California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 10, 2004
Student v. Rocklin Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 401-04, SN04-00401 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino
Rocklin Unified provided a FAPE across three school years; student's accommodation, parent participation and reimbursement claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes these earlier rulings in the case: the Hearing Office's stay put order of October 23, 2003; the November 4, 2003 order denying the Student's motion to stay an IEP meeting; consolidation of the District's February 2004 filing; and denial of the Student's motion to disqualify the prehearing hearing officer. It notes no later appeal, remand or correction.
Summary
A 16-year-old tenth grader at Rocklin High School filed for due process in September 2003. He was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability, a visual processing disorder that affected his reading, writing and organization. In February 2004, Rocklin Unified filed its own case asking for a ruling that it had offered a FAPE, and the two cases were combined. The student claimed that from 2001-02 through 2003-04 the District failed to provide proper classroom accommodations, failed to carry out his goals, and limited his mother's part in the IEP process. The Hearing Officer identified six areas where he needed accommodations and found that every IEP addressed them. That held even when later IEPs reduced accommodations or required the student to ask for some of them, which built self-advocacy. Teacher testimony and about 130 detailed emails from resource teachers showed that the accommodations and goals were carried out. His uneven grades reflected his effort and his uneven use of the supports. The District never put in place the parts of the March 2002 IEP that the mother had signed, but this caused no harm. Sending her communication through the resource teachers did not infringe her participation. The only flaw was an August 2003 offer that left out an assignment planner. It was never implemented and caused no loss. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for Dr. William Merz's private assessment and all other relief.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley to accommodation disputes. The Hearing Officer measured each IEP against the student's identified needs, not against the parent's preferred list. He treated fewer, request-based accommodations as acceptable for a high schooler. He also held that a parent who does not disagree with a district assessment is not entitled to reimbursement for a private evaluation.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1A. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year by failing to provide appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives?
The September 2001 and March 2002 IEPs met all six areas of accommodation need and were implemented. The District's failure to implement the consented parts of the partially signed March 2002 IEP caused no prejudice.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1B. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year by failing to allow STUDENT's mother to participate in the IEP process to the extent required by law?
No law required attaching the prior district's IEP, and the new IEP included comparable accommodations, so there was no procedural denial of FAPE.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2A. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year by failing to provide appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives?
The October 2002, February 2003 and May 2003 IEPs were appropriate even with fewer or request-based accommodations. The resource teacher implemented the accommodations and goals, and uneven grades reflected the student's effort.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2B. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year by failing to allow STUDENT's mother to participate in the IEP process to the extent required by law?
About 54 detailed emails and three IEP meetings kept the mother involved. Parents have no right to unrestricted access to teachers, so participation was not seriously infringed.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 3A. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to provide appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives?
The November 2003 IEP was appropriate and the stay-put accommodations were implemented. The August 19, 2003 administrative offer did not meet the organizational need because it omitted a notebook or planner, but it was never implemented and caused no prejudice.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3B. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to allow STUDENT's mother to participate in the IEP process to the extent required by law?
Leaving the parent box unchecked on the goal pages, routing communication through resource teachers, and having one general education teacher attend the November 2003 meeting did not seriously infringe parent participation.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for an educational assessment performed by William Merz, Ph.D., reimbursement for tutoring services, and other remedies, including revised grades?
Reimbursement for the private assessment was denied because the mother did not obtain it out of disagreement with a District assessment. No other relief was awarded because the planner omission caused no loss of educational benefit.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- The District's request for a determination that it offered and provided a FAPE for the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years was granted, except that the August 19, 2003 administrative offer of placement failed to provide for a notebook or planner.
- All of the Student's requests for relief were denied, including reimbursement for Dr. Merz's assessment and for tutoring, and revised grades.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range Sch. Dist.; School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Thomas v. Cincinnati Bd. of Educ.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b)
People named in the decision
- Debra Hawkins, principal, Rocklin High School
- Jan Lucas, director of special education, Rocklin Unified School District
- William R. Merz, Ph.D., private psychologist; expert witness for Student, Private practice; California State University Sacramento
- Michelle Fitzpatrick, general education and RSP teacher (ninth-grade case carrier), Rocklin High School
- Paul Morrison, biology teacher, Rocklin High School
- Michael Trejo, math (geometry) teacher, Rocklin High School
- Cydney Rochford, RSP teacher, Granite Oaks Middle School
- Stacey (Stacy) Barsdale, school psychologist (2002 triennial assessment), Rocklin Unified School District
- Michael Melton, principal, Granite Oaks Middle School
- Elena Dalfavro, school psychologist and program specialist, Rocklin High School
- Amanda Knipher (Kniphfer), language arts teacher, Rocklin High School
- Katie Ragan, language arts teacher, Granite Oaks Middle School
- Jean Kelley (also spelled Jeane Kelly), RSP teacher (tenth-grade case manager), Rocklin High School
- Matthew Ectman, science teacher, Rocklin High School
- Thomas (Tom) Farmer, math teacher, Rocklin High School
- Kevin Brown, superintendent, Rocklin Unified School District
- Dorothy Jacobs (Jacob), English/language arts teacher, Rocklin High School
- Rebecca Heath, graphic communications teacher, Rocklin High School
- Mr. Eckenberg, geography teacher, Rocklin High School
- Kristy Ramos, Spanish teacher, Rocklin High School
- Mr. Lacy, SEHO hearing officer who presided over the prehearing conference, Special Education Hearing Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on March 25, 26, 30, and April 1, 2, 13, and 14, 2004, in Rocklin, California.
Petitioner/Cross-Respondent STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented at the hearing by attorney ATTORNEY. (Footnote 1) Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner Rocklin Unified School District (District) was represented by attorneys Diane Marshall-Freeman, Anne M. Sherlock, and Cynthia M. Smith from the law firm of Girard & Vinson, LLP. Also present on the District’s behalf were Debra Hawkins, principal at Rocklin High School, and Jan Lucas, District director of special education.
The Student called the following witnesses: William R. Merz, Ph.D., psychologist; Michelle Fitzpatrick, District regular education teacher and resource specialist program (RSP) teacher at Rocklin High School (Rocklin High); Ms. Lucas; Paul Morrison, District biology teacher teacher at Rocklin High; Michael Trejo, District math teacher at Rocklin High; Cydney Rochford, District RSP teacher at Granite Oaks Middle School (Granite Oaks); MOTHER; and Stacy Barsdale, District school psychologist. (Footnote 2)
The Respondents called the following witnesses: Michael Melton, principal at Granite Oaks Middle School; Elena Dalfavro, District school psychologist and program specialist at Rocklin High; Amanda Knipher, District language arts teacher at Rocklin High School; Katie Ragan, District language arts teacher at Granite Oaks; Jean Kelley, District RSP at Rocklin High; Matthew Ectman, District science teacher at Rocklin High; Thomas Farmer, District math teacher at Rocklin High; Kevin Brown, District superintendent; and Ms. Hawkins.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Closing briefs were received by the Hearing Officer on May 10, 2004, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 3)
Issue 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year by (A) failing to provide STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives, and (B) failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the individualized education program (IEP) process to the extent required by law.
Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year by (A) failing to provide STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives, and (B) failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the individualized education program (IEP) process to the extent required by law.
Issue 3: Did the District deny STUDENT FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year by (A) failing to provide STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives, and (B) failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the individualized education program (IEP) process to the extent required by law.
Issue 4: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for an educational assessment performed by William Merz, Ph.D., reimbursement for tutoring services, and other remedies, including revised grades?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born [date redacted], is a 16-year-old student currently completing the tenth-grade at Rocklin High School (Rocklin High), a District school. STUDENT is currently eligible for special education and related services as a child with a specific learning disability arising from a visual processing disorder, which adversely affects his reading, writing, and organizational skills.
STUDENT was first found eligible for special education in May 1999 while attending fifth grade in the Pleasanton Unified School District (PUSD). In March 2000, STUDENT moved to the Mt. Diablo Unified School District (Mt. Diablo) while in the sixth grade. To address his specific learning disability, STUDENT’s Mt. Diablo individualized education program (IEP) team placed him in regular education classes with resource specialist program services and various accommodations. The accommodations, generally, included a “study buddy” for notetaking assistance, use of an assignment organizer checked by STUDENT’s RSP and by STUDENT’s mother, weekly progress reports from STUDENT’s mother to STUDENT’s teachers, the RSP to act as liason for communications between STUDENT’s mother and his teachers, modification of work, including but not limited to a fifty-percent reduction in math and science homework, tests taken in the RSP room, extra time on tests, science textbook available to take home or to listen to on tape in the RSP class, and book level alterations in English. Tests would be returned quickly to STUDENT’s mother.
STUDENT enrolled in the District in May 2001. In August 2001, he began attending the eighth-grade at Granite Oaks Middle School (Granite Oaks) for the 2001-2002 school year. His interim IEP dated September 18, 2001, states that STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability arising from a “sensory-motor disorder.” He was placed in regular education classes with accommodations. One goal with objectives was provided for writing multi-paragraph essays. The IEP also provided for RSP services in the “Learning Center” at Granite Oaks during 15 percent of the school day.
On March 14, 2002, District school psychologist Stacey Barsdale conducted a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT as part of his required triennial review. Her report notes STUDENT’s history of “Specific Learning Disability in the area of written language” and “significant processing deficits” identified “in the areas of visual processing and sensory motor skills.” Considering STUDENT’s first semester grades of “B’s” and “C’s” in his core subjects, Ms. Barsdale concluded that STUDENT continued to exhibit a visual-processing deficit with a weakness in sensory-motor skills but was achieving within his estimated ability level in all three areas of achievement measured. Ms. Barsdale recommended classroom accommodations including using a word processor, shortening written assignments for pencil-paper tasks, stressing quality rather than quantity, providing extra time, providing notes or tapes of lectures, breaking larger assignments into smaller parts with specific due dates, asking STUDENT to repeat directions and checking often for his understanding, and acknowledging that STUDENT may be more successful when demonstrating his knowledge on exams or quizzes orally rather than in writing.
STUDENT’s IEP team met on March 21, 2002, to develop STUDENT’s triennial IEP. Notes from the meeting state that STUDENT continued to demonstrate weakness in written language and organizational skills. STUDENT’s teachers considered him to be cooperative, “very capable,” and good at participating and following directions. Concerns were expressed regarding written language, not submitting work when due, and inconsistency of work completion. As a result, the District offered STUDENT placement for eighty-five percent of his school day in general education classes, twelve percent in RSP class, and the remainder of the day in a combination of RSP “pull-out/push-in” services. The March 21, 2002 IEP includes goals and objectives concerning written-essay structure/organization and concerning organizational skills for assignment completion, and it provides the following accommodations, separated into eight categories.
1. Grades – modified in language arts (writing); collaboration between special and regular education teachers in English/major assignments. 2. Behavioral support – preferential/assigned seating; use of assignment notebook or planner; assignment planner to be used as a home/school communication system. 3. Supplementary aids to support time in general/special education – note taking assistance (NCR paper); access to computer on campus; use of word processing. 4. Supplementary aids to support school personnel – consultation with Learning Center staff specialist. 5. Presentation of materials and instructions for tests/assignments – books on tape; assignments/tests modified to address identified needs of learning styles; shortened tests/assignments; questions on tests/assignments rephrased; preview of tests/assignments; visual aids, flash cards, maps, posters, clues, “ect.”; check for understanding. 6. Response to materials and instruction for assignments/tests – reduced/shortened written tests/assignments; extended time on in-class written assignments/tests; spelling errors not to impact grade. 7. Setting for tests/assignments – tests/assignments completed in the special education environment. 8. Timing/scheduling of tests/assignments – extended time of 10 minutes for every 30 minutes given to non-disabled peers; tests/assignments given in shortened time segments; extended time on written in-class assignments/tests.
MOTHER did not sign consent to the March 21, 2002 IEP at the meeting. Instead, she took the document home to consider it. She subsequently altered the March 21 document by making some written notations on the document. She then signed it, and forwarded it to the Granite Oaks principal with a cover letter dated May 25, 2002. The only such notations pertinent to this case are the addition of two accommodations under category 5 above, concerning presentation of materials and instructions for tests/assignments. Under that category, MOTHER added: “Test questions/assignments- given orally if necessary,” and “tests/assignments directions- read orally if necessary.” There were no notations affecting the goals and objectives.
MOTHER’s cover letter to the principal also mentions, among other matters, MOTHER’s belief that “STUDENT came to Granite Oaks with well-defined modifications” contained in his February 2001 Mt. Diablo IEP, but the modifications, paricularly with regard to math, were not being implemented by the District. In math, STUDENT’s homework grades were lower than his test grades, thereby resulting in an overall grade of “D.” MOTHER believed that the school was not providing math tutoring in resource class as needed and was not communicating with her concerning math homework modifications.
By letter dated July 8, 2002, District special education director Jan Lucas informed MOTHER that MOTHER’s notations on the March 21 proposed IEP invalidated the entire document and, consequently, the District intended to schedule a new IEP meeting shortly after the commencement of school in the fall. Because STUDENT would be starting the ninth grade, the District intended to have staff from Granite Oaks and from Rocklin High in attendance.
STUDENT commenced the ninth grade at Rocklin High on August 21, 2002. The IEP team met on October 16. According to the October 16, 2002 IEP, although STUDENT was “achieving within his estimated ability level in all three areas of achievement measured” and did not meet the “discrepancy criteria” for eligibility due to a specific learning disability, the IEP team maintained his eligibility because of his impending transition to high school. Notes on the IEP also state that although STUDENT was working steadily in his study-skills class, he “sometimes does not have the work with him that he needs to be assessed on or helped with.” Input from STUDENT’s high school teachers generally indicated that STUDENT had some initial problems turning in his homework assignments, but thereafter had been performing in a timely manner. His recent performance indicated to his teachers that few accommodations were necessary. Thus, the accommodations listed in the October 16, 2002 IEP were somewhat fewer than had been listed in the March 21, 2002 IEP. The new IEP also incorporated the March 21, 2002 goals and objectives and preserved STUDENT’s RSP support. Although MOTHER expressed her concerns at the IEP meeting with the accommodations and modifications offered, she signed her consent to the October 16, 2002 IEP.
By letter to Ms. Lucas dated February 20, 2003, MOTHER expressed concerns that STUDENT was “demonstrating a lack of anticipated progress since the last [October 16, 2002] IEP meeting” and that “the present IEP plan is badly flawed and is not addressing my son’s recognized learning disability.” She requested that an IEP meeting be held as soon as possible and noted that attorney ATTORNEY would be present at the meeting. Pursuant to MOTHER’s request, an IEP meeting convened on February 26, 2003. At the meeting, the team reviewed reports from STUDENT’s teachers. The meeting notes state that communication between home and school was a continuing problem in spite of extensive emails being sent home by the District. The notes also indicate that late, missing, and incomplete assignments were still a matter of concern. Several accommodations were added, and the document, labeled as “Addendum to IEP of 10/16/03,” was taken home by MOTHER for review.
MOTHER never consented to the February 26, 2003 IEP addendum. Moreover, by letter to Ms. Lucas dated March 20, 2003, MOTHER stated that she was withdrawing her consent to the October 16, 2002 IEP on the grounds that her consent “was based upon incomplete, inaccurate, and misleading information from the District.” Her letter also stated that she considered the “Tri-annual IEP” to now be in “full force and effect.” It is unclear from the record whether MOTHER’s use of the term “Tri-annual IEP” refers to the March 21, 2002 proposed IEP, as written at the March 21 meeting, or the version unilaterally altered and signed by MOTHER in May 2002.
Because of MOTHER’s withdrawal of consent to the October 16, 2002 IEP, the District began implementing either the altered or unaltered version of the March 21, 2002 triennial IEP. Testimony by witnesses and a letter by MOTHER dated April 25, 2003, confirmed that the District attempted to schedule a new IEP meeting, but MOTHER declined to attend an IEP meeting or to participate in a request by the District for a “Mediation Only Conference.” Instead MOTHER intended to defer attending such meetings until STUDENT had undergone private psychoeducational evaluation.
William R. Merz, Ph.D., conducted a private psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT in April and May 2003. His May 12, 2003 report indicates that STUDENT was referred to him by MOTHER chiefly because of her concerns that STUDENT’s learning disabilities were not being accommodated at Rocklin High, that the District was questioning whether STUDENT still had a learning disability, and that the District was beginning to blame STUDENT’s academic difficulties on lack of effort. Dr. Merz conducted extensive testing and records review. His findings were similar to District school psychologist Stacey Barsdale’s findings in her above-mentioned March 2002 psychoeducational evaluation conducted as part of STUDENT’s triennial review, and he stated that the accommodations listed in the altered version of the March 21, 2002 IEP were appropriate.
Upon completion of the private assessment by Dr. Merz, an IEP team meeting convened on May 19, 2003. Dr. Merz and MOTHER were present, and the District and STUDENT both had their respective attorneys present. Following discussions involving STUDENT’s eligibility, the team agreed to keep STUDENT eligible, but the team was unable to complete an IEP during the meeting. The parties agreed that the District would complete a proposed IEP and forward it to Dr. Merz and/or STUDENT’s representative. The District subsequently completed a proposed IEP bearing the date May 19, 2003, and forwarded it to Dr. Merz.
The proposed May 19, 2003 IEP states that “STUDENT does not meet eligibility criteria for special education services; however, for settlement purposes, the IEP team agrees to continue services” for STUDENT “as a Learning Disabled Student” with visual-processing difficulties. The proposed IEP also provided for RSP services with seventy-five percent of the instructional day to be in general education classes. Goals and objectives were written with respect to having STUDENT complete and submit his work by the due date, miss school only with a note from a doctor, and increase note-taking skills. An extensive set of accommodations was listed, with some variations from prior versions. The May 29, 2003 proposed IEP was submitted to Dr. Merz on behalf of MOTHER early in July, but MOTHER received no copy until Dr. Merz faxed a copy to her on or about August 19, 2003. MOTHER never consented to the May 19, 2003 IEP.
Meanwhile, the District sent MOTHER a notice of an IEP meeting for August 19, 2003. Although MOTHER canceled the meeting, notice of the cancellation did not reach all of STUDENT’s teachers. With STUDENT’s teachers present, school principal Debra Hawkins used the opportunity to meet and have discussions with the teachers concerning STUDENT. On the same date that District personnel met as described above, District special education director Jan Lucas submitted a written “Administrative Offer of Placement” to STUDENT. The accommodations listed on the administrative offer were the same as on the May 29, 2003 proposed IEP, except that use of a notebook or planner was not specified. District witnesses from that meeting all testified that no change to the placement, program, or services was made. MOTHER and STUDENT’s attorney, however, have consistently characterized that meeting as an unauthorized IEP meeting.
On the same date that District personnel met as described above, District special education director Jan Lucas submitted a written “Administrative Offer of Placement” to STUDENT. The accommodations listed on the administrative offer were the same as on the May 29, 2003 proposed IEP, except that use of a notebook or planner was not specified. The offer incorporated the goals and objectives from the May 19, 2003 IEP. Ms. Lucas testified that the administrative offer did not arise from the above-mentioned meeting, but instead was submitted because STUDENT needed a program and his representatives canceled the IEP meeting noticed for August 19, 2003. STUDENT’s representatives, however, asserted that the “unauthorized IEP meeting” held in their absence resulted in the specific provisions of the administrative offer.
STUDENT commenced the tenth grade at Rocklin High on August 20, 2003. Shortly thereafter, the District scheduled another IEP meeting for September 26 and sent MOTHER notice of the meeting.
The present request for due process hearing was filed on September 15, 2003. On September 17, 2003, the Student filed a motion to stay the scheduled September 26 IEP meeting. As his basis for the motion, the Student asserted that the primary purpose of the meeting would be to reduce or eliminate his special education services. The Hearing Office made no ruling on the motion, and MOTHER canceled the September 26 IEP meeting. On September 27, the Hearing Office placed the case “off calendar” by mutual request of the parties. MOTHER then canceled another IEP meeting, scheduled for October 1, 2003.
Meanwhile, following the filing of the Student’s due process hearing request, the parties were unable to agree on what the appropriate “stay put” placement should be. (Footnote 4) The Student asserted that the stay put placement should be the placement described in the March 21, 2002 IEP. The District asserted that because MOTHER had never signed the March 21, 2002 IEP but instead had invalidated it with her unilateral revisions, the last-agreed upon IEP for purposes of stay put was the District’s initial IEP dated September 18, 2001. The Student, in turn, asserted that the September 18, 2001 IEP should also include the documents from Mt. Diablo that the District had refused to attach. The Hearing Office issued a stay put order on October 23, 2003, stating that under State law, if a parent does not consent to all components of a proposed IEP, then the portion of the IEP consented to shall be implemented. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a). Thus, those portions of the March 21, 2002 IEP where no alterations were made constituted an agreed-to placement for stay put. Those portions where MOTHER made alterations were not agreed to, and thus stay put as to those provisions consisted of those corresponding services listed in the September 18, 2001 IEP.
Following issuance of the stay put order, MOTHER constructed a packet containing the stay put order with both applicable IEPs and gave it to Debra Hawkins for distribution to STUDENT’s teachers. In an effort to simplify and clarify the matter for STUDENT’s teachers, STUDENT’s tenth-grade RSP teacher, Jeane Kelly, sent an email to the teachers on November 3, 2003, listing the accommodations that were applicable pursuant to the stay put order. (Footnote 5)
The District then scheduled another IEP meeting for November 5, 2003, to formulate STUDENT’s program for the 2003-2004 school year. In response, the Student filed a motion requesting the Hearing Office to stay the IEP meeting on the grounds that “there is no justifiable reason for the District to schedule another IEP when the matter is still in Mediation.” (Footnote 6) Noting that an order staying an IEP meeting during the pendency of due process proceedings could contravene a district’s legal responsibility to schedule IEP meetings for the review and revision of IEPs as appropriate, the Hearing Office denied the motion by order dated November 4, 2003. (Footnote 7)
The District convened the IEP meeting on November 5, 2003 as scheduled. In spite of the District’s urging that they remain at the meeting, MOTHER and ATTORNEY left the meeting after protesting that not all of STUDENT’s teachers were present. The other members of the IEP team remained at the meeting and drafted the November 5, 2003 proposed IEP, which the District regards as its continuing offer of a “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year. The accommodations listed in the IEP are similar to the version in the May 29, 2003 proposed IEP, with some adjustments. The IEP includes goals and objectives for attendance and STUDENT’s taking responsibility for requesting support.
On February 24, 2004, the District filed its own request for due process hearing, seeking determinations that the District had offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years and that MOTHER had failed to cooperate with the District and thereby impeded the District’s ability to provide STUDENT with a FAPE. Upon motion by the District, the Hearing Office consolidated the District’s case and the Student’s case. A telephonic prehearing conference was convened with the parties by the Hearing Office on March 16, 2004, for the purpose of clarifying the issues presented for hearing and discussing other procedural matters. The prehearing conference order listed the issues presented for hearing and set time limits for the presentation of evidence. (Footnote 8) The present consolidated hearing convened on March 25. On April 13, while the presentation of evidence was still in progress, the parties became informed that STUDENT had passed the California High School Exit Examination (CHSEE), taken by STUDENT on February 3 and 4 in the regular education setting with no accommodations or modifications.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year by (A) failing to provide STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives, and (B) failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the individualized education program (IEP) process to the extent required by law.
Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). State law further defines the term “special education” as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services” that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, at 207-208.
To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district's proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs, provides some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314; 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8), § 1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. (Footnote 9)
(A) Failing to provide STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations
STUDENT asserts that the District denied him a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year by failing to offer and/or provide accommodations that were designed to meet his unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and comported with his IEP. In particular, STUDENT asserts that the accommodations listed in the September 18, 2001 IEP were deficient because they omitted some of the accommodations listed in the prior IEP from Mt. Diablo. He further asserts that the March 21, 2002 IEP, as altered by MOTHER on May 25, 2002, lists all the accommodations that he needed for a FAPE. Finally, he asserts that the District failed to implement the goals and objectives contained in the September 18, 2001 IEP. The District asserts that it provided STUDENT a FAPE at all times during the 2001-2002 school year.
The Hearing Officer will address the above contentions by first identifying STUDENT’s unique needs for the 2001-2002 school year. Thereafter, within the context of STUDENT’s objections to the District’s program, the Hearing Officer will determine whether the program offered and provided by the District met the substantive requirements for a FAPE by (1) being designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) being reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, and (3) comporting with STUDENT’s applicable IEPs.
1. Did the District offer a program for the 2001-2002 school year that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
a. STUDENT’s unique needs.
The parties generally do not dispute the overall nature of STUDENT’s unique educational needs. As discussed above, although STUDENT did not exhibit a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement on standardized testing, the parties agree that STUDENT had educational difficulties that make him eligible for special education and related services due to a specific learning disability. It is also uncontested that STUDENT needed various accommodations to address deficits related to visual processing. Those deficits were generally manifested by speed and accuracy problems in reading and writing and by poor organizational skills. The parties do, however, dispute the nature and extent of the accommodations required for meeting STUDENT’s needs and providing him with educational benefit. Therefore, to examine the appropriateness of the District’s program, it is first necessary to identify what will be referred to in this Decision as STUDENT’s “accommodation-related” needs.
One of the primary assessment documents available to the District when STUDENT enrolled at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year was the April 1999 psychoeducational report from the Pleasanton Unified School District (PUSD). By all accounts, STUDENT’s overall cognitive scores were in low average range and his educational progress was adversely impacted by his visual processing deficits. According to the PUSD report, STUDENT’s “ability to think and solve problems in nonverbal, abstract and conceptual terms was found to be in the deficient range of ability . . . 1st percentile. This factor measures ability to form abstract visual concepts without the use of words, and also ability to manipulate objects as well as perceive relationships between them. Mechanical skills, manual dexterity, speed and accuracy, are all reflected in this factor.” Additionally, compared with children his age, STUDENT showed weaknesses in perceptual alertness and visual memory, perceptual organization and alertness to detail, spatial visualization and abstract conceptualizing ability, assembly skills and perception of part-whole relationships, and visual matching and speed of information processing.
Other significant documents available to the District in August 2001 were the Mt. Diablo “School Vision Screening Report” dated January 12, 2001, the IEP from Mt. Diablo dated February 27, 2001, and the Mt. Diablo special education conference report dated March 29, 2001. As compared to the PUSD psychoeducational report from 1999, the Mt. Diablo documents were particularly significant because they revealed more recent impressions of STUDENT’s needs as demonstrated within the school environment.
The Mt. Diablo vision-screening report states that STUDENT had an “outward turn left eye” and problems with vision fusion. School staff reported observing complaints and behaviors of STUDENT that included “headaches, print blurs after reading a short time, loses place often when reading, short attention span in reading or copying, frequently omits words, rereads or skips lines unknowingly, becomes tired and sleepy while reading, avoids close work, but does reasonably well verbally, closes or covers eye, must slow down considerably to write legibly, has problems in copying from the board and makes many errors, rubs eyes excessively during or after short periods of visual activity.”
The February 27, 2001 IEP from Mt. Diablo states that “STUDENT’s visual learning disability interferes with classroom reading and writing tasks.” Present levels of performance listed adjacent to goals and objectives state that “STUDENT turns in many of his assignments late . . . STUDENT puts materials in backpack without regard to subject. He does not keep papers organized . . . STUDENT writes 80% of assignments in organizer with assistance.”
The March 29, 2001 conference report from Mt. Diablo lists accommodations that were being recommended by MOTHER, and, to a degree that is not clear from the document, consented to by Mt. Diablo. MOTHER was requesting a reader for STUDENT during his study skills class and a one-on-one instructional aide for one period each day, and Mt. Diablo indicated its interest in providing that accommodation during STUDENT’s daily study period. The aide/instructional assistant would “help STUDENT organize his assignments and give him necessary class notes from academics classes and read classroom reading assignments from daytime classroom materials.” The aide would facilitate the reporting of test scores to MOTHER and devote portions of STUDENT’s binder to that purpose. Preferential seating near the front of the class was requested. In math, STUDENT would do every other problem for homework but do all problems on tests. STUDENT would be given extra time on all tests as needed and could bring to his study skill period for completion. Books on tape either would be or had been ordered.
In addition to the above materials from PUSD and Mt. Diablo, STUDENT’s IEP team for the 2001-2002 school year eventually had access to the March 2002 psychoeducational evaluation report by District school psychologist Stacey Barsdale. Ms. Barsdale’s report states that on the WISC-III administered in March 2002, STUDENT’s verbal (99), performance (80), and full scale (89) IQ scores “suggest STUDENT’s overall intellectual functioning falls within the low average range, which is consistent with past testing. STUDENT’s verbal reasoning skills are considered average and are better developed than his non-verbal problem-solving skills, which are considered low average. STUDENT’s non-verbal skills have increased 10 points since his assessment 4-99. Results no longer suggest a significant difference between STUDENT’s verbal and non-verbal performance. The gap between the two areas has grown closer together.” The report states that on individual WISC-III subtests, STUDENT exhibited “significant strength on tasks which measure arithmetic reasoning involving sustained attention and concentration. Relative strengths were demonstrated on tasks involving rote auditory short-term memory and common sense judgment.” STUDENT “scored [112] in the high average range on the categories measuring freedom from distractibility (involving short-term memory and attention).” However, “significant weaknesses were demonstrated on tasks involving visual sequencing and understanding cause and effect relationships, non-verbal problem solving skills, spatial ability, and visual attention to detail. In the classroom, STUDENT’s weaknesses may manifest themselves in significant difficulties with the following: handwriting, completing a series of tasks, and following a sequence of instructions.”
Ms. Barsdale’s report further states that on the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI), STUDENT’s scores suggested average visual-motor integration skills. Previously, he had scored in the low average range. Ms. Barsdale suggested that STUDENT’s identified visual processing deficit “may be more evident when tasks are not structured or provided with specific guidelines (e.g. copying from the board, organizing thoughts on paper, ect.),” and that “STUDENT’s difficulties with pencil paper tasks are more significantly a result of his visual processing deficit and less significantly due to fine motor problems.” The report further states that academic achievement was measured by the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement – Revised (WJ-R/A). Broad Reading (107), Broad Math (90), and Broad Written Language (98) scores were in the average range (90-109).
Noting an improvement from the April 1999 Mt. Diablo assessment in the area of visual motor integration, Ms. Barsdale suggested that STUDENT’s identified visual processing deficit “may be more evident when tasks are not structured or provided with specific guidelines (e.g. copying from the board, organizing thoughts on paper, ect.),” and that “STUDENT’s difficulties with pencil paper tasks are more significantly a result of his visual processing deficit and less significantly due to fine motor problems.”
According to Ms. Barsdale’s report, one of STUDENT’s teachers noted limited effort by STUDENT in his school work and that he “gives up quickly.” The math teacher noted that STUDENT performed well on tests and quizzes but his grade was lowered because of missing homework assignments. Similar concerns were expressed by the science teacher with regard to homework and inconsistent motivation. STUDENT reported that it was hard for him to keep current with the homework and he was devoting 45 minutes to one and one-half hours per night for homework.
Overall, Ms. Barsdale concluded in March 2002 that STUDENT likely was continuing to exhibit a visual-processing deficit with a weakness in sensory-motor skills. She also found that, in the classroom, STUDENT’s weaknesses may manifest themselves in significant difficulties with handwriting, completing a series of tasks, and following a sequence of instructions. Accordingly, she recommended using a word-processor/computer to produce written work; shortening written assignments for pencil/paper tasks, striving for quality of work rather than quantity, or providing extra time when necessary; extra time when copying from the board or overhead, and providing a copy of the teacher’s notes, a student notetaker, or tape recording of lectures; breaking large assignments into smaller parts with specific due dates; asking STUDENT to repeat directions and checking often for his understanding; and, as appropriate, noting that STUDENT may be more successful when demonstrating his knowledge on exams or quizzes orally rather than in writing.
The Hearing Officer notes that the information about STUDENT in Ms. Barsdale’s March 2002 report was consistent with what had been available to the IEP team in September 2001. Ms. Barsdale’s March 2002 statement that “in the classroom, STUDENT’s weaknesses may manifest themselves in significant difficulties with the following: handwriting, completing a series of tasks, and following a sequence of instructions,” was consistent with how the prior assessment and IEP information available at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year had characterized STUDENT’s performance. Also, notes from the September 18, 2001 and March 21, 2002 IEP meetings document a continuing concern with missing homework assignments, either due to lack of organizational skills, motivation, or a combination of those and other factors. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s educational needs remained substantially unchanged throughout the 2001-2002 school year.
In summary, information available to the District at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year and the information obtained during that school year showed that STUDENT needed various accommodations to address deficits related to visual processing. Those deficits were generally manifested by speed and accuracy problems in reading and writing and by poor organizational skills. First, the Hearing Officer finds that because of those deficits, STUDENT needed an accommodation to address, at least in part, his deficits with visual acuity and image fusion. Second, he needed accommodations that would enable him to preserve classroom instruction and review the instruction at his own pace. Third, he needed accommodations that would enable him to understand and preserve homework instructions without having to rely on his limited note-taking skills. Fourth, he needed accommodations to address his slow work output with regard to completion of in-class assignments and homework. Fifth, with respect to slow work output, he needed accommodations that would allow him to express what he was learning by giving him sufficient time to take tests and also by giving him an opportunities, as appropriate to demonstrate his knowledge on examinations and quizzes orally rather than in writing. Finally, sixth, he needed accommodations to address his poor organizational skills, particularly with regard to performing, completing, and turning in his homework assignments.
b. The District’s program offer (2001-2002).
The Hearing Officer will now examine the District’s program offer for the 2001-2002 school year, as delineated in the September 18, 2001 and March 21, 2002 IEPs.
September 18, 2001 IEP.
STUDENT’s initial District IEP dated September 18, 2001, provided for RSP services in the “Learning Center” at Granite Oaks during 15 percent of the school day, and it also provided for accommodations. The accommodations listed in the September 18, 2001 IEP were that grades would be determined by the regular education teacher and modified in language arts; supplementary aids and services would include buddy/peer tutoring, notetaking assistance in the form of “NCR copies of notes,” word processor technology with spell check, calculator, preferential seating, and home/school communication system; support for school personnel would include consultation with specialists at the Learning Center; adaption of materials would include tape recording of required readings and altered/modified assignments/tests by reducing writing as needed; modifications of instruction would include extra time for written responses, shortened assignments/homework, check for understanding/immediate feedback, minimize auditory/visual distractions, encourage classroom participation, assignment notebook, and modified test-taking as needed utilizing “short answer,” “oral,” “open book,” “taken in special education,” “taken in regular education,” and “extended time.” As stated above, the Student asserts that the accommodations listed in the September 18, 2001 IEP were deficient because they omitted some of the accommodations listed in the prior IEP from Mt. Diablo. He also asserts that the version of the March 21, 2002 IEP altered by MOTHER on May 25, 2002, lists all the accommodations that he needed for a FAPE. The Hearing Officer will not engage in an analysis of whether the accommodations preferred by the Student are better than those offered by the District. Instead, the pertinent inquiry is whether the accommodations offered by the District in the September 18, 2001 IEP were designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs, as previously identified above by the Hearing Officer.
Comparison of STUDENT’s needs to the accommodations offered in the September 18, 2001 IEP shows that the offered accommodations addressed all six areas of STUDENT’s accommodation-related needs. Specifically, STUDENT needed an accommodation (1) to address, at least in part, his deficits with visual acuity and image fusion. The September 18, 2001 IEP provided for preferential seating. STUDENT needed accommodations that would (2) enable him to preserve classroom instruction and review the instruction at his own pace. In that regard, the IEP provided notetaking assistance. STUDENT needed accommodations that would (3) enable him to understand and preserve homework instructions without having to rely on his limited note-taking skills. The IEP provided for notetaking assistance, checks for understanding, and an assignment notebook. STUDENT needed accommodations to (4) address his slow work output with regard to completion of in-class assignments and homework. The IEP provided for peer/buddy tutoring, shortened assignments, reduction of required writing, word processing technology, use of a calculator, and extra time for written responses.
STUDENT also needed accommodations that would (5) allow him to express what he was learning by giving him sufficient time to take tests and also by giving him an opportunities, as appropriate to demonstrate his knowledge on examinations and quizzes orally rather than in writing. The IEP provided for extended time on tests, short answer testing, oral testing, open book testing, and the completion of tests in the special education setting (e.g. in the Learning Center). STUDENT needed accommodations to (6) address his poor organizational skills, particularly with regard to performing, completing, and turning in his homework. The IEP provided for shortened homework assignments and an assignment notebook. All of the above was supplemented by a daily period of RSP support.
In addition to the accommodations listed above that matched the identified areas of need, the IEP provided supplemental accommodations that also addressed STUDENT’s needs. Those accommodations included modified grades in language arts, home/school communication system, RSP consultation, tape recordings of required readings, reduction of auditory/visual distractions, and encouragement of classroom participation.
District RSP teacher Cydney Rochford testified that she wrote the September 18, 2001 IEP, and she believes that the IEP was appropriate. She stated that the IEP team understood that STUDENT had a visual processing and sensory motor disorder. She stated that in formulating the September 18, 2001 IEP, the team reviewed the information available from prior assessments and IEPs, and the team also considered input from STUDENT’s teachers concerning his performance during the first four weeks at Granite Oaks.
Ms. Rochford’s testimony and opinion was consistent with the documentary record and with the above discussion of how the IEP addressed each of STUDENT’s areas of need. STUDENT presented no expert testimony directly critical of the September 18, 2001 IEP. Having considered all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the accommodations offered in the September 18, 2001 IEP were designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs.
March 21, 2002 IEP.
The March 21, 2002 triennial IEP specifies twenty-three accommodations, separated into eight categories, as listed above in Background Facts. A detailed analysis of the March 21, 2002 IEP is unnecessary. Comparison of the accommodations listed in the March 21, 2002 IEP to STUDENT’s six areas of accommodation-related needs identified by the Hearing Officer, readily shows that the offered accommodations addressed all those areas of need. MOTHER has consistently maintained that the accommodations in her altered version of the March 21, 2002 IEP have been and remain the accommodations that STUDENT requires for a FAPE. As stated above in Background Facts, the only accommodation alterations were MOTHER’s notations of “test questions/assignments- given orally if necessary,” and “tests/assignments directions- read orally if necessary.” In the present case, those notations do not materially alter or add to the accommodations offered on the District’s original version of the March 21, 2002 IEP. The “oral” accommodations added by MOTHER were already effectively within the parameters of what the original version characterized as “Assignments/tests modified to address identified needs of learning styles.” Furthermore, the accommodations page contained a specific reference the concise list of accommodations as stated on Ms. Barsdale’s March 2002 report, and that list included her recommendation that STUDENT may be more successful when demonstrating his knowledge on examinations and quizzes orally rather than in writing.
Having considered all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the accommodations offered in the March 21, 2002 IEP, as initially written by the District, were designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related needs.
1. Was the District’s program offer reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that the accommodations listed in the September 18, 2001 and March 21, 2002 IEPs were appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs arising from his learning skill deficits. As the school year progressed, the effectiveness of the September 18, 2001 IEP accommodations was confirmed by STUDENT’s completion of the first semester with passing grades of “C” in language arts, “C” in algebra, “B-” in science, “B” in social studies, “A” in physical education, “A-” in Learning Center, and “A” in merit status. The accommodations offered by the District during the second semester pursuant to the March 21, 2002 IEP were even more extensive than the accommodations listed in the earlier, agreed-upon and successful IEP. (Footnote 10) Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that by appropriately addressing STUDENT’s learning skill deficits, both of the above referenced IEPs were reasonably calculated to, and did, provide some educational benefit. (Footnote 11)
3. Did the District’s program comport with STUDENT’s IEPs?
STUDENT asserts that the District failed to implement the accommodations from the September 18, 2001 and March 12, 2002 IEPs. He also asserts that the District failed to implement the goals and objectives contained in those IEPs.
a. September 18, 2001 IEP.
MOTHER testified concerning her belief that the District failed to implement the required accommodations. She testified books on tape were never provided, weekly assignment sheets eventually came “but very later on in the year,” there was no peer tutor, proof reading assistance never happened, open-book and open-notes testing did not occur, STUDENT was not given appropriate notes, and STUDENT was not being given oral tests and oral test directions. She believes that oral tests and directions are critical because that is STUDENT’s way of learning and expressing himself, but she also acknowledges that STUDENT is embarrassed by anything that would call his peers attention to him as being a special needs student. MOTHER also believed that there must have been a failure to provide shortened homework assignments in math because, by March 2002, STUDENT was receiving “B’s” or higher on his tests, but due to poor homework scores his overall grade in math was a “D.” MOTHER stated that the District was holding STUDENT to a “bar” that he had to produce all the homework assignments in math. His “slipping in language arts and science” also indicated to MOTHER that STUDENT was not receiving the required accommodations.
Ms. Rochford, STUDENT’s RSP at Granite Oaks, testified that as STUDENT’s “case carrier” she fulfilled her responsibility of ensuring that STUDENT’s accommodations were implemented in the 2001-2002 school year, both by communication with STUDENT’s teachers and by implementing accommodations herself in the Learning Center. She also noted that STUDENT demonstrated problems with completing and turning in his homework.
Granite Oaks principal Michael Melton testified as to his belief that the accommodations on the September 18, 2001 IEP were being implemented. He stated that STUDENT’s teachers were required to meet each week with Ms. Rochford to discuss whether the accommodations were successful, and he would receive reports from those meetings. He testified that because of concerns expressed by MOTHER to a teacher, he made inquiries and was certain that modifications for extra time and shortened assignments were being implemented and STUDENT was being allowed to take tests in the resource class. Mr. Melton testified that discussions at the March 21, 2002 IEP meeting indicated an overall view from STUDENT’s teachers that STUDENT’s declining performance in the latter part of the school year was a direct result of STUDENT’s inconsistent effort. The teachers reported that when STUDENT did his work, he did it well. (Footnote 12)
Katie Ragan was STUDENT’s language arts teacher at Granite Oaks. She testified that on October 1, 2001, during her first week as a teacher at Granite Oaks, she met with STUDENT’s RSP, Ms. Rochford, and received a copy of the September 18, 2001 IEP. At that meeting, Ms. Rochford explained the accommodations and how they were to be implemented. Ms. Rochford testified in detail how she actually implemented the accommodations. She assigned STUDENT his grades. The grades were modified by placing added weight to content instead of writing mechanics. STUDENT was provided tutoring or a student buddy by being paired with various partners both in the Learning Center and in the language arts classroom. In the language arts classroom, STUDENT was always paired with a student that had strong skills in language arts. Copies of the class notes were provided to Ms. Rochford in advance at the beginning of each week so that Ms. Rochford could distribute the notes to special needs students. A word processor with spell check was available to STUDENT in her class at all times, but he did not use it on a regular basis. STUDENT was given preferential seating in the front of the class to minimize auditory or visual distractions. STUDENT’s home-to-school communication system included regular use of a planner, and a progress report was sent home every two weeks from the Learning Center. All student’s were given a planner at the beginning of the year. At the beginning of each week, the classroom and homework assignments for that week would be listed on the blackboard and the students would be expected to copy it into their planner. She would monitor closely during the first quarter to see that the notes were being copied by each student, and STUDENT was performing that task. However, STUDENT also had that same information supplied to him at the Learning Center.
Ms. Ragan also testified that she consulted with Ms. Rochford at least once every week in a “formal setting” and “many times informally throughout the week.” The formal setting was a meeting among the teachers and the special education team each week to discuss lesson plans, give copies of the lesson plans and notes in advance, and to specifically discuss accommodations and modifications for all of the special education students for every assignment and to discuss the progress of each student. With regard to tape recordings of required readings, several methods were used. Novels or other books would be read in class along with the tape. The same tapes were also available for check out by special education students at the Learning Center. She has no knowledge of STUDENT’s having checked out books on tape. STUDENT’s assignments were altered or modified by shortening written assignments and by giving extra time on written assignments and on tests. For example, for a five-paragraph thesis-driven 750-word essay he would be asked to write a 500-word essay. Instead of the required six quotes from a novel he might be required to have three. She checked for STUDENT’s understanding by actually approaching him, as she would other students, and inquiring to see if he understood his task. She would sometimes watch him work to see how he was performing. STUDENT’s classroom participation was encouraged, and he participated appropriately. Tests were modified for STUDENT. He would start the test in her classroom, then she would pull the test and send it to the Learning Center for completion. The tests would be reviewed at the Learning Center step by step. In that process at the Learning Center, modifications would be made. For example, vocabulary lists would could be shortened and the student could be given a choice of words from a “word bank.” Tests could be shortened and given orally by the RSP teacher.
Ms. Ragan testified that, despite the accommodations, STUDENT did not complete his homework on a regular basis. Test scores varied, depending on whether he had done his homework “beforehand” and had studied. She considered him to be a bright and capable student. She believes that STUDENT’s overall grade (about a “C”) would have been better if he had completed his assignments and taken advantage of all the accommodations that were offered to him– which he did not. (Footnote 13)
Having considered the above, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District’s program for the 2001-2002 school year comported with STUDENT’s applicable IEP. In her testimony, MOTHER showed that her contrary opinions on the matter rest primarily on her belief that the drop in STUDENT’s grades must have been due to failed implementation of accommodations instead of other potential factors. There was no evidence to indicate that MOTHER’s belief was based on direct observation of classroom operations over a significant period of time. By contrast, the District, especially through the testimony of Ms. Ragan, was able to show how a system was in place to ensure the implementation of STUDENT’s IEP accommodations and also the accommodations of other special needs students taking regular education classes. The Hearing Officer is fully persuaded that District-provided accommodations for addressing STUDENT’s weakness with organization, such as the weekly planner updates and the availability of notes and assignments in advance, coupled with shortened assignments, all resulted in a situation where STUDENT’s variations in performance were more likely a product STUDENT’s effort and ability, as compared to a failure by the District to implement accommodations.
b. March 21, 2002 IEP.
The March 21, 2002 IEP was not signed by MOTHER until she submitted an altered version to the District on or about May 25, 2002. With certain exceptions not applicable in the present case, if the parent does not consent to all of the components of an IEP offered by a district, those components of the program to which the parent has consented shall be implemented so as not to delay providing instruction and services to the pupil. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a). Thus, consistent with the reasoning in the stay put order, when MOTHER signed her unilaterally altered version of the March 21, 2002 IEP, those portions (i.e., the unaltered portions) of the IEP to which she consented became part of the agreed-to placement. As to the altered portions, the corresponding provisions of September 18, 2001 IEP remained in effect. Jan Lucas, the District’s special education director, testified that because of her apparent misunderstanding of the law at that time, when she received the altered version of the March 21, 2002 IEP she would have considered the document to be invalid and would have instructed her staff to continue implementing the September 18, 2001 IEP. Therefore, the District failed to implement the agreed-upon portions of the March 2002 IEP when it received MOTHER’s consent. However, given the facts that MOTHER submitted her partial consent only a few days before the end of the 2001-2002 school year, the similarity in accommodations between two IEPs that have both been deemed appropriate, and the fact that the District was implementing the accommodations from at least one of those IEPs, the Hearing Officer concludes that no prejudice resulted from the District’s failure to implement those portions of the March 2002 IEP.
c. Goals and objectives.
STUDENT has also asserted that the District failed to implement and monitor the goals and objectives from his IEPs. STUDENT presented no evidence to support those contentions. A review of evidence shows that the September 18, 2001 IEP contained a single goal with short term objectives that involved the use of graphic organizers to assist STUDENT in writing multi-paragraph essays. The March 21, 2002 IEP contains an updated version of a similar goal involving use of graphic organizers, with short term objectives, and a new goal with objectives related to organizational skills and assignment completion. The RSP teacher, Ms. Rochford, and the language arts teacher, Ms. Ragan, testified that they implemented STUDENT’s IEP. Their uncontested testimony, along with documentary evidence of the updated goal and the new goal persuade the Hearing Officer that the District monitored and implemented STUDENT’s goals and objectives. (B) Failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the IEP process to the extent required by law.
In addition to recognizing the importance of the substantive requirements of the IDEA, the Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484.
The Student asserts that the District’s refusal of MOTHER’s request to attach a copy of the Mt. Diablo IEP to the September 18, 2001 IEP was a procedural violation leading to a denial of FAPE. The Student asserts that this procedural violation denied him a FAPE because the new IEP failed to incorporate the Mt. Diablo provisions for (1) a reader during study skills, (2) an adult assistant to help with assignment organization and provide class notes, (3) returning tests to MOTHER within 72 hours, (4) having to do only every other problem for homework in math, and (5) provision of books on tape. (Footnote 14) The District asserts that it was not required to attach a copy of the Mt. Diablo IEP.
With regard to the specific procedural contentions raised by the Student, the Student presented no legal authority, and the Hearing Officer does not know of any, that requires that the IEP from the prior district be attached to the IEP from the new district. Furthermore, even if one were to assert that all five Mt. Diablo items listed above by the Student had to be incorporated into an interim placement, a review of the September 18, 2001 IEP shows that accommodations in conformity with all of those items were included in the new IEP. Specifically, the RSP teacher and a buddy/peer tutor were available for reading in the Learning Center. As described by the testimony of Ms. Ragan summarized above, the District had extensive interaction between the classroom teacher and the RSP to ensure assignment organization and availability of class notes for STUDENT. Through home/school communication system including a planner and progress reports, MOTHER would be kept informed regarding STUDENT’s assignments and tests. To the extent she may not have received test results within 72 hours, there was no evidence to indicate that would be such a serious infringement as to cause a denial a FAPE. Additionally, shortened assignments were provided as an accommodation. As described by Ms. Ragan’s testimony, the collaboration system at Granite Oaks between the classroom teachers and the RSP, taking into account STUDENT’s ongoing performance, was an appropriate method for address how and to what degree assignments should be shortened. Moreover, the accommodations included tape recordings of required readings.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that for the 2001-2002 school year, there was no denial of a FAPE arising from procedural violations.
* * * * * * * * * * * *
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that for the 2001-2002 school year, the District offered STUDENT accommodations and services that were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and comported with his IEP. The Hearing Officer also finds that for the 2001-2002 school year, there was no denial of FAPE arising from procedural violations. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the entirety of the 2001-2002 school year.
Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year by (A) failing to provide STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives, and (B) failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the individualized education program (IEP) process to the extent required by law.
STUDENT asserts that the District denied him a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year by failing to implement the accommodations that MOTHER agreed to when she signed her altered version of the March 21, 2002 IEP. STUDENT further asserts that the October 16, 2002 IEP, February 26, 2003 IEP, and May 19, 2003 IEP were deficient as to accommodations, and they placed an inappropriate burden on STUDENT to request the accommodations. STUDENT also asserts that the District failed to monitor and implement the goals and objectives contained in the March 21, 2002 IEP. The District asserts that it provided STUDENT a FAPE at all times during the 2001-2002 school year.
(A) Failing to provide STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives.
The Hearing Officer begins by identifying STUDENT’s unique needs for the 2002-2003 school year. Thereafter, within the context of the assertions made by STUDENT, the Hearing Officer will examine whether the program offered and provided by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and comported with his applicable IEP.
1. Did the District offer a program for the 2002-2003 school year that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
a. STUDENT’s unique needs.
As will be discussed below, for the 2002-2003 school year, the evidence showed that STUDENT continued to have the same needs identified as for the 2001-2002 school year.
William R. Merz, Ph.D., completed a private psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT in May 2002. In addition to reviewing prior assessments and conducting other tests, he also administered the WISC-III. His May 12, 2003 report states that STUDENT’s measured “simple difference between aptitude and achievement scores is only 13 scaled score points” and STUDENT therefore does not meet “the 22 standard score simple difference enumerated in the education code.” The report further states, however, that STUDENT still “has serious difficulty with three of the five psychological processes: visual processing, specifically spatial skills; sensory motor skills, specifically integrating perception with fine motor skills; and cognition, specifically some aspects of conceptualization– applying old knowledge to new situations and thinking abstractly.” (Footnote15) Dr. Merz wrote that while STUDENT’s “academic achievement test scores fall within the average range, he still has great difficulty with task completion, planning, and organization. His writing is quite slow, making him vulnerable to not completing his work. He does not organize his approach to school tasks . . .” (Footnote 16) Dr. Merz noted that even with reduction in the amount of homework, STUDENT still lacked that knowledge and skill to actually plan and complete assignments. Accordingly, Dr. Merz believed that STUDENT should be found eligible for special education under the discretion that an IEP team has for finding such eligibility in the absence of a “22 standard score” discrepancy. Dr. Merz also noted that “STUDENT often finds it difficult to ask for assistance because he wants to be just like his peers. He is struggling with his need to be independent and his needs for nurturance and dependence.” Dr. Merz concluded that the “accommodations and modifications identified in the March 21, 2002 Summary IEP documents and in the 2002 Triennial Evaluation documents are appropriate.” Dr. Merz testified that the findings and opinions expressed in his report remain applicable to STUDENT through the present.
District witnesses and Dr. Merz testified that Dr. Merz’ findings and recommendations were basically consistent with and an endorsement of the findings and recommendations made by District school psychologist Stacey Barsdale in her March 2002 report. However, STUDENT’s performance during the 2002-2003 school year was considered by District personnel to be an indication that STUDENT may actually have been better served by a reduction of accommodations. The reasoning, as testified to by several District witnesses, was that one of STUDENT’s primary problems was his failure to complete and turn in homework assignments. District witnesses testified that STUDENT’s failure to complete and turn in homework was adversely affecting not only the homework component of STUDENT’s grades, but also test preparation and test scores. District witnesses testified that they believed STUDENT was becoming too reliant upon the accommodations, such as the options of extended time on homework assignments, or taking multiple retests and having the ability to retain only the highest score. STUDENT’s reliance on accommodations, according to the District, was leaving STUDENT without incentive to do his work timely or properly. In her testimony on this subject, MOTHER was firm in her belief that to be able to complete his work and make meaningful academic progress, STUDENT continued to need all of the accommodations listed in her version of the March 21, 2002 IEP.
The evidence showed that STUDENT’s performance during the 2002-2003 school year fluctuated in terms of his work output and his grades. MOTHER believes that the fluctuations resulted from the District’s inconsistency in implementing the required accommodations. District witnesses who worked with STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year testified that the accommodations were available to STUDENT whether he needed them or not, and they believed that the fluctuations resulted from STUDENT’s inconsistent effort.
Having considered all of the above, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that STUDENT’s previously documented deficits in visual processing continued throughout the 2002-2003 school year, and those deficits continued to be manifested by speed and accuracy problems in reading and writing and by poor organizational skills. This is confirmed by the similarity in findings made by Ms. Barsdale in March 2002 and Dr. Merz in May 2003. Because of those deficits, STUDENT continued to have accommodation-related needs in the same six general categories as identified previously by the Hearing Officer in the discussion of the 2001-2002 school year. However, the evidence also showed, and the Hearing Officer finds, that the accommodations had to designed and implemented in a manner that would not unduly encourage STUDENT to be late with assignments or give less than appropriate effort. b. The District’s program offer.
As discussed elsewhere in this Decision, the evidence demonstrated uncertainty by the District as to whether Rocklin High was implementing the September 18, 2001 IEP at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, or was instead implementing the March 21, 2002 IEP. As found earlier, either IEP would have provided a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year. Because of the similarity in STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs for the 2002-2003 school year in comparison to the prior year, the accommodations in either of the IEPs would have provided a FAPE throughout the 2002-2003 school year. Thus, the remaining portion of the District’s program offer that must be evaluated for purposes of FAPE in the 2002-2003 school year is set forth in the new IEPs dated October 16, 2002, and February 26 and May 19, 2003.
October 16, 2002 IEP.
STUDENT’s objections to the appropriateness of the October 16, 2002 IEP are that, in comparison to MOTHER’s version of the March 21, 2002 IEP, the accommodations are generally fewer and some of the accommodations place an inappropriate burden upon STUDENT to request them. Those accommodations requiring a request by STUDENT were related to oral test questions/assignments, oral tests/assignments directions, copy of notes from the board, and completing tests/assignments in the special education environment. In comparison to the March 21, 2002 IEP, the October 16, 2002 IEP provided for the following accommodations:
1. Grades – modified grades involving writing in language arts was deleted, and collaboration between special and regular education teachers in “English/Major assignments” was deleted. 2. Behavioral support – preferential seating and use of a notebook or planner were unchanged, but for a home school communication system, STUDENT would use a “weekly grade check sheet” instead of an assignment planner. 3. Supplementary aids to support time in general/special education – access to a computer in the Learning Center was specified, but note taking assistance and use of word processing was deleted. 4. Supplementary aids to support school personnel – consultation with Learning Center staff was deleted and “weekly grade check sheet taken by STUDENT to teachers” was added. 5. Presentation of materials and instructions for tests/assignments – books on tape was retained but limited, modification of assignments/tests to address identified needs of learning styles was deleted; shortened tests/assignments was deleted; questions on tests/assignments rephrased was deleted; preview of tests/assignments was deleted; check for understanding was deleted; visual aides etc. was retained; test questions/assignments and tests/assignments directions would be read orally was changed to read “[on the] 2nd try when requested if necessary”; “copy of notes from the board when requested by STUDENT” was added. Tests/assignments given in smaller parts was added. 6. Response to materials and instruction for tests/assignments – reduced/shortened test/assignments was deleted; extended time on in-class assignments was retained but limited to 1 or 2 days without penalty. 7. Setting for tests/assignments – the provision for completing tests/assignments in the special education environment was modified to state “when requested by STUDENT.” 8. Timing/scheduling of tests/assignments – giving tests/assignments in shortened time segments was deleted; the 10-minute per 30-minute formula for extended time was deleted; extended time on in-class assignments/tests was modified to read “1-2 days all classes without penalty.”
Comparison of the accommodations offered in the October 16, 2002 IEP to the six areas of accommodation-related needs previously identified above by the Hearing Officer shows the following: For (1) accommodations to address, at least in part, STUDENT’s deficits with visual acuity and image fusion, the IEP provided for preferential seating. For (2) enabling STUDENT to preserve classroom instruction and review the instruction at his own pace, the IEP provided for books on tape, to a limited extent, and “copy of notes from the board when requested by STUDENT” with regard to presentation of materials and instructions for tests/assignments. For (3) enabling STUDENT to understand and preserve homework instructions without having to rely on his limited note-taking skills, the IEP provided for use of a notebook or planner and a “weekly grade check sheet,” reading directions orally when requested if necessary, copy of notes from the board when requested by STUDENT, and visual aides. For (4) addressing STUDENT’s slow work output with regard to completion of in-class assignments and homework, the IEP provided for extended time of 1 or 2 days without penalty, and giving assignments in smaller parts.
In the area of (5) allowing STUDENT to express what he was learning by giving him sufficient time to take tests and also by giving him opportunities, as appropriate, to demonstrate his knowledge on examinations and quizzes orally rather than in writing, the IEP provided for extended time of 1-2 days, completing tests in the special education environment when requested by STUDENT, giving tests in smaller parts, and reading test directions and questions orally. For (6) addressing STUDENT’s poor organizational skills, particularly with regard to performing, completing, and turning in his homework assignments, the IEP provided for an assignment notebook or planner, and giving tests and assignments in smaller parts. All of the above was supplemented by a daily period of RSP support, and, as noted in the analysis of previous IEPs some of the accommodations addressed multiple areas of need in an overlapping manner.
The above comparison confirms that the October 16, 2002 IEP contained accommodations directed at all six areas of need identified by the Hearing Officer, but some of those areas of need had fewer accommodations than the March 21, 2002 IEP had provided. In addition, some of the accommodations placed responsibility upon STUDENT for requesting them.
The District asserts that the accommodations were revised on the basis of STUDENT’s levels of performance reported at the IEP meeting, and that the accommodations were also revised to encourage STUDENT to advocate for himself. The District’s assertion is consistent with the notes from the October 16, 2002 IEP meeting. According to the notes, STUDENT’s teachers generally reported STUDENT’s having some initial problems at the beginning of the school year with assignment completion, but recently STUDENT was performing well and was choosing to utilize few of the accommodations available to him. His English teacher, Dorothy Jacobs, reported that STUDENT was now completing all assignments on time. The only modification considered as needed in English was extra time of “1-2 days maximum;” otherwise, STUDENT was reportedly performing in the average range among peers in his English class. STUDENT’s math teacher, Mr. Farmer, reported that STUDENT obtained scores of 90 percent and 94 percent on his last two tests and had needed no modifications. Rebecca Heath, STUDENT’s graphic communications teacher, reported that STUDENT had improved his use of time, although some assignments were still being returned late. She was allowing STUDENT to have open-book retakes in the Learning Center. Mr. Eckenberg, STUDENT’s geography teacher, reported that STUDENT had been doing his homework, was participating in class, and was being “very proactive to get his work done and he’s doing very well.”
As reflected in the Hearing Officer’s earlier findings regarding STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs for the 2002-2003 school year, reducing or eliminating certain accommodations was appropriate so long as STUDENT’s unique needs were still being addressed. The Hearing Officer considers the primary change in STUDENT’s accommodations as formulated in the October 16, 2002 IEP to be the reduction of notetaking assistance and the absence of reference to responding to tests orally, other than as might occur in the Learning Center during STUDENT’s daily RSP support sessions. Notetaking or the availability of classroom notes was recommended as an accommodation by Ms. Barsdale after her March 2002 psychoeducational evaluation, as was the accommodation of giving STUDENT an opportunity to demonstrate his knowledge on exams and quizzes orally rather than in writing. Those recommendations were made as a direct consequence of the manifestations of STUDENT’s visual processing disorder. Although Ms. Fitzpatrick testified that she had observed STUDENT’s taking appropriate notes from the board, there was no corroboration from standardized testing that STUDENT’s visual processing disorder had resolved to such a degree that his notetaking, writing, and reading skills had ceased to be areas of deficit. The Hearing Officer also observes, however, that the members of the IEP who formulated the reduction in accommodations were most familiar with STUDENT’s present performance and, significantly, MOTHER was a member of the IEP team and signed her consent to the IEP. (Footnote 17) Moreover, the IEP did not eliminate accommodations in either of those areas, it merely reduced them in accordance with what the team believed STUDENT’s levels of performance to be at that time.
Similarly, encouraging self advocacy and a measure of independence by placing some responsibility on STUDENT to request certain accommodations was appropriate– as STUDENT was now a high school student reportedly with good communication skills, producing grade-level work in the regular education environment, and striving to attend a four-year college. There was no evidence to suggest that by requesting certain accommodations, STUDENT would bring increased attention to himself among his peers as being a student with special needs. To the contrary, giving STUDENT the option of receiving certain accommodations only upon his request would give STUDENT opportunities to demonstrate to his peers that he did not automatically need accommodations for completing tests or understanding every assignment or direction given in class.
No specific evidence was provided to dispute the information described above or to indicate that the reduction or modification of the accommodations resulted in STUDENT’s needs being unmet. Therefore, in light of the persuasive evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the accommodations in the October 16, 2002 IEP were designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs.
February 26, 2003 IEP.
STUDENT asserts that the February 26, 2003 IEP offered by the District was deficient in its accommodations and placed inappropriate burdens on STUDENT to request accommodations. The District asserts that the accommodations were appropriate.
In comparison to the October 16, 2002 IEP, the February 26, 2003 IEP offered an increase in accommodations. The prior accommodations remained substantially intact, but added were accommodations for modified grades, sending an email to MOTHER at the last period of each week, having MOTHER email with teachers as needed, giving test questions orally if needed, providing copies of notes as available, providing a 3-class-period extension of time to complete in-class assignments/tests, and other modifications “as identified in written [IEP] notes.” All of the above was supplemented by a daily period of RSP support. MOTHER did not sign her consent to the February 26, 2003 proposed IEP.
The notes from the February 26, 2003 IEP meeting show that STUDENT’s performance had been diminishing in certain areas. Assignments were missing in physical education. In graphic arts, STUDENT had fallen behind in his assignments. In English, STUDENT was at “59%” and had missing work. In math, Mr. Farmer reported that STUDENT had scheduled several after-school sessions with him, but STUDENT had only attended one. Mr. Farmer stated that STUDENT was not coming to class prepared, and he would often bring the wrong materials to class. In “Comp. Literacy” STUDENT was deemed to be at “84%,” and able to transfer information from the overhead projector to paper and then to the computer. Home-to-school communication was characterized as a “major issue.” Use of the assignment book and the weekly check sheet had been ineffective. Multiple emails to STUDENT’s mother and grandparents had not been as effective as planned. Specific strategies were discussed for math, and the overall accommodations were increased as noted above.
The added accommodations in the February 26, 2003 IEP were directly targeted at STUDENT’s declining performance in assignment completion and in testing. The above-referenced comments from STUDENT’s teachers persuade the Hearing Officer that STUDENT’s declining performance was most likely a direct result of a temporary decrease in effort and attention to detail by STUDENT, as opposed to having insufficient accommodations. Nonetheless, the District appropriately took prompt action by offering the new accommodations. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the February 26, 2003 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs.
May 19, 2003 IEP.
STUDENT asserts that the May 19, 2003 IEP offered by the District was also deficient in its accommodations. The District asserts that the accommodations were appropriate.
The accommodations offered in the May 19, 2003 IEP were:
1. Grades – regular grading criteria used in all subjects.
2. Behavioral support – preferential seating, use of a notebook or planner, use of a “weekly grade check sheet.” 3. Supplementary aids to support time in general/special education – notes given as available, access to a computer on campus. 4. Supplementary aids to support school personnel – RSP consultation on a regular basis with STUDENT’s teachers to goals and objectives and accommodations. 5. Presentation of materials and instructions for tests/assignments – books on tape as available, instructions/directions repeated/rephrased, tests/assignments given in smaller parts, check for understanding, use of multi-modality teaching methods by teachers as appropriate to topic. 6. Response to materials and instruction for tests/assignments – extended time on in-class assignments/tests “1 to 2 class periods without penalty,” spelling errors will not impact grade, upon request STUDENT may retake tests orally and keep higher grade. 7. Setting for tests/assignments – tests/assignments completed in the special education environment. 8. Timing/scheduling of tests/assignments – extended time of two minutes for every one minute given to “non-disabled peers.”
Comparison of the accommodations offered in the May 19, 2003 IEP to the six areas of accommodation-related needs previously identified above by the Hearing Officer shows the following: For accommodations (1) to address, at least in part, STUDENT’s deficits with visual acuity and image fusion, the IEP provided for preferential seating. For (2) enabling STUDENT to preserve classroom instruction and review the instruction at his own pace, the IEP provided for books on tape as available and notes given as available. For (3) enabling STUDENT to understand and preserve homework instructions without having to rely on his limited note-taking skills, the IEP provided for use of a notebook or planner and a “weekly grade check sheet,” instructions/directions repeated/rephrased, check for understanding, and use of multi-modality teaching methods as appropriate to topic.
For (4) addressing STUDENT’s slow work output with regard to completion of in-class assignments and homework, the IEP provided for extended time of 1-2 days without penalty, and, in some cases, extended time of 2 minutes for every 1 minute given to nondisabled peers, completing assignments in the special education environment, and assignments given in smaller parts. In the area of (5) allowing STUDENT to express what he was learning by giving him sufficient time to take tests and also by giving him opportunities, as appropriate, to demonstrate his knowledge on examinations and quizzes orally rather than in writing, the IEP provided for extended time of 1-2 days without penalty, and, in some cases, extended time of 2 minutes for every 1 minute given to nondisabled peers, completing tests in the special education environment, tests given in smaller parts, and, upon request, allowing STUDENT to retake tests orally and keep the higher grade. For (6) addressing STUDENT’s poor organizational skills, particularly with regard to performing, completing, and turning in his homework assignments, the IEP provided for an assignment notebook or planner, and giving tests and assignments in smaller parts. All of the above was supplemented by a daily period of RSP support. Again, some of the accommodations overlapped to address multiple areas of need.
The above accommodations closely resemble the accommodations in the September 18, 2001 and March 21, 2002 IEPs, previously found as being designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs. (Footnote 18) Contemporaneous reports from STUDENT’s teachers support the District’s position that STUDENT did not require additional accommodations.
Specifically, in preparation for the May 19, 2003 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s teachers submitted progress reports concerning STUDENT’s performance. In a memorandum dated May 16, 2003, STUDENT’s math teacher, Tom Farmer, stated that STUDENT’s current grade in algebra was 56.9 percent, equivalent to a “no mark” (NM). Mr. Farmer stated that STUDENT thrived during the first semester, but his production and participation waned thereafter. STUDENT began to fall behind in classwork and homework, in spite of being given extended time. STUDENT had initially been completing 50-60 percent of his homework, but more recently was only completing 10 percent. His assignments had recently been cut by 50 percent, with STUDENT’s only homework being the work not finished in class. He also seemed to be less organized, often coming to class without proper material, such as his assignment organizer. Mr. Farmer stated with specificity the accommodations he had been providing to STUDENT, and those stated accommodations were consistent with STUDENT’s IEPs. He also stated that he had provided STUDENT with copies of all classroom notes, although he had not seen STUDENT use those notes in class. STUDENT was given an opportunity for peer tutoring two days per week through the “Career Center” but had not participated. He also had regular opportunities to receive tutoring from Mr. Farmer or retest before and after school and during lunch, but had done so only twice. Mr. Farmer’s testimony at hearing was consistent with his comments in the progress report.
Ms. Heath, STUDENT’s graphics communications teacher, reported on May 16, 2003, that STUDENT had steadily improved in graphics communications over the year. He had received a “C” the first semester, partly because of missed assignments and low test scores. STUDENT had reportedly told Ms. Heath on several occasions during the first semester that he had not studied, and he seemed to have difficulty “remembering when assignments were due and remembering to hand in assignments.” At the current point in the second semester, STUDENT was earning a B to B+ and had “greatly improved in his written work.” He demonstrated strengths in “visual and spatial abilities” on the computer, with a good sense of how elements should be arranged on an art work. She reported that he always wanted to take his tests with the rest of the class, and she “would have to insist that he go to the other room.” His organization skills and performance had greatly improved, and she attributed that to STUDENT’s better understanding of the “rhythm of the class.”
Kristy Ramos, STUDENT’s Spanish teacher, also submitted a report on May 16, 2003. Her report details the various accommodations she was offering to STUDENT, including provision of lecture notes, vocabulary lists, extended time without penalty, and retakes with extra time, tutoring with her before and after school and by appointment, take “chunks” of a test and then return to take others. She stated that “STUDENT with few exceptions has never come to see me, expressed any concerns about his grade or learning, or asked for help in any way . . . STUDENT does seem to be ‘hopeless’ about his grade. It is difficult for him to admit he needs help. He states that he has tried to study in the past with a tutor his mother provided, however his scores do not show that.”
Dorothy Jacob, STUDENT’s language arts teacher, wrote in her May 16, 2003 report that STUDENT currently had a 72 percent (“C”) on his overall work. She stated that for the last quarter STUDENT had been “very diligent in his English work” and had completed all assignments. She stated that his prior problems with absences and staying current in his work had “vanished.” He still demonstrated difficulties with organizing materials into manageable amounts, and he occasionally needed additional time to read material and respond in writing in the more lengthy assignments. His work on “simple short- writes or questions is at the normal rate of speed.” Spelling and sentencing in written work were challenges that he could manage with a computer. Such errors were always identified in his work but did not affect his grade. She concluded by describing the accommodations STUDENT was receiving. Extended time was rarely requested, and usually only for homework. Because of oral reading of the class novel, books on tape were not currently needed. Tests were usually taken in the Learning Center and with a shortened test, using open book/notes. Notes were rarely taken in her class, but were available. A classroom aide was working with STUDENT and other “RSP students” in the class, checking for understanding and providing one-on-one assistance.
STUDENT’s science teacher wrote on May 16, 2003, that STUDENT currently had a 69 percent in the class and would probably finish the class at above 70 percent. He had completed or was completing all essential skill items. STUDENT had been meeting with his teacher in the mornings to complete exams.
The above information shows that throughout the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT was using some but not all of the accommodations available to him. His success was demonstrated to be heavily dependent on his level of interest in the class, his ability to remain organized, his effort, and his willingness to utilize the accommodations available to him. The evidence did not suggest that in May 2003 STUDENT needed accommodations beyond what the District offered in the May 19, 2003 IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the May 19, 2003 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs.
2. Was the District’s program offer for 2002-2003 reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?
The Hearing Officer has found that all the IEPs offered by the District during the 2002-2003 school year were designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs. The above-referenced progress reports, in addition to testimony from STUDENT’s regular education teachers and RSPs recounted elsewhere in this Decision, also showed that so long as STUDENT availed himself of the available accommodations and did his assignments within the parameters set for him, STUDENT made academic progress. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the entirety of the District’s program offer for the 2002-2003 school year was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
3. Did the District’s program for 2002-2003 comport with STUDENT’s IEP?
STUDENT asserts that the program provided by the District failed to comport with his IEPs because the District failed to implement the accommodations in the March 21, 2002 IEP and in the agreed-upon October 16, 2002 IEP. STUDENT also asserts that the District failed to monitor and implement the goals and objectives contained in those IEPs.
a. The IEPs.
While the evidence showed some uncertainty by the District as to which IEP the District implemented at Rocklin High from August 21 to October 16, 2002, the evidence established that the District in fact intended to implement the March 21, 2002 IEP during this time. (Footnote 19) Michelle Fitzpatrick was STUDENT’s RSP at Rocklin High from the beginning of his ninth-grade year (August 21, 2002) to May 2003. She testified that she received STUDENT’s file at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, that the March 21, 2002 IEP was in the file, and that she implemented the March 21, 2002 from the beginning of the school year. She also believes that she was actually implementing the altered version of the accommodations page containing MOTHER’s “if necessary” notations, discussed above.
On October 16, 2002, the District was required to begin implemented the agreed-upon October 16, 2002 IEP, and Ms. Fitzpatrick testified that she implemented that IEP. On March 20, 2003, MOTHER gave notice that she was rescinding her consent to that IEP and requested implementation of her version of the March 21, 2002 IEP. Ms. Fitzpatrick testified that she thereafter resumed implementing the March 21, 2002 IEP and continued to do so through the end of the school year.
All of the above-referenced IEPs met the requirements of a FAPE for STUDENT. Therefore, for FAPE purposes, the question whether the District’s program comported with STUDENT’s IEP is, in the present situation, not affected by whether the District was implementing the correct IEP at each particular time in the 2002-2003 school year. Instead, the pertinent question is whether the District’s program comported with the IEPs that Ms. Fitzpatrick testified she was implementing in the 2002-2003 school year.
In opposition to Ms. Fitzpatrik’s testimony, MOTHER testified generally that, irrespective of which IEP was to be followed, the District did not provide the applicable accommodations. MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s grades prove the failure to provide accommodations. She also testified that Ms. Fitzpatrick, STUDENT’s RSP for most of the 2002-2003 school year, was opposed to implementing the accommodations and therefore did not implement them.
Ms. Fitzpatrick did in fact testify that she believes the only accommodation needed by STUDENT, if any, is extended time. She bases that opinion on her observations of STUDENT’s performance, STUDENT’s unsatisfactory excuses as to why he did not bring completed assignments to school, and her consequent perception that STUDENT’s grades were primarily a function of his effort. However, she also testified that in fulfillment of her duties as STUDENT’s RSP teacher and case carrier, she ensured that all accommodations in the applicable IEP during each time period were followed, and more. As described above, Ms. Fitzpatrick testified that she did this through regular discussions and sharing of information with STUDENT’s teachers.
The evidence does not support Ms. Fitzpatrick’s opinion that the only accommodation needed by STUDENT is extended time, but the evidence does support her testimony that all accommodations specified in the IEPs were made available to STUDENT. This evidence includes, as described above, the reports of STUDENT’s teachers, written on May 16, 2003, describing their implementation of accommodations consistent with the IEPs. The evidence also supports her belief that the variation in STUDENT’s performance chiefly resulted from variation in his effort, demonstrated through his failure to complete and turn in assignments even with extended time, and demonstrated through his choice not to utilize many of the accommodations available to him.
Finally, the evidence showed that from September 12, 2002, through April 11, 2003, Ms. Fitzpatrick sent approximately 54 highly-detailed emails to either to MOTHER or MOTHER’s parents. The emails contained comprehensive information about STUDENT’s schedule, assignments, progress on assignments, accommodations, achievements, and areas of concern. Ms. Fitzpatrick testified that STUDENT collaborated with her on the development of many of those emails. That level of effort and concern demonstrated by Ms. Fitzpatrick is consistent with an RSP seeking to perform her duties diligently, and it supports her testimony that she implemented STUDENT’s accommodations in accordance with the IEPs. No specific evidence was presented to the contrary. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that for purposes of FAPE, the District’s provision of accommodations in the 2002-2003 school year comported with STUDENT’s applicable IEPs.
b. Goals and objectives.
STUDENT has also asserted that for the 2002-2003 school year, the District failed to implement and monitor the goals and objectives from the March 21, 2002 IEP. As stated previously, the March 21, 2002 IEP contains a goal involving use of graphic organizers, with short term objectives, and a goal with objectives related to organizational skills and assignment completion. The RSP, Ms. Fitzpatrick, testified that she implemented the March 21, 2002 IEP and collaborated with STUDENT’s teachers in implementing the IEP. Her diligence in this matter is confirmed by the content and quality of her 54 emails to MOTHER during the school year. The Student cited no availing evidence to the contrary. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s implementation and monitoring of goals and objectives comported with the March 21, 2002 IEP.
(B) Failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the IEP process to the extent required by law.
The Student asserts that the District seriously infringed on MOTHER’s right to participate in the IEP process by Ms. Fitzpatrick’s failure to cooperate with MOTHER, by misrepresentations from Ms. Fitzpatrick and Ms. Lucas that STUDENT needed only minimal accommodations, and by failing to give MOTHER unrestricted access to STUDENT’s teachers.
Regarding the interaction between Ms. Fitzpatrick and MOTHER, the evidence showed that Ms. Fitzpatrick exerted extraordinary and meticulous effort to keep MOTHER informed of STUDENT’s progress, as demonstrated by the above-referenced 54 emails. (Footnote 20) No credible evidence was provided to establish that any alleged lack of cooperation in any way impacted MOTHER’s ability to attend and participate in the IEP process. Regarding alleged misrepresentations about the level of accommodations needed by STUDENT, the Hearing Officer concluded above that all of the IEPs not consented to by MOTHER offered a level of accommodations that fulfilled the requirements of a FAPE for STUDENT. Thus, the opinions and representations expressed by Ms. Lucas and Ms. Fitzpatrick never resulted in failure by the District to offer appropriate accommodations.
Regarding access to STUDENT’s teachers, no provision in special education law establishes a right of parents unrestricted access to their child’s teachers. Additionally, there was credible evidence that allowing unrestricted access to STUDENT’s teachers by MOTHER would have been counterproductive in many respects. District teachers and other personnel uniformly expressed actual fear over the prospect of being confronted by MOTHER. They testified that she could be calm and reasonable, but she could also be confrontational, threatening, and unconcerned about the amount of time she was taking away from the teachers other duties. For her part, MOTHER demonstrated great concern for STUDENT, and the Hearing Officer is persuaded that MOTHER’s intent was to advocate for STUDENT, not to intimidate. However, the volume of emails and letters from the District to MOTHER, the role of Ms. Fitzpatrick (and later Ms. Hawkins, Rocklin High principal) in communicating MOTHER’s questions and concerns to STUDENT’s teachers and communicating their responses to MOTHER, and the number of IEP meetings (3) during the school year persuade the Hearing Officer MOTHER’s right to participate in the IEP process for the 2002-2003 school was not seriously infringed by the her ability or limited ability to communicate with STUDENT’s teachers.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds there was no denial of FAPE arising from procedural violations.
* * * * * * * * * * * * In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that for the 2002-2003 school year, the District offered a program that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and comported with his IEP. The Hearing Officer also finds that for the 2002-2003 school year, there was no denial of FAPE arising from procedural violations. The District, in its consolidated cross-filing, has sought a determination that it provided all aspects of a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. At the hearing, the District presented evidence on all aspects of the requirements for a FAPE. However, because the appropriateness of accommodations, the implementation and monitoring of goals and objectives, and certain procedural matters are the only portions of the District’s program to which the Student objects, it is unnecessary to address the other undisputed elements of FAPE. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the entirety of the 2002-2003 school year.
Issue 3: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year (A) failing to provide STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives, and (B) failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the IEP process to the extent required by law.
STUDENT’s overall substantive contentions with respect to the 2003-2004 school year are that the school year started with “no signed IEP and no Goals and Objectives in place,” that “minimal accommodations were haphazardly being provided by teachers who did not even know what accommodations were to be provided and did not understand the nature of Student’s specific learning disability,” that the accommodations offered in the November 5, 2003 proposed IEP were insufficient and “cast accountability on the Student rather than upon the Respondent,” that the District has failed to implement the accommodations identified in the October 23, 2003 stay put order.
(A) Failing to provide the STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations and failing to implement and monitor goals and objectives.
In addressing the above contentions, the Hearing Officer again begins by identifying STUDENT’s unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year, and then examines whether the program offered and provided by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and comported with his applicable IEP.
1. Did the District offer a program for the 2003-2004 school year that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
a. STUDENT’s unique needs.
STUDENT completed the first semester of his ninth-grade 2002-2003 school year with semester grades ranging from a low of “C-“ in language arts to a high of “B” graphic communications. His overall grade point average (GPA) at the end of the first semester was 2.38. STUDENT’s second semester grades consisted of a “no mark” in Spanish, “C” in language arts, science, and P.E., “B” in algebra and “computer lit.,” “B+” in graphic communications, and “A” in study skills. His overall GPA for the second semester was also 2.38. His grades ranked him 489th in class of 665 pupils.
STUDENT’s performance during his ninth-grade 2002-2003 school year, as indicated by grades and also by the May 16, 2003 teacher reports recounted in detail above, indicate that STUDENT’s program during that year was successful, that his accommodation-related needs at the commencement of the tenth-grade 2003-2004 school year were being met and were basically unchanged from the six general categories of need identified previously by the Hearing Officer, and that continuation of a similar program into the tenth-grade would be appropriate. In addition, evidence concerning STUDENT’s performance during ninth grade showed that STUDENT did not fully utilize the accommodations available to him. The evidence also showed that when STUDENT utilized accommodations such as organizational assistance, shortened assignments, extended time, and retakes, they were helpful. As discussed previously, the evidence further showed that although STUDENT continued to need accommodations throughout ninth grade, variations in his performance, especially with respect to assignment completion and organization, paralleled his variations in effort. Thus, there was a continuing need to achieve an appropriate balance by offering accommodations while, at the same time, keeping STUDENT motivated to do his work in a timely manner. All of those considerations remained applicable during STUDENT’s tenth-grade year.
b. The District’s program offer.
The Hearing Officer has previously determined that the District’s offer in the May 19, 2003 IEP was appropriate. Because MOTHER did not consent to that IEP and cancelled an IEP meeting scheduled by the District to discuss STUDENT’s placement for the 2003-2004 school year, the District made an administrative offer of placement on August 19, 2003, thereby reiterating the May 2003 IEP offer. Additionally, the District offered a new IEP on November 5, 2003, which resulted from an IEP meeting not attended by STUDENT’s parents. Those two latter offers will now be examined.
August 19, 2003 administrative offer of placement.
The accommodations in the administrative offer of placement were essentially the same as in the May 19, 2003 IEP, except that use of an assignment notebook or planner was not specified. Whether that change may have resulted from an oversight by the District is unknown. In either event, organization was one of STUDENT’s primary areas of need, and evidence from the prior school years showed that use of an assignment notebook or planner was important for addressing that need. There was no evidence that the weekly grade check sheet would have been sufficient substitute. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the administrative offer of placement was not designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs in the area organizational skills. In all other respects, the administrative offer of placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs.
November 5, 2003 IEP.
The November 5, 2003 IEP offered, in many respects, more extensive accommodations than were offered in the May 19, 2003 IEP, already found by the Hearing Officer to be appropriate. Comparison of the November 5, 2003 IEP to the May 19, 2003 IEP shows that regular grading criteria would again be used in all subjects rather than modified grading. The November 5, 2003 IEP added a provision for collaboration between the RSP and regular education teachers concerning STUDENT’s grades. Preferential seating and use of an assignment notebook or planner were maintained. For the home/school communication system, the new IEP provided that instead of STUDENT’s completing weekly grade check sheets, there would be weekly communication through the RSP teacher. Notetaking assistance and access to computer on campus were maintained. To support school personnel, consultation between the RSP and regular education teachers was maintained. Concerning presentation of materials and instructions for tests/assignments, the new IEP continued to provide for books on tape. It also continued to provide for instructions/directions repeated/rephrased, but “as needed.”
The November 5, 2003 IEP also added provisions for test questions/assignments to be given orally if required and tests/assignments directions to be read orally if required. It added provisions for questions on tests/assignments rephrased as needed. It retained the provision for tests assignments given in smaller parts, but added “if required.” It added visual aids, and, in turn, deleted the provision for multi-modality teaching materials. It maintained checking for understanding. Regarding responses to materials and instructions for tests/assignments, the new IEP added reduced/shortened tests/assignments as agreed between the RSP and regular education teachers. The new IEP retained extended time on in-class assignments/tests, but as agreed between the RSP and regular education teachers instead of 1 to 2 class periods without penalty. Spelling errors still would not impact STUDENT’s grade. The specific provision for retaking tests orally upon request and keeping the higher grade was deleted, but the new IEP retained STUDENT’s ability to take tests in the special education environment. Extended time on tests was reduced to 10 minutes for every 30 minutes given to “nondisabled peers” (the earlier IEP had specified 2 minutes for every 1 minute), but the new IEP added provisions for tests and assignments to be given in shortened time segments, for one period of extended time on out-of-class assignments, and for shortened responses to tests.
As identified above, the November 5, 2004 IEP contained several accommodation reductions and limitations in comparison to the May 19, 2003 IEP. However, all six categories of accommodation-related needs previously identified by the Hearing Officer continued to be addressed in the November 5, 2003 IEP. In all instances, those reductions or limitations were consistent with the overall need to achieve an appropriate balance by offering accommodations while, at the same time, keeping STUDENT motivated to do his work in a timely manner. With regard to deletion of the provision for allowing STUDENT to respond orally on test retakes and keep the higher grade, testimony of STUDENT’s teachers presented throughout the hearing showed that STUDENT seldom requested retakes. Furthermore, the provisions for presenting test questions orally if requested, rephrasing questions as needed, given tests in smaller parts, allowing shortened responses, allowing extended time, and allowing completion of tests in the RSP room would enable STUDENT to express his subject knowledge on tests, even with the relative weaknesses in his writing skills.
Having considered all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the November 5, 2003 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs. (Footnote 21)
2. Was the District’s program offer for 2003-2004 reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?
Except for the omission in the August 19, 2003 administrative offer of placement, concerning the use of an assignment notebook or planner to address STUDENT’s deficits in organization, the Hearing Officer has determined that the program offers made by the District for the 2003-2004 school year were designed to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs. Neither of the program offers were implemented, but the program offers were substantially similar to the program the District did implement (i.e., the March 21, 2002 IEP accommodations). Thus, the Hearing Officer can examine STUDENT’s grades during the fall semester of the 2003-2004 school year as an indicator of whether the ongoing program, and by inference the 2003-2004 program offers, were reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
STUDENT’s tenth-grade transcript for the fall semester of the 2003-2004 school year shows semester grades of “no mark” in biology, “C-” in world history, “C’s” in geometry and P.E., “B-” in Spanish 1, “B’s” in language arts and family life, and “B+” in study skills. Thus, STUDENT was maintaining approximately the same level of progress he had achieved in the ninth grade, and, on the basis of grades, no change in his required accommodations would have been indicated during or through the first semester of tenth grade.
Having considered the above, the Hearing Officer finds that with the exception of the omission by the August 19, 2003 administrative offer of placement concerning use of a notebook or planner to address organizational skills, the District’s program offers for the 2003-2004 school year were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Because, as discussed below, those offers were never implemented and the student continued to receive the use of a notebook or planner under a prior IEP, no actual prejudice resulted from the District’s limited omission.
3. Did the District’s program comport with STUDENT’s IEP?
The Student asserts that the District did not distribute the correct lists of accommodations to his teachers, and that the accommodations submitted to the teachers were not followed. Additionally, the Student contends again that the District failed to implement his goals and objectives.
a. Accommodations.
At the commencement of the 2003-2004 school year, the District was required to continue implementing those portions of the March 21, 2002 IEP where no alterations had been made by MOTHER. As to those portions where MOTHER made alterations that were not agreed to, the corresponding provisions listed in the September 18, 2001 IEP remained part of STUDENT’s program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a). This was confirmed in the above-referenced October 23, 2003 stay put order issued by the Hearing Officer. With no new IEP having been agreed to through the date of the due process hearing, the above-described program has remained the applicable program for the District to implement.
Jean Kelley, STUDENT’s RSP for the 2003-2004 school year, testified that at the start of the 2003-2004 school year, she implemented the May 19, 2003 IEP, notwithstanding the fact that she knew it had not been signed by MOTHER. However, no denial of FAPE resulted from this action. The May 19, 2003 IEP was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs in his second year of high school, and perhaps more so than the March 12, 2002 IEP formulated when STUDENT was in the eighth grade.
Ms. Kelley testified that upon her receipt of the stay put order, she made a list of the applicable accommodations and sent it to all of STUDENT’s teachers on November 3, 2003. A review of that list by the Hearing Officer shows that it accurately states the accommodations required by the stay put order. (Footnote 22) Rocklin High principal Debra Hawkins testified that each of STUDENT’s teachers was also forwarded a packet containing the stay put order and the accommodations pages from the September 18, 2001 and March 21, 2002 IEPs. The packet had been prepared by MOTHER. MOTHER testified concerning her doubts that the above-referenced packet was distributed to STUDENT’s teachers. She also asserts that the document prepared by Ms. Kelley was not a sufficient substitute for the actual IEPs. MOTHER’s doubts concerning distribution of the packet were not supported by evidence. Moreover, Ms. Kelley’s consolidation of the pertinent IEP accommodations into a convenient and concise format for the regular education teachers was far preferable to leaving each regular education teacher with the task of reconciling the two IEPs together with the stay put order. In any event, STUDENT’s RSP teacher and case manager, Ms. Kelley, had copies of the IEPs and the stay put order.
MOTHER also testified that STUDENT’s performance confirms the District’s failure to implement the accommodations. However, as discussed previously, STUDENT’s level of performance was often a function of his effort and his willingness to utilize the accommodations available to him. Thus, his performance alone is not determinative of whether he was provided his accommodations. On the contrary, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s accommodations were actually implemented.
Ms. Kelley testified in detail, explaining how each of the accommodations were being implemented. She described her frequent and ongoing interactions with STUDENT and with his teachers in ensuring that the accommodations were followed. The District also submitted into evidence approximately 70 emails, sent by Ms. Kelley throughout the school year to MOTHER and STUDENT’s grandparents, detailing STUDENT’s progress on assignments and tests in each class, and making recommendations directed at helping STUDENT to succeed. As was the case with Ms. Fitzpatrick, the detail, effort, and professional concern expressed in those emails added to Ms. Kelley’s credibility. The content of Ms. Kelley’s emails portrays an RSP teacher dedicated to implementing accommodations, as opposed to ignoring them.
The District also presented testimony by STUDENT’s tenth-grade teachers to show that the IEP accommodations were being implemented. Amanda Kniphfer, STUDENT’s language arts teacher, identified with specificity as to how, throughout the school year, she had been implementing the accommodations received from Ms. Kelley. She testified that STUDENT was utilizing some, but not all, of the accommodations. She also described his excuses for not turning in homework, such as the recurring excuse that he did it but forgot to bring it.
Mr. Trejo, STUDENT’s geometry teacher, testified that he has been following the accommodations of the May 19, 2003 IEP “as amended” by the November 3, 2003 email. He also described in detail how he implemented all of the accommodations applicable to the geometry class. He testified that STUDENT had been utilizing some of the accommodations, but STUDENT still had problems with doing his assignments and turning in his work. Mr. Trejo attributed those problems to “motivation issues.” He also testified that MOTHER had “hammered” him to reduce STUDENT’s homework by 50 percent but he was often unable to comply, as doing so would have violated directives from MOTHER and the IEP regarding keeping the curriculum at college-preparatory level work.
Paul Morrison, STUDENT’s biology teacher, testified that he has followed the IEP accommodations given to him by the District, to the extent the accommodations can be utilized in a biology class. He described in detail how the accommodations were implemented, and also explained how care had to be taken to avoid modifying the work so extensively as to have it not meet course standards. STUDENT was currently failing in biology, both with his test scores and his homework. He was doing some retakes, but still passing few of his tests. Mr. Morrison testified that the assignments STUDENT was doing in class indicated his ability to do his homework in a reasonable amount of time, and he did not know why STUDENT was failing to turn in his other assignments. STUDENT’s usual answer to inquiries on such matters was that he did not do it but he would get it done. According to Mr. Morrison, STUDENT was bright enough to pass the class and could pass it if he put forth the effort and accepted Mr. Morrison’s continuing offers to help him.
In summary, having considered all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s teachers and the RSP provider implemented STUDENT’s IEP accommodations. Although some of the accommodations implemented may have been from the May 19, 2003 IEP instead of the March 21, 2002 IEP, all of the IEPs were sufficiently similar that STUDENT’s accommodation-related unique needs were met and the concerning which IEP should have been implemented resulted in no denial of educational opportunity to STUDENT. (Footnote 23)
b. Goals and objectives.
STUDENT has again asserted generally that for the 2003-2004 school year, the District failed to implement and monitor the goals and objectives from the March 21, 2002 IEP. The Student presented no evidence to directly support his contention. However, the RSP teacher, Ms. Kelley, testified persuasively that she implemented the March 21, 2002 IEP and collaborated with STUDENT’s teachers in implementing the IEP. As was the case with Ms. Fitzpatrick, her RSP predecessor, Ms. Kelley’s diligence in this matter is confirmed by the content and quality of her 70 emails to MOTHER during the school year. Accordingly, and in the absence of contrary evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s implementation and monitoring of goals and objectives comported with the March 21, 2002 IEP.
(B) Failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the IEP process to the extent required by law.
The Student asserted numerous procedural violations for the 2003-2004 school year that concern MOTHER’s right to participate in the IEP process. All of those assertions have been considered by the Hearing Officer, but only those assertions meriting some discussion will be addressed in this Decision. (Footnote 24)
Section 56341.5(a) of the Cal. Educ. Code states that each district convening an IEP meeting for a disabled child shall take steps to ensure that the child’s parents are present at the meeting “or are afforded the opportunity to participate.” Similarly, § 56341(f) states that parents of children with disabilities have the right to present information to the IEP team in person or through a representative and the right to participate in meetings relating to eligibility for special education and related services, recommendations, and program planning.
First, MOTHER asserts that the District seriously infringed on her right to participate in the IEP process by “eliminating the parent’s right to monitor and review goals and objectives.” (Footnote 25) This allegation arises from certain notations on the goals and objectives attached to STUDENT’s various IEPs. The District’s form-pages for goals and objectives contain boxes that are checked to indicate who will be responsible for monitoring and reviewing progress toward the goals. On the March 21, 2002 IEP, the checked boxes indicated that special education providers, general education staff, parent, and STUDENT would monitor and review progress toward the goals. The notes on October 16, 2002 IEP expressly incorporated those same goals and objectives by reference, and they were again incorporated into the February 26, 2003 addendum to the October 16, 2002 IEP. Beginning with the May 19, 2003 IEP, however, the box for “parent” was not checked. From this, MOTHER infers that the district eliminated her right to monitor and review goals and objectives.
MOTHER’s assertion is not supported by the evidence. The District’s intent in not checking the parent box on the goals and objectives pages is unknown. Whatever the intent may have been, the effect did not seriously infringe on MOTHER’s right to participate in the IEP process. There was no evidence to suggest that MOTHER was denied a right to be informed about STUDENT’s progress toward goals and objectives. To the contrary, evidence such as the approximately 130 emails from STUDENT’s RSP teachers to MOTHER detailing STUDENT’s progress during the past two school years, and MOTHER’s opportunity to discuss STUDENT’s progress at multiple IEP meetings held and/or scheduled after the March 21, 2002 IEP meeting, confirms that MOTHER was well informed concerning all pertinent aspects of STUDENT’s progress.
Next, MOTHER asserts that she was denied participation in the IEP process by being deprived of the right to meet with STUDENT’s teachers. The Hearing Officer notes that this allegation was made notwithstanding MOTHER’s having sought orders from the Hearing Office on two occasions in the fall of 2003 to stay the convening of further IEP meetings. When the orders were not granted, MOTHER cancelled, walked out of, or otherwise refused to attend several scheduled IEP meetings. Had MOTHER participated in those meetings, she likely would have had opportunities to converse with STUDENT’s teachers. Moreover, nearly all of the teachers who testified stated quite candidly about their fear of being confronted by MOTHER at unsupervised meetings. Given these circumstances, the District acted appropriately in having STUDENT’s RSP teachers handle communications between MOTHER and STUDENT’s teachers. The evidence showed that the RSP teachers did so thoroughly, effectively, and, for STUDENT’s benefit, in a more constructive manner than would likely have resulted from in-person confrontations.
Finally, MOTHER asserts generally that not enough teachers were present at the November 3, 2003 IEP meeting. The evidence showed that the group in attendance at that meeting met the requirements of Cal. Educ. Code § 56341. Section 56341(b)(2) states that an IEP team shall include at least one regular education teacher if the pupil is participating in the regular education environment. If more than one teacher is providing services to that pupil in the regular education environment, the District may designate one teacher to represent the others. Ms. Kniphfer, STUDENT’s language arts teacher, attended the meeting and thereby satisfied § 56342(b)(2). (Footnote 26)
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not seriously infringe MOTHER’s right to participate in the IEP process for the 2003-2004 school year. Thus, there was no denial of FAPE arising from procedural violations.
* * * * * * * * * * * *
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that with the exception of the omission in the August 19, 2003 administrative offer of placement concerning a notebook and planner, for the 2003-2004 school year the District offered a program that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and comported with his IEPs. The Hearing Officer also finds that for the 2003-2004 school year, there was no denial of FAPE arising from procedural violations. The District, in its cross-filing, has sought a determination that it provided all aspects of a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and presented evidence on all aspects of the requirements for a FAPE. However, because accommodations, the implementation and monitoring of goals and objectives, and certain procedural matters are the only portions of the District’s program to which the Student objects, the Hearing Officer finds it unnecessary to address the other undisputed elements of FAPE. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that with the exception noted above concerning one element of the August 19, 2003 administrative offer of placement, the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the entirety of the 2003-2004 school year.
Issue 4: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for an educational assessment performed by William Merz, Ph.D., reimbursement for tutoring services, and other remedies, including revised grades?
Reimbursement for Dr. Merz’ assessment.
MOTHER seeks reimbursement by the District for the private psychoeducational evaluation performed by Dr. Merz in May 2003. Section 56329(b) of the California Education Code provides that a parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialist, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency, in accordance with 34 C.F.R. § 300.502.
In the present case, the evidence showed that MOTHER did not procure a private assessment because of disagreement with the District’s assessment, including the psychoeducational evaluation by District school psychologist Stacey Barsdale and other components of the March 2002 triennial assessment. Instead, MOTHER testified that she sought the assessment by Dr. Merz because she was dissatisfied with the District’s program offers and concerned about STUDENT’s eligibility. The introductory comments in Dr. Merz’ report are consistent with that aspect of MOTHER’s testimony. Accordingly, the above-stated threshold requirement of Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b), i.e., MOTHER’s disagreement with the District’s assessment, has not been met. Accordingly, the request for reimbursement of the cost of Dr. Merz’ assessment is denied.
Other remedies.
With one relatively minor exception, the Hearing Officer has found that the Student was provided a FAPE for the 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years. The lone exception was the August 19, 2003 administrative offer of placement’s failure to include a notebook or planner.
When a school District denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358 (1985). Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist., 960 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992). Included in the available relief, is reimbursement for privately procured educational services and compensatory education. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990); Miener v. State of Missouri 800 F.2d 749 (8th Cir. 1986). There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).
In the present case, there was absolutely no indication that the above-referenced omission in the August 19, 2003 administrative offer of placement resulted in loss of educational benefit to STUDENT or caused MOTHER to seek private services for STUDENT. MOTHER’s dissatisfaction with the District’s offers for the 2003-2004 school year extended far beyond any concern over, or even awareness of, the omission in the administrative offer. Accordingly, there is no basis for awarding remedies to the Student in this matter.
ORDER
1. The District’s request for a determination that STUDENT was offered and provided a FAPE for the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years is granted, with the exception that the administrative offer of placement made by the District on August 19, 2003, failed to provide for a notebook or planner. (Footnote 27)
2. All of the Student’s request for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
Issue 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year (A) failing to provide STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives, and (B) failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the individualized education program (IEP) process to the extent required by law. The District prevailed on Issue 1.
Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year (A) failing to provide STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives, and (B) failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the individualized education program (IEP) process to the extent required by law. The District prevailed on Issue 2.
Issue 3: Did the District deny STUDENT FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year (A) failing to provide STUDENT with appropriate classroom accommodations and implement and monitor goals and objectives, and (B) failing to allow STUDENT’s mother to participate in the individualized education program (IEP) process to the extent required by law. Except to the very limited extent that the August 19, 2003 administrative offer of placement omitted a provision for a notebook or planner, the District prevailed on Issue 3.
Issue 4: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for an educational assessment performed by William Merz, Ph.D., reimbursement for tutoring services, and other remedies, including revised grades? The District prevailed on Issue 4.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(i).
Dated: ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. ATTORNEY is also STUDENT’s grandfather.
2. Dr. Merz is a licensed psychologist, licensed educational psychologist, credentialed school psychologist, and professor in California State University Sacramento’s school psychology training program.
3. For purposes of analysis, the issues stated hereunder differ slightly in wording from the issues as stated in the March 16, 2004 prehearing conference order. The implementation and monitoring of goals and objectives was not stated as a discrete issue in the prehearing conference order. However, discussion between the Hearing Officer and the parties on the first day of hearing confirmed that the Student intended those aspects of the Student’s goals and objectives to be an issue for hearing. A similar contention had been raised as “Issue No. 2” in the Student’s March 12, 2004 issue statement. Accordingly, the Student’s contentions regarding goals and objectives were allowed to be presented for hearing.
4. Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, a special education student shall remain in his or her current educational placement pending resolution of due process hearing procedures, unless the parties agree otherwise. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); California Education Code § 56346(b), § 56505(d). This provision is commonly referred to as “stay put.” The purpose of stay put is to maintain the status quo of the student’s educational program pending resolution of the due process hearing. For purposes of stay put, the current educational placement is typically the placement agreed upon in an individualized education program and implemented by the parties prior to the dispute arising. Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education, 918 F.2d 618 (6th Cir. 1990).
5. The email included some other information for the teachers, but review of the email shows that none of the information materially altered the appropriate stay put provisions.
6. The intended reference is presumably to due process, not mediation.
7. Citing 34 C.F.R. § 300.343.
8. After completion of the prehearing conference, the Student made a request to have Mr. Lacy, the hearing officer who presided over that conference, disqualified from presiding over the due process hearing. The motion was denied by the undersigned Hearing Officer by minute order issued prior to the first day of hearing. A lengthy list of objections to the prehearing conference order was also submitted by the Student prior to the first day of hearing. Most of the objections arose from the Student’s lack of familiarity with statutory and regulatory special education due process hearing procedures, and were chiefly related to the characterization of the issues presented for hearing. On the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer explained to ATTORNEY that issues as framed in the prehearing conference order were stated in a manner that would allow a meaningful legal analysis in the eventual written decision. By contrast, the issues as phrased in the Student’s issue statements were analogous to factual assertions pertinent to the issues as framed in the prehearing conference order, and would be considered as such. Accordingly, those objections were considered by the undersigned Hearing Officer on the first day of hearing and were overruled.
9. Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and mandates that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. Additionally, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d), 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a). Neither requirements are at issue in the present case.
10. Because MOTHER withheld consent to the March 21, 2002 IEP until her provision of partial consent on or about May 25, 2002, the September 2001 IEP was properly the operative IEP for nearly the entire 2001-2003 school year.
11. In comparison to his first-semester grades, STUDENT’s second semester grades dropped from “C” to “D” in algebra and “B” to “D+” in social studies. His other grades were substantially unchanged. The District attributes this to a drop in STUDENT’s effort. MOTHER attributes this to the District’s alleged failure to provide the accommodations that either were or should been listed on the September 18, 2001 IEP. In either event, the Hearing Officer has found that the programs offered by the District in the September 18, 2001 and March 21, 2002 IEPs were reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
12. Mr. Melton testified that he eventually became “the contact person” for MOTHER because teachers were “put off” by MOTHER’s always questioning them about what they were doing. Thus, he undertook the role of listening to MOTHER’s questions and concerns and relying information to and from STUDENT’s teachers. He stated that he recalls his conversations with MOTHER because they typically were lengthy and, in his opinion, showed a lack of understanding by MOTHER. His staff expressed that they were uncomfortable with MOTHER because she was challenging, accusatory, and would not “let up.”
13. Ms. Ragan stated that she attended the March 21, 2002 IEP meeting and believed that the accommodations offered were appropriate and that more were not needed.
14. This allegation is not strictly within the scope of the procedural issues as identified in the prehearing conference order. The Hearing Officer also notes that a similar allegation by the Student has already been addressed above under rules applicable to substantive denials of FAPE, and the Hearing Officer has found that, irrespective of whether the Mt. Diablo accommodations were incorporated into STUDENT’s program, the September 18, 2001 IEP met the substantive requirements for an offer of FAPE. However, this allegation also raises some procedural questions that the parties both addressed with extensive evidence at the hearing. Consequently, the Hearing Officer will address the procedural aspects of this allegation.
15. The intended “education code” reference is to special education eligibility under the criteria for specific learning disabilities, as defined in Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j).
16. According to Dr. Merz, his administration of the Weschler Individual Achievement Test, Second Edition (WIAT-II) Selected Subtests showed that in spite of what Dr. Merz considered to be “quite poor” grades by STUDENT in school, his academic achievement scores on the WIAT-II were within the average range.
17. MOTHER asserts that she signed the IEP without having been givien the list of modifications. The District asserts that she did receive the modifications page. In either event, MOTHER waited until March 20, 2003 before withdrawing her consent to the October 16, 2003 IEP.
18. Although MOTHER has always advocated her version of the March 21, 2002 IEP accommodations as being the accommodations that she wants for STUDENT, she refused to sign the May 19, 2003 IEP. In her testimony, MOTHER indicated that her refusal to sign the May 19, 2003 IEP was based on her overall distrust of the District and her belief that the IEP did not put closure to present or future inquires as to whether STUDENT still met the eligibility criteria of specific learning disability.
19. The District’s special education director, Jan Lucas, testified that in her opinion MOTHER had not consented to the March 21, 2002 IEP proposed by the District, and Ms. Lucas’ standing instructions to her staff are to follow the last agreed-upon IEP. Ms. Lucas testified that she expects the staff would have continued implementing the September 18, 2001 IEP until MOTHER signed her consent to the October 16, 2002 IEP. She qualified her testimony, however, by stating that after the March 21, 2002 IEP meeting, the original document generated at that meeting remained with the special education teacher and then would have been sent to Rocklin High, and she does not actually know which IEP was implemented thereafter.
20. In her testimony, MOTHER expressed her impression that the emails from the RSPs were often too detailed.
21. The District made another administrative offer of placement, dated October 28, 2003, eight days prior to the November 5, 2003 IEP. The offer was consistent with prior offers by the District, and was shortlived. Examination of that offer would have no effect on the outcome of this Decision
22. STUDENT’s attorney stated in his closing brief that he did not recall Ms. Kelley’s document being introduced into evidence. The document was, in fact, admitted as District exhibit 4208.
23. The evidence showed that none of the teachers attempted to implement the administrative offer of placement.
24. Addressing the remaining assertions would have no effect on the outcome of this Decision.
25. See Student’s closing brief, page 21.
26. Other teachers reportedly had been invited to attend, but because of other obligations, did not. It is unknown whether those teachers would have been available to attend IEP meetings on other dates that had been canceled or rejected by MOTHER in the fall of 2003.
27. This request arose from the issues stated in the cross-filing by the District in Case No. SN04-00401 and was implicit in the issues stated in the prehearing conference order.
