California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 27, 2001

Student v. Oak Park Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 431-01, SN 1599-00 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski

Oak Park Unified must restore 60 minutes of daily resource math and add a classroom aide; assessment, IEE and learning-disability claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 5 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The cases (SN 1599-00 and SN 431-01) were consolidated by order dated March 14, 2001.

Summary

A parent filed for due process against Oak Park Unified School District, and the district later filed its own case. The two cases were consolidated. The student, a 10-year-old fourth grader at Brookside Elementary School, had received resource services as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) since first grade. After a triennial assessment, the district found no severe gap between her ability and her achievement. It proposed changing her eligibility to other health impairment based on ADHD. The parent agreed she met that category. She argued that the student still had SLD, needed memory testing and an independent evaluation, and needed more math time and a classroom aide.

The Hearing Officer found the assessment appropriate. School psychologist Marlaine Jensen Calta's testing covered memory and found no deficit. The parent's tutor admitted she was not qualified to test memory. Statewide SAT-9 scores were not diagnostic. As a result, the district did not have to pay for an independent evaluation, and the student no longer qualified as SLD. The February 2001 IEP offered FAPE in most respects. However, the district gave no reason for cutting resource math from 60 to 50 minutes a day. Preferential seating also did not address significant attention problems in a 28-student class. The district was ordered to provide 60 minutes of daily resource math and a classroom aide, not one-to-one, to redirect her. It must also hold an IEP meeting before the 2001-02 school year.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO weighed standardized test data against a tutor's opinion and statewide test scores in a dispute over assessment and eligibility. It also shows that a district needed to explain why it cut services. When a district identified new attention-related needs, it was expected to show how the IEP's supports addressed them.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1. Did the District, in its triennial assessment, conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?

    The triennial assessment met Education Code section 56320. Standardized testing (WISC-III, TAPS, TVPS, WJ-R) covered memory and showed no memory deficit, and SAT-9 scores and parent anecdotes did not show a need for more testing.

  2. Issue 2. Is STUDENT entitled to an independent educational assessment at public expense?

    Because the District's assessment was appropriate, the District was not required to pay for an independent assessment under Education Code section 56329(b).

  3. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 3. Does STUDENT continue to meet eligibility criteria for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability?

    Every achievement score was higher than her full scale IQ of 86, so there was no severe ability-achievement discrepancy. The SAT-9 is not a diagnostic instrument, and the student no longer qualifies as SLD; she remains eligible as OHI (ADHD).

  4. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the period February 2001 to February 2002? (including whether STUDENT needs an aide in the general education classroom)

    The February 2, 2001 IEP offered FAPE except that the unexplained cut in resource math from 60 to 50 minutes a day and the lack of an instructional aide in the general education class did not meet her needs; goals and other services were appropriate.

  5. Dismissed / withdrawnEligibility

    Issue Withdrawn (fn. 1). Whether STUDENT continued to be eligible to receive speech and language services

    Petitioner withdrew the issue after her own witness, a licensed speech-language pathologist, testified that the student no longer met speech-language eligibility criteria.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. District must provide sixty minutes per day of RSP (resource specialist program) Math.
  • Order to provide or change services. District must provide the services of an aide in the regular education classroom to redirect the student as needed; the aide need not be a one-to-one aide.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. District must convene an IEP meeting before the 2001-02 school year to conform the IEP to the math and aide orders.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337

People named in the decision

  • Cathy Skiba, Director of Pupil Services; credentialed school psychologist; District witness, Oak Park Unified School District
  • Marlaine Jensen Calta, school psychologist; triennial assessor; District witness, Oak Park Unified School District
  • Laurie Larkin, special day class/special education teacher (RSP math); academic assessor; District witness, Oak Park Unified School District
  • Tammy Cohen, speech-language specialist; triennial assessor; District witness, Oak Park Unified School District
  • Kathleen Poole, fourth-grade general education teacher; District witness, Oak Park Unified School District
  • Jean Des Jardin, resource specialist; District witness, Oak Park Unified School District
  • Gia Trombetta, third-grade general education teacher; witness called by Student, Oak Park Unified School District
  • Maria Jiminez, resource specialist teacher (RSP reading and written language), Oak Park Unified School District
  • Mrs. Dorman, witness regarding resource class staffing, Oak Park Unified School District
  • Bobbie E. Quigley, private tutor and licensed speech-language pathologist; expert witness for Student, Private
  • Donna Piazza, resource specialist (1996 assessment), Oak Park Unified School District
  • Ellen E. Ferguson, speech/language specialist (1996 assessment), Oak Park Unified School District
  • Patricia Smith, school psychologist (1996 psychoeducational assessment), Oak Park Unified School District
  • Rosalyn Tenenbaum, speech-language pathologist (1998 assessment), Oak Park Unified School District
  • Sandy Hirano, resource specialist (1998 report), Oak Park Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Oak Park, California, on March 1, April 5, 6, 19, 20, and 23, 2001.

STUDENT (STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by her mother, MOTHER. MOTHER is not an attorney and is not an advocate. The Oak Park Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Andrew V. Arczynski of Filarsky & Watt LLP. Also present on behalf of the District was Cathy Skiba, Director of Pupil Services for the District.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: MOTHER; Gia Trombetta, a teacher at the District; and Bobbie E. Quigley, tutor for Student.

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Tammy Cohen, speech/language specialist for the District; Kathleen Poole, a teacher at the District; Laurie Larkin, a special education teacher for the District; Jean Des Jardin, resource specialist for the District; Marlaine Jensen Calta, school psychologist for the District; and Cathy Skiba, Director of Pupil Services for the District.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision. Additional evidence submitted by the Petitioner which was received by the Hearing Office on June 25, 2001, after the case was closed, was not reviewed and was not considered by the Hearing Officer.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Did the District, in its triennial assessment, conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?

2. Is STUDENT entitled to an independent educational assessment at public expense?

3. Does STUDENT continue to meet eligibility criteria for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability?

4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the period February 2001 to February 2002?(Footnote 2)

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On September 8, 2000, the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) received a request for a due process hearing from MOTHER on behalf of her daughter, STUDENT. The Petitioner named the Oak Park Unified School District as a respondent and raised various issues relating to the failure on the part of the District to ensure that STUDENT fulfill her IEP goals. The Hearing Office designated the case as Case No. SN 1599-00. On September 20, 2000, the Hearing Office received Respondent District’s Statement of Issues. The District contended that it has provided Petitioner with a FAPE.

On March 1, 2001, this matter came on for hearing before this Hearing Officer. The Petitioner had changed her issues since originally filing for hearing; therefore, the Hearing Officer granted the District’s application for a continuance, and no testimony was therefore taken on March 1. The Hearing Officer converted the hearing into a prehearing conference. Issues, evidence packets, and witnesses were discussed. The District’s evidence packet was admitted into evidence without objection from Petitioner.

On March 5, 2001, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from Andrew V. Arczynski on behalf of the District. The District stated as issues for its request whether the District had conducted appropriate assessments of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and whether the District had offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-01 school year. The Hearing Office designated the case as Case No. SN 431-01. The District also requested consolidation of the two cases, and on March 14, 2001, the Hearing Office issued a summary order granting consolidation.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, age 10, is a fourth-grade student at the Brookside Elementary School and has been a student within the District since kindergarten. STUDENT has been receiving special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) since first grade (1998). (Pre-school 1995-96 school year)

STUDENT was first evaluated for eligibility for special education by the District in March 1996, when STUDENT was a five-year-old in preschool at “Teddy Bear Town.” Resource Specialist Donna Piazza, M.S.Ed., indicated within her report that “STUDENT is able to write her name, reversing the s, but was not ready to write any other letters. She was only able to recognize the letters in her name. She can recite the alphabet to g.” Ms. Piazza also noted that STUDENT knew her full name, age, and birthday, but did not know her address or phone number. “STUDENT scored above average in the memory areas. She is able to repeat sentences, words, and numbers accurately. She is able to follow two verbal directions appropriately.” Ms. Piazza recommended that STUDENT appeared to have adequate readiness skills to be successful in kindergarten. (Dist. Exh. 16).

A speech-language assessment conducted on March 7, 1996, by Ellen E. Ferguson, M.A., Speech/Language specialist, found that STUDENT did not qualify for speech and language services in that STUDENT demonstrated age-appropriate oral language skills and age-appropriate articulation (by demonstrating her ability to produce all age-appropriate phonemes and maintain 98-100% speech intelligibility), voice, pitch and fluency of speech. (Dist. Exh. 18)

At the request of STUDENT’s parents, who reported behavioral difficulties at home, a psychoeducational assessment was conducted on March 20, 1996, by District psychologist Patricia Smith. STUDENT achieved a full scale IQ index of 92, within the average range. However, in the area of adaptive functioning, Ms. Smith concluded that on two...measures of adaptive functioning, STUDENT is “approximately one year delayed to age-appropriate.” Ms. Smith noted that STUDENT generally “has average development in both verbal and nonverbal areas of cognitive functioning and speech/language development. [and that STUDENT] does display difficulty with copying tasks [but] there is no evidence of consistent severe deficits which would represent a learning disability or an emotional disorder. She does not qualify for special education services at this time.” (Dist. Ex. 17)

(First grade - 1997-98 school year)

STUDENT was next evaluated in March 1998 when STUDENT was seven years old and in first grade. A March 6, 1998 speech-language evaluation conducted by Rosalyn Tenenbaum, M.S., speech-language pathologist, found STUDENT to be within normal limits for voice quality, resonance, intensity, fluency, rate of speech, and articulation. However, STUDENT’s pitch and intensity were “occasionally high and thin when STUDENT demonstrated an infantile pattern of articulation and prosody.” STUDENT’s ability to comprehend and produce age-appropriate word structures and her ability in the area of receptive vocabulary were within normal limits. However, “STUDENT demonstrated some difficulty with producing rhyming words and using manipulatives.” STUDENT also “demonstrated some difficulty with all receptive language tasks including following oral directions, retaining information from paragraphs presented orally, and demonstrating understanding of syntactic structures presented orally. Expressive language was mildly impaired as were word retrieval abilities.” (Dist. Exh. 15)

On March 16, 1998, the IEP team determined that “STUDENT exhibits a learning disability in the area of auditory processing, which negatively impacts academic achievement in reading, written language, and math.” (Dist. Exh. 6) STUDENT was placed in the resource specialist program for 2 hours and 15 minutes each day (45% of the instructional day). STUDENT was placed for the remainder of the day in the regular education curriculum (55% of the instructional day). The IEP team drafted goals and objectives (for a performance level of 80% accuracy) to assist STUDENT in her work habits, writing skills, spelling, word attack skills, sight vocabulary, reading comprehension, number recognition and counting, and math concepts and applications. (Dist. Exh. 6) The IEP was implemented.

(Second grade - 1998-99 school year)

On February 9, 1999, the IEP team met again, when STUDENT was eight years old and in the second grade. MOTHER withheld her agreement for the IEP recommendation of a continuation of the placement (55% regular classroom and 45% resource room). MOTHER requested another speech and language evaluation and administration of the Woodcock-Johnson battery (WJ-R), and the District agreed to a speech and language assessment. The summary of present levels of educational performance noted that STUDENT “can read sight words on a 1st grade level. She is working on long vowel sounds, sh, ch, th and wh sounds. She reads short sentences to make a short story. She adds and subtracts two digit numbers, tells time on the hour, half-hour and counts small change.” Under parental concerns, the IEP document indicates the parent’s request for another speech-language assessment and a concern about STUDENT’s self-esteem in the regular education classroom. (Dist. Exh. 5)

On April 14, 1999, the IEP team met again, and on the basis of upon the speech and language assessment, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT receive speech and language services once per week for 30 minutes, and the team developed annual goals and short-term objectives/benchmarks for STUDENT in the area of communication skills. (Dist. Exh. 4)

In June 1999 MOTHER requested an IEP meeting to refer STUDENT for an AB3632 assessment by Ventura County Mental Health. However, MOTHER refused to sign the assessment plan and the AB3632 assessment was not performed. (Dist. Exh. 3)

(Third grade - 1999-00 school year)

On February 9, 2000, the IEP team met for STUDENT’s annual review. The IEP team, including the parents, agreed to continue STUDENT’s eligibility as SLD, with integration 56% of the school day. STUDENT was placed in the resource specialist program each morning for two hours each day, 30 minutes each for written language and reading, and one hour for math. STUDENT was scheduled to receive designated services in speech/language two times per week, thirty minutes per class. Under program accommodations and supports, STUDENT was given preferential seating and frequent breaks and was given the opportunity to leave class for resource assistance. The IEP provides that STUDENT participate in state achievement assessments in all content areas with flexible setting. The IEP further provides for small group administration with revised test directions in all content areas to simplify test directions. Under placement options and rationale, the IEP document states the following: Due to a specific learning disability, the student needs a smaller class. The IEP document further indicates that STUDENT’s parents would be informed in writing of progress toward meeting goals and objectives. The parents agreed to and signed the IEP. (Dist. Exh. 2)

On September 8, 2000, STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, filed for a due process hearing on behalf of Petitioner. At that time, Petitioner raised various issues concerning the District’s failure to insure that the Petitioner meet her IEP goals. The parties agreed to take the matter off calendar to attempt mediation.

(Fourth grade - 2000-01 school year)

As part of a triennial assessment, on October 30, 2000, MOTHER signed an assessment plan giving her permission for the proposed assessment. The plan indicated that STUDENT’s special education teacher would assess STUDENT in the area of pre-academic achievement, that a speech & language specialist would assess STUDENT’s language/speech/communication development, and that the school psychologist would assess STUDENT in the areas of social/emotional behavior, self help/adaptive skills, psycho-motor development, intellectual development, health assessment, and vocational/prevocational. Although MOTHER signed the assessment plan, MOTHER also indicated that she wanted to be advised about which tests would be used. (Dist. Exh. 10)

To determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance, to assess STUDENT’s progress, and to consider eligibility and educational needs, special day class teacher Laurie A. Larkin administered the following standardized tests to STUDENT on December 8, 2000: the Woodcock-Johnson Revised (WJ-R); the Test of Written Language (TOWL); and the Visual-Motor Integration Test (VMI). Ms. Larkin observed that the VMI is a skill area that “has always been a strength for STUDENT.” STUDENT received a standard score of 118 (88th percentile), placing her well above average, an increase of 24 points over STUDENT’s previous VMI standard score of 94 received in 1998. STUDENT received the following percentile scores on the TOWL: contrived writing: 40%; spontaneous writing: 27%; and overall writing: 35%. On the WJ-R, Mrs. Larkin reports the following standard scores: for Broad Reading, STUDENT received a standard score of 91, in the “average range” — an increase of four points over 1998; for Basic Reading Skills, 88, in the “low average range” — an increase of twelve points over 1998; for Reading Comprehension, 94, in the “average range” — an increase of two points over 1998; for Written Expression, 106, in the “average range”; for Broad Math composite, 92, and for subtests Applied Problems, 93, and Calculation, 92, placing STUDENT, according to Mrs. Larkin, in the “average range.” Mrs. Larkin reports that STUDENT “can tell time accurately to the hour, half hour and minute, knows the value of coins and can count money to $1.00 by 5 and 10s.” Mrs. Larkin concludes that STUDENT “has made good progress in all academic areas since last tested” and that “STUDENT continues to have difficulty with attention in large learning group environments and this affects retention of material learned.” Mrs. Larkin recommended that STUDENT “continue to receive assistance in special education to provide more structured individualized learning,” which includes the use of “necessary manipulatives, re-teaching with repeated drill, and less distraction” in order to maximize “STUDENT’s retention of learned material.” (Dist. Exh. 9)

Also as part of the triennial assessment, Tammy A. Cohen, M.S., speech and language specialist, administered the following standardized tests to assess STUDENT’s communication skills: the Comprehensive Receptive and Expressive Vocabulary Test (CREVT), which is used to identify students who are significantly below their peers in oral vocabulary; the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals - 3 (CELF-3), which is a clinical test for the identification, diagnosis, and follow-up evaluation of language skill deficiencies in children; the Expressive Vocabulary Test (EVT), which measures expressive vocabulary knowledge and word retrieval; and the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test - Third Edition (PPVT - IIIB), which measures receptive single-word vocabulary. Ms. Cohen also asked STUDENT’s teachers to complete teacher questionnaires relating to STUDENT’s speech and language skills within the classroom. Ms. Cohen also informally assessed STUDENT’s communication skills. According to the results of the standardized tests, Ms. Cohen concluded that STUDENT “demonstrated a mild delay in her word retrieval skills which was mostly evident in the narration of a story.” Ms. Cohen determined STUDENT’s strengths to be in the areas of recalling sentences, formulating sentences, and defining words. Ms. Cohen found STUDENT’s overall articulation, fluency, voice and social language skills to be age-appropriate. According to STUDENT’s standardized test scores, Ms. Cohen found that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria to qualify as a “speech and language disordered student.” (Dist. Exh. 8)

On December 14, 2000, District school psychologist Marlaine Jensen Calta administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - 3rd Edition (WISC-III). On January 19, 2001, Ms. Calta administered the Bender-Gestalt, the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Sills-R (TAPS), and the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills (non-motor) Revised (TVPS). Ms. Calta, states under summary/recommendations that “current testing suggests low average cognitive ability, with no discrepancy between verbal and nonverbal skills.” Ms. Calta found that “STUDENT does not continue to meet eligibility for special education under the specific learning disability (SLD) criteria. She does not exhibit a significant discrepancy between academic achievement and cognitive ability.” Although Ms. Calta found that STUDENT was no longer SLD, Ms. Calta found that STUDENT exhibits “significant difficulty with attention and concentration that is negatively impacting her access to the core curriculum and significantly impeding her educational performance.” Accordingly, Ms. Calta recommended that STUDENT be considered for special education services under the other health impaired (OHI) criteria. (Dist. Exh. 7)

On December 21, 2000, the parties agreed to reschedule the due process hearing.

On February 2, 2001, the IEP team met to discuss the triennial assessment. The team decided that STUDENT no longer demonstrated a significant discrepancy between cognitive ability and academic achievement and concluded that STUDENT did not demonstrate a specific learning disability. However, the team also determined that “attention and concentration difficulties do continue to impact educational performance....It is recommended that the IEP team review eligibility under Other Health Impairment due to STUDENT’s ADHD [which] significantly impact[s] her educational performance.” The IEP team also determined that “STUDENT is no longer eligible for speech/language services due to her progress and current level of skill development.” The IEP team then concluded that STUDENT remains eligible as “Other Health Impaired” due to her ADHD. On the IEP document MOTHER did not agree with the eligibility determination and did not agree with the goals and objectives and placement/services. However, MOTHER acknowledged that she had received and understood her parental rights. (Dist. Exh. 1)

Because MOTHER did not agree with and would not sign the IEP dated February 2, 2001, STUDENT has continued to receive, to date, special education and related services in accordance with the last agreed-upon IEP dated February 9, 2000.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District, in its triennial assessment, conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?

A local educational agency (LEA) is required to reassess a student identified as eligible for special education at least once every three years, or more frequently if conditions warrant a reassessment, or when the student’s parent or teacher requests that a reassessment be conducted and a new IEP be developed. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). As part of any reassessment, the IEP team and other qualified professionals, as appropriate, must first review existing assessment data on the student (including evaluations and information provided by the student’s parents), current classroom-based assessments and observations, and teacher and related services providers’ observations. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(1). On the basis of that review and input from the student’s parents, the IEP team and other qualified professionals, as appropriate, must then identify what additional data, if any, is needed to determine the following: (1) whether the student continues to have a disability that qualifies him or her for special education and related services; (2) the student’s present levels of performance and educational needs; (3) whether the student continues to need special education and related services; and (4) whether any additions or modifications to the special education and related services are needed to enable the student to meet the measurable annual goals set out in the IEP and to participate, as appropriate, in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(1)(B); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(2).

Section 56327 of the California Education Code provides as follows: The personnel who assess the pupil shall prepare a written report, or reports, as appropriate, of the results of each assessment. The report shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following: (a) Whether the pupil may need special education and related services. (b) The basis for making the determination.

(c) The relevant behavior noted during the observation of the pupil in an appropriate setting. (d) The relationship of that behavior to the pupil’s academic and social functioning. (e) The educationally relevant health and development, and medical findings, if any. (f) For pupils with learning disabilities whether there is such a discrepancy between achievement and ability that it cannot be corrected without special education and related services.

(g) A determination concerning the effects of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage, where appropriate. (h) The need for specialized services, materials, and equipment for pupils with low incidence disabilities, consistent with guidelines established pursuant to § 56136.

The Hearing Officer finds that the written reports of the assessments conducted of STUDENT during the triennial assessment complied with the requirements of § 56327 of the California Education Code. The Petitioner did not contend that § 56327 was not complied with, and the Hearing Officer notes that the relevant provisions of § 56327 were appropriately followed within the assessment report of District psychologist Marlaine Jensen Calta and the academic assessment report of District special day class teacher Laurie Larkin.

For the District’s assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which provides in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; be provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication; be validated for the purpose for which they are used; be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; be tailored to assess specific areas of need; and be selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure. California Education Code § 56320 (e), (f), and (g) provide that a student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability, that no single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs, and that the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student’s disability. California Education Code § 56322 requires that the assessments be conducted by persons competent to perform assessments. In addition, California Education Code § 56324 provides that any psychological assessment be performed by a credentialed school psychologist.

The Hearing Officer notes that the Petitioner did not offer any evidence to show that the District’s testing and assessment materials and procedures was racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Furthermore, the testing was administered in English, Petitioner’s primary language. The Petitioner did not offer any evidence to show that the testing and assessment materials and procedures were not valid for the purpose for which they are used. In fact, Petitioner’s expert, Ms. Quigley, acknowledged that the test instruments were valid instruments. Moreover, the Petitioner stipulated that § 56320 was complied with at the outset of the testimony of Laurie Larkin, special day class teacher at Brookside Elementary School, who administered the WJ-R, the TOWL and the VMI to STUDENT.(Footnote 3) Nor did the Petitioner offer any evidence to challenge the qualifications of the personnel who administered the tests or to establish that test instructions were not followed. The Petitioner did not offer evidence to suggest that the testing was not tailored to assess specific areas of need. The Petitioner did not offer any evidence to show that the District had relied upon a single procedure as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. The Petitioner did not offer any evidence to show that the assessment was not conducted by persons competent to perform assessments, or to that the assessment was not conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student’s disability. Moreover, school psychologist Marlaine Jensen Calta credibly testified concerning District compliance with each of the above-mentioned requirements of § 56320, and the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with the above-mentioned requirements.

The Petitioner’s challenge to the assessment focused on two points: that the District gave insufficient attention to the SAT-9 test scores for STUDENT in the area of math (whether the testing accurately reflected the student’s aptitude and achievement level), and that the District did not adequately test Petitioner in a suspected area of disability, the area of memory.(Footnote 4)

The District contends that its assessment of STUDENT was appropriate and met the requirements of California Education Code § 56320. The District further contends that the standardized test results show that STUDENT does not have a memory problem and that further testing is unnecessary. The District argues that STUDENT has a retrieval problem and attentional issues that are being addressed within STUDENT’s IEP, through program modifications and accommodations.

In the instant case, the District proceeded to conduct a triennial assessment of STUDENT, and began the assessment process by obtaining the appropriate consent from STUDENT’s parent, MOTHER. (Dist. Exh. 10) The District began standardized testing in December 2000 and completed its triennial assessment in February 2001. The reports, which include findings and recommendations, were presented at the IEP meeting held on February 2, 2001. The IEP assessment team members decided that STUDENT no longer qualified for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD), but does qualify under the other health impaired (OHI) category as a student with ADHD.

While the Petitioner’s mother, MOTHER, and Ms. Bobbie Quigley, who has acted as STUDENT’s after-school tutor since 1998, argue that STUDENT has a suspected disability in the area of memory that has not been disclosed by the District’s standardized testing, neither MOTHER nor Ms. Quigley was able to identify a specific test instrument appropriate to test STUDENT’s memory. MOTHER based her contention on personal observations of STUDENT at home, and her belief that STUDENT does not remember what she has learned in class. Ms. Quigley, who stated that she is qualified to perform and interpret assessment instruments commonly used to assess a child with special needs, based her contention on a “clinical opinion” that the District’s standardized test results “do not reflect the STUDENT she knows and that STUDENT exhibits significant math deficits and memory problems.” However, Ms. Quigley acknowledged she is not qualified to perform testing for memory and that she did not conduct a formal assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Quigley further acknowledged that she had not observed STUDENT in the classroom. Ms. Quigley stated that she believed she had spoken with STUDENT’s teachers, but could not remember with whom. Both Ms. Quigley and MOTHER cited low test results on SAT-9 tests administered to STUDENT in 1998 and 1999 as support for their view that STUDENT has problems with memory. The SAT-9 scores, according to Ms. Quigley, reveal math deficits for STUDENT that are at least two standard deviations below the norm. Ms. Quigley acknowledged, however, that she considered the District’s standardized assessment instruments to be valid. Petitioner did not provide any evidence that the testing as conducted by the District was performed improperly, or that the test results were incorrect.

School psychologist Marlaine Jensen Calta credibly testified that the standardized test data show that STUDENT does not exhibit a memory problem that would warrant additional testing. Ms. Calta testified that the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III) she administered to STUDENT on December 14, 2000, provides information on how STUDENT’s memory is functioning. Ms. Calta stated that STUDENT’s subtest scaled score of 8 for Digit Span shows that “her short-term auditory memory is comparable to that of other kids her age -- in the average range.” Ms. Calta explained that on the digit span subtest, the child must repeat increasingly longer strings of numbers back to the test-giver, and that this indicated how well STUDENT’s short-term auditory memory was functioning. Ms. Calta also cited STUDENT’s score of 10 (within the average range) on the comprehension test, and stated that STUDENT “would have to remember what she would do in these common situations for her to repeat that back to me.” On vocabulary, STUDENT’s scaled score of 8 (within the average range) was also cited by Ms. Calta to reflect STUDENT’s memory functioning: “They have to retrieve the definitions to tell me the answer.” Ms. Calta also cited STUDENT’s performance on the similarities subtest, with a scaled score of 12, also within the average range, show that STUDENT’s memory was functioning properly: “If they have been exposed to a word before, they have to know what the word means to be able to compare it to the other word and give me an answer they would have to retrieve.”

Ms. Calta also cited STUDENT’s performance on the Woodcock-Johnson Revised (WJ-R) achievement tests (administered on December 8, 2000), which “tap into her knowledge of all areas listed” as evidence that “she would have to remember having learned those skills and apply them during the testing - so that would tap into her memory.” Ms. Calta stated that she gave STUDENT the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills (TAPS) and that STUDENT’s overall auditory processing skills were within the low average range. (Ms. Calta stated that the Auditory Number Memory Forward -- scaled score of 93 -- within the average range; and her Auditory Number Memory Reversed -- scaled score of 84 -- within the low average range are subtests that are very similar to the digit span subtest of the WISC-III, and that the test “taps short-term memory.”) Ms. Calta stated that the Auditory Sentence Memory also taps into short-term memory skills: “I give a sentence, and they have to give the sentence back to me verbatim.” STUDENT’s scaled score of 92 placed her within the average range for her age group. On the Auditory Interpretation of Directions subtest, STUDENT’s scaled score of 87 placed her within the low average range. According to Ms. Calta’s report, STUDENT’s scaled scores for the Word Memory and Interpretation of Directions subtests “suggest that when given meaningful sentences and directions, she is better able to remember information than when just given a list of unrelated words.” (Dist. Exh. 7)Ms. Calta stated that she administered the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills (non-motor) Revised (TVPS). Ms. Calta described the Visual Memory subtest: “I show a picture for a few seconds — I take it away. I show her a number of pictures. She has to pick out the picture she saw.” Ms. Calta also described the Visual Sequential Memory subtest: “They see a list of abstract figures. She has to remember them and remember them in order. I flip the page and she has to point to the exact thing she just saw. So she has to retain it — what they look like and in what order they were in.” Ms. Calta stated that this subtest is more difficult than the Visual Memory subtest, and that the subtests look at visual memory. According to Ms. Calta’s report, STUDENT’s overall visual processing skills and her ability to remember visual information are within the average range. Ms. Calta concludes in her report that “testing in 3/98 and 3/96 also revealed average visual processing skills...and that STUDENT continues to show the ability to use and remember information that she sees.” (Dist. Exh. 7)

Ms. Calta stated that she spoke with STUDENT’s teachers and that none of STUDENT’s teachers said that memory was an issue for STUDENT. Ms. Calta credibly testified that memory is not an area of difficulty for STUDENT. Ms. Calta distinguished between memory and retrieval. According to the testimony of Ms. Calta, memory is retention, while retrieval involves accessing that information when it is called upon. “A child may have put something into memory, but for other reasons may not be able to retrieve it every time [the child is} asked to do so.” Ms. Calta observed that individuals who are mentally retarded or who have suffered a traumatic brain injury can exhibit significant problems with memory. Ms. Calta also testified that individuals with memory issues have “extremely significantly” lower test scores in the area of long-term memory, and that she found no evidence in STUDENT’s history that STUDENT has ever suffered from a traumatic brain injury.

Petitioner placed great reliance on STUDENT’s very low math scores on both administrations of the SAT-9 in the second grade (4/99) and the third grade (4/00) in arguing for further assessments of STUDENT. Ms. Quigley contended that STUDENT’s math scores reflect at least two standard deviations below the mean in the math area and that memory plays a large part: “I think it’s [memory] impacting a lot of academic areas including math.” The Hearing Officer finds that greater weight must be given to the District’s reported test scores, which are derived from valid test instruments and which show that STUDENT does not exhibit signs of a memory problem that would warrant further testing. The Hearing Officer gives less weight to the SAT-9 scores and to the anecdotal testimony of Petitioner’s mother, who testified that STUDENT did not remember certain lessons she had been taught in class after returning home from school. The District offered a plausible explanation for STUDENT’s performance at home, that STUDENT’s medication for ADHD, which is designed to remain effective during the school day to control hyperactivity, no longer controlled hyperactivity by the time STUDENT was home from school.

Ms. Cathy Skiba, the District’s director of pupil services, testified that she is a credentialed school psychologist with twenty-five years of experience and has administered thousands of assessments. Ms. Skiba testified that she reviewed the triennial assessment and attended the IEP meeting where all of the assessment results were discussed. Ms. Skiba credibly testified that she had no reason to believe that further testing of Petitioner was necessary or warranted, and that if there had been cross-validation to indicate that there were significant memory issues that need to be pursued, the District would have obtained and administered additional test instruments.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District, in its triennial assessment, conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.

ISSUE NO. 2: Is STUDENT entitled to an independent educational assessment?

California Education Code § 56329(b) provides that a parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment if the parent disagrees with the assessment obtained by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for an independent assessment.

Since the Hearing Officer found that the District, in its triennial assessment, conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, the District is not required to pay for an independent educational assessment.

ISSUE NO. 3: Does STUDENT continue to meet eligibility criteria for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD)?

Petitioner contends that she continues to meet the eligibility criteria to qualify as a student with an SLD, and the District contends that STUDENT no longer meets the eligibility criteria to qualify as a student with an SLD. Petitioner and the District both agree that STUDENT meets the eligibility criteria for special education and related services as a student with ADHD who is Other Health Impaired (OHI).

A specific learning disability is defined as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoke or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(26)(A). Basic psychological processes include “attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, [and] cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expression.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, Section 3030(j)(1).

To qualify for special education and related services as a child with a specific learning disability, the student must meet the following three requirements: First, there must be a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in the areas of oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, or mathematics reasoning. 34 C.F.R. Section 300.541(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code Section 56337(a). Second, the severe discrepancy must be due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and must not be primarily the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. 34 C.F.R. Section 300.541(b)(3),(4); Cal. Educ. Code Section 56337(b). Finally, the discrepancy cannot be ameliorated through “other regular or categorical services” offered within the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code Section 56337(c); C.F.R. Section 300.543(a)(6).

No persuasive evidence was presented by the Petitioner to show that the standardized tests used by the District are invalid to assess Petitioner’s ability or achievement. Therefore, in order to determine if a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement exists, the District properly compared Petitioner’s test scores on standardized intellectual ability tests(WISC-III) with test scores on academic achievement tests (WJ-R).

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s standardized testing properly shows that STUDENT no longer continues to meet the eligibility criteria to qualify as a student with an SLD.

The law clearly envisions that where the aptitude scores are higher than the achievement scores, and a severe discrepancy exists between aptitude and achievement, the student is SLD. In this case, each of STUDENT’s achievement scores is higher than her full scale score of 86 on the WISC-III. For example, on the WJ-R achievement subtest for broad math, STUDENT received a score of 92, six points higher than her full scale aptitude score of 86. On the WJ-R achievement subtest for reading comprehension, STUDENT received a score of 94, eight points higher than her aptitude score. Ms. Calta therefore credibly testified that STUDENT’s test scores show that STUDENT does not continue to show a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in each of the following academic areas: oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, and mathematics reasoning.

Ms. Calta also credibly testified that STUDENT does not have a visual or auditory processing disorder, but does have an attentional issue which qualifies STUDENT for special education and related services as a student who is Other Health Impaired (OHI) as ADHD. Although Petitioner’s expert, Ms. Quigley, testified that she felt STUDENT had memory problems that affect her math performance, Ms. Quigley acknowledged that she is not qualified to give tests for memory. Moreover, Ms. Quigley also stated that she knew that the test instruments used by the District were valid, and knows that the WISC III and the WJ-R are valid instruments. She stated that she has “no problem” with those tests, including the TOWL and the VMI. Other than emphasizing her viewpoint that STUDENT is not performing well in the math area and that memory and how it influences math should be tested further, Ms. Quigley did not offer any evidence to challenge the validity of the test results for the WJ-R and the WISC-III. However, Ms. Quigley stated that STUDENT “has at least a two (2) standard deviations below the mean in the math area, I think in the memory area,” citing STUDENT’s performance on the Stanford Achievement Test Series, Ninth Edition (SAT-9). (Pet. Exh. V). Ms. Quigley and the Petitioner’s mother cited the Petitioner’s low scores on the SAT-9 in April 1999 in the area of math, as support for Petitioner’s contention that STUDENT continues to have a specific learning disability in memory and in the math area.(Footnote 5) Ms. Calta credibly testified for the District that the SAT-9 does not allow for accommodations, and that the SAT-9 test is not a diagnostic test that can serve to show that a student has an SLD, since the test scores do not have subtests to serve as a comparison to subtest scores for the WJ-R. Ms. Calta stated that the SAT-9 scores indicate that STUDENT has great difficulty in taking tests.

The District’s standardized testing and the IEP team’s determination properly conclude that STUDENT no longer continues to meet the eligibility criteria to qualify as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD). The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the qualifications of school psychologist Marlaine Jensen Calta and to her detailed testimony, and the District’s triennial assessment of STUDENT, and less weight to the observations of Ms. Quigley, who acknowledged that she did not assess STUDENT, did not prepare a written report, and is not qualified to assess in the area of memory. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the weight of the credible evidence establishes that STUDENT no longer qualifies for special education and related services as a student with an SLD.

ISSUE NO. 4: Did the IEP dated February 2, 2001, offer STUDENT a FAPE for the period February, 2001 to February, 2002?

In accordance with the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. Section 1400(D); Cal. Educ. Code Section 56000. A “free appropriate public education” is one which provides special education and related services to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meets the State educational standards and conforms to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(8). “Special education” is specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

To determine whether the District provided or offered STUDENT a FAPE, the proper focus is on the adequacy of the District’s placement. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s proposed program reflects STUDENT’s needs, provides some benefit, and comports with her IEP, the District has offered or provided a FAPE, even if the parent or guardian prefers another program, and even if the preferred program would have resulted in a greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. While the school district is required under Rowley to provide to a child with a disability with a meaningful access to education, it does not require the district to guarantee success. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. The Court stated that districts are only required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley at 207-08. However, a de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some benefit.” Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2d Cir. 1998).

In addition, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that a child be removed from the regular education environment only when the nature or severity of the child’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program for STUDENT must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate educational placement: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit; (3) comport with her IEP; and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE). The Petitioner stipulated during the hearing that the February 2, 2001 IEP meeting was procedurally correct. The Hearing Officer will now analyze the application of these requirements to determine whether the IEP dated February 2, 2001, offers STUDENT a FAPE.

(1) Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs

To determine whether the IEP dated February 2, 2001, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the first step is to identify STUDENT’s unique needs. The discussion that follows takes into account the Hearing Officer’s determination under Issue No. 1 that STUDENT has been appropriately assessed by the District in all areas of suspected disability, that she continues to be eligible for special education and related services as OHI based upon her ADHD and attentional issues, and that she no longer qualifies for special education and related services as a student with an SLD.

The parties agree that STUDENT has attentional issues and needs to be redirected to task. The Petitioner agreed at the hearing with the District’s determination that STUDENT qualifies for special education and related services as OHI based upon STUDENT’s ADHD and attentional issues. The Petitioner did not dispute the District’s offer regarding placement for STUDENT within special education for RSP- Written Language and RSP - Reading and RSP - Math, and the remainder of time spent in regular education. The Petitioner disagrees with the District’s offer of 50 minutes of RSP - math per day instead of the 60 minutes per day STUDENT has received under the previous IEP, which represents 50 fewer minutes of math per week. The Petitioner also contends that she needs an aide in the regular education classroom to redirect her and to obtain a FAPE. The District contends that the Petitioner does not need an aide to access the regular education curriculum and to receive an educational benefit.

The Petitioner disputes the ten-minute reduction (from the previous IEP) in the amount of time that STUDENT is scheduled to be in the RSP - Math class each day. MOTHER testified that STUDENT had not shown progress in math over the past year. Ms. Quigley testified that she has been tutoring STUDENT in math four hours per week since September, 2000, and that STUDENT is significantly delayed in math. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of RSP - Math five times per week for 50 minutes per day is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The District did not explain why STUDENT needed ten fewer minutes per day, and fifty fewer minutes per week of RSP - Math. The District did not persuade the Hearing Officer that any academic benefit achieved by STUDENT in RSP - Math warranted a reduction, by fifty minutes per week, in the provision of RSP - Math. Moreover, the District did not offer any evidence to support a ten-minute reduction in RSP - Math. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer did not address STUDENT’s continuing need for RSP - Math, five times per week, in sixty-minute periods.

MOTHER also contends that STUDENT requires a aide in her regular education classroom. Prior to the due process hearing, MOTHER at first sought a “credentialed aide,” and Ms. Quigley testified at the hearing that she felt STUDENT needed a one-to-one aide in the regular education classroom. However, during the course of the hearing, MOTHER and Ms. Quigley modified their position, and each indicated that STUDENT did not need a one-to-one aide, and that the aide, according to MOTHER, did not need to be credentialed, but “someone with patience and training dealing with children with learning disabilities and ADHD” who can re-direct STUDENT and “check with her every five to ten minutes” to make sure she is on task.

The District contends that the Petitioner does not need an aide to access the regular education curriculum.

The Hearing Officer notes that within the Resource class, each resource teacher was supported by one or two aides, and that the class size was limited to between seven and ten students. (Test. of Mrs. Dorman, Ms. Jiminez, and Ms. Larkin) Further, the general education class of twenty-eight students is not supported by a full-time instructional aide, but by a “roving” aide shared with two other fourth grade classes. (Test. of Mrs. Poole and Ms. Trombetta) However, the District argues that the accommodations and modifications set forth within the February 2001 IEP provide the necessary supports for STUDENT to access the general education curriculum. Those supports include preferential seating and modified assignments and tests. The Hearing Officer also notes that the District, within its February 2001 IEP offer, has proposed a change in Petitioner’s basis for eligibility for special education from SLD to OHI based upon ADHD, citing Petitioner’s significant attentional issues. The District does not explain how the new IEP with the accommodations and supports properly addresses the student’s newly identified attentional issues.

While school psychologist Marlaine Jensen Calta stated that STUDENT does not need an aide in the general education classroom, Ms. Calta reported the following within her assessment report under behavioral observations:

STUDENT was observed in her fourth grade classroom [general education]....The teacher was up at the front of the room giving directions for that day’s homework assignment. STUDENT was drawing a picture. Each student appeared to be working on something different while the teacher gave the instructions. Students were then asked to put their papers away and get out an assignment. STUDENT continued to draw while the teacher talked. STUDENT did not get the appropriate assignment out to begin working. She was focused on her drawing and was not distracted as others put things away and got out their assignments.Other students at her table talked to each other at times, but STUDENT continued to draw and did not appear to notice that others had switched assignments. She did not talk with her peers or look at the teacher instructing.

Ms. Calta further reports under social/emotional functioning that STUDENT’s regular education teacher [Ms. Poole] indicated that STUDENT very often daydreams and often shows a short attention span. Ms. Poole also reported on the Burk’s Behavior Rating Scales that STUDENT, more than one time a week up to once a day, “is reluctant to attempt new assignments or tasks, has difficulty remembering directions and recalling information learned, and requires repeated drill and practice to learn what other students master easily.” Ms. Poole also reported that “more than one time a month up to one time a week, STUDENT does not turn in homework assignments, does not remain on task, and does not comprehend what she reads.” Under summary/recommendations, Ms. Calta concludes that “STUDENT....exhibits significant difficulty with attention and concentration that is negatively impacting her access to the core curriculum and significantly impeding her educational performance.” (Dist. Exh.1)

Special day class teacher Laurie Larkin testified that she has had direct experience with STUDENT for two and-one-half years, and notes the following within her Academic Assessment Report: “STUDENT continues to have difficulty with attention in large learning group environments and this affects retention of material learned. It is recommended that she continue to receive assistance in special education to provide more structured individualized learning. In this situation, the necessary manipulatives, re-teaching with repeated drill, and less distraction can be provided to maximize STUDENT’s retention of learned material.” (Dist. Exh. 9) Ms. Gia Trombetta, STUDENT’s third grade regular education teacher, testified that STUDENT needed “lots of prompts” to perform in class and stated that her grade of “2" (meaning that the skills are developing but are not consistent yet) for “Works Well Independently” was an unusual score for a third-grade child to obtain towards the end of the school year. Ms. Trombetta had given STUDENT a grade of “2" for each of the trimesters, and stated that she would [have] “hoped to see more independence at that point.”

The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP provision for preferential seating inadequately addresses STUDENT’s significant attentional issues within the regular education environment. The regular education teacher testified that she “circulates the classroom constantly” within a classroom of twenty-eight students, and that STUDENT sat near the door to allow her to enter and leave the classroom readily. (Test. of Ms. Poole) However, Ms. Larkin testified that she believed preferential seating meant that STUDENT should be seated “no more than two rows back” from the “teacher in front,” “maybe five or six feet away.” When asked “what if the teacher is moving around constantly?” Ms. Larkin replied, “I don’t think that would ever occur.” Ms. Larkin also testified that STUDENT, in RSP - Math, is seated adjacent to Ms. Larkin’s desk and is “at an angle to me so I can look at her.” Ms. Larkin observed that “she is in an environment that helps her focus.... I try to optimize the environment so she is not distracted.” STUDENT’s resource class teacher, Ms. Maria Jiminez, testified that her understanding of the term preferential seating is that STUDENT would sit “near the teacher.”

The Hearing Officer finds that a regular education teacher who is “moving constantly” around a classroom to accommodate the needs of twenty-eight students cannot reasonably be expected to address the needs of a student who has significant attentional issues -- a student who very often daydreams and who often draws when not on task -- without the daily assistance of an instructional aide. STUDENT’s preferential seating within a classroom where the teacher moves around constantly is no longer “preferential.” Ms. Poole contrasted STUDENT’s need for redirection with that of three classmates: “I can think of three other students in my class whom I have to redirect continually. I am very happy I don’t have to redirect her [STUDENT] also.” The Hearing Officer finds inconsistent the observations that STUDENT daydreams frequently, has significant attentional issues, is off task frequently, and yet does not need redirection, or needs redirection just once a week, or needs frequent prompts.

Ms. Poole testified that the PTA had funded an aide for the fourth grade level, to be shared among three fourth grade classes “because our classes are larger than the K through 3rd grade classes.” “We had specifically requested funding from PTA for an aide,” but “[w]e do not have any full-time aides.” The aide, according to Ms. Poole, assists her in paperwork, and also provides direct assistance to students. Ms. Trombetta also testified that the PTA had sponsored a “roving aide” for the fourth grade and the fifth grade, and that the reason for this was that grades kindergarten through the third grade had state-mandated smaller classes. Ms. Trombetta stated that the aide would help out the teacher in any way the teacher wanted. Ms. Trombetta acknowledged that even in the smaller regular education third grade class, she had the services of many volunteer aides, and many in the afternoon who helped her and that she “used them to help service the children.” Ms. Trombetta acknowledged that STUDENT was assisted by volunteer aides and that she never had STUDENT read aloud in class because STUDENT “wouldn’t be up to par with regular education students.” The Hearing Officer finds that the presence of a part-time aide, in each larger fourth grade classroom is a recognition of the need for an aide to assist the regular education teacher in the fulfillment of her teaching responsibilities for twenty-eight students. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that the District did not provide any evidence to explain why twenty-eight students in a regular education fourth grade classroom were able to use an aide one-third of the time, but STUDENT, with significant attentional issues and ADHD, did not need an aide at all to access the regular education curriculum within this same environment.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs and significant attentional issues warrant more than occasional redirection within the regular education classroom of twenty-eight students. The District’s determination that STUDENT is no longer SLD but is ADHD and OHI signals the need for an aide so that STUDENT can meaningfully access the regular education curriculum. STUDENT’s needs have changed, and she can no longer depend upon preferential seating in class and modified assignments and tests, alone, to remain on task and actively participate in class.

The Hearing Officer finds that for STUDENT to access the general curriculum, and given STUDENT’s unique needs, an instructional aide must be present in the regular education classroom while STUDENT is attending class. STUDENT does not need a “one-to-one aide,” but an aide who can help STUDENT to remain on task as needed.

The District contends that STUDENT’s unique needs within the regular education classroom are met by the accommodations and modifications included within her IEP. The Hearing Officer notes that a comparison of the February 2000 IEP (Dist. Exh. 2), with the February 2001 IEP offer (Dist. Exh. 1) reveals the following: STUDENT is offered the same amount of instructional time in the resource placement (5 times per week at 30 minutes each) in the area of RSP reading and RSP written language. However, STUDENT will be given, under the new IEP, ten fewer minutes per day (50 minute periods, 5 times per week) in RSP math, than offered in the IEP currently in effect. Under program modifications/accommodations needed in general education, STUDENT will continue to be given preferential seating under the new IEP as well as the addition of modified assignments/tests. Under the new IEP, STUDENT will continue to receive the same testing accommodations for all content areas with small- group administration and with revised test directions (simplified language in directions) within a flexible setting. (Dist. Exhs. 1 and 2). The two IEPs are quite similar; however, the previous IEP was based upon an SLD eligibility determination, and the new IEP is based upon an OHI ADHD determination.

Ms. Laurie Larkin, who teaches STUDENT in her Resource math class for one hour per day, five days per week, testified that she drafted the following goals and objectives for the proposed IEP: (1) STUDENT will complete and return homework assignments on time in all academic areas, (2) STUDENT will carry a letter/assignment book daily from school to home, (3) in the special education class, STUDENT will perform fourth grade math skills, and (4) in the special education class, STUDENT will perform simple addition and subtraction word problems making change up to $5.00. Ms. Larkin testified that these goals and objectives are appropriate because STUDENT frequently did not complete and turn in homework assignments and did not always carry a letter/assignment book. Ms. Larkin stated that the first two goals addressed STUDENT’s attentional issues and the need for organization. Ms. Larkin also testified that MOTHER did not make any recommendations for goals or objectives at the February 2, 2001 IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer notes that the Petitioner did not dispute the goals and objectives for RSP - Math. The Hearing Officer further notes that the Petitioner did not offer alternative goals and objectives, either at the February 2, 2001 IEP meeting or at the due process hearing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the RSP - Math goals and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT.

Ms. Maria Jiminez testified that the goals and objectives set forth within the proposed IEP for Reading Comprehension and Reading Decoding are also appropriate for STUDENT, and that Petitioner did not offer recommendations for goals or objectives at the February 2, 2001 IEP meeting. The Hearing Office notes that the Petitioner did not offer alternative goals and objectives at the due process hearing, and that the District’s goals and objectives are appropriate for STUDENT. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives for Reading Comprehension and Reading Decoding are appropriate for STUDENT.

Based upon the weight of the credible evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District IEP offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs except with respect to STUDENT’s need for sixty minutes per day of RSP - Math and the services of an aide in the general education classroom to redirect her as needed.

(2) Be reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit

The Petitioner did not challenge the program or placement generally. While the Petitioner did not challenge any of the specific IEP goals and objectives for STUDENT, the Petitioner contended that STUDENT was not learning or making progress in the general educational curriculum, citing instances where STUDENT did not know the solar system, dinosaurs and their names, how plants grow, California Missions, Native American cultures, or any general education topic. Nevertheless, the Petitioner did not argue that STUDENT should be spending more of her school day within a resource room or within a special education setting. MOTHER basically asserted the need for an instructional aide and the need for further testing, which has already been discussed. The Petitioner did not point to any other aspect of STUDENT’s program which was arguably deficient or was not designed to achieve an educational benefit.

STUDENT’s fourth grade teacher in the general education curriculum, Ms. Kathleen Poole, testified that she had received a copy of STUDENT’s IEP and had spoken with Laurie Larkin, STUDENT’s special education teacher, in the fall 2000.(Footnote 6) Ms. Poole stated that she had “kind of tailored my class for STUDENT to be there” for social studies and science. Ms. Poole said that she felt STUDENT “is doing just fine where she is and for the capabilities that she has....I have seen her grow since September. I have seen her mature along with the class. She is learning not only curriculum type stuff, but social things which are so important. She knows how to get along in the world with other children....and other adults.” Ms. Poole stated that STUDENT has friends in class and participates with friends at recess and lunch and that STUDENT loves to play handball: “I see her out there every morning. She is very good at it -- I don’t want to play her.” Ms. Poole’s testimony focused on the social benefits STUDENT was receiving from the regular education class.

STUDENT received the following grade reports from Ms. Poole for the December 2000 and March 2001 trimesters: under behavioral standards, a “3" grade for Social Skills, Responsibility, Work Habits, and Independence; under History/Social Science, Science, Integrated Technology, and Physical Education, a “2” grade; for Visual & Performing Arts, a “3” grade. A score of 3 indicates in the rubric that STUDENT had mastered trimester standards, had performed independently, had put forth good effort, and was consistent in her performance. A grade of “2" indicates that STUDENT was working to master the standard and may be dependent on others for assistance, and that STUDENT puts forth good effort with generally consistent performance. (Test. of Ms. Poole and Dist. Exhs. 43 and 50). Ms. Poole also stated that she met with STUDENT and her mother for a goal setting conference on October 17, 2000, and that STUDENT, her mother, and Mrs. Poole set three goals for STUDENT: (1) To ask Ms. Poole what I need to do when I return to class, (2) To complete social studies projects - to ask if not sure what to do, and (3) To finish all art projects. Under December comments, Ms. Poole reports that STUDENT “has shown excellent progress in all of her goals. She is a delight to have in class. She is extremely helpful.” Under March Follow-up Comments, Ms. Poole reports that STUDENT “continues to progress in her activities in the classroom. She especially maintains a good attitude with her work and in the area of social behavioral standards.” (Dist. Exhs. 43 and 50).

MOTHER testified that STUDENT “has done very well” in the class taught by Ms. Jiminez (RSP Reading and RSP Written Language).(Footnote 7) MOTHER started that for the first time, STUDENT “is starting to spell for the first time. It never sunk in before that point. She just didn’t get the sounds of letters.” MOTHER further stated that STUDENT has the grades “P’s” for making progress or “M’s” for having met the objectives and that she agrees that STUDENT is making progress on her IEPs (in the special education classes). The Petitioner did not challenge the appropriateness of the RSP - Written Language class or the RSP Reading class. The latter classes are in thirty-minute sessions, five times per week, the same amount of time allocated under the last agreed-upon and implemented IEP dated February 9, 2000. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of STUDENT’s special education teacher, Ms. Jiminez, on the issue of STUDENT’s past progress in RSP Written Language and RSP Reading. The testimony of the school psychologist, Ms. Calta, was also persuasive on the issue of progress. Ms. Calta testified that STUDENT’s achievement scores on the WJ-R indicate that STUDENT had achieved substantial progress.

The weight of the credible evidence, which is largely based upon STUDENT’s past performance, establishes that the District’s offer is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit; however, STUDENT’s needs have changed and she no longer qualifies for special education and related services as SLD. Instead, STUDENT has significant attentional issues and therefore qualifies under a different eligibility criteria -- OHI as ADHD. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit if it includes sixty minutes per day of RSP - Math and the services of an aide within the regular education classroom to redirect her as needed.

(3) Comport with her IEP

This issue was not in dispute. The Petitioner did not raise as an issue the fact that in the past, the District had failed to comport with STUDENT’s existing IEP of February 2000.

(4) Be provided in the Least Restrictive Environment

The Petitioner did not contend that the District’s proposed program is not provided in the least restrictive environment. The Petitioner did not argue, with respect to the District’s offer of placement within the IEP dated February 2, 2001, that STUDENT should spend more, or less, time in the regular education classroom.

The Hearing Officer finds the following: With the exception that the District did not offer sixty minutes per day of RSP - Math and did not offer the services of an aide in the regular education classroom to redirect STUDENT as needed, the District in all other respects offered STUDENT a FAPE for the period February 2001 to February 2002.

ORDER

1. The District is ordered to provide STUDENT with sixty minutes per day of RSP - Math.

2. The District is ordered to provide STUDENT with the services of an aide in the regular education classroom to redirect as needed. The aide need not be a one- to-one aide.

3. The District shall convene an IEP meeting prior to the 2001-02 school year to conform the IEP to items one and two above.

4. All other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

In accordance with California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Did the District, in its triennial assessment, conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability? **The District prevailed on this issue.

2. Is STUDENT entitled to an independent educational assessment at public expense? **The District prevailed on this issue.

3. Does STUDENT continue to meet eligibility criteria for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability? **The District prevailed on this issue.

4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the period February 2001 to February 2002? **The District prevailed on this issue, except in regard to the time for RSP - Math and the provision of an aide in the regular education classroom. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal.Educ.Code § 56505(i). ___________________________________ Date: June 27, 2001 Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: The issues set forth include changes made for purposes of clarification and to facilitate proper analysis, and to reflect the discussions held with the parties on the record on the first day of hearing. The Petitioner withdrew as an issue whether STUDENT continued to be eligible to receive speech and language services after Petitioner’s witness, Ms. Bobbie Quigley, a licensed speech and language pathologist, testified that STUDENT no longer meets the eligibility criteria for speech and language services. Footnote 2: The issue raised by Petitioner as to whether STUDENT needs an aide in the general education curriculum to receive a FAPE is discussed and decided within this issue. Footnote 3: Ms. Quigley testified that she has thirty-eight years of teaching experience and holds master’s degrees in deaf education and communication disorders. Ms. Quigley stated that she also holds teaching credentials in several states and that she holds the following California life credentials: speech and language pathology, secondary education, special education, and deaf education. Footnote 4: Petitioner’s mother at first also contended that the Petitioner might have dyslexia, but Petitioner’s expert, Ms. Quigley, who stated that she had tutored STUDENT in reading to a point where STUDENT’s reading difficulties had been remediated, testified that she “did not see [STUDENT] as a dyslexic student.” District psychologist Calta persuasively testified that there was no indication that STUDENT is dyslexic, and also stated that dyslexia is a reading disability and that “memory” and dyslexia don’t necessarily go hand in hand. Ms. Calta further stated that references to “letter confusions” within a March 16, 1998 report by District Resource Specialist Sandy Hirano reflect developmental problems common for young students and do not indicate dyslexia. (Dist. Exh. 12). Petitioner’s closing brief argued that STUDENT has a memory problem that should be addressed, but the brief did not assert the need to test for dyslexia. Footnote 5: Petitioner argued that STUDENT was given a “non-standard” version of the SAT-9 in April 1999, as further support for her contention that she meets the criteria for SLD. (Pet. Exhs. U and V, and Test. of Ms. Quigley and MOTHER) The District argued that STUDENT was given the standard version (Test. of Ms. Larkin). Since the Hearing Officer finds that the SAT-9 test is not a diagnostic instrument that can support an SLD determination, the issue is moot as to eligibility for SLD. Footnote 6: Ms. Poole has held a California teaching credential in secondary education for twenty-seven years, and has taught in the District for twenty-two years. Ms. Poole has held a credential in elementary education for twelve years. Footnote 7: Ms. Jiminez testified that she has over twenty years of experience as a resource specialist teacher, has a master’s degree in special education and has credentials in severely handicapped and in physically handicapped.