California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 7, 2003
Student v. Pleasanton Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 413-03 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown
Pleasanton Unified must provide 30 hours of compensatory education because no regular education teacher attended an IEP meeting; other claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted in the decision.
Summary
The parents of a six-year-old boy eligible for special education based on autism filed for due process against Pleasanton Unified School District. Their son attended the Tri-Valley SELPA's LASS-1 preschool class for children with autism. He also had an in-home applied behavior analysis (ABA) program and attended a private regular preschool. His April 2002 IEP planned a move to the more advanced LASS-2 class in fall 2002. That move was delayed because older LASS-2 students with aggressive behaviors had not moved on to the next class. The parents removed him from LASS-1 in October 2002. Later, they replaced the in-home provider, Behavior Analysts, Inc., with Synergistic Interventions at their own expense and asked to be reimbursed.
The Hearing Officer found that LASS-1 met his needs and that he made progress there. The parents' disagreement with teacher Monica Berryhill about discrete trial training was a dispute over teaching methods. The in-home program was appropriate even though its consultants changed. Because the mother never objected to managing it, her role was presumed to be with her consent. The District kept the parents informed during the delay. The parents had also waived the special education teacher's attendance at the December 2002 IEP meeting. However, the student's regular preschool teacher was also absent from that meeting, and this denied FAPE because it seriously limited the parents' participation. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement and ordered 30 hours of compensatory education, to be completed by June 2004. The claim about summer 2003 extended school year (ESY) services was not yet ready for decision.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a student's regular education teacher missing an IEP meeting. Here the teacher worked at a private preschool, and SEHO found a procedural denial of FAPE even though the meeting focused on special class placement. It also shows that a parent's waiver of a teacher's attendance, and the lack of any objection to a parent's role in an ABA program, can defeat related claims.
Issues and holdings
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 1(a). Did the District offer or provide FAPE for the 2002 ESY and 2002-2003 school year: was it a procedural violation that the student's special education teacher did not attend the December 10, 2002 IEP meeting?
The LASS-1 teacher's absence was a technical violation of Ed. Code 56341(b), but the parents had said she did not need to attend, so it did not deny FAPE.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1(b). Was the absence of the student's regular education (private preschool) teacher from the December 10, 2002 IEP meeting a procedural denial of FAPE?
No regular education teacher of the pupil attended and the parents did not waive this. A special education teacher with a multiple subject credential did not satisfy the requirement. The absence seriously infringed parent participation and denied FAPE.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1(c). Did the District's failure to move the student to LASS-2 in September or October 2002, and its failure to convene an IEP meeting sooner, amount to a change of placement without parental consent?
The parents were kept informed, and the District sought an IEP meeting once it concluded the delay would not resolve quickly. Because LASS-1 was appropriate, no educational opportunity was lost and there was no procedural denial of FAPE.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1(d). Was the LASS-1 special day class placement designed to meet the student's unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, in conformity with the IEP, and in the LRE?
LASS-1 met the student's needs and he made progress. The dispute over discrete trial training mastery criteria was about methodology. An LRE analysis did not apply to a comparison of two similar special day classes.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1(e). Was the in-home ABA program provided by Behavior Analysts, Inc. appropriate, given the mother's management role and changes in behavioral consultants?
The parents never told the District that the mother no longer consented to managing the program, so her role was presumed consensual. The student progressed despite consultant turnover, so the program was appropriate.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1(f). Did the District deny FAPE by offering too much OT in its February 19, 2003 counter-offer letter?
The December 2002 IEP's OT offer was stipulated as appropriate and never withdrawn, so the February 2003 compromise proposal was not reviewed.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1(g). Did the District deny FAPE because its February 19, 2003 letter failed to offer APE services?
The undisputed December 2002 IEP APE offer remained in effect, so there was no denial of FAPE regarding APE.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Is the student entitled to compensatory education and/or reimbursement as a result of denial of FAPE?
The procedural denial concerned classroom placement, not the in-home program, so reimbursement for Synergistic Interventions was denied. Thirty hours of compensatory education were awarded.
- District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 3. What are the appropriate educational placement, program and services for the student for the summer 2003 ESY?
The District had not yet made its 2003 ESY offer at an IEP meeting, so the issue was not ripe and the underlying question was not reached.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District shall notice an IEP meeting to add the 30 hours of compensatory education to the student's IEP.
- Compensatory education. 30 hours of compensatory education to remedy the procedural denial of FAPE at the December 10, 2002 IEP meeting. The IEP team determines the nature and type of services, which must address the loss of educational opportunity from his absence from the classroom from December 2002 to June 2003. Services may be delivered during the 2003 ESY and/or 2003-2004 school year and must be completed no later than June 2004. The District may use its own staff, other LEAs' staff, or outside providers, but is not required to use outside providers.
Total: 30 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District
People named in the decision
- Monica Berryhill, special education preschool teacher (LASS-1), Tri-Valley SELPA / Dublin Elementary School
- Cathleen Bailey, special education teacher (LASS-2), Tri-Valley SELPA / Dublin Elementary School
- Kimberly Coxe, special education preschool teacher (Skills Development class); observer, District
- Theresa Volpe-Johnstone, licensed clinical psychologist; observer of student at private preschool, Arranged by District
- Betsy Rigotti, occupational therapist, District
- Dr. Ken Wyatt, coordinator of special education, Pleasanton Unified School District
- Kent Rezowalli, SELPA director, Tri-Valley SELPA
- Paul Faris, adaptive physical education teacher, District
- Dr. Edward Ritvo, psychiatrist; witness for District
- Sheila Buckley, special education aide; witness for Student
- Steve Ward, behavior analyst / behavioral consultant for in-home ABA program, Behavior Analysts, Inc.
- Lisa Maurer, behavioral consultant for in-home ABA program, Behavior Analysts, Inc.
- Tiffany Raitz, behavioral consultant for in-home ABA program, Behavior Analysts, Inc.
- Vicki Wells, co-director; witness for Student, Synergistic Interventions
- Kim Stokes, co-director; witness for Student, Synergistic Interventions
- Behavior Analysts, Inc. (BAI), nonpublic agency providing in-home ABA program, Contracted with District
- Synergistic Interventions, private ABA provider retained by parents
- Spectrum Center, nonpublic agency, prior in-home ABA provider, Contracted with District
- Applied Behavioral Consultants (ABC), nonpublic agency, prior in-home ABA provider, Contracted with District
- Sonshine, private regular education preschool
- Regional Center of the East Bay, regional center providing early services
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard in Pleasanton, California, on May 13-16, 20 and 21, 2003, before Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter referred to as Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Eileen Mateucci. Petitioner’s parents, FATHER and MOTHER, were each present during most portions of the hearing. Respondent Pleasanton Unified School District (hereinafter referred to as District) was represented by attorney Karen Rezendes. Attorney Karen Samman also represented the District on some hearing days. Tri-Valley SELPA director Kent Rezowalli was present on behalf of the District.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: FATHER, Petitioner’s father; Vicki Wells, co-director of Synergistic Interventions; Sheila Buckley, special education aide; MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; and Kim Stokes, co-director of Synergistic Interventions.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Kimberly Coxe, special education preschool teacher; Betsy Rigotti, occupational therapist; Dr. Ken Wyatt, coordinator of special education; Monica Berryhill, special education preschool teacher; Dr. Edward Ritvo, psychiatrist; Steve Ward, behavior analyst; Paul Faris, adaptive physical education teacher; and Kent Rezowalli, Tri-Valley SELPA director.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. Upon receipt of closing briefs on June 5, 2003, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Did the District offer or provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002 extended school year (ESY) and 2002-2003 school year?
(2) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education and/or reimbursement as a result of denial of FAPE?
(3) What are the appropriate educational placement, program and services for STUDENT for the summer 2003 extended school year (ESY)?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner STUDENT is a six-year-old boy who is eligible for special education services based on a diagnosis of autism. STUDENT lives with his parents and older brother within the boundaries of the District and the Tri-Valley SELPA.
When STUDENT was two years old, he began receiving services from the Regional Center of the East Bay. At age two years, eleven months, STUDENT was diagnosed with autism and mild mental retardation. (Dist. Exh. 3077.) In May 2000, when STUDENT turned three, he began attending the Language Acquisition and Social Skills 1 (LASS-1) class pursuant to a District individualized education plan (IEP). The LASS-1 class is designed for preschool-age autistic children and is taught by Monica Berryhill; the classroom is located at Dublin Elementary School and is operated by the Tri-Valley SELPA, which serves students in the present District and two other school districts. The SELPA operated a total of three LASS classes for autistic children. The three LASS classes utilized much of the same curriculum, format and philosophy. In particular, LASS-2 had slightly older, higher-functioning students, more group interaction and a less “boxed-in” classroom setup than LASS-1. (Testimony of Ms. Berryhill, Dr. Wyatt.)
Also pursuant to his IEP, STUDENT began receiving an in-home applied behavioral analysis (ABA) program from Spectrum Center, a non-public agency operating pursuant to a contract with the District. Spectrum Center provided STUDENT’s in-home ABA program until March 2001, when the IEP team agreed to the parents’ request to change the non-public agency (NPA) providing the ABA program from Spectrum Center to Applied Behavioral Consultants (ABC). (Dist. Exh. 5089.) The IEP team also agreed to increase the number of in-home hours in STUDENT’s program. After approximately one month of services from ABC, the PARENTS notified ABC and the District that they were terminating ABC as the behavioral consultants. In July 2001, the IEP team agreed that Behavior Analysts, Inc. (BAI) would become the ABA program provider; Lisa Maurer was the BAI behavioral consultant initially in charge of STUDENT’s program. STUDENT’s mother managed the in-home program; in that capacity, she performed tasks including creating the data sheets, tracking data and consulting with the in-home tutors.
Throughout this time, STUDENT continued to attend the LASS-1 class at Dublin Elementary School. In October 2001, the IEP team agreed to add a one-to-one classroom aide to STUDENT’s attendance at LASS-I.
In approximately January 2002 the PARENTS placed STUDENT at Sonshine, a private, regular education preschool. STUDENT attended Sonshine in the afternoons five days per week, after attending LASS-1 in the mornings.
On April 17, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team convened. The team reached agreement on all aspects of STUDENT’s program, including placement, DIS, goals and objectives. The team agreed to continue the in-home ABA program with BAI. Regarding STUDENT’s special education class placement, the IEP document listed both LASS-1 and LASS-2 as the special day class (SDC) placement; the team members orally agreed that STUDENT would continue to attend LASS-1 and would transition to LASS-2.
For the extended school year (ESY) in summer 2002, STUDENT remained primarily in LASS-1 but went to LASS-2 for snack and play time as part of the transition process. In July 2002, Steve Ward replaced Lisa Maurer as the BAI behavioral consultant for STUDENT’s in-home ABA program. Mr. Ward decided to place some of STUDENT’s goals on “hold” so that STUDENT could focus on the goals that contained “prerequisite” skills. Also in July 2002, STUDENT’s parents received a letter from the Tri-Valley SELPA confirming STUDENT’s school, teacher, and start date for the 2002-2003 school year. (Pet. Exh. 154.) The letter identified STUDENT’s school as Dublin Elementary School and his teacher as Cathleen Bailey, who taught the LASS-2 class. In August 2002, MOTHER received a telephone call from the LASS-1 teacher, Monica Berryhill. Ms. Berryhill told MOTHER that there were three parents who were refusing to transition their children from LASS-2 to LASS-3 as planned, and that this would cause some delay in STUDENT’s transition from LASS-1 to LASS-2.
When the school year began in early September 2002, STUDENT returned to his placement in the LASS-1 class. For several days that September, STUDENT cried when his mother dropped him off at school. To address this behavior, Ms. Berryhill reduced demands on STUDENT and used his favorite toys as positive reinforcement for a week until he could gradually return to working on his goals and objectives.
During September and October 2002, STUDENT’s parents continually asked District staff when STUDENT would be able to move to LASS-2. In a letter dated October 14, 2002, District special education coordinator Ken Wyatt wrote that “we are hopeful we can move STUDENT into the LASS 2 program by early to mid November.” (Pet. Exh. 119.) On October 24, 2002, school administrators and all three LASS teachers met to discuss the classroom placement of STUDENT and other LASS students scheduled to transition from one LASS class to another. On October 27, Dr. Wyatt wrote to PARENTS about what occurred at the meeting. Dr. Wyatt explained that the administrators and LASS teachers had decided that they could not yet transition the LASS-2 students to LASS-3, and therefore wanted to keep STUDENT and other LASS-1 students in that classroom, with increased group interaction similar to what those students would have received in LASS-2. (Pet. Exhs. 116-117.) Dr. Wyatt requested that the parents attend an IEP meeting on November 4 to discuss this proposal. (Pet. Exh. 117.)
In response to Dr. Wyatt’s e-mail, FATHER sent an e-mail explaining the parents’ disagreement with continuing the LASS-1 placement and stating that the parents would be removing STUDENT from LASS-1 the following day. FATHER requested that the District send STUDENT’s one-to-one aide to the PARENTS’ home instead of the LASS-1 classroom, so that the parents could include the aide in providing STUDENT’s in-home ABA program.
STUDENT did not return to the LASS-1 class after October 28, 2002. On November 1, 2002, the PARENTS and Dr. Wyatt met for an “interim placement meeting” and signed an IEP addendum that added 17.5 hours to STUDENT’s in-home ABA program to compensate for the loss of classroom hours. (Pet. Exh. 98.) The IEP addendum stated that Dr. Wyatt would arrange for STUDENT to continue receiving OT and speech services at Dublin Elementary School. The addendum also indicated that the PARENTS did not agree with the LASS-1 placement, believed that STUDENT should have been placed in LASS-2, and were interested in placing STUDENT in a “Skills Development” preschool class.
In October 2002, Tiffany Raitz had replaced Steve Ward as the BAI behavioral consultant for STUDENT’s in-home ABA program. In November 2002, Mr. Ward spoke with the PARENTS and District staff about what STUDENT’s placement should be. In a letter dated November 18, 2002, Mr. Ward recommended that STUDENT remain in the LASS-1 class or a similar class. (Pet. Exh. 70.) Because of the parents’ request for STUDENT’s placement in Skills Development preschool class, the District arranged for Theresa Volpe-Johnstone, a licensed clinical psychologist, and Kimberly Coxe, teacher of the Skills Development preschool class, to observe STUDENT at his private preschool and report on whether the Skills Development class would be appropriate for him. Dr. Volpe-Johnstone and Ms. Coxe initially observed STUDENT at Sonshine preschool on November 13, 2002. At the parents’ request, Dr. Volpe-Johnstone and Ms. Coxe conducted a follow-up observation on December 3, 2002. Dr. Volpe-Johnstone and Ms. Coxe reported their conclusions that the Skills Development preschool class would not be appropriate for STUDENT at that time due to his deficits in key skill areas. (Dist. Exh. pgs. 3013-3017; testimony of Ms. Coxe.)
On December 10, 2002, the IEP team convened to discuss STUDENT’s placement. The District offered STUDENT placement in the LASS-1 class and in a typical preschool, with a one-to-one aide accompanying him to both classrooms. For the in-home component, the District offered BAI’s ABA program for 17-18 hours per week and 4-5 hours of behavioral consultation per week. Regarding DIS, the District offered as follows: speech therapy for two 20-minute sessions per week, adaptive physical education (APE) for two 45-minute sessions per week, direct OT services for 45 minutes per week and OT consultation for 60 minutes per week. (Dist. Exhs. 5003-5007.) During the meeting, FATHER explained the parents’ position that LASS-1 was no longer an appropriate placement for STUDENT. (Pet. Exhs. 45-73.) The parents and District staff did not reach agreement, except to agree to continue STUDENT’s previous program, including continuing to replace STUDENT’s hours in LASS-1 with an equal number of hours in the in-home ABA program. (Pet. Exh. 57.)
On December 20, 2002, the PARENTS met with Mr. Rezowalli. During that meeting, the PARENTS informed Mr. Rezowalli that they intended to terminate BAI as the provider of STUDENT’s in-home ABA program and were investigating using another agency called Synergistic Interventions (SI). (Testimony of Kent Rezowalli, FATHER.) In an electronic mail (e-mail) message on January 5, 2003, FATHER informed Dr. Wyatt that the PARENTS hoped to begin services with SI on January 13, 2003. (Pet. Exh. 25.) In another e-mail message on January 10, FATHER wrote that SI would begin providing services on January 13 unless the District could provide “a reasonable and acceptable alternative provider/therapist (qualified and trained)” by that date. (Pet. Exh. 20.)
Beginning on January 13, 2003, SI provided STUDENT’s in-home program at his parents’ expense. On February 5, 2003, District staff met with the PARENTS and the co-directors of SI, Vickie Wells and Kim Stokes, to discuss SI’s proposal to provide STUDENT’s in-home program. The portion of that proposal concerning the in-home ABA program included both a senior-level in-home therapist for 15 hours per week at a cost of $75 per hour and a junior-level in-home therapist for 15 hours per week at $14 per hour. (Pet. Exh. 10; Dist. Exh. 2003.) On February 7, FATHER sent Mr. Rezowalli an e-mail message summarizing the proposals made at the February 5 meeting. In a letter to PARENTS dated February 19, Mr. Rezowalli made a counter-offer. The PARENTS did not accept the District’s counter-offer. On March 4, 2003, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for due process hearing. STUDENT has not returned to a District classroom placement since he left LASS-1 in late October 2002. SI continues to implement STUDENT’s in-home program. He also continues to attend Sonshine preschool for seven and one-half hours per week, with the assistance of a one-to-one aide. Pursuant to the interim agreement of November 1, 2002, the District continued to provide some educational services such as speech therapy and OT.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
(1) Did the District offer or provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002 extended school year (ESY) and the 2002-2003 school year?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and state law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code § 56000.) Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; California Education Code § 56000.) “FAPE” is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards, include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and that are provided at public expense and in conformity with an IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to allow a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(17).) California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
The determination of whether a student has been offered a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate. (Board of Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200.)
A. Procedural Requirements
Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP.” (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 205-206.)
Procedural violations which result in a “loss of educational opportunity” or which “seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE.” (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).) Procedural flaws, however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. (Id. at 1484.) Procedural violations may result in a denial of a FAPE if they result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process. (Id.) Thus, the courts have created a two-prong test for determining if a procedural violation resulted in a denial of FAPE for a student: (1) whether a procedural protection has been violated and (2) whether the procedural violation resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringed on the parents’ participation in the IEP process.
In the present case, at the beginning of the hearing Petitioner argued that procedural violations constituted a procedural denial of FAPE. The procedural claims to be addressed here are: (1) that the District committed a procedural violation because no special education teacher or general education teacher attended that IEP meeting and (2) that the District failed to convene an IEP meeting for over two months after the District knew that it would not be able to transition STUDENT to LASS-2 during the anticipated time period.
Teacher Participation at December 2002 IEP Meeting
California Education Code section 56341(b) identifies which individuals comprise the IEP team, including “at least one special education teacher of the pupil.” After October 28, 2002, STUDENT was no longer attending a special education class, so at the time of the IEP meeting there was no current special education teacher of the pupil. Prior to the December meeting, PARENTS sent the District an e-mail stating that “since STUDENT will no longer be a student in LASS-1, we do not need Monica Berryhill to attend this IEP.” (Dist. Exh. 2022.) Accordingly, Ms. Berryhill did not attend the IEP meeting.
Instead, special education teacher Kimberly Coxe, who had observed STUDENT on two occasions, attended the meeting. The District was not offering Ms. Coxe’s special education class for STUDENT and Ms. Coxe had never been STUDENT’s special education teacher. Given that Ms. Berryhill had been STUDENT’s special education teacher and the District continued to offer her special education class for STUDENT, the failure to have Ms. Berryhill present at the IEP meeting was nevertheless a technical violation of section 56341(b).
However, several factors indicate that this technical violation did not rise to the level of a denial of a FAPE.(footnote 1) Petitioner’s claim of procedural violation is questionable in light of the parents’ statement that Ms. Berryhill need not attend the IEP meeting. Indeed, Education Code section 56341.1(g) states that the California Legislature intends IEP meetings to be nonadversarial; given the parents’ other negative statements about Ms. Berryhill and their statement that she need not attend the IEP meeting, the District’s failure to include her may have been in part an attempt to reduce the adversarial nature of the meeting.(footnote 2)
Petitioner did not argue how Ms. Berryhill’s failure to attend the IEP led to a loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement on the parent’s IEP participation, and the Hearing Officer finds that, considering the parents’ waiver of her attendance, no denial resulted. In light of the factors discussed above, the attendance of Ms. Coxe instead of Ms. Berryhill at the December 2002 IEP meeting did not constitute a procedural denial of a FAPE.
California Education Code section 56341(b) also requires the attendance at the IEP meeting of at least one regular education teacher of the pupil, if the pupil is or may be participating in the regular education environment. At the time of the December 2002 IEP meeting, STUDENT had a regular education preschool teacher in his private preschool, Sonshine, but that teacher did not attend the IEP meeting. There was no evidence or argument from either party regarding whether STUDENT’s teacher at Sonshine preschool was asked to attend the IEP meeting, nor why she did not attend. Thus, on its face, the absence of a regular education teacher was a procedural violation of California Education Code section 56341(b).(footnote 3)
The next question is whether this violation resulted in a loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement of the parents’ right to participate in the IEP meeting. There is no dispute that the purpose of the meeting was to discuss STUDENT’s special education class placement; there was no proposal to change STUDENT’s attendance at Sonshine. Nevertheless, both State and federal laws emphasize the importance of including a regular education teacher in each meeting to develop, review or revise the IEP. (34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(2); Cal. Education Code § 56341.) The purpose of attendance of the regular education teacher is to obtain that teacher’s input and participation, so that the parents and other members of the IEP team will have accurate information upon which to base a decision, and an LEA’s failure to ensure this input seriously infringes on the parents’ participation in the IEP team meeting. (See Target Range School District No. 23, supra at 1484.) Unlike the attendance of the student’s special education teacher, there is no indication that the parents waived the attendance of the student’s regular education teacher. In light of all circumstances, the failure to include the regular education teacher at the December 2002 IEP meeting constituted a procedural denial of FAPE.
Change of Placement
Regarding the second procedural claim, the question is whether, in light of the IEP team’s agreement to transition STUDENT to LASS-2 in fall 2002, the District’s failure to move STUDENT to LASS-2 in September or October 2002 in effect constituted a change of placement without the written consent of one of STUDENT’s parents.(footnote 4) California law provides that a special education program cannot be implemented until a parent of the student consents in writing to all or part of the IEP. (Cal. Education Code § 56346(a).) Thus, a change of placement cannot occur without a parent’s written consent. While changed circumstances may render an agreed-upon placement temporarily unavailable or inappropriate, a parent of the student must consent in writing to changing a placement already agreed upon in a signed IEP. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a).)
STUDENT’s April 2002 IEP listed both the LASS-1 and LASS-2 classes as his placement; witnesses confirmed that the reason for identifying both classes on the IEP document was that STUDENT would be transitioning from LASS-1 to LASS-2.(footnote 5) (Dist. Exh. 5028, 5059A; testimony of Ms. Berryhill, FATHER, MOTHER, Dr. Wyatt.) While the IEP document does not specifically identify when the transition was to take place, a written report from the LASS-1 teacher, Monica
Berryhill, recommended that STUDENT be placed in LASS-2 in fall 2002. (Dist. Exh. 5031.) The PARENTS testified to their understanding that STUDENT would move to LASS-2 in fall 2002.
Pursuant to the April 2002 IEP, in approximately June 2002 STUDENT began attending LASS-2 for a short time each day as part of the transition from LASS-1 to LASS-2. In approximately August 2002, District staff learned that two LASS-2 students were not moving to LASS-3 as planned. District and SELPA staff believed that, because of the aggressive behaviors those two students demonstrated, they should not be placed in the same class with STUDENT. (Testimony of Ms. Berryhill, Dr. Wyatt.) Ms. Berryhill spoke with MOTHER by telephone and explained that there were a few parents who were refusing to move their children from LASS-2 to LASS-3, and that this situation would delay STUDENT’s transition into LASS-2. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Berryhill.) Although Ms. Berryhill did not state how long this delay would be, MOTHER testified that initially she was not concerned because Ms. Berryhill had implied that the delay would be temporary.
Over the next two months, the PARENTS frequently inquired about when STUDENT would be able to move to LASS-2, and District staff replied to the PARENTS’ inquiries about the situation. (See, e.g., Pet. Exhs. 119, 129.) On October 24, 2002, school administrators and all three LASS teachers met to discuss the classroom placement of STUDENT and other LASS students scheduled to transition from one LASS class to another. On October 27, Dr. Wyatt wrote an e-mail to PARENTS about what occurred at the meeting. Dr. Wyatt explained that the administrators and LASS teachers had decided that they could not yet transition the LASS-2 students to LASS-3, and therefore would keep STUDENT and other LASS-1 students in that classroom, with increased group interaction similar to what those students would have received in LASS-2. (Pet. Exhs. 116-117.) In his e-mail letter, Dr. Wyatt requested that the PARENTS attend a meeting on November 4 to discuss this proposal. (Pet. Exh. 117.) On October 27, FATHER replied that the parents disagreed with the District’s position and would be removing STUDENT from LASS-1 the following day. In response to the parents’ removal of STUDENT, the District scheduled an emergency IEP meeting to make an interim arrangement for STUDENT’s educational program. On November 1, 2003, that IEP meeting convened and the team reached an interim agreement for additional tutor hours to replace the time he had previously spent in the LASS-1 classroom.
At the meeting on April 17, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team had agreed that the transition to LASS-2 would take place in fall 2002. There was no specific agreement as to when in fall 2002 the transition would occur, and the evidence established that transitioning a student from LASS-1 to LASS-2 could last weeks or months, depending on the student’s needs. (Testimony of Ms. Berryhill.) In September and October 2002, District staff initially did not know whether the problem with the LASS-2 transition might resolve quickly, if the LASS-2 students moved on to LASS-3 as planned. (See testimony of Ms. Berryhill, Dr. Wyatt, Mr. Rezowalli; Pet. Exh. 119.) During this period, the District and the parents communicated frequently about the situation. (See, e.g., Pet. Exhs. 119, 129-130.) Once the District staff concluded in late October 2002 that the LASS-2 class would not be available for STUDENT in fall 2002, the District sought to convene an IEP meeting with the parents regarding the proposed change. (Pet. Exhs. 60, 117; Dist. Exh. 6054.)
The Hearing Officer considers that during September and October 2002, the parents were kept informed of the placement situation. Moreover, in late October 2002 the District sought to convene an IEP meeting regarding the change in the transition timeline, once the staff concluded that the delay would not resolve quickly.(footnote 6 ) In light of these factors, the failure to convene an IEP meeting in September or October 2002 to address the placement issue did not seriously infringe on the parents’ right to participate in the IEP process.(Footnote 7) Accordingly, this did not rise to the level of a procedural denial of FAPE.
B. Substantive Requirements
Under the IDEA and the decision of the U.S. Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to address the student’s unique needs, be reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and be in conformity with the student’s IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.) To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. (Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) The Rowley opinion explained that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student's potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200.) Moreover, as long as a school district provides an appropriate education, methodology is left up to the school's discretion. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 208.) Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Education Code § 56031.) The LRE requirement is codified in federal law as follows:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities...are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
(20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; California Education Code § 56364.2.)
The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming” or education in the LRE. The law demonstrates “a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” (Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir.1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45.)
Furthermore, the IDEA specifies additional requirements for the provision of a FAPE which are not in dispute in the present case, such as the obligation to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. (See, e.g., 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).)
To summarize, the IDEA and Supreme Court’s decision in Rowley require that an appropriate program: (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit; (3) conform to the student’s IEP; and (4) be in the LRE. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 188.)
Unique Needs and Educational Benefit
Regarding STUDENT’s unique needs, his primary diagnosis is autism, although shortly before his third birthday he was also diagnosed with mild mental retardation. He is cooperative, well-behaved and compliant with instructions that he understands, but he has significant difficulty with social skills and communication. He will sometimes interact with others when prompted and can parallel play, but rarely initiates contact with others. (Testimony of Ms. Berryhill, Mr. Ward; Dist. Exh. 5059; Pet. Exh. 77.) He has deficits in both receptive language and expressive language, including spontaneous language and making requests, although he does use language and will sometimes make requests for items or activities that he wants. As of April 2002, he could label approximately 130 items; his 2002 ABLLS (Assessment of Basic Language and Learning Skills) results indicated deficits in labeling and vocabulary size. (Dist. Exhs. 5055, 8001 et. seq.; testimony of Mr. Ward.) STUDENT has deficits in speech, including articulation, and there is no dispute that he needs speech/language therapy. Similarly, he has deficits in motor skills and there is no dispute that he requires occupational therapy. He also demonstrates some self-stimulatory behaviors, such as hitting his chin, and has needs in self-help skills and attending skills.
The next step is to determine whether the LASS-1 placement was designed to address these unique needs and provide educational benefit. The evidence established, and Petitioner does not dispute, that the general structure of the LASS classes was appropriate for him. Provision of discrete trial training (DTT) on a one-to-one basis in the classroom enabled STUDENT to work on his areas of deficit as specified in his April 2002 IEP goals and objectives. Because of the small class size, small teacher-to-student ratio, and assistance of his one-to-one aide, STUDENT could receive the intensive instruction he needed to work on his goals and objectives. There is no dispute that the classroom format based on the STARS (Strategic Teaching And Reinforcement Systems) program was appropriate to address STUDENT’s needs. (See Dist. Exh. 6005.)
The evidence further established that STUDENT received educational benefit while he was in LASS-1 during the 2002 ESY and beginning of the 2002-2003 school year(footnote 8). STUDENT’s July 2002 progress report and Ms. Berryhill’s testimony identified STUDENT’s progress on numerous goals and objectives during this time period, including expressively identifying pictures and receptively identifying items by category. (Dist. Exhs. 5053-5059, 7019-7027; Pet. Exhs. 147-150.) APE teacher Paul Faris testified that by October 2002, STUDENT showed improvement in following instructions and paying attention in APE class, compared to STUDENT’s abilities in April 2002.
Petitioner contends that LASS-1 was no longer addressing his unique educational needs as of summer/fall 2002 because Ms. Berryhill was not properly implementing his discrete trial training (DTT). The PARENTS contend that Ms. Berryhill’s implementation of DTT had STUDENT repeating areas that he already knew instead of moving on to new skills pursuant to his IEP goals and objectives.(footnote 9) (See Pet. Exh. 113-114; testimony of FATHER, MOTHER.) MOTHER testified that Ms. Berryhill did not understand how many days of correct answers showed that STUDENT had mastered a skill.
Regarding repetition of the objectives in DTT, Ms. Berryhill testified that she implemented STUDENT’s DTT pursuant to his goals and objectives and based on his curriculum designed by the supervisor of his in-home ABA program. Ms. Berryhill explained that she had frequently consulted with MOTHER about implementing the DTT, but noted that she and MOTHER had a difference of opinion regarding STUDENT’s ability to generalize and use language. Ms. Berryhill described how, after STUDENT had learned a new word or skill, he needed to generalize the word or skill three days in a row correctly, in various situations and with each LASS-1 staff member, while MOTHER believed that STUDENT had reached mastery of the new word sooner. Ms. Berryhill stated that unless STUDENT generalized a new word to this degree and each staff member learned to work with him on the new word, he would subsequently lose the new word because he would not generate it spontaneously and the staff would not know to reinforce the new word. (See Dist. Exhs. 6042-6043.) In light of all evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the disagreement between the PARENTS and Ms. Berryhill regarding implementation of the DTT is essentially a dispute over methodology. Understandably, the PARENTS have shown that they want STUDENT to learn as much as he can and go as far as he can, whether in class or in his in-home ABA program. The conflicting philosophies regarding what extent of generalization is required for STUDENT to learn constitute a dispute over methodology and do not establish that the more conservative approach in the LASS-1 class was inappropriate for STUDENT. Indeed, STUDENT made progress on numerous goals and objectives during this time period, including expressively identifying pictures and receptively identifying items by category. (Dist. Exhs. 5053-5059, 7019-7027; Pet. Exhs. 147-150; testimony of Ms. Berryhill.) Therefore, the evidence established that the DTT in LASS-1 was consistent with addressing STUDENT’s unique needs and providing him with educational benefit.
Petitioner also argued that STUDENT needed to be in a group of older, higher-functioning peers than the students in LASS-1. Petitioner argues that because he was showing an interest in other children and was beginning to imitate others, placement in LASS-1 would be inappropriate because the LASS-1 students, some of whom were still in diapers, would provide inappropriate peer models. (Testimony of FATHER; Pet. Exh. 129.) However, Ms. Berryhill testified that Petitioner was in the middle of the LASS-1 student population in terms of both his age and his development. Similarly, Mr. Ward’s unrefuted testimony was that STUDENT’s development level was in the middle of the LASS-1 population. Mr. Rezowalli also testified that, in fall 2002, there were three other students enrolled in LASS-1 who were older than STUDENT.
In comparison, Mr. Rezowalli testified that STUDENT would have been the youngest student in LASS-2. Mr. Ward testified to his opinion that, after observing both the LASS-1 and LASS-2 classes, he concluded in November 2002 that the verbal and social instructions in LASS-2 would have been too difficult for STUDENT at that time and therefore LASS-1 was the more appropriate placement. (See also Pet. Exh. 70, Dist. Exhs. 10,000-10,014.) Ms. Berryhill and Dr. Wyatt testified that LASS-2 was not appropriate for STUDENT in fall 2002 because of the presence of two older students with aggressive behaviors. While some testimony was offered to establish that STUDENT’s one-to-one aide potentially could shield STUDENT from those aggressive behaviors, Ms. Berryhill explained that the aggressive behaviors of those students created risks regarding both STUDENT’s safety and his potential to imitate those inappropriate behaviors.
In order to mitigate any loss of socialization with higher-functioning peers resulting from his continuing placement in LASS-1, the District proposed increasing STUDENT’s group interactions while he remained in LASS-1. (Pet. Exh. 44, 116-177; testimony of Dr. Wyatt.) Additionally, the Hearing Officer considers that a key function of the LASS placement in STUDENT’s education was to generalize the skills he had learned in his in-home ABA program and that the primary method of this was through one-to-one DTT in the classroom. STUDENT did not attend the LASS-1 circle time in the afternoons because he spent his afternoons being mainstreamed at Sonshine, his regular education preschool.(footnote 10) While of course STUDENT would have had interaction with the other LASS students, regardless of whether he was in LASS-1 or LASS-2, it is relevant that the majority of STUDENT’s time in LASS would be spent working directly with an aide.
In light of all of the factors discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs could be met in LASS-1 and he did not require his special education class placement to be with a higher-functioning student population. While STUDENT would likely have derived some benefits from a higher-functioning special education population, the negative behaviors present in LASS-2, the appropriate level of verbal instructions in LASS-1, and the lack of a strong socialization component in either LASS placement counter the benefit of the higher-functioning population. Because STUDENT’s goals and objectives can be addressed in LASS-1 sufficiently to address his needs and provide educational benefit, the LASS-1 placement was appropriate.
As discussed above, the LASS-1 placement was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
Conformity With the IEP
As addressed in this Decision’s section on procedural appropriateness, there was substantial conformity with the April 2002 IEP. For the reasons discussed in that section, the delay in transitioning STUDENT to LASS-2 in early fall 2002 did not create a non-conformity with the IEP sufficient to deny STUDENT a FAPE.
Least Restrictive Environment (LRE)
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Education Code § 56031.) Case law and statutory law regarding the LRE requirement primarily concern the maximum extent that special education students can be mainstreamed with typically developing, non-disabled peers.(footnote 11) (See, e.g., 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Sacramento City Unified Sch. Dist.v. Holland, (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994).)
Here, there is no dispute that STUDENT needed to attend a special education class for part of his school day in order to address his unique needs and make progress on his goals and objectives. However, Petitioner argues that the LRE requirement is applicable because the LASS-1 class was too restrictive and instead STUDENT should have been placed in LASS-2 pursuant to the LRE requirement. Notably, the restrictiveness of an environment is determined by factors such as the amount of interaction with non-disabled students, the amount of socialization opportunities, and the amount of group instruction versus one-to-one instruction. Considering the nature of the LASS classes and the similarities between LASS-1 and LASS-2, it is unclear how to analyze which class is the LRE.
District witnesses explained that the three LASS classes are a continuum of a similar program. Both LASS-1 and LASS-2 are special day classes situated on the same regular education elementary campus, both serve autistic students who have language and socialization deficits, both had similarly small class sizes and small teacher-to-student ratios, and both used the same STARS methodology. There was no evidence of any difference in the amount of mainstreaming or socialization opportunities available in either LASS-1 or LASS-2.
There was evidence that LASS-2 had slightly older and higher-functioning students, more group interaction and a less “boxed-in” classroom setup than LASS-1, although the District proposed modifying STUDENT’s LASS-1 program to provide increased group interaction similar to LASS-2. Notably, in fall 2002 two LASS-2 students manifested behavior problems including aggressive behaviors. (Testimony of Ms. Berryhill, Dr. Wyatt.) While generally higher-functioning students offer more opportunities for interaction with other students, the presence of behavioral needs such as aggressive behaviors can reduce socialization opportunities and create a more restrictive environment. Moreover, Petitioner argues in part that STUDENT’s one-to-one aide could shield him from the aggressive behaviors of the two LASS-2 students; such a situation would therefore reduce STUDENT’s interactions with all of his classmates and increase his interaction with his one-to-one aide, which would constitute a more restrictive environment.
In light of all evidence, an LRE analysis is not applicable in the comparison of these two special day class placements. In summary, because the LASS-1 placement was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit and was in substantial conformity with the IEP, it was appropriate and constituted an offer of a FAPE.
BAI’s In-Home ABA Program
There is no dispute that STUDENT needed an in-home ABA program in order to make educational progress. Rather, the parties dispute whether BAI was providing an appropriate program.
Although this position was not clear during the hearing, in his closing brief Petitioner argues primarily that BAI’s program was inappropriate because it required MOTHER to work extensively as an unpaid volunteer in implementing the program. Petitioner is correct that a school district’s offer of a FAPE may not require a parent to personally provide his or her child’s primary educational services unless the parent consents to do so. Absent parental consent, such a program is not free to the parents, but rather would constitute an LEA impermissibly shifting its responsibility for the student’s education. (See 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) In contrast, no “impermissible shift” occurs when an LEA’s program requires active parental participation, which is generally considered essential to implementation of programs for autistic children. (See, e.g., Collaborative Work Group on Autistic Spectrum Disorders, Best Practices for Designing and Delivering Effective Programs for Individuals with Autistic Spectrum Disorders (July 1997), p. 5.)
In the present case, Petitioner failed to establish that the District impermissibly shifted its responsibilities onto MOTHER without her consent. Petitioner acknowledges in his closing brief that MOTHER did not object to her role in the in-home program when Lisa Maurer was the BAI behavioral consultant and only objected once Mr. Ward took over and her responsibilities greatly increased. Yet despite the large volume of e-mail correspondence the PARENTS sent to District staff, nothing in the exhibits appears to communicate the PARENTS’ nonconsent to MOTHER’s role in implementing the in-home program, nor did witness testimony establish that the PARENTS verbally conveyed this information to District staff prior to the hearing. Thus, the evidence did not establish that FATHER or MOTHER conveyed to the District prior to the hearing that MOTHER no longer consented to her role as the manager of STUDENT’s in-home program. In light of these circumstances, utilization of MOTHER’s time and skills in implementing the in-home program was presumably with her consent and therefore permissible.
Additionally, while there is no dispute that MOTHER spent time managing STUDENT’s in-home program, the evidence did not establish how much time this role required or what the extent of her role was. PARENTS each testified that MOTHER spent time managing the in-home program and mentioned a few of the things she did in that role, such as creating data sheets on the PARENTS’ home computer and meeting with the tutors who provided the in-home program. Testimony from Ms. Berryhill, Ms. Buckley and Mr. Ward was consistent with the parents’ testimony on this point to the extent that the educators described working with MOTHER on implementing STUDENT’s goals and objectives at home and, in the case of Ms. Berryhill, generalizing them in the classroom. However, details such as approximately how many hours of MOTHER’s time the program required would be essential to determining to what extent her role was an impermissible shift of the District’s obligations and was beyond the level of active parent involvement integral to ABA programs.
Petitioner’s other primary allegation regarding BAI’s inappropriateness is that BAI frequently changed the behavioral consultant to STUDENT’s program. Lisa Maurer was the behavioral consultant for nearly the first year of STUDENT’s program, from approximately August 2001 until July 2002, when she left because she moved out of northern California. (Testimony of Mr. Ward.) Mr. Ward was the behavioral consultant from July 2002 until October 2002, when Tiffany Raitz took over largely to relieve Mr. Ward of his heavy caseload. Ms. Raitz remained the behavioral consultant until the parents terminated BAI on December 20, 2002. Petitioner argued that the frequent change of behavioral consultant created inconsistency in STUDENT’s program, in part because each behavioral consultant implemented the in-home program differently.
The District established, and Petitioner did not appear to dispute, that STUDENT made progress in his BAI in-home program.(footnote 12) For example, Mr. Ward’s testimony and written report identified STUDENT’s progress in several areas, including making requests, labeling objects or pictures, and imitation, that occurred when Mr. Ward was the behavioral consultant from July to October 2002. (Dist. Exhs. 10,000-10,014.) Mr. Ward described how the BAI program is generally consistent among the different BAI behavioral consultants, each of whom relies on the same methods and underlying philosophy. (See Dist. Exhs. 6001-6012.) Mr. Ward explained how he was able to continue Ms. Maurer’s implementation of the in-home program using the results of STUDENT’s ABLLS assessment and DTT data, and by twice observing Ms. Maurer’s work in STUDENT’s in-home program.
Attrition among special education staff is a serious problem in many areas of the United States. While turnover of staff does not lessen an LEA’s obligation to provide FAPE, the mere fact that turnover occurred does not create a presumption that the student was denied a FAPE. In light of the evidence regarding STUDENT’s progress in his in-home program and the structure of the BAI program, the Hearing Officer finds that the in-home program provided by BAI was appropriate despite the change of behavioral consultants.
Occupational Therapy (OT)
Petitioner raised the somewhat unusual argument that the District failed to offer a FAPE because it offered him too much OT in a letter dated February 19, 2003. Both the April and December 2002 IEPs offered OT for 45 minutes per week, with an additional 60 minutes per month of OT consultation. Occupational therapist Betsy Rigotti testified that this was the amount of OT she recommended for STUDENT because a 45-minute session would address his needs but would not be too demanding for a child his age.
After the December 2002 IEP team failed to reach agreement, District staff met with STUDENT’s parents and SI staff on February 5, 2003. The PARENTS and SI staff presented their proposal to the District for SI to provide STUDENT’s program. In response, Mr. Rezowalli sent PARENTS a letter dated February 19, 2003. In an attempt to reach a compromise with the parents, Mr. Rezowalli’s letter contained the District’s counter-offer to the PARENTS’ proposal of February 5. (Pet. Exh. 9.) The offer contained in Mr. Rezowalli’s letter specified OT for two 45-minute sessions per week, which appears to be double the previous amount of direct OT services STUDENT had received.
Petitioner stipulated that the offer of OT in the December 2002 IEPs was appropriate. That IEP offer was never withdrawn and covered the period from December 2002 to the end of the school year in June 2003. (Dist. Exhs. 5003-5024; testimony of Mr. Rezowalli.) Because the District continued to offer appropriate OT services for the period from December 2002 to June 2003, the Hearing Officer need not review whether the February 19, 2003 letter offered a FAPE. So long as the District made an ongoing and appropriate IEP offer of OT services, the District remained free to negotiate with the parents in an attempt to resolve the parties’ dispute.
Because the District’s December 2002 IEP made an appropriate offer of OT, the District’s compromise proposal of February 2003 is not analyzed. Accordingly, Petitioner’s claim that the proposed amount of OT was inappropriate does not succeed.
Adaptive Physical Therapy (APE)
Like Petitioner’s above claim regarding OT, Petitioner argues that a denial of FAPE occurred because Mr. Rezowalli’s February 19, 2003 letter failed to offer APE services. The District offered APE as part of the IEP on December 10, 2002, and Petitioner does not dispute the appropriateness of the APE services offered at that time. The District’s December 2002 IEP offer had not been withdrawn and constituted the District’s FAPE offer to STUDENT until the end of the regular 2002-2003 school year in June 2003. Regarding Mr. Rezowalli’s February 19, 2003 letter, this Decision has already concluded that the letter was a counter-offer to the parents’ request on February 5 for an SI program. So long as the District made an ongoing and appropriate IEP offer of APE services in the December 2002 IEP, the District remained free to negotiate with the parents in an attempt to resolve the parties’ dispute.
Because the District’s December 2002 IEP made an appropriate offer of APE, the District’s compromise proposal of February 2003 is not analyzed. Accordingly, there was no denial of FAPE regarding the offer of APE services.
In light of the findings that the April and December 2002 IEP offers regarding the LASS-1 classroom, BAI in-home ABA program, OT services and APE services were appropriate, the Hearing Officer finds that the District substantively offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002 ESY and 2002-2003 school year. The sole finding of denial of FAPE was due to a procedural violation which occurred at the IEP meeting on December 10, 2002.
(2) Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement and/or compensatory education as a result of denial of FAPE?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).) In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting relief. (Burlington, supra; Student W. v. Puyallup School District, supra.)
In the present case, the sole finding of denial of a FAPE concerned a procedural violation at the IEP meeting on December 10, 2002, when the District failed to include STUDENT’s regular education preschool teacher in the IEP team meeting. The procedural denial of a FAPE infringed on the parents’ participation in reaching a decision about the classroom placement. The IEP meeting did not concern Petitioner’s in-home program; at the time of the meeting, Petitioner’s parents had not yet reported any dissatisfaction with BAI as the in-home program provider.
Petitioner’s parents seek reimbursement for their costs in providing STUDENT’s in-home program, but do not seek any reimbursement for costs related to providing services in substitution for STUDENT’s classroom placement. Accordingly, reimbursement for the ABA program by Synergistic Interventions (SI) is not an appropriate remedy for the procedural denial of a FAPE.
Therefore, a remedy of prospective educational services to compensate STUDENT for the denial of a FAPE is warranted. Petitioner requested compensatory education as a remedy, but the parties offered no evidence as to what compensatory services would be appropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer considers that, because the procedural denial of a FAPE affected the parents’ participation in the IEP team meeting wherein the team attempted to find an appropriate classroom placement for STUDENT, the denial of a FAPE arguably had some effect on the team’s ability to reach agreement regarding the classroom placement, although obviously other factors contributed to the team’s inability to reach agreement. The December 10, 2002 IEP offered a classroom placement from December 2002 to mid-June 2003. Thus, a remedy should compensate STUDENT for part of the benefit he lost from being out of a partial-day special education classroom placement for that period of approximately six months, not counting school vacations. Considering the length of the period that STUDENT was out of the special education class and considering also that STUDENT presumably will receive his compensatory education in addition to a full program of classroom time, in-home services and DIS, the Hearing Officer finds that thirty (30) hours of compensatory education is an appropriate compensatory remedy for the denial of FAPE at the December 2002 IEP meeting.
The nature and type of compensatory education shall be determined by the IEP team, but shall be designed to address STUDENT’s needs and loss of educational opportunity due to his absence from the classroom from December 2002 to June 2003. The thirty hours may be delivered over the course of the 2003 ESY and/or 2003-2004 school year. The IEP team shall plan that STUDENT’s receipt of the compensatory services shall be completed no later than June 2004. The District may provide this compensatory education using it own staff or staff from other LEAs, or may contract with outside providers, but is not required to utilize outside providers.
(3) What are the appropriate educational placement, program and services for STUDENT for the summer 2003 extended school year (ESY)?
At the beginning of the hearing, the District moved to dismiss this issue on the grounds that the 2003 ESY was not yet ripe because the District had not yet held an IEP meeting to offer a program for the 2003 ESY. The Hearing Officer ordered that she would take the motion under submission and would allow the parties to present evidence during the hearing regarding whether or not the 2003 ESY issue was ripe.
The hearing convened over the period of May 13-21, 2003. Mr. Rezowalli testified that the 2003 ESY begins during the last week of June 2003. Mr. Rezowalli further testified that during the week of May 13-16, 2003, the District issued a notice for an IEP meeting scheduled for May 22, 2003, although the parents had indicated that they needed the meeting to be rescheduled to another date. Given that the District had not yet made its ESY offer but planned to do so at an upcoming IEP meeting, the issue of the District’s offer for the 2003 ESY is not yet ripe.
ORDER
1. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall notice an IEP meeting for the purpose of adding to STUDENT’s IEP the thirty (30) hours of compensatory education awarded herein, to remedy the procedural denial of FAPE at the IEP meeting on December 10, 2002. The IEP team shall plan that STUDENT’s receipt of those thirty hours be completed no later than June 2004. The District may provide this compensatory education using it own staff or staff from other LEAs, or may contract with outside providers, but is not required to utilize outside providers or any particular outside provider.
2. All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
(1) Did the District offer or provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002 extended school year (ESY) and 2002-2003 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue, except to the limited extent that Petitioner prevailed regarding a claim of procedural denial of FAPE at the IEP meeting on December 10, 2002.
(2) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education and/or reimbursement as a result of denial of a FAPE?
The District prevailed on this issue, except to the limited extent that Petitioner is entitled to thirty hours of compensatory educational services to remedy a procedural denial of a FAPE.
(3) What are the appropriate educational placement, program and services for STUDENT for the summer 2003 extended school year (ESY)?
The District prevailed in its argument this issue was not yet ripe. Because the Hearing Officer did not reach the underlying issue, neither party prevailed on the underlying issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: July 7, 2003 ___________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. It is also relevant that, because of STUDENT’s attendance in LASS-1 for two years, the parents were thoroughly familiar with that class. 2. In an e-mail dated September 29, 2002, the PARENTS wrote that they had “lost confidence in Ms. Berryhill as a teacher” and felt that she “has not delivered the services we expected of her.” (Pet. Exh. 113.) 3. The District argues in its closing brief that Ms. Coxe fulfilled this requirement because she has a multiple subject credential. This argument does not succeed. Given that many special education teachers and administrators likewise hold regular education credentials, it is obvious that the relevant State and federal statutes would not have specified that a “regular education teacher” must attend if such requirement could be fulfilled by special education teachers who possess a regular education credential. Moreover, Ms. Coxe was not a “regular education teacher of the pupil” as section 56341(b) specifies.
4. Petitioner did not specifically raise this as a procedural claim at the beginning of the hearing or in his closing brief. However, the facts warranted addressing this topic as a procedural claim.
5.. Petitioner did not raise any procedural claims regarding the April 2002 IEP, and stipulated at the hearing that the April 2002 IEP was appropriate. 6. The District argues that, at the time of STUDENT’s removal from LASS-1, District staff were still working to facilitate STUDENT’s transition in November 2002, consistent with the fall 2002 transition period in the April 2002 IEP. A determination of whether a November 2002 transition would likely have occurred would be mere speculation at this time, and therefore this Decision does not make a determination on that point. 7. As discussed below, the LASS-1 classroom was appropriate for STUDENT. Therefore, the failure to move him to LASS-2 in September/October 2002 did not result in a loss of educational opportunity for the student. 8. Evidence of STUDENT’s progress in LASS-1 during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years is well-documented and not in dispute. (See, e.g, Dist. Exhs. 5045-5059.) 9. Several witnesses testified to their opinions about STUDENT’s crying behavior when he initially returned to LASS-1 in September 2002. (Testimony of FATHER, Ms. Berryhill, Ms. Buckley; Pet. Exh. 114.) In light of STUDENT’s age and unique needs, nothing in the witness testimony persuaded the Hearing Officer that STUDENT’s crying behavior in September 2002 was related to inappropriateness of the placement. 10. Moreover, STUDENT had opportunities for socialization with and modeling by typically developing peers during his attendance at Sonshine. 11. Because mainstreaming is not the issue here, neither party has argued for analysis pursuant to these standards. 12. To this extent, Petitioner argued that any progress STUDENT made from July through October 2002 was actually the result of learning that took place in his in-home program, not his attendance in LASS-1.
