California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 8, 1999

Student v. Glendale Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 419-99, SN 316-99 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Glendale Unified must fund a second weekly OT session, reimburse private OT, and pay half of private preschool costs.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 7 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes an earlier student-filed case, SN 1545-97, which the parent withdrew on October 13, 1998. It records no later history for this case.

Summary

The parent and Glendale Unified School District each filed for hearing, and the cases were consolidated. The student was a preschooler with a chromosomal condition that delayed her development in every area. Her IEP gave her one weekly session of occupational therapy (OT). Her parent paid for a second weekly session at Children's Hospital Los Angeles. She also enrolled the child three mornings a week at Discoveryland, a private preschool for typically developing children.

The Hearing Officer found that the student needed two weekly OT sessions. Treatment records showed that the District-funded therapists at the Center for Developing Kids rarely worked on her feeding, oral-motor, and self-care goals. Because of that, their view that a second session would not help was not credible. The parent was reimbursed for the private OT, mileage, and parking.

Of the District's 1998-1999 placement offers, only the Lincoln special day class was found appropriate. College View required too long a day and had no typically developing peers on site. Villa Esperanza would not accept a student who could not walk independently. There was too little evidence about Cerritos. Offering about five different placements across a letter and an IEP was a "smorgasbord" rather than a clear offer. This violated Union School District v. Smith and denied FAPE. Discoveryland helped the student but provided no special education instruction, and both sides shared fault. The District must therefore pay half its cost. Reimbursement for two independent assessments was denied because the District's own assessments were appropriate.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith to an IEP that listed several different placements: offering multiple options did not count as a clear, specific written offer. It also shows a Hearing Officer giving less weight to treating therapists who had not worked on IEP goals, and splitting private preschool costs on equitable grounds.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Does STUDENT require two hours weekly of individual occupational therapy (OT)?

    The student needs two weekly OT sessions. The treating therapists' contrary view was not credible because they rarely worked on her feeding, oral-motor, and self-care goals.

  2. Issue 2. Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private OT, including transportation and parking?

    The private OT at Children's Hospital Los Angeles came from a qualified therapist and targeted self-help and feeding, so the parent is reimbursed for it plus mileage and parking.

  3. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3A. Did the district offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year? A. Was the District's placement substantively appropriate?

    Only the Lincoln special day class was appropriate. College View and Villa Esperanza were not appropriate or available (six-hour day, segregated site, mobility licensing limits), and the evidence on Cerritos was too thin to find it appropriate.

  4. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3B. Did the District commit procedural errors that resulted in the denial of a FAPE to STUDENT?

    Offering several different placements in a letter and an IEP was a 'smorgasbord' rather than a clear, specific offer. This violated Union v. Smith and denied FAPE.

  5. Issue 4. Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attending Discoveryland, a private preschool program?

    Discoveryland met some of the student's needs and gave her benefit, but it offered no specialized instruction. Both parties shared fault, so the District pays half the cost.

  6. Issue 5a. Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent psychological assessment by Sandra Kaler, R.N., Ph.D.?

    The District's May 1997 multidisciplinary assessment met Education Code section 56320, so the parent's request for reimbursement was denied.

  7. Issue 5b. Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent occupational therapy assessment by Rosemond Seligson, OTR?

    Qualified therapists completed the District's OT assessments using multiple methods, and they were appropriate, so the parent's request for reimbursement was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to indicate that the student is entitled to two weekly sessions of OT. The District may contract with the current private provider or add a weekly session with the current therapist.
  • Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof, the District must reimburse the actual costs of OT provided by Children's Hospital Los Angeles, plus mileage at the District employee rate and parking, consistent with the invoices in Student's Exhibit 24. No dollar total is stated.
  • Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof, the District must reimburse one-half of the actual costs of Discoveryland Preschool for the 1998-1999 school year, including extended school year, consistent with Student's Exhibit 24. Mileage is reimbursed at the District employee rate. Tuition was $252 per month, and no total is stated.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. Texas Board of Education; Zobrest v. Catalina Foothills School Dist.; Mill Valley Elementary School Dist. v. Eastin

People named in the decision

  • Susan Melly, coordinator of special education, Glendale Unified School District
  • Donna Reed, paralegal for District counsel, Office of Karen E. Gilyard
  • Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer (present as observer on first two days), Special Education Hearing Office
  • Pamela Anderson, physical therapist (nonpublic agency); completed District PT assessment, Center for Developing Kids
  • Ann Hyde, occupational therapist, OTR (nonpublic agency); completed initial OT assessment, Center for Developing Kids
  • Lisa Perschel McCann, treating occupational therapist, OTR (nonpublic agency); District witness, Center for Developing Kids
  • Diane Howard, one-to-one educational services provider (nonpublic agency); witness, Education Spectrum
  • Jodi Ossen, former attorney for Student
  • Sun-Joung An, treating occupational therapist, OTR; District witness, Glendale Adventist Medical Center
  • Emily Levine, private occupational therapist, OTR; independent assessor, Children's Hospital Los Angeles
  • Janyce Johnson, occupational therapist, OTR; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
  • Rosemond Seligson, occupational therapist, OTR; independent assessor
  • Sandra Kaler, R.N., Ph.D., clinical child psychologist in private practice; independent assessor and witness for Student
  • Carol Walker, student's pediatrician, M.D.; witness for Student
  • Enid Kohn, oversees District preschool assessment team; District witness, Glendale Unified School District
  • Timothy Walker, special education coordinator and principal of College View; District witness, Glendale Unified School District
  • Paula Nakaya, special day class teacher, College View, Glendale Unified School District
  • Linda Davis, director of private preschool; witness, Discoveryland Preschool
  • Jean Johnson, Ph.D., director of childhood education (nonpublic school), Villa Esperanza
  • Ellen Turner, school psychologist; District assessor, Glendale Unified School District
  • Rosalind Engman, assisted with pre-academic assessment, Glendale Unified School District
  • Michele A. Hamilton, speech-language pathologist, C.C.C.; District assessor, Glendale Unified School District
  • Linda Engholm, adapted physical education specialist; District assessor, Glendale Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Glendale, California, on May 20 and 21, and July 22 and 23, 1999. STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Carol Hickman Graham. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was her mother. Glendale Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Karen E. Gilyard. Also present on behalf of the District was Susan Melly, coordinator of special education. Donna Reed, paralegal for Ms. Gilyard, and Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer, were present on the first two days of hearing. Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES (1) Does STUDENT require two hours weekly of individual occupational therapy (OT)? (2) Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private OT, including transportation and parking? (3) Did the district offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-1999 school year? (4) If not, is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attending Discoveryland, a private preschool program? (5) Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments by (a) Sandra Kaler, R.N., Ph.D.? (b) Rosemond Seligson, registered occupational therapist (OTR)? BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT is a five-year-old student who is eligible for special education. She has an inverted duplication on the long arm of chromosome 15, a condition associated with delays in all areas of development. STUDENT's individualized educational program (IEP) calls for placement in a special day class (SDC) with opportunities for mainstreaming. The District contracts with a nonpublic agency (NPA) to provide STUDENT with weekly individual occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT). The District also provides individual speech and language therapy. PARENT provides STUDENT with an additional session of OT each week. She also has enrolled STUDENT in a private preschool program, Discoveryland, for three mornings each week. STUDENT is eligible for group speech and language therapy; however, she does not currently receive this service because of scheduling conflicts with the other services and the preschool program. As an infant, STUDENT received services from the Regional Center. On May 21, 1997, a transition meeting was held in anticipation of the District's assuming responsibility for STUDENT's education when she turned three years old on August 26, 1997. PARENT consented to the District's proposed plan for its initial assessment of STUDENT. On June 13, 1997, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss the results of the assessment and to develop goals and objectives. The District's assessors found STUDENT functioning at the one-year-old level in speech and language, at the 17-month level in pre-academic skills, at the 16-month level in fine and gross motor areas, at the 26-month level in social, emotional, and vocational skills, and at the 22-month level in self-help skills. (District's Exhibit 6) PARENT requested a PT assessment and an opportunity to review the proposed IEP goals and objectives prior to consenting to them. The IEP states that PARENT would contact the District to resume the IEP meeting once the PT assessment had been completed. In July 1997, STUDENT began receiving PT from Pamela Anderson, physical therapist, at the Center for Developing Kids (CDK). (Regional Center initially funded STUDENT's PT.) Ms. Anderson completed STUDENT's PT assessment on behalf of the District. On September 2, 1997, the IEP team reconvened to revise STUDENT's current levels of performance, goals, and objectives, and to discuss a classroom placement for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year. STUDENT's initial IEP in the District called for the following services: individual speech and language therapy two times weekly in sessions of 30 minutes each, weekly PT for 60 minutes, direct OT three times a month in sessions of 60 minutes each, monthly OT consultation in class, and adapted physical education (APE), as needed. STUDENT's mother declined transportation services and elected to transport STUDENT herself to the various services she was receiving. The District proposed several possible classroom placements for PARENT to consider for STUDENT. The IEP team met again on September 5, 1997, at which time PARENT consented to STUDENT's placement four days each week in a full inclusion preschool program at Cerritos Elementary School. In September 1997, STUDENT began OT with Ann Hyde, registered occupational therapist (OTR), at the CDK. On September 16, 1997, STUDENT enrolled in the full-inclusion preschool class at Cerritos. STUDENT was accompanied to the class by a one-to-one aide. The IEP called for STUDENT's regular education teacher to meet with a special education teacher at least one time each week to plan STUDENT's program. On approximately December 1, 1997, PARENT withdrew STUDENT from the Cerritos class. PARENT believed that STUDENT was regressing and that her goals and objectives were not being implemented in the class. STUDENT continued receiving OT and PT from the CDK. On December 3, 1997, PARENT requested a special education due process hearing regarding the provision of a free appropriate education (FAPE) for STUDENT. (SN 1545-97) In December 1997, Lisa Perschel McCann replaced Ms. Hyde as STUDENT's occupational therapist. In March 1998, Ms. McCann recommended that STUDENT's OT be increased to two sessions each week to address feeding skills and perceptual and fine motor development, and to continue addressing sensory integrative processing. Based on her understanding that the parties had reached an agreement regarding the appropriate levels of OT for STUDENT, Ms. McCann began providing STUDENT with two weekly OT sessions in April 1998. Also in April 1998, STUDENT began receiving one-to-one educational services from Diane Howard of Education Spectrum, an NPA. Ms. Howard worked with STUDENT to improve fine-motor skills, cognitive skills, social skills, and attention to task. Ms. Howard's services were provided for either by the Regional Center or the District. On June 3, 1998, the District scheduled an IEP meeting to conform STUDENT's IEP to the terms of a settlement agreement reached by Petitioner's former attorney, Jodi Ossen, and the District regarding the levels of OT, PT, and speech and language services the District would provide STUDENT. PARENT did not sign the settlement agreement and did not attend the IEP meeting. Instead, she informed the District that it should contact her new attorney, Ms. Graham, to reschedule the meeting. The District sent PARENT a copy of an addendum to STUDENT's IEP setting forth increases to the level of STUDENT's speech and language therapy from 30 minutes to 40 minutes, and to the level of OT and PT from one session each to two sessions each per week. PARENT did not sign the amendment to STUDENT's IEP. As a result of the lack of consent to increase the services, Ms. McCann reduced STUDENT's OT to one weekly session beginning in June 1998. The District wrote several letters to PARENT asking her to sign the IEP and, in a letter to Ms. Graham dated September 8, 1998, Ms. Gilyard reiterated the terms of the unsigned settlement agreement and reiterated the District's offer of class placements for STUDENT: The more intensive FAPE offered is the six (6) hour, forty-eight week preschool special day class located at College View School. The less intensive FAPE offered is the three (3) hour a day, four (4) days a week special day class at Cerritos Elementary School which includes opportunities for mainstreaming into a regular preschool class located on the same site for up to three (3) hours each day. (Please note that this option is also available at Verdugo Woodlands Elementary School.). (District's Exhibit 23) On September 23, 1998, PARENT withdrew STUDENT from Education Spectrum. In early October 1998, PARENT enrolled STUDENT in Discoveryland. STUDENT began attending three mornings each week. Discoveryland serves typically developing children of preschool age. The school is licensed but is not certified to provide special education. STUDENT is in a group with five to seven other children. On October 13, 1998, PARENT withdrew her request for hearing in case number SN 1545-97. On October 29, 1998, the District convened an IEP meeting. Ms. McCann recommended that STUDENT receive weekly OT. PARENT requested that someone other than Ms. McCann provide STUDENT's OT. The IEP meeting was suspended after lengthy discussions regarding services and placement. On November 18, 1998, the IEP team reconvened. The IEP calls for STUDENT to receive two 50-minute sessions weekly of individual speech and language therapy, one 15- to 30-minute session weekly of small-group speech and language therapy, 50 minutes of individual OT weekly, two 50-minute sessions weekly of individual PT, and reimbursement for the costs PARENT incurs transporting STUDENT to OT, PT, and speech and language therapy. The District offered to place STUDENT in a special day class (SDC) at College View or Lincoln Elementary Schools within the District in with opportunities for interactions with typically developing peers in an afternoon preschool program two to three times weekly. The District also offered to place STUDENT in Villa Esperanza, a nonpublic school. Additionally, the District offered the following: Assistant with consultation from special education teacher provided to support the current preschool where STUDENT is enrolled (pending District's ability to observe classroom/school, determine appropriateness of placement and determine whether IEP could adequately be implemented - Parent would assume cost of program as the District has placement options available). (Student's Exhibit 2) PARENT was provided an opportunity to visit the proposed programs. She did not find appropriate any of the placements offered by the District; however, on December 9, 1998, she consented to implementation of certain portions of the IEP. An amendment to the IEP indicates that PARENT concurred with goals and objectives and consented to STUDENT's receiving OT, PT, and speech and language therapy pursuant to the IEP. She also agreed to the District's offer to reimburse her for transporting STUDENT to and from therapy sessions and to STUDENT's receiving services 47 weeks annually. From December 1998 until March 1999, STUDENT received OT from Sun-Joung An, OTR, at Glendale Adventist Medical Center. Beginning in February 1999, PARENT has provided for STUDENT to receive one additional hour weekly of OT from Emily Levine of Children's Hospital Los Angeles. On March 8, 1999, Ms. Graham requested a due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT. (SN 316-99) On March 22, 1999, the District requested a due process hearing on the issue of FAPE. (SN 419-99) The matters were consolidated. PARENT waived mediation and the matter proceeded to hearing. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ISSUE NO. 1: Does STUDENT require two hours weekly of occupational therapy (OT)? Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C.  1400; California Education Code  56000.) The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student's individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C.  1401(a)(18). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student's individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provided instruction or services that maximize the students' abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 207-208.) Occupational therapy is included in the list of related services available to the student. (footnote 1) Thus, the District is required to provide STUDENT with OT as a related service if OT is necessary for STUDENT to benefit educationally from her instructional program. California Education Code  56363. Occupational therapy is provided to address: (A) Improving, developing or restoring functions impaired or lost through illness, injury, or deprivation; (B) Improving ability to perform tasks for independent functioning if functions are impaired or lost; and (C) Preventing, through early intervention, initial or further impairment or loss of function. 34 C.F.R. 300.24(b)(5)((ii)(A) and (B). The parties agree that for STUDENT to benefit from her special education, she requires the related service of OT. Accordingly, STUDENT's IEP includes OT as a related service. The following also is undisputed: STUDENT has significant deficits in motor skills, sensory integrative functions, and self-care/daily-living skills; STUDENT receives one weekly session of OT, among other services, to address these deficits; and current OT goals and objectives are appropriate. PARENT has consented to STUDENT's receiving one weekly session of OT at the CDK, which is paid for by the District; however, it is PARENT's position that a single weekly session of OT is insufficient. She currently provides an additional session weekly of OT for STUDENT. PARENT testified that based on her observations she concluded that the CDK therapists have not been able to address all of STUDENT's OT goals and objectives during the single weekly OT session. Specifically, PARENT testified that the therapists are not addressing STUDENT's needs related to feeding. She testified that a second session weekly of OT also is necessary to allow STUDENT to progress toward meeting goals and objectives. She asserts that because of STUDENT's cognitive delays and attentional problems, she requires repetition to learn. As to assertions that STUDENT did not show an increased rate of growth during the period she received two sessions of OT from CDK, PARENT testified that six weeks was an insufficient period in which to evaluate STUDENT's ability to benefit from an additional session of OT, given STUDENT's disabilities. Several occupational therapists have also recommended that STUDENT receive two weekly sessions of OT. Janyce Johnson, OTR, testified in support of STUDENT's need for "at least" two weekly sessions of OT. In Ms. Johnson's opinion, STUDENT's goals and objectives "absolutely could not be met in one weekly session of OT." Ms. Johnson testified that one session is necessary to address STUDENT's self-help skills and a second session is necessary to address STUDENT's sensory integration difficulties. Ms. Johnson stated that sensory integration is necessary to bring STUDENT's senses together to improve her overall functioning. Ms. Johnson testified that two sessions would be sufficient only if OT is coordinated with the other services STUDENT receives, such as speech and language, PT, and APE, and if these services provide opportunities for STUDENT to follow up on the skills she is learning in OT. Ms. Johnson also concurred with PARENT's testimony that a period of six weeks is not long enough for STUDENT to learn a task, given her developmental levels and the fact that she has deficits in all major areas or development. Ms. Johnson stated that STUDENT first must be taught a skill and then practice the skill until she is able to perform it in all environments. Ms. Johnson's opinions are based on the OT assessment she conducted of STUDENT on June 11, 1999. The assessment was completed at the request of PARENT. (See Student's Exhibit 36) Emily Levine, OTR, assessed STUDENT on February 9, 1999, at the request of PARENT and, since that date, has provided STUDENT with one hour weekly of private OT. In the report of her assessment, Ms. Levine recommended that STUDENT receive OT one to two times each week to improve adaptive, fine-motor, self-help, play, oral-motor, and visual-motor skills. (Student's Exhibit 9) In the report of another assessment obtained by PARENT in September 1998, Rosemond Seligson, OTR, recommended two sessions weekly to provide sensory integration activities and a third session weekly to "develop and strengthen skills in the areas of self-help, fine motor and cognitive functioning." (Student's Exhibit 10) Occupational therapists from the CDK who have provided OT to STUDENT testified in support of the District's position that STUDENT would not benefit from an additional weekly session of OT. The return to one weekly session of OT in October 1998 was based on the recommendation of Lisa Peschel McCann, OTR, STUDENT's therapist from the winter of 1997 to October of 1998. Ms. McCann testified that the basis for her recommendation was the lack of progress STUDENT made during the two-month period in the spring of 1998 when she provided STUDENT with two sessions weekly of OT. At all other times, Ms. McCann had provided STUDENT with one weekly session. In fact, Ms. McCann testified that STUDENT's rate of progress was unaffected by the number of sessions she received weekly. (See also Student's Exhibit 12) Ms. An, who provided STUDENT's OT from winter of 1998 to spring of 1999, also testified that STUDENT would not benefit from an increase to the number of weekly OT sessions. Ms. An reached this conclusion based on STUDENT's lack of demonstrated progress during the period she provided her with OT. Ms. An described having difficulty with sustaining STUDENT's attention and with her behavior. As to whether OT with the CDK has addressed all of STUDENT's goals and objectives, Ms. McCann wrote in October 1998, that IEP goals and objectives to improve STUDENT's feeding independence and oral-motor skills had "not been consistently worked on in treatment sessions." (Student's Exhibit 12) During testimony, Ms. McCann explained that the primary reason feeding was not consistently addressed during OT was that PARENT did not provide food or utensils to be used during OT. Ms. An testified that she worked with STUDENT on activities to improve fine- and gross-motor skills and self-care skills. She also engaged STUDENT in activities related to sensory processing and gravitational insecurity. STUDENT's initial IEP dated September 5, 1997, included goals and objectives to improve STUDENT's self-help skills. Objectives addressed, among other things, toilet training and feeding. For example, objectives regarding feeding call for STUDENT to learn to finger feed, eat with a spoon, and drink from a cup. STUDENT's IEP drafted June 3, 1998, included a goal to improve "self feeding independence and oral motor skill." One objective was for STUDENT to "pick up finger foods & bring them to her mouth and place them in her mouth with physical prompting 10 times in a mealtime session 100% of the time by 3/99." A second objective was for STUDENT to "bite off a piece of cracker, chew, and swallow it with supervision 100% of the time by 3/99." (District's Exhibit 21) STUDENT's current IEP includes OT goals to improve adaptive skills, self-feeding, independence, oral motor skills, motor planning abilities, undressing and dressing, visual attention, and focus on a task. An additional goal is to normalize motoric responses to the sensory environment. Each goal has two or three objectives. (Student's Exhibit 2) The daily treatment records maintained contemporaneously by STUDENT's occupational therapist from December 15, 1997, through March 16, 1998, show that during 13 OT sessions in that period, self-care and oral-motor areas were addressed one time each and feeding was not addressed at all. For the period from March 23, 1998, through May 28, 1998, which included a total of 14 sessions, self-care skills were addressed one time, oral-motor skills were addressed four times, and feeding was address three times. During 11 sessions from June 1, 1998, through July 30, 1998, self-care skills were not addressed, while oral-motor and feeding skills were each addressed twice. In seven sessions from September 8, 1998, through October 29, 1998, self-care skills were addressed three times and oral-motor and feeding skills were each addressed one time. Thus, during 45 OT sessions spanning ten months, self-care skills were addressed a total of four times, oral-motor skills were addressed eight times, and feeding was addressed six times, whereas all other areas were addressed consistently. As a matter of fact, nearly all other goals and objectives were addressed at each and every OT session. (See District's Exhibit 40) Ms. McCann's testimony confirms that she did not consistently address feeding skills, in particular. She attributed her failure to address STUDENT's needs in this area or to meet STUDENT's goals and objectives to the fact that PARENT did not always bring the necessary food or utensils to the therapy sessions to address feeding. While it may be desirable to employ utensils similar to those used at home and to use foods STUDENT likes, STUDENT's right to receive appropriate services and services called for by her IEP cannot be contingent upon PARENT's providing materials. By her own testimony, Ms. An acknowledged that she also did not address STUDENT's goals and objectives related to feeding. Conspicuously absent from the list of things she testified she addressed during OT with STUDENT were oral-motor skills and feeding. The testimony and documentary evidence establish that the OT STUDENT received from CDK did not address all of her goals and objectives and was not designed to meet her needs in the areas of feeding, oral-motor development, and self-help. Additionally, the evidence establishes that while STUDENT has made growth in some areas of development, including communication, attention to task, fine-motor skills, social skills, and pre-academic tasks, she has not made commensurate growth in self-care/daily living skills. STUDENT's skills in these areas generally fall below the two-year-old level and her eating and toileting skills remain significantly delayed. (Testimony of Ms. Howard; Student's Exhibit 20) Ms. Johnson provided information regarding STUDENT's current daily living skills. During her assessment of STUDENT in June 1999, Ms. Johnson observed that STUDENT was able to eat soft table foods; however, she was unable to munch a cracker, finger feed, eat chunky solid foods, or indicate her pants were wet. (See also Student's Exhibit 36) In a report prepared by Emily Levine, OTR, in February 1999, she stated, "STUDENT is only able to eat food that is pureed or finely chopped, and drink thin liquids. She is not able to bite or chew." (Student's Exhibit 9) In summary, ordinarily the Hearing Officer gives considerable weight to the treating therapists in determining an appropriate level of therapy for a student. The facts in this case compel finding otherwise. Their conclusions regarding the frequency of OT STUDENT requires was not credible because they, in effect, admit failing to regularly address key goals and objectives. Despite STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives calling for OT to address oral-motor functioning, eating, and toileting skills, the evidence establishes that the occupational therapists did not consistently provide STUDENT with instruction in these areas. As a result, STUDENT has shown little growth in eating and other self-care skills, and continues to exhibit significant deficits in even the most rudimentary skills necessary to develop independent eating and toileting skills. There is no evidence that STUDENT's needs have changed since March 1998, when Ms. McCann recommended that STUDENT receive two sessions weekly of OT. (See District's Exhibit 18) Moreover, the recommendation for one therapy session is based on Ms. McCann's perception that STUDENT's rate of growth was the same while receiving two sessions of OT as when receiving only one sessionweekly of OT. The Hearing Officer also finds persuasive the testimony that STUDENT did not receive two weekly sessions of OT for a long enough period of time from which to draw valid conclusions about her ability to benefit from two sessions. Finally, federal special education law sets forth the rationale for providing OT as a related service. Specifically, federal regulations call for OT to be provided to improve the student's ability to perform tasks for independent functions. Federal regulations also recognize the need for early intervention as to OT in particular. In this case, it is noted that STUDENT is a preschool student with significant deficits. Without specific instruction in basic feeding, toileting, and self-help skills, STUDENT will not attain independence in even the most basic skills. Therefore, based on all of the evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that two sessions weekly of OT are necessary to addresses STUDENT's fine- and gross-motor deficits, sensory integration dysfunctions, feeding and other self-help/daily living needs, and to allow her to benefit from her education. To meet STUDENT's current need for two OT sessions weekly, the District may either contract with her current private provider or arrange to have an additional weekly session with her current therapist provided by the District. ISSUE NO 2: Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private OT, including transportation and parking? Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. PARENT is seeking reimbursement for weekly sessions of OT she procured for STUDENT from Children's Hospital Los Angeles beginning in February 1999. It has been concluded above that STUDENT requires two weekly sessions of OT. Private OT is provided by Emily Levine, who is a registered occupational therapist. PARENT testified that during OT, Ms. Levine addresses STUDENT's dressing and eating deficits. Another goal of her therapy is to develop STUDENT's pincer grasp. (See Student's Exhibit 8) The evidence establishes that the therapy is provided by a qualified individual and that the therapy is designed to address STUDENT's deficits in self-help and feeding. For these reasons, it is concluded that the therapy is designed to provide STUDENT benefit. PARENT is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the weekly OT, including round-trip transportation at the rate the District reimburses its employees for mileage and the costs of parking. The District shall reimburse PARENT for the actual costs consistent with the invoices provided in Student's Exhibit 24. ISSUE NO. 3: Did the district offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-1999 school year? Under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. (20 U.S.C.  1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.) In determining whether the school district has offered a FAPE, the focus is on the adequacy of the district's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307. If the district has offered a FAPE, the district is not required to place the student in the program preferred by the parents, even if their preferred program is likely to result in greater educational benefit to the student than the district's program. Id. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents' participation in the IEP process may result in the denial of a free appropriate public education to the student. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479. PARENT contends that the District's offer of placement for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year was substantively and procedurally deficient. PARENT asserts that, substantively, the District's placement failed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs. PARENT asserts that to meet STUDENT's needs, she required placement in a private preschool program for typically developing children and five hours weekly of individual instruction by a credentialed special education teacher. PARENT asserts that the District's offer of placement was also procedurally flawed because STUDENT's IEP did not delineate the amount of mainstreaming proposed for STUDENT and also did not identify where mainstreaming would occur. The District contends that the SDC at College View, Lincoln, or Cerritos Elementary Schools, or at Villa Esperanza (a nonpublic school) with mainstreaming opportunities and the related services of speech and language, OT, and PT offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year. A. Was the District's placement substantively appropriate? STUDENT's Needs To determine whether the District offered a special education placement and services designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs, it is first necessary to understand STUDENT's unique and individual needs. All of the witnesses described STUDENT similarly in that she exhibits delays in all areas of development. The testimony of witnesses and the results of testing establish that STUDENT's language skills fall at or below the two-year-old level. (Testimony of Dr. Kaler, a clinical child psychologist in private practice; Student's Exhibits 6 and 9) There is no dispute that STUDENT requires individual and small-group speech and language therapy to address language deficits. There also is no dispute that STUDENT requires individual OT and PT. The appropriate levels and frequencies of PT and speech and language therapy is not at issue, and it has been determined above that STUDENT requires two weekly sessions of OT to address her needs. (Testimony of Ms. McCann, Ms. An, and Ms. Johnson; See also Student's Exhibits 8, 9, 10, 12, and 13) Ms. Howard testified that STUDENT's greatest area of need is learning to pay attention to task and that for this reason STUDENT requires one-to-one instruction to learn a new task. STUDENT also requires sufficient personnel to be available to assist her because of limited mobility, the potential for seizures, and the possibility of reflux or regurgitation as a result of improper consumption of food. (Testimony of Carol Walker, STUDENT's pediatrician, PARENT, and Ms. McCann) The evidence also establishes that because of STUDENT's distractibility, she requires a class with a small number of students. STUDENT was described by most witnesses as "social." Ms. Howard and Dr. Kaler, in particular, testified that STUDENT can benefit from participation in activities with typically developing children for social development. In summary, STUDENT requires an educational program that offers individual instruction, small class size, low student-to-teacher ratio, and opportunities to mainstream for social interactions with typically developing students. Each of the District's proposed placements is addressed below to determine whether the placement was designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs, was designed to provide her with educational benefit, and whether the placement conformed with her IEP. Because related services are not at issue, they will not be discussed below. COLLEGE VIEW The testimony of Enid Kohn, who oversees the District's preschool assessment team, and Timothy Walker, special education coordinator and principal of College View, establishes the following regarding the SDC taught by Paula Nakaya at College View. The class met six hours daily and focused on students' developing life skills and socialization skills. There was a maximum of 12 students in the class. The students ranged in age from three- to five-years-old and had physical disabilities, autism, and varying cognitive abilities. Two students had behavioral disorders. The class was taught by a credentialed special education teacher. There were two assistants for the physically handicapped (APH) and another assistant to provide one-to-one instruction to a specific child in the classroom. The APHs had received specific training to meet the physical and health needs of students with physical disabilities, including toileting and feeding. District witnesses Ms. Kohn and Mr. Walker testified that the SDC would have met STUDENT's unique and individual needs. Mr. Walker testified that the students offered STUDENT age and cognitively appropriate peers. Ms. Kohn additionally testified that College View was appropriate for STUDENT because she required an intensive program and had a number of goals and objectives that would have been met best by a longer school day. PARENT testified that College View was not appropriate because it is a segregated school site and, therefore, did not provide opportunities for STUDENT to integrate with typically developing peers on site. PARENT observed College View for approximately one hour when STUDENT was three years old. Carol Walker, M.D., STUDENT's pediatrician, testified that a five-hour program would have been detrimental for STUDENT, given her young age and her multiple disabilities. Dr. Walker testified that adding five hours of school to STUDENT's day, which already was filled with a number of other sevices (OT, PT, and speech and langauge) would have made her day very long. Dr. Walker raised valid concerns regarding the appropriateness of College View's program. During the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT was only four years old. It should be noted that, according the the Education Code, group services provided to preschool children shall not exceed four hours per day, unless determined otherwise by the IEP team. (Education Code  56441.3(b)) There has been no determination by the IEP team that STUDENT requires a five-hour school day. The evidence also did not establish that STUDENT requires a full day educational program. In fact, a long school day may have been detrimental to her because of her young age, her short attention span, and the nature and number of her disabilities. As it is, there has been difficulty finding time in STUDENT's busy schedule for her to participate in group speech and language therapy in addition to classroom instruction, OT, PT, and individual speech and language therapy. There also would have been difficulty identifying time for STUDENT to participate in a preschool program with typically developing peers unless she left the SDC while the class was in progress. Additionally, there are no regular education students at College View so there would have been no opportunities for STUDENT to develop social skills at College View and the number of students in the class is greater than the number recommended for STUDENT, given her distractibility. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that College View was not designed to meet STUDENT's needs and, therefore, did not offer her an appropriate placement for the 1998-1999 school year. LINCOLN The testimony of Ms. Howard and Ms. Kohn establishes the following regarding the SDC at Lincoln. The class had five to six students between the ages of three and five years old. The class met four days a week from approximately 8:00 a.m. to 11:30 a.m. The class was located on a campus that also had programs for typically developing students, allowing the students in the SDC to be mainstreamed during recess. Additional opportunities to interact with typically developing students occurred twice weekly when students in the regular education kindergarten class came to the SDC for play. The class was taught by a credentialed special education teacher and there was one assistant in the class. PARENT's principal concern regarding Lincoln is that the class served only students with disabilities and, therefore, would not have been appropriate for STUDENT. Both Ms. Howard and Ms. Kohn testified that Lincoln offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Their testimony establishes that the Lincoln SDC offered specialized instruction at STUDENT's developmental level. The class also offered a low student-to-teacher ratio, which allowed opportunities for the teacher, as well as the aide, to provide one-to-one instruction to STUDENT. The small class minimized the potential for STUDENT to be distracted by her environment. The class also offered opportunities for STUDENT to socialize during class periods, as well as during recesses, with typically developing peers. The fact that they were kindergarten age rather than preschool age did not render the students inappropriate peers. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Kohn and Ms. Howard persuasive as to the ability of the proposed placement at Lincoln to address STUDENT's unique and individual needs. Ms. Kohn oversees the preschool assessment team and attended STUDENT's IEP meetings in October and November 1998. For this reason, Ms. Kohn is familiar with STUDENT's needs. Ms. Howard provided STUDENT with individual educational services in 1998 and participated in STUDENT's IEP meeting in November 1998. Ms. Howard has 28 years' experience at Villa Esperanza and currently operates Education Spectrum, a nonpublic agency. Ms. Howard observed at Lincoln for approximately two hours. Ms. Howard is familiar with STUDENT's educational needs because she worked with STUDENT individually and provided her with educational instruction. The Lincoln placement also was designed to provide STUDENT with benefit. Specifically, individual instruction was available, which STUDENT required to learn pre-academic skills and to progress toward meeting goals and objectives. The opportunities for interaction with typically developing peers would have enhanced her social development. There was no dispute that placement at Lincoln conformed with STUDENT's IEP. Therefore, Lincoln satisfied the requirements of an appropriate placement as set forth in the IDEA and Rowley. CERRITOS So little information regarding the Cerritos SDC was provided that the Hearing Officer cannot determine whether it would have offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1998-1999 school year. Moreover, the offer was made in a letter from the District's attorney and was not specifically offered at the IEP meetings in October and November 1998. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not find the offer of an SDC at Cerritos appropriate. VILLA ESPERANZA The testimony of Ms. Howard establishes the following. Villa Esperanza is a certified nonpublic school (NPS) for children with disabilities. The class proposed for STUDENT convened five days a week from 9:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. It had nine students with varying disabilities. Students were developmentally delayed, autistic, and mentally retarded. There were also three to four typically developing students in the class. The class had one teacher and two assistants. Ms. Howard testified persuasively that Villa Esperanza could have provided an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it offered a structured setting, a small class size, a low student-to-teacher ratio, a special education teacher, and opportunities to interact with typically developing peers. Available at Villa Esperanza was specific instruction at STUDENT's developmental level. PARENT observed Villa Esperanza two times. She testified that during her two visits the children were screaming and banging their heads, as well as objects, on the walls. PARENT concluded that Villa Esperanza would not have been appropriate because STUDENT would have imitated their behavior. This testimony alone does not render Villa Esperanza inappropriate; however; as discussed above, a six-hour school day was inappropriate for STUDENT and a long day would not have allowed her OT, PT, and speech and language to be scheduled. Moreover, PARENT testified that the director of Villa Esperanza informed her that STUDENT would not be accepted because she was not mobile. PARENT's testimony was undisputed and was supported by a letter dated March 17, 1998, from Jean Johnson, Ph.D., director of childhood education at Villa Esperanza. The letter reads as follows: However, as I mentioned in our meeting, she [STUDENT] has very fragile ambulation abilities, and our preschool is not licensed for non-ambulatory youngsters. . . . The definition of "ambulatory" for licensing is that a person can independently exit the facility in the event of an evacuation, without requiring 1:1 assistance. (Student's Exhibit 25) The evidence establishes that during the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT required assistance with getting from a sitting position to a walking position. STUDENT also does not crawl. Thus, STUDENT would not have been accepted as a student at Villa Esperanza and it, therefore, would not have been available as a placement for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year. B. Did the District commit procedural errors that resulted in the denial of a FAPE to STUDENT? Among the procedural violations that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA's procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, 1526, cert. denied 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C.  1415(b)(3). In Union, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals stated, "this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously." The Court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parents of the need to consider seriously whether the proposed placement was appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services, and (3) so that the district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence of the appropriateness of the placement. The Court was unequivocal in stating that "this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously." Union, supra, at 1526. PARENT asserts that STUDENT's IEP is flawed in that it does not delineate the length of time the District proposed that STUDENT would participate in an educational program with typically developing peers and does not indicate where STUDENT's mainstreaming would occur should she attend College View or Lincoln Elementary Schools. Ms. Graham points to California Education Code  56345(a)(4) as standing for the proposition that the IEP must include the extent to which the student will be educated with typically developing peers. The section states that the IEP must include "an explanation of the extent, if any, to which the pupil will not participate with nondisabled pupils in regular classes and in the activities described in this section [extracurricular and other nonacademic activities]." A letter dated September 8, 1998, to Ms. Graham, STUDENT's attorney, from the District's attorney, Ms. Gilyard, sets forth two placements proposed for STUDENT. The letter states: . . .the District has offered two appropriate public educational programs for STUDENT. The more intensive FAPE offered is the six (6) hour, forty-eight (48) week preschool special day class located at College View School. The less intensive FAPE offered is the three (3) hour a day, four(4) days a week special day class at Cerritos Elementary School which includes opportunities for mainstreaming into a regular preschool class located on the same site for up to three (3) hours each day. (Emphasis added.) (District's Exhibit 23) STUDENT's IEP developed in October and November of 1998 describes the placement proposed for STUDENT as a special day class (SDC) with opportunities to interact with typically developing peers "as appropriate." The IEP identifies specific school sites at which STUDENT's IEP could be implemented: College view in collaboration with non-disabled peers interaction in another setting. Lincoln SDC in collaboration with non-disabled peer interaction in a preschool. Villa Esperanza Assistant with consultation from special education teacher provided to support the current preschool where STUDENT is enrolled (pending District's ability to observe classroom/school, determine appropriateness of placement and determine whether IEP could adequately be implemented - Parent would assume cost of program as the District has placement options available. (Emphasis added.) (Student's Exhibit 2) Noted on page 16 of the IEP is that the District-proposed interactions with typically developing peers would occur on two to three afternoons. In summary, when taken as a whole, the District's written offer of placement indicates that STUDENT will be mainstreamed two to three afternoons a week, as appropriate. The District's written offers of placement do not specify a preschool in which the interactions would occur, should STUDENT attend a school that does not have appropriate typically developing peers on site; however, Ms. Melly testified that, at the IEP meeting in November 1998, she identified several potential preschool programs that STUDENT could attend. It is clear from the transcript of the IEP meeting that two preschools were under consideration-both Lake Avenue and A Living Way Preschool were discussed with PARENT at the IEP. (District's Exhibits 42 and 43) The evidence establishes that Ms. Melly had further contact with these preschools and with PARENT regarding placing STUDENT in a preschool program. PARENT participated actively in the IEP meeting and was given a reasonably clear idea of the District's offers related to mainstreaming. Because a number of special education placements were under consideration, details related to mainstreaming were dependent upon the placement ultimately agreed upon. Additionally, the time STUDENT would have participated in a preschool needed to be coordinated with STUDENT's OT, PT, and speech and language services, which are provided at various times and locations. The Hearing Officer concludes that, taken as a whole, the somewhat imprecise statements in STUDENT's IEP regarding the time and location for mainstreaming did, standing alone, result in the denial of FAPE. However, the District's offer of multiple classrooms, school sites, and length of programs as placement options poses a more significant procedural problem. The District initially offered to place STUDENT in a half-day program in an SDC that met four days a week at Cerritos or in a six hour- per-day program in an SDC at College View. (District's Exhibit 23) The District then offered to place STUDENT in a different half-day program in an SDC at Lincoln, at College View, or in a nonpublic school (Villa Esperanza). (Student's Exhibit 2) The District's offers were located on a range of campuses, including a segregated site, a certified nonpublic school, and campuses with typically developing children of kindergarten or preschool age (Cerritos). Although these placement offers were written, they reflect a placement selection process rather than a distinct, coherent offer of placement selected to meet STUDENT's needs and to implement IEP goals and objectives. While the District's apparent goal was to accommodate the parent, it resulted in the parent's having to observe and evaluate each classroom/site and then determine which one constituted an appropriate placement. The parent cannot be assumed to have expertise in evaluating educational programs in the brief period of time allotted to observe in each class. Moreover, a smorgasbord approach is contrary to Union, and did not alleviate the District of its responsibility to make a specific written offer of placement that was designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs, provide her with educational benefit, and conformed with her IEP. Unfortunately, the District did not take the final step in the process of identifying an appropriate placement from a range of possibilities. The District is required to exercise its professional judgment by selecting and offering a specific educational placement which the District's educational experts determined was appropriate to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs. Moreover, it has been concluded above that only one of the placements proposed for STUDENT was appropriate under the IDEA and Rowley. The parent clearly cannot be required to ferret out from multiple inappropriate placements the one placement offered by the District that, in fact, could have offered her daughter an appropriate placement. The law simply does not impose such a duty to the parent. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's approach in offering a wide range of diverse placements violated the intent Union that a clear, coherent placement offer must be made. The offer must be detailed so as to demonstrate to the parent that the District has carefully thought through and selected a placement that, in its professional judgment, will meet the unique and individual needs of the student. Five varying offers does not alert the parent to seriously consider the appropriateness of the offers. Moreover, in this case, there was some confusion regarding which offers were on the table. The letter from Ms. Gilyard identified two offers of placement and the IEP describes two additional "suggestions/offers." It is unclear whether the original offers were still under consideration. The courts have continued to vigorously apply Union. See e.g. Mill Valley Elementary School District v. Eastin, No. C 98-03812 CW (N.D.Cal. filedOctober 1, 1999). Therefore, based on all of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to make a legally sufficient offer of placement for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year. To result in a denial of FAPE, any procedural violations must seriously infringe on the parent's participation in the IEP process or result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student. 960 F.2d 1479. PARENT has participated in the IEP process; however, because the District failed to make a legally sufficient offer of placement, STUDENT has not received the special education instruction she requires to address her unique needs and to provide her with educational benefit, thereby resulting in the denial of FAPE. ISSUE NO. 4: Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attending Discoveryland, a private preschool program? Because the District has failed to provide a FAPE to STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year, PARENT may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attending Discoveryland, if it is determined that STUDENT's placement was appropriate under the IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. To be appropriate, the services provided by a parent must be designed to meet the student's unique needs and to provide the student with educational benefit. Rowley 458 U.S. 176,200. However, parents are not required to provide the "perfect" placement for their children when a school district has failed to provide a FAPE. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. Texas Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161. For purposes of reimbursement, the placement provided by the parent also need not meet every requirement to be appropriate. For example, the placement need not be state-certified as a nonpublic school. Florence County School District Four v. Carter (1993) 510 U.S. 7, 14. PARENT and Linda Davis, director of Discoveryland Preschool, testified regarding STUDENT's program at Discoveryland. Ms. Davis testified that Discoveryland is owned by a church. (footnote 2) It is licensed but it is not certified to provide special education. The cost of Discoveryland is $252.00 monthly. (See also Student's Exhibit 24) STUDENT attends preschool three mornings weekly. Her mother accompanies her. STUDENT is in a class with six to eight other students who are two and three-years old. The other students are near or at STUDENT's developmental level in many areas. The teacher, who does not hold a California teaching credential, is assisted by a parent aide on approximately four days per week. Ms. Davis described Discoveryland as a "developmental program." When asked to explain, Ms. Davis stated that STUDENT engages in activities to foster developmental skills such as painting, coloring, cutting with assistance, and glueing. Ms. Davis testified that she has reviewed STUDENT's IEP and has worked on many of the goals and objectives related to play, domestic, social, pre-academic, and eating skills. At Discoveryland, STUDENT does not receive one-to-one instruction from either a credentialed teacher or from an aide who is under the supervision of such a teacher. On the other hand, the testimony of PARENT and Ms. Davis establishes that Discoveryland offers STUDENT opportunities to develop her social skills with a small group of typically developing peers. Moreover, Discoveryland provides STUDENT with activities designed to address some of her IEP goals and objectives. Based on the above, it is concluded that Discoveryland does address STUDENT's unique and individual needs to the extent possible. Because STUDENT receives a number of services to address motor and language deficits, it is difficult to attribute her progress to any single component of her program. As to STUDENT's benefitting from attending Discoveryland, Ms. Davis and PARENT testified that STUDENT has made "good" progress since enrolling in Discoveryland. Initially, STUDENT was unable to climb stairs. She now climbs with assistance and is beginning to use the railing. STUDENT has begun to imitate the other children and attempts to communicate with them. Her vocabulary has increased and she tries to string words together. STUDENT's self-confidence has increased and she is able to sit and focus for longer periods of time. This testimony is evidence that STUDENT has benefitted from attending Discoveryland. As stated above, parents may be entitled to reimbursement in cases such as this, where the school district failed to offer FAPE. In the present case, the Hearing Officer has concluded that the placement procured by PARENT is not wholly appropriate because STUDENT does not receive specialized instruction from persons with expertise in special education. The court in Alamo provides some guidance in determining what, if any, relief is appropriate. The court stated that factors to consider in determining whether to award the parent full or partial reimbursement include the existence of other, perhaps more suitable, placements, the effort expended by parent, and the cooperativeness of the school district. In this case, the evidence indicates that the District was attempting to work with a challenging parent with well-defined opinions regarding personnel who should provide services to her daughter as well as what constituted the only appropriate placement for STUDENT, namely, a private preschool. (footnote 3) The parent also withheld information from the District regarding STUDENT. For example, when STUDENT was initially referred to the District from the Regional Center, PARENT retrieved from the District the Regional Center records related to STUDENT and would not allow the District access to them. PARENT selectively provided the District with reports of the multiple assessments she has obtained regarding STUDENT. She also did not initially inform the District that STUDENT was attending Discoveryland. (footnote 4) It was not until the first day of hearing that PARENT provided the name of the preschool to the District. The hearing convened some seven months after STUDENT entered Discoveryland. For reasons unclear to the Hearing Officer, PARENT never gave consent to the increased level of OT, PT, and speech and language that had been agreed to for the purpose of settling her first due process hearing. There was no evidence regarding the effort PARENT expended in locating Discoveryland. On the other hand, the District has continued to communicate with PARENT and attempted to identify a placement that would be acceptable to her. The District has contracted with nonpublic agencies to provide services to STUDENT at the request of PARENT. The District has changed service providers when PARENT became disenchanted with the provider and identified a different nonpublic agency that she preferred. PARENT asserted that the District unduly influenced recommendations made by service providers (e.g. Ms. McCann's recommendation regarding the appropriate level of OT). There was no credible evidence to support such claims. In balancing the equities, the Hearing Officer finds that, although the District failed to make an appropriate offer of an educational placement for the 1998-1999 school year, it was generally cooperative in attempting to meet STUDENT's needs. As to the parent, she did not fully cooperate with the District, which impaired its ability to make decisions related to STUDENT's education. However, because of the District's failure to make an appropriate placement offer, she identified and has provided a preschool placement for STUDENT that has met her needs and provided her with benefit. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that neither party's conduct is without fault and that the equities weight in favor of partial reimbursement. Specifically, the Hearing Officer finds the conduct of each party comparable and that, therefore, the parties shall share equally in the costs of STUDENT's attending Discoveryland for the 1998-1999 school year, including the extended school year during the summer of 1999. ISSUE NO. 5(a): Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent psychological assessment by Sandra Kaler, R.N., Ph.D.? A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student. When the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent also has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency's assessment was appropriate. Education Code  56329(b). Petitioner seeks reimbursement for an assessment of STUDENT in July 1998 by Sandra Kaler, R.N., Ph.D. (Petitioner's Exhibit 6.) For the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code  56320, which states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Additionally, individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. Assessments must include tests and other test materials that assess specific areas of educational need and that do not just provide a single general intelligence quotient. Assessment and testing materials also must not measure the student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless that is what the test purports to measure. Subsection 56320(e) states that no single procedure shall be used as the "sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs." Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. Pursuant to subsection (g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Education Code  56324(a) and (b). Education Code  56322 additionally states that assessments shall be conducted by "persons competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area." The basis for PARENT's seeking reimbursement for Dr. Kaler's assessment is unclear. During testimony, she did not raise any objections to the initial assessment conducted by the District. None of the other witnesses testified that the District's assessment was inadequate. There also was no testimony that the District had an obligation to conduct an additional assessment. In Ms. Graham's closing brief, she asserts that the District's assessment was inappropriate because the "team used only one procedure to determine their conclusions. . . ." She also asserts that the District did not "have the knowledge or experience to conduct a meaningful assessment in all areas of STUDENT's suspected disability." The District conducted its initial assessment of STUDENT in May 1997. (District's Exhibits 5, 6, 7, 10 and 11) The assessment included speech and language, OT, PT, APE, and psychoeducational evaluations. Ellen Turner, school psychologist, assessed STUDENT's cognitive, social, and emotional development. With assistance from Rosalind Engman, Ms. Turner also assessed STUDENT's pre-academic skills. They used the Alpern Developmental Profile II to assess STUDENT's pre-academic skills and social/emotional skills. Michele A. Hamilton, C.C.C., evaluated STUDENT's speech and language using the Receptive-Expressive Emergent Language Scale. A PT assessment was completed by Pamela Anderson, physical therapist at the CDK. Ann Hyde, OTR, also of the CDK, completed an OT assessment. Both employed the Revised Gesell Developmental Schedules to the extent they were able to do so. Linda Engholm, APE specialist, utilized the Brigance Inventory of Early Development to assess STUDENT's psychomotor and perceptual skills. Each evaluator supplemented the results of assessments with parental report and personal observations. There is no evidence that the assessment did not meet the criteria of an appropriate assessment as set forth above in Education Code  56320. The evidence fails to support the contention that the District relied on one instrument to make determinations regarding STUDENT's educational needs. The evidence establishes that a number of instruments were employed, as were personal interviews with STUDENT's mother and observations of STUDENT by the assessors. No one challenged the qualifications or competence of the assessors. The assessment resulted in information regarding STUDENT's developmental levels in all areas including cognitive, motor, communication, social, and emotional, and recommendations from the assessors as to how best meet STUDENT's multiple needs. None of the witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT identified deficiencies in the District's assessment. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT and, accordingly denies PARENT's request for reimbursement for the costs of Dr. Kaler's assessment. ISSUE NO. 5(b): Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of an independent occupational therapy assessment by Rosemond Seligson, OTR? PARENT seeks reimbursement for an OT assessment by Rosemond Seligson, OTR, completed on September 29, 1998. (Student's Exhibit 10) In addition to the initial OT assessment by Ms. Hyde (Student's Exhibit 11), Ms. McCann prepared an OT therapy progress report on March 17, 1998. (Student's Exhibit 18) Both Ms. Hyde and Ms. McCann are registered occupational therapists and are qualified to conduct OT assessments. The evidence establishes that both Ms. Hyde and Ms. McCann used a number of different methods to assess STUDENT. Ms. Hyde's assessment consisted of observation of STUDENT and administration of the Gesell Developmental Schedules, to the extent possible given STUDENT's developmental level and lack of attention to task. Ms. Hyde also obtained information from PARENT. Ms. McCann used the following assessment tools: clinical observations of STUDENT's sensory processing, motor control, social interaction, play behaviors; parent interview and report; the Bayley Scales of Infant Development (2nd Revised Edition), parts of the Revised Gesell Developmental Schedules; and reflex testing. None of the witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT identified deficiencies that would render the District's OT assessments inappropriate. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District obtained appropriate OT assessments of STUDENT. PARENT's request for reimbursement is denied. ORDER (1) Within 20 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to indicate that STUDENT is entitled to two weekly sessions of OT. (2) Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse PARENT for the actual costs of OT provided by Children's Hospital Los Angeles, including mileage at the rate the District reimburses its employees, and parking, consistent with the invoices provided in Student's Exhibit 24. (3) Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse PARENT for one-half of the actual costs of STUDENT's attending Discoveryland Preschool during the 1998-1999 school year, including the extended school year, consistent with the invoices provided in Student's Exhibit 24. Reimbursement for mileage shall be provided at the rate the District reimburses its employees. (4) All of Petitioner's other requests for relief are denied. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code  56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: (1) Does STUDENT require two hours weekly of individual occupational therapy (OT)? Student prevailed on this issue. (2) Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private OT, including transportation and parking? Student prevailed on this issue. (3) Did the district offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1998-1999 school year? Student prevailed on this issue. (4) Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attending Discoveryland, a private preschool program? . The Student and the District prevailed equally on this issue. (5) Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments by: (a) Sandra Kaler, R.N., Ph.D.? (b) Rosemond Seligson, OTR? The District prevailed on this issue. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code  56505(i). DATED: October 8, 1999 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1)California's term for related services is "designated instruction and services" or "DIS." 2)The fact that Discoveryland is a sectarian school is not a bar to ordering reimbursement to STUDENT's mother. Such an order directly benefits the parent, not the sectarian school and, therefore, does not violate the Establishment Clause of the Constitution. Zobrest v. Catalina Foothills School District (1993) 113 S. Ct. 2462. 3)It should be noted that during the brief period STUDENT received services from the District, PARENT withdrewn STUDENT from two different educational programs (a full inclusion preschool program and an individualized educational program provided by an NPA) and withdrew STUDENT from OT several times because of her objections to the therapist. 4)The Hearing Officer notes that, although the 1997 amendments to the IDEA now allow a reduction or elimination of reimbursement for a private school placement if a parent fails to notify the school district before such a unilateral placement is made, California did not have a similar requirement in effect until January 1, 1999. (20 U.S. C.  1412(a)(10)(C)(iii); California Educaiton Code  56176.) Therefore, as California law did not contain the additional notice requirement until January 1, 1999, it is not applicable to PARENT's request for reimbursement for Discoveryland since STUDENT was enrolled there in the fall of 1998.