California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 18, 1998
Student v. Long Beach Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 407-98 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim
Long Beach Unified must offer an autism-informed placement, a 40-hour aide, more speech therapy and $1,450 IEE reimbursement.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parent of an eight-year-old girl eligible for special education under autism challenged Long Beach Unified School District's 1998-99 offer. The district proposed keeping her in a severely handicapped special day class at Hudson Elementary with a "reverse inclusion" program. It also offered ten hours a week of one-to-one behavioral aide time, speech-language therapy and occupational therapy (OT).
The Hearing Officer found the placement inappropriate. The teacher and aides had little or no autism training. Classmates were poor communication models, her self-stimulatory behaviors increased around them, and the curriculum was not modified for her. The parent's proposed aphasia class was too vaguely supported to order. Instead, the district must hold an IEP meeting within 15 days and offer a placement with specific features.
Relying on independent psychologist Dr. Melanie Lenington, the Hearing Officer ordered a one-to-one aide 40 hours a week. The aide must be trained in intensive behavior intervention, including discrete trial training. The district must also complete a functional analysis assessment and a behavior plan. Speech therapy rose to three individual and two group sessions a week. Sessions stayed at 30 minutes, and the therapist must know autism.
The district's OT offer was upheld. So was its refusal to add a separate augmentative communication consultant. The district psychologist was not knowledgeable about autism and used no tailored tools, so the district must reimburse $1,450 for the independent assessment.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley to require that staff serving an autistic student actually know about autism. A class, a speech therapist and a psychoeducational assessment were each found inadequate mainly because staff lacked autism training. The Hearing Officer cited the special day class teacher "necessary competencies" rule and Education Code section 56320(g).
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Has the District offered STUDENT a placement for the 1998-99 school year which enables her to obtain a free and appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
The severely handicapped special day class did not meet the student's unique needs. Staff lacked autism training, classmates were poor communication and social models, her autistic behaviors increased around them, and the curriculum was not modified for her. The parent's proposed aphasia class was too vaguely supported to order.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2a. Does STUDENT require 40 hours per week of one-on-one behavioral intervention taking place at both school and home and provided by aides/therapists trained in the treatment of autism, e.g., the Autism Project or CARD, in order to obtain minimal educational benefit?
The student needs a one-to-one intensive behavior intervention aide 40 hours a week, including some discrete trial training. The aide must be trained by people experienced in such programs and have prior autism experience. Training by the Autism Project or CARD specifically was not required.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2b. Does STUDENT require speech and language therapy administered by a therapist knowledgeable in autism in (i) one-hour one-on-one sessions three times per week and (ii) one-hour group sessions two times per week?
Neither side's proposal was shown to be appropriate. The Hearing Officer ordered three individual and two group sessions a week of 30 minutes each, not the one hour requested. The therapist must be knowledgeable about autism.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2c. Does STUDENT require occupational therapy administered in (i) one-hour clinic sessions three times per week and (ii) one-hour classroom sessions/consultations two times per week?
The district's offer of direct OT twice a week for one hour, plus one hour of consultation a month, was appropriate. The higher frequency requested was not shown to be necessary.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2d. Does STUDENT require an augmentative/alternative communication consultant and the support of an assistive technology specialist?
The parent did not show what needed service these specialists would add beyond the district's existing Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) program. The parent's own expert did not dispute that PECS was appropriate.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the assessment and report prepared by Melanie Lenington, Ph.D.?
The district psychologist was not knowledgeable about autism as Education Code section 56320(g) requires. She used no tailored assessment tools and misread the student's comfort in class as a sign the placement was appropriate. The district must reimburse $1,450 for the independent assessment.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to discuss, identify and offer an appropriate 1998-99 placement. The placement must include at least: a structured class with a teacher and support staff reasonably knowledgeable in autism; appropriate peer models for communication and socialization; instruction in functional self-help, communication and socialization skills; a curriculum modified to her level, pace and learning style; classroom emphasis on communication and language; and a generally consistent daily schedule.
- Order to provide or change services. Provide a one-to-one aide 40 hours per week to implement a behavior intervention plan and to train school staff and the parent so the plan is carried out consistently. The aide must be trained by persons very familiar with intensive behavior intervention plans for autistic children, including discrete trial training, and must have prior experience with autism-specific programs.
- Order to assess. Arrange a functional analysis assessment and develop an intensive behavior intervention plan, at least partly discrete trial training, within the first 30 calendar days of the student's attendance at the new placement. Include the plan's terms in the IEP.
- Order to provide or change services. Include in the IEP and provide speech-language services: one-on-one three times per week for 30 minutes each, and in a group two times per week for 30 minutes each. The services must come from a speech-language therapist knowledgeable about autism.
- IEE at public expense. Reimburse the parent $1,450.00 for Dr. Melanie Lenington's independent assessment within 30 days of the decision.
Total: $1,450 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56320; Education Code § 56363; 5 C.C.R. § 3053(c)
People named in the decision
- Melanie Lenington, Ph.D., licensed clinical psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Laurie Cohen, occupational and physical therapist (vendor); conducted OT screening, Long Beach Unified School District (vendor)
- Tiffany Burrell, school psychologist; district psychoeducational assessor, Long Beach Unified School District
- Carrie Henderson, speech and language therapist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Andria Davidson, special education program facilitator, Long Beach Unified School District
- Parisima Shahidi, Ed.D., acting assistant director of special education, Long Beach Unified School District
- Eloise Thompson, director of special education, Long Beach Unified School District
- Rhonda Robles, occupational therapist providing OT consultation, Pediatric Therapy Network
- Allison Cassidy, severely handicapped special day class teacher, Hudson Elementary School, Long Beach Unified School District
- Jimene Miniaci, speech-language pathologist, augmentative/alternative communication consultant and assistive technology specialist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Deborah Griffin, adapted physical education specialist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Anju Khanijou, M.D., physician who performed a developmental re-evaluation (did not testify), Stramski Child Developmental Center
- Edward R. Ritvo, M.D., author of autism therapy guidelines relied on by the District (did not testify), UCLA Medical School (Professor Emeritus)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), in Long Beach, California, on May 14 and 15 and June 8 and 9, 1998.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Bruce Bothwell from the firm of Pray, Price, Williams & Russell. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was her mother, MOTHER. Respondent Long Beach Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney John Hayashida from the firm of Parker, Covert & Chidester. Also present on the District’s behalf for the first two days of hearing was Eloise Thompson, the District's director of special education. Dr. Parisima Shahidi, the District’s acting assistant director, was present on the District’s behalf during the last two days of hearing.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Melanie Lenington, Ph.D., a licensed clinical psychologist who performed an independent assessment of STUDENT; Laurie Cohen, an occupational and physical therapist who provides services for the District; Tiffany Burrell, the District’s school psychologist; Carrie Henderson, the District’s speech and language therapist; Andria Davidson, the District’s special education program facilitator; Dr. Parisima Shahidi; and MOTHER. The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Rhonda Robles, an occupational therapist with Pediatric Therapy Network; Allison Cassidy, STUDENT’s teacher in the severely handicapped special day class; and Jimene Miniaci, the District’s speech and language pathologist and assistive technology specialist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Has the District offered STUDENT a placement for the 1998-99 school year which enables her to obtain a free and appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
2. Does STUDENT require the following support services in order to obtain minimal educational benefit:
a. 40 hours per week of one-on-one behavioral intervention taking place at both school and home and provided by aides/therapists trained in the treatment of autism, e.g., the Autism Project or the Center for Autism Related Disorders (CARD)?
b. Speech and language therapy administered by a speech and language therapist knowledgeable in autism in (i) one-hour one-on-one sessions three times per week and (ii) in one-hour group sessions two times per week?
c. Occupational therapy administered in (i) one-hour clinic sessions three times per week and (ii) one-hour classroom sessions/consultations two times per week?
d. An augmentative/alternative communication consultant and the support of an assistive technology specialist?
3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the assessment and report prepared by Melanie Lenington, Ph.D.?
FACTS
STUDENT is an eight-year-old student eligible for special education as a result of autism. She was first diagnosed as autistic when she was two years and nine months old in September 1992. STUDENT also has asthma and was born with a club right foot. Her asthma is controlled with medications and daily treatments. The club foot was treated during her first year of life and thereafter did not impede her physical activities. (MOTHER Testimony; Dist.’s Exh. 38.)
History of STUDENT ’s Placements and Services
Following a referral by her mother to the District for an initial assessment, STUDENT was found eligible for special education on January 6, 1993. Thereafter, the District placed STUDENT in its special day classes (SDC) for orthopedically handicapped (OH) or severely handicapped (SH) students as follows: in January 1993, the OH class at Hudson Elementary School (Hudson) for preschool; in June 1993, the SH class at Hudson for preschool; in August 1993, the OH class at Carver Elementary School (Carver) for preschool; in January 1994, the SH class at Alvarado Elementary School (Alvarado) for preschool/kindergarten; in February 1997, the SH class at Tincher Elementary School (Tincher) for first grade; and, in November 1997, the SH class at Hudson for second grade.
From the beginning of her education, the District mainstreamed STUDENT to a limited extent. The mainstreaming usually occurred during lunch, recess, special programs and activities, and appropriate activities in the regular education class. About February 1997, MOTHER requested that STUDENT have more frequent mainstreaming opportunities. (Pet.’s Exh. X.) Specifically, MOTHER requested that STUDENT participate in a general education, age appropriate classroom at least three times per week for thirty minutes each time. (Pet.’s Exh. X.) The team responded as follows:
This will be attempted, however [STUDENT] continues to exhibit behaviors such as not sitting in her seat, dancing around and singing to herself which make it difficult for [STUDENT] to focus in a mainstream classroom without direct support. This interaction will be attempted using existing staff, however additional support may be required to make this interaction possible.
(Pet.’s Exh. X.) The District provided an aide to accompany STUDENT to the general education class for mainstreaming, but the aide admitted in her communications with MOTHER that she had not worked with autistic children much. (MOTHER Testimony.)
During Fall 1997, STUDENT was transferred to the SH/SDC at Hudson which participated in a “reverse inclusion” program for eighty-five percent of the school day. General education second-grade students identified as “at-risk” in the areas of reading and mathematics were brought into the severely handicapped class to participate in activities with the SH/SDC students. The general education teacher and STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Allison Cassidy, taught the students together in the following activities: art, music, science, physical education, assemblies, lunch, recess, reading, math and social studies. STUDENT was to participate in the general curriculum with modifications and supplementary aides. The program was meant to benefit the general education “at-risk” students by giving them the opportunity for extended reading and math instruction in a small-group setting. The goal of the program for the SDC students was to provide them with easier access to the general curriculum and role models. All students were meant to benefit from the opportunity to develop friendships with children with different needs. During the inclusion periods, the SDC students were still supervised by the SDC staff. The SDC staff included Ms. Cassidy, a general aide, an aide who serves a certain child, a college aide, and a volunteer who is the grandfather of one of the children. (Cassidy Testimony.)
According to her IEPs, STUDENT has been receiving speech and language (S/L) services from the District to work on her expressive and receptive language skills since October 1993. The services were provided for as follows: from October 1993, twenty to sixty minutes per week; from December 1995, thirty minutes once per week; from December 1996, twice per week for thirty minutes each session; from February 1997, thirty minutes once per week; from November 1997, twice per week for twenty minutes each on a one-to-one basis and once per week for twenty minutes in a group setting; and from March 1998, twice per week for thirty minutes each on a one-to-one basis and once per week for thirty minutes in a group setting. Before November 1997, the S/L services were provided through an “in-class” model, which consisted of lessons developed for the whole class but tailored to address STUDENT’s needs. (Henderson Testimony.)
Since December 1994, STUDENT’s IEPs have required that she receive adapted physical education (APE) twice per week in thirty minute sessions.
Recent Events Surrounding Disagreement Between Parties
On November 3, 1997, MOTHER gave her consent for an assessment in the areas of academic achievement, S/L, intellectual ability, social/emotional/adaptive behavior, perceptual/processing, health/physical status, gross/fine motor development, and assistive technology. Shortly thereafter, the District conducted an assessment with the assistance of the following District personnel: the school psychologist, Tiffany Burrell; the S/L therapist, Carrie Henderson; the augmentative/alternative communication consultant and assistive technology specialist, Jimene Miniaci; and the APE specialist, Deborah Griffin.
The disagreements that are the focus of this due process hearing began to emerge noticeably in late 1997. At an IEP meeting held for STUDENT on November 19, 1997, MOTHER requested that the District place STUDENT in a full inclusion program with a one-to-one aide who “understands autism,” conduct an occupational therapy (OT) assessment, and provide increased speech therapy (individual therapy three times per week and therapy in a group setting two times per week) and a computerized communication device. The District agreed to (1) conduct an OT assessment; (2) increase the S/L therapy services from once per week for thirty minutes to two times per week for twenty minutes each on a one-to-one basis, and once per week for twenty minutes in a group setting; and (3) provide the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) to enhance communication. However, the District thought that STUDENT was appropriately placed in the SH/SDC because it provided inclusion with regular education students for eighty-five percent of the school day, and thus the District declined to change STUDENT’s placement to one of full inclusion.
Shortly thereafter, by letter dated December 10, 1997, Mr. Bothwell informed the District that his client disagreed with the psychoeducational assessment performed by Ms. Burrell and intended to have an independent psychoeducational assessment performed by Melanie Lenington, Ph.D., at the District’s expense. Dr. Lenington performed her assessment of STUDENT in January 1998.
An OT screening was completed on January 20, 1998, by Laurie Cohen. Ms. Cohen concluded that OT was indicated and recommended direct service once per week and consultation once per month. Rhonda Robles from Pediatric Therapy Network, who had been providing OT consultation for STUDENT since February 1998, recommended that STUDENT receive direct OT twice per week and consultation once per month. At the IEP meeting on March 16, 1998, the District offered to provide STUDENT direct OT twice per week for one hour each and consultation services one hour per month, per Ms. Robles’s recommendation.
Following IEP meetings on February 25 and March 16, the parties continued to disagree on the following points: frequency and duration of S/L and OT services, the appropriateness of STUDENT’s placement in the SH SDC, the number of hours an aide is needed and what training the aide must have, and the need for certain software programs. (Pet.’s Exh. EE.)
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
At the most recent IEP meeting held for STUDENT on March 16, 1998, the District offered to continue STUDENT in the severely handicapped special day class at Hudson Elementary for the 1998-99 school year. The District contends that this placement is appropriate because the class is involved in a reverse inclusion program for eighty-five percent of the school day, music is integrated throughout the curriculum, and the class emphasizes language development. The District is offering the following related services for the 1998-99 school year: (1) one-to-one behavioral intervention by an aide, who has been trained by a District teacher, for two hours per day for a total of ten hours per week; (2) one-on-one S/L therapy twice per week for thirty minutes each session; (3) S/L therapy in a group setting once per week for thirty minutes; (4) one-on-one OT services twice per week for sixty minutes each session; (5) classroom consultation by an occupational therapist one hour per month; (6) training in the use of the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS); (7) daily door-to-door transportation; and (8) APE twice per week for thirty minutes each session.
Petitioner contends that the placement offered by the District is inappropriate and that the behavioral intervention, S/L and OT services offered by the District are inadequate. Petitioner alleges that STUDENT requires placement in “a communication and participation based aphasia class with appropriate supports, or other placement which addresses her autism.” Petitioner also alleges that STUDENT requires the following related services due to the inadequacy of the support services the District has provided over the past five years(Footnote 3): (1) forty hours per week of one-on-one behavioral intervention provided by aides/therapists trained in the treatment of autism by a group such as the Autism Project or the Center for Autism Related Disorders, which is to take place both at school and home; (2) one-on-one S/L therapy three times per week for one hour per session; (3) S/L therapy in group sessions twice per week for one hour per session; (4) OT in clinic sessions three times per week for one hour each session; (5) OT classroom sessions/consultations twice per week for one hour each session; (6) an augmentative/alternative communication consult; and (7) the support of an assistive technology specialist.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Has the District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1998-99 school year which enables her to obtain a free and appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services, such as occupational therapy and speech-language services, that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA 1997). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id., 458 U.S. at 207-208.
In determining whether the District has offered a FAPE, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s program reflects the child’s needs, provides some benefit, and comports with the IEP, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208.
Finally, special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 34 C.F.R. 300.550(b)(2); Education Code § 56031.
Taken together, the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley provide four factors for analyzing whether a school district has provided (or offered) an appropriate placement:
1. Whether the district’s placement is designed to meet the student’s unique needs; 2. Whether the district’s placement is designed to provide educational benefit; 3. Whether the district’s placement provides an education in the least restrictive environment; and 4. Whether the district’s placement conforms with the IEP.
20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.
Thus, this issue first requires a determination of STUDENT ’s unique needs. There is no dispute that STUDENT is an autistic child. Both psychologists who have assessed STUDENT recently, Ms. Burrell and Dr. Lenington, agree that she is a high functioning autistic with cognitive ability in the average range, but that her cognitive ability is difficult to confirm because of her communication difficulties. Both psychologists also agree that STUDENT has significant delays in receptive language and expressive language skills, and needs a structured classroom. They disagree, however, on whether the SH special day class at Hudson, or another class, is the appropriate placement for STUDENT.
Ms. Burrell has been a school psychologist for the District since the beginning of the 1997-98 school year. She has a bachelor’s degree in applied sciences and a master’s degree in counseling, and received a pupil personnel services credential in school psychology in May 1997. She is currently the assigned school psychologist for three elementary schools in the District, which contain approximately twenty-five students with autism. Her training and experience with autistic students are composed of the following: in the past five years, she has worked for a number of districts in their special education classes which included students with autism; she was a full inclusion aide for an autistic kindergarten student for one year; she has attended three conferences on autism, two of which were held by Bryna Siegel, Ph.D., the most recent of which was in approximately April 1998; she took a one-year course in assessing children with a variety of handicaps, including autism, during her master’s program; and she has performed approximately one hundred assessments thus far, approximately twenty-five of which involved autistic students.
Ms. Burrell assessed STUDENT in October 1997 to re-evaluate her progress. Her assessment focused on three questions: is STUDENT benefitting from the educational services provided, is her placement in the SH class at Hudson appropriate for her, and in what areas STUDENT is displaying the most progress. (Pet.’s Exh. DD.) Ms. Burrell’s assessment consisted of procedures she described as “ecological,” which she explained was a method of gathering information about a student across a multitude of settings. Specifically, she used the following procedures: a review of STUDENT’s records for approximately one and a half hours; interviews with the Harbor Regional Center respite worker who administers STUDENT’s asthma treatment, MOTHER, and Allison Cassidy, STUDENT’s SH/SDC teacher; consultations with Carrie Henderson, the S/L therapist, and Jimene Miniaci, the assistive technology specialist; and approximately eight hours of observing STUDENT over the course of three classroom observations and one home visit. Ms. Burrell did not use standardized tests, because she felt they would be inappropriate as they would not have been a true measure of STUDENT’s ability and would not show progress. She testified that the redirection needed to focus STUDENT would have invalidated the test scores.
From the assessment, Ms. Burrell found STUDENT was as comfortable and content in her new classroom with Ms. Cassidy as she was at home, indicating that she was adjusting very well to the SH class. Ms. Burrell also found that STUDENT was making progress in communicating her needs by using one-word verbalizations such as “juice,” or by gestures such as pulling adults to objects she wanted; and connecting things she was learning to her environment. From these findings, Ms. Burrell concluded that STUDENT was benefitting from the SH class and that it was an appropriate placement for her. Ms. Burrell recommended that the current placement continue. Ms. Burrell testified that STUDENT’s expressive language has improved since November 1997, and she attributes this improvement in part to STUDENT’s exposure to the regular education students who come into the SH/SDC during eighty-five percent of the school day. She agreed that STUDENT displays more autistic-like behaviors, such as perseverative and self-stimulatory behaviors, around the SH students than around the reverse inclusion students. She testified, however, that it would not be appropriate to place STUDENT in a regular education classroom for the entire school day, because she would lose the support of the special education staff who prompt and redirect her when needed, which results in the more appropriate behavior. Ms. Burrell also testified that full inclusion wouldn’t be appropriate because it would be more difficult to accommodate the coordination of services STUDENT requires in a regular education classroom. She testified that the current SH/SDC placement with the reverse inclusion program is appropriate because it meets STUDENT’s communication and socialization needs, and provides her the structure she needs to make educational progress in the least restrictive environment.
In contrast, Dr. Lenington disagreed with the appropriateness of the SH/SDC placement at Hudson. Dr. Lenington has a bachelor’s of science degree in OT, a master’s degree in psychology and a Ph.D. in clinical psychology, which was awarded in 1993. She is a registered occupational therapist and a licensed clinical psychologist. She has been in private practice for the last four years where she performs psychoeducational assessments of children, many of whom are autistic. She worked with autistic children while an OT assistant in 1977 and for two years while working at the UCLA infant and preschool clinic, where she saw about eight autistic children per month. She has attended three conferences in the last two years that specifically focused on autism, one of which was presented in 1997 by Dr. O. Ivar Lovaas and his staff. She has also given annual presentations on the diagnosis and treatment of autism since 1994 on behalf of the Julia Ann Singer Center in Los Angeles, California.
At the request of Mr. Bothwell, Dr. Lenington assessed STUDENT in January 1998 by using the following methods: observing STUDENT during the morning part of her school day for about four hours and in her office for several hours; reviewing STUDENT’s records of past assessments and IEPs; and administering portions of the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III) and Task Analyses. Dr. Lenington also used specific academic tasks and behavioral contingencies/modifications to assess STUDENT’s abilities and her methods for processing information. Dr. Lenington found that STUDENT had severe delays in her receptive and expressive language, as well as difficulties with pragmatic language. She concluded that STUDENT needs a small, structured, consistent classroom that emphasizes communication and participation, and addresses her learning, behavioral, language and social/emotional needs. She found that STUDENT also needs a class with a typical daily structure and “inherent structures” as well. She stated in her report that STUDENT’s classroom should not include children with communication impairments resulting from specific hearing impairments, physical disabilities such as cerebral palsy, or mental retardation. She suggested an appropriate aphasia or other communication impaired/handicapped classroom. Dr. Lenington stated in her report:
It is the opinion of this examiner that addressing [STUDENT’s language needs] in a classroom setting alone would not be sufficient unless the classroom was designed to focus upon the acquisition of these skills (i.e. all students had these needs and the teacher was trained in the communication domain). [STUDENT] needs both individual and group work to facilitate a desire for communication and to see the benefit of the same which should greatly facilitate her participation in active communications. ... In the absence of the language-based learning environment, [STUDENT] would benefit from daily remediation of at least one hour. This program should be on an individual basis at least 3 times per week. Both classroom and out of classroom procedures should be used with an emphasis on generalization of skills accomplished in individual work per classroom interactions.
Dr. Lenington testified that she has seen a number of SH preschools and that the emphasis in those classes is usually on functional self-help skills. According to Dr. Lenington, functional self-help skills need to be addressed in STUDENT’s program but she has other needs as well. Dr. Lenington testified that she agreed with the recommendation made by Anju Khanijou, M.D., of the Stramski Child Developmental Center in October 1997. According to a report submitted by the parties, Dr. Khanijou performed a re-evaluation of STUDENT on October 27, 1997, and concluded that STUDENT needs placement in a small, structured classroom with emphasis on improving communication and social skills training.(Footnote 4) (Pet.’s Exh. HH.)
Dr. Lenington found that STUDENT behaved well in her current SH class, i.e., she did not tantrum, was generally compliant and had no difficulty with transitions, but she was not challenged to perform any tasks or engage in any interactions beyond what she desired to do. Dr. Lenington also found that there was little individual attention given to STUDENT in order to encourage or reward her appropriate behaviors, or discourage her inappropriate behaviors. For example, Dr. Lenington noted an incident in which STUDENT was observed initiating an interaction with a physically disabled child by singing to the child, but the behavior was not rewarded or praised by the aide that was present.
Other District personnel, besides Ms. Burrell, also offered their opinions about STUDENT’s unique needs. Carrie Henderson is a S/L therapist with the District who has worked with STUDENT since approximately September or October 1997. She testified that, in terms of S/L goals, STUDENT can benefit from having appropriate models because she sometimes imitates others’ speech.
Andria Davidson is the District’s program facilitator who began to work with STUDENT when STUDENT transferred to Alvarado from Carver in approximately January 1994. Ms. Davidson has been a program facilitator with the District for eight years. She has an undergraduate degree in communicative disorders and a master’s degree in learning disabilities, both from Northwestern University. In Illinois, she taught children with communicative disorders who were leaving a developmental center, many of whom were autistic. She has had the following training with regard to autism: some of her undergraduate coursework in communicative disorders in the late 1970's dealt with autism; and she has attended most of the in-service trainings provided by the District on autism, a course about the TEACCH program, training in how to use PECS, and three discrete trial training programs with Ron Leaf. Ms. Davidson testified that the SH/SDC placement at Hudson is appropriate for STUDENT because the pace can be more individualized to accommodate STUDENT and there is reverse mainstreaming, both of which help prevent behavior problems that could be borne out of frustration. She testified that STUDENT’s learning style had, in the past, indicated that she would do better in a class with less desk sitting, and SH classes involve less desk sitting than most classes. She also testified that the teacher working with STUDENT should be knowledgeable in autism.
Parisima Shahidi, Ed.D., the District’s acting assistant director of special education, has been involved with resolving the conflicts between the District and MOTHER regarding STUDENT. She has been with the District for over thirteen years and has been involved in special education in California for the past nineteen years. She has a doctorate degree in education, master’s degrees in art education and fine arts, a learning handicapped credential, a severely handicapped credential, a school psychologist credential which was awarded in 1992, a resource specialist certificate, a pupil personnel services credential, and a school counseling credential. She is also a licensed clinical psychologist and has attended a two-day course in discrete trial training held by Dr. Tracy Parker from the Autism Partnership. Dr. Shahidi testified that she agrees that STUDENT needs remediation of her S/L deficits. Dr. Shahidi stated that the SH/SDC at Hudson is appropriate for STUDENT because it is a communication- and language-based class that heavily involves music, which is of high interest to STUDENT, it offers reverse mainstreaming and allows the multidisciplinary team to implement the services STUDENT needs, and the teacher’s method of discipline (involving follow-through and intrinsic rewards) is effective for STUDENT. She testified that experts tend to agree that time-outs are not good for autistic children because they tend to go into their own world.
STUDENT’s recent IEPs offer additional information regarding her unique needs.(Footnote 5) STUDENT’s current goals and objectives include the following areas: functional self-help skills, such as tying shoelaces; communicative interaction, such as being able to communicate her wants and verbalizing responses; socialization skills, such as cooperative play with peers; and attending and responding.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence establishes that STUDENT needs, among other things, a structured class with a teacher and support staff reasonably knowledgeable in autism, its implications for the classroom, and the preferred methods for teaching and disciplining autistic children; appropriate peer models in terms of communication and socialization skills; instruction in functional self-help skills, communication and socialization, among others; a curriculum modified to accommodate her level of achievement and her pace and style of learning; classroom emphasis on communication and language, with regard to instruction and the participation required of the students; and a generally consistent daily schedule. The District contends that STUDENT’s continued placement in the SH/SDC at Hudson with Ms. Cassidy as the teacher is the appropriate placement for the 1998-99 school year. The evidence establishes that the District’s proposed placement is designed to meet some of STUDENT’s unique needs. For example, Ms. Cassidy testified that the class follows an established daily schedule and music is heavily integrated into the classroom through the daily singing of songs, her playing the piano, and the sing-songy type of voice she tries to use with the students to engage them to copy her.
However, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed placement is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in a number of significant respects. First, the staff of the SH/SDC is not knowledgeable in autism, its implications for the classroom or the preferred methods of teaching and disciplining autistic children. According to Ms. Cassidy, her training in autism is limited to one hour of in-service training provided for teachers of handicapped students by staff who had observed autistic programs in another state. Dr. Shahidi admitted that Ms. Cassidy needs to know more about autism. Dr. Shahidi also testified that the classroom aides working with STUDENT have not had any training in autism. It is clear from the testimony of Ms. Davidson, Dr. Lenington and Dr. Shahidi that knowledge in autism is required for the classroom staff dealing with STUDENT, because the needs of an autistic child are very unique and there are specific techniques that have been shown to be effective in working with autistic children. The District’s failure to provide Ms. Cassidy with the appropriate training in autism has led her to use arguably inappropriate methods of behavior modification for STUDENT, such as time-outs. It has also resulted in a failure to employ any approaches or methods that have been found effective in teaching autistic children. Under the California Code of Regulations, the teacher of a special day class is specifically required not only to hold an appropriate special education credential, but to also possess “the necessary competencies to teach individuals assigned to that class.” 5 C.C.R. § 3053(c). The evidence demonstrates that the District has not provided the training necessary to allow Ms. Cassidy to have the “necessary competencies” to teach STUDENT.
Second, the placement does not offer STUDENT appropriate modeling opportunities in terms of her communication and socialization needs. Although general education students join the SH students for part of the school day as part of the reverse inclusion component of the SH/SDC at Hudson, STUDENT is still exposed to many inappropriate models for the entirety of the school day. Ms. Cassidy testified that there are eleven students in her SH class and that the students suffer from the following disabilities, among others: three have autism, one has Niemann’s disease, three are mentally retarded, and one is orthopedically handicapped. According to Dr. Lenington, the other SH students do not present appropriate models for STUDENT in the areas of communication and socialization. This finding was corroborated by a 30-minute video recording of STUDENT in the SH/SDC at Hudson that was taken in approximately March 1998, and submitted by the District as its exhibit 31. During the thirty minutes displayed in the recording, the SH students did not exhibit any appropriate verbalizations and few, if any, appropriate socialization skills despite being in view for most of the recording. As Dr. Lenington’s recommendations suggest, an appropriate modeling opportunity cannot consist of an equal mixture of appropriate and inappropriate models, because it would be unrealistic to expect a child with inappropriate communication and socialization skills to model only those who display appropriate skills.
Third, the evidence discloses that exposure to the SH students tends to increase the frequency of STUDENT’s “autistic-like” behaviors. According to Ms. Burrell’s testimony and a progress report written by Ms. Cassidy in November 1997, STUDENT tends to exhibit more “autistic-like” behaviors, i.e., perserverative or self-stimulatory behaviors such as dancing and singing to herself, when she is with the SH students. All of the witnesses agreed that engaging in perserverative or self-stimulatory behaviors prevents STUDENT from gaining any educational benefit, and that these behaviors should be extinguished or redirected for positive uses.
Fourth, there is no evidence that the curriculum was appropriately modified to accommodate STUDENT’s pace or style of learning. Dr. Lenington testified that, as with many autistic children, STUDENT does not learn in the same manner as other children typically learn. However, Ms. Cassidy admitted that she did not modify the class for STUDENT except to the extent that her expectations are different for every student, and STUDENT was provided an individual work basket. Despite Ms. Cassidy’s testimony that she agrees that autistic children need different methods in order to learn material, she provided no evidence that she changed or modified her method of teaching to accommodate STUDENT’s needs in this area.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed placement in the SH/SDC at Hudson for the 1998-99 school year does not meet STUDENT’s unique needs and is, therefore, not appropriate. Based on this finding, it is unnecessary to address the other three factors discussed above.
Petitioner proposes that STUDENT be placed in a “communication and participation based aphasia class with appropriate supports, or other placement which addresses her autism” for the 1998-99 school year. (Pet.’s Issue Statement dated 4/15/98.) The parties are in agreement that STUDENT has significant deficits in her language skills which need to be remediated, particularly with respect to her expressive language skills. However, there was only vague testimony regarding the specific placement Petitioner is proposing. Dr. Lenington testified that a class with emphasis and demands in S/L, such as an aphasia class, would be more appropriate for STUDENT because the focus would be on language and the children would be higher functioning than the SH students and have more similar needs, allowing STUDENT to use the children as appropriate models. She also testified, however, that an aphasia class would need to be seen and evaluated to determine its appropriateness for STUDENT. Further, in her report, Dr. Lenington appears to recommend that STUDENT either receive individual speech therapy, as well as therapy in a group setting, or be placed in a classroom focusing on the acquisition of communication skills. On page 22 of her report, she wrote:
It is the opinion of this examiner that addressing [STUDENT ’s language difficulties] in a classroom setting alone would not be sufficient unless the classroom was designed to focus upon the acquisition of these skills (i.e. all students had these needs and the teacher was trained in the communication domain). ... In the absence of a language-based learning environment, [STUDENT] would benefit from daily remediation of at least one hour. This program should be on an individual basis at least 3 times per week.
(Pet.’s Exh. A.) Based on the scant evidence provided that an aphasia or other communication-based class would be appropriate for STUDENT and Petitioner’s failure to identify a specific placement for the Hearing Officer to consider, the Hearing Officer is unable to determine whether Petitioner’s proposed placement is appropriate for STUDENT.
Based upon the analysis above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has failed to offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year and that Petitioner has failed to show that the alternative placement she proposes is appropriate. The Hearing Officer finds that an appropriate placement for STUDENT would have the following characteristics, among others: a structured class with a teacher and support staff reasonably knowledgeable in autism, its implications for the classroom, and the preferred methods for teaching and disciplining autistic children; appropriate peer models in terms of communication and socialization skills; a curriculum modified to accommodate STUDENT’s pace and style of learning; classroom emphasis on communication and language, with regard to instruction and the participation required of the students; and a generally consistent daily classroom schedule.
ISSUE NO. 2: Does STUDENT require the following support services in order to obtain minimal educational benefit:
a. 40 hours per week of one-on-one behavioral intervention taking place at both school and home and provided by aides/therapists trained in the treatment of autism, e.g., the Autism Project or the Center for Autism Related Disorders (CARD)?
Petitioner presented the testimony and report of Dr. Lenington to support her contention that STUDENT requires forty hours per week of one-on-one behavioral intervention by a trained aide. From her assessment, Dr. Lenington concluded that STUDENT needs a trained one-to-one aide, who understands behavior management techniques for autistic children, to provide specific, consistent and focused management of STUDENT’s deficits. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Lenington’s findings on this issue are entitled to great weight because of her experience working with autistic children, her demonstrated knowledge of autism and its implications for the educational setting, her thorough assessment of STUDENT and the detailed basis she provided for her recommendation.
Dr. Lenington testified that during her observation of STUDENT in the classroom, she saw many behaviors that prevented STUDENT from gaining educational benefit, such as a lack of basic attending skills, perserverative behaviors and limited interaction with her peers, and many opportunities for behavior modification that were not used by the classroom staff. For example, she testified that STUDENT engaged in perseverative behaviors without redirection by the classroom staff, STUDENT was not pushed for results, and STUDENT was not rewarded for positive behaviors.
In her report, Dr. Lenington stated that a one-to-one aide would be required to facilitate STUDENT’s appropriate participation until basic attending, responding, and compliance behaviors are evidenced, and until appropriate interactions are initiated and sustained with peers and authority figures; and that she would benefit from intensive behavioral treatment with a focus on developing language, social, self-help and play skills “that are critical to maximizing success.” (Pet.’s Exh. A.) Although not recommending the Lovaas program specifically, Dr. Lenington testified that she believes STUDENT needs a Lovaas-type program for intensive behavior intervention (IBI) in order for STUDENT to obtain educational benefit, i.e., discrete trial training (DTT). Dr. Lenington testified that the DTT should take place in the classroom on functional school-related issues. According to Dr. Lenington, the program would help STUDENT master basic attending and self-help skills that are necessary for her to obtain educational benefit, such as sitting in a chair, staying on-task, asking questions, following directions, and cleaning up after herself, as well as developing her language, social, and play skills. Dr. Lenington testified that STUDENT needs this because her age and the lack of required compliance over the years has made it much more challenging to change behavior as STUDENT has become somewhat set in her ways. However, according to Dr. Lenington, such a program would be effective with STUDENT because, during the assessment, STUDENT showed the ability to comply, and recent research shows that a child STUDENT’s age still has the brain plasticity required to progress in this area.
The District does not appear to dispute the appropriateness of providing IBI by an aide(Footnote 6). In fact, the District is offering STUDENT ten hours per week of one-to-one IBI by an aide trained by a District teacher, to be provided while STUDENT is at school. However, the parties disagree on two points with regard to this issue: the amount of hours per week the aide should be provided and the training the aide should receive.
Amount of Hours Per Week
Ms. Davidson testified that autistic children tend to regress if they are not provided with a consistent program, and that intensive behavior intervention has been found to be successful with some autistic children in assisting them to function in society at a basic level and in gaining educational benefit. She also testified that intensive behavior intervention has not been offered to STUDENT until recently.
According to Dr. Shahidi, after MOTHER requested IBI at an IEP meeting, the District offered an aide, trained in DTT, for ten hours in the school setting; the provision of DTT was to be on a trial basis until its effectiveness could be evaluated at the next IEP meeting in November 1998. Dr. Shahidi testified that the District contemplated that, at the next IEP meeting, the team would evaluate how STUDENT had been responding to DTT and would re-evaluate the number of hours she should receive the service. Dr. Shahidi agreed with Mr. Bothwell that DTT has been successful in helping many and is a recognized form of treatment. Dr. Shahidi’s only reservations appeared to be the effectiveness of DTT for STUDENT, because she is older than the children involved in Dr. Lovaas’s research on DTT. Dr. Shahidi testified that the District based the offer of ten hours on the following authorities: a statement made by Dr. Siegel during a seminar that, based on a finding by Dr. Lovaas, it is believed that ten hours of DTT can be as effective as forty hours and that more than ten hours might actually harm the child by making him or her prompt-dependent; therapy guidelines developed by Edward R. Ritvo, M.D.(Footnote 7), Professor Emeritus at UCLA Medical School, dated October 24, 1997, which includes a recommendation of a maximum of two hours of DTT per day at home or in school (Dist.’s Exh. 32); and a letter entitled “Idealized School Program For a Seriously Ill Young Autistic Pupil” by Dr. Ritvo dated February 4, 1996, which includes the recommendation of a “structured behavior therapy” using positive social reinforcement for one to two hours per day (Dist.’s Exh. 33). Dr. Shahidi also testified that the offer was limited to ten hours to prevent having to take STUDENT away from all the other benefits of the classroom, and that she was unaware that Petitioner wanted intervention every time STUDENT acted inappropriately. Finally, Dr. Shahidi admitted that, although the District’s proposal did not include a home component, it would be important for STUDENT to generalize the skills she learns through DTT while at school to her home setting.
Dr. Lenington testified that the provision of an aide for ten hours per week is insufficient because IBI must take place both at home and at school for it to have the required consistency and persistency, and to ensure that all those working with STUDENT understand and implement the treatment. Further, according to Dr. Lenington, the aide must have an opportunity to make the constant revisions necessary to address STUDENT’s changing needs. Dr. Lenington recommended that IBI be provided forty hours per week, only some of which should be DTT, the exact amount to be determined through a functional analysis. According to Dr. Lenington, the aide should be available the entire time STUDENT is in school, i.e., approximately thirty hours; the remaining ten hours to be used for multidisciplinary team meetings, plan development to address new problems and to weed out unproductive methods, and training to show MOTHER methods to provide consistency and reinforcement at home. Dr. Lenington testified that, if the aide was provided for forty hours, it would result in STUDENT functioning much more closely to the average range since she has needs in multiple domains and many capabilities that have not yet been tapped.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires IBI through the assistance of an aide for forty hours per week, some of which is to be DTT (the exact amount to be determined through a functional analysis), per Dr. Lenington’s recommendation. Dr. Lenington’s findings and recommendations are given substantial weight on this issue because, as discussed previously, she has more experience with autism than any of the District witnesses and personally assessed STUDENT to determine her needs. The only evidence the District presented to refute Dr. Lenington’s recommendation for an IBI aide for forty hours per week was the testimony of Dr. Shahidi. Dr. Shahidi did not assess STUDENT and is thus less persuasive on this issue. Further, Dr. Shahidi’s testimony does not persuasively refute Dr. Lenington’s recommendation for an aide forty hours per week for several other reasons. First, Dr. Shahidi’s recommendation for ten hours relied heavily on guidelines developed by Dr. Ritvo, who did not testify at the hearing. Also, Dr. Ritvo’s guidelines have questionable application to this case as each child has unique needs which must be evaluated on an individual basis. Second, the authorities Dr. Shahidi relied on to limit the provision of an aide to ten hours dealt only with the provision of DTT, not IBI in general; Dr. Lenington has recommended that the aide provide DTT for only part of the forty hours that the aide is available. Third, Dr. Shahidi based at least part of her recommendation on the consideration that STUDENT should not be taken away from her classroom for that long for the provision of DTT. However, Dr. Lenington testified that DTT can and should be provided in the classroom on functional school-related issues. Fourth, Dr. Shahidi admitted that it would be important for STUDENT to generalize the skills learned through DTT to the home setting, and that the District’s offer of ten hours failed to include a home component. Fifth, forty hours appears required based on Ms. Davidson’s testimony that autistic children tend to regress if not provided with a consistent program. According to Dr. Lenington, the forty hours is needed to provide consistency and to ensure that all those working with STUDENT are aware of the IBI and how to implement it.
Amount of Training Aide Should Have
Petitioner contends that the aide should be a person trained in the treatment of autism by a group such as the Autism Project or the Center for Autism Related Disorders (CARD). Petitioner presented the report and testimony of Dr. Lenington to support this claim. In her report, Dr. Lenington stated the following with regard to the training the aide should have:
Ideally, the aide would be experienced with the implementation of programs specific to the needs of children with Autism. It would be imperative that the aide attend multidisciplinary treatment team meetings and receive ongoing training. Ideally, this person should be provided by a group such as the Autism Partnership or the Lovaas Group (UCLA Young Autism Project) to ascertain proficiency of the program implementation in a consistent fashion so very necessary for a child such as [STUDENT]i. Ideally, a background in psychology or special education should be required, as should enthusiasm, reliability, eagerness to learn, and an ability to accept feedback. (Emphasis added.)
(Pet.’s Exh. A at p.18.) During her testimony, Dr. Lenington conceded that it might be appropriate for a person, including a non-psychologist or a teacher, who has been trained by people very familiar with implementing these types of programs to assume the role of the aide. Above all, according to Dr. Lenington, the aide should be someone knowledgeable in autism with an understanding of behavior management techniques such as DTT.
The District has offered an aide trained by a District teacher in discrete trial training. The District did not present any evidence to refute Dr. Lenington’s recommendation that the aide working with STUDENT be knowledgeable in autism, have experience with implementing programs specific to the needs of autistic children, and have an understanding of and training in behavior management techniques, including DTT.
Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the one-to-one aide provided for STUDENT should be someone trained by persons very familiar with implementing IBI for autistic children (including DTT). The aide should also have prior experience with implementing programs specific to the needs of autistic children. Petitioner has not established, however, that the aide must be trained by a group such as the Autism Project or CARD, although this might be highly desirable.
b. Speech and language therapy administered by a speech and language therapist knowledgeable in autism in (i) one-on-one sessions for one hour three times per week and (ii) in group sessions for one hour two times per week?
The District offered to continue to provide the level of S/L therapy services contained in STUDENT’s IEP dated March 16, 1998. This IEP calls for one-on-one S/L therapy two times per week for thirty minutes each session, and S/L therapy in a group setting one time per week for thirty minutes each session. Petitioner argues that the current level of services is inadequate to appropriately address STUDENT’s S/L needs. Petitioner contends that the District should provide three one-hour one-on-one S/L therapy sessions per week and two one-hour group sessions per week. Petitioner also contends that the S\L therapist assigned to work with STUDENT needs to be knowledgeable in autism but that STUDENT’s current S/L therapist, Carrie Henderson, is not knowledgeable in autism.
Frequency & Duration
Carrie Henderson, the District’s S/L specialist working with STUDENT, testified that the District’s offer for S/L services in the IEP of March 16, 1998, is actually for more services than she recommended. Ms. Henderson testified that she recommended that STUDENT receive S/L services only one time per week individually for thirty minutes and one time per week in a group setting for thirty minutes. According to Ms. Henderson, the District’s offer was a compromise between the parent’s recommendation and hers.
Ms. Henderson was awarded a master’s of science degree in communicative disorders in June 1997 by Utah State University and has a clinical or rehabilitative credential in language, speech and hearing, which she testified allows her to work in school districts. According to Ms. Henderson, this is her clinical fellowship year to obtain national certification from the American Speech & Hearing Association (ASHA) and to obtain her California license. She began her employment with the District as a S/L specialist in August 1997. Ms. Henderson admitted that her education and training in autism is limited to a passing mention of autism in a special education course and an in-service presentation by a fellow student, and that she had never worked with school-age autistic children before coming to the District. During the 1997-98 school year, she worked with three autistic children in the District.
Ms. Henderson began to provide S/L services to STUDENT in late September 1997 when STUDENT began attending Hudson. Ms. Henderson testified that this was the first time she had worked with an autistic child individually and, to prepare, she referred to her old textbooks and presentations for different ideas on what to do with STUDENT. After working with STUDENT for several months, Ms. Henderson conducted a S/L assessment using the Non-Speech Test and “informal assessment procedures,” and by interviewing the teacher and observing STUDENT. (Dist.’s Exh. 21.) In her report dated November 16, 1997, Ms. Henderson stated that STUDENT’s articulation, voice and fluency appeared adequate but that she had difficulties in the areas of syntax, pragmatics and semantics. On the Non-Speech Test, STUDENT scored in the 26-29 month age range on the receptive language portion and in the 18-21 month age range on the expressive language portion. Ms. Henderson concluded that STUDENT had improved in the area of receptive language and had met her IEP goal in receptive language, but had failed to meet her expressive language goal. Ms. Henderson admitted that STUDENT has had the same S/L goals for the last five years.
Ms. Henderson testified that she believes Petitioner’s recommendation is not appropriate because it is very difficult to hold STUDENT’s attention for one-hour blocks, it would not be beneficial to remove STUDENT from her class for one hour per day, and it would be difficult to teach that many skills individually that could be generalized to STUDENT’s daily life. Ms. Henderson testified that, based on her experience with STUDENT, she believes that STUDENT derives more benefit from a group setting because it is more comfortable and interesting for her than a one-on-one session. According to Ms. Henderson, when she is working with STUDENT individually, it is more difficult to “get her out of her own world” and to work on the goals. Ms. Henderson currently provides individual therapy to STUDENT in the classroom because, according to the testimony, when Ms. Henderson did pull STUDENT out of class, she found that STUDENT was easily distracted by objects in the S/L room. Ms. Henderson testified that requiring STUDENT to be pulled out of her class for five hours per week would result in a waste of STUDENT’s time and a loss in needed peer interaction.
Petitioner presented the testimony and report of Dr. Lenington to support her claim that increased services are needed. Dr. Lenington testified that, in the last five and a half years, STUDENT has gained three months’ progress in her expressive language and ten months’ progress in receptive language. According to Dr. Lenington, STUDENT needs S/L services on a remedial basis and a number of studies in neuroplasticity have shown the importance of consistency in a program in addressing difficulties, i.e., the need to teach things over and over in a consistent pattern in order to teach a skill. In her report, Dr. Lenington recommended the following:
[STUDENT] should receive speech and language services to address the issues of her receptive and expressive language difficulties in addition to her pragmatic language difficulties. It is the opinion of this examiner that addressing those needs in a classroom setting alone would not be sufficient unless the classroom was designed to focus upon the acquisition of these skills (i.e. all students had these needs and the teacher was trained in the communication domain). [STUDENT] needs both individual and group work to facilitate a desire for communication and to see the benefit of the same which should greatly facilitate her participation in active communications. The district recommended one hour per week (in total) is insufficient.[(Footnote 8)] In the absence of the language-based learning environment, [STUDENT] would benefit from daily remediation of at least one hour. This program should be on an individual basis at least 3 times per week. Both classroom and out of classroom procedures should be used with an emphasis on generalization of skills accomplished in individual work per classroom interactions.
(Emphasis added.)
After a careful consideration of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence failed to demonstrate that the District’s offer was appropriate or that STUDENT needs the frequency and duration of S/L services requested by Petitioner in order to benefit educationally from her program. See Education Code § 56363 (“Designated instruction and services ... shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”).
The District provided only the testimony of Ms. Henderson to support its contention that its offer was appropriate. While Ms. Henderson is an appropriately credentialed S/L specialist, she clearly lacks expertise in working with autistic children. Ms. Henderson was frank in her testimony that she had not received any significant education about autism and had no experience working with autistic children prior to her employment with the District in August 1997. Because Ms. Henderson has extremely limited experience with autism, her testimony on this issue can be given little weight except to the extent that (1) she knows generally about the provision of S/L services, and (2) she has firsthand experience working with STUDENT. Due to Ms. Henderson’s lack of expertise in the area of autism, her testimony standing alone was not sufficient to establish the appropriateness of the District’s offer.
Similarly, Petitioner failed to show that her alternative proposal was appropriate because she relied on the testimony of a person with insufficient expertise to provide a conclusive opinion on this issue, i.e., Dr. Lenington. While Dr. Lenington has significant experience working with autistic children as a psychologist, there was no showing that Dr. Lenington has any particular education, training or experience in the field of speech and language. As Dr. Lenington does not have any specialized training or expertise in the area of S/L, her opinion regarding the frequency and duration with which S/L services should be provided can be given little weight. Also, Petitioner failed to present any evidence to refute Ms. Henderson’s testimony, based on her experience working with STUDENT, that STUDENT is unable to attend to S/L services for longer than half an hour and that any additional time would be misspent. Although Dr. Lenington did recommend that remediation take place for at least one hour every day, there was no showing that STUDENT would be able to attend to S/L services for that long of a period.
Nevertheless, the evidence does establish a number of facts from which the Hearing Officer can determine an appropriate frequency and duration for the provision of S/L services to STUDENT. Both parties agree that STUDENT needs S/L services on an individual and group basis. Ms. Henderson testified that, based on her experience working with STUDENT, (1) half an hour is about as long as STUDENT can attend to therapy at any given time; (2) if therapy is provided for longer than an hour, STUDENT could lose valuable socialization and communication opportunities offered by the classroom while not receiving any additional benefit from therapy because of her attention difficulties; and (3) STUDENT learns well in a group setting because she is more comfortable and interested, and she tends to imitate others. Dr. Lenington also offered some valuable insights based on her assessment of STUDENT and her general knowledge and experience working with autistic children. Dr. Lenington’s testimony establishes that (1) consistency and repetition in a program are generally important in teaching an autistic child; (2) STUDENT needs daily remediation of her S/L deficits(Footnote 9); and (3) there should be an emphasis on generalization of the skills STUDENT learns in individual therapy. Thus, the evidence demonstrates that therapy should not exceed half an hour per session, the therapy should be provided on a daily basis, therapy in a group setting should be reasonably frequent, and there should be an emphasis on generalization. Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs one-on-one S/L therapy three times per week in thirty minute sessions, and S/L therapy in a group setting two times per week in thirty minute sessions.
Training of Therapist
There is no dispute that Ms. Henderson is qualified under the governing regulations to provide S/L therapy in the school setting.(Footnote 10) The question here is whether Ms. Henderson can provide appropriate S/L therapy to an autistic child, such as STUDENT, when she has only limited knowledge about and experience with autistic children. The Hearing Officer finds that, based on the evidence presented at hearing, Ms. Henderson does not have sufficient knowledge about autism to effectively provide S/L services to STUDENT.(Footnote 11)
Under Rowley, a program or a component of a program, such as related services, must be designed to meet a STUDENT’s unique needs, provide educational benefit and comport with the IEP. 458 U.S. at 207-208. STUDENT’s unique needs are clearly intertwined with the fact that she is autistic. The testimony in this case consistently showed that autistic children learn in ways different from most other children and require instruction tailored to their unique styles of learning. Additionally, Ms. Davidson, who has training in numerous methods for teaching autistic children, credibly testified that the speech language therapist working with STUDENT should be knowledgeable about autism. Thus, the evidence clearly established that STUDENT requires a S/L therapist who is knowledgeable about autism in order for the S/L services to meet her unique needs. Finally, the evidence showed that STUDENT gained few educational benefits from her S/L therapy during the 1997-98 school year. Ms. Henderson candidly admitted that, although she sometimes thought STUDENT’s S/L skills had improved from the time she first entered Hudson, she realized after reading prior reports and IEPs that STUDENT had not really made the gains because STUDENT had demonstrated the same or similar skills previously. Ms. Henderson also admitted that STUDENT had not met her expressive language goal.
The Hearing Officer found Ms. Henderson to be a dedicated and sincere professional, and commends Ms. Henderson’s informal efforts to prepare herself to work with autistic children. However, the law requires that the S/L therapy, as a related service, be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and provide her with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer finds that this requires the District to provide STUDENT S/L therapy by a therapist knowledgeable about autism. At the present time, in the absence of training about autism or further experience, Ms. Henderson is not an appropriate S/L therapist for STUDENT.
c. Occupational therapy administered in (i) one-hour clinic sessions three times per week and (ii) one-hour classroom sessions/consultations two times per week?
In the IEP dated March 16, 1998, the District offered to provide STUDENT with direct OT two times per week in one-hour sessions and OT consultation services once a month for one hour. Petitioner argues that the District’s proposed level of services is inadequate and that STUDENT needs one-hour clinic sessions three times per week and one-hour classroom sessions/consultations two times per week. Based on the evidence presented at the hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer is appropriate.
Both Laurie Cohen and Rhonda Robles testified to the appropriateness of the District’s offer.(Footnote 12) Ms. Cohen, as a vendor working with the District, coordinates OT and physical therapy (PT) services with outside vendors on behalf of the District, consults with teachers and staff, provides in-service training to District staff on an ongoing basis and assesses and screens children to determine their OT/PT needs in the educational setting. She received a bachelor’s of science degree in OT in 1976 from Temple University, is a registered occupational therapist, and has twenty-five years of experience as an occupational therapist. She testified that her experience with autism consists of the following: from 1976-1979 she worked with autistic adults in state hospitals using desensitization(Footnote 13) techniques; in the early ‘80's, she contracted with Delaware public schools to use the desensitization techniques for children and then to provide services to the children in their school settings; and has continued to work with autistic children since that time. Ms. Cohen testified that OT is the provision of activities to improve a person’s functional performance and daily living skills; for a child, this is related primarily to school and play. According to Ms. Cohen, in the consultation mode, an occupational therapist will visit the classroom and work with the teacher to provide adaptive equipment and teach him or her how to handle the child, present materials, and/or stimulate the child in the educational setting. Ms. Cohen testified that autistic children typically have fine and gross motor problems, but that not all require OT in order to gain educational benefit.
At the District’s request, Ms. Cohen performed a therapy screening for STUDENT on January 20, 1998. (Pet.’s Exh. JJ.) Based on interviews of persons working with STUDENT, including Andria Davidson and STUDENT’s physical therapist, Ms. Cohen found that STUDENT had substantial OT difficulties that significantly interfered with her educational performance in the following areas: sensory processing, visual processing, perceptual motor, postural control, motor planning, bilateral motor coordination, muscle strength/tone, self-care and endurance and tolerance. At the IEP meeting held on February 25, 1998, Ms. Cohen recommended that STUDENT receive direct OT one time per week and consultation services one time per month. Ms. Cohen testified that STUDENT’s OT difficulties interfere mostly in the area of socialization and that, depending on the setting and the other children present, STUDENT could benefit from OT services. According to Ms. Cohen, some of STUDENT’s OT difficulties, such as sensitivity to noise and tactile defensiveness, could be accommodated by modifications or adaptations within the classroom, which would obviate the need for OT. Ms. Cohen testified that she believes the District’s offer of direct OT two times per week is “more than appropriate.” Rhonda Robles is the occupational therapist who, since February 1998, has been providing consultation services to STUDENT on behalf of the Pediatric Therapy Network (PTN). Ms. Robles was awarded a bachelor’s degree in OT in 1969 from the California State University at San Jose and a master’s degree in education in 1973 from the University of Wyoming. She is currently licensed in two states, neither of which are California, and is certified by the national OT association. She testified that she has been practicing OT for the past twenty-nine years and that her area of specialty is school consultation. According to her testimony, she works with children ages zero to twenty-two and, since August 1997, has worked with approximately thirty autistic children.
Ms. Robles testified that she has seen STUDENT five times in her classroom since the beginning of this year. She described STUDENT’s primary OT difficulties as being in the following areas: postural control (STUDENT maintains a laid-back position to write due to an inability to sit upright because of lack of muscle tone and motor planning); sensory processing (STUDENT is tactilely defensive, which interferes with her ability to interact with the environment and results in problems such as an inappropriate pencil grip); and work behaviors (STUDENT tends to do only those things that are in her comfort zone and does not like to be challenged by new activities or situations, which may result in problems with staying on task). Ms. Robles testified that in her consultations for STUDENT she observes STUDENT in the classroom, reviews her IEP goals, occasionally tries to directly interact with STUDENT, talks to the classroom teacher about ways to maximize STUDENT’s hand-eye control and increase her hand-strength dexterity, and suggests adaptations and modifications to the classroom setting for the teacher to implement to accommodate STUDENT’s OT difficulties, such as using a pencil grip or changing the placement of the paper.
Ms. Robles testified that, at the IEP meeting of March 16, 1998, she recommended that the IEP team increase the frequency of direct OT from once per week to twice per week. She testified that receiving direct OT twice per week and consultation once per month would be appropriate for STUDENT because of the emphasis on the clinic sessions, which are more structured and specialized and where equipment is available, and of the collaborative nature of the program. She testified that this recommendation is based on best practices, research and philosophy within the field of OT. According to Ms. Robles, STUDENT has shown improvement with this frequency of services, such as better spacing and staying in the lines with her writing and an improved ability to accept prompts and handle transitions and changes. Ms. Robles testified that providing direct OT three times per week and consultations two times per week, as proposed by Petitioner, would be excessive. Ms. Robles stated that more is not better in this instance because (1) a collaborative effort would be more effective than working with STUDENT in isolation and (2) consultations two times per week are appropriate during periods of transition for a child (which is not the case here), at which time clinic sessions would be decreased. Ms. Robles further testified that she was unaware of any clinics that provide clinic sessions three times per week because it would be excessive, i.e., more than a STUDENT actually needs.
In support of Petitioner’s proposal to increase the frequency of direct and consultative OT, Petitioner offered the report and testimony of Dr. Lenington. Dr. Lenington earned a bachelor’s of science degree in OT in 1981 from Ohio State University, and worked as an OT from 1981 to 1990 in various hospitals and the Silver Hill Foundation in Connecticut before beginning her graduate studies in clinical psychology. (Pet.’s Exh. CCC.) According to Dr. Lenington, she worked with autistic children as an OT assistant in 1977.
Dr. Lenington testified that she used “task analyses” during her assessment to evaluate STUDENT’s OT needs in January 1998. Dr. Lenington described task analyses as a very traditional method of assessment in the field of OT, but did not specifically describe her findings based on her use of this technique. Dr. Lenington concluded from her assessment that STUDENT had the following OT difficulties, among others: inability to appropriately grip a pencil, sensory processing and integration difficulties, low tone, sequencing and inability to dress herself. Dr. Lenington stated the following in her report:
[STUDENT] would benefit from the services of occupational therapy to address issues of both fine and gross motor skills planning, fluidity, and sequencing. Furthermore, [STUDENT] has a hypersensitivity to sensory stimuli which should be addressed by the use of sensory-integrative modalities and techniques. [STUDENT] would benefit from specific attention to appropriate acquisition to daily living skills and self-help techniques as well. These difficulties are long standing. She would benefit from participation in sensory-integrative therapy to improve her basic attending and self-help skills (including focusing, concentration, and ability to sequence and organize tasks). She would benefit from exposure to both auditory and visually stimulating environments in a progressive fashion to determine if some over-sensitivity to stimuli can be modified. [STUDENT] could further diminish remaining perseverative and self-stimulatory behaviors or learn to utilize these in an increasingly effective manner (and in a less obvious and/or disruptive fashion). [STUDENT] would also benefit from special attention to her pencil grip, ability to cross midline, ability to sequence data, produce written work in a more effective patterning sequence, learn organizational and self-help skills, and possibly work as part of a group or partnership. [STUDENT]’s ability to follow a series of two and three step sequential directions should be enhanced as well. [STUDENT]’s motor skills, especially in the areas requiring planning, motor sequencing, visual-perceptual skills, and eye-hand coordination appear to be lagging for her age. Clinic treatment is necessary at least three times per week for access to appropriate equipment and facilities and in-class or in-school treatment two times per week. ... The occupational therapy evaluation provided and objectives and goals provided are appropriate ones (p, er vendored occupational therapist). However, as noted, the duration and frequency are not considered adequate given the prevalence and duration of the problems noted (as early as 1993). (Emphasis added.)
(Pet.’s Exh. A.)
Given the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of OT services is appropriate. Both Ms. Robles and Ms. Cohen support the appropriateness of the District’s offer, and their opinions are given substantial weight because of the decades of experience they both have in providing OT to children, including autistic children, in the educational setting. Furthermore, Ms. Robles has hands-on experience working with STUDENT and her classroom teacher, and has visited STUDENT’s classroom on numerous occasions. Finally, Petitioner failed to present any evidence that the high frequency of OT she proposes is necessary for STUDENT to benefit from her educational program.
d. An augmentative/alternative communication consultant and the support of an assistive technology specialist?
As part of the triennial assessment of STUDENT that took place in late 1997, the District conducted an assistive technology evaluation. The evaluation was performed by Jimene Miniaci, a S/L pathologist, augmentative/alternative communication consultant and assistive technology specialist who has worked for the District for the past eighteen years. Ms. Miniaci has a bachelor’s of science degree in speech pathology, a master’s of arts degree in speech communication, a clinical rehabilitation services credential, a certificate of clinical competency from ASHA, and an assistive technologies credential from the California State University at Dominguez Hills. She is also a state-licensed speech pathologist. According to Ms. Miniaci, she first met STUDENT in 1996 when she developed a communication book for STUDENT to use at school and home, which allowed STUDENT to communicate her wants by pointing to a picture of the requested item in the book.
Ms. Miniaci testified that she performed the assistive technology evaluation because MOTHER asked for an intervention to use as a communication device for STUDENT. On November 7, 1997, Ms. Miniaci used the Lifespace Access Profile (LAP), a criterion-referenced rating tool consisting of fifty-nine scales which assesses an individual’s physical, cognitive, emotional and support resources in the school, home, work/prevocational, and community settings based on observations of those working with the STUDENT . According to the report, Ms. Miniaci both interviewed STUDENT and received input from the following persons: the classroom teacher, the school psychologist, the school nurse, and the program facilitator. (Dist.’s Exh. 20.) From the evaluation, Ms. Miniaci came to the conclusion that STUDENT’s greatest weakness is in the area of initiation of interaction. Ms. Miniaci found that STUDENT demonstrated strengths in the use of computer activities, but that using the computer appeared to be another method by which STUDENT avoided interaction with people. Ms. Miniaci testified that using a computer for communication would not be beneficial for several reasons, e.g., a computer is hard to move around, STUDENT would use it for entertainment instead of communication, it is too artificial a form of communication, especially for a child like STUDENT who has the ability to verbalize, and it would inhibit socialization and alienate her from the rest of the world. Ms. Miniaci stated that the computer would be a good source of academic instruction for STUDENT but the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) developed at the Delaware Autistic Program, not the computer, should be used to increase STUDENT’s interaction with others. Ms. Miniaci wrote:
To assist in increasing interaction with others, [STUDENT] must first be taught initiation. Use of the PECS program is recommended. The PECS was developed to demonstrate a means of interaction with others on a picture/print level for the autistic child. The exchange of picture/print symbol between two people allows the autistic child to find a “comfortable” avenue for interaction. They use a picture/print symbol to ask for desired items. They are then rewarded by getting the desired item. It has been found that the child’s verbalizations often increase when accompanied with the exchange. Use of the PECs is not done at a set time each day but is integrated within the curriculum. [STUDENT] would initially be trained in the process and then she would be required to use the system during snack time, breakfast, free choice, group language, academics science. The classroom would be set-up with a class generic symbol board in addition to [STUDENT] having her own PECS book which would contain her individual likes. A system would also be developed for the home using items she would request in that setting. I would be a consultant to the class and instruct the classroom staff and parent in the use of the system; this is usually done 2-3 times a week until the student has achieved an 80% accuracy level for the second phase of the program. After her initial training, I would then check with the classroom teacher on a periodic basis.
Ms. Miniaci testified that she had been using PECS for five years.
During the IEP team meeting on November 19, 1997, the team recommended the PECS program to MOTHER. The IEP states: “The Assistive Technology Specialist will be available on a consultative basis to assist in developing [STUDENT]’s PECS program; training of classroom staff; initial phase training of [STUDENT]; and adaptation of the program for home use.” (Pet.’s Exh. Y.) During the November meeting, the following goals were written for STUDENT’s progress on PECS: by February 1998, she was to cross the room to an adult to exchange a picture of a wanted item (phase 2 of PECS) eight out of ten times; by April 1998, she was to discriminate between ten pictures on the PECS board (phase 3) eight out of ten times; and, by June 1998, she was to use a sentence strip containing the icon “I want” to request items (phase 4) eight out of ten times.(Footnote 14)
By the time the IEP team met again on March 16, 1998, STUDENT had not met her February goal but had made some progress. According to the IEP, by that time, STUDENT had accomplished phase 1 and was beginning to show success in phase 2 at forty percent accuracy. (Pet.’s Exh. EE.) The goal was revised as follows: by March 1998, STUDENT will cross the room to exchange a picture of the wanted item with her communication partner eight out of ten times (phase 2); by May 1998, she will discriminate between ten pictures on the PECS board eight out of ten times (phase 3); and, by July 1998, she will use a sentence strip containing the icon “I want” to request items eight out of ten times (phase 4). Ms. Miniaci testified that she had been training STUDENT in PECS one to two times per week for twenty to forty minutes each session. She also testified that, at the time she provided her testimony, i.e., June 9, STUDENT had progressed through phase 3 and was working on phase 4. Ms. Miniaci testified that STUDENT now verbalizes in a one-on-one situation without prompting on a very consistent basis. According to Ms. Miniaci, she had been training STUDENT in PECS in one-on-one sessions because, in her experience teaching PECS, she found that teaching the child first works better since they can later utilize it with anyone. She stated that the next step is to use PECS in the classroom setting by training the staff in PECS.
At the IEP meeting held on December 1, 1997, MOTHER disagreed with the use of the PECS program as a communication device. (Pet.’s Exh. AA.) Petitioner requests that the District instead provide “an augmentative/alternative communication consultant and the support of an assistive technology specialist.” (Pet.’s Issue Statement dated April 15, 1998.) In support of this contention, Petitioner has presented the report of Dr. Lenington, which states:
[STUDENT] should receive the services of the Augmentative/Alternative Communication Consultant. In tandem with these services, [STUDENT] should receive the support of the Assistive Technology Specialist. The initial duration and frequency suggested via the IEP does not seem sufficient. However, the use of the PECS system as one method of communication facilitation is worthy of implementation only if it is used consistently and with expectation. [STUDENT] needs specific lesson plans developed and facilitated to gain academic skills using the computer (rather than the free form interaction observed.) As above[,] functional communication is imperative.
(Pet.’s Exh. A.) During her testimony, however, Dr. Lenington did not explore this issue except to say that (1) she felt Ms. Miniaci’s assessment was appropriate and should have been done sooner and (2) on the videotape submitted by the District, STUDENT was not using PECS according to the recommendation. The latter observation by Dr. Lenington will be given little weight, however, as Ms. Miniaci testified that there was no PECS training or use shown on the videotape. According to Ms. Miniaci, at the time the videotape was recorded, she had not yet incorporated PECS into STUDENT ’s classroom setting by training the staff.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has not shown that it is necessary for STUDENT to have “an augmentative/alternative communication consultant and the support of an assistive technology specialist” to benefit from her education. First, the only expert witness Petitioner provided on this issue, Dr. Lenington, does not dispute that the PECS program is appropriate to use for STUDENT. Second, Dr. Lenington’s conclusion in her report that “the initial duration and frequency suggested via the IEP does not seem sufficient” is too vague and unsupported to be given much weight. It is unclear what “frequency and duration” Dr. Lenington is referring to, and there was no evidence that Dr. Lenington has any particular expertise in this area. Third, although Ms. Miniaci’s findings support Dr. Lenington’s recommendation that “specific lesson plans” be developed to allow STUDENT to gain academic skills using the computer, there was no evidence that this role required the expertise of an assistive technology specialist. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, Petitioner failed to describe any “necessary” service that an augmentative/alternative communication consultant or assistive technology specialist would add to STUDENT’s educational program that is not already a part of the program and related services currently being provided by the District. For all these reasons, Petitioner’s argument fails.
ISSUE NO. 3: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the assessment and report prepared by Melanie Lenington, Ph.D.?
Petitioner contends that she should be reimbursed for the cost of Dr. Lenington’s assessment, because the District’s psychological assessment in November 1997 by Tiffany Burrell was inappropriate.
California Education Code § 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. However, if the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. Id.
For the educational agency’s assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of Education Code § 56320. Section 56320 requires that the assessment be conducted by qualified persons; that tests and assessment materials and procedures be administered in a nondiscriminatory manner by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, and include tests and other assessment materials tailored to assess specific areas of educational need; and that no single procedure be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program. Education Code § 56320(a)-(e). Section 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. Subsection (g) states: “The assessment of a pupil ... shall be conducted by persons knowledgeable of that disability.” Psychological assessments, as well as being required to meet the criteria of Section 56320, must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist. Education Code § 56324(a). A written report detailing the results of the assessment must be prepared. Education Code § 56326. The report must contain the relevant behavior noted during the observation of the student in an appropriate setting and the relationship of that behavior to the student’s academic and social functioning. Education Code § 56326(c)-(d).
Based on the evidence presented at hearing, the Hearing Officer finds the District failed to conduct an appropriate psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT and, therefore, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the assessment performed by Dr. Lenington. The District’s assessor, Ms. Burrell, is not “knowledgeable of [autism]” as required by Education Code § 56320(g). Ms. Burrell has very limited experience assessing autistic children and, because of this inexperience, failed to meet a number of assessment criteria. For example, Ms. Burrell failed to use any tests or assessment data specifically tailored to assess STUDENT’s areas of educational need, as required by Education Code § 56320(c). She based her findings wholly on observations of STUDENT and interviews. There was no indication that she ever attempted any direct contact with STUDENT in order to assess the way STUDENT processes information or collect any other educationally relevant data. Second, Ms. Burrell failed to appreciate the implications of STUDENT’s behavior in the classroom and to evaluate the behavior with regard to STUDENT’s academic and social needs, as required by Education Code § 56326. Others knowledgeable in autism testified at hearing that autistic children seek comfort in repetition and sameness, but that they need to be challenged and made uncomfortable in order to learn. In her report, Ms. Burrell incorrectly relied on STUDENT’s comfort level in her current classroom to find that the placement was appropriate. For these reasons, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement. The District shall reimburse Petitioner the amount of $1,450.00, the amount Dr. Lenington charged for her assessment. (Pet.’s Exh. B.)
ORDER
1. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to discuss, identify, and offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year. That placement shall have, at the minimum, characteristics that are the same as or comparable to the following: a structured class with a teacher and support staff reasonably knowledgeable in autism, its implications for the classroom, and the preferred methods for teaching and disciplining autistic children; appropriate peer models in terms of communication and socialization skills; instruction in functional self-help skills, communication and socialization, among others; a curriculum modified to accommodate her level of achievement and her pace and style of learning; classroom emphasis on communication and language, with regard to instruction and the participation required of the students; and a generally consistent daily schedule.
2. With regard to intensive behavior intervention treatment:
a. The District shall provide STUDENT with a one-to-one aide for forty hours per week to implement a behavior intervention plan, as well as train the school staff working with STUDENT and MOTHER in their respective roles in order to provide consistency in the implementation of the behavior intervention plan. The aide must be a person trained by persons very familiar with implementing intensive behavior intervention plans for autistic children, including discrete trial training. The aide must also have prior experience with implementing programs specific to the needs of autistic children.
b. The District shall arrange for a functional analysis assessment and develop an intensive behavior intervention plan for STUDENT, at least a portion of which should involve discrete trial training, within the first thirty calendar days of her attendance at her new placement. The terms of the behavior intervention plan shall be included in STUDENT’s IEP.
3. With respect to speech and language services:
a. The District shall include in the IEP and provide to STUDENT speech and language services (i) in one-on-one sessions three times per week for thirty minutes each session and (ii) in a group setting two times per week for thirty minutes each session.
b. The District shall provide the services through a speech and language therapist knowledgeable about autism.
4. The District shall reimburse Petitioner for the cost of the assessment provided by Melanie Lenington, Ph.D., (i.e., $1,450.00) within thirty days of the date of this decision.
5. All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:
1. Has the District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1998-99 school year which enables her to obtain a free and appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
2. Does STUDENT require the following support services in order to obtain minimal educational benefit:
a. 40 hours per week of one-on-one behavioral intervention taking place at both school and home and provided by aides/therapists trained in the treatment of autism, e.g., the Autism Project or the Center for Autism Related Disorders (CARD)?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
b. Speech and language therapy administered by a speech and language therapist knowledgeable in autism in (i) one-hour one-on-one sessions three times per week and (ii) in one-hour group sessions two times per week?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue with respect to the frequency and duration of sessions insofar as the frequency was increased to the level Petitioner requested; the District prevailed insofar as the duration remained half an hour per session, as the District offered. Petitioner prevailed on this issue with respect to the training required of the speech and language therapist.
c. Occupational therapy administered in (i) one-hour clinic sessions three times per week and (ii) one-hour classroom sessions/consultations two times per week?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
d. An augmentative/alternative communication consultant and the support of an assistive technology specialist?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the assessment and report prepared by Melanie Lenington, Ph.D.?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(I).
Date: September 18, 1998 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1.The issues listed here differ slightly in wording from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Any changes were made for the purpose of reflecting Petitioner’s clarification of issues at the beginning of the hearing 2.There is no dispute regarding the transportation and APE services offered by the District. 3.When the Hearing Officer questioned Mr. Bothwell about the implications of this allegation on the first day of hearing, Mr. Bothwell stated that the past years would be discussed during the hearing only to demonstrate the need for “fairly intensive” services at this time, and that Petitioner was not “formally” seeking compensatory education services. Based on this representation from Mr. Bothwell, this decision will not consider issues relating to the need for awarding compensatory education, i.e., the decision will not adjudicate the appropriateness of the placements and related services offered by the District during the last five years. The decision will, therefore, be limited to a determination of whether the placement and services the District has offered for the 1998-99 school year are appropriate and whether Petitioner should receive reimbursement for Dr. Lenington’s assessment, as set forth in Petitioner’s statement of issues. 4.There is no evidence in the record about Dr. Khanijou’s qualifications to make such a recommendation (except that he appears to be a medical doctor), or the grounds upon which he based his finding. Further, he did not testify at the hearing and thus there was no opportunity for the District to cross-examine him about his recommendation. Based on the foregoing, Dr. Khanijou’s recommendation will be given little weight. 5.Although MOTHER expressed disagreement with the progress noted in the present levels of performance recorded in the IEP dated March 16, 1998, there is no indication that there is any disagreement with the appropriateness of the goals and objectives in STUDENT ’s IEPs. 6.Apart from Ms. Burrell, the District witnesses who testified regarding the appropriateness of an aide for STUDENT, i.e., Dr. Shahidi and Ms. Davidson, stated that IBI by an aide might benefit STUDENT. Ms. Burrell, however, felt that a full-time aide would be a detriment to STUDENT. Ms. Burrell testified that, based on her observations of STUDENT, she believes STUDENT would use an aide as a crutch because she becomes dependent on help that is readily available to her. Ms. Burrell acknowledged that experts in the field of educating autistic children, such as Bryna Siegel, believe that a one-to-one aide can be helpful in preventing an autistic child from engaging in autistic behaviors, in facilitating interactions, and in gaining educational benefit. However, Ms. Burrell stated that she believes a one-to-one aide would interfere with STUDENT ’s interaction with peers, not facilitate it, as STUDENT tends to become focused on her teacher to the exclusion of others. Ms. Burrell based this opinion on her experience as a full-inclusion aide for an autistic kindergarten STUDENT for two and a half hours per week for one year. She admitted, however, that as an aide she did not function as a behavior intervention aide such as that used by the Lovaas program. Ms. Burrell’s testimony on this matter is given little weight for several reasons. Other District personnel who testified on this issue, Dr. Shahidi and Ms. Davidson, have more experience and training working with autistic children than Ms. Burrell, particularly with regard to IBI. Additionally, the basis for Ms. Burrell’s conclusion, i.e., her one-year working as an aide for an autistic kindergarten STUDENT , is inapplicable here as her aide role did not involve the type of behavior intervention proposed in this case. Finally, there appears to be no real dispute between the parties that it would be appropriate to provide an aide for STUDENT for this purpose. 7.Dr. Shahidi testified that Dr. Ritvo has done a significant amount of research on autism and is well-known in the field. 8.This characterization of the District’s current offer is based on the IEP dated November 19, 1997, which stated that S/L services were to be provided in one-on-one twenty minute sessions twice per week and in a group setting once per week for twenty minutes (for a total of one hour of services per week). The IEP dated November 19, 1997, was the most recent IEP available at the time Dr. Lenington wrote her report in January 1998. The District’s current offer, which totals one and a half hours per week, did not appear in any of STUDENT ’s IEPs until March 16, 1998. 9.Ms. Henderson did testify against the provision of S/L services for five hours per week, as requested by Petitioner, and specifically denounced one-hour sessions. However, she did not dispute the appropriateness of daily remediation. The importance of daily remediation to provide consistency and repetition was established by Dr. Lenington’s testimony. The Hearing Officer finds this unrefuted portion of Dr. Lenington’s testimony persuasive because of her general knowledge about teaching autistic children. 10.Title 5, section 3051(a)(3), of the California Code of Regulations states that designated instruction and services, such as S/L development and remediation, shall be provided by “qualified” entities and individuals. Section 3001(af) defines “qualified” as follows:
“Qualified” means that a person has met federal and state certification, licensing, registration, or other comparable requirements which apply to the area in which he or she is providing special education or related services, or, in the absence of such requirements, the state-education-agency-approved or recognized requirements, and adheres to the standards of professional practice established in federal and state law or regulation, including the standards contained in the California Business and Professions Code. Nothing in this definition shall be construed as restricting the activities in services of a graduate needing direct hours leading to licensure ... as authorized by state laws or regulations.
Specifically with regard to the provision of S/L services, section 3051.1(a)(2) provides:
An individual holding an appropriate credential with specialization in language, speech, and hearing may provide services which include ... [s]pecialized instruction and services for individuals with disorders of language, speech, and hearing, including monitoring of pupil progress on a regular basis, providing information for the review, and when necessary participating in the review and revision of individualized education programs of pupils. 11.This does not mean, however, that Ms. Henderson could not become fully qualified to provide appropriate S/L services to STUDENT with sufficient training by the District. 12.The occupational therapist currently providing direct OT in the clinic setting to STUDENT did not testify at the hearing. 13.Ms. Cohen described desensitization as a mechanism used to calm the neurological system. 14. According to Ms. Miniaci, the PECS program consists of six phases.
