California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 14, 2003

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 476-03, SN-476-03 · Hearing Officer Christian P. Hurley

Los Angeles Unified must reimburse one private assessment because its testing was incomplete, but the student was found not eligible for special education.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 5 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a seven-year-old filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. They argued that their son, who was finishing first grade at Van Gogh Elementary, qualified for special education under the specific learning disability category. The District had found him ineligible after assessments in 2001 and October 2002. Hearing Officer Christian Hurley found severe gaps between the student's superior cognitive ability and his achievement in basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and written expression. He relied on the October 2002 scores and treated higher retest scores from December 2002 as a likely practice effect. But the evidence did not tie these gaps to a disorder in the basic psychological process the parents claimed, the cognitive ability of expression. Regular education could also correct them, based on teacher testimony, his grades, and his progress in a District reading program. So he was not eligible, and the request for compensatory services was denied.

The Hearing Officer did find that the District failed to assess in all areas of suspected disability. It did not assess language or phonological processing, and it skipped the speech-language testing listed in its own plan. The District was ordered to reimburse the parents for Dr. Lorie Humphrey's May 2003 assessment. Two earlier private evaluations were not reimbursed because the parents got them before receiving the District's reports. The IEP team did not truly consider the private evaluations. This was a procedural violation, but it caused no harm.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied California's three-part test for specific learning disability, including the requirement that regular education cannot correct the gap. It also shows that a district could have to fund an independent evaluation for incomplete testing, but not evaluations obtained before parents received the district's assessment reports.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2002-2003 school year?

    The Hearing Officer found severe discrepancies in basic reading skills, reading comprehension and written expression. But they were not shown to result from a disorder in the claimed cognitive ability of expression, and the regular instructional program could correct them, so the student was not eligible for 2002-2003 or currently.

  2. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2. Did the District assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?

    The District's October 2002 assessment was inappropriate. Test results called for assessing language processing and phonological processing, and the District never did the speech-language assessment listed in its own assessment plan.

  3. Issue 3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained assessments (Dr. Eichenstein, approx. $1700; Dr. Nguyen, approx. $115; Dr. Humphrey, approx. $1275)?

    Reimbursement was denied for the Eichenstein and Nguyen evaluations because the parents obtained them before receiving the District's reports and so could not yet disagree with them. Reimbursement was granted for Dr. Humphrey's assessment, which addressed the areas the District failed to assess.

  4. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 4. Did the District consider the independent educational evaluations obtained by Petitioner?

    The District did not meaningfully consider the IEEs at the February and June 2003 IEP meetings because its psychologist was unfamiliar with several of the instruments used. That was a procedural violation, but there was no prejudice because the student was not eligible.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. If STUDENT was or is eligible for special education services, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of Lindamood-Bell services, language therapy, and/or counseling?

    Because the student was not eligible for special education, he was not entitled to compensatory education.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District must reimburse the parents for the cost of Dr. Lorie Humphrey's independent psycho-educational assessment conducted in May 2003. The order gives no amount; the issue statement lists the cost as approximately $1275.

Total: $1,275 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479; San Dieguito Union High School District, SEHO Case No. SN02-01363; Redlands Unified School District, SEHO Case No. SN03-00953; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j); 5 C.C.R. § 3030(c)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329

People named in the decision

  • Lorie Humphrey, Ph.D., independent assessor and expert witness for Student
  • Rita Eichenstein, Ph.D., private neuropsychological-educational assessor (IEE)
  • Trang Nguyen, O.D., F.A.A.O., private optometrist, functional vision assessment (IEE)
  • Lisa Marlow, kindergarten teacher, witness for Student, North Valley Jewish Community Center
  • Hope Watterson, first grade teacher, Van Gogh Elementary, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Paula Himmelstein, first grade teacher, Van Gogh Elementary, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Alnita Rettig Dunn, Ph.D., school psychologist, expert witness for District, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Linda Joslin, school psychologist, assessor, Van Gogh Elementary, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Donna Zero, principal, Van Gogh Elementary, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Virginia Williams, school psychologist, 2001 assessor, El Oro Way Elementary School, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • V. Silver, resource specialist, 2001 assessor, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Linda Hirsch, resource specialist, administered WJ-III, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Patricia Wilson, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Tonya Gregory, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Melinda Lopez, paralegal, Office of the General Counsel, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Carrie Watts, advocate for Student, A2Z Educational Advocates

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Christian Hurley, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific. The matter proceeded to hearing in Los Angeles, California on June 19, 20, 24, 25, 26, and 27, 2003.

Petitioner Student (STUDENT) was represented by attorney N. Jane Dubovy and advocate Carrie Watts of A2Z Educational Advocates. Also present on STUDENT=s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. STUDENT=s father, FATHER, also attended portions of the hearing. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District was represented by attorney Peter Keup, assistant general counsel for the District. The following individuals were also present on behalf of the District during different portions of the hearing: Patricia Wilson, due process specialist for the District; Tonya Gregory, due process specialist for the District; and Melinda Lopez, paralegal for the District=s Office of the General Counsel.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Lorie Humphrey, Ph.D., MOTHER, STUDENT=s mother; FATHER, STUDENT=s father; and Lisa Marlow, STUDENT=s kindergarten teacher. The District called the following witnesses: Hope Watterson and Paula Himmelstein, STUDENT=s first grade teachers; Alnita Rettig Dunn, Ph.D., school psychologist; Linda Joslin, school psychologist; and Donna Zero, principal of Van Gogh Elementary, STUDENT=s school of attendance.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties submitted written closing briefs. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES , (Footnotes 1 & 2)

1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2002-2003 school year?

2. Did the District assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?

3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained assessments?

4. Did the District consider the independent educational evaluations obtained by Petitioner?

5. If STUDENT was or is eligible for special education services, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of Lindamood-Bell services, language therapy, and/or counseling?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

The Hearing Office received written closing briefs from Petitioner and Respondent on July 14, 2003. On July 28, 2003, the Hearing Office received a motion by Respondent to strike all references contained in Petitioner=s closing brief to evidence not offered or received at hearing. Specifically, Respondent contends that Petitioner=s closing brief contains information from articles not introduced into evidence at the due process hearing. According to Respondent, such references include quotes or descriptions from the following articles: AUse of the WJ III Discrepancy Procedures for Learning Disabilities Identification and Diagnosis,@ AStandards for Educational and Psychological Testing,@ ALearning Disabilities Diagnosis in Postsecondary Students: A comparison of discrepancy-based diagnostic models,@ and AThe non-word reading deficit in developmental dyslexia: a review.@ Respondent contends that all references to the foregoing articles should be stricken for the following reasons: 1) The articles were not provided to the District at least five days before the hearing as required by 34 C.F.R. Section 300.509(a)(3) and California Education Code section 56505(e)(7); 2) The articles were not offered or received into evidence during the hearing; 3) The articles were not provided to Respondent=s counsel at hearing or any time thereafter; 4) Petitioner did not establish a foundation for admission of the articles; 5) Respondent did not have an opportunity to question Petitioner=s witnesses or Respondent=s witnesses regarding the articles; and 6) Respondent was not afforded an opportunity to rebut the referenced information from the articles or Petitioner=s arguments that were based on the articles.

On July 28, 2003, the Hearing Office received Petitioner=s response to Respondent=s motion to strike. Petitioner contends that Respondent=s expert witness, Dr. Alnita Dunn, testified at hearing regarding the Woodcock Johnson-III subtest scores, subtest comparisons, and the interpretation of the test by experts. Petitioner further contends that Dr. Dunn did not provide a written report or assessments prior to hearing and that, as a result, Petitioner had no way of knowing that she would testify regarding the use of subtests in determining eligibility. Petitioner contends that he did not produce the articles prior to hearing because they were not relevant and did not become relevant until Dr. Dunn testified at hearing regarding the use of subtests. Petitioner contends that his first opportunity to rebut Dr. Dunn=s testimony was in his closing brief.

The Hearing Officer finds Petitioner=s arguments unpersuasive. Petitioner had opportunities to present the information contained in these articles as evidence both prior to and during the hearing, but failed to do so. Specifically, Petitioner had the opportunity to offer the actual articles as evidence both prior to and during the hearing. Petitioner also had the opportunity to cross-examine Dr. Dunn regarding her testimony on the use of subtests and to ask her questions regarding information and opinions contained within the articles quoted in Petitioner=s closing brief. Finally, Petitioner had the opportunity to recall his own expert witness to rebut Dr. Dunn=s testimony but did not do so.

Other factors also weigh in favor of striking the references to these articles. For example, Petitioner did not establish a foundation for the admission of the articles. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, allowing this new information into evidence after the conclusion of the hearing would deny Respondent its right to confront and cross-examine Petitioner=s witnesses regarding the articles as well as its right to rebut the information contained in the articles and Petitioner=s arguments which were based on the articles. For the foregoing reasons, Respondent=s motion to strike all references to the aforementioned articles quoted or described in Petitioner=s closing brief is granted.

CONTENTIONS

Petitioner contends that he is eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. First, he contends that a severe discrepancy exists between his ability and achievement in the following academic areas: oral expression, basic reading skills, and reading comprehension. Second, Petitioner claims that this discrepancy is due to a disorder in the basic psychological process of the cognitive ability of expression, specifically his ability to retrieve information from his memory and convey this information verbally and in writing. Third, he contends that this discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. Petitioner also alleges that the District=s assessment of STUDENT in October 2002 was inappropriate because the District failed to adequately assess STUDENT for a reading disability and that the District failed to consider the independent educational evaluations (IEEs) procured by STUDENT=s parents. Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the IEEs obtained from Dr. Rita Eichenstein, Ph.D., Dr. Trang Nguyen, O.D., F.A.A.O., and Dr. Lorie Humphrey, Ph.D. Finally, Petitioner seeks an award of compensatory education that would include an eighty-hour intensive reading program, two hours per week of language therapy and one hour per week of counseling.

The District contends that Petitioner is not eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. Specifically, the District argues that a severe discrepancy does not exist in any of the academic areas identified in California Education Code Section 56337(a), that Petitioner does not have a disorder in one of the basic psychological processes as set forth in Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, Section 3030(j)(1), and that even if a severe discrepancy exists, it can be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. The District further contends that it appropriately assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and that STUDENT=s parents are therefore not entitled to reimbursement for the IEEs they obtained.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seven-year-old boy who has never been found eligible for special education. He is to begin second grade in the fall at the District=s Van Gogh Elementary (AVan Gogh@). STUDENT resides with his parents, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT, and an older brother, BROTHER. STUDENT=s school of legal residence is El Oro Way Elementary School, but he attends Van Gogh pursuant to a District transfer due to his parents= employment. STUDENT=s medical history is significant for grade one bleeding in the brain at birth, enlarged subdural and ventrical cavities in the brain, and viral meningitis with a high fever at age two and one-half, which required hospitalization.

STUDENT attended the North Valley Jewish Community Center (JCC) from age two through six. At age three, STUDENT was attending nursery school at the JCC when a gunman entered the building and began to shoot at adults and children. Several people were killed. During the shooting incident, STUDENT hid with his classmates and teacher in a closet in his classroom.

In the fall of 2001, STUDENT=s parents requested that STUDENT be assessed out of concern that STUDENT was experiencing difficulty retaining new information he was learning at school. At this time, STUDENT was attending kindergarten at the JCC.

The District=s psycho-educational assessment was conducted in October 2001 by Virginia Williams, school psychologist for El Oro Way Elementary School, and V. Silver, resource specialist. The Matrix Analogies Test (MAT) was used to measure STUDENT=s cognitive ability. It produced a standard score of 96, placing STUDENT in the thirty-ninth percentile. The Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement, Revised (WJ-R) and the Wide Range Achievement Test, III (WRAT-III) were administered to measure STUDENT=s levels of achievement. On the WJ-R, STUDENT received the following scores:

Standard Score Percentile Ranking

Oral Language 100 49 Oral Expression 96 40

Picture Vocabulary 79 8 Listening Comprehension 102 56 Letter-Word Identification 95 37 Story Recall 109 74 Understanding Directions 109 72 Applied Problems 98 45 Picture Vocabulary 92 30 Oral Comprehension 97 42 Qualitative Concepts 90 25 Passage Comprehension 85 16 Spelling 83 13 Math Reasoning 93 33 Quantitative Concepts 90 25

On the WRAT-III, STUDENT received a standard score of 84 in reading, placing him in the average to low average range; a score of 93 in spelling, placing him in the low average range and a score of 96 in arithmetic, placing him in the average range. To measure STUDENT=s motor skills, Ms. Williams administered the Bender Gestalt Test (Bender), a paper and pencil task wherein he is required to copy nine designs. The Bender yielded results in the average range and ranked at the fiftieth percentile. To measure STUDENT=s auditory and visual perception, Ms. Williams administered the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills-Revised (TAPS-R) and the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills-Revised (TVPS-R). STUDENT=s performance on the TAPS-R in auditory memory placed him in the well above average range. Overall, his auditory perceptual skills were in the high average range. His fund of general knowledge was low average. On the TVPS-R, a non-motor test of visual perception, STUDENT=s performance fell in the below-average range. His visual memory was in the average range. These assessors concluded that STUDENT did not qualify for special education services as a student with a specific learning disability because he was performing in at least the average range. MOTHER testified at hearing that she did not want an IEP meeting to be held following the assessment by Ms. Williams because she was concerned about the ramifications of STUDENT being labeled as learning disabled.

STUDENT=s Kindergarten Progress Report for the 2001-2002 school year is unremarkable. He received grades of Avery good@ in all areas, including academic development, oral expression, pre-reading/reading/language skills, science, and social studies, with the exception of Ameets new challenges with confidence@ on which STUDENT received a mark of Agood.@

In the fall of 2002, when STUDENT was beginning the first grade at Van Gogh, FATHER and MOTHER requested a second psycho-educational assessment. On September 13, 2002, the District prepared a Special Education Assessment Plan for STUDENT. On September 19, 2002, MOTHER signed the assessment plan, indicating her consent to assess STUDENT. MOTHER also indicated on the assessment plan that she and her husband were in the process of obtaining an independent assessment. The assessment plan indicates that the District received it on October 7, 2002, and that the last date to hold the IEP meeting was November 25, 2002.

In October 2002, MOTHER requested an IEP meeting. On October 22, 2002, the IEP team met to review the results of the psycho-educational assessment conducted by Virginia Williams in 2001 and to determine whether STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. (Footnote 3) The District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. Specifically, they concluded that there was no evidence of a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement and that there was no evidence of a processing disorder.

On October 22 and 29, 2002, Linda Joslin, school psychologist for Van Gogh Elementary, conducted a psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the assessment plan developed in September. Ms. Joslin administered the Cognitive Assessment System (CAS) to measure his cognitive processing ability. STUDENT obtained a full scale score of 121 on the CAS, which falls within the superior range. To measure STUDENT=s academic achievement, Linda Hirsch, the District=s resource specialist, administered the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement, III (WJ-III), Form A. On the WJ-III, STUDENT received the following scores:

Standard Score Percentile Ranking

Oral Language 105 63 Total Achievement 96 40 Broad Reading 91 28 Broad Math 111 77 Broad Written Language 95 37 Math Calculation Skills 115 85 Written Expression 94 34 Academic Skills 102 56 Academic Fluency 94 34 Academic Applications 93 32 Letter-Word Identification 99 48 Reading Fluency 91 26 Story Recall 107 69 Understanding Directions 104 60 Calculation 116 86 Math Fluency 105 64 Spelling 97 42 Writing Fluency 96 39 Passage Comprehension 86 17

Applied Problems 104 60 Writing Samples 95 37

Ms. Joslin also administered the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills-Revised (TAPS-R), the Motor-Free Visual Perception Test-Revised (MVPT-R), the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test, the Sentence Completion Test, and Draw-A-Person. STUDENT=s auditory-perceptual skills on the TAPS-R were within normal limits as were his visual perceptual skills as measured by the MVPT-R and his perceptual-motor skills as measured by the Bender-Gestalt. In her report, Ms. Joslin drew the following conclusions:

AThere is evidence of a severe discrepancy between his ability and his achievement in reading and written expression based upon standardized test scores. However, STUDENT=s total achievement score is within grade level and his teachers state that he is at grade level in all academic areas and they do not note any difficulties in his academic performance.@

On December 20, 2002, STUDENT=s parents obtained an independent neuropsychological-educational evaluation of STUDENT by Dr. Rita Eichenstein, Ph.D. At this time, STUDENT was seven years old. Dr. Eichenstein administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scales for Children, III (WISC-III) to assess STUDENT=s cognitive ability. STUDENT received the following standard scores on the WISC-III:

Verbal IQ 117 Performance IQ 119 Full Scale IQ 120

Dr. Eichenstein administered the WJ-III, Form A, to assess STUDENT=s academic achievement. STUDENT received the following scores on the WJ-III:

Standard Score Percentile Ranking

Oral Language 115 85 Basic Reading Skills 114 82 Academic Skills 106 67 Academic Applications 109 72 Phon/Graph Knowledge 106 66 Letter-Word Identification 107 67 Story Recall 114 82 Understanding Directions 112 79 Calculation 125 95 Math Fluency 105 64 Spelling 89 23 Passage Comprehension 104 60 Applied Problems 116 86 Writing Samples 103 59

Word Attack 118 88 Spelling of Sounds 83 13 Sound Awareness 110 75

Dr. Eichenstein also administered the McCarthy Scales of Children=s Abilities (selected subtests), the Bender, the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML), the Wide Range Assessment of Visual Motor Abilities (WRAVMA), the Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CTOPP), the Grey Oral Reading Test-4, Test of Variabilities of Attention-Visual (TOVA-V), Conners= Parent Rating Scale-Revised, Barkley ADHD Structured Interview, NEPSY: A Developmental Neuropsychological Assessment: Selected Subtests, the Brief Rating Inventory of Executive Function, Wisconsin Card Sorting-64, the Quick Neurological Screening Test, the Test of Visual Perceptual Skills, Revised (TVPS-R), Children=s Apperception Test (CAT), the Children=s Anxiety Test (RCMAS), House-Tree-Person, and the Piers-Harris Children=s Self Concept Scale.

On the Grey Oral Reading Test, which measures reading fluency and comprehension, STUDENT=s reading rate, accuracy, and fluency scores were all at the pre-kindergarten level and his comprehension score was at the kindergarten level. On the CTOPP, STUDENT received the following scores:

Subtest Age Equiv. Percentile Stand. Score

Ellision 14.9 99 18 Blending Words 7.9 63 11 Memory for Digits 14.9 98 16 Rapid Digit Naming 6.6 25 8 Nonword Repetition 7.6 50 10 Rapid Letter Naming 6.9 37 9 Rapid Color Naming 5.6 16 7 Phoneme Reversal 5.9 16 7 Rapid Object Naming 5.6 9 6 Blending Nonwords 8.9 50 10

According to Dr. Eichenstein=s report, STUDENT=s high scores in Ellision, Memory for Digits, and Blending Nonwords demonstrated his Aextremely strong skills in auditory to verbal processing.@ STUDENT=s much lower scores in the tasks of Rapid Color Naming, Rapid Object Naming, and the Phoneme Reversal Task indicated that he is significantly weaker in visual to verbal processing and his complex working memory for phonemic identification. According to Dr. Eichenstein=s report, STUDENT=s significant weakness in using and organizing language rapidly and his weakness in phonemic reversal suggested a language based reading disability. In other words, his ability to access this information visually and link the visual to verbal processing of phonemic information was impaired.

On the WRAML, STUDENT=s memory function was in the average to above average range with the exceptions of the Picture Memory and Sound Symbol subtests, on which STUDENT scored in the low range. According to Dr. Eichenstein, this suggested a short-term memory deficit involving symbol to sound issues, i.e. the pairing of a visual symbol to an auditory sound. Her report stated that weak sound symbol issues are linked to reading difficulties. Dr. Eichenstein concluded that this is a visual processing impairment which presents as a memory weakness.

Dr. Eichenstein found that STUDENT scored in the superior range of cognitive abilities. She noted that STUDENT displayed Asuperior to gifted abilities in his non-verbal problem solving abilities, his ability in complex verbal analytic reasoning and higher order critical thinking skills.@ Dr. Eichenstein described STUDENT as Asignificantly weaker in his visual attention to detail, visual discrimination, visual sequencing.@ She noted that these weaknesses can be an underlying component of a reading difficulty. With regard to tests of academic achievement, Dr. Eichenstein found that STUDENT scored significantly above grade level in most areas of academics that are not related to reading, writing, or spelling. By contrast, she noted that STUDENT displays a relatively weak cluster of reading related skills. She stated that his significantly weak areas are in visual to verbal processing, auditory complex working memory and weak verbal fluency for focused access of lexicon. She noted that A[t]hese weak areas are indicative of a visual to language based disability which compromises reading and writing mastery.@ Dr. Eichenstein diagnosed STUDENT with a reading disorder and generalized anxiety disorder secondary to posttraumatic stress syndrome. Her recommendations included an intensive and structured reading remediation program such as the Lindamood Bell system in order to increase his reading fluency. According to Dr. Eichenstein, such a program would assist STUDENT in grapheme phoneme development and would stimulate his visual memory and sight word recognition. In her report, Dr. Eichenstein also recommended further investigation of STUDENT=s visual abilities, specifically visual tracking, visual discrimination, visual matching, visual attending, and all areas of eye movement skills, eye focusing skills and eye teaming skills. She suggested that STUDENT might benefit from a developmental optometry exam in order to rule out visual dysfunctions. Finally, she recommended that STUDENT receive psychotherapy to address anxiety caused by the events at the JCC when STUDENT was in nursery school.

On January 18, 2003, STUDENT=s parents obtained an independent functional visual assessment of STUDENT by optometrist Trang Nguyen. According to Dr. Nguyen=s report, the assessment covered STUDENT=s visual intake skills, visual perception, eye health, eye movement skills, eye teaming skills, visual motor organization skills, visual motor skills, and visual motor integration. He also screened STUDENT for visual dyslexia. In his report dated January 19, 2003, Dr. Nguyen concluded that STUDENT has excellent visual intake skills, good accommodative focusing skills, normal color vision and good peripheral vision. Dr. Nguyen noted weaknesses in STUDENT=s visual tracking skills and visual perception skills, including reduced tracking speed. Dr. Nguyen went on to state: AAs a result, STUDENT may have difficulty completing his classroom assignments on time, difficulty copying from the board efficiently, and difficulty transferring answers from his textbooks onto worksheets.@ Dr. Nguyen also noted that STUDENT demonstrated weak visual memory and visual figure ground skills. According to Dr. Nguyen=s report, these visual perception skills can impact overall academic performance: ABecause STUDENT has difficulty visually remembering patterns or words, he may have difficulty recognizing words based on visual recall.@ Dr. Nguyen recommended home vision therapy activities to improve STUDENT=s speed of tracking to age appropriate levels. Dr. Nguyen also performed a visual dyslexia screening. This testing evaluates one=s ability to visually recognize and decode words. The results of this test revealed that STUDENT has difficulty visually recognizing whole words. According to Dr. Nguyen, STUDENT tended to decode each word, making reading slow and laborious. Dr. Nguyen recommended that STUDENT be assessed by a reading specialist to rule out dyseidetic dyslexia and to provide educational treatment recommendations.

The IEP team reconvened on February 25, 2003 to review the results of the psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT conducted by school psychologist Linda Joslin, the neuropsychological-educational assessment conducted by Dr. Eichenstein, and the functional vision assessment by Dr. Nguyen. (Footnote 4) The District=s members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. Under the section entitled AReason(s),@ the IEP document states as follows: AThere is a severe discrepancy between his ability and his achievement. However, his weakness in visual processing do not appear to be adversely impeting [sic] on his academic achievement & classroom performance in meeting standards and accessing the curriculum.@

On March 10, 2003, the Hearing Office received a written request for due process hearing from Mrs. PARENT. On March 18, 2003, the matter was taken off-calendar at the request of the parties to accommodate their pending mediation.

On May 6, 2003, STUDENT=s parents obtained an independent assessment of STUDENT by Lorie Humphrey, Ph.D. To assess STUDENT=s language functioning, Dr. Humphrey administered the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals, III (CELF-III), the Picture Vocabulary subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Achievement, and the Rapid Picture Naming subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities. She also administered the Children=s Memory Scale and two measures of visuoconstruction, the Beery VMI and the Rey-Osterrieth. Based on the results of this testing and her review of prior assessments, Dr. Humphrey diagnosed STUDENT with a reading disability, learning disorder, expressive language disorder, and post-traumatic stress disorder.

On June 3, 2003, the IEP team reconvened to consider Dr. Humphrey=s report and to discuss STUDENT=s progress in school. The IEP document indicates that District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was still able to access the curriculum. According to the IEP document, the IEP team also discussed STUDENT=s auditory comprehension problems in relation to his reading and phonic skills and stated its intent to request a speech and language assessment to investigate possible central auditory processing disorders. Finally, the IEP team indicated its intent to conduct a 504 plan to collaboratively write accommodations to ensure that STUDENT continued to successfully access his reading and language arts program and address his needs for additional time for comprehension tasks and test taking situations. MOTHER testified at hearing that she initially consented to the speech and language assessment proposed at the June IEP meeting, but changed her mind out of concern that the assessment might delay STUDENT=s due process hearing, which was scheduled for June 19. Thus, the speech and language assessment has not been completed.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Was Petitioner eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2002-2003 school year?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. ' 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56000.) A child with a disability, including a specific learning disability, is one who by reason of that disability needs instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. (20 U.S.C. ' 1401(3)(A); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56026(a), (b).) In this case, Petitioner asserts that he is eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability.

The IDEA defines Aspecific learning disability@ as a Adisorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, written or spoken, which disorder may manifest itself in an imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.@ (20 U.S.C. ' 1401(26).) California Education Code Section 56337 sets forth the following three requirements that must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability:

(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the following academic areas:

(1) Oral expression;

(2) Listening comprehension;

(3) Written expression;

(4) Basic reading skills;

(5) Reading comprehension;

(6) Mathematics calculation;

(7) Mathematics reasoning.

(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.

(c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.

Pursuant to Section 56337(c), the existence of a severe discrepancy alone is not sufficient to qualify a student as eligible for special education due to an SLD. Rather, the local educational agency must also be unable to remediate the student=s severe discrepancy within the regular educational program.

Addressing each subsection of Section 56337, the Hearing Officer finds as follows:

(a) Severe Discrepancy Between Intellectual Ability and Achievement

A severe discrepancy can be established either through a formula using standardized tests (5 C.C.R. ' 3030(j)(4)(A)), by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid (5 C.C.R. ' 3030(j)(4)(B)), or through a determination by an IEP team that such a discrepancy exists (5 C.C.R. ' 3030(j)(4)(C).) The existence of a severe discrepancy cannot be based solely upon a single score or product of scores, test or procedure. (5 C.C.R. ' 3030(j)(4).)

When standardized tests are considered valid, a severe discrepancy is established by the following:

[F]irst, converting into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 15, the achievement test score and the ability test score to be compared; second, computing the difference between these common standard scores; and third, comparing this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests.

(5 C.C.R. ' 3030(j)(4)(A).)

The calculation of this formula has commonly involved interpreting the required difference for a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement standard scores to be at least 22.5 points (1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of 15), plus or minus 4 points, which is one standard error of measurement. The computed difference constitutes a severe discrepancy when such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments and work samples, as appropriate. (Id.)

In the present case, there was no allegation or evidence that standardized tests are invalid in measuring STUDENT=s ability or achievement. Therefore, to determine if a severe discrepancy exists, STUDENT=s scores on standardized intellectual testing can be compared with his scores on achievement testing.

Petitioner contends that a severe discrepancy exists between STUDENT=s ability and achievement in the following academic areas: oral expression, basic reading skills, and reading comprehension. The District concedes that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy in the areas of reading and written expression based upon the results of the October 2002 assessments, but disputes the existence of a discrepancy in the area of oral expression. In addition, the District contends that STUDENT=s severe discrepancies in reading and written expression were no longer evident in December 2002, as demonstrated by STUDENT=s performance on the WJ-III administered by Dr. Eichenstein on December 20, 2002.

Oral Expression

Dr. Humphrey testified that she found a severe discrepancy between STUDENT=s ability and achievement in the area of oral expression. She based this finding on STUDENT=s scores on the CELF-III, the Rapid Picture Naming subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities, and selected subtests of the CTOPP administered by Dr. Eichenstein. There was no testimony by Dr. Humphrey, however, as to whether any of these tests are tests of academic achievement. Dr. Alnita Dunn, the District=s expert, testified that none of these tests are tests of academic achievement, with the possible exception of some of the subtests of the CELF-III. This testimony was not rebutted during the hearing.

On cross-examination, Dr. Humphrey testified that the Oral Expression cluster of the WJ-III Tests of Achievement is comprised of two subtests: Story Recall and Picture Vocabulary. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that STUDENT=s scores on these tests of academic achievement are the most appropriate scores to utilize in order to determine whether a severe discrepancy exists in the area of oral expression. STUDENT received a standard score of 107 on the Story Recall subtest when it was administered by resource specialist Linda Hirsch in October 2002 and received a standard score of 114 when it was administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002. STUDENT received a standard score of 101 on the Picture Vocabulary subtest when Dr. Humphrey administered it in May of 2003. (Footnote 5) When compared to STUDENT=s CAS full scale score of 121, the differences are fourteen points, seven points, and twenty points, respectively. Thus, in comparing STUDENT=s scores on these tests of achievement with his cognitive ability, there is no severe discrepancy in the area of oral expression.

Basic Reading Skills

Dr. Humphrey also testified that she found a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of basic reading skills. She based her finding on a comparison of STUDENT=s cognitive ability with his scores on the WJ-III Broad Reading Cluster, Reading Fluency subtest, Passage Comprehension subtest and Letter Word Identification subtest administered by District resource specialist Linda Hirsch in October 2002. STUDENT received a standard score of 91 on the Broad Reading Cluster, a score of 91 on the Reading Fluency subtest, a score of 86 on the Passage Comprehension subtest and a score of 99 on the Letter-Word Identification subtest. In comparing STUDENT=s scores to his CAS full scale score of 121, the differences are thirty points, thirty points, thirty-five points, and twenty-two points, respectively. Thus, utilizing this set of scores, a severe discrepancy would exist between STUDENT=s ability and achievement in the area of basic reading skills.

The District contends that STUDENT=s score on the Basic Reading Skills cluster administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002 is the appropriate score to utilize in determining whether a severe discrepancy exists in the area of basic reading skills. Dr. Dunn relied in part on this score in reaching her conclusion that STUDENT does not have a severe discrepancy in the area of basic reading skills. STUDENT received a standard score of 114 on the Basic Reading Skills cluster. When compared to his CAS full-scale score of 121, the difference is seven points, which would not constitute a severe discrepancy.

The Hearing Officer must determine which set of scores more accurately measures STUDENT=s achievement level in the area of basic reading skills: the October 2002 WJ-III administered by Linda Hirsch or the December 2002 WJ-III administered by Dr. Eichenstein. Dr. Humphrey and Dr. Dunn both testified regarding practice effect. According to Dr. Humphrey, the practice effect can occur when an IQ or achievement test is repeated within a short period of time. The subject will perform better on the test the second time around because he is familiar with the material. Dr. Humphrey testified that the manual for the Wechsler Intelligence Scales for Children (WISC) recommends that the test should not be repeated within less than a year=s time. Dr. Dunn testified that she has seen research articles suggesting that a practice effect can occur with respect to cognitive ability assessments, such as the WISC, but she has not seen any such research regarding the WJ-III Tests of Achievement or other academic achievement tests. She attributed the higher scores that STUDENT received on the WJ-III administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002 to the curriculum at Van Gogh.

The Hearing Officer did not find either expert=s testimony on this issue to be particularly persuasive. Given the proximity of the two dates on which the WJ-III was administered to STUDENT, however, the Hearing Officer concludes that the higher scores that STUDENT received in December 2002 were more likely the result of a practice effect than an actual increase in STUDENT=s achievement levels brought about by two months of regular education curriculum. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the October 2002 WJ-III test scores are a more accurate and reliable measurement of STUDENT=s achievement level in the area of basic reading skills and that these scores show a severe discrepancy in this academic area. In addition, STUDENT=s scores on the Grey Oral Reading Test-4 (GORT-4), which measures reading fluency and comprehension, support a finding that a severe discrepancy exists in the area of basic reading skills. On the GORT-4, STUDENT=s reading rate, accuracy, and fluency scores were all at the pre-kindergarten level and his comprehension score was at the kindergarten level. The Hearing Officer thus finds that STUDENT has a severe discrepancy in the area of basic reading skills.

Reading Comprehension

Petitioner contends that he has a severe discrepancy between cognitive ability and achievement in the area of reading comprehension. In comparing STUDENT=s CAS full scale score of 121 to his score of 86 on the Passage Comprehension subtest of the WJ-III administered by Ms. Hirsch in October 2002, a severe discrepancy of 35 points is apparent. The District contends that STUDENT=s score of 104 on the Passage Comprehension subtest administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002 is the more appropriate score by which to measure his academic achievement in the area of reading comprehension. As set forth above, however, the Hearing Officer has concluded that the results of the December WJ-III testing are suspect in light of the proximity of that testing to the October WJ-III administered by Linda Hirsch. In addition, STUDENT=s reading comprehension score on the GORT-4 placed him at the kindergarten level, which is more consistent with the October 2002 Passage Comprehension score. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has a severe discrepancy in the area of the area of reading comprehension.

Written Expression

STUDENT received a standard score of 95 on the Broad Written Language cluster of the WJ-III administered by Linda Hirsch and received a standard score of 94 on the Written Expression cluster of that test. These scores led District psychologist Linda Joslin to conclude in her report that STUDENT has a severe discrepancy in the academic area of written expression. While STUDENT=s score on the Writing Samples subtest increased from a standard score of 95 in October 2002 to a standard score of 103 in December, the Hearing Officer concludes that the cluster scores obtained in October 2002 provide a more reliable measure of STUDENT=s achievement level in the area of written expression for the reasons previously stated. In addition, at the end of the first reporting period for STUDENT=s first grade class, STUDENT was below grade level in writing. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that a severe discrepancy exists between STUDENT=s ability and achievement in the area of written expression.

b) Disorder in Basic Psychological Processes

The second requirement for eligibility based upon a specific learning disability is that the disability must involve a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written which disorder may manifest itself in an imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell or do mathematical calculations. (20 U.S.C. ' 1401(26)(A); 5 Cal. Code Regs. ' 3030(j).) Basic psychological processes include Aattention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expression.@ (5 Cal. Code Regs. ' 3030(j)(1).) In addition, the disorder must not primarily be the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. (34 C.F.R. ' 300.541(b)(4); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56337(b).)

The Hearing Officer must thus determine if STUDENT=s difficulties in reading and written expression are due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using written or spoken language. Petitioner contends that he has a disorder in the Acognitive ability of expression,@ specifically his ability to retrieve information from his memory and convey this information verbally and in writing. (Footnote 6) According to Petitioner, his disorder in the cognitive ability of expression is evidenced by the results of the expressive subtests of the CELF-III, his scores on the rapid word retrieval subtest of the WJ-III, and his scores on the Arapid naming@ subtests of the C-TOPP. The District disputes that Petitioner has a psychological processing disorder in the cognitive ability of expression. Specifically, the District contends that STUDENT=s expressive language test scores are within the average range, along with his scores on other processing tests such as the TAPS-R, MVPT-R, and the Bender.

Petitioner=s expert, Dr. Humphrey, testified concerning the results of her assessment of STUDENT and her review of prior assessments. According to Dr. Humphrey, STUDENT was not previously assessed in the following areas: language, memory and visual motor functioning. To assess STUDENT=s language functioning, Dr. Humphrey administered the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals, III (CELF-III), the Picture Vocabulary subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Achievement, and the Rapid Picture Naming subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities. On the CELF-III, STUDENT received a standard score of 114 for receptive language, placing him in the eighty-second percentile; a score of 94 for expressive language, placing him in the thirty-fourth percentile; and a total language score of 104, placing him in the sixty-first percentile. On the three subtests that measure receptive language, STUDENT=s scores fell above the ninetieth percentile with the exception of Concepts and Directions, where STUDENT=s score fell in the twenty-fifth percentile. On the three subtests that measure expressive language, STUDENT scored as follows: Word Structure (thirty-seventh percentile), Formulated Sentences (sixteenth percentile); and Recalling Sentences (sixty-third percentile). On the Picture Vocabulary subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Achievement, STUDENT received a standard score of 101, placing him in the fifty-third percentile. On the Rapid Picture Naming subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities, STUDENT received a standard score of 77, placing him in the sixth percentile. On the Children=s Memory Scale, most of STUDENT=s immediate memory scores were within expected limits, ranging from the thirty-seventh to the seventy-fifth percentile. STUDENT scored significantly lower on certain subtests, such as the Stories-Delayed Recognition and Stories-Delayed Thematic, Word Pairs-Long Delay, and Faces-Delayed. On the Beery VMI, a test of visual motor integration, STUDENT=s score placed him at the thirty-fourth percentile. On the Rey-Osterreith, STUDENT copied a complex design and then drew it again from memory. His scores placed him at the forty-eighth and fifty-ninth percentiles.

Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT=s severe discrepancies in reading and written expression are due to a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression, specifically his ability to retrieve information from his memory and convey this information verbally and in writing. She diagnosed STUDENT with an expressive language disorder. She based her diagnosis on STUDENT=s scores on the expressive language portion of the CELF-III, specifically STUDENT=s total expressive language score and his scores on the Word Structure subtest and the Formulated Sentence subtest. According to Dr. Humphrey, STUDENT=s scores on these tests should be compared to his cognitive ability, rather than the mean of the test, in order to determine whether a psychological processing disorder exists. Dr. Humphrey compared STUDENT=s total expressive language score of 94 on the CELF-III with STUDENT=s full scale CAS score of 121 and noted a discrepancy of 27 points. She also compared STUDENT=s expressive language score to his receptive language score and found that his expressive score was twenty points lower than his receptive language score. Dr. Humphrey also testified that STUDENT exhibited relative weaknesses on some of the expressive language subtests of the CELF-III. According to Dr. Humphrey, STUDENT had difficulty providing irregular plurals, auxiliary verbs plus A-ing,@ regular and irregular past tense, demonstrative pronouns and future tense on the Word Structure subtest. STUDENT received a scaled score of 9, which, according to Dr. Humphrey, translates to a standard score of 95 and falls within the thirty-seventh percentile. She also testified that STUDENT experienced significant difficulties on the Formulated Sentence subtest, on which STUDENT was required to make up a sentence about a picture he was shown. STUDENT=s scaled score was 7, which translates to a standard score of 90 and places him in the sixteenth percentile. According to Dr. Humphrey, STUDENT=s performance on this test revealed significant difficulties with language organization. Specifically, she testified that STUDENT exhibited significant word finding abilities. Finally, Dr. Humphrey found that STUDENT also exhibits problems with working memory and organization that support her finding of a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression related to his ability to retrieve information from his memory and express it. She testified that although STUDENT=s immediate memory scores on the Children=s Memory Scale were within expected limits, his delayed memory scores were significantly lower.

In contrast, the District=s expert, Dr. Dunn, testified that STUDENT does not have a processing disorder in the cognitive ability of expression. Dr. Dunn based her opinion on STUDENT=s expressive language scores on the CELF-III. She testified that in determining whether a child has a psychological disorder, the child=s score on the processing test is compared to the mean for the test, not to the child=s cognitive ability. If the child=s score on the processing test is within the average range, the child does not have a processing disorder. According to Dr. Dunn, the reason for comparing the child=s score to the mean, as opposed to the child=s cognitive ability, is that the tests, including the CELF-III, are normed to the mean. Dr. Dunn compared STUDENT=s CELF-III expressive language score of 94 to the mean of 100 and noted that his score is in the average range, only six points below the mean.

Dr. Dunn testified that the Cognitive Fluency cluster of the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities would also provide a good measure of STUDENT=s cognitive expression ability. Dr. Dunn pointed out that Dr. Humphrey administered the Rapid Picture Naming subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities, which is one of the three subtests that make up the Cognitive Fluency cluster. She testified that STUDENT=s standard score of 77 on the Rapid Picture Naming subtest, which placed him in the sixth percentile, is not a sufficient basis on which to make a determination as to whether STUDENT has a processing disorder in the cognitive ability of expression. Rather, she stated that that the entire cluster should be administered in order to obtain a complete picture of STUDENT=s cognitive expression.

In support of its position that a processing disorder is determined by comparing the student=s score to the mean, rather than the student=s cognitive ability, the District points to Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3030(c)(4), which sets forth the criteria by which a receptive or expressive language disorder is determined. This section requires a comparison of a student=s scores on standardized tests in the area of language development with the mean of the test. According to sections 3030(c)(4)(A) and 3030(c)(4)(B), the pupil must score at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean, in addition to meeting other requirements, in order to establish a language disorder. The District contends that STUDENT does not meet the requirements for an expressive language disorder under section 3030(c)(4) because STUDENT=s expressive language score of 94 on the CELF-III is less than one-half standard deviation from the mean.

Petitioner contends that the criteria set forth in section 3030(c)(4) are inapplicable to his claim because he is not alleging a language or speech disorder under that section or under California Education Code section 56333. Rather, Petitioner is claiming eligibility under section 3030(j), which does not contain a requirement that the student=s score on the test must be at least 1.5 standard deviations from the mean in order for the student to qualify as having a disorder in a basic psychological process.

The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Dr. Dunn to be persuasive with regard to the methodology to use in determining whether STUDENT has a disorder in the psychological process of the cognitive ability of expression. Specifically, the Hearing Officer is convinced by her testimony that the most appropriate score to utilize in determining the existence of such a disorder is STUDENT=s expressive language score on the CELF-III. The Hearing Officer also finds Dr. Dunn=s testimony persuasive regarding the use of the test=s mean, as opposed to STUDENT=s cognitive ability score, as the appropriate standard by which to compare STUDENT=s score on the CELF-III in determining whether a processing disorder exists. Dr. Dunn=s testimony is supported, in part, by the California Code of Regulations, Title 5, section 3030(c)(4), which requires a comparison of the student=s score on a language test to the mean of the test. (Footnote 7) Thus, in comparing to STUDENT=s expressive language score of 94 on the CELF-III to the mean of 100, a discrepancy of six points, less than one-half a standard deviation, is found. Even if STUDENT=s scores on individual subtests on the CELF-III are used as the basis for comparison, the discrepancy is still less than one standard deviation. For example, on the Word Structure subtest, STUDENT=s standard score of 95 is five points below the mean. On the Formulated Sentence subtest, STUDENT=s standard score of 90 is ten points below the mean. Therefore, considering the totality of the evidence presented at hearing, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT=s severe discrepancies in the areas of in reading and written expression are not due to a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression.

Dr. Humphrey also diagnosed STUDENT with a reading disability, specifically a deficit in phonological processing. According to Dr. Humphrey, phonological processing is the ability to process the individual sounds, or Aphonemes@ in words, and has been identified as the core component of quick, efficient reading. She based her diagnosis on STUDENT=s Broad Reading cluster score on the WJ-III administered in October 2002, his scores on the Arapid naming@ and Phoneme Reversal subtests of the CTOPP, the Grey Oral Reading Test 4 (GORT-4) administered by Dr. Eichenstein, and STUDENT=s reading of the Brown Bear book to Dr. Humphrey. Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT=s score of 91 on the Broad Reading Cluster of the WJ-III represents a twenty-nine point discrepancy between his ability and achievement in the area of reading. On the CTOPP, which measures phonological processing, STUDENT scored lowest on the Arapid naming tests.@ This test was administered by Dr. Eichenstein when STUDENT was 7.0 years old. On Rapid Digit Naming, STUDENT=s score placed him in the twenty-fifth percentile with an age equivalent of 6.6 years. On Rapid Letter Naming, STUDENT=s score placed him in the thirty-seventh percentile, with an age equivalent of 6.9 years. On Rapid Color Naming, STUDENT=s score placed him in the sixteenth percentile with an age equivalent of 5.6 years. On Rapid Object Naming, STUDENT=s score placed him in the ninth percentile, with an age equivalent of 5.6 years. Finally, on the Phoneme Reversal subtest, STUDENT=s score placed him in the sixteenth percentile with an age equivalent of 5.6. According to Dr. Humphrey, children in kindergarten and first grade who experience difficulty with these tests are more likely to have reading problems. Dr. Humphrey also relied upon STUDENT=s scores on the GORT-4, which measures reading fluency and comprehension. According to Dr. Eichenstein=s report, STUDENT=s reading rate, accuracy, and fluency scores were all at the pre-kindergarten level and his comprehension score was at the kindergarten level. Finally, Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT was able to read the Brown Bear book, but demonstrated significant slowing when he needed to decode an unfamiliar word.

Dr. Dunn disagreed with Dr. Humphrey=s conclusion that STUDENT has a reading disorder. According to Dr. Dunn, the CTOPP measures phonological processing, which is a component of auditory processing. Dr. Dunn acknowledged that STUDENT exhibits some weakness in the Arapid naming@ subtests of the CTOPP, but testified that his total score on the CTOPP was in the average range and would not constitute an area of relative weakness. Dr. Dunn also testified regarding other tests that measure auditory processing skills and specifically phonological processing skills. Specifically, Dr. Dunn testified that the Phoneme/Grapheme Knowledge Cluster and the Word Attack and Sound Awareness subtests of the WJ-III Tests of Achievement all test phonological skills. On the Phoneme/Grapheme Knowledge Cluster, STUDENT received a standard score of 106, placing him in the sixty-sixth percentile. On the Word Attack subtest, STUDENT received a standard score of 118, placing him in the eighty-eighth percentile. Finally, on the Sound Awareness subtest, STUDENT received a standard score of 110, placing him in the seventy-fifth percentile. Dr. Dunn testified that these scores, along with STUDENT=s scores on the CTOPP, establish that STUDENT does not have a phonological processing disorder.

The weight of the evidence suggests that STUDENT may have a reading disorder. Specifically, STUDENT=s scores on the GORT-4 were at the pre-kindergarten and kindergarten level. Moreover, Dr. Humphrey, Dr. Eichenstein, and STUDENT=s parents and teachers noted labored decoding when STUDENT read to them. And, as discussed in the prior section, STUDENT=s scores on the WJ-III Broad Reading, Passage Comprehension subtest, and Reading Fluency subtest are significantly discrepant from STUDENT=s cognitive ability. Despite this evidence, however, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence presented at hearing did not establish a link between STUDENT=s reading difficulties and the claimed disorder in the cognitive ability of expression. For while the evidence suggests that STUDENT may have a phonological processing disorder, Dr. Dunn testified credibly that phonological processing is a component of auditory processing as opposed to a component of the cognitive ability of expression. And no testimony was presented at hearing that STUDENT has a disorder in auditory processing, which is another of the basic psychological processes set forth in Education Code section 56337(b). Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT=s severe discrepancy in the areas of basic reading skills, reading comprehension and written expression are not due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes.

(c) Discrepancy Cannot be Corrected Through Other Regular or Categorical Services Offered Within the Regular Instructional Program

The final requirement for eligibility as a child with a specific learning disability is that the severe discrepancy cannot be ameliorated through Aother regular or categorical services@ offered within the regular instructional program. (Cal. Educ. Code ' 56337(c); see 34 C.F.R. ' 300.543(a)(6).) The Petitioner contends that his needs cannot be accommodated in regular education. Respondent contends that STUDENT=s discrepancy can and is being corrected within the regular instructional program.

As indicated above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT=s severe discrepancies in the areas of basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and written expression were not caused by a disorder in the psychological process of the cognitive ability of expression. However, even if STUDENT=s severe discrepancies were due to a processing disorder, the evidence further established that STUDENT=s severe discrepancies can be corrected within the regular instructional program.

MOTHER, STUDENT=s mom, testified that she and FATHER spend between one and two hours per night working with STUDENT on his academic skills, with a focus on his reading and spelling skills. She testified that STUDENT is a slow reader who has difficulty with letter and word recognition and frequently has trouble remembering a word that he learned to sound out moments before. She also testified that STUDENT has difficulty expressing himself verbally, sometimes using two to three sentences to get a point across to the listener.

While the Hearing Officer found FATHER and MOTHER to be both credible witnesses and devoted parents, the Hearing Officer found the testimony of STUDENT=s first grade teachers to be the most persuasive. As set forth below, their testimony supports the District=s position that STUDENT=s severe discrepancy can be corrected through the regular instructional program.

STUDENT=s first grade class was taught by Paula Himmelstein and Hope Watterson. Ms. Himmelstein and Ms. Watterson both testified that STUDENT=s academic skills were at grade level with the exception of reading fluency. With regard to STUDENT=s reading fluency, Ms. Himmelstein testified that she and Ms. Watterson taught STUDENT=s class using the Open Court System, a State standards based curriculum. Ms. Himmelstein testified that three of the first grade teachers decided to team teach and divided their students into three reading groups based on each student=s skill level: Ahigh,@ Amiddle,@ and Alow.@ Ms. Himmelstein taught the middle group, of which STUDENT was a member. She testified that while STUDENT had good reading comprehension skills, he experienced difficulty sounding out and decoding words. In March 2003, the District recommended that STUDENT be placed in an Extended Learning Program to assist him with his reading. This program took place each Monday for one hour for a total of 8 weeks. STUDENT=s Student Progress Report for the Extended Learning Program reflects that he attended six of the eight sessions. The report describes STUDENT=s progress as Asatisfactory@ as opposed to Aunsatisfactory.@ Under the heading of ATeacher Comments,@ the program=s teacher wrote: A[STUDENT] works hard to decode words and is making progress in his oral fluency.@ Ms. Himmelstein testified that STUDENT=s reading fluency improved during the course of the year. Moreover, she testified that STUDENT=s reading comprehension skills were at grade level and that he was always able to answer questions about a passage or story he read. She expressed the opinion that STUDENT can improve his reading fluency by continuing the Open Court Reading curriculum. Specifically, she recommends that STUDENT continue to be taught the sounds that make up words so that he learns letter patterns better, which she believes will increase his reading rate.

Ms. Himmelstein testified that she provided a few accommodations to STUDENT during class due to his difficulties with following directions and his reading fluency. Specifically, she placed his desk towards the front of the class, repeated directions for him when needed, and allowed him additional time to complete reading assignments, with the exception of timed reading assignments. Ms. Himmelstein expressed the opinion that with these accommodations, STUDENT would be able to continue to access the curriculum. Based on the foregoing testimony and evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT=s discrepancies in the areas of basic reading skills and reading comprehension can be corrected through regular education programs.

Ms. Himmelstein testified that STUDENT=s writing skills were below grade level at the beginning at the end of the first reporting period. In November 2002, a notice was sent home to STUDENT=s parents advising them that STUDENT was working below grade level in writing. Ms. Himmelstein testified that his writing skills improved during the course of the school year and that he was writing at grade level by the end of the year. In fact, she testified that STUDENT=s writing improved to the point that he was almost above grade level by the end of the school year. (Footnote 8)Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT=s discrepancy in the area of written expression can and is being corrected through regular education programs.

STUDENT=s grades also support the District=s position that STUDENT=s severe discrepancy can be corrected through the regular instructional program. On his progress reports, STUDENT received grades in the Aproficient@ range (Footnote 9)in reading, writing, listening, speaking, mathematics, history/social science, and science. STUDENT received one Apartially proficient@ mark in writing at the end of the first quarter. However, this mark improved to Aproficient@ for the second and third quarters.

Similarly, during STUDENT=s kindergarten year, he received grades of Avery good@ in all areas, including academic development, oral expression, pre-reading/reading/language skills, science, and social studies, with the exception of Ameets new challenges with confidence@ on which STUDENT received a mark of Agood.@ Lisa Marlow, STUDENT=s kindergarten teacher at the JCC, testified that STUDENT performed at grade level and was able to access the curriculum taught to him, although she was concerned by his difficulty in learning and remembering the letters of the alphabet, words, and days of the week. With regard to his pre-reading and reading skills, however, Ms. Marlow testified that STUDENT received a score of Agood@ at mid-year which improved to Avery good@ at the end of the year. According to Ms. Marlow, STUDENT was able to read and blend words together by the end of the school year.

Taking into account the totality of the evidence presented at hearing, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT=s severe discrepancies can be corrected within the regular instructional program. While the evidence showed that STUDENT did not require special education, the evidence should also put the parties on notice that STUDENT may need special education at some time in the future if modifications and accommodations in the regular education program prove less successful in enabling him to benefit. STUDENT=s difficulties with fluency, perhaps related to a slow processing speed, may require more careful consideration by all.

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT exhibits a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and written expression. The Hearing Officer further determines that these severe discrepancies were not caused by a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression and that STUDENT=s severe discrepancy can be corrected through the regular instructional program. (Footnote 10)

ISSUE NO 2: Did the District assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?

Petitioner contends that the District denied him a free and appropriate public education by failing to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. Specifically, Petitioner contends there were clues in the District=s assessment testing results that indicated that STUDENT had a reading disability. Petitioner contends that the District could and should have given other appropriate assessments, such as the CELF-III and other tests used by Dr. Eichenstein and Dr. Humphrey, to assess STUDENT=s processing abilities and reading difficulties. (Footnote 11) The District contends that its assessments of STUDENT were appropriate based upon the referral of a suspected learning disability.

When a school district conducts an assessment of a child for special education and related services, the school district is required to assess the child in all areas related to the suspected disability. (20 U.S.C. ' 1414(b)(2) and (b)(3)(iii)(C); 34 C.F.R. ' 300.532(g); Cal. Educ. Code '' 56320(f) and 56381(a).). Areas related to a suspected disability may include health and development, vision (including low vision), hearing, motor abilities, language function, general intelligence, academic performance, communicative status, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social emotional status. (34 C.F.R. ' 300.532(g); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56320(f).) According to the IDEA, the purpose of the assessment is to gather all relevant information, including information provided by the parents, that will assist the IEP team to determine whether the student is a child with a disability and, if so, to provide the team with the information it will need to develop an appropriate individualized education plan. (20 U.S.C. ' 1414(b)(2)(A).)

In this case, STUDENT=s parents referred him for assessment at Van Gogh due to concerns over STUDENT=s difficulties in learning and retaining academic subjects and specifically his difficulties in letter and word recognition and reading comprehension. They were also concerned about his memory and his ability to express himself verbally. On September 13, 2002, the District prepared a Special Education Assessment Plan for STUDENT. According to the plan, STUDENT was to be assessed in the following areas: social/emotional development, cognitive development, academic achievement, perceptual development, motor development, communications/language functioning, and health. On September 19, 2002, MOTHER signed the assessment plan, indicating her consent to assess STUDENT. On October 22 and 29, 2002, Linda Joslin, school psychologist for Van Gogh elementary, conducted a psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the assessment plan developed in September. Ms. Joslin administered the Cognitive Assessment System (CAS) to measure his cognitive processing ability. To measure STUDENT=s academic achievement, Linda Hirsch, the District=s resource specialist, administered the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement, III (WJ-III), Form A. Ms. Joslin also administered the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills-Revised (TAPS-R), the Motor-Free Visual Perception Test-Revised (MVPT-R), the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test, the Sentence Completion Test, and Draw-A-Person. (Footnote 12)Finally, she reviewed the parent questionnaire, the teacher assessment form and STUDENT=s school records. As previously set forth, Ms. Joslin concluded that STUDENT demonstrated a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of reading and written expression. Ms. Joslin testified that she did not see any indication of a processing disorder based upon STUDENT=s scores on the TAPS-R, the MVPT-R, and the Bender. Ms. Joslin also testified that she did not see the need for further testing based upon the results of her assessments.

Dr. Humphrey, the Petitioner=s expert, testified that, in her opinion, the previous assessments did not address all areas of concern. She stated that the areas not previously addressed were STUDENT=s memory, language, and visual motor functioning. According to Dr. Humphrey, STUDENT=s scores on the achievement tests administered by the District should have put the District on notice that STUDENT was struggling with language development in ways that were inconsistent with his ability. She discussed STUDENT=s scores on the WJ-R administered by Virginia Williams in 2001 and STUDENT=s scores on the WJ-III administered by Linda Hirsch in October 2002. With respect to the testing by Ms. Williams, Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT=s scores on the following subtests of the WJ-R were indicative of a potential learning disability: STUDENT=s standard score of 79 on the Picture Vocabulary subtest, which placed him at the eighth percentile; his standard score of 80 on the Verbal Analogies subtest, which placed him in the tenth percentile; his standard score of 83 on Spelling, which placed him in the thirteenth percentile; and his score on Passage Comprehension, which placed him in the sixteenth percentile. With respect to the testing conducted by Linda Hirsch, Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT=s score of 86 on the Passage Comprehension subtest of the WJ-III, which placed him at the seventeenth percentile, was also unexpected given STUDENT=s cognitive ability. According to Dr. Humphrey, these results would compel an experienced clinician to investigate further into STUDENT=s language system. Specifically, Dr. Humphrey opined that the standard of practice would be to administer language assessments as well as an assessment of STUDENT=s phonological processing.

Based upon the totality of the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District=s assessment of STUDENT was not appropriate because the District failed to conduct assessments in the areas of language processing and phonological processing. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Humphrey=s testimony on this issue persuasive. Specifically, the Hearing Officer finds that in light of STUDENT=s scores on the WJ-R administered by Virginia Williams and his scores on the WJ-III administered by Linda Joslin, assessments of STUDENT=s language processing and phonological processing should have been administered. While Ms. Joslin found a severe discrepancy between STUDENT=s ability and achievement in the areas of reading and written expression, she did not undertake any additional testing to attempt to determine the reason for these discrepancies. In addition, the evidence establishes that the District failed to assess STUDENT in the area of speech and language even though the assessment plan called for such testing. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District violated its obligation to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.

ISSUE NO 3: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following privately obtained assessments:

1 Neuro-psychoeducational assessment by Dr. Rita Eichenstein on December 20, 2002, in the approximate amount of $1700;

2 Functional visual assessment by optometrist Trang Nguyen on January 18, 2003, in the approximate amount of $115;

3 Psychological and educational assessments by Dr. Lorie Humphrey on May 8, 2003, in the approximate amount of $1275?

Petitioner contends that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of assessments they procured because the District=s assessment of him in October 2002 was inadequate. The District contends that STUDENT=s parents are not entitled to reimbursement because the District=s assessments were appropriate and because the assessments by Dr. Eichenstein and Dr. Nguyen were obtained prior to MOTHER=s receipt of the District=s assessment reports.

California Education Code section 56329 (b) and (c) provides that a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation.

In this case, Petitioner seeks reimbursement for multiple assessments. Two of the assessments, however, were procured before Petitioner received the District=s assessment reports from the assessments conducted in October of 2002. Specifically, Dr. Eichenstein=s assessment in December 2002 and Dr. Nguyen=s assessment in January of 2003 were obtained before STUDENT=s parents received the District=s assessment reports and before those assessments were first discussed at the IEP meeting on February 25, 2003. MOTHER testified that she knew the District was going to complete the assessments she requested in September 2002 at the time that she decided to obtain outside assessments. Despite this knowledge, however, she proceeded to obtain Dr. Eichenstein=s evaluation and Dr. Nguyen=s vision evaluation before receiving the District=s assessments. In San Dieguito Union High School District, SEHO Case No. SN02-01363, the Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for independent assessments procured before the school district completed its assessments. In Redlands Unified School District, SEHO Case No. SN03-00953, the Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for independent assessments procured before the parents received the District=s assessment reports. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT=s parents could not disagree with the District=s October 2002 assessment reports prior to the time they sought the independent evaluations by Dr. Eichenstein and Dr. Nguyen because their testimony establishes that they had not yet received the District=s assessment reports. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner=s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the assessments conducted by Dr. Eichenstein and Dr. Nguyen.

Petitioner also seeks reimbursement for the assessment conducted by Dr. Humphrey in May 2003. MOTHER testified at hearing that she obtained the assessment from Dr. Humphrey because she disagreed with the District=s October 2002 assessments, which were discussed at the IEP meeting of February 25, 2003. Since this assessment was obtained after MOTHER received the results of the District=s assessment, it is appropriate to consider Petitioner=s request for reimbursement of the cost of this assessment.

The Hearing Officer determined above that the District did fail to assess STUDENT appropriately in the areas of language functioning and phonological processing. Additionally, Dr. Humphrey=s testimony established that she was qualified to assess STUDENT and that her assessment addressed those areas of need that the District did not assess appropriately, namely STUDENT=s language functioning. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents are entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Humphrey=s assessment.

ISSUE NO. 4: Did the District Consider the Independent Educational Evaluations Obtained by Petitioner?

Petitioner contends that the District failed to adhere to the procedural requirements of State and federal law by failing to consider the independent educational evaluations by Dr. Eichenstein and Dr. Nguyen at the February 25, 2003 IEP meeting and by failing to consider those two assessments and Dr. Humphrey=s assessment at the IEP meeting on June 3, 2003.

The courts have created a two-pronged test for determining whether a procedural violation resulted in a denial of FAPE for a student: 1) whether a procedural protection has been violated, and 2) whether the violation resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringed on the parent=s participation in the IEP process. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483.)

The IDEA and State law assures the parents the right to participate in the IEP process. (20 U.S.C. ' 1400(c)(5)(B).) One or both parents are to be included on an IEP team. (Cal. Educ. Code ' 56341(b)(1).) If the parents disagree with the district=s assessment, they have the right to obtain their own independent assessment and to have the results of that assessment considered by the district. (20 U.S.C. ' 1400(c)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. ' 300.502(c)(1); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56329(b).)

In this case, the evidence establishes that the District failed to consider the IEEs of Dr. Eichenstein and Dr. Nguyen at the February 2003 IEP meeting. MOTHER testified that she provided copies of Dr. Eichenstein=s and Dr. Nguyen=s reports to the IEP team just prior to the IEP meeting. However, the IEP notes from that meeting do not reflect any discussion of either report. While Linda Joslin, the District school psychologist, testified that she reviewed Dr. Eichenstein=s report during the IEP meeting, she also admitted that she did not consider Dr. Eichenstein=s report in reaching her determination that STUDENT does not have a processing disorder. Furthermore, she testified that she was unfamiliar with some of the testing instruments used by Dr. Eichenstein, including the WRAVMA, the NEPSY, the Children=s Anxiety Test, the CTOPP, and the TOVA. Because she was unfamiliar with these tests, she was unable to offer a competent opinion as to the implications of the results of this testing. Despite her lack of familiarity with the testing, Ms. Joslin did not contact Dr. Eichenstein during the meeting, even though Dr. Eichenstein was available during the meeting by telephone.

Similarly, the evidence establishes that the District failed to consider the IEEs of Dr. Eichenstein, Dr. Nguyen, and Dr. Humphrey at the June 2003 IEP meeting. While the notes of the June IEP meeting contain summaries of these reports, Ms. Joslin testified that she was not familiar with some of the testing instruments used by Dr. Humphrey, including the CELF-III. Because the evidence clearly establishes that Ms. Joslin did not have a sufficient understanding of several of the testing instruments used by Dr. Eichenstein and Dr. Humphrey, it necessarily follows that the IEP team could not appropriately consider these IEEs at either IEP. Based on this evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District=s failure to consider the IEEs of Dr. Eichenstein, Dr. Nguyen, and Dr. Humphrey at the February and June 2003 IEP meetings was a procedural violation of State and federal law.

The second prong for determining whether a procedural violation resulted in a denial of FAPE is whether the student has suffered any prejudice. In this case, the Hearing Officer heard testimony from Dr. Humphrey and reviewed her assessment report, in addition to those prepared by Dr. Nguyen and Dr. Eichenstein. After consideration of this and other evidence presented at hearing, the Hearing Officer concluded that STUDENT is not eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner was not prejudiced by the District=s failure to consider these assessments. (Footnote 13)

ISSUE NO. 5: If Petitioner was or is eligible for special education services, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of Lindamood Bell services?

Petitioner contends that the District has denied him a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) and requests a compensatory education award that would include an eighty-hour intensive reading program, two hours per week of language therapy, and one hour per week of counseling.

The Hearing Officer found that STUDENT is not currently, nor was he eligible for special education services at any time during the 2002-2003 school year as a student with a specific learning disability. Therefore, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education in the form of Lindamood Bell services, language therapy, or counseling.

ORDER

1. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse the parents for the cost of the independent psycho-educational assessment conducted by Dr. Humphrey, Ph.D., in May 2003.

2. All of Petitioner=s remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:

1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2002-2003 school year?

The District prevailed on this issue.

2. Did the District assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained assessments?

The District prevailed with respect to reimbursement for the assessments by Dr. Eichenstein and Dr. Nguyen. The Petitioner prevailed with respect to reimbursement for the assessments by Dr. Humphrey.

4. Did the District consider the independent educational evaluations obtained by Petitioner?

The District prevailed on this issue.

5. If STUDENT was or is eligible for special education services, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of Lindamood-Bell services, language therapy, and/or counseling?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).)

Date: August 14, 2003 ___________________________________ Christian P. Hurley, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The issues are not listed specifically as stated on the first day of hearing. They have been reorganized for this Decision to facilitate analysis.

2. In his closing brief, Petitioner alleges, for the first time, various procedural violations by the District. These include allegations that the District: 1) Afailed to act in a manner that is conducive with the policies of the IDEA, California education laws and the Chanda Smith decree@; 2) Afailed to have all required members of the IEP team present at the February and June 03 IEP meetings@; and 3) Afailed to produce a written report regarding the finding as to eligibility.@ Petitioner requested the hearing in this matter and thereby was entitled to frame the issues for hearing. Because these alleged violations were not put at issue as required by Education Code ' 56505(e)(6), the Hearing Officer will not adjudicate these issues through this Decision.

3. MOTHER testified at hearing that she was told by District representatives that the assessments conducted in October 2001 would have to be addressed at the October 2002 IEP meeting before additional assessments could be undertaken.

4. The IEP document dated February 25, 2003, reflects that the IEP meeting was originally scheduled for November 26, 2002, but was postponed on numerous occasions at the request of STUDENT=s mother to allow for outside assessments and the attendance of STUDENT=s prior teachers. No evidence was presented at hearing contradicting this statement.

5. According to the evidence presented at hearing, the Picture Vocabulary subtest was also administered by resource specialist Virginia Williams in October of 2001. STUDENT received a standard score of 79, placing him in the eighth percentile. Since this subtest was administered by Dr. Humphrey approximately nineteen months after the original testing, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT=s score on the later test is the better measurement of STUDENT=s current achievement level in the area of oral expression.

6. At the beginning of the hearing, during the clarification of the issues, Petitioner contended that his severe discrepancies were due to an auditory processing disorder. During the testimony of Petitioner=s expert, Dr. Humphrey, Petitioner dropped this contention and instead alleged that his severe discrepancies were caused by a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression, which is one of the psychological processes enumerated in Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3030(j)(1).

7. In reading the entirety of section 3030, it is clear that the criteria set forth in section 3030(c)(4) with respect to the determination of a language disorder are not incorporated into or otherwise referenced in section 3030(j). Nevertheless, section 3030(c)(4) is the only section in the Code of Regulations which provides any guidance as to the appropriate methodology to use in determining the existence of an expressive language disorder.

8. Ms. Himmelstein testified that STUDENT=s writing ability would be above grade level but for his spelling. She stated that his spelling ability does not correspond with his strong writing ability, but described his spelling as age appropriate. She further testified that STUDENT=s spelling errors demonstrate that he is learning the rules of phonics because he spells phonetically even when he misspells a word, i.e. Abruther@ instead of brother and Afrend@ instead of friend.

9. According to STUDENT=s progress report, Aproficient@ means Ameets grade level standards.@ The scores are defined as follows: A1@ equals Anot proficient,@ A2@ is Apartially proficient,@ A3@ is Aproficient,@ and A4@ is Aadvanced.@

10. Petitioner also contends that STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability for the 2003-2004 school year. For the reasons previously set forth, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is not eligible, at this time, for special education for the 2003-2004 school year under the category of specific learning disability.

11. In his closing brief, Petitioner also alleges, for the first time, that the District failed to offer a mental health assessment or make a referral for AB 3632 mental health services despite a diagnosis of post traumatic stress disorder by Dr. Eichenstein and Dr. Humphrey. Because these alleged violations were not put at issue as required by Education Code ' 56505(e)(6), the Hearing Officer will not adjudicate this issue through this Decision.

12. Although the assessment plan called for a speech and language assessment, no speech and language testing was conducted as part of the October 2002 psycho-educational assessment. At the hearing, Ms. Joslin testified that she does not conduct speech and language assessments and does not know why STUDENT did not undergo speech and language testing. At the June 2003 IEP meeting, the District indicated its intent to conduct a speech and language assessment of STUDENT to investigate possible central auditory processing disorders. MOTHER testified that she initially accepted this offer, but later rescinded her acceptance out of concern that additional testing could delay STUDENT=s due process hearing.

13. This finding does not excuse the District=s conduct with respect to these IEP meetings. In the future, the District should take steps to ensure that its psychologists have appropriate experience with the testing instruments utilized by private assessors so that they can meaningfully discuss the test results with the other members of the IEP team.