California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 25, 2003

Student v. San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 408-03 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel

San Bernardino County Superintendent and Banning Unified denied FAPE to a court-school student; compensatory education ordered, residential placement denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 9 of 11 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted in the decision. The decision records that four respondents settled and were dismissed during the hearing, and that the Behavioral Health issue settled on the last hearing day.

Summary

A 17-year-old student under juvenile court jurisdiction filed against the San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools, Banning Unified School District, and the San Bernardino County Department of Behavioral Health. Between July 2000 and the 2003 hearing, the court moved him more than ten times, and his school changed with each move. The County repeatedly enrolled him at the Burton Thrall court school in Juvenile Hall without special education, even though its own intake questionnaires showed he had an IEP from San Bernardino City Unified. The Hearing Officer held that each time he arrived, the County had to identify him and provide an interim placement under Education Code section 56325. The County denied FAPE in all six periods. It gave no services, delayed placements and IEP meetings, skipped agreed assessments, delivered far less RSP time than promised, and left a February 2003 IEP unfinished. Banning denied FAPE at the Whitewater nonpublic school. Its interim placement did not follow the existing IEP, and it exited him from special education in May 2001 without new assessments or parent input. The Hearing Officer found him eligible only under specific learning disability, not emotional disturbance or other health impairment, and denied residential placement. The County must hold an IEP meeting within 30 days and offer specified services. Compensatory education of 225 minutes per week for two school years or 18 months was ordered, split 86% County and 14% Banning. The Behavioral Health claim settled.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the interim-placement rule in Education Code section 56325 to a juvenile court school. It treated each return to Juvenile Hall as a new transfer. It also shows that exiting a student from special education required current assessment data and parent input, not reliance on an outdated IEP.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedChild find

    Issue 1. For the time period July 13, 2000 through September 21, 2000, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

    The student still had an IEP from San Bernardino City Unified, and the County's own intake questionnaire showed prior special education. The County should have known this and provided an interim placement under Ed. Code 56325, but it provided no services, so it denied FAPE.

  2. Student prevailedChild find

    Issue 2. For the time period December 15, 2000 through February 8, 2001, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

    The County's duty to identify the student and provide an interim placement began again when he re-entered Burton Thrall. It again provided no special education, so it denied FAPE.

  3. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 3. For the time period February 13, 2001 through May 31, 2001, did Banning fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

    Banning's interim placement was timely, given the delay in receiving records, but it did not follow the existing IEP because no RSP pullout was provided. Banning also improperly exited the student in May 2001 without current assessment data or parent input, so it denied FAPE.

  4. Student prevailedChild find

    Issue 4. For the time period August 22, 2001 through September 19, 2001, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

    Because Banning's exit was improper, the April 2000 IEP was still in effect. The County failed to identify the student or provide an interim placement or any services, so it denied FAPE.

  5. Student prevailedChild find

    Issue 5. For the time period November 29, 2001 through January 7, 2002, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

    This period mirrored the prior one: the County did not identify the existing IEP or provide any services, and it offered no explanation, so it denied FAPE.

  6. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 6. For the time period February 22, 2002 through September 30, 2002, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

    The County denied FAPE. It took two months to start an interim placement, held no IEP meeting within 30 days, cut RSP time without explanation and delivered only 150 of more than 700 minutes, never did the June 2002 assessments, and could not identify the student's needs in September 2002. The student lost on two claims: the County had no duty to give medication (Probation's job), and removals did not exceed 10 days.

  7. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 7. For the time period January 8, 2003 through the present, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

    The County denied FAPE. Its interim placement did not follow the City's November 2002 IEP goals in written language and peer interaction, and the February 2003 IEP meeting was never finished, so no complete offer was made. The County won the other claims: the slightly late IEP meeting caused no significant harm, the assessment covered all areas (auditory processing, social-emotional, no neurological assessment needed), and it had no medication or discipline-meeting duty.

  8. Student prevailed in partEligibility

    Issue 8. Is STUDENT eligible for special education under the categories specific learning disabled, emotionally disturbed, and other health impaired?

    The student is eligible under specific learning disability (undisputed). Crediting the school psychologist over the student's expert, the Hearing Officer found he does not meet emotional disturbance criteria, and his ADHD is not currently limiting his alertness or performance enough for other health impairment.

  9. Dismissed / withdrawnAssessment

    Issue 9. Did Behavioral Health fail to assess STUDENT pursuant to a May 13, 2003 referral from the County?

    The parties settled on the record: Behavioral Health will assess and hold an IEP meeting by July 7, 2003. The decision says no party prevailed.

  10. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 10. Does STUDENT currently require a residential placement?

    The student's needs can be met in a structured general education classroom with RSP, counseling, a twelve-step program, a behavior support plan, and a transition plan. Residential placement would be overly restrictive.

  11. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 11. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

    Because both agencies denied FAPE in every period at issue, the student gets 225 minutes per week of after-school compensatory services for two school years or 18 months. The County pays 86% and Banning 14%.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 30 calendar days of the decision, the County must convene an IEP team meeting and develop a program that includes, at a minimum, placement in a structured general education classroom and two 50-minute periods a day of RSP services in reading comprehension, writing, and math.
  • Order to provide or change services. The student must receive individual, group, and family counseling for social interaction and family issues, in an amount and timing based on Behavioral Health's recommendations. He must also be enrolled in a twelve-step substance abuse program.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP team must develop a behavior support plan addressing disruptive and defiant behaviors and a transition plan based on the statutory criteria.
  • Compensatory education. 135 minutes per week of individual after-school academic instruction in reading comprehension, writing, and math, plus 45 minutes per week of counseling for peer interaction and family issues and 45 minutes per week of transition services. These are in addition to FAPE services and continue for 'two school years or eighteen months.' The County bears 86% of the cost and Banning 14%.
  • Settlement read into the record, not an order on the merits: Behavioral Health will assess the student under AB 2726/3632 for mental health services and hold an IEP meeting on or before July 7, 2003. The County will schedule that meeting.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56325; 34 C.F.R. § 300.533

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Scott Tommey, clinical psychologist; independent psychoeducational evaluator and expert witness for Student, Referred by Student's attorney
  • Sue Hamlin, principal for east valley operations; County special education supervisor, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools
  • Terry McLaughlin, assistant superintendent, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools
  • John Rico, school psychologist; conducted September 2002 psychoeducational assessment, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools
  • Lynn Eaves, RSP teacher, Burton Thrall School (County)
  • Bernardine Murphy, general education teacher, Burton Thrall School (County)
  • Donald Nute, principal of the juvenile court school, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools
  • Kathy Little, director of student services, Banning Unified School District
  • Dr. Ray Easler, principal/coordinator for Riverside County SELPA; school psychologist at May 7, 2001 IEP meeting, Riverside County SELPA
  • Gregory Hepner, former principal, Whitewater School (nonpublic school)
  • Michael Cole, math teacher, Whitewater School (nonpublic school)
  • Alphonse Winters, director of residential treatment facility (identified as director of Trinity-Anza and of Trinity-Whitewater), Trinity Children and Family Services
  • Diana Rhodes, social service practitioner; assigned educational rights holder, Trinity-Whitewater residential facility
  • David Satre, clinical therapist, San Bernardino County Department of Behavioral Health
  • Dr. Drieberg, former elementary school psychologist (interviewed by assessor), San Bernardino City Unified School District
  • Whitewater School, nonpublic school, Trinity-Whitewater residential treatment facility, within Banning Unified
  • Wilson Academy, nonpublic school, Within San Bernardino City Unified
  • Kelly School, school at group home, Imperial County Office of Education

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Bernardino, California, on May 13, 14, 15, 20, 21, 22, 23, 27, 28, 29, and 30, 2003.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorneys Janeen Steel and Ines Kuperschmidt. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf at different times during the hearing were FATHER, his step-father; MOTHER, his mother; Erika Sandoval, law clerk; Kerri Strunk, law clerk; Paula Pearlman, attorney; Benjamin Kim, attorney; Jill Rowland, intern; Audrey Kraus, attorney; Rebekah Weldon, intern; Oscar Pardo, intern; Steven DeVore, intern; Devon Mayers, law clerk; and Asma Chandani, intern.

Respondent San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools (County) was represented at the hearing by attorney Karen Gilyard. Also present on the County’s behalf was Terry McLaughlin, assistant superintendent for the San Bernardino County Schools. Respondent Banning Unified School District (Banning) was represented at the hearing by attorney Maria Gless. Also present on Banning’s behalf at times during the hearing were Kathy Little, director of student services for the Banning Unified School District, and Lysa Saltzman, attorney. Respondent San Bernardino Department of Behavior Health (Behavior Health) was represented at the hearing at different times by attorney Javan Rad and attorney Richard Clouse. Also present on Behavioral Health’s behalf at times was David Satre clinical therapist.

The following witnesses were called to testify at the hearing: MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; FATHER, STUDENT’s step-father; Dr. Scott Tommey, clinical psychologist; Sue Hamlin, principal for east valley operations; Diana Rhodes, social service practitioner; Alphonse Winters, director of Trinity-Anza; Kathy Little, director of student services; Michael Cole, teacher; Gregory Hepner, former principal of the Whitewater school; Lynn Eaves, RSP teacher; Donald Nute, principal of the juvenile court school; Bernardine Murphy, teacher; Dr. Ray Easler, principal/coordinator for the Riverside County SELPA; John Rico, school psychologist; and David Satre, clinical therapist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Upon the receipt of closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL HISTORY

A prehearing conference was held in this matter on April 1, 2003. At that time there were a total of seventeen respondents: San Bernardino City Unified School District, San Bernardino County Superintendent Of Schools, East Valley SELPA, San Bernardino County Probation Department, San Bernardino County, Trinity Children And Family Services, Advance Education Services, California Youth Authority, Kelly Adolescent Treatment Center, Imperial County Office Of Education, Imperial County SELPA, Fouts Spring Youth Facility, Colusa County Office Of Education, Colusa County SELPA, San Bernardino County Department Of Behavioral Health, Riverside County SELPA, and Banning Unified School District. As a result of that conference, the following parties were dismissed: Colusa County SELPA, San Bernardino County Probation Department, San Bernardino County, Imperial County SELPA, Riverside County SELPA, East Valley SELPA, Fouts Spring Youth Facility, Kelly Adolescent Treatment Center and Trinity Children and Family Services. On the first day of hearing, AES was also dismissed.

During the first two days of hearing, the remaining parties engaged in settlement discussions outside of the presence of the Hearing Officer. As a result of these discussions, California Youth Authority, San Bernardino City Unified School District, Imperial County Office of Education, and Colusa County Office of Education each reached separate settlement agreements with Petitioner. The parties to the settlements agreed that all issues related to this hearing had been resolved and requested that the listed respondents be dismissed. The Hearing Officer granted the request and dismissed the California Youth Authority, San Bernardino City Unified School District, Imperial County Office of Education, and Colusa County Office of Education pursuant to their agreements with Petitioner.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. For the time period July 13, 2000 through September 21, 2000, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE? 2. For the time period December 15, 2000 through February 8, 2001, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE? 3. For the time period February 13, 2001 through May 31, 2001, did Banning fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE? 4. For the time period August 22, 2001 through September 19, 2001, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE? 5. For the time period November 29, 2001 through January 7, 2002, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE? 6. For the time period February 22, 2002 through September 30, 2002, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE? 7. For the time period January 8, 2003 through the present, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE? 8. Is STUDENT eligible for special education under the categories specific learning disabled, emotionally disturbed, and other health impaired? 9. Did Behavioral Health fail to assess STUDENT pursuant to a May 13, 2003 referral from the County? 10. Does STUDENT currently require a residential placement?

11. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

During the time period at issue, STUDENT has been under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court. The Court changed STUDENT’s residential placement over ten times, resulting in changes to the schools he has attended. With each change in placement, the educational agency responsible for the provision of special education services to STUDENT changed. As set forth in the procedural history portion of this Decision, some of the educational agencies involved in the different placements reached settlements with Petitioner prior to the taking of evidence. The remaining agencies, the County and Banning, were each responsible for STUDENT’s education at different times as set forth in the issues section. Petitioner’s basic contention is that neither the County nor Banning offered STUDENT a FAPE during any of the time periods at issue. The specific allegations in relation to each time period will be set out more fully in the analysis section of this Decision.

The only issue related to Behavior Health is its alleged failure to conduct an assessment pursuant to a May 13, 2003 referral from the County.

Petitioner is seeking a finding that he is eligible for special education under the categories specific learning disabled, emotional disturbance, and other health impaired. Petitioner is also seeking a residential placement. In addition, as the result of the past denials of FAPE, Petitioner is requesting compensatory education.

Banning contends that it properly determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. The County contends that, initially, it did not have any reason to know that STUDENT was eligible for special education or had an existing individualized education program. The County also contends that, after it determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education services, it did provide a FAPE.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is currently a seventeen-year-old student who is incarcerated at the San Bernardino County Juvenile Hall. He attends the Burton Thrall School, a court school on the grounds of Juvenile Hall operated by the San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools (County). STUDENT is currently eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability. He was first found eligible for special education in 1994 by the San Bernardino City Unified School District (City) as a student with a speech/language impairment. In 1996, the City changed STUDENT’s eligibility to other health impaired in response to a diagnosis of ADHD.

STUDENT’s triennial evaluation was performed in February 1999. On the Woodcock-Johnson Revised STUDENT scored a 99 in broad reading, 80 in broad math, 53 in broad written language, and 81 in broad knowledge. On the TONI-III, a test of cognitive ability, STUDENT scored an 81, in the low average range. On testing of STUDENT’s attentional abilities it was found that STUDENT scored in the range of a student with ADHD. It was also noted that STUDENT had major behavior problems involving refusals to do work, deliberately taunting other students, and being disruptive in class. The psychoeducational assessment concluded that STUDENT qualified for special education as a student with a specific learning disability in the area of written language. The IEP team meeting following this evaluation was held on February 18, 1999. The IEP team notes state that the team concluded that STUDENT no longer qualified for special education because, “there is no discrepancy.(Footnote 2) ” However, the team recommended a one-year transitional RSP program. The IEP also contained a behavior improvement plan.

On March 27, 2000, an IEP meeting was convened to address ongoing behavioral concerns. At that meeting, STUDENT’s teacher stated that STUDENT appeared very distracted in class and was very confrontational with other students and with her. The IEP team determined that STUDENT needed to be in a smaller class and reviewed and revised STUDENT’s behavior improvement plan.

The school psychologist completed a new psychoeducational assessment on March 30, 2000. The assessor reviewed writing samples and teacher input but performed no new formal testing. The assessment report states that the teacher reported that STUDENT was able to write and spell adequately and that his primary difficulty was motivation, not ability. The assessment concluded that there was no longer a discrepancy between achievement and ability.

STUDENT’s next annual IEP was held on April 3, 2000. The team concluded that STUDENT had the ability to learn but was not applying himself to completing classroom and homework assignments. The team recommended the continuation of the transition RSP plan until STUDENT reached high school. It was planned that an IEP team meeting would be held in October or November of 2000 to review STUDENT’s program with the intention that he would be exited from special education at that time. STUDENT had not met any of his goals and objectives from the 1999 IEP, so those goals were continued as part of the April 2000 IEP. Services were listed as RSP consultation and pullout twice a week for forty-five minutes per session.

On May 17, 2000, a pre-expulsion manifestation determination meeting was held. Expulsion was being considered due to continuous violations of the California Education Code section 48900(k), which prohibits disruption of school activities or willful defiance of school personnel. The team reviewed STUDENT’s prior IEP and concluded that there was no reason to stop the expulsion process. An expulsion hearing was scheduled for June 22, 2000, and STUDENT was subsequently expelled. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT was arrested and incarcerated in the San Bernardino County Juvenile Hall.(Footnote 3)

On July 13, 2000, STUDENT began attending the Burton Thrall court school, the school located on the grounds of Juvenile Hall and operated by the County. STUDENT was placed in a general education class with no special education services.

In September 2000, the Juvenile Court changed STUDENT’s residential placement to the Kelly Group Home. As a result, on September 22, 2000, STUDENT began attending the Kelly School operated by the Imperial County Office of Education. STUDENT was placed in a thirty-day interim placement that consisted of RSP services on a consultation basis.

On December 15, 2000, STUDENT returned to Burton Thrall. Following his return to Burton Thrall, STUDENT was again placed in a general education classroom with no special education services.

In February 2001, the Court again changed STUDENT’s residential placement, moving him to the Trinity-Whitewater residential treatment facility. On February 13, 2001, STUDENT began attending the Whitewater School, a nonpublic school operated on the grounds of the residential facility. The Whitewater School is within the Banning Unified School District (Banning). On February 17, 2001, MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, signed an assignment of educational rights, which authorized Diana Rhodes, an employee of Trinity-Whitewater, to act as STUDENT’s parent representative. After requesting and receiving records from previous schools, Banning established an interim placement for STUDENT beginning on March 28, 2001. The placement consisted of placement in a nonpublic school (the Whitewater School). The only difference between STUDENT’s placement before and after the interim placement was that the April 3, 2000 IEP from the City was distributed to STUDENT’s teachers at Whitewater. On May 7, 2001, an IEP team meeting was held to review the interim placement. The IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s goals from the April 3, 2000 IEP, the March 30, 2000 assessment report from the City, and considered input from STUDENT’s teachers at Whitewater. The IEP notes state, “Previous IEP & assessment found STUDENT no loner eligible for special ed. services. A transition plan was written. This IEP was to review previous plan & determine if exit is still appropriate. Team agreed w/previous information. Student was deemed not eligible.” On the basis of this IEP, STUDENT was exited from special education. However, as with the interim placement, there was no actual change to STUDENT’s placement or the services being provided. On May 31, 2001, STUDENT left Whitewater.

On August 23, 2001, STUDENT returned to Burton Thrall.(Footnote 4) STUDENT was again placed in a general education class. STUDENT’s placement at Burton Thrall only lasted until September 19, 2001, at which time he was transferred to a California Youth Authority facility and attended a school operated by that agency. On November 29, 2001, STUDENT returned to Burton Thrall, where he remained through January 7, 2002. On January 9, 2002, STUDENT began attending the Nielson High School operated by the Colusa County Office of Education. This placement lasted until January 28, 2002 after which STUDENT again returned to Burton Thrall.

In April, STUDENT was suspended twice, once for defiance during PE, and once for refusing to complete schoolwork. On April 29, 2002, the County established an interim placement for STUDENT based upon the City’s April 3, 2000 IEP. The interim placement called for RSP services twice a week for forty-five minutes per session.

An IEP team meeting was held on June 10, 2002. The IEP team reviewed the results of testing including the STAR reading and math tests and the Wide Ranging Achievement Test – 3 (WRAT-3) in reading, math and spelling. These tests indicated that STUDENT was working at the sixth grade level in reading, the third grade level in math, and the fourth grade level in spelling. During the meeting, MOTHER reported that STUDENT was taking Wellbutrin for ADHD. The team also reviewed the April 2000 IEP from the City, and the City’s March 2000 assessment report. The team found the City’s assessment and IEP confusing because the March 2000 assessment stated that STUDENT did not qualify for special education, but that assessment report was not specifically referenced in the April 2000 IEP. The team determined that additional assessments were necessary to determine if STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education. It was agreed that STUDENT would continue to receive RSP support twice a week for thirty minutes each session. One goal was drafted in the area of math. An assessment plan was also developed and agreed to by MOTHER. The plan called for assessments in the areas of academic achievement, cognitive development, perception/processing/memory, and social/emotional/behavior.

STUDENT was again suspended in July for defying school staff. STUDENT’s next IEP team meeting was held on September 9, 2002; however, the assessments agreed to in June had not been performed. Mr. Rico, the school psychologist, had been in contact with the City regarding its 2000 assessment. Mr. Rico reported that the City had assessed STUDENT’s reading and writing but not math, and that the testing was dated, having been done over two years ago. It was also reported that STUDENT was taking Wellbutrin and Concerta, though no information was provided as to the reasons for these medications. The IEP team again decided that additional assessments were necessary to determine if STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education. The goal and services from the June 2002 IEP were continued. A new assessment plan was drafted and agreed to by MOTHER. This plan called for assessments in the areas of academic achievement, cognitive development, perception/processing/memory, motor development, language/speech, social/emotional/behavior, and self-help.

Mr. Rico’s psychoeducational report was completed on September 24, 2002. Mr. Rico interviewed MOTHER, STUDENT, STUDENT’s teacher, and the City’s school psychologist. He also administered the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML); the Bender, a test of visual-motor skills; the Learning Efficiency Test (LET), a test of the student’s preferred modality for learning; the Matrix Analogy Test (MAT), a test of visual processing; the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test (WRMT); and the Key Math test. To test STUDENT’s cognitive functioning Mr. Rico utilized alternative procedures including use of the Piagetian tasks, a series of activities designed to assess a student’s cognitive development. Mr. Rico concluded that STUDENT was functioning in the average range of cognitive ability. In academics, Mr. Rico noted weaknesses in word identification and word attack skills. He also found that STUDENT’s math skills were at the fourth grade level. In addition, Mr. Rico concluded that STUDENT had a significant deficit in the area of auditory processing. Mr. Rico also described a history of defiant behavior in the learning environment. STUDENT’s teacher reported that he was easily frustrated by certain academic tasks, especially involving math. Mr. Rico concluded that STUDENT’s mood swings and frustrations in the classroom were directly related to his difficulty with performance and achievement. During testing, Mr. Rico observed attention problems that were aggravated by STUDENT’s low frustration level. In summary, Mr. Rico found that STUDENT had a specific learning disability due to an auditory processing disorder. Mr. Rico concluded that STUDENT’s attention problems were only moderate and did not consider them significant at that time.

On September 30, 2002, before the RSP teacher had completed her testing of STUDENT’s academic achievement, STUDENT left Juvenile Hall and Burton Thrall and returned to the City, enrolling at the San Bernardino High School. On October 23, 2002, STUDENT enrolled at the Wilson Academy, a nonpublic school. On November 21, 2002, the City held an IEP team meeting for STUDENT. The IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability and recommended continued placement at the Wilson Academy because of its highly structured, self-contained environment. A referral for an AB2726 assessment was also recommended. While enrolled at Wilson, STUDENT ran away from home and was subsequently returned to Juvenile Hall.

On January 8, 2003, STUDENT returned to the Burton Thrall School. The County developed an interim placement for STUDENT based upon the June 10, 2002 IEP. On February 4, 2003, Ms. Eaves, the RSP teacher, completed her assessment of STUDENT’s academic achievement. On the Woodcock Johnson STUDENT received grade normed standard scores of 87 in broad reading (an 8.4 grade equivalent), 74 in broad math (a 5.4 grade equivalent), and 78 in broad written language (a 6.0 grade equivalent).

An IEP team meeting was held on February 21, 2003. The assessments were reviewed and the team agreed that STUDENT was eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability. The team also agreed to increase the RSP time to four times a week for thirty minutes each session, although MOTHER was requesting forty-five minute sessions. The team also agreed that the reading and writing goals from STUDENT’s April 3, 2000 IEP would be continued and the math goal from the June 10, 2002 IEP would also be continued. Other goals were discussed but the meeting was adjourned before the team was able to develop new goals and objectives. MOTHER and her representatives raised the need for a behavior support plan similar to what STUDENT had had under the City’s March 27, 2000 IEP, but a copy of that IEP was not available for the team to review. It was agreed that the IEP team meeting would be concluded at a later date. As of the conclusion of the hearing, the IEP team meeting had not been reconvened.

On March 14, 2003, STUDENT left Juvenile Hall and Burton Thrall for another school operated by the County. STUDENT only attended this school for two days before leaving without permission. On April 4, 2003, STUDENT returned to Burton Thrall. The County resumed providing services pursuant to the February 21, 2003 IEP. On May 14, 2003, STUDENT was moved the Unit 3 residential unit, which is one of the maximum-security units at Juvenile Hall.

On May 10, 2003, Dr. Scott Tommey completed an assessment report based upon his evaluation of STUDENT. STUDENT had been referred to Dr. Tommey by his attorney for a psychoeducational evaluation. Dr. Tommey performed formal testing, reviewed records, and conducted telephone interviews with both of STUDENT’s parents. Dr. Tommey administered the Bender-Gestalt; the Stanford-Binet, a test of cognitive ability; the Weschler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), a test of academic achievement; the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT), a test of personality development; the Rorschach; the Trauma Symptom Checklist; the Barkley Rating Scales for ADHD; the Adolescent Substance Use Self Evaluation; the Child Depression Inventory; Picture Drawings; and the Achenbach Youth Self-Report form.(Footnote 5) Dr. Tommey reviewed three previous IEPs, four previous psychoeducational assessments, and several sets of STAR test results.

Dr. Tommey reported that STUDENT had a history of substance abuse over the last five years. Dr. Tommey also reported that STUDENT’s mother had a long history of substance abuse. STUDENT told Dr. Tommey that his criminal problems began during a time when he was using crystalline methamphetamine on a heavy basis. STUDENT also stated that he recognized that he had anger control problems. On the basis of the Stanford-Binet, Dr. Tommey concluded that STUDENT had an IQ of 82, in the low average range. Dr. Tommey noted strengths in visual processing and a significant weakness in the area of auditory processing. On the WIAT, STUDENT’s language composite score was 89 (a grade equivalent of 6.6), his reading composite score was 74 (a grade equivalent of 5.8), his math composite score was 63 (a grade equivalent of 4.6), and his writing composite score was 65 (a grade equivalent of 4.9). Dr. Tommey stated that the TAT and Rorschach suggested that STUDENT was depressed, although STUDENT denied current depression on the self-report questionnaires. Other test results indicated that STUDENT did best in clearly defined, well-structured settings. Dr. Tommey also noted that STUDENT tended to misperceive events and failed to anticipate the consequences of his actions. In addition, Dr. Tommey stated that the testing indicated low self-esteem. Dr. Tommey testified that reports from STUDENT’s teacher and parents indicated some attention problems; however, he believed this could have been the result of STUDENT’s auditory processing disorder rather than ADHD. Dr. Tommey’s diagnostic impressions were that STUDENT suffered from a mathematics disorder, a disorder of written expression, a conduct disorder, an impulse-control disorder, amphetamine dependence, and a history of seizures. Dr. Tommey recommended further evaluations in the areas of auditory processing, ADHD, and to rule out a seizure disorder. Dr. Tommey also recommended individual, family and group therapy, as well as possible antidepressant medication. Academically, Dr. Tommey recommended placement in a highly structured residential facility with intensive academic instruction.

Through the conclusion of the hearing, STUDENT remained incarcerated at Juvenile Hall and attending the Burton Thrall School.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

During the time period at issue in this case, July 13, 2000 through the present, STUDENT’s placement has changed twelve different times. Many of these placements lasted less than two months. Some of the placements were at schools operated by parties that reached settlements with Petitioner prior to the taking of evidence in this case. The remaining time periods and placements are those set forth in the statement of issues section of this Decision. Each of the relevant time periods will be examined separately in chronological order.

The basic issue for each time period is whether the responsible educational agency provided STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), a FAPE is special education and related services designed to meet a student’s unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 (d). The term “free and appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).

However, from July 13, 2000 through April 29, 2002, STUDENT was not provided any special education services except for a brief interim placement from March 28 through May 7, 2001. Therefore, the primary issue for July 2000 through April 2002 is not whether the services provided by the responsible educational agencies constituted a FAPE, but whether the agencies had an obligation to provide STUDENT with any special education services. One of the educational agencies’ fundamental duties in relation to this issue is referred to as “child find.” The federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and State law impose upon each educational agency the duty to actively and systematically identify, locate, and assess all children with disabilities who require special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3) (formerly 20 U.S.C. § 1412(2)(C)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56300, 56301. A related duty arises when a student with an existing IEP transfers from one educational agency to another agency within a different SELPA. In that case, the receiving agency has a duty to provide the student with an interim placement not to exceed 30 days. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56325 (a).) The interim placement must be in conformity with the student’s existing IEP to the extent possible within existing resources. These obligations, among others, will be addressed in this Decision.

1. July 13, 2000 through September 21, 2000

This was STUDENT’s first admission to the Burton Thrall School, a court school operated by the County on the grounds of Juvenile Hall. Petitioner contends that the County failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during this time period by failing to provide STUDENT with any special education services. The County alleges that it had no reason to know that STUDENT was eligible for special education during this time period.

STUDENT’s April 3, 2000 IEP developed by the City stated that the team concluded that STUDENT’s written language skills no longer constituted a learning disability, but recommended ongoing RSP services until STUDENT reached high school. That IEP did not exit STUDENT from special education. The next IEP team meeting was on May 17, 2000. However, this was not a regular IEP team meeting, it was a manifestation determination meeting, the purpose of which was to determine whether the City’s proposed expulsion of STUDENT should go forward. At that meeting, the team concluded that the expulsion could go forward but did not exit STUDENT from special education. Because the City had never exited STUDENT from special education, he continued to be eligible for special education services when he entered Burton Thrall in July 2000. This conclusion is undisputed by the parties.

When STUDENT entered Burton Thrall, responsibility for his education shifted from the City to the County. While State law is silent as to the appropriate placement for special education students in this situation, STUDENT’s case is analogous to a student leaving one district and transferring to another district within a different SELPA. That situation is governed by California Education Code section 56325, which, as stated earlier, requires the receiving agency to provide an interim placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that when STUDENT entered Burton Thrall, the County was required to provide STUDENT with an interim placement in conformity with his existing IEP. The County failed to provide STUDENT with any placement. The County claims that it was unaware that STUDENT had an existing IEP when he first entered Burton Thrall. As set forth above, the County’s “child find” obligation required it to actively and systematically identify, locate, and assess all children with disabilities who require special education and related services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56300, 56301. This duty includes the obligation to identify those students who enter County schools with existing IEPs. To identify which incoming students have existing IEPs, Burton Thrall had each new student complete a questionnaire that was designed to determine whether the student had ever received special education services in the past. When a student indicated that he or she had previously received special education, Burton Thrall’s policy was to request the most recent IEP and assessments from the student’s prior school. The record contains numerous examples of these questionnaires completed by STUDENT at different times, one of which is from STUDENT’s July 2000 enrollment.(Footnote 6) Although the questionnaire is undated, it states that STUDENT was 14 year old, and that he last attended King Middle School two months prior to the admission to Burton Thrall. These facts establish that the questionnaire was completed in July 2000. On the questionnaire, STUDENT indicated that he had received special education, including RSP services. On the basis of this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that, had the County followed its own procedures, it would have discovered that STUDENT had an existing IEP, the City’s April 3, 2000 IEP, at the time he first entered Burton Thrall in July 2000. Therefore, the County knew, or should have known, that STUDENT was a student who was eligible to receive special education services. In this case, Education Code section 56235 required the County to provide STUDENT with an interim placement in conformity with the April 3, 2000 IEP. The County failed to provide STUDENT with an appropriate interim placement or with any special education services during this time period.

The County failed to provide STUDENT with any special education services during the time period at issue. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the time period July 13, 2000 through September 21, 2000.

2. December 15, 2000 through February 8, 2001

This was STUDENT’s second admission to the Burton Thrall School.(Footnote 7) Petitioner contends that the County continued in its failure to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during this time period by failing to provide STUDENT with any special education services. The County again alleges that it had no reason to know that STUDENT was eligible for special education during this time period.

Because STUDENT was still a student with an existing IEP (the April 3, 2000 IEP) he was still eligible for special education services. Even though this was STUDENT’s second admission to Burton Thrall, because STUDENT had left the County’s jurisdiction and then returned, the County’s legal obligation to identify STUDENT as a student with an existing IEP and provide an interim placement began anew. The Hearing Officer has already determined that the County knew or should have known that STUDENT had an existing IEP. The County presented no evidence that it received any information during this time period that would alter the Hearing Officer’s determination on this issue. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, during this time period, the County knew or should have known that STUDENT had an existing IEP and that the County had a duty to provide STUDENT with at least an interim placement in conformity with that IEP. The County continued in its failure to provide STUDENT with any special education services.

The County failed to provide STUDENT with any special education services during the time period at issue. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the time period December 15, 2000 through February 8, 2001.

3. February 13, 2001 through May 31, 2001

During this time period, STUDENT attended the Whitewater School, an NPS within Banning. Petitioner alleges that Banning failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during this time period by failing to provide a timely and appropriate interim placement. Furthermore, Petitioner contends that Banning failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE at the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting by failing to assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability, failing to allow the parent to participate in the IEP process, and failing to find STUDENT eligible for special education.

Banning contends that it did provide STUDENT with a timely and appropriate interim placement. Banning also contends that, at the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting, it properly determined that STUDENT was no longer eligible for special education and, therefore, was not required to offer STUDENT a FAPE.

Was the interim placement timely and appropriate?

As set forth earlier in this Decision, as the district receiving a student who had an existing IEP, Banning had a duty to provide STUDENT with an interim placement not to exceed 30 days. That interim placement had to be in conformity with the student’s existing IEP to the extent possible within existing resources. Cal. Educ. Code § 56325 (a). Banning did develop an interim placement for STUDENT, but not until March 28, 2001, more than a month after he first enrolled at Whitewater. Petitioner contends that this delay was unreasonable. Whitewater requested records from STUDENT’s prior placements on the day he was admitted. The evidence established that the City did not fax STUDENT’s special education records until March 14, 2001. Banning developed the interim placement fourteen days after receipt of the records. The Hearing Officer finds that this was not an unreasonable delay. In order to develop an interim placement in conformity with a student’s prior IEP a district must be allowed a reasonable time to obtain the records from the other student’s previous educational agencies. The Hearing Officer finds that Banning’s delay in developing the interim placement was reasonable under the facts of this case.

Although the interim placement developed by Banning was timely, it was not in conformity with the existing IEP. STUDENT’s existing IEP called for RSP pullout and consultation twice a week for forty-five minutes per session. Banning’s interim placement provided for placement at the Whitewater NPS. No RSP or other pullout services were indicated. Mr. Hepner, the principal at Whitewater, stated that STUDENT’s teachers would have been provided with the interim placement form along with a copy of the existing IEP (in this case the April 3, 2000 IEP). He stated that it was up to the individual teacher to provide any required pullout services. Banning provided no evidence that STUDENT ever received any pullout services while at Whitewater. Placement at an NPS, even one with relatively small classes and with extra teaching assistance in the class, is not “in conformity” with a program calling for pullout RSP services. Furthermore, there was no evidence that Whitewater did not have the resources to provide pullout services.(Footnote 8) On the basis of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the interim placement provided by Banning was not in conformity with STUDENT’s existing IEP as required by section 56325.

At the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting, did Banning properly determine that STUDENT was no longer eligible for special education?

To determine whether a child continues to be eligible for special education the law requires that the public educational agency convene an IEP meeting at which a group of qualified professionals and the parent of the child determine whether the child is a child with a disability as defined in the IDEA. Before determining that a child is no longer a child with a disability, the public agency must evaluate a child with a disability in accordance with sections 300.532 and 300.533 of part 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations. 34 CFR § 300.534. Section 300.533 sets forth what information the IEP team must consider. That section states, in part, that the team must:

(a)(1) Review existing evaluation data on the child, including-- (i) Evaluations and information provided by the parents of the child; (ii) Current classroom-based assessments and observations; and (iii) Observations by teachers and related services providers; and (2) On the basis of that review, and input from the child's parents, identify what additional data, if any, are needed to determine-- (i) Whether the child has a particular category of disability, as described in § 300.7, or, in case of a reevaluation of a child, whether the child continues to have such a disability; (ii) The present levels of performance and educational needs of the child; (iii) Whether the child needs special education and related services, or in the case of a reevaluation of a child, whether the child continues to need special education and related services; and (iv) Whether any additions or modifications to the special education and related services are needed to enable the child to meet the measurable annual goals set out in the IEP of the child and to participate, as appropriate, in the general curriculum… (c) Need for additional data. The public agency shall administer tests and other evaluation materials as may be needed to produce the data identified under paragraph (a) of this section.

34 CFR § 300.533

At the May 7, 2001 IEP meeting, the team reviewed the City’s March 30, 2000 assessment update, the City’s April 3, 2000 IEP, and written and verbal reports from STUDENT’s teachers at Whitewater.(Footnote 9) After reviewing these two reports and considering the testimony of Kathy Little, Alphonse Winter, Diana Rhodes, Michael Cole, Gregory Hepner, and Dr. Easler, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team had insufficient information on which to determine that STUDENT was no longer eligible for special education. The City’s March 30, 2000 assessment contained no actual assessment data. The report states that the assessor reviewed the February 1999 assessment, and summarizes the results of that assessment as indicating the STUDENT was functioning in the low average range of cognitive ability and was marginal for a learning disability in the area of written language. The April 3, 2000 IEP also contained no actual assessment results. Therefore, the IEP team did not consider the existing assessment data, they only considered two very brief summaries of the assessments. The IEP team was completely unaware of what STUDENT’s actual test scores had been on any of his previous assessments. Furthermore, the IEP team obtained no input from either Mr. or MOTHER. MOTHER had executed an assignment of education rights, appointing Diana Rhodes, an employee of the Trinity-Whitewater residential facility, to act on her behalf in educational matters.(Footnote 10) Although Ms. Rhodes attended the IEP, neither parent was present. Ms. Rhodes may have had authority to assent to the IEP, but this did not mean that she brought the same information to the IEP process that a parent would bring. In fact, testimony established that neither Kathy Little, Banning’s director of student services; Dr. Easler, the school psychologist; Mr. Hepner, the principal of Whitewater; nor Ms. Rhodes had ever even spoken to either FATHER or MOTHER. Section 300.533 requires the team to obtain input from the parent, not simply the legal consent of the parent.

The testimony and documentary evidence establish that the IEP team relied, almost entirely, on the conclusion reached by the April 3, 2000 IEP team, that STUDENT no longer had a specific learning disability. They did not consider existing assessment data or input from the parent. The team’s reliance on the April 2000 IEP was inappropriate under the facts of this case. First, the IEP relied on was, by May 2001, over a year old. Second, the most recent assessments had been done in February 1999 and were then over two years old. Third, STUDENT’s situation had changed significantly since his last IEP. He had been incarcerated and had attended three different schools in the interim. Fourth, academically, STUDENT was performing significantly below grade level, especially in math. Mr. Cole, STUDENT’s math teacher at Whitewater, testified that STUDENT was functioning at around the third grade level in math. Fifth, STUDENT was exhibiting significant behavioral problems. Mr. Cole stated that STUDENT disobeyed rules, was defiant, disrespectful, disruptive, and could be vicious when he did not get his way. Furthermore, Mr. Winter, the director of Trinity-Whitewater, had specifically requested that Banning conduct additional assessments due to his concerns about STUDENT’s behavioral history. Finally, the May 2001 IEP team determined that STUDENT had not made progress on any of his academic goals or objectives from the April 2000 IEP. On the basis of these factors, the Hearing Officer finds that the May 7, 2001 IEP team did not have sufficient information on which to determine if STUDENT continued to have a disability as defined by the IDEA, or whether he continued to need special education services. In fact, the team had a great deal of evidence that indicated that STUDENT continued to have significant academic and behavioral problems. Additional assessments were required in order to properly determine if STUDENT continued to qualify for special education, and if he did, what his unique needs were. Neither Banning nor Whitewater conducted any new assessments. Mr. Winter’s request for assessments was ignored. Because Banning failed to make a proper determination that STUDENT was not eligible, STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education services.

Banning argues that, even if its discharge of STUDENT from special education was improper, STUDENT was not harmed because he continued to receive special education services at an NPS. Banning points to the fact that STUDENT continued to receive the same services after the May 2001 IEP meeting as he did before the IEP meeting. This argument ignores what a district’s duty is under the IDEA. As stated earlier, a FAPE is special education and related services designed to meet a student’s unique needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 (d). Having failed to conduct the necessary assessments, Banning had no means of determining what STUDENT’s unique needs were. Without a determination of STUDENT’s unique needs, Banning had no way of establishing that the services it provided to STUDENT met those needs. Furthermore, part of the definition of what constitutes a FAPE is that the services provided conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Without an IEP, Banning could not, by mere coincidence, have provided a FAPE.

The Hearing Officer finds that Banning did not have adequate information to support its May 7, 2001 determination that STUDENT was no longer eligible for special education. Therefore, STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education after the May 2001 IEP meeting. Because Banning failed to identify STUDENT’s unique needs or develop an IEP, it did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE.

The Hearing Officer previously found that Banning’s interim placement, though timely, was not in conformity with STUDENT’s existing IEP. It has also been determined that Banning failed to properly exit STUDENT from special education at the May 7, 2001 IEP, and failed to provide him with a FAPE thereafter. Therefore, Banning failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the time period February 13, 2001 through May 31, 2001.

4. August 22, 2001 through September 19, 2001

STUDENT left Trinity-Whitewater and the Whitewater School without permission. On August 22, 2001 he was returned to Juvenile Hall and to Burton Thrall. The contentions relating to this time period are the same as the two previous admissions to Burton Thrall: Petitioner contends that the County continued in its failure to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during this time period by failing to provide STUDENT with any special education services and the County alleges that it had no reason to know that STUDENT was eligible for special education during this time period.

Because Banning’s attempt to exit STUDENT from special education was improper, he was still a student with an existing IEP, the April 3, 2000 IEP, at the time he returned to Burton Thrall in August 2001. The County continued to have the duty to identify STUDENT as a student with an existing IEP and provide him with at least an interim placement. The County did not claim that it relied on, or was entitled to rely on Banning’s May 7, 2001 IEP. Furthermore, the County presented no evidence as to why it failed to identify STUDENT as a student with an existing IEP during this period of time. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, during this time period, the County knew or should have known that STUDENT had an existing IEP, and that the County had a duty to provide STUDENT with at least an interim placement in conformity with that IEP. The County continued in its failure to provide STUDENT with any special education services.

The County failed to provide STUDENT with any special education services during the time period at issue. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the time period August 22, 2001 through September 19, 2001.

5. November 29, 2001 through January 7, 2002

After September 19, 2001, STUDENT was transferred to a school operated by the California Youth Authority. On November 29, 2001, STUDENT was transferred back to Juvenile Hall and Burton Thrall. The circumstances and allegations for this time period are identical to those raised in relation to the prior time period. The County failed to identify STUDENT as a student with an existing IEP, and failed to provide any special education services. Again, the County presented no evidence as to why it failed to identify STUDENT as a student with an existing IEP during this period of time.(Footnote 11) Therefore, the Hearing Officer’s finding is the same, the County failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the time period November 29, 2001 through January 7, 2002.

6. February 22, 2002 through September 30, 2002

On January 9, 2002, STUDENT began attending school at the Nielson High School in Colusa County. On February 22, 2002, he was transferred back to Juvenile Hall and re-enrolled at Burton Thrall. It was during this admission that STUDENT first received special education services from the County, beginning with an interim placement on April 29, 2002. Two IEP team meetings were held, on June 10 and on September 9, 2002. Each of these IEP meetings resulted in assessment plans.

For this time period, Petitioner contends that the County failed to provide a timely interim placement, failed to hold an IEP meeting within thirty days, failed to offer a FAPE at either IEP meeting, failed to assess STUDENT in all areas, failed to provide STUDENT with his prescribed medication, and failed to hold an IEP meeting after removals totaling more than ten days. Each allegation will be addressed separately.

Did the County fail to provide a timely interim placement?

On April 29, 2002, the County implemented an interim placement on the basis of STUDENT’s April 3, 2000 IEP, calling for RSP services twice a week for forty-five minutes per session. At that point, STUDENT had been attending Burton Thrall for over two months. The evidence established that STUDENT completed questionnaires on February 22 and February 27, stating that he had previously received special education services. However, the County presented no evidence as to why it took until April 29 to implement an interim placement. Although some delay might be understandable, a two-month delay, especially when the County had had so much prior contact with STUDENT, is unreasonable. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County failed to provide STUDENT with a timely interim placement.

Did the County fail to hold an IEP meeting within thirty days?

Education Code section 56325 requires that the interim placement last no more than thirty days. Before the expiration of the thirty-day period, the interim placement must be reviewed by the individualized education program team and a final recommendation made by the team in accordance with the requirements of the IDEA. Cal. Educ Code § 56325. In this case, the IEP team meeting was not held until June 10, 2002, over forty days after the start of the interim placement and over three months after STUDENT’s enrollment on February 22, 2002. The County presented no evidence as to why the IEP was not held sooner. In some cases, a delay of only ten days might be excused if it resulted in no harm to the student. In this case, given the delay in instituting the interim placement, any additional delay only compounded the potential harm to STUDENT.(Footnote 12) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County unreasonably failed to hold an IEP within thirty days as required by section 56325.

Did the County offer STUDENT a FAPE at the June 10, 2002 IEP meeting?

As set forth earlier, a FAPE is special education and related services designed to meet a student’s unique needs, prepare him or her for employment and independent living, and conform with the student’s IEP. Among other things, a student’s IEP must provide for him or her to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s potential. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services, which are individually designed to provide some educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley the proposed educational program must 1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, 2) provide for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, 3) be calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, and 4) conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.

At the June 10, 2002 IEP meeting, the team reviewed the results of diagnostic testing done when STUDENT reentered Burton Thrall. According to the STAR and Wide Ranging Achievement Test, STUDENT was reading at the sixth grade level and his math was at a third grade level. The team also concluded that the past testing (the February 1999 assessment) was too old, and that additional assessments were necessary in order to identify STUDENT’s unique needs and determine if he continued to be eligible for special education. At the meeting, MOTHER also stated that STUDENT had ADHD and was taking Wellbutrin for this condition. The team agreed to continue the interim placement while the assessments were done, drafted a goal in math, and recommended RSP services twice a week for thirty minutes each session (a reduction from the interim placement.)

The first step in developing an appropriate IEP for a student is the identification of the student’s unique needs. In this case, due to the lack of current data, the team determined that additional assessments were needed before it could identify STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer finds that, given the information available to the IEP team, the decision to obtain new assessments was not only reasonable but also necessary. However, this decision was, for STUDENT, too little, too late. If the County had provided STUDENT with an interim placement in a timely manner, and held an IEP meeting within the thirty-day time limit, then the assessments would have been completed by June 10. Furthermore, rather than continue the interim placement pending the assessments, the team actually reduced the level of services. Neither Ms. Eaves, the RSP teacher, nor Ms. Hamlin, the County’s special education supervisor, offered any explanation for the reduction other than Ms. Eaves’ general statement that it was what she felt STUDENT needed. Furthermore, the record shows that even this reduced level of services was not provided. A review of the RSP logs indicates that STUDENT only received a total of 150 minutes of RSP services between June 10 and the next IEP meeting, September 9, 2002. STUDENT should have received over 700 minutes of RSP instruction during this time period.

Because of the delay in holding the IEP team meeting, the unexplained reduction in services, and the failure to provide services in conformity with the IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that the County’s June 10, 2002 IEP was not an offer of FAPE.

Pursuant to the June 10, 2002 assessment plan, did the County assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability?

The law requires that a student be assessed in all areas related to his suspected disability. If appropriate, assessments must include health and development, language function, general ability, academic performance, and social and emotional status. Calif. Educ. Code § 56320(f). Once MOTHER consented to the assessment plan, the County had fifty days to complete the assessments and convene an IEP meeting. Cal Educ. Code § 56043. It is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to determine whether the County’s proposed assessments covered all areas related to STUDENT’s suspected disability because no assessments were done. The County did not conduct any of the proposed assessments under the June 10 plan. Ms. Hamlin stated that she decided to delay the assessments because she was in the process of hiring a new school psychologist. This does not excuse the County’s failure in this case. The Hearing Officer finds that the County failed to assess STUDENT pursuant to the June 10, 2002 assessment plan.

Did the County offer STUDENT a FAPE at the September 9, 2002 IEP meeting?

Again, the first step in developing an appropriate IEP is to identify the student’s unique needs. However, due to the County’s failure to assess STUDENT, the September 9 IEP team was still unable to identify STUDENT’s needs. The team did review STUDENT’s STAR testing and determined that his reading had improved to the ninth grade level and that his math had improved to the forth grade level. Ultimately, the team again recommended assessments, continued the services from the prior IEP, and agreed to reconvene after the assessments had been completed.(Footnote 13) The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team could not have offered STUDENT a FAPE because it could not identify STUDENT’s unique needs due to the County’s failure to assess STUDENT. The Hearing Officer also finds that the team’s conclusion that STUDENT was making progress was not supported by the evidence. The IEP team based its conclusion on STUDENT’s STAR test results. The Hearing Officer finds that these results were too unreliable to support the team’s conclusion. STUDENT had been administered STAR tests repeatedly during his various admissions to Burton Thrall. Looking at the results of these tests shows such a variance that it calls into question the accuracy of any of the test scores. A sample of the results are as follows:

8/23/01 Reading GE (Footnote 14) 7.4 Math GE 5.7 9/6/01 Reading GE 4.5 11/29/01 Reading GE 3.1 Math GE 2.8 2/22/02 Reading GE 7.1 Math GE 4.5 4/26/02 Reading GE 6.1 Math GE 2.2 5/24/02 Reading GE 4.7 6/10/02 Reading GE 6.6 Math GE 3.4 8/7/02 Reading GE 9.3 Math GE 4.3

No evidence was presented to explain the above pattern. Given the highly variable results, even between tests given only weeks apart, the Hearing Officer finds that he can give no weight to the results of the STAR testing.

On the basis of the County’s failure to assess STUDENT, resulting in its inability to identify his unique needs, the Hearing Officer finds that the County failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE at the September 9, 2002 IEP meeting.

Did the County fail to provide STUDENT with his prescribed medication?

Testimony established that, at Juvenile Hall, it was exclusively the responsibility of the Probation Department staff to administer prescribed medication. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County did not have a duty to provide STUDENT with his prescribed medication.

Did the County fail to hold an IEP meeting after removals totaling more than ten days?

The removal of a child with a disability from the child’s current placement for more than ten school days in a school year for any violation of school rules constitutes a change of placement, and requires the educational agency to convene an IEP team meeting. 34 CFR §§ 300.519, 300.520. According to the report cards in the file, STUDENT was suspended on three occasions for a total of six days between February and September 2002. These are the only times that STUDENT was removed from class for violations of school rules. STUDENT did miss approximately fifteen additional days during that time period, but those days were the result of the Probation Department’s disciplinary actions related to problems that occurred on the residential unit. As such, these absences are not covered by the regulations set forth above. Petitioner argues that many of the report cards indicate that STUDENT did not receive full credit for being in class on certain days. Petitioner contends that because STUDENT did not get credit for class work on certain days, the County failed to prove that STUDENT was actually in class on those days. This argument is contrary to the evidence. Testimony established that a check mark on the report card for each given subject on a given day is an indicator of how productive STUDENT was in class on that day, not of his attendance. If STUDENT had been absent, rather than present but not productive, the report card would have indicated his absence with a notation of an absence or a suspension. On the basis of this testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not removed from his placement for more than ten school days in a school year. Therefore, the County did not have a duty to hold an IEP as required by sections 300.519 and 300.520 of the Code of Federal Regulations.

The Hearing Office has found that the County failed to provide STUDENT with a timely interim placement, failed to hold an IEP meeting within thirty days, failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE at the June 10 IEP meeting, failed to assess STUDENT pursuant to the June 10 assessment plan, and failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE at the September 9 IEP meeting. On the basis of these findings, the Hearing Officer finds that the County failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the time period February 22, 2002 through September 30, 2002.

7. January 8, 2003 through the present.

STUDENT’s last day at Burton Thrall was September 30, 2002. STUDENT returned to his mother’s home and enrolled at San Bernardino High School. On October 23, 2002, STUDENT enrolled at the Wilson School, an NPS within the City. The City held an IEP meeting for STUDENT on November 21, 2002. The IEP continued STUDENT’s placement at Wilson. According to MOTHER STUDENT ran away from home while enrolled at Wilson and was eventually picked up and returned to Juvenile Hall. STUDENT re-entered Burton Thrall on January 8, 2003. STUDENT remained at Burton Thrall through the end of the hearing in this matter except for a short period of time from March 14, 2003, through April 4, 2003. During that time, the evidence established that STUDENT attended another school operated by the County. No other evidence was presented relating to this brief placement. Because STUDENT did not leave the County, the County’s duty in relation to STUDENT’s special education program was not affected by this change in placement.

For the time period January 8, 2003 through the present, Petitioner contends that the County failed to provide an appropriate interim placement, failed to hold an IEP meeting within thirty days, failed to assess STUDENT in all areas, failed to offer a FAPE at the February 21, 2003 IEP meeting, failed to provide STUDENT with his prescribed medication, and failed to hold an IEP meeting after removals totaling more than ten days.

Did the County provide an appropriate interim placement?

When STUDENT reentered Burton Thrall on January 8, 2003, his existing IEP was the November 21, 2002 IEP developed by the City. As set forth earlier in this Decision, the County’s duty was to provide STUDENT with an interim placement in conformity with the existing IEP to the extent possible within existing resources. Cal. Educ. Code § 56325. Instead, the County continued to provide services pursuant to the September 9, 2002 IEP. The City’s November 2002 IEP called for placement at a highly structured self-contained NPS with goals in written language and peer interaction. Because STUDENT was incarcerated at Juvenile Hall, the County did not have the option of placing STUDENT at an NPS; therefore, this was not within the County’s resources. However, the County could have provided services to address the written language and peer interaction goals. The County presented no evidence that it did so. The testimony of the RSP teacher established that the only special education services were RSP services in math. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County failed to provide an appropriate interim placement.

Did the County hold a timely IEP meeting?

The County did not hold the IEP meeting until February 21, 2003. This was over forty days after STUDENT’s return to Burton Thrall. Section 56325 requires the IEP meeting to be held within 30 days of the commencement of the interim placement. Although the County’s IEP meeting was not held within 30 days as required by the statute, STUDENT did not suffer any significant prejudice as a result of the relatively brief delay. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County did hold a timely IEP meeting.

Did the County assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability?

As set forth above, the law requires that a student be assessed in all areas related to his suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). The purpose of the assessments is to gather all relevant information, including information provided by the parents, that will assist the IEP team to determine whether the student is a child with a disability and, if so, to provide the team with the information it will need to develop an appropriate individualized education plan. 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (b)(2)(A). Pursuant to the September 9, 2002 assessment plan, the County was to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic achievement, cognitive development, perception/processing/memory, motor development, speech/language, social/emotional/behavioral functioning, self-help, and health. Petitioner contends that the County failed to properly assess STUDENT in the areas of auditory processing, social/emotional/behavioral functioning, and a possible neurological disorder.

Auditory processing

In relation to auditory processing, Petitioner argues that the County’s assessment was not sufficiently comprehensive to provide the IEP team with the information to develop an appropriate IEP. As part of his September 2002 assessment, Mr. Rico addressed STUDENT’s auditory processing. To specifically assess STUDENT’s auditory processing, Mr. Rico administered the WRAML and the LET. On the basis of these tests, Mr. Rico determined that STUDENT did have an auditory processing disorder. In particular, Mr. Rico noted that STUDENT had problems remembering small pieces of information, but was able to grasp the “big picture.” Mr. Rico also noted that STUDENT’s memory for information presented visually was better than his memory for information presented auditorily. Mr. Rico recommended that STUDENT be presented with auditory information in large semantic units (paragraphs and stories), and that auditory information be reinforced visually. Mr. Rico testified that, as a result of the auditory processing disorder, STUDENT had a specific learning disability in the areas of math, reading, and written language. There is no dispute that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder, or that it affects his reading, writing, and math skills. The only other current assessment in this area was performed by Dr. Tommey. Dr. Tommey also concluded that STUDENT’s auditory processing affected his math and his reading/writing skills. Upon review, the Hearing Officer finds that, though using different test instruments, both Mr. Rico and Dr. Tommey came to similar conclusions regarding STUDENT’s auditory processing disorder. Mr. Rico went beyond simply noting the presence of the disorder, but recommended specific strategies to utilize in teaching STUDENT. After reviewing the reports of Mr. Rico and Dr. Tommey, the Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Rico’s assessment did provide the IEP team with sufficient information to determine whether STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder and the information needed to develop an appropriate individualized education plan. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County appropriately assessed STUDENT in the area of auditory processing.

Social/Emotional/Behavioral

Petitioner contends that the County failed to assess STUDENT’s social/emotional functioning because it did not administer tests sufficient to determine if STUDENT was eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed. Again, it was Mr. Rico who assessed STUDENT in relation to his social/emotional needs as part of his September 2002 assessment.

Mr. Rico stated that he evaluated STUDENT’s social/emotional functioning by considering the background information he was given; his interviews with MOTHER, STUDENT’s teachers, probation staff, and Dr. Drieberg (the school psychologist from STUDENT’s elementary school); and by his interview and observation of STUDENT. Mr. Rico concluded that STUDENT had a history of strained personal adjustments with off-task and defiant behavior in the learning environment. Mr. Rico also noted a long-term history of substance abuse. However, Mr. Rico stated that both MOTHER and STUDENT denied depression or any history of depression. Furthermore, Mr. Rico did not observe any behaviors characteristic of depression nor did he receive any reports of symptoms of depression from any of the staff he interviewed. Mr. Rico also observed that STUDENT was able to work well with his teachers and peers when in a structured setting and when working on tasks that were at his ability level. Mr. Rico found that STUDENT’s defiant and disruptive behavior in class was primarily related to difficulties with academic performance and achievement. Mr. Rico also observed a moderately short attention span during the testing process. However, Mr. Rico found that STUDENT could maintain good attention and concentration when working on tasks that STUDENT perceived as being easier. Mr. Rico concluded that STUDENT had behavioral difficulties related to his attention and concentration, but that these were the result of STUDENT’s low frustration level, not to an underlying emotional disturbance. Mr. Rico determined that no additional social/emotional/behavioral assessments were necessary.

Mr. Rico reviewed the criteria for an emotional disturbance under special education law. Under both the IDEA and state law, a child with a disability includes a child with an emotional disturbance (ED). If that child requires special education and related services as a result of this disability, he or she may be eligible for services. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (3)(A). A student has a serious emotional disturbance when he or she exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affects educational performance:

(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

20 U.S.C. § 1401 (3), 34 C.F.R.§ 300.7(c)(4)(i); Tit. 5, Cal. Code Regs. § 3030(i).

Mr. Rico found that the primary cause of STUDENT’s poor educational performance was related to his learning disability, not to an emotional disturbance. He noted that STUDENT was able to build and maintain interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. Mr. Rico based this on his own observations, as well as his interviews with staff, STUDENT, and MOTHER. Mr. Rico concluded that STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors, specifically off-task and defiant behavior, were related to difficulties with academic achievement, not to an underlying emotional disturbance. Mr. Rico found no indications of any current pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression other than what would be the normal unhappiness associated with being incarcerated. Mr. Rico did not find any tendency on STUDENT’s part to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems. On the basis of the foregoing analysis, Mr. Rico concluded that STUDENT did not have an emotional disturbance as defined by the IDEA.

Petitioner bases his disagreement with the adequacy of Mr. Rico’s assessment on two factors: Mr. Rico’s unfamiliarity with STUDENT’s previous assessments, IEPs, and medical reports and the failure of Mr. Rico to perform any formal testing in the social/emotional/behavioral area. Although Mr. Rico had not seen actual prior assessments (other than the 1999 and 2000 assessments) or discipline reports from the City, he did obtain a history from MOTHER, STUDENT, and Dr. Drieberg. The actual information contained in those records, a history of disruptive and defiant behavior, was consistent with Mr. Rico’s understanding of STUDENT’s behavioral history. The only document that was inconsistent with the verbal information Mr. Rico obtained was a hospital admission from 1997 that diagnosed STUDENT as having a depressive disorder. MOTHER had told Mr. Rico that STUDENT did not have any history of depression. Although, on this point, Mr. Rico’s history was inaccurate, the Hearing Officer finds that this inaccuracy did not affect the appropriateness of Mr. Rico’s assessment. The hospital admission in question was five years old at the time of Mr. Rico’s assessment. Furthermore, the 1997 hospital admission is the only document in evidence that was in existence at the time Mr. Rico performed his assessment that mentions depression or a history of depression. Most significantly, none of the teachers or staff from Burton Thrall reported any signs of depression to Mr. Rico.

Mr. Rico testified that he did not do any formal testing in the social/emotional area because he believed that he had obtained sufficient information from his observations and interviews and saw no “red flags” that would warrant additional testing. The Hearing Officer finds Mr. Rico’s testimony and report regarding STUDENT’s social/emotion/behavioral issues to be consistent with the evidence as a whole as well as with the testimony of FATHER, MOTHER, Ms. Murphy (one of STUDENT’s teachers at Burton Thrall), and Ms. Eaves. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Rico has substantial experience in assessing students, as well as assessing students who are incarcerated. On the basis of these factors, the Hearing Officer gives Mr. Rico’s testimony significant weight. The Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Rico’s assessment of STUDENT’s social/emotional/behavioral needs did provide the IEP team with sufficient information to determine whether STUDENT had an emotional disturbance and the information needed to develop an appropriate individualized education plan. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County appropriately assessed STUDENT in the area of his social/emotional/behavioral functioning.

Neurological Disorder

The only evidence of a possible neurological disorder is an abnormal EEG report from September 1994. The report stated that the results were suggestive of an underlying seizure disorder. There is no evidence that this report was acted on by STUDENT’s doctor in 1994 or at any time thereafter. Furthermore, none of the witnesses reported having observed STUDENT exhibiting any seizure activity. On the basis of these facts, the Hearing Officer finds that a neurological disorder was not an area related to STUDENT’s suspected disability and did not require assessment.

On the basis of the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that the County did assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability.

Did the County fail to offer a FAPE at the February 21, 2003 IEP meeting?

Although it has been found that the County did assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability, the County did not offer STUDENT a FAPE at the February 21, 2003 IEP meeting primarily because the IEP meeting was not completed. At the IEP meeting, the team reviewed the assessments and reports from STUDENT’s general education and RSP teachers. Progress on his math goal was discussed. The team also discussed a possible behavior support plan and goals in reading comprehension, math, and writing skills. The possibility of a referral to the Department of Behavioral Health for additional assessments was also raised. Unfortunately, MOTHER had to leave before the meeting could be concluded. The team agreed to continue STUDENT’s math goal from his September 2002 IEP and to increase his RSP services to four times a week for thirty minutes per session. The team also agreed to reconvene to complete the IEP on or before February 28, 2003. This continuation of the IEP meeting never occurred.

Because the IEP was not completed there was no consensus reached as to STUDENT’s unique needs, goals and objectives, or services required to implement the goals and objectives. In fact, no new goals and objectives were drafted. Therefore, the February 2003 IEP failed to identify all of STUDENT’s unique needs or offer services to meet those needs. Therefore, the February 21, 2003 IEP was not an offer of FAPE.

Did the County fail to provide STUDENT with his prescribed medication?

As set forth earlier, the County was not responsible for providing STUDENT with his prescribed medication; that duty lay with the Probation Department. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County did not have a duty to provide STUDENT with prescribed medication.

Did the County fail to hold an IEP meeting after removals totaling more than ten days?

The evidence established that there were no additional removals from school for violations of school rules during this period of time. Therefore, the County did not fail to hold an IEP after removals totaling more than ten days.

The Hearing Officer has found that the County failed to provide STUDENT with an appropriate interim placement, and failed to offer him a FAPE at the February 13, 2003 IEP meeting. On the basis of these findings, the Hearing Officer finds that the County failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the time period January 8, 2003 through the conclusion of the hearing.

8. Is STUDENT eligible for special education under the categories specific learning disabled, emotionally disturbanced, and other health impaired?

Petitioner contends that STUDENT is currently eligible for special education under all three of these categories. Each category will be addressed separately.

Specific Learning Disability

The County does not dispute that STUDENT is currently eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability.

Emotional Disturbance

As set forth earlier, in September 2002, Mr. Rico assessed STUDENT for eligibility for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance. Mr. Rico concluded that STUDENT did not qualify under this category. In May 2003, Dr. Tommey completed a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Tommey concluded that STUDENT did qualify for special education under this category. Dr. Tommey identified STUDENT as having a depressive disorder and a conduct disorder. However, Mr. Rico testified to numerous problems with Dr. Tommey’s assessment in this area. First, Mr. Rico noted that Dr. Tommey relied almost entirely on the results of his testing, and failed to obtain needed information from STUDENT’s teachers, probation staff, or from observations of STUDENT outside of the testing environment. Mr. Rico also stated that Dr. Tommey’s test results were not consistent with the behaviors he observed or the behaviors reported by school and probation staff. Specifically, he stated that STUDENT did not exhibit any significant withdrawal, lethargy or depressed mood. Second, Mr. Rico noted that several of the tests administered indicated that STUDENT was not significantly depressed. Mr. Rico testified that neither the Trauma Symptom Checklist nor the Child Depression Inventory indicated that STUDENT was depressed. He also noted that STUDENT’s answers on the Child Depression Inventory showed significant emotional strength. Mr. Rico testified that the TAT was not an appropriate test for a psychoeducational evaluation. He stated that it is outdated, and the questions are very leading and tend to produce negative responses. Mr. Rico did believe that the Rorschach, because of its open-ended nature, was a more appropriate test. However, on reviewing the protocols, Mr. Rico found that STUDENT’s answers were too short and provided too little information for valid scoring. Mr. Rico also found numerous scoring errors that resulted in Dr. Tommey overestimating the presence or significance of depression. Mr. Rico also noted that Dr. Tommey’s interpretation of the test results tended to ignore the fact that STUDENT had been incarcerated for the last three years. Mr. Rico stated that many of the responses that Dr. Tommey found significant were relatively normal considering STUDENT’s situation. As stated earlier, the Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Rico’s testimony is entitled to significant weight. On the basis of Mr. Rico’s testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Tommey’s conclusion regarding the presence of an emotional disturbance is not supported by the evidence. The Hearing Officer accepts Mr. Rico’s conclusion that, although STUDENT does have significant behavior problems, most are related to social maladjustment and frustration over poor academic performance, not to the presence of an emotional disturbance. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not meet the criteria set forth in regulation 3030(i) for an emotional disturbance. The Hearing Officer notes that this does not necessarily mean that STUDENT is not entitled to services to address social/emotional/behavioral issues. The IDEA requires that the educational agency provide services to address all of a student’s unique needs, not just those needs that directly relate to a student’s qualifying disability.

Other Health Impaired

A pupil qualifies for special education under the category other health impaired (OHI) if, due to an acute or chronic illness, he or she has limited strength, vitality, or alertness that adversely affects his or her educational performance. (C.C.R. § 3030(f).)

Petitioner contends that STUDENT qualifies under this category as a result of his ADHD. It is undisputed that STUDENT has been diagnosed in the past as suffering from ADHD. It is also undisputed that STUDENT continues to exhibit some attention problems. However, his attention problems are not currently limiting his strength, vitality or alertness, nor are they adversely affecting his educational performance. Testimony established that STUDENT’s current attention problems are mild. Dr. Tommey stated that STUDENT was able to attend and concentrate during six straight hours of testing. Mr. Rico also noted that STUDENT was able to attend to tasks when doing work that was within his abilities. It was only during more difficult tasks that STUDENT displayed problems remaining on task. Mr. Rico’s observations were corroborated by the testimony of Ms. Murphy and Ms. Eaves, neither of whom felt that STUDENT had significant issues with attention. Even Dr. Tommey concluded that STUDENT’s attentional problems were more likely the result of his learning disability rather than ADHD. On the basis of this information, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s ADHD is currently not significantly limiting his strength, vitality or alertness, nor is it adversely affecting his educational performance. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not currently qualify for special education under the category of OHI.

9. Did Behavioral Health fail to assess STUDENT pursuant to a May 13, 2003 referral from the County?

On the last day of the hearing in this matter, the parties engaged in settlement discussions outside of the presence of the Hearing Officer. The parties reached a settlement in relation to this issue. The settlement, which was read into the record, is as follows:

San Bernardino County Department of Behavioral Health will, pursuant to Assembly Bill 2726/3632, assess STUDENT and hold an IEP team meeting on or before July 7, 2003 for eligibility for mental health treatment services including outpatient treatment, therapy, wrap around service, day treatment, residential placement, and medication monitoring. San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools will agree to schedule the IEP team meeting within the agreed upon time.

10. Does STUDENT currently require a residential placement?

Petitioner contends that STUDENT requires a residential placement in order to receive a FAPE. The IDEA requires that the local educational agency consider nonpublic, nonsectarian schools when no appropriate public education program is available. Cal. Educ. Code § 56365(a). Therefore, the issue is whether STUDENT requires a residential placement in order to receive a FAPE.

As a recap, in order to provide a FAPE, the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley require that the proposed educational program must 1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, 2) provide for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, 3) be calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, and 4) conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176. An additional component of FAPE is that it must provide the student with the opportunity to be educated and participate with nondisabled students to the maximum extent possible (often referred to as least restrictive environment or LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.

The first step on the analysis is to identify STUDENT’s unique needs. On the basis of Mr. Rico’s assessment, STUDENT needs academic assistance in math, reading comprehension, and written language. Due to his auditory processing disorder, STUDENT will need all auditory information presented with visual reinforcement. Mr. Rico also noted that STUDENT performs best in a structured setting. STUDENT will also need services to address his impaired social interaction skills, family issues and substance abuse issues.

Dr. Tommey also identified depression as an area of need. The Hearing Officer has already found that the evidence does not support Dr. Tommey in this conclusion. However, the Hearing Officer does find that STUDENT will need behavioral supports to address his disruptive and defiant behaviors. The Burton Thrall staff all testified that they did not believe this was an area of educational need because STUDENT had demonstrated the ability to control his behavior in the classroom setting. The staff testified that STUDENT’s behavior problems primarily occurred in the residential unit. However, in the case of a pupil whose behavior impedes his or her learning or that of others, the law requires that the IEP contain strategies, including positive behavioral interventions and supports to address that behavior. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1. STUDENT has a long history of disruptive and defiant behavior in the school setting. Since March 2002 STUDENT has been suspended for six days. More significantly, STUDENT has missed at least an additional fifteen days of class due to behavior problems in the residential unit. Although STUDENT’s behaviors are primarily occurring in the residential setting, the result has been that he has missed a significant amount of school; therefore, STUDENT’s behavior problems have been impeding his education. More recently, STUDENT has been moved to the maximum-security residential unit. This is an indication that STUDENT’s behavior problems are increasing.

STUDENT also requires transition services. The term "transition services" means a coordinated set of activities for an individual with exceptional needs that does the following:

(1) Is designed within an outcome-oriented process, that promotes movement from school to post school activities, including postsecondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, including supported employment, continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living, or community participation. (2) Is based upon the individual pupil's needs, taking into account the pupil's preferences and interests. (3) Includes instruction, related services, community experiences, the development of employment and other post school adult living objectives, and, when appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and functional vocational evaluation. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1

The law requires that, beginning at age sixteen or younger, a statement of needed transition services be included in the pupil’s individualized education program, including whenever appropriate, a statement of interagency responsibilities or any needed linkages. Id. STUDENT is currently seventeen years old. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that one of STUDENT’s needs is for transition services.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs academic assistance in math, reading comprehension, and written language. Instruction should be done in a structured classroom setting. STUDENT will need all auditory information presented with visual reinforcement. STUDENT will also need services to address his impaired social interaction skills, family issues and substance abuse issues. In addition, STUDENT needs positive behavioral interventions and supports to address his defiant and disruptive behaviors. Finally, STUDENT needs transition services to help him transition from school to post school activities.

Mr. Rico testified that STUDENT’s academic needs could be met with a combination of a structured general education classroom and maximum RSP services. The testimony of Ms. Murphy and Ms. Eaves supports Mr. Rico’s opinion. Ms. Murphy testified that, although there were some behavior problems, STUDENT was able to participate and progress in her general education class. Ms. Eaves also testified that STUDENT has made progress on his math goal with the assistance of RSP services. On the basis of this testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that an educational placement that combines a structured general education classroom with maximum RSP services in reading comprehension, written language and math is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

Only Dr. Tommey offered an opinion as to the kinds of services that would be appropriate to address STUDENT’s impaired social interaction skills, family issues and substance abuse issues. Dr. Tommey recommended a combination of individual, group and family counseling as well as a twelve-step substance abuse program. The Hearing Officer accepts Dr. Tommey’s uncontradicted testimony on this issue. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT will need a combination of family, group and individual counseling to address his social interaction skills, and family issues. STUDENT will also need to be involved in a twelve-step program to address his history of substance abuse.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s placement will need to consist of a structured general education classroom; RSP services in reading comprehension, writing, and math; individual, group, and family counseling; a twelve step substance abuse program; a behavior support plan; and a transition plan. The Hearing Officer finds that none of the services listed above require a residential placement. As stated earlier, LRE requires that a student be educated and allowed to participate with nondisabled students to the maximum extent possible. A residential placement is one of the most restrictive placements possible and allows little to no participation with non-disabled students. STUDENT does not require such a placement. A placement in a regular high school setting with the services described above will meet STUDENT’s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require a residential placement.

Although STUDENT does not require a residential placement, he is entitled to a FAPE. It has already been found that the County’s current offer of placement does not constitute a FAPE. Therefore, the County must convene a new IEP team meeting and offer a program that provides for the services set forth in this section: a structured general education classroom; RSP services in reading comprehension, writing, and math; individual, group, and family counseling; a twelve step substance abuse program; a behavior support plan; and a transition plan. Mr. Rico stated that STUDENT needs “maximum” RSP services. Considering STUDENT’s other needs, including counseling and transition services, the Hearing Officer finds that “maximum” RSP amounts to two periods (fifty minutes each) a day of RSP services to address STUDENT’s academic needs in reading, writing, and math. The Hearing Officer notes that Behavior Health has agreed to conduct an assessment of STUDENT. The amount of weekly and daily counseling to address his social interaction and family issues shall be determined based upon the results of that assessment. The IEP team shall determine the transition plan based upon the criteria set forth in the statute.

11. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is "appropriate" in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington also have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497.

It has already been determined that both Banning and the County failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any of the time periods at issue in this case. With the exception of the RSP services in math, which the County has provided, STUDENT’s unique needs have gone unmet. He has received no special education services in relation to reading comprehension or writing skills. As a result, STUDENT’s academic skills have shown little improvement. According the Dr. Tommey’s and Dr. Rico’s testing, STUDENT’s math and reading skills are at the fourth to fifth grade level. His writing skills were tested to be at the sixth grade level by Ms. Eaves, and Ms. Murphy testified that STUDENT’s grammar skills were poor, he did not know proper punctuation, did not know correct capitalization, and could not identify the parts of sentences such as subjects and verbs. Furthermore, STUDENT has received no counseling to improve his peer interaction or family relations. STUDENT’s defiant and disruptive behaviors continue to be a problem for him, resulting in his recent transfer to the high security unit at Juvenile Hall. In addition, STUDENT has received no transition services. These facts establish that STUDENT needs and is entitled to compensatory education in the areas of academics, peer interactions, family relations, behavior management, and transition services.

However, there are practical limits to the amount of additional instruction, counseling, and transition services that STUDENT is likely to tolerate. Although STUDENT has stated that he wishes to graduate from high school with a regular high school diploma (as opposed to a GED), the Hearing Officer finds that it is not reasonable to expect that STUDENT will willingly participate in a program that requires him to spend a significant amount of after-school hours getting extra instruction. Based upon STUDENT’s age, aspirations, and educational history, the Hearing Officer finds that the maximum after-school time for compensatory education is forty-five minutes a day or 225 minutes a week. Both Dr. Tommey and Dr. Rico concluded that STUDENT’s most significant need is in academics; therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT shall receive one hundred and thirty-five minutes a week of individual academic instruction after school in the areas of reading comprehension, writing, and math. The remaining ninety minutes a week shall be divided equally between counseling and transition services. Because of the extended amount of time that STUDENT has been denied a FAPE, the Hearing Officer finds that these compensatory education services shall continue for two school years or eighteen months.

Because the County was responsible for STUDENT’s education for a significantly longer time than was Banning, the Hearing Officer finds that it would be inequitable to divide the cost of the compensatory education evenly between them. The Hearing Officer finds that the cost shall be divided based upon each agency’s proportional share of the time at issue in this hearing. After examining the number of school days each agency was responsible for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that the County shall bear 86% of the cost of the compensatory education and Banning shall bear the remaining 14% of the cost.

CONCLUSION

For the time periods July 13, 2000 through September 21, 2000 and December 15, 2000 through February 8, 2001, the County failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE by failing to identify him as a student with an existing IEP and failing provide him with an interim placement in conformity with his existing IEP. Furthermore, the County failed to provide STUDENT with any special education services during these periods of time.

For the time period February 13, 2001 through May 31, 2001, Banning failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with an interim placement in conformity with his existing IEP. Banning also failed to properly determine whether or not STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education services at the May 7, 2001 IEP team meeting, and failed to offer him a FAPE thereafter.

For the time periods August 22, 2001 through September 19, 2001 and November 29, 2001 through January 7, 2002, the County failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE by failing to identify him as a student with an existing IEP and failing to provide him with an interim placement in conformity with his existing IEP. Furthermore, the County failed to provide STUDENT with any special education services during these periods of time.

For the time period February 22, 2002 through September 30, 2002 the County failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with a timely interim placement, failing to hold a timely IEP team meeting, and failing to assess him pursuant to the June 10, 2002 assess plan. The County also failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE at the June 10, 2002 and September 9, 2002 IEP team meetings.

For the time period January 8, 2003 through the present, the County failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide STUDENT with an interim placement in conformity with his existing IEP and failing to offer him a FAPE at the February 13, 2003 IEP team meeting. However, the County did assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability.

The Hearing Officer also determined that STUDENT is currently eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability. However, STUDENT is not eligible under the categories for emotional disturbance and other health impaired.

Although STUDENT is currently eligible for special education and related services, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT does not require a residential placement in order to receive a FAPE. In order to receive a FAPE, STUDENT will require a placement that consists of a structured general education classroom; two periods a day of RSP services in reading comprehension, writing, and math; individual, group, and family counseling; a twelve step substance abuse program; a behavior support plan; and a transition plan.

As a result of the County’s and Banning’s failures to offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the time periods at issue in this case, STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education. Compensatory education shall include one hundred and thirty-five minutes a week of individual academic instruction after school in the areas of reading comprehension, writing, and math. STUDENT shall also receive an additional ninety minutes a week of compensatory counseling and transition services. Because of the extended amount of time that STUDENT has been denied a FAPE, these compensatory education services shall continue for two school years or eighteen months. The County shall bear 86% of the cost of the compensatory education and Banning shall bear the remaining 14% of the cost.

ORDER

1. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this Decision, the County shall convene an IEP team meeting. At this meeting the IEP team shall develop a program for STUDENT that includes, at a minimum, placement in a structured general education classroom; two periods (fifty minutes each) a day of RSP services in reading comprehension, writing, and math. STUDENT shall also receive individual, group, and family counseling to address his social interaction and family issues. The amount and timing of these services shall be based upon the recommendations of Behavioral Health. The team shall also develop a behavior support plan to address STUDENT’s disruptive and defiant behaviors. In addition, the IEP team shall develop a transition plan for STUDENT based upon the statutory criteria. STUDENT shall also be enrolled in a twelve-step substance abuse program.

2. At the IEP team meeting described above, the IEP team shall develop a plan for providing STUDENT with compensatory education. STUDENT shall receive one hundred and thirty-five minutes a week of individual academic instruction after school in the areas of reading comprehension, writing, and math. STUDENT shall also receive an additional forty-five minutes a week of counseling to address his peer interaction and family issues. Furthermore, STUDENT shall receive forty-five minutes a week of compensatory transition services. All of these compensatory services are to be provided in addition to the services required to provide STUDENT with a FAPE. These compensatory services shall continue for two school years or eighteen months.

3. The cost of the compensatory education shall be split between the County and Banning. The County shall bear 86% of the cost and Banning shall bear 14% of the cost.

4. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

1. For the time period July 13, 2000 through September 21, 2000, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

2. For the time period December 15, 2000 through February 8, 2001, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

3. For the time period February 13, 2001 through May 31, 2001, did Banning fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

4. For the time period August 22, 2001 through September 19, 2001, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

5. For the time period November 29, 2001 through January 7, 2002, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

6. For the time period February 22, 2002 through September 30, 2002, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

7. For the time period January 8, 2003 through the present, did the County fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

8. Is STUDENT eligible for special education under the categories specific learning disabled, emotionally disturbanced, and other health impaired?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue only to the extent that Petitioner is eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability.

9. Did Behavioral Health fail to assess STUDENT pursuant to a May 13, 2003 referral from the County?

No party prevailed on this issue.

10. Does STUDENT currently require a residential placement?

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

11. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: July 25, 2003 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1.For purposes of clarification and organization, the Hearing Officer has revised the parties’ statements of the issues. These revisions only affect the organization of the Decision and not the substantive analysis. 2. The Hearing Officer interpreted this to mean that the IEP team did not find a significant discrepancy between STUDENT’s academic ability and his academic achievement. 3. No evidence was presented at the hearing regarding the factual basis for STUDENT’s arrest and incarceration. 4. There was no evidence present regarding STUDENT’s status for the time from May 31, 2001 through August 23, 2001. It was also stipulated that there were no issues regarding this time period. 5. STUDENT was also given the MMPI to complete, but the completed test was never returned to Dr. Tommey. 6. On every example contained in the record STUDENT answered that he had previously received special education. 7. From September 2000 through December 2000 STUDENT attended the Kelly School within Imperial County. The evidence established that the Kelly School did provide STUDENT with an interim placement; however, there was no evidence that it developed a new IEP. 8. It should be noted that Banning did not have an option to place STUDENT at a school other that Whitewater. STUDENT had been placed at the Trinity-Whitewater residential facility by the Probation Department. As part of that placement, STUDENT was required to attend the on-site school, Whitewater. 9. Dr. Easler, the school psychologist in attendance at the IEP, testified that he believed he had also seen the May 17, 2000 manifestation determination prior to the IEP meeting, but this document is not referenced in the IEP itself. 10. MOTHER testified that she did not assign her educational rights to anybody, but admitted that it was her signature on the assignment in evidence. 11. The County does state that it finally became aware that STUDENT had an existing IEP on January 7, 2002, the last day of his attendance during this time period. 12. This is true without even taking into account the County’s repeated past failures to implement an interim placement. 13. STUDENT’s last day at Burton Thrall was September 30, 2002. STUDENT’s departure prevented the County from completing the assessments and convening an IEP meeting. 14. GE stands for “grade equivalent”