California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 12, 2002
Student v. Alta Loma Elementary School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 480-02 · Hearing Officer Judy F. Hirano
Alta Loma Elementary and San Bernardino DBH must reimburse private reading and therapy costs and fund 12 weeks of Lindamood-Bell.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted in the decision.
Summary
A 12-year-old boy filed this case against Alta Loma Elementary School District, West End SELPA, and the San Bernardino County Department of Behavioral Health (DBH). He was eligible for special education under specific learning disability and also had ADHD and Tourette's disorder. His claims covered grades 1 through 6, when he was mostly in the District's regular-education independent study program at home.
The Hearing Officer found that the District ignored a 1996 request to assess him, which cost him about two months of speech services. She also found that the District's fluency-based Read Naturally program did not address his phonemic awareness, decoding, or comprehension needs, and that the District did not formally assess his social use of language (pragmatics) until 2002. It then withheld that speech report from the parent. Neither the District nor DBH ever assessed his Tourette's. They offered no real plan to bring him back to school and left his therapist off the IEP team. The District also failed to give written notice when it refused requested Lindamood-Bell services.
The District must reimburse Stowell Learning Center and a summer 2001 Lindamood-Bell program. The District and DBH must jointly reimburse private therapy with Dr. Aubrey Fine. Other orders include a Tourette's assessment, an IEP meeting, a transition plan with staff training, 12 weeks of intensive Lindamood-Bell instruction, and parent training. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for Dr. Boccumini and future therapy with Dr. Fine, who was not a state-certified agency.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated private test results given to a district as notice of areas it had to assess. It also shows that missing prior written notice or a withheld assessment report could itself deny FAPE. Mental health agencies could share liability for therapy that ignored school-related needs.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partChild find
Issue 1a. During the 1996-1997 school year (grade 1), did the District fail to identify and assess Petitioner for special education in response to the parent's September 1996 letter requesting an assessment or under its child-find obligation?
The District gave no assessment plan or prior written notice after the parent's letter. This cost the student about two months of speech services, but he would not then have qualified as having a learning disability.
- District prevailedChild find
Issue 1b. During the 1997-1998 school year (grade 2), did the District fail to timely identify and assess Petitioner pursuant to its child-find obligation?
Any violation from the parent's unwritten oral request had minimal effect, because the District assessed him in May 1998 after her written request and found him eligible.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2a. During the 1996-1997 school year, did the District fail to conduct appropriate assessments (phonemic awareness, pragmatics, social-emotional, AB 3632 referral)?
Phonemic awareness, pragmatics, and the social-emotional area were not areas of suspected disability in grade 1, so no AB 3632 referral was required.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2b. During the 1997-1998 school year, did the District fail to conduct appropriate assessments (phonemic awareness, pragmatics, social-emotional, AB 3632 referral)?
Phonemic awareness became a suspected area late in the year, but the failure to assess it had only a de minimis effect. Pragmatics and social-emotional concerns were not suspected areas.
- Student prevailed in partAssessment
Issue 2c. During the 1998-1999 school year, did the District fail to conduct appropriate assessments (phonemic awareness, pragmatics, social-emotional, Tourette's, AB 3632 referral)?
Private test results the parent gave the District put phonemic awareness and pragmatics on notice, and the District failed to assess either. Social-emotional concerns and Tourette's were not yet suspected areas. The decision states neither party prevailed.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3a. Did the District deny Petitioner a FAPE during the 1996-1997 school year?
The student was not yet eligible and would not have been found eligible, so no FAPE was owed that year beyond what Issue 1(a) covered.
- Student prevailed in partIEP procedure
Issue 3b. Did the District deny Petitioner a FAPE on procedural grounds during the 1997-1998 school year (late IEP meeting; no prior written notice of refusal of Lindamood-Bell services)?
Holding the IEP meeting 10 days past the 50-day deadline did not deny FAPE. Failing to give prior written notice when it refused the requested Lindamood-Bell services did deny FAPE. The decision states neither party prevailed.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3c. Did the District deny Petitioner a FAPE on substantive and procedural grounds during the 1998-1999 school year?
The fluency-based Read Naturally program and goals did not address decoding, phonemic awareness, or comprehension. Speech therapy ignored pragmatics, and the program gave minimal benefit. Reporting progress to the parents only once was also a FAPE denial.
- Student prevailed in partAssessment
Issue 4a. During the 1999-2000 school year, did the District and DBH fail to conduct appropriate assessments (phonemic awareness, pragmatics, Tourette's)?
Dr. Tibbetts' December 1999 testing assessed phonemic awareness. An informal, observation-only pragmatics review was inadequate, and no one assessed Tourette's.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 4b. During the 2000-2001 school year, did the District and DBH fail to conduct appropriate assessments (pragmatics, Tourette's)?
The District and DBH again failed to assess pragmatics and Tourette's.
- Student prevailed in partAssessment
Issue 4c. During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District and DBH fail to conduct appropriate assessments (pragmatics, Tourette's)?
The District finally assessed pragmatics in February 2002 and found him eligible for speech therapy. Tourette's still was not assessed. The decision states neither party prevailed.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5a. Did the District and DBH deny Petitioner a FAPE on substantive and procedural grounds during the 1999-2000 school year?
Recycled goals and the Read Naturally program gave minimal benefit. Nothing addressed pragmatics, Tourette's, or a plan to return him to school, and individual therapy was missing for about five months. Progress reporting was deficient but not prejudicial that year.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 5b. Did the District and DBH deny Petitioner a FAPE on substantive and procedural grounds during the 2000-2001 school year?
No appropriate program was shown for fall 2000. The one-hour SDC with Lindamood-Bell instruction gave some benefit. Still, there was no adequate transition plan, the therapist was left off the IEP team, therapy ignored school-related issues, and there was no prior written notice refusing summer Lindamood-Bell. The student substantially prevailed.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 5c. Did the District and DBH deny Petitioner a FAPE on substantive and procedural grounds during the 2001-2002 school year?
The SDC offer was reasonably calculated to give some benefit. However, there was no transition plan, nothing addressed pragmatics or Tourette's, and individual therapy ignored school issues. Withholding the February 2002 speech report and not convening an IEP meeting denied FAPE from about March 1, 2002. The student substantially prevailed.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6a. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of services from Stowell Learning Center?
Stowell addressed decoding, spelling, and phonemic awareness. Late notice did not bar reimbursement because the parent was not told of the notice requirement. Regular-year costs for 1998-2001 must be reimbursed.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6b. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including transportation, of services from Lindamood-Bell?
The summer 2001 Pasadena Lindamood-Bell program was appropriate and produced gains, so the District must reimburse it.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6c. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of counseling services from Paul Boccumini, Ph.D.?
Reimbursement denied. The District had no notice of this need in grade 3, and the nature of Dr. Boccumini's services was unclear.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6d. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of counseling services from Aubrey Fine, Ph.D.?
DBH's individual therapy was inappropriate, and Dr. Fine's therapy met the student's needs. The District and DBH must jointly reimburse it from November 1, 2001, to the decision date.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 7a. Is Petitioner entitled to Lindamood-Bell services as compensatory education?
Awarded 12 weeks of intensive Lindamood-Bell instruction, 4 hours a day, 5 days a week.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 7b. Is Petitioner entitled to individual counseling from Aubrey Fine, Ph.D., as compensatory education?
Denied. Dr. Fine is not a state-certified nonpublic agency, and mental health services are provided at the county's discretion.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 7c. Is Petitioner entitled to parent counseling and training as compensatory education?
Parent training was awarded, with the nature, amount, frequency, and trainer credentials to be set by the IEP team.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. District must reimburse the cost of Stowell Learning Center services during the regular school year, not summers, for 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001, plus round-trip mileage at the District's employee rate. Proof is due within 20 days of the decision; payment is due within 25 days of receiving proof. The District alone is responsible.
- Reimbursement. District must reimburse the cost of the Lindamood-Bell clinic in Pasadena from June 2001 through August 2001, plus round-trip mileage at the District's employee rate. Proof is due within 20 days; payment is due within 25 days of receiving proof. The District alone is responsible.
- Reimbursement. District and DBH, jointly and severally, must reimburse the cost of individual therapy with Dr. Aubrey Fine from November 1, 2001, to the decision date, plus round-trip mileage. Proof is due within 20 days; payment is due within 25 days of receiving proof.
- Order to assess. Within 18 calendar days, the District must obtain either a formal Tourette's disorder assessment under Ed. Code section 56320 et seq. or a report from the treating physician, Dr. David Comings. It must cover effects on behavior, medication side effects, needed services and accommodations, and staff training. The District and DBH share the cost jointly and severally, and the results go to the ordered IEP meeting.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days, the District must convene an IEP meeting that includes a DBH representative. The team must review the February 2002 speech-language assessment and offer speech therapy for pragmatic and expressive language needs. It must also address Tourette's disorder based on the new assessment or report.
- Order to provide or change services. The IEP team must design a transition plan for a gradual return to a full school day. The plan must involve the student's therapist and include supports such as coaching, social monitoring, and on-site counseling and behavioral interventions.
- Staff training. The transition plan must provide training for school staff, including the student's teachers, so they understand and appropriately handle his disabilities.
- Compensatory education. Intensive Lindamood-Bell program, 4 hours a day, 5 days a week, for 12 weeks at a Lindamood-Bell clinic or similar setting. It must begin within 5 days of the ordered IEP meeting, and the student should attend at least one period of a special education class if possible. The District alone pays.
- Compensatory education. Parent training, with the nature, amount, frequency, and trainer credentials set by the IEP team. It must begin within 10 days of the IEP meeting. The District and DBH share the cost jointly and severally.
Total: 240 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees; School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Educ.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Amanda J. v. Clark County School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Landgraf v. USI Film Products; Department of Educ. v. Cari Rae S.
People named in the decision
- Kevin Kirkland, director of special education and pupil services, Alta Loma Elementary School District
- Joann Reilly, due process program manager, West End SELPA
- Michael Crane, Ph.D., clinic supervisor, AB 2726 unit, San Bernardino County DBH
- Christopher Russell, advocate for Student
- Rodney Ford, staff of Student's counsel's office, Office of Tania Whiteleather
- Linda Livoni, speech pathologist, Alta Loma Elementary School District
- Diane Talbott, resource specialist teacher, Carnelian Elementary School
- Carol Morrison, Independent Study teacher and coordinator, Alta Loma Elementary School District
- Susan Shaw, learning handicapped SDC teacher (Lindamood-Bell trained), Alta Loma Elementary School
- Amy Duncan, program specialist, West End SELPA
- Leo Juarez, L.C.S.W., clinic supervisor, DBH Rancho Cucamonga Counseling Services Clinic
- Aubrey Fine, Ed.D., licensed psychologist; private therapist and expert witness for Student, private practice
- Susie Jacobson, speech and language pathologist (February 2002 assessment), Alta Loma Elementary School District
- Terry Tibbetts, Ph.D., clinical and educational psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness, independent (former West End SELPA due process program manager)
- Linda Prish, school psychologist (October 2001 triennial), Alta Loma Elementary School District
- Karen Williams, Ph.D., licensed psychologist; AB 3632 assessor and therapist, San Bernardino County DBH
- Laura DeChenne, Ph.D., former DBH therapist, DBH Rancho Cucamonga Counseling Services Clinic
- Kelline de Espinosa Alvarez, Psy.D., clinical therapist (group therapy), DBH Rancho Cucamonga Counseling Services Clinic
- Nerissa Galang-Feather, M.D., lead child psychiatrist, San Bernardino County DBH
- Lourdes Pineda, M.D., psychiatrist (medication support evaluation), San Bernardino County DBH
- Chris Kislingbury, private psychologist (March 1997 independent assessment), private
- Peter Ruthenbeck, educational psychologist (May 1998 assessment), Alta Loma Elementary School District
- David Comings, M.D., treating physician, City of Hope Medical Center
- David Rice, M.D., child neurologist, private
- Paul Boccumini, Ph.D., private psychologist, private
- Marlene Carter, O.T.R., private occupational therapist, private
- Ms. Costa, SELPA consultant; Lindamood-Bell tutor and phonemic awareness assessor, West End SELPA
- Erin Hames, District tutor (Lindamood-Bell LiPS, summer 2000), Alta Loma Elementary School District
- Ms. McMurty, former special education director, Alta Loma Elementary School District
- Michael Geary, SEHO Hearing Officer (prehearing orders), Special Education Hearing Office
- Stowell Learning Center, private learning center (Lindamood-Bell services)
- Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes (Pasadena and Newport Beach clinics), private reading clinic
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Rancho Cucamonga, California, on March 11-14, April 11-12, 18-19, May 9-10, June 3, and 27, 2002. STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Tania Whiteleather. Also present on his behalf were his mother, MOTHER; his advocate, Christopher Russell, on most of the days; and Rodney Ford from Ms. Whiteleather’s office on several days. Respondents Alta Loma Elementary School District (District) and West End SELPA (SELPA) were represented by educational consultant Robert Roice. Also present were Kevin Kirkland, director of special education and pupil services, on the District’s behalf, and Joann Reilly, due process program manager, on the SELPA’s behalf. Respondent San Bernardino County Department of Behavioral Health (DBH) was represented by deputy county counsel Susan Nash on most of the days and also by deputy county counsel Scott Runyan on two days. Also present on DBH’s behalf was Michael Crane, Ph.D., clinic supervisor, AB2726 unit.
Petitioner, the District, and the SELPA called the following witnesses: Linda Livoni, District speech pathologist; Diane Talbott, resource specialist, Carnelian Elementary School (Carnelian); Mr. Kirkland; Carol Morrison, District Independent Study teacher and coordinator; Susan Shaw, learning handicapped (LH) special day class (SDC) teacher, Alta Loma Elementary School (ES); and Amy Duncan, SELPA program specialist. Petitioner also called the following witnesses: parent MOTHER; Mr. Russell; Leo Juarez, L.C.S.W., clinic supervisor, DBH Rancho Cucamonga Counseling Services (RCCS) Clinic; Aubrey Fine, Ed.D., licensed psychologist; Susie Jacobson, District speech and language pathologist; and Terry Tibbetts, Ph.D., clinical and educational psychologist. The District and SELPA called the following witnesses: Linda Prish, District school psychologist, and Ms. Reilly. DBH called the following witnesses: Karen Williams, Ph.D., licensed psychologist; Laura DeChenne, Ph.D., former therapist, RCCS Clinic; Kelline de Espinosa Alvarez (Alvarez), Psy.D., clinical therapist, RCCS Clinic; and Nerissa Galang-Feather (Feather), M.D., DBH lead child psychiatrist. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter submitted for a decision.
ISSUES
1. During the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998 school years, did the District fail to identify and assess Petitioner for special education in response to the parent’s September 1996 letter requesting an assessment or pursuant to its child-find obligation?
2. During the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, and 1998-1999 school years, did the District fail to conduct appropriate assessments of Petitioner?
3. Did the District deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) on substantive and procedural grounds during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, and 1998-1999 school years?
4. During the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years, did the District and DBH fail to conduct appropriate assessments of Petitioner?
5. Did the District and DBH deny Petitioner a FAPE on substantive and procedural grounds during the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years?
6. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including the cost of transportation, of educational or counseling services from the following:
a. Stowell Learning Center?
b. Lindamood-Bell?
c. Paul Boccumini, Ph.D.?
d. Aubrey Fine, Ph.D.?
7. If Petitioner was denied a FAPE during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years, is he entitled to the following as compensatory education services:
a. Lindamood-Bell?
b. Individual counseling from Aubrey Fine, Ph.D.?
c. Parent counseling and training?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 12-year-old boy who resides within the District. He was first found eligible for special education because of a speech and language impairment and then a specific learning disability (SLD). He has been diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), Tourette’s disorder, and scotopic sensitivity syndrome. Since grade 3, he has had an Independent Study regular education program. He has also received, at different times, speech therapy; resource specialist program (RSP) services; SDC instruction; and AB3632 individual, group, and family counseling. In addition, his parents have paid for private services, such as the Lindamood-Bell (LMB) program, occupational therapy (OT), and individual counseling. He has been prescribed medications for ADHD, Tourette’s, and anxiety.
When STUDENT was in grade 1 at Carnelian, his mother wrote a letter to his teacher stating that he should be tested because he might be slow in learning and might have ADHD. District speech pathologist Ms. Livoni did a fall 1996 speech and language screening and noted that he should be rescreened in January 1997 at age 7. (Pet. Exh. B-4; Testimony of Ms. Livoni.) He started receiving Title I reading services. In January 1997 he was found eligible for, and was provided, speech and language services for articulation and grammar. During grade 1, he started taking Ritalin and his motor tics started. (Testimony of MOTHER.)
In a March 1997 independent assessment of STUDENT, psychologist Chris Kislingbury diagnosed ADHD; disruptive behavior disorder, not otherwise specified (NOS); and learning disorders. He found that STUDENT had auditory, visual, and attention processing deficits but not a severe discrepancy between IQ and academic achievement. He recommended RSP, or at least a Section 504 plan; reduced schoolwork to prevent frustration; and social skills training. At a May 1997 conference, the mother was informed that STUDENT did not qualify for special education, and a Section 504 plan with classroom and homework modifications was developed.
At the start of grade 2, STUDENT continued with Title I reading services, speech therapy, and Ritalin medication. He also received private tutoring. In response to his mother’s request, District educational psychologist Peter Ruthenbeck assessed him for special education in May 1998. The results supported an ADHD diagnosis. Mr. Ruthenbeck found that STUDENT had average overall cognitive ability; a processing disorder in auditory memory, visual perception, and attention; and a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in reading and written language, including spelling. He noted no significant concerns in the social-emotional area. A health assessment states that STUDENT had glasses for light sensitivity that also helped his migraines.
A June 4, 1998 individualized education program (IEP) states that STUDENT was eligible for special education because of a primary SLD and a secondary speech and language impairment. He had significantly below average reading decoding and comprehension, writing, and spelling scores. The IEP provides for RSP and speech therapy and contains reading decoding, reading fluency, and writing and spelling dictation goals. In July 1998, STUDENT was assessed by LMB.
In September 1998, when STUDENT was in grade 3, he started the District’s regular education Independent Study program (ISP). An October 5, 1998 IEP provides for RSP for 30 minutes 4 times weekly, speech therapy, and private tutoring at Stowell Learning Center (Stowell). A March 25, 1999 IEP meeting was held to address the parent’s request for an intensive LMB program. After the ISP and RSP teachers’ progress reports, the special education director stated that STUDENT’S current program was appropriate. The parent declined additional RSP time. The parent reported STUDENT’S Tourette’s diagnosis and medication treatment, including medication for anxiety. An April 1999 Stowell report states that STUDENT had shown progress in reading, comprehension, spelling, and attention focus. On April 1, 1999, the parents filed for due process.
An April 1999 letter from private physician Dr. David Comings of the City of Hope Medical Center reports STUDENT’S diagnoses of ADHD, Tourette’s, and scotopic sensitivity syndrome and his medication treatment. An April 1999 letter from STUDENT’S child neurologist, Dr. David Rice, states that since 1997 STUDENT had been treated for ADD and Tourette’s and that he also had dyslexia and dysgraphia. A May 1999 letter from private psychologist Dr. Paul Boccumini states that he saw STUDENT in September 1998 for behaviors related to his ADHD and visual-perceptual difficulties. In his grade 1 year, STUDENT had started playing with fire and matches, and when this behavior recurred, Dr. Boccumini, who specializes in this area, came to the family home for 8 to 9 months during STUDENT’S grade 3 year to work with him. A total of about 4 or 5 incidents occurred, with the last incident during his grade 4 year. (Testimony of MOTHER.)
In a May 1999 assessment report, speech pathologist Ms. Livoni recommended STUDENT’S dismissal from the speech and language program. A May 1999 independent assessment report by occupational therapist Marlene Carter, O.T.R., found that STUDENT had significant delays in all areas, including fine motor skills. She started providing private OT to STUDENT. Pursuant to a June 1999 mediation agreement, the District referred STUDENT for an AB3632 assessment and offered summer school in an SDC with LMB tutoring for 5 hours weekly from SELPA consultant Ms. Costa. His mother removed him from summer school because of increased behavioral outbursts. (Testimony of MOTHER.) A June 27, 1999 IEP addendum states that goals for the 1999-2000 school year would be developed at a September IEP meeting.
On June 29, 1999, DBH psychologist Dr. Williams conducted an AB3632 assessment of STUDENT, found him eligible for services, and recommended individual and family therapy. In August 1999, STUDENT started therapy with Dr. Williams. In a September 1999 letter, the mother rescinded authorization for DBH to release confidential information without her prior approval because DBH had given the SELPA an assessment report copy without giving her a copy. At the parent’s request, STUDENT started therapy with another therapist, Dr. DeChenne, in December 1999.
During his grade 4 year, STUDENT continued with the ISP and RSP (45 minutes 4 times weekly) and received AB3632 services. An October 4, 1999 IEP provides for continuing the June 4, 1998 IEP goals and objectives and states that the parents had requested a speech and language assessment. The IEP also indicates that an academic assessment was to be conducted and that the IEP team would then meet to review the assessment results, goals and objectives, and special education services. In October 1999, speech pathologist Ms. Livoni conducted an assessment and concluded that STUDENT did not qualify for speech and language services.
In a December 1999 report of his independent psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT upon the parties’ agreement, clinical and educational psychologist Dr. Tibbetts summarized that the academic achievement tests indicated progress in word attack, passage comprehension, and broad reading skills but a continuing spelling concern. Test results indicated a significant deficit in auditory memory and processing. On the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization (LAC) test, which assesses phonemic awareness, STUDENT had difficulty integrating and shifting sounds. Dr. Tibbetts recommended classroom accommodations for STUDENT’S ADHD and Tourette’s disorder.
A January 6, 2000 IEP was signed by the parent with exception, noting that the current goals could continue until a February meeting. The IEP provides for RSP (45 minutes daily) and ISP. The IEP team reviewed the previous goals and objectives and agreed that a draft IEP would be developed and another meeting held to discuss services. In a February 2000 letter, the parents informed the District of their disagreement with the proposed goals in the draft IEP sent to them.
A February 2000 assessment report by private occupational therapist Ms. Carter, who provided continuing OT to STUDENT, states that speed and stamina in fine motors skills were problematic and that he should learn keyboard skills to keep up with the work in upper grades. In June 2000, RSP teacher Ms. Talbott reported STUDENT’S Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTEA) grade equivalent (GE) scores for reading and spelling to be 2.4 and 2.0, respectively. ISP teacher Ms. Morrison’s report states that STUDENT had started the grade 3 level reading program in February 2000. A June 22, 2000 IEP provides for RSP for 60 minutes 4 times weekly. The IEP contains goals for reading, spelling, and cursive writing. The District offered a summer 2000 program of LMB tutoring. Starting in July 2000, District tutor Erin Hames provided STUDENT 5 hours weekly of tutoring in the LMB LiPS program for two months.
The ISP had moved to Jasper Elementary School (Jasper), so STUDENT was to transfer to the RSP at Jasper for his grade 5 year. (Testimony of Ms. Talbott.) However, there is no indication that he attended the RSP at Jasper. In a September 1, 2000 letter, the parent notified the District that she intended to place STUDENT in the LMB program at Stowell and seek reimbursement for the cost. In fall 2000, he continued with the ISP and received LMB instruction at Stowell. In October 2000, STUDENT was assessed as part of the annual review. On the LAC test, he had difficulty when asked to shift, omit, add, repeat, or substitute sounds.
A November 13, 2000 IEP, signed by the parent, provides solely for ISP. The District proposed an LH SDC with an LMB-trained teacher. The IEP team agreed to meet in December 2000, when the District would provide further details. In a December 11, 2000 letter, the District offered an SDC at Alta Loma ES with teacher Ms. Shaw, who had recently completed LMB training. The letter states that the amount of time that she would work one-on-one with STUDENT would be determined by the IEP team. A December 15, 2000 IEP provides for ISP; an SDC starting on January 8, 2001, for 60 minutes daily; and DBH counseling twice monthly. The District offered an SDC at Alta Loma ES with a teacher trained in the LMB programs. The goal was to gradually transition STUDENT into the regular school day program, starting with a modified program. The IEP contains goals and objectives for reading, spelling, writing, and cursive writing. In January 2001, STUDENT started attending an LH SDC at Alta Loma ES and received one hour daily of one-to-one LMB instruction from teacher Ms. Shaw. (Testimony of Ms. Shaw.)
A January 19, 2001 Stowell progress report states that STUDENT had been working on increasing attention focus, phonemic awareness, and processing skills and recommended continuing work in these areas and also starting work on increasing comprehension and oral and written expression. In April 2001, when STUDENT was in grade 5.8, he obtained the following GE scores on the Stanford Achievement Test, ninth edition (SAT-9): Total Reading, 3.3; Reading Vocabulary, 3.8; Reading Comprehension, 3.0; and Spelling, 2.7. He started DBH group therapy besides individual therapy. On April 30, 2001, the LMB clinic in Pasadena tested STUDENT.
At a May 31, 2001 IEP meeting, the IEP team discussed a recent altercation at school involving STUDENT and two other students which led to his saying that he no longer wanted to return to school. The IEP states that this was a major setback, and the parent requested an intensive summer LMB program to build his self-esteem and academic skills. By a May 31 letter, the parents gave the District notice of their intent to enroll STUDENT in the program at the Pasadena LMB clinic and seek reimbursement. He attended the LMB program during the summer for 12 weeks. (Testimony of MOTHER.) An LMB report compares his April 2001 and August 2001 scores following treatment in the LiPS, Seeing Stars, and Visualizing/Verbalizing programs.
An October 2001 triennial psychoeducational assessment report by school psychologist Ms. Prish sets forth STUDENT’S WISC-III IQ scores as follows: 84 verbal, 108 performance, and 95 full scale. She noted that his low abstract verbal reasoning and vocabulary subtest scores indicated that language was still an area of concern. A significant discrepancy existed between his ability and achievement in written language, spelling, and reading. She also noted his ADHD diagnosis and medication. The teacher’s responses on the Child Behavior Checklist showed the Somatic Complaints syndrome to be in the borderline clinical range. His mother’s responses indicated Total Problems, Externalizing, Attention Problems, and Aggressive Behavior scores in the clinical range and Internalizing and Delinquent Behavior scores in the borderline clinical range. STUDENT’S responses fell in the normal range, except for the Social Problems profile. The nurse’s summary indicated that he wore filtered glasses for light sensitivity. At the time, he was taking Adderall, Clonidine, and also Buspar, an anti-anxiety medication.
In November 2001, STUDENT’S therapist for individual therapy left DBH, and he started private individual therapy with Dr. Fine. An unsigned December 2, 2001 IEP provides for ISP, an SDC, and DBH small-group counseling. The District offered the same SDC that STUDENT had attended in grade 5, designated instruction and services (DIS) counseling, and a speech and language assessment. The parent requested an intensive LMB program at a nonpublic agency (NPA) for 20 hours weekly for 12-16 weeks. A February 26, 2002 assessment by District speech pathologist Ms. Jacobson revealed expressive and pragmatic language problems that qualified STUDENT for speech therapy. She recommended speech therapy in these areas.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: During the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998 school years, did the District fail to identify and assess Petitioner for special education in response to the parent’s September 1996 letter requesting an assessment or pursuant to its child-find obligation?
Petitioner contends that during the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998 school years, when he was in grades 1 and 2, respectively, the District failed to meet its obligation to identify and assess him for special education. The federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and State law impose upon each school district the duty actively and systematically to identify, locate, and assess all children with disabilities who require special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3) (formerly 20 U.S.C. § 1412(2)(C)); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300, 56301. Under State law, the school district must establish written policies and procedures for a continuous child-find system. Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. The policies and procedures must include written notification to all parents of the procedure for initiating a referral for assessment. Id. Identification procedures shall include systematic methods of referrals of students by teachers, parents, agencies, professional persons, and members of the public. Cal. Educ. Code § 56302. Under State law, all referrals for special education and related services shall initiate the assessment process and shall be documented. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3021(a). If an oral referral is made, the school district staff must offer assistance to make the request in writing. Id. A referral for assessment means any written request for assessment made by a parent, teacher, or other service provider. Cal. Educ. Code § 56029.
(a) 1996-1997 School Year: Grade 1
Petitioner contends that during the 1996-1997 school year, when he was in grade 1, the District failed to assess him for special education in response to his mother’s September 1996 letter requesting an assessment. In a September 19, 1996 letter to STUDENT’S grade 1 teacher, the mother stated that he should be tested “to prevent any delay in learning” because he might be slow in learning and might have borderline ADHD. (Pet. Exh. B-1.) The question is whether the District should have identified Petitioner as a student who may have a disability and assessed him for special education based upon the mother’s September 1996 letter or during the 1996-1997 school year pursuant to its independent child-find obligation.
The District does not argue that the mother’s September 1996 letter was not a request for assessment. Rather, the District asserts that the mother’s letter ended with a request that the teacher contact her to discuss the matter, and the District was not obligated to assess STUDENT because it “is apparent that [the letter] was discussed and a decision reached not to test STUDENT at that time.” (Dist. Brief at 26.) However, the law required that the District either present the parent with an assessment plan within 15 days of her September 1996 request pursuant to California Education Code Section 56321(a), or provide prior written notice of its refusal to assess, as required by 20 U.S.C. Section 1415(b)(3) (formerly 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1)(C)). It is undisputed that the District did not offer an assessment plan within 15 days and did not conduct an assessment for special education at that time.
Further, District speech pathologist Ms. Livoni, who did a September 20, 1996 speech and language screening of STUDENT at his teacher’s request, indicated in a note that he should be rescreened in January 1997 at age 7. (Pet. Exh. B-4; Testimony of Ms. Livoni.) However, there is no indication that this note, which contains the names of two other students apparently also screened, was ever provided to STUDENT’S parents. Thus, Ms. Livoni’s screening note does not constitute prior written notice of the District’s refusal to assess STUDENT for special education in compliance with the statute. The District did not provide the requisite prior written notice. The District thus violated the statutory requirements.
The question is whether STUDENT suffered prejudice from the failure to assess because he would have been found eligible for special education if assessed in the fall. He was subsequently assessed, and on January 31, 1997 was found eligible, for speech and language services to address articulation and grammar concerns. He qualified for speech and language services because of essentially the same problems (articulating the “r” and “th” sounds) he exhibited in September. (See Testimony of Ms. Livoni.) Thus, it is concluded that if the District had conducted an assessment, not a mere screening, in fall 1996, he would have been found eligible for speech and language services at that time. If the District had complied with its statutory obligations, it should have presented the parent with an assessment plan within 15 days of her request for an assessment, and the parent would have had 15 days to decide whether or not to consent to the plan. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a), (c). An IEP meeting, required to offer an IEP as a result of the assessment, must occur within 50 days of receipt of the parent’s written consent for assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56344. Thus, if the maximum time limits were used, an IEP meeting offering speech and language services should have been held by approximately the first week of December 1996. The District’s failure to assess STUDENT in response to the mother’s request resulted in the loss of educational opportunity for him and deprived him of a FAPE for at least two months. W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).
A further question is whether STUDENT would have been found eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability (SLD) if the District had assessed him in fall 1996 in response to his mother’s letter. The requirements for an SLD include (1) a basic psychological processing disorder that results in (2) a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in the areas of oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, or mathematics reasoning. Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(a), (b); see 34 C.F.R. § 300.541(a)(2). A third requirement is that the discrepancy cannot be ameliorated through “other regular or categorical services” offered within the regular education program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(c); see 34 C.F.R. § 300.543(a)(6).
The results of the March 1997 independent psychoeducational assessment of Petitioner by Mr. Kislingbury are pertinent to a determination of whether STUDENT would have been found eligible for special education if assessed in fall 1996. Mr. Kislingbury diagnosed ADHD; disruptive behavior disorder, NOS; and learning disorders; found that STUDENT suffered from auditory and attention processing deficits; and found no severe discrepancy between STUDENT’S average nonverbal ability (the best estimate of his learning potential) and his below-grade level academic achievement scores. He noted STUDENT’S immaturity (e.g., hiding under the chair) and his Ritalin medication. He recommended RSP services if STUDENT failed to make sufficient academic progress and, if he did not receive these services, a Section 504 accommodation plan to address modifications. Thus, although STUDENT had auditory and attention processing disorders, no severe discrepancy existed for eligibility in the SLD category.
Moreover, even if STUDENT’S achievement may have been lower in the fall than in the spring, when he was tested by Mr. Kislingbury, the third eligibility criterion provides for correction of any discrepancy through services offered within the regular education classroom. About mid-year, STUDENT started receiving Title I reading assistance and speech therapy. Hismother testified that about that time, his homework assignments also were modified. Although he had a slow start in developing reading skills, as reflected in his first-trimester report card, the teacher’s comment was that he was making steady progress. On his second- and third-trimester report cards, he received check marks indicating success in reading fluency and reading comprehension, although his instruction in these areas as well in speaking and writing was adapted to his level. A comment on both report cards was that he continued to make steady progress in reading. From the foregoing, it is concluded that even if the District had assessed STUDENT for special education in fall 1996, he would not have been found eligible because of an SLD at that time. Thus, Petitioner suffered no prejudice in this regard although the District violated the statutory requirement by not assessing STUDENT in response to his mother’s letter.
As discussed above, an independent psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT was conducted in March 1997. In May 1997, the assessment results were reviewed at a conference, and the mother was informed that he did not qualify for RSP and that a Section 504 plan would be enacted. Petitioner argues that the District failed to meet its obligations by not holding an IEP meeting and conducting a special education assessment upon receipt of Mr. Kislingbury’s assessment report. However, even if the District should have assessed STUDENT for special education pursuant to its child-find obligation, STUDENT would not have been found eligible at that time, as discussed above, so no prejudice ensued.
(b) 1997-1998 School Year: Grade 2
Petitioner contends, in essence, that during the 1997-1998 school year, when he was in grade 2, the District failed timely to assess him for special education pursuant to its child-find obligation. The mother testified that sometime during the middle of STUDENT’S second-grade year, she orally asked his teacher about an assessment, and the teacher said that he was doing fine at the time. The evidence is that the mother was not informed, or offered assistance, to put her request in writing. Nevertheless, the precise time that the oral request was made is unclear, and the Hearing Officer finds that any procedural violation had minimal effect because the District did complete a May 1998 psychoeducational assessment in response to the mother’s March 13, 1998 letter, and STUDENT was found eligible for special education because of an SLD.
ISSUE 2: During the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, and 1998-1999 school years, did the District fail to conduct appropriate assessments of Petitioner?
Petitioner contends that during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, and 1998-1999 school years, when he was in grades 1, 2, and 3, respectively, the District did not conduct appropriate assessments. The appropriateness of the District’s assessment is governed by the requirements set forth at California Education Code Sections 56320, 56322, and 56324. Tests and other assessment materials must be provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language or other mode of communication; must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b). The pupil must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development; vision, including low vision; hearing; motor abilities; language function; general ability; academic performance; self-help; orientation and mobility skills; career and vocational abilities and interests; and social and emotional status. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). The assessment shall be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g). Assessment materials must assess specific areas of educational need and not merely provide a single general intelligence quotient. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c). Further, no single procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for a special education child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e). Moreover, psychological assessments, including individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning, must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(b)(3), 56324. Assessments must be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area. Cal. Educ. Code § 56322.
(a) 1996-1997 School Year: Grade 1
Petitioner contends that in the 1996-1997 school year, the District failed to assess all areas of suspected disability. He asserts generally that the District failed to assess phonemic awareness, pragmatics, or the social and emotional area. He also asserts that the District failed timely to make an AB3632 referral. These areas will be addressed in turn.
1. Phonemic Awareness. The District did not assess for special education in response to the mother’s September 1996 request, but the parents obtained a March 1997 independent psychoeducational assessment by psychologist Mr. Kislingbury. He found an auditory processing deficit and below grade-level reading scores but did not indicate the need for further testing in phonemic awareness at that time. Thus, no support exists for finding phonemic awareness to be an area of suspected disability during this school year.
2. Pragmatics. Petitioner asserts that the September 1996 screening by speech pathologist Ms. Livoni and the District’s January 1997 speech and language assessment that found him eligible for speech therapy both failed to assess pragmatics, an alleged area of suspected disability. STUDENT’S first-grade report cards indicate that his speaking assignments and instruction had been adapted to his level. However, his mother’s September 1996 letter did not mention a speech and language concern, and Mr. Kislingbury’s March 1997 psychological assessment found that STUDENT performed above expectations on the WISC-III Picture Arrangement subtest, which in part measures the ability to recognize nonverbal cues in social situations. There is no indication that pragmatics was an area of suspected disability during this school year.
3. Social-Emotional Area. On the Connors Rating Scale administered by Mr. Kislingbury, the parent reported significant restless and disorganized behavior, antisocial behavior (e.g., stealing and fire-setting), and borderline conduct disorder behavior (e.g., temper outbursts). The teacher reported high anxiety-passivity and few friendships. The mother testified that he cried at home because he did not want to do homework and that Ritalin did not improve his attention problem. At this time, his tics started. However, Mr. Kislingbury’s DSM-IV diagnoses did not indicate any serious social-emotional concerns, apart from behavioral issues reflected in the diagnosis of disruptive behavior disorder, NOS, at home. He noted that oppositional and defiant behaviors, while prevalent, were not significant, and recommended social skills training, not counseling. STUDENT’S first-grade report cards showed satisfactory marks in all areas of social behavior and study skills, including following directions and exercising self-control. In addition, the mother’s September 1996 letter mentioned a concern about impulsive and inattentive behavior but not social or emotional concerns. Thus, it is concluded that this was not an area of suspected disability in the first grade, and an AB3632 referral was not required.
In summary, the evidence does not support the conclusion that the above areas were areas of suspected disability during the 1996-1997 school year.
(b) 1997-1998 School Year: Grade 2
Petitioner contends that during the 1997-1998 school year, when he was in grade 2, the District again failed to assess all areas of suspected disability, specifically, phonemic awareness, pragmatics, and social-emotional problems, and failed to make a timely AB3632 referral. Each of these areas will be addressed. In May 1998, the District assessed STUDENT for special education and found him eligible because of an SLD. Educational psychologist Mr. Ruthenbeck assessed the areas of health, intellectual functioning, language and auditory functioning, psycho-motor and visual-spatial functioning, self-help skills, social-emotional functioning, and academic achievement. He stated that the results supported an ADHD diagnosis. He concluded that STUDENT had a visual, auditory, and attention processing disorder and a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in reading and written language, including spelling.
1. Phonemic awareness. The May 21, 1998 psychoeducational assessment report sets forth STUDENT’S academic achievement test results obtained by RSP teacher Ms. Talbott. His KTEA standard and GE scores, respectively, were as follows: Reading Decoding, 79, 1.5; Reading Comprehension, 78, 1.2; and Spelling, 80, 1.5. He achieved the following Woodcock-Johnson Achievement Battery-Revised (WJ-R) standard and GE scores, respectively: Letter-Word Identification, 86, 1.8; Passage Comprehension, 80, 1.5; Broad Reading, 81, 1.6; Dictation, 70, 1.1; Writing Samples, 83, 1.7; and Broad Written Language, 78, 1.4. During the testing Ms. Talbott observed that he displayed weak word attack skills and awareness of vowel patterns in reading decoding and spelling. She noted that an analysis of his writing sample errors revealed difficulty with auditory segmentation, identification of initial clusters, and common phonograms (e.g., “-ing”). Thus, phonemic awareness was then an area of suspected disability. Moreover, such an area must be formally assessed pursuant to California Education Code Section 56320, and there is no evidence of such an assessment. However, because this was near the end of the school year and any assessment would likely not have been completed until the following year, this procedural violation did not have more than de minimis effect during this school year.
2. Pragmatics. Mr. Ruthenbeck’s assessment report indicates that he assessed language and auditory functioning through observation and subtests on the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children. A speech and language assessment had been conducted in January 1997, when STUDENT qualified for speech therapy for articulation and received therapy for articulation and expressive language. (Testimony of Ms. Livoni.) He continued to receive speech therapy during his second-grade year, but there is no indication that he was assessed for pragmatics. With regard to another school year, speech pathologist Ms. Livoni testified that she did not conduct a formal assessment for pragmatics because no teacher reported that he was not getting along socially, and he was able to communicate with her. According to Mr. Ruthenbeck’s report, STUDENT stated that he had friends, and he appeared to have adequate oral communication skills and conversed and conveyed his thoughts with no apparent difficulties. Moreover, STUDENT’S report cards reflected successful performance in speaking throughout the year. Thus, there was no indication that pragmatics was an area of suspected disability during this school year.
3. Social-Emotional Area. The mother testified that STUDENT would cry and throw a tantrum if he had to do a report, and doing homework elicited behavioral outbursts. Her Connors Rating Scale responses also revealed significant indications of conduct problems, psychosomatic complaints, and impulsivity/hyperactivity. Mr. Ruthenbeck’s observations during the testing and in the classroom were that STUDENT appeared to be strong-willed and manipulative, liked to tell “tall tales,” and wanted to do things his way. He also was frequently off-task and had difficulty with work completion. However, he was also polite and reported having friends, and the teacher’s comments did not indicate any social-emotional concerns. Mr. Ruthenbeck found no significant concerns in this area. Moreover, while STUDENT’S first-trimester report card showed marks between satisfactory and improvement needed in wise use of time, neat and orderly work production, and assignment completion, by the second and third trimesters, he received satisfactory marks in these and all other areas of social behavior and study skills. In the last trimester, the teacher commented on his hard work and excellent behavior. The evidence does not support the conclusion that the social-emotional area was an area of suspected disability and that an AB3632 referral was required at this time.
To summarize, the pragmatic and social-emotional areas were not areas of suspected disability, and the District’s failure to assess phonemic awareness, which was an area of suspected disability, had de minimis effect during this school year.
(c) 1998-1999 School Year: Grade 3
During STUDENT’S grade 3 (1998-1999) year, he started the regular education Independent Study program (ISP) and also received RSP and speech therapy. He contends that during this school year, the District failed to assess all areas of suspected disability, in particular, phonemic awareness, pragmatics, social-emotional problems, and Tourette’s disorder. He also asserts that the District failed to make a timely AB3632 referral. These areas will be addressed.
1. Phonemic Awareness. In the ISP, STUDENT’S mother worked with him individually at home. The mother testified that he could read independently only at the kindergarten and grade 1 levels because he would miss letters and sounds in words. Petitioner asserts that the July 31, 1998 LMB assessment and the April 5, 1999 Stowell progress report identified phonemic awareness as a deficit area. The LMB assessment report shows a 43 score on the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization (LAC) test and indicates that phonetic processing, specifically, phonemic awareness, was an area of need. (Pet. Exh. K.) The Stowell progress report shows a 55 LAC test score and states that he was working on a serious deficit in phonemic awareness. (Pet. Exh. V.) The mother testified that she gave a copy of the July 1998 LMB assessment report to the District at the start of the school year and also gave the District a copy of the April 1999 Stowell report. Thus, during this school year, phonemic awareness was an area of suspected disability. Ms. Livoni testified that in May 1999 she administered expressive vocabulary and articulation tests to STUDENT and assessed his use of irregular verbs with a spontaneous language sample. However, she did not testify that she assessed for phonemic awareness. There is no evidence that the District assessed this area. Thus, its assessment was inappropriate.
2. Pragmatics. On July 31, 1998, STUDENT was assessed by LMB in Newport Beach. One of the tests administered was the Test of Problem Solving (TOPS), which assesses for pragmatics, according to the testimony of speech pathologist Ms. Livoni. According to her, a percentile score of 7 or lower indicates a problem with pragmatics. In July 1998, STUDENT obtained a TOPS score of 4 percentile. According to Ms. Livoni’s testimony, this score indicated that pragmatics was problematic for STUDENT. The mother’s undisputed testimony was that she gave the District a copy of the LMB assessment report at the beginning of the 1998-1999 school year. Thus, pragmatics was an area of suspected disability at this time, but the District did not assess this area. In May 1999, speech pathologist Ms. Livoni assessed STUDENT for expressive vocabulary and articulation and recommended that he be exited from the speech and language program, but she did not assess pragmatics at that time. Because the District failed to assess pragmatics during this school year, its assessment was inappropriate.
3. Social-Emotional Area. The mother testified that during STUDENT’S third-grade year, psychologist Dr. Boccumini came to their home to work with him on his fire-setting behavior. She further testified that, although STUDENT seemed to like the ISP, in which he was presented curriculum at his functioning level, his outbursts continued about 3 to 4 days a week when he was frustrated with the academic work and would cry and say that he was dumb and could not do the work and would not want to go to school for RSP. However, as discussed below, it is unclear when the mother informed the District about the fire-setting or outbursts at home. At Stowell, he was working on attention focus control, and the April 1999 Stowell progress report states that his attention focus was improving, and he was better able to ask questions and express himself rather than talking out of turn and not following directions. He was also attending RSP for 30 minutes 4 times weekly, and his RSP teacher Ms. Talbott testified that on some days he did not do what he was supposed to do in class, but he did not throw a tantrum or cry, and she was unaware of any outbursts from him. He was also receiving speech therapy for 30 minutes twice weekly, and speech pathologist Ms. Livoni testified that she thought that he interacted well when she worked with him, and she could not think of any behavioral concern. Although STUDENT may have had problems related to fire-setting and doing academic work at home, the evidence overall does not support the conclusion that the District had knowledge which would have put it on notice that the social-emotional area was an area of suspected disability before June 1, 1999. An AB3632 referral was not required before then.
On June 1, 1999, Petitioner and the District entered into an interim mediation agreement providing for an AB3632 referral and for SELPA-provided DIS counseling in the event he did not qualify for AB3632 services. On June 29, 1999, DBH conducted an AB3632 assessment and determined that he was eligible for AB3632 mental health services.
4. Tourette’s Disorder. The mother testified that Dr. Comings assessed STUDENT and diagnosed Tourette’s. The March 25, 1999 IEP states that the mother reported that STUDENT was diagnosed with Tourette’s and was taking medication for it. In an April 19, 1999 letter, Dr. Comings states that he had been treating STUDENT for ADHD, Tourette’s, and scotopic sensitivity syndrome with medications that had helped his behavior and concentration. The mother testified that she gave a copy of this letter to the District, but it is unclear when this was done. Thus, the evidence does not establish that during this school year, the District had definite information about this diagnosis and that Tourette’s was an area of suspected disability.
Thus, the social-emotional area and Tourette’s were not areas of suspected disability, but phonemic awareness and pragmatics were areas of suspected disability that the District failed to assess. Its failure to assess these areas resulted in STUDENT’S IEP not addressing these areas of need during this school year.
In conclusion, during the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998 school years, the District did not have an obligation to assess which resulted in prejudice to STUDENT. However, during the 1998-1999 school year, by failing to assess phonemic awareness and pragmatics, the District failed to offer a program that addressed these needs, as discussed below.
ISSUE 3: Did the District deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) on substantive and procedural grounds during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, and 1998-1999 school years?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A free appropriate public education (FAPE) is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student’s unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a) (“designated instruction and services” shall be available when necessary for a student to benefit from special education). In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court held that the IDEA provides students with disabilities with a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of “access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit” but stated that these services need not maximize each child’s potential. Id. at 198-99, 200-01.
The IDEA also requires the State and local educational agencies to guarantee to children with disabilities and their parents certain procedural safeguards with regard to provision of a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(a). In Rowley, the Supreme Court stated: “It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents . . . a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard.” 458 U.S. at 205-06 (citation omitted). Central among the safeguards is the process of formulating the IEP, including parental participation in the process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights afforded parents also include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes or refuses to initiate or to change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the right to a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in a loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process do constitute denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.
Thus, the inquiry in determining whether a FAPE has been provided is twofold: (1) whether the District has offered an appropriate educational program and (2) whether the District has complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-07.
(a) 1996-1997 School Year: Grade 1
Because STUDENT had not yet been found eligible for special education, and it was determined above that he would not have been found eligible even if assessed during the 1996-1997 school year, he was not entitled to a FAPE during this school year.
(b) 1997-1998 School Year: Grade 2
At a June 4, 1998 IEP meeting, STUDENT was found eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability in reading, writing, and spelling. Regarding the 1997-1998 school year, Petitioner alleges solely procedural violations. First, he asserts that when his mother submitted her March 1998 written assessment request, the District failed to hold an IEP meeting within the 50-day period required by California Education Code Section 56344. In response to the mother’s March 1998 request, the District provided her with a proposed assessment plan, which she signed. Following receipt of her consent on April 3, 1998 (Pet. Exh. G), the District had 50 days, by May 25, 1998 (the Monday following the fiftieth day), to complete the assessment and hold an IEP meeting. Cal. Educ. Code § 56344. The District held an IEP meeting on June 4, 1998, 10 days late. (Pet. Exh. J.) Moreover, no signed waiver of the 50-day time period or evidence of any other reason for an extension is in the record. The evidence is that the District failed to meet the statutory requirement. However, the June 4 IEP indicates that RSP services were not to start until the following fall, in September 1998. Thus, the delay in holding the IEP meeting did not result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. This violation, while not to be condoned, did not result in denial of a FAPE.
Moreover, Petitioner asserts that the District failed to provide the requisite prior written notice of its refusal to provide LMB services in response to his mother’s request. Her undisputed testimony is that at the June 4, 1998 IEP meeting, she requested LMB services, but her request was not written in the IEP. Neither RSP teacher Ms. Talbott nor speech pathologist Ms. Livoni, who attended the June 4 IEP meeting, provided contrary testimony. There is no evidence that the District provided written notice of its denial of her request. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to meet the statutory requirement of prior written notice of its refusal to change the educational placement of a child. 20 U.S.C. Section 1415(b)(3). Because the District failed to give the requisite written notice, including a description of the requested action, an explanation for its refusal, and options considered and rejected and the reasons, this violation seriously infringed upon the parents’ opportunity to participate meaningfully in the IEP process. The result was denial of a FAPE.
(c) 1998-1999 School Year: Grade 3
During the 1998-1999 school year, when STUDENT was in grade 3, his mother placed him in the regular education Independent Study program (ISP), and he received RSP, speech therapy, and also private LMB services from Stowell from mid-year to the end of the school year. He contends that the District denied him a FAPE on both substantive and procedural grounds. The District contends that it provided a FAPE.
A. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year, it is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet his unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and (3) conformed with his IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89. Petitioner argues, in essence, that he was denied a FAPE in that the District failed to identify and address all of his unique needs, specifically, phonemic awareness, pragmatics, and a transition plan for his return to school from the ISP, and failed to offer a program that conferred educational benefit. (1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a program during the 1998-1999 school year that was designed to meet his unique needs, it is first necessary to identify his needs. With the exception discussed below, there was little disagreement about his needs, established by the psychoeducational, speech and language, health, RSP, LMB, Stowell, and OT assessments and IEPs up through the 1998-1999 school year. In 1997, he was diagnosed with ADHD, combined type; disruptive behavior disorder, NOS, at home; and learning disorders, NOS. He had auditory, visual, and attention processing deficits, which were confirmed in 1998. He started taking Ritalin for ADHD. In 1998, his ADHD diagnosis was confirmed, and he was identified as having significantly below average reading decoding and comprehension, writing, and spelling skills. During 1997 and 1998, he exhibited on behavioral rating scales significant scores for antisocial conduct problems, hyperactivity, anxiety and passivity, learning problems, and psychosomatic complaints. In 1997, speech and language deficits in articulation and grammar were identified but were determined by a May 1999 assessment no longer to exist. Since grade 1, STUDENT had had recurring fire-setting behavior, for which he received private psychological treatment during his third-grade year. For a light sensitivity problem, he wore glasses which also helped with migraines. In April 1999, he continued to have well below average reading skills and a serious deficit in phonemic awareness. In May 1999, an OT assessment revealed significant delays in posture, movement, and gross and fine motor skills.
Further, as discussed above under Issue 2(c), a July 1998 assessment indicated that he had a problem with phonemic awareness, indicated by his low LAC test score, and also a pragmatic language problem, reflected in his low TOPS score (see Testimony of Ms. Livoni). However, although they were areas of suspected disability during this school year, the District failed to assess these areas and identify or address them as unique needs.
Because of these deficits, STUDENT had certain instructional needs. The IEP team agreed that he required RSP services, speech therapy, and classroom modifications such as modifying spelling and writing assignments and using tapes for reading. An area of disagreement was whether he required a transition plan to assist his return to the regular school setting. The District asserts that such a plan was unnecessary because he settled into his RSP class with ease and had good attendance and behavior and thus did not have a “critical or chronic” need for such a plan. (Dist. Brief at 24-25.) However, even RSP teacher Ms. Talbott testified that there were days when STUDENT did not want to do what he was supposed to do in class. His mother testified that he did not like to go to the RSP class and was defiant in not wanting to go to school, though she made him go. She testified that she noticed resistance in the way he spoke to Ms. Talbott.
The mother testified that she had placed STUDENT in the ISP because he was behind academically and displayed emotional problems in not wanting to go to school, and she had a concern about the larger class size in grade 3 compared to the first two grades. She decided thatshe would get him up to grade level through the ISP and Stowell program and then have him return to the regular school setting. She also testified that the District appeared to agree with the ISP placement, and the IEPs in fact provide for such a placement.
Nonetheless, there was universal agreement by the witnesses who testified about the matter that having STUDENT return to a school setting was desirable. (E.g., Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Shaw, Mr. Kirkland, Ms. Costa, Dr. Fine, Dr. Tibbetts, Ms. Jacobson.) Disagreement existed as to the reasons that he did not return to school and the means necessary to get him back. A transition plan would have provided a goal to work toward. But the problems underlying STUDENT’S difficulty with handling school and schoolwork needed to be identified and addressed first. As discussed above under Issue 2(c), there is no indication that the mother communicated her concerns about his outbursts at home related to doing homework and attending school until the June 1999 mediation. When asked on cross-examination whether she had communicated emotional concerns as a reason that he could not return to school, she replied that she expressed her concerns, but there is no indication of when this was done, if at all, prior to June 1999.
The Hearing Officer finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that during the 1998-1999 school year, the District lacked the information to know of underlying emotional, social, and behavioral concerns related to school attendance and homework completion to have notice that the ISP was not appropriate and that a transition plan was necessary. Thus, a transition plan was not an identified unique need at this time.
The next step in determining whether the proposed program was designed to address STUDENT’S unique needs is to examine the IEP. The IEP is a written statement of the goals and objectives developed to meet the student’s unique needs and the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services that will be provided to assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii), (iii).
The June 4, 1998 IEP was in effect at the start of the 1998-1999 school year. STUDENT’S mother testified that she decided to place him in the District’s ISP starting that school year, and an October 5, 1998 IEP merely changed his regular education placement to ISP. Petitioner argues that the IEPs in effect that school year failed to address all of his unique needs, including phonemic awareness and pragmatics.
The October 5 IEP amends the June 4 IEP to change the regular education placement and amount of RSP services but itself contains no goals and objectives. (See Testimony of Ms. Talbott.) The June 4 IEP contains 2 goals. The first goal is to improve “reading/decoding and fluency.” The objectives are to identify the first two “letters/consonant clusters” in a word; to read words from the First and Second 100 Most Used Words list; and to read a passage at the 2.0 or higher level at a minimum of 50 words per minute and with 90 percent accuracy. The first objective apparently was intended to address STUDENT’S decoding deficit, but it is not clear why only two-letter consonant clusters are mentioned since, because of his phonemic awareness deficit, he initially required assistance with identifying and differentiating sounds, not merely two-consonant clusters, and their number, order, and position (see Testimony of Dr. Tibbetts). The second objective addresses assistance with sight words. The third objective, as the goal indicates, was intended to improve fluency, but fluency was not an identified unique need at this time. Moreover, the reading goal and objectives do not address STUDENT’S phonemic awareness deficit and need in reading comprehension. They were thus inappropriate.
The second goal is to improve “writing/spelling dictation skills.” The objectives are to average 80 percent or higher on weekly spelling and daily Signs for Sounds (spelling program) lessons; to complete Level 1 Signs for Sounds at 80 percent or higher; and to write 4 sentences using the first 200 most used words with no more than 5 writing mechanics and spelling errors. The first two objectives address STUDENT’S spelling deficit and the third addresses his writing need.
The October 5, 1998 IEP provides the following program and services. Besides ISP, the IEP provides for RSP for 30 minutes 4 times a week and speech therapy for 30 minutes twice weekly. The testimony of RSP teacher Ms. Talbott established the following regarding the RSP program. She provided to STUDENT RSP services for 30 minutes 4 times a week in reading decoding, reading fluency, and writing, specifically, spelling. The Read Naturally reading program was utilized to build fluency. STUDENT’S program was individualized, and for 15 minutes each day he received one-to-one attention when he did the “cold” (initial) oral reading and “hot” oral reading (after listening to the tape three times and following along) and his words-correct-per-minute rate was recorded, and when he did a writing summary and practice. The rest of the time, he listened to a tape of a passage until he was ready to do the hot reading. Reading comprehension was part of the program in that there were multiple-choice questions at the end of a passage which were read orally to STUDENT.
Ms. Talbott emphasized that the Read Naturally program was utilized to build fluency. However, as noted above, fluency was not identified as one of STUDENT’S unique needs at this time. Independent psychologist Dr. Tibbetts testified that a reading program that emphasized fluency would not be appropriate for STUDENT because an increase in fluency without a corresponding increase in accuracy is meaningless. According to him, with timed oral readings, a child may be able to read faster but may still mispronounce the same words or same number of words, just mispronounce them more quickly. Moreover, there was no evidence that the Read Naturally program addressed STUDENT’S reading needs in reading decoding and phonemic awareness or, except to a limited extent, reading comprehension. Thus, the reading program the District provided failed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs.
According to Ms. Talbott, Signs for Sounds is a spelling program. Given a word, STUDENT had to circle the letters corresponding to the sounds he heard in CVC (i.e., consonant-vowel-consonant) and CCVC patterns and then write the word. She testified that when she used this program, she tried to reinforce the labels (such as “lip-poppers”) from the LMB LiPS program. The spelling program was designed to meet STUDENT’S spelling needs, including a sound-based program. The June 4 IEP provides for classroom accommodations such as modifying spelling and writing assignments and permitting STUDENT to use tapes for reading. These addressed his reading, writing, and spelling needs.
Regarding speech therapy, as discussed above under Issue 2(c), by the start of STUDENT’S grade 3 year, pragmatics was an area of suspected disability that the District failed to assess during this school year. Thus, the District failed to identify this speech and language need and, although it provided speech therapy for articulation and grammar, the speech therapy did not address his pragmatics need. Finally, Petitioner contends that the District failed to address his unique needs by not developing a transition plan to assist his return to the regular school setting. However, as discussed above, a transition plan was not identified as a unique need at this time.
In summary, during this school year, a transition plan for STUDENT’S return to a school setting was not yet a unique need, and the District’s proffered spelling program and accommodations were designed to address his needs, but the reading program and speech therapy failed to address his unique needs.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Determining whether a program is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit requires a review of various measures, including, among other things, standardized test scores, teacher and staff observations, ratings on course work and tests, grade advancement, and progress on annual goals and short-term objectives. Petitioner contends that the District’s program failed to provide educational benefit. The District asserts that STUDENT made measurable growth, as reflected in his RSP test results and increase in ISP grade-level work.
Ms. Talbott’s March 29, 1999 RSP progress report states that since fall 1998, STUDENT had shown at least a month-for-month growth in the Read Naturally program in that he had gone from level 1.3 to 2.0 (7 months’ improvement), and his fluency had also increased from about 45 words correct per minute (WCPM) at level 1.3 to 85 WCPM at level 2.0. However, the December 1999 psychoeducational report of independent psychologist Dr. Tibbetts suggests that less weight should be accorded the RSP results because they were not standardized test score measurements. As noted above, he also testified that an increase in reading rate without a corresponding increase in accuracy is meaningless because a child is then merely misreading faster. Ms. Talbott’s report concluded that STUDENT was still about 1.5 to 2 years below grade level in reading. At the March 25, 1999 IEP meeting, ISP teacher Ms. Morrison also reported that he was reading at the first-grade level.
A comparison of STUDENT’S May 6, 1998 and April 5, 1999 WJ-R reading standard scores (in parentheses) and GE scores reveals the following: 5/6/98 4/5/99
Letter-Word Identification (86) 1.8 (77) 1.8 Passage Comprehension (80) 1.5 (80) 1.7 Broad Reading (81) 1.6 (77) 1.8
Dr. Tibbetts testified that most academic tests have a 3- to 4-point standard error of measurement, and a decrease of 5 or more points over time indicates a meaningful decline, and a decrease of 4 points is in the gray area that the child is showing actual decline. STUDENT’S Broad Reading standard score (SS) decreased by 4 points and his Letter-Word Identification SS, by 9 points. The latter is a significant decline.
On the other hand, in July 1998, on the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test, STUDENT obtained a Word Attack GE score of 1.2, at the 2 percentile, and in April 1999, on the WJ-R, he obtained a Word Attack GE score of 2.0, at the 17 percentile. Similarly, in July 1998, he obtained a LAC test score of 43 and in April 1999, 55. In both of these areas, STUDENT did show progress.
STUDENT was in the ISP during grade 3, and no report cards are in the record. Moreover, the record contains little evidence of his progress on his IEP goals and objectives except for his RSP teacher’s incomplete recollection of events that occurred three years earlier. (She recalled that the fluency goal was met.) District special education director Mr. Kirkland testified that progress on goals is recorded on the IEPs themselves, but no copies of IEPs indicating progress on the goals during this school year are in the record. Nevertheless, the fact that the October 4, 1999 IEP states that the June 4, 1998 goals and objectives were to continue in effect during fall 1999 may be evidence that STUDENT failed to meet his IEP goals during this school year.
The evidence is that STUDENT showed some progress in reading comprehension, word attack skills, and phonemic awareness. From approximately the middle of the school year, according to the mother’s testimony, he started receiving LMB services at Stowell. Since there was no indication that the District’s Read Naturally program specifically addressed word attack or phonemic awareness, it appears that any progress in these areas is likely attributable to the Stowell services. Thus, any benefit STUDENT received from the District’s program was minimal.
In conclusion, the District’s reading program and speech therapy did not meet STUDENT’S unique needs, and its educational program was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Therefore, STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year.
B. Compliance with Procedural Safeguards
Petitioner claims that the District failed to comply with the requirement that his parents be informed of his progress toward his IEP goals and objectives. The District claims that it had a procedure for reviewing and marking progress on the goals of prior IEPs at IEP meetings. The IDEA requires that the IEP contain a statement of how the child’s progress toward his annual goals will be measured and how the “parents will be regularly informed (by such means as periodic report cards), at least as often as parents are informed of their nondisabled children’s progress, of–(aa) their child’s progress toward the annual goals . . .; and (bb) the extent to which that progress is sufficient to enable the child to achieve the goals by the end of the year.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(viii).
First, the record contains STUDENT’S trimester report cards for his kindergarten through second-grade years but none for the period when he was receiving special education services beginning with grade 3. Nonetheless, the evidence is that parents were informed of their nondisabled children’s progress through trimester report cards. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that to comply with the IDEA, the District needed to inform STUDENT’S parents at least 3 times periodically during the year of his progress toward his goals and also the extent to which the progress was sufficient for him to achieve the goals by the year’s end. The question, thus, is whether the District complied with this statutory requirement.
During STUDENT’S third-grade year, IEP meetings were held on October 5, 1998; March 25, 1999; and June 27, 1999. The October 5 IEP was primarily to change his regular education program to ISP, and there is no indication that his progress toward his goals was discussed. The March 25 IEP states that the purpose was to address the parent’s request for the LMB program. The IEP indicates that there was discussion about STUDENT’S progress thus far by his RSP teacher, Ms. Talbott, and the ISP teacher, Ms. Morrison. Thus, this IEP meeting did provide the parents information about STUDENT’S progress, though the IEP does not indicate that progress on specific goals was reviewed. The June 27 IEP is an addendum which states that an IEP meeting would be held in September 1999 to develop goals for the upcoming year. There is no indication of information imparted to the parents about STUDENT’S progress toward his goals. Thus, during the 1998-1999 school year, the District provided STUDENT’S parents with information about his progress only once, although the parents of nondisabled children would have received trimester report cards. Thus the District did not report on STUDENT’S progress to his parents as frequently as the parents of nondisabled children were provided reports. There is also no indication that the parents were informed of the extent to which any progress was or was not sufficient to permit him to achieve the goals by the end of the year. Thus, the evidence does not establish that the District complied with this statutory requirement.
Moreover, the District’s failure to do so seriously infringed upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process because without periodic reports on STUDENT’S progress in the special education program, the parents lacked timely knowledge to be able to assess whether the program required either minor or substantial alteration because of a lack of improvement in educational skills. Thus, the result was denial of a FAPE.
ISSUE 4: During the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years, did the District and DBH fail to conduct appropriate assessments of Petitioner?
Petitioner contends that in the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years, when he was in grades 4, 5, and 6, respectively, the District and DBH did not conduct appropriate assessments. A mental health assessment is a “service designed to provide formal, documented evaluation or analysis of the nature of the pupil’s emotional or behavioral disorder.” The assessment must meet the same requirements imposed on the District. Cal. Code Regs. tit 2, § 60020(g).
(a) 1999-2000 School Year: Grade 4
Petitioner contends that in the 1999-2000 school year, when he was in grade 4, the District and DBH failed to assess all areas of suspected disability, specifically, phonemic awareness, pragmatics, and Tourette’s. These areas will be addressed in turn.
1. Phonemic Awareness. As discussed above under Issue 2(c), by the start of the 1998-1999 school year, the District had notice that phonemic awareness was an area of suspected disability, but there was no evidence that the District assessed this area during that school year. Ms. Livoni testified that in October 1999, she conducted a speech and language assessment in the production of speech sounds, semantics, syntax, language processing, and receptive and expressive language. She testified that the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills (TAPS), which she also administered, tests for auditory memory and auditory processing through word description, ability to follow directions, and general knowledge. Upon questioning by the District, she testified that the TAPS also “to a certain extent looks at” phonemic awareness, which she described as the discrimination between words that vary by one sound. However, she did not testify as to STUDENT’S performance related to phonemic awareness. Further, the testimony of independent psychologist Dr. Tibbetts established that phonemic awareness involves more than mere discrimination of sounds. Thus, the Hearing Officer determines that this area was not assessed appropriately in October 1999. In a December 1999 report, however, Dr. Tibbetts, who was contracted by the District to assess STUDENT, sets forth the results of his administration of the LAC test, which assesses phonemic awareness. The report states that STUDENT showed little difficulty recognizing and differentiating sounds but that his performance decreased when required to integrate and shift sounds, particularly within a sustained pattern. (Pet. Exh. MM.) Thus, the District did assess this area at that time.
2. Pragmatics. As discussed above under Issue 2(c), by the start of the 1998-1999 school year, the District had notice that pragmatics was an area of suspected disability but did not assess the area. In May 1999, speech pathologist Ms. Livoni assessed STUDENT and recommended that he be dismissed from speech and language services, but she did not assess pragmatics. At an October 4, 1999 IEP meeting, the parents requested a full speech and language assessment. Later that month, Ms. Livoni administered to STUDENT the Comprehensive Receptive and Expressive Vocabulary Test, Language Processing Test-Revised, TAPS, and Test of Language Development-Intermediate. She also determined, based upon clinical observations, that voice, fluency, articulation, pragmatics, and language were within expectancy. She concluded that his language skills were within normal limits and that he did not qualify for speech and language services. Ms. Livoni testified that she assessed pragmatics informally and did not think a formal assessment was necessary because STUDENT communicated with her and no teacher had reported that he did not get along socially. However, speech pathologist Ms. Jacobson, who administered a pragmatics language test to STUDENT in February 2002 and found that he qualified for speech therapy for pragmatics and expressive vocabulary, testified that it is necessary to use a formal standardized test to identify a pragmatics difficulty. The Hearing Officer found Ms. Jacobson to be forthright and credible and places great weight on her testimony. Because the District had prior notice that pragmatics was an area of suspected disability, an assessment was required to be conducted pursuant to the statutory requirements commencing with California Education Code Section 56320. An informal assessment based solely on observation did not meet these requirements. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to conduct an appropriate assessment of pragmatics during this school year.
3. Tourette’s Disorder. Pursuant to a June 1999 mediation agreement, STUDENT was referred to DBH for an AB3632 assessment conducted on June 29. The mother’s undisputed testimony is that she took a copy of Dr. Comings’ letter regarding the Tourette’s diagnosis, along with other documents, to DBH. When she received a copy of the AB3632 assessment report at a fall 1999 IEP meeting, she was concerned that the report contained nothing about Tourette’s. DBH assessor Dr. Williams testified that it was an oversight not to include Tourette’s in the medical history portion of the report but that she did not find out about the diagnosis until the IEP meeting. On August 19, 1999, DBH psychiatrist Lourdes Pineda, M.D., saw STUDENT for medication support services and completed a 5-page evaluation report which notes that Dr. Comings had prescribed Clonidine, Adderall, and Buspar and refers to diagnoses with which she concurred and which she suspected but does not mention Tourette’s as a diagnosis. Dr. Tibbetts’ District-contracted December 1999 psychoeducational assessment mentions a Tourette’s diagnosis and recommends classroom accommodations for ADHD and Tourette’s. He testified that he did not recall the effects of Tourette’s on STUDENT. DBH therapist Dr. DeChenne, who started treating STUDENT in December 1999, testified that the mother indicated that he was receiving medication treatment from Dr. Comings for ADHD and Tourette’s. Dr. DeChenne testified that a DBH referral to a medical doctor was the standard practice but that she was unaware of a referral for an evaluation for Tourette’s and that, although he was evaluated by a psychiatrist, she did not know if DBH assessed him for Tourette’s. A May 2000 DBH diagnosis completed by Dr. DeChenne identifies, besides ADHD and learning disability, Tourette’s reported by the parent. During this school year Tourette’s was an area of suspected disability but there is no evidence that this area was assessed pursuant to the statutory requirements commencing with California Education Code Section 56320. To that extent, the assessment of the District and DBH was inappropriate.
In summary, by the start of the 1999-2000 school year, DBH had conducted an AB3632 assessment of the social-emotional area, and in December 1999, the District assessed phonemic awareness. However, during this school year, the District and DBH failed to assess all areas of suspected disability by failing to assess pragmatics and Tourette’s.
(b) 2000-2001 School Year: Grade 5
Petitioner contends that in the 2000-2001 school year, when he was in grade 5, the District and DBH again failed to assess all areas of suspected disability, in particular, pragmatics and Tourette’s disorder. Each area will be addressed.
1. Pragmatics. As discussed above, by the start of the 1998-1999 school year, pragmatics was an area of suspected disability, and the District failed to assess this area in the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years. The District did not provide evidence that it assessed pragmatics during this school year, and the Hearing Officer concludes that it failed to assess this area during the 2000-2001 school year.
2. Tourette’s Disorder. As stated above, in the 1999-2000 school year, Tourette’s was an area of suspected disability and the District and DBH failed to assess this area. They also did not assess this area during the 2000-2001 school year. Thus, their assessment was inappropriate.
In sum, during the 2000-2001 school year, the District and DBH failed to assess pragmatics and Tourette’s, both previously determined to be areas of suspected disability.
(c) 2001-2002 School Year: Grade 6
Petitioner contends that during the 2001-2002 school year, when he was in grade 6, the District and DBH failed to assess all areas of suspected disability, specifically, pragmatics and Tourette’s. Each area will be addressed.
1. Pragmatics. As stated above, pragmatics was an area of suspected disability by the start of the 1998-1999 school year, when STUDENT was in grade 3, and the District failed to assess this area in the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years. In October 2001, school psychologist Ms. Prish conducted a triennial psychoeducational assessment and noted that STUDENT’S low scores on the WISC-III abstract verbal reasoning and vocabulary subtests might indicate that language was still an area of concern. At a December 2001 IEP meeting, she suggested that a re-assessment of language processing and speech and language services might be appropriate. In a February 26, 2002 assessment by speech and language pathologist Ms. Jacobson when STUDENT was age 12 years, 0 months, he obtained an expressive vocabulary standard score of 65, at the 1 percentile and 6 years, 9 months age-equivalent (AE) level. On the Test of Pragmatic Language, he obtained a 58 quotient, at the less than .3 percentile and 5 years, 6 months AE level. Ms. Jacobson concluded that he qualified for speech therapy and recommended speech therapy in pragmatics and also expressive language, particularly, expressive vocabulary. Thus in February 2002, the District finally assessed this area of suspected disability and STUDENT met the eligibility requirements for speech therapy.
2. Tourette’s Disorder. As discussed above, Tourette’s was an area of suspected disability during the 1999-2000 school year, and the District and DBH failed to assess this area from that time to the end of the 2000-2001 school year. This area was also not assessed during the 2001-2002 school year. Thus, the assessment during this year was inappropriate.
Thus, during the 2001-2002 school year, the District assessed pragmatics in February 2002 for the first time. However, the District and DBH failed to assess Tourette’s.
In conclusion, as a result of the failure timely to assess all areas of suspected disability, specifically, pragmatics and Tourette’s, as discussed above, the District and DBH did not offer a program that addressed these needs, as discussed below.
ISSUE 5: Did the District and DBH deny Petitioner a FAPE on substantive and procedural grounds during the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years? To determine whether the District and DBH offered STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years, it is necessary to engage in a two-part inquiry: (1) whether the District and DBH offered an appropriate educational program and (2) whether they complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-07.
(a) 1999-2000 School Year: Grade 4
In late June 1999, STUDENT qualified for AB3632 services. During the 1999-2000 school year, when in grade 4, he remained in the ISP, with RSP and AB3632 services and continued private LMB services from Stowell and private OT. He alleges that he was denied a FAPE on both substantive and procedural grounds. The District and DBH disagree.
A. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
It is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit, and (3) was in conformity with his IEP. Petitioner contends that he was denied a FAPE in that the District and DBH failed to identify and address all of his unique needs, specifically, pragmatics, Tourette’s, a transition plan for his return to the regular school setting, and individual therapy; implemented inappropriate goals and objectives; failed to provide appropriate AB3632 therapy; and failed to provide a program that bestowed educational benefit.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District and DBH offered STUDENT a program during the 1999-2000 school year that was designed to meet his unique needs, the first step is to identify his needs. Areas of disagreement are discussed below. Needs about which there was little disagreement were established by the AB3632, psychoeducational, DBH, and OT assessments, medical reports, and IEPs up through the 1999-2000 school year. In 1999, STUDENT was diagnosed with ADHD, combined; learning disorders, NOS; and scotopic sensitivity syndrome. He continued to have a significant deficit in auditory memory and processing. He was reading 1.7 to 2.2 years below grade level. He needed to develop automatic word-attack skills. He continued to have a spelling problem and a phonemic awareness difficulty, particularly with integrating and shifting sounds. He had weak fine motor skills and had difficulty with cursive writing and written work. In the gross motor area, he had poor coordination and difficulty with laterality. He suffered from impulsivity and low frustration tolerance. He had another fire-setting incident during the current year. At home, he engaged in name-calling, lying, disobedience, and angry outbursts, both oral and physical, against his parents and his 6-year-old sister. In therapy, he was at times uncooperative, sarcastic, oppositional, or silly. He had glasses for his continuing light sensitivity condition and related headaches but did not wear them consistently. He took medications for ADHD, anxiety, and Tourette’s.
Finally, as discussed above under Issue 4(a), pragmatics was an area of suspected disability that was not assessed during this school year. If it had been properly assessed, it likely would have been identified as a unique need. Thus, the failure to assess resulted in not identifying and addressing a unique need. An area of difference regarding his needs was whether STUDENT’S behavioral problems were confined to his home. Although the District’s witnesses in general attempted to disclaim or minimize any behavioral problems outside the home, the evidence is that in his RSP class and in therapy, he was at times defiant and uncooperative or “silly.” Once, when he did not want to comply with the RSP teacher’s request, he slapped her arm as she sat next to him. (Dist. Exh. 14; see Testimony of Ms. Talbott, MOTHER.) In therapy, he was rude, sarcastic, and oppositional or acted silly and engaged in baby talk. His current private therapist, Dr. Fine, testified that his social-emotional issues do not occur only in the home. STUDENT had difficulty in Boy Scouts and thought that the others picked on him. Based upon the persuasive evidence in the record, including Dr. Fine’s testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’S emotional and behavioral problems extended beyond his home to include the school setting.
A difference of opinion also existed as to whether Tourette’s, diagnosed by Dr. Comings in 1999, constituted a unique need. Petitioner asserts that this was a unique need that had to be addressed to provide him an appropriate program and therapy. The District argues, in essence, that if STUDENT has Tourette’s, it has had no impact on his education or therapy, according to District and DBH witnesses, and thus was not a unique need that had to be addressed. RSP teacher Ms. Talbott and speech pathologist Ms. Livoni testified that they did not observe symptoms of Tourette’s but also acknowledged that they had no medical background or training in Tourette’s. STUDENT’S current private therapist, Dr. Fine, testified that children with Tourette’s and ADHD display many of the same symptoms and that although Tourette’s is a tic disorder, it has challenging psycho-social side effects, including social difficulties such as fire-setting. In his December 1999 independent psychoeducational assessment report, Dr. Tibbetts recommended classroom accommodations for ADHD and Tourette’s, apparently recognizing that Tourette’s is a condition that needs to be addressed in the classroom. He testified that Tourette’s could interfere with social reciprocity and could also subject a child to ridicule. STUDENT’S DBH therapist, Dr. DeChenne, testified that Tourette’s is a condition that DBH should have assessed, with the implication that it should then have been addressed. From the credible evidence presented by the psychologists, the Hearing Officer finds that Tourette’s was a unique need for STUDENT.
Because of the above deficits, STUDENT had these instructional needs agreed upon by the IEP team. He required RSP services and AB3632 therapy. He required classroom modifications such as a seat close to the teacher for monitoring, reduced written assignments, a check for understanding when given directions, and use of a spell checker or Alpha-Smart keyboard. He required a multi-sensory approach using visual, auditory, and tactile techniques. He required support such as working on coping skills, self-esteem, and anger and frustration management.
There was disagreement about two areas of instructional needs, a transition plan and individual therapy. A difference of opinion existed as to whether STUDENT required a transition plan for his return to the regular school setting. The mother testified that in grade 4 he continued with the ISP because he was still behind academically and in the ISP he did not feel pressured that he was not up to the other children’s level. She testified that the District agreed with the ISP. The District asserts, in effect, that STUDENT had good attendance and behavior in his RSP class, so there was no indication of a need for such a plan. However, the June 1999 AB3632 assessment report had revealed STUDENT’S problems with fire-setting, disobedience, and angry outbursts. The IEP team knew that he was taking medications for ADHD, anxiety, and Tourette’s. During his grade 4 year, he in fact exhibited in his RSP class behavior which the District witnesses claimed occurred only at home. According to Ms. Talbott’s end-of-year RSP summary, STUDENT generally stayed focused and worked well, with monitoring, in class. However, particularly toward the end of the year, at times he was resistant to doing his work, acted “silly,” and exhibited defiance to the point of shutting down and not wanting to cooperate. (Dist. Exh. 14; see Testimony of MOTHER.) Notably, this behavior occurred when he was receiving AB3632 therapy. During this school year, the District had notice that STUDENT had emotional and behavioral problems and that some of these were related to schoolwork. From the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that a transition plan to assist STUDENT to return to the regular school setting from the ISP was a unique need.
A second area of disagreement regarding STUDENT’S needs was whether he needed individual, not just family, therapy through DBH. He started therapy with Dr. Williams in August 1999, and in October 1999, the parent requested a change in therapists because of Dr. Williams’ unwillingness to provide individual therapy to STUDENT alone. The mother testified that during the therapy sessions, Dr. Williams gave her parenting tips regarding STUDENT’S behavior and interacted only with her. She claimed that Dr. Williams did not communicate directly with STUDENT, and he was not responsive to her. The mother testified that she saw minute changes but not improvement in his anxiety level or other emotional difficulties, and during the time that he was seeing Dr. Williams, another fire-setting incident occurred. Dr. Williams testified that she did not agree to provide individual therapy because STUDENT was reluctant to separate from his mother and was showing improvement on his target goal without such therapy. When the parent’s advocate requested individual therapy, Dr. Williams agreed to provide it but was removed from the case shortly thereafter. It is undisputed that Dr. Williams never provided individual therapy to STUDENT. Dr. DeChenne became STUDENT’S therapist in December 1999, and, according to her testimony, started providing individual therapy in January 2000.
Dr. DeChenne testified that individual therapy with STUDENT alone was appropriate for part of the time (in addition to therapy with both him and his mother). According to her, individual therapy permits the therapist to establish a relationship with the child separate from the family and allows the child to raise issues he might not express in his family’s presence. Dr. DeChenne testified that at first, STUDENT had an excessively close relationship with his mother, to the point that he did not have opinions separate from hers. However, after individual therapy, along with family therapy, he was able to tell Dr. DeChenne when he preferred to have individual therapy without his mother present. Thus, although a primary reason Dr. Williams gave for not providing individual therapy was STUDENT’S difficulty separating from his mother, it appears that such therapy addressed this very problem and assisted him in separating from his mother. Dr. Williams testified that a normal 9-year old child would be expected to be able to separate from his parent, and it appears that individual therapy helped him to do so. The Hearing Officer finds from Dr. DeChenne’s persuasive testimony that individual therapy was a unique need for STUDENT.
(a) IEPs. Next, it is necessary to examine the IEP to determine whether the proposed program was designed to address STUDENT’S unique needs. At the start of the school year, the June 4, 1998 IEP, as amended by the October 5, 1998 IEP, was in effect until the October 4, 1999 and January 6, 2000 IEPs were developed. Petitioner argues that the goals and objectives in the IEPs were inappropriate.
When the school year started, the goals and objectives in the June 4, 1998 IEP were still in effect. The October 4, 1999 IEP specifically provides for continuing these goals and objectives during the time that academic and speech and language assessments were to be conducted. (Pet. HH-3.) After the assessments were completed, a January 6, 2000 IEP meeting was held, and the parent consented to the IEP with the exception that the current (i.e., June 4, 1998) goals could continue until a February meeting. The IEP notes state that a subsequent meeting would be held following the development of a draft IEP, which was to be faxed to the parent and advocate. The next IEP meeting was held on June 22, 2000, when new goals and objectives were agreed upon. Thus, the June 4, 1998 IEP goals and objectives developed for STUDENT’S third-grade year remained in effect for the entirety of his fourth-grade year as well. The discussion above under Issue 3(c) regarding the June 4, 1998 goals and objectives applies here. It is noted, however, that the fact that the very same goals and objectives were used for two successive years raises questions about whether these goals and objectives were met during the prior school year, and, if so, whether goals already met were continued in effect without modification. As discussed above, because there is no written, only fleeting anecdotal, evidence of STUDENT’S actual progress toward the June 1998 IEP goals and objectives, this cannot be ascertained. The District has failed to establish that the goals and objectives in effect from September 1999 to the end of the 1999-2000 school year were appropriate.
In addition, the program and related services must be designed to carry out the goals and objectives. The October 5, 1998 IEP amended the June 4, 1998 IEP to provide for RSP for 30 minutes 4 times a week. The October 4, 1999 IEP provides for RSP for 45 minutes 4 times a week and DBH services for 1 to 4 times a month. The January 6, 2000 IEP provides for RSP for 45 minutes daily. The evidence is that during STUDENT’S fourth-grade year, in the RSP the same Read Naturally reading program and the same spelling programs were used to carry out the same goals and objectives as in his third-grade year. Thus, the discussion above under Issue 3(c) regarding these programs applies here. In addressing Issue 3(c), the Hearing Officer determined that the reading program failed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs. Moreover, the fact that during the current school year, the same goals and objectives from the prior year apparently were implemented without modification raises a serious question about the appropriateness of the program. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s educational program that was provided to carry out what the Hearing Officer determined were inappropriate goals and objectives and that was, in fact, the same program provided during the previous year to carry out the identical goals and objectives was not appropriate to meet STUDENT’S unique needs.
As discussed under Issue 4(a), pragmatics and Tourette’s were areas of suspected disability that were not assessed. The Hearing Officer also specifically found above that Tourette’s was a unique need for STUDENT. Because these areas were not assessed, the IEP did not address them, including their effects on STUDENT, in the present levels of performance. The IEP also did not offer a speech and language goal or speech therapy for pragmatics or address the type of accommodations and other support and services he required because of Tourette’s. Thus, the IEP and proposed program and services did not meet these unique needs. In addition, the Hearing Officer found above that a transition plan to support his return to a school setting was a unique need. Because the District did not offer such a plan, it failed to meet this unique need.
(b) AB3632 Therapy. Finally, Petitioner contends, in effect, that his AB3632 therapy was inappropriate in failing to address all of his unique needs. Initially, it is noted that the Hearing Officer found above that individual therapy was a unique need. Dr. Williams started providing therapy to STUDENT in August 1999, but he did not receive any individual therapy until January 2000. Thus, for an approximately 5-month period, the District and DBH failed to meet this unique need. Petitioner further argues that the therapy failed to address other unique needs, specifically, Tourette’s and school-related issues, including social-emotional needs related to his return to a school setting.
Regarding Tourette’s, as discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that Tourette’s constituted a unique need. Because this area was not assessed, the manner in which this condition manifested in STUDENT and affected his behavior is unknown and was not addressed in his therapy. Thus, the therapy failed to address this unique need.
As for school-related social-emotional issues, Petitioner contends that his therapy did not address how his emotional needs affected his education. He asserts, in effect, that because he had poor reading and writing skills due to his learning disability, he had emotional issues related to self-esteem, anxiety, and frustration. Consequently, according to Petitioner, he had issues related to attending school and returning to a school setting. The therapy chart notes indicate that from August to October 1999, Dr. Williams provided what was essentially family therapy with a focus on parental strategies to address STUDENT’S physical and verbal aggression toward his younger sister. As discussed above, the therapy during this time failed to meet STUDENT’S need for individual therapy to address his emotional and behavioral issues. The chart notes further indicate that from December 1999 to the end of the school year, when Dr. DeChenne was his therapist, STUDENT at times spoke in “baby talk”; refused to speak or answer questions; was sarcastic, rude, and oppositional; said he was bored; or avoided eye contact. Thus, a focus of the combination of both individual and family therapy, while working on identified milestones, or goals, was for Dr. DeChenne to establish a rapport and relationship with STUDENT. Nevertheless, in May 2000, with reference to a goal to express anger or upset without name-calling or yelling, the objective was to follow his parents’ and teacher’s directions without argument. The Hearing Officer finds that the therapy provided by Dr. DeChenne addressed STUDENT’S initial need for her to establish a therapeutic relationship with him, given his difficulty participating in therapy. Although she was thus unable to spend more therapy time on school-related emotional issues, during this school year the therapy was appropriate.
In summary, the program during this school year failed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs with regard to reading, phonemic awareness, pragmatics, Tourette’s, a transition plan for his return to school, and individual therapy (for an approximately 5-month period).
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Determining whether a program is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit requires a review of various measures, including, among other things, standardized test scores, teacher and staff observations, ratings on course work and tests, grade advancement, and progress on annual goals and short-term objectives. Petitioner contends that his academic program and therapy failed to bestow educational benefit. The District asserts that STUDENT made progress, as reflected in his RSP and SAT-9 test results and increase in grade-level ISP work.
(a) Academic Program. RSP teacher Ms. Talbott’s June 2000 report states that STUDENT had completed levels 3.5 and 4.0 of the Read Naturally program with fluency rates of 110 and 127 WCPM, respectively, and 83 percent comprehension on both levels. ISP teacher Ms. Morrison’s June 2000 report states that in February he had started the grade 3 level in reading fluency, comprehension, writing and spelling. As noted above, however, Dr. Tibbetts expressed reservations about reliance on results not based on standardized scores.
A comparison of STUDENT’S April 5, 1999 and December 1999 WJ-R reading standard scores (in parentheses) and GE scores reveals the following: 4/5/99 12/99
Letter-Word Identification (77) 1.8 (78) 2.1 Passage Comprehension (80) 1.7 (86) 2.6 Word Attack (86) 2.0 (85) 2.1 Broad Reading (77) 1.8 (80) 2.3
His standard scores indicate steady progress in letter-word identification, word attack, and broad reading skills, and a 6-point increase in passage comprehension. Dr. Tibbetts stated that STUDENT’S WJ-R GE scores placed him 1.7 to 2.2 years below grade level. During this period, STUDENT was in the ISP, with RSP for 3 to 3-3/4 hours weekly, and was receiving 6 hours weekly of private LMB services at Stowell. Dr. Tibbetts stated that any reading improvement was likely due to a combination of these programs.
In December 1999, STUDENT obtained the following Gray Oral Reading Test-3 (GORT-3) percentile and GE scores, respectively: Rate, 9, 2.7; Accuracy, 2, <1.9; Passage, 5, <1.9; and Comprehension, 16, 2.8. Dr. Tibbetts indicated that STUDENT’S oral reading rate had increased significantly since he took the GORT-3 in July 1998, but his accuracy had not shown commensurate growth. His report states that because the GORT-3 comprehension items are multiple-choice, he felt that STUDENT’S improvement was due to his ability to compensate by using contextual information. In a June 2000 report, RSP teacher Ms. Talbott set forth STUDENT’S KTEA standard and GE scores, respectively, as follows: Reading, 79, 2.4 and Spelling, 73, 2.0. She noted that these scores, significantly lower than his reading level in the Read Naturally program and in the curriculum used in the ISP, were not considered valid. However, the KTEA reading scores are comparable to his December 1999 WJ-R Broad Reading scores, set forth above.
In December 1999, on the Test of Written Spelling-4 (TWS-4), he obtained 81 standard and 2.4 GE scores (compared to 87 standard and 1.1 GE scores in March 1997). Dr. Tibbetts stated that the lack of significant improvement may reflect his auditory processing deficits. The 6-point decrease in scores reflects a decline not attributable to the standard error. (See Testimony of Dr. Tibbetts.) In December 1999, STUDENT obtained a total LAC score of 76, compared to a 55 in April 1999. Dr. Tibbetts noted that although he had little difficulty recognizing and differentiating sounds, his performance decreased when required to integrate and shift sounds. STUDENT’S 2000 SAT-9 GE scores when he was in grade 4.8, compared to his scores two years earlier in 1998, when he was in grade 2.8 (in parentheses), are as follows: Total Reading, 2.0 (1.7); Reading Vocabulary, 2.0 (1.2); Reading Comprehension 2.2 (2.2); and Spelling, 2.9 (1.6). (Pet. Exh. PPP.) He showed slight improvement from two years prior in all areas except reading comprehension, which showed no improvement.
In summary, although STUDENT made some progress, he was still reading approximately 2 years below grade level, and, as Dr. Tibbetts noted, spelling was still a concern. Because all of his instructional programs had reading as a component, it is likely that his improvement in comprehension on the WJ-R and GORT-3 was due to all programs. The Read Naturally program, which focused on fluency (according to teacher Ms. Talbott), likely assisted STUDENT in improving his reading rate. As discussed above under Issue 3(c), however, Dr. Tibbetts testified that an increase in rate without a corresponding increase in accuracy is meaningless. Moreover, this program did not directly address decoding skills or phonemic awareness, as the Stowell program did; thus progress in these areas likely is attributable to the Stowell services. Because reading decoding, reading comprehension, and phonemic awareness skills were identified as unique needs and reading rate was not, it is concluded that the Stowell program, in contrast to the Read Naturally program, played a significant part in STUDENT’S improvement in these areas, and the evidence is that the RSP had minimal impact on his progress in these areas. From the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s reading and spelling programs were not reasonably calculated to bestow benefit on STUDENT.
(b) AB3632 Therapy. The mother asserted that she did not see a positive change in STUDENT’S anxiety level or behavior as a result of the AB3632 therapy. However, the evidence is that he made progress and met the first two goals to reduce aggression toward his younger sister and eliminate fire-setting incidents for a 3-month period. (DBH Exhs. Q, V-55, V-47; Testimony of Dr. DeChenne.) The third goal, to express anger and upset without name-calling, yelling, or rumination for 3 consecutive months, had a May 31, 2001 target date and was thus still being worked on at the end of the school year. A reduction in anxiety was not a targeted goal during this school year, but STUDENT’S behavior in the targeted areas did show improvement. Thus, the therapy was reasonably calculated to, and did, confer benefit.
To summarize, it was determined above that the goals and objectives in effect during this school year were not appropriate, and the District’s program, including the Read Naturally reading program, did not meet STUDENT’S unique needs. In addition, he was not provided a transition plan and, for about a 5-month period, individual therapy to meet his unique needs. He also was provided no speech and language services to address his need in pragmatics. Further, his educational program and therapy failed to addressed his Tourette’s. While he showed some progress in therapy, his overall educational program bestowed only minimal benefit. The result was denial of a FAPE.
B. Compliance with Procedural Safeguards
Petitioner contends that the District failed to inform his parents regularly of his progress toward his IEP goals and objectives, as required by law. It was found above under Issue 3(c) that the District informed parents of their nondisabled children’s progress at least 3 times a year through trimester report cards. There are no report cards in the record for STUDENT’S grade 4 year. Thus, the question is whether the District informed his parents through other means, as regularly as the parents of nondisabled children were informed (that is, at least 3 times a year), of his progress toward his goals and also the extent to which the progress was sufficient for him to achieve the goals by the year’s end. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(viii).
The District asserts that it has a procedure for reviewing and marking progress on the goals of prior IEPs at IEP meetings. During STUDENT’S grade 4 year, IEP meetings were held on October 4, 1999; January 6, 2000; and June 22, 2000. The October 4 IEP states that following additional assessments, the IEP team would meet to review the assessment results, goals and objectives, and support and services. Thus, there is no evidence that during this IEP meeting, the parents were informed of STUDENT’S progress toward his goals. The January 6 IEP indicates that previous goals and objectives were reviewed, and the testimony of the mother and RSP teacher Ms. Talbott concurred that this was done. Ms. Talbott testified that she recalled that the goal regarding fluency was met, but she acknowledged that the IEP does not document progress on specific goals and objectives. Thus, at this IEP meeting, it appears that the parent was informed of STUDENT’S progress toward his goals. The June 22 IEP indicates that prior goals and objectives were reviewed, and the mother’s testimony confirmed this. Thus, at this IEP meeting, the parent was informed of STUDENT’S progress toward his goals
During this school year, the evidence is that STUDENT’S parents were informed of his progress toward his goals at two IEP meetings. However, they were not informed 3 times during the year, as the parents of nondisabled children were. Moreover, no evidence was presented that STUDENT’S parents were informed of the extent to which any progress was sufficient to enable him to achieve the goals by the end of the year. Thus, the District failed to comply with the IDEA requirement. During this year, however, the Hearing Officer finds that the procedural violation was not prejudicial. At the October 4 IEP meeting, the IEP team agreed upon additional assessments which would shed light on STUDENT’S progress. At the January 6 IEP meeting, the assessment results and prior goals and objectives were reviewed and new goals and objectives were proposed, but the parent did not agree to them. Prior goals and objectives were again reviewed and new goals and objectives adopted at the June 22 IEP meeting. Thus, the evidence is that during this school year, the parent was actively involved and participated in the IEP process of reviewing STUDENT’S progress toward his goals and objectives and in formulating a new IEP with new goals and objectives.
(b) 2000-2001 School Year: Grade 5
During the 2000-2001 school year, when STUDENT was in grade 5, he continued in the ISP, which had moved to Jasper, and was to continue in the RSP program (at Jasper instead of Carnelian). However, during the first semester, he attended the private LMB program at Stowell instead. In the second semester, he attended an LH SDC at Alta Loma ES for one hour daily and continued to receive AB3632 services and private Stowell LMB services. He asserts that he was denied a FAPE on both substantive and procedural grounds. The District and DBH disagree. A. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
It is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit, and (3) was in conformity with his IEP. Petitioner argues that he was denied a FAPE in that the District and DBH failed to identify and address all of his unique needs, specifically, pragmatics, Tourette’s, and an appropriate transition plan to assist his return to the school setting; failed to provide appropriate AB3632 therapy; and failed to provide a program that conferred educational benefit.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District and DBH offered a program designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs during the 2000-2001 school year, it is necessary to identify his needs. The following essentially undisputed needs were established by the specialists’ reports, DBH assessments and reports, and IEPs during this school year. He continued to have weaknesses in reading decoding, comprehension, writing, and spelling. His WJ-R GE scores for Broad Reading and Broad Written Language were 2.2 and 1.5, respectively. In the ISP, in November 2000 he started the grade 3-2 level reading program and did grade 2-1 level independent reading. In the area of phonemic awareness, he still found it difficult to shift, omit, add, repeat, or substitute sounds. He continued to have difficulty focusing and staying on task. He continued to have problems with low frustration tolerance, anger, and compliance with adults’ instructions. In therapy, he continued to display sarcasm and occasional oppositional or negative behavior. He continued to take medications for ADHD, anxiety, and Tourette’s. Moreover, as discussed above under Issue 4(a), pragmatics was an area of suspected disability during this school year but was not assessed. If it had been assessed, it likely would have been identified as an area of need. Under Issue 5(a) above, the Hearing Officer found that Tourette’s was a unique need, but it still was not assessed and identified as such during this school year.
Because of these deficits, STUDENT had the following agreed-upon instructional needs. He required small-group and some one-to-one instruction and individual and group therapy. He required a multi-sensory reading program such as LMB. He required that educational tasks be broken down into steps and examples provided. He required cooperative learning and assistance in prioritizing work. He continued to require an Alpha-Smart keyboard because of a fine-motor difficulty. He continued to require work on coping skills, self-esteem, and anger or frustration management. He required a modified school program to assist his transition back to a regular school day program. Further, as the Hearing Officer found above under Issue (5)(a), he also required a transition plan to prepare, and provide the necessary support, for his return to school.
(a) IEPs. The next step is to examine the IEP to determine whether the proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs. At the start of the school year, the June 22, 2000 IEP was in effect; on November 13, 2000, an interim IEP was developed; and on December 15, 2000, a new IEP was developed. These will be addressed in turn.
1. June 22, 2000 IEP. The June 22 IEP contains goals to improve the ability to decode simple-syllable and two-syllable words; visualize and verbalize each sentence of a 4-sentence paragraph; spell; recognize letters, sounds, and labels for all of the consonants and vowels in isolation; read and spell nonsense and real words with simple syllables in isolation; and write in cursive. These goals were designed to address STUDENT’S reading decoding, reading comprehension, spelling, and cursive writing needs. To carry out these goals and objectives, the June 22 IEP provides for a program of ISP and pull-out RSP for 60 minutes 4 times weekly.
Carnelian RSP teacher Ms. Talbott testified that she did not have further contact with STUDENT after the June 2000 IEP meeting because the ISP had moved to Jasper and he was transferred to the Jasper RSP. However, on September 1, 2000, the mother gave the District notice that she was placing him in the Stowell LMB program and would seek reimbursement. There is no credible evidence that he ever attended the RSP at Jasper. No evidence was presented regarding the RSP at Jasper or elsewhere that the District offered STUDENT in fall 2000. The evidence fails to establish that its proposed program was appropriate to meet his needs.
2. November 13, 2000 IEP. The November 13, 2000 IEP, signed by the parent as an interim IEP pending a December 2000 meeting, provides solely for ISP at Jasper, with no special education services. The IEP contains no goals and objectives. According to the IEP, District staff were receiving LMB training, and the District proposed for STUDENT an LH SDC at Alta Loma ES with an LMB-trained teacher. An IEP meeting was to be held in December 2000, when the District would present details of the SDC placement. Because no RSP or any other special education services were offered to meet STUDENT’S reading, writing, and spelling needs, the program proposed in the November 13 IEP failed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs.
3. December 15, 2000 IEP. The December 15, 2000 IEP contains goals to improve the ability to decode simple-syllable and two-syllable words; read a story and answer comprehension questions; spell; recognize letters and sounds for all of the consonants and vowels in isolation; write a paragraph; write in cursive; and read a passage and answer comprehension questions orally. These goals addressed STUDENT’S reading decoding, reading comprehension, spelling, cursive writing, and writing needs. The IEP provides for ISP; an SDC starting on January 8, 2001, for 60 minutes daily; and DBH counseling for 60 minutes twice monthly.
Teacher Ms. Shaw testified that in her LH SDC there were 10 to 14 students in grades 4 to 6. She had a classroom aide, and one student had his own one-on-one aide. The students were taught in small groups and as a whole class, and she also worked with all students one-to-one while her aide worked with a small group or other students did other work. She used the Project Read reading program which, like LMB, is a multi-sensory program that includes the kinesthetic modality. She testified that she has LMB training and in her class blended LMB with her existing program. She provided to STUDENT solely LMB instruction (Visualizing/Verbalizing and Seeing Stars and also LiPS as needed) one-to-one at his mother’s request. She testified that the LMB program was to assist with the auditory hearing and production of sounds, reading decoding and comprehension, and spelling. The program provided to STUDENT met his phonemic awareness, reading decoding and comprehension, and spelling needs; his need for a multi-sensory program like LMB; and also his need for one-to-one instruction for a portion of the time.
As discussed under Issue 5(a), pragmatics and Tourette’s were areas of suspected disability that were not assessed, and the Hearing Officer found above that Tourette’s was a unique need. Because these areas were not assessed, the District’s proposed program failed to address them and provide necessary services and accommodations.
The Hearing Officer also found above that a transition plan for STUDENT’S return to school was a unique need. Petitioner argues that the modified program the District proposed was inadequate as a transition plan because it failed to involve STUDENT’S therapist and to provide necessary therapeutic interventions and coping strategies to support his return to the regular school setting. The District asserts that it offered an effective plan, as set forth in the December 15, 2000 IEP. The December IEP provides for a modified program of one hour of SDC daily with the IEP team meeting periodically to assess and monitor the program and placement. In January 2001, STUDENT started and then continued with one hour of SDC instruction through the end of the school year.
Independent psychologist Dr. Tibbetts testified that there should be a written transition plan with clear guidelines as to when to move to the next step. He testified that the IEP team should create the plan based upon STUDENT’S mental health goals, the amount or lack of motivation to return, and the degree of anxiety, and that his counselor should be part of the team. STUDENT’S current private therapist, Dr. Fine, testified that STUDENT’S social-emotional problems will not just go away, and his successful return to school requires a good psycho-social transition plan which includes coaching in school; social monitoring, particularly during recess; adaptations and accommodations to address his needs; and staff, including teachers, who can work with a boy with behavioral traits (such as impoliteness and intrusiveness) that can make people uncomfortable. He also requires staff who understand that what may appear to be a lack of motivation could be an executive functioning problem (i.e., difficulty organizing effectively).
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s modified program composed solely of a reduced schedule, with periodic monitoring, was inadequate and that an effective transition plan must be created with the involvement of STUDENT’S counselor, whether Dr. Fine or his DBH therapist, and must address STUDENT’S social-emotional needs and provide a support system for him at school, with coaching, social monitoring, and on-site behavioral interventions and counseling, as appropriate. The plan necessarily requires informed and understanding staff coordinating and overseeing his return to school. Because the District’s plan did not address his social-emotional and behavioral needs, it was inappropriate.
(b) AB3632 Therapy. Petitioner argues that the AB3632 therapy failed to address his needs related to Tourette’s and school-related issues, including a transition plan for his return to school. First, the discussion above under Issue 5(a) regarding Tourette’s applies here. As stated there, no assessment of this area was done to determine how Tourette’s affects STUDENT’S behavior; thus the therapy failed to address this unique need. Regarding school-related issues, including a transition plan for STUDENT’S return to school, his DBH therapist Dr. DeChenne testified that a proper focus of AB3632 therapy is social-emotional issues that interfere with academic performance. She testified that self-esteem is tied to reading ability and that STUDENT’S mother was very concerned about his reading skills, but Dr. DeChenne acknowledged that she did not know the academic area affected by STUDENT’S learning disability. She also testified that getting him back to school was not a focus of the therapy because he was being home-schooled at the time. She testified that although the mother reported his frustration with school, he himself did not express frustration or anxiety about going to school but said that he did not want to go to school because it was boring. Dr. DeChenne opined that he did not like schoolwork and the structure of school because play was more fun. She did acknowledge, however, that STUDENT expressed frustration about not getting his way. The chart notes indicate that Dr. DeChenne did broach the subject of school, including his new school setting and learning something new that he did not understand, and he did on occasion tell her about his academic progress as well as his dislike of studying and learning. However, the evidence is that the therapy did not focus on school-related issues and address STUDENT’S attitude toward school and learning and his emotional issues stemming from his academic deficiencies.
Moreover, because Dr. DeChenne did not attend the November and December 2000 IEP meetings, she was not part of the IEP team that discussed his return to school. As discussed below, the Hearing Officer found that the failure to include STUDENT’S therapist as part of the IEP team resulted in denying STUDENT a FAPE. If she had been part of the IEP team, as a psychologist she would have had the knowledge and expertise to assist with devising a plan with the necessary steps and support services to facilitate STUDENT’S return to school. Dr. Tibbetts testified that an effective transition plan must be based upon STUDENT’S mental health needs, lack of motivation, and degree of anxiety, and that his counselor should be part of the IEP team. The Hearing Officer found above that an effective transition plan required that STUDENT’S counselor be involved and that his social-emotional and behavioral needs be addressed. Because the therapy did not address STUDENT’S school-related emotional problems, it failed to meet his need for an effective transition from the ISP back to the school setting.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Determining whether a program is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit requires a review of various measures, including, among other things, standardized test scores, teacher and staff observations, ratings on course work and tests, grade advancement, and progress on annual goals and short-term objectives. Petitioner contends that his academic program and therapy failed to bestow educational benefit. The District asserts that STUDENT’S progress is reflected in his increase in grade-level ISP work and SAT-9 test results.
(a) Academic Program. In October 2001, STUDENT achieved a WJ-III Broad Reading standard score (SS) of 78, compared to a WJ-R 67 SS in October 2000. The 78 SS appears to be consistent with prior WJ-R Broad Reading standard scores of 77 and 80 in April 1999 and December 1999, respectively. The report of STUDENT’S SDC teacher Ms. Shaw, who administered the WJ-III, states that his knowledge of phoneme-grapheme relationships was low. (Pet. Exh. RRR.) Also in October 2001, he obtained a 75 KTEA Reading SS, which can be compared with a 79 June 2000 score. Dr. Tibbetts testified that obtaining the same standard score year to year indicates, at a minimum, year-to-year growth, although a 4-point decrease is in the gray area of the possibility of an actual decline.
Ms. Shaw testified that by May 2001, STUDENT showed a significant increase in the sight words he could read, and in the LMB Seeing Stars program, he showed growth in the kinds of words he could deal with. He also showed improvement in an informal phonics assessment. In April 2001, he obtained Word Attack standard and GE scores of 86 and 2.8 on the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test, compared to WJ-R Word Attack standard and GE scores of 85 and 2.1 in December 1999, 15 months earlier. He obtained a total LAC score of 88 in October 2001, compared to 76 in October 2000. STUDENT was receiving SDC instruction in the LMB program with an emphasis on decoding and phonemic awareness, but was also receiving LMB services at Stowell. Thus, both programs likely contributed to his progress in these areas.
In October 2001, STUDENT obtained a 66 WJ-III SS for Broad Written Language, compared to a 53 WJ-R Broad Written Language SS a year earlier. Ms. Shaw’s WJ-III assessment report states that his performance was low in written expression and very low in basic writing skills. She testified that STUDENT needed more special education services than one hour daily so that he could be taught a variety of programs. She testified that STUDENT did writing activities in the ISP, and she did some work on writing with him, but the focus of the one hour daily in her SDC was the LMB instruction. Thus, his low writing score cannot be attributed primarily, if at all, to the SDC program but likely is due to a lack of consistent special education writing instruction. In April 2001, his Wide Range of Achievement Test, Revised-3 Spelling standard and GE scores were 75 and 2.0. In October 2001, he had a KTEA Spelling SS of 72 (compared to a 73 in June 2000). Spelling continued to be an area of concern.
STUDENT’S 2001 SAT-9 GE scores when he was in grade 5.8, compared to his 2000 scores when he was in grade 4.8 (in parentheses), are as follows: Total Reading, 3.3 (2.0); Reading Vocabulary, 3.8 (2.0); Reading Comprehension, 3.0 (2.2); and Spelling, 2.7 (2.9).
Thus, STUDENT showed steady progress in reading, including reading decoding, and in phonemic awareness. Both the SDC and Stowell services likely contributed to his progress in these areas. However, he continued to have a spelling and writing problem. Given STUDENT’S limited amount of time in the SDC of 5 hours weekly, the Hearing Officer finds that the SDC program that he was provided from January 2001 to the end of the school year was reasonably calculated to and did bestow some benefit on him.
(b) AB3632 Therapy. The testimony of therapist Dr. DeChenne and the documentary evidence establish that during this school year, STUDENT underwent a change from being generally sarcastic and oppositional and engaging in baby talk in therapy to being able to discuss his argumentative behavior and yelling. However, the evidence was that he still needed to work on responding to instructions without argument, managing his anger, and reducing his negative behavior. The mother testified that in May 2001, STUDENT had been receiving therapy from DBH, but his behavioral problems had not decreased. STUDENT’S therapist, Dr. DeChenne, acknowledged that the same goal (to improve frustration tolerance, self-esteem, and anger management) developed in December 2000 was continued for another 6 months in June 2001. (DBH Exhs. F-1, J-1.) Moreover, because, as discussed above, the therapy did not address STUDENT’S needs related to Tourette’s and school-related emotional issues, he failed to make progress in these areas. The therapy thus conferred minimal benefit.
In conclusion, during approximately the first half of the 2000-2001 school year, the evidence did not establish that the District offered STUDENT an appropriate educational program. During the second half of the school year, the District offered a program that met some of STUDENT’S unique needs and bestowed some educational benefit. However, it did not meet his unique needs related to pragmatics, Tourette’s, and an appropriate transition plan to assist his return to school. Further, during this school year the AB3632 therapy notably failed to meet his need regarding school-related social-emotional issues, conferred minimal benefit, and was thus inappropriate. All in all, during this school year STUDENT was substantially denied a FAPE.
B. Compliance with Procedural Safeguards
First, Petitioner argues that the December 15, 2000 IEP team improperly failed to include a DBH representative, although it was important to have STUDENT’S therapist involved in planning his return to the regular school setting from the ISP. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that the District’s transition plan for STUDENT’S return to school was inappropriate in failing to address his social-emotional and behavioral needs and that his counselor or therapist must be an integral part of the IEP team that fashions an effective plan, as set forth above.
When appropriate, the IEP team shall include individuals who possess expertise or knowledge necessary for the development of the IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(c)(2). In this case, as discussed above, STUDENT’S therapist would have had expertise and knowledge necessary to develop a transition plan that would address his social-emotional needs in a school setting. Thus, the failure to include his therapist as part of the IEP team at the December 2000 IEP meeting that discussed his return to school in an SDC resulted in lost educational opportunity. Because the therapist was not included, a plan addressing his social-emotional and behavioral needs, with the therapist’s expertise, was not devised. His initial program of one hour of SDC instruction daily was never increased beyond recess and some time for vision activities twice a week. Moreover, when an incident occurred involving two boys who allegedly beat him up, no on-site support system was in place to assist him to deal with this type of incident. According to the mother’s undisputed testimony, STUDENT was disciplined along with the two boys because he threatened to get a gun and shoot them, but there is no evidence of any on-site support services to assist him to deal with peer relation problems at school. According to the mother, the incident had a traumatic effect on him, and was a major setback for his return to school. From the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the failure to include STUDENT’S therapist as part of the IEP team when the therapist would have had expertise and knowledge necessary to develop his IEP, including an effective transition plan to support his return to school, resulted in denial of a FAPE.
Next, Petitioner requests reimbursement for the Pasadena LMB program during summer 2001 for 12 weeks. He may be entitled to reimbursement if he was denied a FAPE during this period and the Pasadena LMB program was appropriate, as discussed below. The question is whether he was denied a FAPE to be entitled to reimbursement for the summer program. The May 2001 IEP indicates that an altercation involving two boys, which caused STUDENT to say that he did not want to return to school, was a major setback. According to the IEP, the parent requested an intensive LMB summer program to build his self-esteem and academic skills, and the SELPA offered counseling and behavior modification interventions to counter the effects of the incident. The parent gave notice orally at the meeting, as reflected in the IEP, and by a letter that she was planning to enroll STUDENT in the LMB program in Pasadena and seek reimbursement. However, the May IEP does not directly address the parent’s request for an intensive summer LMB program.
As discussed above under Issues 1(a) and 3(b), federal law requires the District to provide to the parents prior written notice of its refusal to change the educational placement of a child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). The notice must include, among other things, an explanation for the refusal; other options considered and rejected and the reasons; and each test, record, or report used as a basis for the refusal. Here, there is no evidence of the District’s prior written notice of its refusal to provide the requested LMB program that meets the IDEA’s requirements. Although the IEP indicates that the SELPA offered counseling and behavioral modification services, there is no explanation for the District’s refusal to provide the requested summer LMB program, including the basis for the refusal. The failure to provide prior written notice in accordance with the statutory requirements resulted in seriously infringing upon the parent’s opportunity to participate meaningfully in the IEP process. Although the District had offered a summer school SDC and LMB tutoring during prior summers, no options other than counseling and behavior modification were offered, and there apparently was no open communication about proposed options, including reasons for their rejection. Thus, the result was also a loss of educational opportunity. The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner was thereby denied a FAPE.
(c) 2001-2002 School Year: Grade 6
During the 2001-2002 school year, when STUDENT was in grade 6, he continued in the ISP and received AB3632 individual therapy for part of the year and group therapy throughout the year. The District continued to offer an SDC placement, but instead of attending the SDC, he received private LMB services from Stowell. He also received counseling from a private therapist. He contends that he was denied a FAPE on both substantive and procedural grounds. The District and DBH assert that they have provided a FAPE.
A. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
To determine whether STUDENT was offered a FAPE, it is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet his unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit, and (3) was in conformity with his IEP. Petitioner argues that he was denied a FAPE in that the District and DBH failed to identify and address all of his unique needs, specifically, Tourette’s, pragmatics, a peer-relation problem, and an appropriate transition plan to assist his return to the regular school setting; failed to provide appropriate AB3632 therapy; and failed to provide a program that conferred educational benefit.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
The first step in determining whether STUDENT was offered a program designed to meet his unique needs is to identify his needs. There was little disagreement about most of his needs, established by the academic, psychoeducational, and speech and language assessments and IEPs up through the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT continued to have reading decoding, reading comprehension, spelling, and writing deficiencies, including weak mechanics skills. He continued to have processing deficits in visual sequential memory and attention and to have a problem with phonemic awareness. Low WISC-III abstract verbal reasoning and vocabulary subtest scores indicated that language was still an area of concern. He continued to have low frustration tolerance and anger management problems. Behavioral rating scale responses indicated concerns about somatic complaints, attention, rule-breaking behavior, and problems of an aggressive nature. In therapy, at times he still exhibited sarcasm or negative behavior. He continued to have a fine-motor problem and handwriting difficulty. He continued to take medications for ADHD, anxiety, and Tourette’s and still had filtered glasses for light sensitivity.
In addition to these agreed-upon needs, the Hearing Officer found under Issue 5(a) above that Tourette’s was a unique need, but during this school year it still was not assessed or identified as such. Although pragmatics was an area of suspected disability, it was not assessed until February 2002. The assessment found deficits in pragmatics and expressive language qualifying STUDENT for speech therapy, but no IEP meeting was held to address this area of need.
An area of disagreement was whether STUDENT had a peer-relation problem. Although the District attempted to portray him as having no such a problem, the evidence is to the contrary. In her psychoeducational assessment report, school psychologist Ms. Prish stated that STUDENT’S own responses on the behavior rating scale fell in the normal range except for the Social Problems profile. The testimony of his grade 5 SDC teacher Ms. Shaw indicated that although the other children in the class seemed to like him, he did not interact with them. She testified that when he later stayed for recess and lined up with the other children, he would “interact” by turning around to see what the others were doing. Thus, self-initiated engagement in peer interactions appeared to be minimal. Private therapist Dr. Fine testified that STUDENT thought that the other boys in Boy Scouts picked on him. Speech pathologist Ms. Jacobson, who assessed him in February 2002 and diagnosed a pragmatics (social use of language) problem qualifying him for speech therapy, testified that he told her that he had no friends. The Hearing Officer found the testimony of Ms. Jacobson to be credible. Independent psychologist Dr. Tibbetts testified that the psychological aspect of a pragmatics problems is a social skills deficit that results in having difficulty in most types of social interactions and with problem resolution with peers. From the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that a peer-relation problem was a unique need.
Due to these deficit areas, STUDENT had these agreed-upon instructional needs. He needed educational services to address his reading, writing, and spelling deficiencies. He required individual and group therapy. He required small-group and some one-to-one instruction. He required a multi-sensory program like LMB that includes kinesthetics. He also required classroom modifications such as seating close to the teacher for interventions and lessons being broken down and structured. Moreover, it was found above that an appropriate transition plan to support STUDENT’S return to the school setting, as discussed under Issue 5(b), was an instructional need. If an IEP meeting had been held to address the February 2002 speech and language assessment recommendation of speech therapy for pragmatics and expressive language, such therapy would have been identified as an instructional need during this school year.
(a) IEPs. The next step is to examine the IEP to determine whether the proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs. At the start of the school year, the December 15, 2000 IEP, with the agreed-upon goals and objectives, remained in effect. The discussion above under Issue 5(b) regarding the goals and objectives and program offered in this IEP apply here. On December 2, 2001, another IEP, unsigned by the parent, was developed. The December 2 IEP contains goals to be able to read words with vowel digraphs and diphthongs and with soft “c” and “g” sounds; be able to read a list of 1000 sight words; have an overall 6.5 GE reading level on the WJ-III; be able to develop a 6-section story board with a descriptive sentence for each section; wear prescribed eyeglasses when doing close schoolwork; and develop symbol imagery skills and be able to write and spell two-syllable words. These goals address STUDENT’S reading, writing, spelling, and light sensitivity needs.
The December 2 IEP provides for the following program and services: ISP, an SDC (with small-group and one-to-one instruction) for up to 310 minutes 5 times weekly, and DBH small-group counseling for 4 times a month. STUDENT’S grade 5 SDC teacher Ms. Shawtestified that in fall 2001 she had expected him to return and had wanted him to increase the amount of time in her class. According to her, a full day is about 5 hours of instruction, and some of her students go to regular education classes for science, math, and social studies, or to RSP if making a transition. She testified that in her class of 10 to 14 students, all had visual processing problems and about half had language processing problems. She testified that she had a classroom aide and that the students were taught in small groups or as a whole class and that all of her students received some one-to-one instruction. Ms. Shaw used the Project Read reading program, a multi-sensory program involving the kinesthetic sense, and she blended LMB with this program. She testified that she worked on writing, using a story board pre-writing activity, and spelling. The program offered in Ms. Shaw’s SDC was designed to meet STUDENT’S reading decoding and comprehension, spelling, and writing needs; his need for a multi-sensory program including kinesthetics; and his need for small-group and some one-to-one instruction.
Petitioner argues that the District and DBH again failed to offer a transition plan that addressed his social-emotional and behavioral needs. As in the prior school year, during the 2001-2002 school year, the District failed to offer an appropriate transition plan that involved STUDENT’S counselor and addressed these needs. The discussion above under Issue 5(b) regarding the inadequacy of the District’s proffered plan applies here. Moreover, because the IEP team did not convene to review the February 2002 assessment recommendation of speech therapy, the District failed to offer speech therapy to address STUDENT’S pragmatics and expressive language needs identified by the assessment. The program also failed to offer accommodations and services to address his Tourette’s.
(b) AB3632 Therapy. Throughout this school year, STUDENT received group therapy from DBH. As Petitioner acknowledges and DBH group therapist Dr. Alvarez’s testimony confirmed, group therapy addressed social skills and peer-relationship issues. The DBH group therapy addressed STUDENT’S need regarding peer-relation problems. However, Petitioner again asserts that the DBH therapy failed to address his Tourette’s and school-related social-emotional issues. The discussion above under Issue 5(b) applies here. Because Tourette’s was not assessed, the therapy did not address this unique need. Further, until STUDENT’S individual therapist Dr. DeChenne left DBH in November 2001 and STUDENT ceased receiving individual therapy from DBH, the focus of individual therapy did not change from the prior year and failed to address school-related social-emotional issues to support his return to school. Thus, the therapy offered during this school year substantially failed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Determining whether a program is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit requires a review of various measures, including, among other things, standardized test scores, teacher and staff observations, ratings on course work and tests, grade advancement, and progress on annual goals and short-term objectives. Petitioner contends that his academic program and therapy were not reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit.
(a) Academic Program. Because STUDENT did not receive special education instructional services from the District during this school year, no measures of his progress in the SDC during this school year exist. However, during grade 5, he attended, for about 5 months, the same SDC proposed for his grade 6 year. (Teacher Ms. Shaw had testified that fourth- to sixth-grade students were in her SDC.) During his grade 5 year, he spent one hour daily in the SDC, and the amount of time offered to him for his grade 6 year was up to a full instructional day of about 5 hours. As discussed above, he required an effective written transition plan to support his eventual full-time return to a school setting from the ISP, and the District failed to offer such a plan during his sixth-grade year. But even with one hour of one-to-one SDC instruction in the LMB program during his grade 5 year, along with Stowell LMB services and ISP instruction, he had shown progress in reading decoding and comprehension and in phonemic awareness. In her SDC, Ms. Shaw used the Project Read multi-sensory reading program in addition to LMB strategies, and with increased class time, STUDENT could have worked on this program also. At the end of his grade 5 year, he still revealed deficits in writing and spelling, and with increased SDC time beyond one hour daily to work in these areas, he may have shown progress in these two areas as well. Based upon STUDENT’S progress during just one hour in the SDC during his grade 5 year, the program was reasonably calculated to confer some educational benefit. However, his ability to increase the amount of SDC time was hampered by the lack of an effective, supportive transition plan that addressed his social-emotional and behavioral needs, as discussed above.
(b) AB3632 Therapy. When STUDENT’S individual therapist Dr. DeChenne left DBH in November 2001, he no longer received individual therapy from DBH. However, according to the testimony of STUDENT’S group therapist Dr. Alvarez and the documentary evidence, he showed progress in his group therapy during the past year. Dr. Alvarez testified that a purpose of group therapy is to build social skills. Initially, he did not want to talk or participate in the group discussion, made ridiculous comments, and did not give helpful feedback to the other group members. Recently, however, he had been able to participate and give good feedback to the others. Recently he also had no problem following instructions in the group therapy session and reported having no problem arguing with adults during the past week (a therapy goal for him). The evidence is that group therapy was reasonably calculated to bestow some benefit on STUDENT.
In conclusion, the District and DBH offered a program that was designed to meet some of STUDENT’S unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide some benefit. However, because the program lacked an effective transition plan to support his return to school, it failed to meet essential needs and thus had severely limited benefit. In addition, the program failed to meet his needs with respect to pragmatics and Tourette’s, and the individual therapy provided through November 2001 failed to address his need regarding school-related emotional issues. From the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was substantially denied a FAPE.
B. Compliance with Procedural Safeguards
Petitioner contends that after the February 26, 2002 speech and language assessment was completed, the District failed to give his parents a copy of the assessment report in response to their request and failed to convene an IEP meeting to review the assessment results. A procedural right guaranteed to parents of a child with a disability under the IDEA is the right “to examine all records relating to such child . . .” 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1). Under State law, the parent has the right to examine and to receive copies of all school records within 5 days of an oral or written request. Cal. Educ. Code § 56504.
District speech pathologist Ms. Jacobson, who assessed STUDENT in February 2002, testified that she finished her assessment report on February 26 or 28. According to her, during the testing, the mother had requested a copy of her report, but her superior, special education director Mr. Kirkland, told her to wait to give a copy to the parent. On May 13, 2002, Petitioner filed a motion to admit into evidence Ms. Jacobson’s speech and language assessment report, and the motion was granted. Attached to the motion was a March 25, 2002 letter from the mother to Ms. Jacobson requesting a copy of the speech and language assessment report. Another attachment was a declaration by the mother stating that she did not receive a copy of the report until the May 10, 2002 hearing day. The District does not dispute that the parent requested a copy of the assessment or that she did not receive a copy until May 10 and has tendered no explanation for the failure to timely comply with her request.
In her February 26 assessment report, Ms. Jacobson concluded that STUDENT had deficits in pragmatics and expressive language and that he qualified for speech therapy and recommended speech therapy to address these deficit areas. Thus, this is a situation where the District had information in its records which, if disclosed, would have re-qualified STUDENT for speech and language services and thus resulted in the provision of speech therapy to address his severe pragmatics deficit and expressive language need. Because the assessment report was not provided to the parents, they were denied the right to participate meaningfully in the IEP process. Significantly, this procedural violation resulted in the loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT. When the hearing concluded in late June, no evidence was presented that an IEP meeting had been held to review the assessment results, and he was thus still not receiving speech therapy four months after completion of the assessment report. The District’s failure to disclose the assessment report to STUDENT’S parents in violation of both federal and State law denied him a FAPE from approximately March 1, 2002, to the end of the school year. See Amanda J. v. Clark County School Dist., 267 F.3d 877, 891 (9th Cir. 2001) (finding a denial of FAPE under the IDEA where the District failed to timely disclose the student’s educational records, specifically, assessments indicating possible autism and suggesting further psychiatric assessment).
ISSUE 6: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including the cost of transportation, of educational or counseling services from the following : a. Stowell Learning Center?
b. Lindamood-Bell?
c. Paul Boccumini, Ph.D.?
d. Aubrey Fine, Ph.D.?
When a school district has denied a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to appropriate relief in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for services that they obtained for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate program and services, and the program or services obtained by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. The Hearing Officer found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for approximately 2 months during the 1996-1997 school year, in June 1998, and during the 1998-1999 school year. Further, the District and DBH denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year and substantially denied him a FAPE during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years.
Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the costs of educational services his parents incurred at Stowell Learning Center from approximately the middle of his third-grade (1998-1999) year through 2001 and at the LMB clinic in Pasadena for 12 weeks during summer 2001. (Pet. Exh. MMM; Testimony of MOTHER.) He also seeks reimbursement for the costs of counseling services from Dr. Boccumini during the 1998-1999 school year and from Dr. Fine from November 2001 to the present. (Pet. Exh. MMM; Testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Fine.)
(a) Stowell Learning Center. The District contends, in effect, that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the period before the parent gave the requisite 10 days’ notice in September 2000 of the intent to seek reimbursement for the cost of services at Stowell. The amount of reimbursement for a private school placement may be reduced or denied if, either at least 10 business days prior to removing the child from the public school, or at the most recent IEP meeting that the parents attended prior to removing their child from the public school, the parents did not inform the District that they were rejecting the District’s proposed placement, including stating their concerns and their intent to enroll their child in a private school at public expense. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii)(I); Cal. Educ. Code § 56176(a), (b). However, the amount of reimbursement may not be reduced or denied for failure to so notify the District if the parent was not notified of the reimbursement notice requirement. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iv)(IV). Although evidence was presented that the parent was given a copy of the procedural safeguards at the IEP meetings, no evidence was presented that the document contained notice of the reimbursement notice requirement pursuant to federal law. Thus, any failure to give timely notice of the intent to seek reimbursement for the unilateral placement at Stowell should not preclude reimbursement if otherwise appropriate.
The documentary evidence and testimony of the mother establish that STUDENT received LMB and other services at Stowell for 6 hours weekly from 1998 through at least 2001 (E.g., Pet. Exhs. M, V, YY, EEE, MMM; Dist. Exhs. 4, 25, 28.) At Stowell, he received educational therapy to address his attention, reading, listening, written expression, and spelling problems, and an April 1999 Stowell progress report indicated improvement in most of these areas. (Pet. Exhs. M, V; Testimony of MOTHER.) The 1999 report identified a serious phonemic awareness deficit and noted that STUDENT could decode simple-syllable level words most of the time but that he needed to continue working on complex-syllable level words. Because it was difficult for him to picture words due to his inefficient auditory memory, it also recommended that he continue with the LMB Seeing Stars program to teach him to make visual images of words to assist with spelling. A January 2001 progress report indicated that he continued to work on phonemic awareness, specifically, automatic recognition of vowel sounds in isolation and in context for reading and spelling. His decoding skills had improved and he was working on mastering words consisting of up to 4 sounds.
During part of the time that he was receiving Stowell services, STUDENT also received RSP or SDC instruction. As discussed above under Issues 3(c), 5(a), and 5(b), the Hearing Officer determined that any progress shown in work attack and phonemic awareness skills during STUDENT’S third- and fourth-grade years likely were due to the Stowell services since the RSP Read Naturally reading program did not address these areas directly. During his fifth-grade year, he received LMB services for 5 hours weekly in an SDC for approximately one-half year starting in January 2001, and even during this year, part of his progress in these areas was likely due to his Stowell services. The evidence establishes that the Stowell program addressed STUDENT’S needs in reading decoding, spelling, and phonemic awareness, and he did show some progress. Thus, it was appropriate, and the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of Stowell educational services, including the cost of transportation, during the regular school year, excluding the summer, for the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years. The District is solely responsible for the entire cost.
(b) Lindamood-Bell. Petitioner requests reimbursement for the cost of LMB services that STUDENT received at the LMB clinic in Pasadena for 12 weeks during summer 2001. As discussed above under Issue 5(b), the Hearing Officer found the denial of a FAPE stemming from the District’s failure to provide prior written notice of its refusal of the mother’s request for such services, which request was documented in the May 31, 2001 IEP. Thus, the Hearing Officer determines that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the summer 2001 LMB program if appropriate. A June 2001 progress report from the Pasadena LMB clinic indicates that STUDENT had shown progress in phonemic awareness and reading in context. An August 2001 LMB report compares STUDENT’S test scores between April and August 2001. Upon examining the scores, independent psychologist Dr.Tibbetts testified that STUDENT showed improvement in almost all the tests. Notably, he showed improvement in word attack skills, reading accuracy, and reading comprehension. The evidence establishes that the LMB program addressed his needs in phonemic awareness, reading decoding, and reading comprehension, and he showed growth in his areas of reading need. Thus, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs, including the cost of transportation, of the LMB program in Pasadena during summer 2001, from June 2001 through August 2001. The District has sole responsibility for the cost.
(c) Paul Boccumini, Ph.D. The mother testified that Dr. Boccumini came to their home during most of STUDENT’S grade 3 year to deal with his fire-setting behavior, which had started in grade 1. According to the mother, there were about 4 or 5 such incidents, with the most recent in grade 4. She testified that Dr. Boccumini recommended a change in diet and other medications besides Ritalin. She seeks reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Boccumini’s counseling services. However, as discussed above under Issue 2(c), during STUDENT’S grade 3 year, the evidence did not establish that the District had notice that this was an area of suspected disability that needed to be assessed and addressed. Moreover, Dr. Boccumini did not testify, and the nature of the services he provided is not clear. Thus, the evidence does not establish that the parents are entitled to reimbursement for this cost.
(d) Aubrey Fine, Ph.D. Dr. DeChenne, STUDENT’S DBH therapist who provided him individual therapy, left DBH in November 2001. According to her, STUDENT was to be transferred to another DBH therapist, but he started therapy with a private therapist instead. STUDENT started individual therapy with Dr. Fine in November 2001, and his parents seek reimbursement for the cost of his counseling services. The Hearing Officer found that during the 2000-2001 school year, the AB3632 individual therapy was inappropriate, and this same therapy continued through November 2001, when Dr. DeChenne left DBH. Thus, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of individual therapy he obtained from Dr. Fine if otherwise appropriate.
First, the individual therapy STUDENT received from Dr. Fine met his need for such therapy. Dr. Fine testified that he did not do a diagnostic work-up but testified about some of the effects of STUDENT’S diagnoses (learning disability, ADHD, and Tourette’s) on his behavior, including his impulsivity and social difficulties. He testified that the thrust of the therapy was for STUDENT to address his social difficulties and learn cooperative strategies and ways to get along with family members and others. Dr. Fine testified that he had talked to both STUDENT and his mother about the need for STUDENT to return to school and face both the challenge of being with peers and the rigidity of a traditional day school program and that STUDENT needed to learn to become a cooperative learner. Thus, the therapy with Dr. Fine addressed STUDENT’S needs related to his diagnoses, social-relation difficulties, and return to school. Dr. Fine also testified that STUDENT was very receptive to therapy, responded relatively well, and at a recent social gathering of children showed some awkwardness but behaved very well. Thus, the evidence is that STUDENT has derived benefit from his therapy. Moreover, because of his multi-faceted disabilities, the Hearing Officer finds that he required consistent therapy that continued beyond the regular school year. The Hearing Officer finds that appropriate relief is reimbursement for the costs, including the cost of transportation, of individual therapy provided to STUDENT by Dr. Fine from November 1, 2001, to the date of this Decision. The District and DBH shall be jointly and severally responsible for these costs.
ISSUE 7: If Petitioner was denied a FAPE during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years, is he entitled to the following as compensatory education services:
a. Lindamood-Bell?
b. Individual counseling from Aubrey Fine, Ph.D.?
c. Parent counseling and training?
The Hearing Officer found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for about 2 months during the 1996-1997 school year, in June 1998, and during the 1998-1999 school year, and the District and DBH denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year and substantially denied him a FAPE during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years. Therefore, he is entitled to appropriate relief. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i); Burlington, 471 U.S. at 369. Compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. at 1497. Equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; Student W., 31 F.3d at 1496.
Petitioner requests as compensatory education an intensive program of additional LMB services provided at an LMB clinic or similar setting and 2 years of counseling with Dr. Fine, his current private therapist. The Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT was entitled to reimbursement for the cost of 6 hours weekly of Stowell educational services during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years. The Hearing Officer also found him entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the 12-week LMB program in Pasadena during summer 2001. The Hearing Officer further determined that STUDENT was entitled to reimbursement for the cost of individual therapy from Dr. Fine from November 2001 to the date of this Decision. However, he is also entitled to appropriate relief for the denial of a FAPE for about 2 months during 1996-1997 and in June 1998 and for the substantial denial of a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year. Because of the denial of a FAPE, STUDENT has continued deficiencies in reading, writing, and spelling, and also continuing language deficits, specifically, in pragmatics and expressive language. Because the District and DBH have not addressed his social-emotional and behavioral problems to provide for his return to a school setting, he continues to have social-relation and behavioral problems that impede his learning. The Hearing Officer finds that he is entitled to compensatory education for lost educational services.
Independent psychologist Dr. Tibbetts testified that the combination of an SLD and ADHD is more difficult to remediate, and STUDENT has emotional issues in addition to academic deficiencies. Moreover, because traditional methods have not been effective, he requires an enriched, intensive multi-modal approach, including the kinesthetic modality, to give him a “jump start” and increase his opportunity to learn to read. Dr. Tibbetts recommended LMB as an effective approach with a child like STUDENT. In reviewing STUDENT’S test results over a 4-month period of an intense (4 hours per day for 5 days a week) LMB program, Dr. Tibbetts testified that STUDENT showed improvement in almost all the test areas. To address the denial of a FAPE and provide STUDENT the enriched program he requires, the Hearing Officer finds that appropriate relief would be an intensive (4 hours a day for 5 days a week) LMB program for a period of 12 weeks at an LMB clinic or similar setting to address his needs in phonemic awareness, spelling, and reading decoding and comprehension. This program would complement and support the speech therapy in pragmatics and expressive language that he requires. The LMB program shall begin within 5 days of the IEP meeting called for in Item 5 of the Hearing Officer’s Order. Because it would be desirable for STUDENT to start a transition to the regular school setting, with an appropriate supportive plan in place, it is suggested that, if possible, he attend at least an hour of a special education class, as determined by the IEP team, while he attends the LMB program.
As for the request for Dr. Fine’s counseling services as compensatory education, State regulations provide that mental health services, including psychotherapy, “shall be provided directly or by contract at the discretion of the community mental health service.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60020(i). Further, a hearing officer may not render a decision that results in service to a child with a disability provided by an NPA that has not been certified by the State. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.2. Upon therapist Dr. DeChenne’s departure from DBH, STUDENT had the opportunity to receive individual therapy from a different DBH therapist but began private therapy with Dr. Fine instead. (See Testimony of Dr. DeChenne.) However, Dr. Fine’s testimony established that he is not a State-certified NPA. Therefore, the statute prohibits the Hearing Officer from awarding to STUDENT prospective counseling services from Dr. Fine. The request for prospective services from Dr. Fine as compensatory services is thus denied. However, since STUDENT has established a working therapeutic relationship with Dr. Fine, DBH may wish to consider contracting for his services. Petitioner has also requested parent training, as recommended by Dr.Tibbetts, to assist the parents to work with a child like STUDENT and mediate his learning pursuant to a program such as the mediated learning format. 34 C.F.R. § 300.24(b)(7); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3051.11. The Hearing Officer finds that such training would be appropriate compensatory services to enable the parents to help STUDENT with his learning and academic work. The parent training shall commence within 10 days of the date of the IEP meeting called for in Item 5 of the Order below. The IEP team shall determine the appropriate nature, amount, and frequency of such training and the appropriate credentials for the trainer.
ORDER
1. (a) Within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the cost of the educational services he received at Stowell Learning Center during the regular school year, excluding the summer, for the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for this cost.
(b) Within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the number of sessions he attended at Stowell during the above time periods and the round trip mileage for these sessions. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for transportation mileage for these sessions at the rate the District reimburses its employees. The District shall have sole responsibility for the costs associated with Stowell.
2. (a) Within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the cost of the educational services he received at the Lindamood-Bell clinic in Pasadena from June 2001 through August 2001. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for this cost.
(b) Within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the number of sessions he attended at the LMB clinic in Pasadena from June 2001 through August 2001 and the round trip mileage for these sessions. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for transportation mileage for these sessions at the rate the District reimburses its employees. The District shall have sole responsibility for the costs associated with the LMB program.
3. (a) Within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District and DBH proof of the cost of the individual therapy he received from Dr. Fine from November 1, 2001 to the date of this Decision. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District and DBH shall reimburse Petitioner for this cost.
(b) Within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District and DBH proof of the number of sessions he had with Dr. Fine from November 1, 2001 to the date of this Decision and the round trip mileage for these sessions. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District and DBH shall reimburse Petitioner for transportation mileage for these sessions at the rate the District reimburses its employees. The District and DBH shall be jointly and severally responsible for the costs associated with the therapy from Dr. Fine.
4. Within eighteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall obtain either a formal assessment of STUDENT’S Tourette’s disorder conducted pursuant to the statutes commencing with California Education Code Section 56320 or obtain from STUDENT’S treating physician, Dr. David Comings, a report that addresses this condition, including the effects on his behavior, the side-effects of the combination of his medications, services and accommodations he requires in the classroom and in school because of this condition, and the training school staff, including his teachers, require to understand and deal appropriately with this condition. The assessment results or Dr. Comings’ report shall be reviewed at the IEP meeting called for in Item 5. The District and DBH shall be jointly and severally responsible for the cost of the assessment or the report.
5. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting (which includes a DBH representative and other appropriate resource persons) to accomplish the following:
(a) The IEP team shall review the February 2002 speech and language assessment results and offer an appropriate amount and frequency of speech therapy to address STUDENT’S pragmatic and expressive language needs. Based upon the Tourette’s assessment or Dr. Comings’ report, the IEP team shall also take appropriate measures to address STUDENT’S Tourette’s disorder, including its effects, in his educational program and therapy.
(b) The IEP team shall design an appropriate transitional plan, as discussed above under Issue 5(b), to prepare for and support STUDENT’S gradual return to a full day in the school setting. His therapist, whether Dr. Fine or his current DBH therapist, should be included as part of the IEP team, and the plan shall provide for the necessary supportsystem and services (such as coaching, social monitoring, and on-site counseling and behavioral interventions) to facilitate his return to the school setting and to meet the contingencies that may arise during the school day because of his needs related to his learning disability, ADHD, Tourette’s, and social-emotional and behavioral problems. The plan shall provide for the proper training of school staff, including STUDENT’S teachers, to assist them to understand and deal appropriately with his multi-faceted disabilities.
(c) The IEP team shall arrange for the provision of compensatory education services, as set forth in this Decision. Commencing within five days of the date of the IEP meeting called for in Item 5 of this Order, STUDENT shall be provided compensatory education in the form of an intensive LMB program (of 4 hours a day for 5 days a week) for a period of 12 weeks at an LMB clinic or similar setting. During the time that he attends the LMB program, he should attend, if possible, as the scheduling permits, at least one period of a special education class, as determined by the IEP team. The District shall be solely responsible for the cost of the LMB program.
As compensatory services, STUDENT’S parents shall be entitled to parent training of a nature and in an amount and frequency to be determined by the IEP team, as discussed above. The parent training shall commence within ten days of the date of the IEP meeting called for in Item 5. The IEP team shall determine the appropriate credentials for the trainer. The District and DBH shall be jointly and severally responsible for the cost of the parent training.
6. All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
The District prevailed on this sub-issue except to the extent of the denial of a FAPE for a two-month period: Issue 1(a).
The District prevailed on these sub-issues: Issue 1(b); Issues 2(a) and 2(b); Issue 3(a).
Neither party prevailed on these sub-issues: Issue 2(c); Issue 3(b); Issue 4(c).
Petitioner prevailed on these sub-issues: Issue 3(c); Issue 4(b); Issue 5(a); Issues 6(a), 6(b), and 6(d); Issues 7(a) and 7(c).
Petitioner substantially prevailed on these sub-issues: Issue 4(a); Issues 5(b) and 5(c).
Respondents prevailed on these sub-issues: Issue 6(c); Issue 7(b).
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: September 12, 2002 ____________________________________ Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. On May 20, 2002, the Hearing Officer held a telephone conference in which all parties participated.
2. On the first day of hearing, DBH raised an affirmative defense that if the Hearing Officer found that DBH had failed to provide appropriate mental health services to Petitioner, it should not be held liable because in a September 16, 1999 letter, the mother had rescinded authorization for DBH to release any information about STUDENT or his family without her prior approval, and DBH was thus precluded from communicating with the District. The presiding Hearing Officer noted that this matter was preserved for hearing by a February 13, 2002 order by Hearing Officer Michael Geary addressing DBH’s prehearing motion to be dismissed as a party. In its closing brief, DBH indicated that no evidence was presented that the parent’s withdrawal of consent to disclose confidential information interfered with its ability to provide appropriate counseling services, and thus this matter was not at issue. Nevertheless, DBH stated that if the Hearing Officer made any findings against DBH, it reserved the right to file a rebuttal brief. By not presenting any argument and, in fact, acknowledging that no evidence supports its claim of prejudice from the parent’s rescission of authorization, DBH has conceded that this defense lacks merit. This matter will not be addressed further in this Decision. The parties agreed to submit closing briefs by a specific date but did not agree to submit any reply briefs. Thus, it would be unfair for DBH to have the opportunity belatedly, after issuance of the Decision, to do so.
3. Petitioner set forth his issues in an amended prehearing statement and in his closing brief. On October 18, 2001, and February 14, 2002, Hearing Officer Michael Geary convened the hearing and issued a February 22, 2002 memorandum of hearing orders which clarified the issues for hearing. The presiding Hearing Officer listened to the parts of the hearing audio tapes where the issues were discussed, and at the hearing reviewed and further clarified the issues. The issues have been consolidated, clarified, and presented in a different order to facilitate the analysis.
4. According to STUDENT’S mother, scotopic sensitivity is a sensitivity to light which causes letters to appear to be distorted under fluorescent light and may lead to a line being skipped.
5. Despite references to a “home-school” program in the individualized education programs (IEPs) and reports, it was clarified at the hearing that the program in which STUDENTwas placed by his parents was the District’s regular education Independent Study program, in which the parent provides instruction at home with curriculum materials provided by the District and with oversight by Independent Study teacher and coordinator Ms. Morrison.
6. Assembly Bill (AB) 3632/882, codified at California Government Code §§ 7570-7588 as Chapter 26.5, provided for inter-agency responsibility for furnishing certain related services to children with disabilities. Legislation enacted in 1996 (AB 2726) amended or added provisions of this chapter. In this Decision, the commonly used term “AB 3632" will be used to refer to mental health services under this chapter.
7. OT, adapted physical education, and vision therapy were not raised as issues in this hearing and are not addressed as such in this Decision.
8. At the time that Petitioner filed for due process in this case, Dr. Tibbetts was the West End SELPA’s due process program manager but had left this position when he conducted an independent assessment of STUDENT.
9. Ms. Prish noted that the 24-point discrepancy between the verbal and performance IQ scores had educational significance.
10. When the instant due process hearing concluded on June 27, 2002, an IEP meeting had not yet been convened to review the speech and language assessment results and revise STUDENT’S IEP to offer speech therapy.
11. The IDEA was amended in 1997, and most of the provisions became effective on June 4, 1997. The implementing regulations were amended on March 12, 1999. These amendments were not retroactive. Department of Educ. v. Cari Rae S., 158 F.Supp.2d 1190, 1193 n.1 (D. Hawaii 2001). Except as indicated, only the current versions of federal and State statutes and regulations are cited in this Decision. However, the Hearing Officer will apply the statutes and regulations in effect at the time of the events at issue, in accordance with the general rule against the retroactive application of the law. Landgraf v. USI Film Products, 511 U.S. 244, 265 (1994).
12. Federal law requires the District to provide to parents prior written notice whenever the District, among other things, refuses to initiate an assessment of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3) (formerly 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1)(C)). The notice must include, among other things, a description of the action; an explanation for the refusal to take the requested action; other options considered and rejected and the reasons; each test, record, or report used as a basis for the refusal; and other relevant factors. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(c).
13. Ms. Livoni testified that the reason she recommended a speech and language rescreening in January 1997 rather than a speech and language assessment for special education in September 1996 was that the period before age 7 is a developmental time when a child may “outgrow” speech and language problems. However, the District has cited no authority that a child must be age 7 before qualifying for speech and language services, and Ms. Livoni acknowledged the lack of such a legal requirement.
14. The only special education eligibility categories Petitioner has asserted are SLD and speech and language impairment. An SLD is defined as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26)(A).
15. Petitioner also asserts that in response to his mother’s March 18, 1998 written request, the District conducted an assessment but failed to hold an IEP meeting within the 50-day period required by State law. This matter will be addressed below in the FAPE discussion.
16. The reports and testimony of independent psychologist Dr. Tibbetts and SELPA consultant Ms. Costa, who both assessed STUDENTfor phonemic awareness, indicate that phonemic awareness skills include the identification of the number, order, and position of sounds in words and the ability to integrate, shift, and otherwise manipulate sounds. Speech pathologist Ms. Jacobson, who assessed STUDENTfor pragmatics, testified that pragmatics is the social use of language and involves nonverbal cues such as tone of voice, facial expression, and body language. In his closing brief, Petitioner mentions symbol imagery as an area of suspected disability. However, he did not raise this area in his amended issue statement and proposed resolution or on the February 14, 2002, or March 11, 2002, hearing days when the issues were discussed and clarified. Further, there is scant evidence of this alleged area of suspected disability, including precisely what it entails. Thus, this area will not be addressed.
17. According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th ed. (DSM-IV) (1994), at page 94, disruptive behavior disorder, NOS, is for disorders characterized by conduct or oppositional defiant behaviors that do not meet the criteria for Conduct Disorder or Oppositional Defiant Disorder.
18. Petitioner’s additional contention that the District failed timely to assess was addressed in Issue 1 above.
19. Tourette’s was not specifically identified as an alleged area of suspected disability in the clarification of issues in February and March 2002 but was raised as such in the testimony of the mother, the first witness, and in the questioning of subsequent District and DBH witnesses.
20. A criterion to qualify for the expressive or receptive language disorder category is a score below the 7 percentile on at least one standardized test in certain language areas. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(c)(4). With reference to a TOPS score obtained in LMB testing on another date, Ms. Livoni testified that there was no reason to think that the score was not accurate.
21. The fact that the June 1, 1999 mediation agreement provided for an AB3632 referral and that STUDENTwas found to qualify for AB3632 services does not undercut the above conclusion. The mother testified that the reasons for the AB3632 referral as part of the mediation agreement were STUDENT’S fire-setting behavior
22. Petitioner also asserts that the District failed to address his social-emotional needs by not providing counseling and not making an AB3632 referral and also failed to address his Tourette’s diagnosis. However, as discussed above under Issue 2(c), the Hearing Officer found that during the regular school year, the social-emotional area was not yet an area of suspected disability, and the evidence did not establish that the District had definite knowledge that Tourette’s was an area of suspected disability. Thus, during the 1998-1999 school year, the District did not have an obligation to assess or address these two areas.
23. The District also argues that STUDENTparticipated, without any indication of problems, in District-provided LMB tutoring with Erin Hames during summer 2000, the parent-funded Stowell program of LMB services, and the parent-funded program at the LMB clinic in Pasadena in summer 2001. However, these programs are distinguishable from an RSP class or SDC in that they were all provided solely one-on-one.
24. The District argues that although the school members of the IEP team agreed with the parent’s choice of ISP, it had no reason to know that ISP was unworkable for STUDENTbecause of an intense conflict with his sister, inconsistent parenting, “enmeshment” of the mother and STUDENT, and constant struggles between the two when it came to schoolwork. (Dist. Brief at 21.) According to the District, STUDENT’S outbursts, crying, and defiance when his mother would try to get him to do his homework took place only in the home, not at school, so this information was not known to the IEP team.
25. In the October 5 IEP, the RSP amount was reduced to 30 minutes from the 60 minutes provided for in the June 4 IEP. The reason for the reduction is not clear.
26. The IEP also provides for private tutoring (at Stowell), which was paid for by the parents. However, parent-funded tutoring cannot be considered to be part of the District’s offer of an appropriate educational program.
27. Dr. Tibbetts has bachelor’s and master’s degrees and a Ph.D. in psychology and is licensed as a clinical psychologist and an educational psychologist. He worked at the State Diagnostic Center in Los Angeles for 6-1/2 years and oversaw assessments as lead psychologist. He has had considerable experience in mental health care, assessment, and special education and is currently special education director for another school district. He has had training in the LMB LiPS, Visualizing/Verbalizing, and Seeing Stars programs.
28. Ms. Talbott testified that because STUDENTwas working on his reading program, he did not have much time for Making Words, a spelling program in which the student manipulates letter tiles.
29. Ms. Talbott has a bachelor’s degree with a major in elementary education and a minor in special education, a master’s in education, learning handicapped and severely handicapped credentials, and an RSP certificate. She has worked for the District for 20 years as a classroom teacher and resource specialist. She has taken course work and has received in-service training in teaching reading. Ten years ago, she received training in the auditory discrimination in-depth (ADD) program, a precursor to the current LMB LiPS program, but she has not received training in the LiPS program itself.
30. A June 27, 1999 IEP addendum to the June 4, 1998 and March 25, 1999 IEPs states that an IEP meeting would be held in September 1999 to develop goals and objectives for the 1999-2000 school year. However, because the October 1999 IEP states that the June 1998 goals and objectives were to continue in effect, it appears that STUDENTdid not meet these goals, unless in fall 1999, he continued to work on goals he had already met.
31. Conformity with the IEP is not disputed.
32. Petitioner asserts that the District failed to provide prior written notice of its refusal to grant his mother’s March 1999 written request for an intensive LMB program. However, at a March 1999 IEP meeting to address the request, the mother expressed her concerns and the need for the LMB program, and the ISP and RSP teachers reported on STUDENT’S progress. Then-special education director Ms. McMurty stated that he was showing growth and the District’s program was appropriate. She suggested increased RSP services, which the parent declined. Thus, the IEP substantially met the requirements for prior written notice of the District’s refusal to change the placement.
33. Because DBH conducted an AB3632 assessment on June 29, 1999, after the end of the regular school year, the appropriateness of its assessment will be addressed in a discussion of the 1999-2000 school year. The mother testified that a reason that in September 1999 she rescinded authorization for DBH to disclose confidential information was that the District received a copy of the AB3632 assessment report before she did, and she did not receive a copy until the October 4, 1999 IEP meeting to discuss the results. DBH assessor Dr. Williams confirmed the mother’s testimony. However, State law requires that a copy of the mental health service assessment report be made available to the parent at least two days before the IEP meeting. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60045(f).
34. An “assessment” is an individual evaluation of a pupil in all areas of suspected disability in accordance with California Education Code Sections 56320 through 56329 and the pertinent federal regulations. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60010(c).
35. Dr. Tibbetts’ report describes the LAC test as follows: “Using colored blocks as a means of measuring auditory conceptualization, the student is asked to demonstrate increasingly complex skills in phonemic recognition and differentiation of phonemic omissions, substitutions, and additions of selected phonemes across first, medial, and ending positions.” (Pet. Exh. MM.)
36. Ms. Livoni testified that in the speech and language area, listening is really a “formal” assessment of pragmatics, though not standardized.
37. Ms. Jacobson has a bachelor’s degree in speech pathology and a master’s degree in communicative disorders and has been a speech pathologist for 24 years, 23 of which have been with the District.
38. It is noted that Dr. Pineda’s handwriting is, in parts of her report, difficult to read, but she mentions Tourette’s in relation to family history but does not mention it in connection with diagnoses. (DBH Exh. V64-65.)
39. As for phonemic Awareness, as discussed above, Dr. Tibbetts assessed this area in December 1999. In October 2000, SELPA consultant Ms. Costa also administered to STUDENTthe LAC test. She reported that he could differentiate sounds and was able to hear and demonstrate up to 3 sounds but had difficulty when asked to shift, omit, add, repeat, or substitute sounds. Thus, phonemic awareness was reassessed during this school year.
40. During this school year, the District again assessed phonemic awareness. As part of the triennial assessment, in October 2001, SDC teacher Ms. Shaw administered to STUDENTthe LAC test and recommended that he continue to develop phonemic awareness with activities involving integrating and shifting sounds.
41. For practical reasons, in the discussion of the issues, both the District and DBH are collectively referred to as the “District,” unless DBH itself has raised a matter unique to itself. A reference to only the District should be apparent from the context.
42. STUDENT’S first DBH therapist, Dr. Williams, testified that she did not believe that STUDENThad Tourette’s, but she saw him for only 6 sessions, until she was removed at the parent’s request because she refused to provide individual therapy to STUDENTalone.
43. The mother testified that STUDENTwould cry and have outbursts and tantrums when she made him go to school or tried to get him to do his homework. The fact that this extreme behavior was not observed in class may be due to the fact that there is no indication that the teacher attempted to get him to do what he was supposed to do but did not want to do, or otherwise addressed his noncompliance.
44. A March 25, 1999 IEP and a June 27, 1999 IEP addendum did not alter the goals, program, or services offered in the June 4, 1998 IEP and will not be discussed here. A September 13, 1999 interim mediation agreement between the parties states that the annual review IEP meeting would be held on October 4, 1999. In a September 16, 1999 letter, the mother withdrew STUDENTfrom RSP until the October 4 IEP meeting.
45. Petitioner also contends that the October 4, 1999 IEP failed to include a speech and language goal, although he was receiving speech therapy at the time. However, the May 1999 speech and language assessment had recommended dismissal from speech therapy, and the October 4 IEP states that speech therapy was suspended pending a parent-requested full speech and language assessment, which was completed later in October. The parent agreed to the October 4 IEP without exception. The need for a speech and language goal and services to address pragmatics is addressed below.
46. The District apparently sent a draft IEP to the parent’s advocate, who wrote a February 29, 2000 letter stating that the parents did not agree with the proposed goals and objectives in the draft IEP. Prior to the June 22, 2000 IEP meeting, when new goals and objectives were agreed upon, RSP teacher Ms. Talbott stated in her June 15, 2000 report that “without goals and objectives with which to measure his progress, it’s difficult to say whether STUDENTshould remain in the Resource program.”
47. It is noted that the October 4, 1999 and January 6, 2000 IEPs contain what appear to be the District’s proposed goals and objectives which apparently were not agreed to by the parent. If the parent disagrees with a component of a special education program that the District determines is necessary for provision of a FAPE, the course of action available to the District is to initiate a due process hearing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(b).
48. Petitioner’s contention that the therapy improperly failed to address scotopic sensitivity, peer relations, ADHD, and fire-setting lacks merit. There was no indication that scotopic sensitivity was a social-emotional concern. Further, during this school year, STUDENT’S mother, his DBH therapists, and the DBH records mentioned a conflict with a younger sister but not peer-relation problems generally. However, these records and the therapists specifically mentioned improving impulse control as a focus; thus the therapy addressed STUDENT’S ADHD. As for fire-setting, the evidence is that after an incident occurred about a month after therapy started with an initial goal of reducing aggression toward his sister, fire-setting became a focus of treatment as well.
49. During summer 2000, STUDENTreceived 5 hours of tutoring weekly in the LMB LiPS program from District tutor Erin Hames. Her September 2000 report shows that he made some progress and that the program was reasonably calculated to provide benefit. With a few exceptions, he had mastered the vowel sounds and then progressed from reading words with only two sounds to words with six sounds. He had learned to read and write, and was beginning to learn to spell, words with difficult consonant clusters.
50. Conformity with the IEP was not disputed.
51. The January 6, 2000 and June 22, 2000 IEPs state that methods of reporting progress toward goals were trimester grade reports and IEP team meetings.
52. The status of an unsigned IEP document dated June 20, 2000 is unclear. (Dist. Exh. 5.)
53. A May 31, 2001 IEP looks to the upcoming school year and will be addressed during the following year in terms of the educational program offered.
54. Although the IEP does not mention AB3632 services, the evidence is that STUDENTwas still receiving therapy and continued to do so during the 2000-2001 school year. The IEPs list the ISP as a program offered, but the evidence was that the ISP was solely a regular education, not a special education, program.
55. Even assuming that the District continued to offer the RSP at Carnelian, despite Ms. Talbott’s contrary testimony, the Read Naturally program provided at Carnelian was found above not to meet STUDENT’S
56. At some point he stayed for recess and also did vision-correcting activities twice weekly with Ms. Shaw.
57. At some point he stayed for recess and also did vision-correcting activities twice weekly with Ms. Shaw.
58. Regarding peer-relation problems, Petitioner acknowledges that these were addressed in group therapy.
59. The mother testified that Ms. Shaw was frequently absent from class, and when she was not there, no LMB services were provided. However, Ms. Shaw’s testimony and the documentary evidence establish that STUDENT nevertheless did show some progress in her class.
60. As for conformity with the IEP, the June 2000 and November 2000 IEPs in effect from September 2000 to December 15, 2000, failed to mention AB3632 services as part of STUDENT’S program, although the evidence is that he continued to receive these services. However, no argument has been raised regarding this discrepancy.
61. District special education director Mr. Kirkland testified that he did not notify STUDENT’S DBH therapist of the date and time of IEP meetings because he assumed that he could not communicate such information to DBH as a result of the mother’s September 1999 letter rescinding authorization for DBH to disclose confidential information to others. However, he acknowledged that once when he called STUDENT’S DBH therapist, he was informed that DBH could not disclose information outside IEP meetings. Thus, there was no reason not to invite the therapist to the IEP meetings to share information in the presence of the mother and with her approval.
62. There was no indication that STUDENTno longer needed individual therapy after Dr. DeChenne, his therapist for individual therapy, left DBH in November 2001. Dr. DeChenne testified that upon her departure, STUDENT was to be transferred to another DBH therapist (in addition to his DBH therapist for group therapy), but he started individual therapy with a private therapist instead.
63. A May 31, 2001 IEP did not substantially change the December 15, 2000 IEP other than to increase DBH counseling to 3 times monthly.
64. The December 2 IEP does not provide for individual therapy, one of STUDENT’S unique need s. However, Petitioner does not argue that the District and DBH failed to offer individual therapy, and the evidence is that the parent knew that when STUDENT’S individual therapist Dr. DeChenne left DBH, he could have had another DBH therapist for individual therapy. (Testimony of MOTHER, Dr. DeChenne.) Thus, although the District has the obligation to make an offer of an appropriate program even if the parent is unlikely to accept it, in this case no prejudice ensued. See Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 512 U.S. 965 (1994). Moreover, although the December 2 IEP contains a notation that the District offered a referral to SELPA clinical counseling, the parent’s advocate, and, it appears, the parent initialed this notation and thus presumably had the opportunity to discuss this option. No argument has been raised that the proffered counseling was inappropriate. 65. Conformity with the IEP was not disputed.
66. The declaration states that after multiple unsuccessful attempts, the mother submitted a written request for a copy of the assessment report and also for an IEP meeting to review the report. Her March 25 letter requests a report copy and a date for a “meeting time.” An IEP meeting shall be held within 30 days of receipt of the parent’s written request for such a meeting. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343.5. When the hearing was concluded, no evidence had been presented that an IEP meeting had been held or was scheduled to consider the assessment results.
67. The IDEA specifically requires that the copy of the procedural safeguards which must be given to the parents of a child with a disability upon, among other things, notification of an IEP meeting, must include notice of the requirements for unilateral private placement by the parents at public expense. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(d)(2)(H). Unlike Section 1412(a)(10)(C)(iv)(IV) (its IDEA counterpart), California Education Code Section 56177(d) provides that reimbursement for a parent’s unilateral private placement may not be reduced or denied because the parents failed timely to give to the District the requisite notice of the intent to seek reimbursement if the parent did not receive notice of the due process hearing rights under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 56500). Chapter 5, dealing with procedural safeguards, sets forth due process hearing rights but says nothing about notifying the parents of the requirements for reimbursement for a unilateral private placement. The federal statute requiring that the parents be specifically notified of the reimbursement notice requirement appears to be more protective of parents’ rights and governs here. See Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 512 U.S. 965 (1994) (the more protective standard, whether federal or State, is controlling under the IDEA).
65. In his closing brief, Petitioner requests reimbursement for “expenses” related to LMB services. However, he does not specifically mention assessments, and he did not identify, either at the hearing or in his closing brief, particular assessments for which reimbursement is sought. More importantly, none of the assessors testified, and no evidence was presented to establish that they were qualified specialists to conduct the assessments. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). Therefore, reimbursement for expenses incurred at Stowell and the LMB clinic does not include reimbursement for the cost of assessments.
