California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 29, 2005

San Mateo Union High School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 456-05 · Hearing Officer Claudia J. Wrazel

San Mateo Union High School District did not deny FAPE by firing and replacing a student's longtime one-to-one aide.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 5 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

At the start of the hearing, the Hearing Officer denied the Student's motion to reconsider the denial of consolidation with his own case, No. SN05-00689. The issues were reformulated on the second hearing day. The decision notes that Case No. SN05-00689, which raises assessment, behavior plan and reimbursement claims, was off calendar.

Summary

San Mateo Union High School District filed for due process after it fired a ninth grader's one-to-one instructional aide and the parents kept the student home. The 15-year-old attended Aragon High School. He was eligible for special education as visually impaired and also had significant autism-related needs. The aide had worked with him since sixth grade and also tutored him at home. Both sides agreed he needed a full-day one-to-one aide.

The Hearing Officer found he did not need this particular aide to receive a FAPE. The district understood his academic, safety and behavior needs. Another aide, Leila de Castro, had worked with him daily in history class for months without problems and was ready to take over the next school day. The district hired a permanent aide within a month.

Replacing the aide was not a change in placement that required an IEP meeting. The IEP called for a district-provided aide, not a named person, and the aide's role had shrunk in high school. The law did not require a formal transition plan. The district did violate state law by not holding an IEP meeting within 30 days of the father's written request. However, the district had offered to meet, and the father said he would set a date after hiring a lawyer, so his ability to take part was not seriously harmed. No remedy was ordered.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a staffing change when the IEP called for a one-to-one aide but did not name a person. The Hearing Officer treated replacing the aide as a personnel matter, not a change in placement. A missed 30-day IEP meeting deadline did not deny FAPE because the district offered to meet and the parent put off scheduling.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. During the 2004-2005 school year, did Student need a one-to-one instructional aide in the classroom?

    The parties stipulated that Student needed a one-to-one aide, and the Hearing Officer found the aide was a related service required for him to benefit from his education.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Was this particular aide necessary for Student to receive a FAPE?

    The district understood Student's needs and behaviors and had a qualified, trained interim aide ready and a permanent aide hired soon after, so the particular aide was not needed for a FAPE.

  3. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3A. Did the removal and replacement of the aide constitute a change in Student's educational placement or program that should have been addressed at an IEP meeting?

    The IEP called for a district-provided aide, not a named person, and the aide's role had shrunk in high school, so replacing him was not a change requiring an IEP meeting.

  4. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3B. Should the District have had a transition plan in place to help Student adjust to a new aide, and did it fail to do so?

    No formal transition plan was legally required. The district's informal plan prevented any loss of educational opportunity, and the May 2004 IEP had addressed his anticipated transition needs.

  5. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 3C. Did the District's failure to hold an IEP meeting in response to Father's request constitute a violation of its procedural obligations to the Student?

    Not holding an IEP meeting within 30 days of the written request violated Education Code section 56343.5. Parent participation was not seriously harmed because the district offered to meet and the father deferred scheduling.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • No relief ordered. The Hearing Officer found the district's removal and replacement of the aide did not deny FAPE.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No. 23; 34 C.F.R. § 300.136(f); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3042(a); Educ. Code § 56343(c); Educ. Code § 56343.5

People named in the decision

  • Marvin Meyers, director of special education, San Mateo Union High School District
  • Judy Warner, school psychologist, San Mateo Union High School District
  • Catharine Davis, Ed.D., inclusion specialist and co-case manager, San Mateo Union High School District
  • Leila de Castro, instructional aide (interim one-to-one aide), San Mateo Union High School District
  • Michael Flynn, physical education teacher, San Mateo Union High School District
  • Lisa Fox, speech-language pathologist, San Mateo Union High School District
  • Michael Gibbons, special education history teacher and co-case manager, San Mateo Union High School District
  • Lillian Cotter-Heslop (also spelled Cotter-Haslop), instructional aide (permanent replacement one-to-one aide), San Mateo Union High School District
  • William Foss, vision specialist / orientation and mobility specialist, San Mateo County Department of Education
  • Robert Patterson, Psy.D., psychoeducational assessor (1999 assessment)
  • Ms. Shin, sixth grade language arts teacher, Foster City School District
  • Daisy Jiminez, personnel office staff, San Mateo Union High School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law, in San Mateo, California, on May 31 and June 1, 7, and 9, 2005.

Petitioner San Mateo Union High School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Diane Finkelstein. Also present on the District’s behalf was Marvin Meyers, director of special education. Respondent STUDENT (STUDENTor Student) was represented by attorney Richard Ruderman. Also present on the Student’s behalf were his father, FATHER, and his grandparents, GRANDPARENTS.

The District called the following witnesses: Judy Warner, school psychologist; Catharine Davis, Ed. D., inclusion specialist and STUDENT’S co-case manager; Leila de Castro, instructional aide; Michael Flynn, physical education (PE) teacher; Lisa Fox, speech/language (S/L) pathologist; Michael Gibbons, special education history teacher and STUDENT’S co-case manager; Lillian Cotter-Heslop, instructional aide; and Marvin Meyers.

The Student called the following witnesses: William Foss, vision specialist for the San Mateo County Department of Education; “E,” former instructional aide for the District and current home aide for STUDENT; and FATHER. (Footnote 1)

Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of closing briefs on June 27, 2005, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the beginning of the hearing, the Student sought reconsideration of an order denying his earlier request to consolidate this matter with Case No. SN05-00689, a due process case filed by the Student against the District. (See Summary Order, May 27, 2005.) The Student argued that the issue presented for hearing in this case -- whether the District’s dismissal from employment of the STUDENT’s instructional aide, and its replacement of that aide, denied the Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) – was not within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. In addition, the Student argued that if the cases were not consolidated, any findings in this hearing regarding the District’s success or failure in providing a FAPE to the Student could have unintended res judicata effects upon the Student’s due process case.

There is no provision in special education law for reconsideration of an order of the Hearing Office. However, the Hearing Office generally has held that reconsideration of an order may be appropriate where new or different facts, circumstances or law justify reconsideration, and a party seeks reconsideration within a reasonable time.

In this case, the Hearing Officer found that no new facts or law justified reconsideration. The Hearing Officer found that the District’s issue for hearing was appropriately within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office as set forth in Section 56501(a) of the Education Code, and that a determination of the narrow issue of the appropriateness of the District’s termination and replacement of the instructional aide would not affect the broader FAPE issues set forth in the Student’s case. Accordingly, the Student’s motion for reconsideration of the order denying consolidation was denied.

On the second day of the hearing, after evidence had been taken from two District witnesses, the Hearing Officer revisited the Student’s concern that the District’s issue for hearing, as currently formulated, might have unintended res judicata effects on the Student’s FAPE issues in its pending due process case. In addition, the Hearing Officer expressed the concern that evidence relating to whether the District was justified in dismissing the instructional aide might raise labor issues outside the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer reformulated the issues on the second day of the hearing as set forth below.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Issue No. 1: During the 2004-2005 school year, did STUDENT need a one-to-one instructional aide in the classroom?

Issue No. 2: Was this particular aide necessary for STUDENT to receive a free, appropriate, public education (FAPE)?

Issue No. 3: Did the manner in which the District removed and replaced the aide constitute a procedural violation sufficient to deny STUDENT a FAPE?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The parties stipulate that STUDENT needs a one-to-one instructional aide in the classroom. However, the District contends that STUDENT did not need this particular aide, E, to receive a FAPE, because an appropriately qualified and trained aide was available to replace E, and because STUDENT had demonstrated an ability to work successfully with other aides.

Further, the District contends that the manner in which it terminated E’s employment and replaced him with another aide complied with its procedural obligations to STUDENT. Specifically, the District asserts that although its personnel policies prevented it from notifying the PARENTS of E’s pending termination, it promptly notified them once the termination occurred. In addition, the District asserts that prior to E’s termination, it had prepared a plan to ensure STUDENT’S smooth transition from E’s services to those of an interim aide, and eventually to the services of a new aide hired by the District.

The Student contends that he needs E’s services to receive a FAPE because E has been his classroom aide for over three years, knows him better than any District personnel, and is the person best equipped to deliver his instruction and control his problem behaviors. In addition, the Student contends that the District was unprepared to replace E as his aide, because it lacked sufficient understanding of his educational needs and problem behaviors to be able to appropriately train a replacement aide for him.

The Student further contends that, even if he did not need this particular aide to receive a FAPE, the manner in which the District removed and replaced E denied the Student a FAPE. Specifically, the Student contends that the District failed to inform his parents of any plan to address his needs in E’s absence or to include them in the decision-making process in developing such a plan.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student with multiple developmental delays associated with premature birth. He was born more than three months before his due date, hospitalized for the next three months, and diagnosed with “retinopathy of prematurity” (detached retinas and arrested eye growth, leading to blindness) as well as jaundice, respiratory distress syndrome, chronic lung disease, and other conditions resulting from prematurity. Shortly after birth, STUDENT had an eye operation in which “buckles” were implanted to hold his retinas to his optic nerves and thereby preserve some sight.

As a toddler, STUDENT was identified as eligible for special education services as visually impaired, and was enrolled in a special education preschool and later in a kindergarten special day class (SDC). STUDENT is legally blind, but has retained enough vision to read large print. He also can see well enough to move about his immediate environment, although he needs a white cane or an aide to help him travel safely in the community. (D. Exhs. 1, 5.)

In addition to his visual impairment, STUDENT exhibits significant symptoms of autism spectrum disorder, particularly the areas of receptive and expressive communication, adaptive skills, and social interaction. According to a 1999 psycho-educational assessment conducted by Robert Patterson, Psy.D., when STUDENT was ten years old, STUDENT’S basic math, reading, and decoding skills tested at his then third grade level, and he had an above average memory for digits, but he was significantly below grade level in his ability to process or remember lengthy verbal directions. In adaptive skills, STUDENT could dress himself and use the toilet with minimal assistance, and knew to avoid dangerous objects and places, but did not appear to understand what constituted socially acceptable behavior. STUDENT showed more interest in adults than peers, did not understand social cues or appropriate personal space, perseverated on topics, and was unable to sustain a conversation. Finally, Dr. Patterson observed that STUDENT’S ability to learn was hampered by his short attention span, lack of organization, and low tolerance for frustration:

He leaves his seat in the classroom or in other situations where remaining seated is expected and he is easily frustrated in his efforts. He has difficulty completing work, has no friends, avoids or expresses reluctance about engaging in tasks that require sustained mental effort, such as homework, and has difficulty sustaining attention in tasks or play activities. He has trouble concentrating in class and does not seem to listen to what is being said to him. He needs close supervision to get through assignments and . . . has difficulty organizing tasks and activities. (D. Exh. 5.) (Footnote 2)

STUDENT’S parents wanted him to be included with his peers as much as possible, and at their request, STUDENT was enrolled in regular education classes in the Foster City School District (FCSD) from first through eighth grade. (Testimony of FATHER). Since at least the fifth grade, STUDENT’S educational program has included the provision of a one-to-one instructional aide in the classroom, as well as the services of an S/L pathologist, vision impairment/orientation and mobility (VI/OM) specialist, and adaptive physical education (APE) specialist. (D. Exhs. 1-5.) (Footnote 3)

The hiring of E as STUDENT’S aide

After FCSD attempted but failed to retain an instructional aide for STUDENT’S sixth grade year, FATHER tried to recruit an aide at local colleges without success, and finally advertised for an aide on the Internet. Among those who responded was E, a graduate in psychology from the University of California at Santa Cruz who had previous experience working in a mental hospital. FATHER was impressed with E’s resume, references, and interview, and sent him to FCSD to apply for the position as STUDENT’S instructional aide. FCSD was pleased to hire E, since it had found no one else suitable for the position. (Testimony of FATHER.)

From the time E was hired, STUDENT made “excellent progress.” E had initiative, organization, and diligence, and became very involved in STUDENT’S sixth grade program. STUDENT’S tantrums, or “meltdowns,” diminished, and when E offered his services as a home aide as well as a school aide, the PARENTS gratefully accepted. From sixth through eighth grade, E worked as STUDENT’S full-time school aide and also tutored STUDENT after school for two to three hours per day. (Testimony of FATHER and E.)

STUDENT’S middle school teachers praised E’s ability to work with STUDENT in the classroom. They noted, however, that STUDENT’S tendency to talk, sing, and make other noises in class was having a negative impact on other students’ ability to learn, and that strategies to discourage this behavior had been tried with “inconsistent success.” (S. Exhs. 1007, 1012, 1037-38.)

Further, the teachers expressed concerns that STUDENT’S class materials and tests were so significantly modified by E that they were unsure of what STUDENT actually was learning or retaining. (Id.) STUDENT’S sixth grade Language Arts teacher, Ms. Shin, noted that it was difficult for her to assess STUDENT’S learning and organizational skills because E was his primary instructor, and most of his work was completed outside of class with E’s assistance. Nor could she determine how STUDENT was progressing, because he was excused from work he could not or would not do, his assignments were created by E, his tests were modified by E, and he was only graded on work or test questions that he completed. Ms. Shin stated that the work STUDENT completed was “very different than anything I teach.” (S. Exhs. 1010-1011.) Similar concerns were expressed by other middle school teachers. (Testimony of Ms. Warner and Mr. Meyers; S. Exhs. 1038-39.)

STUDENT’S transition to high school

In March of 2004, District special education director Mr. Meyers met with the PARENTS to discuss the placement options that would be available to STUDENT when he entered ninth grade at Aragon High School (AHS) in the fall. In May, Mr. Meyers and other District and AHS personnel attended STUDENT’S annual IEP to help plan his transition to high school. The team discussed STUDENT’S current performance levels, and determined that in most classes, his need for a modified curriculum would be best addressed by special education teachers. Accordingly, the team designed a program that included SDC classes in history and English, a resource specialist program (RSP) in math, and a VI/OM class period. This represented a significant change from middle school, where STUDENT had been placed in regular education classes with a program designed and implemented by E. STUDENT’S high school program also included a regular education computer class, a regular education PE class with adaptations designed by an APE specialist, and summer school. (Testimony of Dr. Davis and Mr. Meyers; see D. Exh. 1.)

At the May 2004 IEP meeting, the PARENTS urged the District to hire E to be STUDENT’S classroom aide. Mr. Meyers had reservations about doing so because reports from STUDENT’S middle school teachers had raised concerns about whether E could separate his role as a District employee from his role as a home aide employed by the PARENTS. He also was concerned about whether E could adjust to the fact that STUDENT’S SDC and RSP teachers now would be primarily responsible for modifying his curricula and tests, and that E’s role in creating and adapting STUDENT’S program would be considerably reduced. Nevertheless, since E’s knowledge of how to work with STUDENT would be helpful, and since his presence would ease the transition for both STUDENT and his parents, Mr. Meyers agreed to hire E as STUDENT’S aide. (Testimony of Mr. Meyers.)

At the District’s invitation, STUDENT, his parents, and E visited AHS more than once before the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year so STUDENT could meet his teachers and familiarize himself with the campus. Also during this period, District inclusion specialist Dr. Davis, who had observed STUDENT in his middle school classes on several occasions, talked with his middle school teachers, counselors and service providers to get a sense of STUDENT’S strengths and deficits in a classroom setting.

STUDENT’S first months in ninth grade (August - October 2004)

At the beginning of the school year, Dr. Davis observed STUDENT in class every day to see how he was doing and to try to determine the causes for STUDENT’S reported tendency to talk out loud in class. She prepared a “Behavioral Observational Baseline” to develop strategies to deal with STUDENT’S talking and off-task behavior, and met once a week with E and another one-to-one aide, Ms. de Castro, to discuss their students and address any problems. (D. Exh. 9.) In addition, Dr. Davis spoke regularly with STUDENT’S teachers and his co-case manager, Mr. Gibbons, and met with the PARENTS once a month at school to discuss STUDENT’S progress. (D. Exh. 10.)

From Dr. Davis’ observations and the reports of his teachers, STUDENT appeared to begin ninth grade at AHS without any noticeable difficulties. He adjusted well to his new teachers and new school setting. His talking in class continued to be an issue, but his teachers addressed it as part of normal classroom discipline, and STUDENT generally complied with directives from E or a teacher to quiet down and return to his class work. (Testimony of Dr. Davis and Mr. Gibbons.)

Dr. Davis believed STUDENT’S primary deficits were his vision and his difficulties with pragmatic speech and social interaction. In addition, STUDENT’S PE teacher Mr. Flynn had expressed concerns about STUDENT’S inclusion in regular PE, since his medical records indicated that a blow to the head could dislodge the buckles on his retinas, causing him to lose his remaining vision. This concern was discussed in the monthly meetings with the PARENTS, and STUDENT’S APE therapist modified his PE program to make sure he did not participate in ball-throwing or other dangerous activities. (Testimony of Dr. Davis and Mr. Flynn.)

According to E, STUDENT’S adjustment to high school was more difficult than it appeared to others. Since beginning to work with STUDENT in sixth grade, E had known STUDENT to experience tantrums, or “meltdowns,” when he would scream, cry, drop to his knees, hide under his desk, or otherwise lose emotional control when frustrated or upset. E had learned to cope with this behavior in middle school by taking STUDENT for walks until he calmed down. Over time, E learned to recognize “precursors” to these meltdowns, such as when STUDENT would go limp in his seat, raise his voice, or begin to shake. When he noticed these precursor behaviors, E would take STUDENT on short walks (“once around the building”) to help him decompress and avoid full-scale meltdowns. (Testimony of E.) E testified that STUDENT’S teachers and peers were unaware of these precursor behaviors, and did not notice that STUDENT experienced them twice a week or more in most of his classes at the beginning of the school year. E would take him for walks to head off more serious meltdowns, and the behaviors subsided as STUDENT adjusted to his new school. (Id.) (Footnote 4)

The District’s concerns about E’s performance

The District had hired E on a probationary basis for the first six months of the 2004-2005 school year, with a decision on permanent employment to be based on his performance evaluations for that period. According to Dr. Davis, E missed several days of work during the first weeks of school. Dr. Davis felt his absences were excessive and were detrimental to STUDENT, since the PARENTS kept STUDENT home from school when E was not there to work with him. (Footnote 5) Dr. Davis also believed that when E was at school, he should be assisting other aides and teachers when STUDENT did not need his direct attention, but E failed to do so. On one occasion when STUDENT was absent from school, E read a travel magazine instead of helping other teachers.

Dr. Davis also was concerned that E seemed unwilling to work as part of a team to help STUDENT adjust to high school. When she asked E for a list of known “triggers” for STUDENT’S problem behaviors and insights as to how he dealt with them, E’s only response was to suggest that others could learn his techniques by watching him work with STUDENT. When Dr. Davis suggested new teaching techniques for STUDENT, E often resisted her suggestions, responding,“that won’t work,” “I’ve tried that,” or “STUDENT won’t do that.” Dr. Davis also was displeased with E’s decision to excuse STUDENT from having to perform significant portions of his final examination in math, and insisted that E bring STUDENT back to finish the exam a few days later. (Testimony of Dr. Davis.) In preparation for E’s mid-semester probationary evaluation, Dr. Davis spoke with STUDENT’S therapists and teachers, and received other unsatisfactory reports about E’s work. S/L therapist Ms. Fox noted that, when she explained STUDENT’S pragmatic speech goals to E in an effort to enlist E’s help in reinforcing those goals throughout the school day, E responded, “STUDENT doesn’t do conversation.” PE teacher Mr. Flynn expressed concerns that E did not comply with his safety instructions regarding STUDENT’S use of the weight room, or his directive to stand by with a safety crook when STUDENT was in the swimming pool. Further, E did not facilitate conversation between STUDENT and the “peer buddy” assigned to walk the track with him. Instead, E spent much of the PE period sitting in the bleachers and talking on his cell phone. (Testimony of Ms. Fox, Mr. Flynn, and Dr. Davis.)

Finally, Dr. Davis and other District staff noted that in many ways, STUDENT and E seemed more like brothers than like student and teacher. While this closeness and familiarity provided STUDENT with emotional comfort, it did not always seem conducive to learning. Several District witnesses testified that at times E did not appear to notice when STUDENT behaved inappropriately, and that STUDENT often ignored or defied E’s directives. (Testimony of Dr. Davis, Ms. Warner, and Mr. Gibbons.)

When Dr. Davis informed Mr. Meyers of her concerns about E’s performance during his probationary period, Mr. Meyers suggested that she create an opportunity for STUDENT to work with another one-to-one aide, Leila de Castro, by assigning E and Ms. de Castro to work with each other’s students for one class period per day. Dr. Davis made the arrangements, and Ms. de Castro began to work as STUDENT’S one-to-one aide during Mr. Gibbons’ history class every day. (Footnote 6)

The District’s decision to terminate E

After the first half of his probationary period was completed, E received a negative performance evaluation from the District. E told the PARENTS, Ms. de Castro and VI/OM specialist Mr. Foss that he had received a negative evaluation. (Testimony of E, Ms. de Castro, Mr. Foss, and FATHER.)

E did not miss any workdays during the second half of his probationary period, but Dr. Davis’ other concerns about his performance continued. As the probationary period drew to a close, Dr. Davis and STUDENT’S co-case manager Mr. Gibbons discussed the possibility that E might be terminated. They decided that if this occurred, Ms. de Castro should become STUDENT’S interim classroom aide until a new aide could be hired to replace E. Ms. de Castro already worked as STUDENT’S aide in his history class, and she and STUDENT worked well together. (Testimony of Dr. Davis and Mr. Gibbons.)

Dr. Davis ultimately recommended to Mr. Meyers that E should be terminated prior to the end of his probation. She and Mr. Meyers knew the PARENTS would be very upset by this decision, but felt constrained by personnel rules that prohibited them from giving the PARENTS any advance notice of the pending termination. Further, personnel rules prevented them from advertising for a replacement aide until after E had been terminated. Mr. Meyers asked Dr. Davis to explain to him how STUDENT would be assisted through the transition from E to an interim aide and eventually to a permanent aide in order to make sure that “there wouldn’t be a stitch dropped” in the implementation of STUDENT’S IEP when E was terminated. (Testimony of Dr. Davis and Mr. Meyers.)

Dr. Davis advised him that Ms. de Castro would be the interim aide, and that a male aide would be made available if STUDENT needed assistance in the locker room during his PE class. Further, Dr. Davis would be personally present to assist Ms. de Castro until both Ms. de Castro and STUDENT were fully comfortable with the transition. Mr. Meyers approved of the plan, and in order to secure a permanent replacement for E as soon as possible, decided to seek union approval of a one-week posting for a new aide instead of the usual two-week posting for newly available positions.

Dr. Davis and Mr. Meyers also discussed how and when the PARENTS should be informed of E’s termination. As FATHER had indicated that the best way to communicate with him was by e-mail, they decided that Dr. Davis would e-mail the news of the termination to the PARENTS thirty minutes after it had occurred. (Testimony of Dr. Davis and Mr. Meyers.)

E’s termination and aftermath (January – February 2005)

E was terminated by the District on Friday, January 28, 2005, at 3 p.m. As planned, Dr. Davis sent an e-mail to the PARENTS thirty minutes after the termination meeting had ended, notifying them that E had been released from employment by the District, but that STUDENT “would continue to have one-to-one coverage for his classes.” The e-mail also gave the PARENTS the name and telephone number of Daisy Jiminez in the personnel office if they sought further information about E’s termination. (S. Exh. 4007.)

By the time Dr. Davis had sent her e-mail, E already had notified the PARENTS that he had been terminated, and FATHER had sent an immediate e-mail to Mr. Meyers, with a copy to Dr. Davis, indicating that the termination would have a “devastating effect” on STUDENT’S development. FATHER stated that he could not fathom any circumstances that would warrant E’s dismissal and demanded to know the basis for it, adding, “I sincerely doubt my son’s best interests were even considered.” FATHER stated that he would seek legal counsel to advise him on the rights of his son and of E, and noted that he “would like to set up an IEP meeting as soon as possible, as I believe a huge mistake has been made.” (S. Exh. 4006.)

Within the hour, FATHER also responded to Dr. Davis’ e-mail, noting he had left a message for Ms. Jiminez in personnel and asking, “what are the qualifications of the new aide?” (S. Exh. 4007.) At the hearing, Dr. Davis acknowledged that she must have received the e-mail, but does not believe she responded to it.

On the following Monday, January 31, Mr. Meyers and Ms. Jiminez met with FATHER to discuss his displeasure regarding E’s termination. Mr. Meyers and Ms. Jiminez explained that personnel rules had prohibited them from informing the PARENTS about the termination in advance, and declined to answer FATHER’s questions about why E had been terminated or how he might be reinstated. As FATHER’s primary concern at the meeting was the District’s dismissal of E, there was little discussion of any transition to an interim aide or new permanent aide. Mr. Meyers did inform FATHER, however, that the District was attempting to secure union approval of an employment notice that could be acted upon in a week, and that in the meantime, an aide who was familiar with STUDENT would be assigned to work with him in the classroom. (Testimony of Mr. Meyers and FATHER.)

The next day, February 1, FATHER sent an e-mail to Mr. Meyers stating that, as he had indicated at the January 31 meeting, STUDENT would be home schooled until FATHER had met with counsel regarding STUDENT’S rights and remedies in connection with E’s termination. (Footnote 7) FATHER asserted that, as the District “[did] not currently have a person with the qualifications and training” to assist STUDENT adequately, and since STUDENT “has always had great difficulty transitioning,” the PARENTS could not afford to risk reversals in his development. FATHER expressed extreme displeasure that the decision to terminate E had been made “without notice or opportunity for discussion, and with seemingly reckless disregard of the best interests of our child.” He repeated his request for an IEP meeting “as soon as possible.” (S. Exh. 4009.)

In response, Mr. Meyers sent a letter to FATHER on February 2 indicating his “strong disagreement” with the statement that the District did not have a trained, qualified instructional aide to work with STUDENT in the classroom. He noted that another aide had been working with STUDENT for several months, enjoyed a positive relationship with him, was familiar with his unique needs and his IEP, and had been trained and supervised by Dr. Davis. (S. Exh. 3001.) (Footnote 8) At the end of the letter, Mr. Meyers responded to FATHER’s request for an IEP meeting, stating, “please contact me to schedule an IEP. I will make every effort to be available next week.” (Id.)

FATHER responded by letter on February 5, indicating that he believed that the interim aide offered by the District, Ms. de Castro, was a “truly caring and well-meaning person,” but that STUDENT needed “much more” in an aide. He stated that E was the best aide STUDENT had ever had, was an excellent role model, and possessed a “sterling resume, references, and experience with STUDENT” that uniquely qualified him as STUDENT’S aide. (S. Exh. 3002.) In response to Mr. Meyers’ invitation to contact him with dates for an IEP meeting, FATHER stated, “I will contact you to arrange an IEP after we have retained counsel, if not before.” (Id.) A few days later, Mr. Meyers called FATHER to see if he was willing to meet for another discussion. The two met again on February 8, and Mr. Meyers informed FATHER that he had been able to post a one-week employment notice for a new aide, and that Ms. de Castro would work with STUDENT until the new aide was hired and trained. FATHER responded that this was not a satisfactory arrangement, and that he would not send STUDENT to school. Mr. Meyers responded that in that event, the District would have no choice but to file a request for a due process hearing. There was no further discussion between the parties about holding an IEP meeting at this time. (Testimony of Mr. Meyers and FATHER.) (Footnote 9)

On February 23, 2005, the District filed its request for due process hearing. (Footnote 10) STUDENT did not return to the District for the remainder of the school year or for summer school.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: During the 2004-2005 school year, did STUDENT need a one-to-one instructional aide in the classroom?

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a student free of charge, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17). Under State special education law, related services are defined as transportation and “other developmental, corrective, or supportive services if they are required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z). (Footnote 11)

In this matter, STUDENT’S IEP for the 2004-2005 school year specified that he would receive the support of a one-to-one instructional aide for the full school day. (S. Exh. 1079.) At the hearing, the parties stipulated that STUDENT needs such an aide to benefit from his education. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that under federal and State law, the one-to-one instructional aide assigned to STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year constituted a “related service” required to assist him in benefiting from his education. As with special education instruction, a special education “related service” must meet the unique needs of the student and confer some educational benefit. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982).

Issue No. 2: Was this particular aide necessary for STUDENT to receive a FAPE?

Federal regulations allow paraprofessionals and assistants who are “appropriately trained and supervised, in accordance with State law, regulations, or written policy,” to assist in the provision of special education and related services to children with disabilities. 34 C.F.R. § 300.136(f). State law requires regular and special education personnel to be “adequately prepared” to provide instruction and services to students. Cal. Educ. Code § 56001(o). However, neither federal nor State special education regulations set forth specific training or credentialing requirements for classroom instructional aides. See 34 C.F.R. § 300.23; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(y).

The District asserts that E’s particular services as an instructional aide were not necessary to assist the Student in benefiting from his education. In his closing brief, the Student acknowledges that with appropriate qualifications and training, an instructional aide other than E might also have helped him to benefit from his education. However, the parties disagree as to whether, at the time of E’s dismissal, the District was prepared to replace E with an appropriately trained aide.

A. Contentions

The District contends that Ms. de Castro was appropriately qualified and trained to be STUDENT’S interim aide while it sought a permanent aide to fill the position. Further, the District argues that it advertised for a permanent aide to replace E as promptly as circumstances permitted, hired a qualified aide, Ms. Cotter-Haslop, within three weeks of E’s dismissal, and provided her with appropriate training to be STUDENT’S one-to-one aide. Finally, the District argues that E’s particular services were not necessary to meet STUDENT’S unique needs or to allow him to benefit from his education because STUDENT’S educational history shows he has made the transition to new aides and service providers without difficulty.

The Student responds that E’s longstanding relationship with him made E essential to his educational program, and that in fact, “E was his program.” He asserts that the District was not prepared to train a replacement aide to address his unique educational needs because the District did not know his present levels of academic performance, was unaware of his safety and self-help needs, and did not know how to address his behavioral needs. (Footnote 12) Accordingly, the Student asserts that it was necessary for E to continue as his aide “until such time as the District knew and understood [his] needs and could properly train someone to replace [E],” and that, for the 2004-2005 school year, he needed E as his particular instructional aide to benefit from his education.

B. Discussion (1) Did the District understand STUDENT’S unique needs?

The parties do not dispute that STUDENT’S primary deficits are his visual impairment and his autistic-like deficits, particularly his lack of pragmatic speech and other social skills, his developmental delays in reading comprehension and written expression, and his lack of focus and concentration in the classroom. (Testimony of Ms. Warner, Dr. Davis, Ms. de Castro, Mr. Foss, and E.) (Footnote 13) As reflected in the goals and objectives set forth in his May 2004 IEP, STUDENT’S unique needs include increasing his independent ability to move safely about the community, developing his social pragmatic skills, improving his ability to focus on his schoolwork, and expanding his vocabulary and his understanding of cause and effect, sequential order, grammar, and other skills associated with reading comprehension and written expression. (D. Exh. 1.) To help him achieve his goals, STUDENT’S IEP provided him with the services of a VI/OM specialist, an S/L pathologist, and a one-to-one instructional aide in the classroom. (Id.)

The Hearing Officer finds that the Student’s assertion that the District did not understand his unique educational, safety, and self-help needs is contrary to the evidence. Dr. Davis, Mr. Gibbons, and other District witnesses testified to the extensive groundwork undertaken by the District in preparation for STUDENT’S transfer to AHS. District staff reviewed STUDENT’S past IEPs, spoke to his middle school teachers and service providers, and met with the PARENTS on several occasions before the 2004-2005 school year began in order to prepare for STUDENT’S transition to high school. STUDENT’S VI/OM specialist, Mr. Foss, testified that in the spring of 2004, he began talking to AHS staff about STUDENT’S visual needs in the classroom (such as enlargement of printed materials), as well as his mobility and safety needs in moving about the campus, and that he took STUDENT to meet his teachers and learn the layout of the AHS campus before school began.

The District also clearly understood STUDENT’S physical safety issues in his regular education PE class. STUDENT’S IEP emphasized his need to avoid blows to the head, and several District witnesses testified to their knowledge of this issue. Although STUDENT’S PE teacher Mr. Flynn was concerned that a regular education PE class might be too dangerous for STUDENT, the District acceded to the PARENTS’ request that STUDENT be placed in a regular PE class for its social benefits, and an APE specialist developed parallel activities for STUDENT when other students were engaged in sports activities that might endanger him. (Testimony of Mr. Flynn and FATHER; see D. Exhs. 1, 10.)

The Hearing Officer also finds that the District understood STUDENT’S academic needs. The May 2004 IEP contains reports by STUDENT’S VI/OM and S/L therapists with detailed information about his then-current levels of performance in reading comprehension, written expression, vocabulary, and speech, and the Student does not argue that his goals and objectives for the 2004-2005 school year were inappropriate to his current levels of performance. (D. Exh. 1.) STUDENT’S high school academic program was created and modified by his special education teachers, who also took primary responsibility for his instruction and testing. For example, STUDENT’S history teacher Mr. Gibbons testified persuasively that at the beginning of the school year, he assessed STUDENT’S reading and comprehension skills by asking him to read and talk about passages in history texts of graduated levels of difficulty, and choosing the text that appeared most suited to STUDENT’S level of understanding.

STUDENT’S May 2004 IEP also indicates that, based on his IEP team’s assessment of his current performance levels in math, he was placed in an RSP math class in high school, which was more advanced than an SDC class. At the hearing, E confirmed that the RSP math class was a good fit for STUDENT: His skills were similar to those of the other students in the class, and he needed only visual modifications and simplification of the wording in word problems to do the work expected of him.

Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student’s contention that the District was unprepared to address certain of his self-help needs, such as his extreme sensitivity to noise and his tendency to pack food in his cheeks, is unsupported by the evidence. District witnesses Ms. Warner and Dr. Davis testified to their knowledge of both of these issues. Ms. de Castro testified that she and her student regularly ate lunch with E and STUDENT, and when STUDENT packed food in his mouth, she or E would remind him to chew and swallow it, and he would do so. (Footnote 14)

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District understood STUDENT’S unique educational needs sufficiently to be able to train a replacement aide for him at the time of E’s dismissal.

(2) Did the District know how to address STUDENT’S behaviors?

The Student further asserts that the District was unprepared to replace E as his aide because it did not know how to address his problem behaviors in class. He argues that many of his behaviors, such as echolaic speech, perseveration on a topic, and difficulty focusing on a task are autistic in nature, but Mr. Gibbons had never had an autistic student in his class and did not know how to deal with him. The Student notes that Dr. Davis’ initial classroom observations of him indicated that he was often off task, would talk loudly, and would sometimes fail to respond to E’s directions to stop talking, but the District never developed a behavior plan to address these issues. (See D. Exh. 9.) Further, the Student argues that the District was unaware of his “precursor behaviors” and susceptibility to emotional “meltdowns.” He asserts that, if E had not noticed his precursor behaviors and taken him for walks on several occasions during the first months of school, he could have had a meltdown and, given his increasing age, size and strength, might have hurt himself or someone else. (Testimony of E and FATHER.)

The Hearing Officer finds that the Student’s contentions are not supported by the evidence. First, AHS provided STUDENT with a broader foundation of behavioral support than had been provided in middle school, where E had been his primary disciplinarian. In high school, Dr. Davis was responsible for ensuring STUDENT’S successful inclusion in the classroom, and she observed him daily at the beginning of the year, taking notes on his behaviors and meeting regularly with his teachers and with E to address any issues affecting his progress. STUDENT’S teachers were directly responsible for the supervision of his classroom behavior, and they addressed his talkativeness and his difficulty attending to task as a part of normal classroom discipline, sharing with E the responsibility for redirecting STUDENT when necessary. (Testimony of Dr. Davis, Ms. de Castro, and Mr. Gibbons.)

Second, District efforts to improve STUDENT’S classroom behavior proved effective. Dr. Davis testified that she was concerned that STUDENT’S isolation at a table in the back of the classroom might be prompting some of his tendencies to get out of his seat or to talk loudly to the teacher. She suggested to E that STUDENT could be moved to a desk closer to his peers, but E resisted the suggestion, stating that STUDENT needed the larger table to manage his enlarged printed materials. When Dr. Davis made the same suggestion to Ms. de Castro in STUDENT’S history class, however, Ms. de Castro moved STUDENT to a desk next to another student. (Testimony of Dr. Davis and Ms. De Castro; see S. Exh. 4017.) Mr. Gibbons, STUDENT’S history teacher, testified that STUDENT’S disruptive behaviors lessened after he was moved to a desk with his peers.

Third, the District was aware of and supported E’s central strategy for calming STUDENT when he was frustrated or upset. E testified that his practice of taking STUDENT for walks when he showed signs of stress (“precursor behaviors”) was first suggested to him by STUDENT’S S/L therapist when STUDENT was in sixth grade. He testified that both middle school and AHS staff accommodated this practice, and that the walks generally were an effective way to address STUDENT’S problem behaviors in class. Ms. de Castro testified that she knew about E’s use of walks to calm STUDENT down, and although she never needed to take STUDENT for a walk herself when working as his history class aide, the strategy remained available to her and to E’s permanent replacement.

Finally, there was no evidence that STUDENT posed a danger to himself or anyone else when he felt stress in the school setting. Although FATHER testified that STUDENT had once left marks on FATHER’s wrists during a “meltdown” he experienced at home, STUDENT’S only period of severe emotional difficulty at school in the last week of October 2004 consisted mostly of defiance, crying, and name calling, and did not include any actual, attempted, or threatened physical harm to himself or to anyone else. (See S. Exh. 4003.)

For the reasons set forth above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District knew how to address STUDENT’S problem behaviors sufficiently to train a replacement aide for E.

(3) Did the District have an appropriately qualified and trained aide ready to replace E when he was dismissed?

The Student does not challenge the qualifications of Ms. de Castro, the interim aide proposed by the District to replace E until a permanent replacement was hired. (Footnote 15) However, the Student asserts that Ms. de Castro was not appropriately trained to be his aide because she had received no specific training in how to work with him, was not even aware that she would be his interim aide, and testified that she “did not feel prepared” to work with him on a full-time basis.

Ms. de Castro testified that during the 2004-2005 school year, she worked as a one-to-one classroom aide for a student who was nonverbal and used a wheelchair. Her duties included taking notes for her student, making sure he understood his assignments, and helping him with his schoolwork – duties she assumed for STUDENT when she and E began to exchange students for one period per day in the fall of 2004.

Prior to working with STUDENT in his history class, Ms. de Castro reviewed his IEP with Dr. Davis. She also talked to E about some of STUDENT’S problem behaviors and how to address them. For example, E told her that STUDENT needed to be reminded to respect the personal space of other people and not to touch their hair, which he sometimes liked to do. E told her that STUDENT could take care of his own restroom needs, and to her knowledge, STUDENT had no problems with going to the restroom appropriately when she worked with him.

STUDENT accepted the transition to Ms. de Castro as his aide in his history class without difficulty. Ms. de Castro noted that STUDENT talked a lot, repeated himself, and had trouble changing topics. His talking was loud and sometimes disruptive in class, but he would stop when she redirected him. STUDENT worked on the same assignments as the other students in his history class, but he used enlarged printed materials, and when necessary, either Mr. Gibbons or Ms. de Castro would rephrase or simplify questions for him. STUDENT also needed regular prompts to focus on his class work. (Testimony of Ms. de Castro.)

According to Ms. de Castro, “it wasn’t hard to manage STUDENT, but it wasn’t easy.” She admired E’s patience with STUDENT, and appreciated E’s advice on how to deal with him. E had told her to “be firm” with STUDENT, and she found that when she gave STUDENT a firm directive, he would comply. She never had to take STUDENT for a walk to manage his behavior. Ms. de Castro acknowledged that she might have made comments to E such as “I don’t know how you handle STUDENT,” or “I could never be his full time aide.” At the hearing, Ms. de Castro testified that she felt she was competent to serve as STUDENT’S full time aide, although to feel fully comfortable in the position she would want to familiarize herself with the curricula in his other classes.

Dr. Davis observed Ms. de Castro working with STUDENT on several occasions. In Dr. Davis’ weekly meetings with Ms. de Castro and E regarding their students, Ms. de Castro reported that STUDENT was doing well in his history class and she was having no difficulties with him. Although Dr. Davis did not tell Ms. de Castro that she would be working full time with STUDENT at some point, Dr. Davis did ask her to become familiar with STUDENT, and when Ms. de Castro learned E had been dismissed, she assumed she would be taking over as STUDENT’S aide. Dr. Davis confirmed this assumption after E’s dismissal. (Testimony of Ms. de Castro.)

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. de Castro was appropriately qualified to work as a one-to-one instructional aide, and was appropriately trained and ready to replace E at the time of his dismissal. Ms. de Castro had substantial experience as an instructional aide and one-to-one aide when she began working with STUDENT for one class period per day. By the time E was dismissed in late January 2005, Ms. de Castro had worked with STUDENT every day for almost three months (according to E), and perhaps as long as four and one-half months (as Ms. de Castro and other District witnesses recalled), and had done so with noticeable success. Her testimony that STUDENT accepted her as his aide without difficulty was un-refuted. Further, Mr. Gibbons testified that STUDENT was more compliant with Ms. de Castro’s directives than he was with directives from E, which Mr. Gibbons attributed to the fact that Ms. de Castro presented a new voice of authority, whereas the relationship between STUDENT and E seemed more one of peers than of a student and an instructor.

Ms. de Castro received specific training as to how to work with STUDENT from Dr. Davis and consulted regularly with E, whose advice on managing STUDENT’S behaviors was helpful to her. Although Ms. de Castro acknowledged that she might have told E that she “could never be STUDENT’S full time aide,” such a comment in context appears to have been intended as a compliment to E’s patience, gratitude for his advice, or simply a recognition of the fact that STUDENT is a challenging student. The evidence indicates that Ms. de Castro was competent to be STUDENT’S aide, and she testified that she felt able to do so once she was learned about the curricula in his other classes. In this regard, Dr. Davis testified that she was prepared to offer her full time support to Ms. de Castro until she was comfortable working with STUDENT in all of his classes.

The Hearing Officer also finds that the District was prepared to replace Ms. de Castro with an appropriately qualified and trained permanent aide for STUDENT in a timely fashion. The District hired Ms. Cotter-Haslop on February 23, 2005, less than one month after E had been dismissed. Ms. Cotter-Haslop testified that she possessed a bachelor’s degree in education and had seven years’ experience working with adults with developmental disabilities. After she was hired, Ms. Cotter-Haslop reviewed STUDENT’S IEP, talked with all of his teachers, consulted with Dr. Davis and Mr. Foss about his educational needs, and although STUDENT no longer was in school, sat in on all of his classes to prepare herself regarding his curricula. From February through April, Ms. Cotter-Haslop corrected the math and history assignments STUDENT completed at home. (Testimony of Ms. Cotter-Haslop.)

The adequacy of Ms. Cotter-Haslop’s qualifications and training were unchallenged by the Student. Further, if STUDENT had remained in school, the District had planned to continue Ms. Cotter-Haslop’s training by having her “shadow” Ms. de Castro and STUDENT as an understudy until she felt able to assume Ms. de Castro’s position as his aide. (Testimony of Dr. Davis.) Given Ms. de Castro’s successful experience working with STUDENT during the fall of 2004, which was due in part to E’s ongoing advice and consultation, this final training component would have provided a valuable bridge from E’s services to the services of Ms. Cotter-Haslop as STUDENT’S new permanent aide. Although, as with any change in circumstances, some period of adjustment would be expected to occur, there is nothing in the evidence to indicate that the District’s provision for E’s replacement as STUDENT’S aide would not have been successful. (Footnote 16)

For the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District had an appropriately qualified and trained interim aide to replace E at the time that he was dismissed, and an appropriately qualified and trained permanent aide shortly thereafter.

* * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that, due to the District’s extensive preparation for STUDENT’S transition to high school, and its assumption of primary responsibility for STUDENT’S educational program in high school, the District understood STUDENT’S educational needs and knew how to address his behavioral issues sufficiently to allow it to train an instructional aide to replace E at the time of E’s dismissal. The Hearing Officer further finds that the District had an appropriately qualified and trained interim aide ready to replace E at that time, and retained an appropriately qualified and trained permanent aide for STUDENT shortly thereafter. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not need E to be his instructional aide in order to receive a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year.

Issue No. 3: Did the manner in which the District removed and replaced the aide constitute a procedural violation sufficient to deny STUDENT a FAPE?

Among the IDEA’s procedural mandates is the requirement that the process for the development of the IEP allow the parents to meaningfully participate in it. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 206-207. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE, but ones that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board Of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

The District asserts that the manner in which it removed and replaced E did not violate its procedural obligations to STUDENT under the IDEA. It acknowledges the PARENTS’ surprise and displeasure at E’s termination, but asserts that personnel policies prevented it from discussing its concerns about E’s performance with the PARENTS or from giving the PARENTS advance notice that the termination would occur.

The Student does not directly challenge the District’s contentions about its personnel policies. Rather, the Student alleges that the District erred in treating the removal and replacement of E solely as a personnel issue, when in fact it constituted a change in the STUDENT’S educational placement or program that should have been addressed at an IEP meeting. Further, the Student alleges that the District should have had a transition plan in place to help him adjust to working with a new aide, but that it failed to do so.

A. Did the removal and replacement of E as STUDENT’S instructional aide constitute a change in his educational placement or program that should have been addressed at an IEP meeting?

Under federal and State law, an IEP for a child with a disability must include, among other things, a statement of the special education, related services, and program modifications or supports for school personnel that will be provided for the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3). The IEP must be reviewed at least annually to determine whether the child’s goals are being achieved, and must be revised as appropriate to address any lack of expected progress, the results of any reevaluations, information about the child provided by or to the parents, the child’s anticipated needs, or “other matters.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(4)(A). Changes in the child’s “educational instruction, services, or placement” may be made only on the basis of revisions to the IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56366(a)(3).

State law defines “specific educational placement” as “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the individual education program.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3042(a). Here, STUDENT’S IEP for the 2004-2005 school year stated that due to his visual impairment, he needed a one-to-one aide to provide him with access to a general education curriculum. The IEP listed the one-to-one aide under the category of “support for school personnel,” and specified that the person or agency responsible for providing this support was “SMUHSD [the District].” (S. Exh. 1079.) The IEP did not indicate that STUDENT would receive one-to-one aide services specifically from E. (D. Exh. 1.)

STUDENT’S IEP also included a list of program accommodations and modifications comprised of preferred classroom seating, extended time for assignments, enlarged reading materials, shortened reading assignments, and a PE program minimizing the risk of head injury. As specified in the IEP, these accommodations and modifications were provided by AHS staff: STUDENT’S teachers modified his reading assignments, the APE specialist modified his PE program, and the VI/OM specialist taught him to enlarge his reading materials. Dr. Davis supervised the implementation of these accommodations and modifications, and was displeased when E declined to change STUDENT’S classroom seating arrangement as she suggested. Further, when E took it upon him self to shorten STUDENT’S math test, Dr. Davis intervened and required him to have STUDENT complete the entire test.

Clearly, STUDENT’S educational program at AHS was provided primarily by his special education teachers, service providers, and other specialists, and as a result, E’s role in STUDENT’S program had diminished. Although the Student’s assertion that “E was his program” may well have been true in middle school, the Hearing Officer finds that in high school, E had been moved to a supporting role, and no longer was so important to his program that his replacement might be considered to be a substantive change to the program that would require the holding of an IEP meeting. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the removal and replacement of E as STUDENT’S instructional aide did not constitute a change in his educational instruction, services or placement requiring the holding of an IEP meeting.

Finally, the Hearing Officer notes that, although the District hired E at the PARENTS’ request, E’s retention or dismissal, like that of any public school employee, was a matter within the sole authority of the District and its governing board. See Cal. Educ. Code §§ 44932 (dismissal of permanent employees for cause); 44948.3 (dismissal of probationary employees for unsatisfactory performance). There is no provision in federal or State law that requires a school district to obtain the approval of, or to engage in discussions with, a special education student’s IEP team prior to dismissing an employee who provides services to the student.

B. Should the District have had a transition plan in place to help STUDENT adjust to a new aide, and did it fail to do so?

The District asserts that it developed a transition plan to ensure that E’s termination and replacement would not affect the implementation of STUDENT’S IEP. In a meeting to discuss E’s possible termination, Dr. Davis and Mr. Gibbons agreed that Ms. de Castro, who had been working as STUDENT’S aide in his history class, should replace E on an interim basis, with a male aide made available in case STUDENT needed assistance in his PE class. Mr. Meyers approved the plan, instructed Dr. Davis to notify the PARENTS as soon as E was terminated, and took steps to shorten the process for hiring a new permanent aide for STUDENT. In accordance with the plan, E was dismissed on a Friday afternoon, the PARENTS were promptly notified of his dismissal and of the fact that STUDENT would continue to receive one-to-one aide services, and Ms. de Castro was available to replace E the following Monday. (Testimony of Dr. Davis, Mr. Gibbons, Mr. Meyers, and Ms. de Castro.)

The Student asserts that the District’s claim that it had a transition plan in place is not credible because no IEP meeting was held to develop such a plan, no written plan was in evidence, and not even Ms. de Castro was informed of the plan in advance of E’s termination.

Neither federal nor State special education law requires a school district develop a formal transition plan for the dismissal and replacement of an employee who provides special education services to a student. (Footnote 17) Rather, a school district must ensure that teacher and staff turnover, which is common in special education, takes place in a manner that does not result in the loss of educational opportunity to a special education student or seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. See W.G. v. Board Of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, supra, 960 F.2d at 1483-1484.

In this matter, the Hearing Officer finds that the District took appropriate steps to ensure that E’s termination would not result in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT. First, when Dr. Davis began to have doubts about E’s performance early in the school year, she took Mr. Meyers’ advice to arrange for E and Ms. de Castro switch students for one period per day, so that Ms. de Castro would be prepared to work with STUDENT if E became unavailable. Ms. de Castro began working as STUDENT’S aide in his history class between mid-September and early November 2004, and by all accounts, STUDENT adjusted to her without difficulty. Accordingly, by the time E was terminated on January 28, 2005, Ms. de Castro had at least three months’ successful experience working with STUDENT.

Second, the District made sure that STUDENT’S receipt of one-to-one services would not be disrupted by E’s termination. E was dismissed on a Friday, Dr. Davis immediately notified the PARENTS that there would be no interruption in STUDENT’S receipt of the services of a one-to-one aide, and Ms. de Castro was ready to assume E’s position the following Monday. (S. Exh. 4007.) Dr. Davis testified that personnel rules prohibited her from notifying Ms. de Castro of the plan in advance of E’s termination, but as the Hearing Officer already has found, Ms. de Castro was available and was competent to assume E’s position upon his termination.

Finally, Mr. Meyers took steps to shorten the process for hiring a permanent replacement aide for STUDENT, and the District hired Ms. Cotter-Haslop as the new aide within three weeks of E’s termination. Ms. Cotter-Haslop testified to her qualifications and to her preparation regarding STUDENT’S educational curricula, and Dr. Davis testified that Ms. Cotter-Haslop would be further trained regarding STUDENT’S needs by “shadowing” Ms. de Castro and observing how she worked with STUDENT. (Footnote 18)

The Hearing Officer also finds that the District’s failure to hold an IEP meeting to prepare a transition plan in advance of E’s termination did not infringe upon the rights of STUDENT’S parents to participate in the IEP process. Although the law requires the IEP process to address a student’s “anticipated needs,” the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’S anticipated transition needs were adequately addressed at his May 2004 IEP meeting, which was attended by middle school and high school personnel as well as by STUDENT’S parents. The May 2004 IEP meeting functioned as an overall transition plan to address STUDENT’S anticipated needs at a new school, with new teachers and service providers, and with a newly structured educational program that, among other things, reduced E’s previously central role in his program. When Ms. de Castro assumed the role of STUDENT’S aide for one class period per day, E’s role was further reduced without objection from the PARENTS. By all accounts, STUDENT had little or no difficulty adjusting to his new teachers, new service providers, or Ms. de Castro as his aide, and Ms. de Castro’s asserted ability to work well with STUDENT was un-refuted.

Accordingly, by the time E was terminated in late January 2005, STUDENT’S anticipated needs in adjusting to new personnel in general, and to Ms. de Castro in particular, had been met with considerable success, and did not require further advance planning at another IEP meeting. The fact that the District’s decision to terminate E was not shared with the IEP team in advance is understandable, given the confidentiality of personnel proceedings, and did not infringe on the PARENTS’ rights to participate in the IEP process.

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s actions in terminating and replacing E as STUDENT’S instructional aide did not violate its procedural obligations to STUDENT and his parents.

C. Did the District’s failure to hold an IEP meeting in response to FATHER’s request constitute a violation of its procedural obligations to the Student?

The Student asserts that the District failed to hold an IEP meeting as requested by his parents when they learned of E’s dismissal. The District responds that it took appropriate steps to plan a meeting, but that the PARENTS never responded to its request to supply a date when they would be able to attend a meeting.

Although a school district is not required to convene an IEP meeting in anticipation of a change in personnel, sound policy practices might favor the holding of an IEP meeting shortly after such a change to address any issues or concerns regarding the student’s adjustment to the new teacher, aide or service provider. Further, State law provides that a special education student’s IEP team shall meet under specified circumstances, including when “the parent or teacher requests a meeting to develop, review, or revise” the student’s IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(c). The meeting shall be held within thirty days of the parent’s written request. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343.5.

The evidence indicates that on January 28, 2005, FATHER sent an e-mail to the District expressing his shock and disapproval regarding E’s termination and requesting an IEP meeting “as soon as possible.” (S. Exh. 4006.) FATHER and Mr. Meyers met the following Monday to discuss E’s termination, and in a follow-up e-mail on February 1 FATHER repeated his request for an IEP meeting. (S. Exh. 4009.) On February 2, Mr. Meyers responded with a letter indicating that he would make himself available for an IEP meeting the next week and asking FATHER to contact him to set a date. (S. Exh. 3001.) FATHER responded by letter on February 5, stating “I will contact you to arrange an IEP after we have retained counsel, if not before.” (S. Exh. 3002.) At the hearing, Mr. Meyers testified that FATHER never followed up on his expressed intention to contact the District to schedule an IEP meeting, and that Mr. Meyers did not pursue the matter further because the District filed its request for due process hearing shortly thereafter.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to hold an IEP meeting within thirty days of FATHER’s request constitutes a violation of its procedural obligations under State law. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the violation did not seriously infringe upon his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. The District did not refuse or evade FATHER’s request for a meeting, nor did it hold a meeting in the PARENTS’ absence. Instead, Mr. Meyers promptly indicated his readiness to hold a meeting upon receipt of dates the PARENTS would be available, and FATHER’s February 5 letter indicates that he understood this message and would follow up with suggested dates at a later time. Accordingly, the PARENTS were aware that the District was ready and willing to hold an IEP meeting at their convenience, which would have afforded them the opportunity to address any concerns they had about the adequacy of Ms. de Castro’s training or her ability to work with STUDENT on a full time basis pending the hiring of a permanent replacement aide.

The evidence indicates, however, that FATHER had sought the IEP meeting to express his displeasure at E’s termination and to seek E’s reinstatement – issues he ultimately discussed with Mr. Meyers at two informal meetings directly after E’s termination, where Mr. Meyers made clear that reinstatement would not occur. Thus, it is unlikely that an IEP meeting between the parties in response to FATHER’s January 28 request would have accomplished anything FATHER sought at that time. (Footnote 19)

* * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that District’s removal and replacement of E as the Student’s instructional aide did not constitute a change in his educational placement or program that should have been addressed at an IEP meeting, and that the manner in which the aide was removed and replaced neither denied the Student any educational opportunity nor seriously infringed upon his parents’ right to participate in the IEP process. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s removal and replacement of E did not deny the Student a FAPE.

CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

The Hearing Officer finds as follows:

(1) The Student needed a one-to-one instructional aide in the classroom during the 2004-2005 school year.

(2) The particular services of E as an instructional aide were not necessary for the Student to receive a FAPE.

(3) The manner in which the District removed and replaced E as the Student’s instructional aide did not constitute a procedural violation sufficient to deny the Student a FAPE.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The parties stipulated to the decision on Issue No. 1. The District prevailed on the remaining issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).

Date: July 29, 2005 _________________________________________ Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

To protect the privacy of the instructional aide whose termination from employment was central to the issues at hearing, the parties jointly requested that his name not be published in this Decision. Accordingly, the aide is referred to herein as E.

2 Although STUDENT’S most recent triennial assessment occurred in May 2002, he did not receive a psycho-educational assessment at that time. Accordingly, Dr. Patterson’s 1999 assessment was the most recent psycho-educational assessment in evidence.

3 A VI/OM specialist helps visually impaired students learn to navigate their environment through recognition of streets and landmarks, use of canes or other assisting devices, and street safety training. (Testimony of Mr. Foss.)

4 Witnesses for both parties agreed that STUDENT had one significant period of problem behavior during the school year. In the last week of October 2004, STUDENT experienced “meltdowns,” could not focus in class, defied E and his teachers, and called Mr. Gibbons and another teacher bad names. Mr. Gibbons sent an e-mail to the PARENTS about the incidents, and FATHER responded that family stress over the illness of STUDENT’S grandfather probably was at the root of STUDENT’S bad behavior. (S. Exh. 4004.) At the hearing, Mr. Gibbons testified that FATHER’s explanation probably was correct, since STUDENT’S behavior returned to normal after that week.

5 The District had a back-up aide ready to assist STUDENT if his assigned aide was unavailable, but the back-up aide was not used because STUDENT was kept home when E was absent. (Testimony of Dr. Davis.)

6 Dr. Davis, Ms. de Castro, and Mr. Gibbons testified that the “aide-switching” arrangement for one period per day began in mid-September; E testified that it began in early November.

7 E worked as STUDENT’S home tutor during the 2004-2005 school year, and provided home schooling services to STUDENT after he was withdrawn from school in late January 2005.

8 Although Mr. Meyers’ letter did not identify the aide in question, FATHER acknowledged in testimony that he understood that Mr. Meyers was referring to Ms. de Castro, who had been STUDENT’S aide in his history class for several months.

9 According to the District, its last IEP meeting for STUDENT was an IEP addendum held on December 6, 2004. (S. Exh. 1088.) The Student disputes whether the December 6 meeting constituted an actual IEP meeting. He further alleges that the District was required to hold an annual IEP meeting for him by May 2005 but failed to do so. As these allegations are not at issue in this hearing, however, they are not addressed in this Decision.

10 On March 21, 2005, the Student filed a request for due process hearing naming the District as respondent, alleging that (1) he was not appropriately assessed by the District; (2) the District denied him a FAPE by dismissing E as his aide; (3) the District failed to develop an appropriate behavior plan for him; and (4) the District should be required to reimburse him for the cost of an independent assessment and for the costs of all education services provided at his home since January 31, 2005. That case was assigned Case No. SN05-00689. As noted earlier, the Hearing Officer denied the Student’s motion to consolidate that case with the instant case, and Case No. SN05-00689 currently is off calendar.

11 Related services include, but are not limited to, “designated instruction and services” (DIS) specified in a pupil’s IEP such as S/L therapy, audiological services, vision and mobility services, physical and occupational therapy, and psychological services and counseling. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.

12 In further support of this argument, the Student contends that during his last triennial assessment in May 2002, the District improperly failed to assess his cognitive skills or academic achievement levels, and failed to conduct a behavioral assessment. As these are the primary issues raised in Case No. SN05-00689, the Student’s due process case filed against the District, and as the Student’s motion to consolidate that case with the instant case was denied, these allegations are not addressed in this Decision.

13 The Student also contends that STUDENT’S problem behaviors in the classroom constitute a significant area of need. This issue is addressed in Section B(2) infra.

14 E also testified that the District was unaware that STUDENT sometimes needed to be reminded to go to the bathroom, and that on two occasions STUDENT wet his pants at school when he forgot to do so. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that E was the person in the best position to know about this issue, that Dr. Davis held weekly meetings with E precisely to determine whether there were any issues with STUDENT that needed to be addressed, and that E did not tell Dr. Davis that this problem existed.

15 Ms. de Castro testified that she earned a bachelor’s degree in social work from the University of the City of Manila in 1985. At the time she was hired by the District as a one-to-one aide for another student at the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year, she had worked as a special education instructional aide in another district for three years and within the District for a prior year, and had received District-sponsored training in first aid and in working with autistic children.

16 In fact, the transition might have benefited STUDENT by generalizing his skills and reducing his dependence on any single individual.

17 The law requires IEPs to contain specific transition plans or services in two circumstances: To prepare students for post-secondary education, vocational training, or employment, and to help students transfer from a special class or nonpublic school into a regular education class in the public school system. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(vii); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56345(b)(4), 56345.1.

18 The District also was aware that E worked as STUDENT’S home tutor, a fact that reasonably could have been expected to soften any negative impact on STUDENT that might occur from E’s termination as STUDENT’S school aide.

19 At the hearing, FATHER testified that if E were not reinstated, FATHER would want a transition plan allowing E to instruct the new aide in how to work with STUDENT. As indicated above, however, that aspect of a transition already occurred between E and Ms. de Castro when she became STUDENT’S aide for one period per day in the fall of 2004.