California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 30, 1998
Student v. Santa Barbara County Office of Education et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 478-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
Santa Barbara County Office of Education must reimburse a preschooler's home behavioral program, private preschool and one independent evaluation.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a five-year-old with autism filed for a hearing against the Santa Barbara County Office of Education and Santa Barbara SELPA. They challenged placement offers covering spring 1996 through the 1997-98 school year. Since early 1996 the parents had paid for an intensive home-based 1:1 behavioral program supervised by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD). The boy also attended a small private preschool, Melody's Day Preschool, with a 1:1 aide.
Hearing Officer Mark Paxson found that the County's 1996 offer of 25 hours a week of 1:1 therapy, with a 15-hour-a-week summer program, did not meet the boy's needs. His experts and therapists showed he needed at least 30 hours of 1:1 therapy plus support at preschool. For 1996-97, the County never made a specific written offer, only a choice between program types. Under Union School District v. Smith, that denied FAPE. The 1997-98 offer combined an inclusion preschool and an autism special day class with little 1:1 instruction, so it also did not meet his needs.
The Hearing Officer found both CARD and Melody's proper and ordered reimbursement from April 1996 through extended school year 1998. Costs paid by the Regional Center and ordinary household items were excluded. The County's 1996 assessment was adequate. Its failure to reassess in 1997 justified reimbursement only for Dr. Diane Kirchner's 1997 reevaluation. The other independent evaluations were not reimbursed.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith: a menu of placement options without set hours or services was not a valid offer. It also shows reimbursement under Burlington and Carter for a parent-run home behavioral program. Finally, it shows that reimbursement for a parent's evaluation depended on whether conditions called for a district reassessment.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did Respondents propose an appropriate placement for the remainder of the 1995-96 school year and extended school year 1996, at the IEP meetings held in April 1996?
The offer of 25 hours of 1:1 therapy a week (19 at home, 6 at day care) and a 15-hour-a-week, eight-week summer program did not meet the student's unique needs; he needed at least 30 hours of home 1:1 therapy plus support at preschool.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2. Did Respondents propose an appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year?
Respondents never made a formal written offer of a specific placement for 1996-97. Offering a choice between an inclusion model and a special day class, with hours and services left undecided, violated Union v. Smith, confused the parents, and denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Did Respondents propose an appropriate placement, including goals and objectives, for the 1997-98 school year?
The offer of a Village Park preschool inclusion program plus an autism special day class at Orange Avenue would have given roughly 7 to 11.5 hours of 1:1 instruction a week. The student did not learn incidentally and needed intensive 1:1 instruction, so the offer was not designed to meet his needs.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the CARD program, including materials and supplies, from April 12, 1996, to the end of the 1997-98 extended school year?
The CARD home program gave significant educational benefit and was proper under Burlington and Carter. It must be reimbursed, except costs the Regional Center paid and ordinary items parents would normally buy.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs, including tuition, 1:1 aide and transportation, associated with the Melody Day Preschool from April 12, 1996, to the end of the 1997-98 extended school year?
Melody's small, structured setting with typically developing peers and a 1:1 aide was a proper placement for socialization and for generalizing skills, so its costs must be reimbursed.
- Student prevailed in partIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 6. Is Petitioner entitled to retroactive reimbursement for independent assessments conducted by Dr. Jacquelyn Wynn, Dr. Tristram Smith, and Dr. Diane Kirchner?
The County's 1996 assessment without standardized tests was appropriate for a preschooler. However, the County's failure to reassess by summer 1997 justified reimbursement for Dr. Kirchner's 1997 reassessment. Dr. Wynn's evaluation, Dr. Kirchner's first evaluation and Dr. Smith's consultation are not reimbursable.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Upon presentation of proof, reimburse costs of the in-home program supervised by CARD from April 1996 through the end of extended school year 1998. Excluded: costs already paid by the Regional Center, and materials and supplies not specifically designed for the CARD program that are ordinary items parents would normally buy.
- Reimbursement. Upon presentation of proof, reimburse costs of the student's participation at Melody's Day Preschool from April 1996 through the end of extended school year 1998. The issue as framed included tuition, the 1:1 aide and transportation.
- IEE at public expense. Upon presentation of proof, reimburse costs of Dr. Diane Kirchner's 1997 reevaluation, including travel expenses for that visit.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56381; Education Code § 56441.11(e); 5 CCR § 3042(a)
People named in the decision
- Florene Bednersh, Director of special education, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
- Marcia McClish, SELPA director, Santa Barbara SELPA
- Jacqueline Wynn, Assistant director; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention
- Diane Kirchner, Neurolinguist in private practice; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student
- Melody Wynn, Director and owner of private preschool, Melody's Day Preschool
- Elizabeth McGivern, 1:1 behavioral therapist, CARD-supervised home program
- Melissa Hayward, 1:1 behavioral therapist, CARD-supervised home program
- Tristram Smith, Assistant professor of psychology; consultant and expert witness for Student, Washington State University
- Doreen Granpeesheh, Clinical director; behavioral program supervisor and expert witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Sandy Danaher, Coordinator, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
- Rennett Facciobene, Preschool specialist; district assessor, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
- Jo Tibbetts, Speech-language pathologist and preschool specialist; assessor and speech provider, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
- Charlene Cunningham, Special day class preschool teacher, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
- Adriana Schuler, Professor of special education; expert witness for Respondents, San Francisco State University
- Howard Rothman, School psychologist, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
- Jan Traphagen, Special day class teacher; proposed discrete trial consultant, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
- Catherine Breen, Coordinator, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
- Colleen Jamison, School psychologist; expert witness for Respondents, State of Hawaii Department of Education
- Tiina Itkonen, Special education teacher and mainstream liaison, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
- Sheela Buckley, Special day class teacher (proposed supervisor), Santa Barbara County Office of Education
- Beth Anderson, Occupational therapist; evaluator and OT provider
- Peter Hasler, Medical consultant (evaluator), Tri-Counties Regional Center
- Karen Davidson, Developmental pediatrician (evaluator)
- Ann Blanton, Infant specialist (evaluator), Tri-Counties Regional Center
- Celina Andrada, Service coordinator, Tri-Counties Regional Center
- Lani Hughes Ashley, Staff psychologist (evaluator), Tri-Counties Regional Center
- Debra Wright, Advocate for Student (filed hearing request)
- Holdsambek and Associates, Agency that employed one of the student's therapists
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), Private behavioral intervention provider
- Melody's Day Preschool, Private (noncertified) day care preschool
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Santa Barbara, California, on February 17, 18, 19, and 20, April 7, 8, 9, 16, and 17, and May 26, 27, and 28.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Kathryn Dobel. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER. Respondents Santa Barbara County Office of Education (COE) and Santa Barbara SELPA (SELPA) were represented by attorney Sharon Watt. Also present on the COE’s behalf was Florene Bednersh, director of special education. Present on the SELPA’s behalf was Marcia McClish, director.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing briefs. Those briefs were received, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
The following witnesses testified during the hearing: Florene Bednersh, director of special education for the COE; Jacqueline Wynn, assistant director of the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention; Diane Kirchner, a neurolinguist in private practice; Melody Wynn, director and owner of Melody Day Preschool; Elizabeth McGivern, one of STUDENT’s behavioral therapists; Melissa Hayward, one of STUDENT’s behavioral therapists; GRANDMOTHER STUDENT’s grandmother; GRANDMOTHER, STUDENT’s grandmother; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; FATHER, STUDENT’s father; Tristram Smith, assistant professor in psychology at Washington State University; Doreen Granpeesheh, clinical director for CARD; Sandy Danaher, coordinator with the COE; Rennett Facciobene, preschool specialist with the COE; Jo Tibbetts, speech pathologist and preschool specialist with the COE; Charlene Cunningham, special day class preschool teacher for the COE; Adriana Schuler, professor of special education, San Francisco State University; Howard Rothman, school psychologist with the COE; Jan Traphagen, special day class teacher with the COE; Catherine Breen, coordinator with the COE; Colleen Jamison, school psychologist with the State of Hawaii Department of Education; Tiina Itkonen, special education teacher and mainstream liaison with the COE;
ISSUES(FOOTNOTE 1)
(1) Did Respondents propose an appropriate placement for the remainder of the 1995-96 school year and extended school year 1996, at the IEP meetings held in April 1996?
(2) Did Respondents propose an appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year?
(3) Did Respondents propose an appropriate placement for the 1997-98 school year?
(4) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the CARD program, including materials and supplies, from April 12, 1996, to the end of the 1997-98 extended school year?
(5) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs, including tuition, 1:1 aide and transportation, associated with the Melody Day Preschool from April 12, 1996, to the end of the 1997-98 extended school year?
(6) Is Petitioner entitled to retroactive reimbursement for independent assessments conducted by Dr. Jacquelyn Wynn, Dr. Tristram Smith, and Dr. Diane Kirchner?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a five-year-old boy whose birthdate is [date redacted]. He is eligible for special education as a result of autism. He currently attends preschool at a noncertified, nonpublic day care program, Melody’s Day Preschool (Melody’s), and participates in a 1:1 intensive behavioral intervention program at home through the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD). STUDENT started at Melody’s in September 1995 for three eight-hour days per week. Once STUDENT was diagnosed with autism, his attendance at Melody’s was cut back to four hours per day. STUDENT currently attends Melody’s five days per week for four hours per day. STUDENT started the CARD program on February 10, 1996, with 1:1 therapy provided at home for approximately 25 hours per week. The CARD program is a workshop program, which means that, while CARD provides the senior therapist, STUDENT’s parents hired and paid for the 1:1 therapists, who are trained by CARD and supervised by the senior therapist provided by CARD. CARD also provides ongoing training and weekly meetings with all therapists working with STUDENT.
On November 9, 1995, shortly before his third birthday, STUDENT was evaluated by Dr. Peter Hasler, a medical consultant for the Tri-Counties Regional Center (Regional Center). Based on his observations of STUDENT, Dr. Hasler determined that “STUDENT clearly has a number [of] areas of strength, including all motor skills. While his speech and social skills are substantially delayed, they are not absent. He shows affection in his positive relationship with his family. He shows the ability to communicate both nonverbally and with several single words. He shows understanding of basic routines and rules within his house. Numerous examples given by his family demonstrates his ability to learn and to acquire new skills relatively quickly.” Dr. Hasler further stated that “within the spectrum of Pervasive Developmental Disorders, STUDENT’s situation appears substantial but not severe. If this is confirmed as his diagnosis I would be optimistic about his ability to acquire new social and language skills given proper support services.” Dr. Hasler recommended that direct services to STUDENT include behavioral, educational, and communication interventions.
On November 13, 1995, Dr. Karen Davidson, a developmental pediatrician, evaluated STUDENT. Dr. Davidson reported in her report that “STUDENT was unable to tolerate the intensity of the interactions that [formal assessment] involves. His skills appeared very uneven, with strength in motor areas. His problem solving skills could not be evaluated, as he did not engage in any elaborative play or schema formation, and tended to be very regressive and disconnected, locked within his sensory-motor routines.” Dr. Davidson concluded that STUDENT demonstrated a “disability included in the autistic spectrum.”
On December 7, 1995, an Infant Assessment Report of STUDENT was completed by Ann Blanton, infant specialist with the Regional Center. Ms. Blanton evaluated STUDENT in the areas of social/self-help, fine motor, gross motor, expressive language, and receptive language. STUDENT’s developmental levels in these areas ranged from the 20-23 month level in some self-help skills and in some receptive and expressive language skills to the 32-35 month level for gross motor skills. Ms. Blanton determined that STUDENT’s primary delays were in the areas of speech, social and fine motor skills.
On December 14, 1995, Celina Andrada, service coordinator for the Regional Center, referred STUDENT to the Santa Barbara County Office of Education (COE). On January 3, 1996, MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, signed an assessment plan developed by the COE. The assessment called for a review of the current independent assessments along with observations of STUDENT and parent and teacher interviews.
During a series of Individual Program Plan meetings held on December 19, 1995, February 6, 1996, and February 8, 1996, the Regional Center developed a plan which included the following components:
(1) An intensive behavioral modification program will be undertaken. (2) Specially trained therapists will train parent[s] in CARD techniques so they can act as the primary change agents in developing communication, social skills, and modify inappropriate behavior. (3) The Regional Center agrees to fund 25 hours of parent training, under the direction of vendored behavior therapist, Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, at which time service provision and parent training will terminate.
On January 4, 1996, Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, clinical director for the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), completed a diagnostic evaluation report. Dr. Granpeesheh concluded that STUDENT has “behaviors which are consistent with the diagnosis of Autism” and recommended that STUDENT “receive 20-30 hours [per week] of intensive behavior modification therapy to improve behavioral skills in all of STUDENT’s delayed developmental areas. Specifically, therapy will provide STUDENT with an appropriate learning environment in which deficient skills will be replaced by newly acquired appropriate behaviors.”
On February 12, 1996, Dr. Hasler completed a Medical ID Note. Dr. Hasler stated in the Note that “while it is clear that STUDENT has significant impairments in the basic areas of reciprocal social interaction, development of language and communication, and his range of activities and interest ... he clearly has a number of strengths and positives which suggest that the degree of disorder is on the mild end of the spectrum. These features include his current expressive capability of almost 100 words, his affectionate nature within his family context, and his lack of severe repetitive stereotypic behaviors. These features provide circumstantial evidence to the impression that STUDENT probably has normal cognition and is beginning to develop functional language.” Dr. Hasler suggested that STUDENT’s program address four areas of need: acquisition of communication skills, development of reciprocal social relationships, a complete educational program, and “the instillation of behavioral/disciplinary self-regulation.” Dr. Hasler concluded the Note with the following statement:
As a pediatrician and parent, it would be my goal for all services to be focused on tapping into STUDENT’s potential for developing personally rewarding relationships with other individuals. I would like him to comprehend as much as he is possible the benefits of social interactions. I firmly believe that it is this drive to be connected with others, which is the most powerful force within human development in the areas of communication, language, and social skills. Therefore, I would recommend that the basis for evaluating and monitoring any interventional program or service be the quality of the relationships which are developed within that service or program. This can compliment or conflict with other appropriate goals, such as the acquisition of vocabulary, socially appropriate behaviors, or the extinguishment of atypical habits.
On February 22, 1996, Dr. Lani Hughes Ashley, a staff psychologist with the Regional Center, completed a Psychological ID Note. Dr. Ashley observed STUDENT and completed the Gillman Autism Rating Scale. STUDENT’s score on the Gillman fell in the range of 89-100 which, according to Dr. Ashley, placed him in the “probable autism” range. Dr. Ashley concluded “that STUDENT does possess mild autism with his most significant weakness in communication.” Dr. Ashley recommended that STUDENT receive speech and language services and behavior therapy services, including parent education and discreet trial training.
On March 8, 1996, Rennett Facciobene, preschool specialist, and Jo Tibbetts, speech and language specialist, completed an assessment of STUDENT. Both assessors observed STUDENT at his home and day care setting several times and reviewed the earlier assessments. Ms. Tibbetts worked with STUDENT a total of eight times from January 18 until the report was prepared. Each session was at STUDENT’s day care and lasted for approximately one hour. Ms. Tibbetts noted that “from the initiation of this diagnostic period, this evaluator has seen improvements in STUDENT’s ability to maintain eye contact during a singing and gesture activity, interact with toys more appropriately, initiate social interaction, and use words and word approximations with prompts. These observations of emerging skills are indeed encouraging.” The assessors suggested the following goals: improving receptive and expressive language skills, improving attending skills, improving pragmatics, improving social interaction skills with peers, expanding interest in and appropriate interaction with a variety of toys and preschool materials, and expanding participation in group activities. The assessors did not make any specific recommendation regarding the type of program STUDENT should participate in.
On March 15, 1996, Dr. Granpeesheh completed an Initial Assessment of STUDENT. The assessment was based on observations of STUDENT at home, parent interview, review of records, and a “reinforcement inventory” completed by STUDENT’s parents. Dr. Granpeesheh identified a series of target behaviors, such as noncompliant behavior, tantrum behavior, inappropriate sleeping, inappropriate toileting, and self-stimulatory behavior and recommended an intervention plan for the target behaviors. The intervention plan consisted of a series of reinforcement steps of appropriate behavior, disapproval and redirection steps for inappropriate behavior, and objectives addressing each of the target behaviors.
By April 1996, CARD was providing STUDENT with 30 hours of 1:1 therapy per week at home. A 1:1 aide for STUDENT did not start at Melody’s until Fall 1996 because his parents could not afford the additional time.
The first IEP meeting for STUDENT was convened by the COE on April 12, 1996. During the meeting, STUDENT’s parents presented information regarding the progress STUDENT had made since starting the CARD program and also presented an extensive list of goals and objectives to address fine motor, gross motor, cognitive, receptive and expressive language, rote, articulation, verbal imitation, nonverbal imitation, verbal directions, general and conversational speech, self-help, social, and inappropriate behaviors. The goals and objectives list included over 120 different objectives. The COE offered a special day class, which was rejected by STUDENT’s parents, who requested a 1:1 behavioral program for 35 hours per week, including six hours at STUDENT’s preschool. STUDENT’s parents also requested supervision of the program by CARD for four hours every six weeks, speech and language services three times per week for one hour per session, occupational therapy for two times per week for one hour per session, and supplies to be provided by the COE or to be budgeted for in the amount of $50 per month. STUDENT’s parents requested that these services continue through the summer.
On April 25, 1996, STUDENT’s IEP team again met. During this meeting, the COE offered 45 minutes of speech and language services per week, supervision by a discreet trial consultant employed by the COE for four hours per month, and 20 hours of 1:1 therapy per week. The 1:1 therapy would be provided by instructional assistants for 19 hours per week and by a special day class teacher for 1 hour per week. The 1:1 therapy would consist of 6 hours in the day care and 14 hours at home. The special day class teacher would also provide 2 hours of supervision per week. The discreet trial consultant was identified as Jan Traphagen. The special day class teacher was identified as Sheela Buckley. The COE also offered a six-week summer program and proposed that STUDENT transition to a special day class in September 1996. STUDENT’s parents continued to request a 35-hour-per-week program of 1:1 therapy provided by CARD. The 35 hours was to be broken up into 29 at home and 6 hours at Melody’s. They also requested 3 hours of speech and language per week. STUDENT’s parents also expressed concern about transition from the CARD program to a program supervised by the COE. The COE indicated a willingness to have its staff trained by CARD. The IEP team was unable to reach an agreement regarding placement. Issues remained regarding having Jan Traphagen supervise STUDENT’s program because of his parents’ concerns regarding her training, the number of hours of 1:1, and the length of the extended school year program.
On April 29, 1996, Dr. Ashley submitted a memo to the Regional Center regarding her recommendation for STUDENT, stating the following:
I was encouraged that a productive discussion took place at the planning meeting held on 4/25/96 in the Carpinteria office, where the County Schools representative said that they were willing to offer 20 hours a week of discreet trial training, 14 hours in home and 6 hours in a preschool setting.
I feel clinically that STUDENT would benefit greatly from this intervention through the schools. I recommend that Regional Center fund 25 additional hours to help transition STUDENT into the 20 hour per week program. This should include helping the trainings of the County Schools acquire the skills currently being offered to STUDENT through the CARD system. Clinically, discreet trial training is the best intervention for STUDENT at this time due to his age and degree of autism....
On May 8, 1996, the COE faxed a final IEP to Debra Wright, who was serving as Petitioner’s advocate at the time.(FOOTNOTE 2) The IEP called for 45 minutes per week of speech and language, four hours per month of supervision by a certificated special education teacher, and 25 hours per week of 1:1 therapy provided by instructional assistants. The instructional assistants would work with STUDENT for 6 hours per week in his day care setting and 19 hours per week at home and would be supervised by a special day class teacher for 2 hours per week. The special day class teacher would also provide 1:1 therapy for STUDENT for one hour per week. The IEP also called for STUDENT to receive extended school year services, consisting of 15 hours per week of 1:1 therapy provided by instructional assistants with one hour of supervision by a special day class teacher, for eight weeks. The IEP also included 22 pages of goals and objectives addressing fine motor, social, self-help, cognitive, and gross motor. Finally, the IEP states, “review 9/1/96 to determine and develop transition plan into SDC preschool -- choice between inclusion model or traditional SDC, number of hours of attendance (preschool/home) to be determined by IEP team, with continuation of 1:1 instructional assistants for 25 hours per week.
On May 14, 1996, Ms. Wright requested a due process hearing on behalf of Petitioner because of continuing disagreement over placement, and goals and objectives.
On May 20, 1996, Dr. Granpeesheh drafted a “To Whom It May Concern” letter in which she stated that “in my professional opinion, STUDENT has done well in the past few months and will certainly benefit from a home-based 1:1 behavior modification program, the most appropriate being at least 35 hours a week of 1:1 behavior intervention for this child. Furthermore, these services are recommended on a year round basis, including extended year services, because the success of this treatment is dependent upon its’ consistency.”
On May 24, 1996, STUDENT’s parents signed an IEP approving speech and language services only. While the IEP does not so state, testimony established that the IEP team agreed to the provision of 45 minutes of speech and language services per week. Since May 1996, Jo Tibbetts has provided speech and language services for STUDENT on behalf of the COE. Initially, those services were provided at STUDENT’s home, but in fall 1997, at STUDENT’s parents’ request, Ms. Tibbetts began providing the services at Melody’s.
On May 27, 1996, Beth Anderson completed an occupational therapy evaluation of STUDENT. Ms. Anderson recommended occupational therapy for STUDENT for two sessions per week, 45 minutes per session, with one of the sessions being in a small-group setting in Ms. Anderson’s therapy room. Subsequently, on May 29, 1996, STUDENT’s IEP team met and agreed to the provision of occupational therapy services. The team agreed to the recommendation of Ms. Anderson, with the small-group session dependent on Ms. Anderson’s having a student on her caseload who would be appropriate for such a session with STUDENT. Ms. Anderson has provided the occupational therapy services both at the SELPA office and at Melody’s.
On June 24, 1996, Dr. Granpeesheh completed a progress report for STUDENT. STUDENT’s expressive language had increased from 100 one- and two-word utterances in March 1996 to 200 one- and two-word utterances. STUDENT did not demonstrate any progress in basic self-help skills or social interaction. The estimated incidents of the target behaviors Dr. Granpeesheh had identified in March 1996 had been reduced by the following amounts:
(1) Noncompliant behavior: 450 incidents per month in March to 180 incidents in June. (2) Tantrum behavior: 300 incidents per month in March to 90 incidents in June. (3) Inappropriate sleeping: 90 incidents per month in March to 30 incidents in June. (4) Inappropriate toileting: 240 incidents per month in March to 150 incidents in June. (5) Self-stimulatory behavior: 100% of opportunities presented in March to 60% of opportunities presented in June.
STUDENT’s progress in behaviors #1 and #2 above were attributed by Dr. Granpeesheh to his increased receptive and expressive skills, and “consequently not becom[ing] so frustrated.” STUDENT’s progress in behavior #3 was attributed to an increase in his activity schedule. STUDENT’s progress in behavior #4 was attributed to STUDENT’s increased ability to verbally express himself. The objectives proposed by Dr. Granpeesheh were modified to recognize the reductions in the target behaviors. For instance, in March, one of STUDENT’s noncompliant behavior objectives was that he would decrease his rate of noncompliant behavior from the baseline rate of 450 times per month to 225 times per month for two consecutive months. In June, that objective was changed so that his rate of noncompliant behavior would decrease from 180 times per month to 90 times per month for two consecutive months. Dr. Granpeesheh continued to recommend that STUDENT receive at least 35 hours per week of 1:1 discreet trial therapy.
At some point during fall 1996, discussions were held regarding a potential placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year. As a result of those discussions, STUDENT’s parents visited the full inclusion preschool program at Village Park, a special day class at Franklin, and a full inclusion preschool program at Discoveries. There was no agreement regarding placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year.
On October 21 and 22, 1996, Dr. Diane Kirchner, a neurolinguist, conducted a language and communication assessment of STUDENT at his parents’ request. Dr. Kirchner administered several language tests, including the MacArthur Inventory, Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test (EOWPVT-R), the Test of Auditory Comprehension of Language-Revised (TACL-R), and the Communicative and Symbolic Behavior Scales (CSBS). Dr. Kirchner’s findings and conclusions, which were based on her own assessment, observations, review of records, parent interview, and observations of proposed placements, include the following:
What is most important for intervention is that the profile of acquisition both [with] respect to rate and content across domains for STUDENT is “atypical” -- and this is to underscore that his development is unlike that of children at younger stages of normal or “typical” development. As well, strategies such as “modeling,” “recasting,” and “commenting” will have no appreciable effect on language, cognition, communication, or social skills.... STUDENT has not yet acquired the foundational skills of imitation, attention, language comprehension, language expression, and compliance to benefit from placement in any of the program proposed by the County nor from any form of naturalistic approaches which emphasize play and “commenting” by an adult. He currently attends a small, structured, preschool which provides appropriate and direct instruction in generalization, socialization, and language with typical peers.... At the time of Dr. Davidson’s initial evaluation STUDENT was agitated and anxious during the examination period - now he is responsive to instruction and can participate in standard assessment; he did not acknowledge the presence of the examiner - he clearly acknowledged my presence during the assessment and spontaneously at home; and he produced mainly jargon and words related to his own context but with little communicative intent - he now exhibits clear intentional communication and persists in his attempts to communicate even when he is not understood at first. Without question, STUDENT has demonstrated significant progress in the present program and an interruption now will only serve to delay further progress.
Dr. Kirchner’s recommendations were for STUDENT to continue the in home program for 30 hours per week, 50 weeks per year, continue at Melody’s for 12 hours per week with a 1:1 instructional assistant, and continue with occupational therapy at the current level.
On November 15 and 18, 1996, Dr. Jacqueline Wynn, assistant director of the Lovaas Institute for Early Education, evaluated STUDENT at his parents’ request. Dr. Wynn administered the Bayley Scales of Infant Development, Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scales of Intelligence-Revised, Merrill-Palmer Scale of Mental Tests, Reynell Developmental Language Scales, and Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales. The first day of testing was from 10:00 a.m. until 3:30 p.m. with a 45-minute break for lunch. The testing took place at Dr. Wynn’s clinic. By the end of the day, STUDENT was exhibiting signs of fatigue. The second day of testing, the following Monday morning at STUDENT’s home, started at 8:30 a.m. and concluded at 10:15 a.m. During that day, STUDENT appeared tired and sick.
On the Bayley, STUDENT scored at the 25-month developmental age, approximately 22 months less than his chronological age. On the Wechsler, an intelligence test for children from 3 to 7 years of age, STUDENT was unable to complete any of the items except for several items on the Vocabulary subtest. On the Merrill-Palmer, STUDENT scored at the 29 month mental age level, which Dr. Wynn indicated means that “when STUDENT’s cognitive abilities are assessed independent of language functioning, his scores are somewhat higher.” On the Reynell, STUDENT scored at the 17-month developmental level in verbal comprehension and at the 22-month developmental level in expressive language. Finally, on the Vineland, STUDENT received a composite score of 22 months, with his “domain” scores ranging from 15 months in socialization to 32 months in motor skills. STUDENT’s results on the Vineland placed him in the mildly to moderately delayed range of adaptive functioning. Based on the test results, Dr. Wynn concluded that STUDENT was “mildly to moderately delayed in his overall cognitive functioning, with a lesser delay in his visual-spatial skills and greater delays in his language and social skills.”
Dr. Wynn also reviewed the assessments of STUDENT that were conducted when he was first diagnosed. Based on those assessments, Dr. Wynn stated that STUDENT “has made progress in all areas. Despite this evidence, it is clear from working with STUDENT that in order for him to acquire information, it needs to be presented through intensive behavioral interventions ... for at least 30 hours per week.” Dr. Wynn recommended that STUDENT’s 30-hour-per-week program be supervised with visits occurring at least every 6 weeks and an aide accompanying him to preschool.
On November 18, 1996, Dr. Granpeesheh produced an untitled report that appears to be a summary of STUDENT’s current functioning and modification of his goals and objectives based on his functioning level. The Revised Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Early Development was administered to obtain STUDENT’s functioning levels in gross motor, fine motor, self-help, speech and language, general knowledge and comprehension, social and emotional, and basic math. Dr. Granpeesheh stated that “STUDENT needs to develop more interactive communication skills and other social skills, such as interactive play skills, sharing with other children, compromising, and taking turns without being prompted by an adult. STUDENT likes social interaction; however, his social skills are limited due to the fact that he does not have the appropriate social language to maintain a social interaction with his peers. STUDENT does not know how to proceed with his peers after he has initiated a social contact without constant prompting from an adult.” Dr. Granpeesheh recommended that STUDENT “needs to learn in a structured, one-to-one, calm environment at home and be mainstreamed into a regular preschool classroom with a shadow teacher. At this time, it is recommended that STUDENT receive 30 hours per week of one-to-one behavior modification therapy at home. In addition, it is recommended that STUDENT receive 12 hours per week in a regular preschool setting with a shadow teacher trained either by the University of California at Los Angeles or by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders in the Lovaas methodology. In order to achieve success in a school setting, STUDENT has to first develop his skills in his delayed developmental areas, increase his attention span and ability to concentrate in a visually and auditorily stimulating environment, become more compliant, improve his ability to use language appropriately, and be taught the social skills needed to function more independently in a classroom.
As of June 1997, STUDENT’s program consisted, in general, of the following: two three-hour shifts of 1:1 at home each day, Monday through Friday; three hours at Melody’s three days per week with a 1:1 aide with STUDENT most of the time; 45 minutes of speech and language and 90 minutes of occupational therapy each week; and one three-hour session of 1:1 therapy at home on Saturdays.
In June and July 1997, a series of IEP team meetings were held to address STUDENT’s placement for the 1997-98 school year. Respondents offered the following placement: the preschool inclusion program at Village Park with a special day class teacher and 1:1 aide for four days per week, three hours per day; supplemental direct instruction in a special day class at Orange Avenue for autistic children for four days per week, three hours per day; individual and small-group occupational therapy two times per week for 45 minutes per session; individual and small-group speech and language services three hours per week; consultation for four hours per month; 1:1 assistant at home and/or in the community for two hours per week; and a 15-hour-per-week program for eight weeks in the summer. STUDENT’s parents did not agree with the placement proposed by Respondents. The IEP included 58 pages of goals and objectives with which STUDENT’s parents did agree.
For the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT’s parents requested a program consisting of the following: behavioral intervention services specialist for up to four hours per month to design and oversee STUDENT’s program; 1:1 behavioral therapy for 36 hours per week at home, in the community, and at preschool; individual speech and language services for three hours per week, individual and small group occupational therapy for 90 minutes per week; weekly meetings with therapists and parents; monthly team meetings; training workshops every six weeks; mainstream preschool program for 12 hours per week; and school year and extended school year to include only a two week break.
In July 1997, Dr. Kirchner conducted a Speech, Language, and Communication Reassessment of STUDENT. Dr. Kirchner administered the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test (EOWPVT), the Receptive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test (ROWPVT), and the MacArthur Communicative Development Inventory-Words and Sentences (MacArthur Inventory), and obtained a language and phonological sample. On the EOWPVT, STUDENT scored at the 2.6 age equivalent level, compared to the 2.2 age equivalent level score he received when Dr. Kirchner first evaluated him in October 1996. STUDENT had been unable to take the ROWPVT in October, but in July, he scored at the 3.0 age equivalent level. On the MacArthur Inventory, STUDENT showed a growth of at least 134 words. He was also beginning to use morphological markers such as “-ing” and had “made significant progress with respect to vocabulary development.”
In addition to the standardized assessments, Dr. Kirchner also again observed STUDENT’s home program and Melody’s. Based on her observation of the home program, Dr. Kirchner stated that it is clear that STUDENT has made significant growth in the in-home program. There are ways in which the in-home program can be elaborated now, based on his progress. What is clear, however, is that STUDENT will not make progress without intensive 1:1 and that the program he has now is tailored to meet his needs. He has a level of distractibility and deficits in attentional focus which interfere significantly with his ability to benefit from instruction; as well he has a significant level of verbal self-stimulatory behavior which has increased since my last visit. Notably, his physical self-stimulatory behaviors have decreased. Therefore, this is not a regression; rather it is a change in modality. In fact, it is my experience that verbal self-stimulatory behavior is much harder to modify than physical stimulation and therefore, the need for intensive 1:1 is even greater.
Regarding her observation of Melody’s, Dr. Kirchner stated that this is an excellent group of children and placement for STUDENT. This is a teacher who has taught and enlisted the help of STUDENT’s peers in constructing social and communicative contexts in which STUDENT can participate.... At lunch time one of the peers asks STUDENT questions and reinforces him for answering; they engage in games of chase with him and they follow him until he gives them hugs. Though STUDENT’s language deficits are severe, it is very important to note that he is not socially avoidant and he has always been very affectionate and desiring of social interaction. When one child attempted to engage him in a “get you” game hiding behind a pole on the play structure, STUDENT attended, participated, and was always happy to have any child come get him. One little girl was asked to go get STUDENT and play with him. She went to him, took his hand, said “Come here STUDENT and play with me. Sit down. Now play in the sand. Do this STUDENT” and modeled using the sand tools. This is the ideal environment for STUDENT; these are ideal children and I cannot emphasize how impressed I have been with the preschool, the children, and their teacher.... My recommendation, however, is that STUDENT have a 1:1 instructional aide at this site in order to facilitate social interactions since this is such an ideal environment.
In addition to her recommendations regarding the in-home program and the program at Melody’s, Dr. Kirchner recommended an extended school year program for STUDENT that would be a minimum of 50 weeks per year because STUDENT “is vulnerable to regression.”
On September 23, 1997, Dr. Tristram Smith, assistant professor of psychology with Washington State University, completed a Consultation Report at STUDENT’s parents’ request. Dr. Smith, while finding that the CARD program was appropriate, made several proposals to modify STUDENT’s 1:1 program and recommended that “continuation of intensive, home-based, behavior analytic treatment appears is indicated in order to help STUDENT expand on the substantial gains he made thus far. The acquisition of sentences and grammar (the focus of STUDENT’s current program) is time-consuming for children with autism and hence is unlikely to be accomplished in a program of lower intensity than the one he is receiving.... Continuation of day care or placement in a preschool class with typically developing children is also important, as it will promote generalization of skills to new settings and help STUDENT become accustomed to classroom routines.”
STUDENT’s current schedule consists of the following: two three-hour shifts of 1:1 therapy at home, Monday through Friday (the shifts are from 7:30 - 10:30 a.m. and 4:00 - 7:00 p.m.); speech and language provided by Jo Tibbetts for 45 minutes per week on Monday at Melody’s; occupational therapy on Mondays and Thursdays; Melody’s from approximately 11:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Monday through Friday, with a 1:1 aide with him for a portion of each day (the schedule at Melody’s includes a dance class on Tuesdays and a music class on Thursdays and a 1:1 aide with STUDENT at Melody’s for most of his time there). STUDENT also participates in a swimming class Tuesday evenings and Friday afternoons and a gymnastics class on Thursday evenings.
DISCUSSION
(1) Did Respondents propose an appropriate placement for the remainder of the 1995-96 school year and extended school year 1996, at the IEP meetings held in April 1996?
State and federal law require that students with disabilities receive a free appropriate public education. California Education Code § 56000 et seq. And the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq. “Free appropriate public education” means special education and related services, provided at public expense, that conform with the student’s individualized education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specifically designed instruction to meet the unique needs of a disabled child. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, EHLR 553:656, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialist instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” 458 U.S. 175,200.
Taken together, the IDEA and Rowley provide three factors for analyzing whether Respondents’ offered placement for the 1995-96 school year was appropriate. Those three factors are as follows:
(A) Was Respondents’ placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs? (B) Did Respondents’ placement conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
(C) Was Respondents’ placement designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit?
(A) Was Respondents’ placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
As of May 8, 1996, Respondents’ final proposal for the remainder of the 1995-96 school year was for STUDENT to receive 25 hours of 1:1 assistance with 19 hours of 1:1 therapy provided at home and 6 hours of 1:1 assistance provided for STUDENT at Melody’s. The 1:1 therapy would be provided by instructional assistants with supervision and consultation by a special day class teacher. Respondents also proposed to provide 45 minutes of speech and language services per week. Respondents also proposed that STUDENT receive 15 hours of 1:1 assistance during an eight-week summer program.
Petitioner’s major contentions regarding the appropriateness of Respondents’ placement offer relates to the number of hours of 1:1 therapy Respondents offered, the setting for the therapy, and the individuals who would be providing the therapy. All of Petitioner’s experts, including Dr. Wynn, Dr. Kirchner, Dr. Smith, and Dr. Granpeesheh, testified that STUDENT needed a minimum of 30 hours of 1:1 therapy per week, with additional 1:1 support in his preschool or day care setting. Dr. Wynn testified that STUDENT required at least 30 hours of 1:1 therapy per week because of his intensive needs, his learning style, and the progress he had made up to that point. Dr. Wynn also testified that 19 hours of 1:1 would not have been sufficient for STUDENT to receive benefit. Dr. Kirchner testified that STUDENT requires a minimum of 30 hours of 1:1 therapy at home and that the therapy continue through the summer because his profound language, social, and developmental problems required that he have continuous attention without interruption. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT needed at least 30-40 hours of 1:1 therapy per week based on his research and also on the fact that STUDENT was already working well at that level in the CARD program. Dr. Smith also testified that the number of hours should not be reduced until STUDENT can learn on his own, a point STUDENT had not reached by May 1996. Finally, Dr. Granpeesheh testified that STUDENT’s distractibility is more severe than “typical” autistic children and, although his attention has improved significantly, he still cannot learn necessary skills through incidental learning. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that the placement offer made by Respondents on May 8, 1996, did not provide sufficient 1:1 therapy because the 6 hours of 1:1 help at Melody’s were a part of the total of 25 hours, rather than in addition. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that STUDENT should receive at least 30 hours of 1:1 therapy at home per week, with additional 1:1 support at Melody’s. Petitioner’s experts also testified that without a full-day program, STUDENT would experience regression in his behavior because he would have more unstructured time. If STUDENT had too much unstructured time, it would allow him to engage in more self-stimming behavior than was appropriate.
The testimony of Petitioner’s experts was supported by the testimony of therapists who have worked with STUDENT in a 1:1 setting. Elizabeth McGivern, who worked with STUDENT from January through August 1997, testified that STUDENT continued to need at least 30 hours of 1:1 therapy per week because STUDENT learns individual skills through the techniques used by the therapists. Melissa Hayward, who has worked with STUDENT from July 1997 through the present, testified that when she first started working with STUDENT he was a “high energy kid, with a lot of self-stimming behaviors, good eye contact, and very little spontaneous speech.” Ms. Hayward also testified that STUDENT learns things by having them broken down into smaller parts and that he could not learn new skills in a preschool. While neither Ms. McGivern nor Ms. Hayward worked with STUDENT in spring or summer 1996, it is significant that they believed a year later that STUDENT continued to need at least 30 hours of 1:1 therapy.
Respondents’ primary experts, Adriana Schuler and Colleen Jamison, both testified that they did not believe STUDENT was an appropriate candidate for 1:1 discreet trial therapy because, based on their review of the records, they did not believe he had significant behavioral issues that required such intensive therapy. Dr. Schuler and Dr. Jamison’s testimony is contradicted, however, by the testimony of STUDENT’s parents and grandmothers. PARENTS, along with GRANDMOTHER and GRANDMOTHER, testified persuasively that before STUDENT started the CARD program it was almost impossible for them to get STUDENT to sit and attend to tasks. This testimony is buttressed by the videotapes that Petitioner submitted into evidence. (Petitioner’s Exhibits MMM, NNN, and CCCC) The videos of STUDENT that were made prior to his introduction to the CARD program show that he was easily distracted, had very little attention skills, and did not relate at all to those around him. In addition, Jo Tibbetts, the speech pathologist who evaluated STUDENT prior to the IEP meetings in April and May 1996, testified that STUDENT had a very short attention span, put everything in his mouth, had a lot of self-stimming behaviors, and was unable to follow directions. The testimony of STUDENT’s family and Ms. Tibbetts, along with the contents of the videos, establishes that, contrary to the testimony of Respondents’ experts, STUDENT did have behavioral issues that required the type of comprehensive 1:1 therapy program sought by Petitioner. While there was no evidence that STUDENT was engaged in serious or self-injurious behavior, the evidence does establish that STUDENT had significant behavioral issues relating to attention, following directions, self-stimming, and social interaction that required a 1:1 therapy program to address. Therefore, the Hearing Officer gives little weight to the opinions of Drs. Jamison and Schuler regarding STUDENT’s educational needs.(FOOTNOTE 3)
The Hearing Officer also relies on the number of goals and objectives proposed by Petitioner and ultimately developed by STUDENT’s IEP team in April and May 1996. As stated above, the goals and objectives cover 27 pages in STUDENT’s IEP. They address fine motor and gross motor skills, social skills, self-help skills, cognitive skills, receptive and expressive language skills, pragmatics, and articulation. For example, STUDENT’s goals and objectives addressing his needs in social skills include 18 different objectives relating to 5 goals. The sheer number of goals and objectives developed by the IEP team suggests that STUDENT’s needs required that he be in a much more intensive program than that proposed by Respondents.
Based on the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents’ placement offer of 25 hours of 1:1 therapy per week with 19 hours of the therapy at home and 6 hours in the form of a 1:1 aide for STUDENT at Melody’s, and for an extended school year program of only 15 hours per week was not appropriately designed to meet his needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents’ placement offer for the remainder of the 1995-96 school year and summer 1996 was not appropriate. Based on this finding, it is unnecessary to address the other two factors discussed above. However, the Hearing Officer notes that it is also questionable whether STUDENT would have received educational benefit from the program proposed by Respondents. Petitioner’s witnesses testified that, without a structured program throughout the day, every day, STUDENT could experience regression as a result of increased self-stimming and not benefit from the therapy that he did receive. Based on that testimony, the Respondents’ proposed program of 19 hours of 1:1 at home and 6 hours at Melody’s would have likely caused STUDENT to regress during the unstructured times and it is questionable whether such a program was reasonably designed to provide him with educational benefit.(FOOTNOTE 4)
(2) Did Respondents propose an appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year?
In 1992, the Ninth Circuit held that procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process “clearly result in the denial of FAPE.” W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range, 18 IDELR 1019 (9th Cir. 1992). Among the procedural violations which the Ninth Circuit has held constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with IDEA’s procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith, 20 IDELR 987 (9th Cir. 1994). The Smith Court stated that the “IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child.” Smith, 20 IDELR 987,990. The requirement of a written offer serves several purposes, including creating “a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later” and “will greatly assist parents in ‘present[ing] complaints with respect to any matter relating to the ... educational placement of the child.” Id.
In the present case, Respondents failed to comply with the procedural requirements of IDEA in providing a specific placement offer for the 1996-97 school year. The IEP dated May 8, 1996, states that STUDENT would receive certain services for the remainder of the 1995-96 school year and certain additional services for eight weeks during the summer. However, with regards to the 1996-97 school year, the IEP states: “review 9/1/96 to determine and develop transition plan into SDC preschool - choice between inclusion model or traditional SDC, number of hours of attendance (presch./home) to be determined by IEP team, with continuation of 1:1 instr’l assistants for 25 hours per week.” By fall 1996, Respondents verbally proposed a range of potential placements for STUDENT, and several people observed those placements on his behalf. However, there was never a formal, written offer made regarding what specific placement was being offered by Respondents. As noted above, the earlier IEP states that there would be a choice between an inclusion model or a traditional special day class. The difference between these two types of programs is significant and there is nothing in writing detailing specifically what Respondents proposed. There is nothing in writing regarding the number of hours STUDENT would participate in a proposed classroom program. There is also nothing in writing regarding any additional support services he would receive, including a 1:1 aide, speech and language services, and occupational therapy.
The Hearing Officer also notes that simply offering Petitioner with a range of alternatives from which to pick does not necessarily constitute an offer pursuant to Smith, especially considering California’s definition of placement. California Code of Regulations, Title 5, § 3042(a) defines “specific educational placement” as that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the individualized education program, in any one or a combination of public, private, home and hospital, or residential settings.
The language of § 3042(a) combined with Smith makes clear that the IDEA requires that an offer of placement be more than just an offer of a range of alternatives. Instead, the Respondents were required to provide Petitioner with a specific, formal, and written offer of the “unique combination of facilities, personnel, location and equipment” necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs. Respondents did not do so for the 1996-97 school year.The result of Respondents’ failure to provide a specific, formal, and written offer has resulted in exactly what the Smith Court feared and sought to prevent with a very specific procedural requirement. In the present case, rather than focusing on a specific program offered by Respondents, numerous witnesses were required to review their observations of the number of different programs and classes proposed by Respondents for the 1996-97 school year. Furthermore, STUDENT’s parents were clearly confused as to what specifically was being offered for STUDENT. Under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents failed to provide a formal, written offer of a specific placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year. Furthermore, that failure created confusion for STUDENT’s parents and hampered their ability to effectively participate in the development of an educational program for him for the 1996-97 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents failed to offer an appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year as required by Smith.
(3) Did Respondents propose an appropriate placement, including goals and objectives, for the 1997-98 school year?
As noted above, to determine whether Respondents’ proposed placement for the 1997-98 school year was appropriate for STUDENT, it is necessary to apply the three factor test adopted by the IDEA and Rowley.
(A) Was Respondents’ placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
By the conclusion of the IEP meeting held on July 25, 1997, Respondents had made the following placement offer:
Periodic Parent Consult/Training 3 hours per month Preschool Inclusion with SDC teacher 4 days per week, three hours per day Supplemental Direct Instruction in SDC 4 days per week, three hours per day Occupational Therapy 2 45-minute sessions per week Individual and small group Speech and Language Services 3 hours per week, individual and small group Discreet Trial Consult 4 hours per month Assistant in home/community 2 hours per week Extended school year 8 weeks, 15 hours per week
The IEP also stated, “all goals to be embedded into large group and incidental learning experiences and measured for mastery and level of generalization across all environments.” Testimony of Respondents’ witnesses established that the full inclusion component proposed by Respondents was at Village Park, a regular preschool site in which several special education students are fully included with the assistance of a special day class teacher and aide. The special day class referred to at hearing as the Orange Avenue program, was a class designed specifically to address the needs of autistic children and would have taken place in the afternoon. The Orange Avenue program was a new program that first started in fall 1997. At the time of the July 1997 IEP meeting, when this program was offered for STUDENT, a site for the program had not yet been located, nor had all the specifics of the program been developed. The testimony of Respondents’ witnesses also established that STUDENT would receive up to 20-30 minutes of 1:1 work each day at Village Park and approximately 15 minutes of 1:1 work each day at Orange Avenue. (Testimony of Charlene Cunningham, the SDC teacher who would work with STUDENT at both programs)
Based on the testimony of Ms. Cunningham, it appears that STUDENT would have received less than 5 hours of 1:1 educational instruction per week if placed in Respondents’ program. He would have also received 2 hours of 1:1 assistance either at home or in the community; 3 hours of speech and language services, some of which would have been 1:1; and 90 minutes of occupational therapy, some of which would have been 1:1. Based on that information, STUDENT could have received anywhere from 7 hours of 1:1 instruction to 11 ½ hours of 1:1 instruction, although it is questionable whether STUDENT would have received 11 ½ hours of 1:1 instruction since Respondents proposed that at least a portion of his speech and language services and occupational therapy be in small-group settings.
Petitioner’s experts continued to recommend that STUDENT receive more 1:1 therapy than that proposed by Respondents. Dr. Wynn testified that the program proposed by Respondents was inappropriate because it would not provide STUDENT with sufficient 1:1 instruction for him to acquire new skills. Dr. Wynn also testified, based on her observations of Village Park and Orange Avenue, that, although the programs had some good points, both classes lacked certain necessary modifications; for example, she would have liked to see children sitting independently during circle time, and changing activities for children during free time rather than allowing children to stay with the same activity for the entire free period so that they did not engage in self-stimming behavior. Dr. Kirchner testified that STUDENT continued to need a minimum of 30 hours of 1:1 therapy because he continued to need more work on his language, attention skills, compliance, ability to follow instructions, and social skills before he could be successful in a kindergarten program, which is the objective for STUDENT. Dr. Smith testified that, when he saw STUDENT in September 1997, STUDENT continued to need 30 hours of 1:1 therapy per week at home to learn new skills. Dr. Smith also testified that it would be “dangerous” for STUDENT to be in a setting with other autistic children because of the potential for STUDENT to not get a response to his attempts at social interaction with the other autistic children. The danger, according to Dr. Smith, is that without getting responses from other children, STUDENT would no longer try to initiate social interaction. Dr. Smith also testified that STUDENT’s language development would be at risk due to the potential for lack of responses from the other children. Finally, Dr. Granpeesheh testified that, as of July 1997, STUDENT continued to need intensive therapy because of his age and continuing behavioral issues that were interfering with his learning. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that STUDENT needed more appropriate language and cognitive development before the 1:1 therapy could be cut back.
In addition to recommending more intensive 1:1 therapy than that proposed by Respondents, Petitioner’s experts also noted the need for STUDENT to be exposed to typically developing peers. The experts testified that Melody’s would provide a more appropriate opportunity for STUDENT to interact with typically developing peers because of his familiarity with the children and staff at Melody’s, because he would be easily distracted in the larger environment of Village Park, and because children at Village Park would not choose to interact with him because of the number of other children in the program. Ms. McGivern, the therapist who worked with STUDENT from January through August 1997, described an incident in which she accompanied STUDENT to a story time activity at a library in which there were over 30 children. According to Ms. McGivern, during the activity, which lasted for approximately one hour, STUDENT’s attention span was much shorter than usual and he became so excited that she had to take him to a different part of the library on four separate occasions to calm him down. Ms. McGivern also testified that STUDENT is more excited and more distractible at Melody’s then he is at home. A larger environment than that provided at Melody’s would make it difficult for STUDENT to function and work on generalizing the skills he has acquired. Ms. McGivern testified that the 1:1 program requires a lot of concentration from STUDENT and that he is too distracted by other children to be able to effectively participate in the 1:1 program in a school setting where other children are present.
At its best, Respondents’ program would have provided STUDENT with 7 hours of 1:1 per week, with some additional time being provided in speech and language services and occupational therapy. Meanwhile, the experts and therapists who have worked with and followed STUDENT continued to recommend significant amount of 1:1 therapy above that offered by Respondents. Furthermore, Petitioner’s experts and the therapists who worked with STUDENT all testified that STUDENT does not learn incidentally, that he needs a 1:1 intervention to learn new skills, and that it is only after he learns new skills in a 1:1 setting that he should be expected to generalize those skills into a group setting or other environment. While Respondents had several witnesses who testified that STUDENT can learn new skills incidentally and in other environments, their testimony was based on their limited knowledge of STUDENT, and seemed also to be premised on their broad assumption that all people, including autistic children, can learn incidentally.
Based on the testimony of Petitioner’s experts regarding STUDENT’s learning style and his continuing need for an intensive 1:1 program, the Hearing Officer finds that the program proposed by Respondents was not appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Therefore, Respondents did not propose an appropriate program for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year. Based on this finding, it is unnecessary for this decision to address the other two factors listed above. The Hearing Officer notes again, however, that it is questionable whether the program proposed by Respondents would have provided STUDENT with any appreciable educational benefit. Dr. Kirchner, in her first evaluation, noted that the programs offered by Respondents provided an “eclectic” approach to teaching and learning. The testimony of Respondents’ witnesses also established that there would be multiple teaching strategies used with STUDENT throughout the day in a variety of settings. Considering the testimony of those who worked with STUDENT and the other witnesses called by Petitioner, it is questionable whether STUDENT could have received benefit in such a program. The testimony of Petitioner’s experts strongly suggests that STUDENT does not learn incidentally and requires 1:1 instruction to learn new skills. A program, as proposed by Respondents, which would have given STUDENT very little 1:1 instruction (with most of it in classroom settings) is not a program that is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
(4) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the CARD program, including materials and supplies, from April 12, 1996 to the end of the 1997-98 extended school year?
The United States Supreme Court has held that parents are entitled to reimbursement for a nonpublic school placement upon a finding that the educational agency’s placement violated IDEA, and that the placement unilaterally made by the parents was proper under the Act. See Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 358 (1985); Florence County School District Four, et al v. Carter, 20 IDELR 532, 534 (1993). As already noted above, Respondents failed to provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT from April 1996 to the present. Therefore, it is necessary to determine whether the CARD program provided for STUDENT by his parents is “proper under the Act.” The Florence Court specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral nonpublic school placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement with the contents of their child’s IEP or provide a placement at a facility that is certified by the state. It appears, then, that the Supreme Court has recognized that parents do not have to meet as high a standard in providing a unilateral nonpublic school placement as school districts do in providing free and appropriate placements to children within their jurisdiction.
In the present case, faced with proposed placements that were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the PARENTS decided to continue STUDENT in the CARD program of 1:1 intensive behavioral therapy at their own expense. Since April 1996, STUDENT has remained in the CARD program and received as much as 36 hours of 1:1 therapy per week at home and has also received assistance from his therapists at Melody’s and in the community. The evidence establishes that STUDENT has received significant benefit from the program provided through CARD.
The individuals who know STUDENT and see him on a regular basis testified regarding the progress they have seen in STUDENT. Melody Wynn, the operator of the day care STUDENT attends, testified that STUDENT is starting to generalize learned skills; his language skills have improved immensely; he knows other children’s names; he will run to children and want to play; he sits through group time for the most part; he is more willing to participate in drawing, coloring, and painting; he does not mouth things as much; he has a routine and knows to sit at the table, have lunch, and take his plate to the trash. Ms. Wynn testified that when STUDENT first started at her day care, he was unable to do any of these things, even with prompts. Ms. Wynn also testified that STUDENT is now greeting people on his own, is requesting things that he wants, and is generalizing and understanding more words. Finally, Ms. Wynn testified that STUDENT has gone from ignoring the other children to running up to them, smiling, touching their faces, and trying to initiate conversation or play with them.
Ms. McGivern, one of STUDENT’s therapists who worked with him from January through August 1997, testified that by the time she left, his verbalizations were longer, he had increased his use of spontaneous language and on-task behavior, and his ability to recognize objects and emotions had improved. Ms. McGivern also noted that he had increased his ability to generalize games to play them with other people and in other settings. Ms. McGivern attributed these gains directly to the 1:1 therapy, because the therapy taught him the skills that he could generalize to other settings. Ms. Hayward, the other therapist who has worked with STUDENT since July 1997, testified that she has seen an immense amount of growth in STUDENT’s appropriate and spontaneous use of language. She has also noticed an increase in his interest in the environment around him and is generally interested in toys now. Ms. Hayward also testified that STUDENT’s articulation has grown significantly, as well as his interactions with other children, including children he is not familiar with. STUDENT’s father, FATHER, testified that, prior to the CARD program, STUDENT was very inwardly focussed and that now he looks at the world and asks questions. He also stated that STUDENT is reciprocating play more.
The testimony of these witnesses is strengthened by other evidence that was submitted at hearing. Most compelling are the videotapes provided by Petitioner. The videotapes show a child who was almost totally unresponsive to his parents’ attempts to interact with him and who had very little language skills before he started CARD. By February 1998, however, the videotapes show that STUDENT was responsive and attentive to his parents, interacted with them, had a significant amount of language skills that did not exist before he started CARD, and was much more functional than he had been. These increased skills were apparent both in therapy sessions and more “natural” interactions and environments.
Based on the testimony as outlined above and the videotapes presented by Petitioner, the Hearing Officer finds that the CARD program provided by STUDENT’s parents has provided him with a significant educational benefit. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the CARD program is the intense type of behavioral program recommended by Petitioner’s experts to meet his many needs. It has provided STUDENT with the type of intense 1:1 program with the appropriate number of hours that the experts indicated STUDENT needed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the CARD program was “proper under the Act” pursuant to Burlington and Florence and that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with the CARD program from April 1996 through the end of the 1997-98 extended school year.
While Petitioner presented evidence regarding expenses relating to CARD, some of the items are not clear. (Petitioner’s Exhibit D) For instance, for at least a portion of the time, one of STUDENT’s therapists was employed by Holdsambek and Associates and some of those expenses were reimbursed by the Regional Center. It is unclear whether the figures included in Exhibit D incorporate that amount or not. Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for any amount that was already paid for by the Regional Center. Exhibit D also includes an item for “Materials and Supplies.” As described by FATHER during the hearing, it is unclear whether Materials and Supplies includes items that are specifically designed for incorporation into the CARD program, or if Materials and Supplies also includes items that parents would normally buy for their children. Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for any expenditures for items that parents would normally buy for their children. Upon presentation of proof, Respondents are expected to reimburse Petitioner for all costs associated with the CARD program, with the exception of any services paid for by Regional Center, and any materials and supplies that are not specifically designed for the CARD program and which are items that parents would normally buy for their children.
(5) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs, including tuition, 1:1 aide and transportation, associated with the Melody Day Preschool from April 12, 1996 to the end of the 1997-98 extended school year?
The analysis regarding whether Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for Melody’s is identical to the analysis relating to CARD. In other words, as long as placement at Melody’s was “proper under the Act,” Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement. One thing that all witnesses agreed on was STUDENT’s need for interaction with typically developing peers. Without an opportunity to interact with typically developing peers, it would be very difficult for STUDENT to learn appropriate social interaction skills. STUDENT’s participation at Melody’s was intended by his parents to provide him with the necessary exposure to typically developing peers.
During the past two years, Melody’s has provided STUDENT with an environment in which there are at most four or five other children, several of whom are close in age to STUDENT. The program at Melody’s is structured and provides STUDENT with opportunities for social interaction. Ms. Wynn testified that she attended trainings offered by CARD so that she could provide consistency for STUDENT at her day care. Ms. Wynn also testified that she worked with the other children to have them interact with STUDENT regularly and work on the skills he was working on. There was also a 1:1 aide with STUDENT during most of his time at Melody’s to help him with the social interactions and activities at Melody’s. STUDENT’s family members and service providers also testified regarding the positive interactions and progress that STUDENT has made at Melody’s.
While Respondents raised some concerns regarding Melody’s -- for example, that the children there were too “scripted” and not natural in their interactions with STUDENT -- those concerns do not counteract the overwhelming evidence that Melody’s provided STUDENT with an opportunity to work on his social skills and also on generalizing the skills he learned in the 1:1 therapy. Much of the evidence presented by Respondents was based on very limited observations. On the other hand, Petitioner presented several individuals who have worked with or observed STUDENT regularly at Melody’s and were impressed by what they saw happening at Melody’s.
Based on the small size of Melody’s, the interactions between the children as described by Ms. Wynn and other witnesses, the assistance of the 1:1 aide, and the progress STUDENT has made in his social skills and interactions, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s placement at Melody’s has been a “proper” program for his socialization skills. The placement has met STUDENT’s needs in the areas of socialization and generalization and has also provided him with educational benefit by providing him with opportunities to interact with typically developing peers. Therefore, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with Melody’s from April 1996 through the end of the extended summer 1998 program.
(6) Is Petitioner entitled to retroactive reimbursement for independent assessments conducted by Dr. Jacquelyn Wynn, Dr. Tristram Smith, and Dr. Diane Kirchner?
Special education law allows the PARENTS to obtain reimbursement for independent evaluations if Respondents failed to appropriately assess STUDENT. Education Code § 56329(b). Petitioner contends that “neither the County or SELPA has ever attempted to perform any extensive evaluation of STUDENT, save for record review, parent interview and observation.”
During the first several months of 1996, Rennett Facciobene, preschool specialist, and Jo Tibbetts, speech and language pathologist and preschool specialist, observed STUDENT numerous times in his day care setting. Ms. Facciobene and Ms. Tibbetts collaborated on the drafting of the COE’s evaluation of STUDENT dated March 8, 1996. Ms. Facciobene testified that she did not conduct any standardized tests to STUDENT because several such tests had recently been administered. Ms. Tibbetts testified that she tried some standardized assessments with STUDENT but that he was unable to attend to the tasks and was also unable to point to pictures on tests that required pointing. Both Ms. Facciobene and Ms. Tibbetts relied on the evaluations of Dr. Peter Hasler, Ann Blanton, Dr. Karen Davidson, and Celina Andrade in preparing their evaluation.
Education Code § 56441.11(e) provides that “when standardized tests are considered invalid for children between the ages of three and five years, alternative means, for example, scales, instruments, observations, and interviews shall be used as specified in the assessment plan.” The assessment plan developed by the COE and signed by STUDENT’s mother on January 3, 1996, states that the assessment team would use alternative means of assessment, including “review current independent assessment results, observations, parent and teacher interview.” Under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents’ evaluation of STUDENT was appropriate and in compliance with the applicable provisions of special education law. Section § 56441.11(e) specifically allows school districts to use means other than standardized tests for children from three to five years ago. The mere fact that the COE did not use any standardized testing of its own in April 1996 does not render the evaluation inappropriate. Furthermore, considering the wealth of information contained in the reports of Dr. Hasler, Dr. Davidson, Ms. Blanton, and Ms. Andrade, and the numerous observations that Ms. Facciobene and Ms. Tibbetts made of STUDENT, the COE has more than enough information to create a comprehensive picture of STUDENT and his educational needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the COE’s evaluation of STUDENT in April 1996 complied with the requirements relating to assessment contained in special education law.
The problem for Respondents is that there apparently was never another attempt to reevaluate STUDENT. Education Code § 56381 provides that “a reassessment of the pupil ... shall be conducted at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant...” Considering that STUDENT was not in an educational program operated by Respondents, that he was at an age when incredible progress can be made in a short time, that he has a complex disability, and the nature of the program he was in during the past two years, conditions warranted a reevaluation at some point between April 1996 and the present. Without such a reassessment, it is difficult to know how Respondents could have developed a placement proposal for the 1997-98 school year. Under the circumstances, the Respondents’ failure to reevaluate STUDENT during summer 1997, other than in occupational therapy, was a violation of § 56381 and warrants a determination of what, if any, of the independent evaluations Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement.
Petitioner has requested reimbursement for evaluations conducted by Dr. Jacqueline Wynn, Dr. Tristram Smith, and Dr. Diane Kirchner. Dr. Wynn evaluated STUDENT in November 1996. Dr. Kirchner first evaluated STUDENT in October 1996 and then reevaluated him eight months later in June 1997. Dr. Smith conducted a “Consultation Report” in September 1997. As noted above, § 56381 requires that reassessments take place as “conditions warrant.” In the present case, while the Hearing Officer is sympathetic to the PARENTS’ desire to obtain information regarding STUDENT, there is nothing in the record to suggest that, from an educational perspective, conditions warranted additional assessments in October and November 1996, just six to seven months after the COE had completed its assessment of STUDENT, and eight months after STUDENT had started the CARD program. Therefore, reimbursement for Dr. Wynn’s assessment and Dr. Kirchner’s first evaluation would not be appropriate.
On the other hand, by summer 1997, it had been more than one year since the COE had evaluated STUDENT and more than one year since STUDENT had started the CARD program. Additionally, the parties were engaged in an attempt to determine an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year. Under the circumstances, conditions warranted a reevaluation of STUDENT to determine the progress he had made and what his needs were. The COE failed to perform any reevaluation of STUDENT. Dr. Kirchner did conduct a comprehensive “Speech, Language and Communication Reassessment” in which she reviewed STUDENT’s history and conducted several standardized tests to determine the progress STUDENT had made. Based on the failure of Respondents to reevaluate STUDENT in summer 1997, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with Dr. Kirchner’s evaluation completed in June 1997, including travel costs for that visit.
Finally, Dr. Smith then completed his “consultation report” in September 1997 as a result of STUDENT’s parents’ request that he make “recommendations on STUDENT’s home-based behavior analytic program.” From Dr. Smith’s report and his testimony it is apparent that his evaluation consisted of nothing more than observations of STUDENT’s program. There is no indication that Dr. Smith conducted any standardized testing of STUDENT. Furthermore, Dr. Smith’s report is, as he states, simply recommendations of areas that STUDENT’s in-home can be improved and his recommendations that STUDENT continue in the program. Dr. Smith’s evaluation is not an independent assessment to which Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement.
ORDER
Upon presentation of proof by Petitioner, Respondents shall reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with the following:
(A) STUDENT’s in-home program supervised by CARD from April 1996 through the end of the extended school year 1998, with the exception of costs already paid for by Regional Center and materials and supplies which are not specifically designed for the CARD program and which are not items which parents would normally purchase for their children. (B) STUDENT’s participation at Melody’s Day Preschool from April 1996 through the end of the extended school year 1998. (C) Costs associated with Dr. Diane Kirchner’s reevaluation conducted in June 1997, including travel expenses associated with that visit.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed on all issues heard and decided, with the exception of reimbursement for certain assessments.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: June 30, 1998 ____________________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1.The Hearing Officer notes that the issues as listed below have been modified from those submitted by Petitioner at the outset of the hearing. Most significantly, Petitioner included several issues raising the question of what STUDENT’s IEPs should have included at the times they were developed. Considering that the relevant school years are not over, the only question is whether the placements proposed by Respondents were appropriate. Therefore, this decision will not address those questions with the specificity called for in Petitioner’s statement of issues 2.Testimony at hearing established that the COE faxed the final IEP, dated May 8, 1996, to Ms. Wright as she requested, rather than holding a meeting to discuss it. 3.The Hearing Officer is also troubled by the opinions of Dr. Schuler and Dr. Jamison because of the limited interaction they had with STUDENT. While both observed him at home and at Melody’s, and also reviewed his records, it was clear that on at least some points, the information they were relying on to form their opinions was incorrect. For instance, there were criticisms of the home program because the therapist they observed covered too many things in the time Dr. Schuler and Dr. Jamison observed. What was apparent by the end of the hearing was that during observations, the therapists were demonstrating a sampling of the drills they worked on with STUDENT rather than performing a “standard” therapy session. Ultimately, based on the limited interaction both Dr. Schuler and Dr. Jamison had with STUDENT, it’s questionable just how well they knew him. 4.The Hearing Officer notes that both parties addressed other issues relating to the appropriateness of Respondents’ placement offer, including the identity of the service providers, the training of the staff proposed by Respondents, and the length of extended school year services. As a result of the finding that the program offered by Respondents was not appropriate because it did not provide sufficient hours of 1:1 therapy to meet STUDENT’s needs or provide him with benefit, it is unnecessary to address the other issues addressed by the parties.
