California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 18, 2000

Student v. Poway Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 435-00 · Hearing Officer Paul R. Gant

Poway Unified must repay $600 for a private OT assessment and four months of private OT services after a flawed behavior plan.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 4 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A nine-year-old boy with Asperger's Syndrome, eligible for special education under autism, filed against Poway Unified School District. His behavior problems were tied to sensory integration deficits. In November 1999 he moved from a special day class at Garden Road Elementary to the Moyers Center, a nonpublic agency. The parent challenged the District's 1998 occupational therapy (OT) assessment and its program from September 1999 through September 2000. She also sought repayment for a private OT assessment and services from Chris Vinceneux, OTR.

The Hearing Officer found the District's OT assessment inappropriate. The sensory test used was valid for this student, and the assessor relied on several sources. But she never watched him in the classroom, where his sensory problems played out. The District also should have reassessed him before September 1999, when his behavior was not improving. The OT services the District offered were appropriate. However, the behavior intervention plan written by District behavior analyst Dan Petro ignored the student's sensory needs and missed sensory triggers. Its promised staff training at Moyers did not happen until early 2000. This denied FAPE from September 1999 through February 28, 2000. The District must pay $600 for the private OT assessment. It must also repay the parent, on a signed invoice, for Mr. Vinceneux's services from October 25, 1999 through February 28, 2000. Repayment for later months was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated a missing classroom observation as a defect when a student's behavior depended on his classroom setting. It also held that a behavior plan for a student with autism had to account for sensory needs. And it allowed repayment for a private occupational therapist's work even though it was not strictly behavioral services.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue I. Did the District conduct an appropriate occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT?

    The SIPT was a valid tool and the assessor did not rely on a single procedure. But the March 1998 OT assessment had no classroom observation, and the District should have reassessed sensory needs before September 1999 when behavior did not improve.

  2. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue II. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the period September 1999 through September 2000 by failing to offer a program that was designed and reasonably calculated to meet his behavioral needs, provide educational benefit, and comport with his IEP?

    The OT services offered were appropriate. The BIP did not address sensory needs or identify sensory antecedents, and its staff training at Moyers was delayed. This denied FAPE from September 1999 through February 28, 2000, but not afterward.

  3. Issue III. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent evaluation by Chris Vinceneux, registered occupational therapist (OTR)?

    Because the District's OT assessment was not appropriate and Mr. Vinceneux was qualified, the parent is entitled to $600 reimbursement for his September 15, 1999 assessment.

  4. Issue IV. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the services provided by Chris Vinceneux, OTR?

    Under Burlington and Alamo Heights, the parent gets reimbursed for Mr. Vinceneux's services from October 25, 1999 through February 28, 2000. During that time he provided the only behavior intervention tailored to the student. Later months are not reimbursed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days, District shall pay $600 to the parent for the September 15, 1999 independent OT assessment by Chris Vinceneux, OTR.
  • Reimbursement. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, Petitioner shall give the District a signed invoice from Chris Vinceneux listing the dates, nature, and cost of services for October 25, 1999 through February 28, 2000. Within 15 calendar days of receiving it, the District shall pay the parent the documented amount. The decision states no dollar figure.

Total: $600 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington; Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.

People named in the decision

  • Joanne Murphy, executive director for special education, Poway Unified School District
  • Betsy Slavik, occupational therapist (OTR), District assessor, Poway Unified School District (contract)
  • Chris Vinceneux, private occupational therapist (OTR), independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Private provider
  • Patricia Oetter, clinical director; author of letter on the SIPT, The Ayres Clinic/Sensory Integration International
  • Dan Petro, behavior analyst; functional analysis assessor, Poway Unified School District
  • Tracy Bosanac, special day class teacher, Garden Road Elementary School, Poway Unified School District
  • Mr. Scull, principal, Garden Road Elementary School, Poway Unified School District
  • Teri Brislin, occupational therapist (OTR), service provider, Poway Unified School District
  • Sara Frampton, PhD, expert witness for Student
  • Donald Tyssee, special education consultant, Moyers Center (nonpublic agency)
  • Ann Weime, instructor, Moyers Center (nonpublic agency)
  • Jennifer Trinkle, case manager
  • Moyers Center, nonpublic agency placement
  • Banyan Tree Learning Center, nonpublic agency placement

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Paul R. Gant, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Poway, California, on September 26 and 27, and October 24 and 25, 2000.

STUDENT (the Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by Eric B. Freedus, attorney at law, of the law firm Frank & Freedus. Respondent Poway Unified School District (the District) was represented by G. Robert Roice, educational consultant. Also present at the hearing were the Petitioner’s mother, PARENT, and Joanne Murphy, the District’s executive director for special education.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. Closing briefs were received on November 14, 2000, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

I. Did the District conduct an appropriate occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT?

II. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the period September 1999 through September 2000 by failing to offer a program that was designed and reasonably calculated to meet his behavioral needs, provide educational benefit, and comport with his IEP?(Footnote 2)

III. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent evaluation by Chris Vinceneux, registered occupational therapist (OTR)?

IV. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the services provided by Chris Vinceneux, OTR?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a nine-year-old boy who is eligible for special education and related services based on a diagnosis of Asperger’s Syndrome, an autism spectrum disorder. STUDENT also has previously been diagnosed with oppositional defiant disorder and atypical obsessive-compulsive disorder. As a result of his autism spectrum disorder, STUDENT suffers from delays in academic and social functioning, attention, and communication. STUDENT has a history of mild to severe behavioral problems connected, at least in part, with his autism spectrum disorder.

From September 1997 to June 1998, STUDENT attended kindergarten in a regular education classroom at Westwood Elementary School, a District school. During his kindergarten year, STUDENT’s teacher referred STUDENT for special education services, based in part on STUDENT’s behavior, which the teacher indicated was causing a serious disruption in the classroom. STUDENT was determined to be eligible for special education services on February 4, 1998, and has been receiving services from the District since that time.

On March 20 and 27, 1998, STUDENT was assessed by Betsy Slavik, OTR, at the request of the District, to determine whether his behaviors impacting school performance were connected with problems in sensory integration. Ms. Slavik concluded that STUDENT would benefit from occupational therapy services on a direct and consultative basis which would include a sensory program (otherwise termed a “sensory diet”) to help STUDENT “cope with sensory demands of his environment” and decrease his “sensory defensiveness,” with the ultimate goal of improving classroom behavior.

For STUDENT’s 1998-1999 first grade school year, his placement was changed from his general education classroom at Westwood Elementary to a special day class (SDC) at Garden Road Elementary School, another District school. STUDENT’s placement was changed at the suggestion of the District based on the fact that Westwood Elementary did not have special education facilities or a sufficiently small class size to meet STUDENT’s sensory and behavioral needs.

STUDENT’s Individualized Education Program (IEP) team met on February 25, 1999. (Pet. Exh.11). The team noted that STUDENT suffered from a developmental disability that significantly affected verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction, adversely affecting his educational performance. The team also noted that STUDENT was responding unpredictably in normal social situations and having difficulty taking turns with peers or adults when playing a game. STUDENT became frustrated when working on challenging assignments, and was having difficulty following a daily schedule, accepting unplanned changes, and completing tasks. STUDENT was not respectful of authority. Concluding that STUDENT was exhibiting behavioral problems that significantly interfered with the implementation of his IEP, the District proposed a plan to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA). PARENT did not agree at that point to the FAA plan.

In approximately April 1999, after a one-hour meeting with Dan Petro, the District’s proposed functional analysis assessor, PARENT gave her approval for the District to proceed with the FAA. Mr. Petro completed his assessment on June 14, 1999.

The IEP team met again on June 25, 1999. (Dist. Exh. 2). The results of the FAA and a Behavioral Intervention Plan (BIP) were presented by Dan Petro. Tracy Bosanac, STUDENT’s special day class teacher, and Mr. Scull, the school principal, shared their concerns regarding STUDENT’s lack of progress in the behavioral realm. Mr. Scull felt that STUDENT had shown an increase in the amount of inappropriate behaviors since September 1998, and that the behaviors had become so severe that they threatened the safety of other students and could result in STUDENT’s suspension from school. All the team members except PARENT believed that STUDENT would benefit from placement at a nonpublic agency. However, based in part on recommendations by STUDENT’s private psychologist and psychiatrist, PARENT did not consent to a change of placement, preferring to give STUDENT a further opportunity for success at Garden Road.

Nonetheless, shortly thereafter it became apparent to all team members, including PARENT, that STUDENT’s placement at Garden Road was not succeeding. Accordingly, the IEP team met on October 25, 1999, and agreed on a change of placement to the Moyers Center, a nonpublic agency (NPA).

Thereafter, STUDENT attended Moyers Center from November 1999 to October 2000, at which time the Moyers Center closed and STUDENT was transferred to his current placement at Banyan Tree Learning Center, also an NPA.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE I: Did the District conduct an appropriate occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT?

The Petitioner contends that the March 1998 assessment by Betsy Slavik, conducted on behalf of the District, was inappropriate because: (1) Ms. Slavik improperly relied on a test that was not validated for the purpose it was used; (2) Ms. Slavik improperly relied on a single procedure; and (3) Ms. Slavik did not conduct an observation of STUDENT in his regular classroom as part of the assessment. Petitioner also contends that the District improperly failed to conduct a reassessment when it became apparent that STUDENT was not progressing behaviorally. The District responds that the assessment by Betsy Slavik was complete, accurate, and appropriate. Petitioner alleges that the Sensory Integration and Praxis Test (SIPT), which Ms. Slavik administered to STUDENT as part of her occupational therapy assessment, was not valid for children with autism. The District contends that the SIPT was appropriate for testing STUDENT’s autism-related sensory deficits. Under California special education law, the testing materials used in an educational assessment must have been validated for the specific purpose they were used. (California Education Code §56320 (b)(2)).

Betsy Slavik, OTR, testified that the SIPT consists of 17 separate measures designed to help understand the way some children have difficulty learning or behaving as expected. The test is intended to assess certain aspects of sensory processing or perception that are related to language development, academic achievement, and social behavior, and also to evaluate “praxis,” the child’s ability to cope with tangible, physical, two- and three-dimensional work.

Chris Vinceneux, OTR, testifying on Petitioner’s behalf, stated that he had contacted the company that markets the SIPT and was told that results on the test are not valid for children with autism spectrum disorders. Ms. Slavik responded in her testimony that, in her opinion, the SIPT is appropriate for autistic children such as STUDENT who have a comparatively high level of academic functioning. This was confirmed by a letter from Patricia Oetter, clinical director of The Ayres Clinic/Sensory Integration International, the organization which certifies occupational therapy professionals in administration of the SIPT. (Dist. Exh. 40). An article reprinted from the Journal of the American Occupational Therapy Association indicated that, although not routinely administered to children with autism, the SIPT may be used in testing such children to detect “specific patterns of sensory integrative dysfunction.” (Dist. Exh 41).

Ms. Slavik’s testimony regarding the appropriateness of the SIPT is accorded greater weight than that of Chris Vinceneux. According to her undisputed testimony, Ms. Slavik is certified in the administration and interpretation of the SIPT. Since 1986, Ms. Slavik has served as an instructor for Sensory Integration International in the areas of administration and interpretation of the SIPT. Furthermore, she participated in the collection of normative data for developing this test. The letter from Sensory Integration International and the article from the Journal of the American Occupational Therapy Association provide support for Ms. Slavik’s direct testimony. There was no evidence that Mr. Vinceneux has any significant experience in administering the SIPT or interpreting its results. Moreover, Mr. Vinceneux conceded that he was not certified to administer the test. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the SIPT was an appropriate assessment tool for STUDENT.

Petitioner also contends that Ms. Slavik’s assessment was improper because she relied on the results of a single procedure in forming her recommendations regarding STUDENT’s OT and behavioral needs. The California Education Code provides: “No single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs.” (California Education Code §56320(e))

Ms. Slavik testified that she also relied on information gathered from completion of sensory history questionnaires by both the general education classroom teacher at Westwood Elementary and PARENT, STUDENT’s mother. Ms. Slavik stated that she evaluated the results of the questionnaires and found “significant agreement” between the two. In addition, Ms. Slavik administered a handwriting sample, conducted a clinical observation of STUDENT, and reviewed his educational records. Accordingly, the evidence does not support the contention that Ms. Slavik relied solely on the SIPT in forming her opinions regarding STUDENT’s program.

Petitioner further contends that the March 1998 assessment was improper because Betsy Slavik did not conduct an observation of STUDENT in the classroom. The California Education Code requires that an assessment report include a description of “the relevant behavior noted during the observation of the pupil in an appropriate setting.” (California Education Code §56327(c))

It is undisputed that the primary purpose of Ms. Slavik’s assessment was to determine the possible sensory factors influencing STUDENT’s behavior in the classroom and impacting on the ability of the classroom teacher to conduct the lessons. Chris Vinceneux, OTR, testified that a classroom observation would have revealed the degree to which STUDENT was being affected by environmental factors, such as noise level, commotion, pace of class activity, visual clutter, nature of the instructional staff, and method of instruction, and that most of STUDENT’s behavioral problems involved being overwhelmed by the distractions in the classroom environment. Neither Betsy Slavik nor any other District witness disputed the importance of performing a classroom observation. Indeed, Betsy Slavik herself, when discussing her later observation of STUDENT’s Moyers Center placement, confirmed the importance of observing the student in the actual educational environment. Tracy Bosanac, STUDENT’s special day class teacher for the 1998-1999 school year, also agreed that it is important to observe a child’s behavior in the classroom when there is a sensory integration problem.

The District argues that Ms. Slavik’s failure to conduct a classroom observation at Westwood was justified based on the amount of time that STUDENT was out of the class because of disruptive behaviors. Ms. Slavik testified that she did not observe STUDENT in the classroom because he was outside the class in one-on-one instruction on the day she was at the school to conduct her assessment. Joanne Murphy, director of special education for the District, testified that STUDENT was out of the classroom a significant amount of time at Westwood, including at least twelve occasions when he was taken out of the class to the offices of the principal and vice-principal because of behavior disruptions. Nonetheless, the evidence submitted by the District was not sufficient to establish that STUDENT’s absences from class at Westwood were so frequent or sustained that it would have been impracticable for Ms. Slavik to arrange an alternative time to return to Westwood to complete her assessment by observing STUDENT’s behavior in the classroom setting.

It is credible that Ms. Slavik’s one-on-one observation of STUDENT, observation of STUDENT during an out-of-class adapted physical education session, and information gathered by means of written questionnaires yielded useful information in assessing STUDENT. However, based on the undisputed evidence that STUDENT’s actual classroom environment had a significant impact on STUDENT’s sensory problems, it is concluded that an appropriate assessment of this student would necessarily include an observation of his behavior in the classroom setting. There was no evidence that the one-on-one meeting Ms. Slavik conducted with STUDENT was an adequate substitute for such a classroom observation.

Finally, Petitioner contends that even if the initial OT assessment by Betsy Slavik had been appropriate, the District should have a conducted reassessment of STUDENT when it became apparent that he was not progressing with regard to his behavioral needs (which had been determined to have a sensory integration basis). Pursuant to the California Education Code: “A reassessment . . . shall be conducted at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant . . . .” (California Education Code §56381, emphasis added)

There was no credible evidence adduced at hearing to establish that STUDENT’s behavioral problems substantially improved during the 1998-1999 school year. Although Teri Brislin, OTR, issued a report, dated January 18, 1999, which recorded a twenty-five percent improvement in inappropriate behaviors from the time of Ms. Slavik’s assessment at Westwood, neither Ms. Brislin nor any other witness at hearing could point to any information to establish a base level of disruptive behaviors at Westwood. Ms. Brislin testified that she established her baseline from conversations with Betsy Slavik. However, Betsy Slavik did not observe STUDENT in the Westwood classroom and could not identify at hearing any specific basis that would reasonably enable Ms. Brislin to establish a reliable means for concluding that STUDENT experienced a twenty-five percent improvement in behaviors between March 1998 and January 1999. In fact, Ms. Slavik testified that, prior to February 1999, neither she nor anyone involved in STUDENT’s education kept a record of the frequency of his problem behaviors. Finally, Tracy Bosanac, in testimony supported by statements by Principal Scull at the June 25, 1999 IEP meeting, stated that STUDENT experienced virtually no improvement in his behaviors during the 1998-1999 school year while in her class at Garden Road.

Accordingly, based on the failure of the March 1998 assessment to include a classroom observation, STUDENT’s lack of progress in behavioral issues, and the fact that the behaviors were connected to sensory integration and modulation problems, it is concluded that the District should have reassessed STUDENT for sensory problems prior to September 1999 to determine the factors contributing to his lack of progress.

Having failed to conduct an appropriate occupational assessment in March 1998 and having failed to appropriately reassess STUDENT’s sensory problems prior to September 1999, the District did not meet its obligation to conduct an appropriate occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT.

ISSUE II: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the period September 1999 through September 2000 by failing to offer a program that was designed and reasonably calculated to meet his behavioral needs, provide educational benefit, and comport with his IEP?

Under State and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (California Education Code §56000; 20 U.S.C. §1400) The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) defines “free appropriate public education” as special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(18))

“Special education” means specially designed instruction at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S. C. §1401(a)(16)) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. §1401 (a)(17)) California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” (Cal. Ed. Code §56363(b))

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA 1997). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id at 200. According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require a school district to provide special education students the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor or opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id at 201. Special education law further requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (34 C.F.R. §300.550)

In short, under the IDEA and Rowley, an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, to provide the student with some educational benefit, to comport with the IEP, and must be provided in the least restrictive environment.(Footnote 3)

Petitioner contends that the program offered by the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE because (1) the sensory diet developed by the District OTR’s was general in nature and not tailored to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) the District OTRs were not providing monitoring, training, and consultation with the classroom staff at Garden Road and, as a result, the staff was not able to implement appropriate strategies to address STUDENT’s behavior; and (3) the BIP component of the District’s program did not incorporate information regarding STUDENT’s sensory needs and did not provide for appropriate consultation and training to the classroom staff.(Footnote 4) STUDENT’s Unique Needs

In order to analyze the appropriateness of the educational program offered by the District to address STUDENT’s behavior, it is first necessary to determine the nature of STUDENT’s unique and individual needs in the behavioral realm.

There was no substantial dispute between the parties regarding the nature of STUDENT’s unique needs. Based on the record as a whole, and particularly the testimony and assessments of Betsy Slavik, OTR, Chris Vinceneux, OTR, and Sara Frampton, PhD, STUDENT suffers from a developmental disability that affects verbal and nonverbal communication, social interaction, and behavior, adversely impacting on his educational performance. STUDENT experiences deficits in sensory integration, modulation, and processing, including hypersensitivity to sensory input across tactile, auditory, taste, and smell domains. (Pet. Exhs.1, 18).

STUDENT’s sensory modulation problems cause him to be sensitive to environmental stimuli in the classroom such as noise level, commotion, pace of activities, visual clutter, changes in routine and space, and the content, style, and method of classroom instruction. STUDENT has difficulty filtering sensory information and tuning out background multi-sensory input. STUDENT has difficulty in handling transitions in activities and between locations and is sometimes over-aroused. STUDENT is subject to attention deficits, disorganization, and behavior disruptions as stressful or over-arousing events build up in his nervous system causing a cumulative effect.(Footnote 5)

At hearing, Mr. Vinceneux and Ms. Slavik were in substantial agreement that STUDENT requires an educational program that provides instruction using a multidisciplinary approach, involving the teacher, psychologist, behavioral specialist, and assistive physical education instructor. Because of STUDENT’s sensitivity to environmental factors, his instruction should include one-on-one intervention in a small (6-8 children), predictable setting. STUDENT’s teaching staff should help keep him on task, redirecting him as necessary, addressing behavior and attention problems, and providing structure and immediate feedback. In addition, STUDENT requires a sensory diet developed and implemented by an occupational therapist with experience and expertise in the treatment of sensory disorders in autistic children to improve the level of arousal and minimize sensation-seeking behavior, and to provide frequent calming and organizing input and a variety of sensory activities integrated into the regular classroom schedule. STUDENT also needs occupational therapy services delivered by a registered OTR utilizing sensory integrative equipment and techniques such as the “Willbarger protocol,” a system of brushing and joint compression. Furthermore, the OTR working with STUDENT must train, monitor and consult with the classroom staff in order to incorporate sensory strategies including inhibiting, calming, organizing techniques, and multi-sensory strategies in all aspects of teaching in the classroom, to instruct as to safe and proper implementation of the OT techniques (such as the Willbarger protocol), and to monitor STUDENT’s performance and behaviors. Finally, the OTR must conduct a monthly meeting with STUDENT’s classroom staff and STUDENT’s mother to review progress and make necessary adjustments to the occupational therapy program. (Pet. Exh. 18)

In addition to STUDENT’s occupational therapy needs, substantial evidence was presented at hearing that STUDENT requires the implementation of behavioral modification strategies to address his problems with behavioral disruption. The undisputed evidence at hearing established that STUDENT has a history of disruptive behaviors in school ranging from mild (talking out, interrupting conversations, name calling) to severe (threatening, spitting, hitting, kicking staff and peers, running form the classroom, threatening to bring a gun to class and kill staff and peers). According to Dan Petro, behavior analyst for the District, his FAA revealed that antecedents to STUDENT’s mild behaviors include STUDENT refusing a request, being told to change activities, or being subjected to an intervention used for his misbehavior (e.g. changing his card from green [favorable] to another less favorable color). Severe behaviors followed from unsuccessful interventions to the mild behaviors. Dan Petro indicated that STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors were occurring continually throughout the week at the time of the FAA. (Pet. Exh.15).

At an IEP meeting dated June 25, 1999, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT needed a behavioral intervention plan. The team further agreed that STUDENT needed goals and objectives in the following areas to address STUDENT’s behavioral and social needs: stating needs, identifying and expressing emotions (particularly anger), taking turns, accepting winning and losing, reacting predictably in social situations, initiating tasks, acknowledging the presence of new persons, making choices, completing work, participating in activities, limiting of duration of tantrums and off-task behavior, reacting to transitions, and initiating and maintaining eye contact with peers and adults.

Mr. Petro recommended additional goals and objectives for STUDENT’s IEP to reduce problem behavior. These included having STUDENT independently remove himself from uncomfortable situations with minimal interruption to the classroom or social setting in question, and reduction in the frequency of the problem behaviors. Mr. Petro recommended the following types of intervention designed to address STUDENT’s behavioral problems: (1) upon STUDENT approximating the inappropriate behavior, he was to be given a choice of directions incompatible with the problem behavior. (2) If STUDENT made a choice, instruction would continue, if not, STUDENT should self-initiate “take a break” procedure. (3) If behavior escalated, staff was to prompt “take a break.” Mr. Petro gave detailed instructions regarding the “take a break” procedure.

Mr. Petro also recommended a program for providing STUDENT with “replacement behaviors.” Mr. Petro recommended to that STUDENT participate in a social skills instructional program to teach him how to respond to teaching and how to consistently occasion desirable attention from peers. Mr. Petro recommended interventions aimed at enabling STUDENT to maintain desired behavior, including giving more staff attention (rewards) for “right” behaviors than for “wrong” ones.

With regard to the specific behavioral strategies and their use with STUDENT, Mr. Petro testified that he did not expect the school staff to rely solely on his written report, rather in-service training would be needed as part of the behavioral plan. That training would include providing more details on how to implement the interventions in a flexible manner in light of STUDENT’s unique needs.

Although Chris Vinceneux did not disagree that recommendations made by Mr. Petro were generally appropriate for STUDENT, Mr. Vinceneux testified that the BIP also needed to include strategies to reduce distracting environmental factors and raise STUDENT’s tolerance to stimulation. Mr. Vinceneux also indicated that STUDENT needed a program that included providing choices in activities and systematic use of reinforcement such as stickers for appropriate performance and behavior. Mr. Vinceneux testified that, because the sensory deficits were part of the basis for STUDENT’s behavior problems, it was important that the behavior analyst developing and implementing the BIP consult with the occupational therapists providing STUDENT’s care. Sarah Frampton, PhD, agreed that STUDENT needed a behavioral intervention plan that included input from the occupational therapists. According to Dr. Frampton, STUDENT’s behavior modification program needed to be based on the recognition that his behaviors were not willful but were neurologically driven. In addition, behavior intervention strategies needed to take into account STUDENT’s sensory needs by instituting a system that included sensory activities as rewards.

Mr. Vinceneux was the only witness with expertise in sensory integration who provided substantial testimony regarding the need to include a consideration of STUDENT’s sensory needs in developing behavioral intervention strategies. The Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Vinceneux’ testimony was convincing regarding the need to include consideration of environmental factors and consultation with STUDENT’s occupational therapist in determining and implementing appropriate behavioral interventions for STUDENT.

Based on the foregoing, STUDENT needed one-on-one instruction utilizing a multi-disciplinary approach in a small environment (6-8 student classroom) to benefit from his education for the period September 1999 through September 2000. STUDENT needed direct and consultative occupational therapy services provided by a registered OTR with experience and background in treatment of autistic students with sensory integration deficits. STUDENT also needed a sensory diet utilizing appropriate sensory integration equipment and techniques incorporated into the daily instruction through consultation and training of the classroom staff by the OTR. The assigned OTRs also needed to provide ongoing monitoring and consultation with the classroom staff in order to adjust to ongoing changes in STUDENT’s sensory needs and related behaviors. Finally, STUDENT required a behavioral intervention plan which included strategies consistent with his sensory integration deficits and which was designed to reduce the level and frequency of STUDENT’s problem behaviors. The BIP needed to provide strategies to teach STUDENT to remove himself from the classroom with minimal disruption, and also provide appropriate replacement behaviors.Design of the District’s Proposed Program to Meet STUDENT’s Needs

The District contends that it provided occupational therapy services and a behavioral intervention plan appropriately designed to meet STUDENT needs. While the District concedes that STUDENT’s behavior problems did not substantially improve until December 1999 at the earliest, the District contends that such delay in improvement was primarily the result of STUDENT’s placement in an overstimulating classroom environment at Garden Road.

Besty Slavik testified that the sensory diet that she and Ms. Brislin developed in conjunction with the Garden Road special day class teachers through October 1999 included the use of a schedule system for accessing structured sensory input, for example, physical activities such as wall push-ups, lying on the floor, squeezing a ball, using the swings, and running laps around the track, as well as classroom chores incorporating proprioceptive input such as stacking chairs and moving books. The program was also designed to allow opportunities for movement at intervals of at least every fifteen minutes, either by allowing STUDENT to get up from the desk or having him engage in seated movement.

Teri Brislin provided STUDENT’s OT services for the period August 1998 through October 1999. Ms. Brislin testified that because of STUDENT’s particular difficulty with transitions between activities, the sensory diet incorporated very structured transitions, involving reminders of each activity’s conclusion, verbal scripting (orally reviewing the steps before transition to a new activity), as well as strategies to close each activity appropriately. Because the classroom environment often became too overwhelming for STUDENT, the staff at Garden Road utilized a quiet space within the classroom itself as well as the option of a separate quiet room for calming solitary activity. Additionally, the staff applied the “Willbarger Protocol,” a therapeutic system of brushing and joint compression on a specific schedule, approximately every one and one-half hours to two hours throughout the day, and had STUDENT wear a weighted vest throughout the school day for additional proprioceptive input (though the weighted vest use was discontinued at some point in the 1998-1999 school year because of STUDENT’s refusal to wear it). (Pet. Exh. 3)

Ms. Slavik, Teri Brislin, and special day class teacher Tracy Bosanac testified that to implement the occupational therapy services and address necessary modifications in the sensory program, the occupational therapists had ongoing discussions and consultations, both formal and informal, with the class teacher. (Dist. Exh. 10, R. Exh. 29) According to Ms. Brislin and Ms. Bosanac, the precise elements of the sensory diet to be used at any given time with STUDENT were flexible depending on his needs, and it was the practice of the occupational therapist and the classroom teacher to make adjustments as necessary. Betsy Slavik admitted that she did not personally go back into the class to determine whether the program was being implemented in accordance with her recommendations, but explained that it was not her role to be a service provider, but rather to serve as an additional consultant.

Chris Vinceneux, OTR, offered a number of criticisms of the District’s program. As part of his September 15, 1999 assessment, Mr. Vinceneux visited STUDENT’s Garden Road classroom and had significant concerns regarding the manner in which the staff were implementing STUDENT’s program. Specifically, Mr. Vinceneux noted that the aide was not giving STUDENT adequate opportunities for movement, was presenting too much of the material verbally, was not giving adequate choices, was not prompting STUDENT appropriately, and was relying too much on “hand over hand” tactile prompting. Mr. Vinceneux also observed that the staff were not performing the Willbarger protocol appropriately, holding the brush in the wrong direction and not performing the joint compression component. Mr. Vinceneux suggested that these problems were the result of an inadequate level of consultation between the District OTRs and the classroom staff. Mr. Vinceneux admitted, however, that he did not interview the occupational therapist for the district or the classroom staff in detail to specifically determine the amount of informal consultation that was taking place, or the amount of training or skills the staff possessed in implementing STUDENT’s program. Teri Brislin and Tracy Bosanac testified that, contrary to Mr. Vinceneux’ impression, Ms. Brislin engaged in ongoing consultation and monitoring in the Garden Road classroom.

Dr. Sara Frampton testified consistently with Chris Vinceneux that when she observed STUDENT’s classroom on September 7 and 8, 2000, the intervention strategies used by the staff at Garden Road were inappropriate for STUDENT. Dr. Frampton testified that the lesson she observed was not structured enough for STUDENT. She also noted that the aides in the class used a system of tickets for reinforcing STUDENT’s appropriate behaviors that actually caused him to become more distracted. Further, Dr. Frampton felt that the Willbarger protocol the aide was providing to STUDENT was not appropriate because it was being given in intervals that were too long, the brush being used was too small and wasn’t held in the correct direction, and no joint compression was applied. Dr. Frampton further testified that in presenting the lesson, the aides were overly animated, asking open-ended questions, “bombarding” STUDENT with verbal information, and raising their voices at STUDENT when his behavior began to escalate. Dr. Frampton believed that the classroom staff’s actions were inconsistent with STUDENT’s sensory integration problems and demonstrated insufficient training in dealing with STUDENT’s sensory needs.

Chris Vinceneux also testified that occupational services were being delivered in the wrong setting and manner at Garden Road in September 1999. As the purpose of OT is to support the child in the classroom, Mr. Vinceneux believed that the pullout method of delivering the services did not address STUDENT’s unique needs. The District, however, presented substantial evidence based on the testimony of virtually all the witnesses, but particularly Tracy Bosanac and Teri Brislin, that the classroom environment at Garden Road was overstimulating STUDENT and interfering with his ability to benefit from educational services. Under such circumstances, it was reasonable that the direct OT services were provided in a quieter, one-on-one setting. Indeed, when Mr. Vinceneux initially began providing OT direct services at Moyers, he did so on a one-on-one basis in his office.

Based on the foregoing, it is determined that occupational therapy services offered by the District for the 1999-2000 school year were designed to meet STUDENT’s behavioral needs, notwithstanding the District’s failure to obtain a formal assessment that incorporated a detailed observation by the occupational therapist of STUDENT’s classroom conduct. By June 1999, the IEP team had a clear understanding of the nature and severity of STUDENT’s conduct based on input of PARENT, Tracy Bosanac, STUDENT’s class teacher, and Teri Brislin, STUDENT’s occupational therapist. The team recognized the sensory basis for STUDENT’s behavioral issues. The District offered to place STUDENT in an alternative nonpublic educational placement based on a clear indication that STUDENT was being overstimulated by the Garden Road environment. The District offered occupational therapy services by registered OTRs who had training and experience in autism and sensory integration. (Dist. Exhs. 31, 44, 45) The District’s proposed program also provided for consultation with and training of the classroom staff by the District occupational therapists. The testimony of Ms. Brislin and Ms. Bosanac regarding training, consultation, and monitoring by the OTR at Garden Road was credible in light of the fact that Ms. Brislin and Ms. Bosanac were the individuals most knowledgeable regarding the degree of OT consultation at Garden Road. Furthermore, there was no evidence offered at hearing to suggest that the District would fail to provide the requisite monitoring and training once STUDENT moved to the Moyers Center in November 1999.

Petitioner also contends that the BIP developed on behalf of the District was not adequately designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, because the BIP was developed without appropriate OTR input and consideration of sensory needs and because there was inadequate training of and consultation with the staff at Moyers Center.

Mr. Vinceneux testified that in conducting the FAA and developing the BIP, Mr. Petro failed to seek input from the occupational therapists involved in STUDENT’s education. It was uncontroverted at hearing that major underlying factors in STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties were sensory integration and sensory modulation deficits in connection with STUDENT’s autism spectrum disorder. Mr. Petro acknowledged on cross-examination that having an understanding of the underlying neurological basis for the student’s behavior was important in developing a BIP. However, nowhere in Mr. Petro’s report and recommendations did he reference STUDENT’s autism spectrum disorder or address how his proposed interventions would be coordinated with the OT sensory processing treatment strategies. It is noted that although it was uncontroverted that Mr. Petro had the requisite experience and background to develop a BIP, there was no evidence that Mr. Petro had any substantial background in sensory integration or autism that may have qualified him to develop a comprehensive plan in the absence of close consultation with a qualified occupational therapist well-versed in STUDENT’s sensory integration and modulation needs.

Because Mr. Petro neither had the expertise in STUDENT’s unique sensory needs, nor incorporated in his analysis and plan detailed input from the occupational therapists, it is not surprising that, as Mr. Vinceneux credibly testified, Mr. Petro failed to include in his plan a discussion of several sensory-related antecedents to STUDENT’s problem behaviors, including noisy environment, visual clutter, changes in routine, changes in space, and nature of the task. Failure to identify antecedents to problem behavior is inconsistent with special education regulations pertaining to the development of a BIP. (Title 5, California Code of Regulations §3052).

Furthermore, Mr. Petro testified that he did not expect the school staff to rely solely on his written report; rather, he contemplated that in-service training and consultation would be an integral part of the behavioral plan. The evidence established that STUDENT’s placement was changed to the Moyers Center in early November 1999. Mr. Petro testified that although he went to Moyers early in the placement to instruct the staff generally about the BIP, he did not provide a detailed “line-by-line” consultation to the staff specifically relating to STUDENT’s difficulties at Moyers until late January or early February 2000. Thus, the consultative and training aspects of Mr. Petro’s plan did not in fact address STUDENT’s individual needs until several months after STUDENT was transferred to Moyers Center.

Based on the forgoing it is concluded that BIP developed by Mr. Petro for the District was not adequately tailored to STUDENT’s unique needs at any time prior to February 2000.

Nevertheless, both Mr. Vinceneux and Mr. Petro agreed that in approximately early February 2000, Mr. Petro provided an in-service training to the Moyers staff, and Mr. Vinceneux and Mr. Petro began collaborating regarding strategies for intervening in STUDENT’s behavior problems. Mr. Petro testified that his consultations to the Moyers Staff included recommendations regarding increasing consistency in applying the interventions, including “tightening up” the “take a break” procedure and reinforcement schedules for STUDENT. Although at hearing Mr. Petro and Vinceneux each tended to downplay the significance of the other’s contribution in designing STUDENT’s behavioral program, the evidence supports a conclusion that it was their collaborative effort, in combination with the more appropriate environment provided in the one-on-one educational setting at Moyers Center, that led to the improvements in STUDENT’s behavior. This conclusion is supported by the February 28, 2000 letter of Donald Tyssee, Moyers’ Center special education consultant, in which he made note of STUDENT’s progress in the new one-on-one format with a behavioral intervention plan in place and specifically referenced the input from Dan Petro. (Dist. Exh. 34). Because Mr. Petro provided the necessary consultation and training designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and engaged in consultation with the OTR (Mr. Vinceneux) in February 2000, it is concluded that the deficiencies in the District’s behavioral program were corrected by February 28, 2000, the date of Mr. Tyssee’s letter.

Reasonably Calculated to Benefit the Student

The evidence established that the occupational therapy services offered by the District for the period September 1999 through September 2000 school were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with education benefit. The District offered occupational therapy services by qualified providers designed to meet STUDENT’s unique sensory needs. The program offered by the District included appropriate training, monitoring and consultation, designed to provide the classroom staff with techniques to address STUDENT’s sensory deficits and thereby improve his behavior. The testimony of both the District’s and Petitioner’s witnesses established that such an occupational therapy program could be expected to improve STUDENT’s behavior problems by addressing his underlying sensory deficits.

The testimony of Chris Vinceneux and Dr. Frampton strongly suggests that in September 1999, the Garden Road teacher and aides were not yet implementing STUDENT’s sensory program effectively. In addition, as previously discussed with regard to assessment, the evidence established that STUDENT’s behavioral problems did not improve during his placement at Garden Road through October 1999. However, the evidence offered at hearing established that the teacher and the aides in September 1999 had only begun instructing STUDENT and implementing the strategies being taught by the District OTR for a few days at the time of observations by Mr. Vinceneux and Dr. Frampton. Furthermore, the evidence also established that the placement at Garden Road was overly stimulating, and thus interfering with his ability to benefit from his instruction. In addition, as discussed above, the District did not develop an appropriate behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT at Garden Road. With appropriate changes in those elements of STUDENT’s program it is reasonable to conclude that the occupational therapy services offered by the District would have provided STUDENT with benefit regarding his sensory needs and thus contributed to an improvement in his behavior.

The IDEA does not require that the District guarantee the success of the proposed educational program, but rather requires that the program provide a "basic floor of opportunity" that includes access to specialized instruction and related services which are “reasonably calculated” to provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S.175 at 207-209. In the instant matter, the evidence established the OT services offered by the District were reasonably calculated to provide an educational benefit to STUDENT. The evidence did not establish that STUDENT’s failure to progress at Garden Road and any inadequacies in the Garden Road staff’s implementation of the program in September 1999 were a result of an inappropriately designed occupational therapy program by the District.

However, as noted previously, the BIP itself did not reflect adequate consideration and integration of STUDENT’s sensory needs and did not sufficiently identify sensory-related behavior antecedents. Because the BIP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it also was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Indeed, STUDENT’s failure to progress with regard to behavior in the early part of his placement at Moyers Center led to his near removal from the school.

Comported With the IEP

There was no evidence offered that the occupational therapy program offered by the District for the period September 1999 to September 2000 failed to comport with the IEP.

However, the evidence established that the BIP by Dan Petro did not comport with the IEPs of June 25, 1999 and October 25, 1999. Mr. Petro testified that the BIP was intended to include a training component. Mr. Petro’s also testified that he did not go into Moyers Center to provide detailed training unique to STUDENT’s needs until late January 2000 at the earliest. It is concluded that the delay in this important component of the BIP, along with Mr. Petro’s failure initially to work closely with the occupational therapist in implementing the BIP in light of STUDENT’s sensory needs, substantially contributed to STUDENT’s near removal from Moyers because of his lack of progress in behavior. It is therefore concluded that the BIP did not comport with STUDENT’s IEPs.

Because the District’s program failed to adequately address STUDENT’s behavior, it was not designed to meet his needs or reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Moreover it was not implemented by Mr. Petro in a manner consistent with STUDENT’s IEP. Therefore, it is concluded that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the period September 1999, through February 28, 2000.

Issue No. III: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent evaluation by Chris Vinceneux, registered occupational therapist (OTR)?

Petitioner contends that he should be reimbursed for the September 15, 1999 assessment of Chris Vinceneux since the District failed to provide appropriate assessment of STUDENT’s sensory deficits.

The California Education Code provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. However, if the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. (California Education Code §56329(b))

The evidence established that Mr. Vinceneux, a certified OTR with training and experience in addressing sensory integration and modulation problems in autistic students, was qualified to assess STUDENT. (Pet. Exh. 23). As the District’s assessment of STUDENT’s sensory deficits was not appropriate, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the assessment of Mr. Vinceneux dated September 15, 1999.

ISSUE NO. IV: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the services provided by Chris Vinceneux, OTR?

As it has been determined that the District provided a FAPE with regard to OT services, it must be determined whether the inadequacies of the BIP justify reimbursement for the services of Mr. Vinceneux obtained by STUDENT’s mother. Petitioner contends that, because Dan Petro’s BIP was inadequate, PARENT should be reimbursed for privately obtained services from Chris Vinceneux, because those services were calculated to improve STUDENT’s behavior in the absence of an adequate program by the District.

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is "appropriate" in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. §1415(i). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. However, the Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The Alamo court stated that “the rationale behind Burlington's holding is that parents who elect to risk shouldering the costs of what they perceive to be a more appropriate placement, and whose judgment is wholly or in part vindicated by the district court, should receive more than an "empty victory." As stated by the Court, if "appropriate relief" in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed," the child's right to a free appropriate public education, the parent's right to participate fully in developing a proper IEP, and all of the procedural safeguards would be less than complete." Id.

In the instant case, PARENT testified that she initially engaged the services of Chris Vinceneux because after reading his assessment report she felt that she had “finally found someone who knows STUDENT.” Based on her history of negative experiences with STUDENT’s teacher, Tracy Bosanac, and Teri Brislin, OTR, who she believed did not appear open to her suggestions regarding assisting STUDENT, PARENT requested that the District contract with Mr. Vinceneux to provide STUDENT’s OT services. The District refused to do so, indicating that it had qualified OTRs under contract to provide the appropriate services. Upon STUDENT’s transfer to Moyers Center, PARENT rejected the OTR services offered by the District and hired Mr. Vinceneux as the provider.

As has been previously discussed, the evidence established that from the time Mr. Vinceneux began providing services to STUDENT at the Moyers Center, until Mr. Petro conducted his intensive BIP training and began consulting with Mr. Vinceneux at Moyers, STUDENT was not receiving services from the District designed to meet his behavioral needs.

According to the testimony of one of STUDENT’s instructors at Moyers, Ann Weime, at the time that STUDENT was transferred to Moyers, the classroom staff were informally advised through STUDENT’s case manager, Jennifer Trinkle, of the BIP strategies proposed by Mr. Petro. The staff attempted to use the strategies but they were not effective in reducing STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors. There came a point at which the director of Moyers was considering asking that STUDENT be removed from the Center because the behaviors were out of control and staff did not have effective strategies to reduce the behaviors. In light of the fact that Moyers did not allow physical restraint, it became doubtful that STUDENT could remain at Moyers.

Chris Vinceneux, OTR, testified that shortly after he began providing OTR services to STUDENT, he received an urgent contact from the Moyers staff regarding STUDENT’s severe behavioral problems, Mr. Vinceneux sought from STUDENT’s mother more authority to be involved in STUDENT’s program. PARENT testified that she agreed because Mr. Vinceneux had developed a positive rapport with STUDENT and seemed to have a good understanding of his needs. Ms. Weime confirmed that Mr. Vinceneux’ involvement in STUDENT’s program then increased substantially. Ms. Weime testified that Mr. Vinceneux began attending weekly team meetings at Moyers and conducting weekly observations of STUDENT in the classroom, as well as providing ongoing consultation with the Moyers staff and suggestions regarding what intervention strategies would help with behavior. Mr. Vinceneux conducted an in-service training for Moyers staff in November and also made himself available by telephone for consultation. He explained the benefits of “quiet time,” and otherwise advised on ways to avoid over-arousing STUDENT. He helped the staff identify signs of escalation, modeling techniques for teaching STUDENT, and demonstrated physical relaxation and message techniques, such as the Willbarger protocol and “jungle walk” (physical pressure on STUDENT’s back). Other strategies taught by Mr. Vinceneux included incorporating humor, using timers to signal the end of activities, and “affirming a willingness to go to where STUDENT was at.” Mr. Vinceneux also recommended the use of visual cues and physical input. Mr. Vinceneux advised the staff on the use of routines, scheduling, rewards, engaging STUDENT’s special interests, and providing snacks and water breaks. A major recommendation Mr. Vinceneux made was to change STUDENT’s classroom environment from the downstairs area where he was in a group setting to a room upstairs where STUDENT received one-on-one instruction in a less distracting environment. Ms. Weime testified that shortly following Mr. Vinceneux’ increased involvement, STUDENT’s behavior escalations decreased from three times per week to one time per week, and there was continued improvement through the end of STUDENT’s placement at Moyers.

Ms. Weime stated that virtually all the recommendations she received regarding how to address STUDENT’s behavior and instruct him in a manner to reduce escalations came from Chris Vinceneux. She recalled receiving no input, either directly or indirectly, from Dan Petro, aside from the informal information she received regarding the BIP from the case manager.

Based on Mr. Vinceneux’ testimony and report, it is concluded that he had an excellent understanding of STUDENT’s sensory needs. Because of his ongoing observations of STUDENT at the Moyers placement, Mr. Vinceneux was also well-informed regarding the STUDENT’s behavior problems as they arose in the Moyers placement. The efforts Mr. Vinceneux made in assisting the Moyers staff in addressing STUDENT’s behavior demonstrate that such services were calculated to benefit STUDENT. Mr. Vinceneux employed sensory techniques in conjunction with behavioral strategies, some of which were similar to those in the Petro BIP, to effect an improvement in STUDENT’s behaviors. Based on the evidence presented, it is found that Mr. Vinceneax’ services at Moyers Center contributed to a substantial decrease in STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors. Such behaviors, according to the testimony of Ms. Weime and Mr. Vinceneux, began to turn around in December and based on all evidence presented at hearing on this issue, were substantially improved by February 2000.

Although it is arguable that a qualified District OTR could have provided services to STUDENT at Moyers that were consistent with STUDENT’s IEPs, shortly after the Moyers placement began, Mr. Vinceneux increased his level of involvement in STUDENT’s program. In addition, the evidence established that by the time he was called upon to increase his services to STUDENT at Moyers, Mr. Vinceneux had established a special rapport with STUDENT. It is reasonable to conclude that Mr. Vinceneux’ ability to assist the Moyers’ staff in bringing STUDENT’s behavior into an acceptable range between December 1999 and February 2000 was in part a result of his existing therapy relationship with STUDENT. It is further reasonable to conclude that even after Mr. Petro began actively consulting and collaborating regarding STUDENT’s behavioral program at Moyers, it was appropriate for Mr. Vinceneax to remain involved in providing services at least until STUDENT’s behavior was brought into an acceptable range. The evidence also established that by February 28, 2000, the efforts of Mr. Vinceneux, Mr. Petro, and the Moyers’ staff were successful in getting the most severe and disruptive of STUDENT’s behaviors under control.

Under Burlington and Alamo, the Hearing Officer has the discretion to award relief to the Petitioner, even though the services of Mr. Vinceneux, an OTR, are not precisely the type of educational services that would have been provided had the District not failed in its obligation to provide an appropriate BIP. In light of the fact that from October 25, 2000, until at least early February 2000, the only behavioral intervention specifically tailored to STUDENT’s unique needs at Moyers was being provided by Chris Vinceneux, it is found that reimbursing STUDENT’s parent for the services of Chris Vinceneux for the period October 25, 1999 through February 28, 2000, is an appropriate remedy in this matter.

ORDER

1. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall pay the sum of $600 to Petitioner’s mother, PARENT, as reimbursement for the September 15, 1999 independent assessment of Chris Vinceneux, OTR.

2. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this decision, Petitioner shall present a signed invoice from Chris Vinceneux to the District reflecting the specific dates, nature of services, and cost of services on behalf of STUDENT for the period October 25, 1999, through February 28, 2000.

3. Within fifteen calendar days of the receipt of proof set forth in Order No. 2, the District shall tender payment to Petitioner’s mother, PARENT, in the sum documented for services rendered by Christopher Vinceneux for the period October 25, 1999 through February 28, 2000.

PREVAILING PARTY OF EACH ISSUE

I. Did the Poway Unified School District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?

-Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

II. Did the Poway Unified School District provide STUDENT a free appropriate education (FAPE) for the period September, 1999 through the end of September, 2000? -Petitioner partially prevailed on this issue as FAPE was denied for six of the thirteen months during the period at issue.

III. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the assessment of Chris Vinceneax dated September 15, 2000.

-Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

IV. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the services of Chris Vinceneax for the period November, 1999 through the end of September, 2000.

-Petitioner partially prevailed on this issue to the extent that reimbursement is due for four months of the eleven months at issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt o this decision. California Education Code §56505(j).

Dated: December 18, 2000

_________________________________ Paul R. Gant, Hearing Officer California Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: The issues stated here differ in wording from those originally noticed by Petitioner. Changes reflect discussions held at the time of hearing.

Footnote 2: At hearing the parties agreed that the Hearing Officer should address the appropriateness of the District’s program and associated reimbursement issues through the end of STUDENT’s attendance at Moyers Center. Although there was evidence presented that the STUDENT transferred from Moyers to his subsequent placement at Banyan Tree Learning Center in October 2000, no specific date for the transfer was provided by the parties and specific charges for privately obtained educational services were only provided through the end of September 2000. Accordingly, this decision will only address issues arising through the end of September 2000.

Footnote 3: Petitioner did not contend nor present evidence at hearing that STUDENT would have benefitted from an educational environment that was less restrictive than that offered by the District. Accordingly, this decision will not address the least restrictive environment component of the Rowley test.

Footnote 4: Petitioner also argued in his closing brief that he was denied FAPE on two additional bases: (1) the July 30, 1998 IEP was insufficiently specific regarding the amount of weekly OT services to be provided during the 1998-1999 school year and (2) the District failed to deliver the OT services in the 1998-1999 school year in accordance with the IEP. These contentions are not relevant to the time period at issue in this matter, specifically the period September 1999 to September 2000. Accordingly, they are not addressed in this decision.

Footnote 5: Chris Vinceneux also testified that STUDENT’s sensory modulation problems sometimes cause difficulties with under arousal which contribute to self-stimulatory behavior. Betsy Slavik agreed that STUDENT displays self-stimulatory behavior but did not attribute it to under arousal. As this difference of opinion did not lead to any disagreement between Ms. Slavik and Mr. Vinceneux regarding the nature of the components needed to be included in STUDENT’s educational program, it is unnecessary to resolve this conflict in the OTRs’ testimony.