California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 22, 2000

Student v. Elk Grove Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 456-00 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown

Elk Grove Unified must provide 13 hours of compensatory reading tutoring for missed IEP tutoring; other implementation claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 4 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Prior due process case SN 854-99 (filed June 3, 1999) was dismissed by agreement in February 2000.

Summary

A 17-year-old senior at Sheldon High School, eligible for special education with a specific learning disability, filed for due process with his mother representing him. He claimed that Elk Grove Unified did not provide the tutoring, accommodations and modifications, and teacher meetings promised in his IEPs from March 1997 onward. The Hearing Officer limited the case to whether services matched the IEPs, because his issue statement did not raise whether the program was appropriate. She also applied a three-year statute of limitations. Before the hearing, the student withdrew a mental health reimbursement claim, and Sacramento County Mental Health was dismissed. The District's attorney was barred from representing it because the District gave notice too late.

The Hearing Officer found that the District failed to provide about 26 hours of tutoring. These hours fell in three periods: spring 1998, June–July 1999 under a written agreement, and fall 1999. Tutoring in all other periods matched the IEPs. Teachers carried out the agreed classroom modifications. One all-teacher conference required by the August 1998 IEP never took place. Because the case manager consulted with the teachers often, this did not deny FAPE. The student asked for a nonpublic school placement as compensatory education. The Hearing Officer denied that request because he had made significant reading progress and was on track to graduate. Instead, she ordered 13 hours of reading tutoring by a credentialed teacher, half of the missed hours, and an IEP meeting within 15 days to arrange it.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled claims that a district did not deliver IEP services. The Hearing Officer added up the missed tutoring hours period by period. She then used equitable discretion under Puyallup to award fewer replacement hours than were missed, based on the student's progress. She also limited the hearing to the issues stated in the parent's issue statement.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partImplementation

    Issue 1a. From March 1997 to the present, did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to conform to his IEPs in the area of tutoring?

    The District failed to provide about 26 tutoring hours (late March–April 1998, June 14–July 13, 1999 under a written agreement, and fall 1999); tutoring otherwise conformed to the IEPs.

  2. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1b. From March 1997 to the present, did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to conform to his IEPs in the area of accommodations and modifications?

    Case manager and English teacher testimony showed the agreed modifications, including retroactive grade adjustments, were implemented in substantial conformity with the IEPs.

  3. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEImplementation

    Issue 1c. From March 1997 to the present, did the District deny Student a FAPE by failing to conform to his IEPs in the area of teachers' meetings?

    The all-teacher conference required by the August 1998 IEP never happened, but the case manager's frequent consultation with teachers kept them informed, so the lapse did not deny FAPE.

  4. Student prevailed in partImplementation

    Issue 2. Is Student entitled to compensatory education due to a denial of FAPE?

    The request for nonpublic school placement was denied. The student had made significant progress and was on track to graduate, so half of the missed hours (13 hours of reading tutoring) was awarded.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of receipt of the decision, District shall convene an IEP meeting to discuss provision of 13 hours of reading tutoring during July and August 2000.
  • Compensatory education. 13 hours of reading tutoring by a credentialed teacher (District teachers permitted) during July–August 2000. If the student is unavailable, he may elect to receive all or part of the hours during the 2000-2001 school year.

Total: 13 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Todd v. Andrews; Houston Independent School District v. Caius R.; Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District

People named in the decision

  • Louise Rocheford-Gould, former District teacher; graduate reading-specialist candidate who tutored student; witness for Student, Elk Grove Unified School District (former)
  • Mark Swanitz, English teacher, now vice-principal; witness for Student, Elk Grove Unified School District
  • Bill Tollestrup, director of special education; District representative and witness, Elk Grove Unified School District
  • Shareen Rendon, program specialist; witness for District, Elk Grove Unified School District
  • Patricia Peak, special education teacher and tutor; witness for District, Elk Grove Unified School District
  • Jeff Miller, special education teacher and tutor; witness for District, Elk Grove Unified School District
  • Laura Kahrs-Emeigh, teacher and tutor; witness for District, Elk Grove Unified School District
  • Canndy Seymour, teacher and special education case manager; witness for District, Elk Grove Unified School District
  • Suzanne Trefethen, special education department chair and tutor, Elk Grove Unified School District
  • Van Vu, SEHO Hearing Officer who handled pre-hearing motions, Special Education Hearing Office
  • Dr. Shefflebine, professor whose training the parent requested for tutors, California State University, Sacramento

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on May 4 and 5, 2000, in Elk Grove, California, before Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.

Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter referred to as Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Elk Grove Unified School District (hereinafter referred to as District) was represented by Bill Tollestrup, District director of special education. Also present on the District's behalf was Shareen Rendon, District program specialist.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Louise Rocheford-Gould, former District teacher; Mark Swanitz, former District teacher and current District vice-principal; MOTHER, Petitioner's mother; and Bill Tollestrup, District director of special education.

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Patricia Peak, District teacher; Jeff Miller, District teacher; Laura Kahrs-Emeigh, District teacher; Canndy Seymour, District teacher and special education case manager; and Shareen Rendon, District program specialist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the parties' closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

(1) From March 1997 to the present, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to conform to his individualized education programs (IEPs) in the areas of:

(a) tutoring (b) accommodations and modifications (c) teachers' meetings (2) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education due to a denial of FAPE?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On May 2, 2000, the Hearing Office added Sacramento County Mental Health (SCMH) as a Respondent in this matter, pursuant to a request from the District. On May 3, 2000, Hearing Officer Van Vu held a telephone conference in this matter. Respondent SCMH requested to be dismissed as a party or, in the alternative, for a continuance of the hearing. The District also requested a continuance of the hearing. Petitioner opposed any continuance and agreed to withdraw his hearing issue regarding reimbursement for mental health therapy services. Because no issues remained involving SCMH, Hearing Officer Vu granted the motion to dismiss SCMH, and denied the motion for a continuance. Hearing Officer Vu denied a motion from Petitioner to change the burden of going forward at the hearing, and Petitioner withdrew a motion to exclude the District's evidence as untimely.

Also at the telephone conference, Petitioner made a motion to prohibit the District from being represented by an attorney at the hearing, on the grounds that the District gave notice of its attorney representation only one and a half days prior to the hearing. In a minute order issued immediately after the telephone conference, Hearing Officer Vu granted Petitioner's motion to bar the District from being represented by an attorney at the hearing, on the grounds that the District did not provide notice of its attorney representation ten days prior to the hearing, as required by California Education Code Section 56507(a). The minute order specified that the District was not prohibited from having its attorney present as an observer pursuant to California Code of Regulations Section 3082(e).

On the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer addressed the issues for hearing, pursuant to Petitioner's issue statement dated March 28, 2000. The March 28 statement set forth issues regarding the District's alleged denial of FAPE due to its alleged failure to provide services promised in STUDENT's IEPs since 1997. However, during the discussion, Petitioner asserted that he also had issues for hearing regarding denial of FAPE due to inappropriateness of his educational program. The Hearing Officer held that Petitioner's issue statement had not put the District on notice that the appropriateness of STUDENT's program would be at issue. The Hearing Officer explained that Petitioner could amend his issue statement to include those new issues but, in that event, the District would be entitled to a continuance of the hearing, so that it would receive the required ten days' notice of issues for hearing. Petitioner indicated that he did not want the hearing continued, and thus did not seek to amend the issue statement. Therefore, the only issue regarding denial of FAPE concerned alleged failure to provide the services specified in those IEPs, not the inappropriateness of the program itself.

Petitioner's issue statement also listed disagreement with the services offered in STUDENT's IEPs from 1990 to 1997. The Hearing Officer explained that the statute of limitations in due process matters is three years from the date of filing for due process hearing. (See Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District (9th Cir. 1987) 817 F.2d 551, 555; California Code of Civil Procedure § 338(a).) Petitioner did not contend that the statute of limitations was tolled in the present case, and the Hearing Officer is not aware of any circumstances indicating tolling of the statute. Thus, Petitioner can only recover for denials which occurred on or after March 20, 1997.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT is a 17-year-old senior at Sheldon High School in the Elk Grove Unified School District. STUDENT is scheduled to graduate high school in June 2000. STUDENT is eligible for special education based on a specific learning disability. The District initially found STUDENT eligible in 1991, when he was in fourth grade. STUDENT received some special education services in elementary school and junior high, including resource specialist program (RSP) services.

For the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT attended ninth grade at the District's Elk Grove High School. For that year, STUDENT's IEP provided for RSP two periods per day, five days a week, with the remainder of his time in regular education. (District's Exh. p.52.) In June 1997, the IEP team met to plan his transition to another District high school, Sheldon High. In July 1997, during the summer prior to STUDENT's sophomore year, the IEP team agreed to new provisions in STUDENT's program for the upcoming school year, including an "all-teacher conference" and "individualized one-to-one instruction in reading/language twice weekly for 20-30 minutes per session." Instead of STUDENT's attendance in the RSP, the IEP provided for the resource specialist to provide "on-going facilitation, monitoring and progress reporting."

On August 21, 1997, STUDENT's four regular education teachers met with Program Specialist Shareen Rendon and Special Education Department Chair Suzanne Trefethen for the all-teacher conference. The meeting notes include the statement that Ms. Trefethen would provide STUDENT's one-to-one instruction during first period. (Petitioner's Exh. IV-P.)

In fall 1997, STUDENT began his sophomore year at Sheldon High. From October 1997 to February 1998, Ms. Trefethen tutored STUDENT on several occasions. (Petitioner's Exh. IV-Y1.) Meanwhile, STUDENT's IEP team met on January 23, February 24 and March 10, 1998. The February 24 IEP states that Mrs. PARENT requested that STUDENT receive tutoring in reading and writing, and further states that the program specialist would contact Mrs. PARENT by March 2 with information about tutoring services. The March 10 IEP specified that "STUDENT will be provided individualized tutoring/instruction in reading and written expression 2 hours per week beginning no later than March 23, 1998 and to be provided through the end of August."

From approximately May to September 1998, STUDENT received tutoring from Patricia Peak, a District special education teacher. (Testimony of Mrs. PARENT, Ms. Peak; District's Exh. pp.10-12.) In August 1998, STUDENT's IEP team convened to determine his placement for his upcoming junior year. The team recommended that STUDENT receive "continued tutorial assistance (individual)...1-3 hours per week," and that "an all-teacher conference will be coordinated...." The IEP also provided that STUDENT would receive RSP monitoring and consultation one to three times per school term, with the remainder of STUDENT's program in regular education.

From September 1998 to February 1999, STUDENT received tutoring from District special education teacher Jeff Miller. (Testimony of Mr. Miller; District's Exh. pp. 13-17.) Also during fall 1998, STUDENT met regularly with Louise Rocheford-Gould, as part of Ms. Rocheford-Gould's graduate program to obtain her reading specialist credential. As part of that program, Ms. Rocheford-Gould tutored STUDENT from October to December 1998. (Testimony of Ms. Rocheford-Gould.)

In November 1998, STUDENT's IEP team met to review his program. That IEP noted that "reading tutoring is ongoing at this time 2 hours per week." The IEP document stated that STUDENT's then-new case manager, Canndy Seymour, explained that she had met individually with each of STUDENT's teachers to "identify teachers' perceptions of strengths and needs and get current progress reports." (Testimony of Ms. Seymour; Petitioner's Exh. IV-KK.) The IEP provided that Ms. Seymour would contact STUDENT's English teacher, Mark Swanitz, to discuss modifications for STUDENT. Those modifications included allowing STUDENT to use his home computer to complete lengthy written assignments, and allowing STUDENT extended time to work on tests and on lengthy written assignments.

In January 1999, the IEP team met again to review STUDENT's progress in his program. Ms. Seymour reported that she had spoken with all of STUDENT's second-semester teachers. Mrs. PARENT requested that a different tutor work with STUDENT, instead of Mr. Miller; accordingly, the IEP document stated that "a trained tutor to replace the current instructor providing tutorial services will be identified by 2/9/99 - changes requested by parent."

The IEP team reconvened on February 17, 1999. That IEP confirmed that STUDENT's placement was 98% in regular education, with one hour per week of monitoring and consultation by the resource specialist, and two to three hours per week of individual tutoring. (Petitioner's Exh. IV-NN.) The IEP notes state that STUDENT will receive grade and variable credits for completion of reading tutorial sessions. STUDENT's case manager reported that, during the previous semester, STUDENT's English teacher had implemented modifications for STUDENT, including silent sustained reading, warm-ups and vocabulary modification. (Id.)

Also during February 1999, District teacher Laura Kahrs-Emeigh agreed to become STUDENT's new tutor. STUDENT had his first tutoring session with Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh on February 26, 1999. Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh continued to tutor STUDENT approximately twice a week until the end of the school year. (Testimony of Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh, Mrs. PARENT.)

The IEP team met twice in April 1999, and agreed to extend STUDENT's then-current program. On June 3, 1999, Mrs. PARENT requested a special education due process hearing, which the Hearing Office identified as case no. SN 854-99. On June 11, the parties signed a written agreement that included a provision that the District would provide "up to 3 hours per week of individual tutoring in reading skills for STUDENT beginning the week of June 14 and continuing through the IEP meeting date of July 13, 1999." At the July 13 IEP meeting, the parties agreed that the tutoring in reading would continue at two hours per week through the end of summer school on August 3, 1999, and would begin again when school started in the fall and continue until the IEP team reconvened.

Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh did not tutor STUDENT during the 1999 summer, but Ms. Peak did. (Testimony of Ms. Peak, Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh.) Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh resumed her tutoring sessions with STUDENT when school resumed in September 1999. (Testimony of Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh.) On November 4, 1999, the IEP team convened and outlined modifications to STUDENT's program. Those modifications included opportunities to turn in late work, to rewrite assignments, to receive extra time to complete assignments, and to be graded for effort and improvement. (Petitioner's Exh. IV-ZZ.)

In a subsequent IEP dated December 2, 1999, the IEP document reflected Ms.Kahrs-Emeigh's reports of STUDENT's progress in their reading tutorial sessions. (Petitioner's Exh. C.) That IEP noted that Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh had tutored STUDENT twice a week for one hour per session. Regarding future scheduling of tutoring, the IEP stated that "schedule has fluctuated as needed, with STUDENT assuming responsibility for rescheduling. Parent agrees with a plan of flexible scheduling as needed." (Id.) The IEP document specified that STUDENT's program was 90% regular education and 10% special education; the IEP identified STUDENT's designated instructional services as resource services for forty minutes per week and mental health services for 45 minutes per week, but did not identify a specific amount of tutoring services that STUDENT would receive. (Petitioner's Exhs. A, C.) Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh continued to tutor STUDENT from December 1999 through spring 2000. She tutored STUDENT on only a few occasions in January and February 2000, but more frequently in March and April as STUDENT sought tutoring more often.

In February 2000, the parties agreed to dismiss case no. SN 854-99. On March 20, 2000, the Hearing Office received another due process request from Mrs. PARENT, initiating the present proceeding. As of the hearing conducted in early May 2000, STUDENT was scheduled to graduate from Sheldon High in June 2000.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

(1)(a) From March 1997 to the present, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to conform to his individualized education programs (IEPs) in the area of tutoring?

Petitioner contends that the District did not provide the full amount of tutoring services specified in STUDENT's IEPs, although Petitioner does not allege any failure to provide those services for the period from May to September 1998. The District contends that, for the entire time period from March 1997 to May 2000, it provided all tutoring as specified in the IEPs. The District further contends that any failure to provide tutoring was "due primarily to parent's insistence on specific individuals and/or specific types of training." (District's Closing Brief, p.5.)

Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and state law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code § 56000.) Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; California Education Code § 56000.) "FAPE" is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards, include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and that are provided at public expense and in conformity with an IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)

The standard for determining whether a local educational agency's provision of services substantively provided a FAPE involves three factors, as follows: whether the services were designed to address the student's unique needs; whether the services will provide educational benefit to him; and whether the services conform to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034.) As previously discussed in the "Procedural Matters" section of this decision, in the present case the only issue is whether or not the services provided conformed to STUDENT's IEPs.

July 1997-February 1998

Regarding the District's alleged failure to provide tutoring specified in the IEPs, the July 1997 IEP was the first of STUDENT's IEPs to include tutoring services. That IEP provided that STUDENT would receive "individualized one-to-one instruction in reading/language twice weekly for 20-30 minutes per session." While the IEP does not specify the date that the tutoring would begin, the IEP stated that STUDENT's placement date was August 25, 1997. Notes from the All-Teacher Conference on August 21, 1997, state that "Mrs. Trefethen will begin working with STUDENT the second week of school, and will develop a prescriptive instructional plan within two weeks (by Sept.12)." Accordingly, Suzanne Trefethen, chair of the school's special education department, tutored STUDENT on several occasions from September 1997 to February 1998. At the January 1998 IEP meeting, Mrs. Trefethen reported that "in her individual sessions with STUDENT (approximately 30 minutes per session) STUDENT made rapid progress, he was actively involved in the instruction on a mature level. Work focused on decoding, sound combinations, attention to oral reading accuracy." (Petitioner's Exh. IV-X.)

The evidence is sparse regarding the frequency of Mrs. Trefethen's tutoring sessions. The District explained that Mrs. Trefethen was not available to testify at the hearing. No timesheets or similar documentary evidence was submitted. Petitioner offers his mother's record of the tutoring schedule, which reflects that only eight tutoring sessions occurred between October 26, 1997, and January 23, 1998. (Petitioner's Exh. IV-Y; see also Petitioner's Exh. I-B.) Mrs. PARENT's logbook reflects both occasions when tutoring did not occur because Mrs. Trefethen was unavailable, and occasions when tutoring did not occur because STUDENT was not available. (Id.)

In any event, Mrs. PARENT's records alone are not sufficient to support an evidentiary finding that those eight sessions were the only sessions during that three-month period. First, Mrs. PARENT's logbook, itself an out-of-court statement, is primarily based on out-of-court statements from STUDENT. Second, Petitioner's account of events may contain some inaccuracies, as demonstrated by some inaccurate dates in the chronology in his evidence binder's Table of Contents.

Moreover, testing conducted in January 1998 demonstrated that STUDENT had made significant growth in his reading and writing skills, when compared with his test scores from August 1997. (Petitioner's Exh. IV-W.) Petitioner's progress in reading and writing skills does not support Petitioner's allegation that he did receive the promised tutoring in reading and writing. As noted by the school administrator who conducted the testing, "the growth in the majority of areas is impressive, and it would be reasonable to assume that the work in his individualized program has had a substantial impact." (Id.)

Thus, the available evidence supports the District's position that STUDENT received the tutoring as specified in his IEP. In light of all evidence, no failure to provide services has been demonstrated.

March 1998-September 1998

Petitioner does not allege any failure to provide tutoring services from May to September 1998, when District teacher Patricia Peak tutored STUDENT. Petitioner alleges that Ms. Peak missed a few tutoring sessions in August 1998, but she provided those missed sessions in September 1998. (See also testimony of Ms. Peak; District's Exh. p.10.)

The only alleged nonconformity in tutoring for this period concerns April 1998, and the last week of March 1998. As specified in STUDENT's IEP dated March 10, 1998, the District was to provide STUDENT with "individualized tutoring/instruction in reading and written expression 2 hours per week beginning no later than March 23, 1998, and to be provided through the end of August." Petitioner alleges that Ms. Peak did not begin tutoring STUDENT until May 1998. In addition to testimony of Petitioner's mother in support of this allegation, correspondence from Mrs. PARENT to the District confirms that Ms. Peak tutored STUDENT from May to September 1998. (Testimony of Mrs. PARENT; Petitioner's Exhs.I-B, IV-OO.)

Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's program did not conform to his IEP for approximately five weeks, during which time he did not receive the two hours of tutoring each week that was specified in his IEPs. In response, the District argues that "any gaps in the provision of tutoring services were due primarily to parent insistence on specific individuals and/or specific types of training." (District's Closing Brief, p.3.) Petitioner's mother acknowledged that, beginning in February 1998, she requested that the individual assigned to tutor STUDENT have training by Dr. Shefflebine, a professor at California State University, Sacramento. (Petitioner's Closing Brief, p.5.) As one recent court decision noted, educational agencies often have difficulty locating qualified individuals to provide a student's educational services. (Houston Independent School District v. Cauis R., 30 IDELR 578, 582 (S.D.Tex.1998). That court stated that an educational agency's brief delay in implementing an IEP did not constitute a denial of FAPE where the agency offered the student compensatory services and the overall amount of services that the student received was not affected. (Id. at 582.)

In the present case, there is no evidence to suggest that the District offered additional tutoring to replace the tutoring missed in March and April 1998. Thus, that absence of tutoring services constitutes a failure to provide STUDENT with ten hours of tutoring specified in his IEP for that five-week time period.

September 1998-February 1999

In August 1998, STUDENT's IEP team agreed that STUDENT's placement for the upcoming school year would include individual reading tutoring for one to three hours per week. (Petitioner's Exh. IV-FF.) Petitioner alleges that Jeff Miller tutored STUDENT on four occasions only. (Petitioner's Closing Brief, p.3.) In contrast, Mr. Miller's time sheets reflect that he tutored STUDENT approximately two hours per week from early October 1998 until early February 1999. (District's Exhs. pp.13-17; see also testimony of Mr. Miller.) Similarly, STUDENT's November 1998 IEP document confirms that "reading tutoring is ongoing at this time 2 hours per week." In light of the evidence regarding Mr. Miller's tutoring for two hours per week, the Hearing Officer concludes that the services provided were in conformity with STUDENT's IEPs for this period. (Footnote 2)

February 1999-June 1999

STUDENT's IEP dated January 23, 1999, indicated that a "trained tutor" would replace Mr. Miller, pursuant to Mrs. PARENT's request. The next IEP meeting occurred on February 17, 1999, at which meeting the participants agreed that STUDENT would receive two to three hours of individual tutoring per week. Accordingly, from February 1999 to June 1999, STUDENT received tutoring from District teacher Laura Kahrs-Emeigh. (Testimony of Mrs. PARENT, Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh.) Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh testified that she first met with STUDENT on February 26, 1999, and held tutoring sessions with him on seven occasions in March, six occasions in April, eight occasions in May, and two occasions in June 1999, before the end of the school year. Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh had kept extensive records regarding her tutoring sessions with STUDENT, and was able to reliably recall details of those tutoring sessions. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh's testimony was credible, and concludes that Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh provided the amount of tutoring alleged in her testimony. As this amount of tutoring approximately totaled the minimum two hours per week specified in the February 1999 IEP, no failure to provide services occurred for the February to June 1999 time period.June-July 1999

On June 11, 1999, the parties signed a written agreement, titled "Agreement For Extension Of Special Education Services." That agreement included a provision that the District would provide "up to 3 hours per week of individual tutoring in reading skills for STUDENT beginning the week of June 14 and continuing through the IEP meeting date of July 13, 1999." (Petitioner's Exh. IV-UU.) Petitioner now alleges that no tutor was provided between June 14 and July 13, until Patricia Peak resumed tutoring STUDENT in mid-July. (Footnote 3) (Petitioner's Exh. I-B.) The District offered no evidence to indicate that such tutoring was provided. Again, the District's position appears to be that "any gaps in the provision of tutoring services were due primarily to parent insistence on specific individuals and/or specific types of training." (District's Closing Brief, p.3.)

Given that there is no evidence that any tutoring was provided during the one-month period in question, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not provide the services specified in the agreement dated June 11, 1999. The language of the June 11 agreement specifies that "up to 3 hours per week" would be provided, although notably the agreement does not provide a minimum amount of tutoring. Clearly the parties agreed to some minimum amount, because the alternative interpretation would have imposed no obligation on the District. Thus, considering that STUDENT's IEPs generally provided for at least thirty minutes per tutoring session, the District failed to provide the minimum of at least thirty minutes of tutoring per week for the period from June 14 to July 13, 1999. In order for his program to conform to the agreement, STUDENT should have received at least four hours of tutoring during that time period.

July-November 1999

At the IEP meeting on July 13, 1999, the parties agreed that the tutoring in reading would continue at two hours per week through the end of summer school on August 3, 1999, and would begin again when school started in the fall.

In July 1999, Patricia Peak resumed tutoring STUDENT until early August 1999. (Testimony of Ms. Peak.) Thus, no nonconformity occurred in July or August 1999.

In September 1999, Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh resumed tutoring STUDENT. Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh testified that she tutored STUDENT on four occasions in September, two occasions in October, and one in November. Given that the July 1999 IEP provides that STUDENT was to receive two hours of tutoring per week, STUDENT's services were not in substantial conformity with his IEP during fall 1999. In order for his program to comport with his IEP, STUDENT should have received approximately twelve additional hours of tutoring during that three-month period.

December 1999-May 2000

In an IEP dated December 2, 1999, the team agreed that tutoring would be on a flexible schedule as needed, and that it would be STUDENT's responsibility to schedule future sessions. (Petitioner's Exh. C.) Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh testified that, thereafter, the frequency of her tutoring sessions with STUDENT varied depending on when he sought her out. Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh reported that she tutored STUDENT on four occasions in December1999, three in January 2000, one in February, four in March, and six in April. As of Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh's testimony on May 5, 2000, she had tutored STUDENT twice so far that month.

During this period, the IEP did not provide for a specified number of tutoring hours or sessions. STUDENT received several hours of tutoring during this time period. Thus, no failure to provide services specified in the December 1999 IEP has been demonstrated.

Thus, analysis of tutoring services provided from March 1997 to May 2000 revealed only one brief time period during which STUDENT did not receive the amount of tutoring services promised: September to November 1999. During that period, STUDENT received approximately twelve fewer hours than was specified in his IEP. During all other time periods in question, STUDENT's receipt of tutoring services was in substantial conformity with his then-current IEP.

(1)(b) From March 1997 to the present, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to conform to his individualized education programs (IEPs) in the area of accommodations and modifications?

Some of STUDENT's IEPs have included accommodations and modifications to be implemented in his classes. In particular, on November 2, 1998, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT's case manager, Canndy Seymour, would contact STUDENT's English teacher, Mark Swanitz, to discuss modifications for STUDENT. (Testimony of Ms. Seymour; Petitioner's Exh. IV-KK.) The IEP document identified modifications including allowing STUDENT to use his home computer to complete lengthy written assignments, allowing STUDENT extended time to work on tests and on lengthy written assignments, and revising STUDENT's past grades based on retroactive implementation of modifications. (Id.)

In her testimony, Ms. Seymour explained that the agreed-upon modifications were implemented. Ms. Seymour described the modifications as including shortened assignments, extended time on homework assignments, exemption from some reading assignments, and the option of taking tests in a location different than the regular classroom. (Testimony of Ms. Seymour.) Ms. Seymour reported that initially there was some confusion between Mr. Swanitz and Mrs. PARENT regarding implementation of the modifications, but thereafter Ms. Seymour spoke with Mr. Swanitz and reached agreement about implementing the modifications. (Id.) Ms. Seymour's report of these modifications is also reflected in the IEP document dated February 17, 1999, which stated that "modifications were applied to English II Term I included: SSR, warm-ups and vocabulary modifications."

Similarly, Mr. Swanitz testified regarding the modifications implemented for STUDENT in eleventh-grade English class. Mr. Swanitz described how STUDENT was allowed to take practice Scholastic Aptitude Tests in place of the class's regular vocabulary and in-class reading assignments, was allowed to write shorter assignments than the other students, and received shorter vocabulary study lists than the other students, and received extra time to complete assignments. Mr. Swanitz also described how he and Ms. Seymour adjusted STUDENT's grades based on retroactive implementation of these modifications.

For the following school year, STUDENT's IEP also included some modifications. The IEP document dated November 4, 1999, stated that "STUDENT Is Allowed To Turn In Late Work - Modifications Also Include More Time, Grading For Growth, Effort Points, Rewrite Opportunities." (Petitioner's Exh. IV-ZZ.) In her testimony, Ms. Seymour reported that all of the agreed-upon modifications had been implemented, and that none of STUDENT's teachers ever resisted making the modifications. Ms. Seymour noted that STUDENT was still responsible for completing his senior project this year, and that special education students are just as accountable for doing their senior projects as are regular education students.

Thus, there is no evidence to support Petitioner's allegation that the accommodations and modifications were not implemented as promised in the IEPs. The Hearing Officer concludes that the accommodations and modifications were in substantial conformity with the then-current IEPs.

(1)(c) From March 1997 to the present, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to conform to his individualized education programs (IEPs) in the area of teacher's meetings?

Some of STUDENT's IEPs specify that his teachers will meet in an "all-teacher conference," or will consult with STUDENT's case manager. In particular, the July 1997 IEP specified that STUDENT's teachers would meet for an "all-teacher conference." Accordingly, that meeting occurred on August 21, 1997, attended by STUDENT's teachers, Ms. Trefethen, and Program Specialist Shareen Rendon. (Petitioner's Exh. IV-Q; testimony of Ms. Rendon.)

For the 1998-99 and 1999-2000 school years, STUDENT's case manager, Ms. Seymour, frequently consulted with STUDENT's teachers. Ms. Seymour testified that she met with each teacher at least once every three weeks and met with others more frequently, up to twice a week in some cases. Ms. Seymour regularly reported the IEP team and to Mrs. PARENT specifically regarding the teachers' reports on STUDENT's progress. (Testimony of Ms. Seymour; Petitioner's Exh. IV-KK, IV-NN

The only potential area of failure concerns the IEP dated August 25, 1998. That IEP provided that "an All-Teacher Conference will be coordinated by Suzanne Trefethen to consult on reading strengths and deficits and alert them to inconsistent study habits...." (Petitioner's Exh. IV-FF.) Despite this clear statement, there is no evidence that this meeting took place. Thus, the District's failure to arrange this meeting constituted failure to comport with that IEP.

However, the entirety of the evidence in this case demonstrates that this isolated occurrence did not constitute an overall denial of FAPE. The purpose of the All-Teacher Conference was to consult with STUDENT's teachers about STUDENT's reading strengths and deficits and alert his teachers to problems with his study habits. Given the undisputed evidence of extensive consultation between STUDENT's teachers and his case manager, it is clear that STUDENT's teachers were kept informed regarding his strengths, deficits and particular problem areas. Even if one All-Teacher Conference did not occur, STUDENT's teachers were nevertheless kept well-informed about STUDENT's special needs. Thus, the failure to hold one of the All-Teacher Conferences did not rise to the level of a denial of FAPE. (2) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education due to a denial of FAPE?

In Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts (1985) 471 U.S. 358, the Supreme Court concluded that equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA. Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. (Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir.1994) 31 F.3d 1489; see also Todd v. Andrews (11th Cir. 1991) 933 F.2d 1576.) The purpose of compensatory education is to "ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA." (Parents of Student W., 31 F.3d at 1497.) Compensatory education does not include an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity or time missed. (Id.)

In the present case, the District failed to provide all agreed-upon tutoring hours during short periods from March to April 1998, June to July 1999, and September to December 1999. Specifically, the District provided twelve fewer hours than the IEP specified for the September/December 1999 period. Regarding the March/April 1998 and June/July 1999 periods, in each instance the District had approximately a one-month delay between when the services should have commenced and when the services actually commenced. For all three time periods combined, the District failed to provide a total of approximately twenty-six tutoring hours specified in the IEPs. Petitioner argues that compensatory education for these deficiencies should be in the form of placement at a non-public school. However, there is no persuasive evidence to establish that such placement would be appropriate and little evidence to indicate how the denial of services negatively affected STUDENT's education. While STUDENT received twenty-six fewer hours of tutoring than specified in his IEPs, he nevertheless received regular tutoring over the course of his high school career. Indeed, STUDENT's tutors and his case manager all testified that STUDENT had made significant progress on his reading, that he was on track to graduate high school in June 2000, and that his academic skills were more than adequate to allow him to pursue higher education or employment after graduation. (Testimony of Ms. Peak, Ms. Kahrs-Emeigh, Ms. Seymour.) Ms. Seymour testified that STUDENT was the highest academic achiever within her caseload of special education students.

Considering the testimony from STUDENT's tutors describing the progress he made during tutoring, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not need to receive all twenty-six tutoring hours to replace the lost services. In light of all evidence regarding STUDENT's current needs, the Hearing Officer concludes that the appropriate compensation for the lost tutoring hours is provision of half of the tutoring hours that the District failed to provide. Thus, the District shall provide STUDENT with approximately thirteen hours of reading tutoring by a credentialed teacher. These tutoring services shall be provided during July and August 2000, and may be provided by District teachers. Should Petitioner be unavailable to attend tutoring during these summer months, he may instead elect to receive the all or part of the tutoring during the 2000-2001 school year.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen calendar days of receipt of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to discuss provision of thirteen hours of reading tutoring during July and August 2000. If Petitioner is unavailable for tutoring during July or August 2000, he may instead elect to receive all or part of the thirteen hours of tutoring during the 2000-2001 school year.

2. All of Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

(1) From March 1997 to the present, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to provide services in his individualized education programs (IEPs) in the areas of:

(a) tutoring

Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that he was denied thirteen hours of tutoring from September to December 1999. The District prevailed on the remainder of this issue.

(b) accommodations and modifications

The District prevailed on this issue.

(c) teachers' meetings

The District prevailed on this issue.

(2) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education due to a denial of FAPE?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that he is entitled to thirteen hours of tutoring in compensation for a denial of FAPE. The District prevailed on the remainder of this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: June 22, 2000 ___________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. As is addressed more extensively in the "Procedural Matter" portion of the decision, the Hearing Officer has clarified Petitioner's statement of the issues.

2. Petitioner also alleges that Mr. Miller was not qualified as a tutor because he was not certified in the "Language!" program. However, STUDENT's August 1998 and November 1998 IEPs do not specify that STUDENT's tutor needed to be certified in that program. Thus, Mr. Miller's lack of certification in the "Language!" program does not constitute a nonconformity with the IEPs. To the extent that Petitioner is alleging that he needed a tutor certified in the "Language!" program, that allegation is outside the scope of the issues at this hearing.

3. The June 11 agreement did not contain any reference to any due process proceeding, nor did it indicate that the agreement was any type of mediation or settlement. The District did not object to admission of the agreement, nor did it object to the Hearing Officer considering the District's fulfillment of its obligations under the agreement.