However, the Hearing Officer notes again that this DSM-IV diagnosis does not automatically satisfy the legal SED criteria. In fact, Mr. McTighe indicates that one of the criteria STUDENT meets under borderline personality disorder is a "marked shift in moods." Therefore, this particular criteria weighs against a finding of serious emotional disturbance under the category of pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression because of the requirement of "pervasiveness."

Additionally, Mr. McTighe acknowledged that borderline personality disorder is generally a diagnosis reserved for adults. 5."Dist. Exh." refers to the District's Exhibits, marked 1-47, 50-52, 54-56a, 58-60a, 62-75, and 77-83. 6. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) describes "conduct disorder" as "a repetitive and persistent pattern of behavior in which the basic rights of others or major age appropriate social norms or rules are violated." Conduct disorder can include real or threatened physical harm to others, property theft or damage, deceit, and serious rule violations. DSM-IV, p. 85. 7.Dr. Nunno stated the diagnosis of conduct disorder was secondary to his diagnoses of borderline personality and dysthymic disorders. Dr. Nunno explained that the difference between oppositional defiant disorder or conduct disorder versus borderline personality disorder is that both oppositional defiant disorder and conduct disorder are behavioral disorders which do not necessarily indicate mental disorders, while borderline personality disorder is, in fact, an mental/emotional disorder. Dr. Nunno said that the job of the diagnostician is to "rule out" the existence of emotional factors when dealing with people with conduct disorders. 8. The DSM-IV is widely relied upon by parties to special education due process hearings to describe mental disabilities. 9. The fact that the criteria of borderline personality include "a pattern of unstable and intense interpersonal relationships characterized by alternating between extremes of idealization and devaluation" does not alter this conclusion. 10. The Hearing Officer notes that in residential placements other than juvenile hall (Sherman House, Family Life Center), STUDENT has acted in such a way as to be thrown out. (Testimony of Ms. PARENT.) It is likely that due to his extreme opposition to such "ordinary" residential placements (not ordered by the juvenile court), STUDENT would cause his rejection from any such residential placement ordered in any case.