California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 11, 2001
Student v. Desert Sands Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 486-01 · Hearing Officer Judy F. Hirano
Desert Sands Unified must reimburse private educational therapy and provide compensatory auditory processing instruction after denying FAPE for two years.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions a prior due process request filed and withdrawn in 2000.
Summary
A 14-year-old with a specific learning disability, including an auditory processing disorder, filed for due process against Desert Sands Unified School District. His mother home-schooled him from 1998 to 2000 and paid for private educational therapy at Discovery House. He then returned to Palm Desert Middle School for seventh grade. Hearing Officer Judy Hirano barred claims from before March 12, 1998, because the mother knew the relevant facts by 1999 but did not file until 2001. The fifth-grade resource class in spring 1998 provided FAPE.
For 1998-1999 and 1999-2000, the district offered only in-class resource support, with pull-out help as needed. That did not provide the regular small-group instruction in reading, writing and spelling that his IEPs called for. The May 1999 IEP also had no reading goal despite a 32-point gap in basic reading. Both years were a denial of FAPE, and the home schooling did not count as a voluntary private placement. The summer 2000 ESY program was appropriate. So was the 2000-2001 program, a small multisensory SRA Corrective Reading class. The Hearing Officer found no proof that he needed Lindamood Bell in particular.
The parent's failure to give notice did not block reimbursement because the district did not show it had told her about the notice rule. The district must reimburse 1999-2000 Discovery House therapy and mileage, plus half the cost of Seeing Stars materials. It must also provide compensatory auditory processing instruction set by the IEP team. All other claims were denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled several issues. It treated home schooling caused by an inadequate offer as something other than a voluntary private placement. It allowed reimbursement without parent notice when the district could not prove it explained the notice requirement. It also held that an IEP must include a reading goal where testing shows a significant basic reading discrepancy.
Issues and holdings
Issue 1. Does the statute of limitations bar Petitioner's claims arising prior to March 12, 1998?
The mother knew the facts underlying her claims by 1999 but did not pursue a hearing until March 2001, so claims before March 12, 1998 are barred by the three-year limit.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2a. Did the District offer Petitioner a FAPE from March 12, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year?
The fifth-grade RSP class with multisensory (Orton-Gillingham-based) reading instruction met his needs and produced moderate progress, so FAPE was provided.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2b. Did the District offer Petitioner a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year?
Home schooling was not a voluntary private placement; the offered in-class RSP model with as-needed pull-out did not provide the consistent small-group reading, writing and spelling instruction his IEP required, and the IEP did not state the frequency of RSP services, so FAPE was denied.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2c. Did the District offer Petitioner a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 extended school year (ESY) session?
FAPE was denied for 1999-2000 because the May 1999 IEP had no reading goal despite a 32-point basic reading discrepancy and offered only in-class RSP with as-needed pull-out; the summer 2000 ESY program using Caught Reading was appropriate.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2d. Did the District offer Petitioner a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?
A small RSP reading class using SRA Corrective Reading, plus in-class support, met his needs, produced measurable gains, and was implemented in conformity with the IEP.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Does a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year require a multisensory language arts program such as Lindamood Bell?
Whether FAPE was offered for 2001-2002 was not ripe; there was insufficient evidence that Lindamood Bell specifically, as opposed to other multisensory programs, was one of his unique needs.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4a. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational services, including transportation, obtained at Sylvan Learning Center?
Summer 1999 Sylvan services were not reimbursable because the student was not shown to need ESY services that summer.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4b. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational services, including transportation, obtained at Discovery House?
Lack of notice did not bar reimbursement because the district did not show the parent was told of the notice requirement; 1999-2000 Discovery House therapy was appropriate and reimbursable, but summer 2000 and September-October 2000 were not.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5a. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for Lindamood Bell Seeing Stars materials used during home schooling?
The Seeing Stars materials were appropriate and helped his reading; the district must reimburse 50 percent, the share used for this student.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5b. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the parent's Lindamood Bell training?
Little evidence showed the training was used with the student and no authority supported reimbursing parent training.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5c. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for school supplies during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years?
Insufficient evidence showed the rest of the home-schooling program was appropriate, so supplies were not reimbursed.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE, is he entitled to compensatory education?
For the denial of FAPE, the student is entitled to compensatory instruction in Lindamood Bell or an equivalent auditory processing program, with the amount set by the IEP team.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 7. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the April 2001 assessment conducted by the Sylvan Learning Center?
There was no evidence the parent disagreed with the district's assessments, and those assessments were appropriate, so the Sylvan assessment was not reimbursed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Reimburse the cost of Discovery House educational therapy during the 1999-2000 school year (excluding summer 2000 ESY), including application, materials and related fees, within 25 calendar days of receiving proof; the parent must submit proof within 20 calendar days of the decision.
- Reimbursement. Reimburse mileage for each Discovery House session actually attended in 1999-2000 (excluding summer 2000), at the district's employee rate, within 25 calendar days of receiving proof of sessions and round-trip mileage (proof due within 20 calendar days).
- Reimbursement. Reimburse 50 percent of the cost of the Lindamood Bell Seeing Stars program used during the last three months of 1998-1999, within 25 calendar days of receiving proof (proof due within 20 calendar days).
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Convene an IEP meeting within 15 calendar days of the decision to develop a compensatory education plan.
- Compensatory education. Instruction in Lindamood Bell or an equivalent program that specifically addresses auditory processing, from the IEP meeting date through the end of the district's second trimester of 2001-2002. The IEP team sets amount, frequency and provider credentials, considering the roughly six-month denial of FAPE, time needed for improvement, and the student's schedule and tolerance. District staff or a qualified private provider may deliver it.
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School Dist.; Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School Dist.; Foley v. Special School Dist. of St. Louis County; K.R. v. Anderson Community School Corp.; Cefalu v. East Baton Rouge Parish School Bd.; KDM v. Reedsport School Dist.
People named in the decision
- Cynthia Moses, educational therapist (NILD-certified), witness for Student, Discovery House
- Geraldine Johnson, lead instructor, witness for Student, Sylvan Learning Center
- Barbara White, RSP teacher, Palm Desert Middle School and Washington Charter School
- Jeffery Ball, humanities teacher, Palm Desert Middle School
- Elka Kelly, District program specialist, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Debra Wilson, RSP teacher, Palm Desert Middle School
- Karon Ann Wylie, science teacher, Palm Desert Middle School
- Betsy Kreger, RSP teacher, Gerald Ford Elementary School
- Christopher Nugent, principal, Palm Desert Middle School
- John O'Connell, school psychologist (also referred to as Jack O'Connell), Desert Sands Unified School District
- Joan Taylor, school psychologist, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Judy Matthews, former school psychologist, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Carolyn Rounsaville, director of special education, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Ms. Cabe, teacher of record for reading class, Palm Desert Middle School
- Mary L. Cote, hearing officer (observer on June 7, 2001), Special Education Hearing Office
- Discovery House, private educational therapy provider (NILD)
- Sylvan Learning Center, private learning center
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in La Quinta, California, on June 5, 6, 7, and 12, 2001. STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented by attorney Gary Finn. Also present on STUDENT’S behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Desert Sands Unified School District (hereinafter District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Maria Gless and also, on June 5, 2001, by attorney Jack Clarke, Jr. Also present on the District’s behalf was Carolyn Rounsaville, District director of special education. The parent indicated that she wished to have an open hearing, and on June 5, 2001, a member of the public was present. Mary L. Cote, hearing officer, was present on June 7, 2001.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: STUDENT, Petitioner; MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; Cynthia Moses, educational therapist; and Geraldine Johnson, M.A., lead instructor, Sylvan Learning Center. Respondent called the following witnesses: Barbara White, M.S., resource specialist program (RSP) teacher, Palm Desert Middle School (PDMS) and Washington Charter School; Jeffery Ball, M.S., PDMS humanities teacher; Elka Kelly, M.S., District program specialist; Debra Wilson, M.S., PDMS RSP teacher; Karon Ann Wylie, PDMS science teacher; Betsy Kreger, M.S., RSP teacher, Gerald Ford Elementary School; Christopher Nugent, M.S., PDMS principal; John O’Connell, M.A., District school psychologist; Joan Taylor, M.S., District school psychologist; and Judy Matthews, Ph.D., former District school psychologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision. ISSUES(Footnote 2)
1. Does the statute of limitations bar Petitioner’s claims arising prior to March 12, 1998?
2. Did the District offer Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the following periods: a. From March 12, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year? b. During the 1998-1999 school year?
c. During the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 extended school year (ESY) session? d. During the 2000-2001 school year?
3. Does a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year require a multisensory language arts program such as Lindamood Bell?
4. If the District denied Petitioner a FAPE from March 12, 1998, through the end of the 2000-2001 school year, is he entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the educational services, including the cost of transportation, obtained at the following: a. Sylvan Learning Center?
b. Discovery House?
5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following costs incurred during the period of home schooling: a. Lindamood Bell Seeing Stars materials?
b. The parent’s Lindamood Bell training?
c. School supplies during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years?
6. If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE, is he entitled to compensatory education?
7. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the April 2001 assessment conducted by the Sylvan Learning Center?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 14-year-old boy who was first found eligible for special education as having a speech and language impairment and then a specific learning disability. He received resource specialist program (RSP) services and weekly speech therapy from the third through the fifth grade. Then his mother home-schooled him during the following two school years. She retained him in the sixth grade during the second year of home schooling. When he returned to the public school in grade 7, he was exited from speech therapy but again received RSP services. In January 1996, when STUDENT was in grade 3, he displayed articulation errors, was found to have a speech and language impairment, and started receiving speech and language services. In April and May 1996, school psychologist Jack O’Connell assessed STUDENT for special education because of concerns about his reading, spelling, ability to write down his thoughts, and reversals. On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III), his performance score was in the high average range, and his verbal and full scale IQ scores were in the average range. The Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test (Bender Gestalt) results revealed advanced visual-motor integration skills. However, his scores on the Learning Efficiency Test, Second Edition, indicated problems in auditory and visual sequential memory for symbols. According to Mr. O’Connell, these problems might have been related to weaknesses in reading and spelling skills. He indicated that STUDENT’S Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) and Diagnostic Achievement Battery results revealed weaknesses in reading recognition, reading comprehension, and spelling. Mr. O’Connell concluded that STUDENT possessed a psychological processing disorder in the area of auditory and visual sequential memory and exhibited a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in reading and spelling.
At a May 22, 1996 IEP meeting, when STUDENT was in grade 3, he was found eligible for special education as having a specific learning disability (SLD). The IEP indicates that he had severe discrepancies between ability and achievement in basic reading skills, reading comprehension, spelling, and oral expression. According to the IEP, he had problems in auditory and visual sequential memory that might be affecting his reading and spelling progress. The IEP recommends a resource specialist program (RSP) and weekly speech therapy.
During the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998 school years, when STUDENT was in the fourth and fifth grades, respectively, he continued in RSP for one period a day and continued to receive weekly speech articulation services. During the 1998-1999 school year, instead of entering Palm Desert Middle School (PDMS) as a sixth-grader, STUDENT was home-schooled by his mother. She testified that she home-schooled him using curriculum materials that she obtained from the District, “old” SRA reading comprehension cards, and, later in the school year, the Lindamood Bell Seeing Stars program that she purchased.
On May 14, 1999, when STUDENT was in grade 6, school psychologist Judy Matthews, Ph.D., conducted a triennial assessment. On the WISC-III, STUDENT obtained a 110 verbal IQ and 111 performance and full scale IQ scores. He scored at an age-appropriate level on the Bender Gestalt. On the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML), used to assess auditory memory, his ability to repeat digits presented auditorily was at the 15 percentile. When the material was more meaningful and contextually relevant and when he had to recall, after a delay, a larger amount of material conveyed in a story, he also performed in the below average range. STUDENT obtained the following WIAT standard scores: Basic Reading, 79; Reading Comprehension, 90; Mathematics Reasoning, 99; Numerical Operations, 104; Spelling, 71; and Written Expression, 88. Dr. Matthews stated that the test results revealed a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in spelling and written language.(Footnote 3) She also stated that STUDENT exhibited a perceptually-based learning disability in auditory memory skills that appeared to affect his academic achievement. She concluded that he continued to require special education.
A May 20, 1999 IEP states that STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education as having an SLD. He had been home-schooled during the former year. The recommended placement was in-class RSP with pull-out services as needed, for 88 minutes daily. Weekly speech and language services were also recommended. The SLD eligibility summary sheet, which is part of the IEP, indicates that STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder and that the following discrepancies existed between STUDENT’S 111 full scale IQ and his achievement standard scores in these areas: Basic Reading Skills, 32; Spelling, 41; and Written Expression, 23. The IEP states that his auditory memory delay resulted in a significant discrepancy between his ability and achievement in written language. The May 1999 IEP contains one goal--for writing.
An August 28, 1999 Sylvan Learning Center (Sylvan) progress report when STUDENT was in grade 6 indicates that on January 20, 1999, he obtained the following grade equivalent (GE) scores on the California Achievement Test (CAT): Vocabulary, 3.2; Comprehension, 2.8; and Total Reading, 3.0. On August 24, 1999, after 36 hrs of Sylvan instruction, he obtained the following CAT GE scores: Vocabulary, 4.0; Comprehension, 3.7; and Total Reading, 3.8.
STUDENT continued to be home-schooled during the 1999-2000 school year, when he would have been in grade 7. The mother testified that she decided to retain him in the sixth grade because of his academic deficits, age, and stature. During this school year, summer 2000, and September and October 2000, STUDENT received educational therapy from educational therapist Cynthia Moses at the Discovery House. Ms. Moses testified that she uses techniques from the National Institute for Learning Disabilities (NILD) and Lindamood Bell programs, both based upon deficit stimulation. In a May 2000 annual report, she set forth the April and May 2000 test results when STUDENT was in grade 6 (for the second time). She recommended that he continue with the Discovery Program during the summer and the 2000-2001 school year to strengthen his perceptual and cognitive deficits and build upon the learning strategies that he had acquired.
On May 31, 2000, resource specialist Barbara White conducted an academic assessment of STUDENT when he was age 12 years, 10 months. He obtained the following WIAT standard and GE scores, respectively: Basic Reading, 75, 3.2; Math Reasoning, 112, 9.4; Spelling, 73, 3.4; Reading Comprehension, 94, 5.6; Numerical Operations, 112, 8.6; and Written Expression, 94, 5.9. His composite standard and GE scores, respectively, were as follows: Reading, 78, 4.1; Mathematics, 112, 9.2; and Writing, 76, 4.0.(Footnote 4)
A June 12, 2000 IEP was developed when STUDENTwas still being home-schooled and was in grade 6 for the second time. The IEP recommends pull-out RSP services for one hour daily, but states that STUDENT was being exited from speech therapy.(Footnote 5) The IEP states that because of severe auditory memory deficits, he required specialized reading (small-group) instruction. The IEP also states that the parent requested reimbursement for expenses related to his education, and she was informed that she should put her request in writing. Pursuant to this IEP, STUDENT attended summer school at PDMS during summer 2000 and received reading instruction.
In fall 2000, STUDENT returned to school and attended PDMS as a seventh-grader. His report cards for the first two trimesters of the 2000-2001 school year reflect primarily B and C grades and grade point averages of 2.75 and 2.8, respectively.
In January 2001, at the mother’s request, STUDENT was assessed for memory and academic achievement when he was age 13 years, 6 months, and in grade 7. School psychologist Joan Taylor administered the verbal memory index of the WRAML. She noted that his WRAML scores showed some improvement, but testified that he continued to have difficulty in the auditory memory area, particularly with memory for details read aloud. STUDENT obtained the following WIAT standard and GE scores, respectively: Basic Reading, 89, 5.9; Spelling, 71, 3.6; Reading Comprehension, 96, 6.5; Numerical Operations, 76, 5.0; and Written Expression, 96, 6.9. His standard and GE composite scores, respectively, were as follows: Reading, 90, 6.1; and Writing, 76, 4.3. Ms. Taylor noted that STUDENT had made substantial gains in sight word reading, reading comprehension, and written language, and some gain in spelling. She concluded that his current academic program appeared to be meeting his educational needs.
A February 7, 2001 IEP developed when STUDENT was in grade 7 recommends in-class and pull-out RSP services for one hour daily. The IEP indicates that he had a weakness in auditory and sequential memory and required a small-group placement. The IEP also states that his concentration on tasks was inconsistent and he lacked attention to details and needed to use self-correction strategies. The IEP states that a multisensory approach worked best as his learning strength or preference. STUDENT’S RSP teacher, Ms. White, testified that the reading program she used during the 2000-2001 school year had a multisensory approach. The February 2001 IEP sets forth one dictation goal to improve STUDENT’S auditory processing skills. The IEP states that the mother requested Lindamood Bell training for STUDENT to improve his auditory processing and spelling, but the District members of the IEP team disagreed, stating that he was making progress in the current program.
On March 12, 2001, Petitioner filed a due process hearing request alleging the denial of a FAPE because of his insufficient progress in reading, reading comprehension, and spelling, and requesting Lindamood Bell therapy and reimbursement for out-of-pocket expenses the parent incurred in providing private educational services to STUDENT.
An April 6, 2001 Sylvan reading diagnostic assessment when STUDENT was age 13 years, 8 months, indicates that on the Gray Oral Reading Test-3, he obtained the following percentile and GE scores and ratings, respectively: Rate, 5, 5.1, poor; Accuracy, 5, 4.8, poor; Passage, 5, 5.1, poor; and Comprehension, 16, 5.2, below average. His Oral Reading Quotient was 76, a poor rating. On the CAT, he achieved the following GE scores: Vocabulary, 5.3; Comprehension, 6.7; and Total Reading, 5.9. The report indicates that he needed to work on word-analysis skills.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: Does the statute of limitations bar Petitioner’s claims arising prior to March 12, 1998?
Petitioner argues that the statute of limitations does not bar his claims arising prior to March 12, 1998, because his parent did not become aware that the District was not providing STUDENT with a FAPE until 1999, and she filed for due process in 2000. He contends that because his parent filed for due process in 2000, the allegations of the denial of a FAPE going back to 1997 and the 1996-1997 school year are at issue here. The District argues that the parent testified that she received a copy of her procedural rights in 1996 and thus cannot claim that the statute of limitations was tolled. Consequently, the District argues, the issues in this hearing go back only three years from the date of filing to March 12, 1998.
A request for a due process hearing arising under California Education Code Section 56501(a) “shall be filed within three years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for the request.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(j); see Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School Dist., 817 F.2d 551, 555 (9th Cir. 1987).
STUDENT’S mother testified that at the May 1997 IEP meeting, she learned that his prior year’s IEP goals were not being met. She testified that when she received the notice of parent rights in 1996, she was told that a due process hearing was a procedure that could be used if she disagreed with his placement, assessment, or goals. She testified that she did not disagree with these things but just thought that the District should do something else to help STUDENT. Thus, from the mother’s testimony, it appears that, although she became aware in 1997 that STUDENT was not meeting his IEP goals, she did not file for due process at that time because of alleged misinformation about the purpose of such a hearing.
In his closing brief, however, Petitioner acknowledges that by 1999, his mother became aware that the District was not providing STUDENT a FAPE, and she filed for a due process hearing in 2000. The mother testified that by May 1999, she had talked to educational therapist Ms. Moses and had done enough research to know what STUDENT needed to improve his reading, spelling, and written expression, and she also knew that STUDENT still needed to improve his reading even though the rest of the IEP team thought that he was doing fine and thus did not write a reading IEP goal for the following school year. Petitioner’s cause of action accrued when his parent knew or had reason to know of the injury that constitutes the basis of his due process hearing request. Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School Dist., 22 F.3d 228, 232 (9th Cir. 1994).
Here, Petitioner concedes that in 1999, his mother knew of the facts underlying the basis for the due process hearing request. If she had filed for due process in 1999, the hearing in that case could have included claims going back three years to 1996. Instead, as Petitioner admits in his closing brief, his parent filed for due process in 2000. The Hearing Office records indicate that a prior hearing request was filed and later withdrawn in 2000. The ensuing hearing in that case could have included claims going back three years to 1997. There is no evidence that a hearing was held in that case and that any claims adjudicated thereby are now barred by res judicata. In any event, since the parent knew in 1999 of the facts underlying the basis for the current hearing request, by failing to file for a due process hearing and to pursue adjudication of Petitioner’s claims until 2001, any claims prior to March 12, 1998, are now barred by the three-year statute of limitations.(Footnote 6) Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(j); Alexopulos, 817 F.2d at 555.
ISSUE 2: Did the District offer Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the following periods: a. From March 12, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year? b. During the 1998-1999 school year?
c. During the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session? d. During the 2000-2001 school year?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student’s unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a) (“designated instruction and services” shall be available when necessary for a student to benefit from his or her special education program).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA provides such a student with a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of “access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit.” Id. at 200-01. The Court stated that the specialized educational services furnished need not maximize each child’s potential. Id. at 198-99.
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education, it is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs; (2) was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit; and (3) conformed to his IEP. See Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89.
a. From March 12, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year
Petitioner contends generally that in several IEPs, the District failed to include meaningful goals and failed to provide services offered in the IEPs.(Footnote 7) For the period from March 12, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year, when STUDENT was in grade 5 at Ford Elementary School (Ford), the mother alleged, in essence, that the District failed to offer a FAPE by not providing a multisensory reading program and phonics.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District’s proposed program for the period from March 12, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, the first step is to identify his needs. His needs were established by the speech and language, psycho-educational, and academic achievement assessments and IEPs up through the 1997-1998 school year. STUDENT’S cognitive ability was in the average to high average range. He had a significant deficit in articulation. He displayed a problem with auditory and visual sequential memory for symbols. He had weaknesses in reading recognition, reading comprehension, and spelling. The May 1996 IEP indicates that he had auditory and visual processing disorders. The May 1996 and May 1997 IEP teams had identified his areas of need as reading, spelling, written expression, and speech, particularly articulation. Because of the above deficits, STUDENT had certain instructional needs. He required speech therapy weekly to address his articulation problem. He also required resource specialist services and small-group instruction.
The next step in determining whether the proposed program was designed to address STUDENT’S unique needs is to examine the IEP. The IEP is a written statement of the goals and objectives developed to meet the student’s unique needs and the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services that will be provided to assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii), (iii).
Although only the period from March 12, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year is at issue here, it is necessary to examine the May 22, 1997 IEP, which was in effect during most of this time period.(Footnote 8) The May 22 IEP, signed by the parent, sets forth goals and objectives to address STUDENT’S needs in reading, spelling, written expression, and articulation. The reading objectives were designed to improve STUDENT’S ability to read a third-grade level paragraph and demonstrate comprehension by paraphrasing the main idea and answering comprehension questions; to read lists of words using strategies such as phonics, syllabication, and application of a knowledge of prefixes and suffixes; and to listen to grade-level passages and demonstrate through discussion an oral comprehension of the concepts, vocabulary, and topic. The spelling objectives addressed having repeated experiences using high-frequency spelling words and using aids such as the computer spell check, a dictionary, curricular texts, and stages of the writing process to improve spelling accuracy in classroom written work.
The objectives related to written expression were designed to improve his ability, through editing (without adult assistance), to write paragraphs focused on only one topic and to improve his ability to write (without adult assistance) a three-paragraph response to a class assignment using a check-off rubric. The articulation objectives addressed the ability to produce the “er” sound spontaneously in single words and phrases and to produce initial and medial “r” and “er” sounds first in short sentences and phrases and then in conversation. These goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT’S needs in these areas as identified by the assessments and IEPs.
The May 1997 IEP provides the following program, services, and accommodations for STUDENT. The IEP proposes RSP services for one period a day and speech therapy for 20-30 minutes weekly. Ms. Kreger, STUDENT’S RSP teacher at Ford during the fourth and fifth grades, testified that he was in her RSP class for 40 minutes five days a week.(Footnote 9) She testified that in this class, she taught reading, spelling, and written language, as called for by the IEP. According to her, two days a week, the students did remedial work, and two days a week, she worked on modifying the core curriculum in their regular education classes to enable them to participate in these classes. Ms. Kreger testified that for the remedial work, she used the Rene Herman reading kit of the Orton Gillingham Society, which is a multisensory reading program.(Footnote 10) According to her, the program entailed using a developmental film strip and following a script. She testified that in addition to the other senses, this program involved the tactile sense in that the students wrote down what they heard when she sounded out a word. The mother testified that when she observed Ms. Kreger’s RSP class in 1997, she did not see any reading program being taught. According to her, the children only did group reading in the core curriculum literature, worked on spelling words, and did class writing assignments. She testified that she visited the class several times and stayed for a short period of time but did not specify the amount of time per visit.
According to the mother’s testimony, she believed that a multisensory reading program and phonics would have helped STUDENT to improve his reading and spelling. Although the assessments and IEPs up to that point do not specifically mention that he needed these types of programs, Ms. Kreger’s testimony nevertheless indicates that her reading program contained these elements. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Kreger to be credible and persuasive. The Hearing Officer finds that her RSP class, which involved instruction in reading, spelling, and writing, was designed to address STUDENT’S needs in these areas.(Footnote 11)
The May 1997 IEP provides for accommodations in STUDENT’S regular education classes, such as having problems read aloud and obtaining assistance with difficult words, not meanings, which addressed his reading problem. An accommodation such as being provided a check-off rubric of required elements for written essays was designed to assist with writing. Being provided a chart of high-frequency spelling words and using the computer spell-check were accommodations to assist with his spelling problem. Further, having questions rephrased using fewer or less complex words was an accommodation to address his auditory processing difficulty. These accommodations were designed to address STUDENT’S needs in these areas.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Determining whether a program is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit requires a review of various measures, including, among other things, standardized test scores, teacher and staff observations, ratings on course work and tests, grade advancement, and progress on annual goals and short-term objectives.
A comparison of STUDENT’S present levels of performance in the May 1997 and May 1998 IEPs is instructive to assess his progress during the intervening school year. According to Ms. Kreger, the May 1997 IEP sets forth present levels of performance based upon his written work, class work, and informal reading tests. She testified that she uses the Brigance Oral Reading Recognition List and Fry reading paragraphs for the annual review. The May 1997 IEP states that STUDENT was reading at a high second-grade level and that when he read a third-grade-level passage, he was unable to paraphrase the main idea. The May 1998 IEP states that his reading recognition was at the mid-third-grade level and reading comprehension was at the fourth-grade level. The IEP states that he was beginning to break down multi-syllabic words using strategies he had been taught. Thus, according to informal testing, STUDENT’S reading comprehension showed an improvement of approximately one grade level in a year’s time.(Footnote 12) Further, the May 1998 IEP indicates that STUDENT met both of the prior year’s (1997) reading objectives.(Footnote 13)
As for spelling, STUDENT’S present level of performance in May 1997 was as follows: On a District spelling paragraph, he achieved a 72 percent at the grade 1 level and 52 percent at the grade 2 level. A year later, in May 1998, his ability to spell high-frequency second-grade level words was 66 percent. Further, the May 1998 IEP indicates that one of the prior year’s spelling objectives was partially met and the other was met “with adult assistance.” However, as the mother notes in her time line of events, since adult assistance was not part of the second objective, this objective was, at most, only partially met. The mother acknowledged that STUDENT obtained 90's and 100's on his spelling tests, but she asserted that he nevertheless continued to make spelling errors in his writing assignments. Thus, the evidence establishes that he made limited progress in spelling.
In the area of written expression, the May 1997 IEP states that STUDENT was able to write a two-paragraph response to a class assignment using a check-off rubric to include all required elements, but only with adult assistance. In May 1998, he was able to write a three-paragraph response with some adult guidance using a check-off rubric of required elements, but needed a spelling error monitoring system. He thus showed some improvement but still required adult assistance. The May 1998 IEP indicates that one of the prior year’s written expression objectives was met and the other was partially met. The mother acknowledged that STUDENT obtained C grades in his classes, but she stated that, according to his teachers, his grades were based upon effort because of his learning disability.(Footnote 14) According to her, the teachers said that he was functioning below grade level. She testified that she saw no improvement in STUDENT’S reading or spelling ability. Although the mother’s testimony indicated that STUDENT’S grades did not necessarily reflect his achievement, the test results did show improvement. STUDENT’S reading comprehension score increased approximately one grade level in a year. Moreover, although his progress in spelling and written language was more limited, he did show progress, albeit with adult assistance. It appears that he needed to learn to work independently to monitor his own spelling and written work. In addition, he did advance to grade 6.
Considering all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that while STUDENT’S progress was moderate, he did demonstrate improvement, particularly in reading comprehension. Consequently, it is concluded that the District’s program was reasonably calculated to confer on him educational benefit.
(3) Conformed to the IEP
There is no dispute regarding whether the program that was provided conformed with the IEP.
In conclusion, the District’s proposed program from March 12, 1998, to the end of the 1997-1998 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. No dispute exists with respect to whether it conformed to the IEP. Therefore, the program provided STUDENT a FAPE.
b. During the 1998-1999 school year
Petitioner contends, in essence, that during the 1998-1999 school year, when he was to enter PDMS as a sixth-grader, the District failed to offer an appropriate program to address his needs in reading, writing, and spelling. During this school year, instead of attending PDMS, STUDENT received home schooling from his mother. The District argues, in effect, that STUDENT was not entitled to special education and related services during this school year because his parent voluntarily chose to home-school him for reasons other than dissatisfaction with the District’s proffered program. The District’s argument will be addressed first.
Under the 1997 IDEA amendments and 1999 regulations, children voluntarily enrolled in a private school have no individual right to special education and related services if the local educational agency offered them a free appropriate public education and their parents elected to enroll them in a private school.(Footnote 15) 34 C.F.R. § 300.454; see Foley v. Special School Dist. of St. Louis County, 153 F.3d 863, 864 (8th Cir. 1998); K.R. v. Anderson Community School Corp., 125 F.3d 1017, 1019 (7th Cir. 1997), cert. denied, 118 S.Ct. 1360 (1998); Cefalu v. East Baton Rouge Parish School Bd., 117 F.3d 231, 233 (5th Cir. 1997).
The District argues that the parent, in essence, transformed the home schooling program into a private school placement by filing an affidavit to qualify for the private school exemption from the State compulsory education law. See Cal. Educ. Code §§ 48415, 48222. According to the District, because the parent’s reason for home schooling STUDENT was unrelated to the District’s proffered program, the result was a voluntary enrollment in a private school. The parent testified that she filed an affidavit to avoid a lawsuit for educational neglect by failing to comply with the compulsory attendance law.(Footnote 16)
The District argues that STUDENT’S mother made a voluntary decision to home-school STUDENT for personal reasons in that, according to the testimony of RSP teacher Ms. Kreger, the mother did not express dissatisfaction with the proffered program but rather expressed concerns about peer influences and instruction about evolution at the middle school. Further, the mother consented to the May 1998 IEP, which offered a program substantially similar to his prior school year’s program. Ms. Kreger testified that at the end of STUDENT’S fifth grade year, when he was to enter middle school in the fall, STUDENT’S mother mentioned home schooling and a concern about peer relations. Ms. Kreger testified that she did not recall if this exchange occurred at a formal meeting or informally. She further testified that the mother did not tell her that she was concerned about the program at the middle school.
STUDENT’S mother testified that at the end of STUDENT’S fifth grade year, she decided to home-school him. According to her, he had not met all of his goals. Further, at the 1998 IEP meeting, she inquired as to the type of RSP program that would be provided to (STUDENT, and the program described was the in-class model. She testified that she feared that because that program did not provide reading instruction, it would not help STUDENT with his reading. According to her, it would also not provide writing instruction but only help him with his papers. She was concerned that with the in-class RSP program, STUDENT would not ask for help because he would not want to draw attention to himself. According to her, she thought that home schooling would provide small-group instruction, which he needed. Her undisputed testimony is that she told the IEP team at the 1998 IEP meeting that she planned to home-school (STUDENT, but that the other team members stated that the IEP should be written as if STUDENT were returning to school in the event that she was unable to home-school him. She testified that she transferred STUDENT to the District home- school program and obtained the curriculum information and materials and began that program. According to her, during that school year, STUDENT continued to receive weekly speech therapy.
STUDENT also testified that he was home-schooled because his mother did not think that the school would teach him what he needed to learn because the school would teach him in the same way that other students were taught, but his brain did not work like the brains of other students. He continued that he was kept out of school so that he could take Ms. Moses’ program and other programs that his brain could learn so that he would learn more. He added that another reason for the home schooling was that the middle school was teaching evolution.
The Hearing Officer finds that although there may have been nonprogram-related reasons for the home schooling, the mother’s credible testimony revealed that she had legitimate concerns about the program proposed at the middle school. The Hearing Officer finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the mother’s primary reason for home schooling STUDENT was the inadequacy of the District’s proposed program. It is noted, however, that in 1998, California law did not yet require notice prior to a unilateral placement for reimbursement purposes. Cal. Educ. Code § 56176.(Footnote 17) Thus, there was no such requirement or any other notice requirement related to the 1998-1999 school year. The District has cited no authority to the contrary. Therefore, the home schooling during this school year was not a “voluntary” placement that precluded STUDENT from being entitled to special education services.
The Hearing Officer will now turn to the question of whether the District’s proposed program for the 1998-1999 school year offered STUDENT a FAPE. It is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet his unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit, and (3) conformed with his IEP. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District’s proposed program for the 1998-1999 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, it is necessary to identify his needs. During this school year, he continued to have an articulation deficit, an auditory and visual sequential memory problem, and weaknesses in reading recognition, reading comprehension, spelling, and written expression. The May 13, 1998 IEP indicates that in addition to speech therapy, RSP services, and specialized small-group instruction, he needed a spelling error monitoring system.
To determine whether the District’s proposed program for the 1998-1999 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s individual needs, it is necessary to examine the May 13, 1998 IEP. The May 13 IEP, signed by the parent, contains goals and objectives to address STUDENT’S needs in reading, spelling, written expression, and articulation. The reading objectives were intended to improve his ability to read and comprehend high fourth-grade and beginning fifth-grade paragraphs and to use recognition strategies to read grade-level material and answer written comprehension questions. The spelling objectives were designed to improve his spelling error monitoring by using high frequency third-grade level spelling words in daily writing and by using various spelling strategies (dictionary, computer spell check, and curricular texts) to reduce spelling errors in written work. The objectives for written expression addressed writing, without adult assistance, a three- to four-paragraph response using a check-off rubric of required elements and writing, without adult assistance, a four-paragraph response with all the required elements and proper paragraph structure (topic, details, and “wrap-up”). The speech objectives were designed to improve articulation of “r” and “er” sounds in single words and sentences.
The May 1998 IEP recommends the following program, services, and accommodations. It provides for STUDENT to continue in RSP and to receive speech and language services 20 minutes weekly. He was to be in regular education for five periods, or 84 percent of the time, including P.E. This IEP states that STUDENT required specialized small-group instruction. The IEP contains accommodations similar to those provided for in the May 1997 IEP. These accommodations were designed to address STUDENT’S needs in reading, spelling, and writing.
However, the May 1998 IEP does not specify the frequency, amount, or type of RSP services (whether pull-out or consultative RSP services or an RSP class) to be provided. Under federal and State law, the IEP must contain a statement of the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided and, among other things, the frequency of services. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii), (vi); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3), (6). The amount of services to be provided must be included in the IEP to ensure that the level of the District’s commitment of resources is clear to the parent, other IEP team members, and those involved in implementing the IEP. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. A, Q. 35 (1999). Because the above information is missing from the May 1998 IEP, these requirements were not met.
During grade 6, RSP teacher Ms. Wilson would have taught STUDENT if he had attended PDMS instead of being home-schooled by his mother.(Footnote 18) Ms. Wilson testified that at PDMS, she does not use a particular reading program but rather uses strategies from many different programs depending on a student’s IEP. She further testified that in her teaching, she uses multisensory techniques no matter what program she is using.
Ms. Wilson testified that if STUDENT had attended PDMS during grade 6, she would have provided an in-class RSP model with pull-out services as needed. In the in-class RSP model, she stays with the RSP students in a particular regular education class and takes students out, often one or two at a time, to provide them with strategies to assist with their deficit areas. The pull-out services involve helping the students, one-on-one or in a small group, to work on assignments in their IEP areas, such as reading, written language, or decoding. According to her, she works on students’ IEP goals in the context of their current curriculum in a regular education class. When asked by Petitioner’s attorney how much individual assistance STUDENT would have received in such a program, Ms. Wilson testified that since the humanities class was 88 minutes per period, the maximum potential weekly amount of time for individual assistance would have been 88 times 5 (presumably the number of periods per week). However, she further testified that some weeks, the RSP students may not need individual help, and she merely remains in the regular education classroom with them.
Ms. Wilson’s testimony establishes that if STUDENT had attended grade 6 at PDMS, in the in-class RSP model with pull-out services that she described, he would not have had a relatively small RSP class for one period five days a week, with regular instruction in reading, writing, and spelling, like Ms. Kreger’s fifth-grade RSP class at Ford Elementary. Instead, Ms. Wilson would have been in one of STUDENT’S regular education classes, and he would have been removed from that class to receive, as needed, pull-out RSP services (one-on-one or in a small group) to assist him in his deficit areas with his regular education curriculum. Because he would have received individual or small-group instruction only on an “as needed” basis (that is, only when he was removed from the regular classroom for pull-out services), he would have had limited small-group instruction. However, his May 1998 IEP states that the justification for his special education placement was that “[r]emediation of whole language skills and articulation require specialized small group instruction.” On the same page, the IEP identifies his special education areas of need as reading, spelling, writing, and speech. (District’s Exhibit 18 at 2.) This statement indicates that STUDENT needed small-group instruction in his areas of need, specifically, reading, spelling, writing, and speech. Thus, an in-class RSP model with pull-out services, as described by Ms. Wilson, would not have provided what he needed and what the IEP called for.
Moreover, the language quoted above from the May 1998 IEP is virtually identical to the language in the May 1997 IEP. During the 1997-1998 school year, according to Ms. Kreger, the RSP program provided to STUDENT was one period of an RSP class that provided instruction in reading, writing, and spelling, including a multisensory reading program, at least two days a week. During an additional two days, she worked on modifying the students’ regular education curriculum, but apparently the class size would have been remained essentially the same. All of STUDENT’S IEPs from the time he was found eligible for special education in 1996 indicate that he required small-group instruction, and the IEPs were implemented to provide this in an RSP class.(Footnote 19) The District has provided no evidence that STUDENT’S needs had changed so that he no longer required such a setting during the 1998-1999 school year. At the end of the 1997-1998 school year, he still had deficits in reading recognition, spelling, and written expression, and required small-group instruction in these areas of deficit, as the May 1998 IEP indicates. Absent evidence to the contrary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continued to require small-group instruction in his deficit areas during the 1998-1999 school year. Merely periodic individual or small-group assistance as problems arose in his regular education class would not meet this requirement. Therefore, the in-class RSP model with pull-out services as described by Ms. Wilson was not designed to meet his reading, writing, and spelling needs, including small-group instruction in these areas.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Because STUDENT did not attend grade 6 at PDMS during the 1998-1999 school year, there are no measures of his progress in the program proposed for that year. However, at the end of his fifth grade year, his reading was still at the mid-third-grade to fourth-grade level, he was having difficulty spelling second-grade level words, and he needed assistance to write a multi-paragraph response to an assignment. In May 1999, his WIAT scores reveal that he still had severe discrepancies between ability and achievement in reading, writing, and spelling. Thus, he required a program of instruction in these areas, not merely occasional help with assignments in a regular education class. The result of 36 hours of a reading program he received at Sylvan in 1999, showing a total reading score gain of 8 months, attests to the efficacy of a program of reading instruction for STUDENT. By contrast, the proffered program of occasional RSP pull-out services for specific strategies to use in tackling regular education assignments was not reasonably calculated to confer on STUDENT educational benefit.
(3) Conformed to the IEP
Because it has been determined that the District failed to offer a program that met STUDENT’S unique needs and was reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit, it is unnecessary to address whether the District would have provided a program in conformity with the IEP.
In conclusion, because the District’s proposed placement did not provide for a program of consistent small-group instruction in reading, writing, and spelling, but only occasional pull-out services, it was not designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. The result was the denial of a FAPE.(Footnote 20)
c. During the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session
To determine whether the District complied with the IDEA during the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session, it is necessary to address whether its proposed program (1) was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs; (2) was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit; and (3) conformed with his IEP. See Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89.
Petitioner contends that the District denied him a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year because the May 20, 1999 IEP contained no reading goal or objectives. During this school year, as in the past year, STUDENT did not attend PDMS but instead received home schooling from his mother. Because the District again suggests that the parent’s decision to provide home schooling to STUDENT for a second year was for personal reasons not related to the District’s proposed program, this matter will be addressed first.
The mother testified that at the May 20, 1999 IEP meeting, the RSP program proposed was 88 minutes of an in-class model with pull-out services as needed. She testified that there would be no consistent small-group instruction, which she thought STUDENT needed, only classroom instruction. According to her, he would merely be pulled out for assistance with reading or a writing assignment if he asked for help. The mother further testified that at the May 1999 IEP meeting, she asked RSP teacher Ms. Wilson how much time she would actually spend each week giving STUDENT one-on-one assistance, and Ms. Wilson told her 15 to 20 minutes. The mother testified that she did not think that was sufficient time to instruct STUDENT in reading. The mother testified that at the IEP meeting, she was told that because STUDENT’S reading comprehension was at the 4.5 grade level, his reading was fine, and no IEP reading goal was developed. The mother’s undisputed testimony is that she told the IEP team that she wanted to hold STUDENT back. She testified that she wanted him to re-do grade 6 at home, with a focus on reading and processing problems. The mother’s testimony establishes that she had concerns about the in-class RSP model with its lack of consistent reading instruction and small-group instruction. She testified that after one year of home schooling, she was still looking for a program that would help STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds, on the basis of the mother’s credible testimony, that her concerns about the proposed in-class RSP program and the lack of a reading program for STUDENT constituted the primary reason for her decision to home-school him for a second year.(Footnote 21) Therefore, the home schooling program during this school year was not a voluntary placement that precluded STUDENT from being entitled to special education services.
A. 1999-2000 School Year
The question is whether the District’s proposed program for the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session, offered STUDENT a FAPE. The 1999-2000 school year will be addressed first, and the 2000 summer school session will be discussed separately. During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was home-schooled for a second year by his mother and received twice weekly educational therapy at the Discovery House.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District’s proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, it is necessary first to identify his needs. He continued to have an articulation deficit. The May 1999 triennial assessment revealed his number and letter, sentence, and story memory to be all below average. The assessment indicated that he had a perceptually-based learning disability in auditory memory skills. During the testing, he revealed some difficulty retrieving labels and concepts. Although his reading comprehension showed improvement, he continued to attain low WIAT scores in basic reading skills, spelling, and written expression. The May 1999 IEP continued to identify an auditory processing disorder. The IEP also indicates that he was on task most of the time but needed to be reminded to complete his work. The IEP further states that his student learning strength or preference was multisensory and visual. These were STUDENT’S unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year.
The next step is to examine the goals and objectives in the IEP. The applicable IEP during the 1999-2000 school year is the May 20, 1999 IEP. This IEP, signed by the parent, contains only one goal (for writing)–to write two to three paragraphs on an assigned topic, presented in a proper format and edited for spelling, mechanics, and usage. The objectives are to write a minimum of two to three paragraphs on an assigned topic with a sentence containing the main idea, a body containing details, and a conclusion; and to write these paragraphs edited for spelling, mechanics, and usage with 80 percent accuracy. The writing goal and objectives were designed to address STUDENT’S needs in written expression.
In the mother’s written time line of events, she notes that the May 1999 IEP contains no reading goal. When Ms. Wilson administered the WIAT to STUDENT in May 1999, he obtained a 79 Basic Reading subtest standard score. At the hearing, school psychologist Dr. Matthews conceded that this score represented a significant discrepancy from STUDENT’S 111 full scale IQ. However, her report of the May 14, 1999 triennial assessment states that a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement existed solely in spelling and written language. Dr. Matthews testified that she did not include reading as an area of significant discrepancy because of STUDENT’S relatively high reading comprehension standard score (of 90). However, basic reading skills (in contrast to reading comprehension) is an area in which a significant discrepancy will satisfy one of the SLD eligibility criteria. Cal. Educ. Code. § 56337(a)(4). Ms. Wilson, who was present at the May 1999 IEP meeting, testified that she could not recall specifically why there was no reading goal because STUDENT’S reading score was low. A 32-point discrepancy between ability and achievement in basic reading skills was a significant discrepancy that represented a deficit area that needed to be addressed in the IEP. (District’s Exhibit 2 - SLD eligibility summary sheet.) Thus, by failing to include a reading skills goal, the May 1999 IEP failed to address all of STUDENT’S unique needs.
The District argues that the lack of a reading goal in the May 1999 IEP did not result in the denial of a FAPE because Ms. Wilson testified that after she had worked with STUDENT for a month or so, she could have developed additional IEP goals for him. However, Ms. Wilson had administered to STUDENT the WIAT in May 1999 and thus should have had a clear enough idea of what his academic needs were to develop goals for him in May 1999. STUDENT was entitled to an IEP, including appropriate goals and objectives, before the start of the school year. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(2)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.342(a).(Footnote 22)
The May 1999 IEP proposes the following program, services, and accommodations for STUDENT. The recommended placement was in-class RSP with pull-out services as needed, for 88 minutes daily. Speech and language services were recommended for 20 minutes weekly. He was to be in special education for 32 percent of the time and was to be in regular education for all of his academic courses (language arts, math, social studies, and science), P.E., and electives. The IEP sets forth accommodations and other support, such as modified assignments and consultative and collaborative RSP services to STUDENT’S regular education teachers, which were designed to meet his reading, writing, and spelling needs. The RSP services were to be provided by Ms. Wilson, as discussed above. Ms. Wilson testified that during the 1999-2000 school year, since she had not worked with (STUDENT, she would have started with the in-class model with pull-out services and would have re-evaluated the program at any time if it was not working for him. She further testified that if STUDENT needed a more restrictive special education program, she could have called another IEP meeting for him. However, since she had administered the WIAT to him in May 1999, she should have known what his areas of weakness were and the severity of his deficits and proposed an appropriate program for him at that time. As determined above, the in-class model with pull-out services described by Ms. Wilson failed to address STUDENT’S need for systematic instruction in writing, spelling, and, particularly, reading, in a small group.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
STUDENT did not attend grade 7 at PDMS during the 1999-2000 school year, so no evaluative measures of his progress in the proposed program exist. However, at the end of his sixth grade year, he had reading recognition and reading comprehension GE scores of 3.0 and 4.5, respectively; and spelling and written expression GE scores of 2.6 and 3.9, respectively. His reading recognition and spelling GE scores were more than three years below grade level. A year later, in June 2000, his WIAT scores still disclosed a severe discrepancy between cognitive ability and academic achievement in reading, writing, and spelling. To address his severe deficits, he required a substantive program of instruction in these areas. Thus, an RSP program of periodic pull-out services to instruct in strategies to assist with regular education class assignments, as discussed above, was not reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit. Moreover, because the May 1999 IEP contained no reading goals or objectives, the proposed program was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
(3) Conformed to IEP
There is no dispute as to whether the District would have provided a program in conformity with the IEP.
In summary, it was determined that because the May 1999 IEP lacked a reading goal and offered the in-class RSP model with pull-out services that did not meet STUDENT’S need for small-group instruction in reading, spelling, and writing, the District’s proposed program for the 1999-2000 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, and it was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. The matter of conformity with the IEP is not disputed. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year.(Footnote 23)
B. Summer 2000 ESY Session
On June 12, 2000, another IEP was developed. The box for ESY services on this IEP is not checked. However, the second page of the IEP indicates that the mother had requested summer school at the NILD Discovery House, but the District offered instead a four-week summer school with special education services.(Footnote 24) The mother testified, without objection, that the District offered summer school pursuant to a mediation agreement. See Cal. Code. Regs. tit. 5, § 3086(b). Since the District in fact offered STUDENT an ESY program in summer 2000, the question is whether the District’s ESY program was appropriate.(Footnote 25)
According to the mother, STUDENT was to receive instruction in the Open Court reading program during summer school, but she acknowledged that she did not know what that program entailed. The IEP does not mention a specific reading program for summer school.(Footnote 26) The June 12 IEP contains a reading goal to improve reading decoding skills, which is designed to address STUDENT’S need in the area of basic reading skills. RSP teacher Ms. White testified that during the summer 2000 ESY session, she used the Caught Reading program, which emphasizes phonics, comprehension, and some writing skills. According to her, some of the stories are of high interest to middle school students. The Caught Reading program, which emphasizes both phonics and comprehension, was designed to assist STUDENT to improve his reading decoding skills. Moreover, Ms. White testified that he enjoyed reading a couple of the books that were in the classroom. Based upon the foregoing, it is concluded that the District’s summer 2000 ESY program, offered pursuant to the parties’ mediation agreement, was designed to meet STUDENT’S reading need and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Therefore, it was appropriate. As a result, as discussed below under Issue 4, the parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the summer 2000 session at the Discovery House.
d. During the 2000-2001 school year
During the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT returned to public school as a seventh-grader at PDMS. During the previous summer he had attended summer school at PDMS and also continued to receive educational therapy at the Discovery House. To determine whether the District offered a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, it is necessary to address whether the District’s proposed program (1) was designed to meet his unique needs; (2) was reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit; and (3) conformed with his IEP. See Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89. Petitioner contends that he was denied a FAPE because the District failed to provide a program that addressed his needs in auditory processing and spelling. The applicable IEPs for this school year are the June 12, 2000 and February 7, 2001 IEPs.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
The first step in determining whether the District’s proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs is to identify his needs. He continued to have a perceptually-based learning disability in auditory memory and an auditory processing disorder. However, he no longer had an articulation deficit for which he required speech therapy. The May 2000 WIAT scores revealed continued deficits in basic reading skills, writing, and spelling. In addition, the April and May 2000 NILD Discovery House assessment report revealed that STUDENT still had difficulty making the sound-symbol association for spelling (errors of omission and substitution) and applying the rules for plurals, possessives, prefixes, suffixes, and verb tense in both oral and written language. According to the report, he still had occasional problems completing his homework. The June 2000 IEP stated that because of severe auditory memory deficits, he needed specialized small-group instruction, particularly for reading. His January 2001 WIAT scores revealed continued deficits in spelling and writing. According to the February 2001 IEP, although he had shown growth in the basic processing areas, he still had a weakness in auditory and sequential memory. He still required a small-group placement to address his SLD. Like the May 1999 IEP, the February 2001 IEP identifies a multisensory approach as his learning strength or preference. With reference to an April 2001 Sylvan diagnostic assessment, Sylvan instructor Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT was below grade level in vocabulary and reading, and a main area of need was word analysis skills. STUDENT had these unique needs during this school year.
(a) June 12, 2000 IEP
The next step is to examine the IEP. The June 12, 2000 IEP, signed by the parent with exception,(Footnote 27) sets forth goals and objectives for written language, reading decoding, and auditory skills. The writing goal was designed to help STUDENT write clear, coherent, and focused essays using the stages of the writing process (at sixth-grade District standards). The objectives were intended to assist him to write multiple-sentence paragraphs using correct spelling, grammar, and punctuation; to use the process of writing, re-writing, and obtaining peer review of a one-page essay; and to improve his written vocabulary. The reading goal addressed improving reading decoding skills by one year’s growth. The objectives were intended to assist STUDENT to decode fourth-grade-level material correctly 80 percent of the time and to decode from fourth-grade-level material at least 100 words correctly. The auditory skills goal was designed to improve auditory skills through daily oral exercises. The objectives were intended to help him to write correctly, on a daily basis, three dictated sentences of at least 7 words, and to write 8 dictated sentences of at least 7 words at the fourth-grade level with 90 percent accuracy.
The June 2000 IEP recommends pull-out RSP services for one hour daily and mentions consultative and collaborative RSP support to be provided to his regular education teachers. STUDENT was to be in special education for 20 percent of the time and the remainder of the time in regular education, including all academic subjects. The IEP states that because he had met his speech goal, he was being exited from speech and language services.
STUDENT’S RSP teacher, Ms. White, testified that he was in her first period RSP reading class, which met for 48 minutes five times weekly.(Footntoe 28) In this class, made up of 4 to 5 students, she used the SRA corrective reading program, which she described as a program of multisensory instruction. According to her, in this program, the students hear, say, and practice sounds; read materials with the same sound combination; and touch the first word, with reinforcement and repetition. She follows a script in the accompanying manual and also talks about vocabulary. At the end, the students complete a workbook exercise focused on word attack skills.
Educational therapist Ms. Moses testified, however, that the SRA corrective reading program did not specifically address auditory processing skills but rather permitted STUDENT to use his strong logical and sequential skills. Ms. White testified that the program was designed to assist students with an auditory processing difficulty. Moreover, school psychologist Ms. Taylor testified that the SRA corrective reading program addressed STUDENT’S auditory processing disorder. According to her, the result is seen in his increased reading scores.(Footnote 29) The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Taylor and Ms. White to be persuasive. The Hearing Officer finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the SRA corrective reading program used during the 2000-2001 school year addressed STUDENT’S auditory processing disorder.
Ms. White testified that she also was in STUDENT’S humanities classroom (a combination of language arts and social studies during the second and third periods) to provide needed services to about 6 RSP students, including STUDENT. According to her, she is available to help with strategies or provide an outline on how to do the class work, and, in consultation with the humanities teacher, she can provide help at a table in the classroom or take students out of the class to assist with, for example, test review. Ms. White testified that STUDENT had not needed that type of review. According to her, the humanities teacher felt that STUDENT was quite capable of taking the class tests because he was doing very well in the class. However, STUDENT had requested feedback and editing help with written assignments. Ms. White further testified that the humanities teacher did a fine job of working on the vocabulary in social studies, and the teacher had told her that STUDENT was doing fine without pull-out services. Ms. White also testified that the students are at an age when they are embarrassed by too much attention, so in the humanities class, she works with the RSP students when they are working in a group activity or when they go to her for assistance.
The reading program addressed STUDENT’S need for multisensory language instruction focused on sounds and word analysis skills. The RSP reading class met his need for small-group instruction. The in-class RSP services in the humanities class satisfied his need for assistance with class writing assignments. The Hearing Officer finds that the small RSP reading class in particular, supplemented by in-class RSP services in the humanities class on an as-needed basis, was designed to meet STUDENT’S needs in reading, spelling, written expression, and auditory processing.
The June 12 IEP also sets forth modifications, accommodations, and support, such as assignment modifications, use of a word processor, and consultation and collaboration between RSP and regular education teachers, which addressed his reading, spelling, and writing needs. Additional accommodations for reading and writing were to be allowed more time per test item; have directions read aloud; get help with difficult words, not meanings, except when assessing reading skills; have questions rephrased using fewer or less complex words; be provided with examples of procedures or concepts; be provided a simple outline for written essays; and be allowed to give oral responses as an alternative to a written exam if needed. These accommodations addressed STUDENT’S needs related to reading, writing, and spelling problems.
(b) February 7, 2001 IEP
A February 7, 2001 IEP was signed by the parent with exception. The parent indicated on the IEP that she felt that STUDENT required Lindamood Bell training to improve his spelling and auditory processing skills.(Footnote 30) The IEP sets forth one auditory processing skills goal to address STUDENT’S auditory processing deficit. The goal is to write a dictated sentence of at least seven words correctly 8 out of 10 times when presented at his vocabulary level.
The February 2001 IEP recommends in-class and pull-out RSP services for one hour daily. RSP teacher Ms. White testified that this was the current IEP, and it appears that this was the IEP that she was implementing. Her testimony indicated that she was continuing the program started pursuant to the June 2000 IEP. The testimony of Ms. White, school psychologist Ms. Taylor, and PDMS principal Mr. Nugent was essentially that at the time of the February 7, 2001 IEP meeting, STUDENT’S test scores and his teachers’ progress reports indicated good gains in the SRA corrective reading program with Ms. White and that it was appropriate to continue that program. The Hearing Officer concludes that during rest of the 2000-2001 school year, the February 2001 IEP was implemented to carry out the program that Ms. White started under the June 2000 IEP. Thus, it was designed to meet STUDENT’S reading, spelling, written language, and auditory processing needs, as discussed above. In addition, District program specialist Ms. Kelly testified that after the January 2001 WIAT testing, STUDENT’S spelling program was supplemented to include a greater emphasis on sound-symbol association, phonemic awareness, and prefixes and suffixes, and to teach spelling in the regular education curriculum.
The February 2001 IEP sets forth accommodations such as the use of a word processor and support such as collaboration between STUDENT’S special education and regular education teachers. These were designed to address STUDENT’S reading, spelling, and writing needs. Because he was to become age 14 in July 2001, the IEP contains a transition plan. The plan sets forth goals and objectives to improve written language, to be involved in community activities, to complete assignments on time, to follow verbal directions, and to explore career interests. This plan addressed his vocational needs, including those related to his pertinent deficit areas.
In conclusion, the RSP class, supplemented by in-class RSP services in the humanities class, and the accommodations and transition plan set forth in the IEPs were designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, specifically, his reading, spelling, writing, and auditory processing needs.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
As discussed above, determining whether a program is reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit requires examining a variety of measures, such as standardized test scores, teacher and staff observations, ratings on class work and tests, grade advancement, and progress on annual goals and short-term objectives.
STUDENT’S grade 7 report cards dated November 30, 2000 and March 18, 2001 reflect the following grades for the first two trimesters, respectively: reading,(Footnote 31) B, B+; P.E., C+, C; science, P, B; and math, B-, B+. In the first trimester, he obtained a B- for his yearbook class and in the second trimester, a B- for humanities. His grade point average (GPA) was a 2.75 for the first trimester and a 2.8 for the second trimester. The mother testified that the science teacher told her that STUDENT had obtained a D in science during the first trimester but that he received a P (passing) grade instead because the RSP teacher would not permit him to receive a D. According to the mother, a P, unlike a D, did not lower his GPA. However, she did testify that STUDENT subsequently was doing quite well in science. She noted that she had asked the RSP teacher to help him with the science vocabulary for 10 minutes a day during the reading class.
Although the last trimester was not yet over at the time of the hearing, the following evidence was presented of STUDENT’S level of work during this period. His science teacher, Ms. Wylie, testified that although he worked hard at his spelling, he had many spelling errors but that in her class, she was more concerned with the comprehension of concepts than spelling. According to her, he was doing A level work in her class at the time. The mother testified that the day before, STUDENT had told her that he was getting a C in humanities. She further testified, however, that he did not need to do grade-level work because his curriculum was modified. When STUDENT testified a few days later, he stated that he did not want to continue in RSP the following year because the work was made easier for him (for example, the assignments were shortened), and he thought that he would learn more if he was no longer in RSP. He also testified that recently he had obtained an F on a humanities test. Humanities teacher Mr. Ball testified that STUDENT had been in his class for only about three months because of a change in STUDENT’S class schedule. At first, Mr. Ball had asked resource specialist Ms. White to pull STUDENT out of the class several times to help him to focus in a small group on an assignment and to have quizzes read aloud to him, with leading questions asked, at Mr. Ball’s suggestion. Mr. Ball testified, however, that he had determined that STUDENT did not need these pull-out services. He further testified that STUDENT was doing C+ to B- level work in his class. Ms. White testified that in the humanities class, at STUDENT’S request, she had provided assistance with writing assignments. The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence establishes that for the most part, STUDENT was performing above-average work in his academic courses during the school year, although in science and humanities, he did receive some resource assistance, as provided for by his IEP.
Moreover, the WRAML and WIAT results from the January 2001 testing when STUDENT was age 13 years, 6 months, and in grade 7 revealed progress in most areas. His scaled score on the WRAML story memory subtest was a 6, the same as in May 1999. However, his scaled score on the sentence memory subtest improved from a 6 to a 7, and on the number-letter memory subtest from an 8 to a 10. School psychologist Ms. Taylor concluded that the WRAML scores showed some improvement in the auditory memory area.
The WIAT was also re-administered to STUDENT. A comparison of his May 31, 2000 and January 31, 2001 WIAT standard scores (in parentheses) and GE scores in reading, spelling, and writing reveals the following: 5/31/00 1/31/01
Basic Reading (75) 3.2 (89) 5.9 Reading Comprehension (94) 5.6 (96) 6.5 Spelling (73) 3.4 (71) 3.6 Written Expression (94) 5.9 (96) 6.9
Composite Reading (78) 4.1 (90) 6.1 Composite Writing (76) 4.0 (76) 4.3
In an approximately five-month instructional period, all of STUDENT’S standard scores increased except for his spelling and composite writing scores. He showed an increase in GE scores ranging from .2 in spelling to 2.7 in basic reading skills. District program specialist Ms. Kelly testified that after the January 2001 WIAT results were obtained, STUDENT’S spelling program was supplemented, as discussed above.
On April 6, 2001, Sylvan assessed STUDENT’S reading when he was in grade 7. He achieved the following CAT GE scores: Vocabulary, 5.3; Comprehension, 6.7; and Total Reading, 5.9. These scores are comparable to the January 2001 WIAT reading scores.
The February 7, 2001 IEP indicates that STUDENT had met his written language and reading decoding goals and objectives from the June 2000 IEP but had only partially met the auditory skills goal (he had met one objective but had only partially met the other objective in this area).(Footnote 32) RSP teacher Ms. White testified that STUDENT was inconsistent in the auditory skills area, and spelling was a problem. She further testified that he was still at the 70 to 80 percent level of accuracy but was getting closer to 90 percent on the remaining objective.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT progressed in basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and written expression, as reflected in his increased test scores and achievement of his reading and written language IEP goals. His improvement in spelling is more limited, but he did achieve one of his auditory skills objectives and is making progress on the other. As Ms. White testified, an auditory processing disability affects spelling, so this is an area that may require more time for STUDENT to show greater progress. He has been doing predominantly above-average work in his academic courses. Considering all of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s program during the 2000-2001 school year was reasonably calculated to, and did, bestow educational benefit on STUDENT.
(3) Conformed to the IEP
Petitioner argues that he did not receive daily dictation and copying exercises, as required by the June 2000 IEP goals and objectives. This IEP contains an auditory skills goal that by June 2001, STUDENT was to improve his auditory skills by oral exercises on a daily basis. One objective is, by November 2000, to write three dictated sentences of at least 7 words correctly on a daily basis. The second objective is, by April 2001, to write dictated sentences of at least seven words at the fourth-grade level with 90 percent accuracy on teacher-made tests. When asked whether he was doing dictation and copying exercises in his RSP class, STUDENT said that if that was reading something and answering questions about it, that’s what he was doing. When he was asked whether Ms. White read a sentence, which he then had to remember and write down, he said that he was not doing that. Upon being asked if he was given tests on dictation and copying, he said that he did not know. Ms. White was asked whether she was working on the second auditory skills objective, and she answered affirmatively. She acknowledged that STUDENT had not yet met this objective because, according to her, he was inconsistent and had a spelling problem, but stated that he was getting closer to 90 percent accuracy.
The Hearing Officer finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the auditory skills goal and objectives were implemented. The February 7, 2001 IEP, signed by the parent (with exceptions not pertinent here), indicates that this goal and the second objective were only partially met but that the first objective was met. The first objective, requiring daily dictation, needed to be achieved by November 2000, and there was no need to continue working on this objective after it was met. Ms. White’s undisputed testimony was that she was working on the second objective, requiring assessment by teacher-made tests. Thus, it is concluded that the program that was provided conformed to the IEP.
In summary, the District’s proposed program for the 2000-2001 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, and conformed to the IEP. Therefore, the District provided STUDENT a FAPE during this school year.
ISSUE 3: Does a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year require a multisensory language arts program such as Lindamood Bell?
On the first day of hearing, Petitioner indicated that he asserted the denial of a FAPE through the 2001-2002 school year. The February 7, 2001 IEP states that it is effective from February 2, 2001 to February 7, 2002. According to the testimony of RSP teacher Ms. White, during the 2000-2001 school year, the February 7 IEP was implemented similarly to the June 12, 2000 IEP in that the same RSP program started in the fall was continued to the end of the school year. However, the February 2001 IEP states that the RSP services would be both in-class and pull-out for one hour daily, whereas the June 2000 IEP provides for only pull-out, not in-class, RSP services for one hour daily. The February 2001 IEP does not specify the amount of pull-out (in contrast to in-class) services. Neither party presented testimony that addressed the difference between the two IEPs, and no witness testified as to how the RSP program proposed in the February 7 IEP would be implemented during the coming school year given this difference. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer determines that the issue of whether a FAPE was offered for the 2001-2002 school year is not ripe for a decision and, therefore, will not be addressed.
Petitioner asserts, however, that he requires a multisensory language arts program such as Lindamood Bell to improve his auditory processing and spelling skills. (Petitioner’s Brief at 2, 8, 9.) He, in essence, is contending that such a program, in contrast to a program like the SRA corrective reading program provided during the past school year, is one of his unique needs. The District argues that it determines methodology. “[O]nce a court determines that the requirements of the Act have been met, questions of methodology are for resolution by the States.” Rowley, 458 U.S. at 208 (stating that courts lack the “specialized knowledge and experience” necessary to resolve “persistent and difficult questions of educational policy”). Although it was determined above that the question of whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year is not yet ripe for a decision, the Hearing Officer will address whether a multisensory program such as the Lindamood Bell program is one of STUDENT’S unique needs.
From the time that STUDENT was found eligible for special education because of an SLD, he was known to have an auditory processing disorder. School psychologist Ms. Taylor, who administered the WRAML verbal memory index to STUDENT in January 2001, testified that he had phonological and auditory processing disorders, which affected his speech articulation and spelling. She testified that the WRAML results indicated that he continued to have difficulty in the auditory memory area, particularly in listening comprehension and with memory for details read aloud. School psychologist Dr. Matthews also testified that her May 1999 assessment revealed that STUDENT had delays in auditory memory and thus had difficulty remembering what was said to him, especially as the communication became more complex. At the hearing, she recommended a multisensory program such as Slingerland or Lindamood Bell. STUDENT’S seventh grade RSP teacher, Ms. White, also testified that he needed a multisensory approach. Her undisputed testimony was that the SRA corrective reading program that she used with him provided multisensory instruction.
Petitioner contends, however, that he requires a Lindamood Bell type of program to address his auditory processing and spelling needs. Ms. Moses testified that the Lindamood Bell program focuses on processing sound and visual stimuli and can help STUDENT spell better. As discussed above under Issue 2.d., the Hearing Officer found that the SRA corrective reading program used by the District addressed STUDENT’S auditory processing disorder. Ms. Taylor testified that he had made limited progress in spelling because spelling is a difficult area to remediate for someone with a phonological processing disorder. Dr. Matthews testified that she did not know if the Lindamood Bell program would address a spelling problem. According to her, in middle school and high school, spelling generally is not addressed per se but is part of the editing process in writing. STUDENT’S auditory processing and spelling needs have long been identified. As discussed above under Issue 2, the District’s program during the 2000-2001 school year addressed his needs in the areas of auditory processing and spelling, as well as his need for multisensory instruction. He continues to need a program that addresses his auditory processing disorder and spelling problem. However, the Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient evidence that the Lindamood Bell program, apart from other multisensory programs that address an auditory processing disorder, is one of STUDENT’S unique needs at this time.(Footnote 33)
ISSUE 4: If the District denied Petitioner a FAPE from March 12, 1998, through the end of the 2000-2001 school year, is he entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational services, including the cost of transportation, obtained at the following: a. Sylvan Learning Center?
b. Discovery House?
Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the costs of educational services his parent incurred by enrolling him at the Sylvan Learning Center (Sylvan) during summer 1999 and at the Discovery House during the 1999-2000 school year, summer 2000, and September and October 2000. The District contends that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for these costs because the parent failed to give the requisite ten days’ notice of her intent to seek reimbursement prior to the unilateral placement at these two programs.
The amount of reimbursement for a private school placement may be reduced or denied if, either at least 10 business days prior to removing the child from the public school, or at the most recent IEP meeting that the parents attended prior to removing their child from the public school, the parents did not inform the District that they were rejecting the District’s proposed placement, including stating their concerns and their intent to enroll their child in a private school at public expense. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii)(I); Cal. Educ. Code § 56176(a), (b). However, the amount of reimbursement may not be reduced or denied for failure to so notify the District if the parent was not notified of the reimbursement notice requirement. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iv)(IV).(Footnote 34) Here, the notice of parents’ rights which the parent received in 1996 was admitted as an exhibit, and she testified that she received a six-page notice of parents’ rights, which was in bigger print and thus easier to read, at the June 2000 IEP meeting. However, no District witness testified, and no evidence was presented, that the notice of parents’ rights informed the parent of the reimbursement notice requirement.(Footnote 35) Therefore, the parent’s failure to give notice of her intent to seek reimbursement for the unilateral placement at the two programs should not preclude her from such reimbursement if otherwise appropriate.
When a school district has denied a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to appropriate relief in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 369; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for educational services that they obtained for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate program and services, and the program or services obtained by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. The Hearing Officer found that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years.
a. Sylvan Learning Center
Petitioner requests reimbursement for the reading instruction he received at Sylvan during summer 1999. The District argues that he is not entitled to reimbursement for Sylvan services during summer 1999 because the IEP team had not recommended extended school year (ESY) services for him during the summer. The May 1999 IEP that was in effect from May 1999 to May 2000 does not provide for ESY services during summer 1999. The mother testified that she did not ask the District for summer school for STUDENT during summer 1999.(Footnote 36) ESY services are generally provided where the student requires consistent services to address a continuing problem to avoid a regression which would impede his educational progress. Petitioner has not established that he required ESY services during summer 1999. Because the May 1999 IEP team did not identify ESY services as a needed service, Petitioner was not entitled to ESY services during summer 1999. Consequently, he is not entitled to reimbursement for educational services provided by Sylvan during this period.
b. Discovery House
Petitioner also requests reimbursement for the educational therapy he received at the Discovery House during the 1999-2000 school year, summer 2000, and September and October 2000. The District argues that the educational therapy was, at best, in the nature of a related service, and STUDENT did not need the therapy to benefit from his proffered educational program. However, the Hearing Officer found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year. Thus, he may be entitled to reimbursement if otherwise appropriate. Each of the three time periods for which Petitioner seeks reimbursement will be addressed in turn.
(1) 1999-2000 school year
The question is whether the placement at the Discovery House was appropriate under the IDEA. The mother testified that STUDENT received educational therapy from Ms. Moses at the Discovery House twice weekly for 80-minute sessions.(Footnote 37) On alternate days, the mother did the program with STUDENT at home. Ms. Moses testified that she is an educational therapist certified by the NILD(Footnote 38) and has been working with learning disabled students for 10 years.(Footnote 39) She further testified that she has been trained in the Lindamood Bell program and has much experience using its techniques. She testified that she uses NILD deficit stimulation and Lindamood Bell language processing techniques in her educational therapy and that students are in educational therapy for an average of three to four years. According to her, in educational therapy, deficit stimulation, which is neurologically-based, involves changing the way the brain functions so that a student who is not an efficient learner can function more efficiently. She testified that deficit stimulation is not concerned with content mastery, although content is used because the student must think about something while learning how to think.(Footnote 40)
Ms. Moses testified that STUDENT has auditory processing, auditory perceptual, and language processing problems. He also has problems with visual imagery and symbol imagery and has difficulty remembering what a word looks like. She testified that because of STUDENT’S relatively older age, she first used Lindamood Bell techniques with him, and he responded rapidly and well. According to her, Lindamood Bell techniques isolate the identification and sequencing of sounds so that a student cannot use language centers and visual tricks to compensate but rather must work in a deficit area. Ms. Moses testified that she first worked on STUDENT’S ability to discriminate and sequence sounds in our language. Initially, he was not able to identify or sequence sounds, but when he left her program, he was sequencing five sounds accurately and was also able to do multiple sounds within multi-syllables. Ms. Moses testified that the amount of progress with deficit stimulation depends upon the combination and degree of deficits. According to her, STUDENT was just getting a good start in deficit stimulation when he stopped the sessions with her.
STUDENT testified that Ms. Moses had him do rhythmic writing–for example, he would follow the lines of the number 8, would be asked math problems, and would again follow the lines of the number 8, perhaps changing the direction and moving from right to left. He also worked with blocks with different letters and was asked to change a word made with blocks by using a different prefix or suffix and was then asked what had changed. He said that was hard to do. Ms. Moses also read STUDENT a story in five parts. She would read the first part and then have him tell her the first part. Then she would read the second part, and he would have to tell her both the first and second parts. He said that it was hard to do that. He also read to her. STUDENT testified that Ms. Moses’ program was harder than the resource programs that he had been provided in school and that it was not boring.
STUDENT’S unique needs were identified under Issue 2 above. The Discovery House program provided one-on-one instruction and thus addressed his need for small-group instruction. Further, through the use of Lindamood Bell techniques, the program was designed to address his auditory processing and auditory discrimination needs and improve his ability to discriminate and sequence sounds in language. In addition, other techniques, such as rhythmic writing and using blocks to break words down into roots, prefixes and suffixes, met his need for a multisensory approach, including the tactile sense. Another technique of having STUDENT listen to a story in parts and then remember and re-tell it in parts addressed his auditory memory need. A May 29, 2000 annual report by Ms. Moses sets forth the results of evaluative testing conducted in April and May 2000. The report lists the particular tasks that STUDENT was able to perform or skills that he possessed, abilities that he was improving, and tasks with which he still displayed difficulty in the areas of personality, visual motor, visual perception, auditory perception, language, and thinking. In the area of visual perception, STUDENT was improving his use of visual imagery for spelling and language comprehension and was improving his visual attention to detail. In the auditory perception area, STUDENT had greatly improved his ability to identify and sequence sounds in words up to two syllables and was not distracted by sounds in or beyond the immediate environment. In addition, he was improving his ability to discriminate accent in a syllable and discriminate between loud and soft volume, and he was making fewer discrimination errors in conversation with the therapist. He was also improving his ability to follow oral instructions, including a series of instructions; to repeat dictated sentences; and to identify linguistic patterns. However, he still had difficulty making the sound-symbol association for spelling (errors of omission and substitution).
In the language area, STUDENT was improving the quality of his articulation (he spoke up more without prompting and with more clarity) and his ability to articulate the “r” sound. He also was improving his knowledge of, and ability to use, vocabulary, including working with multiple meanings of words. In addition, he was improving his ability to generate a complete sentence with correct usage and to elaborate (using modifiers, phrases, and clauses). He also was improving his ability to understand nuances in words and to draw conclusions, make inferences, and understand implications for reading comprehension. However, he still had difficulty applying the rules for plurals, possessives, prefixes, suffixes, and verb tense in both oral and written language. The evaluation report indicates that STUDENT made progress in visual and auditory perception, language use, and vocabulary.
STUDENT was administered the WIAT in May 1999, before he started the Discovery House program, and in May 2000, at the end of the school year that he attended the Discover House program twice weekly. Comparing STUDENT’S May 14, 1999 and May 31, 2000 WIAT standard scores (in parentheses) and GE scores in reading, spelling, and writing discloses the following:
5/14/99 5/31/00
Basic Reading (79) 3.0 (75) 3.2 Reading Comprehension (90) 4.5 (94) 5.6 Spelling (71) 2.6 (73) 3.4 Written Expression (88) 3.9 (94) 5.9
Composite Reading None given (78) 4.1 Composite Writing None given (76) 4.0
Although STUDENT’S basic reading score showed limited progress in this area, his reading comprehension went up more than one grade level, and his written expression increased two grade levels. Moreover, his score in spelling, an area of great difficulty for him, also showed a .8 grade level increase, which was relatively high compared to his progress during other years.
The May 2000 Discovery House evaluation report and May 2000 WIAT results reveal that the Discovery House program of twice-weekly educational therapy sessions was reasonably calculated to, and did, bestow educational benefit on STUDENT. Thus, the Discovery House program was appropriate under the IDEA. Consequently, the parent is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the Discovery House program during the 1999-2000 school year, including related fees and the cost of transportation.
(2) Summer 2000 ESY session
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that the District’s summer 2000 ESY program was an appropriate program. Therefore, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the Discovery House program during summer 2000.
(3) September and October 2000
The mother testified that STUDENT attended Discovery House sessions during September and at the beginning of October 2000. The District argues that the parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the Discovery House program during September 2000 because, although she gave notice of her intent to seek reimbursement for Discovery House services because of the alleged unavailability of a resource specialist for (STUDENT, RSP teacher Ms. White was at PDMS 10 days later.
A September 8, 2000 letter from the parent to the District states that because the District did not have a resource person able to provide the “necessary Auditory Processing work” that STUDENT required, the parent had enrolled him in a private program with a therapist for work in the Lindamood Bell and NILD programs to address his auditory and visual sequential memory processing deficit. The letter states that the parent expected reimbursement for the expenses. The mother testified that at the fall 2000 registration, she was informed that Ms. White, who was to be STUDENT’S RSP teacher, had transferred to another school. However, Ms. White testified that she returned to PDMS on September 18, 2000, and met with STUDENT’S class on that day.(Footnote 41) Thus, since the parent’s reason for the unilateral placement was a concern about the lack of an RSP teacher for STUDENT’S reading class, the reason no longer existed with the return of Ms. White on September 18. Consequently, despite the parent’s notice, no basis exists for reimbursement for the cost of the Discovery House program from September 18, 2000 on.
As for the period before September 18, Ms. Wilson, who was a PDMS RSP teacher for primarily grade 7 students during the 2000-2001 school year, testified that in fall 2000, when STUDENT returned to PDMS for grade 7, school started on September 4 or 5. According to PDMS principal Mr. Nugent, PDMS has four RSP teachers and Ms. Wilson initially was overseeing STUDENT’S case in terms of scheduling (he wanted a yearbook elective class) and an appropriate reading program. According to Ms. Wilson’s testimony, because the mother wanted STUDENT to have certain electives and also a reading class, a decision apparently was made to “split” his double-period humanities class to accommodate all of his classes. Ms. Wilson further testified that during the first week of school, students with learning disabilities receive orientation, not direct services. STUDENT acknowledged that his schedule was changed at the beginning of the school year. He further testified that Ms. White was his RSP teacher from the first day of class. From the foregoing, the Hearing Officer determines that no basis exists for reimbursement for Discovery House services before September 18. In summary, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for Discovery House expenses during September and October 2000.
ISSUE 5: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following costs incurred during the period of home schooling: a. Lindamood Bell Seeing Stars materials?
b. The parent’s Lindamood Bell training?
c. School supplies during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years?
The mother requests reimbursement for the costs of the Lindamood Bell Seeing Stars program which she purchased during the last three months of the 1998-1999 school year and the workshop fees, book fees, and transportation mileage related to the six-day Lindamood Bell training she took during summer 1999. In addition, she requests reimbursement for school supplies, including books and teaching materials, during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years, when she home-schooled STUDENT. She acknowledged that the Seeing Stars program, Lindamood Bell training, teaching materials, and school supplies were to instruct both STUDENT and his brother during the period of home schooling. Therefore, reimbursement for any of these items would be fifty percent of the actual cost, which would represent the cost of home schooling STUDENT only.
a. Lindamood Bell Seeing Stars materials
When a school district has denied a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to appropriate relief in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 369; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for educational expenses that they incurred when the school district failed to provide an appropriate program and services, and the program or services obtained by the parents for their child were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370.
The mother testified that during the last three months of the 1998-1999 school year, she ordered and purchased the Seeing Stars portion of the Lindamood Bell program for use with STUDENT. According to her, the Seeing Stars program teaches sight words and involves the use of flash cards for words and spelling charts, and some tracing and visualizing. The Seeing Stars program was designed to improve STUDENT’S reading ability, particularly in the area of sight, and thus met his need in this area. It helped to carry out his IEP reading goal and objectives. Moreover, the mother testified that she thought that the program helped to improve STUDENT’S reading ability. The May 1999 WIAT results reveal that STUDENT’S reading comprehension went up to the 4.5 GE level. School psychologist Dr. Matthews testified that in May 1999, reading was not identified as an area of need for STUDENT because of his high level of comprehension. Although STUDENT’S basic reading skills score was still low in May 1999, his comprehension did show a marked improvement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program was appropriate, and the parent is entitled to reimbursement for fifty percent of the cost of the program, the amount attributable to use of the program with STUDENT.
b. The parent’s Lindamood Bell training
The mother testified that in summer 1999 she received six days of Lindamood Bell training in Pasadena before she enrolled STUDENT in the Discovery House program. According to her, she tried to use Lindamood Bell techniques with (STUDENT, but it was very difficult for him. In fall 1999, she enrolled him in the Discovery House program. Ms. Moses testified that she uses both deficit stimulation and Lindamood Bell techniques in her educational therapy at the Discovery House. There is little evidence that the mother utilized her Lindamood Bell training, apart from the Seeing Stars program, in the home-schooling program she provided to STUDENT. Moreover, Petitioner cites no authority that the cost of training a parent or tutor who provides home schooling is reimbursable under the IDEA.(Footntoe 42) In this case, the evidence establishes that the parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her Lindamood Bell training.
c. School supplies during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years
The parent requests reimbursement for the cost of school supplies used in the home schooling program she provided to STUDENT during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years. The Hearing Officer determined that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during both of these school years. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the parent’s 1999 purchase of the Lindamood Bell Seeing Stars program and the Discovery House educational therapy STUDENT received during the 1999-2000 school year. Little evidence was presented of the remainder of the home schooling program in terms of whether it was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs and was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. Therefore, because there is insufficient evidence that the remainder of the home schooling program was appropriate, the request for reimbursement for the cost of school supplies is denied.
ISSUE 6: If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE, is he entitled to compensatory education?
Because the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years, he is entitled to appropriate relief. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i); Burlington, 471 U.S. at 369. Compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. at 1497. Equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; Student W., 31 F.3d at 1496.
As set forth above, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT was entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the Lindamood Bell Seeing Stars program his parent purchased for use in the home schooling program in the last three months of the 1998-1999 school year and the Discovery House educational therapy he received during the 1999-2000 school year. However, he is also entitled to appropriate relief for the denial of a FAPE for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year. Because of the denial of a FAPE, STUDENT has substantial auditory processing needs. The Hearing Officer finds that he is entitled to compensatory education for lost educational services.
The Hearing Officer found in Issue 3 that a program such as Lindamood Bell is not specifically one of STUDENT’S unique needs. However, to address the denial of a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year, he requires intensive auditory processing training beyond what he would receive as part of a FAPE. The Hearing Officer finds that instruction in a program that specifically addresses auditory processing, such as Lindamood Bell or an equivalent program, is appropriate relief as compensatory education. RSP teacher Ms. Wilson testified that Lindamood Bell is a reading program based upon auditory processing which utilizes a highly multisensory approach and works on improving auditory discrimination and auditory processing skills.(Footnote 43) She testified that if a student with an auditory processing problem practiced auditory processing skills through a program like Lindamood Bell, he could improve those skills. School psychologist Dr. Matthews recommended for STUDENT a multisensory program such as Slingerland or Lindamood Bell.
The District may use its own staff trained in Lindamood Bell or comparable techniques or use a private service provider with the requisite training. Instructional services in this program shall be provided from the date of the IEP meeting called for in Item 5 of the Hearing Officer’s Order through the end of the District’s second trimester of the 2001-2002 school year. The amount and frequency shall be determined by the IEP team, considering STUDENT’S schedule and tolerance for additional services. In determining the amount of such services, the IEP team should consider that STUDENT was denied a FAPE for approximately six months, and remediation may take time given his severe deficit. The IEP team shall also determine the appropriate credentials for the service provider.
ISSUE 7: Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the April 2001 assessment conducted by the Sylvan Learning Center?
A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student from a qualified specialist, at public expense, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the District, unless the District shows at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).
Petitioner requests reimbursement for the April 2001 Sylvan assessment.(Footnote 44) He does not argue that his parent disagreed with the District’s assessments or that the assessments were inappropriate, and, if so, in what ways they were inappropriate. In any event, no evidence was presented that the parent disagreed with any of the District’s assessments that fall within the statutory limitation period going back to March 12, 1998 (that is, the May 1999 triennial assessment conducted by school psychologist Dr. Matthews and RSP teacher Ms. Wilson; the May 2000 academic assessment by RSP teacher Ms. White; and the January 2001 psychological and academic assessments conducted by school psychologist Ms. Taylor and Ms. White). Moreover, even if the parent had disagreed with any of the pertinent assessments, the evidence, including the testimony of the District’s witnesses such as Dr. Matthews, Ms. Taylor, Ms. Wilson, Ms. White, and program specialist Ms. Kelly, establishes that the assessments were conducted in conformance with the requirements of the law and are thus appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320, 56322, 56324. Consequently, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the April 2001 Sylvan assessment.
ORDER
1. Petitioner’s claims arising prior to March 12, 1998 are barred by the statute of limitations.
2. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the cost of the Discovery House educational therapy provided to him during the 1999-2000 school year (excluding the summer 2000 ESY session), including application, materials, and other related fees. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for these costs.
3. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the actual number of sessions that he attended at the Discovery House during the 1999-2000 school year (excluding the summer 2000 ESY session), and the round trip mileage for these sessions. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for transportation mileage for each session that he actually attended at the Discovery House during the school year at the rate the District reimburses its employees.
4. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the cost of the Lindamood Bell Seeing Stars program his mother used with him during the last three months of the 1998-1999 school year. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for fifty percent of this cost, which is the amount attributable to the mother’s use of this program with STUDENT.
5. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate compensatory education plan for Petitioner. Commencing with the date of the IEP meeting and continuing until the end of the District’s second trimester of the 2001-2002 school year, he shall be entitled to compensatory education in the form of instruction in a program like Lindamood Bell or an equivalent program that specifically addresses auditory processing skills. The IEP team shall determine the amount and frequency of these compensatory education services, taking into account the denial of a FAPE for approximately six months, the length of time improvement in this area will require, and Petitioner’s schedule and tolerance for additional services. The IEP team shall also determine appropriate credentials for the service provider.
6. All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Does the statute of limitations bar Petitioner’s claims arising prior to March 12, 1998? The District prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District offer Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the following periods: a. From March 12, 1998, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year? The District prevailed on this sub-issue.
b. During the 1998-1999 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue.
c. During the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 extended school year (ESY) session? Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue with respect to the 1999-2000 school year; the District prevailed with respect to the summer 2000 ESY session. d. During the 2000-2001 school year?
The District prevailed on this sub-issue.
3. Does a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year require a multisensory language arts program such as Lindamood Bell? The District prevailed on this issue.
4. If the District denied Petitioner a FAPE from March 12, 1998, through the end of the 2000-2001 school year, is he entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational services, including the cost of transportation, obtained at the following: a. Sylvan Learning Center?
The District prevailed on this sub-issue.
b. Discovery House?
Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue with regard to the 1999-2000 school year; the District prevailed with respect to summer 2000 and September and October 2000. 5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following costs incurred during the period of home schooling: a. Lindamood Bell Seeing Stars materials?
Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue.
b. The parent’s Lindamood Bell training?
The District prevailed on this sub-issue.
c. School supplies during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years? The District prevailed on this sub-issue.
6. If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE, is he entitled to compensatory education? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
7. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the April 2001 assessment conducted by the Sylvan Learning Center? The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: September 11, 2001 ____________________________________ Judy F. Hirano, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1.Please note that the Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number. 2.On the first day of hearing, Petitioner’s attorney clarified that the time period alleged for the denial of a FAPE was from 1996, when STUDENT was first found eligible for special education. The District argued that the three-year statute of limitations barred any claims prior to March 12, 1998. Petitioner’s attorney reserved the right to do further research to ascertain whether an exception to the limitation period applied in this case. Issue 3 is a reframing of Petitioner’s issue 3 and proposed resolution in his statement of issues related to whether the District should be required to provide STUDENT a program such as Lindamood Bell. The District withdrew its issue 4 related to whether a prior settlement agreement between the parties resolved some or all of the issues presented in this case. The remaining issues have been clarified and their order changed to facilitate the analysis. 3.At the hearing, Dr. Matthews acknowledged typographical or editing errors in her report. She admitted that the word “no” should be deleted from the following sentence on page 4 of her report: “There appears to be no severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in spelling and written language.” She also acknowledged that the word “not” should be deleted from another statement, also on page 4: “ . . . [STUDENT] does not qualify as a child with exceptional needs under the current criteria.” 4.On the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery-Revised, he achieved the following standard and GE scores, respectively: Broad Reading, 89, 5.0; Broad Math, 113, 9.2; and Broad Written Language, 78, 3.6. 5. The IEP states that he still had problems with the “r” sound but was able to self-correct when cued. 6. Although Petitioner appears to make an implicit relation-back argument (that is, that the current due process hearing somehow relates back to the prior closed proceeding), he cites no authority that such a doctrine applies in a special education due process hearing and alleges no facts to support the application of the doctrine even if it did. 7. In his closing brief, Petitioner contends that the District’s failure to carry out the above acts constitutes violations of procedural safeguards. However, the Hearing Officer determines that these contentions are more properly addressed in a discussion of the substantive appropriateness of the District’s proposed program. In addition, Petitioner’s attorney acknowledged that speech was not at issue in this hearing. Thus, the speech goals and services are not addressed in the FAPE analysis. 8. A new IEP was developed on May 13, 1998, but because it looks primarily to the following school year, it will not be addressed for the 1997-1998 school year. 9. Ms. Kreger testified that she has a master’s degree in special education with a special emphasis in reading disorders. 10. She described a multisensory program as one in which the children “read it, say it, see it, and hear it.” 11. There is no evidence of the number of students in Ms. Kreger’s class, but the parent has not argued that the class size was excessive. 12. STUDENT’S reading recognition progress cannot be ascertained because no grade level was given for May 1997 as a basis of comparison. 13. In her time line of events, the mother indicates that the 1997 reading goals and objectives were the same as those in 1996. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 1.) However, this contention goes to the appropriateness of the 1996-1997 school year, which is not at issue here. 14. The May 1997 IEP provides for accommodations for STUDENT in testing situations for reading, writing, and social studies. It does not, however, provide for differential grading standards. 15. The public school agency need only provide a proportionate share of federal funds to children voluntarily enrolled in a private school. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(A)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.453; e.g., Russman v. Board of Educ., 150 F.3d 219, 221-22 (2d Cir. 1998), cited in KDM V. Reedsport School Dist., 196 F.3d 1046, 1049 (9th Cir. 1999), cert. denied, 121 S.Ct. 564 (2000). 16. The mother testified that she filed the pertinent affidavit in October 1999. See Cal. Educ. Code § 33190. However, she also testified that during the 1998-1999 school year, she transferred STUDENT to the District home- school program, and he continued to receive weekly speech therapy at PDMS. Thus, if the home-schooling program she provided was not transformed into a private school program by the filing of the requisite affidavit, it appears that it was a public school program for purposes of entitlement to special education. 17. The 1997 amendment of the IDEA imposed on parents, for reimbursement purposes, a requirement that they provide timely notice of a rejection of the District’s proposed program and an intent to enroll their child in a private school at public expense. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii)(I). However, California Education Code Section 56176, requiring a parent to give such notice to the District, did not become effective until January 1, 1999. The state statute is more protective of parents’ rights and thus governs here. Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 512 U.S. 965 (1994) (state procedures that impose a greater duty to educate children with disabilities, if not inconsistent with federal standards, are enforceable under the IDEA). 18. Ms. Wilson testified that she has a master’s degree in special education. According to her, she has worked with learning disabled students for over 20 years. She has been a resource specialist in California since 1989 but prior to that was a learning disability specialist in Colorado 19. In fall 2000, when STUDENT returned to public school as a seventh grader at PDMS, he was again provided one period of an RSP class that provided small-group instruction in a multisensory reading program, according to the testimony of his RSP teacher that year, Ms. White. 20. The District’s proposed program was thus not the least restrictive environment (LRE) that would have provided a FAPE. 21. By the 1999-2000 school year, State law required prior notice of an intent to enroll the child in a private school at public expense for reimbursement purposes. This matter will be discussed below in addressing the parent’s reimbursement request. 22. The District further argues that because the reading goal in the May 1998 IEP was not met, it could have been continued to the next school year. However, the District has set forth no reason why the reading goal in the May 1998 IEP was not re-stated in the May 1999 IEP if it was to be continued for another year. 23. As a result, the District’s program was not the LRE that would have provided him a FAPE. 24. The IEP states that STUDENT would miss the first week but would attend the last three weeks of summer school. According to the mother, it is difficult for STUDENT to attend summer school because he spends a portion of the summer with his father. 25. Because Petitioner requests reimbursement for the cost of the summer 2000 session at the Discovery House, it is necessary to address whether the District’s summer 2000 ESY program was an appropriate program. 26. Program specialist Ms. Kelly testified that the Open Court program is designed for the elementary school level. 27. The parent indicated that she consented to the IEP except for the issues of reimbursement for past educational expenses and of eight NILD Discovery House sessions during the summer. 28. Ms. White is a resource specialist half-time at PDMS and half-time at Washington Charter School. She has a master’s degree in reading and language, a learning handicapped special education credential, and an RSP certificate. She has taught in California for approximately 15 years and prior to that was a teacher in Oklahoma for 4 years. According to her, she received training in the SRA corrective reading program in fall 2000, and prior to coming to the District had used Project Read, which is based on phonics and the auditory discrimination of sounds. 29. Ms. Taylor explained that an educational program targets an auditory processing disorder through a structured, systematic approach to develop the sound-symbol correlation or the association of movement with sound. She testified that first one sound is taught, and when that sound is mastered, another sound is taught. She testified that a student can learn to break down unfamiliar words by learning to pair sounds with symbols. The result, according to her, would be an increase in reading level. 30. The parent also indicated that she sought to be reimbursed for past educational expenses before the District started the corrective reading program. 31. The report card for the second trimester shows a C grade for reading crossed out and a B+ handwritten in its place. Ms. White testified that Ms. Cabe, whose name is on the report card, is the teacher of record for the reading class. According to Ms. White, the wrong grade for the reading class was recorded, and as soon as she learned of the error, she had the grade corrected to a B+. 32. The February 2001 IEP indicates that two auditory skills objectives were met and the last was only partially met. However, because the June 2000 IEP contains only two objectives, it is assumed that one was met and the other was partially met. The objective that STUDENT only partially met was by April 2001 to write 8 dictated sentences of at least 7 words at the fourth-grade level with 90 percent accuracy, as measured by teacher-made tasks. 33. The District correctly argues that it has no responsibility under the IDEA to “cure” STUDENT’S disability or to ensure that he performs at his grade level. Its obligation is to offer an educational program that meets his unique needs and is reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89. 34. The District correctly argues that it has no responsibility under the IDEA to “cure” STUDENT’S disability or to ensure that he performs at his grade level. Its obligation is to offer an educational program that meets his unique needs and is reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89. 35. California Education Code Section 56500.1(b) provides that at each IEP meeting, the District responsible for convening the meeting shall inform the parent and student of the federal and state procedural safeguards that were provided in the notice of parent rights pursuant to Section 56321. California Education Code Section 56321(a), which specifically requires that a copy of the notice of parent rights be attached to a proposed assessment plan, states that the notice of parent rights must include a written explanation of the procedural safeguards under the IDEA and the rights and procedures contained in Chapter 5, commencing with Section 56500. Section 56321(a) further states that the notice shall include, among other things, information related to the procedure for requesting a due process hearing, the time line for the process, whether the process is optional, and the type of representative who may be invited to participate. Section 56321 does not specifically mention notice of the requirements if the parent intends to seek reimbursement for a private placement. Because the California Education Code does not specifically mention notice of the requirements for a unilateral private placement at public expense, it cannot be assumed that the copy of rights provided to the parent here at the IEP meetings included notice of the reimbursement notice requirement, absent affirmative proof. 36. According to the mother, it was difficult for STUDENT to attend summer school because he spent six weeks with his father during the summer. 37. The mother testified that the Discovery House program has no affiliation with the Christian School of the Desert, although it is located adjacent to it. She further testified that the Discovery House program does not contain religious instruction. STUDENT also testified that Ms. Moses did not teach religion in her program. 38. Ms. Moses testified that the NILD, with headquarters in Norfolk, Virginia, is an international organization that is in almost all the states and approximately two dozen countries and is designed to work inside the school system of private Christian schools to offer deficit stimulation for learning disabled students. 39. Ms. Moses testified that she has no California teaching credential or special education credential but was a full-time classroom teacher for grades 3, 5, and 6 for eight to nine years at the Christian School of the Desert (which is accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges). She also was a relief teacher in junior high and high school for a couple of years. She testified that she used the SRA program as a classroom teacher. 40. Ms. Moses testified that although students improve rapidly in content areas used, improvement in the academic area is not the purpose of deficit stimulation. Rather, the purpose is to make the learner independent so that he does not need modifications in the curriculum or instruction. 41. Ms. White testified that she was trained in the SRA corrective reading program on Wednesday and Thursday of the week that she returned to PDMS. 42. The Hearing Officer does not determine whether in another case, with different circumstances, such training might not be reimbursable. 43. Ms. Wilson testified that as part the program for her master’s degree in special education, she reviewed many reading programs, including Lindamood Bell. 44. On the first day of hearing, Petitioner identified the April 6, 2001 Sylvan assessment of STUDENT as an assessment for which he sought reimbursement, in addition to expenses listed in Petitioner’s Exhibit 12. Among the itemized Sylvan expenses in Exhibit 12 is a $75.00 testing fee for STUDENT. However, no testimony was presented as to which testing session is referred to or when the testing was done. Because there is insufficient evidence with respect to this testing fee, the request for this amount will not be addressed.
