California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 7, 1999
Student v. Poway Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 442-99 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Poway Unified provided a FAPE to a fifth grader with a speech impairment; compensatory education and OHI eligibility claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision describes earlier related cases: SN 991-98, resolved by a final mediation agreement (a request to reopen it was denied by the Hearing Office), and SN 1773-98, settled by stipulation on March 16, 1999 and dismissed.
Summary
A fifth grader eligible for special education with a speech and language impairment, represented by his mother, filed against Poway Unified School District. He claimed a denial of FAPE in 1997-98 and 1998-99, sought compensatory education through a nonpublic school placement, and asked to be found eligible as other health impaired (OHI) because of allergies. Earlier disputes had been settled, including a March 16, 1999 settlement that moved him from a special day class to a general education fifth-grade class at Canyon View Elementary with resource specialist support, speech, counseling, occupational therapy and adapted PE. Because of those settlements, the Hearing Officer reviewed 1998-99 only from March 16 through the hearing and refused to reopen compensatory speech claims. For 1997-98, the student offered no other evidence, so the Hearing Officer found a FAPE was provided. For the later period, the school psychologist who counseled him and the resource specialist testified that his needs were met and he was making steady progress. The District never wrote a new IEP after the placement change. The Hearing Officer called this a procedural violation but found it did not cost the student any educational benefit. With no denial of FAPE, no compensatory education was owed. The OHI claim failed because no medical evidence linked his allergies to his schooling. The District prevailed but was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within two weeks to write an IEP matching his actual program.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated issues already resolved by mediation or settlement as closed, and limited review to the period after the last settlement. It also shows that changing a placement by agreement without writing a new IEP was treated as a procedural violation. That violation did not deny FAPE because the student's needs were still met.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1a. Did the District provide the student with a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year?
Compensatory speech claims were barred as already resolved by a final mediated agreement; with no other evidence offered, the Hearing Officer found the District provided a FAPE in 1997-98.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b. Did the District provide the student with a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year from March 16, 1999, through the date of the hearing?
Services met the student's unique needs and gave him educational benefit in the LRE; the District's failure to write a new IEP after the move from the SDC to general education was a procedural violation that caused no prejudice.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. If not, is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education?
Because the student was not denied a FAPE and lost no educational services, no compensatory education or nonpublic school placement was owed.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 3. Should the Petitioner have been identified for special education as other health impaired (OHI)?
No medical or other evidence showed the student's allergies significantly interfered with his education; only two of 25 absences were attributed to allergies.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within two weeks of the date of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to draft an IEP consistent with the student's program.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School District v. B.S.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Todd v. Andrews; Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696; Bernhard v. Bank of America; Sabek v. Engelhard Corp.
People named in the decision
- JoAnn Murphy, director of special education and health services, Poway Unified School District
- Linda Scarpa, school psychologist and student's counselor, Poway Unified School District
- Anne Brady, resource specialist, Poway Unified School District
- Dr. Martha Ingham, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessor), Poway Unified School District
- Mr. DeCremer, general education fourth-grade teacher, Los Penasquitos Elementary School
- Mrs. Lane, general education fifth-grade teacher, Los Penasquitos Elementary School
- Jan Messali, special day class teacher, Canyon View Elementary School
- Ms. Georggin, general education fifth-grade teacher, Canyon View Elementary School
- Christina Leslie, speech-language pathologist (assessor), Poway Unified School District
- Deborah Llewellyn, independent speech-language pathologist (assessor), San Diego Children's Hospital
- Rachel Kochera, private speech therapist, Therapists Unlimited
- Dr. C.A. Nicholson, independent neuropsychological evaluator
- Robert Roice, educational advocate for District, G. R. Roice & Associates
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 442-99 Case Year: 1999 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Eligibility Individual Education Program Non Public School Placement CDS Code: 37-68296 District: Poway Unified Disability Type: Speech or Language Impairment
Case Details This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Poway, California, on May 6 and 7, 1999.
STUDENT (herein after STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented by his mother, Mrs. PARENT. STUDENT was also present for a portion of the first day of hearing.
Poway Unified School District (hereinafter Poway or District) was represented by educational advocate Robert Roice of G. R. Roice & Associates. Also present on Poway's behalf was JoAnn Murphy, Poway's director of special education.
Mrs. PARENT, Petitioner's mother, called the following witness to testify: STUDENT, Petitioner.
Poway called the following witnesses to testify: JoAnn Murphy, director of special education; Linda Scarpa, school psychologist; Anne Brady, resource specialist; and Dr. Martha Ingham, school psychologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and Mr. Roice orally presented the Respondent's closing argument at the conclusion of the hearing. The record was left open for the submission of a written closing argument by the Petitioner. Petitioner's closing argument was received, the record was closed, and the issues were submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Arrangements were not made between the parties for Poway to produce District witnesses for the Petitioner's direct examination, nor did the Petitioner receive the subpoenas he requested from the Special Education Hearing Office. To avoid unnecessary delay, the Respondent agreed that, in addition to cross-examining the District's witnesses, the Petitioner could also conduct direct examination of the witnesses as if he had called them himself.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner contends that the District did not provide him with a free and appropriate education (FAPE) for the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years. As a result, he claims that he is entitled to compensatory education through placement in a nonpublic school. He further contends that he should be identified as "other health impaired" (OHI) as an additional disabling condition.
The District contends that at all times it provided STUDENT with an appropriate education and that, therefore, he is not owed compensatory education. It maintains that numerous meetings were convened to address concerns raised by the parents and that changes were made to STUDENT's program to accommodate those parental concerns. Several assessments were conducted pursuant to the requests of Mr. and Mrs. PARENT. The District also claims that it has never received any information from a physician, or other medical source, indicating that STUDENT's allergies render him OHI.
ISSUES (footnote 1)
1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year and for the 1998-99 school year from March 16, 1999, through the date of the hearing? (Footnote 2)
2. If not, is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education?
3. Should the Petitioner have been identified for special education as OHI?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a fifth-grade student in the Poway School District who has qualified for special education since 1990 with a speech disorder. STUDENT has received therapy for articulation from the District throughout his education, with the exception of his third grade (1996-97 school year), when his parents withdrew him from speech therapy.
STUDENT continued at his home school, Los Penosquitos Elementary School (hereinafter Penosquitos), for the fourth grade. He was placed in Mr. DeCremer's general education fourth- grade class for the 1997-98 school year. His parents agreed to reinstate his speech and language services for articulation. In June of the fourth grade, resource specialist services (RSP) were added for written language. During the 1997-98 school year, the District had difficulty providing a speech therapist at STUDENT's elementary school. Consequently, STUDENT and other students entitled to speech services were deprived of their therapy. On April 20, 1998, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT and the District reached an agreement which included an independent speech evaluation and compensatory speech services. The District further agreed that the school psychologist would evaluate STUDENT and determine whether he needed counseling services. The psychological evaluation was conducted and, on July 7, 1998, the parties agreed that STUDENT would receive weekly counseling to address his diminished self-esteem and his lack of self-confidence with peers. On July 16, 1998, the District further agreed to conduct a psychoeducational evaluation and fund a private Fast ForWord language program, as well as provide compensatory speech services during the 1997-98 extended school year (ESY).
The Petitioner filed a compliance complaint with the California Department of Education (CDE) during the late summer of l998, alleging that the District had failed to implement the above- described agreement. (Footnote 3) Thereafter, on July 6, 1998, he also filed for a due process hearing regarding the same issues. The due process issues were resolved on October 2, 1998, through a mediated final agreement that also provided for a change in STUDENT's fifth-grade placement. On November 19, 1998, the Petitioner's request to reopen the issue of compensatory speech therapy was denied by the Hearing Office following a finding that the issue had already been addressed through a final mediation agreement.
The psychoeducational evaluation the District agreed to in July 1998 was conducted by Dr. Martha Ingham, a Poway school psychologist, and her report was issued on August 2, 1998. In her opinion, STUDENT's presenting problems were complicated and it was difficult to separate the contributions of his emotional, physical, cognitive and auditory processing deficiencies upon his ability to learn. Dr. Ingham did not find a significant discrepancy between his cognitive and academic abilities. Standardized testing showed academic functioning in the low average to average range. Cognitive assessments revealed a "significant scatter with a pattern suggestive of depression, anxiety and poor contact with reality." Further testing suggested that his depression and anxiety were caused by poor social relationships secondary to inadequate social perceptions. Dr. Ingham found that STUDENT tends to make unreasonable and unrealistic conclusions about his social environment. Dr. Ingham also found that because STUDENT views his environment and reacts to it in a way that is different from others' perceptions of reality, he will often be viewed as behaving inappropriately in social situations. He "generally feels helpless in social situations and complex social settings appear chaotic to him." These feelings hamper his ability to establish social relationships. Dr. Ingham also noted that STUDENT has health problems caused by allergies which reportedly result in an average of twenty missed school days per year. She found it likely that STUDENT seeks benefit from his physical ailment by using it to avoid school. Dr. Ingham concluded that STUDENT qualified for special education as speech and language impaired. Although STUDENT was having some difficulty with written language, Dr. Ingham's evaluation did not reveal the significant discrepancy between ability and achievement that would signify a learning disability. She recommended the continuation of counseling to assist STUDENT in establishing accurate social perceptions and developing effective social skills. She stated that if STUDENT were to focus on enhancing these skills, it would address his secondary issues of depression and low self-esteem. Dr. Ingham also suggested "participatory teaching" activities, emphasizing the accuracy of his work over the speed at which it is completed, tailoring his work to his level of alertness, rewarding assertive gestures, and teaching him relaxation techniques. She felt it would be helpful for an adult to explain social situations that STUDENT was misinterpreting or found confusing. Dr. Ingham's evaluation essentially paralleled one conducted in July 1998 by Linda Scarpa, another Poway school psychologist. Ms. Scarpa also found that STUDENT suffered from depression, anxiety, low self-esteem and issues of inappropriate social behavior. She also recommended that he receive social skills training. A referral was made by the District to County Mental Health (CMH), which the parents declined on November 30, 1998. Mr. and
Mrs. PARENT disagreed with Dr. Ingram's report and requested that it be removed from STUDENT's records. Ultimately, Mrs. PARENT discussed her concerns with Dr. Ingham and the psychological report was modified.
STUDENT began his fifth-grade year at Penosquitos in Mrs. Lane's regular education class. Speech therapy, RSP and counseling services were provided. Although the District had agreed to an independent speech assessment in June 1998 through the San Diego Children's Hospital, STUDENT's parents requested another speech assessment in September 1998. The speech pathologist at Children's Hospital had diagnosed a moderate central processing disorder, mild to moderate receptive/expressive language disorder, and mild articulation impairment. The District agreed to another evaluation, and Christina Leslie, a District speech pathologist, assessed STUDENT during eleven test sessions for a total of nine hours over fifteen days. Ms. Leslie found that STUDENT exhibited moderate auditory processing problems, and mild receptive and moderate expressive language difficulties. She suggested that STUDENT work on sound discrimination, auditory comprehension, auditory association, defining words, reasoning, sentence formation, sentence recall, oral motor skills, and articulation.
Pursuant to the parents' request, STUDENT was also assessed by an occupational therapist on September 9, 1998. She found that STUDENT displayed some difficulties with fine and gross motor skills in the areas of running speed, agility, balance, coordination and strength, and recommended adapted physical education (APE) with continued participation in the general fifth-grade physical education program. The occupational therapist found STUDENT to be "perfectly capable" of participating in the fifth-grade physical education activities with some modifications. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT believed that STUDENT required a smaller class size to benefit from his education. As part of the final mediation agreement of October 2, 1998, the District agreed to place STUDENT in a learning handicapped special day class (SDC). This type of class was not available at STUDENT's home school, Penosquitos. He was therefore transferred to an SDC taught by Jan Messali at Canyon View Elementary School (hereinafter Canyon View). STUDENT's parents were initially very happy with this placement. On October 19, 1998, Mrs. PARENT wrote a note to Ms. Messali that stated, "Thank you for your nurturing type of teaching. STUDENT is really happy and looks forward to going to school. I have never seen him so excited about his studies." On November 5, 1998, an IEP meeting was held to add OT and APE services to STUDENT's IEP.
Mrs. PARENT requested an IEP meeting on January 13, 1999, and expressed dissatisfaction with the SDC. She stated that the academic work was not at a fifth-grade level and STUDENT was not being prepared for sixth-grade. Mrs. PARENT reported that STUDENT did not understand why he was placed in an SDC when he only needed speech therapy and that he felt he was in a "retarded class." Although she had thought that the SDC would be good for STUDENT's self-esteem, STUDENT was disturbed by his placement and did not want his peers to see him in the SDC class. Ms. Scarpa, STUDENT's school counselor, confirmed that these issues would be addressed in his weekly counseling sessions as would STUDENT's embarrassment with his clumsiness in social situations. Another CMH referral was offered to STUDENT and again declined. Mrs. PARENT thought STUDENT might need a resource specialist to work with him in his class. She also said STUDENT required more activities such as keyboarding and access to a computer with fifth-grade materials. Mrs. PARENT also wanted him challenged with homework of an hour per day. Ms. Georggin, the regular education fifth-grade teacher in whose class STUDENT had been mainstreamed for the D.A.R.E. program(drug and alcohol dangers), was invited to the IEP meeting to discuss the possibility of additional inclusion in her class for language arts. (Footnote 4) Mrs. PARENT stated that she wanted STUDENT fully integrated into the regular fifth-grade classroom by June 1999 and that STUDENT did not want to return to his home school, Penosquitos.
Six days later, on January 19, 1999, Mrs. PARENT wrote the SDC teacher stating that "STUDENT has finally found a happier academic environment. He wants to be in this 5th grade class next week. I informed STUDENT that whatever it took I would support his right to be in Ms. Georggin's class." On the same date, Mrs. PARENT wrote Ms. Georggin that "STUDENT had informed me that he wants to be in your class full time. I want him in your classroom full time -- by next week. It's imperative to move him out of that class. He informs me that he hates rm.6 -- I need a quick transition to happen for him." Ms. Georggin and STUDENT's SDC teacher responded to Mrs. PARENT, stating that a change in placement would require an IEP meeting and that the District IEP team members were available on February 9, 1999.
On February 9, 1999, another IEP meeting was convened. Ms. Georggin reviewed some of STUDENT's work from the general education setting and reported that he rarely recorded his homework assignments in his binder. She also advised the team that her class was a "gate cluster" class and sometimes STUDENT seemed to "feel lost" during his inclusion time in her class. Ms. Georggin suggested that STUDENT"gradually" (emphasis in original) be moved into the general education setting. At this meeting, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT would continue in general education for language arts and also be mainstreamed for social studies in the fifth-grade class. Science in the general education fifth grade might be added later.
The Petitioner filed another due process hearing request in February 1999, alleging a denial of FAPE and a failure to assess in all areas of suspected disability. Pursuant to an interim mediation agreement, the District offered to provide the independent neuropsychology evaluation requested by the Petitioner and to transfer STUDENT out of the SDC and into Ms. Georggin's fifth-grade class with RSP support. It advised the PARENTs of the procedure for requesting the removal of Dr. Ingham's report from STUDENT's file and refused the parents' request for an independent OT assessment. The mediation process was not successful and the case proceeded to a due process hearing on March 16, 1999. Before the hearing began, the parties entered into a stipulated settlement agreement. The settlement agreement provided for the following school schedule for STUDENT on Mondays, Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Fridays:
9:00 - 9:15a.m. Fifth-grade class 9:15 - 11:00a.m. RSP program, counseling, APE and speech 11:00 - 11:15a.m. Recess 11:15 - 11:50a.m. Math in a fifth-grade classroom 11:50 - 12:40p.m. Math in RSP 12:40 - 1:20p.m. Lunch 1:20 - 3:20p.m. Fifth-grade class
On Thursdays, additional aide support in the fifth-grade class was to be provided. STUDENT was also to have access to a computer in the RSP room to develop his keyboarding skills and attend the 1998-99 ESY program. This is the schedule in effect when the instant due process hearing was filed.
On March 28, 1999, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT filed the instant due process request claiming that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years and is therefore entitled to compensatory education through placement in a nonpublic school. The Petitioner further alleges that he should be given an additional special education qualification as OHI.
DISCUSSION
"Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . " 20 U.S.C. §1401(25). Under both federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the students individualized education program.
In determining whether a district has offered a free, appropriate public education, the focus is on the adequacy of the district's proposed placement. The criterion is not whether the parents desire another program, or whether that program would result in greater educational benefit to the child. A placement is adequate if it is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th Cir. 1987) In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court held that "the µbasic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or "potential-maximizing" education for the individual child. Seattle School District v. B.S., 24 IDELR 68 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994); Rowley, supra.
As part of an appropriate education, the child is also entitled to related services. The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). California Education Code §56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management.
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code §56031.
Thus, a district has fulfilled its obligation to offer an appropriate education pursuant to the IDEA, and the interpreting case law, when its offer of placement and services (1) identifies and addresses the student's unique needs, (2) affords the student some educational benefit, (3) conforms to the IEP, and (4) occurs in the least restrictive environment. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.
ISSUE NUMBER ONE
Did the District provide STUDENTwith a free and appropriate public education?
1. 1997-98 school year
Other than the evidence relating to the District's failure to provide the required speech therapy, the Petitioner did not offer any evidence that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year. In response to Poway's objections, the Hearing Officer ruled inadmissable evidence relating to compensatory speech therapy. The issue of compensatory speech services had been resolved through a final mediated agreement in a prior due process case. A motion by the Petitioner to reopen this prior hearing had also been denied by the Hearing Office. The resolved issue of speech make-up sessions is therefore also barred by the principle of res judicata and will not be reconsidered by the Hearing Officer. (For further discussion, see footnote #3.) As no other evidence was admitted concerning the provision of a FAPE during this school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year.
2. 1998-99 school year from March 16, 1999, through May 7, 1999
Did the District identify and address STUDENT's unique needs?
To determine whether the District addressed STUDENT's needs between March 16, 1999, and May 7, 1999, the Hearing Officer must first identify STUDENT's unique needs during that time. During the summer prior to the 1998-99 school year, and soon after it began, multiple assessments were conducted. Other than STUDENT himself, the Petitioner did not present any witnesses during the hearing. The Hearing Officer will therefore determine STUDENT's unique educational needs from March through May 1999 by relying upon the information presented through his recent assessments, both parties' documentary evidence, and the witnesses called by Poway.
Although STUDENT has processing deficits, which will be discussed below, his difficulties are predominantly in the areas of perception of his environment, behavior in social situations, confidence and self-esteem. These areas were addressed through the testimony of two school psychologists, the director of special education, a resource specialist, STUDENT and documentary evidence.
Martha Ingham, PhD. , conducted a psychological assessment of STUDENT during four forty-five- minute sessions in July 1998. Dr. Ingham found that STUDENT's test results were more representative of depression than a learning disability. STUDENT displayed episodic fatigue and somatic complaints. His motivation, energy and attention varied. His full scale IQ was measured at 83 to 95, in the low average range. However, Dr. Ingham noted that his difficulties with concentration, planning abilities, memory and processing speed may have suppressed his IQ score. On the WISC-III, he scored in the average to low average range. The high levels of "scatter" on the subtest scores were significant to Dr. Ingham when she interpreted the meaning of the WISK-III. Dr. Ingham testified that STUDENT's emotional indicators, combined with the variability on his subtest scores, indicated more than a processing disorder. Depression, perfectionist tendencies and avoidance behaviors were suggested by his tendency to give up quickly or voice physical complaints when confronted with tests he perceived to be difficult. Dr. Ingham also noticed that STUDENT's articulation problems became more pronounced when he was unsure of his answers. The verbal and nonverbal WISK-III subtests on which STUDENT performed poorly are commonly suppressed in individuals who are depressed, anxious or socially withdrawn. Dr. Ingham also found that STUDENT's tendency to score better on digits backward than digits forward, his poor performance on planning ability, his slow processing of information, the low scores on tests requiring attention, concentration and memory, his mother's observational history, and STUDENT's statements, as well as Dr. Ingham's observations, were consistent with depressive features.
Dr. Ingram also gave STUDENT the Rorschack Psychodiagnostic Technique (Rorschark) test. She credibly testified regarding her familiarity and expertise with this test. Dr. Ingham explained that she was trained by a leading expert on the Rorschack test and had conducted her PhD on the test. Dr. Ingham stated that the Rorschark evaluated an individual's perception of reality. The majority of people who take the test interpret the ink blots in a similar way. Those who do not see reality in the standard manner have significantly different connotations when describing the ink blots. According to Dr. Ingham, it has been established that viewing the ink blots in an uncommon way translates into inappropriate social behaviors, because these individuals do not see reality as others see it. STUDENT's results on the Rorschark fell outside the norm and corroborated the findings on other tests given to STUDENT by Dr. Ingham.
Dr. Ingham concluded that her evaluation of STUDENT in August 1998 did not correlate with a diagnosis of a processing disorder, as his performance on the verbal and nonverbal tasks were relatively similar overall. However, his psychological and physical complaints complicated the diagnosis. She found that he expressed feeling sad, fearful, and like he did not fit in with his peers. He also felt he was not "negotiating his social environment well" and that this feeling was contributing to his depression, in addition to probably exacerbating his physical symptoms. (Footnote 5)
In her report, Dr. Ingham summarized that
[STUDENT] is having more problems in thinking and reality contact than he really concedes. Indeed, he currently feels overwhelmed and unable to cope with external stress. He has difficulty perceiving himself and his world accurately. He makes unreasonable conclusions regarding the relationship of the things in his world, and has a tendency to make unrealistic generalizations about his social environment. Others will probably view his behaviors as inappropriate. . . . As a result of inadequate interpersonal effectiveness, STUDENTmanifests symptoms consistent with depression and anxiety.
Based upon the assessment she conducted, Dr. Ingham believed that STUDENT had unique needs for (1) speech and language therapy (however, she states that "the current evaluation does not indicate there is a learning disability"), (2) continuation of DIS counseling services to assist STUDENT in forming more accurate social perceptions and effective social skills (which would help alleviate the underlying depression and low self-esteem), (3) participatory teaching techniques and tailoring teaching to his levels of alertness, (4) emphasizing accuracy over speed, (5) encouraging and rewarding assertive behavior, (6) an adult to orally explain specific social conduct, (7) an adult to provide insight into inappropriate social behavior, and (8) relaxation techniques and assertiveness training.
Linda Scarpa, the school psychologist who provides STUDENT's counseling services, also evaluated him and provided testimony. She essentially concurred with Dr. Ingham's findings. Ms Scarpa's written report summarizes that STUDENT's "anxiety, depression, self-esteem and issues of social inadequacy may interfere with classroom performance." Because she thinks it is beneficial for him to continue with the same counselor, she still counsels STUDENT each week, even though she no longer provides psychological services to other children at his school. Ms. Scarpa testified that she has been STUDENT's counselor since July 1998. She stated that STUDENThad difficulties and was very uncomfortable and unhappy when he was placed in the SDC during the 1998-99 school year. He told Ms. Scarpa that he felt that he had been placed in the "retarded class" and he was embarrassed to be seen by his peers in that classroom. Contrary to Mrs. PARENT's assertions of STUDENT's unhappiness and feelings of inadequacies in his current general education class, Ms. Scarpa finds him significantly improved since his transfer from the SDC. She stated that he has been working on adjusting to his new class and that he has made steady progress. She has "high hopes" for his regular education placement with RSP support. Ms. Scarpa further testified that she has not found him to be "as out of touch with reality or as depressed" since he has moved from the SDC to the fifth-grade class. Her areas of concern for STUDENT continue to be that he does not have good strategies in place to deal with difficult requirements, he is reluctant to find a solution to difficult tasks and situations, he tends to avoid solving hard undertakings himself, and he "prefers to give his problems to someone else for solutions." Ms. Scarpa is concerned that STUDENT's shyness has been enhanced because he has been moved so much this school year. She believes that his unique needs are in the areas of handwriting, self-esteem, social situations, social rules and expectations, and the use of a "matter of fact" approach when he is acting out or testing limits. In addition to consistent responses to overtly inappropriate behaviors, STUDENT requires explanations of the reality of social situations without making him feel that this assistance is punitive,
Anne Brady, the resource specialist, testified regarding her work with STUDENT since the March 16, 1999 settlement agreement. Ms. Brady stated that she is in close contact with STUDENT's general education teacher and speaks with her every day. She also meets formally with STUDENT's teacher each week to organize his lesson plans. STUDENT goes to Ms. Brady's class for language arts two hours and fifteen minutes each day, four days per week. During this time he also receives his DIS services. Ms. Brady also provides fifty minutes of math assistance the same number of days per week. On the fifth day of the week, STUDENT has two hours with an instructional aide. Ms Brady testified that STUDENT has good keyboarding skills and the keyboarding experience requested by Mrs. PARENT is accomplished by bringing STUDENT to her class earlier than the other RSP students each day. STUDENT previously received keyboarding every day. However, Thursday keyboarding was eliminated in response to Mrs. PARENT's request that her son focus on math on Thursdays. Ms. Brady gives STUDENT modified curriculum and additional time to complete his work. Twice a week she gives him his math homework. STUDENT is also responsible for learning six words each week from the regular fifth-grade spelling list. He must write sentences with these words and take a spelling test on Fridays. He is also required to do some of the homework from the general education class. Ms. Brady has found that STUDENT often does not return his homework. To assist with this problem, she went into his regular education class to confirm that STUDENT understood the location in the classroom where his teacher writes the daily homework and that he was able to transfer it to his homework binder. She also now has the aide go into STUDENT's fifth-grade class each day to ensure that he has his homework written in his binder.
Ms. Brady testified that STUDENT is able to keep up with his peers in her resource class. In fact, during the prior week, STUDENT successfully completed, and self-corrected, a five-paragraph essay with better success than the majority of her other students. Ms. Brady described STUDENT as very cooperative and polite. However, he is frequently absent, which has an effect upon his academic performance. He also attempts to avoid his school work, but when he is instructed that it must be completed, he will finish it. It is Ms. Brady's observation that STUDENT does not take enough responsibility for himself and that he needs to work on that skill. She finds that he sometimes appears to withdraw and wait for someone else to provide assistance. In response to Mrs. PARENT's assertion that STUDENT was by himself on the playground, Ms. Brady testified that she had noticed STUDENT alone on the playground on one occasion. She did not, however, have extensive knowledge of his lunch activities because she was not usually on campus at that time of the day. She did testify that her observations were that STUDENT gets along well with his peers. In the opinion of Ms. Brady, STUDENT's primary educational need is assistance in overcoming his lack of confidence in his capabilities. He works a little slower than his general education peers; therefore, he also requires extra time to complete his school work. He would benefit from organizational and study skills since he tends to work very slowly. Ms. Brady testified that STUDENT's present levels of services are appropriate.
JoAnn Murphy, the District's director of special education and health services, testified to all of the above-described evaluations that the District had preformed on STUDENT at his parents' request. Ms. Murphy also described STUDENT's transfer from a general education class with RSP support to an SDC and his return to a general education class with RSP assistance, pursuant to mediation, a due process settlement agreement and the parents' request. STUDENT has never been identified on his IEPs as having a specific learning disability or as health impaired. She also confirmed that STUDENT's current IEP was drafted for the SDC placement and it provides for (1) speech therapy two times per week for 30 minutes per session, (2) APE twice a week for thirty minutes per session, (3) individual OT for thirty minutes per week and consultation for 60 minutes, and (4) weekly counseling for thirty minutes. However, the agreement reached between the parties before the prior due process hearing of March 16, 1999, began, specified that STUDENT would spend two hours and fifteen minutes each morning in RSP and would receive his written language, speech and counseling services during this time. He would then receive forty minutes in the afternoon for RSP math support following the math lesson in his regular fifth-grade class. Recess, lunch, social studies and science were provided in the regular education fifth-grade class. Ms. Murphy testified that a new IEP was not drafted to reflect the change in STUDENT's placement from the SDC to the fifth-grade class with RSP services. She stated that STUDENT was appropriately placed in the fifth-grade class and that his IEP goals were being implemented in his new placement as previously written. She acknowledged that he needs, and receives, math assistance and that he should not have received a grade of "F" on a math test. (According to the evidence presented, this only occurred on one occasion.)
Neither the District's speech therapist nor the speech pathologist who conducted the independent evaluation at Children's Hospital testified at the hearing. However, their reports were admitted into evidence. Christina Leslie, a District speech pathologist, evaluated STUDENT between September
9 and 24, 1998. She concluded that STUDENT had a moderate auditory processing disorder with mild receptive and moderate expressive difficulties. He also displayed a mild to moderate articulation disorder which was secondary to his auditory processing problems. Ms. Leslie recommended that STUDENT receive assistance with his auditory sound discrimination, critical listening comprehension, learning how words relate to each other, word definitions, reasoning skills, the creation of syntactically correct sentences, recalling spoken sentences, oral motor coordination, and articulation, particularly for the /r/ sound.
STUDENT was evaluated in June 1998 by the speech department of Children's Hospital. Its speech pathologist, Deborah Llewellyn, found that STUDENT displayed the following problem areas:
1. Not listen carefully;
2. Easily distracted by background sounds;
3. Difficulty with phonics;
4. Within a few moments oral information is forgotten;
5. Difficulty following oral directions;
6. Poor auditory learning;
7. An articulation disorder;
8. Delayed responses to verbal stimuli; and 9. Demonstrates a below average ability in some academic areas.
Ms. Llewellen suggested that STUDENT receive speech and language training with an emphasis on auditory training, medical follow-up for his allergies, and consideration for an assistive listening device to transmit the teacher's voice directly to his ears.
Speech therapy was also provided to STUDENT in July and August 1998 by Rachel Kochera with Therapists Unlimited. She and STUDENT worked on articulating "r" words but did not achieve correct oral placement or production. In her report, Ms. Kochera stated that STUDENT continued to need therapy to attempt to remediate his pronunciation problem. As part of his therapy, STUDENT also responded to verbal instructions with multiple steps. Overall, he was successful 80% of the time. However, when he was required to follow two- to three-step directions, rather than a one-step direction, his success rate dropped to 20%. Ms. Kochera summarized that although STUDENT could pronounce "r" in isolation, his accuracy decreased when using "r" in words and sentences. He could follow three-step directions if they were repeated to him.
At the request of Mr. and Mrs. PARENT, STUDENT received an independent neuropsychological evaluation from Dr. C.A. Nicholson on April 27 and 29, 1999. Dr. Nicholson's report was completed during the hearing and admitted into evidence without an objection. He reported that the Test of Memory and Learning ( TOMAL) revealed average processing abilities in both the right and left hemispheres of the brain. Although Dr. Nicholson found statistically significant differences between STUDENT's verbal and nonverbal test performances, he stated that this was the result of superior performance on two subtests of the Nonverbal Memory Scale and not the result of deficiencies on the Verbal Memory Scale test. Dr. Nicholson concluded that STUDENT's profile was dissimilar to that of children with a brain dysfunction. He also stated that the results he obtained on STUDENT's psychological evaluation were similar to those reported in the District's psychological assessment. While Dr. Nicholson did not find a discrepancy between STUDENT's ability and achievement, he noted weaknesses in abstract visual memory and verbal expression. In his opinion, this strongly suggested a "learning dysfunction" which could make academics difficult for STUDENT without remedial assistance. Dr. Nicholson did not test STUDENT in the social-emotional area. However, his impression was that STUDENT related well during the testing and that STUDENT expressed positive feelings about his interactions with his peers. Dr. Nicholson opined that some of STUDENT's social difficulties are a consequence of his problems expressing himself. As a result, STUDENT's coping method is to react passively or avoid situations that he finds stressful. Dr. Nicholson's reported assessment results essentially parallel those expressed in other evaluations of STUDENT. His findings indicate that STUDENT requires speech therapy for expressive language and processing difficulties, RSP assistance with academics, and counseling to work on social interactions
Based upon the information provided, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's unique needs from March 16, 1999 through May 7, 1999, are in the following six categories: (1) speech therapy, (2) counseling:,(3) APE, (4) OT,(5) RSP support for academics, and (6) general education modifications. To address STUDENT's speech needs, the therapist must assist him with his articulation of the "r" sound, his oral motor coordination, his syntax and his difficulties with phonics. The therapist must also respond to his processing difficulties that cause him to rapidly forget oral information, display delayed responses to verbal stimuli, have problems following verbal directions, evidence reduced listening abilities, and be easily distracted by background noise. His RSP teacher and/or resource aide need to collaborate with his general education teacher, modify his curriculum, provide him with extra time to complete assignments and tests, as well as monitor his understanding of his academic curriculum. The RSP staff also needs to work with STUDENT on his organizational and study skills, confirm that his homework is appropriate, and that he writes it in his homework binder. STUDENT's parents need to follow up with his homework completion and see that it is returned to school as required. Math is particularly difficult for STUDENT; therefore, his RSP teacher needs to enhance his understanding of math concepts. Counseling must focus on his diminished self-esteem, assisting with his interpretation of his environment, building social skills and developing greater self-confidence. To further benefit in his classroom, the counselor, with the collaboration of all of his teachers, needs to help STUDENT learn strategies to prevent his avoidance of tasks he perceives to be difficult, and to take responsibility for himself. STUDENT requires OT assistance with his handwriting. The APE teacher should focus on improving STUDENT's endurance and muscular strength. Regular education modifications should include preferential seating to facilitate STUDENT's attention difficulties, reductions in academic work requirements commensurate with his abilities, extra time to complete assignments, facilitation of appropriate social interactions in the classroom, and collaboration with STUDENT's DIS providers. STUDENT further needs to remain in one classroom placement throughout the school year so that he can become familiar with his environment and thereby increase his self-confidence.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District has properly responded to STUDENT's unique needs. During the relevant time period, STUDENT was enrolled in a general education fifth-grade class with RSP pull-out support approximately two and a half hours per day, four days a week. On the fifth day of the week he received assistance from an instructional aide. His specific daily schedule was specified through the parties' March 16, 1999 agreement. Ms. Brady, STUDENT's RSP teacher, provided all of the support identified in the above paragraph. She and Ms. Georggin communicated daily to address STUDENT's need for classroom modifications. Each week, included in his RSP time, the District also provided STUDENT with speech therapy, APE, OT and counseling.
The goals and objectives that were in effect from March 1999 through May 1999, were contained in the IEP signed on January 13, 1999. STUDENT's speech related IEP goals were as follows: improve his oral motor strength and speech intelligibility (particularly the "r" sound); define grade appropriate vocabulary words; describe objects' functions and what they look like; listen to a story, relate events in sequence, and answer factual and inferential questions. These goals met his speech needs. His OT goal provided for the handwriting assistance he required in forming numbers and cursive letters correctly. His counselor worked on reinforcing his self-esteem, understanding the reality of social situations, increasing his confidence, and taking responsibility for himself. His RSP and general education teachers provided academic help through the following IEP goals: (1) write a three to a four-paragraph essay with correct sentences, spelling and punctuation utilizing peer and teacher assistance, a spell checker, word processor and dictation, (2) cluster his ideas and explain them orally, (3) write a three- to a five-sentence paragraph with the assistance of a graphic organizer, and (4) complete a written assignment consisting of two to three short paragraphs within an allotted time. STUDENT's need for more assistance with math was accommodated by increasing his math resource time and providing it immediately after his general education math instruction so the concepts could be reinforced. In addition, his RSP teacher modifies his math assignments and tests, in addition to providing extra time for their completion. The APE teacher's goals are to improve STUDENT's cardiovascular endurance and improve his abdominal and upper body strength. All of these are appropriate goals and services that addressed STUDENT's unique needs from March 16, 1999, through the final day of the hearing.
Ms. Llewellyn briefly mentioned in her independent evaluation that consideration of an assistive listening device may be appropriate for STUDENT in his classroom. However, the rationale for this remark was not explained and no other witness mentioned a need for such technology. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that there was insufficient evidence presented to establish that STUDENT has a unique need for this equipment.
Following a consideration of the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that Poway was providing all of the services required to address STUDENT's unique needs. The District did not, however, convene an IEP meeting to redraft STUDENT's IEP to reflect the changes made in his program when he transferred from an SDC to a general education program with RSP support.
Did the District's placement provide STUDENTwith educational benefit?
In support of his contention that he is not receiving educational benefit in his current placement, the Petitioner produced evidence about two assignments from his general education class. Mrs. PARENT's concern about a project required in Ms. Georggin's class about rocks and another done on the Jamestown settlement was evident in her questioning of witnesses. Although the District's witnesses disputed it, Mrs. PARENT contended that STUDENT was supposed to buy rocks to complete the project and STUDENT was unaware of this requirement. She was adamant that STUDENT felt bad because he was the only student without his own rocks and that this was the primary reason he could not complete the project. The District claimed that buying rocks was not necessary and STUDENT could have used rocks located in the classroom to do the project. Mrs. PARENT asked STUDENT several questions regarding both the rock and Jamestown assignments. STUDENT testified that the other students were examining their rocks and writing on 3x5 cards. Because he did not have his own rocks, and he did not understand what he was required to do with the 3x5 cards, he sat unattended during that portion of the class. He also testified that he did not ask Ms. Georggin for assistance. Regarding the Jamestown project, STUDENT testified that he understood that he was to choose a character and do a comparison of two settlers from Jamestown. He claimed that he was unaware that this project was to be completed within a week and that some of it was to be done as homework. He stated that this assignment was hard for him and Ms. Georggin did not assist him. He did, however, request help from Ms. Brady and she provided it. Mrs. PARENT emphasized through her cross-examination of the District's witnesses and her documentary evidence that she viewed these two projects as examples of STUDENT's receiving inadequate support in, and benefit from, his general education class.
The Petitioner introduced one of STUDENT's math tests upon which a grade of "F" was written by Ms. Georggin. Mrs. PARENT contested this method of grading her son's schoolwork and argued that it established that STUDENT was receiving an inadequate education. The special education director agreed that such grading was inappropriate for STUDENT. However, she emphasized that it only occurred on one occasion. STUDENT testified that he "felt bad" when he received the "F" on his general education math test. The Hearing Officer concurs that this is not a beneficial grading technique for a child who has processing difficulties and is being counseled for issues of confidence and self-esteem. However, no evidence was presented that this one-time occurrence deprived STUDENT of educational benefit during the months at issue herein. In fact, STUDENT's RSP teacher began specifically discussing STUDENT's math assignments with his general education teacher, modifying them, and assigning his math homework herself. She further testified that she modifies STUDENT's math tests and provides him with extra time to complete them. STUDENT also receives his first twenty minutes of math in his general education class, then immediately goes to his RSP teacher for further assistance in math. Recently, STUDENT's afternoon RSP math support has been further increased by having him come to the RSP class ten minutes before the other RSP students.
Because such a brief period of time is presented for consideration in this case, it is difficult to analyze the extent of educational benefit provided to STUDENT. However, based upon the evidence presented, it is the determination of the Hearing Officer that STUDENT benefitted educationally from the program and services provided by Poway and that he will continue to do so. Ms. Scarpa testified persuasively that STUDENT is benefitting from his psychological services. She stated that she has seen "steady progress and a lot of growth" since STUDENT left the SDC. This growth has continued between March 16, 1999, and the date of the hearing. Ms. Scarpa has "high hopes" for his progress in his present placement. She also said that although he had difficulties with the other students while in the SDC, she is unaware of any problems in his current class. It is the opinion of Ms. Scarpa that STUDENT's mood has significantly improved since he returned to a general education fifth-grade class. He is happier and is adjusting well to his class. He is also much better at remaining in touch with the reality of social situations. She has noticed that his perception of his social environment has markedly improved since his transfer to Ms. Georggin's class. Ms. Scarpa related a telephone call she received from Mrs. PARENT during the time frame at issue, in which Mrs. PARENT told her that STUDENT was having problems in the fifth-grade class (i.e., depression and difficulties in class). Because Mrs. PARENT's perception was so contrary to hers, Ms. Scarpa immediately spoke with STUDENT and he specifically denied any of the concerns expressed by his mother. Ms. Scarpa also testified that during their counseling sessions , she routinely broaches the subject of whether STUDENT is experiencing any school problem. She is confident that STUDENT would share any concerns with her, as they have established a relationship of trust, and he has always confided in her in the past. Unlike the time STUDENT spent in the SDC, during which he expressed many difficulties with school, STUDENT now indicates that "things are going OK" in his current classroom.
Ms. Brady provided testimony that STUDENT is receiving social and academic benefit in his current placement. She testified that STUDENT has never expressed feeling any discomfort in his fifth-grade class since she began working with him in March 1999. He relates well to the other students in her RSP class and plays with them during recesses. Academically, STUDENT does well in her class. He is always able to keep up with the reading assignments and he understands the language arts and spelling requirements in her class. STUDENT is responsible for six of the general education spelling words each week. She provides the spelling words on Mondays. Her class then works with the words throughout the week and has a spelling test on Friday. Immediately prior to the hearing,
STUDENT successfully wrote a five-paragraph essay. She acknowledged that during the first two weeks of Ms. Georggin's class, STUDENT had some difficulty with the regular education math. In response, she now speaks daily with Ms. Georggin, specifically discussing math, and obtains STUDENT's math assignments once a week. She then gives him his math homework two times a week and modifies his math tests. Ms. Brady finds that this routine has enabled STUDENT to understand his math assignments.
The testimony of Ms. Scarpa and Ms. Brady demonstrates to the Hearing Officer that STUDENT is receiving educational and psychological benefit in a general education classroom, in the company of his peers, with RSP and DIS support. Based upon the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer therefore concludes that during the relevant time period, Poway has provided the placement and services STUDENT needs to receive some educational benefit from his educational program.
Did the District's services conform to STUDENT's IEP?
There was no evidence presented at the hearing alleging that compliance with STUDENT's last agreed- upon IEP was a disputed issue between the parties. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the services the District provided between March 16, 1999, and May 7, 1999, did not conform to the last agreed-upon IEP. This IEP had been drafted while STUDENT was a student in an SDC. STUDENT's placement and services had been changed through agreements and due process settlements entered into between the parties. These changes were not formally incorporated into an IEP document. STUDENT's fifth-grade teacher was not provided with an IEP that advised her of STUDENT's specific needs in her classroom. She was therefore initially working with a new student without the benefit of specific notice of his limitations or how best to meet his needs. The Hearing Officer is convinced that this caused much of the misunderstanding and resulting dissatisfaction expressed throughout the Petitioner's evidence. These problems may have been minimized had an IEP meeting been held when STUDENT entered Ms. Georggin's class that clarified STUDENT's needs, established necessary classroom modifications, and identified the party responsible for monitoring each aspect of STUDENT's special educational.
Although this is a procedural violation, the Hearing Officer finds that it caused no prejudice to the Petitioner. The placement and RSP services actually provided met STUDENT's unique needs and provided him with some educational benefit even though the changes were not formally documented in his IEP. Moreover, Ms. Brady and Ms. Georggin communicated regarding STUDENT's needs for modifications and made them to his program. The District also continued the appropriate goals and objectives and provided STUDENT's DIS services pursuant to the last agreed-upon IEP.
Was STUDENT's placement in the least restrictive environment?
This was not a disputed issue between the parties. However, the Hearing Officer notes that after a review of the evidence, the least restrictive environment for STUDENT is a general education class with support, where he can work on his social skills in the most natural environment for a child his age. STUDENT is currently placed in this environment.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence discussed above supports a finding that Poway provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1998-99 school year from March 16, 1999, through May 7, 1999. (Footnote 6)
ISSUE NUMBER TWO
Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education?
Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. §1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such "relief as it determines is appropriate." "The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services." Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F. Supp. 867 (8th Cir.1996) Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir, 1991). There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. "Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court's resources in crafting appropriate relief . . . Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA." Student W. V. Puyallup, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir.1994). Equitable considerations are therefore appropriate when fashioning compensatory remedies. An application of equitable principles requires that the actions of the parties themselves must be considered when evaluating the circumstances surrounding the child's lost educational opportunity and in creating an adequate remedy. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (supra). Thus, when considering a request for compensatory education, it is first necessary to determine whether a school district failed to provide a FAPE. If that issue is answered in the affirmative, the subsequent question is not what precise services were missed but, rather, what compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law.
The Hearing Officer has already determined that STUDENT's unique needs are being properly addressed and that he is receiving some educational benefit from his general education placement with DIS services. Because the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the relevant portion of the 1997 -98 school year and the Petitioner did not lose educational services, he is not entitled to compensatory education.
ISSUE NUMBER THREE
Should the Petitioner be identified as eligible for special education as other health impaired
The Petitioner claims that he has severe allergies which constitute an additional special education eligibility classification as OHI. Some of the Petitioner's evidence mentioned STUDENT's upper respiratory allergies and the District does not dispute that STUDENT suffers from allergies. However, the Petitioner presented no evidence that his allergies, or any other health concerns, are a significant health problem which interferes with his education. The Petitioner did not present any witnesses at the hearing, nor were any medical reports introduced into evidence, that documented STUDENT's allergies, discussed any medical consequences from his allergies , or established their effect upon his educational abilities. Ms. Murphy testified that the District had never been provided with any oral or documentary information from a physician pertaining to STUDENT's allergies.
The Petitioner maintains that his allergies cause him to miss an average of twenty school days per year and that some of his allergy medications can cause drowsiness which interferes with his ability to attend to class lessons. He argues that, for these reasons, his allergies render him OHI. Again, there was no evidence presented regarding the connection between STUDENT's allergies and missed school, nor were the side effects of his medications established. The District did introduce STUDENT's attendance record for the current school year on which is recorded the reason given by the parent for a student's absence from school. STUDENT has missed twenty-five school days through April 12, 1999. Of those days, only two were reported as resulting from allergies. The Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner did not meet his burden of establishing that he qualifies for special education as OHI
CONCLUSION
The evidence established that Petitioner was provided a FAPE from March 16, 1999, through May 7, 1999. Because he was not deprived of a FAPE, the Petitioner is not entitled to compensatory education. The Hearing Officer also concluded that Petitioner should not be found eligible for special education under the additional category of OHI.
ORDER
1. All of the Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.
3. Within two weeks of the date of this decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to draft an IEP consistent with STUDENT's program.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The Respondent prevailed on the issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).
Dated:_________________________ _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
Footnotes 1. The Petitioner initially presented fifteen issues. However, after discussion, it was agreed that many of the issues identified by the Petitioner were factual allegations supporting his contention that the District had failed to provide a FAPE, rather than separate legal issues. The Petitioner's issues are therefore restated in this decision as agreed upon by the parties. 2. The Petitioner previously filed for a due process hearing (SN 1773-98) alleging that the District failed to provide STUDENTwith a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year and that it had not assessed him in all areas of suspected disability. On March 16, 1999, prior to the commencement of the hearing scheduled for that case, the parties entered into a stipulated settlement. At the request of the parties, the Hearing Officer incorporated the parties' settlement into an agreement and dismissed case number SN 1773-98. Accordingly, pursuant to the principle of res judicata, the Hearing Officer will not reconsider the issue that was raised in case number SN 1773-98 and resolved through an agreement between the parties. Bernhard v. Bank of America, 19 Cal.2d 807 (1942) Sabek v. Engelhard Corp.. 65 CalApp.4th 992 (1998). When the Petitioner filed the current due process request, he reasserted the same issue of a denial of a FAPE during the 1998-99 school year. Because a party may not reassert previously resolved issues (res judicata), the Hearing Officer will address only the issue of whether the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE from March 16, 1999, the date SN 1773-98, was settled, through the date of this hearing, as well as the consequent issue of compensatory education and the Petitioner's qualification for special education as "other health impaired." The Hearing Officer notes that the Petitioner's parents are familiar with the principle that disputed issues that have been resolved through either a final settlement agreement or adjudication cannot be relitigated. On November 9, 1998, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT requested that another prior due process matter (SN 991-98) involving the issue of compensatory speech therapy, which had been settled through a final mediation agreement, be reopened. This request was denied by the Hearing Office on the ground that a due process case that has been settled cannot be relitigated. 3. The Petitioner has filed a total of eleven compliance complaints with the CDE from the date of this complaint through April 9, 1999. Although similar allegations may have been asserted in the compliance complaints and the present due process hearing, the Hearing Officer will address only the issues raised at the due process hearing. 4. Mrs. PARENT had removed STUDENTfrom the D.A.R.E. program on December 3, 1998, so that he could remain in the SDC for reading, writing and spelling activities. 5. The Hearing Officer is referring to the second, modified report by Dr. Ingham, which was introduced at the hearing by the Respondent without objection. Dr. Ingham's original report was changed pursuant to Mrs. PARENT's objections about some of the information contained therein, and that initial report was not introduced or admitted into evidence. 6. The Hearing Officer has already determined that the issue of denial of a FAPE for the 1997-98 is barred by res judicata.
