California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 23, 1999
Student v. Santa Cruz City Schools
SEHO Case No. SN 430-99 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim
Santa Cruz City Schools denied FAPE in reading instruction; must fund a Cabrillo College program, not a Landmark or LDI placement.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
An 18-year-old twelfth grader at Soquel High School filed for a hearing against Santa Cruz City Schools. She was eligible under specific learning disability and took resource specialist classes. Her reading and writing stayed near the fourth- to fifth-grade level. A three-year statute of limitations barred claims before March 27, 1996. The Hearing Officer relied on independent neuropsychologist Tina Guterman and found the student had dyslexia-type phonological processing deficits. The District denied FAPE from March 27, 1996 through 1996-97, and again from fall 1998 until March 23, 1999. It gave no multisensory or phoneme-awareness reading instruction, and its goals had no short-term objectives. The 1997-98 program was marginally appropriate because teacher Carolyn Klindt-Stoops used a multimodal decoding approach. However, transition services from age 16 through 1997-98 were inadequate. The District also ignored the parent's April 1999 request for a speech-language assessment and missed about 12 hours of home instruction. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for private tutoring because there was no evidence it was appropriate. He also denied reimbursement for Dr. Guterman's evaluation because the parent withdrew consent to the District's qualified, non-employee assessor. Two years at Life Development Institute or Landmark College were denied. Instead, the District must fund two years of Cabrillo College tuition, five weekly hours of one-on-one teaching, Kurzweil 3000 access, 30 weekly minutes of vocational services, 12 make-up hours, and a speech-language assessment.
Why it matters
Shows how SEHO granted compensatory education by adopting and adding to a district's two-year community college offer instead of an out-of-state residential program. It also shows that a parent who withdrew consent to the district's qualified, non-employee assessor was not reimbursed for a private evaluation.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1a. Did the District properly evaluate and offer and provide a FAPE to Student during the 1995-96 school year?
Claims through March 26, 1996 were barred by the three-year statute of limitations. From March 27, 1996, the District denied FAPE: it gave no multisensory or phoneme-awareness reading instruction and its goals had no short-term objectives. No procedural violations were found.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b. Did the District properly evaluate and offer and provide a FAPE to Student during the 1996-97 school year?
FAPE was denied. Reading instruction was inappropriate, goals and objectives were inadequate, and transition services were generic. The IEP also did not state how often vocational services would be provided, and transition services began about a month late (found de minimis).
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1c. Did the District properly evaluate and offer and provide a FAPE to Student during the 1997-98 school year?
The program was marginally appropriate because the RSP English teacher used a multimodal decoding approach and the student received some benefit. However, transition services and transition goals were inadequate. A late annual review was de minimis.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1d. Did the District properly evaluate and offer and provide a FAPE to Student during the 1998-99 school year?
FAPE was denied until March 23, 1999: there was no appropriate reading instruction, and goals were inadequate until April 28, 1999. The District failed to respond to the parent's April 1999 request for a speech-language assessment and missed about 12 hours of one-on-one instruction. The assistive technology assessment was timely, the one-month reassessment delay was de minimis, and transition services were appropriate.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2a. Is Student's parent entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred for private tutoring with Carol Beckstrom of Aptos Instruction from January 1996 to March 1997?
Reimbursement was denied because the record had no evidence about the specific tutoring provided or whether it was appropriate.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2b. Is Student's parent entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred for a neuropsychological assessment by Tina Guterman, Ph.D.?
Reimbursement was denied. The District offered a qualified evaluator who was not a District employee, and the parent withdrew consent. With no District evaluation to disagree with, there was no right to an IEE at public expense.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Is Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of two years of schooling (1999-2000 and 2000-2001) at either the Life Development Institute in Phoenix, Arizona, or Landmark College in Putney, Vermont, due to the District's failure to provide a FAPE?
A residential program was not needed. The District's two-year compensatory offer (Cabrillo College tuition, five hours per week of one-on-one instruction, and Kurzweil 3000 access) was appropriate once 30 minutes per week of vocational services was added.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Is Student entitled to appropriate assistive technology in the form of Kurzweil 3000 equipment and appropriate software as part of compensatory education?
This was not decided because the Kurzweil 3000 was already part of the District's compensatory offer. Neither party prevailed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to assess. The District shall immediately conduct a speech and language assessment under federal and state assessment procedures. The decision date is treated as the date of referral.
- Compensatory education. Twelve hours of one-on-one instruction in reading and/or written language by a learning handicapped credentialed teacher, by the end of the 1999 calendar year unless the parties agree otherwise. This is in addition to the five weekly hours below and must not interfere with school or work.
- Compensatory education. For the 1999-2000 and 2000-01 school years: five hours per week of case management and one-on-one instruction by a qualified, certificated teacher on IEP goals, using multisensory and/or other suitable approaches for phonological processing deficits and compensatory strategies.
- Full tuition at Cabrillo Community College in Aptos, California, for the 1999-2000 and 2000-01 school years.
- Order to provide or change services. Ready access to a computer with the Kurzweil 3000 program.
- Order to provide or change services. A minimum of 30 minutes per week of direct and indirect vocational services and consultation during 1999-2000 and 2000-01; the IEP team decides what those services are.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 days of the order, an IEP meeting to decide the vocational services and consultation for 1999-2000. Before the 2000-01 school year begins, an IEP meeting to review progress on goals and revise them as appropriate.
Total: 12 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range Sch. Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified Sch. Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; M.C. v. Central Regional Sch. Dist.; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm.; Landgraf v. USI Film Products
People named in the decision
- Andrew Todd, director of special education, Santa Cruz City Schools
- William Rosse, administrative intern and assistant to the director of special education, Santa Cruz City Schools
- Miriam Bodin, educational consultant retained by parent, Bodin & Associates
- John Fleming, educational consultant to parent; witness for Student
- Tina Guterman, Ph.D., pediatric neuropsychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Robert Crawford, director and founder; witness for Student, Life Development Institute, Phoenix, Arizona
- Francis Sopper, dean of admissions and enrollment; witness for Student, Landmark College, Putney, Vermont
- David Paul, resource specialist teacher, Soquel High School
- Andrew Zehnder, resource specialist teacher and case manager, Soquel High School
- Terrance Pearman, assistant principal, Soquel High School
- Carolyn Klindt-Stoops, resource specialist teacher (RSP English, 1997-98), Soquel High School
- Staci LaCagnin, resource specialist teacher (RSP English, fall 1998), Soquel High School
- Sarah Green, vocational transition specialist, Santa Cruz City Schools Workability Program
- Gayle White, home school teacher providing one-on-one instruction, Santa Cruz City Schools
- Janet Bacon, vocational specialist, Santa Cruz City Schools Transition Partnership Program
- Deborah Shulman, director of Learning Skills Program; witness for District, Cabrillo Community College
- Katie Merchant, Ed.D., school psychologist and private educational psychologist; District's proposed independent neuropsychological assessor; former interim director of special education for the District, San Lorenzo Unified School District
- Bill Schraft, school psychologist (1998 triennial assessment), Santa Cruz City Schools
- Lauren Leff, assistive technology assessor
- Barbara Poole, licensed educational psychologist (1995 triennial assessment), Soquel Elementary School District
- Carol Beckstrom, private tutor, Aptos Instruction
- Aptos Instruction, private tutoring provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Santa Cruz, California, on June 1-3 and 10-11, 1999. The hearing was also convened by telephone on June 14, 1999.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathryn Dobel from the Law Office of Kathryn E. Dobel. Also present on STUDENT's behalf was her father, FATHER. Respondent Santa Cruz City Schools (the District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bridget Flanagan from the law firm of Miller, Brown & Dannis. Also present on the District's behalf was Andrew Todd, the District’s director of special education. William Rosse, an administrative intern and assistant to Mr. Todd, was present on the District’s behalf on June 14, 1999, when the hearing was convened by telephone.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: STUDENT; FATHER; Andrew Todd; Miriam Bodin, an educational consultant; John Fleming, an educational consultant; Tina Guterman, Ph.D., a pediatric neuropsychologist; Robert Crawford, the director and founder of the Life Development Institute in Phoenix, Arizona; and Francis Sopper, the dean of admissions and enrollment at Landmark College in Putney, Vermont.
The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: David Paul, a resource specialist (RS) teacher at Soquel High School (SHS); Andrew Zehnder, an RS teacher at SHS and STUDENT’s case manager; Terrance Pearman, the assistant principal at SHS; Carolyn Klindt-Stoops, an RS teacher at SHS; Staci LaCagnin, an RS teacher at SHS; Sarah Green, a vocational transition specialist with the District’s Workability Program; Gayle White, a home school teacher for the District; Janet Bacon, a vocational specialist with the District’s Transition Partnership Program; Deborah Shulman, the director of the Learning Skills Program at Cabrillo Community College; William Rosse; and Katie Merchant, Ed.D., a school psychologist for the San Lorenzo Unified School District and a part-time private educational psychologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES (footnote 1)
1. Did the District properly evaluate and offer and provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT during the following school terms:
a. the 1995-96 school year?
b. the 1996-97 school year?
c. the 1997-98 school year?
d. the 1998-99 school year?
2. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred for the following:
a. private tutoring with Carol Beckstrom of Aptos Instruction from January 1996 to March 1997? b. a neuropsychological assessment by Tina Guterman, Ph.D.?
3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of two years of schooling (i.e., during the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school terms) at either the Life Development Institute in Phoenix, Arizona, or Landmark College in Putney, Vermont, due to the failure of the District to provide STUDENT a FAPE?
4. Is STUDENT entitled to appropriate assistive technology in the form of Kurzweil 3000 equipment and appropriate software as part of compensatory education?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eighteen-year-old twelfth-grade student who qualifies for special education and related services because of a specific learning disability (SLD). She was first found eligible in March 1992 while a fifth-grade student at Good Shepherd Primary School, a private religious school which she had attended since kindergarten. The individualized education program (IEP) team, which included personnel from Soquel Elementary School District (Soquel ESD), her district of residence, found that STUDENT had average cognitive ability but was performing approximately one and a half years below grade level in reading, mathematics and written language. (footnote 2) The team also noted on the IEP that STUDENT’s short-term memory was weak and that her visual memory was stronger than her auditory memory. After being found eligible, STUDENT continued to attend Good Shepherd for the remainder of her fifth-grade year and during her sixth-grade year. However, during this time, she also received small-group and individual instruction from the resource specialist programs (RSPs) at her neighborhood public schools a few times per week in order to support her efforts in reading, mathematics, and written language, and to develop her organizational skills.
During her seventh- and eighth-grade years, STUDENT attended New Brighton Middle School (NBMS) within Soquel ESD on a full-time basis. (footnote 3) She was enrolled in mainstream classes and, according to her IEP, in a number of resource specialist (RS) classes to support her in reading, mathematics, and written language, and to develop her organizational skills. At an IEP meeting held on March 18, 1994 (during STUDENT’s second semester in seventh grade), Soquel ESD staff recommended that STUDENT’s parent seek private tutoring to help develop STUDENT’s basic reading and writing skills. In approximately May 1994, STUDENT’s father engaged Aptos Instruction (Aptos) to provide tutoring after school in the areas of reading and written language. STUDENT received tutoring from Aptos during the summers of 1994, 1995, and 1996, and intermittently from January 2, 1996, to March 17, 1997.
In April and May 1995, near the end of STUDENT’s eighth-grade year, Soquel ESD conducted a triennial evaluation. Assessment reports were submitted by a licensed educational psychologist and a resource specialist from NBMS. Like the initial assessment conducted in 1995, the triennial assessment found that STUDENT had average cognitive ability but was significantly behind her peers in academic achievement. STUDENT’s then-current grade placement was 8.8, but her broad reading score on the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Academic Achievement Revised (WJ-R) was at the 4.5 grade level, her broad written language score was at the 4.6 grade level, and her broad math score was at the 7.1 grade level. The resource specialist’s report noted that STUDENT’s results on the Detroit Test of Short Term Auditory Memory No. 6 indicated that her short-term auditory memory ability was approximately six years below the levels expected for her age, suggesting that she had a difficult time processing and retaining information presented orally. Her visual memory skills were found to be delayed one to two years, making visual memory a relative strength for STUDENT. The resource specialist also noted that STUDENT’s records showed frequent absences, which occurred less frequently near the end of the school year. This was corroborated by the psychologist, who indicated that STUDENT reported she missed school frequently (at the rate of one day per week). The psychologist found that STUDENT had significant processing deficits in the area of short- and long-term memory and mild motor planning problems. The psychologist also found that STUDENT was socially oriented and generally uninterested in school. The psychologist recommended a number of strategies to counteract STUDENT’s tendency to avoid school, such as arranging for extra support when introducing new materials, reinforcing any interest in school with behavioral strategies, making academic subjects relevant to social issues, and rewarding regular school attendance with socially oriented rewards. Recommendations were also made to improve STUDENT’s academic performance, such as teaching her strategies for rechecking work, encouraging her to proofread her work, encouraging her to continue using her hand-held calculator, and teaching her to take notes, possibly in visual/pictorial form, to help her record information. Based on these assessment results, the IEP team found that STUDENT continued to qualify for special education due to a discrepancy between her overall cognitive ability and reading and written language skills.
Beginning with the ninth grade (the 1995-96 school year), STUDENT became the responsibility of the District since Soquel ESD served only elementary and middle school students. From the ninth through twelfth grades, STUDENT attended Soquel High School (SHS) and was enrolled in two to three RS classes (English, math, social studies, or tutorial) per semester. High school did not go smoothly for STUDENT. Her grades ranged from A’s to F’s and resulted in a total grade point average of 1.735 by the end of her first semester in twelfth grade. STUDENT also consistently had a high number of absences and tardies. Finally, there were a number of disciplinary incidents involving marijuana use and confrontations with teachers. STUDENT has been suspended three times over the course of her high school career thus far: in February 1996 for smoking marijuana during lunch at school, in early March 1999 for being under the influence of an illegal substance while at school, and in mid-March 1999 for threatening a teacher. STUDENT’s problems with substance abuse, absences and tardies, and difficulty with authority figures have been documented in her IEPs.
Beginning in April 1997, STUDENT’s IEPs included individual transition plans and services from the vocational specialist. Sarah Green, the assigned vocational specialist, later helped STUDENT obtain two part-time jobs, one at Santa Cruz Cinema 9 and the other at the local Ross Department Store (she still works at the latter).
In May 1998, a triennial assessment was completed by Bill Schraft, the District’s school psychologist, and Andrew Zehnder, STUDENT’s case manager. As with previous assessments, STUDENT was found to have average cognitive ability but a significant delay in academic performance. STUDENT’s then-current grade placement was about 11.9, but her broad reading score on the Woodcock-Johnson Psychoeducational Battery - Revised was at the 5.2 grade level, her written language score was at the 4.8 grade level, and her math score was at the 6.5 grade level. Mr. Schraft found that STUDENT’s short-term auditory memory was improved compared to prior test results, but her long-term memory for general information remained weaker. He also found that her expressive vocabulary had declined somewhat, suggesting that she needed to read more, and that her arithmetic reasoning had also declined somewhat. Additionally, he noted that teachers, administrators, and peers had reported that on occasion STUDENT appeared “high” (i.e., under the influence of a controlled substance such as marijuana). He recommended that she continue in the RSP and that the parent consider seeking assessment and/or treatment by an outside agency for the suspected substance abuse.
At about this time, FATHER, STUDENT’s father, engaged the services of John Fleming, an educational consultant, to assist him with the IEP process. Mr. Fleming accompanied FATHER to the IEP meeting that was held to review the triennial assessment on June 9, 1998. The IEP team found that STUDENT continued to qualify for special education based on a significant discrepancy in the areas of reading and written language (specifically spelling), and recommended continued placement in the RSP with vocational education consultation services as needed. FATHER did not indicate agreement with the IEP until a subsequent informal meeting with Mr. Zehnder and Mr. Schraft on June 15, 1998, when amendments were made to portions of the IEP based on FATHER’s recommendations. This was the last IEP on which the parties completely agreed.
By letter dated September 30, 1998, FATHER requested that the District perform an assistive technology assessment in an attempt to facilitate STUDENT’s ability to read and write. When there was no definitive response from the District, this request was reiterated in a letter dated November 23, 1998. However, two days later, FATHER wrote a letter “releasing the district of its time requirement” to perform the assessment until the need for an assessment could be discussed at the upcoming IEP meeting in December 1998, and asked the District to instead focus on providing vocational counseling for STUDENT. At an IEP meeting held on December 3, 1998, the parties could not agree on the appropriate services with regard to transition planning.
By letter dated January 17, 1999, FATHER renewed his request for an assistive technology assessment. The next day, FATHER also requested that the District reassess STUDENT in a fashion similar to the initial assessment for special education eligibility. By letter dated January 19, FATHER informed the District that he was retaining the services of Miriam Bodin of Bodin & Associates because of the District’s failure to provide “appropriate and timely vocational career planning assistance and appropriate academic counseling and programming,” and would seek reimbursement for the cost of her services.
On January 20, 1999, the District filed a request for a due process hearing based on the allegations that it failed to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) and the request for reimbursement for Ms. Bodin’s services.
By letter dated January 21, the District requested that the parent consent to refer STUDENT to the Santa Cruz County Children’s Mental Health for an assessment to determine whether she might qualify for AB 3632 school-based therapy. The District based the request on STUDENT’s continued high absentee rate and her failure to be present to take her final examinations for the semester. Four days later, FATHER declined to consent to the referral and informed the District that STUDENT was seeing a private counselor.
On February 1, 1999, the District provided FATHER with an assessment plan for an assistive technology assessment, which he signed the next day. The District also asked FATHER if he wanted the time line for the “additional testing” to begin. The assistive technology assessment was completed on February 19, 1999, by Lauren Leff. Ms. Leff administered the Peabody Individual Achievement Test - Revised to STUDENT to ascertain her reading and spelling ability. STUDENT scored at the 4.4 grade level in reading recognition, at the 4.4 level in reading comprehension, and at the 5.6 level in spelling. Ms. Leff acknowledged in her report that she had only limited knowledge of what is available for adults with low reading and spelling skills, but concluded that the Kurzweil 3000 (PC-based reading software for people with reading difficulties) could be a valuable tool in assisting STUDENT to read and write closer to the level expected for her grade.
At an IEP meeting held on March 5, 1999, the District recommended that STUDENT continue to receive a minimum of two periods of RSP per semester and a minimum of thirty minutes of direct and indirect vocational consultation per week, and receive access to a Kurzweil 3000 system and one and a half hours of one-on-one instruction in reading, math, and written language two times per week. STUDENT and her father agreed generally with the proposed services but only agreed to a one-month provision of one-on-one instruction (until April 14, 1999) and disagreed that STUDENT should be provided only with “access” to the Kurzweil 3000 (they wanted “provision” of the system in conjunction with training by a qualified person). Additionally, STUDENT and her father told the team that they wanted placement at the Life Development Institute (LDI) in Phoenix, Arizona, for the 1999-2000 school year (based on a recommendation by Ms. Bodin) and wanted the District to perform a complete neuropsychological and academic assessment. An assessment plan was developed at the meeting for the requested assessment, and STUDENT and her father signed it. That same day, the District withdrew its request for a due process hearing. Twenty-one days later, Petitioner’s attorney informed the District that the family did not believe that Katie Merchant, Ed.D., the person the District selected to perform the neuropsychological assessment, was an appropriate assessor and they would instead have Tina Guterman, Ph.D., perform the assessment. That same day, Petitioner filed a request for a due process hearing.
In the beginning of April 1999, Dr. Guterman completed her neuropsychological evaluation of STUDENT. Dr. Guterman found that STUDENT had a long-standing history of dyslexia and language-based learning disabilities. Dr. Guterman also found that STUDENT’s current overall cognitive functioning was in the average range, although there was a 27-point discrepancy between her overall verbal comprehension abilities (low average range) and perceptual organization abilities (average to high average range). Dr. Guterman summarized the remainder of her findings about STUDENT’s abilities and deficits as follows:
On neurocognitive tasks, relative strengths emerge on tasks requiring visual spatial reasoning of concrete stimuli. However, [STUDENT] demonstrates significant weaknesses in the areas of encoding, processing symbolic information, and verbal expression and comprehension. Her academic skill level in reading, written expression, and math is in the borderline range of functioning and significantly below age and grade expectancies indicating little progress to date. STUDENT continues to have trouble with encoding and decoding phonological representations as well as word retrieval. The lack of automaticity in STUDENT’s decoding skills negatively impacts her reading comprehension. She is dysnomic and cirumlocutious meaning that her problems with accessing specific words result in the use of wrong words, the use of fillers, and the use of roundabout speech that at times does not arrive at the point at hand. Consistent with language based deficits, STUDENT’s memory style across verbal and visual domains is “impressionistic” in which the overall gestalt of the information is retained, but the details are more likely to be omitted or distorted upon free recall. However, recognition accuracy is strong, indicating difficulties with retrieval, not with storage. Current testing reveals lateralizing signs and suggest left hemisphere inefficiencies.
Dr. Guterman concluded that the District had failed to accurately determine the nature of and appropriately address STUDENT’s learning disability. She stated that the District had misinterpreted STUDENT’s cognitive functioning as being composed of equally developed verbal and nonverbal abilities and had misdiagnosed her greatest area of difficulty, which was an encoding deficit, not a memory deficit. Dr. Guterman found that, at a minimum, STUDENT should have been provided individual tutoring using the Orton Gillingham, Slingerland, DISTAR, or Lindamood methods upon her entry into special education to help develop decoding skills, comprehension strategies, and study skills. She also found that a word processor with a spell checker and/or a hand-held spell checker should have been used to compensate for STUDENT’s deficit in spelling, but that the District’s assessment suggested only that STUDENT might “enjoy using one.” Dr. Guterman concluded that STUDENT should have also received a speech and language evaluation, if not speech therapy, to help with her fluency. Finally, Dr. Guterman found that STUDENT’s episodes of “acting out” through absenteeism, tardiness, and occasional substance abuse “likely” reflected her poor coping strategies and inability to manage feelings of frustration, inferiority, and hopelessness.
Dr. Guterman recommended the following for STUDENT: a transition program following high school to help develop compensatory strategies, strengthen basic academic skills, and acquire workplace literacy and life skills (she recommended that strong consideration be given to placement at LDI or Landmark College (Landmark) in Putney, Vermont); assistive technology to help compensate for the learning disability, such as the Kurzweil 3000; continued tutoring to help with reading for context, learning to use outlining techniques for written language assignments, and study skills; and a speech and language evaluation to address fluency.
By letter dated April 14, 1999, the District’s attorney informed Petitioner’s attorney that the District still wanted to assess STUDENT using the evaluator of its choice and that, because the parent had withdrawn consent for the assessment, it would resubmit to STUDENT a new assessment plan for her consent. Dr. Merchant never assessed STUDENT, however, because the District did not receive consent again for the assessment.
At an IEP meeting held on April 28, 1999, Dr. Guterman presented her assessment findings and recommendations to the IEP team. Gayle White, the home school teacher who had been working with STUDENT on a one-on-one basis since March 22, 1999, also presented an update of STUDENT’s progress in home instruction. The District recommended that for the remainder of the 1998-99 school year STUDENT continue with two periods of RSP per semester, a minimum of thirty minutes of direct and indirect vocational consultation, three hours per week of one-on-one instruction in reading and writing, and access to the Kurzweil 3000 system, and daily one-on-one instruction from a teacher intern from the University of California at Santa Cruz (UCSC) during her RS tutorial class. STUDENT and her father consented to the recommended placement and services, but also requested that STUDENT receive at least five hours per week with Ms. White and one-on-one instruction at all times during her RS classes for the remainder of the school year and for the extended school year (ESY). They also requested a speech and language assessment by a neurolinguistic specialist with a Ph.D. to further explore the possibility of a language disability, placement at LDI or Landmark for the 1999-2000 school year, and “provision” of the Kurzweil 3000 system with training by a qualified person for the remainder of the school year, as well as the ESY and the 1999-2000 school year.
By letter dated May 5, 1999, the District offered STUDENT an educational program for the 1999 ESY and 1999-2000 school year as compensatory education. The District stated that it believed that it had provided her with an appropriate education over the past few years, but that the offer was being made “to the extent that the school district may not have provided [her] with every necessary service.” The District also indicated that its offer was not contingent on whether or not STUDENT graduated during the 1998-99 school year. The 1999 ESY offer included thirty hours of one-on-one instruction and case management (at least twenty-four of the hours to be direct instruction) by a qualified and certified teacher, enrollment in the summer school program at either SHS or Cabrillo Community College (Cabrillo), access to a computer with the Kurzweil 3000 program, and consultation with a vocational specialist as needed during the length of the District’s summer high school program (June 16 to July 21). For the 1999-2000 school year, the District offered five hours per week of case management and one-on-one instruction by a qualified and certified teacher to address IEP goals and objectives, enrollment at Cabrillo on a full-time basis, access to a computer with the Kurzweil 3000 program, and vocational services and consultation as needed through the District’s Transition Partnership Program or Workability Program. In a subsequent letter, the District offered to extend the offer for the 1999-2000 school year through the end of the 2000-2001 school year.
On a final note, STUDENT has earned all the credits that she needs to graduate from high school and has passed two of the three competency tests that are needed to graduate (math and reading). She has taken the written language competency test two times but failed both times. She presently refuses to take the test again, stating that she feels she is not yet able to pass the test and does not want to fail it again. District personnel working with STUDENT believe that she could presently pass the writing competency because of the extra assistance she has been receiving from the UCSC interns and Ms. White.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (footnote 4) 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d) (1997) (former version at 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c) (1994)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000 (Deering 1987). The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997) (former version at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18) (1994)).
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25) (1997) (formerly 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16) (1994)). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22) (1997) (former version at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17) (1994)). Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of possible related services are psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, parent counseling and training, specially designed vocational education and career development, and counseling and guidance. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22) (1997) (former version at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17) (1994)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b) (Deering 1987).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b) (1997) (amending 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1994)). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Thus, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold, requiring the hearing officer to determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been violated and to determine whether the FAPE provided was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.
1. Did the District properly evaluate and offer and provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT during the following school terms:
a. the 1995-96 school year?
Before examining the procedural and substantive aspects of the 1995-96 school year, the Hearing Officer notes that a three-year statute of limitations governs the filing of claims brought under the IDEA in California pursuant to Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified Sch. Dist., 817 F.2d 551, 555 (9th Cir. 1987), and the recently enacted California Education Code § 56043(p). The existence of a three-year statute of limitations was raised during the discussion of the issues on the first day of hearing. Petitioner conceded that a three-year statute of limitations applied although she suggested that this case might be related to the District’s request for a hearing, which had been filed and withdrawn before Petitioner filed her request for the instant hearing. Petitioner has presented no authority, however, for relating the instant matter back to the District’s withdrawn request in the absence of a consolidation and in light of the fact that the previous request was not made by Petitioner. Since the instant matter is not an amendment of a complaint previously filed by Petitioner, the Hearing Officer finds that the relation back doctrine is not applicable and that the three-year statute of limitations applies from the date Petitioner filed her request for a due process hearing. Fed. R. Civ. P. 15(c); Cal. Civ. Proc. Code § 473(a)(1); Honig v. Financial Corp. of America, 6 Cal. App. 4th 960, 966 (2d Dist. 1992).
Because Petitioner filed her request for a hearing on March 26, 1999, she is barred from raising any claims that accrued on or before March 26, 1996. Therefore, this decision will address on the merits only those claims that accrued on or after March 27, 1996.
(1) procedural appropriateness
There were no allegations of procedural violations specific to the 1995-96 school year. However, Petitioner alleged that the District committed a number of procedural violations which were not specific to any particular year, but were of a continuing nature. Petitioner alleged that the District improperly (1) failed to assess STUDENT in the area of speech and language, (2) failed to assess her prior to May 1998 given the issues presented, (3) failed to track and record her progress on goals and objectives in her IEPs, and (4) failed to specify the frequency and duration of services on her IEPs. Each argument will be addressed in turn.
Assess in the Area of Speech and Language
When evaluating a student for special education purposes, a school district must assess the student in all areas related to the suspected disability including, where appropriate, language function. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(a)(f) (1996) (codified at 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(C) (1997)) ; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f) (Deering Supp. 1999). There is no dispute that since the fifth grade STUDENT has been eligible for special education and related services on the basis of a specific learning disability. More specifically, she has a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in the areas of basic reading, written language, and (beginning in at least June 1998) math calculation due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written. See 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(15) (1994) (current version at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26) (1997)); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030 (1988). (Her IEPs indicate that the IEP team found that she had a disorder in attention, although it is not apparent from the record why she was found to have a disorder in attention.) Additionally, there is no dispute that the District has never conducted a formal speech and language evaluation for STUDENT, and that STUDENT has never been referred for a speech and language evaluation until her parent requested one in the spring semester of her twelfth-grade year based on a recommendation made by Tina Guterman, Ph.D.
Petitioner offered the testimony of Dr. Guterman to support her position that the District should have evaluated STUDENT in the area of speech and language earlier. Dr. Guterman, who assessed STUDENT at her father’s request in April 1999, is a fully qualified and licensed psychologist specializing in pediatric neuropsychology. Dr. Guterman found that STUDENT’s expressive language was “problematic” and that she had significant word retrieval problems. Dr. Guterman also found that STUDENT was dysnomic and circumlocutious, meaning that her problems with accessing specific words resulted in the frequent use of wrong words, the use of fillers such as “you know” and “all that,” and the use of roundabout speech that at times did not “arrive at the point at hand.” Dr. Guterman concluded that the District should have assessed STUDENT in the area of speech and language, if not provided her speech therapy to help with fluency issues. Dr. Guterman’s report issued in April 1999 recommended that STUDENT be evaluated in the area of speech and language to determine if there were any recommendations to help with fluency.
The evidence taken as a whole, however, fails to establish that the District should have assessed STUDENT in the area of speech and language during the 1995-96 school year. Dr. Guterman did not meet or assess STUDENT until April 1999, did not find that there were any indications in STUDENT’s past records of a fluency or retrieval problem, and did not establish that there were any past indications of a fluency or retrieval problem by speaking with any of the school staff who worked with STUDENT. To the contrary, STUDENT’s triennial assessment in April 1995 found that she did not require further testing in the area of communication because her articulation, voice use, and fluency seemed to be in the normal range. Further, there were no reports from any of STUDENT’s teachers or her parents suggesting that there were ever concerns regarding her speech and language development before Dr. Guterman’s assessment. In fact, STUDENT’s teachers reported that she spoke well during class discussions and was very sociable with her peers. Finally, there was no evidence that any problems STUDENT might presently have with fluency are of a long-standing nature or that they existed during the 1995-96 school year. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not obligated to assess STUDENT in the area of speech and language during the 1995-96 school year.
Assess Prior to May 1998
A child with a disability must be reassessed at least every three years, or more frequently if “conditions warrant” or the child’s parent or teacher requests an evaluation. 34 C.F.R. § 300.534(b) (1996) (codified at 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A) (1997)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381 (Deering 1987) (current version at Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a) (Deering Supp. 1999)). STUDENT received a triennial evaluation by Soquel Elementary School District (Soquel ESD) in April and May 1995. The District reassessed STUDENT in May 1998. Neither STUDENT’s parents nor her teachers requested a reevaluation of her before May 1998. No evidence was presented that conditions warranted a reevaluation of STUDENT between March 27, 1996, and the end of the 1995-96 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not violate STUDENT’s right to a FAPE by not evaluating her between March 27, 1996, and the end of the 1995-96 school year.Track and Record Progress on Goals and Objectives
The provisions in effect during the 1995-96 school year required a school district to initiate and conduct meetings at least annually to review a student’s IEP and, if appropriate, revise its provisions. 34 C.F.R. § 300.343(d) (1996) (codified at 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(4)(A) (1997)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(d) (Deering Supp. 1999). They also required a school district to include in the IEP appropriate objective criteria and evaluation procedures and schedules for determining, at least annually, whether instructional objectives were being achieved. 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(5) (1996); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(6) (Deering 1987) (amended 1998).
The evidence established that the District met its obligation to review STUDENT’s progress at least annually during the 1995-96 school year. The District convened an IEP meeting on May 1, 1996, to review STUDENT’s progress on the goals and objectives listed on her IEP dated June 6, 1995. STUDENT and her father were present at the meeting, as well as Bill Schraft, the school psychologist, and Andrew Zehnder, STUDENT’s case manager and RS English teacher. According to Mr. Zehnder’s testimony, because he was STUDENT’s case manager, Mr. Zehnder collected information regarding her progress from his own experience with her in his RS English class and from her other teachers. Using this information, Mr. Zehnder prepared a document detailing STUDENT’s present levels of performance and reviewed the information with the IEP team during the annual review. Mr. Zehnder also testified that, while STUDENT’s progress on goals and objectives was not noted in writing on her IEPs, her progress on goals and objectives was reviewed at each of the annual review meetings. This was not controverted by Petitioner. Additionally, the evidence established that STUDENT’s IEPs during the 1995-96 school year contained appropriate objective criteria and evaluation procedures and schedules for determining, at least annually, whether instructional objectives were being achieved. Both her IEP dated June 6, 1995, and her IEP dated May 1, 1996, contained objectives that were clearly defined in terms of the goal to be achieved and the accuracy rate sought, as well as the method of evaluation. (footnote 5) However, the Hearing Officer is not aware of any authority, and Petitioner did not present any, which would have required the District to record STUDENT’s progress on goals and objectives on her IEPs during the 1995-96 school year. Although such a written record would have been beneficial for both the IEP team’s review and for the hearing in this matter, nothing in the IDEA requires the District to have kept such a record.
In light of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not commit a procedural violation by failing to track and record STUDENT’s progress on goals and objectives during the 1995-96 school year.
Specify Frequency and Duration of Services
During the 1995-96 school year, the IDEA required that the IEP of a child with a disability describe the specific special educational instruction and related services required by the child, as well as the projected date for initiation and the anticipated duration of the services. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(20) (1994); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a) (Deering 1987). The IEP must also have designated the amount of services to be provided so that the level of the school district’s commitment of resources would be clear to the parents and other IEP team members. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 51 (1996). Both the IEP dated June 6, 1995, and the IEP dated May 1, 1996, clearly noted the frequency and duration of the RSP services that were to be provided to STUDENT. Her IEP dated June 6, 1995, stated that she was to receive three periods of RSP per day. Her IEP dated May 1, 1996, stated that she was to receive two to three periods of RSP per day. Because a “period” is a common unit of time used in high schools, it adequately denoted the amount of RS assistance STUDENT was to receive. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not find persuasive Petitioner’s argument that the IEPs failed to specify the frequency and duration of the services provided during the 1995-96 school year.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not violate any of the procedural safeguards of the IDEA from March 27, 1996, to the end of the 1995-96 school year..
(2) substantive appropriateness
In determining whether the District provided a FAPE, the focus is on the adequacy of the District’s program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). To be appropriate, an educational program must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the student’s IEP. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208. An “appropriate” public education does not mean, however, the absolutely best or “potential-maximizing” education for the student. Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.
Designed To Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs
In order to determine whether the placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, it is first necessary to understand STUDENT’s needs. The assessments conducted by Soquel ESD in 1992 and 1995, by the District in 1998, and by Dr. Guterman in 1999 establish that STUDENT is a student of overall average intellectual ability who has deficits that affect her academic achievement in reading and written language. During the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT’s reading and written language skills were significantly below the levels expected for her grade and age. Her triennial assessment in 1995 found that her skills in reading and written language were approximately four years behind her current grade placement. On the Woodcock Johnson Test of Academic Achievement - Revised (WJ-R), which was administered in April 1995 when STUDENT’s grade placement was 8.8, STUDENT obtained a broad reading score at the 4.5 grade level and a broad written language score at the 4.6 grade level. The fact that her skills in these areas was severely depressed was corroborated by the testing done by Aptos Instruction in 1994, the District in May 1998, and Dr. Guterman in April 1999. In fact, STUDENT was unable to score above the fifth-grade level in reading and written language on the WJ-R even by the time she was in the twelfth grade.
While the fact that STUDENT had very low reading and written language skills is clearly established by the evidence, what was not so clear was the exact nature of the deficits which contributed to her low functioning in these areas. As previously mentioned, STUDENT was assessed by Soquel ESD in April 1995 and by the District in May 1998. Barbara Poole, the licensed educational psychologist who apparently performed the 1995 assessment for Soquel ESD, found that STUDENT had “significant” processing deficits in short- and long-term memory. She reported that STUDENT’s scores on the Visual-Aural Digit Span Test indicated that her overall short-term memory age was equivalent to a child of eight years to eight years, five months (STUDENT was fourteen years and two months old at the time). Ms. Poole noted that STUDENT’s weakest scores were on tasks requiring recall of visually presented materials calling for written expression and recall of auditorally presented materials calling for oral expression (both were in the tenth percentile or less range). Bill Schraft, the school psychologist who performed the District’s triennial assessment in May 1998, found that STUDENT’s short-term auditory and visual memory were age-appropriate (short-term auditory memory having improved considerably compared to past test results). Mr. Schraft also found that her language-based abilities were relatively equally developed with her visual-spatial abilities, but that her expressive vocabulary was relatively weak. Additionally, he reported that her test profile suggested some weaknesses in auditory concentration and knowledge acquisition. (footnote 6)
Dr. Guterman, who conducted the most recent assessment, testified that STUDENT had a long-standing history of dyslexia and language-based learning disabilities, and disagreed with Ms. Poole’ s finding that STUDENT had a memory deficit. Dr. Guterman is a fully qualified and licensed psychologist who specializes in pediatric neuropsychology. Dr. Guterman assessed STUDENT in April 1999 by reviewing past educational records, interviewing FATHER for about one hour, and interviewing and formally testing STUDENT for seven to eight hours. (Dr. Guterman did not interview STUDENT’s mother, speak with any school personnel, or observe STUDENT in the school environment.) After the assessment, Dr. Guterman found that even though STUDENT performed in the average range on overall intellectual functioning on the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Test - Third Edition (WAIS-III), a twenty-seven point difference between her verbal comprehension score (84) and her perceptual organization score (111) showed that she had significantly weaker verbal cognitive abilities. Dr. Guterman noted that STUDENT’s performance on the intelligence tests were very similar to that of a person with dyslexia, i.e., she had problems with symbolic information (footnote 7) and language-based learning disabilities. Dr. Guterman testified that STUDENT had deficits in encoding (she described this as taking information in on the “front end”), especially with symbolic or noncontextual material, and not memory (or losing information). Dr. Guterman testified that STUDENT needed assistance learning information, not necessarily with retaining information, and needed a physical strategy in order to learn. She found that STUDENT performed better when material was repeated and concrete or contextual, and, because of problems with retrieving stored information, with multiple choice activities. Finally, she found that STUDENT was only performing at the fifth-grade level in phonetic decoding, sight reading, and reading comprehension by the end of her twelfth-grade year.
On the whole, the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Guterman’s conclusions more credible than those contained in the assessments conducted by Soquel ESD and the District. Neither Ms. Poole nor Mr. Schraft were at the hearing to testify about their assessments; only their written reports were admitted into evidence. Regardless of whether or not the reports would be admissible in civil actions, Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3082(b), (footnote 8) the reports standing alone do not provide persuasive evidence about STUDENT’s unique needs, especially when contradicted by the testimony of Dr. Guterman. Many questions go unanswered when the assessors are not presented to testify and when the reports fail to fully explain themselves (i.e., fail to provide information that could establish the validity of the findings contained therein). For instance, there is no evidence in the record regarding either Ms. Poole’s or Mr. Schraft’s qualifications to perform psychoeducational assessments, their experience in conducting such assessments, how the tests were administered, or the testing conditions under which the results were obtained. In contrast, Dr. Guterman provided a detailed written report and extensive testimony to establish in the record the validity of her conclusions. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer accepts as persuasive Dr. Guterman’s conclusions about the nature of STUDENT’s learning disability and the specialized instruction needed to address her disability.
Having determined STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer now turns to the question of whether the District provided STUDENT a program that addressed her needs from March 27, 1996, to the conclusion of the 1995-96 school year. STUDENT was enrolled in the following courses during the spring semester of the 1995-96 school year: RSP Math, RSP English, Women’s Chorus, Spanish I, World Civilization, and physical education (PE). The RSP classes were to provide small-group and individual instruction to support reading, written language, and math skill development. Her IEP dated June 6, 1995, also provided that the case manager was responsible for weekly consultation and/or collaboration with the regular education teachers to support reading and written language skill development.
Petitioner contended that the foregoing program was not appropriate because STUDENT required an educational program that was more intensive than the RSP assistance she received while in the ninth grade to remediate her deficits in reading and written language. Petitioner based her contention on numerous allegations, most of which were not supported by the evidence. Those allegations included the following. Petitioner argued that she required immersion in a multisensory, phoneme awareness program, or other suitable program to address her phonological processing deficits, such as the Orton Gillingham, Slingerland, DISTAR, or Lindamood-Bell program. Petitioner also contended that she required one-on-one instruction to benefit from her educational program, that the educational program was not sufficiently tailored to address STUDENT’s memory deficits, and that the goals and objectives were inappropriate. Petitioner contended that these inadequacies resulted in a failure to progress academically. Each of these arguments will be addressed in turn.
program to address phonological processing deficits
The evidence clearly established that the District did not provide STUDENT with a multisensory, phoneme awareness, or other suitable program to address her phonological processing deficits from March 27, 1996, to the end of the 1995-96 school year. Mr. Zehnder, STUDENT’s case manager and ninth-grade RSP English teacher, testified that he never employed a decoding program, such as Slingerland, with STUDENT and did not testify that he used multisensory approaches to teach her. Mr. Zehnder testified that he understood STUDENT’s learning disability affected her reading and written language skills, resulted in trouble decoding, and consisted of problems with short- and long-term memory. He did not, however, have any concerns about phonemic awareness with STUDENT because, based on her ability to perform class assignments, he judged that she was an “okay” reader, regardless of whether she used decoding to read. Mr. Zehnder testified that he had found it “frustrating” and not worthwhile to teach phonics to high school students, especially those with learning disabilities, because it is a sequential and time-consuming program that requires the students to master skills at each level. Mr. Zehnder testified that he instead used spelling packets and vocabulary lessons to teach the students how to recognize and pronounce words. According to Mr. Zehnder, the class reviewed the spelling words, which were frequently used words, learned the broader rules of word construction, like those concerning prefixes, and learned the pronunciation and meaning of vocabulary words. He also testified that, while he did not use any instructional strategies to teach decoding, he had the class read out loud to practice fluency.
In contrast, Dr. Guterman testified that, because of her dyslexia and language-based learning disabilities, STUDENT required immersion in a multisensory or phoneme awareness program. Dr. Guterman found that STUDENT had encoding difficulties, particularly with symbolic or noncontextual information, phonological processing deficits, and trouble processing verbal information without accompanying visual cues. According to Dr. Guterman, research in the area of dyslexia and language-based learning disabilities in general has shown that “sustained and systematic” instruction targeting phonological coding through the approaches used by programs such as Orton Gillingham, Slingerland, DISTAR, or Lindamood-Bell is effective for disabilities like STUDENT’s. The testimony of Gayle White, a home school teacher for the District who has been working with STUDENT since March 1999 on reading, writing, and vocabulary, supported Dr. Guterman’s conclusions. Based on her three months’ experience working with STUDENT on a one-on-one basis, Ms. White testified that STUDENT requires multisensory input (such as visualization combined with verbalization) to learn reading and spelling skills. Ms. White also testified that STUDENT needs phonetic skills to decode before she can read because, if she cannot decode, she will have difficulty understanding what she has read. Before starting to work as a home school teacher for the District in March 1999, Ms. White had worked as a regular education classroom teacher for five years, a private tutor for six years, and an RS teacher for twenty-nine years. She testified that she has had many hours of training in Lindamood-Bell, Orton-Gillingham, and DISTAR, as well as over seventy-five postgraduate units in special education and counseling.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District should have provided, but failed to provide, STUDENT with a program to address her phonological processing deficits, such as a multisensory or phoneme awareness program. The testimony of Dr. Guterman and Ms. White established that STUDENT required such a program. The District did not present any evidence to refute this. While Mr. Zehnder testified that a phoneme awareness program can be frustrating for a high school student, there was no evidence that such an approach would have been inappropriate to use with STUDENT. Additionally, no evidence was presented as to how the approach used by Mr. Zehnder addressed STUDENT’s unique needs except that it addressed reading disabilities in general. While many students in a particular classroom may have reading disabilities (what Mr. Zehnder defined as an inability to “retain that type of information”), the cause of a particular student’s reading disability is likely to vary from those of his or her classmates. Hence, to assist the student to benefit, the approach or method used with each student should vary in accordance with the unique nature of the student’s reading disability and should not be premised on a general conclusion that he or she suffers from a reading disability. The evidence failed to show that any members of STUDENT’s IEP team or any of her teachers understood the unique nature of her disability, or that any of her teachers taught her in ways designed to allow her to learn despite her disability. For example, the evidence established that STUDENT has encoding difficulties, particularly with symbolic and noncontextual information. Despite this, there was no evidence to explain how an approach that required STUDENT to learn words (i.e., symbolic information) in isolation (noncontextual), like the spelling packets and vocabulary lessons used by Mr. Zehnder, were designed to address her unique needs. Further, there was no dispute that STUDENT required instruction that involved multiple sensory input and repetition of material in order for her to benefit, yet there was no evidence that the District provided such instruction.
This is not, as the District argued, simply a question of preferred methodology. While the determination of which educational method is most suitable to a child’s needs is properly left to state and local educational agencies in cooperation with the parents or guardian of a child, Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207, the District failed to provide any evidence that its method of instruction was actually designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs.
one-on-one instruction
With regard to Petitioner’s second contention, that STUDENT required one-on-one instruction in order to benefit from her education, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence failed to support this contention. Dr. Guterman’s report stated that STUDENT should have received individual tutoring using a multisensory or phoneme awareness program, but no explanation was offered as to why the instruction needed to be on a one-on-one basis. A bare conclusion, without more, is insufficient to establish an ultimate fact, and it is not apparent from STUDENT’s unique needs why the instruction needed to be on a one-on-one basis. Further, no evidence was offered to establish that STUDENT otherwise required one-on-one instruction. On the contrary, Mr. Zehnder testified that STUDENT showed an ability to perform assignments in the classroom without one-on-one instruction. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT did not require one-on-one instruction to benefit from her education.
memory deficits
Petitioner argued that the District’s program failed to address STUDENT’s memory deficits. However, Dr. Guterman testified that STUDENT did not have a memory deficit, and no persuasive evidence was presented to establish otherwise. Dr. Guterman found that STUDENT has difficulty retrieving or accessing stored information, which might very well appear as if it is a memory problem. As Petitioner’s own expert concluded that no memory deficit existed and there was no persuasive evidence to refute this, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program did not have to address a memory deficit.
goals and objectives
With regard to Petitioner’s fourth contention regarding the appropriateness of IEP goals and objectives, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s IEP dated June 6, 1995, contained goals and objectives in the areas of reading, written language, school responsibility, and self-help. Her IEP dated May 1, 1996, contained goals and objectives to address reading, written language, and math computation. These goals and objectives addressed STUDENT’s undisputed areas of need. According to Andrew Zehnder’s testimony, he drafted the goals and objectives in the IEP dated May 1996 based on STUDENT’s classroom performance and demonstrated needs in light of the general education curriculum. (footnote 9) Dr. Guterman, however, criticized the goals and objectives as general and broad. She testified that all of the goals and objectives developed by the District for STUDENT, with the exception of the goals and objectives developed at the IEP meeting in April 1999, were inappropriate because they failed to mention the strategies or other means for achieving the objectives. The Hearing Officer does not find this testimony persuasive. The IDEA does not require that the IEP include the specific methods, activities, and materials that will be used to accomplish the objectives. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 39 (1996). Therefore, Dr. Guterman’s conclusion that the goals and objectives were inappropriate is not consistent with the requirements of the IDEA.
However, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives in effect from the period March 27, 1996, to the end of the 1995-96 school year were inappropriate on alternate grounds. An IEP is required to include short-term instructional objectives. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(20) (1994) (current version at 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii) (1997)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2) (Deering Supp. 1999). Short-term instructional objectives (i.e., IEP objectives) are measurable, intermediate steps between the child’s present levels of educational performance and the annual goals that are established for the child. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 39 (1996). The objectives should be developed based on a logical breakdown of the major components of the annual goals and should be projected to be accomplished over an extended period of time, such as a school quarter or semester. Id. The IEP objectives provide general benchmarks for measuring the child’s progress toward meeting the annual goals. Id. Neither the IEP dated June 6, 1995, nor the IEP dated May 1, 1996, contained short-term instructional objectives. For example, the IEP dated June 1995, which was in effect from March 27, 1996, until the next IEP was adopted in May 1996, contained only one objective that was meant to address STUDENT’s reading deficit. One objective, standing alone, cannot constitute an intermediate step or a breakdown of the major components of the annual goal. Short-term instructional objectives are especially important here where STUDENT was functioning four grades below in subjects as basic as reading and writing, and needed the benchmarks to determine whether she was making adequate progress in improving her reading and writing skills.
Furthermore, goals and objectives should focus on offsetting or reducing the problems resulting from a child’s disability that interfere with learning and educational performance in school. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 40 (1996). For a child with a learning disability who is functioning several grades below his or her indicated ability in reading, such as STUDENT, the IEP goals and objectives should be directed to (1) closing the gap between the child’s indicated ability and current level of functioning, and (2) helping the child improve the specific skills that are contributing to the discrepancy between ability and functioning. Id. Most of STUDENT’s goals and objectives failed to target the problems or weak skill areas that were contributing to her low functioning in reading and written language. For instance, the IEP dated May 1, 1996, had as its major reading objective that STUDENT would read in every RSP English class for fifteen minutes and record what she had read in a log. There was no evidence that this objective, meant simply to increase the time and amount of reading that STUDENT did, addressed the deficits that were leading to STUDENT’s low functioning in reading, as required by the IDEA.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program from March 27, 1996, to the end of the 1995-96 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs to the extent that it failed to appropriately address her primary deficit in reading and failed to include appropriate goals and objectives.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s proposed program must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Id., 142 F.3d at 130; M.C. v. Central Regional Sch. Dist., 81 F.3d 389, 393 (3d Cir. 1996).
The Hearing Officer found above that the District failed to appropriately address STUDENT’s primary deficit in reading, and failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives. Because the evidence established that STUDENT’s primary deficit (reading) was not addressed through appropriate specialized instruction or appropriate goals and objectives, and because reading skills significantly impact a student’s ability to be successful in most other academic areas, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. This conclusion is supported by the poor progress STUDENT made on goals and objectives and the low grades she received in regular education academic courses. (footnote 10) Mr. Zehnder testified that STUDENT failed to achieve any of her reading and written language objectives by the conclusion of the 1995-96 school year. Mr. Zehnder also testified that, although STUDENT’s writing skills might have improved somewhat, her reading comprehension, decoding, and general reading skills were the same by the end of the tenth grade as they were when she entered SHS in the ninth grade. As for grades, STUDENT received an “F” in World Civilization and a “C” in Spanish. Moreover, she made only nominal advancement on standardized achievement testing over a three-year period. Her broad reading score on the WJ-R failed to increase by more than 0.7 of a grade level between the April 1995 and May 1998 administrations of the WJ-R (4.5 grade level in April 1995 and 5.2 in May 1998), and her broad written language score failed to increase by more than 0.2 of a grade level (4.6 grade level in April 1995 and 4.8 in May 1998). From this, it is reasonable to conclude that STUDENT obtained little, if any, benefit from her education from March 27, 1996, to the end of the 1995-96 school year.
The District argued that STUDENT failed to make adequate progress because of problems with absences, tardies, conflicts with authority figures, and drug use. While there was evidence that STUDENT did have problems with attendance, authority figures, and drug use, any problems STUDENT had did not excuse the District from providing her an appropriate program. Furthermore, Dr. Guterman and Mr. Fleming both testified that these were likely secondary issues that developed because of STUDENT’s poor history of success in the school setting and her long-standing frustration with her inability to learn in school (i.e., her inability to succeed in school resulted in a desire to avoid school). In other words, they testified that STUDENT’s attendance and drug use problems likely resulted from the District’s failure to meet her educational needs. (footnote 11)
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit and, in fact, did not provide her any significant educational benefit.
Comport With the IEP
There was no dispute that the District’s program comported with STUDENT’s IEP, and no persuasive evidence was presented that the District’s program failed to comport with the IEP.
*****
In summary, the District failed to provide a program from March 27, 1996, to the end of the 1995-96 school year that was designed to address STUDENT’s unique educational needs or that was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit. The District failed to appropriately address her primary deficit in reading and failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE from March 27, 1996, to the end of the 1995-96 school year.
b. the 1996-97 school year?
(1) procedural appropriateness
There were no allegations of procedural violations that were specific to the 1996-97 school year. Inasmuch as the discussion regarding Petitioner’s allegations of continuing violations (i.e., failure to perform a speech and language assessment, failure to assess prior to May 1998, failure to track and record progress on goals and objectives, and failure to specify frequency and duration of services) is applicable to the 1996-97 school year, the Hearing Officer adopts the previous findings. No evidence was presented that would alter those findings for the 1996-97 school year, except with regard to the frequency of services on the IEP.
On the IEP dated April 21, 1997, the District failed to specify the frequency and duration of vocational education services to be provided by the vocational specialist, as required. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 51 (1996). While the IEP did list the specific services that the vocational specialist would perform for STUDENT, a mere listing of services did not give the parent adequate notice of the amount of time that the District was committing to provide STUDENT. Id. In fact, later the parent and STUDENT were both very concerned that STUDENT was not getting sufficient assistance from the vocational specialist but, because there was no specific designation of the frequency of vocational education services in the IEP, STUDENT was only provided assistance as the District deemed necessary. This violation, standing alone, would not amount to a denial of FAPE. However, when combined with inadequate transition services and/or goals and objectives, this violation very well could lead to a loss of educational opportunity. The adequacy of the transition services and/or goals and objectives will be evaluated later in the section dealing with substantive appropriateness. On a separate but related note, the District also failed to include transition services in STUDENT’s IEP until more than a month after her sixteenth birthday. The IDEA requires that a student’s IEP begin to include a statement of the transition services needed by the student by at least his or her sixteenth birthday. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(2))(1994) (current version at 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(vii) (1997)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1 (Deering Supp. 1999). No explanation was offered for the delay. However, this delay of one month in the provision of services was de minimis and, standing alone, would not rise to a denial of a FAPE.
The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District committed two procedural errors during the 1996-97 school year, the second of which did not result in the denial of a FAPE. The first error, in combination with the actual provision of transition services (which will be discussed shortly in the section dealing with substantive appropriateness), did contribute to the denial of a FAPE. In other words, the failure to list the frequency by which transition services would be provided lead to the failure to provide adequate services.
(2) substantive appropriateness
Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs
STUDENT was enrolled in the following courses during the first semester of the 1996-97 school year: RSP English, RSP Math, Science I, Women’s Chorus, Health, and PE-Aerobics. During the second semester, Women’s Chorus and Health were replaced by World Civilization and three vocational classes entitled Agricultural Occupations, Florist & Greenhouse, and Florist Occupations Laboratory. The RSP classes were meant to provide small-group and individual instruction to support the development of skills in reading, written language, and (starting with the IEP dated April 21, 1997) math. Mr. Zehnder continued to be STUDENT’s RSP English teacher in the tenth grade. He testified that the program he provided to STUDENT during her tenth-grade RSP English class was basically the same as that provided to her during her ninth-grade year, only the “units” changed. As previously mentioned, the IEP dated April 21, 1997, also included vocational education services to be provided by the vocational specialist for the exploration of career interests and assistance with obtaining a part-time job.
As with the 1995-96 school year, Petitioner contended that the educational program for the 1996-97 school year failed to meet STUDENT’s needs because it (1) did not include a multisensory, phoneme awareness, or other suitable program to address her phonological processing deficits, (2) did not provide one-on-one instruction, (3) did not address STUDENT’s memory deficits, and (4) did not include appropriate goals and objectives. Petitioner also contended that the District failed to provide adequate transition services or goals and objectives.
The previous analysis of Petitioner’s first, second, and third contentions, which is contained in the review of the 1995-96 school year, applies with equal force here. Both STUDENT’s unique needs and the program remained essentially unchanged between the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years. STUDENT even continued to have Mr. Zehnder for RS English, and Mr. Zehnder used the same program as he had in the 1995-96 school year. Based on the aforementioned discussion contained in the review of the 1995-96 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the District should have provided, but failed to provide, STUDENT with a program to address her phonological processing deficits, such as a multisensory or phoneme awareness program, during the 1996-97 school year. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT required one-on-one instruction to benefit from her education or that the District’s program should have addressed a memory deficit.
With regard to the appropriateness of the goals and objectives, the Hearing Officer already determined that the goals and objectives contained in the IEP dated May 1, 1996, were inadequate because they failed to include short-term instructional objectives to measure progress and failed to address the problems that were contributing to the discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and her functioning in reading and written language. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goals and objectives contained in the IEP dated April 21, 1997, were inappropriate for the same reasons. However, it must be noted that the goals and objectives in the April 1997 IEP were even more deficient than the previous year’s. Despite the fact that STUDENT was functioning approximately six years below her grade level in reading and written language, the IEP contained only one objective to improve reading skills and no objectives in the area of written language. (footnote 12) Given how seriously impacted STUDENT’s reading and written language skills obviously were, the scant attention paid to goals and objectives in these areas was clearly inadequate.
Finally, the Hearing Officer finds, based on the following reasons, that the IEP failed to contain necessary transition services and goals and objectives. As mentioned earlier, starting by at least age sixteen, a student’s IEP must include a statement of the transition services needed by the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(20) (1994) (current version at 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(vii) (1997)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1 (Deering Supp. 1999). The phrase “transition services” means a coordinated set of activities for a student designed with an outcome-oriented process that promotes movement from school to post-school activities, including postsecondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living, or community participation. 34 C.F.R. § 300.18 (1996) (now codified at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(30)(A) (1997)). The coordinated set of activities must be based on the student’s needs, taking into account his or her preferences and interests, and include instruction, community experiences, the development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives, and, if appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and a functional vocational evaluation. 34 C.F.R. § 300.18(b) (1996) (now codified at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(30)(B)-(C) (1997)).
Here, STUDENT was invited to and was present at the IEP meeting held on April 21, 1997, to provide input on her preferences and interests with regard to post-school activities. Sarah Green, the vocational transition specialist who would be working with STUDENT, was also present at the meeting to help develop the transition goals and objectives. The team determined that Ms. Green would work with STUDENT to determine her career interests through administration of the Career Assessment Inventory (which only confirmed STUDENT’s well-known interest in fashion merchandising and retail), assist with obtaining part-time employment, practice interview skills, and obtain interviews with local people working in STUDENT’s fields of interest. While these activities were ostensibly designed to determine and promote STUDENT’s post-school interests, the IEP failed to provide adequate support services to allow STUDENT, a learning disabled student with severely depressed reading and written language skills, to explore her well-known goal of entering the field of fashion merchandising and to evaluate her ability to fulfill her goal of attending the Fashion Institute of Design & Merchandising (FIDM) in San Francisco.
Instead, the IEP only indicated that STUDENT was to research different job interests and obtain a part-time job in the fall of 1997, as well as obtain a high school diploma and apply to the Department of Rehabilitation in her senior year. The IEP did not provide a “coordinated set of activities” taking into account her preferences and interests, as the IDEA requires. Instead, it was a generic transition plan which did not take into account her preferences and interests, and which provided inadequate support for a student with disabilities that were known to inhibit the ability to independently prepare herself for postsecondary education or post-school employment. By the time this IEP was written, STUDENT was almost a junior in high school, yet there had been no determination of the specific type of instruction or community experience that she might need to pursue her interests. The District should have, but did not, provide assistance to STUDENT in determining what types of classes she should take to prepare her for a career in her field of interest or for whatever postsecondary education it may require. The District also should have, at a minimum, provided services to assist her with identifying appropriate postsecondary education institutions (in light of her preferences and interests) and evaluating the feasibility of her attending particular institutions. On this point, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Mr. Fleming’s testimony that a student with learning disabilities such as STUDENT has difficulty processing such information and required guidance (as opposed to simply information) to appropriately use the information to make decisions about her post-school activities.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program for the 1996-97 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs to the extent that it failed to appropriately address her primary deficit in reading, failed to include appropriate goals and objectives, and failed to include necessary transition services and goals and objectives.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The Hearing Officer found above that the District failed to appropriately address STUDENT’s primary deficit in reading and failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives during the 1996-97 school year. These were the same deficiencies found during the period March 27, 1996, to the end of the 1995-96 school year. Therefore, as before, it is reasonable to conclude that STUDENT’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. Moreover, STUDENT again failed to make any significant progress during the 1996-97 school year. There was no evidence that STUDENT made any significant progress on her goals and objectives. Additionally, as previously mentioned, Mr. Zehnder testified that STUDENT’s reading comprehension, decoding, and general reading skills were the same by the end of her tenth-grade year as they were when she entered SHS in the ninth grade. As for grades, STUDENT received failing grades in all of her regular education academic courses: she received a “D” in her first semester of Science I, and “F”s in the second semester of Science I, Health, and World Civilization. Finally, as detailed earlier, she made only nominal advancement on standardized achievement testing. From this, it is reasonable to conclude that STUDENT obtained little, if any, benefit from her education during the 1996-97 school year.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit and, in fact, did not provide her any significant educational benefit.
Comport With the IEP
There was no dispute that the District’s program comported with STUDENT’s IEP, and no persuasive evidence was presented that the District’s program failed to comport with the IEP.
*****
In summary, the District failed to provide STUDENT a program during the 1996-97 school year that was designed to address her unique educational needs or that was reasonably calculated to provide her educational benefit. The District failed to appropriately address her primary deficit in reading, failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives, and failed to provide necessary transition services and goals and objectives. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year.
c. the 1997-98 school year?
(1) procedural appropriateness
Inasmuch as the discussion regarding Petitioner’s allegations of continuing violations (i.e., failure to perform a speech and language assessment, failure to assess prior to May 1998, failure to track and record progress on goals and objectives, and failure to specify frequency and duration of services) is applicable to the 1997-98 school year, the Hearing Officer adopts the previous findings. No evidence was presented which would alter those findings for the 1997-98 school year, especially since the IEP dated April 21, 1997, the appropriateness of which has already been reviewed, was the IEP in effect during the 1997-98 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District should have, but did not, specify the frequency of transition services.
Petitioner asserted the following additional procedural violation for the 1997-98 school year: failure to hold a timely annual review. While technically true, the violation was de minimis and did not result in the denial of a FAPE. The annual review of the IEP was conducted only a month and a half beyond the one-year review anticipated by the IDEA. Moreover, there was evidence that the IEP meeting was postponed from its original date (which was three weeks beyond the one-year review date required by the IDEA) at the request of the father so that John Fleming, his educational consultant, could attend the meeting. (footnote 13)
The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District committed two procedural errors during the 1997-98 school year, but that the errors standing alone did not result in the denial of a FAPE.
(2) substantive appropriateness
The changes to IDEA which became effective in June 1997 did not substantially alter the meaning of FAPE. IDEA ‘97 continues to define the term FAPE to mean special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the state educational standards, and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18) (1997). Thus, the analysis remains essentially the same as to whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year. Namely, was the District’s placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, was the District’s placement designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, and did the placement conform with STUDENT’s IEP?
Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs
STUDENT was enrolled in the following courses during the first semester of the 1997-98 school year: RSP English, RSP Math, RSP Social Studies, World Civilization, Keyboarding, and PE. During the second semester, she continued to be enrolled in three RSP classes and was also enrolled in Computer Applications. The RSP classes were meant to provide small-group instruction to support the development of skills in English, reading, and math. She also received vocational education services from Sarah Green, the vocational specialist, for the exploration of career interests and assistance with obtaining a part-time job.
As with the prior school years, Petitioner contended that the educational program for the 1997-98 school year failed to meet STUDENT’s needs because it (1) did not include a multisensory, phoneme awareness, or other suitable program to address her phonological processing deficits, (2) did not provide one-on-one instruction, (3) did not address STUDENT’s memory deficits, (4) failed to include appropriate goals and objectives, and (5) failed to include necessary transition services or goals and objectives.
Since there was no evidence that STUDENT’s unique needs changed for the 1997-98 school year and the IEP dated April 21, 1997, continued to be the IEP in effect throughout the year, the previous analysis of Petitioner’s second through fifth contentions applies with equal force here. Based on the aforementioned discussion, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT required one-on-one instruction to benefit from her education or that the District’s program should have addressed a memory deficit. On the other hand, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP in effect during the 1997-98 school year (i.e., the IEP dated April 21, 1997) failed to contain adequate goals and objectives, and failed to provide necessary transition services and goals and objectives.
As for Petitioner’s first contention, a closer review of the appropriateness of the District’s program is required because certain key elements of her educational program during the 1997-98 school year were different from those of the prior school years. STUDENT’s RSP English teacher was now Carolyn Klindt-Stoops. Ms. Klindt is a fully qualified and credentialed RS teacher at SHS. She has a bachelor’s degree in language arts, a multiple subject credential for grades kindergarten through twelfth grade, a learning handicapped credential, a RS credential, and a learning disabled credential.
Ms. Klindt testified that she used a multimodal approach (i.e., an approach using visual, memory, and kinesthetic strategies to present and reinforce lessons) to instruct STUDENT’s class in reading, writing, decoding, and organization. According to Ms. Klindt, these strategies included using videos, interactive activities, visual presentation of a topic, many different types of reading materials, varying types of literature, spelling and grammar lessons, a writing journal, and oral presentations. Her full-time aide, a teacher credentialed in another state, reinforced the materials she presented. As for decoding, Ms. Klindt testified that she is trained in linguistics and word decoding, and teaches these skills in her classroom. Ms. Klindt testified that she knew that STUDENT often had difficulty decoding or getting meaning from words, so she taught her, along with the rest of the class, how to break down words by orthographics or word analysis. Ms. Klindt described orthographics, or word analysis, as a strategy that helps students with difficulty reading to be successful at the high-school level. Ms. Klindt also testified that STUDENT especially had trouble with larger, multisyllabic words, and that she addressed this in her classroom by using cadence and meter to help STUDENT break down the words. In addition to decoding techniques, Ms. Klindt also taught the class compensatory strategies to glean information from text, such as highlighting and scanning. According to Ms. Klindt, instruction was always on a small-group, and sometimes individual, basis by her or her aide. STUDENT’s class had approximately sixteen students during the first semester and eight students in the second semester, but would occasionally be broken into even smaller groups for instruction. Ms. Klindt testified that, in practice, STUDENT often received one-on-one instruction from the aide because she had missed lessons due to absences and/or tardies. In light of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with a program to address her phonological processing deficit, e.g., a multisensory or phoneme awareness program, during the 1997-98 school year.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program for the 1997-98 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs, except to the extent that it did not contain necessary transitions services and goals and objectives, and did not contain adequate goals and objectives in reading and written language. However, as will be explored further in the following section, the inadequacy of the goals and objectives in reading and written language did not result in a loss of educational opportunity or otherwise deny STUDENT a FAPE.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The Hearing Officer found above that the District appropriately addressed STUDENT’s primary deficit in reading, but failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives in reading and written language during the 1997-98 school year. The IEP failed to contain appropriate short-term instructional objectives in the area of reading and failed to include any goals or objectives in the area of written language. The inclusion of goals and objectives in an IEP, as well as the annual IEP review, is meant to provide a mechanism whereby parents and school districts can determine (1) whether the anticipated outcomes for the student are being met and (2) whether the placement and services are appropriate to the student’s special learning needs. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 37 (1996). In effect, these requirements are meant to provide a means by which the IEP team can track the student’s progress in special education. Id. The omission of appropriate goals and objectives is a serious, not fatal, flaw where there are other means of judging progress.
Here, it has been determined that STUDENT’s unique reading needs were addressed through the District’s program. The evidence established that STUDENT’s unique written language needs were also addressed through the program, despite the lack of goals and objectives. Ms. Klindt testified that she used a multimodal approach designed to instruct those with language disabilities, such as STUDENT’s, in order to present written language lessons, such as spelling and punctuation and the practice of writing skills. Further, the evidence showed that STUDENT obtained some benefit from her educational program during the 1997-98 school year and that she likely would have obtained more if she had been more available for learning (e.g., had less frequent absences and tardies). Ms. Klindt testified that, by the end of the year, STUDENT had improved significantly in writing and giving oral presentations. She also testified that STUDENT made some progress on the reading and written language goals and objectives contained in prior IEPs.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit and, in fact, did provide her with some educational benefit.
Comport With the IEP
There was no dispute that the District’s program comported with STUDENT’s IEP, and no persuasive evidence was presented that the District’s program failed to comport with the IEP.
*****
In summary, the District did not commit any procedural errors which, standing alone, resulted in the denial of a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year. Additionally, the District provided a program that was designed to address STUDENT’s unique educational needs, that was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit, and that comported with her IEP during the 1997-98 school year, except to the extent that it failed to contain necessary transition services and goals and objectives. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that, looking at the program as a whole, the District’s program was marginally appropriate. Consequently, the District satisfied its obligation to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year, however marginally, except to the extent that it failed to provide necessary transition services.
d. the 1998-99 school year?
(1) procedural appropriateness
Inasmuch as the earlier discussion regarding Petitioner’s allegations of continuing violations is applicable to the 1998-99 school year, the Hearing Officer adopts the previous findings. However, the contention that the District should have performed a speech and language assessment must be revisited because the parent actually requested that the District perform such an assessment on April 28, 1999. Additionally, Petitioner alleged that the following procedural violations occurred during the 1998-99 school year: failure to timely conduct an assistive technology assessment based on the parent’s request in fall 1998 and failure to timely conduct a comprehensive reevaluation based on the parent’s request in January 1999. Each argument will be addressed in turn.
As for Petitioner’s contention that the District should have performed a speech and language assessment, the Hearing Officer notes that the first time STUDENT was referred for a speech and language assessment was by the parent during an IEP meeting on April 28, 1999, based on Dr. Guterman’s recommendation, and that it is undisputed that the District has never conducted a speech and language evaluation for STUDENT. A school district is required to reassess a student with disabilities whenever, inter alia, a parent requests a reassessment. 20 U.S.C § 1414(a)(2)(A) (1997); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a) (Deering Supp. 1999). The District has not disputed the need for a speech and language evaluation. Yet, there was no evidence that the District responded at all to the parent’s request for a speech and language assessment, either by indicating that the assessment was not needed or by preparing an assessment plan for the parent’s approval. Further, there was no explanation offered as to why the District failed to respond to the parent’s request for an assessment. Unless the parent agrees in writing to an extension, State law requires that whenever an assessment is to be conducted the parent be given in writing a proposed assessment plan within fifteen days of the referral for assessment, and that the assessment be conducted and an IEP meeting be held within fifty days of receipt of the parent’s consent for assessment. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56321(a), 56344 (Deering Supp. 1999). In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District should have assessed STUDENT in the area of speech and language following the parent’s request on April 28, 1999. Since the District still has not conducted a speech and language evaluation, it must immediately take steps to perform the evaluation (i.e., develop an assessment plan, assess in the area of speech and language, and convene an IEP meeting to discuss the results and revise the IEP, if appropriate).
With regard to the parent’s request for an assistive technology assessment, the evidence established that FATHER initially requested such an assessment by letter dated September 30, 1998. However, by letter dated November 25, 1998, and on the advice of Mr. Fleming, FATHER told the District that he “released” it of its obligation to conduct an assistive technology assessment until the matter could be discussed at the next IEP meeting, which was scheduled to be held in early December 1998. When the issue was not resolved at the IEP meeting, FATHER renewed his request for an assistive technology assessment by letter dated January 17, 1999. The District thereafter developed a proposed assessment plan on February 1, FATHER signed the plan on February 2, and seventeen days later, on February 19, Lauren Leff conducted the assessment. On March 5, 1999, the IEP team met and discussed Ms. Leff’s assessment and revised STUDENT’s IEP to include access to the Kurzweil 3000. Given the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District timely conducted an assistive technology assessment. Although the parent initially requested the assessment in late September, the parent later agreed in writing to extend the applicable time lines so that the team could discuss whether an assessment was indeed necessary. Furthermore, the assessment was eventually conducted within the applicable time lines, given the date of FATHER’s subsequent request for an assessment.
As for Petitioner’s final contention, that the District failed to timely conduct a reevaluation, the evidence established that by letter dated January 18, 1999, FATHER requested that the District conduct a complete reevaluation in order to assess how much STUDENT had progressed and to determine her present levels of performance. Based on this letter, the District should have submitted to the parent a proposed assessment plan within fifteen days of receipt of his request. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a) (Deering Supp. 1999). Instead, when the District sent FATHER the proposed assessment plan for the assistive technology assessment on February 1, it attached a letter asking him if he wanted the assessment time line to begin for the complete reevaluation. Then, no further action took place until the IEP meeting held on March 5, 1999, during which the family indicated that they wanted a complete neuropsychological assessment. The District agreed to conduct the requested neuropsychological assessment and, at the same meeting, the parent signed a plan giving consent for the assessment. However, the District never conducted the neuropsychological assessment because Petitioner retracted consent for the assessment through a letter dated March 26, 1999. Petitioner stated that she objected to the assessment being conducted by Katie Merchant, Ed.D., whom the District had selected, and would instead obtain an independent assessment. Based upon the above facts, the Hearing Officer finds that the one-month delay in developing a proposed assessment plan was a de minimis violation that did not result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Further, the parent’s ultimate request for an assessment sought a different type of assessment than that requested in January 1999.
The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District committed two procedural errors during the 1997-98 school year. First, the District failed to assess STUDENT in the area of speech and language following the parent’s request on April 28, 1999. The District must immediately take steps to complete the evaluation (i.e., develop an assessment plan, assess in the area of speech and language, and convene an IEP meeting to discuss the results and revise the IEP, if appropriate). Second, the District failed to timely submit an assessment plan for the complete reevaluation requested by the parent but, because it was only a one-month delay and the ultimate request was for a different type of assessment, the Hearing Officer finds that the violation was de minimis and did not result in the denial of a FAPE.
(2) substantive appropriateness
Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs
STUDENT was enrolled in the following courses during the first semester of the 1998-99 school year: RSP English, RSP Tutorial, RSP Social Studies, Computer Applications, and Computer Graphics. During the second semester, she was enrolled in RSP Social Studies, RSP Math, Introduction to Foods, Small Business Management, Computer Applications, and Work Experience. In March 1999, RSP Math was replaced by RSP Tutorial. The RSP classes were meant to provide small-group and/or individualized instruction to improve her skills in reading, written language, math calculation, organization, test-taking, and attendance. She was also to receive vocational education services from Ms. Green to assist in maintaining regular attendance and punctuality, increasing career exploration, and developing an after-high school career program. The IEP dated February 3, 1999, changed the service description for vocational education services to the following: career assessment, job placement and monitoring, and consultation with employers and educational staff as appropriate. (Additionally, beginning with the February IEP, for the first time STUDENT’s IEP began to specify the amount of vocational education services she was entitled to receive: a minimum of thirty minutes per week of direct and indirect consultation.) The service description was again changed by the IEP dated March 5, 1999, to “support for vocational and work/transition goals, pre-transition assistance, and conflict resolution skills.” This last service description remained essentially the same in the IEP dated April 28, 1999.
During Spring 1999, however, a number of significant additions were made to STUDENT’s IEP. From February 3 to March 4, her IEP included a minimum of fifteen minutes per week of counseling and guidance with a credentialed school psychologist to address issues relating to her transition to a postsecondary educational setting. Starting March 5, STUDENT’s IEP included access to the Kurzweil 3000 system and training to use the system by a qualified person, and one-on-one instruction in reading and writing by a credentialed (learning handicapped) teacher for one and a half hours two times per week. Beginning April 28 and to the end of the 1998-99 school year, the District also agreed to provide one-on-one instruction by teacher interns from the University of California, Santa Cruz (UCSC), to assist STUDENT during her RSP Tutorial class daily.
As with the prior school years, Petitioner contended that the educational program for the 1998-99 school year failed to meet STUDENT’s needs because it (1) did not include a multisensory, phoneme awareness, or other suitable program to address her phonological processing deficits, (2) did not provide one-on-one instruction, (3) did not address STUDENT’s memory deficits, (4) failed to include appropriate goals and objectives, and (5) failed to include necessary transition services or goals and objectives.
There was no evidence that STUDENT’s unique needs changed for the 1998-99 school year. Thus, the previous analysis of Petitioner’s second and third contentions applies with equal force here. Based on the aforementioned discussion, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT required one-on-one instruction to benefit from her education or that the District’s program should have addressed a memory deficit.
As for Petitioner’s first contention, the Hearing Officer notes that this was the first year that STUDENT did not have RSP English for the entire year. She was only enrolled in an English course during the first semester, and there was no evidence that she received any reading and/or written language instruction during the second semester until she began one-on-one instruction with Gayle White on March 23, 1999. Thus, STUDENT did not receive any instruction in her primary areas of deficit for approximately three months during the 1998-99 school year. There was no dispute, however, that she received appropriate instruction to address her reading and written language deficits through her lessons with Ms. White beginning March 23.
During the first semester, STUDENT was enrolled in an RSP English course taught by Staci LaCagnin. According to Ms. LaCagnin’s testimony, the class was taught reading, spelling, word usage, grammar, vocabulary, and writing techniques through teaching strategies based on Anita Archer’s Skills for School Success, which teaches students to self-question as they read in order to check for comprehension; from the University of Kansas (no explanation was offered as to what these strategies consisted of); and “sheltering” techniques, which include preteaching vocabulary, constantly checking for understanding, and breaking units into smaller instructional chunks. While Ms. LaCagnin stated that these methods were research-based, there was no explanation as to how they addressed STUDENT’s specific learning disabilities. For instance, there was no evidence that Ms. LaCagnin provided STUDENT with a program to address her phonological processing or encoding deficits, such as a multisensory or phoneme awareness program, or even that she taught compensation strategies in a manner that would allow STUDENT to learn how to glean information from text without decoding. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District should have provided, but failed to provide, STUDENT with a program to address her phonological processing deficits, such as a multisensory or phoneme awareness program, from the beginning of the 1998-99 school year until March 22, 1999.
With regard to the appropriateness of goals and objectives, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP failed to contain appropriate goals and objectives until April 28, 1999. Until that date, the goals and objectives suffered from the same or similar deficiencies noted in previous years (i.e., they included only one “objective” each for reading and written language, and failed to include benchmarks or short-term objectives). 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A) (1997); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a) (Deering Supp. 1999). Beginning April 28, 1999, the goals and objectives became much more detailed and specific, and included appropriate benchmarks. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that during the 1998-99 school year STUDENT’s IEP failed to contain appropriate goals and objectives until April 28, 1999.
Finally, after a review of the transition services provided and the transition goals and objectives in effect during the 1998-99 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that they were appropriate in light of STUDENT’s needs. The services provided during the 1998-99 school year were much more intensive than those provided during the previous years and included frequent one-on-one consultation regarding jobs, local schools offering fashion merchandising and retail courses, and conflict resolution skills, and interviews with people working in the field in which STUDENT is interested. The more intensive efforts resulted in STUDENT’s obtaining work experience in her field of interest, a better understanding of the educational opportunities available locally in her field of interest, and counseling to improve her conflict resolution skills. While the description of transition services changed frequently during the year, the services provided remained essentially the same and were appropriate throughout the year.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program for the 1998-99 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs to the extent that it failed to appropriately address her primary deficit in reading until March 23, 1999, and failed to include appropriate goals and objectives until April 28, 1999.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The Hearing Officer found above that, during the 1998-99 school year, the District failed to appropriately address STUDENT’s primary deficit in reading until March 23, 1999, and failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives until April 28, 1999. These were the same deficiencies found during the period March 27, 1996, to the end of the 1995-96 school year and during the 1996-97 school year. As before, it is reasonable to conclude that STUDENT’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit from the beginning of the 1998-99 school year to at least March 23, 1999. (footnote 14) Moreover, STUDENT again failed to make any significant progress during the 1998-99 school year until after March 23, 1999. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT had made any significant progress on her reading and writing goals by March 5, 1999, when STUDENT’s progress on the goals were reviewed by the IEP team. Finally, as noted earlier, she made only nominal advancement on standardized achievement testing. From this, it is reasonable to conclude that STUDENT obtained little, if any, benefit from her education during the 1998-99 school year until after March 23, 1999.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit and, in fact, did not provide her any significant educational benefit until after March 23, 1999.
Comport With the IEP
The evidence disclosed that the one-on-one instruction in reading and writing provided by Ms. White was not provided with the frequency required by the IEP. According to the IEP, Ms. White was to tutor STUDENT three hours per week, but Ms. White testified that she was unavailable every third week to tutor STUDENT. While Ms. White testified that she offered to make up the sessions with STUDENT, there was no evidence that any of the lost time was actually made up. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the provision of services did not comport with the IEP to the extent that the one-on-one instruction was not provided three hours every week, as designated on the IEP. This likely resulted in a loss of approximately twelve hours of instruction. The District shall make up the twelve hours of instruction in a manner educationally appropriate for STUDENT.
*****
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed two procedural errors during the 1998-99 school year, but that one of the errors was de minimis and did not result in the denial of a FAPE. As for the second, the District should have assessed STUDENT in the area of speech and language based upon the request of the parent and failed to do so within the timeframes required. The District must immediately take steps to complete the evaluation (i.e., develop an assessment plan, assess in the area of speech and language, and convene an IEP meeting to discuss the results and revise the IEP, if appropriate). Additionally, the District failed to provide STUDENT a program during the 1998-99 school year that was designed to address her unique educational needs or that was reasonably calculated to provide her educational benefit until March 23, 1999. The District failed to appropriately address her primary deficit in reading until March 23, 1999, and failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives until April 28, 1999. The District also failed to provide one-on-one instruction by a credentialed teacher with the frequency designated on the IEP, and shall make up the approximately twelve hours that were not provided. Given the totality of the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 1998-99 school year until March 23, 1999.
2. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred for the following:
a. private tutoring with Carol Beckstrom and Aptos Instruction from January 1996 to March 1997?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and/or services, and the placement and/or services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. Petitioner contended that, because the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, she is entitled to reimbursement for parent-funded tutoring services provided to STUDENT from January 1996 to March 1997 through Carol Beckstrom and Aptos Instruction.
Even though it was concluded above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from March 27, 1996, through the 1996-97 school year, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement because she failed to present any evidence regarding the appropriateness of the tutoring services provided by Carol Beckstrom or Aptos Instruction. (footnote 15) While the testimony established that STUDENT received parent-funded tutoring, the record is insufficient to support a finding that the tutoring provided was appropriate under the IDEA because there was no evidence about the specific tutoring services provided. Therefore, Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for expenses associated with the tutoring provided by Carol Beckstrom and Aptos Instruction is denied.
b. a neuropsychological assessment by Tina Guterman, Ph.D.?
Petitioner contended that she is entitled to reimbursement for the independent neuropsychological assessment performed by Dr. Guterman in April 1999, because the District failed to conduct the assessment despite the parties’ agreement that the District would fund an independent neuropsychological assessment and Petitioner’s subsequent notice that she would obtain the assessment independently. A parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) at public expense if the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency, unless the educational agency shows at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b) (1999) (former version at 34 C.F.R. § 300.503(b) (1996)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b) (Deering Supp. 1999).
Here, the parties agreed at the IEP meeting held on March 5, 1999, that the District would fund an independent neuropsychological assessment. The parent gave consent for the assessment on the assessment plan drafted at the meeting. However, the parent thereafter revoked his consent based on the identity of the examiner chosen by the District to perform the assessment. There was no dispute that Dr. Merchant, the examiner chosen by the District, was not an employee of the District at the time and there was no dispute that she was qualified to perform a neuropsychological assessment. However, Petitioner objected to Dr. Merchant on the ground that she was not an “independent or appropriate” evaluator because she had “acted over the years as acting Director of Special Education for the district” and had a “long standing relationship with the administration.” (Dr. Merchant had been employed as the interim director of special education for the District from March 1993 to October 1996, but was currently employed as a school psychologist for the San Lorenzo Unified School District.) Petitioner informed the District that she would instead have Dr. Guterman conduct the neuropsychological assessment. Dr. Merchant did not, therefore, conduct the assessment. Dr. Merchant testified that she was willing and able to assess STUDENT at the time.
An IEE is an evaluation conducted by a qualified examiner who is not employed by the public agency responsible for the education of the student in question. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(a)(3)(i) (1999) (former version at 34 C.F.R. § 300.503(a)(3)(i) (1996)). The evidence established that Dr. Merchant is qualified to perform neuropsychological assessments, and that she was not a District employee at the time she was asked to assess STUDENT. Thus, had the parent consented to Dr. Merchant’s assessment of STUDENT, her assessment would have constituted an IEE. Because the District offered an examiner qualified and available to conduct an independent neuropsychological assessment of STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Guterman’s assessment. The right of a parent to obtain an IEE at public expense is triggered when the parent disagrees with a public agency-initiated evaluation. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502, Attachment 1 (1999). Where, as here, the parent refuses to consent to the public agency’s proposed evaluation, the parent is not entitled to an IEE at public expense because there is no public evaluation with which the parent can disagree. Id. If the parent believes that the proposed public evaluation is inappropriate, he or she may seek an appropriate publicly-funded evaluation through the mediation and/or due process procedures available under the IDEA. Id.
Accordingly, since the District was willing and able to provide an independent educational evaluation at public expense at the time the parent obtained his assessment, the Hearing Officer finds that the parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the assessment by Dr. Guterman. (footnote 16)
3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of two years of schooling (i.e., during the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school terms) at either the Life Development Institute in Phoenix, Arizona, or Landmark College in Putney, Vermont, due to the failure of the District to provide STUDENT a FAPE?
As previously noted, when a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). However, compensatory education does not necessarily involve an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity or time missed. Id. at 1497. The purpose of compensatory education is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id.
The Hearing Officer concluded above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from March 27, 1996, to the end of the 1996-97 school year and during the 1998-99 school year until March 23, 1999, because it failed to provide appropriate specialized instruction necessary to address her deficit in reading and failed to include in her IEP appropriate goals and objectives to address her deficits in reading and written language. The Hearing Officer also concluded that the District failed to provide STUDENT with appropriate transition services and goals and objectives from March 14, 1997, (her sixteenth birthday) to the end of the 1997-98 school year. STUDENT is clearly entitled to compensatory education because of these omissions. (footnote 17) The only remaining question, then, is the appropriate type and amount of compensatory education.
The District offered STUDENT the following as compensatory education: (footnote 18)
* For the 1999 extended school year session, thirty hours of one-on-one instruction and case management by a qualified and certificated teacher from July 6 to August 13 (at least twenty-four hours to be direct instruction, focusing on IEP goals and objectives); access to a computer with the Kurzweil 3000 program; summer school at either Cabrillo Community College (Cabrillo) or SHS; and consultation with a vocational specialist as needed from June 16 to July 21.
* For the 1999-2000 school year, five hours per week of case management and one-on-one instruction by a qualified and certificated teacher to address IEP goals and objectives; full tuition paid at Cabrillo (this included a schedule of classes recommended by Cabrillo staff); access to a computer with the Kurzweil 3000 program; and vocational services and consultation as needed through the District’s transition partnership program or workability program.
* For the 2000-01 school year, the same program as that offered for the 1999-2000 school year.
Petitioner contended that the District’s offer was inadequate and requested placement at either Landmark College (Landmark) in Putney, Vermont, or Life Development Institute (LDI) in Phoenix, Arizona, for the 1999-2000 and 2000-01 school years. Both Landmark and LDI would be residential programs for STUDENT. Landmark focuses heavily on remediation of basic academic skills, while LDI emphasizes independent living skills. The Hearing Officer finds that neither Landmark nor LDI are warranted under the circumstances, because residential placement is not necessary for her to benefit from her education. Furthermore, the District has offered more than appropriate compensatory education instruction and services, notwithstanding the fact that it is now too late to implement the offer for the 1999 extended school year session.
The testimony of Deborah Shulman established the appropriateness of the Cabrillo program for STUDENT. Ms. Shulman is a learning disabled specialist and has been the director of the learning skills program at Cabrillo for the past six years. She has a bachelor’s degree in education and a master’s degree in special education with a specialty in learning disabilities. She also has a standard teaching credential, a learning handicapped credential, an RS certificate, and a community college instructor credential that allows her to work with the disabled population. She has twenty-two years of experience working with high school and postsecondary students with disabilities.
Ms. Shulman testified that she reviewed STUDENT’s educational records and assessments, and discussed STUDENT and the appropriateness of Cabrillo with FATHER, Ms. White, Ms. LaCagnin, Dr. Merchant, and a number of instructors and administrators at Cabrillo. According to Ms. Shulman, STUDENT is eligible to attend Cabrillo regardless of whether or not she has graduated from high school, because she is eighteen years old and a California resident. Ms. Shulman testified that Cabrillo has courses offering remedial instruction in basic skills, and that the learning skills program offers strategy and tutorial classes to teach students how best to learn material in light of their handicaps, in addition to other extensive services for learning disabled students such as counseling, diagnostic evaluations, specialized instruction, coordination of services, and community liason services. Also available at Cabrillo are labs in which students can get one-on-one instruction from teachers, and tutorial centers where they can receive one-on-one assistance from peer tutors. Ms. Shulman testified that the maximum class size at Cabrillo is thirty-five students but that most of the classes recommended for STUDENT consist of only ten to fifteen students, and that all of the instructors have at least a master’s degree. Ms. Shulman also testified that there is ready access to the Kurzweil 3000 on campus because there are a total of five computer stations with the system (a main scanning station and four read-only stations), and the system is not used extensively by Cabrillo students. Additionally, an academic counselor is available to help STUDENT determine which courses she should take in light of her career goal. (According to Ms. Shulman, there have been a number of Cabrillo students who have gone on to FIDM.)
Ms. Shulman testified that the instructional level and structure of the lower-level Cabrillo courses would allow a person of STUDENT’s abilities (including reading skills at about the fifth-grade level) to benefit from the instruction if the person was motivated and willing to work hard. There has been much testimony throughout the hearing from Petitioner’s witnesses and STUDENT herself that establish that STUDENT now has a strong desire to remediate her basic reading and written language skills, and is willing to put forth the effort necessary to achieve her goals. Further, the evidence showed that STUDENT has the ability and sufficient self-knowledge to enable her to request assistance when needed from the many sources offered by Cabrillo, including the labs, tutorial centers, and course instructors.
Further, STUDENT’s program at Cabrillo would be overseen and supplemented by a qualified and certificated teacher. Specifically, the teacher will provide five hours per week of case management and one-on-one instruction to address IEP goals and objectives. Ms. White’s experience with STUDENT has shown that one-on-one instruction in reading through a qualified teacher can be very successful with STUDENT in teaching her decoding skills and improve her reading comprehension through compensatory strategies. Additionally, the IEP goals and objectives that have been developed by the District for the 1999-2000 school year include detailed short-term objectives and benchmarks which demonstrate that the instruction will include multisensory instruction in decoding and compensatory strategies. The goals and objectives also address written language, life skills, organizational skills, and study skills. Of course, the IEP team will have to meet before the beginning of the 2000-01 school year to review STUDENT’s progress on goals and objectives and revise them as necessary for the 2000-01 school year.
The only portion of the District’s offer that fails to detail the services necessary for compensatory education is that relating to vocational services and consultation. The Hearing Officer finds that the District must provide a minimum of thirty minutes of direct and indirect vocational services and consultation per week during the 1999-2000 and 2000-01 school years. The specific nature of the services shall be determined by the IEP team, and must be documented on STUDENT’s IEP. To that end, the District is ordered to convene an IEP meeting to discuss the vocational services and consultation needed by STUDENT within twenty days of the date of this decision.
The District’s program, as modified, also fits the recommendations made by Dr. Guterman. She recommended for STUDENT, inter alia, (1) a transition program to help develop compensatory strategies, strengthen basic academic skills, and acquire workplace literacy and life skills; (2) assistive technology to help compensate for her learning disability, such as the Kurzweil 3000; and (3) continued tutoring to help with reading for context, using outlining techniques for written language assignments, and with study skills. The one-on-one instruction by a qualified and certificated teacher will provide one-on-one instruction through a multisensory approach aimed at improving decoding and reading comprehension skills, as well as the ability to use compensatory strategies. Additionally, the program as a whole is designed to strengthen basic academic skills and acquire workplace literacy and life skills. Finally, STUDENT will have ready access to the Kurzweil 3000 to assist her in reading and writing. Moreover, Dr. Guterman and Ms. Boden both conceded that STUDENT does not require a residential program in order to receive the remediation and other instruction required.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of compensatory education made by the District, with the addition of thirty minutes of direct and indirect vocational services per week, is appropriate in light of the nature and extent of the District’s failures to provide STUDENT a FAPE in the preceding years. (footnote 19) The District shall provide STUDENT services during the 1999-2000 and 2000-01 school years in accordance with the aforementioned offer, as modified.
4. Is STUDENT entitled to appropriate assistive technology in the form of Kurzweil 3000 equipment and appropriate software as part of compensatory education?
Petitioner contended that the Kurzweil 3000 should be made part of the order for compensatory education. As it is already a part of the District’s offer, this issue need not be explored further.
ORDER
1. The District shall immediately conduct a speech and language assessment in accordance with the applicable assessment procedures set forth in federal and state statutes. The date of this decision shall constitute the date of the referral for assessment.
2. In addition to the five hours contained in the program for compensatory education, the District shall provide STUDENT twelve hours of one-on-one instruction in the areas of reading and/or written language by a learning handicapped credentialed teacher by the end of the 1999 calendar year, unless the parties agree otherwise. The instruction shall be provided in a manner that does not interfere with STUDENT’s school program or work responsibilities.
3. The District shall provide STUDENT services during the 1999-2000 and 2000-01 school years in accordance with its offer for compensatory education, as modified. Specifically, the District shall provide the following:
a. Five hours per week of case management and one-on-one instruction by a qualified and certificated teacher to address IEP goals and objectives (in accordance with the goals and objectives, the teacher shall instruct STUDENT through a multisensory and/or other suitable approaches designed to address STUDENT’s phonological processing deficits and provide her with compensatory strategies);
b. Full tuition at Cabrillo Community College in Aptos, California;
c. Ready access to a computer with the Kurzweil 3000 program; and d. A minimum of thirty minutes per week of direct and indirect vocational services and consultation (the nature of which is to be determined by the IEP team).
4. Within twenty days of the date of this order, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to determine the nature of the vocational services and consultation to be provided to STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year.
5. Before the beginning of the 2000-01 school year, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to review STUDENT’s progress on goals and objectives, and revise the goals and objectives as appropriate.
6. All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the District properly evaluate and offer and provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT during the following school terms:
a. the 1995-96 school year?
* The District prevailed on this sub-issue to the extent that Petitioner was barred from raising any claims involving the beginning of the 1995-96 school year through March 26, 1996. Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue with respect to claims arising on or after March 27, 1996.
b. the 1996-97 school year?
* Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue.
c. the 1997-98 school year?
* The District prevailed on this sub-issue, except with regard to transition services.
d. the 1998-99 school year?
* Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue.
2. Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred for the following: a. private tutoring with Carol Beckstrom and Aptos Instruction from January 1996 to March 1997? b. a neuropsychological assessment by Tina Guterman, Ph.D.?
* The District prevailed on this issue.
3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of two years of schooling (i.e., during the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school terms) at either the Life Development Institute in Phoenix, Arizona, or Landmark College in Putney, Vermont, due to the failure of the District to provide STUDENT a FAPE? * The District prevailed on this issue.
4. Is STUDENT entitled to appropriate assistive technology in the form of Kurzweil 3000 equipment and appropriate software as part of compensatory education? * Neither party prevailed on this issue, because the District offered to provide this as part of compensatory education.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i) (Deering Supp. 1999).
Date: August 23, 1999 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues listed here differ slightly in numbering and content from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis and to reflect the discussion held on the first day of hearing between the parties and the Hearing Officer with regard to the issues for hearing.
2. Soquel ESD is not a party to this action and is not part of the District (i.e., Santa Cruz City Schools). As will be explained later, Soquel ESD was STUDENT’s district of residence only until she completed the eighth grade, at which time the District became obligated to serve her.
3. STUDENT had received resource specialist services at NBMS on a part-time basis during her sixth-grade year.
4. In 1997, the IDEA was amended (IDEA ‘97). Most of the provisions of IDEA ‘97 became effective on June 4, 1997; others became effective January 1, 1998, or July 1, 1998. Thereafter, changes were made to a number of State code provisions, and new federal regulations were issued to reflect the mandates of IDEA ‘97. Senate Bill No. 1686, which became effective January 1, 1999, amended various State statutes relating to special education. The Department of Education issued new regulations to accompany IDEA ‘97 on March 12, 1999. Petitioner’s claims relating to the 1995-96 school year and the 1996-97 school year arose prior to the enactment of IDEA ‘97. While IDEA ‘97 did not alter the general standards reflected in the IDEA, the Hearing Officer will apply the law and regulations that were in effect at the time the disputed events occurred in compliance with the general rules against the retroactive application of laws. Landgraff v. USI Film Products, 511 U.S. 244 (1994).
5. The appropriateness of the goals and objectives themselves will be discussed later in the section dealing with the substantive appropriateness of the District’s program.
6. The preceding information was gleaned from the assessment reports. Neither Ms. Poole nor Mr. Schraft testified at the hearing.
7. She defined “symbolic information” to include names, dates, and times.
8. Section 3082(b) provides that hearsay evidence is admissible in due process hearings, but only to supplement or explain other evidence. Hearsay evidence is not sufficient in itself to support a finding, unless it would be admissible over objection in civil actions. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3082(b).
9. Mr. Zehnder has been STUDENT’s case manager since she entered SHS in the fall of 1995. He was also her RSP English teacher during the ninth and tenth grades.
10. While an IEP is never a guarantee that a student will progress at a specified rate (34 C.F.R. § 300.350 (1996); Walczak, 142 F.3d at 133), the student’s actual progress, or lack of progress, can be a helpful guidepost in determining whether the IEP was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
11. Petitioner did not raise the District’s failure to address these issues as a part of her claim of a denial of FAPE. (Petitioner stated that her allegations of denial of FAPE centered around lack of remediation and transition services.)
12. No evidence was presented that the IEP team had agreed to continue any of her previous objectives which had not been met.
13. The issue of the substantive appropriateness of the IEP dated June 9, 1998, and its addendum will be explored during the discussion of the 1998-99 school year, because it was not actually implemented until the 1998-99 school year and, therefore, is not relevant to the 1997-98 school year in a substantive sense.
14. As noted earlier, inclusion of goals and objectives in an IEP, as well as the annual IEP review, is meant to provide a clear, concise, and mutually understandable mechanism whereby parents and school districts can track the student’s progress in special education. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 37 (1996). The omission of appropriate goals and objectives would not necessarily indicate that the program was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, or that the student failed to benefit from his or her educational program if other means for determining progress were readily available or were employed
15. The Hearing Officer also concluded that Petitioner was barred by the statute of limitations from raising any claims that arose on or before March 26, 1996.
16. There was neither evidence nor argument that the parent obtained the assessment by Dr. Guterman because he disagreed with the triennial assessment performed in May 1998 by the District. In fact, the evidence showed that the only reason the parent requested the assessment was that he wanted a complete reevaluation before STUDENT’s graduation from high school in order to determine and document her levels of performance and provide a final record of her disabilities.
17. The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive the District’s arguments that STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education because of her refusal to take the written competency test or problems with attendance, attitude toward authority figures, or drug use. As stated earlier, notwithstanding any problems STUDENT might have had with attendance, attitude, and drug use, the District remained obligated to provide her with a FAPE. Additionally, it is uncertain how STUDENT’s attitude towards school might have been different had the District offered her appropriate instruction and services to address her learning disabilities, thereby allowing her to feel successful in school. Finally, the evidence established that STUDENT has already attempted to pass the written competency test twice and failed, which dispels any doubt that she is merely refusing to take it now because she wants to prevent her graduation from high school. Her inability to pass the written competency is more than likely directly attributable to the District’s reluctance to educate her properly within the meaning of the IDEA. Under the circumstances, STUDENT’s wish to defer taking the competency test for the third time until she feels able to pass it is entirely reasonable and does not demonstrate bad faith, but rather a realistic appraisal of her situation.
18. The District stated that this offer was not affected by STUDENT’s graduation status.
19. Because it exceeds the instruction and services STUDENT would normally receive based on her needs, this program also provides her with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year.
