California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 16, 2001
Student v. Temecula Valley Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 404-00 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel
Temecula Valley Unified must repay $130,165.74 for a brain-injury rehabilitation program and provide compensatory services after the student graduated.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Parents of a high school student filed against Temecula Valley Unified School District. The student had a traumatic brain injury from a skateboard accident in April 1998, during tenth grade. The District did not begin assessing him until September 1998. In December 1998 it found him eligible based on traumatic brain injury, but offered only Resource Specialist Program "monitoring" with no scheduled services. After behavior problems, the District twice moved him to home/hospital instruction.
The Hearing Officer found that the District violated its child-find duty by not assessing him in spring 1998, when it knew of his brain surgeries. The 1998 assessment was appropriate in academic, cognitive and social-emotional areas. However, the District failed to properly assess speech and language, vision, occupational therapy and physical therapy. Every IEP from December 1998 through February 2000 denied FAPE. None addressed his behavior or physical needs in a meaningful way. The home/hospital placements were not the least restrictive environment, and the extended school year services in his IEP were never provided. The February 2000 offer of Oak Grove nonpublic school plus an in-home behavior program was too vague under Union School District v. Smith. The parents' placement at the Center for Neuro Skills was appropriate even without academics, because it met his main behavioral and therapy needs. The District must repay $130,165.74 and provide at least nine months of compensatory language therapy, behavior support and college transition counseling, even though the student has graduated.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a serious brain injury as triggering child find even while the student was recovering. It held that a student's wish to avoid services did not excuse the district. It also approved reimbursement for a rehabilitation program with no academics and ordered compensatory transition services after graduation.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedChild find
Issue 1. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE from May 1998 through December 1998 by failing to identify him as a student eligible for special education and related services?
District knew of two brain surgeries and need for home instruction; its failure to assess when the student was ready to return in May 1998 violated child find and denied FAPE from May through December 1998.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 2. Did the District fail to properly assess STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year?
Academic, cognitive, psychomotor, vocational and social-emotional testing was appropriate, but the District failed to properly assess speech and language (protocols not followed, mis-scored), vision, OT and PT despite clear notice of those needs.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE from December 1998 through the end of the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 extended school year?
December 1998 IEP (RSP monitoring only, two goals) did not address behavior, motor or vision needs; April 1999 home/hospital addendum removed goals, ignored positive behavioral interventions and was not LRE; ESY in the IEP was never provided.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year?
District changed placement without an IEP meeting; September 1999 IEPs lacked goals and needed assessments; January 2000 IEP had no placement; February 2000 Oak Grove/in-home offer was too unspecific, with vague goals, no BIP and unassessed areas, and did not offer FAPE.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the tuition costs for STUDENT's attendance at the Center for Neuro Skills during the 1999-2000 school year?
Although CNS had no academic component, its brain-injury rehabilitation services met the student's primary behavioral and therapy needs during a short placement; parents awarded $130,165.74.
- Student prevailedTransition
Issue 6. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Compensatory education may be awarded after graduation; because the student never received required transition services and did not complete pragmatics therapy, District must provide at least nine months of services, though return to CNS was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days, reimburse parents $130,165.74 for tuition at the Center for Neuro Skills, April 2000 through August 2000.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 30 calendar days, convene an IEP meeting to develop a compensatory plan; reconvene after nine months to review progress and decide whether more services are needed.
- Compensatory education. For a minimum of nine months: language therapy addressing pragmatics and problem solving; an ongoing behavior management plan (organization, off-task behavior, judgment, social skills, task initiation and completion); counseling on specific college opportunities; counseling on and assistance arranging college disability services; other services based on the student's preferences, interests and needs. No hours specified.
Total: $130,165.74 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; School Committee of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Board of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Valerie J. v. Derry Coop. School Dist.; Cal. Ed. Code § 56301; Cal. Ed. Code § 56320; Cal. Ed. Code § 56345; Cal. Ed. Code § 56345.1; Cal. Ed. Code § 56346
People named in the decision
- Edwin Egelsee, assistant to Student's counsel
- Deborah Miller, director of special education, Temecula Valley USD
- Troy Knudsvig, program administrator, Temecula Valley USD
- Dr. Lamont Lee, private treating psychologist, Private
- Al Cariss, RSP teacher and case manager, Temecula Valley USD
- James Nolen, general education teacher, Temecula Valley USD
- Jim Smolenski, assistant principal, Temecula Valley High School
- Vicki Alban, RSP teacher; home/hospital teacher, Temecula Valley USD
- Roxanne Hunter, school nurse, Temecula Valley USD
- Eric Hollins, school psychologist (1998 assessment), Temecula Valley USD
- Lisa Dorn, school psychologist (October 1999 assessment), Temecula Valley USD
- Richard Thompson, home/hospital teacher, Temecula Valley USD
- Chris Persel, clinical case manager, Center for Neuro Skills
- Brenda Morgan, school psychologist (functional behavior analysis), Temecula Valley USD
- Dr. Mary Joann Lang, neuropsychologist retained by District to assess, Independent contractor for District
- Dr. Jeffrey Garrett, psychologist assisting neuropsychological testing
- John Hannaman, speech-language pathologist, Temecula Valley USD
- Michael Runyen, director of child welfare and attendance, Temecula Valley USD
- Deanne Johnson, school psychologist
- Catherine McIntyre, school nurse
- Edward Sibby, home/hospital teacher, Temecula Valley USD
- Charles Smith, school counselor
- Chris Martinez, occupational therapist
- Sandra Skeith, case manager (senior year), Temecula Valley USD
- Liz McCaughey, registrar (also described as language therapist), Temecula Valley USD
- Pam Metzger, speech therapist, Temecula Valley USD
- Dr. Jack Schnel, psychologist, District witness
- Tasha Arneson, director of outpatient and day program services, Oak Grove (nonpublic school)
- Yvonne Beaman, assistant principal, Temecula Valley High School
- Sharon Popp, director of special education, Temecula Valley USD
- Coral French, school psychologist
- Donna Ramirez, teacher
- Nanci Jordan, ROP (retail occupational program) teacher
- Shannon Abrams, former teacher
- Delvnn Heid, former teacher
- David Dempster, former teacher
- Dr. Clark, private treating physician
- Center for Neuro Skills, nonpublic agency; residential brain-injury rehabilitation program (unilateral placement)
- Oak Grove, nonpublic school offered by District
- Kitlowski and Associates, in-home behavior intervention provider offered by District
- Rancho Physical Therapy, private OT/PT provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Temecula, California, on May 15 and 16, and August 21, 22, 23, 24, 27 28, and 29, 2001.
STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathleen Loyer. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were MOTHER, his mother; FATHER, his father (present on May 15 and 16, and August 22, 23, 24, 27, and 28); and Edwin Egelsee, assistant to Ms. Loyer. Temecula Valley Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Nancy Stephens. Also present on the District’s behalf was Deborah Miller, District director of special education, and Troy Knudsvig, program administrator (present on August 21 only).
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Dr. Lamont Lee, psychologist; Al Cariss, Resource Specialist Program (RSP) teacher; James Nolen, teacher; Jim Smolenski, assistant principal; Vicki Alban, RSP teacher; Roxanne Hunter, school nurse; Eric Hollins, school psychologist; Lisa Dorn, school psychologist; Richard Thompson, teacher; Chris Persel, clinical case manager; Brenda Morgan, school psychologist; Dr. Mary Joann Lang, neuro-psychologist; John Hannaman, speech pathologist; Michael Runyen, director of child welfare and attendance; Deanne Johnson, school psychologist; Catherine McIntyre, school nurse; Edward Sibby, teacher; Charles Smith, school counselor; Chris Martinez, occupational therapist; and MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Sandra Skeith, case manager; Liz McCaughey, registrar; Pam Metzger, speech therapist; Dr. Jack Schnel, psychologist; Deborah Miller, director of special education; Tasha Arneson, director of outpatient and day program services; Yvonne Beaman, assistant principal; Sharon Popp, director of special education; Coral French, school psychologist; Donna Ramirez, teacher; and Nanci Jordan, teacher. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the final brief on September 20, 2001, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from May 1998 through December 1998 by failing to identify him as a student eligible for special education and related services?
2. Did the District fail to properly assess STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year?
3. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from December 1998 through the end of 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 extended school year?
4. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the tuition costs for STUDENT’s attendance at the Center for Neuro Skills during the 1999-2000 school year?
6. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
From May 1998 through December 1998, Petitioner contends that the District denied him a FAPE because it failed in its “child-find” duties as set forth in California Education Code Section 56301. The District contends that it was not appropriate to identify and assess Petitioner because he was in a period of rapid recovery from his accident. The District argues that it was therefore reasonable to expect that Petitioner could continue to be educated within the regular education program. Petitioner argues that the serious nature and severity of his accident should have triggered an assessment, regardless of the course of his recovery.
For the 1998-1999 school year, Petitioner contends that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. In addition, Petitioner contends that the District denied him a FAPE because of procedural violations and because the District’s program was substantively inappropriate. Petitioner also contends that the District failed to provide him with extended school year services during the summer of 1999. The District contends that it did assess Petitioner in all areas. Furthermore, the District contends that it provided Petitioner with a FAPE because the program offered a basic floor of opportunity to Petitioner. The District also contends that Petitioner did not want any direct special education services.
For the 1999-2000 school year, Petitioner contends that the District continued in its failure to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. In addition, Petitioner contends that the District denied him a FAPE because of procedural violations of the IDEA and because the District’s program was not substantively appropriate. The District’s assertions for this school year are the same as for the 1998-1999 school year.
Petitioner contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for his unilateral placement at the Center for Neuro Skills during the 1999-2000 school year. The District contends that this unilateral placement was not appropriate because it had no educational component. In addition, the District contends that its offer of placement was appropriate in that it offered Petitioner a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.
Petitioner also seeks compensatory education. The District contends that compensatory education is not appropriate because Petitioner graduated from high school, demonstrated good academic skills, and received a proper transition plan.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT was born on [date redacted]. He graduated from high school in the Temecula Valley School District in June 2001. STUDENT was diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, and began taking Ritalin in the seventh grade. Prior to April 1998, STUDENT had never been identified as eligible for special education and related services. On April 22, 1998, STUDENT was involved in a skateboard accident that resulted in a traumatic brain injury. STUDENT was hospitalized and underwent two craniotomies. At that time, STUDENT was in the tenth grade at Temecula Valley High School. In May 1998, STUDENT was referred to Rancho Physical Therapy (RPT) by his treating doctor, Dr. Clark. STUDENT was complaining of pain in his low back, bilateral knee and right ankle pain, and pain in his left hand. STUDENT was also experiencing double vision. STUDENT began receiving occupational and physical therapy from RPT. In June 1998, STUDENT was diagnosed with right optic nerve atrophy, right 6th nerve palsy and visual field defects consistent with his brain injury (Student Exhibit 15). STUDENT underwent EMG testing in June 1998 that revealed left upper extremity ulnar neuropathy (Student Exhibit 14).
After the accident in April, STUDENT did not return to regular classes that school year. During May and June 1998, STUDENT received home/hospital instruction taught by Richard Thompson. STUDENT took only driver’s education and world history in the third trimester of the 1997-1998 school year. Because of the accident, it was decided that STUDENT should repeat the tenth grade. In the fall of the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT returned to school on a modified program. He enrolled in only three classes. MOTHER noticed that STUDENT was very tired each day after school and that he was having some social problems. MOTHER decided to reduce STUDENT’s schedule to just one class, U.S. History. On August 31, 1998, MOTHER wrote to Mrs. Beaman, the assistant principal, and asked that STUDENT be evaluated by Eric Hollins, the school psychologist. An assessment plan was prepared and approved by MOTHER on September 15, 1998. The plan called for STUDENT to be evaluated in the areas of academic achievement, social/emotional adaptive behavior, psychomotor development, intellectual development, vocational/career development and vision/hearing (Student Exhibit 31). Also in September, STUDENT was hospitalized at Charter Hospital for a suicide attempt. Upon release from Charter, STUDENT started counseling with Dr. Lamont Lee, a psychologist. STUDENT was prescribed Resperdol and Depakote.
Mr. Hollins completed his assessment report in December 1998 (Student Exhibit 44). Roxanne Hunter, the school nurse, and Al Cariss, a special education teacher, collaborated on the report. Mr. Hollins noted that STUDENT complained of headaches, blurred vision and excessive fatigue. STUDENT had developed swan neck deformity over three fingers of his left hand. During the testing, Mr. Hollins noticed that STUDENT used his right hand exclusively. STUDENT also complained of left leg and knee pain, and walked with a limp. The report noted that STUDENT was receiving physical and occupational therapy and counseling. Mr. Hollins stated that the biggest change since the accident was in STUDENT’s behavior. In addition to his suicide attempt, STUDENT had exhibited violent rages at home resulting in verbal and physical abuse of his parents. Mr. Hollins observed STUDENT in class and interviewed his teacher, Mr. Nolen. Mr. Hollins noticed that STUDENT was off task for much of an independent reading assignment, and required assistance from a classmate during a writing assignment. Mr. Nolen stated that STUDENT tried, but seemed to have trouble processing the information. STUDENT told Mr. Hollins that he was upset about his life and felt that what was happening to him was unfair. STUDENT said that he was having trouble concentrating and staying focused on anything. STUDENT felt he had lost some of his friends because “they don’t understand me now.”
Mr. Hollins administered the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III), the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML), and the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI). On the WISC-III, STUDENT attained a full scale IQ score of 94, which placed him in the average range. Mr. Hollins noted that STUDENT’s test-taking behavior demonstrated impulsivity and that STUDENT did not attempt problems that seemed too hard or would take too long to complete. STUDENT scored in the 1st percentile on the coding subtest, which could indicate problems with concentration and memory. STUDENT also scored in the low average range on subtests involving the processing of visual material. On the WRAML, a test of visual and auditory memory, STUDENT scored below average. However, Mr. Hollins noted that on a similar task on the WISC-III testing auditory sequential memory, STUDENT scored significantly better. Mr. Hollins stated that impulsivity and attentional problems could have affected STUDENT’s score on the WRAML. On the VMI, STUDENT scored in the average range. Mr. Hollins observed that STUDENT continued to skip tasks that were more difficult or time-consuming. To test STUDENT’s academic achievement, Al Cariss administered the Wide Range Achievement Test - 3rd Edition (WRAT-3), the Woodcock-Johnson Psychoeducational Battery-Revised (WJ-R), and the Test of Written Language - 3rd Edition (TOWL-3). In broad reading, STUDENT scored in the average range. However, STUDENT’s reading comprehension skills were only at the 7.6 grade level. STUDENT’s mathematics scores were also in the average range. Mr. Hollins noted that STUDENT skipped most problems requiring fractional computation and made errors on multi-digit division problems. STUDENT’s written language skills were in the average range on both the TOWL-3 and the WRAT-3.
Mr. Hollins also gave STUDENT two self-report tests: the Reynolds Adolescent Depression Rating Scale (RADS) and the Behavior Assessment System for Children Rating Scale (BASC). STUDENT’s responses on the RADS were within the normal range for his age. STUDENT’s answers on the BASC indicated that STUDENT felt he was having significant relationship problems with his parents. STUDENT also had a score in the “at risk” range on the “locus of control” scale. This indicated that STUDENT felt that aspects of his life were being controlled by others. STUDENT’s parents completed the Devereux Scales of Mental Disorders (DSMD), the Attention Deficit Disorder Evaluation Scale (ADDES), and the BASC. The PARENT’s responses indicated that they were concerned about STUDENT’s aggression, conduct problems, depression, somatic complaints and attentional problems. In his conclusions, Mr. Hollins stated that STUDENT had expressed a desire to not have any direct special education services. Mr. Hollins recommended that the Individualized Education Program (IEP) team be sensitive to this desire.
The school nurse did a vision and hearing screening (Student Exhibit 12). The screening noted significant visual changes because of the accident, but indicated that they were corrected with glasses. The hearing testing was within normal limits. John Hannaman had performed a speech and language assessment in August 1998 (District Exhibit 26). The results of this testing were incorporated into the assessment report. STUDENT’s test results were generally in the average range; however, his score on the test of expressive language was 23 points higher than his score on the test of receptive language. Mr. Hannaman stated that this could indicate a mild retrieval problem, and recommended retesting in six months.
An IEP team meeting was held on December 8, 1998 (Student Exhibit 21). The team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services as a result of a traumatic brain injury. STUDENT’s disability caused problems with attention, memory and fatigue which affected his ability to stay focused and follow through with assignments. Under “Present Levels of Performance,” the following were noted:
• STUDENT’s gross motor skills were affected by the accident. His mobility was slightly impaired. • STUDENT’s behavior at school was good. His teacher felt STUDENT was frustrated in class. STUDENT’s parents said his behavior at home was aggressive, belligerent, and angry. • STUDENT was legally blind in his right eye. He was receiving occupational therapy, physical therapy and counseling(Footnote 2). STUDENT was experiencing fatigue. • STUDENT’s daily living skills were age appropriate, but he required many reminders from his parents. • STUDENT avoided difficult tasks, and at times lost focus.
Placement was in a Resource Specialist Program (RSP) class, for monitoring only. It was explained that “monitoring only” meant that STUDENT had no scheduled time in the RSP class, but could go there for assistance when he felt the need. Summer school also was part of the placement. Two goals were listed. The first called for STUDENT to visit his case manager regarding general education classes. The second goal called for STUDENT to visit the career center regarding employment opportunities. STUDENT was to look for sources of employment information, complete a job application, rehearse interview skills, and prepare a resume. STUDENT would be on a modified schedule of four periods a day to accommodate his rehabilitation schedule. Mr. and MRS. PARENT approved the IEP.
Al Cariss was the RSP teacher and STUDENT’s case manager. Over the next several months, STUDENT did not visit the RSP class on a regular basis. STUDENT did fail a U.S. History test, which he was allowed to retake in the RSP class. Mr. Cariss attempted to counsel STUDENT on his off-task behavior, impulsivity, anger management and social skills. Mr. Cariss did not find STUDENT very receptive to his counseling. STUDENT also was displaying some behavior problems in class. STUDENT also was exhibiting fatigue and making some inappropriate comments. Mr. Cariss believed STUDENT was having some social problems. STUDENT did not visit the career center. STUDENT failed the U.S. History class, his only class in the first trimester. STUDENT passed three out of the four classes he took in the second trimester.
STUDENT enrolled in four classes for the third trimester. During the third trimester, STUDENT’s behavior deteriorated further. Mr. Smolenski, an assistant principal, and MOTHER received complaints that STUDENT had threatened some of his friends. In addition, Mr. Smolenski had received “sexual harassment” complaints against STUDENT. It was alleged that STUDENT was making inappropriate comments to girls and engaging in inappropriate touching. MOTHER was afraid that something bad was going to happen, so she called Mrs. Beaman, an assistant principal, and told her that she was pulling STUDENT out of school. Mrs. Beaman offered to provide home/hospital instruction to STUDENT. Vicki Alban was assigned as STUDENT’s home/hospital teacher.
An IEP meeting was convened on April 29, 1999 (Student Exhibit 22). The IEP team recommended that STUDENT be on home/hospital instruction to reduce his stress and minimize peer conflicts. The PARENTS approved this IEP. The day after the IEP meeting, FATHER noticed that STUDENT had been dispensed the wrong medications, and had been taking the wrong medications for the previous three weeks. STUDENT was supposed to be taking DDAVP, but was given Detrol. According to MOTHER, the Detrol listed side-effects that included changes in behavior. The PARENTS believed that the medication mistake could have caused the behaviors that were of concern. MOTHER immediately informed Mr. Smolenski of their discovery. STUDENT remained on home instruction anyway.
During the home instruction, Ms. Alban noticed that STUDENT was having trouble with attention and off-task behavior. She also observed that STUDENT had difficulty sitting for an extended period of time, retaining material over time, reasoning, writing, and expressing himself verbally. She also stated that STUDENT had problems with headaches, fatigue and occasional depression. STUDENT did better when tasks were broken down into small segments with frequent review. The only formal goal she was told to address was to try to get STUDENT to examine social situations and explore options for dealing with these situations. Ms. Alban received this goal verbally from Mr. Smolenski. Ms. Alban believed that STUDENT had become better able to understand the feelings of others by the end of the trimester. Ms. Alban’s instruction ended in June 1999 and STUDENT received good grades in all four of his classes. STUDENT did not receive any instruction during the summer of 1999.
STUDENT enrolled in general education classes in the fall of 1999. At back-to-school night, MOTHER discovered that none of STUDENT’s teachers knew he was a special education student and had an IEP. MOTHER called Ms. Beaman and complained about this situation. The next day Mr. Cariss called her back and suggested a “mini IEP” meeting to go over STUDENT’s status.
An IEP meeting was held on September 14, 1999, with STUDENT in attendance (Student Exhibit 23). At the meeting, the IEP team received reports from STUDENT’s teachers. The reports indicated that STUDENT was keeping up with all of his academics. The team discussed whether STUDENT continued to need any RSP services. MOTHER requested that STUDENT remain in the RSP for monitoring only. Mr. Smolenski spoke about his concerns in relation to the sexual harassment complaints. Mr. Smolenski stated that there had been new complaints. STUDENT became very angry, threw his backpack across the room, and left the meeting. Mr. Smolenski followed STUDENT out of the meeting, and called campus security. Mr. Smolenski and a campus security officer followed STUDENT around campus, telling him to stop. STUDENT continued to walk way from them, telling them to leave him alone, and apparently used some colorful language in the process. At some point, regular police arrived. The police approached STUDENT, pepper-sprayed him, forced him to the ground, and handcuffed him. At this point, MOTHER arrived on the scene. She calmed STUDENT down, and she and STUDENT convinced the police to remove the handcuffs. MOTHER was allowed to take STUDENT home. A disciplinary meeting was held on September 16. At the meeting, it was decided STUDENT would be suspended for 5 days, retroactive to September 15 (Student Exhibit 35).
Another IEP meeting was held on September 21, 1999 (Student Exhibit 24). Mr. Cariss said that STUDENT was failing some of his classes. The IEP team determined that STUDENT would remain in the RSP for monitoring only. The team also determined that additional testing was required to formulate a behavior plan to address STUDENT’s social problems. It was agreed that Dr. Lee, the psychologist who was counseling STUDENT, would work with the school psychologist throughout the evaluation process and in the development of the behavior plan. STUDENT also was to meet with Mr. Hollins on a weekly basis, and Mr. Hollins would discuss any issues that arose with Dr. Lee. The assessment plan called for Lisa Dorn, another school psychologist, to assess STUDENT’s social, emotional, and behavioral development. Ms. Dorn also was to conduct observations and interviews (District Exhibit 20). On the day of the IEP meeting of September 21, Mr. Smolenski presented STUDENT with a “behavior contract” (District Exhibit 21). This document stated that it was a “formal written warning and notification...that [STUDENT] has displayed inappropriate conduct which will not be tolerated.” The “inappropriate conduct” was listed as sexual harassment and inappropriate touching of females, harassment and intimidation, and defiance of authority. STUDENT returned to school on the September 22. On the 23rd, there was another incident during which STUDENT allegedly grabbed a girl’s ankle. Another discipline meeting was held on the September 24. STUDENT was again suspended for five days, beginning September 27.
An IEP meeting was held on September 30, 1999 (Student Exhibit 25). At the meeting, the PARENTS were presented with a new assessment plan (District Exhibit 19). STUDENT was to be assessed by a neuro-psychologist in the areas of cognitive development, speech and language, and social/emotional/behavioral development. The plan also called for a functional behavior analysis to be completed by District staff. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT receive ten hours of home/hospital instruction until both the September 21, 1999, and the September 30, 1999 assessments were completed. The team also offered to refer STUDENT to county mental health, but the PARENTS declined this offer. MOTHER accepted this IEP.
Mr. Sibby was STUDENT’s home/hospital teacher. Mr. Sibby only taught STUDENT for a few weeks. Mr. Sibby believed that he was having trouble getting STUDENT to focus on material. STUDENT would try to engage Mr. Sibby in conversations, rather than work on the assigned course material. Mr. Sibby and MOTHER mutually agreed that Mr. Sibby was not being successful with STUDENT, and a new home/hospital teacher, Richard Thompson, was assigned. Mr. Thompson noted that STUDENT displayed numerous problems. STUDENT’s vision problems impaired his reading. STUDENT had trouble maintaining attention on what he read, but was better able to maintain attention on material he enjoyed. Mr. Thompson believed that STUDENT avoided writing because he did not have the patience to reduce his thoughts to writing. Mr. Thompson stated that STUDENT enjoyed math and science. STUDENT liked to do hands-on work, but that the lack of facilities and supplies in the home/hospital setting made lab work difficult. Mr. Thompson noted that STUDENT did better on short quizzes than he did on longer tests. Mr. Thompson said that, socially, STUDENT was very opinionated and aggressive in discussing controversial issues. STUDENT had little patience for people who did not see things his way (Student Exhibit 5). STUDENT underwent an emergency appendectomy during this trimester, which delayed completion of the assessments.
Lisa Dorn, a school psychologist, completed an assessment report dated October 11, 1999 (District Exhibit 22). Ms. Dorn stated that the purpose of her assessment was to determine if STUDENT was emotionally disturbed. Ms. Dorn received written reports from three of STUDENT’s former teachers: Shannon Abrams, Delvnn Heid, and David Dempster. Ms. Dorn administered the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory - Adolescent (MMPI-A), the BASC, and the RADS. All of STUDENT’s teachers noted off-task behavior. Two noted problems with social interaction. On the MMPI-A, STUDENT’s scores were generally in the normal range. STUDENT’s scores were slightly elevated on the somatic scale and on the hysteria scale; however, because of his injuries, neither of these scores was seen as significant. STUDENT’s responses on the BASC and the RADS also were within the normal range. Ms. Dorn concluded that the behavioral and emotional problems that STUDENT had displayed were the result of his traumatic brain injury, not an underlying psychopathology. Ms. Dorn believed that STUDENT felt he was physically different from other students, that his friends had turned their backs on him, and that sports were lost to him.
Dr. Lang was the neuro-psychologist the District hired to assess STUDENT. Her report was dated December 8, 1999 (Student Exhibit 41). Dr. Jeffrey Garrett, a psychologist, assisted Dr. Lang with the testing. Dr. Lang reviewed various medical records, including progress notes from Dr. Lee. Dr. Lee’s notes indicated that his goals were to reduce STUDENT’s depression, irritability and impulsiveness, and improve his concentration and appropriate behavior. Dr. Lee indicated that progress had not been good. Dr. Lang also reviewed the 1998 assessments done by the District. Dr. Lang administered the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale - Third Edition (WAIS-III), the Wechsler Memory Scales - Third Edition (WMS-III), the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), the Halstead-Reitan Neuropsychological Test Battery for Adults (Halstead), the Test of Variable Attention (TOVA), the WJ-R, and the Millon Adolescent Personality Inventory. On the WAIS-III, STUDENT obtained a full scale IQ of 105, within the average range. STUDENT’s neurological functioning was in the normal range. All problems noted were related to STUDENT’s motor skills and coordination deficits on his left side. In the area of attention and concentration, STUDENT’s scores were varied. STUDENT had consistent difficulty with visual attention tasks. His performance on auditory attention tasks was more variable, appearing to be dependent on the demands of the task and STUDENT’s interest in the subject matter.
In the areas of receptive and expressive language, STUDENT’s scores, overall, were in the average range. However, testing revealed that STUDENT had problems with pragmatic communication skills, emotional reactivity, and poor impulse control. STUDENT’s visual/spatial skills were in the average range, and showed improvement over the results of the prior testing. Dr. Lang stated that this was probably due to ongoing recovery from the traumatic brain injury. STUDENT demonstrated a severe impairment in the area of fine motor control. Dr. Lang observed that STUDENT was unable to use his left hand for any fine or gross motor grasping, and required special finger braces on each finger of his left hand. Dr. Lang also noted that the medical records indicated that there were concerns regarding STUDENT’s vision in his right eye. In the areas of memory and learning, STUDENT’s scores were again in the average range. Testing did indicate that STUDENT’s strength was in the area of language skills, and he had difficulty with visual attention to detail. STUDENT demonstrated some problems in the area of auditory working memory, and immediate memory recall. STUDENT’s academic skills were consistent with his intellectual ability. STUDENT demonstrated strengths in reading and math skills, and difficulties with written language. On the MAPI, STUDENT’s answers indicated the he was moody, impulsive and unpredictable. STUDENT had feelings of low self-worth, felt misunderstood, and was easily angered. STUDENT showed a marked disinclination to restrain his impulses and reflect on probable consequences.
Dr. Lang concluded that STUDENT’s TBI caused ongoing deficits in the areas of motor control, vision, attention, concentration, and resulted in verbal and physical aggression towards himself and others. Dr. Lang made the following recommendations:
• follow-up by a physiatrist to gain and maintain as much sensory and motor function as possible • follow-up by a neurologist or psychiatrist to monitor medications • annual ophthalmological exams to monitor STUDENT’s vision deficits • physical therapy • occupational therapy • language assessment to assess STUDENT’s pragmatic language skills
Dr. Lang made the following cognitive recommendations:
• STUDENT will respond better to situations he finds interesting. Time required for sustained attention to tasks should be balanced with more active, hands-on learning. • STUDENT will tend to lose focus more as the day progressed. The most demanding material should be in the morning. • Auditory, visual and social distractions should be limited. STUDENT will also need a place to unwind and de-stress during the school day. • STUDENT will tend to be overwhelmed by large assignments. Tasks need to be adjusted down to smaller sizes. • Teachers need to make sure STUDENT establishes eye contact before instruction begins in order to improve his understanding and task follow through. • Directions need to be given one step at a time. In addition the use of multiple modes of instruction would assist STUDENT’s understanding.
Dr. Lang made the following recommendations in relation to the educational environment:
• STUDENT needs an academic environment that incorporates general behavioral modification training. STUDENT needs assistance in the areas of basic skills planning, natural consequences, multi-step task completion, problem identification, problem solving without aggression, and basic daily living skills. STUDENT needs to learn to generalize his social skills training. • STUDENT needs an environment that utilizes behavior contracts, structured consequences, and watches for attentional problems and impulsivity. • STUDENT needs small group instruction at a slower pace, and with shorter sessions. • STUDENT needs instruction by a properly trained staff, familiar with the consequences of a TBI. • STUDENT would also need ongoing individual and group therapy to assist him in behavior modification. • Family therapy would also be useful in helping STUDENT and his family deal with STUDENT’s problems.
Brenda Morgan completed the functional behavior analysis report on January 11, 2000 (District Exhibit 18). Ms. Morgan testified that a functional behavior analysis is done to determine why problem behaviors are occurring and to identify substitute behaviors. Based on this information, a behavior intervention plan is developed. STUDENT’s problem behavior was described as inappropriate and unwanted touching of female students along with negative comments. The behavior had occurred in student transition areas and school lunch areas. Because STUDENT was in home/hospital, Ms. Morgan could not observe him in the setting where the problem behaviors had occurred, nor could she attempt to substitute different behaviors. Ms. Morgan reviewed medical records and contacted some of STUDENT’s teachers, including Richard Thompson and Vicky Alban, as well as school psychologist Eric Hollins and assistant principal Jim Smolenski. Ms. Morgan hypothesized that the problem behaviors resulted from STUDENT’s efforts to be included in peer groups. Ms. Morgan also hypothesized that a structured setting inhibited the behaviors, because the problem behaviors did not appear to occur in class. No behavior intervention plan was developed.
An IEP meeting was held on January 19, 2000 (District Exhibit 3). By all accounts this was a very lengthy and involved meeting. The team developed goals, but did not decide on a placement. The District members of the team also recommended additional assessments in the areas of occupational therapy, assistive technology, and adaptive physical therapy. The IEP team identified the following needs and developed goals to address those needs:
1. STUDENT did not initiate tasks without prompts and assistance. The goal was for STUDENT to stop a non-goal-directed activity and redirect himself with only nonverbal and environmental cues on eight out of ten activities.STUDENT did not produce written work beyond one or two paragraphs. The goal was for STUDENT to increase the integration of relevant information into written output by completing a two to three paragraph essay incorporating relevant data without monitoring by his teacher. 3. STUDENT needed to increase his awareness and understanding of social cues and respond in a socially appropriate manner. The goal was written the same as the need. 4. STUDENT needed to explore possible careers and to determine two or three areas of interest. The goal was for STUDENT to take formal and informal career assessments and participate in career activities. 5. STUDENT needed assistance with organizational and sequencing skills. The goal was for STUDENT to complete all assignments within the allotted time lines.
At the IEP meeting, the PARENTS informed the District that STUDENT would be attending the Center for Neuro Skills (CNS), a nonpublic agency located in Bakersfield. The PARENTS requested that the District pay for this placement. The District personnel agreed to gather more information about CNS and discuss placement at a reconvened IEP meeting. Other matters still to be decided were the percentage of time STUDENT would be in special education, transportation, and extended school year services. Sharon Popp, the director of special education, visited CNS. She recalled that the program provided occupational therapy, and speech and language therapy, but had no real educational component. Ms. Popp also was concerned about CNS because it was a residential program, and most of the clients were older than STUDENT. From her visit, she concluded that the District should explore other placement options.
The next IEP meeting was on February 23, 2000 (District Exhibit 2). At this IEP, no new goals were developed, but a placement offer was made. Staff from Oak Grove, a nonpublic school, gave a presentation about their program. There is some dispute as to what this presentation contained. Tasha Arneson, the director of Oak Grove, testified at the hearing. She stated that the Oak Grove staff did not have STUDENT’s IEP when they made their presentation, so they gave a general description of their program. Oak Grove is a K-12 school, providing six hours a day of combined instruction and therapeutic services. Services include counseling and behavior modification plans. Oak Grove has adaptive physical therapy available and can provide occupational therapy, physical therapy and speech and language therapy if those services are requested by the District. Ms. Arneson testified that Oak Grove had a program for children with neurological injuries in place as of February 2000. The program included several students suffering from traumatic brain injuries. Dr. Lang and MOTHER both recall that Oak Grove was offering to develop a TBI program to serve STUDENT, but did not then have one in place. None of the other witnesses had any specific recollection about the presentation by Oak Grove at the IEP. The District offered the following placement:
• A day treatment program at Oak Grove for six to eight hours a day • An in home behavior modification program provide by Kitlowski and Associates for one to three hours a day • One hour a month of consultation by a neuro-psychologist • An occupational therapy assessment, possibly including assistive technology • An adaptive physical therapy assessment • A visually handicapped services assessment • Referral to mental health • A speech and language assessment in the area of pragmatics only • Door to door transportation • Extended school year services
The PARENTS did not accept the offer of placement, and placed STUDENT at CNS April 2000. Chris Persel, STUDENT’s case manager at CNS, had done an initial evaluation of STUDENT in January 2000 (Student Exhibit 57). Mr. Persel concluded that STUDENT had a moderate level of disability, and was a good candidate for a post-acute rehabilitation program. Mr. Persel recommended that STUDENT attend CNS for several months, then return to the District for his senior year. Mr. Persel concluded that STUDENT had ongoing problems in the areas of cognition, impulsivity, judgement, low endurance, decreased initiation, low frustration tolerance, poor social skills, depression and poor adjustment to his disability. Mr. Persel recommended an integrated program involving counseling, a behavioral program, physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, living skills, and educational services. STUDENT was admitted to CNS on April 3, 2000. CNS’s general treatment team goals were for STUDENT to improve his cognitive, physical, and psychosocial skills so that he could live with his parents, attend school, and reintegrate socially into the community without disruptive behavior (Student Exhibit 58). CNS staff evaluated STUDENT in the areas of medical, residential rehabilitation, cognition/speech pathology, education, occupational therapy, physical therapy, and psychosocial functioning. Goals and objectives were developed in each area. STUDENT was the youngest client in the residential program. However, there were other clients who were 19, 20 and 21 years old. There were also female clients and female staff members. STUDENT received up to five hours of therapy a day, Monday through Friday. A Rehabilitation assistant was provided in the apartment setting to supervise morning, evening and overnight hours. In addition, there were two community outings each week that allowed STUDENT to learn to generalize his social skills.
STUDENT was discharged from CNS in August 2000. The discharge assessment found that STUDENT had made improvement in all areas (Student Exhibit 60). Specifically, CNS found that STUDENT had shown improvement in independent living skills, balance and coordination, visual perceptual disruption, cognitive and processing difficulties, and psychosocial adjustment issues. CNS made numerous recommendations for ongoing services, both at school and at home. The following are the major recommendations:
• Provide a developmental optometrist to follow visual needs • Maintain a consistent, structured daily routine • Continue Speech/language therapy to continue to address memory and attention deficits • Continue use of a day planner to improve STUDENT’s ability to recall details • Require STUDENT to write down all instructions and assignments in his day planner • Provide STUDENT with a “buddy” at school so STUDENT can double check notes and assignments • Provide a one-on-one, or one-on-two aide throughout the school day to monitor behavior and provide assistance • Provide all assignments in writing • Continue occupational therapy to address left upper extremity function • Continue occupational therapy to address driving issues • Continue physical therapy to address left ankle strength and gait training • Continue one-on-one and family counseling to address readjustment issues
On August 8, 2000, an IEP meeting was held to transition STUDENT from CNS into the District. It was determined that STUDENT would attend Chaparral High School, in general education, with RSP monitoring provided. In addition, STUDENT would have an aide throughout the day. A full assessment would be completed and further services determined during the first trimester.
On October 3, 2000, the final IEP meeting was held (District Exhibit 1). It was decided that STUDENT would continue at Chaparral High School for his senior year. He would be in RSP for 69 minutes a day, five days a week. STUDENT would also receive speech therapy one day a week for 30 minutes. STUDENT would receive home/hospital instruction for six weeks to complete Algebra 2A. STUDENT’s one-on-one aide would be used only on an as-needed basis. Goals were developed in the areas of language pragmatics/problem solving, and completion of assignments. Instruction on a five-finger keyboard would be provided, as well as a “study buddy.” An audiology assessment was to be performed. The IEP stated that in order to graduate STUDENT needed to complete Algebra 2A, complete 10 hours of community service and pass the writing proficiency test.
STUDENT completed almost all his classes during the 2000-2001 school year and graduated from high school. In the third trimester, he received 15 units for a retail internship program. STUDENT’s language therapy was scheduled for after school hours.(Footnote 3) Pam Metzger, the therapist, was working with STUDENT on a three-part program in pragmatics and problem solving. STUDENT completed most of the first section. This proceeded to hearing while STUDENT was in his senior year, and STUDENT graduated before the hearing concluded.
FINDING OF FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from May 1998 through December 1998 by failing to identify him as a student eligible for special education and related services?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that is provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 (d); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000, 56031. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
California law requires each school district to maintain a continuous child-find system which addresses the identification, screening, referral, assessment, planning, implementation, review, and the triennial assessment of students who may be eligible for special education. Cal. Ed. Code § 56301.
STUDENT suffered a traumatic brain injury as the result of a skateboard accident in April 1998. The PARENTS provided the District with medical records, and the District kept in touch with the PARENTS through Mr. Hollins, the school psychologist. Mr. Hollins’ May 1, 1998 memorandum to STUDENT’s teachers states that STUDENT had undergone two brain surgeries, would not return to school during that trimester, and would begin home schooling as soon as he was able (Student Exhibit 9). STUDENT received home/hospital instruction from Mr. Thompson in May and June 1998. The District contends that the information it had led it to believe that STUDENT was recovering and could be served as a regular education student during the remainder of the 1997-1998 school year.
The District’s failure to assess STUDENT after he returned to school in May 1998 was a violation of its child-find obligation. The District was aware that STUDENT had undergone two brain surgeries. The District was also aware that STUDENT required home instruction in May and June 1998 just to complete two classes. An injury as serious as STUDENT’s should have triggered the District’s child-find system and a formal assessment plan should have been prepared as soon as the District was made aware that STUDENT was ready to return to school. The District’s argument that STUDENT appeared to be recovering rapidly is of no avail in this kind of injury. This was not the kind of injury for which full recovery could have been expected in a matter of weeks or even months. Dr. Lang, the neuro-psychologist hired by the District to assess STUDENT, testified that the most rapid recovery from a brain injury occurs during the first six to eight months following the injury. However, significant recovery continues to occur for approximately two years. The District took no formal action to investigate STUDENT’s medical condition, assess his level of injury, or assess the impact of STUDENT’s injuries on his education.
When the District did begin to assess STUDENT in September 1998, it found him eligible for special education. According to Dr. Lang, STUDENT’s condition was probably worse in May 1998 than in September 1998. Therefore, it is concluded that, had the District assessed STUDENT in May or June 1998, it would have found him eligible for special education at that time. Had the District found STUDENT eligible in June 1998, it could have developed an appropriate IEP for STUDENT for the 1998 extended school year, or at least for the beginning of the 1998-1999 school year. As it was, the District did not hold its first IEP meeting for STUDENT until December 1998.
As a result of its failure to assess STUDENT in May 1998, the District denied STUDENT a free and appropriate public education from May 1998 through December 1998, when the District did find him eligible for special education.
2. Did the District fail to properly assess Petitioner during the 1998-1999 school year?
The law requires the school district to assess students in all areas of suspected disability including, when appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, interests, and social emotional status. The assessments must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.
The District prepared its first assessment plan in September 1998. At that time, what were STUDENT’s areas of suspected disability? In July 1998, the PARENTS, at their doctor’s direction, had requested that STUDENT be assessed in the area of speech and language.(Footnote 4) The assessment plan itself called for STUDENT to be assessed in the areas of academics, social/emotional behavior, psychomotor development, intellectual development, vocational development, vision, and hearing. The assessment team report stated that STUDENT suffered from a swan neck deformity over three fingers of his left hand and noted that STUDENT only used his right hand during testing. It was also noted that STUDENT complained of left leg and knee pain and walked with a limp. Furthermore, the report stated that STUDENT was receiving occupational therapy, physical therapy and counseling.(Footnote 5) The school nurse’s vision screening indicated that STUDENT was suffering from significant visual changes because of his accident, but stated that his vision was corrected with glasses. STUDENT also complained of headaches and blurred vision. Based on this information, as of September 1998, the areas that STUDENT should have been assessed in were speech and language, academics, social/emotional behavior, psychomotor development, intellectual development, vocational development, vision, hearing, physical therapy and occupational therapy.
To be appropriate, the District's assessment must have met the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that the student must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability; that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Additionally, tests and other assessment materials are to include those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need and not merely those which are designed to provide a single general intelligence quotient. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician.
The District did an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in the areas of academics, social/emotional behavior, psychomotor development, intellectual development, and vocational development. The District assessors used a wide variety of standardized tests to assess STUDENT in these areas. To test STUDENT’s intellectual development, and psychomotor development, the team used the WISC-III, WRAML, and the VMI. To assess STUDENT’s social/emotional behavior, Mr. Hollins, the school psychologist, used the RADS, BASC, DSMD, ADDES, observation and interviews with STUDENT, his PARENTS and teacher. The WRAT, WJ-R and TOWL-3 were used to assess STUDENT’s academic achievement. These tests were all validated for the specific purpose for which they were used. All of these tests were performed in accordance with test instructions, by properly qualified personnel. The psychological testing was done by a school psychologist. The assessment team could have been more thorough in the area of STUDENT’s social/emotional behavior. The team was aware the STUDENT was in counseling as the result of a suicide attempt, yet no effort was made to contact the counselor or obtain records or a report from him. Despite this failing, the assessment team report was accurate in identifying STUDENT’s behavioral and emotional difficulties.
On the other hand, the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the areas of speech and language, vision, physical therapy and occupational therapy. The speech and language assessment was performed by John Hannaman, a speech and language pathologist. Mr. Hannaman administered the Expressive and Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary tests, and the TOWK. However, at the hearing Mr. Hannaman admitted that he did not follow test protocols on any of the tests, and miss-scored the TOWK and the Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary test. Given these failings, there is no way to judge the accuracy of the results of this testing. The speech and language assessment did not meet the requirement of Education Code Section 56320.
The school nurse performed a vision screening. A screening is designed to identify areas that need a more thorough evaluation. In this case, the nurse’s report noted that STUDENT was suffering from significant visual changes because of his accident. Despite this, a full vision assessment was not performed. The fact that STUDENT’s vision was correctable with glasses did not eliminate the need for a full assessment. Visual acuity is only one area of possible vision impairment. By way of example, the vision testing done by CNS in April 2000 assessed acuity, ocular pursuits, saccades, convergence, eye alignment, stereopsis, suppression, visual fields and color discrimination. Given the knowledge that STUDENT was complaining of blurred vision and headaches, and that he had suffered what the nurse termed “significant visual changes,” the District should have performed a full vision assessment.
The District also failed to assess STUDENT in the areas of occupational and physical therapy. The District was aware that STUDENT was receiving occupational and physical therapy as part of his post-accident rehabilitation. The District also was aware that STUDENT had a significant deformity of his left hand, and only used his right hand. Furthermore, the District was aware that STUDENT complained of left leg and knee pain, and walked with a limp. Despite all this information, the District did not assess STUDENT in these areas. The District did not even request reports from STUDENT’s private therapists. The District argues that a full occupational therapy assessment was not necessary because STUDENT was observed to perform the standardized testing without problems, using only his right hand. California Education Code Section 56320 requires the District to assess students in all areas of suspected disability. When a school district is aware that a student has been in a serious accident, is observed to have a significant deformity of one hand, and also is observed to exclusively use his other hand, that school district is on notice that motor skills is an area of suspected disability. The requirements of Section 56320 are not satisfied by having the school psychologist observe the student during the taking of standardized tests. Similarly, the fact that STUDENT walked with a limp, complained of leg pain, and was known to be receiving private physical therapy should have triggered a physical therapy assessment. The areas of gross and fine motor skills were areas of suspected disability, and the District should have performed physical therapy and occupational therapy assessments.
The District failed to assess STUDENT in the areas of speech and language, vision impairment, occupational and physical therapy. As a result of this failure, the District did not have enough information to properly identify STUDENT’s needs, or address those needs in an IEP through appropriate goals and objectives. The District continued to assess and reassess STUDENT in various areas between August 1998 and February 2000. The issue of an adequate assessment will be re-examined in this Decision as an aspect of FAPE at the point, chronologically, that each new assessment was performed.
3. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from December 1998 through the end of the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 extended school year?
Under State and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (California Education Code §56000; 20 U.S.C. §1400) The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) defines “free appropriate public education” as special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(18))
“Special education” means specially designed instruction at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S. C. §1401(a)(16)) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. §1401 (a)(17)) California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” (Cal. Ed. Code § 56363(b))
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA 1997). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id at 200. According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require a school district to provide special education students the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id at 201. Special education law further requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (34 C.F.R. Section 300.550)
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484.
In summary, the inquiry is twofold. The first question is whether the school district has complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA. The second inquiry under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley is whether the proposed educational program is designed to meet the student’s unique needs, to provide the student with some educational benefit, and to comport with the IEP, and whether it is provided in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.
Counsel for Petitioner has alleged that the District committed procedural violations and that its program did not meet the substantive requirements of the IDEA. In this case, the substantive requirements of Rowley and the IDEA will be looked at first. During the 1998-1999 school year and the 1999-2000 school year, the District held a total of seven IEP meetings. Each IEP will be examined separately.
The December 8, 1998 IEP team meeting
At the December 8, 1998 IEP meeting the District found STUDENT eligible for special education because of his traumatic brain injury. The first step in examining the substance of the December IEP is to identify STUDENT’s unique needs. As set forth earlier, the District had failed to properly assess STUDENT, so there is no way of accurately identifying all of STUDENT’s unique needs at the time of this IEP. However, for the sake of completeness, the Hearing Officer will identify those areas of need that were known.
The District’s assessment team noted that the biggest change in STUDENT after his accident was in his behavior. STUDENT was exhibiting violent rages at home. These rages had resulted in both verbal and physical assaults. At school, STUDENT was observed to be off task frequently. On testing, STUDENT consistently avoided difficult tasks. STUDENT stated that he was having a difficult time focusing and staying focused on anything. STUDENT also was experiencing a significant amount of fatigue. STUDENT’s academics appeared adequate, but his teacher had stated that STUDENT appeared to be having trouble processing information. STUDENT’s motor skills were impaired by the loss of use of his left hand. STUDENT’s mobility was impaired by his limp and left leg pain. STUDENT’s vision was impaired. STUDENT’s daily living skills were adequate, but he required frequent prompts from his parents. These areas of need were all identified in the IEP, at least to some extent, in the present levels of performance section.
Unfortunately, the IEP team developed only two goals, and provided no direct services to meet the goals or address STUDENT’s areas of need. The first goal was, “By 12/99 STUDENT will visit his case carrier regarding gen. ed. classes.” Mr. Cariss, STUDENT’s case carrier, testified that this goal addressed STUDENT’s fatigue and processing problems by allowing him to retake tests in the RSP room if necessary. STUDENT’s behavioral problems were addressed by Mr. Cariss counseling him, when Mr. Cariss saw STUDENT. Unfortunately, Mr. Cariss did not see STUDENT on a regular basis because the IEP did not require STUDENT to be in the RSP class for any specified time. STUDENT’s services were described as RSP, monitoring only. It was explained at the hearing that this meant that STUDENT could go the to RSP class for additional support when he felt it was necessary. The only other goal was a vocational goal. The goal stated, “By 12/99 STUDENT will visit the student career center regarding employment opportunities.” The goal listed four activities STUDENT was to engage in: look for sources of information, complete a job application, rehearse interview skills, and prepare a resume.
The December 8, 1998 IEP failed to address STUDENT’s motor skills deficits, mobility deficits or vision impairment. The IEP also failed to address, in any meaningful way, STUDENT’s behavioral needs. Infrequent counseling with the RSP teacher (Mr. Cariss, who had no formal training in or experience with students suffering from traumatic brain injuries) was not sufficient to effectively address STUDENT’s difficulties with attention and concentration, off task behavior, avoidance of difficult tasks, or violent rages.
The District argues that more services were not offered because STUDENT stated that he did not want any direct special education services. However, the IDEA requires the District to provide qualified students with a FAPE that meets all the requirements set forth above. The law does not permit the District to not meet this standard because the student wishes otherwise. In fact, the law requires the District to initiate due process hearing proceedings if a student refuses services that are necessary to provide a FAPE. Cal. Ed. Code § 56346.
The District also argues that additional services were not necessary because STUDENT made adequate progress in his classes. STUDENT did perform reasonably well academically in the second trimester of the 1998-1999 school year. However, adequate academic progress did not transform the December 1998 IEP into an offer of FAPE when that IEP failed to address all of STUDENT’s unique needs, in particular, his behavioral needs. Future events would demonstrate how important a failure that was.
The December 8, 1998 IEP failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE because it failed to address all of his unique needs. Because the IEP failed to meet the substantive requirements of the law, it is not necessary to address the alleged procedural violations.
The April 29, 1999 IEP team meeting
The District did not preform any new assessments in preparation for the April 1999 IEP meeting. Therefore, the effects of the District’s failure to properly assess STUDENT in 1998 continue to carry forward into this IEP.
This IEP meeting was convened to address serious concerns about STUDENT’s behavior at school. Students, and parents of students had made allegations that STUDENT had been threatening some students and engaging in sexual harassment of certain female students. To avoid further complaints, MOTHER had removed STUDENT to home/hospital instruction prior to the IEP meeting. The IEP team decided to continue STUDENT’s placement in home/hospital instruction. No new goals were developed.
The April IEP Addendum continued all of the failings of the previous IEP. In fact, it eliminated the previous IEP’s two goals, however inadequate they may have been. Because STUDENT was moved to home/hospital instruction, he was no longer able to visit his case carrier or visit the career center. No direct services were provided to address any of STUDENT’s nonacademic needs; STUDENT was simply removed from campus.
In the case of a child whose behavior impedes his learning or that of others, the IEP team is required to consider, when appropriate, strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, strategies and supports to address the behavior. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(B)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2)(i). Given the nature of the allegations and the IEP team’s actions, it appears that STUDENT’s behavior had impeded his learning as well as the learning of others. However, there is no indication in the IEP Addendum, or in the testimony of any of the IEP team members, that any positive behavioral interventions were considered. The only strategy appeared to be removing STUDENT from school.
This placement also failed to meet the requirement that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment. The law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular educational environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (34 C.F.R. Section 300.550). In this case, the only supplementary aides or services that had ever been attempted was the “RSP monitor only.” Therefore, there was no basis for the District to conclude that it was necessary to remove STUDENT from the regular education environment.
The PARENTS later discovered that STUDENT had been taking the wrong medications. This may have contributed to the reported behaviors; however, it does not appear that the medication problem caused all of those behaviors. STUDENT continued to display significant behavior problems at home and at school, including poor social judgment, frequent off-task behavior, poor task initiation and follow through, and inappropriate social interaction. The April 29, 1999 IEP Addendum did nothing to improve on the already inadequate offer of FAPE by the District. In fact, the Addendum increased the failings of the previous offer by eliminating the goals, failing to address the significant behavioral problems, and failing to offer placement in the least restrictive environment. Because the IEP failed to meet the substantive requirements of the law, it is not necessary to address the alleged procedural violations.
The 1999 Extended School Year
The December 8, 1998 IEP stated that STUDENT was to receive extended school year services. There was no indication in the April 29, 1999 IEP Addendum that this part of the program had been changed. No extended school year services were provided. One of the requirements of a FAPE is that the services comport with the IEP. In this case, services called for in the IEP were simply not provided. The District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1999 extended school year.
From the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 extended school year.
4. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
The District did not perform any new assessments at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year. Therefore, the effects of the District’s failure to properly assess STUDENT in 1998 continued to carry forward into this school year.
STUDENT began the 1999-2000 school year in regular education. No IEP meeting was held to determine this change of placement. At the hearing, Mr. Cariss, STUDENT’s case carrier, Mr. Smolenski, the assistant principal, and Mr. Hollins, the school psychologist, were all asked how STUDENT went from home schooling at the end of the previous school year to regular education at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year. None of those witnesses knew how the change of placement had come about. Any revision to a student’s IEP must be done by an IEP team at an IEP meeting. Cal. Ed. Code § 56341. It was a violation of the IDEA for the District to change STUDENT’s placement without holding an IEP meeting. An IEP meeting was finally held in September after MOTHER called Ms. Beaman, another assistant principal, to ask why STUDENT was in regular education classes.
The September 14, 1999 IEP team meeting
At the September 14 meeting the IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s academic performance, and discussed placement for the 1999-2000 school year. MOTHER requested that STUDENT return to the RSP monitoring program he had been in for part of the previous school year. Mr. Smolenski then shared his concerns about STUDENT’s behavior in relation to members of the opposite sex. At this point, the incident occurred in which STUDENT threw his backpack and stormed out of the meeting. As a result of this incident, no program or placement was developed. Further discussion on STUDENT’s program was postponed for one week, and STUDENT was suspended from school for five days.
The September 21, 1999 team meeting
The IEP meeting reconvened on September 21. At this IEP meeting, a new assessment plan was formulated to evaluate STUDENT’s social/emotional and behavior needs. The new assessment plan called for Lisa Dorn, a school psychologist, to conduct the assessment. The IEP also called for a behavior plan to be developed. It was decided that STUDENT would continue in the RSP monitoring only program, but that he would also meet with Mr. Hollins on a weekly basis. Mr. Hollins was also to consult with Dr. Lee, STUDENT’s treating psychologist, regarding any problems that arose. It also was agreed that the school psychologist and Dr. Lee would work together during the evaluation process and in the development of a behavior plan.
Although the District was moving in a productive manner to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs, the IEP still failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE. The District continued in its failure to assess STUDENT in the areas of speech and language, occupational therapy, physical therapy and vision. As a result of the failure to assess, no services were offered in these areas. The IEP itself contained no new goals and objectives, and the previous goals and objectives have already been found to have been inadequate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The only new service offered was the weekly meetings with the school psychologist. Although these meetings may have helped to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs, there was no information about when these meetings would occur and what the duration would be, and there were no new goals set forth for the school psychologist to address at those meetings.
Because of the District’s continued failure to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, its failure to develop an IEP that addressed all of STUDENT’s unique needs, and its failure to develop an IEP that was specific enough that it could implemented, the District had failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE at the September 21, 1999 IEP team meeting. Because the IEP failed to meet the substantive requirements of the law, it is not necessary to address the additional alleged procedural violations.
STUDENT returned to school for two days following his suspension. Another incident involving alleged sexual harassment occurred on September 23. STUDENT was again suspended for five days.
The September 30, 1999 IEP team meeting
As a result of STUDENT’s second suspension, a new IEP meeting was held on September 30 to reassess STUDENT’s program. At this meeting, STUDENT’s placement was changed back to home/hospital instruction. New assessments were also agreed on. STUDENT would be assessed by Dr. Lang, a neuro-psychologist, in the areas of cognitive development, speech and language and social/emotional behavioral development. In addition, a functional behavioral analysis was to be completed by the District. A referral to county mental health was offered, but the PARENTS declined this offer. Again, no new goals and objectives were developed.
Although the District continued to move in a positive direction, this time adding a new assessment in speech and language, and a functional behavioral analysis, the program offered still failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE. STUDENT’s occupational therapy, physical therapy and vision needs were still unassessed. The home/hospital placement again invalidated the only two goals and objectives that had ever been developed. Furthermore, the weekly meetings with the school psychologist that had just been added to STUDENT’s program were eliminated before they had begun. In summary, the September 30, 1999 IEP failed to address any of STUDENT’s unique needs. Because the IEP failed to meet the substantive requirements of the law, it is not necessary to address the alleged procedural violations.
The January 19, 2000 IEP team meeting
Lisa Dorn completed her assessment report on October 11, 1999, and Dr. Lang completed her report on December 8, 2000. The functional behavioral analysis report was completed on January 11, 2000.(Footnote 6)
Lisa Dorn’s report did not identify any new needs, nor did it make any recommendations for placement or services. It concluded that although STUDENT was exhibiting behavioral problems, including off-task behavior and inappropriate social interaction, these problems were the result of his traumatic brain injury, not any underlying psychopathology.
Dr. Lang’s report concluded that STUDENT had ongoing deficits from his accident in the areas of motor control, vision, attention, concentration, language pragmatics, and aggression. Dr. Lang recommended follow-up by a physiatrist to address STUDENT’s motor skills, an ophthalmologist to address STUDENT’s visual deficits, a full language assessment to address STUDENT’s pragmatic language skills, occupational therapy, and physical therapy. Dr. Lang also recommended a placement that incorporated general behavior modification training. STUDENT would also need an opportunity to generalize his social skills. She recommended utilizing behavior contracts with structured consequences and monitoring of any attentional problems or impulsivity. STUDENT also would need small-group instruction, at a slower than normal pace, and in shorter sessions. Instruction should be by a staff trained in dealing with students with traumatic brain injuries. Dr. Lang recommended ongoing individual and group therapy to assist STUDENT with behavior modification and family therapy.
The functional behavior analysis was incomplete. Because STUDENT was in home/hospital the entire time the analysis was being done, Brenda Morgan, the psychologist assigned to do the analysis, could not observe the problem behaviors, or their antecedents. Because of this, Ms. Morgan was only able to hypothesize that STUDENT’s problem behaviors, described as the inappropriate touching of female students, were caused by STUDENT’s efforts to be included in peer groups. Ms. Morgan also hypothesized that structured settings inhibited these behaviors based upon reports that the behaviors did not occur in class. Ms. Morgan did not contact or work with Dr. Lee, STUDENT’s treating psychologist, in the preparation of this report as was required by the September 21, 1999 IEP. No behavior intervention plan was developed.
This IEP again called for additional assessments, primarily based upon Dr. Lang’s recommendations. New assessments in the areas of occupational therapy, vision impairment, assistive technology and adaptive physical education were to be completed. The IEP noted that STUDENT’s prior two goals (contained in the December 1998 IEP) had not been met. A total of five goals were developed. The areas addressed were task initiation, written output, social skills, career planning, and organizational and sequencing skills. Program modifications were listed as a low student-teacher ratio, written support for all directions, minimizing the need for note-taking by providing written outlines, notes and use of a tape recorder, extended time for written tests, and extra time between classes. In general education classes, STUDENT was to be provided alternate seating and an aide to assist with responding. It was noted that behavior interventions were needed and were addressed in the IEP goals.
At the meeting, the PARENTS informed the District that they wanted STUDENT placed at CNS. CNS is a nonpublic agency operating a rehabilitation facility in Bakersfield that specializes in the treatment of traumatic brain injuries. The PARENTS proposed that STUDENT be placed in the residential program at that facility. Because of this request, placement was not decided at this meeting. District personnel wanted additional time to evaluate CNS and other placement options. No other placement options were discussed at the January IEP meeting.
Because the January 19, 2000, IEP did not contain an offer of placement, it did not offer STUDENT a FAPE.
The February 23, 2000 IEP team meeting
The IEP meeting February 23 was convened to complete the offer of services and placement started at the January 19 IEP meeting. This IEP added extended school year services, and called for a speech and language evaluation to be completed to assess STUDENT’s pragmatic language skills. A referral to county mental health was also recommended. The placement offered was in a special day class at the Oak Grove School, a nonpublic school located in the local area, for six to eight hours a day. In addition, an in-home behavioral intervention program through Kitlowski and Associates was to be provided five days a week for one to three hours a day. One hour of consultation by a neuropsychologist would also be provided once a month. The Oak Grove staff described their program at the meeting.
At the hearing, Tasha Arneson, the director of the Oak Grove day program, stated that the Oak Grove staff had not reviewed any of STUDENT’s records, assessments or IEPs before giving their presentation at the IEP. For this reason, the presentation was an overview and not specific to STUDENT. The Oak Grove program has a significant behavioral component. The program addresses behavior modification utilizing a system of privileges and rewards. Each student has an individual behavioral intervention plan. Individual and group counseling are usually part of the program. Oak Grove can also provide services in the area of speech and language, adaptive physical therapy, occupational therapy and physical therapy, depending on the individual child’s IEP. Each student’s particular program is individualized for that student depending upon his or her needs and the student’s IEP. The program also includes a full academic component. All educational credits are transferable back to the student’s home district. The District’s offer of placement for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year was a combination of the special day class at Oak Grove and the home program through Kitlowski and associates. As this offer was the first time the District has offered direct services, specified program modifications, and developed goals and objectives that attempted to address STUDENT’s unique needs, the question must be asked, “What should an IEP contain?”
California Education Code Section 56345 provides, in part:
(a) The individualized education program is a written statement determined in a meeting of the individualized education program team and shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following: (1) The present levels of the pupil's educational performance. (2) The annual goals, including short-term instructional objectives. (3) The specific special educational instruction and related services required by the pupil. (4) The extent to which the pupil will be able to participate in regular educational programs. (5) The projected date for initiation and the anticipated duration of the programs and services included in the individualized education program. (6) Appropriate objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, on at least an annual basis, whether the short-term instructional objectives are being achieved.
Did the District’s offer as contained in the IEPs of January 19 and February 23 address all of STUDENT’s unique needs and comport with the statutory requirements set forth above? First, the Hearing Officer must re-examine what STUDENT’s areas of need were. STUDENT’s areas of need had not changed, but had been added to and refined by the additional assessments that had been completed. STUDENT needed a program that addressed the following:
• violent outbursts at home • frequent off task behavior • avoidance of difficult tasks, in particular, written output • attentional and impulsivity difficulties • significant fatigue • loss of use of the left hand • mobility problems • vision deficits • problems initiating activities of daily living • poor social judgement and poor social skills • deficits in language pragmatics • problems with organizational skills • difficulties processing information • transition planning
STUDENT’s violent outbursts at home were to be addressed by the home program through Kitlowski and Associates. However, there were no goals written that dealt with STUDENT’s behavior at home. Therefore, there were no directions on what specific behaviors the home program was to address, how they were to be addressed, and how progress was to be measured.
Frequent off-task behavior was to be addressed by Oak Grove’s behavior modification program and the low student-teacher ratio. The task initiation goal was for STUDENT to stop a non-goal-directed activity and redirect himself with only nonverbal and environmental cues 8 out of 10 times. This goal is specific and measurable, as are the objectives that were drafted. STUDENT’s avoidance of difficult tasks was also to be addressed by Oak Grove’s behavior modification program and the low student-teacher ratio. The written output goal related to this area of need; however, this goal dealt only with written output, and did not deal with STUDENT’s broader problems with task initiation. The staff at Oak Grove would have had to develop goals to address this problem on a broader scale and to develop measurable objectives to be able to judge progress towards the goals.
STUDENT’s attentional problems and impulsivity would have been addressed by the low student-teacher ratio, and the requirement of written support for all directions also would have helped in this area. The goals dealing with off-task behavior and social skills related to his area of need. STUDENT’s fatigue was not specifically addressed by any service or program modification. In fact, the length of the combination of the day program and the home program (between 7 and 12 hours a day) probably would have posed a problem. Given the levels of fatigue STUDENT had previously demonstrated in class, home school, and during assessments, it is hard to believe that he would have been able to maintain adequate attention during the long days proposed in this IEP.
STUDENT’s loss of use of the his left hand would have been addressed by the extra time allowed for on tests, as well as the provision of written directions, outlines, notes, and the use of a tape recorder. In addition, the IEP called for an occupational therapy evaluation, including assistive technology. However, because this evaluation had never been done, no specific services were offered and no goals relating to this area were developed. STUDENT’s mobility problems were addressed by the allowance for extra time between classes. However, a physical therapy evaluation had never been completed, and was not proposed in this IEP. STUDENT’s vision deficits were addressed by the referral for a vision assessment. Again, because no assessment had ever been completed, not specific services were offered and no goals were developed.
STUDENT’s problems initiating activities of daily living might have been addressed in the home behavior program. As stated earlier, no goals or objectives were developed in the area of home behavior, so there were no specifics as to what this program would address, or how progress would be measured. STUDENT’s poor social skills were to be addressed by the Oak Grove program. The social skills goal called for STUDENT to increase his awareness and understanding of social cues and respond in a socially appropriate manner. However, Ms. Arneson from the Oak Grove school pointed out that neither this goal nor its objectives were measurable. She testified that the goal would have to be rewritten to provide a more specific and measurable goal so that progress could be measured.
STUDENT’s deficits in language pragmatics were addressed by the referral for a speech and language assessment. Once again, because this assessment had never been completed, no services were offered and no goals or objectives were developed. STUDENT’s problems with organizational skills were addressed by the small student-teacher ratio, the provision of all directions in writing, and the provision of written outlines, notes and use of a tape recorder. This area of need might also have been addressed within Oak Grove’s behavior modification program. The organizational and sequencing goal related to this area of need. This goal called for STUDENT to complete all assignments on time. STUDENT’s difficulties processing information would have been addressed by the low student-teacher ration, the provision of all directions in writing, the provision of written outlines, and notes, and the extra time allowed STUDENT to take tests. No goal was developed that related specifically to this area of need.
STUDENT’s transition needs were not specifically addressed by any service or program modification. The transition goal was for STUDENT to take formal and informal career assessments and participate in career activities. STUDENT was also supposed to watch career videos and listen to career speakers. He was to discuss these presentations with his career counselor. It was also suggested that STUDENT contact the regional center and the Department of Rehabilitation. STUDENT was the only party responsible for achieving these goals. The most obvious problem with this plan is that it places all the responsibility for accomplishing the goals on STUDENT. Given STUDENT’s problems with organizational skills, attention, and avoidance of difficult tasks, it was unrealistic to expect that STUDENT would accomplish these tasks on his own. In fact, this goal looks almost identical to the original vocational goal drafted in 1998, toward which STUDENT never made any progress.
In summary, the District’s offer of placement and services, in one way or another, did attempt to address all of STUDENT’s needs. However, the offer is so unspecific as to be really an offer to develop a program, rather than the offer of a program. The District is required to make a formal, specific written offer of placement and services. Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994). This offer must include annual goals and short-term objectives, the specific special educational instruction and related services required by the student, as well as appropriate objective criteria for measuring the student’s progress toward his goals. Cal. Ed. Code § 56345(a)(2),(3),(6). In this case, a special day class ranging from six to eight hours a day was the offer. From the testimony at the hearing, the Oak Grove school appeared capable of providing a comprehensive program that would have included, among other things, individual and group therapy, social skills training, and a behavior intervention plan. Unfortunately, how this program could address STUDENT’s unique needs was not presented at the IEP meeting. In addition, the IEP provided no specifics as to what instruction and related services were to be part of the program, how often the services were to be provided or for what duration. One of the most important goals, the goal addressing social skills, was so general and vague that the staff of Oak Grove would have had to rewrite it to have something to work with. The only related service that was somewhat specific was the home intervention program, and that program had no goals or objectives developed for it. The District was finally proposing to assess STUDENT in the areas of occupational therapy, vision therapy and speech and language therapy, but this was too little, too late. The District knew in 1998 that occupational therapy, speech and language therapy and vision were all areas of need, and should have assessed them at that time. The District still failed to assess STUDENT in the area of physical therapy.
The offer provided no specifics as to what special educational instruction or related services were to be part of the program. The goals were incomplete, and in some cases too vague to be useful. The areas of occupational therapy, speech and language therapy, vision therapy and physical therapy were never assessed and no services were offered to address those areas of need. A behavior intervention plan was to be part of the program, but no plan had ever been developed. The vocational plan was basically the same plan that had failed to produce any results since it was developed in the first IEP in December 1998. In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement contained in the IEPs of January 19 and February 23 did not constitute an offer of FAPE.
5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the tuition costs for STUDENT’s attendance at the Center for Neuro Skills during the 1999-2000 school year?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).) Because of the District’s failure to provide STUDENT with a FAPE from May 1998 through February 2000, STUDENT’s parents have satisfied the first part of the test set forth above.
To determine whether the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the unilateral placement of STUDENT at CNS, it must also be determined whether the placement was proper under the IDEA. In Florence County School District, Four v. Carter (1993) 114 S.Ct. 361, the Court held that parents may receive reimbursement for their unilateral placement even if the placement does not meet certain requirements of the IDEA. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the child’s IEP, and need not provide a placement that meets state education standards. Moreover, the parents’ unilateral placement is not required to be in the least restrictive environment. However, while the parents’ placement need not be an exact proper placement under the IDEA, the placement still must have met the child’s needs and provided educational benefit. (Florence v. Carter, supra; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.)
In this case, STUDENT’s parents are seeking reimbursement for STUDENT’s unilateral placement at CNS. The PARENT’s did not choose CNS at random. Dr. Lang, after completing her evaluation, advised MOTHER that STUDENT should not return to a regular high school campus. At the hearing, Dr. Lang stated that STUDENT needed a program specifically designed to treat traumatic brain injuries. She stated that such a program should offer an integrated approach focusing on cognitive rehabilitation, psychological issues such as anxiety and depression, social skills training, and work or academic skills depending on the needs of the patient. Dr. Lang also said that, although she was not personally familiar with CNS, it had a good reputation in the community, and was known to offer what is considered a model program for treating traumatic brain injuries. MOTHER did extensive research into possible placements for STUDENT, both on her own, and with the assistance of Sharon Popp, the District director of special education. MOTHER investigated CNS, the Deveraux School in Santa Barbara, the Brown School in Texas, and a school in Idlewild, California (MOTHER could not remember the name of that school). MOTHER chose CNS because its program was focused specifically on treating traumatic brain injuries. According to the documents submitted at the hearing, the cost of STUDENT’s placement at CNS was $130,165.74 (Student Exhibit 61).
The District’s main contention is that CNS was not a proper placement for STUDENT because it had no educational component. This is not actually true. CNS had no academic component; however, the services CNS provided STUDENT - counseling, a behavioral program, physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, and living skills - were all services that addressed STUDENT’s needs as identified by the District in its most recent offer of placement. These were also areas of need that the District should have been providing services for as part of STUDENT’s IEPs since May 1998.(Footnote 7) Based upon the CNS discharge summary, the testimony of Chris Persel, and the testimony of MOTHER, STUDENT made progress in all of these areas. Was it detrimental to STUDENT not to receive academic instruction during the four months he was at CNS? All of STUDENT’s teachers testified that STUDENT’s problems were not really in the area of academics. Dr. Lang testified that STUDENT’s behavioral needs needed to be addressed before he could achieve academic success. Ms. Arneson, the director of the Oak Grove program, testified that students suffering from traumatic brain injuries often needed to learn to manage their behavioral problems before they could benefit from academics. In fact, the
District had not been able to address STUDENT’s academic needs except through home/hospital instruction. STUDENT’s behavior problems were so severe that the District had concluded that he could not be on campus until those problems were addressed.
Although it would have been preferable for STUDENT to receive appropriate academic instruction while he was at CNS, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s primary need in April 2000 was to be in a program that addressed his behavioral problems. The program at CNS was specifically designed to address the needs of a person who had suffered a traumatic brain injury, which was the type of program that Dr. Lang had recommended for STUDENT. In addition, the program at CNS was for a relatively short duration (only four months), which minimized the impact of the lack of academics. The Supreme Court in Rowley held that the sole test for an appropriate education is not academic achievement. Rowley 458 U.S. 175. Taking into account the nature of the services provided by CNS, STUDENT’s need for those services, and the District’s past failure to address STUDENT’s behavioral problems (except by simply removing him from school), the PARENTS’ decision to unilaterally place STUDENT at CNS was appropriate. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the tuition cost for STUDENT’s placement at CNS.
6. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is "appropriate" in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington also have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services. Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (8th Cir. 1996). There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497.
The District contends that STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education because he graduated in June 2001 and the IDEA does not allow for services to be provided after graduation. However, courts in various jurisdictions have concluded that compensatory education can be awarded despite a student’s graduation from high school. See, e.g., Valerie J. v. Derry Coop. School Dist., 771 F.Supp. 483 (D.N.H. 1991) (student entitled to seven and one-half months of compensatory education after high school graduation or 21st birthday, whichever comes later); Straube v. Florida Union Free School District 801 F.Supp. 1164 (S.D.N.Y. 1992); Puffer v. Reynolds, 761 F.Supp. 838 (D. Mass. 1988) (student entitled to compensatory remedial services based on procedural violations occurring before her bona fide graduation); Novato Unified School Dist., 22 IDELR 1056 (SEA Ca. 1995) (student eligible for compensatory transition services after graduation based on denial of FAPE prior to graduation). The Hearing Officer finds that an award of compensatory education may be appropriate, despite STUDENT’s graduation from high school.
Counsel for Petitioner contends that STUDENT never received appropriate transition services, and generally did not earn all the credits he needed to graduate. Petitioner is requesting, as compensatory education, that STUDENT be returned to the program at CNS.
California Education Code Section 56345.1 provides, in part:
b) Beginning at age 16 or younger and annually thereafter, in accordance with Section 56462 and paragraph (30) of Section 1401 of Title 20 of the United States Code, a statement of needed transition services shall be included in the pupil's individualized education program, including whenever appropriate, a statement of interagency responsibilities or any needed linkages. (c) The term "transition services" means a coordinated set of activities for an individual with exceptional needs that does the following: (1) Is designed within an outcome-oriented process, that promotes movement from school to post-school activities, including post-secondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, including supported employment, continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living, or community participation. (2) Is based upon the individual pupil's needs, taking into account the pupil's preferences and interests. (3) Includes instruction, related services, community experiences, the development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives, and, when appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and functional vocational evaluation.
STUDENT’s last IEP, dated October 3, 2000, contained no transition plan. The District contends that STUDENT received adequate transition services. The District argues that STUDENT had strong academics, and that STUDENT had spoken with Ms. Skeith, his case manager during his senior year, about college opportunities. In addition, STUDENT took and passed a retail occupational program (ROP) class in his senior year.
Although STUDENT made significant progress at CNS, he was not “fully rehabilitated.” The CNS discharge report listed various services STUDENT would need to help him to continue with his recovery and to reinforce the skills he had acquired. These services included a structured daily routine, speech/language therapy, and one-on-one counseling. STUDENT did receive services during his senior year. STUDENT received language therapy in the areas of pragmatics and problem solving. Liz McCaughey, STUDENT’s language therapist, testified that STUDENT’s deficits in language pragmatics could affect whether, and how well, STUDENT understood what others were trying to communicate to him, whether others understood what STUDENT was trying to communicate to them, and whether STUDENT reacted appropriately in certain situations. These problems could affect STUDENT’s interactions with professors and peers at college, as well with employers and co-workers in a work situation. STUDENT also took the ROP class and a five-finger keyboarding class. Unfortunately, STUDENT did not even complete 1/3 of the pragmatics and problem solving program. In the ROP class, STUDENT exhibited behavioral problems that went unresolved. STUDENT showed poor judgement at times, was argumentative, exhibited off-task behavior, and had excessive absences. Nanci Jordan, the ROP teacher, stated that she made a number of allowances for STUDENT, including allowing him many more absences than normal,(Footnote 8) so that STUDENT could receive credit for the class. It does appear that STUDENT successfully completed the one-handed keyboarding class.
As set forth above, the purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services. The District failed to provide STUDENT any services to address his physical limitations and behavioral needs from May 1998 (when STUDENT first returned to school following his accident) through March 2000. However, the intensive program that STUDENT received through his placement at CNS appears to have adequately addressed STUDENT’s non-academic needs up to that point. STUDENT made significant progress at CNS, but still needed ongoing services. STUDENT did not receive transition services, as required by law, either before he went to CNS or during his senior year with the District. STUDENT only received informal counseling regarding college, and the ROP class, which he did not successfully complete (despite the fact that STUDENT received 15 credits for the ROP class). In addition, STUDENT did not complete the language pragmatics and problem solving therapy he was receiving. Counsel for Petitioner has argued that STUDENT’s needs can best be met by additional services through CNS. However, CNS made no such recommendation as part of its discharge report. Furthermore, no witness testified that STUDENT continued to need an intensive rehabilitation program such as that provided by CNS. STUDENT’s needs can be adequately meet through the provision of additional services. STUDENT requires the following services:
1. Language therapy addressing language pragmatics and problem solving. 2. An ongoing behavior management plan designed to address STUDENT’s continued behavioral deficits including organizational skills, off-task behavior, impaired judgment, impaired social skills, and impaired task initiation and task completion. 3. Counseling about specific college opportunities, keeping in mind STUDENT’s continuing needs in relation to his traumatic brain injury. 4. Counseling about what services may be available to STUDENT through specific colleges to assist him in overcoming his deficits, and assistance in contacting those colleges and arranging for needed services. 5. Other services that may be necessary based on STUDENT’s preferences and interests and his ongoing needs.
The District shall convene an IEP team meeting to develop an appropriate plan that includes, at a minimum, those services set forth above. In light of STUDENT’s ongoing needs as outlined in the CNS discharge report, and the services STUDENT did not successfully complete during his senior year, the Hearing Officer finds that the recommended services should continue for at least one school year, or nine months. At the conclusion of this time period, the IEP team shall reconvene to review STUDENT’s progress and determine if additional services are necessary.
ORDER
1. Within thirty (30) calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents $130,165.74 for the cost of tuition for STUDENT’s placement at CNS from April 2000 through August 2000.
2. Within thirty (30) calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate plan for STUDENT. This plan shall include the following services:
a. Language therapy addressing language pragmatics and problem solving. b. An ongoing behavior management plan designed to address STUDENT’s continued behavioral deficits including organizational skills, off-task behavior, impaired judgment, impaired social skills, and impaired task initiation and task completion. c. Counseling regarding specific college opportunities, keeping in mind STUDENT’s interests and his continuing needs in relation to his traumatic brain injury. d. Counseling about what service may be available to STUDENT through specific colleges to assist him in overcoming his deficits, and assistance in contacting those colleges and arranging for needed services. e. Other services that may be necessary based on STUDENT’s preferences, interests, and his ongoing needs.
These services shall be provided for a minimum of nine months. At the end of the nine months, the IEP team shall reconvene to review STUDENT’s progress and determine if additional services are necessary.
3. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
1. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from the date of his accident through September 1998 by failing to identify him as a student eligible for special education and related services?
Student prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District fail to properly assess STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year?
Student prevailed on this issue.
3. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from December 1998 through the end of the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 extended school year?
Student prevailed on this issue.
4. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
Student prevailed on this issue.
5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the tuition costs for STUDENT’s attendance at the Center for Neuro Skills during the 1999-2000 school year?
Student prevailed on this issue.
6. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Student prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: October 16, 2001 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. For purposes of clarification and organization, the Hearing Officer has revised the parties’ statements of the issues. 2. These services were being provided by STUDENT’s parents.
3. This was the only time the therapist had available.
4. This assessment was performed in August 1998, but was not done pursuant to a special education assessment plan. The report of this assessment was included in the assessment team report that resulted from the September 1998 assessment plan. 5. The counseling was the result of STUDENT’s suicide attempt in September 1998. 6. Completion of some of these reports was delayed, in part, because STUDENT developed appendicitis and underwent an emergency appendectomy. 7. CNS did provide educational counseling. However, this appears to have been at a very remedial level, not consistent with STUDENT’s previous academic achievement. Various District employees visited CNS to evaluate its academic curriculum, and CNS staff repeatedly told the District personnel that CNS was not designed to be a school. 8. Ms. Jordan testified that she normally allows only three absences, because that is all an employer would allow in the same time frame, and STUDENT had approximately 15 absences during the trimester.
