California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 22, 2004
Student v. San Ramon Valley Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 394-04, SN04-00365, SN04-00394 · Hearing Officer Jessica Katz
San Ramon Valley Unified must provide 15 hours of math tutoring for a 2001 lapse; its 2003-2004 IEP offer is upheld.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A parent filed for due process against San Ramon Valley Unified School District. The District then filed its own case asking for a ruling that its 2003-2004 offer was appropriate. The student was 15 and in ninth grade at California High School. He was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability and had needs in written language, spelling, math, organization and attention. The parent argued that his goals were only "paper-compliant" and that he never truly mastered them. She asked for Lindamood-Bell instruction as compensatory education.
Hearing Officer Jessica Katz used the Rowley standard to review each period from February 2001 through the 2003-2004 school year. She found that the specialized core program at Iron Horse Middle School met the student's needs from sixth through eighth grade. She also found that writing new goals each year was proper because the goals reflected his present levels. There was one exception: from February to June 2001, the District stopped working on his annual math goal. That meant his program did not follow his IEP in math. Falling grades in eighth grade did not show a denial of FAPE, because the District had offered extra help that the parent turned down. The October 30, 2003 and February 11, 2004 IEPs were found appropriate and may be implemented. The Hearing Officer rejected the Lindamood-Bell request and ordered 15 hours of one-on-one math tutoring by a credentialed teacher, to be finished by August 1, 2004.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO separated a failure to implement one goal from an otherwise appropriate program. It also shows the Hearing Officer sizing compensatory education to a short violation period instead of awarding the private program the parent requested. Under Rowley, a student's lack of progress by itself was not treated as a denial of FAPE.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue 1. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a FAPE from February 2001 through June 2001?
The specialized core program met the student's needs in written language and organization, but the District did not implement his annual math goal from February to June 2001, which denied FAPE in math.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year?
The revised goals were properly based on present levels and seventh-grade standards; goals need not state teaching strategies, and the program was reasonably calculated to provide benefit.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year?
The program built on the Diagnostic Center assessment was appropriate; declining grades did not show a denial of FAPE because the District offered extra help that the parent declined.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Has the District offered and/or provided Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
The October 30, 2003 and February 11, 2004 IEPs, including resource English and math, a tutorial class, and counseling, were appropriate; promotion to ninth grade was proper.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. If the District failed to offer and/or provide Student with appropriate special education services, is he entitled to compensatory education for any loss of educational opportunity?
The student received 15 hours of one-on-one math tutoring by a credentialed teacher for the 2001 math lapse; the request for Lindamood-Bell services was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District's proposed IEPs dated October 30, 2003 and February 11, 2004 are appropriate for the 2003-2004 school year and may be implemented.
- Compensatory education. Fifteen hours of one-on-one math tutoring from a credentialed teacher with expertise in mathematics. Tutoring must begin within ten business days of the decision and be completed by August 1, 2004 unless the parties agree otherwise in writing. No more than two hours per week during the school year and no more than ten hours per week during the summer.
Total: 15 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; Honig v. Doe; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District
People named in the decision
- Charlene David, clinical director, private provider; witness for Student, Lindamood-Bell
- Dr. MaryAnne Wolf, expert witness for Student, Center for Reading and Language Research, Tufts University
- Alice Rector, speech and language pathologist; specialized core teacher; learning center director, Iron Horse Middle School
- Rebecca Ingram, assistant principal, Iron Horse Middle School
- Shawn Armstrong, teacher, Iron Horse Middle School
- Janet Terranova, resource specialist; academic assessor, California High School
- Duff Danilovich, assistant principal, California High School
- Dr. Jacqueline Cheong, former school psychologist; triennial assessor, San Ramon Valley Unified School District (former)
- Kristen Cavin, resource English teacher (credentialed special education teacher); described as world history teacher on witness list, California High School
- Judy Simkin, owner of tutoring center; witness for District, Learning Dynamics
- Denise Hibbard, assistant principal, Iron Horse Middle School
- Ken Slasor (also spelled Slazer), resource specialist for mathematics; resource math teacher, California High School
- Sandy Cline, resource specialist, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Douglas Mason, biology teacher, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- John Korsick, math teacher (Algebra I), California High School
- Damon Wright, school psychologist, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Karen Heilbronner, assistant director of special programs, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Leslie Schroeter, resource specialist; academic assessor (2000), San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Deborah Roof, psychological assessor (2000), San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Ms. Nassoura, specialized core special education teacher (seventh grade), Iron Horse Middle School
- Monica Baker, specialized core teacher (eighth grade), Iron Horse Middle School
- Diagnostic Center of Northern California, assessing agency, State Diagnostic Center
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Jessica Katz, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Danville, California, on March 18, 19, 23, 30, and 31, and April 1, 2004.
Petitioner/Cross-Respondent Student (Student) was represented at the hearing by his mother. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner San Ramon Valley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Kimberly Schulist. Karen Heilbronner, the District’s assistant director of special programs, was also present on behalf of the District.
The Student called the following witnesses: Charlene David, clinical director of Lindamood-Bell; Mother; Student; and Dr. MaryAnne Wolf, director of the Center for Reading and Language Research at Tufts University.
The District called as its witnesses: Alice Rector, speech and language pathologist and learning center staff at Iron Horse Middle School (Iron Horse); Rebecca Ingram, assistant principal of Iron Horse; Shawn Armstrong, teacher; Janet Terranova, resource specialist; Duff Danilovich, assistant principal at California High School (Cal); Dr. Jacqueline Cheong, former school psychologist for the District; Kristen Cavin, world history teacher; Judy Simkin, owner of Learning Dynamics; Denise Hibbard, assistant principal of Iron Horse; Ken Slasor, resource specialist for mathematics; Sandy Cline, resource specialist; Douglas Mason, biology teacher; John Korsick, math teacher; Damon Wright, school psychologist; and Karen Heilbronner.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed upon receipt of final written arguments and the matter was submitted for Decision.
ISSUES
1. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from February 2001 through June 2001?
2. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year?
3. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year?
4. Has the District offered and/or provided Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
5. If the District failed to offer and/or provide Student with appropriate special education services, is he entitled to compensatory education for any loss of educational opportunity?
CONTENTIONS
The Student asserts that the District failed to provide him with a FAPE by failing to implement properly his goals and objectives and by failing to provide him with individualized services from February 2001 through the 2002-2003 school year. The Student further asserts that the program offered during the 2001-2002 school year did not set forth specific strategies for remediation. The Student additionally contends that he regressed during the 2002-2003 school year and had requested that he not be promoted into high school due to the regression, but was promoted to California High School (Cal). The Student asserts that during the 2003-2004 school year, the District has not offered and provided him an appropriate program. Specifically, the Student asserts that his math and written language classes are not appropriate and that the tutorial program does not offer a remedial component. The Student’s overall contention with each year’s program was that the goals and objectives were just “paper-compliant.” (Footnote 1) The Student alleges that he never mastered any of his goals and objectives and should not have moved on to different goals and objectives until the previous ones were met. The Student requests compensatory education provided by Lindamood Bell (LMB) in the areas of math and written language, and an order permitting him to attend LMB for math and written language and attend Cal for all other subjects. The Student is requesting 180-220 hours of instruction in written language and 160-200 hours of instruction in math from LMB as compensatory education for the denial of FAPE from February 2001 through the 2003-2004 school year.
The District asserts that it provided Student with a FAPE from February to June 2001 and for the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years. The District asserts that its goals and objectives were appropriate and that Student made progress. The District further asserts that during the 2001-2002 school year, it implemented the goals and objectives from the previous school year because the parent had failed to sign and agree to the proposed goals and objectives proposed by the District. The District also asserts that for the 2003-2004 school year, it has offered and provided an appropriate placement and services to Student.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student is a fifteen-year-old freshman currently enrolled in California High School (Cal) within the San Ramon Valley Unified School District. He resides at home with his parents, sister, and three brothers.
Student moved into the District in second grade during the 1996-1997 school year. He was referred to the student study team (SST) in March of 1997 due to difficulties with attention and academic progress. A second referral was made to the SST while Student was in third grade because of concerns in the areas of writing, math, and handwriting skills. The SST recommended that Student be assessed for special education. Upon completion of the assessment, Student was found ineligible for special education. The parents elected to place Student at New Vistas Christian School for fourth grade and continued his enrollment though January of Student’s fifth-grade year, when he returned to the District. At the parents’ request, Student was reassessed for special education towards the end of his fifth-grade year.
Student was first identified as eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability in the spring of 2000, towards the end of his fifth-grade school year while enrolled at Bollinger Canyon Elementary School within the District. Student was found to have a processing disorder that contributed to his learning difficulties. His areas of difficulty were identified as inattention, distractibility, impaired short-term memory for digits, lack of concentration on mental arithmetic, and impaired short-term visual memory combined with poor visual-motor speed. Student was found to have significant strengths in verbal comprehension, perceptual organization, verbal abstract reasoning, expressive vocabulary, practical knowledge, long-term memory for visual details, and visual-sequential reasoning.
Because Student was to be enrolled at Iron Horse Middle School (Iron Horse) for sixth grade, the individualized education program (IEP) meeting was continued to August 2000. The IEP team agreed to place Student in a specialized core program at Iron Horse with Ms. Rector as his teacher. The specialized core program is for students with IEPs who need a little extra assistance. In the specialized core program, the same general education curriculum is taught at a slower pace with twelve to thirteen students per class, and the students have one special education teacher for English and history. Student also was placed in a specialized core mathematics class. He was in general education for all other subjects. On January 9, 2001, the IEP team reviewed Student’s progress and revised his written language goal.
Student achieved an overall grade point average (GPA) of 3.0 in the sixth grade and received all positive comments on his report card including that he was “a pleasure to have in class,” “excellent effort,” and “positive attitude.” The IEP notes that Student made progress on his written language goal set forth in the January 9, 2001 IEP.
An IEP meeting was held on September 6, 2001, at the start of Student’s seventh-grade school year. Mother did not agree with the District’s proposed goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year and refused to sign the IEP. However, Mother did agree to Student’s continued placement in the specialized core program and the continued implementation of the written language goal from the January 2001 IEP. Student did well at the beginning of seventh grade and received all positive teacher’s comments. His overall GPA from August 29, 2001 to October 26, 2001 was a 3.14. However, as the school year progressed, Student’s grades dropped to below a 2.0 GPA, and he received teacher comments such as “missing incomplete work,” “needs to improve attitude,” “needs to be prepared for class,” “absences affecting progress,” “in danger of failing,” and “needs to improve participation.” In November 2001, Student’s written language goal from the previous year was reviewed and the team noted that he had met all objectives in his written language goal by 75-80%. A subsequent IEP meeting was held on February 20, 2002, to further discuss Student’s placement and services.
On February 20, 2002, the IEP team discussed the development of a behavior plan because Student had begun acting out in class by calling out, making noise, and playing with his classroom materials. The District presented to Mother a proposed plan to have Student assessed by the Diagnostic Center in the areas of social and emotional development and to initiate counseling from county mental health. The team agreed to meet by March 30, 2002 to further discuss the program because Mother refused to sign the IEP. Mother also submitted additional comments as an attachment to the IEP document. In Mother’ss attachment, she indicated that Student was not making progress and she requested weekly communication, homework modification due to his attention difficulties, and copies of work samples. Mother later agreed to the Diagnostic Center assessment.
Further, during seventh grade, Student was on various medications for mood stabilization, attention, and focus. The District created a behavior support plan in March 2002 to address Student’s declining behavior. On April 9, 2002, an email was sent from the District to Mother. Mother responded on April 10, 2002. The letter addressed several areas of concern including an IEP meeting scheduled for March 28, 2002, which Mother had cancelled. This letter also addressed Student’s progress in the seventh grade, work samples, modifications and accommodations, and mental health services that Mother continued to decline. Mother stated that she had obtained private counseling services and did not trust the county mental health agency.
On June 4 and 5, 2002, Student was assessed by the Diagnostic Center of Northern California. The IEP team had asked the Diagnostic Center to assess Student to determine (1) the social and emotional factors impacting his academic performance and classroom behavior; (2) behavior strategies that would help Student; (3) ways to increase on-task behavior; (4) teaching strategies that would be most appropriate and helpful; and (5) the most appropriate learning environment for Student.
The Diagnostic Center made several recommendations including the development of a behavior intervention plan to remediate maladaptive behaviors, the continuation of medical treatment to ensure that medications were appropriate, participation in school activities or work with younger students to help bolster his self-esteem, participation in counseling or a peer-support group, a system to monitor Student’s on-task behavior, traditional classroom instruction with an interactive curriculum, the development of organizational skills to use during instruction, a clear written format provided on the chalkboard or overhead, the use of a word-processor, and the continued use of visuals, written instructions, and manipulatives. The assessment report recommended that large tasks be broken down and that checklists be utilized. The Diagnostic Center also recommended permitting Student to complete some of the homework in class and having it checked and teaching Student his own strengths and weaknesses.
On August 23, 2002, prior to the start of the 2002-2003 school year (eighth grade), the IEP team met to discuss Student’s placement for the upcoming school year. The team agreed to have Student continue his placement in the specialized core program at Iron Horse and developed a portfolio system to keep Student’s work and a student weekly reporting system. The team also agreed to meet in October 2002 for a full IEP meeting that would incorporate the Diagnostic Center’s recommendations.
On October 16, 2002, an IEP meeting was held. The parties discussed the District’s proposed goals and objectives and created a homework log that would be Student’s responsibility to bring to and from school, which would allow him to check with his teacher regarding homework for the day. The team also discussed the development of a whole-class behavior system. The team agreed that Student’s teacher, Ms. Baker, would develop a behavior system with the assistance of the school psychologist. Student’s proposed placement consisted of placement in the specialized core program in the areas of reading, writing, and math. Student also received classroom accommodations: flexible seating during tests, revised test directions, an assignment notebook, and pacing/sequencing on the word processor. Mother signed and agreed to the implementation of the IEP. The team agreed to reconvene to assess the success of the behavior system and homework log.
In November 2002, a student support plan meeting was held because Student’s scores on the statewide standardized testing, the Stanford Achievement Testing--Ninth Edition (SAT-9), were below the 35th percentile in reading, math, and language arts. Student also was suspended for one day in November 2002 for threatening to hurt another student. In December 2002, Mother requested a continuation of the IEP review to February 2003. Another student support plan meeting was held in March 2003 due to Student’s low score on statewide testing. The District recommended at the meeting that Student participate in the homework club and morning study hall, but Mother did not agree to have Student participate in either program. There was no IEP team review of the success of the behavior plan and homework log during the 2001-2002 school year because Mother had requested that the meetings be rescheduled.
In March 2003, the District sent a re-evaluation review form to the parents in order to conduct the three-year triennial assessment. Mother requested that the triennial evaluation be delayed until the start of the 2003-2004 school year. Mother indicated that she wanted to have Jackie Cheong, Ph.D., a school psychologist from Cal, conduct the psychological assessment. Dr. Cheong began her assessment of Student in September 2003. Janet Terranova, a resource specialist at Cal, conducted the academic portion of the assessment. Dr. Cheong left the District in October of 2003, and the District asked Ms. Terranova to complete the evaluation. Mother was concerned, however, about having an inaccurate assessment and requested that Dr. Cheong complete the assessment in spite of her employment with a different school district. Dr. Cheong agreed to complete the assessment and an IEP meeting was held on October 30, 2003 to review her assessment.
Meanwhile, on October 2, 2003, the District held Student’s annual IEP meeting and recommended that Student be placed in the resource specialist program (RSP) for written language. Goals were created in the areas of written language and behavior/attention. Mother refused to sign the IEP because the triennial assessment had not been completed yet, but she agreed to placement in resource and agreed to an organizational goal. Student helped create the organizational goal, which consisted of a folder system to keep track of his homework, class work, and work samples.
Dr. Cheong completed her assessment on October 24, 2003. She tested Student using the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III), Weschler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC), Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test (BVMG), Beery-Buktenica Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI), and Matrix Analogies Test-Expanded Form (MAT-EF), and through observations, work samples, and a file review. Student was very cooperative during the testing and the test results were considered valid. Student was found to be in the high average range for intellectual functioning, verbal reasoning skills, and nonverbal reasoning abilities. Student demonstrated relative weaknesses in short-term auditory memory and visual-motor coordination requiring accuracy and speed. Dr. Cheong noted in her report that his abilities deteriorated on complex tasks, such as writing, when demands were placed on his working memory for coordination and that his ability to process visual-motor information deteriorated when speed and accuracy were required. Dr. Cheong confirmed his attention problems and ADHD and found that his complex processing, behavioral, and attention problems hampered his high cognitive abilities. Dr. Cheong noted that his frustration regarding his school performance affected his behavior and his ability to coordinate the processing of information.
In regards to written language, Dr. Cheong determined that Student had skills in the low to low average range. His skills were found to be average in the areas of generating words within a category, combining sentences, and organizing paragraphs. His skills were low average in terms of his ability to correctly spell words presented verbally. Student’s overall math skills were in the deficient to below average range. Student had more difficulty on numerical reasoning and basic math including adding and subtracting. His math reasoning skills (i.e. understanding of numbers and concepts) were slightly higher. Student’s reading skills were in the low average to average range. He did well decoding words and inferring meaning from passages. Student’s oral language skills were in the average to superior range and his listening skills were in the above average range. Dr. Cheong found Student’s social, behavioral, and emotional functioning concerning. She reported that his results fell in the “clinically significant” range in terms of internalizing problems, hyperactivity, atypicality, and social skills and that he was in the “at risk” range for withdrawal. Dr. Cheong reported that Student was eager to do well in school but that once he experienced difficulty, he would either leave the room or become uncooperative if he did not like the task. His frustrations tended to overwhelm him at times and he would act out or blurt out in class. Additionally, he had difficulty regulating his feelings of frustration with peers and adults.
Dr. Cheong recommended that Student continue in a resource program; that he have accommodations including use of a calculator, word processor, and a spell checker; that the team develop a behavior plan to support his positive prosocial behavior with input from Student on the development; and that the District initiate a referral for AB 3632 mental health services for parent support because his attention, learning, and school problems required intense intervention.
On October 30, 2003, the triennial IEP meeting was held at the District. (Footnote 2) Based on the psychological assessment, the District offered placement in RSP for written language and math. A tutorial program and a psychological consult also were offered. Goals and objectives were created in the areas of behavior/attention, written language and mechanics, writing and spelling, writing process, math reasoning, and transitioning for the future. Mother refused to sign the IEP and asked for the continued implementation of the goals and objectives agreed upon in October 2002 and the organizational goal from October 2, 2003. Mother indicated that she disagreed with the proposed goals and objectives because she felt Student had never mastered the previous goals and objectives. Further, Mother refused to sign the IEP because there was no representative present from the SELPA. Mother did agree to work with the District regarding an AB 3632 referral to county mental health to have the family assessed for wraparound services.
The IEP meeting was reconvened to December 8, 2003, with a SELPA facilitator present. The District continued to offer the same placement and goals and objectives as offered on October 30, 2003. Mother agreed to observe a different math class because Student was struggling in his Algebra I class. However, Mother did not agree with the offered placement and goals and objectives. The IEP team agreed to meet again on January 13, 2004.
Following the December IEP meeting, Mother observed the resource math class and sent an email disagreeing with Student’s placement in that class. Student’s grades were distributed on December 16, 2003, with all Ds and Fs. Following the receipt of the grades and Mother’s classroom observation, Mother refused to send Student to school for a week.
On January 13, 2004, the IEP meeting reconvened and was again facilitated by the SELPA. The District continued to offer the same placement and services as at the October 30, 2003 IEP. The teachers reported on Student’s struggles and his poor grades. The organizational goal also was reported as unsuccessful because Student did not bring his folders to the class and continued to neglect to turn in his homework. Mother requested additional information regarding the wraparound services from county mental health, but continued to refuse to sign the consent to refer Student to county mental health. No agreement was reached and the IEP team agreed to meet again on January 28, 2004.
On January 28, 2004, the next facilitated IEP meeting was held. Mother declined the AB 3632 mental health assessment and informed the school psychologist that she had obtained private counseling services and would not require any services from the county mental health agency. The District continued to offer the placement and services from the October 30, 2003 IEP meeting, including the AB 3632 referral. Some discussion occurred regarding the use of a calculator as a tool for math and a word processor as a tool for spelling. Mother refused to consent to any accommodations in the classroom or for tests. Mother also continued to refuse to sign the IEP document or agree to the resource math class in spite of Student’s failing grades. The IEP team also discussed adding essays in English and history in order to measure the goals and objectives in written language. Mother requested the development of an additional spelling goal; the resource specialist agreed to draft the additional spelling goal. There was no agreement on January 28, 2004, and the IEP meeting was scheduled to reconvene on February 11, 2004.
On February 11, 2004, a facilitated IEP meeting was again held at the District. A new spelling goal was offered, in addition to the previous placement and services from the October 30, 2003 IEP meeting. Mother brought a letter to the District that stated all her reasons for disagreeing with the IEP and that she would be removing Student from the District. Her letter addressed her concern of Student’s lack of progress on his goals and objectives and future ability to graduate. Mother noted her concern regarding Student’s emotional state. Mother stated her appreciation for all the time put forth in the IEP meetings but that she was concerned about retaliation from the District; she indicated that she had sent letters to several local and State officials.
On February 18, 2004, Mother filed for due process on behalf of Student contending that the District failed to offer him a FAPE (SN04-00365). On February 24, 2004, the District filed a request for due process seeking a determination as to whether it had offered Student a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year (SN04-00394). Although the District asserts that it offered an appropriate program and services, it offered 105 hours each for math and written language from a District-selected agency with credentialed teachers on the first day of hearing.
Student did not attend any educational program from February 11, 2004 through March 27, 2004, when he returned to Cal for physical education (PE) and oceanography. On March 20, 2004, Student began attending LMB for three hours a day at the parent’s expense. (Footnote 3) The District did not agree to the transfer of placement. The District has initiated the student attendance review board (SARB) process because Student has not attended any core classes since February 11, 2004.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from February 2001 through June 2001?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) Federal and State law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000 et seq.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401 (8).) Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). (20 U.S.C. § 1412 (a)(5)(A).) The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] educational delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed and revised for each child with a disability. (Honig v. Doe (1988) 484 U.S. 305, 108 S.Ct. 592, 598; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345.) The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, special education and related services, and program modifications or supports for the school personnel that are to be provided to meet the child’s needs resulting from his or her disability and to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and be educated and participate with nondisabled children to the maximum extent possible. (Honig v. Doe (1988) 484 U.S. 305, see also 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.)
In Rowley, the Supreme Court determined the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student’s potential. (Board of Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176.) The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Id. at 200.) Additionally, as long as a school district provides an appropriate education, the question of methodology is left up to the school district’s discretion. (Id. at 208.) In determining whether the school district has offered a FAPE, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the district has offered the student a FAPE, the district is not required to place the student in the program preferred by the parents, even if the preferred program is likely to result in greater educational benefit. (Id.)
The standard for determining if the program provided Student a FAPE involves consideration of the following factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address Student’s unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.) (Footnote 4)
The Student contends that the District failed to provide him with a FAPE from February through June 2001 by failing to implement properly his goals and objectives and by failing to provide him with individualized services. Additionally, the Student contends that the goals and objectives were not measurable and that he had not actually mastered the goals and objectives as reported by the District.
The District asserts that it provided Student with a FAPE from February to June 2001. The District argues that its placement and goals and objectives were appropriate and that Student made progress.
Was Student’s program at Iron Horse designed to meet his unique needs?
Before it can be determined if the District provided Student with a FAPE, it is important first to understand Student’s needs from February through June 2001. There is no dispute that Student was eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability in the area of written language, that his ability to learn was impaired by a processing disorder, as well as a diagnosed attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and that at times he exhibited impulsivity, oppositional behavior, and anxiety. The parties agree that Student had very high oral skills and that he enjoyed learning.
In the spring of 2000 District resource specialist Leslie Schroeter assessed Student using the WIAT and the Woodcock Johnson Test of Achievement-Revised Edition (WJ-R). On the standardized testing batteries, Student’s reading and math skills fell within the average range. Student’s reading comprehension skills were in the high average range. Ms. Schroeter noted that his oral reading was fluent and passages read out loud demonstrated appropriate pausing for punctuation and good voice inflection.
Written expression was Student’s greatest challenge. He did not score well on his writing sample on the WJ-R because he did not use complete sentences. Ms. Schroeter reported that on both the WIAT and the WJ-R, he exhibited minimal writing efforts with little organization, no extension of detail, and weak sentence structure. He also had low spelling scores.
Student underwent a District psychological assessment by Deborah Roof in the spring of 2000. She administered the WISC-III, and Student achieved a verbal intelligence quotient (IQ) score of 121, a performance IQ score of 119, and a full-scale IQ score of 122. Ms. Roof noted significant strengths were found in verbal abstract reasoning, expressive vocabulary, practical knowledge, long-term memory for visual details, and visual-sequential reasoning. Ms. Roof found relative weaknesses in mental arithmetic, short-term auditory memory for digits, and short-term visual memory combined with visual-motor speed. At the time, he also exhibited many indications of inattention, hyperactivity, impulsivity, oppositional behavior, and anxiety.
According to Ms. Rector, Student had difficulty expanding his thoughts in his writing. He was very competent verbally but struggled getting his excellent oral vocabulary and thoughts into a logical and sequential final product. Additionally, Student had difficulty adding supporting detail to his paragraph construction.
From February to June 2001, Student was placed in Ms. Rector’s specialized core (a resource specialist program) for English and history, for 196 minutes a day. Student also was placed in RSP math. The specialized core program is a program that offers classes consisting of twelve to thirteen students where a student can work on the core curriculum in reading and writing over three periods a day, with the assistance of a special education teacher and a full-time classroom aide. In the classroom, the specialized core teacher is able to work on specific skills within the general education curriculum in an individualized manner and at a slower pace.
In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s main areas of academic need were written language and spelling, mathematics, and organization and task completion. It is undisputed that Student also needed and was provided classroom accommodations including a smaller class size, a one-to-six student teacher ratio, and slower-paced academic instuction.
Written language and Spelling
Student was placed in Ms. Rector’s specialized core class for English and history. Ms. Rector, the director of the learning center at Iron Horse, has been a speech and language pathologist for thirty years and has been employed by the District for the past eight years. She received her teaching credential and is licensed as a speech and language pathologist in the areas of clinical and rehabilitative intervention. Ms. Rector testified that she has spent her entire career addressing the area of language and that she had trainings in the specialized core program, in reading comprehension, and through literacy programs. She also participated in a District task force to write language arts benchmarks and a Bay Area writing project.
Ms. Rector testified that she had a good rapport with Student and that he is “full of sunshine” and had a good attitude in school. She explained that the other students respected Student and that he was a natural leader. She testified that he was a reluctant reader and writer and that she developed the goals to work on his specific areas of need in written language. She explained that the goals and objectives were developed based on Student’s District assessment in June 2000. A revised goal was created in January 2001 to assist Student on his written language deficits.
Student’s January 2001 written language goal was designed to address strategies of the writing process for a variety of purposes including: writing on command, grammar, mechanics, and spelling. Seven objectives/benchmarks were created to assist Student in meeting his goal:
(1) Given a grade-appropriate writing assignment, Student will combine sentences for fluency and thought with 85% accuracy as measured by work samples and teacher observation; (2) Student will demonstrate, through work samples or tests, the ability to construct sentences and paragraphs using correct punctuation, capitalization, grammatical structure, spacing, indentation with 85% accuracy; (3) Student will demonstrate through work samples and/or tests, the ability to use prewriting techniques to construct a paragraph with a topic sentence, supporting details and closing, using correct punctuation, capitalization and spelling form with 85% accuracy; (4) Student will demonstrate through work samples and behavior the ability to select and use prewriting activities including: outlining, mapping/grouping, researching, note taking with 85% accuracy; (5) given a topic, Student will construct an outline including: main ideas, supporting details, appropriate sequence of information with 85% accuracy as measured by work samples and teacher observation; (6) Student will use a variety of writing types such as autobiographical, report of information, persuasion, and cause/effect as measured by work samples and teacher observation and be able to attain a rubric score of 4-5; and (7) Student will demonstrate the ability to spell at the fifth/sixth grade level using sound/symbol recognition, sound blending skills and rote memory with 85% accuracy as measured by work samples, tests, and teacher observation.
Ms. Rector testified that the goal was designed specifically to address Student’s written language deficits. Ms. Rector explained that he was a reluctant reader and had challenges in written language and spelling. Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds Student’s placement in specialized core and goal in the area of written language were properly designed to meet his unique needs in written language and spelling.
Mathematics
Student was placed in specialized core for mathematics where he received individualized attention, a smaller class size, and a slower-paced general education curriculum.
The District initially created an annual goal in June 2000 in the area of mathematics. The District determined that Student had an inconsistent application of mathematical procedures and developed a goal to improve his math skills. His instructional objectives were in the areas of number concepts, multiplication, division, values, decimals, and fractions.
According to the June 2000 IEP document, the goal was specifically designed so that Student would benefit from resource support in the area of mathematics as new concepts and skills were introduced in middle school. The Hearing Officer finds that the placement in the specialized core program and the goal in mathematics were properly designed to meet his unique needs in math.
Organization and Task Completion
There is no dispute that Student had organizational needs in sixth grade. The IEP specifically required accommodations in homework and class work and stated that he needed specialized instruction. Ms. Rector testified that the specialized core class was specifically designed to meet his needs in obtaining organizational skills. It had a smaller class size, one-on-one individualized work, and a slower pace. Further, within the curriculum, Ms. Rector developed graphic organizers and other hands-on tools to help Student with organization in writing. There was also a binder-reminder system for all the students in her class so that the homework could be checked on a daily basis. Additionally, Ms. Rector testified that she developed curriculum regarding time management.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s placement was designed to meet his organizational needs. Ms. Rector implemented an appropriate program to assist Student in organizing and completing his work.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement was designed to meet Student’s unique needs in written language and spelling, mathematics, and organization and task completion.
Was the program reasonably calculated to provide Student educational benefit?
Mother argued that Student did not make any progress on his goal because it was invalidly measured. She further argued that he did not receive individualized services and the curriculum was “watered down.” The District argued that Student’s program was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit and it, in fact, did provide him with benefit.
Written language
Student was placed in a small classroom setting with a specific goal and multiple objectives to address written language. Each objective had reasonable benchmarks and the results were measured through multiple variables including teacher observation, work samples, and test results. Mother argued that the goal was not measurable and that Student had not mastered the goal as reported by the District. However, each objective was very specific for Student’s areas of need with multiple ways to measure progress and specific standards that Student was expected to achieve to make progress on the goal.
Additionally, although Mother asserted that Student did not make any progress during his sixth-grade year, the evidence submitted by both parties’ states otherwise. Student received an overall GPA of 3.00 during his sixth-grade year and received all As and Bs in Ms. Rector’s subjects. Additionally, in May 2001, Student took the state standardized achievement tests and scored in the average to above average range in areas of written language except capitalization and spelling. In September 2001, the IEP team met and determined that Student had made significant progress on the goal and objectives from sixth grade.
In regards to the contentions about individualized services and a “watered down” curriculum, Ms. Rector explained in her testimony that she worked on daily oral language (correcting mistakes in sentences), test preparation and how to work within time restraints, quick writes, and pre-writing activities. Ms. Rector explained that she spent much time working on the process of writing by creating Venn diagrams, persuasive writings, and organized hands-on tools to assist with organization. (Footnote 5) Ms. Rector also worked on Student’s spelling difficulties using discreet spelling and gave only ten words a week to learn and practice. Ms. Rector also testified that she utilized the general education sixth-grade curriculum but provided instruction at a slower pace. Ms. Rector testified that she worked on a one-on-one basis with Student and individualized the program to meet his needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that the placement was reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit in the area of written language.
Mathematics
Student was placed in a small-group setting resource math class with a specific goal and multiple objectives to address his needs in mathematics. Each objective had reasonable benchmarks and the results were measured through multiple variables including teacher observation, work samples, and test results. Mother argued that the goal was not measurable and that Student had not mastered the goal as reported by the District. However, each objective was very specific for Student’s areas of need with multiple ways to measure progress and specific standards that Student was expected to achieve to make progress on the goal.
He was also able to have more individualized attention and work at a slower pace than in a general education math class. Student’s report card indicated that he received an overall grade of B- in mathematics and that his teacher reported him to be “a pleasure to have in class.” In spite of his math grade, Student continued to test below average in mathematics on the statewide testing in geometry, computation, and rounding. (Footnote 6)
Although Mother asserts that Student did not make progress, the evidence shows that the placement was reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit. Student received the general curriculum in a small-group setting, individualized services, and had a math goal that was designed to meet his unique needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement was reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit in the area of mathematics.
Organization and Task Completion
Student was placed in a small-group setting for English, history, and mathematics where the teacher and an aide worked with twelve to thirteen students. Ms. Rector testified that Student was provided individual attention and that she worked on his specific organizational needs. Ms. Rector developed graphic organizers and binder reminders for homework. She also worked on several strategies to help Student with task completion including: rewards, positive reinforcement, help with time management, and a slower class pace to accommodate his attention difficulties.
Based on the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement was reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit in the area of organization and task completion.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement was reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit in the areas of written language and spelling, mathematics, and organization and task completion.
Did Student’s program conform to his IEP?
Mother argued that the goals were not properly implemented in accordance with the IEP. Mother argued that the District only tested Student enough times to show that he had met the goal appropriately, but there was no evidence or work samples to show that Student could actually meet the goal as set forth in his IEP.
The District argued that it implemented the placement and services in conformity with Student’s IEP. The District argued that it implemented the goal in the specialized core program as agreed upon in the IEP.
In June 2000, the Student’s annual IEP was held. Goals were developed in the areas of written language and mathematics. Review meetings were held in August 2000, when Student entered Iron Horse, and in January 2001. In January 2001, an IEP meeting convened and progress was reported on the goals and objectives. At the time, Student was reported to continue to struggle in the area of decimals and his homework completion had been inconsistent. However, a revised goal was created only in the area of written language, and there is no evidence that the previous mathematic goal continued to be implemented past January 2001.
Ms. Rector testified that she implemented the January 2001 revised goal in written language. However, there was no evidence presented that Student’s June 2000 annual math goal was implemented beyond January 2001. Although he was placed in a resource math class, no evidence was presented that his teacher worked on his specific deficits in mathematics beyond January 2001. Additionally, progress reports created in the fall of 2001, after Mother refused consent to goals proposed by the District for the 2001-2002 school year, reported whether Student had made progress on the 2001 written language goals, but contained no indication that the math goals had continued to be implemented. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District implemented his goal in written language but failed to implement his annual math goal between February and June 2001. For this reason, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s program did not conform to his IEP in the area of mathematics from February 2001 to June 2001.
Although Student was placed in a resource math class, because his teacher did not work on his annual goals, there was no way for her to measure his progress or inform Mother of his progress to determine if the placement was addressing his needs effectively. The purpose of annual goals and short-term objectives or benchmarks is to enable teachers, parents and others involved in developing and implementing the IEP to gauge, at intermediate times during the year, how well a child is progressing toward achievement of goals. (64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12471.) The Hearing Office finds that Student suffered educational harm because he did not have any goals and objectives in math from February through June 2001. The District determined that Student needed revised math goals and objectives at the beginning of seventh grade because of his decline on his statewide testing and his sixth-grade performance.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the program was designed to meet Student’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit but did not conform to his IEP in the area of mathematics from February 2001 to June 2002. The Hearing Officer finds that the District provided Student a FAPE in all areas but mathematics from February 2001 to June 2001.
2. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year?
As set forth above, the standard for determining whether the program provided the Student a FAPE involves consideration of the following factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address Student’s unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)
With regard to the 2001-2002 school year, the Student asserts that the District failed to provide him with a FAPE by failing to develop properly his goals and objectives and by failing to provide him with individualized services. The Student asserts that since he had not met his previous goal from sixth grade, he should not have had different goals and objectives for seventh grade. The Student further asserts that the goals did not provide specific strategies for remediation.
The District asserts that it provided Student with a FAPE and that the goals and objectives that it proposed were designed to meet Student’s unique needs based on his present levels of performance in September 2001. The District asserts that it implemented the goal from the previous school year because the parent had failed to sign and agree to the revised goals and objectives proposed for the 2001-2002 school year. The District asserts that Student continued to make progress during the 2001-2002 school year.
Was Student’s program designed to meet his unique needs?
Student’s unique needs for seventh grade continued to be in the areas of written language, mathematics, and organization/task completion. The District also identified reading and attention/behavior as areas of need in the September 6, 2001 IEP.
Mother contended that the program offered on September 6, 2001 was not designed to meet his unique needs because the District had not developed appropriate goals. Mother asserted that Student had not met his sixth-grade goals and therefore he should not work on revised goals and objectives.
On September 6, 2001, at the beginning of the school year, the IEP team convened to discuss Student’s placement and goals and objectives for seventh grade. The District continued to offer specialized core/resource for English and history and specialized core/resource math. The District also offered a curriculum assistance program five times a week in forty-four minute sessions to assist Student in areas where he was having difficulty and to work on his goals and objectives. The District developed proposed goals and objectives in the areas of written language, reading, and mathematics. Mother refused to consent to the proposed goals and objectives but consented to Student’s placement in specialized core.
Written Language
According to Student’s September 6, 2001 IEP, Student continued to struggle with descriptive detail and figurative language. He was beginning to understand the correct use of grammar and mechanics but had difficulty self-correcting his work. His weaknesses were impeding his work in the general curriculum.
Student was placed in the specialized core program for written language. Ms. Nassoura, a credentialed special education teacher, was Student’s teacher in seventh grade. She testified that she helped design the revised IEP goals and objectives that were offered on September 6, 2001.
The District developed two goals in the area of written language: (1) to develop strategies of the writing process to write for a variety of purposes and (2) to write with a command of the written conventions of English including grammar, usage, punctuation, capitalization, spelling, and handwriting. Several objectives were written for each goal to help Student further understand the writing process, paragraph and report writing, and basic conventions of the written language. Each objective was to be measured by work samples, teacher-made tests, and work samples.
Mother argued that Student needed to first meet the goal from the previous school year before moving on to the District’s proposed goals and objectives. Mother asserted that there was no evidence that he had met the previous goal because there were no work samples to prove that the District was accurate in its measurement of his progress. Mother argued that he could not move on to higher-level goals and objectives until he had mastered the previous goal. The District argued that it designed the revised goals based on his present levels of performance and his needs in September 2001 and seventh-grade standards and curriculum.
California Education Code section 56345 sets forth requirements in the development of goals and objectives. The District was required to develop annual measurable goals based on the student’s present levels of performance. (Cal Educ. Code § 56345; see also 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (a)(1)(A)(ii).) According to the evidence, the revised goals and objectives were developed based on Student’s present levels of performance, his progress during sixth grade, and the seventh-grade curriculum. As found above, Student had made progress on his sixth-grade goal, received As and Bs in his English and history class, and did well on his standardized tests. In comparing the sixth-grade and seventh-grade goals, the Hearing Officer notes that the revised goals were very similar to the previous goal but were developed for seventh-grade standards and curriculum and challenged Student more in the area of writing paragraphs and report writing. The Hearing Officer finds that the proposed written language goals were designed to meet Student’s needs in seventh grade. The goals were based on his present levels of performance and his seventh grade standards and curriculum.
Mathematics
According to Student’s September 6, 2001 IEP, Student attempted all his math problems and had a good fundamental understanding but he needed to strengthen his math skills. He needed to work on calculation and problem solving. The IEP noted that there was concern that pre-algebra would become conceptually more difficult for Student without support in building his thinking and problem-solving skills.
Student was placed in the specialized core program for mathematics. Several goals and objectives were recommended at the September 6, 2001 IEP meeting to address the following elements of math: understanding operations and processes of computation, using appropriate strategies and tools for problem solving, understanding functions and algebra at seventh-grade standards, and understanding the concepts of measurements, geometry, and spatial relationships. Six specific objectives were created to measure Student’s progress based on work samples and teacher-made tests.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District developed annual measurable goals in the area of mathematics that were specifically designed to address Student’s unique needs in mathematics.
Reading
Student was placed in specialized core for English and history. According to Student’s September 6, 2001 IEP, Student had difficulty with reading comprehension, which was evident in his class work and participation in his core-class reading activities. He had difficulty answering factual and interpretive comprehension questions based on his reading.
Several goals and objectives were developed to address Student’s reading needs including: reading for meaning using appropriate strategies, reading a range of complex materials for a variety of purposes, and reading for recreation. His objectives were developed to measure his progress based on student reading logs, student work samples, and teacher-made tests.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District developed annual measurable goals in the area of reading that were specifically designed to meet Student unique needs in reading.
Attention/Behavior and Organization
Student was placed in the specialized core program for sixty-three percent of his day. This program was designed to give him the individualized attention that he needed. He had a small class size and slower-paced seventh-grade curriculum. Student also was placed in a curriculum assistance program to help him with organization, task completion, and class work and homework completion.
In February 2002, when Student’s behaviors became concerning, the District developed a behavior plan to address his calling out in class and playing with classroom materials. A referral also was made to initiate counseling services.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District offered Student a placement that was designed to meet his unique needs in the areas of attention/behavior and organization.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the program the District offered on September 6, 2001 and the subsequent behavior plan offered on February 20, 2002 were designed to meet Student’s unique needs in all areas.
Was the program reasonably calculated to provide Student educational benefit?
As previously set forth, the District developed appropriate goals and objectives that were designed to meet Student’s unique needs. Mother contends that the program was not individualized and the goals did not provide strategies for remediation.
However, the evidence relating to these contentions establishes otherwise. In regards to individualized services, Student was placed in the specialized core program for English, history, and mathematics. He received individualized attention in a classroom with twelve to thirteen students from a special education teacher and a full-time aide. He worked on seventh-grade curriculum at a slower pace. He also attended a curriculum assistance class one period a day to help him with the core curriculum, his goals and objectives, and homework. Additionally, when Student’s behavior began to decline in the seventh grade, the District developed a behavior plan to work with him in decreasing his inappropriate behaviors.
In regards to strategies for remediation, Student’s revised goals and objectives that were offered on September 6, 2001, were based on his present levels of performance and his needs at the time. According to Ms. Ingram, the goals were developed based on his statewide standardized test scores, his progress on his sixth-grade goal, and his sixth-grade academic performance. Thus, the revised goals were remedial in nature because they were based on his levels at the time they were created. Further, there is no requirement that the IEP goals describe the specific teaching strategies that will be used to implement the goals. The Hearing Officer finds that the District offered a program that was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
Did the program conform to Student’s IEP?
There is no dispute that the IEP was implemented during the 2001-2001 school year as agreed upon by all parties in September 2001.
Based on all the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered and provided Student a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year.
3. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year?
As set forth above, the standard for determining whether the program provided the Student a FAPE involves the following factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address Student’s unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)
The Student asserts that the District failed to provide him with a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year by failing to properly develop his goals and objectives. The Student further contends that the District failed to provide him with individualized services and he therefore regressed.
The District asserts that it provided Student with a FAPE. The District asserts that the goals and objectives were developed appropriately and that Student received appropriate resource and behavior support.
Was the program designed to meet Student’s unique needs?
Mother contends that Student’s goals and objectives during the 2002-2003 school year were not properly developed to meet his unique needs.
Student underwent an assessment in June 2002 with the Diagnostic Center. Based on that assessment, the Diagnostic Center recommended that Student have more male role models and receive psychological counseling, more organizational help, and assistance in the academic areas in which he was weak.
On August 23, 2002, the IEP team convened to review the Diagnostic Center’s assessments and recommendations and develop a schedule for the 2002-2003 school year. Based on the assessment report and prior classroom performance, the IEP team identified Student’s unique needs at the beginning of eighth grade to be in the following areas: reading comprehension, math, written language, organization, and behavior. The team developed a portfolio system to keep copies of work samples for Mother to track Student’s progress.
On October 16, 2002, the IEP team reconvened to further discuss the goals and objectives and classroom accommodations. Goals were created in the areas of written language, reading, math, and behavior. Further, the IEP team recommended the following accommodations: flexible seating for tests, revised test directions, an assignment notebook for the staff and Student to complete, and pacing and sequencing of work with the word processor. Mother agreed and consented to the goals and objectives and the classroom accommodations.
Student’s written language goals addressed the use of strategies of the writing process, writing for a variety of purposes, writing techniques that clarify and enhance ideas and create voice, and writing with a command of the conventions of English including grammar, usage, punctuation, capitalization, spelling, and handwriting. Student’s math goals focused on use of the language of algebra, performance of operations with real numbers, graphs and linear equations and inequalities, and application of strategies in the problem-solving process. Student’s reading goals addressed reading comprehension and strategies to apply to the meaning of text, reading a range of increasingly complex materials, and reading for recreation and personal growth. Student’s behavior goal focused on decreasing his attention-seeking behaviors.
Student’s placement consisted of specialized core to address reading and writing for 440 minutes a week and specialized core for mathematics for 220 minutes a week. Additionally, because the Diagnostic Center recommended that Student be in leadership positions and advised that he needed male role models, Student had two periods in a teacher assistant position with Mr. Armstrong and Ms. Rector. On August 23, 2002, the team also developed a program for Student and the staff to maintain weekly reports and keep a bimonthly portfolio of Student’s work to show that goals and objectives were being met.
Thus, the evidence established that Student’s goals and objectives were based on several tools: the Diagnostic Center’s assessment, his previous grades and classroom performance, and his statewide testing. Additionally, the annual goals were measurable and had specific objectives in accordance with California Education Code section 56345. Further, when Student was not making progress, the District met with the mother to discuss additional services and to address his emerging needs. Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s program was designed to meet his unique needs. It addressed all areas of need both academically and socially. He had goals and objectives that focused on his deficits as well as on personal growth. The Hearing Officer finds that the placement was designed to meet Student’s unique needs during the 2002-2003 school year.
Was the program reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?
Mother contended that Student’s placement failed to provide him individualized services and he therefore regressed during the 2002-2003 school year.
As determined above, Student had supports and services in place that were designed to meet his unique needs. He had three core classes, a curriculum assistance class, and a teaching assistant class where he could work on additional areas of science that he may have missed during an earlier period science class. His core classes offered extra assistance from a special education teacher in a small classroom setting of twelve to thirteen students. The curriculum assistance class further supported his areas of difficulty. Additionally, Student’s teachers were communicating with Mother on a weekly basis via email regarding his progress and homework assignments. Student also helped to develop a homework log so that he could print out the daily agenda and assignments on a daily basis. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
Notwithstanding Student’s appropriate placement and services and goals and objectives, the Hearing Officer notes that Student’s grades and behavior declined during the eighth grade. For instance, while Student passed the eighth grade, his overall GPA was 2.143. Additionally, he was suspended several times during the school year for conduct that disrupted school activities or for threatening behavior towards other students and was ineligible for the class trip to Great America. However, in spite of his ineligibility, Mother transported Student to Great America. Furthermore, while he attended classes on a regular basis, Student turned in little or no homework or class work.
The Hearing Officer finds, however, that the District responded appropriately to the changes in Student’s needs. The District met with Mother in both November 2002 and March 2003 to offer Student additional individualized services including homework club and morning study hall because his SAT-9 scores were below the 35th percentile. Mother refused the additional services and Student testified that his “afternoons were his.”
Additionally, a behavior plan was recommended by the Diagnostic Center where Student, the teachers, and the family needed to work together. It was never agreed upon. His specialized core teacher, Monica Baker, developed a whole class behavior system and encouraged Student to gauge his own behaviors by writing down whether or not they were acceptable. Communication logs were created in eighth grade that were supposed to be taken home each day; however, the logs were not returned on a daily basis.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District proposed program was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit when it was created at the beginning of the school year. Additionally, further supports and services were offered when Student began to struggle academically and behaviorally during the course of the school year. Under California Education Code section 56345(c), the Legislature recognized that some students may not meet or exceed the growth projected in the annual goals and objectives of the student’s IEP. (See also 34 C.F.R. § 300.350) The Hearing Officer does not find that Student’s placement and services were inappropriate simply because Student failed to make progress as expected during the school year.
Did the program conform to Student’s IEP?
There is no dispute that Student’s IEP was implemented as agreed upon on August 23, 2002 and October 16, 2002.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement and services offered and provided by the District for the 2002-2003 school year offered Student a FAPE.
4. Has the District offered and/or provided Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
As set forth above, the standard for determining whether the program offered and provided the Student a FAPE involves the following factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address Student’s unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)
The Student asserts that the District has not offered and provided an appropriate placement to him for the 2003-2004 school year. Specifically, the Student asserts that the proposed math and written language classes are not appropriate and that the tutorial program does not offer a remedial component. The Student asserts that he should not have been promoted to Cal because he had not met his previous goals and objectives.
The District asserts that has it offered and provided an appropriate placement and services to Student for the 2003-2004 school year.
Was the program offered on October 30, 2003, designed to meet Student’s unique needs?
Before it can be determined if the District made an appropriate offer of FAPE, it is important to understand Student’s needs at the time of the offer. Student continued to have needs in the areas of written language, reading, math, and behavior. Student’s grades continued to suffer because he did not turn in his homework, so he needed organizational assistance. Student’s behavior both in and out of the classroom environment also had deteriorated, and the District was concerned that Student had psychological needs as well.
Mother contended that the goals and objectives that were proposed on October 30, 2003 are inappropriate because Student has not met his goals from the previous school year.
Based on Student’s triennial assessment conducted in September 2003, the October 30, 2003 IEP team developed goals and objectives in the areas of behavior/attention, language arts, writing, math, transition, and organization.
Student’s annual language arts goals are that (1) Student will write with the command of the conventions of English including grammar, mechanics, and spelling, and (2) Student will use strategies of the writing process for a variety of purposes. Each goal has a series of measurable objectives in mechanics, punctuation, spelling, sentence, and paragraph writing with the use of a variety of techniques. Student’s annual math goal stated that Student will understand and use number operations and the process of computation. This goal is to be measured by four objectives in the areas of multiplication, addition and subtraction of fractions, two-step word problems involving multiplication and division, and problems involving reading graphs and grids. Student’s behavior/attention goals are (1) Student will attend to instruction independently and appropriately, and (2) Student will self-monitor his learning and classroom performance. Each goal has measurable objectives and is to be measured by completion of assignments, teacher/student/parent ratings, and observations. Student’s annual transition goal is created to help him plan for options upon graduation from high school. The goal is for Student to utilize the resources, including the career center on campus, and complete career searches in addition to having one computer course at Cal. Student’s organization goal was continued from October 2, 2003. Student helped create this binder-reminder and homework-collection goal.
In addition to the goals and objectives, Student was offered resource for written language, math, and tutorial, as well as psychological counseling one time a week with consultation for the teachers, parents, and Student at the October 30, 2003 IEP meeting. Mother only consented to placement in resource language and an organizational goal that Student helped create on October 2, 2003.
The District convened six IEP meetings from October 2003 to February 2004 to work with Mother on the development of Student’s program. (Footnote 7) The District also requested Mother’s permission to make an AB 3632 referral to mental health for psychological/wraparound services, but she never completed the paperwork. Additional goals and objectives were offered in February 2004 in the areas of spelling and organization. Mother continued to assert that the goals and objectives were inappropriately developed.
Mother argued that Student should not have been promoted because he has not mastered his goals and objectives from eighth grade. She also argued that the tutorial program does not provide a remedial component, that it is just a study hall.
The Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives offered by the District on October 30, 2003, with subsequent revisions on February 11, 2004, is designed to meet Student’s unique needs. The District developed several goals to help Student work on his areas of deficit. The testimony established that the goals and objectives were created based on Student’s triennial assessment, his tests, school performance, input from his teachers, input from Student, and input from Mother. The goals and objectives were very specific and tailored specifically to address Student’s unique needs in all areas and his present levels of performance. The District conducted an extensive assessment to determine those levels and created revised goals that would be appropriate for ninth-grade standards. Dr. Wolf, the Students’ expert, also reviewed the District’s offer of February 11, 2004, and said, “the District should be commended,” and testified that the goals and objectives were appropriate. (Footnote 8) She also stated that the proposed program would be appropriate so long as the teachers were highly trained. In regards to Mother’s contention that Student should not have been promoted to the ninth grade, the Hearing Officer finds that Mother failed to present and evidence to support this argument. As previously found above, the District provided Student a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year. At Mother’s request, the triennial assessment was delayed to the start of ninth grade and a thorough evaluation ensued. Additionally, Student passed all his eighth-grade classes and was appropriately placed in ninth grade.
Mother also contended that the tutorial program did not offer a remedial component. However, the tutorial program was specifically offered to give Student additional help and remediation in his areas of deficit. Mother’s only argument was that the class was at 7:30 in the morning and that it was too early for Student. The Hearing Officer finds her argument unpersuasive and finds that the tutorial program was offered specifically for purposes of remediation.
Finally, the District was persistent in working with Mother to try to develop goals and objectives that would be agreeable. There were six IEP meetings held between October 2003 and February 2004. When it became obvious that Mother was not going to agree with the District’s offered placement, the District filed for due process in accordance with California Education Code section 56346(b).
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed goals and objectives for the 2003-2004 school year are designed to meet Student’s unique needs and that the District has offered Student a placement and services that are designed to meet his unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year.
Was the program reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?
Mother asserted that the proposed English and math classes are not appropriate for Student.
In regards to Student’s English class, Student was placed in the resource class of Kristen Cavin, a credentialed special education teacher. Ms. Cavin testified that there are twelve resource students who are her responsibility in a general education ninth-grade English class with a total of thirty-two students. Ms. Cavin worked very closely with Mother to implement the organization goal’s binder system to assist Student in completing his English homework. Ms. Cavin testified that she emailed Mother on a regular basis and if Student forgot his homework binder, she emailed Mother to inform her of Student’s homework. Ms. Cavin testified that she continued to implement the goals and objectives from eighth grade to work on Student’s deficits in the areas of written language, reading, and spelling.
As previously found above, the October 30, 2003 IEP is designed to meet his unique needs in the area of written language. Prior to Student’s removal by his mother in February 2004, Student had been placed in a resource class that provided individualized attention. Student’s teacher attempted to implement Student’s organizational goal to encourage him to do his homework. She also communicated with Mother on a regular basis to work on Student’s needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the English class is reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit.
In regards to mathematics, Student was offered resource math on October 30, 2003, but Mother refused to consent to the placement. The resource math class is taught by Ken Slazer, who has an emergency special education credential in the area of mild to moderate disabilities. Mr. Slazer testified that his resource math class has thirteen students and a full-time aide to work with students on a one-to-one basis. He explained that his course of study specifically addresses the needs identified in Student’s IEP. Mr. Slazer also testified that because many of his students have difficulty with turning in homework, he developed a policy to accept late homework for partial credit.
Because Mother did not agree to the resource math class, Student was placed in a slow-paced Algebra I class with John Korsick. Mr. Korsick explained that his class was a two-year algebra class to help students understand algebra at a slower pace. Because Student was struggling in mathematics and receiving an F, the December 8, 2003 IEP team recommended that Student be placed in a resource math class. Mother observed the resource math class but refused this placement after observing the class for approximately twenty minutes in December. Mother argued and Mr. Korsick agreed that the algebra class was too difficult for Student. However, Mother refused to have him placed elsewhere and was unable to explain why the resource math class was inappropriate.
The Hearing Officer finds that the proposed resource math class is reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit. It provides a small-group setting with a low student-teacher ratio where he could receive individualized attention to work on his deficits. Basic math skills are taught that would remediate Student’s deficits.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed English and math classes are reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit during the 2003-2004 school year.
Did the program conform to his IEP?
There is no contention that Student’s program has not conformed to his IEP during the 2003-2004 school year.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has offered Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year.
5. If the District failed to offer and/or provide Student with appropriate special education services, is he entitled to compensatory education for any loss of education opportunity?
Compensatory education is an equitable remedy to compensate a student for lost educational opportunity when the school district has failed to provide the student with appropriate special education services. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359 see also: 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii).) The Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education does not require that the student be compensated by providing day-for-day replacement for each educational day lost. “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief...designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” (Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1496, 1497 (9th Cir. 1994).)
The Student asserts that as compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide him a FAPE from February 2001 through the 2003-2004 school year, he should receive 160-200 hours (four hours a day) of intensive sensory-cognitive training in math in order to “manifest the ability to self-generate and self-correct mathematical computation and story problem tasks that are appropriate to the student’s age or school grade level” from Lindamood Bell (LMB). The Student also asserts he requires a minimum of 180-220 hours (four hours a day) of intensive sensory-cognitive training in phonemic awareness and symbol imagery “until the student manifests self-generating, self-correcting reading and spelling” from LMB. Finally, the Student asserts that he should attend LMB for his core subjects in the morning and attend Cal for PE and oceanography in the afternoon.
The District asserts that it provided Student with a FAPE, but that if the Hearing Officer determines that the District did not provide Student with a FAPE from February 2001 through the present he should receive 105 hours each of math and written language instruction from a program such as Learning Dynamics, or from a credentialed teacher for two hours a week after school and ten hours a week for ten weeks during the summer.
As stated above, the District denied Student a FAPE in the area of mathematics from February 2001 through June 2001. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that compensatory education is not warranted in the areas of written language or reading.
Dr. Cheong assessed Student in the fall of 2003 in the area of mathematics and found that his mathematic skills range from deficient to below average. According to Dr. Cheong, his performance on tasks that require him to add, subtract, multiply, and divide one to three digit numbers is unevenly developed and is weaker than his performance on tasks that require understanding of concepts and word problems. He scored low in numerical operations and math reasoning. John Korsick, Student’s math teacher, testified that Student struggled in math and that before he can work on algebra, he needs basic math and pre-algebra.
Judy Simkin, the owner of Learning Dynamics, and Dr. Wolf, the Student’s expert, testified that Student needs one-on-one tutoring from a credentialed teacher to make up his deficits. (Footnote 9) Ms. Simkin testified persuasively that students should not have more than two hours a week of tutoring after school and recommends no more than ten hours a week during the summer.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student needs compensatory education in the area of mathematics to redress loss of educational opportunity in mathematics from February to June 2001. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Dr. Wolf and Ms. Simkin’s testimony that he needs one-on-one tutoring by a credentialed teacher to work specifically on his math deficits as part of his compensatory education award.
The Hearing Officer finds Mother’s argument that Student requires LMB unpersuasive. Charlene David, clinical director of LMB, assessed Student in the area of mathematics. Ms. David has her bachelor’s degree in communication disorders and began working at LMB as an intern out of college, less than four years ago. However, she has had no formal training in interpreting test results, other than LMB training. Ms. David explained that it is not a requirement to have a teaching credential to work with students at LMB. She testified that LMB is individualized, yet she explained that the same program and teaching methods are used with all students. Additionally, while LMB tested Student in math using a series of tests, many of the tests were outdated as new revisions have been created. Based on the test results, as interpreted by Ms. David, a recommendation for services was created. However, Ms. David did not review any of Student’s educational records or speak with any of his teachers. While she did review his psychological assessment, she testified that she did not take that into consideration when making her recommendations. For those reasons, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. David’s testimony unpersuasive and that LMB is not necessary for Student to receive appropriate compensatory services.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no dispute that Student continues to have significant deficits in mathematics and that he is entitled to compensatory education in mathematics to redress the FAPE denial from February through June 2001. The Student does not persuade the Hearing Officer, however, that LMB would be appropriate. As explained above, it is a “one size fits all” program taught by uncredentialed teachers. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that Student needs one-on-one tutoring in his areas of deficit by a credentialed teacher who has expertise in mathematics as part of his compensatory education award. Because the Hearing Officer has found that Student was denied a FAPE in math from February 2001 through June 2001, the Hearing Officer awards Student a portion of the District recommended services--fifteen hours of one-on-one tutoring from a credentialed teacher. The District shall immediately, but no later than ten business days from the date of this Decision, begin to provide Student tutoring in math through a credentialed teacher with expertise in mathematics on a one-on-one basis. The District shall provide all fifteen hours of compensatory services by August 1, 2004, unless the parties agree otherwise in writing. Finally, the District shall provide no more than two hours per week of compensatory tutoring during the school year and no more than ten hours per week during the summer.
ORDER
1. The Hearing Officer hereby determines that the District’s proposed IEPs dated October 30, 2003 and February 11, 2004 are appropriate for the 2003-2004 school year and may be implemented.
2. The District shall arrange for the provision of fifteen hours of one-on-one math tutoring from a credentialed teacher who has expertise in mathematics. The District shall provide no more than two hours per week of compensatory tutoring during the school year and no more than ten hours per week during the summer. The tutoring shall begin within ten business days of the date of this Decision and be completed by August 1, 2004, unless the parties agree in writing otherwise.
3. All of the Student’s remaining requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507 (d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with the statute:
1. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from February 2001 through June 2001?
The Student prevailed with regard to implementation of mathematics goals; the District prevailed with regard to all other aspects of this issue.
2. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year?
The District prevailed.
3. Did the District offer and/or provide Student a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year?
The District prevailed.
4. Has the District offered and/or provided Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
The District prevailed.
5. If the District failed to offer and/or provide Student with appropriate special education services, is he entitled to compensatory education for any loss of education opportunity?
The Student prevailed insofar as compensatory education was awarded in the area of mathematics for the period of February through June 2001. The District prevailed with regard to the remainder of this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505 (i).
Date: May 22, 2004 ______________________________________Jessica Katz, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office
Mother continually used the phrase “paper compliance.” She believed that the District was just claiming that he had met his goals and objectives on paper, but that there was no evidence of this based on work samples or test results.
2 Due to the disagreement with the District on October 2, 2003, Mother contacted the special education local plan area (SELPA) for assistance in facilitating the October 30, 2003 IEP meeting that was scheduled to discuss the assessment by Dr. Cheong. According to Mother, the SELPA agreed to facilitate an IEP meeting but was not able to attend on October 30, 2003. Mother testified that the SELPA directed her not to sign anything without its attendance.
3 Mother had requested an independent study program on February 18, 2004.
4 Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal Educ. Code § 56031.) In this case, LRE was not raised as an issue, and therefore, it will not be addressed. Further, no argument was presented from either party that the District committed any procedural violations during the entire time in question. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will address only the substantive requirements of the provision of a FAPE.
5 A Venn diagram is an organization tool to help a student with idea formulation.
6 The Hearing Officer notes that although a placement must be “reasonably calculated” to provide a child with educational benefit, there is no guarantee of progress and a failure to make progress does not in and of itself constitute a denial of FAPE. 34 C.F.R. § 300.350; Cal Educ. Code § 56345(c).
7 From December 2003 through February 2004, all IEP meetings were facilitated by the SELPA.
8 Dr. Wolf has been a professor of Child Development at Tufts University for twenty years. She has conducted research and developed curricula for children with disabilities and on the importance of fluency and comprehension.
9 Ms. Simkin has been a special education teacher for thirty years with a specialty in speech and language. She runs a tutoring center in Danville that addresses all areas of deficits including mathematics. She reviewed Student’s records and determined that he needed remediation in mathematics.
