California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 18, 2001
Student v. Alvord Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 395-01, SN 395-01A, SN 395-01B · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard
Alvord Unified had no prior basis of knowledge of a disability, so a tenth grader's expulsion stands.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The case was bifurcated. This decision resolves only expedited case SN 395-01A. Non-expedited case SN 395-01B, on eligibility and FAPE, was ordered set for a separate hearing.
Summary
A tenth grader at Alvord Unified's Norte Vista High School was expelled after classmates reported that he had made threats of violence at school. He was a general education student. After the expulsion, his mother asked for a special education assessment, and the District found him not eligible. Through an education advocate, the student asked for an expedited hearing. He argued that before the October 25, 2000 incident, the District knew or should have known he had an emotional disturbance. That knowledge would have given him special education discipline protections. He relied on a fifth-grade teacher's 1996 referral to anger management counseling in another district. He also relied on a depression diagnosis made three days after the incident. The Hearing Officer heard the expedited issue separately and ruled for the District. His parents had not raised concerns in writing or asked for an assessment before the incident. His teachers described average to above-average work and almost no discipline history. No staff member had referred him to the Student Study Team. The 1996 referral was not in his District file and was five years old. No one received the diagnosis until January 2001. The District had no duty to search every general education student's file. The Hearing Officer denied the request to rescind the expulsion and set the separate eligibility and FAPE claims for a later hearing.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the 1997 IDEA "basis of knowledge" rule to a student disciplined before any special education referral. An old counseling referral, a diagnosis made after the misconduct, and a condition the student kept hidden did not count as prior knowledge. Without earlier warning signs, the student could be disciplined like any general education student.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue 1. Did the District have a basis of knowledge that Student was a child with an emotional disturbance (ED) disability before the behavior of October 25, 2000, which precipitated his suspension and ultimate expulsion from Norte Vista High School?
No basis of knowledge under any of the four statutory conditions: parents made no written concern or assessment request before the incident; Student's behavior and grades showed no need for services; no staff raised concerns through the SST/SAT referral system; a fifth-grade anger management referral from five years earlier and a depression diagnosis received months after the incident did not establish knowledge, and the District had no duty to search all general education cumulative files.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Student's claims in the expedited case (SN 395-01A), including rescinding the expulsion and removing it from his records, were denied. The non-expedited claims on eligibility and FAPE (SN 395-01B) were ordered set for hearing on the next available dates.
Key authorities
20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8); 34 C.F.R. § 300.527; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(j); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 48900(a)(1), 48900.7
People named in the decision
- Emily Capaceta De Rivera, fifth grade teacher (made 1996 anger management counseling referral), Jefferson Elementary School, Corona-Norco Unified School District
- Frank Macias, ninth grade algebra teacher, Alvord Unified School District
- Mary Elizabeth Young, ninth and tenth grade French teacher, Alvord Unified School District
- Theodore Devian, tenth grade algebra teacher, Alvord Unified School District
- Scott Gotreau, tenth grade world culture teacher, Alvord Unified School District
- Linda Tatum, tenth grade English teacher, Alvord Unified School District
- Elizabeth Ann Kurtz, director of pupil personnel services, Alvord Unified School District
- Sharon Nelson Smith, coordinator of child welfare and attendance, Alvord Unified School District
- Eloise Thompson, director of special education, Alvord Unified School District
- Tracy Bunz, assistant principal, Norte Vista High School, Alvord Unified School District
- Charles Stevens, assistant principal, Norte Vista High School, Alvord Unified School District
- Dr. Ralford Jones, school psychologist, Alvord Unified School District
- Dr. Ray Easler, school psychologist, Riverside County SELPA
- Mary Ricks, school counselor, Alvord Unified School District
- Ronald Bennett, Ed.D., superintendent (precluded as witness), Alvord Unified School District
- Sherri Smith, District staff member (motion to preclude testimony denied), Alvord Unified School District
- Madeline Newman Rios, certified Spanish language interpreter
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Riverside, California, on March 14, 16 and 20, 2001.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter, Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by education advocate Gil Navarro. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his parents, FATHER and MOTHER.(Footnote 1) STUDENT was present throughout the hearing.
Respondent Alvord Unified School District (hereafter, Respondent or the District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Nancy Finch-Heuerman. Also present on the District’s behalf was Eloise Thompson, director of special education.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: STUDENT’s fifth grade teacher Emily Capaceta De Rivera; District teachers Frank Macias (ninth grade algebra), Mary Elizabeth Young (ninth and tenth grade French), Theodore Devian (tenth grade algebra), Scott Gotreau (tenth grade world culture), and Linda Tatum (tenth grade English); Elizabeth Ann Kurtz, director of pupil personnel services; Sharon Nelson Smith, coordinator of child welfare and attendance; Eloise Thompson, director of special education; Norte Vista High School assistant principals Tracy Bunz and Charles Stevens; district school psychologist Dr. Ralford Jones; Riverside County SELPA school psychologist Dr. Ray Easler; school counselor Mary Ricks; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; SISTER, STUDENT’s sister; and STUDENT.
Due to the overlap in Petitioner’s and Respondent’s witness lists, Respondent did not call any witnesses, but cross-examined those witnesses called by Petitioner.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. On March 20, 2001, the parties presented their oral closing arguments. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE
Did the District have a basis of knowledge that STUDENT was a child with an emotional disturbance (ED) disability before the behavior of October 25, 2000, which precipitated his suspension and ultimate expulsion from Norte Vista High School. (Footnote 2)
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Several procedural matters were addressed on the first day of the hearing. First, the Hearing Officer bifurcated the expedited issue for hearing, as set forth above, from the unexpedited issues raised in Petitioner’s March 2, 2001 statement of issues. The expedited case is SN 395-01A. The unexpedited case is SN 395-01B. It raises issues of eligibility for special education and the provision of a free and appropriate public education by the District. Case No. SN 395-01B will proceed by separate hearing.
Second, the Hearing Officer granted the District’s motion to preclude Petitioner from calling District Superintendent of Schools Ronald Bennett, Ed.D., as a witness in this proceeding on the ground of relevance, based upon Dr. Bennett’s declaration that he had no knowledge of STUDENT prior to October 25, 2000. Similar motions, supported by similar declarations, relating to Tracy Bunz, Sherri Smith, and Ann Kurtz were denied, based upon the Petitioner’s offers of proof.
Third, the Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion to sequester STUDENT during the testimony of his teachers.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT first entered the District’s Norte Vista High School for ninth grade during the 1999-2000 school year as a regular education student. In September 2000, he returned to Norte Vista and began tenth grade.
On October 25, 2000, Norte Vista school staff began an investigation of STUDENT after several students reported that STUDENT had been talking about shooting and blowing up people at school for the past week. According to these reports, STUDENT stated that he had a gun tucked in his pants, that he was making a bomb, and that he was making a list of names. One student reported that STUDENT was writing names in a spiral notebook. When confronted by school staff, STUDENT denied having a gun. A spiral notebook, found during a search of STUDENT’s backpack, described his depression following his girlfriend’s decision to break up their relationship. It also included a list of the names of 87 students, as well as references to suicidal and homicidal ideation, and to a gun which STUDENT indicated he had brought to school. In one entry, STUDENT explained that he was “writing this to the parents of the students who died during my frantic rage.” STUDENT later clarified that the list of names were friends whom he did not intend to kill and that those he would kill would be random individuals.
Police were contacted and STUDENT was placed on a 72-hour psychiatric hold at Charter Oaks Hospital. No weapons or explosives were found during a search of his family’s home.
STUDENT was suspended from school based upon allegations that he caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person and made terroristic threats against school officials or school property, or both, as described in Education Code Sections 48900(a)(1) and 48900.7. He was subsequently recommended for expulsion.
On January 3, 2001, an expulsion hearing was held. At its conclusion, the hearing panel recommended expulsion.
On January 9, 2001, STUDENT’s parents received a faxed copy of the October 28, 2000 discharge summary for STUDENT from Aurora/Charter Oaks Hospital. The summary indicated that on discharge STUDENT’s diagnosis was depressive disorder, not otherwise specified (NOS).
On January 11, 2001, the Board of Education formally expelled STUDENT for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year based on a violation of Education Code § 48900(a)(1).
On January 31, 2001, MOTHER wrote to the District and requested that STUDENT be assessed for special education. The District thereafter assessed STUDENT and determined that he was not eligible for special education.
On February 27, 2001, Petitioner filed a request for a due process hearing on the basis that STUDENT had been expelled rather than assessed for special education and that the District had denied him a free appropriate public education. An expedited hearing was requested.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
STUDENT contends that the District had or should have had a basis of knowledge before October 25, 2000, that he was a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) disability based upon (1) his referral to anger management counseling by his fifth-grade teacher in a different school district and (2) his October 28, 2000 medical diagnosis of depressive disorder NOS. Essentially, STUDENT’s position is that his depression existed before the incident of October 25, 2000, and that the District had an obligation to carefully review his cumulative file as part of its “child find” obligation. In Petitioner’s view, if the District had done so, it would have uncovered his previous referral to anger management counseling which would, in turn, have triggered an in-depth review of both his emotional condition and his eligibility for special education. Petitioner requests an order rescinding his expulsion and removing all references to his suspension and expulsion from his school records.
The District contends that there are no facts to support a conclusion that it had a basis of knowledge that STUDENT was a child with an ED disability prior to October 25, 2000, because (1) STUDENT was in the tenth grade at the time of the incident which precipitated the discipline; (2) there were no behavior or performance concerns raised regarding STUDENT in the five years since the anger management referral, and (3) it did not receive the medical diagnosis of depressive disorder NOS until several months after the incident.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under federal and State special education law, students found eligible for special education are accorded certain rights in disciplinary matters. Among those rights is the right to a determination of whether the student’s misconduct arose from either a disability or from an improper educational placement. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5(a). In 1997, Congress amended the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) to extend the protections afforded to eligible students to some students who have not yet been determined to be eligible for special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1415 (k)(8); 34 C.F.R. §300.527. These protections extend to students not previously determined to be eligible for special education services only if the following conditions are established: (1) the student has engaged in behavior that violated any rule or code of conduct of the school district (the local educational agency), and (2) the school district had knowledge, or is deemed to have had knowledge, that the student was a child with a disability “before the behavior that precipitated the disciplinary action occurred.” 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8)(A).
A school district will be “deemed” to have had a “basis of knowledge” that a student was a child with a disability when one of the following four conditions is established: (1) the parent of the child has expressed concern in writing to personnel of the appropriate educational agency that the child is in need of special education and related services; (2) the behavior or performance of the child demonstrates the need for such services; (3) the parent of the child has requested an evaluation of the child(Footnote 3); or (4) the teacher of the child, or other personnel of the local educational agency, has expressed concern about the behavior or performance of the child to the director of special education of such agency or to other personnel of the agency. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8)(B). If the school district did not have a basis of knowledge that the student was a child with a disability prior to taking disciplinary measures, “the child may be subjected to the same disciplinary measures as measures applied to children without disabilities who engaged in comparable behaviors....” 20 U.S.C. §1415(k)(8)(C); 34 C.F.R. § 300.527 (d).
The sole purpose of this expedited hearing is to determine whether the District had a “basis of knowledge” that STUDENT was a student with an ED disability before he was disciplined. It is not to determine whether STUDENT satisfied the underlying eligibility criteria as a student with an emotional disturbance.
I. Did STUDENT’s Parents Express a Concern or Request an Evaluation for Him Prior to October 25, 2000?
STUDENT did not contend that his parents expressed a concern or requested an evaluation for him prior to October 25, 2000. Rather, he argued that the outcome of his discipline for the October 25, 2000 incident would have been altered if his parents had “known their rights” under the special education laws. The IDEA and the regulations provide protections for parents who are illiterate and do not know how to express their concerns for their child in writing and for parents who have a disability that prevents a written statement. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8)(B)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.527(b)(1)). There was nothing in the testimony of MOTHER, however, to suggest either that she could not express her concerns or requests in writing to the District or that she ever orally attempted to express any concerns to District personnel prior to October 25, 2000. In fact, the evidence demonstrated that MOTHER submitted a written request in English to the director of special education for an assessment of STUDENT approximately three months after the October 25, 2000 incident, on January 31, 2001.(Footnote 4) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no evidence to support a basis of knowledge by the District under either conditions (1) or (3) above.
II. Did STUDENT’s Behavior or Performance Demonstrate a Need for Special Education Services Prior to October 25, 2000?
Petitioner’s argument that the District had or should have had knowledge of his potential emotional disturbance disability is based upon a “Child Evaluation Form” dated June 11, 1996, completed by STUDENT’s fifth grade teacher, Ms. Rivera. This form was completed by Ms. Rivera for each of the students in her combined fifth-sixth grade class. On STUDENT’s form, Ms. Rivera indicated that STUDENT was referred to the counselor for anger management and that STUDENT was “well rounded academically. Often displays very immature behavior and has difficulty controlling his temper.” (Student’s Exhibit K-4). At the time this form was completed, STUDENT was attending Jefferson Elementary School within the Corona-Norco Unified School District.
Ms. Rivera testified that she considered STUDENT to be an unusually warm and emotional youngster who had sudden outbursts of temper that did not seem warranted and who would occasionally cry. While he was generally very respectful and courteous, his temper would flare up around other students. STUDENT had a high regard for his parents and would become particularly angry when anything remotely negative was said about them. To the best of her recollection, STUDENT had incidents of crying or anger on a weekly basis. Ms. Rivera testified that she referred STUDENT to anger management counseling following an incident in which STUDENT held another student in a headlock hold following the student’s derogatory comment about STUDENT’s mother. STUDENT kept the student in a headlock for approximately ten minutes. The other student was not hurt, but Ms. Rivera was concerned for his physical safety. Ms. Rivera testified that STUDENT attended counseling with a small group of students twice a week for an unspecified length of time, that he seemed receptive to counseling, and that it appeared to be working for him because incidents in her class decreased over the year. The 1996 Child Evaluation Form made no reference to the headlock incident.
Ms. Rivera testified that she never considered referring STUDENT for special education. Because STUDENT responded to the counseling, the severity of his behavior problems diminished and he was learning in class. Although she communicated frequently with STUDENT’s family, she did not mention special education to them. She felt fortunate that the counseling program was in existence that year and personally believed that STUDENT’s counseling should have continued. She did not recall if she ever referred STUDENT to the Student Study Team (SST), but indicated that there would be a record of this referral in the file if she had done so. Ms. Rivera had no contact with STUDENT after the fifth grade.
The Hearing Officer concludes that there was no evidence to indicate that the District had a basis of knowledge that STUDENT was a student with an ED disability based upon his behavior or performance before October 25, 2000. Petitioner argues that the District was not diligent in reviewing the cumulative files of all students in an ongoing effort to “child find” those who may be in need of special education. There is no support for this argument. There is no requirement that a school district conduct ongoing searches of the cumulative records of all of its general education students in order to establish that it does not have a basis of knowledge of a student’s suspected disability. Indeed, given the size of many school districts, such a requirement would be unduly burdensome.(Footnote 5) In addition, STUDENT’s referral to anger management counseling five years before the disciplinary incident at issue is legally meaningless in the absence of more current information that his behavior or performance demonstrated a need for special education services. Indeed, it is outside the three-year statute of limitations for filing requests for due process. Calif. Education Code § 56505(j). As discussed below, there is no evidence of any such incidents in the intervening years which would have given the District a basis of knowledge.
First, the evidence indicated that the District was not aware of the 1996 referral prior to October 25, 2000. STUDENT’s cumulative file was reviewed after the October 25, 2000 incident in preparation for the expulsion hearing.(Footnote 6) The 1996 “Child Evaluation Form” was not found during the review of STUDENT’s file and was first provided to the District by Mr. Navarro at STUDENT’s individualized educational planning meeting in March of 2001. (Testimony of Tracy Bunz, Mary Ricks, Dr. Jones)
Second, both school psychologists who testified, Dr. Jones and Dr. Easler, testified that the fifth-grade referral to anger management counseling by itself would not cause them to suspect that STUDENT had an emotional disturbance disability. Given the passage of time, such a referral would be significant only if it were coupled with more current behavioral or disciplinary problems. Dr. Jones testified that there was no indication in STUDENT’s cumulative files of similar behavior problems or counseling in the past several years. As a result, knowledge of this referral would not change his assessment methods or his recommendation of ineligibility. Dr. Easler testified that he would consider the 1996 referral to determine both whether STUDENT met the ED eligibility criteria and whether the District had a basis of knowledge. However, because there were no indications of behavior problems or referrals for discipline from the sixth through the ninth grade, in his opinion, it appeared that the anger management referral was an appropriate intervention. It would not suggest that the District had a basis of knowledge of a suspected disability.
Third, testimony was uncontradicted that STUDENT’s disciplinary history at Norte Vista prior to the disciplinary incident at issue was very minor. One witness characterized STUDENT’s conduct on campus as “almost exemplary.” (Testimony of Charles Stevens) From the beginning of the ninth grade until October 25, 2000, STUDENT received three detentions issued by teachers and attendance officers for minor issues (being tardy, failing to dress out). STUDENT was never referred to the administrative office for discipline. This evidence was reinforced by MOTHER’s testimony that STUDENT had no problems at school from the sixth grade through the eighth grade.(Footnote 7) Both MOTHER and her adult daughter SISTER testified that STUDENT had problems in the ninth grade following an incident in which STUDENT was the potential victim of a knife attack by a fellow student. According to SISTER, Mr. Stevens and Ms. Bunz were aware that STUDENT was nervous and crying when he learned about the possible attack. Mr. Stevens testified that he told STUDENT to contact him if he was having problems dealing with this situation. He saw nothing in STUDENT’s demeanor after the threat to cause him concern or to indicate a need to refer STUDENT to therapy. There was no evidence that STUDENT’s status as a potential victim was due to any inappropriate behavior or performance on his part which would suggest a need for special education.
Fourth, the evidence also established that there was nothing in STUDENT’s academic performance to suggest a suspected disability. STUDENT’s teachers testified that he had been an average to an above-average student in his class work. (Testimony of Mr. Devian, Mr. Gotreau, Ms. Young) One consistent observation by STUDENT’s teachers was that he did well on assignments he completed in class, but was not consistent in turning in his homework, which lowered his grades. (Testimony of Mr. Gotreau, Ms. Tatum, Mr. Macias, Ms. Young) While STUDENT received an “F” in one semester of English in the ninth grade, he earned a “C” after repeating English during the summer. Similarly, his teachers testified that STUDENT was not a discipline problem and was never referred to the office. (Testimony of Mr. Devian, Mr. Gotreau, Ms. Tatum, Mr. Macias, Ms. Young) Although he did not fit in with some students, STUDENT was observed to socialize and to work well with other students. (Testimony of Mr. Devian, Mr. Gotreau, Ms. Young) One teacher characterized STUDENT as a “loner” but interpreted this as self-reliance and was not concerned because STUDENT was able to socialize in class. (Testimony of Mr. Devian) STUDENT participated in class, worked with other students in small groups and seemed “very typical.” (Testimony of Ms. Tatum, Mr. Gotreau) STUDENT was not observed to be angry, to have temper outbursts, or to cry in his classes. (Testimony of Mr. Devian, Gotreau, Mr. Macias, Ms. Young)(Footnote 8)
Fifth, STUDENT’s own testimony provided the most compelling evidence that the District did not have a basis of knowledge of his potential emotional disturbance disability. STUDENT testified about becoming depressed after his girlfriend broke up with him in mid-September 2000. It was at this time that STUDENT made the journal entries describing “his frantic rage” as a way “to let go of” his emotions. STUDENT candidly testified that he kept all of his problems inside and never talked to a teacher or an administrator about his intense emotional feelings. He testified that “they would have no idea he was upset.” Although close to his mother, STUDENT never told her about his journal entries before the incident. STUDENT also testified that he did not have similar feelings of depression in the ninth grade and that he got along well with friends. He did have feelings of anger in the ninth grade as a result of the knife threat made against him by another student. He used a punching bag at home to release this anger. He used his journal entries as a way to let go of his anger and sadness.
Sixth, the fact that STUDENT was medically diagnosed with depression NOS on October 28, 2000, did not provide the District with a basis of knowledge of a suspected disability. It was undisputed that neither STUDENT’s family nor the District received this diagnosis until sometime in early January 2001. The Hearing Officer accepts Petitioner’s contention that his depression existed prior to the October 25, 2000 incident and was merely documented after that date. Nonetheless, as detailed above, there were no objective manifestations of STUDENT’s emotional condition prior to October 25, 2000, that would in any way have provided the District with a basis of knowledge of a suspected emotional disturbance. STUDENT’s own testimony, which the Hearing Office finds credible, supports this notion. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no evidence to support a finding that the District had a basis of knowledge of a potential disability based upon STUDENT’s behavior or performance prior to October 25, 2000.
III. Did STUDENT’s Teachers or Other District Personnel Express a Concern About His Behavior or Performance to the Director of Special Education or Other Personnel Prior to October 25, 2000?
The regulations specify that the expression of concern by teachers or other district personnel be done “in accordance with the agency’s established child find or special education referral system.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.527(b)(4). Witnesses testified that unless a parent specifically requested an assessment, the District’s child find or special education referral system was through referral to the Student Assistance Team (SAT), also known as the Student Study Team (SST). (Testimony of Ms. Thompson, Ms. Bunz) STUDENT’s teachers testified that they were familiar with, or had received in-service training on, special education referrals and/or had made such referrals. (Testimony of Mr. Devian, Mr. Gotreau, Ms. Tatum , Mr. Macias ) As indicated above, STUDENT’s teachers never expressed a concern about his emotional condition, his behavior or performance to the director of special education or other personnel before the October incident or even considered referring him to the SST/SAT. (Testimony of Mr. Devian, Mr. Gotreau, Ms. Tatum, Mr. Macias, Ms. Young). Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no evidence to support a finding that the District had a basis of knowledge of a potential disability based upon expressions of concern by STUDENT’s teachers or other district personnel.
* * * *
For the reasons outlined above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the evidence failed to demonstrate that the District had a “basis of knowledge” that STUDENT was a student with an emotional disturbance disability under any of the four knowledge categories. Accordingly, there is no basis under federal or state special education law to rescind STUDENT’s expulsion.
ORDER
1. Petitioner’s claims for relief in SN 395-01A, the expedited hearing, are denied.
2. Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief in SN 395-01B, the unexpedited hearing, shall be placed on calendar for hearing on the next available dates.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
On the sole issue raised, the Respondent prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: April 18, 2001 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: Madeline Newman Rios was sworn in at the hearing as the Spanish language interpreter for STUDENT’s parents. Ms. Rios is a certified Spanish language interpreter in federal district and state court. Her administrative hearing interpreter certificate number is 0608985. Footnote 2: At the outset of the hearing, the parties stipulated that October 25, 2000, was the date of the behavior that led to STUDENT’s suspension and ultimate expulsion. Emotional disturbance was the only potential basis of special education eligibility raised by the Petitioner at the expedited hearing. Footnote 3: California uses the word “assessment” to refer generally to what the IDEA terms “evaluation.” Footnote 4: MOTHER requested that the District conduct an assessment of STUDENT in the following areas of suspected disability: “academic; speech and motor skills; S.E.D.; ADD & ADHD.” In response to this request, the District assessed STUDENT for special education after his expulsion. Because the District withdrew all of its exhibits related to this assessment as outside the relevant time frame, the Hearing Officer is unaware of the areas assessed. School psychologist Dr. Jones testified that, based upon the results of the assessment, it was determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. Petitioner may challenge this eligibility determination in SN 395-01B. Footnote 5: Assistant principal Charles Stevens testified that Norte Vista High School alone has approximately 2,150 students Footnote 6: Where a student is actually facing expulsion, a review of the cumulative file is appropriate and such a review was performed for STUDENT’s expulsion hearing. District director of special education Eloise Thompson testified that there is always a cumulative record review undertaken for students who are pending an expulsion and have not previously been identified as students with a disability. If the file review indicates that there is some reason to suspect that the student may have a disability, the expulsion process is placed on hold until there is a determination of whether it rises to the level that there was a basis of knowledge. In some cases, based upon that review, the expulsion may be altogether halted. Footnote 7: By contrast, MOTHER testified that STUDENT had frequent discipline problems from the kindergarten to the fourth grade Footnote 8: In early 2001, STUDENT’s teachers were asked to complete a “General Education Teacher’s Report” for the special education department. (Dist. Ex. 14) The District was not on notice of the information contained in these reports prior to October 25, 2000. The Hearing Officer considered these reports only to the extent that they contradicted the testimony of teachers regarding their observations of STUDENT prior to October 25, 2000. No contradictions of significance were found.
