California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 2, 1996

Student v. Colton Joint Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 44-96 · Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel

Colton Joint Unified's Corrective Reading tutoring upheld, but the IEP must add multisensory language arts instruction, a computer and a spellchecker.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 4 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision refers to an earlier case (SN 872-95, also cited as SN 875-95) that was settled through mediation agreements in November and December 1995 and withdrawn.

Summary

A parent filed this case for her 13-year-old eighth grader at Colton Middle School. He is eligible for special education with a specific learning disability (dyslexia). In a December 1995 mediation, the District agreed to provide one hour of multisensory reading tutoring every day after school. It chose the Corrective Reading program, taught by resource specialist Dennis Soto. The parent argued that the program did not suit a student with dyslexia and that Mr. Soto was not qualified. She asked for tutoring at the private Southern California Reading Clinic, which uses the Slingerland method.

Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel found Corrective Reading appropriate. District witnesses and the student's former private tutor supported it, and his reading improved within weeks. A district may choose its teaching method even when a parent prefers another one. Mr. Soto's emergency credential and training were enough. Under the parties' stipulation, the student gets 10 makeup tutoring sessions because the tutoring started late.

The parent won on the resource specialist program. Within 15 days, the District had to amend the IEP to require multisensory language arts instruction and to add grade levels to the criteria for objectives. The IEP also had to give him access to a computer and an electronic spellchecker. A request for Touch Math was denied. The Hearing Officer denied $650 for private tutoring because the earlier settlement covered costs through December 1995. He also denied $90 for an evaluator's letter because the letter was not an assessment.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO used Rowley. A district's chosen reading method stood even though the parent preferred another. Still, the student's fast progress with private multisensory tutoring was used to require multisensory classroom instruction. It also shows that a mediated settlement can bar later reimbursement claims for costs incurred before the settlement.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Is the District's Corrective Reading tutoring program appropriate for STUDENT? If not, must the District provide for tutoring by the private Southern California Reading Clinic, which uses the Slingerland method?

    The Corrective Reading program was a multisensory method reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and the tutor was qualified. The District's choice of method stands even though the parent preferred Slingerland. By stipulation, the student receives 10 compensatory sessions for the District's late start.

  2. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2. Are the resource specialist services currently being provided to STUDENT in language arts and math pursuant to his IEP appropriate? If not, what changes must be made to STUDENT's Individualized Education Plan?

    The IEP must require multisensory instruction in resource specialist language arts and grade-level performance criteria in objectives, and must provide access to a computer and an electronic spellchecker. The request for Touch Math in math was denied.

  3. Issue 3a. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for private tutoring by Debbie Bunger?

    The tutoring was appropriate, and the District denied FAPE in fall 1995. However, the binding December 1995 mediation settlement capped the District's costs through that date at $1,300, so the $650 claim was denied.

  4. Issue 3b. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for Regina Richards' written evaluation of the District's Corrective Reading program?

    The parent identified no District assessment she disagreed with. The $90 letter was not an assessment, and its author said she could not evaluate the program, so reimbursement was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Compensatory education. Based on the parties' stipulation, ten (10) compensatory one-hour tutoring sessions by the end of the 1995-96 academic year. These may be provided through the District's Corrective Reading program.
  • Order to provide or change services. Within 15 days of the decision, amend the IEP so that: (a) criteria for success on language arts objectives include a performance grade level; (b) resource specialist instruction in language arts uses multisensory teaching techniques; (c) the student has access to a computer for written assignments; (d) the student has access to an electronic spellchecking device.

Total: 10 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Union School Dist. v. Smith; D.R. v. East Brunswick Board of Education; Education Code §56329; Education Code §56345; Education Code §56337.5

People named in the decision

  • Debbie Bunger, private tutor (special education teacher, Rialto Unified School District); witness for Student, Rialto Unified School District
  • Regina Richards, private educational therapist; independent assessor, Private
  • Gail Lindberg, District representative, program manager, East Valley SELPA
  • Bonnie Russell-Hunt, director of pupil personnel services, District
  • Rosemary Bratkowski, coordinator of special education; witness for District, District
  • Sue Barker, SELPA program specialist/reading specialist; drafted tutoring plan, East Valley SELPA
  • Dennis Soto, resource specialist and Corrective Reading tutor, District
  • Al Ong, school psychologist, District
  • Joni Schumacher, speech therapist, District
  • Mr. Skinner, former resource specialist teacher, District
  • Southern California Reading Clinic, private reading clinic (Slingerland method) requested by parent, Private

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing office, McGeorge School of Law, in Colton, California, on February 27, 1996.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by his mother, PARENT, and his aunt, AUNT. Respondent was represented by Gail Lindberg, program manager, East Valley SELPA. Also present on the behalf of the District were Bonnie Russell-Hunt, director of pupil personnel services, and Rosemary Bratkowski, coordinator of special education.

The following witnesses testified on behalf of Petitioner:

STUDENT; AUNT; and Debbie Bunger, special education teacher, Rialto Unified School District. The following witnesses testified on behalf of Respondent: Ms. Bratkowski; Sue Barker, SELPA program specialist; Dennis Soto, resources specialist; Al Ong, school psychologist; and Joni Schumacher, speech therapist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the parties' request, the record was left open until March 15, 1996, for the receipt of closing briefs. At that time the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Is the District's Corrective Reading tutoring program appropriate for STUDENT? If not, must the District provide for tutoring by the private Southern California Reading Clinic, which uses the Slingerland method?

2. Are the resource specialist services currently being provided to STUDENT in language arts and math pursuant to his IEP appropriate? If not, what changes must be made to STUDENT' Individualized Education Plan?

3. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for (a) private tutoring by Debbie Bunger and (b) Regina Richards' written evaluation of the District's Corrective Reading program?

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE

1. Chronological Summary

STUDENT (also known as "STUDENT") is thirteen years old and attends eighth grade at Colton Middle School in the District. STUDENT is eligible for special education by reason of a specific learning disability. He has been diagnosed with dyslexia, a type of reading disability. (P 1, 15) (Footnote 1) He attends regular education classes in all subjects except language arts and math. In those two subjects he, along with a small group of special education students, receives instruction from a resource specialist.(Footnote 2)

STUDENT has been served by special education programs in the District for several years. He has consistently scored well below grade level on standardized achievement testing. For example, testing in January 1993, when STUDENT was in the fifth grade, revealed that he was functioning at approximately a second grade level in reading and third grade level in math. (R 23) (Footnote 3)

In May 1995, when STUDENT was nearing completion of seventh grade, his mother, PARENT, obtained an independent assessment from Regina Richards, a private educational therapist. (P 1) Ms. Richards, found that STUDENT was still reading at approximately a mid-second grade level and that he was now performing in math at approximately a fourth grade level. (P 1) (Footnote 4) Ms. Richards recommended that STUDENT receive remedial assistance in (1) reading, using multisensory techniques and emphasizing phonics; and (2) math, using manipulatives. She also recommended that STUDENT use a computer and an electronic "spellchecking" device for writing.

In June 1995, STUDENT began to receive private tutoring from Debbie Bunger, a special education teacher in the Rialto Unified School District (RUSD), which borders the District. The tutoring was arranged for by STUDENT's aunt AUNT, an RUSD administrator, and paid for by the STUDENT's mother, PARENT. The tutoring took place twice weekly for one hour pr session, after school. In reading, Ms. Bunger used the Project Read teaching method, including such techniques as hand signals, breaking words into pieces, and phonic spelling. She encouraged STUDENT to use the computer to complete written work. In math, STUDENT worked on regrouping and multiplication tables. Ms Burger used "touch math," in which the student touches raised dots on paper. Both Ms. Burger and STUDENT were pleased with the tutoring. In the fall of 1995, STUDENT entered eighth grade. On September 5, PARENT filed a request for a due process hearing because of concerns about STUDENT's need for remedial help in reading. (P 16; Case No. SN 875-95) That fall, STUDENT attended resource specialist classes in language arts and math with Mr. Skinner. In language arts, students were instructed to read silently for significant periods of time.

On November 16, the parties reached an interim mediation agreement in Case No. SN 872-95. PARENT was represented by counsel at the mediation. The agreement provided that the District would (1) reimburse PARENT in the amount of $430.00, the cost of Ms. Richards' assessment, and (2) provide STUDENT with a new resource specialist, Dennis Soto. (P 27) Mr. Soto holds an ‘emergency" credential as a resource specialist. He is in his first year of working with special education students. He has no formal education or training in special education, but attended a one-day workshop on "full inclusion" presented by District personnel.

Also in November 1995, the District conducted its triennial assessment of STUDENT. (R 16) Testing results showed that STUDENT was now reading at a third or fourth grade level.(Footnote 5) The District's assessment team recommended use of (1) meaningful, age appropriate reading material (because STUDENT is a contextual reader); and (2) a computer and electronic spellchecking device for written work. (R 16)

At an IEP meeting on December 13, the parties reached a final mediation agreement in Case No. SN 872-95. Petitioner was again represented by counsel at the mediation. The District agreed to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one tutoring program for one hour every day after school through the end of the 1995-96 school year. The tutoring would use '‘ multisensory approach with emphasis on phonic skills.""(P 33-34). The District further agreed to provide PARENT with a written plan describing the tutoring program by January 9, 1996, and to implement the program by January 10. (P 33-34) Finally, the agreement stated:

District agrees to pay Petitioner in the amount of $1,300.00 to cover costs of attorney's fee and related educational costs . . . [E]xcept as noted [above], each party agrees to bear their own costs to date for attorney's fees and other costs related to this matter. (P 33-34)

In return for these undertakings by the District, Petitioner agreed to withdraw his request in Case No. SN 872-95. (P 33-34) Once this agreement was reached, the privately arranged tutoring relationship between Ms. Burger and STUDENT ended.

In early January 1996, Sue Barker, SELPA reading specialist, drafted a written plan for STUDENT's after-school tutoring. (R 33) The plan used the Corrective Reading approach. (R 33, P 46) Mr. Soto, STUDENT's resource specialist, agreed to perform the tutoring. (R 33) In mid-January 1996, Ms. Barker gave Mr. Soto a two-hour training in Corrective Reading, and Mr. Soto gave STUDENT a placement test to determine in which section of the Corrective Reading manuals they should begin.

On January 16, the Hearing Office received a new request from PARENT for a due process hearing. The request was assigned Case No. SN 44-96 – the present case. In her request, PARENT indicated that she believed the District had not honored the mediation agreement in Case No. SN 872-95. More specifically, she asserted that (1) Corrective Reading has not been proven effective with dyslexic students, and (2) Mr. Soto is not qualified to tutor STUDENT. She indicated that she was seeking an order that the District provide for tutoring through the private Southern California Reading Clinic, which employs the Slingerland method. (P 35-36)

Tutoring began on January 30. (The parties stipulated at the hearing that STUDENT is entitled to 10 compensatory tutoring sessions because of the District's delay in beginning the sessions.) In early February, PARENT asked Ms. Richards, who had performed the independent assessment of STUDENT in May 1995, to evaluate the appropriateness of Corrective Reading. On February 12, Ms. Richards sent PARENT a letter stating that she did not have sufficient familiarity with Corrective Reading to express an opinion as to its appropriateness for STUDENT. (P 56) (Footnote 6)

At the hearing in February 1996, Petitioner expresses concerns not only about the Corrective Reading tutoring program but also as to STUDENT's resource specialist classes in language arts and math. Additionally, PARENT sought reimbursement for two separate out-of-pocket expenses: $650.00 paid to Ms. Burger for her tutoring of STUDENT, and $90.00 to Ms. Richards for her February 1996 letter regarding the Corrective Reading program.

2. The Corrective Reading Tutoring Program

Corrective reading is a multisensory, structured, sequential, remedial reading program for students with reading disabilities, including dyslexia. If focuses on word attack skills, decoding skills, and comprehension skills. It involves teacher-directed instruction, cumulative development of skills, and review of mastered skills. In each lesson, students learn a skill – such as sound blends – at the beginning, and then apply the skill in context by reading at the end. The lessons are "scripted" – that is, the teacher's guide tells the teacher what to say and what answer is expected from the student. (R 33, P 46)

The District chose Corrective Reading for STUDENT's tutoring program despite the fact that PARENT expressed a preference for either of two other remedial reading methods, Slingerland and /or Orton/Gillingham. District witnesses testified that the latter methods are perhaps better suited to younger children in that they teach skills in isolation such as through the use of word lists. Conversely, according to the District witnesses, Corrective Reading teaches skills in context and is therefore more appropriate foe STUDENT.

Each of the District's witnesses testified that they believe the Corrective Reading tutoring program drafted by Ms. Barker is appropriate for STUDENT. Ms. Bunger, who successfully tutored STUDENT using another multisensory approach, Project Read, testified that Corrective Reading is appropriate program "if used consistently."

By the time of the hearing in late February 1996, STUDENT had received Corrective Reading tutoring from Mr. Soto for several weeks. Mr. Soto testified that STUDENT (1) has been receptive to tutoring, (2) has increased his oral reading rate from 90 to 108 words per minute, (3) is scoring 95% in comprehension, and (4) is reading more difficult stories.

3. The Resource Specialist Program

During the 1995-96 school year STUDENT has attended regular education classes for all subjects except language arts and math. In those two subjects, he has received instruction from a resource specialist in a small group of special education students. Since November 1995 STUDENT's RSP teacher has been Mr. Soto.

In language art class, Mr. Soto has not specifically employed a multisensory approach such as Project Read or Corrective Reading. The students engage in oral reading using the regular education seventh grade language arts textbook, and writing in journals. STUDENT has not used the computer for writing, although he practiced his keyboarding skill on one occasion. He does, on occasion, use an electronic spellchecking device. Mr. Soto testified that STUDENT has made some progress in the textbook. He testified that STUDENT enjoys reading, has shown increased responsibility and improved task completion, and is a leader in class discussions.

In math, Mr. Soto has not specifically employed a multisensory approach such as Touch Math. STUDENT is currently working in a fraction booklet. Mr. Soto testified that STUDENT has made some progress in fractions. He has not yet mastered decimals.

DISCUSSION

1. Is the District's Corrective Reading tutoring program appropriate for STUDENT? If not, must the District provide for tutoring by the private Southern California Reading Clinic, which uses the Slingerland method?

The evidence showed that STUDENT made minimal progress in reading prior to May 1995. More specifically, while receiving special education services from the District between January 1993 (middle of fifth grade) and May 1995 (end of seventh grade) – a period of nearly two and one-half years – STUDENT's overall reading scores remained in the second grade range. (R 23, P 1)

In June 1995, STUDENT began to receive private tutoring from Ms. Burger using multisensory Project Read method. By November 1995, just five months later, the District's achievement testing of STUDENT showed that his reading scores were in the third and fourth grade range. (R 16) While these scores remained well below grade level for STUDENT, an eighth grader, they showed an encouraging, fairly dramatic, and previously unseen improvement in a short period of time. During this period STUDENT's resource specialist class in language arts did not employ multisensory teaching techniques. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT's reading improvement was attributable to Ms. Burger's tutoring. The evidence thus showed that, in order for a language arts program to be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, it must employ a multisensory approach. Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207 (1982).

In recognition of this fact, the District agreed in mediation in December 1995 to develop a remedial reading tutoring program employing multisensory techniques. After considering several remedial reading methods, the District chose Corrective Reading.

The District's witnesses testified that Corrective Reading is a proven, multisensory approach which teaches skills in an age-appropriate context. Ms. Burger, who successfully tutored STUDENT using multisensory Project Read approach, agreed that Corrective Reading is an appropriate program "if used consistently." Mr. Soto, who received training in Corrective Reading from Ms. Barker, the SELPA reading specialist, testified that within weeks of beginning the tutoring, STUDENT had increased his oral reading rate from 90 to 108 words per minute and was reading more difficult stories with 95% comprehension. Thus, the evidence showed that a remedial reading tutoring program based on the Corrective Reading approach is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.(Footnote 7)

As long as a school District's choice of teaching methodology is methodology is reasonably designed to provide a student with educational benefit, that choice shall not be disturbed. Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176, 207-208 (1982). This is so even if the parent prefers another method. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). Because it has been determined above that the District's Corrective Reading tutoring program is appropriate for STUDENT, the District is not required to provide for tutoring by the private Southern California Reading Clinic, which uses the Slingerland method.

Pursuant to the stipulation of the parties, the District must provide STUDENT with ten compensatory tutoring sessions by the completion of the 1995-96 school year because of the District's delay in starting the sessions. However, these sessions may be provided by the District's Corrective Reading tutoring program, and need not involve the Southern California Reading Clinic.

2. Are the resource specialist services currently being provided to STUDENT pursuant to his IEP appropriate? If not, must changes be made to STUDENT's Individualized Educational Plan?

The evidence showed that several revisions to STUDENT's IEP are required. First, it has been determined herein that in order for a language arts program to be reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit on STUDENT, it must employ multisensory teaching techniques. STUDENT is currently receiving after-school tutoring using the multisensory Corrective Reading method. However, the evidence showed that Mr. Soto's resource specialist class in language arts does not employ multisensory techniques. Therefore, STUDENT's IEP must be revised to provide that resource specialist instruction in language arts will use multisensory techniques.(Footnote 8)

Second, an IEP must contain appropriate objective criteria and evaluation procedures and schedules for determining, on at least an annual basis, whether instructional objectives are being achieved. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a) (20) (F); Education Code §56345(a) (6). The objectives in language arts and math in the December 1995 IEP do contain measurement criteria, but these criteria do not indicate a performance grade level. (R 1)

STUDENT is an eighth-grader who is performing several years below grade level. Between January 1993 and May 1995 he made very little progress in reading and remained in the second grade range. He is now reading at approximately a third or fourth grade level. To adequately determine if STUDENT is making reasonable progress in reading, it is critical for objectives to include a performance grade level. For example, rather than simply stating that STUDENT must master 35 of 40 vocabulary words, an objective might indicate that STUDENT must do so at a fifth grade level of difficulty.

Third, the evidence was undisputed at the hearing that STUDENT must have access to both (1) a computer for completing written classwork and (2) an electronic spellchecking device. There was evidence that STUDENT has had some access to a spellchecking device. On the other hand, the evidence showed that Mr. Soto has not incorporated use of the computer into STUDENT's language arts program. It does not appear, based on the documents submitted into evidence, that either device is presently provided for in STUDENT's IEP. These assistive technology devices are related services necessary to assist STUDENT to benefit from special education services. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a) (25); 34 C.F.R. 300.308; 20 U.S.C. §1401(a) (17). Therefore, they must be provided for in STUDENT's IEP.

3. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for (a) private tutoring by Ms. Bunger and/or (b) Regina Richards' written evaluation of the District's Corrective Reading tutoring program?

A free, appropriate education (FAPE) includes special education and related services that are individually designed to meet a student's unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. 20 U.S.C. §1400(c); §§1401(a) (16-18); Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 206-207. The evidence showed that by failing to provide multisensory language arts instruction to STUDENT during the fall of 1995, the District denied him FAPE. Under IDEA, decision makers can award "appropriate relief" for violations of fape. 20 U.S.C. §1415(e)(2). Such relief may include reimbursement for appropriate, privately obtained educational services. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, ___ U.S. ___ (1994).

a. Ms. Bunger's tutoring

There is no dispute that Ms.. Bunger's private tutoring of STUDENT was appropriate and greatly benefitted him. In considering whether reimbursement is appropriate, however, the Hearing Officer must take into account the fact that in Case No. SN 872-95, on December 13, 1995, the parties entered into a settlement agreement. Petitioner was represented by counsel at the mediation. In the agreement, the District agreed to reimburse Petitioner in the amount of $1,300.00 for ‘attorney's fees and related educational costs" to date. (P 33-34) (Footnote 9) The agreement further provided that "except as noted [above], each party agrees to bear their own costs to date for attorney's fees and other costs related to this matter." (P 33-34) Based on the agreement, Petitioner agreed to withdraw his request for due process hearing in Case No. 872-95.

All of Ms. Bunger's tutoring was performed prior to the date of the December 1995 agreement. The tutoring began in June 1995 and concluded at the time of the agreement, based on the District's agreement to develop a multisensory tutoring program for STUDENT. Settlements of special education disputes achieved at mediation are binding. D.R. v. East Brunswick Board of Education, 20 IDELR 957 (D.N.J. 1993). The issue of whether or not the District must reimburse Petitioner for Ms. Bunger's tutoring was necessary resolved by the language of the settlement agreement.

More specifically, the agreement limited the District's responsibility for reimbursement for attorney's fees and other educational costs related to the case through December 13, 1995, to $1,300.00. Therefore, the District is not responsible for reimbursement for additional expenses incurred prior to the date of the settlement agreement. Accordingly, the District is not required to reimburse Petitioner for additional $650.00 for tutoring performed by Ms. Bunger from June-December 1995.

b. Ms. Richards' February 1996 letter

PARENT testified that because Ms. Richards indicated she would not by available to testify at the hearing, she requested that Ms. Richards submit, for use at the hearing, a written opinion as to the appropriateness of the District's Corrective Reading program. In the letter, Ms. Richards concluded that she did not have sufficient familiarity with Corrective Reading in order to evaluate its appropriateness for STUDENT. (P 56-57)

Under some circumstances, parents may be entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments. This may occur when the parent disagrees with a District assessment and obtains an independent one, and it is determined at a due process hearing that the District's assessment was not appropriate. Education Code §56329. In this case, (1) PARENT has not identified a District assessment with which she disagrees, (2) Ms. Richards' February 1996, letter does not constitute and assessment, (3) in the letter, Ms. Richards concluded that she does not have sufficient familiarity with Corrective Reading to evaluate its appropriate. For the above reasons, the District is not required to reimburse PARENT for the $90.00 she paid to Ms. Richards for preparation of the February 1996 letter.

ORDER

1. Based on the stipulation of the parties, STUDENT shall receive ten (10) compensatory one-hour tutoring sessions by the completion of the 1995-96 academic year.

2. Within fifteen (15) days of the date of this Decision, STUDENT's IEP shall be amended to reflect the following:

a. The criteria for success on objectives in language arts shall include a performance grade level.

b. Resource specialist instruction in language arts must use multisensory teaching techniques.

c. STUDENT must have access to a computer for completing written assignments.

d. STUDENT must have access to an electronic spellchecking device.

All of petitioner's remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

ISSUE # 1: Is the District's Corrective Reading tutoring program appropriate for STUDENT? If not, must the District provide for tutoring by the private Southern California Reading Clinic, which uses the Slingerland method?

Respondent substantially prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE #2 Are the resource specialist services currently being provided to STUDENT in language arts and math pursuant to his IEP appropriate? If not, what changes must be made to STUDENT's Individualized Education Plan?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i)

DATED: April 2, 1996 ______________________________ Leonard Garfinkel Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: A student with dyslexia or another related reading dysfunction who meets eligibility criteria in the category of specific learning disability is eligible for special education. Education Code § 56337.5

Footnote 2: Resource specialist provide special education services to disabled students who are assigned to regular classroom teachers for a majority of the school day. Education Code § 56362.

Footnote 3: STUDENT's scores on January 1993 tests providing grade equivalents were as follows: Wrat Word Recognition 2M Spelling 1E Math Comprehension 3B

Footnote 4: STUDENT's scores on May 1995 tests providing grade equivalents were as follows:

Brigance Comprehension 3.0 Key Math 4.4

Peabody Individual Achievement Test General Information 4.6 Reading Recognition 2.8 Reading Comprehension 2.2

Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests Letter Identification 2.9 Work Attack 1.9

Footnote 5: STUDENT's scores on November, 1995 tests providing grade equivalents were as follows:

Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests Word Identification 3.5 Word Attack 2.4 Word Comprehension 5.2 Passage Comprehension 4.9

Norris Educational Achievement Test Word Recognition 3E Spelling 2B Math 4B

Brigance Inventory of Basic Skills Oral Reading 4.0 Spelling 3.0 Word Recognition 4.0+ Vocabulary Comprehension 4.0 Math Calculation 4.0 Word Problems 3.0

Footnote 6: Ms. Richards did not testify at hearing.

Footnote 7: The evidence showed that Mr. Soto is qualified to provide the tutoring. He holds an emergency credential which qualifies him to provide special education services as a resource specialist. Education Code § 44225; Education Code 56362.6; Title 5, California Code of Regulations Section 3001(x). He has received some training in Corrective Reading and has used the program successfully with STUDENT.

Footnote 8: Petitioner also requests that STUDENT's IEP be revised to provide that specialist instruction in math use the "Touch Math" approach. The evidence did not show that the use of Touch Math had a significant effect on STUDENT's math achievement scores, which did not increase during Ms. Bunger's tutoring. (P 1, R 16) Therefore, this request is denied.

Footnote 9: The District had previously, in an interim mediation agreement in November 1995, agreed to reimburse Petitioner in the amount of $430.00 for the cost of Ms. Richards' May 1995 assessment. (P 27)