California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 3, 2003
Student v. Rialto Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 428-03, SN03-00428 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Rialto Unified denied FAPE in 2001-2003 and must fund reading instruction, tutoring, and an independent assessment; 2000-2001 claim denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Footnote 1 states the decision was amended only to correct references to "Respondents," since Rialto Unified School District is the only respondent. The decision also refers to a related SEHO decision of March 13, 2003 (SN03-00166). That decision found the District's pre-expulsion assessment did not meet Education Code section 48915.5 and barred the pending expulsion until the District conducted a proper assessment.
Summary
A 13-year-old eighth grader filed this case against Rialto Unified School District. She was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability involving auditory and visual-motor processing disorders. She challenged her education from 2000-2001 through 2002-2003 and asked for tutoring and an independent assessment. The Hearing Officer found no procedural violations in any year. The parents attended IEP meetings and received notice of their rights.
The District won on 2000-2001. After a poor first semester, the January 2001 IEP added language arts goals and raised resource specialist program (RSP) time to 110 minutes a day, and the student made some progress. The student won on 2001-2002. She was failing nearly every class, but the District kept an outdated IEP in place. The March 2002 IEP had no reading goals, fewer accommodations, and no added services, even though her reading comprehension and math computation scores dropped about 15 points. Telling her to attend tutoring before or after school did not replace supports in the IEP. The student also won on 2002-2003. The October 2002 IEP dropped her RSP language arts class even though she read at about a third-grade level. An earlier SEHO decision had found the District's pre-expulsion assessment inappropriate, so the District must pay for an assessment by a psychologist it does not employ. It must also provide individual reading instruction from a certified nonpublic school or agency in summer 2003, plus extra tutoring in 2003-2004.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley when a student kept failing her classes. An IEP that worked before had to be revisited when grades and standard scores fell. The decision also shows that steering a special education student to optional tutoring outside the school day did not take the place of supports written into the IEP.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1 (2000-2001). Did Respondent Rialto Unified School District provide Petitioner with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year?
No procedural violations; after poor first-semester grades the January 2001 IEP added language arts goals and increased RSP to 110 minutes daily, and the student made some progress, so FAPE was provided.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 1 (2001-2002). Did Respondent Rialto Unified School District provide Petitioner with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?
The District left an outdated IEP in place despite failing grades, and the March 2002 IEP lacked reading goals, cut accommodations, and added no services despite falling standard scores, denying FAPE; no procedural violation found.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?
The October 2002 IEP removed the RSP language arts class and had no language arts goals although the student read at about a third-grade level and was failing; relying on before- or after-school tutoring did not meet her needs, so FAPE was denied.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. If the District failed to provide Petitioner with a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory education in the form of private tutoring?
Because FAPE was denied in 2001-2002 and 2002-2003, the District must fund individual reading instruction from a certified nonpublic school or agency during summer 2003 ESY, plus additional tutoring in 2003-2004.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. Is the District required to fund an independent psychoeducational assessment of Petitioner?
Because a prior SEHO decision (SN03-00166) found the District's pre-expulsion assessment inappropriate, the student is entitled to an assessment at District expense by a qualified psychologist not employed by the District.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- IEE at public expense. District to fund an assessment of auditory processing skills and academic achievement by a qualified psychologist within the SELPA (not presently employed by the District) with training and experience assessing African-American students with learning disabilities; if none exists in the SELPA, District to arrange an outside assessor. District to provide transportation. Assessment to be completed by the beginning of the 2003 extended school year program.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. IEP team to consider the assessment results in designing program, placement and services for the 2003-2004 school year.
- Compensatory education. District to identify, arrange, and provide individual reading instruction during the summer 2003 extended school year from a certified nonpublic school or agency specializing in reading remediation (hours not specified).
- Compensatory education. During the 2003-2004 regular school year, District to fund "two weeks hourly of tutoring" in addition to IEP placement and services, to ensure the student has enough support to achieve passing grades (amount as written is unclear).
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Amanda J. v. Clark County School Dist.; Adams v. State of Oregon; Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Board of Education; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; M.C. v. Central Regional School Dist.; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5
People named in the decision
- Lorena Higareda, school psychologist (triennial assessor), Rialto Unified School District
- Barbara Mori, director of student services, Rialto Unified School District
- Gail Lindberg, program manager, District representative at hearing, East Valley SELPA
- Carolyn DeMorton, volunteer advocate for Student, Los Padres Center for Educational Justice
- Cheryl Cooper-Sannes, sixth-grade English teacher; eighth-grade AVID coordinator, Frisbie Middle School
- Yemela Bell-Gomez, sixth-grade exploratory reading teacher, Frisbie Middle School
- Laura Anderson, seventh-grade life science teacher, Frisbie Middle School
- Tobin Brinker, seventh-grade world history teacher, Frisbie Middle School
- Denise Miller, seventh-grade wood shop teacher, Frisbie Middle School
- Anthony Gibson, English teacher and debate coach, Frisbie Middle School
- Wade Cormier, eighth-grade physical science teacher, Frisbie Middle School
- Donald Morris, eighth-grade social studies teacher, Frisbie Middle School
- Laurie Dunbar-Smalls, eighth-grade mathematics teacher, Frisbie Middle School
- Monique Means, eighth-grade general education English teacher, Frisbie Middle School
- Regina Hartman, eighth-grade RSP math teacher, Frisbie Middle School
- Anthony Green, security officer, Frisbie Middle School
- Katrina Patterson, counselor (also referred to as Ms. Peterson), Frisbie Middle School
- Kennon Mitchell, principal, Frisbie Middle School
- Felicia Limbrick, assistant principal, Frisbie Middle School
- Sharon Straughter, home/hospital teacher, Rialto Unified School District
- Selina Yvette Vinson, sixth-grade science teacher; now third-grade teacher, Preston Elementary School
- Julius McChristian, seventh-grade RSP teacher; now SDC teacher/football coach, Eisenhower High School
- Gary Collier, sixth-grade RSP teacher for mathematics and English; now SDC teacher, Hughbanks Elementary School
- Mr. Munoz, school psychologist proposed by Student as assessor, Chaffee School District (as stated)
- Steven Renis, school psychologist proposed by Student as assessor, San Bernardino School District (as stated)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific McGeorge School of Law on March 27 and 28, April 8 and 9, 2003, in Rialto, California.
Petitioner STUDENT was present at the hearing and was represented by Carolyn DeMorton, volunteer advocate from Los Padres Center for Educational Justice. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were her MOTHER, and her GRANDMOTHER. Respondent Rialto Unified School District was represented at the hearing by Gail Lindberg, program manager for the East Valley Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA). Also present on behalf of the District was Barbara Mori, director of student services.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following oral closing arguments by telephone, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
The following witnesses testified at the hearing: STUDENT, MOTHER, GRANDMOTHER, Dr. Mori, and Lorena Higareda, school psychologist. Witnesses from Frisbie Middle School included: Cheryl Cooper-Sannes, STUDENT’s sixth-grade English teacher and currently the eighth-grade AVID coordinator; Yemela Bell-Gomez, STUDENT’s sixth-grade exploratory reading teacher; Laura Anderson, STUDENT’s seventh-grade life science teacher; Tobin Brinker, STUDENT’s seventh-grade world history teacher; Denise Miller, STUDENT’s seventh-grade wood shop teacher; Anthony Gibson, English teacher and STUDENT’s debate coach; Wade Cormier, STUDENT’s eighth-grade physical science teacher; Donald Morris, STUDENT’s eighth-grade social studies teacher; Laurie Dunbar-Smalls, eighth-grade mathematics teacher; Monique Means, STUDENT’s eighth-grade general education English teacher; Regina Hartman, STUDENT’s eighth-grade resource specialist program teacher (RSP) math teacher; Anthony Green, security officer; Katrina Patterson, counselor; Kennon Mitchell, principal; Felicia Limbrick, assistant principal; and Sharon Straughter, STUDENT’s current home/hospital teacher; Selina Yvette Vinson, third-grade teacher, Preston Elementary School; and STUDENT’s sixth-grade science teacher, Julius McChristian, special day class (SDC) teacher/football coach, Eisenhower High School, and STUDENT’s seventh-grade RSP teacher; and Gary Collier, SDC teacher, Hughbanks Elementary School, and STUDENT’s sixth-grade RSP teacher for mathematics and English.
ISSUES
(1) Did Respondent Rialto Unified School District provide Petitioner STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years?(Footnote 2)
(2) Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?
(3) If the District failed to provide Petitioner with a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory education in the form of private tutoring?
(4) Is the District required to fund an independent psychoeducational assessment of Petitioner?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old student in the eighth grade. STUDENT is eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability (SLD). STUDENT has auditory processing and sensory-motor disorders resulting in a severe discrepancy between her intellectual ability and academic achievement in math reasoning. STUDENT had attended Frisbie Middle School since the sixth grade. However, in December 2002, the District alleged that STUDENT was involved in an incident of fire setting in a restroom and recommended that she be expelled. The IEP team agreed to home teaching pending resolution of due process proceedings. Since January 23, 2003, the District has provided STUDENT with approximately two and one-half hours of home teaching on three days each week.
The individualized educational program (IEP) team initially found STUDENT eligible for special education in March 1997. STUDENT then was in the second grade. Testing indicated that STUDENT’s cognitive skills fell within the average range while her academic performance fell in the low average range. The IEP team determined that STUDENT exhibited a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in reading/language arts and mathematics. For the remainder of the school year, STUDENT attended a general education class and received assistance from the resource specialist program (RSP) in both math and reading.
STUDENT continued to receive the same services during the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years. In November 1999, the District undertook a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. Because STUDENT is African-American, the District was precluded from administering standardized intelligence tests to her. The assessor concluded that STUDENT potentially was functioning cognitively in the low average range but that the previous assessment suggested slightly stronger functioning within the average range. The assessor stated that “[STUDENT] does show average reading scores with high average math computation that may suggest stronger abilities.” (Respondent’s Exhibit 13, page 49) However, math reasoning scores fell in the low average range. The IEP team continued to recommend pull-out RSP services for 60 minutes on four days each week to address discrepancies between cognitive skills and mathematic reasoning. The IEP goals and objectives addressed math word problems, money, and working independently.
STUDENT entered Frisbie Middle School for the sixth grade in the fall of 2000. Frisbie is divided into teams of approximately 150 students each. Teams include general education teachers in typical subject areas and special education teachers. Wednesdays are shortened school days for the students so that the teaching teams can meet to jointly plan, receive training, and discuss strategies to meet the needs of students. STUDENT was placed in general education classes with one period of RSP services for mathematics. STUDENT’s report card the first quarter reflects the following grades: one “P” or “passed,” two “C” grades, and two “D” grades. The second quarter STUDENT received one “C,” one “D,” and two “F” grades. The annual IEP meeting took place on January 18, 2001. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT should be placed in RSP classes for both mathematics and English/language arts. The IEP notes that STUDENT was experiencing low self-esteem and that at times, she was engaging in negative interactions with peers and teachers. STUDENT’s report card for the third quarter reflects that she received one “P,” three “D,” and two “F” grades. For the final quarter, STUDENT received one “P,” four “D” grades, and one “F” grade. During summer school, STUDENT took a basic study skills course and received a grade of “D.”
STUDENT returned to Frisbie for the seventh grade and continued to participate in RSP classes for mathematics and English/language arts. During the first quarter of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT received one “three,” one “two,” and four “one” grades.(Footnote 3) For the second quarter, STUDENT received one “two” grade and five “one” grades. For the third quarter, STUDENT received one “two” grade and five “one” grades. For the final quarter, STUDENT received a “three” in physical education, “two” grades in English and mathematics, and “one” grades in two general education classes. STUDENT did not participate in summer school.
In August 2002, the District undertook a triennial assessment of STUDENT. School psychologist Lorena Higareda conducted the psychoeducational portion of the assessment. Because she was precluded from administering intelligence testing, Ms. Higareda undertook an alternative evaluation of STUDENT’s cognitive ability. Ms. Higareda estimated that STUDENT’s cognitive ability fell within the low average range. Ms. Higareda also concluded that STUDENT’s academic achievement, with the exception of mathematic reasoning (or application), was consistent with her ability. The IEP team discussed the results of the triennial assessment at a meeting in October 2002, and, based on Ms. Higareda’s assessment, concluded that STUDENT did not exhibit a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in reading.(Footnote 4) The IEP team also concluded that STUDENT would remain in her RSP placement for mathematics but that she would be placed in a collaborative general education class for English/language arts.(Footnote 5) STUDENT’s mother consented to the change in placement.
For the first quarter of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT received a “three” in wood shop and “two” grades in English, social studies, and physical education. For the second quarter, STUDENT received grades of “two” in RSP and social studies and grades of “one” in all other classes.
On December 17, 2002, the District identified STUDENT as part of a group of students who participated in setting a fire in a bathroom. On December 19, 2002, the District suspended STUDENT for five days and recommended expulsion. At an IEP meeting on January 13, 2003, the District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT’s alleged participation in the fire-setting incident was not a manifestation of her disability, that she was appropriately placed at the time of the incident, and that her disability did not impair her ability to understand the impact and consequences of her behavior or her ability to control her behavior. STUDENT’s parents did not agree with the District’s findings and filed for a due process hearing (SN03-00166). The IEP team did agree that pending resolution of due process proceedings, STUDENT would receive home/hospital instruction. Prior to STUDENT’s removal from Frisbie Middle School, she was an active member of the school community. STUDENT was a student council representative and member of the Frisbie debate team. STUDENT also belonged to several clubs and was vice-president of Delta, an organization for young women.
On March 4, 2003, STUDENT’s parent filed this matter (SN03-00428) alleging past and present denials of a free appropriate public education (FAPE). In a decision rendered on March 13, 2003, in case SN03-00166, the hearing officer concluded that the District failed to conduct a pre-expulsion assessment that met the requirements of California Education Code section 48915.5 and, because of the flawed assessment, the District could not proceed with the pending expulsion proceedings for STUDENT. The hearing officer also stated that if the District wished to continue with disciplinary action against STUDENT, it was required to undertake an assessment in accordance with California Education Code section 48915.5 and then hold another manifestation determination meeting.
On March 27, 2003, this matter proceeded to hearing on issues regarding the District’s provision of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT. For the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide her with a procedurally and substantively appropriate education. As to the alleged failure of the District to adhere to procedural requirements, Petitioner asserts that the District failed to inform her parents of their rights and denied their requests for additional assistance to address Petitioner’s reading deficits, thereby infringing on the parents’ participation as equal members of the individualized educational program (IEP) team. Petitioner also asserts that the District failed substantively to provide her with a FAPE because she did not benefit from her education as evidenced by failing grades and poor reading skills. Finally, Petitioner asserts that the District failed to provide her a FAPE by requiring her to participate in tutoring before and/or after school rather than providing her with the appropriate level of support she needed to succeed in school during the regular school day. Petitioner has also requested that the District pay for an independent assessment.
The Respondent contends that Petitioner has received an appropriate education at all times that she has attended school in the Rialto Unified School District. The District is willing to arrange for STUDENT to be assessed by an appropriately qualified school psychologist who has not previously assessed her so long as that psychologist is employed by the District or another school district within the East Valley SELPA.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the Rialto Unified School District provide Petitioner STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP).(Footnote 6) 20 U.S.C. § 1418. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, etal. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.
The Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural protections afforded by the IDEA, which are designed to ensure effective parental participation in the IEP process and careful consideration of a student’s educational needs. One of the rights afforded to parents is the right to be provided a formal written offer of placement by the school district. Union v. Smith, 157 F.3d. 1519 (9th Cir. 1994); cert.denied 115 S. Ct. 428 (1994). The Court in Union noted that one of the reasons for a formal written offer is to provide parents the opportunity to decide whether the offer of placement is appropriate and whether or not to accept the offer.
Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of a FAPE. Procedural flaws must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process to constitute a denial of a FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S., at 206-207; See also W.G. v. B.D. of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F. 2d 1479, 1483-1484; Amanda J. v. Clark County School District (9th Cir. 2001) 267 F.3d 877.
The 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years will be reviewed separately below. Additionally, because STUDENT’s annual IEP review occurs during the middle of the school year, each school year also will be analyzed according to the period covered by the controlling IEPs.
2000-2001 SCHOOL YEAR
September 2000 to January 18, 2001
STUDENT began the school year at Frisbie in the sixth grade and received one period of RSP services in mathematics. All of her other classes were in general education.
Procedural Appropriateness
For each year at issue, Petitioner raised generally that the District failed to adhere to procedural requirements by failing to inform her parents of their rights and by denying her parents’ request for additional assistance to address Petitioner’s reading deficits. Petitioner did not present any evidence specifically to support her allegations regarding procedural defects at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the parents’ participation in the IEP was not infringed upon and the student did not lose educational opportunity because of procedural violations by the District.
Substantive Appropriateness
Was the District’s offer designed to meet Petitioner’s unique and individual needs?
The first inquiry regarding whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year is related to whether the offer was designed to address STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Before evaluating whether the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, it is necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique and individual needs as she entered the sixth grade at Frisbie. There is no dispute that at the beginning of the school year STUDENT was exhibiting deficits in mathematics, particularly in the area of applied mathematics or word problems. There also is no dispute that STUDENT has processing disorders in auditory and visual-motor areas.
Lorena Higareda, school psychologist, provided insight into appropriate teaching techniques to employ with STUDENT in light of her processing disorders.(Footnote 7) Ms. Higareda testified that STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits affect her ability to benefit from instruction in the classroom. For example, when information is being presented orally, STUDENT may have difficulty understanding or remembering part or all of the information. STUDENT’s visual-motor processing disorder affects her ability to look at visually-presented material and reproduce the information in writing. For example, STUDENT may experience problems copying information from the chalkboard. Ms. Higareda provided credible testimony that for the above reasons, instruction should be provided to STUDENT using multiple modalities while focusing on her area of strength, namely, visual processing. Katrina Peterson, counselor at Frisbie, holds a pupil personnel credential. She knows STUDENT quite well because of her involvement in school clubs. Ms. Peterson’s testimony supported the testimony of Ms. Higareda regarding STUDENT’s processing deficits. The testimony of Ms. Higareda and Ms. Peterson was based on their education, training, and experience as a school psychologist and counselor respectively. There was no testimony elicited to rebut the testimony of Ms. Higareda and Ms. Peterson. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the testimony of Ms. Higareda and Ms. Peterson establishes that STUDENT required use of a multi-modal approach to teaching to address auditory and visual-motor processing disorders.
Turning to the adequacy of the IEP with which STUDENT entered the 2000-2001 school year, a review of the IEP indicates that it included goals and objectives to improve her ability to do math word problems, count money, make correct change, and work independently. To implement goals and objectives in mathematics, the IEP called for STUDENT to receive one period of RSP mathematics. Because the IEP addressed STUDENT’s deficits in mathematics and processing deficits, the Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP was designed to address STUDENT’s needs.
As to whether the program STUDENT received addressed her needs, MOTHER asserted that the teachers were not appropriately qualified to provide instruction to meet STUDENT’s needs. Gary Collier was responsible for providing STUDENT’s special education instruction. He holds multi-subject and special education credentials and a single-subject credential in mathematics. Kennon Mitchell, Ph.D., Frisbie’s principal, and Dr. Mori testified that all of the other teachers on STUDENT’s teams have met minimum requirements for their assignments. Pursuant to the District’s policy, all teachers must have a pre-intern or higher credential. Dr. Mori additionally testified that the teachers receive training prior to the students’ arrival for instruction. The testimony of Dr. Mitchell, Dr. Mori, and Mr. Collier establishes that STUDENT’s teachers were sufficiently qualified to provide her with instruction.
In determining whether STUDENT’s program met her needs, Gary Collier, STUDENT’s RSP teacher, testified that he employed multi-modal teaching techniques. For example, Mr. Collier testified that he used visual prompts, posters, and manipulatives in the mathematics class. Mr. Collier also was the teacher assigned to STUDENT’s collaborative language arts class. Selina Yvette Vinson, STUDENT’s science teacher, testified persuasively that she employed a multi-modal approach to teaching. Ms. Vinson testified that her classroom activities included hands-on science experiments and information presented on an overhead projector. She also discussed STUDENT’s homework assignment individually with her before she sent it home with STUDENT and asked questions of STUDENT to ensure that she understood what was going on in class. The testimony of STUDENT’s teachers, including Mr. Collier and Ms. Vinson, establishes that STUDENT was provided with a multi-modal teaching approach that was determined necessary to address her processing deficits.
Next, it must be determined whether STUDENT received instruction to address learning disabilities in mathematics. Mr. Collier provided instruction to STUDENT in an RSP mathematics class. Mr. Collier testified persuasively that he addressed STUDENT’s math deficits. He used standard California textbooks that he modified to accommodate STUDENT’s needs. Petitioner did not present any evidence to rebut Mr. Collier’s testimony.
Because the IEP was designed to address STUDENT’s identified needs and provided her with appropriate instruction to meet deficits in processing disorders and mathematics application, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District satisfied the first prong of an appropriate education under Rowley and the IDEA.
Was the District’s offer reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit?
To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s proposed program, services, and placement must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Rowley 458 U.S. at 200.
Petitioner asserts that she did not benefit from her education during the 2000-2001 school year. MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s poor and failing grades reflect that she did not make progress during the 2000-2001 school year. MOTHER also testified that STUDENT’s reading skills did not improve and that they remained around the third-grade level.
The District asserts that STUDENT’s program was designed to provide her with benefit and she did make progress in the identified area of need.
Looking initially to the first two quarters of the school year, Mr. Collier, an experienced RSP teacher, testified that STUDENT made good progress in mathematics during the first two quarters of the 2000-2001 school year. The Hearing Officer finds his testimony persuasive. Moreover, STUDENT’s grades during the first quarter of the 2000-2001 school year support Mr. Collier’s testimony. The report card indicates that STUDENT received “C” grades in Mr. Collier’s RSP mathematics class. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT made progress in her identified area of need.
In summary, goals and objectives, specialized teaching, and RSP support were in place and subsequently were provided to address STUDENT’s deficits in mathematics and auditory and visual-motor processing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered a program designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
During the first two quarters of the 2000-2001school year, STUDENT did not demonstrate the same competency in other classes as she did in mathematics. However, the law requires a school district to make an appropriate offer of placement based on information reasonably available at the time an offer is made. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Board of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993)). It is concluded that the program and services in place at the beginning of the school year were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and to provide her with educational benefit.
Did the District provide Petitioner with a program and services that conformed to her IEP?
No concerns were expressed regarding conformity with the IEP.
Summary
The conclusions above were that at the beginning of the school year, the program offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and to allow her to achieve educational benefit. However, when circumstances changed or new information became available, namely STUDENT’s poor academic performance during the first part of the 2000-2001 school year, the District was required through a variety of procedures to address those changes. Whether the District responded appropriately will be addressed in the section below.
January 18, 2001 to the End of the School Year
The District assessed STUDENT’s academic achievement using the Kaufman Test of Academic Achievement (K-TEA). At the IEP meeting on January 18, 2001, the IEP team determined that STUDENT’s placement would continue in pull-out RSP. STUDENT’s participation in the RSP was increased to 110 minutes, or two periods daily, to provide both math and English/language arts RSP classes. The remainder of her other classes were in general education, including a special reading class. The January IEP included math and language arts goals and called for modifications to the general education classes that included assistance with tests and class assignments, in class assistance from special education staff, modification to assignments, assistance with organizational issues, extension of time to complete activities, and instruction for assistance at home. (Respondent’s Exhibit 9)
Procedural Appropriateness
As to the parents’ allegation that they were denied equal participation in the IEP process, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, and STEPFATHER both attended the IEP meeting on January 18, 2001, and consented to implementation of the IEP. The IEP indicates that a copy of parental rights was given to the parents. There is no evidence that the parents later dissented or asked that comments be attached to the IEP. (See Respondent’s Exhibit 10) Although the IEP does not indicate who initiated the recommendations to change STUDENT’s program from the prior IEP, the January 2001 IEP reflects that the team agreed to address STUDENT’s poor performance in language arts during the first two quarters of the school year by developing a new IEP that included goals and objectives in mathematics and language arts, and by providing her with instruction in both RSP English/language arts and mathematics classes. The parents did not prepare a dissent to the IEP or request that the District convene another IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the above evidence that the parents’ participation in the IEP was not infringed upon nor did the action result in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT.
Substantive Appropriateness
Was the District’s offer designed to meet Petitioner’s unique and individual needs?
As to STUDENT’s needs in January 2001, the evidence establishes that STUDENT continued to demonstrate deficits in mathematics. An assessment using the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (K-TEA) indicated that in math computation, STUDENT was functioning at the 5.0 grade level with math applications falling at the 1.4 grade level. STUDENT’s scores in reading decoding fell at the 3.2 grade level equivalency and reading comprehension scores fell at the 4.3 grade level. Additionally, results of the Test of Written Language-3 (TOWL-3), indicated that STUDENT then was functioning below the first-grade level in written language. Comments on the IEP state that STUDENT’s “capitalization, punctuation, grammar and syntax mechanics demonstrate low ability in composition [ability] to convey information adequately in written communication.” (Respondent’s Exhibit 9) The testimony of the witnesses, which is substantiated by test results, establishes that STUDENT continued to require specialized instruction in mathematics and also was demonstrating substantial deficits in written language and reading decoding. As determined above, because of processing deficits, STUDENT required a multi-modal approach. Finally, by report of the IEP team in January 2001, STUDENT also was experiencing difficulty with peer and teacher relationships. Therefore, an appropriate program needed to address STUDENT’s math application, written language, and reading decoding deficits, and poor relationships with peers and teachers.
STUDENT’s IEP dated January 18, 2001, included goals and objectives (1) to learn to construct a two-paragraph essay using proper capitalization, punctuation, grammar and syntax; (2) to increase word association with math applications; (3) to increase multiple-function tasks; and (4) to decrease peer conflict.
As determined above, STUDENT required a program that took into account her processing deficits. STUDENT’s IEP addressed her processing deficits by calling for the teachers to provide her with assistance with organizational skills, modification of assignments, extension of time to complete activities, and consultation provided by the special education staff to the regular staff regarding academic or behavioral issues.
At the beginning of the school year, STUDENT had been placed in a collaborative English/language arts class. The class was taught by Ms. Cooper-Sannes, a general education English teacher, and Mr. Collier provided RSP support within the class. STUDENT did not do well in the class. The IEP developed in January 2001 resulted in STUDENT’s placement in Mr. Collier’s RSP class for language arts, as well as for mathematics. Mr. Collier testified that the classes were smaller than general education classes and allowed him to provide instruction to meet STUDENT’s needs. STUDENT also was placed in an exploratory reading class taught by Yamela Bell-Gomez during the second semester. Ms. Bell-Gomez testified that she focused on Project Read and provided work on phonics. The evidence as discussed above establishes that the District IEP offered goals, objectives, and a placement that were designed to address STUDENT’s deficits in reading/language arts and mathematics. The modifications called for were designed to address STUDENT’s needs related to processing disorders. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Additionally, in response to STUDENT’s continuing to receive poor grades, the District enrolled her in a study skills class during the extended school year (ESY).
Was the District’s offer reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit?
While requiring the District to provide STUDENT with meaningful access to education, Rowley does not require the responsible educational agency to guarantee totally successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). However, de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Id., 142 F.3d at 130; M.C. v. Central Regional School District, 81 F.3d 389, 393 (3rd Cir. 1996). STUDENT’s grades did show some improvement during the last two quarters of the 2000-2001 school year. Both RSP English and general science classes improved from “F” to “D” grades and the only “F” grade STUDENT received was in physical education. Despite receiving a poor grade in her class, STUDENT’s general education English teacher, Ms. Cooper-Sannes, testified that STUDENT made good progress, which is reflected by her improved scores on the STAR reading test between September 2000 and September 2001. STUDENT’s scores on the STAR reading increased from 1.6 to 2.5. (Respondent’s Exhibits 17 and 18) Ms. Cooper-Sannes holds a clear multi-subject teaching credential and CLAD certification.(Footnote 8) Ms. Higareda testified that grade-equivalent scores can be deceptive and that standard scores are more reliable for purposes of measuring year-to-year progress because standard scores compare the student’s scores to the scores of same age peers. However, Ms. Higareda did not specifically contradict the testimony of Ms. Cooper-Sannes regarding STUDENT’s progress in reading nor did she dispute that STUDENT’s scores on the STAR showed progress.
Another measure of progress is the student’s achievement on goals and objectives. At an IEP meeting on June 6, 2001, it was reported that STUDENT had partially met three out of four goals and the first objective of the fourth goal. Thus, on measures other than grades, STUDENT demonstrated some progress during the 2000-2001 school year. There were no reports of ongoing peer problems. The record taken as a whole establishes that STUDENT did make some progress despite receiving relatively poor grades.
Moreover, as previously discussed, the record establishes that the District responded appropriately to the difficulty STUDENT experienced during the first semester of her sixth-grade year by reevaluating her academic achievement and by developing a new IEP. The IEP team developed goals and objectives to improve language arts skills, to complete multiple-function tasks, and to decrease peer conflict. The prior IEP called for STUDENT to receive 60 minutes of RSP services four times each week, whereas the January 2001 IEP called for STUDENT to receive 110 minutes of RSP services five days each week. Additionally, STUDENT was enrolled in a supplemental reading class during the spring semester and received a “P” or passing both quarters. Goals and objectives on STUDENT’s prior IEP were limited to the areas of mathematics and independent work skills. It has been concluded that the increase in services and additional goals and objectives in language arts were reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. Because the IEPs were designed to address STUDENT’s identified needs, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offers of program, services, and placement sufficiently satisfied the Rowley requirement and were reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit.
Did the District provide Petitioner with a program and services that conformed to her IEP?
No concerns were raised regarding conformity with the IEP.
Summary
The Hearing Officer determined above that the District offered STUDENT a program, services, and placement that were designed to meet her unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide her with some education benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District provided her with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year.
2001-2002 SCHOOL YEAR
September 2001 to March 29, 2002
STUDENT entered the seventh grade at Frisbie with the same goals and objectives and services set forth in her IEP dated January 18, 2001. Petitioner continues to contend that the District denied her a FAPE both procedurally and substantively, because she failed to make academic progress. Petitioner contends that she required additional services to address reading skills that had not improved and to address her ongoing failure to obtain passing grades. The District contends that sufficient support and services were in place to allow Petitioner to receive a FAPE. The District asserts that its offer was sufficiently designed to meet Petitioner’s unique and individual needs and that any lack of success on the part of STUDENT was the result of poor motivation or her failure to participate in tutoring programs available to her before or after school.
Procedural Appropriateness
Petitioner asserts that meaningful parental participation in the IEP process was thwarted by Respondent. Petitioner failed to put forth any persuasive evidence that the participation of her parents in the IEP process was infringed upon or that procedural errors resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT.
Substantive Appropriateness
Was the District’s offer designed to meet Petitioner’s unique and individual needs?
Turning first to STUDENT’s needs, there is no dispute that STUDENT’s needs remained the same at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year as they had been during the prior school. STUDENT continued to exhibit deficits in language arts and math application, and to have the same processing disorders. Turning to whether the District’s offer was designed to meet Petitioner’s unique and individual needs, the evidence establishes that at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT’s goals and objectives continued from the IEP developed in the middle of the prior school year. The goal to address deficits in language arts was to construct a two-paragraph essay with proper capitalization, ending and inner punctuation, grammar and syntax. A second goal, to address deficits in math application skills, was to increase word association with math applications. The third goal related to increasing multiple-function tasks and the final goal was in the area of peer relationships. There is no dispute that the goals and objectives addressed identified areas of need for STUDENT. The IEP continued to include modifications to address STUDENT’s processing deficits. STUDENT continued to receive RSP services in both math and English, thereby addressing her math and language arts deficits. STUDENT also enrolled in a study skills class. The Hearing Officer concludes that at the beginning of the school year, the District’s offer was designed to meet her unique and individual needs.
However, STUDENT’s grades for the first quarter of the 2001-2002 school year continued to be very poor. In fact, STUDENT’s grades of “one” indicate that she was failing to meet standards in RSP English and math, general science, and social studies. She received a “two” in study skills and a “three” in physical education. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s continuing to fail academically during the first quarter put the District on notice that the IEP, which was designed to meet her needs in January 2000, no longer was appropriate. Despite mounting evidence that STUDENT’s IEP was not meeting her needs, the District took no steps to convene an IEP to develop a plan to address STUDENT’s failing grades. STUDENT fared even worse the second quarter of the 2001-2002 school year. Every grade she received the second quarter was a “one” except for physical education, which had fallen to a “two.” Again, the District took no steps to make any modifications to STUDENT’s IEP, program, placement, or services. Additionally, although the prior IEP expired on January 18, 2002, the District did not convene a new IEP until March 29, 2002. By the end of the third quarter in March, STUDENT had received another set of failing grades, with her only “two” in physical education. (Respondent’s Exhibit 3)
The District could not coast through the first three quarters of the school year on an IEP developed the prior January that no longer was meeting STUDENT’s needs or providing her with educational benefit. Therefore, Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to provide STUDENT with an education designed to meet her needs or that was designed to provide her with educational benefit.March 29, 2002, to the end of the school year
Procedural Appropriateness
The evidence establishes that MOTHER participated in the IEP developed on March 29, 2002. The IEP document states that parental rights “were given and explained, and an opportunity for discussion was allowed for.”(FOOTNOTE 9) (Respondent’s Exhibit 7) There was no evidence that MOTHER requested another IEP meeting or raised any dissent to the IEP. The Hearing Officer concludes that there was no persuasive evidence supporting Petitioner’s assertion that the District committed procedural errors infringing on the parents’ rights or resulting in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT.
Substantive Appropriateness
At the IEP meeting on March 29, 2002, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT continue to receive 110 minutes daily of RSP pull-out services for mathematics and language arts. STUDENT’s relationships with peers and teachers improved and no concerns were noted in social areas at the IEP meeting in March. While social skills had improved, by the time the annual IEP was convened some two months late, STUDENT’s needs in other areas had expanded. While previous testing had revealed low scores in reading decoding and math application, testing undertaken for the annual review revealed that STUDENT’s reading comprehension and math computation scores had fallen. STUDENT obtained standard scores of 78 on both reading comprehension (2.9 grade equivalency) and math computation. STUDENT’s reading comprehension scores fell 14 points and her scores on math calculations decreased by 15 points. Thus, STUDENT’s needs in language arts and mathematics were broader than during the prior school year. Additionally, during the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT’s grades continued to slide. By teacher report at the IEP meeting in March 2002, STUDENT was receiving grades of “one” in social studies, language arts, study skills, and mathematics. STUDENT’s report card shows that during the first three quarters of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT received grades of “one” in all classes, including special education, with the exception of study skills and physical education. The highest grade STUDENT received was a “three” for one quarter in physical education.(Footnote 10)
Several teachers offered reasons for STUDENT’s lack of achievement. It was Ms. Anderson’s opinion that STUDENT “did work when she wanted to.” Tobin Brinker testified that STUDENT received a grade of “one” because she did not turn in her work and did not put sufficient effort into her work. Ms. McChristian also testified that the primary reason STUDENT did not succeed was a lack of effort. The testimony of the witnesses establishes that an additional need during the 2001-2002 school year was to improve STUDENT’s lack of motivation or effort or whatever the source to which the teachers ascribed STUDENT’s lack of motivation.
Unlike the prior school year when the District added goals and objectives and services to address STUDENT’s changed needs at the annual IEP, the annual IEP developed in March 2002 IEP did not add goals, objectives, or services. The March 2002 IEP included goals and objectives in areas of language arts, math, and vocation. There were one goal and two objectives in each area. The language arts goal built upon the prior goal and called for STUDENT to write three paragraphs, an increase of one paragraph from the prior IEP, using correct punctuation, sentence structure, capitalization, commas and quotation marks. The mathematics goal was to solve eight out of ten word problems involving two operations. The vocational goal was to complete and turn in 100% of classroom and homework assignments. (Respondent’s Exhibit 7)
The Hearing Officer concludes that the goals and objectives were inadequate to address all of STUDENT’s needs given her significant deficits identified through testing in reading comprehension and math calculations, in addition to previously identified deficits in reading decoding and math applications. The IEP did not include any goals or objectives to improve reading skills although STUDENT’s reading skills remained within the third-grade level. Moreover, the IEP did not include any goals or objectives to address STUDENT’s lack of academic achievement. There also was not a goal to address the lack of motivation to which STUDENT’s teachers ascribed her lack of achievement.
As to the modifications STUDENT required to successfully participate in the general education curriculum, the IEP in effect at the beginning of the school year identified multiple modifications, as discussed in the first issue above. The only modification or support identified on the March 2002 IEP was to “use positive praise when student is on task and turns in assignments.” (Respondent’s Exhibit 7) The Hearing Officer concludes that the March 2002 IEP did not provide adequate guidance to the general education or special education teachers regarding modifications or accommodations that STUDENT required because of her processing deficits. In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the March IEP was deficient in that it did not contain sufficient goals and objectives to address all of STUDENT’s academic needs and did not sufficiently identify appropriate modifications to address auditory and visual-motor processing deficits.
Despite the lack of guidance from the IEP, Respondent’s witnesses testified that they each provided appropriate modifications for STUDENT. Laura Anderson, life science teacher, has taught at Frisbie for 11 years and has prior teaching experience in special education. Ms. Anderson testified that she made the following modifications: She broke down tasks into smaller components, read the text with STUDENT, talked STUDENT through assignments, and employed multisensory teaching techniques. Tobin Brinker, world history teacher, employed similar techniques and additionally provided STUDENT with a workbook that summarized concepts from the reading assignments at a lower reading level, extended the due date for STUDENT to turn in assignments, and allowed STUDENT to complete assignments with peer assistance.
Julius McChristian, STUDENT’s RSP teacher during the 2001-2002 school year, holds a pre-intern credential. Mr. McChristian testified regarding the general accommodations he made for STUDENT and the specific methods he employed in RSP classes to meet her needs. In general, Mr. McChristian allowed STUDENT to use her notes during tests, to make up work during class, and to take tests for other classes in the RSP. Additionally, Mr. McChristian tested STUDENT orally. To address STUDENT’s needs in math, Mr. McChristian grouped STUDENT with two other students, explained problems to her, and had peers tutor her. At the beginning of the school year in language arts, Mr. McChristian focused on reading decoding and comprehension.
Although it would appear that STUDENT’s teachers generally provided appropriate modifications to allow STUDENT to succeed in the general education curriculum, STUDENT did not obtain passing grades. Teacher comments consistently pointed to poor test scores as the reason for her low grades. Only Mr. McChristian testified that he modified test-taking procedures and had administered tests orally to STUDENT. Given STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits, it is unclear that oral administration of a test would be an appropriate modification.
Petitioner, her mother, and her grandmother testified that STUDENT goes to the library after school on five days each week for the purpose of working on her homework. Her family supports her in this effort. However, MOTHER testified that STUDENT required additional support in her classes to receive passing grades.
Nearly all of STUDENT’s teachers were of the opinion that STUDENT should have taken advantage of the multiple tutoring programs available at Frisbie to receive the support she needed to improve her grades. The teachers and administrators testified that tutoring programs were available either before or after school. Some teachers were also available during lunch time. It is the conclusion of the Hearing Officer that the call for STUDENT to attend tutoring is tacit acknowledgment by the teachers that STUDENT required additional support to succeed in school and, therefore, is consistent with Petitioner’s contention that she required additional support to benefit from her education. Moreover, it is the responsibility of the IEP team to develop an IEP that provides appropriate support rather than requiring the student to participate in tutoring or other programs outside of the regular school day to meet her needs.
In summary, the March 2002 IEP did not increase goals, objectives, services, or additional support to meet STUDENT’s needs and identified fewer modifications to support her participation in general education. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer in March 2002 did not sufficiently address STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.
Was the District’s offer reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit?
Petitioner asserts that the lack of an offer designed to meet her needs resulted in the District’s offer being fatally flawed because it was not reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. Petitioner asserts that her continued failure to achieve passing grades supports her contention and resulted in the denial of a FAPE. The Respondent asserts that STUDENT received adequate support services to allow her to obtain higher grades and to benefit from her education.
Although there is some dispute as to whether STUDENT’s cognitive skills fall in the average or below average range, there is no dispute that she possesses sufficient cognitive skills to allow her to receive passing grades.(Footnote 11) STUDENT had not received good grades the prior school year and she generally continued to fail to meet grade standards in the fall and winter of the 2001-2002 school year. In fact, STUDENT has received multiple notices that she is a candidate for retention.
The results of testing also indicated that STUDENT was not benefitting from her education. On testing in January 2001 utilizing the K-TEA, STUDENT had earned standard scores (SS) of 84 in reading decoding, 92 in reading comprehension, 64 in math applications, and 93 in math computations. On the same measures given in March 2002, some fourteen months later, STUDENT received standard scores of 82 in reading decoding, 78 in reading comprehension, 65 in math applications, and 78 in math computations. (Respondent’s Exhibits 7 and 9) Ms. Higareda testified that standard scores are the most reliable measure to assess progress from year-to-year because they compare the student to his/her same-age peers. Therefore, if a student maintains the same score from year to year, the student has maintained his/her place compared to peers and, arguably, has made progress. However, STUDENT’s reading comprehension scores fell 14 points and her scores on math calculations decreased 15 points. Relying on Ms. Higareda’s testimony, it is concluded that STUDENT’s skills in reading comprehension and math computations decreased during the 2001-2002 school year.
The evidence points unequivocally to the District’s failing to adequately take into consideration STUDENT’s lack of progress when developing her IEP. There were no increases to goals or objectives or services despite clear information that Petitioner was not benefitting from her education. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer was not designed to provide her with educational benefit.
Did the District provide Petitioner with a program and services that conformed to her IEP?
There were no issues regarding conformity to the IEP.
Summary
The District’s offer for the 2001-2002 school year as set forth in the IEP existing at the beginning of the school year addressed Petitioner’s needs. However, the subsequent IEP developed in March 2002, failed to adequately address Petitioner’s needs or offer her a program reasonably designed to allow her to benefit educationally. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?
STUDENT entered the eighth grade at Frisbie for the 2002-2003 school year with the IEP developed in March 2002 calling for placement in RSP for math and language arts. At the IEP meeting on October 10, 2002, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT continue to participate in the RSP pull-out program for mathematics. Other general education classes included physical education, art, history, writing, science, social studies, reading, and health. Her IEP called for modifications in general education classes as needed including assignments, class tests, seating arrangement. IEP goals addressed the areas of math, careers, and completing homework assignments. (Respondent’s Exhibit 6)
Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer her a FAPE. Petitioner asserts that her reading skills remained at the third-grade level and that rather than provide her with specialized instruction she required in language arts, the IEP team eliminated her RSP language arts class. The District contends that it has offered Petitioner a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. The District asserts that sufficient support is available in general education classes to allow Petitioner to benefit from her education. The District also asserts that Petitioner’s progress allowed resource specialist program (RSP) services to be reduced in the fall of 2002 from two periods to one period daily.
Procedural Appropriateness
Petitioner alleged the same procedural problems as raised during prior school years. MOTHER attended STUDENT’s IEP meetings and there was no persuasive evidence that Respondent infringed on her participation in the process or resulted in the denial of educational opportunity to STUDENT.
Substantive Appropriateness
Was the District’s offer designed to meet Petitioner’s unique and individual needs?
Again, STUDENT’s needs must be determined prior to analyzing the offer for the 2002-2003 school year. There is no dispute that STUDENT continued to have auditory and visual-motor processing disorders for which she required a multi-modal approach to teaching and other modifications in general education classes. There also is no dispute that STUDENT continued to need specialized instruction in math application.
As to language arts, Ms. Higareda testified that her testing of STUDENT in August 2002 revealed that STUDENT no longer was exhibiting a severe discrepancy between her ability and achievement in reading. Ms. Higareda reached this conclusion by comparing STUDENT’s cognitive skills, which she estimated fall in the low-average range, with low-average scores on reading decoding and reading comprehension tests on the K-TEA. Ms. Higareda described STUDENT’s comprehension skills as “commensurate with her decoding skills.” She also concluded that STUDENT’s reading comprehension was “adequate for her age” and that she no longer required specialized services in language arts.
The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Higareda’s testimony unpersuasive as to the adequacy of STUDENT’s reading skills. At the time of Ms. Higareda’s testing, STUDENT was entering the eighth grade. Her reading comprehension score placed her at approximately the 2.9 grade level. Moreover, the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers establishes that STUDENT continued to struggle with language arts tasks. Mr. Cormier, STUDENT’s science teacher, contradicted Ms. Higareda’s testimony, stating that even with modifications, STUDENT experienced difficulty comprehending concepts in an eighth-grade text when her reading skills were at the third-grade level. MOTHER also described STUDENT’s difficulty reading her language arts book, which was also at the eighth-grade level. In October 2002, STUDENT’s RSP English teacher reported that STUDENT was getting a “one” grade because of poor test scores and missing homework assignments.(Footnote 12) As to written language skills, STUDENT was able to create a simple story with a beginning, middle, and end. She was writing in complete sentences with correct subject-verb agreement and adequate spelling and grammar but was not writing multiple paragraphs spontaneously or sufficiently developing her story. (Testimony of Ms. Higareda and Respondent’s Exhibit 6 and 11) In light of STUDENT’s below grade-level reading and writing skills, the testimony that STUDENT was exhibiting difficulty with general education curriculum in part because of her below grade-level skills, and the fact that STUDENT continued to receive failing grades in RSP language arts, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT continued to need specialized instruction in language arts.
The IEP drafted on October 10, 2002, is contained in Respondent’s Exhibit 6. The IEP indicates that STUDENT requires modifications of assignments, class tests, and the classroom seating arrangement, as needed. The IEP does not elaborate regarding the specific modifications STUDENT required. The IEP includes only one goal and several objectives each in areas of solving math word problems, completing homework, and vocational. There are no goals or objectives related to language arts.
The IEP team concluded that because there was no discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and reading she no longer was eligible for language arts RSP. Petitioner asserts that the decision to reduce her RSP services resulted in the denial of FAPE. The District asserts that there were sufficient supports in place to meet STUDENT’s needs. The testimony of STUDENT’s teachers, which is reflected in progress reports and comments on the IEP, establishes that STUDENT was also getting a “one” in social studies and RSP math, and was in danger of retention. All of the teachers commented that poor test scores contributed to STUDENT’s failing grades. (See also Petitioner’s Exhibit J, page B) The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s failing grades were not for a lack of effort. STUDENT’s family testified that they work with her nightly to help her complete homework assignments. Moreover, whereas in the past STUDENT’s motivation had been questionable, the IEP indicated that in October of 2002, STUDENT tried hard and was motivated to do her best.
The response of the District to STUDENT’s failing grades was to recommend that STUDENT participate in the tutoring program. The teachers testified that tutoring is available before and after school. STUDENT testified that when she attempted to go to tutoring, there were other students there and she would have to wait to receive assistance. She also experienced difficulty getting to all of her teachers in one day. STUDENT testified that teachers frequently were unavailable for tutoring. The teachers’ testimony contradicted STUDENT’s testimony as to their availability. The Hearing Officer finds that tutoring outside of the school day does not adequately meet STUDENT’s needs as special education student. The District is required to provide special education students with appropriate supplementary aides and services to meet the student’s needs. These services should fall within the school day. Additionally, given STUDENT’s failing grade in RSP language arts and the fact that STUDENT was at risk of being retained, the Hearing Officer concludes that a reduction in special education services was not warranted. In summary, the District’s response to STUDENT’s failing academic achievement by developing an IEP that decreased special education services was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.
Was the District’s offer reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit?
In light of the finding that one period of RSP in mathematics did not meet STUDENT’s needs and because there was insufficient support to allow STUDENT to achieve satisfactory grades in RSP and general education classes, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Did the District provide Petitioner with a program and services that conformed to her IEP?
Petitioner did not raise any issues regarding conformity with her IEP.
In Summary
The District’s offer did not meet all of Petitioner’s needs and was not reasonably designed to provide her with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer finds that these deficiencies resulted in a denial of FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year.
ISSUE NO. 3: If the District failed to provide Petitioner with a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory education in the form of private tutoring?
A special education student may be entitled to relief when a school district has failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE). School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.)
Petitioner contends that because the District failed to teach her reading skills, she was not able to progress in the general education curriculum. STUDENT testified that she also needs additional help in reading and “would be pleased to have [help] during the summer.”
The Hearing Officer determined above that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years. As discussed above, STUDENT’s reading and language arts skills remain below grade level. STUDENT has expressed interest in receiving additional reading instruction. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that an appropriate compensatory remedy is instruction in reading. Because STUDENT indicated she is willing to spend her summer receiving instruction, it is concluded that the District shall arrange for STUDENT to receive individual instruction in reading during the extended school year program. Because the District has failed in its opportunity to properly instruct STUDENT during the past two years, it is concluded that the District shall identify, arrange for, and fund STUDENT’s instruction from a certified nonpublic school or agency that specializes in reading remediation of students with learning disabilities. During the regular school year 2003-2004, the District shall also fund two weeks hourly of tutoring, in addition to placement and services to which she is entitled pursuant to her IEP, to ensure that STUDENT has sufficient support to achieve passing grades.
.
ISSUE NO. 4: Is the District required to fund an independent psychoeducational assessment of Petitioner?
A parent may obtain reimbursement for an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist, as defined by regulations of the board, if the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency, and the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).
Petitioner has not obtained an independent assessment for which she seeks reimbursement from the District. However, she contends that she is entitled to IEE at the District’s expense because the hearing officer determined as a result of the hearing in case number SN03-00166 that the District failed to conduct an appropriate preexpulsion assessment. Petitioner additionally asserts that she is entitled to an IEE paid for by the District because, in December 2002, the District offered to have her assessed by an independent assessor. In particular, Petitioner seeks an assessment of auditory processing skills and academic achievement. Petitioner proposes that either Mr. Munoz, school psychologist from the Chaffee School District, or Steven Renis, school psychologist from the San Bernardino School District, conduct the assessment.
The District concurs that it has offered to have STUDENT assessed. However, the District proposes that the assessment be undertaken by an appropriately credentialed school psychologist from another school district within the SELPA or by a psychologist from the District who has not previously assessed STUDENT. Neither the Chaffee nor the San Bernardino districts are within the East Valley SELPA.
Petitioner disagreed with the preexpulsion assessment undertaken by the District in December 2002, and filed for a due process hearing (SN03-00166). On March 13, 2003, the decision in SN03-00166 was rendered. The hearing officer concluded that the District had failed to conduct an appropriate preexpulsion assessment of STUDENT.(Footnote 13) Therefore, it has already been determined at a due process hearing that the District’s preexpulsion assessment was not appropriate. For this reason, STUDENT is entitled to an independent assessment at District expense. Given the multiple disputes between the parties regarding assessments in part related to the measuring of STUDENT’s cognitive skills, as well as disputes regarding FAPE, the Hearing Officer determines that the assessment should be undertaken by someone not presently employed by the District. The District shall select an appropriately qualified psychologist within the SELPA with training and experience assessing African-American students with learning disabilities, if such a person exists. If no such person exists within the SELPA, then the District must make arrangements for the assessment to be undertaken by an outside individual. The District is also responsible for providing transportation related to STUDENT’s getting to and from the assessment. The District shall arrange for the assessment to be completed prior to the extended school year (ESY) so that the summer program will have the results of the assessment to take into consideration in developing STUDENT’s program. The IEP team shall also consider the results of the assessment in designing an appropriate program, placement, and services for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year.
ORDER
(1) The District shall fund an assessment of STUDENT’s auditory processing skills and academic achievement by a qualified psychologist within the SELPA with training and experience assessing African-American students with learning disabilities. If such a person does not exist within the SELPA, the District shall identify and arrange for an outside person to undertake the assessment. The District shall also be responsible for STUDENT’s transportation to and from the assessment. The assessment shall be completed by the beginning of the 2003 extended school year program.
(2) The IEP team shall take into consideration the results of the assessment in designing an appropriate program, placement and services for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year.
(3) The District shall identify, arrange, and provide for STUDENT to receive during the extended school year in the summer of 2003, individual instruction in reading from a certified nonpublic school or agency specializing in reading remediation.
(4) During the regular school year 2003-2004, the District shall also fund two weeks hourly of tutoring in addition to placement and services to which she is entitled pursuant to her IEP, to ensure that STUDENT has sufficient support to achieve passing grades.
(5) All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) Did Respondent Rialto Unified School District provide Petitioner STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years?
Respondent prevailed as to the 2000-2001 school year. Petitioner substantially prevailed as to the 2001-2002 school year.
(2) Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(3) If the District failed to provide Petitioner with a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory education in the form of private tutoring?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(4) Is the District required to fund an independent psychoeducational assessment of Petitioner?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: June 3, 2003 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The Decision has been amended for the sole purpose of correcting several references to “Respondents” when, in fact, there is only one Respondent, the Rialto Unified School District. 2. The Hearing Officer’s authority is limited to addressing issues falling within the three-year statute of limitations. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(j). Petitioner initially alleged that there were deficiencies in her education for the entire 1999-2000 school year through the current school year. The Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for hearing on March 4, 2003. Therefore, issues arising prior to March 4, 2000 would be barred by the statute of limitations. Moreover, neither Petitioner nor Respondent presented evidence regarding the 1999-2000 school year. Accordingly, this Decision addresses the appropriateness of Petitioner’s education from the 2000-2001 school year forward. 3. During the 2001-2002 school year, the District changed its grading system. Rather than receiving letter grades, all of the students received number grades spanning from one through four. The students are evaluated and graded according to their achievement on State standards. A grade of “one” means that the student is performing at least two years below grade level and is a candidate for retention. A grade of “two” indicates that the student has some skills that are approaching proficiency but that grade level content standards have not been met. A student performing at level “two” is at risk of retention. A grade of “three” indicates that the student is proficient and that content standards for the grade level are being met. A grade of “four” indicates that the student has achieved mastery of grade level content standards. “For special education students, achievement of IEP goals determines retention status in the area of disability. In other areas, the District’s retention criteria is followed.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit K) 4. Earlier IEP teams had determined that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy in reading and mathematics. 5. The language arts class is taught by a general education teacher and an RSP teacher. 6. The 1997 reauthorization of the IDEA also calls for school districts to provide special education students with access to the general education curriculum and instruction and related services designed to prepare the students for employment and independent living. 7. Ms. Higareda has been a school psychologist for four years. She also has four years of teaching experience 8. CLAD stands for Cross-Cultural Language Acquisition and Development. Teachers may obtain CLAD certification by completing classes that prepare them to address the needs of children from varying language and cultural backgrounds. 9. No one raised a concern or explained why the annual IEP meeting was apparently convened two months late. For this reason, the Hearing Officer declines to address whether the timeliness or lack thereof related to the District’s convening the March 2002 IEP meeting constituted a procedural violation. 10. Ironically, MOTHER testified that the District sent home a notice that at an evening assembly on February 27, 2002, STUDENT would receive an award for academic achievement for the second quarter of the school year. ( See Petitioner’s Exhibit H, pages B and C) STUDENT’s report card indicates that for the second quarter, she received grades of “one” in all classes except physical education. A “one” is defined as “below basic - Attainment of content standards at least two years below grade . . .” and is equivalent to an “F.” 11. Ms. Higareda testified that her assessment of STUDENT in August 2002 led her to conclude that STUDENT’s cognitive skills fall in the low average range, whereas previous assessors concluded that STUDENT’s cognitive skills fell in the average range. It is unnecessary at this point to determine which is correct since either low average or average cognitive skills are more than adequate to allow STUDENT to benefit from general education classes and receive passing grades. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT exhibited excellent debate skills and earned the highest points on the team. STUDENT’s success on the debate team reflects that she is able to competently learn new information and to demonstrate her knowledge on various subjects. (Testimony of Anthony Gibson, debate coach) 12. It is noted that the principal and other teachers testified that homework does not figure into the grade that a student is given. They testified uniformly that homework provided opportunities for the student to practice and allowed the to teacher to evaluate whether the student was grasping the concepts being addressed in the class. Since the English teacher did not testify, it is unclear what effect missing homework had on STUDENT’s grade. 13. Pursuant to California Education Code section 48915.5, the District was required to undertake an assessment satisfying the requirements of 34 C.F.R. section 104.35, which includes a “review of the appropriateness of the pupil’s placement at the time of the alleged misconduct, and a determination of the relationship, if any, between the pupil’s behavior and his or her disability.”
