California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 3, 1995

Student v. Fremont Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 412-95 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson

Fremont Unified barred from expelling a student with a learning disability because his special day class placement was inappropriate.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Footnote 1: the Hearing Officer resolved separate stay put issues by an order issued September 12, 1995, before the hearing concluded. An issue about assigning a security aide was also identified, but the decision does not resolve it.

Summary

A 17-year-old student with a specific learning disability at American High School requested a hearing after Fremont Unified School District recommended him for expulsion. The recommendation followed an April 1995 fight that began when other students directed racial slurs at him. He attended special day classes for core subjects. Under the Education Code section 48915.5 then in effect, the district could not expel him if the misconduct was caused by his disability or if he was not appropriately placed when it happened.

The Hearing Officer found the district committed several procedural violations. One IEP meeting was held at the home without an administrator present. Another was held with only same-day phone notice to the parent. The pre-expulsion assessment by school psychologist Dennis Devine was admittedly incomplete. On the first issue, the district prevailed. Applying Doe v. Maher, the Hearing Officer found that frustration or low self-esteem linked to a disability creates only an attenuated connection to misconduct. The Hearing Officer also found the evidence did not show an expressive language disability.

On the second issue, the student prevailed. His Woodcock-Johnson scores stayed flat or dropped over three years. His IEP had only two thin academic goals, and his program never changed. The district skipped his overdue triennial reassessment. He therefore was not receiving educational benefit. The district was barred from starting expulsion proceedings over the incident.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled the pre-1997 "appropriately placed" test in expulsion cases. The Hearing Officer found no link between the disability and the misconduct. Even so, years of flat test scores, thin goals and a skipped triennial assessment were enough to block expulsion.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 1. Was Student's alleged misconduct on April 11, 1995, a direct manifestation of, or caused by his disability?

    Applying Doe v. Maher, the Hearing Officer found the conduct, provoked by racial epithets, bore only an attenuated relationship to the learning disability; frustration or low self-esteem does not create a direct link, and no expressive language disability was shown.

  2. Student prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 2. Was Student appropriately placed at the time of the alleged misconduct?

    Student was not appropriately placed: achievement scores stayed flat or fell over three years, the IEP had only two thin academic goals, the program never changed, and the overdue triennial assessment was skipped, so he received no educational benefit under Rowley.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Fremont Unified School District is barred from starting expulsion proceedings against Student for the April 11, 1995 incident.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Doe v. Maher, 793 F.2d 1470 (9th Cir. 1986); Board of Education v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982); Education Code § 48915.5; Education Code § 56320; Education Code § 56381; Education Code § 56341(b); 34 C.F.R. § 300.504; 34 C.F.R. § 104.35

People named in the decision

  • Claire Hintergardt, program specialist, Fremont Unified School District
  • Deedra Josserand, assistant director, special services, Fremont Unified School District
  • Janice Brown, special day class teacher (history and math), American High School
  • Christine Nandi, special day class English teacher, American High School
  • Dorothy Davis, assistant principal, American High School
  • Dennis Devine, school psychologist (pre-expulsion/triennial assessor), Fremont Unified School District
  • Bianca Hirsch, private psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Private practice

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Fremont, California, on August 2, 3, 24, 25, and September 28, 1995.

Petitioner STUDENT was present for portions of the hearing and was represented by attorney Darryl Hamm. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Fremont Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Bridget Flanagan. Also present on behalf of the District were Claire Hintergardt, program specialist, and Deedra Josserand, assistant director, special services.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the parties agreed to submit their closing arguments in written form. Those briefs were received by the Hearing Office on October 16, 1995. The record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

(1) Was STUDENT's alleged misconduct on April 11, 1995, a direct manifestation of, or caused by his disability?

(2) Was STUDENT appropriately placed at the time of the alleged misconduct?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a 17-year-old senior at American High School eligible for special education services as a result of a specific learning disability. STUDENT's placement at Fremont for the past three years has consisted of special day classes for his core subjects and mainstreaming in regular education classes for his electives.

On April 11, 1995, STUDENT was involved in a racial incident at American High School. Several Hispanic students referred to STUDENT with a racial epithet, and he confronted them. A fight involving several students ensued, although the exact cause of the incident is unclear. It is unclear also what STUDENT's involvement was in the incident. Testimony regarding STUDENT's involvement ranged from "he didn't do anything" to "he pushed a Hispanic student." STUDENT was stabbed by a Hispanic male who was not a student at American High School. The District's "Notice of Pupil Suspension" dated April 26, 1995, states:

On 4/11/95 between classes 3 & 4 STUDENT approached a group of Hispanic students. He asked them why they were name calling. Two students pulled STUDENT away before any exchange. Again, lunch STUDENT approached Hispanic students where he allegedly pushed a Hispanic & a fight ensued where STUDENT was stabbed by a non-student.

This incident was part of an escalating conflict between Hispanic and African-American students at American High School in which students from one group or the other would "stare-down" students in the other group. In addition, students from one group or the other would call students in the other group racial names. The District has recommended STUDENT for expulsion for his involvement in the incident of April 11, 1995.

Grades and Test Scores

Each year, prior to development of STUDENT's individualized education plan, his achievement level was assessed with the Woodcock-Johnson. Those scores for his three years at Fremont are as follows:

June 1, 1993

Reading Math Grade Equivalent: 5.4 Grade Equivalent: 4.9 Percentile: 19 Percentile: 5

Written Language General Knowledge Grade Equivalent: 6.6 Grade Equivalent: 8.2 Percentile: 25 Percentile: 43

March 18, 1994

Reading Math Grade Equivalent: 5.5 Grade Equivalent: 6.0

Written Language General Knowledge Grade Equivalent: 6.6 Grade Equivalent: 7.0

April 13, 1995

Reading Math Grade Equivalent: 5.6 Grade Equivalent: 5.0 Standard Score: 81 Standard Score: 71 Percentile: 11 Percentile: 3

Written Language General Knowledge Grade Equivalent: 3.2 Grade Equivalent: 6.1 Standard Score: 59 Standard Score: 81 Percentile: .03 Percentile: 14

STUDENT's grades in his core subjects during the ninth, tenth, and eleventh grades were as follows:

Ninth Grade Tenth Grade Eleventh Grade

Math Math Math 1st Semester: B 1st Semester: A 1st Semester: B 2nd Semester: F 2nd Semester: B 2nd Semester: B

Science Science U.S. History 1st Semester: B 1st Semester: B 1st Semester: D 2nd Semester: C 2nd Semester: C 2nd Semester: D

English English English 1st Semester: D 1st Semester: C 1st Semester: D 2nd Semester: C 2nd Semester: C 2nd Semester: D

Geography World History 2nd Semester: C 1st Semester: C 2nd Semester: C

Summer School Grades

Summer 1993 Summer 1995

Math: B Math: B Science: B English: A

In addition, STUDENT received an F for both semesters of his "Wood" class in ninth grade, a D in the 1st semester of Crafts and a C in the 2nd semester of Crafts in the tenth grade, and a D for both semesters for both semesters of his Calligraphy class in eleventh grade.

Assessments and IEPs

The District completed a triennial assessment of STUDENT on March 5, 1992. At that time, STUDENT was in the eighth grade at Thornton Middle School in Fremont Unified School District.(Footnote 2) The results of the assessment were that STUDENT had deficits in visual-motor integration and visual and auditory processing. Following the assessment, an IEP team was convened and an IEP was developed on March 12, 1992. The IEP included the following goals and objectives:

(1) Improve reading (a) STUDENT will decode words in core class English & literature class with 80% accuracy. (b) STUDENT will read passages in the core curriculum and answer comprehension questions with 80% accuracy. (2) Improve writing (a) STUDENT will write 3-4 paragraph themes with correct spelling, grammar, and mechanics at the mid-eighth grade level with 75% accuracy. (3) Improve math (a) Review +, -, x, and division of whole numbers, fractions and decimals with 80% accuracy. (b) Solve 2- and 3-step word problems requiring +, -, x and division with 75% accuracy. (c) Solve simple algebraic problems with 75% accuracy.

On June 1, 1993, staff at American High School convened an IEP team developed STUDENT's IEP for ninth grade. In that IEP, STUDENT's academic goals and objectives were as follows:

(1) Math -- By June, 1994, STUDENT will respond to teacher's and/or aide's assistance to enable him to master borrowing in subtraction with 80% accuracy. (2) Social Studies -- By June, 1994, STUDENT will turn in 75% of homework, 85% of the time. (3) Science -- By June, 1994, STUDENT will understand the steps of the scientific method and be able to name two functions or more of six or more systems of the human body with 80% accuracy.

On March 18, 1994, STUDENT's IEP for tenth grade was developed. His academic goals and objectives in that IEP were as follows:

(1) By March, 1995, STUDENT will complete Book Five of the Math Competency Library Series with scores of 80% or above. (2) By March, 1995, STUDENT will write a business letter correctly using headings, greeting, body of letter and closing with a score of 80% or above.

Both IEPs from June 1993 and March 1994 also included behavior goals and, in March 1994, a vocational goal and transition plan were added to STUDENT's IEP.

Because the last triennial assessment was completed on March 5, 1992, STUDENT's next triennial assessment was due in March 1995. However, at that time, a triennial assessment was not completed and the only testing done was the Woodcock-Johnson.

Two days following the racial incident, on April 13, 1995, STUDENT's special day class teacher, Janice Brown, came to his home to develop a new IEP. Present at the IEP meeting were Ms. Brown and STUDENT's mother, MOTHER. Ms. Brown and MOTHER agreed to continue with the same educational program for STUDENT. Following the meeting, Ms. Brown took the IEP back to school and had Dorothy Davis, assistant principal at American High School, approve and sign the IEP.

By the end of April, STUDENT was suspended and recommended for expulsion for his involvement in the racial incident on April 11, 1995. On May 1, 1995, another IEP meeting was held. MOTHER was not present and did not receive written notice of the meeting. The IEP team recommended home instruction for five hours per week pending completion of the expulsion procedures. Following completion of the IEP meeting, Ms. Brown took the IEP to STUDENT's home and asked his mother to sign it. MOTHER refused to sign the IEP. At this time, Ms. Brown also provided MOTHER with written notice of a pre-expulsion IEP meeting that was scheduled to take place on May 8, 1995.

On May 8, 1995, MOTHER brought STUDENT to school in order to be assessed by Dennis Devine, school psychologist. Mr. Devine completed a "triennial/pre-expulsion" assessment. Mr. Devine's assessment results were that STUDENT has a weakness in visual-motor integration. Mr. Devine also noted some problems with internalizing and externalizing problems, but Mr. Devine attributed these problems to STUDENT's recent suspension.

Shortly after Mr. Devine completed his assessment, an IEP meeting was convened at which time the IEP team concluded that STUDENT's misconduct was not a direct manifestation of, or caused by, his disability, and that he was appropriately placed at the time of the misconduct.

On July 7, 1995, Dr. Bianca Hirsch completed an assessment of STUDENT at his mother's request. The "Summary and Conclusions" section of Dr. Hirsch's report indicates that STUDENT has dyslexia and is functioning at the fourth to seventh grade level in all academic areas. Furthermore, it states that his cognitive abilities are within the borderline to low average range when visual material is presented and that he has difficulties expressing his ideas clearly. Dr. Hirsch also indicates that STUDENT has a "great deal of difficulty" expressing his ideas in writing when material is presented to him orally. Dr. Hirsch found that STUDENT's specific learning disability is in visual motor integration. Dr. Hirsch states that STUDENT's "alleged misconduct can, in part, be attributed to frustration and a lack of guided direction toward realistic, relevant plans for a future career."

Dr. Hirsch made numerous recommendations at the conclusion of her report. Among these recommendations, are the following:

(1) Placement in a Resource Specialist Program.

(2) AB 3632 counseling.

(3) Vocational counseling.

(4) Speech and language evaluation.

(5) Work on structure, organizational skills, and study habits. 6) Electives that do not focus on visual motor skills, since that is his area of weakness and could lead to greater frustration.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

WITNESSES FOR PETITIONER

MOTHER

MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified extensively regarding STUDENT's school history. MOTHER testified that STUDENT enjoyed school and did well at Thornton Middle School. MOTHER testified that the staff at Thornton were committed to providing STUDENT with the level of services he requires. MOTHER testified that the staff at American High School hasn't been as willing to provide assistance to STUDENT. As an example, MOTHER testified that STUDENT still has problems expressing himself, but nobody at American has recommended speech and language services for him.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT's primary weaknesses are in the areas of expression and memory. MOTHER testified that for STUDENT to be able to do something, he has to be told how to do it and then shown how to do it. Regarding STUDENT's ability to express himself, MOTHER testified that when he gets frustrated he cannot express himself and becomes quiet and withdrawn. MOTHER also testified that she has recently been diagnosed with dyslexia.

According to MOTHER, the only complaints she received regarding STUDENT's behavior during the ninth and tenth grades were related to his talking too much in class or being late to class. MOTHER testified that these problems increased during the tenth grade. MOTHER testified that Ms. Brown, one of STUDENT's special day class teachers, noticed a change in his behavior during the eleventh grade. MOTHER met with Ms. Brown and Ms. Nandi, STUDENT's English special day class teacher, and STUDENT's behavior improved for awhile. MOTHER testified that nobody recommended counselling, behavior management plans, or behavior contracts to improve STUDENT's behavior problems.

MOTHER testified that most of STUDENT's behavior problems were in Ms. Nandi's class. MOTHER attributed the problems to a personality clash between STUDENT and Ms. Nandi. MOTHER testified that STUDENT told her that Ms. Nandi picks on him. MOTHER testified that STUDENT does not have behavior problems with any of his other teachers. MOTHER testified that, other than the one meeting with Ms. Brown and Ms. Nandi, she never had an opportunity to discuss STUDENT's behavior problems with Ms. Nandi.

MOTHER was present during the assessment conducted on May 8, 1995. MOTHER testified that the assessment lasted for approximately 45 minutes and that there was very little conversation between STUDENT and Mr. Devine. MOTHER also testified that Mr. Devine did not ask for any background information regarding STUDENT. MOTHER testified that she came back to the school an hour or two after the assessment was completed to attend the pre-expulsion IEP meeting.

MOTHER testified that the IEP form was already filled out when she came to the IEP meeting on May 8, 1995, and that she did not have a real opportunity to provide input. MOTHER testified that she felt the IEP on May 8, 1995, was just a formality and that STUDENT was going to be expelled. MOTHER testified that the IEP team did not discuss STUDENT's alleged misconduct.

STUDENT

STUDENT also testified regarding his school history. According to STUDENT, his behavior problems with Ms. Nandi result from her inability to explain things to the class. STUDENT testified that he felt "stuck" in the class because he did not know what he was doing. STUDENT testified that he could do the classwork but that he needed someone to explain it to him. He testified that a lot of the times he got in trouble it was because he was asking another student for help because he could not understand Ms. Nandi.

STUDENT testified that Ms. Nandi had the students do essays almost every day. In addition, the students worked on "job packets," which are designed to prepare students for jobs by having them practice filling out applications and writing thank you notes. STUDENT testified that the only books he read in the English class were To Kill A Mockingbird and Death of a Salesman.

Regarding the assessment on May 8, 1995, STUDENT testified that he had never met Mr. Devine before the assessment. The only testing that STUDENT recalled involved drawing things and reciting words to test his recall. STUDENT testified that the IEP team discussed the test results and whether or not he was appropriately placed, but that the IEP team did not discuss his alleged misconduct.

Janice Brown

Janice Brown was STUDENT's History and Math special day class teacher during the eleventh grade. Ms. Brown also taught STUDENT during the tenth grade. Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT was a lot of fun during the tenth grade and had only a few behavior problems. During the eleventh grade, STUDENT did not have any significant behavior problems in Ms. Brown's class other than that he became more quiet and withdrawn. Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT also was not applying himself as much and was not getting as much homework done as he had in the past.

Ms. Brown testified that she frequently discussed STUDENT with his mother and that she was always responsive. Ms. Brown testified that she set up a conference during the fall of eleventh grade to discuss STUDENT with his mother and Ms. Nandi. Ms. Brown testified that following the conference, STUDENT's behavior improved somewhat.

Regarding speech and language, Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT was never offered services by American. Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT's communication problems were not severe enough to warrant speech and language services. Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT uses full sentences when he answers questions in class, is able to give oral reports, and is able to communicate his thoughts to other students during group discussions.

Ms. Brown testified that she utilizes a hands-on approach with auditory and visual reinforcement to teach STUDENT. Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT appears to benefit from visual aids and that she uses a lot of visual demonstrations, including videotapes, overheads, and computers. She also incorporates a lot of practical exercises, such as simulating the purchase of a car.

Ms. Brown's math instructional materials are the Math Competency Library Series. In March 1994, the IEP team established a goal for STUDENT that he complete Book Five in the series. Ms. Brown testified that by March 1995, STUDENT had just started Book Four.

Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT is on track to graduate with his class at the end of the 1995-96 school year. During summer school in 1995, STUDENT received an A in English and a B in Math. Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT did well in summer school because there is no homework in summer school and he receives more assistance than during the regular school year.

Ms. Brown testified that the drop in STUDENT's written language scores from March 1994 to April 1995 were a result of a change in the Woodcock-Johnson. The April 1995 scores are based on a version of the test different from the one administered in 1994. According to Ms. Brown, the version administered in 1995 includes a more difficult written language test. Ms. Brown testified that all of the students to whom she administered the new version exhibited a similar decline in scores. Regarding STUDENT's specific score, Ms. Brown testified that he has trouble putting his thoughts on paper with correct spelling and form. Ms. Brown testified that the score for written language on the April 1995 Woodcock-Johnson most accurately reflects STUDENT's writing ability. Regarding STUDENT's math score on the Woodcock-Johnson, Ms. Brown testified that the score in April 1995 indicated that STUDENT did not learn any new skills during the 1994-95 school year, and actually missed problems he had right when he took the test in March 1994.

Ms. Brown testified that a complete triennial assessment was not completed in March 1995 because the school psychologist told her that the District does not conduct triennial assessments for students who are in their last semester of eleventh grade or in twelfth grade. Regarding the assessment on May 8, 1995, Ms. Brown testified that she talked with Mr. Devine about MOTHER's desire to be present during the assessment. However, Ms. Brown did not recall discussing STUDENT with Mr. Devine. Ms. Brown also testified that she did not recall the IEP team discussing STUDENT's alleged misconduct other than that Dorothy Davis, assistant principal, stated that STUDENT was one of the instigators of the incident.

Ms. Brown testified that she filled out page 2 of the IEP -- present levels of educational performance -- before the meeting and that the goals and objectives were also prepared ahead of time. Ms. Brown testified that the goals and objectives could be modified as necessary during the IEP meeting. The goals and objectives included in the IEP dated May 8, 1995, are similar to those included in the IEP dated April 13, 1995, and agreed to by MOTHER.

Finally, Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT is appropriately placed. According to Ms. Brown, STUDENT cannot function in a regular education class or resource specialist program because of his disabilities and he does not need a more restrictive setting. Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT should be able to pass his classes in his current program with C's or above. Ms. Brown also believes that STUDENT's alleged misconduct was not caused by his disabilities. Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT's unique needs include small-group instructions and the ability to proceed at his own pace.

Bianca Hirsch

Bianca Hirsch is a retired school psychologist who is now in private practice. Dr. Hirsch conducted an assessment of STUDENT at the University of California, San Francisco, on July 7, 1995. Prior to assessing STUDENT, Dr. Hirsch discussed him with MOTHER to determine what was going on and what issues to look into. In addition, MOTHER completed a Behavioral Dimensions Rating Scale. Dr. Hirsch assessed STUDENT in the areas of intellectual level, visual-motor, auditory and visual memory, emotional status, and dyslexia. Dr. Hirsch's assessment did not include a classroom observation, teacher interviews, or a review of any school documents other than STUDENT's IEPs. Dr. Hirsch's conclusions were drawn entirely from her observations during the assessment, the results of the assessment, and her review of STUDENT's IEPs.

To assess STUDENT's intellectual level, Dr. Hirsch used the Matrix Analogies Test (MAT), a visual cognitive test that assess reasoning skills.(Footnote 3) Dr. Hirsch testified that STUDENT is a slow to below-average learner but that he has more potential than he has shown.

Dr. Hirsch also administered the Wide Range Achievement Test-3 (WRAT). The results from the WRAT indicated that STUDENT is not close to grade level in any area. Dr. Hirsch testified that the fact that STUDENT achievement scores remained the same for three years should raise the following questions to be answered: is the program effective, what are his weaknesses, why is he misbehaving, and why is he not making any progress? Dr. Hirsch testified that a program is not appropriate if the student is not making progress. Dr. Hirsch also testified that if STUDENT's reading level is at the fifth grade level, his reading materials should also be at the fifth grade level.

To assess visual-motor skills, Dr. Hirsch administered the Bender Gestalt Test of Visual Motor Integration (Bender).(Footnote 4) Dr. Hirsch testified that the results from the Bender indicated a serious delay in visual-motor skills because STUDENT's drawings were immature. Furthermore, STUDENT was not able to complete all of the drawings which indicated impaired visual memory. Dr. Hirsch testified that the STUDENT's IEP does not include any specific steps to address STUDENT's visual-motor integration weakness. Dr. Hirsch testified that dyslexia should have been assessed by the District because of how poor his visual-motor integration skills are.

To assess visual perceptual skills, Dr. Hirsch administered the Jordan Left Right Reversal Test (Jordan). Dr. Hirsch testified that the results from the Jordan, including word reversals in sentences and letter reversals in words, provide evidence that STUDENT has dyslexic-like symptoms. However, Dr. Hirsch was not willing to diagnose dyslexia. Dr. Hirsch testified that there is nothing in STUDENT's 1994 and 1995 IEPs which address dyslexia. Dr. Hirsch testified that without remediation, dyslexia can be a long-standing problem that will affect a student socially, emotionally, and behaviorally. Furthermore, dyslexia can affect test scores because it affects reading comprehension, word attack skills, sequencing, and spelling. To address dyslexia, Dr. Hirsch recommended a multisensory approach in which STUDENT would take information in visually, then write it down and say it.

Dr. Hirsch administered the Auditory Memory subtest of the Woodcock Johnson to assess STUDENT's auditory perceptual skills. Dr. Hirsch testified that STUDENT scored at the 4.6 grade level. Dr. Hirsch also administered the Visual Auditory Digit Span Test. Based on the results from these two tests, Dr. Hirsch testified that STUDENT has strategies he can use when he sees information, but that he has trouble holding on to information that he hears. In addition, STUDENT's skill and memory breaks down when he has to write information down. Dr. Hirsch recommended that STUDENT needs to learn to write down what he hears.

To assess STUDENT's social and emotional status, Dr. Hirsch relied on the Behavior Dimensions Rating Scale (BDRS) completed by MOTHER and the Thematic Apperception Test administered to STUDENT. The results of the BDRS indicate that STUDENT does not have problems with aggressive or acting out behavior. Dr. Hirsch testified that the BDRS did indicate that STUDENT is distractible, unmotivated, poorly organized, withdrawn, quiet, and shy. Dr. Hirsch testified that STUDENT seemed self-reliant and aware of proper social conduct. Dr. Hirsch testified that any aggressiveness or defensiveness exhibited by STUDENT could be the result of frustration over his lack of progress. Dr. Hirsch testified that STUDENT is smart enough to know that he is not succeeding or progressing. Dr. Hirsch testified that it appeared that STUDENT had given up and that he may need counselling.

Dr. Hirsch testified that STUDENT's verbal expression was not age-appropriate and she would recommend a speech and language evaluation. Dr. Hirsch testified that her testing and observations led her to suspect that STUDENT may have a deficit in expressive language. Dr. Hirsch testified that if STUDENT does have an expressive or receptive language deficit, it cannot be remediated in a special education class and he will need the services of a speech and language therapist. Dr. Hirsch also testified that without a speech and language assessment, it would be difficult to determine the precise reason for STUDENT's auditory processing deficit.

Regarding the District's assessment conducted on May 8, 1995, Dr. Hirsch testified that it was a cursory evaluation that did not include cognitive or communicative issues. Furthermore, the assessment did not include a school or family history. Dr. Hirsch also testified that the District's assessment did not determine the causes of STUDENT's deficits.

Regarding STUDENT's IEPs, Dr. Hirsch noted that they do not identify his specific learning disability. Dr. Hirsch also testified that many of his goals are too low and should include more specific things that his teachers can do to help him learn.

Finally, regarding the issues identified for this hearing, Dr. Hirsch testified that learning disabled students are very vulnerable and have a low tolerance level. If STUDENT was called racial epithets by other students, it may have affected his self-esteem and his attitude toward others, possibly leading to retaliation on his part. Dr. Hirsch attributed STUDENT's vulnerability to his lack of success. Dr. Hirsch testified that STUDENT's lack of progress, depression and withdrawal, expressive language deficits, and the racial epithets combined to cause his misconduct. In other words, Dr. Hirsch is of the opinion that STUDENT's alleged misconduct was a direct manifestation of his disability.

Regarding whether STUDENT was appropriately placed at the time of the alleged misconduct, Dr. Hirsch testified that STUDENT needs more realistic goals and work that goes to his strengths, including a multisensory approach throughout the day. Dr. Hirsch also testified that STUDENT should be provided with work on skills that will make him more marketable, such as computer skills. Dr. Hirsch testified that STUDENT should be assessed in speech and language and auditory processing. Dr. Hirsch testified that there is no evidence from STUDENT's IEPs and assessments that the District has provided these services.

WITNESSES FOR THE DISTRICT

Christine Nandi

Christine Nandi was STUDENT's English teacher in his eleventh grade special day class. Ms. Nandi testified that STUDENT's primary disability is in the area of memory. Ms. Nandi testified that she has not seen any visual-motor integration problems.

Regarding the curriculum in her class, Ms. Nandi testified that it includes literature, poetry, job skills packets, current events, and grammar and sentence structure exercises. The assignments for literature for the 1994-95 school year were To Kill a Mockingbird, Life of Walter Mitty, Death of a Salesman, and Walking in the Woods on a Cold Winter Morning. The students are expected to write reports on each book and present their reports to the class. Ms. Nandi also has her students write short essays on a daily basis. Ms. Nandi testified that she uses a multisensory approach in her classroom and uses a lot of repetition and modelling to work on STUDENT's memory.

Ms. Nandi testified that STUDENT had an excellent attitude at the start of the school year, but, after he was tardy a few times, his attitude worsened. Ms. Nandi described STUDENT's behavior problems as eating in class, talking back, talking to other students, and disrupting the class by coming in late. STUDENT's received several one-day suspensions from her class as a result of his behavior.

Ms. Nandi testified that STUDENT has the ability to get better grades and to improve, but he failed her class the first semester because he did not do the classwork. At the end of the 2nd semester STUDENT received a D because he did very well on the final. STUDENT took his final at home because of his suspension. Ms. Nandi testified that she offered STUDENT one-to-one assistance but that he refused her assistance. During the course of the school year, Ms. Nandi sent progress reports home with STUDENT every two weeks. Ms. Nandi testified that the progress reports were never returned to her, so she does not know if MOTHER ever saw them.Ms. Nandi testified that STUDENT should not be in a resource specialist class because of his short-term memory problems and his work skills. Ms. Nandi also testified that she did not see any reason for STUDENT to have a speech and language assessment.

Dennis Devine

Dennis Devine is the school psychologist who assessed STUDENT on May 8, 1995. Mr. Devine testified that his assessment was to serve the dual function of a triennial assessment and a pre-expulsion assessment and that it lasted from approximately 9:30 - 11:00 a.m. Mr. Devine testified that he reviewed STUDENT's file, including reports, IEPs, and test protocols. In addition, he spoke with Ms. Brown prior to the assessment to find out what areas to look into. Mr. Devine testified that he received no information that raised concerns regarding speech and language. He also testified that Ms. Brown told him that STUDENT was working at a steady pace and that it seemed as though STUDENT was making adequate progress. Mr. Devine did not have the opportunity to observe STUDENT in the classroom.

Mr. Devine testified that he did not know STUDENT's academic achievement levels until the IEP meeting. Mr. Devine testified that he would normally review this information during the assessment, but because of time constraints he was unable to do so in this case.

To assess STUDENT's learning potential, Mr. Devine administered the Children's Auditory-Verbal Learning Test-2 (CAVLT-2). Mr. Devine testified that the CAVLT-2 measures auditory and verbal learning and memory. The CAVLT-2 is normed up to 17 years, 11 months. On the CAVLT-2, STUDENT's auditory learning ability was average, his delayed recall was weak, and his short-term memory was a relative strength. Based on STUDENT's performance on the CAVLT-2, Mr. Devine testified that STUDENT should rely on his auditory memory and that he should be able to understand verbal directions.

To assess STUDENT's visual-motor integration, Mr. Devine administered the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (DTVMI). The DTVMI is normed up to 18 years of age. Mr. Devine testified that STUDENT was particularly weak in visual-motor integration.

Mr. Devine testified that STUDENT has a prescription for glasses but that he does not wear the glasses. Mr. Devine testified that a visual defect could impact STUDENT's performance on tests but that he does not know what STUDENT's visual defect is or how it affects his visual-motor integration deficit. Mr. Devine also testified that the assessment results are incomplete without knowing what the specific vision defect is and its severity. Mr. Devine testified that the triennial assessment completed in March 1992 raised issues regarding visual processing.

To assess STUDENT's social and emotional status, Mr. Devine had STUDENT complete the Youth Self Report (YSR). Mr. Devine testified that STUDENT's score on the YSR showed some problems with social and emotional behavior. Specifically, Mr. Devine found that STUDENT has problems with internalizing, rather than with externalizing. This means that STUDENT is more likely to internalize his problems than to act out. Mr. Devine testified that he found nothing to indicate that STUDENT has problems with his thought process or is seriously emotionally disturbed.

Mr. Devine reviewed STUDENT discipline referrals and, based on the quantity of them, testified that he would have called a meeting with STUDENT's parents and teachers. If the meeting was unsuccessful at resolving the behavior problems, Mr. Devine would have modified STUDENT's IEP to address the behavior problems and, if necessary, would have considered an AB 3632 referral or Hughes Bill.

Regarding a speech and language assessment, Mr. Devine testified that he did not believe one was necessary because STUDENT's oral language was clear and distinct and he used normal vocabulary. Regarding Dr. Hirsch's finding of dyslexia, Mr. Devine testified that her report did not indicate that any standardized test validated for assessing dyslexia was administered to STUDENT. Furthermore, Mr. Devine testified that dyslexia is difficult to determine unless you hear a student read and Dr. Hirsch's report does not indicate that she had him read for her. Mr. Devine testified that he was unaware of STUDENT's family history of learning disabilities.

At the IEP meeting following his assessment, Mr. Devine presented his results to the team and advised the IEP team that STUDENT's learning disability was based on weak visual-motor integration skills and weak long-term auditory memory. Mr. Devine testified that Dorothy Davis read from the suspension notice regarding STUDENT alleged misconduct. The IEP team concluded that the misconduct was not a direct manifestation of STUDENT disability and that he was appropriately placed.

Dorothy Davis

Dorothy Davis is an assistant principal at American High School. Her duties include student discipline and attendance. Ms. Davis testified regarding numerous behavior problems with STUDENT. These include: possession of a beeper in violation of school rules, for which he was eventually suspended; hitting a student without provocation; profanity directed at administrators; possible gang involvement, as reported by the police; and in-class behavior problems, such as arriving late and talking back to the teachers.

Ms. Davis testified that she has spoke fairly regularly on the phone with MOTHER and had at least five face-to-face meetings with her. Ms. Davis has also informally observed STUDENT in Ms. Nandi's and Ms. Brown's classes, and during lunch and breaks. Ms. Davis testified that she has had numerous informal conversations with STUDENT.

Regarding the IEP meeting of May 8, 1995, Ms. Davis testified that she does not remember what was said specifically regarding STUDENT's alleged misconduct, but she is sure it was discussed. Ms. Davis did not recall reading from a document regarding the alleged misconduct. Ms. Davis testified that the IEP team discussed Mr. Devine's assessment and whether the alleged misconduct was related to STUDENT's disability. Ms. Davis testified that her understanding of STUDENT disability is that he has a problem with visual recognition and short-term memory. Ms. Davis testified that STUDENT's alleged misconduct involved social conduct that is not related to his academic abilities. Ms. Davis also testified that STUDENT is appropriately placed because he has shown success in his classes.

Claire Hintergardt

Claire Hintergardt is a program specialist for Fremont Unified School District. Ms. Hintergardt was contacted by Ms. Davis on April 27 to provide assistance with the pre-expulsion procedures for STUDENT.

Ms. Hintergardt testified that she called MOTHER the morning of May 1, 1995, to suggest an IEP meeting be held that afternoon to place STUDENT on home instruction. Ms. Hintergardt testified that MOTHER did not know whether she would be able to make the meeting.

Regarding the IEP meeting on May 8, 1995, Ms. Hintergardt testified that the IEP form had only names and background information on it prior to the meeting and that the rest of the IEP was filled out during the meeting. Ms. Hintergardt testified that Mr. Devine discussed his assessment, Ms. Brown discussed the Woodcock-Johnson results, and Ms. Davis reviewed STUDENT's attendance and discipline file and read the suspension notice to describe the alleged misconduct.(Footnote 5) Ms. Hintergardt testified that the IEP team reviewed STUDENT's goals and objectives and there was some concern expressed regarding his English goal.(Footnote 6) Ms. Hintergardt testified that the concern was alleviated when Ms. Nandi explained that the goal was meant to be an example of what STUDENT would be doing in her English class.

Ms. Hintergardt testified that each team member was asked whether he or she thought STUDENT's alleged misconduct was caused by his disability. Ms. Hintergardt testified that the misconduct was not caused by STUDENT's disability because a visual-motor integration deficit does not correspond with misconduct. Ms. Hintergardt testified that MOTHER agreed that the misconduct was not caused by STUDENT's disability.

Regarding whether STUDENT was appropriately placed at the time of the misconduct, Ms. Hintergardt testified that STUDENT is appropriately placed in special day classes. Ms. Hintergardt also testified that each team member, including STUDENT and MOTHER, agreed that he was appropriately placed. Ms. Hintergardt testified that the IEP team discussed progress that STUDENT made during the school year, but the IEP team did not review STUDENT progress over the past three years. Ms. Hintergardt testified that if grade level scores on the Woodcock-Johnson remain the same over a period of three or four years, she would recommend further intervention.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Education Code § 48915.5(h) provides that an individual with exceptional needs may not be expelled until a pre-expulsion assessment is conduct. Section 48915.5(b) provides the following:

all applicable procedural safeguards prescribed by federal and state law and regulations apply to proceedings to expel pupils with previously identified exceptional needs, except that ... parental consent is not required prior to conducting a preexpulsion educational assessment pursuant to subdivision (e)....

Subdivision (e) provides that a pre-expulsion assessment must be conducted in accordance with Section 104.35 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations and should include a review of the student's placement and relationship between his alleged misconduct and his disability.

Section 104.35 of Title 34 covers only the type of test materials that should be used in an assessment and does not include any requirements regarding the extent of the pre-expulsion assessment. However, state education law requires that any psychological assessment of a student be conducted in accordance with Section 56320 of the Education Code. Education Code § 56324(a). Section 56320 includes the following requirements: The assessment instruments and procedures must not be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; the student must be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability; and the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability.

Read together, Education Code §§ 48915.5(b) and 56320, provide that students who have been recommended for expulsion are entitled to the same procedural protections that they receive when going through the "regular" assessment and IEP process and that they must be accored all rights provided by law. Furthermore, the pre-expulsion assessment must be conducted in the same manner as a triennial assessment.

The facts of this case establish that, from the date of the alleged misconduct, the District engaged in a pattern of conduct that violated procedural safeguards implemented to protect the rights of students with exceptional needs facing expulsion. On April 13, 1995, the District held an IEP meeting at STUDENT's home without a member of the administration present in violation of Education Code § 56341(b). The IEP was then taken to Ms. Davis, assistant principal, who signed the IEP as though she were present.

On May 1, 1995, the District convened an IEP meeting without giving adequate notice to STUDENT's parents in violation of § 300.504 of the Code of Federal Regulations, which requires that written notice be given to the parents of a disabled child before a school district proposes to change the child's educational placement. At most, the District phoned MOTHER on the morning of May 1, 1995, to notify her of the IEP meeting scheduled for that day.

On May 8, 1995, the District conducted an assessment which, by the school psychologist's testimony, was incomplete because he did not determine what STUDENT's specific vision defect is. Mr. Devine also testified that he would have performed additional testing if he had more time. The testimony of Mr. Devine and Ms. Brown also raises a concern that Mr. Devine was not fully informed regarding STUDENT's disability and needs prior to conducting the assessment. The testimony of those who attended the IEP meeting on May 8, 1995, raises concerns that the IEP team was not fully informed of STUDENT's misconduct, that the IEP team was not fully informed regarding STUDENT's disability, that the IEP meeting may have been a formality, and that STUDENT and MOTHER may not have had an opportunity to meaningfully participate in the IEP.

The fact that the pre-expulsion assessment was incomplete would be enough to send this case back to the District and require the District to conduct a comprehensive assessment in compliance with special education law. In addition, the numerous procedural violations committed by the District would also be sufficient to send this case back to the District. However, the Hearing Officer finds that there is adequate information in the record to reach a decision on the two issues identified for hearing.

Education Code § 48915.5(a) provides that certain conditions must be met before a child with previously identified exceptional needs may be expelled. Those conditions are the following:

(1) An individualized education program team meeting is held and conducted pursuant to Article 3 (commencing with Section 56340) of Chapter 2 of Part 30;

(2) The team determines that the misconduct was not caused by, or was not a direct manifestation of, the pupil's identified disability; and (3) The team determines that the pupil had been appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred.

Section 48915.5(f) provides that if an IEP team "determines that the alleged misconduct was not caused by, or a direct manifestation of, the pupil's disability, and if it is determined that the pupil was appropriately placed, the pupil shall be subject to the applicable disciplinary actions and procedures prescribed under this article." If the student was not appropriately placed at the time of the misconduct or if the alleged misconduct was caused by, or a direct manifestation of, the student's disability, the student is not subject to the applicable disciplinary actions and procedures.

(1) Was STUDENT's alleged misconduct on April 11, 1995, a direct manifestation of, or caused by his disability?

STUDENT's identified disability is a specific learning disability. Specifically, the District and Petitioner agree that STUDENT has a deficit in visual-motor integration. The District's psychologist also found evidence of weak long-term auditory memory, and Dr. Hirsch, the psychologist employed by Petitioner to conduct an independent assessment, raised some concerns regarding dyslexia, speech and language, and behavior.

Petitioner acknowledges that his involvement in the racial incident may not have been directly related to his disability in visual-motor integration. However, Petitioner contends that his alleged misconduct was directly related to his feelings of frustration and low self-esteem that resulted from the District's failure to adequately address his learning disability. Petitioner contends that, although there may have been other sources for his frustration and low self-esteem, these other sources cannot be separated from the problems he has experienced as a result of his learning disability.

Petitioner also contends that he has an unidentified disability in expressive language and that his inability to communicate is directly related to his misconduct on April 11, 1995. Petitioner relies significantly on Dr. Hirsch, who was of the opinion that STUDENT had difficulty expressing himself and that he may not be able to verbalize an appropriate response when called a racial epithet.

The District contends that, although STUDENT's disability may lead to frustration, there was no evidence of a direct relationship between his alleged misconduct and disability.

The Ninth Circuit, in Doe v. Maher, 793 F.2d 1470, 1480 (9th Cir. 1986), interpreted the phrase "conduct that is caused by, or has a direct and substantial relationship to, the child's handicap" as meaning the following:

Put another way, a handicapped child's conduct is covered by this definition only if the handicap significantly impairs the child's behavioral controls.... It does not embrace conduct that bears only an attenuated relationship to the child's handicap. An example of such attenuated conduct would be a case where a child's physical handicap results in his loss of self-esteem, and the child consciously misbehaves in order to gain the attention, or win the approval, of his peers. Although such a scenario may be common among handicapped children, it is no less common among children suffering from low self-esteem for other, equally tragic reasons.

While § 48915.5 did not take effect until after the Maher case was appealed, the Hearing Officer notes that the Maher court was interpreting a phrase that is substantially similar in effect to the language contained in § 48915.5. The Hearing Officer finds that the Maher court's interpretation of "conduct that is caused by, or has a direct and substantial relationship to, the child's handicap" is applicable to the phrase "misconduct was not caused by, or as not a direct manifestation of, the pupil's identified disability." The Maher language is persuasive in finding that STUDENT's alleged misconduct was not caused by, or a direct manifestation of, his identified disability.

The misconduct STUDENT is alleged to have committed was the result of provocation in the form of racial epithets being directed at him by Hispanic students. It is unclear exactly what STUDENT's role was once he confronted the students. However, at most he was accused of pushing another student. STUDENT's alleged misconduct bears an attenuated relationship to his learning disability. STUDENT may have experienced greater frustration or low self-esteem as a result of his disability. However, the Maher court establishes the principle that low self-esteem, or frustration, arising from a disability alone does not create a direct link between misconduct and a disability. Most children, at some point, experience frustration and self-esteem. Furthermore, many individuals, regardless of whether they are learning disabled, may respond in a physical manner such as STUDENT did when confronted by a situation in which they are being called racial names. Acting out because of frustration or low self-esteem is the type of misconduct that is not caused by, or a manifestation of, a learning disability as defined by § 48915.5.

As to Petitioner's contention that his misconduct was a direct manifestation of, or caused by, his disability in expressive communication, the Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient evidence to conclude that STUDENT has a disability in expressive communication. While Dr. Hirsch testified that she found he had problems expressing himself, testimony of District witnesses who have worked with STUDENT for several years contradicted Dr. Hirsch's testimony and established that STUDENT was very capable of expressing and communicating his thoughts. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT testified extensively during the hearing and appeared to be able to express and communicate his thoughts in that setting.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's alleged misconduct was not a direct manifestation of, or caused by, his learning disability.

2) Was STUDENT appropriately placed at the time of the alleged misconduct?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have a right to a free appropriate public education. (California Education Code Section 56000 et seq., and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) 20 USC 1400 et seq.) The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. 20 USC Section 1401(18). "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents or guardians, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability," including classroom instruction, home instruction, instruction in physical education, and instruction in hospitals, institutions, and other settings. 20 USC Section 1401(16).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education services or that the services be sufficient to maximize each child's potential. Rather, the Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" student in question. 458 U.S. 176, 200.

As to whether STUDENT's educational placement was designed to meet his needs and provide him with educational benefit, STUDENT's test scores and grades for the past three years provide compelling evidence that the placement was not providing him with educational benefit. During the three years STUDENT was at American High School, his academic achievement scores on the Woodcock-Johnson remained essentially the same or dropped. Significantly, the scores were at a level substantially below his grade level, and several witnesses testified that STUDENT had not reached his potential. Given that testimony and the consistently low scores, it appears that STUDENT's placement was not designed to allow STUDENT to benefit from his education. In fact, STUDENT did not receive benefit from his education.

Several witnesses, including Dr. Hirsch and Ms. Hintergardt, testified that academic achievement scores that remain the same or drop over a period of three or four years would raise concerns that the student's program may need to be modified. However, at no time during STUDENT first three years at American High School was his program changed in any serious way. Some behavior goals were added. However, for a student who was five to six grades below grade level, Petitioner's IEPs contained almost nothing in terms of academic goals. STUDENT's March 1994 IEP, which was operative at the time of his alleged misconduct, contained only two academic goals both of which were virtually empty of any means of addressing his significant delays in academic achievement. Furthermore, based on Ms. Brown's testimony, the math goal was unrealistice because, while the goal was to complete Book Five of the math series, STUDENT had only started on Book Four a year after the goal was implemented. The Hearing Officer also notes that Ms. Nandi's testimony regarding her reading materials establishes that the reading materials assigned to STUDENT in her class were beyond his capabilities based on the grade level at which he was reading.

A school district confronted with a student whose academic achievement scores had remained constant, or dropped, over a period of three or four years should, at a minimum, convene an IEP team or conduct a new assessment to determine how to address the student's lack of progress. However, the District, in this case, appeared to do nothing other than hold annual IEP meetings and continue STUDENT's program essentially the same each year. Additionally, the most recent annual IEP meeting, on April 13, 1995, not only was at least a month over due, but was also not held in compliance with special education law.

On STUDENT's two most recent IEPs -- April 1995 and March 1994 -- behavior goals and vocational goals were added. However, in the area of academics, it appears that the District was essentially operating under the assumption that STUDENT's problems were related to behavior or that he had reached his potential, contrary to the opinion of several District employees who thought he had not reached his potential. Finally, at no time during those years was any consideration given to assessing STUDENT to determine why he was failing to make any progress in academics. In fact, at the time of the alleged misconduct, a triennial assessment had been due for at least a month.

Education Code § 56381 provides that reassessments must be conducted every three years, or more frequently if conditions warrant. A student who has made essentially no academic progress for at least three years is a student who needs to be reassessed to determine why his educational program is not working. Instead of conducting an assessment of STUDENT, the District determined that one was unnecessary because he was in the last semester of his junior year.

While it is true that STUDENT is on track to graduate with his class, many of his passing grades were either C's or D's. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's lack of progress on academic achievement tests establish that STUDENT was not making progress in academic areas and that his grades, while passing, were essentially meaningless when compared to his lack of progress on achievement test. The Hearing Officer notes that, while the assessment conducted on May 8, 1995, was not conducted in compliance with special education law, there was sufficient evidence to establish that STUDENT had not reached his potential. Furthermore, there was no evidence presented that STUDENT is incapable of learning. Therefore, STUDENT should have shown at least some progress on his academic achievement test scores if he was placed in an educational program that was meeting his needs and providing him with educational benefit. As such, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not appropriately placed at the time of the alleged misconduct.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not placed in an educational program that provided him with educational benefit and, therefore, he was not appropriately placed at the time of the alleged misconduct on April 11, 1995.

ORDER

Fremont Unified School District is precluded from instituting expulsion proceedings against STUDENT for the incident which occurred on April 11, 1995.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

The hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. Education Code § 56507(d). The following findings are made in accordance with § 56507(d).

Issue #1: Respondent prevailed.

Issue #2: Petitioner prevailed.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: November 3, 1995 ________________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. On August 2, 1995, the parties identified two additional issues relating to "stay put" and the assigning of a security aide to STUDENT. Because of the delays caused by continuing the hearing over a two-month span, Petitioner asked that the "stay put" issues be addressed prior to the conclusion of the hearing. The "stay put" issues were resolved by an Order issued by the Hearing Officer on September 12, 1995.

2. STUDENT' grades for the 1st semester of eighth grade were A's and B's with C+'s in U.S. History and Calligraphy. STUDENT had no D's or F's for the 1st semester of eighth grade, or for the 2nd semester of seventh grade.

3. Dr. Hirsch administered the MAT rather than a standardized IQ test because STUDENT is and African-American student.

4. The Bender, Jordan, and VADS are not normed for 17-year-olds. The Bender and VADS have a norm ceiling of 12 years, while the Jordan has a norm ceiling of approximately 17 years. Dr. Hirsch testified that, although these tests are nott normed for a child of STUDENT' age, they can still provide information regarding whether he is perfomring at age appropriate levels. Furthermore, Dr. Hirsch testified that his results indicated that he was not performing above the sixth grade level so she did not see any harm in using these tests. Finally, Dr. Hirsch testified that the scores are not as important as the evidence of deficits she obtains from the tests.

5. Ms. Hintergardt was also one of several witnesses who testified that they do not recall the IEP team discussing the possibility the STUDENT may have been provoked at the time of the incident because he was being called racial epithets by Hispanic students.

6. STUDENT' English goal on both April 13, 1995 IEP and the May 8, 1995 IEP was: STUDENT will read pgs. 7-20 of To Kill a Mockingbird and write a summary including setting, main character, and plot so far.