California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 25, 1996

Student v. San Luis Coastal Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 490-94 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

San Luis Coastal Unified must give a deaf-blind student 30 weekly teacher hours, more interpreter time, and a case manager.

Split decision: student prevailed on 7 of 18 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The 1994 request was taken off calendar after an interim mediation agreement on August 25, 1994, and was re-calendared at Student's counsel's request on April 22, 1996. No appeal or remand is noted.

Summary

A 14-year-old deaf-blind student about to start high school filed for due process against San Luis Coastal Unified School District over her transition IEP. The case was first filed in 1994 and put back on calendar in 1996. She has normal cognitive potential, uses sign language and spoken English, reads large print and braille, and attends general education classes with support. The main dispute was how many hours her special education teacher and sign-language interpreter should work. The District offered a 60% teacher (about 21.5 hours a week) and an interpreter for four class periods a day. Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found the teacher hours too low and ordered 30 hours a week. She relied on deaf-blind education experts Blair Roger and Steven Perreault and on the student's teacher and interpreter from the prior year. She also ordered at least 1.5 more interpreter hours a day, so the student would have an interpreter at lunch and the interpreter would have time to prepare and meet with the team. She required a case manager, monthly support-team meetings, staff awareness training before school started, and a social-skills objective, but she did not require the Circle of Friends program. She also ordered a plan to assess assistive technology needs. She denied individual speech therapy and most other proposed objectives and IEP components. She did not award compensatory education because the District had already committed to a five-year high school plan.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated case management as a related service for a student with complex needs. It also shows SEHO setting specific staffing hours based on expert and staff testimony. The Hearing Officer added a needed social-skills objective but left the choice of teaching method to the district.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue I(A)(1). Must the IEP include the objective: Student will participate in a minimum of three regular education classes each semester?

    Not an objective, and the IEP already specifies three regular education classes; not required.

  2. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue I(A)(2). Must the IEP include an objective that by October 1, 1996, Student will participate in an evaluation of present math and reading levels, with new objectives written afterward?

    Everyone agreed current academic levels are unknown, but the statement is not a measurable step toward a goal and does not belong in the IEP as an objective.

  3. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue I(A)(3). Must the IEP include an objective for participation with deaf and deaf-blind people and events and assisting the mother in accessing funds for AADB functions and camps?

    No persuasive evidence that the objective supports any goal or is required for FAPE.

  4. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue I(A)(4). Must the IEP include the objective: Student will participate as an active member in a social circle that meets regularly and demonstrate the ability to communicate and problem solve in social situations?

    Student needs a formal, structured social-skills program and the IEP had no objective supporting its social goal, so the objective must be added; the District chooses the method and need not use Circle of Friends.

  5. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue I(A)(5). Must the IEP include the objective: Student will participate in discussions and development of her IEP as appropriate?

    No evidence the student was kept from participating in her IEP; objective not needed.

  6. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue I(A)(6). Must the IEP include an individualized adapted PE swimming program after school at Cal Poly with an interpreter and APE specialist?

    Insufficient evidence the student needs the swimming program; the IEP already addresses lifelong fitness activities.

  7. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue I(B)(1). Must the IEP state that academic progress will be documented through an annual portfolio of work?

    No testimony showing need, and the District's IEP already refers to an annual portfolio.

  8. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue I(B)(2). Must the IEP state that general in-service training/awareness will be made available to general educators and school staff before the first day of school?

    High school staff had no experience with deaf-blind students and the District did not credibly rebut the need; the component must be included.

  9. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue I(B)(3). Must the IEP provide professional training in deaf-blindness, inclusion, deaf-blind interpreting, etc., for staff working with Student?

    The training and experience of the 1996-97 staff were not addressed at hearing, so a need for training could not be determined.

  10. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue I(B)(4). Must the IEP require that a substitute pool of interpreters be established and trained?

    Interpreter services are vital, but how to ensure suitable interpreters are available is for the District to decide.

  11. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue I(B)(5). Must the IEP provide collaboration time among staff, with the primary teacher coordinating with the VI teacher, interpreter and general educators, and monthly team meetings?

    Given past communication problems and the student's complex needs, staff need regular collaboration time; monthly support team meetings ordered.

  12. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue I(B)(6). Must the IEP state that present levels in reading, written language, writing and math will be assessed annually?

    Present levels are already required in the IEP, and no evidence showed conditions warranting annual rather than triennial assessment.

  13. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue II. What is the appropriate level of services from a special education teacher for Student to receive a FAPE?

    The District's 60% (about 21.5 hours/week) teacher was insufficient given preparation, adaptation and consultation needs; 30 hours per week is appropriate for 1996-97.

  14. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue III. What is the appropriate level of interpreter/tutor services for Student to receive a FAPE?

    The interpreter's four-period day left the student without communication at lunch and gave no preparation or team time; hours must increase by at least 1.5 hours per day.

  15. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue IV. What, if any, assistive technology does Student require to receive a FAPE?

    No witness with assistive technology expertise testified, so the specific devices could not be decided; the District must assess the student's assistive technology needs.

  16. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue V. What is the appropriate level of speech and language services for Student to receive a FAPE?

    No persuasive evidence the student needs individual therapy; weekly speech-language consultation, consistent with the Perkins recommendation, is sufficient.

  17. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue VI. To receive a FAPE, does Student require that someone be designated to coordinate and oversee her educational program?

    Case management can be a related service; given the student's complex needs and many providers, a case manager is required, chosen at the District's discretion.

  18. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue VII. Is Student entitled to compensatory education?

    Because the District had increased services and committed to a five-year high school plan, the Hearing Officer found it unnecessary to decide entitlement to more compensatory education.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP team to amend the IEP to add the social-circle objective and these components: pre-school-year in-service training/awareness, monthly support team meetings, a case manager, a special education teacher for 30 hours per week, and an interpreter for at least 5.5 hours per day.
  • Order to provide or change services. Upon receipt of the decision, increase the special education teacher's hours to 30 hours per week.
  • Order to provide or change services. Upon receipt of the decision, increase the interpreter's hours by at least 1.5 hours per day (covering lunch, preparation and team consultation).
  • Order to provide or change services. Within 15 calendar days, appoint someone with Ms. Heuer's experience and qualifications as case manager to coordinate and oversee the educational program.
  • Staff training. IEP to state that general in-service training/awareness will be made available to general educators and school staff before the first day of school.
  • IEP to provide for monthly meetings of the student's support team.
  • Order to assess. Within 20 calendar days, prepare a plan to assess the student's augmentative and assistive technology needs, and complete the assessment within Education Code timelines.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education of Massachusetts; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Lachman v. Illinois State Bd. of Educ.

People named in the decision

  • Katherine Thomas-Anderson, Ed.D., District director of student services, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Jane E. Heath, legal assistant to District counsel, District counsel's office
  • Kathleen Mockus, sign-language interpreter (fourth and fifth grades), San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Kathleen McKinnon (formerly Romano), sixth-grade interpreter/teacher; independent educational advocate and District consultant; witness for District
  • Betsy Dunn, special education (home/hospital) teacher, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Jill Heuer, special programs facilitator and full-inclusion case manager, San Luis Obispo County Office of Education
  • Suzanne Anderson-Ruble, sign-language interpreter/tutor (1995-96), San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Blair Roger, independent educational consultant; deaf-blind inclusion expert, witness for Student, San Francisco State University deaf-blind project
  • Ted Wheeler, school board president; former teacher and District consultant; witness for Student, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Bruce Powers, Ph.D., licensed psychologist; witness for Student, Tri-Counties Regional Center
  • Michael Simkins, Ph.D., former principal, Baywood Elementary School, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Diana Barnhart, eighth-grade science teacher, Los Osos Middle School
  • Mary Jo DeSio, SELPA director and assistant superintendent, San Luis Obispo County Office of Education
  • Rick Robinett, assistant principal supervising special education, San Luis Obispo High School
  • Patsy Ried, special day class teacher and special education department chair, San Luis Obispo High School
  • Jean Keller, District personnel analyst, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Stephen D. Perreault, educational consultant; deaf-blind expert (deposition), Perkins School for the Blind
  • Michael T. Collins, director, Hilton/Perkins Program, Perkins School for the Blind
  • Bev DeWitt-Moylan, teacher of the visually impaired (VI)
  • Carol Lopes, mentor teacher; Circle of Friends coordinator, San Luis Coastal Unified School District
  • Valerie Vanaman, Student's former attorney (filed 1994 request)
  • Bobbie F. Albanese, District attorney at mediation
  • Ryan Bezerra, District attorney at deposition

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Luis Obispo, California, on June 27 and 28, July 30 and 31, and August 1 and 2, 1996, and by telephone on August 5, 1996.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney David R.

Ellison. Also present on behalf of Petitioner was her mother, PARENT. Respondent San Luis Coastal Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Thomas M. Duggan. Also present on behalf of the District were Jane E. Heath, legal assistant to Mr. Duggan, and Katherine Thomas-Anderson, Ed.D., District director of student services.

Oral and documentary evidence was received, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

ISSUE NO. I: To receive a free appropriate public education, must STUDENT's IEP include:

(A) the following additional goals and objectives?

(1) STUDENT will participate in a minimum of three regular education classes each semester.

(2) By October 1, 1996, STUDENT will participate in an evaluation to determine more precisely her present levels of math performance--as they relate to the District curriculum--and to determine her present levels of reading performance. At that time, additional objectives will be written which address specific skills.

(3) STUDENT will participate to the maximum extent feasible with deaf and deaf-blind people and events. STUDENT will assist her mother in accessing funds to attend American Association of Deaf-Blind (AADB) functions and camps.

(4) STUDENT will participate as an active member in a social circle that meets on a regular basis. She will demonstrate the ability to communicate and problem solve effectively in social situations.

(5) STUDENT will participate in discussions and development of her IEP as appropriate.

(6) STUDENT will participate in an individualized adapted PE swimming program which is held after school at Cal Poly and is facilitated by an interpreter and Adaptive PE specialist.

(B) the following components?

(1) STUDENT's academic progress will be documented through the establishment of an annual portfolio of work which will include writing samples, test samples, etc.

(2) A general in-service training/awareness will be made available to the general educators and school staff prior to the first day of school.

(3) Professional training opportunities in the areas of deaf-blindness, academic and social considerations, inclusion, and deaf-blind interpreting, etc., will be acquired for the staff working with STUDENT.

(4) A substitute pool of interpreters will be established and trained.

(5) Collaboration time among staff supporting STUDENT is necessary. The schedule will allow for the primary teacher to coordinate with the teacher of visually impaired, interpreter, and general educators. Designated times for team meetings will be arranged on a monthly basis.

(6) STUDENT's present level of performance in the areas of reading, written language, writing, and math will be assessed annually.

ISSUE NO. II: What is the appropriate level of services from a special education teacher for STUDENT to receive a free appropriate public education?

ISSUE NO. III: What is the appropriate level of interpreter/tutor services for STUDENT to receive a free appropriate public education?

ISSUE NO. IV: What, if any, assistive technology does STUDENT require to receive a free appropriate public education?

ISSUE V: What is the appropriate level of speech and language services for STUDENT to receive a free appropriate public education?

ISSUE VI: To receive a free appropriate public education, does STUDENT require that someone be designated to coordinate and oversee her educational program?

ISSUE VII: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old, ninth-grade student who will enter high school in the fall of 1996. STUDENT has a significant bilateral sensorineural hearing loss and is legally blind due to optic atrophy. She has also been diagnosed with processing disorders and mild ataxic cerebral palsy. She uses spoken English and sign language to communicate. STUDENT has some useable vision in one eye and is able to read large print with magnification. She also reads braille. STUDENT has normal cognitive potential and has been educated in a mainstream environment. Pursuant to her IEP, STUDENT is entitled to services for the visually impaired (VI), orientation and mobility services (O/M), speech and language consultation, and adaptive physical education (APE). These services are provided by the San Luis Obispo County Office of Education (SLOCOE).

In May of 1985, STUDENT entered a preschool program at Cal Poly. In 1987, STUDENT entered kindergarten. She was placed in a special day class (SDC) for students with orthopedic impairments at Jesperson School, a segregated site operated by SLOCOE. STUDENT attended Jesperson for four years. During the third grade, STUDENT was mainstreamed briefly into a regular education class. She transferred to C.L. Smith School for the fourth grade and was mainstreamed in a regular fourth-grade class. For the first time, STUDENT was provided with a sign-language interpreter. Kathleen Mockus served as STUDENT's interpreter for both the fourth and fifth grades. STUDENT attended her neighborhood school, Baywood Elementary for the fifth grade. She was provided resource services (RSP) four times a week for 30 to 45 minutes with an additional hour of consultation, and VI, O/M, and APE services. (Respondent's Exhibit 4) In December 1992, a behavioral intervention plan was developed to improve STUDENT's compliance and on-task behavior. (Respondent's Exhibit 5) From March 1 - 5, 1993, the California School for the Blind assessed STUDENT. The assessors made numerous recommendations, including that further assessments be undertaken to evaluate STUDENT's technological needs and her academic skills. A neurological evaluation was also recommended. (Petitioner's Exhibit 12)

STUDENT continued to attend Baywood for the sixth grade.

Kathleen Romano, who had worked with STUDENT during the summer, was hired as STUDENT's interpreter and also to provide her with individual instruction. (FOOTNOTE 1) STUDENT had some problems with on-task behavior and noncompliance with instructions. In December 1993, California Deaf-Blind services conducted an assessment of STUDENT. Concerns noted by the assessors included STUDENT's manipulative behavior and the need for program coordination and adaptation of the curriculum. (Respondent's Exhibit 34) There was a dispute between PARENT and school personnel regarding the fact that STUDENT was being disciplined by using time out. Approximately eight weeks before the end of the school year, PARENT removed STUDENT from school. On May 21, 1994, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing from attorney Valerie Vanaman on behalf of STUDENT. (FOOTNOTE 2) Through mediation on August 25, 1994, the parties reached an interim agreement and the matter was taken off calendar. (FOOTNOTE 3) Thereafter, the parties participated in further mediation.

STUDENT entered Los Osos Middle School for the seventh grade.

The interpreter assigned to work with STUDENT decided almost immediately after school started that she was going to resign. The District reassigned her to work elsewhere within the District and another interpreter was hired to work with STUDENT. The new interpreter was available only three days per week from 11:00 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. through Dec. 16, 1994. A letter dated November 17, 1994, from Dr. Thomas-Anderson, describes some of the District's attempts to locate an interpreter for STUDENT. Dr. Thomas-Anderson's letter also suggests that an out-of-county setting should be located for STUDENT because of her "unique needs that cannot be met within our district or in other districts within the county." (Respondent's Exhibit 17) In the spring of 1995, the District hired Betsy Dunn to be STUDENT's home teacher.

On March 6, 7, and 8, 1995, the Perkins School for the Blind evaluated STUDENT. Recommendations from the assessment included the following: a teacher (or at least an aide) who is trained to work with deaf or deaf-blind students; help for STUDENT when meeting new people and in defining her communication needs and visual limitations; participation in classes with a small student-to-teacher ratio; individual and small-group instruction; continued use of low vision devices including magnifiers; and instruction in braille and orientation and mobility. The assessor noted that STUDENT requires an interpreter to assist the mobility specialist, if that person does not sign. OT was recommended to increase STUDENT's independence in the bathroom, zipping, and household management, and to improve her awareness of safety. The assessor also recommended that STUDENT use a computer for writing because the "effort for her to perform this activity is fatiguing...." STUDENT also may not always be able to read her own handwriting. It was recommended that STUDENT receive speech and language therapy to improve expressive, receptive, and pragmatic language skills, to develop strategies and skills to learn how to communicate effectively with hearing as well as deaf individuals, and to maintain current articulation skills. The report also states that materials presented to STUDENT should be of high contrast and uncluttered, and includes specific recommendations regarding STUDENT's technological needs. (Petitioner's Exhibit 9)

STUDENT attended Los Osos for the eighth grade during the 1995-96 school year. STUDENT continued to receive the related services of O/M, VI, and APE. Jill Heuer, SLOCOE special programs facilitator, was assigned as STUDENT's case manager. (Respondent's Exhibit 11) Ms. Dunn continued her work with STUDENT. She was hired to prepare materials and to work with STUDENT for a total of six to ten hours per week. Ms. Dunn spent the majority of her time adapting and preparing materials for STUDENT and worked from one to two hours weekly with STUDENT. STUDENT had the services of Suzanne Anderson-Ruble, an interpreter/tutor, for 7.5 hours daily. For three periods of the school day, Ms. Anderson-Ruble provided one-to-one instruction to STUDENT in math, social studies, and study skills. STUDENT was mainstreamed in three regular education classes during which Ms. Anderson-Ruble interpreted for STUDENT. For the first semester of the eighth grade, STUDENT received "A" grades in integrated science, physical education and English.

During the second semester, she received an "A" in integrated science and "A-" grades in both physical education and social science. (Respondent's Exhibit 18)

In March 1996, attorney David R. Ellison was retained to represent Petitioner. On April 22, 1996, Mr. Ellison requested that the matter be placed on calendar to address the ongoing dispute regarding STUDENT's educational program. (FOOTNOTE 4)

Petitioner's main area of contention is regarding the number of hours proposed by the District for STUDENT's special education teacher. Petitioner contends that, to meet her needs, she requires the services of a special education teacher for 30 to 35 hours a week to provide three periods daily of individual instruction, with the remaining time for preparation of materials and adaptation of curriculum. Petitioner also contends that she requires either one full-time interpreter or two part-time interpreters to assist her in her regular education and keyboarding classes and to allow her to participate with peers in lunchtime activities and after school activities. Petitioner contends that STUDENT requires one-to-one support for language pragmatics from a qualified speech and language specialist.

The District's proposed IEP indicates that STUDENT's special education instructor will be employed for approximately 20 hours per week to provide three periods of one-to-one instruction to STUDENT with an additional period per school day for preparation related to STUDENT's educational program. (FOOTNOTE 5) The District's proposal calls for the interpreter to assist STUDENT in her three regular education classes and in her keyboarding class. The District has proposed that a speech and language pathologist provide weekly consultation services regarding STUDENT. The District has also "committed" to a five-year educational plan for STUDENT in the event she requires additional time in school. The plan will be developed by January 1997.

The parties agree that STUDENT should continue to receive VI, O/M, and APE services. The District has also agreed that it will consult periodically with San Francisco State University (SFSU) and the Perkins Institute. PARENT signed the IEP indicating that she was in agreement with "the vast majority of the goals and objectives." The goals and objectives and services remaining in dispute are discussed more thoroughly below. (See also Petitioner's proposed IEP, which is contained within Petitioner's Exhibit 1 and the District's proposed IEP, which is contained within Respondent's Exhibit 15.)

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Petitioner's Witnesses

PARENT described STUDENT as "very bright and very motivated to learn." She testified, however, that STUDENT's math skills are low and she has other gaps in her education. PARENT testified that STUDENT's math and reading skills have not been evaluated so it is impossible to really know at what level she presently is functioning. PARENT testified regarding the services and the goals and objectives she believes need to be added to STUDENT's IEP. Of paramount concern to PARENT is the number of hours per day the District has proposed for STUDENT's special education or primary teacher. (FOOTNOTE 6) PARENT testified that three hours per day is not sufficient time for a primary teacher to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs. PARENT testified that her contention that the primary teacher must be provided for 30 hours per week is supported by information from Ms. Dunn, STUDENT's teacher during the prior school year, by information garnered from literature regarding the education of deaf-blind students, and by the recommendations of experts from SFSU and the Perkins Institute who are familiar with STUDENT and the District's program.

PARENT testified that the "best case scenario" is the proposed schedule with two interpreters. (Petitioner's Exhibit 1)

According to PARENT, professional interpreters change every 20 minutes; however, STUDENT has always had only one interpreter. PARENT testified that it is a very intense job interpreting for STUDENT. She cited the following additional benefits of two interpreters: STUDENT would learn to work with more than one person and would not be as dependent upon one individual; two interpreters would allow STUDENT to participate with her peers in lunch and after school activities; and if one of the interpreters or STUDENT's teacher is absent, the other interpreter could be used to interpret for STUDENT.

PARENT testified that, for STUDENT to benefit from her education, she requires appropriate computers and other technological devices that will allow her to access information and to communicate independently with peers and teachers. PARENT also testified that, with the assistance of appropriate technology, STUDENT could be expected to assume responsibility for completing her assignments, projects, and tests. PARENT stated that the list of items provided by STUDENT's VI teacher, Bev DeWitt-Moylan, sets forth STUDENT's assistive technology needs. (See Petitioner's Exhibit 1)

PARENT testified regarding additional goals and objectives she proposed for STUDENT. She stated that an objective is need to facilitate STUDENT's participation in activities with adults who have become deaf or blind. PARENT suggested this population because most persons who are deaf-blind from birth do not have normal intelligence, whereas STUDENT does. PARENT contends that this objective is necessary so that STUDENT will know that there are other persons like her. According to PARENT, the District would not include this objective on STUDENT's IEP because there are no other deaf-blind students on the high school campus. PARENT testified that an objective for STUDENT to improve communication strategies with peers and school staff is necessary to assist STUDENT in learning to anticipate when someone is speaking to her. It is also necessary to develop her skills to communicate in different environments. PARENT testified that STUDENT's IEP should also include an objective regarding STUDENT's contributing something positive to the school. This objective would also encourage STUDENT to avoid becoming passive.

PARENT contends that it is "absolutely vital" for STUDENT to improve her social skills. She testified that STUDENT has not made new friends since the sixth grade and will be going to a high school at which she does not know anyone. PARENT testified that STUDENT participated in the Circle of Friends program while in the sixth grade. PARENT stated that the program was very helpful at that time and she believes that it currently is necessary to facilitate STUDENT's communication with other students and to allow STUDENT to develop social skills.

PARENT testified that staff working with STUDENT must participate in training prior to the opening of school so that they will be generally aware of STUDENT's needs. PARENT asserted that it is necessary for the in-service training requirement to be set forth in STUDENT's IEP because, in the past, teachers and other staff were unprepared to work with STUDENT because they had little knowledge of her needs. PARENT also asserted that certain school administrators prevented information regarding STUDENT from being shared with her teachers prior to the commencement of the school year. PARENT testified that it is necessary to have all of the information contained on the supplemental page to STUDENT's IEP in great detail because, over the years, there has been a lack of consistency in STUDENT's program. According to PARENT, the details set forth on the proposed supplementary page are also necessary so that new persons working with STUDENT will understand the components of STUDENT's program and so that turmoil and confusion surrounding STUDENT's educational needs will be diminished.

PARENT testified that STUDENT should be entitled to compensatory education for the lack of an appropriate education provided to her in the past. PARENT testified that beginning in the first grade she asked that STUDENT be taught to braille and to sign. She stated that rather than provide these services, STUDENT was instructed to read in a closet in the classroom where the teacher spoke slowly and loudly enunciated the words. PARENT testified that when STUDENT was in the fourth grade, the District acknowledged that it did not have an appropriate program for STUDENT and recommended a residential placement for STUDENT. An appropriate residential placement was never located.

PARENT testified that the sixth grade school year did not get off to a good start because the school principal, Dr. Simkins, did not facilitate STUDENT's transition to a new classroom. There also were interpersonal issues between the interpreter and STUDENT throughout the school year. PARENT testified that STUDENT was not learning during the sixth grade because there was very little adaptation being made to the curriculum and materials. Also, STUDENT was suspended or sent to time out without anything to do. PARENT testified that STUDENT was suspended because she put her head down in class and said, "I can't do this. I give up." PARENT testified that, for the first time, STUDENT was not motivated to learn and did not want to go to school. PARENT testified that STUDENT was not in school for most of the seventh grade because she did not have an interpreter. PARENT testified that, for the first time, all of the essential components of an appropriate education for STUDENT were available at the beginning of the eighth grade school year. She stated that STUDENT was happy and anxious to go to school and she that she received "A's" in her regular education classes.

Blair Roger is an independent educational consultant and has served as director of a project to support full inclusion of special education students in regular education classrooms. Ms. Roger first met STUDENT in February 1994, while working on the federal grant at SFSU designed to identify and support model programs serving deaf-blind students in California. At various times beginning in 1994, Ms. Roger has observed STUDENT and has met with teachers, family, and others to plan for STUDENT's educational needs. Ms. Roger testified that, during the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT's support team determined that, because STUDENT was receiving services from a number of different persons, there should be a "point person" to coordinate her program. Ms. Roger stated that a point person was not designated and, for this reason, the District was not then selected as a "model site" to receive services from the federal grant on which Ms. Roger was working.

In January 1996, at the request of the District, Ms. Roger again participated in developing STUDENT's educational program. Ms. Roger testified that she was pleased with the improvements to STUDENT's educational program, especially given her understanding that STUDENT was performing well academically. Ms. Roger noted that the program in place for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year would have qualified as a model site under the SFSU program guidelines. Ms. Roger testified that STUDENT's IEP transitioning her to high school was not completed because the parties could not reach agreement on all areas and because no one was present at the meeting on behalf of the high school. Ms. Roger concurred with PARENT that STUDENT's present levels of performance need to be assessed. She recalled that everyone at the IEP meeting agreed that an assessment is necessary because it is not clear where STUDENT presently functions academically, especially in math.

Ms. Roger testified that the services listed on the supplemental page prepared by PARENT (Petitioner's Exhibit 1) are necessary to provide appropriate support to STUDENT in her educational program at the high school and to allow her to achieve her goals and objectives. Ms. Roger testified that 20 hours is insufficient for STUDENT's teacher to provide STUDENT with the support she requires. Ms. Roger testified that STUDENT's teacher requires 30 to 35 hours to provide individual instruction to STUDENT, to determine how best to present information to STUDENT, and to prepare and adapt the curriculum materials. Ms. Roger testified that STUDENT requires assistive technology devices to allow her to communicate in a variety of environments and educational settings. Ms. Roger testified that STUDENT is isolated, has difficulty connecting with her peers, and requires assistance in developing a social network. Ms. Roger recommended that the school implement a Circle of Friends, which involves formulation of a group of students who volunteer to provide social support to STUDENT. She suggested that the group initially meet for one-half hour each week and then as needed.

Betsy Dunn has been STUDENT's special education teacher since the spring of 1995. She was hired as a home/hospital teacher and initially provided one-to-one services to STUDENT at her home. For the 1995-1996 school year, Ms. Dunn was hired to provide six to ten hours per week of support to STUDENT. Ms. Dunn testified that, at the beginning of the 1995-1996 school year, she was prevented from providing information to the regular education teachers regarding STUDENT. She had ongoing difficulty getting together with STUDENT's regular education teachers for the purpose of gathering classroom materials so that she could modify them in advance of the lessons being presented in class. Ms Dunn stated that she often received materials to modify for STUDENT on the Monday of the week in which they were to be used in class. The ultimate result was that STUDENT often got materials later than the other students in her class or STUDENT's interpreter was left to make modifications on the spot. Ms. Dunn testified that, for the spring semester, she was able to provide information to STUDENT's teachers before she was placed in their classes. She testified that, in general, the spring went better for STUDENT.

Ms. Dunn testified that there was never enough time to do everything that was necessary to prepare materials for STUDENT and to consult with her teachers. She testified that minimally the special education teacher needs to provide 15 hours per week of direct services to STUDENT. The teacher also needs at least 15 hours per week to prepare and to adapt materials for STUDENT's regular education classes. Additional time is needed to attend team meetings and to consult with STUDENT's teachers and service providers. Ms. Dunn testified that simply enlarging the print in a previously prepared document is insufficient to meet STUDENT's needs. Ms. Dunn testified that because of the gaps in STUDENT's knowledge and the fact that she has multisensory disabilities, materials had to be modified in size and content to make the information relevant to STUDENT's knowledge and experiences.

During her testimony, Ms. Dunn provided many examples of the modifications she made to regular education materials to make them accessible for STUDENT. (See Petitioner's Exhibits 34 through 50) Ms. Dunn stated that modifications she made included re-typing written materials so that the print was appropriately spaced and the colors were sufficiently contrasting so that STUDENT could see the print; summarizing some materials so that STUDENT would be able to complete the work; providing supplemental information where STUDENT has gaps in her knowledge; and making some of the vocabulary less linguistically difficult so that STUDENT could grasp the concept rather than become bogged down on vocabulary with which she was not familiar. Sometimes it was necessary to reduce the length of sentences or the number of questions in an assignment. Ms. Dunn testified that she also had to find alternative means for STUDENT to learn the concepts presented in some lessons. For example, in science the students were working on a computer program regarding streams. Rather than describing the unit, Ms. Dunn used sand and water models along with written materials she developed. Ms. Dunn testified that STUDENT was very successful and mastered those portions of the curriculum that were modified for her; however, Ms. Dunn estimated that STUDENT was provided only approximately one-half of the core concepts for each class.

Ms. Dunn estimated that STUDENT's math skills fall between the first- to third-grade level. STUDENT can do simple addition but has difficulty carrying. She can do simple subtraction but is not able to do multiplication or division. STUDENT can read a novel at the fifth- or sixth-grade level but does not necessarily have a commensurate understanding of the vocabulary or of all the information contained in a passage. Ms. Dunn testified that STUDENT has not been a behavior problem with her. She stated that when STUDENT was provided with materials she could understand, her frustration lessened and she was willing to work. Ms. Dunn testified that STUDENT did well in her regular education classes; however, she asserted that in science, STUDENT mastered 58% of the core concepts presented to the class and, in social science, she also mastered 50% of the concepts. In English, STUDENT mastered the same concepts as other students, with the exception of those related to grammar.

Ms. Dunn testified that STUDENT's interpreters have "burned out" because of the high level of intensity involved with working with STUDENT. The interpreter must be in close proximity to STUDENT so that she is able to see the interpreter. Ms. Dunn noted also that, during the prior school year, the interpreter did not have any breaks. Ms. Dunn testified that most interpreters for deaf-blind persons alternate every 20 minutes. Ms. Dunn testified that the educational interpreter needs preparation time so that he/she can be familiar with the vocabulary and information contained in the lesson. Ms. Dunn testified that lunch was an extremely painful and isolating experience for STUDENT. STUDENT was not able to participate in activities that took place during lunch because she did not have an interpreter. STUDENT was similarly isolated during breaks between classes. Ms. Dunn testified that unless STUDENT is provided some means by which to facilitate communication, she will just sit and will not be able to communicate or socialize with her peers.

Suzanne Anderson-Ruble was STUDENT's full-time sign language interpreter during the 1995-96 school year. Ms. Anderson-Ruble has a profound hearing loss and used an F-M amplifier system to facilitate communication with STUDENT's teachers. Ms. Anderson-Ruble described STUDENT as "very intelligent and anxious to learn." She stated that STUDENT did well academically and that, by the end of the school year, her behavior had improved tremendously. Ms. Anderson-Ruble expressed concern regarding STUDENT's lack of a social life. Ms. Anderson-Ruble stated that, when she took a lunch break, STUDENT had no way to communicate with her peers.

Additional problems during the 1995-96 school year included the lack of administrative support at the school level and the failure to clearly define the roles of the special education teacher and interpreter.

Ms. Anderson-Ruble testified that she required two to three hours daily to communicate with STUDENT's teachers, to prepare materials for STUDENT, to make modifications in the classroom, and to provide instruction to STUDENT. She noted that part of the work she did was necessary because Ms. Dunn, the special education teacher, was employed for only 10 hours per week and was not always available to meet and plan with STUDENT's teachers. Ms. Anderson-Ruble stated that she, personally, was "burned out" by the end of the school year because it took a lot of work to make modifications for STUDENT. Ms. Anderson-Ruble stated that she had hoped to continue working with STUDENT; however, because the District advised her that her position with STUDENT would be for only four hours daily during the 1996-97 school year, she has found other employment.

Ted Wheeler is currently the president of the school board for the District. Mr. Wheeler first met STUDENT during the 1990-91 school year when she was integrated into his class. After retiring in 1991, Mr. Wheeler worked with STUDENT as a consultant to the District. He continues to be involved with STUDENT's education at the request of PARENT. Mr. Wheeler testified that many problems have existed over the course of STUDENT's education that could have been alleviated by adopting the recommendations of SFSU that an individual with expertise in the needs of deaf-blind students be designated as STUDENT's primary teacher. He stated that the primary teacher's role would be to coordinate STUDENT's educational program, to support STUDENT's regular education teachers, to provide STUDENT with one-to-one instruction, and to adapt lessons from the regular education classes. Mr. Wheeler made the additional recommendation that the primary teacher also be responsible for ongoing evaluation of the program.

Mr. Wheeler testified that STUDENT's educational history has been one of ups and downs. He noted that even when he worked with STUDENT in 1990-1991, she had gaps in her education. For example, although she was a proficient reader, she did not know some of the vocabulary words with which most third-grade readers are familiar. Mr. Wheeler testified that STUDENT's sixth-grade year was particularly difficult. There was a lack of support from the administration and a clash of personalities between STUDENT and her interpreter. STUDENT was also suspended and, according to Mr. Wheeler, made very little educational progress. Mr. Wheeler stated that there was no pro-active preparation for STUDENT's transition to middle school. STUDENT also had a new interpreter who was quickly reassigned to another student. Mr. Wheeler understood that STUDENT did not attend school consistently in the seventh grade and that she did not always have an interpreter. Mr. Wheeler described the eighth grade as a vast improvement over the prior school year because there was some coordination of STUDENT's program by Ms. Heuer, and Ms. Dunn provided specialized instruction and modified curriculum. Mr. Wheeler testified that there was not sufficient time, however, for Ms. Dunn to be in the regular education classes with STUDENT or to modify all of her regular education curriculum. Mr. Wheeler concurred with the recommendation of other witnesses that STUDENT should be involved in a program, such as Circle of Friends, to develop her social skills.

Mr. Wheeler described the high school special education department at San Luis High as "adequate." He concurred with the District that Mr. Robinett, the vice principal in charge of special education, is dedicated, reliable, and committed to working with STUDENT. He testified that while there are clubs in which STUDENT may participate at the high school, she will need an interpreter to facilitate her participation and her communication with the other students. Mr. Wheeler conceded that it is very expensive for the District to educate STUDENT. He testified, however, that STUDENT will ultimately need to be supported by society or her family if she is not taught the skills that will allow her to be an independent-living, tax-paying adult.

Bruce Powers, Ph.D, licensed psychologist, is employed by Tri-Counties Regional Center. Dr. Powers first met STUDENT when she was in preschool. At that time, she was having tantrums and was not compliant. In 1994, Dr. Powers also participated in development of STUDENT's IEP and in mediations. Dr. Powers testified that he has found PARENT to be a caring, concerned, and educated parent. Dr. Powers emphasized that STUDENT has complicated and unique needs in that she is part of a very small population of persons with severe hearing and visual impairments who also have average intellectual potential. He believes that STUDENT's impairments are progressive. Dr. Powers testified that STUDENT may need some remedial assistance to allow her to "catch up."

Respondent's Witnesses

Kathleen McKinnon (formerly Romano), independent educational advocate and interpreter, holds a master's degree in deaf education. Ms. McKinnon was a consultant for the District regarding STUDENT and was STUDENT`s teacher/interpreter when STUDENT was in the sixth grade. Ms. McKinnon testified that STUDENT had a number of behavioral problems during the sixth grade and showed a lack of respect toward her. Ms. McKinnon related incidents in which STUDENT physically restrained her and refused to work. At the end of the school year, when she described STUDENT as "unmanageable," Ms. McKinnon would deal with STUDENT's misbehavior by sending her to the office for time out. Ms. McKinnon attributed STUDENT's behavioral problems to her frustration with the difficult level of the work she was expected to do in her regular sixth-grade class and to the fact that there were gaps in STUDENT's knowledge and skills. Ms. McKinnon also described some of STUDENT's poor behavior as typical for pre-teens. Ms. McKinnon testified that the school principal, Dr. Simkins, was very supportive of her efforts to work with STUDENT and shared with her ideas and techniques to implement with STUDENT.

Ms. McKinnon testified that, in preparation for her testimony, she met with Mr. Robinett, the high school vice principal, and Ms. Anderson-Ruble, and reviewed the District's proposed IEP. Ms. McKinnon concluded that the District has offered STUDENT a program that is designed to meet her needs and to allow her to make educational benefit. Ms. McKinnon testified that a 60% teacher can adequately meet STUDENT's needs at the high school. Ms. McKinnon noted that her opinion was consistent with the opinion expressed to her by Ms. Anderson-Ruble regarding the amount of time needed by STUDENT's special education teacher to provide individual instruction and to prepare materials. Ms. McKinnon testified that there are more "natural" ways for STUDENT to increase her social skills than by implementing the Circle of Friends. She stated that the high school's student assistance services (SAS) offers programs that include students who may be experiencing similar social problems. Ms. McKinnon also expressed the opinion that when Circle of Friends was implemented with STUDENT in the sixth grade, it resulted in too much focus being put on STUDENT's needs while, on other occasions, it became a time for the other students to pick on

STUDENT.

Michael Simkins, Ph.D., is the project manager for an educational/technical grant at Stanford University. He was the principal of Baywood Elementary School when STUDENT attended school there in the fifth and sixth grades Dr. Simkins testified that prior to STUDENT entering Baywood, school staff attended some training with PARENT. During the school year, the staff and PARENT met approximately monthly to address how to best meet STUDENT's needs. They also met informally at other times. Dr. Simkins described STUDENT's IEP as an ongoing process, which was not finalized because of an intervening assessment of STUDENT at the Fremont School for the Blind. Dr. Simkins testified that PARENT was never satisfied and became disenchanted with the experts when they did not hold the same opinion as she did. Dr. Simkins testified that he developed a behavioral intervention plan to address some of STUDENT's inappropriate behaviors at school. He stated that the plan was successful while STUDENT was in the fifth grade but that it was not successful in the sixth grade because PARENT withdrew consent for its implementation. Dr. Simkins testified that STUDENT was disciplined in the same manner as other students. For example, STUDENT, as well as other students, were sent to time out in the office when they misbehaved in class.

Diana Barnhart was STUDENT's science teacher during the second semester of her eighth grade. Ms. Barnhart has been teaching in the District for 17 years and has been teacher-of-the-year on seven separate occasions. Ms. Barnhart testified that STUDENT earned an "A" in her class. She stated that STUDENT completed about 70% of the interactive tasks and met nearly 100% of the objectives of the class. In her opinion, STUDENT benefitted educationally from being in her class. Ms. Barnhart testified that STUDENT appeared happy and had friends who would sometimes wait for her after class.

Jill Heuer, special projects facilitator for SLOCOE, served as STUDENT's full-inclusion case manager during the 1995-96 school year. She viewed her role as that of a liaison between STUDENT's parent, teachers, interpreter, and service providers. She also was responsible for ensuring that everything was working and in place for STUDENT's educational program. She also conducted regular monthly meetings with team members. Ms. Heuer was unclear what her role would be for the 1996-97 school year. Ms. Heuer testified that STUDENT did very well during the eighth grade. She stated that no one ever expressed concern to her that STUDENT was not actually earning her "A" grades or that she was only getting one-half of the information.

Ms. Heuer testified that the District's proposed IEP will provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Ms. Heuer noted that STUDENT will actually be provided more services than she was provided the prior school year. Ms. Heuer testified that the SAS will be available to provide peer helpers and other support for STUDENT. Her teacher will have greater accessibility to specialized materials at the high school. Ms. Heuer concurred with other District witnesses that 21.5 hours is sufficient for STUDENT's teacher to provide her with individual instruction and to prepare and adapt materials for her. Ms. Heuer testified that some of the materials Ms. Dunn created may already have been available through either the District or the County.

Dr. Thomas-Anderson, director of student services, testified that the District has done a number of things to make STUDENT's education successful. For example, during the sixth grade, the District paid for the staff involved with STUDENT to attend a workshop during the summer which addressed issues related to full inclusion. During the sixth grade, Dr. Thomas-Anderson met weekly with PARENT to attempt to come to some accord regarding STUDENT's education. According to Dr. Thomas-Anderson, STUDENT's behavioral problems escalated during the sixth grade and she was ultimately removed from school by her mother after the principal gave STUDENT the option of working in his office for the afternoon or going home.

Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that the interpreter assigned to STUDENT at the beginning of the seventh grade worked only briefly with STUDENT because of STUDENT's behaviors. STUDENT pushed the interpreter away and held her hands down so that she could not sign to her. Another interpreter was then hired; however, she was available only three days per week. Following her departure on December 16, 1994, the District was unable to locate a qualified interpreter although it conducted an ongoing search. In the spring, Ms. Dunn put in an application for a computer-related job with the District. On learning of her experience working with deaf students, Dr. Thomas-Anderson persuaded Ms. Dunn to work part-time with STUDENT.

Regarding recommendations in 1994 that a point person coordinate and monitor STUDENT's program, Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that the District suggested that an RSP teacher or someone else already employed by the District be utilized to fulfill this function. Dr. Thomas-Anderson stated also that Carol Lopes, a mentor teacher, was already consulting with District staff regarding STUDENT and directing STUDENT's participation in the Circle of Friends program. Dr. Thomas-Anderson expressed surprise that the District would be asked to hire someone even before an IEP had been adopted for STUDENT.

As for the 1996-97 school year, Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that as early as October 1995, the District had requested that PARENT determine which high school she wanted STUDENT to attend. It was not until May 1, 1996, that PARENT informed the District of her decision, which had caused the District to delay convening a transition IEP. On May 7, 1996, the District sent notices for an IEP meeting for May 20, 1996. Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that representatives from the high school were present at the IEP meeting on May 20, 1996. STUDENT's new vision specialist and other DIS providers were also present.

Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that most of the revisions proposed to PARENT's draft of the IEP were what she termed "word-smithing." Dr. Thomas-Anderson stated that she attempted to clean up some of the language used in the goals and objectives drafted by PARENT because they were not measurable or observable. As for the interpreter's time, Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that STUDENT would be receiving direct instruction for three hours per day from a signing teacher and, therefore, would not require an interpreter during this period of the school day. Dr. Thomas-Anderson also testified that the four hours per day allotted for the interpreter is a baseline amount of time. She stated that there is some flexibility to allow the interpreter to attend activities and assemblies with STUDENT. The interpreter must, however, have obtained permission to extend his/her hours in advance.

Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that the District has already posted a 60% teaching position to work with STUDENT. Sixty percent time is approximately 21.5 hours per week, which Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified is sufficient to provide STUDENT with individual instruction in math and language arts, to provide her with individual support for her other classes, and to prepare and adapt materials and curriculum. She noted that STUDENT's VI specialist will coordinate preparing braille and large print materials for STUDENT. Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that STUDENT's gaps in math and other areas will be addressed during the periods STUDENT receives individual instruction. Dr. Thomas-Anderson stated that either STUDENT's counselor or the special education department chairperson will be STUDENT's case manager when she enters high school. Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that it will not be necessary to implement the Circle of Friends at the high school because the SAS program already is in place.

Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that the District is in the process of purchasing a computer for STUDENT. She stated that, on July 3, 1996, the District prepared a requisition order for the items set forth in Petitioner's Exhibit 28. According to Dr.

Thomas-Anderson, she has submitted the additional items recommended by Ms. DeWitt-Moylan for consideration by the Special Education Operations Council (SEOC). SEOC's members include the directors of special education in San Luis Obispo County, who are given the responsibility of determining what, if any, technological equipment should be purchased for students with low-incidence disabilities attending schools within the county. Dr. Thomas-Anderson anticipated that the matter would be re-addressed at SEOC's August meeting following an assessment of STUDENT's needs. Dr. Thomas-Anderson testified that the Tri-Counties Regional Center agreed at the IEP meeting that they would provide a face-to-face communication device for STUDENT because the equipment would be used by STUDENT in the community as well as in school.

Mary Jo DeSio, SELPA director, and assistant superintendent of SLOCOE, testified regarding the District's request to SEOC for low-incidence funding for STUDENT. Ms. DeSio described the procedure for requesting assistive technology from the low incidence funds as follows: the IEP team meets and describes the needs of the child; the district director of special education determines if the student and his/her needs meet the low incidence definition, researches the price and type of the equipment being requested, and submits the request along with a rational statement to the committee; the committee conducts its own research of the requested equipment and determines whether low-incidence equipment guidelines are satisfied; and the committee takes a vote regarding whether to authorize the purchase.

Ms. DeSio testified that Dr. Thomas-Anderson brought the request for equipment for STUDENT to the May 1996 meeting of SEOC. SEOC returned the request to Dr. Thomas-Anderson to respond to the committee's questions regarding whether the county has the expertise to make decisions regarding STUDENT's needs or whether she should be referred for an assessment by an outside group. Ms. DeSio stated that SEOC members also questioned whether the equipment requested is the best to meet STUDENT's needs.

Ms. DeSio testified that a number of resources currently are available to STUDENT's teachers, including the expertise of the County's staff serving the visually impaired. Staff is also available to braille and enlarge materials. The Department of Education also has technicians with expertise in areas of low incidence and there are books on tape.

Rick Robinett testified that part of his responsibilities as assistant principal of San Luis Obispo High School includes supervising the special education department, attending IEP meetings, and meeting regularly with teachers. Mr. Robinett testified that the high school has approximately 1,447 students, including 100 special education students. The special education department has three full-time teachers, one part-time teacher, an APE teacher, and four instructional assistants. The San Luis Obispo County Office of Education also has classes located on the campus.

Mr. Robinett testified regarding the process of transitioning students to the high school. Approximately two weeks before school begins, all ninth grade students participate in an orientation. STUDENT and her orientation and mobility teacher will have access to the campus prior to the beginning of school. During the second through sixth weeks of school, counselors meet with their students. To assist STUDENT, Mr. Robinett suggested that STUDENT be placed in a "life support" group for students who need additional assistance getting familiar with the school and to ensure that she is included in the school community. Life support groups meet one time a week for 10 weeks with the counselor and a teacher. Mr. Robinett testified that additional support available to STUDENT at the high school includes the "peer helper" group, the student study team, and counseling services. Activities and club meetings take place during lunch time and STUDENT would be a welcome participant. Mr. Robinett testified that he would personally oversee the scheduling of STUDENT's classes to ensure that she is placed in appropriate classes with receptive teachers.

Patsy Ried, special day class teacher, San Luis Obispo High School, has been a teacher for 19 years and, for five of those years, has been the chairperson for the high school special education department. Ms. Ried testified that the following resources are available to teachers at the high school: the expertise of the faculty itself; District program specialists; materials from other teachers; and the library. Resources within the County include the instructional materials center (IMC) and the educational technology center, which have materials available to teachers including teaching kits, videos, and manipulatives. Both centers will also laminate materials. Ms. Ried testified that, to meet STUDENT's needs, additional aides could be assigned. Ms. Ried stated, however, that since no deaf-blind students have previously attended the high school, the materials that are available were not specifically designed for a deaf-blind student.

Jean Keller, District personnel analyst, testified regarding posting and hiring of positions related to STUDENT. On June 22, 1993, the interpreter position was first posted at a salary of $12.79 to $15.00 per hour, which was slightly higher than the average hourly salary offered at that time by 31 other school districts. After the interpreter hired for STUDENT at the beginning of the 1994-1995 school year was reassigned, the interpreter job was re-posted. Ms. Keller testified that the District did not receive any applications for the job, which was then re-posted in November. Between November 1994 and April 1995, the District received three applications for the interpreter position. One person was hired to work with another student. Ms. Keller testified that PARENT has assisted in the preparation of an announcement of the interpreter position and that the District has advertised in a number of forums including out-of-state credentialing programs. She also testified that the District has continued to offer a higher salary than other districts. Ms.

Keller testified that, in June 1995, the District received three applications, from which Ms. Anderson-Ruble was selected to work with STUDENT. Ms. Keller testified that the District hired a new interpreter for STUDENT in June 1996. (See Respondent's Exhibits 17 to 20)

Deposition of Steven D. Perreault, Perkins School for the Blind

The parties submitted into evidence the sworn deposition of Stephen D. Perreault, educational consultant for the Perkins School for the Blind. Mr. Perreault's deposition was taken on May 23, 1996. (FOOTNOTE 7) Mr. Perreault holds a masters of education degree with an emphasis in special education. Since 1978, Mr. Perreault has held a number of positions at Perkins, including classroom teacher in the deaf-blind program. Mr. Perkins also served for several years as coordinator of the deaf-blind services unit, Massachusetts Commission for the Blind. Mr. Perreault has met STUDENT several times at conferences on deaf-blindness and coordinated a one-week evaluation of her in the spring of 1995. Mr. Perreault observed STUDENT in San Luis Obispo and met with the persons working with her in both October 1995 and January 1996. He also provided information regarding deaf-blind education to Ms. Dunn at the Perkins School in the spring of 1996.Mr. Perreault recommended that STUDENT be provided a balanced program in which she participates in regular education classes and also in a separate program of individual instruction in the areas of English, math, reading, social studies, and current events. Mr. Perreault stated that during the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT's teacher, Ms. Dunn, had time to "support the activities around adapting materials, teaching STUDENT what she needed to know to participate in those two [regular education] classes, but what she didn't seem to have time to do was to structure the program of teaching STUDENT in other areas that were not being addressed in the classes and with the foundation concepts she needed for those two classes." (Petitioner's Exhibit 2, p. 28-29) He estimated that the teaching time should be increased up to "20 to 25 hours, if not more." (p. 31) In a letter dated April 12, 1996, Mr. Perreault had recommended that Betsy's hours be increased from ten to twenty to "both help STUDENT remain current with her regular eduction class along with providing tutoring instruction to compensate the learning gaps that have occurred because of her prior educational experiences." (Petitioner's Exhibit 2, Exhibit No. 3)

Mr. Perreault stated that one individual who knows STUDENT's learning needs should be "in charge of the program" and be responsible for writing the IEP based on a functional assessment of STUDENT's current needs, managing the IEP, overseeing the "objectives in regular classes, in special classes, in one-to-one time, in interpreting situations, in tutoring situations...."

(Petitioner's Exhibit 2, p. 34) Because STUDENT is moving to high school, Mr. Perreault recommended that STUDENT be provided guidance counseling and social support to be able to fully benefit from what is offered in the high school setting. Regarding STUDENT's technological needs, Mr. Perreault stated that STUDENT does not have access to the best technology available that could make her educational information more readily accessible. For example, he stated that STUDENT does not have access to braille printers even though she has learned some braille. Her CCTV does not do color and the image focusing is old. Mr. Perreault recommended that someone aware of the range of available technology undertake an assessment of STUDENT's technological needs.

Mr. Perreault stated that STUDENT has splinter skills or gaps in her learning. For example, her math skills are at a very basic level and she has gaps in her vocabulary development. Mr.

Perreault stated that STUDENT's gaps are a function of the failure to be provided learning in a way that was "accessible and available to her in the way that she could learn." (Petitioner's Exhibit 2, p. 80) Mr. Perreault also attributed the gaps to STUDENT's moving from one educational setting to another from kindergarten to the present, not having anyone involved in her education that could address her needs as a person who is deaf-blind, and missing incidental learning because of vision and hearing losses. Mr. Perreault stated that a functional assessment of STUDENT's educational levels should be conducted to determine the foundational concepts she has missed. Mr. Perreault expressed the opinion that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory educational services to fill the gaps in her learning. Mr. Perreault was unable to quantify the amount of compensatory education that should be provided.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. I(A): To receive a free appropriate public education, must STUDENT's IEP include the following additional goals and objectives?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.

An appropriate IEP must be designed to meet a student's unique and individual needs pursuant to the standard set forth in Rowley. Additionally, the IEP must include, among other things, the following: present levels of the student's educational performance; annual goals and short-term instructional objectives; specific special education instruction and related services required by the student; the extent to which the student will participate in regular education; the projected date for initiation and duration of special education programs and services; a statement of transition services for students beginning no later than age 16; and objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, at least annually, whether objectives are achieved. For students with low incidence disabilities, specialized services, materials, and equipment shall be identified in the IEP as well. Education Code § 56345; 20 U.S.C. 1401; 34 C.F.R. 300.346.

The goals and objectives contained within the District's proposed IEP, which have been agreed to by PARENT, are designed to improve STUDENT's general and specific knowledge/skills; conceptual and functional math skills; organizational skills; proficiency in use of an educational interpreter; proficiency in American Sign Language signs, idioms, and structure; use of her voice;

understanding and use of language pragmatics; expressive and receptive communication skills and ability to communicate with non-signers; effective use of the various technology and tools made available to her; braille reading and writing skills; braille technology; orientation and mobility skills; reading skills; and general health-related physical fitness. (Respondent's Exhibit 15)

In addition to agreed upon goals and objectives, PARENT contends that the following objectives need to be added to the District's IEP:

(1) STUDENT will participate in a minimum of three regular education classes each semester.

Goals describe what a student can reasonable be expected to accomplish within a year's period and objectives are measurable, intermediate steps toward meeting the goals. 34 C.F.R. 300.346, Appendix C, Questions 37, 38, and 39. The proposed statement above does not fall within this definition of an objective.

An appropriate IEP must indicate the extent to which the student will participate in regular education. Education Code § 56345(a)(4). Page "12 of 12" of the District's proposed IEP for STUDENT indicates that STUDENT will participate in regular education for 42% of the day (3 classes). (Respondent's Exhibit 15) Because the proposed statement above is not an objective and the IEP already specifies that STUDENT will participate in three regular education classes, the Hearing Officer concludes that it is not necessary to include the above in STUDENT's IEP.

(2) By October 1, 1996, STUDENT will participate in an evaluation to determine more precisely her present levels of math performance--as they relate to the District curriculum--and to determine her present levels of reading performance. At that time, additional objectives will be written which address specific skills.

All of the witnesses concurred that STUDENT has gaps in her knowledge and that she has rather significant deficits in her math skills; however, there are no current measures of STUDENT's current levels of academic functioning. PARENT testified that it is necessary that an assessment of STUDENT be undertaken to determine her present levels of performance, particularly in the areas of reading and math. Other witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT, including Ms. Roger and Mr. Perreault, concurred that an assessment should be undertaken. The District witnesses did not dispute the need to have a better understanding of STUDENT's current academic functioning.

The Hearing Officer concludes, however, that the proposed objective is not a measurable, intermediate step toward a goal for STUDENT and, therefore, it is not appropriate to include it in her IEP as an objective.

(3) STUDENT will participate to the maximum extent feasible with deaf and deaf-blind people and events. STUDENT will assist her mother in accessing funds to attend American Association of Deaf-Blind (AADB) functions and camps.

PARENT testified that the objective proposed above is designed to help STUDENT learn about other people like her. The District asserted that this objective is not related to the provision of a free appropriate public education and noted that there are no other deaf-blind students within the school district. There was no persuasive evidence that this objective is designed to support any of STUDENT's goals nor was there evidence that for STUDENT to receive an appropriate education, the District is required to ensure her participation in events with deaf and deaf-blind people or to assist her mother in accessing funds. Therefore, it is not appropriate to include the proposed objective in STUDENT's IEP.

(4) STUDENT will participate as an active member in a social circle that meets on a regular basis. She will demonstrate the ability to communicate and problem solve effectively in social situations.

A number of witnesses expressed concern regarding STUDENT's social skills. Their concern was accentuated by the fact that STUDENT is entering a new school where she does not know anyone. PARENT testified that STUDENT has not made any new friends since the sixth grade. The IEP team concurred that STUDENT needs to improve her social skills and included the following goal in her IEP: STUDENT will participate in a variety of social environments--structured and unstructured--both during and outside of the school setting. The only objective to support this goal is that "STUDENT will demonstrate improved understanding of interpersonal issues with staff and peers in academic and social situations."

A number of witnesses who have worked directly with STUDENT or who have observed her over several years' time testified that STUDENT's social skills will not improve unless she is included in a formal, structured program that will help her to develop a social network and that will provide her with the tools to address social issues. Ms. Roger, who worked on the grant at SFSU, who described STUDENT as "isolated," testified that STUDENT needs assistance in order to develop friends. Ms. Roger recommended a program such as the Circle of Friends, which was used successfully with STUDENT when she was in the sixth grade. Mr. Wheeler, the school board president, concurred. Ms. Anderson-Ruble testified that STUDENT did not have a social life and that she did not know how, or have the ability to, independently socialize with students during school breaks and lunch. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Anderson-Ruble, STUDENT's interpreter/tutor, particularly persuasive, given that Ms. Anderson-Ruble was with STUDENT in every one of her classes during the 1995-1996 school year.

PARENT contends that the Circle of Friends is the appropriate formalized means to involve STUDENT in a group of peers and to improve her social skills. Several other witnesses who testified on behalf of STUDENT also recommended the Circle of Friends program, citing STUDENT's successful participation in the program while in the sixth grade. The District's witnesses from STUDENT's high school placement testified that a number of programs are already available at the high school to support STUDENT's development of social skills and that, for this reason, it is not necessary to adopt another program. For example, there are peer helper groups and a lunch buddy program. Counselors also provide an ongoing support program for students. Ms. McKinnon, who worked with STUDENT when she was in the sixth grade, also testified that there is a more "natural" way for STUDENT to make friends than to use the Circle of Friends program. Ms. McKinnon challenged other testimony regarding the success of the Circle of Friends in the past with STUDENT. She testified that the program brought too much attention to STUDENT and, on some occasions, provided a forum for other students to express negative feelings toward STUDENT.

STUDENT's IEP does not include any objectives to address the way in which STUDENT will achieve the goal of improving her social skills. Moreover, the evidence discussed above establishes that STUDENT needs to be involved in a formal, structured program that is designed toward improving her social skills. STUDENT's need for a formalized program is particularly important in light of her dual sensory impairments. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs to develop social skills, the proposed objective shall be added to STUDENT's IEP. However, because teaching methodology is generally within the discretion of school staff, the Hearing Officer does not require the District to specifically implement a Circle of Friends. See Lachman v. Illinois State Bd of Educ. (7th Cir. 1988) 852 F.2d 290. The Hearing Officer leaves to the District's best judgment how to meet this objective.

(5) STUDENT will participate in discussions and development of her IEP as appropriate.

Education Code § 56341(C)(1) states that when appropriate, the IEP team shall include the student. There was no evidence that STUDENT has been prevented from participating in the development of her IEP or that this objective needs to be added to her IEP.

Therefore, it is not necessary to include the proposed objective in STUDENT's IEP.

(6) STUDENT will participate in an individualized adapted PE swimming program which is held after school at Cal Poly and is facilitated by an interpreter and Adaptive PE specialist.

PARENT testified that STUDENT should be encouraged to develop an interest in some sort of physical activity in which she can participate lifelong. She asserted that the swimming program offers STUDENT the opportunity to do so. No additional information regarding the program was provided. There is insufficient evidence to establish that STUDENT requires this program to meet her unique and individual needs or to provide her with educational benefit. Moreover, STUDENT's IEP indicates that during physical education, she "will be exposed to various individualized health related fitness activities and be able to describe 10 health related physical activities that she might be able to participate with peers outside of school." (Respondent's Exhibit 15, p. 10 of 12) Based on the above, the Hearing Officer denies the request to include this objective in STUDENT's IEP.

ISSUE NO. I(B): To receive a free appropriate public education, must STUDENT's IEP include the following additional components?

As discussed above, to satisfy the requirements of special education law and the standard set forth in Rowley regarding the provision of an appropriate education, a student's IEP must specify what is necessary to meet the unique needs of the student and to provide the student with educational benefit. In this District, components of a student's educational program that are necessary for a student to receive an appropriate education are described in an "Addendum to the IEP." (FOOTNOTE 8) PARENT contends that the following additional components must be added to the proposed educational program for STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year to ensure that she receives a free appropriate public education.

(FOOTNOTE 9)

(1) STUDENT's academic progress will be documented through the establishment of an annual portfolio of work which will include writing samples, test samples, etc.

There was no testimony to substantiate that the above statement is necessary to meet STUDENT's unique needs or to provide her with educational benefit. Moreover, on page 1 of 12 of the District's proposed IEP for STUDENT, it states that "Specific objectives studied are available and held in her annual portfolio of school work." Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the above statement regarding the establishment of an annual portfolio of work is not necessary and does not need to be added to STUDENT's

IEP.

(2) A general in-service training/awareness will be made available to the general educators and school staff prior to the first day of school.

PARENT contends that STUDENT's IEP must indicate that a general in-service training/awareness will be conducted prior to the first day of school and that STUDENT's general education teachers and other school staff who will be working with her will be included in the training. PARENT testified that, in the past, the teachers working with STUDENT did not have an opportunity to learn about her unique needs in advance of STUDENT's showing up in their classes. PARENT testified that the result has been that the staff is not prepared to work with STUDENT.

As all of the witnesses testified, STUDENT is a unique individual with unique needs. She is a member of a very small population of persons who are deaf-blind with at least normal intellectual potential. The witnesses from the high school stated that they have not previously educated a deaf-blind student and that their collective experience with students who are blind is also significantly limited. It is likely that regular education teachers have even less, if any experience, educating students who have disabilities similar to STUDENT's. Moreover, the District did not credibly rebut the need to make available to STUDENT's teachers and other school staff in-service/awareness training. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs, the above statement shall be included in her IEP.

(3) Professional training opportunities in the areas of deaf-blindness, academic and social considerations, inclusion, and deaf-blind interpreting, etc., will be acquired for the staff working with STUDENT.

There is no doubt that persons providing special education services to STUDENT require certain expertise in the education of deaf, blind, and/or deaf-blind students. However, at the hearing, the special education training and experience of the persons who would be working with STUDENT during the 1996-1997 school year were not addressed. For this reason, it is not possible to determine at this time whether the persons who will be working with STUDENT require training to meet STUDENT's needs. Therefore, it is not appropriate to add the above component to STUDENT's IEP.

(4) A substitute pool of interpreters will be established and trained.There is no dispute that it is vital to STUDENT's ability to participate in her education that she have the services of a sign-language interpreter. There also is no dispute that it is the responsibility of the District to provide STUDENT's interpreter. There was a substantial amount of testimony regarding the difficulty encountered by the District in attracting qualified interpreters to apply for a position in the District. It has even had more difficulty providing a qualified interpreter for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer hopes that the District will continue to take steps to locate qualified interpreters. However, it is up to the District to determine how best to ensure that it has available suitable interpreters for STUDENT. For this reason, the Hearing Officer declines to add the above component to STUDENT's IEP.

(5) Collaboration time among staff supporting STUDENT is necessary. The schedule will allow for the primary teacher to coordinate with the teacher of visually impaired, interpreter, and general educators. Designated times for team meetings will be arranged on a monthly basis.

Petitioner contends that, due to the number of persons providing services to STUDENT and because of her complex needs, it is necessary that the staff supporting STUDENT collaborate on a regular basis. Ms. Anderson-Ruble and Ms. Dunn testified regarding the difficulty she had arranging to meet and plan with STUDENT's regular education teachers. Ms. Heuer and other District witnesses also testified that, at various times, there have been misunderstandings regarding the roles of the persons involved in STUDENT's education. Some District witnesses asserted that STUDENT's special education teacher may have unnecessarily prepared or modified materials for STUDENT that either already were available or should have been prepared as part of the responsibilities of the VI specialist.

Under the proposed IEP, STUDENT has a number of service providers including VI, O/M, APE, and speech and language specialists. She also has a primary special education teacher and an interpreter, as well as regular education teachers. Based on the testimony regarding prior problems with communication among the staff, the benefits of regular collaboration among STUDENT's support team, and the complexity of STUDENT's educational requirement, the Hearing Officer concludes that to meet STUDENT's needs, it is necessary that the staff supporting STUDENT be provided time to collaborate regularly. Although there were some communication problems during the prior school year, STUDENT generally had a successful school year. According to Ms. Heuer, STUDENT's support team met nearly monthly during the prior school year. (See Respondent's Exhibit 13) No one testified that meetings of the support team should take place more or less frequently. Therefore, the Hearing Officer adopts the recommendation of PARENT and Ms. Heuer that the team meet monthly.

(6) STUDENT's present level of performance in the areas of reading, written language, writing, and math will be assessed annually.

PARENT contends that the IEP must state that STUDENT's academic progress will be evaluated at least annually to determine her present level of performance in the ares of reading, language, writing, and math. Education Code § 56345(a)(1) states that the student's present levels of educational performance must be included in the student's IEP. Therefore, it is not necessary to include a similar statement in STUDENT's IEP.

Moreover, a district is only required to reassess a student every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the student's parent or teacher requests an assessment and a new individualized education program to be developed. Education Code § 56381. There was no persuasive evidence that conditions warrant an annual rather than a triennial assessment of STUDENT. It also would be premature at this point in time to conclude that conditions will exist in the future that warrant an annual assessment. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the proposed statement regarding an annual assessment is not required.

ISSUE NO. II: What is the appropriate level of services from a special education teacher for STUDENT to receive a free appropriate public education?

The parties agree that STUDENT shall receive individual instruction for three periods daily for a total of approximately 15 hours per week from a specialist who is knowledgeable in the needs and learning strategies of deaf-blind individuals. The instructional areas include math, art, and English. STUDENT's mainstreaming classes include physical education, social science, and peer communication. STUDENT has an additional period called "keyboarding," which will include instruction in braille and use of technology, as well as instruction in mobility. The interpreter will accompany STUDENT to all but the classes taught by the special education teacher.

The parties do not agree about the additional amount of time that is required for the special education teacher to carry out other responsibilities, including adapting materials, providing support in other classes, and consulting with other members of STUDENT's support team. The District has offered to provide an additional period per day for preparation. (The special education teacher position was posted as a 60% position, which is approximately 21.5 hours per week.) This is an overall increase of 11.5 hours from the prior school year. All of the witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT were of the opinion that 21.5 hours are insufficient to meet all of STUDENT's needs at the high school. Mr. Perreault estimated that the teacher requires 20 to 25 hours or more to meet STUDENT's needs. Ms. Anderson-Ruble concluded that 30 to 35 hours would be necessary. In a letter dated July 24, 1996, which was prepared while the hearing was in progress, Mr. Collins of the Perkins School stated that STUDENT requires a specialist teacher for "at least 25 hours per week, and perhaps as much as 30 hours per week." (Petitioner's Exhibit 53) STUDENT's interpreter and special education teacher from the prior school year also testified regarding the need for additional time over what was allotted last year to modify the curriculum for STUDENT and to collaborate with the interpreter and STUDENT's regular education teachers. Ms. Dunn, who was STUDENT's teacher during the prior school year, testified that she never had enough time to prepare all of the materials STUDENT needed or to consult with STUDENT's regular education teachers. She also testified that she spent a lot of time beyond the ten hours she was employed last year to prepare materials for STUDENT.

PARENT testified that to meet STUDENT's unique needs, the special education teacher requires between 30 to 35 hours per week. She asserts that the following time is needed to provide the necessary support for STUDENT:

(1) A minimum of three hours per week each for social science and peer communications classes, and a minimum of two hours per week for the physical education class to modify/adapt materials to ensure STUDENT is learning the core concepts and information required of the class; to create materials to support objectives of the class through tactile and multi-modal approaches and for vocabulary and pre-learning needs; and to preview movies/multi-media presentations and summaries. (FOOTNOTE 10)

(2) A minimum of two hours per week for STUDENT's English class to select and mix the English objectives with social science content.

(3) A minimum of two hours per week to select, modify, and support selected arts/crafts activities which support specific art objectives through a multi-modal approach to the enjoyment of art.

(4) A minimum of three hours per week to modify/adapt math materials.

(5) Fifteen hours per week of one-to-one teaching.

(6) Approximately five additional hours per week for meetings with the interpreter and general education teachers, to research and acquire materials, and to communicate with parents, teachers, interpreter, and school administrators.

Petitioner's Exhibit 1.

The District contends that the number of hours it has offered to provide STUDENT with a special education teacher is sufficient to meet her needs and is based on the recommendations made by Mr. Perreault. District witnesses also pointed out that the teacher's hours have more than doubled from last year. Additional factors that the District's witnesses cited in support of their offer include the following: STUDENT received "A" grades during the prior school year and benefitted from her education; and responsibilities for preparing some materials--enlarging and brailling--have been designated to STUDENT's service providers.

The District has increased from last year the number of hours of individual instruction that STUDENT will receive from the special education teacher. Last year the teacher provided approximately three hours per week of individual instruction to STUDENT. This year, the teacher is providing STUDENT with daily instruction for three periods in three different subject areas. The teacher also continues to provide STUDENT with support for her three regular education classes. Thus, the teacher has more classes and subject areas for which she must prepare and adapt materials than she did the prior school year. However, for this school year, the amount of preparation time allotted to STUDENT's special education teacher has actually decreased slightly from the time allotted to her the prior school year. Moreover, Ms. Dunn testified credibly that she spent time beyond the 10 hours in order to prepare materials for STUDENT's three classes.

Given the consistent testimony that there was not enough time last year allotted for preparation and consultation, the complexity of STUDENT's needs, the gaps that remain in her education, and the fact that STUDENT is entering her first year of high school, the Hearing Officer concludes that the total hours proposed for STUDENT's teacher by the District is insufficient to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs. In reaching this decision, the Hearing Officer relies heavily on the witnesses in this case who have expertise in the area of deaf-blind education--Ms. Roger and Mr. Perreault. The expertise of these witnesses is recognized nationally and both Ms. Roger and Mr. Perreault have personally observed STUDENT and have been involved in her educational program for several years. The Hearing Officer also gives great weight to the testimony of the persons who worked directly with STUDENT during the prior school year--Ms. Anderson-Ruble and Ms. Dunn.

As to the specific number of additional hours that are necessary for the special education teacher to meet STUDENT's needs, all of the witnesses except Mr. Perreault recommended a minimum of 30 hours per week. Mr. Perreault, on the other hand, recommended "at least...20 to 25 hours, if not more."

(Petitioner's Exhibit 2, p. 31) Thirty 30 hours would be consistent with Mr. Perreault's recommendations. Therefore, the Hearing Officer determines that 30 hours is the appropriate level of support from a special education teacher to provide STUDENT with an appropriate education during the 1996-1997 school year.

ISSUE NO. III: What is the appropriate level of interpreter/tutor services for STUDENT to receive a free appropriate public education?

Petitioner contends that she requires an interpreter for a minimum of 40 hours per week, with additional hours for special events, unstructured social school time, and for after-school activities, as requested by STUDENT. The District has offered to provide STUDENT's interpreter for four periods per day to accompany her to her regular education classes and to interpret for her during the keyboarding class.

Ms. Anderson-Ruble, STUDENT's interpreter during the 1995-1996 school year, testified that to perform her job appropriately and to meet STUDENT's needs, she required two to three hours daily to obtain information from STUDENT's regular education teachers to make adaptations, and to consult with STUDENT's special education teacher. The District's proposed schedule for the interpreter does not currently include any preparation time for the interpreter nor does it allow any time for consultation with STUDENT's teachers and other support staff. Ms. Anderson-Ruble testified that some of her preparation hours were necessary because the special education teacher was not available to communicate with STUDENT's regular education teacher. With the additional hours that it has been determined above are necessary for the special education teacher to modify materials and curriculum, and the fact that the teacher will regularly be available on the high school campus, the interpreter should not need as much time for preparation during the 1996-1997 school year as she did the prior school year. Ms. Anderson-Ruble testified, however, that to perform her job in a professional manner and to be able to appropriately interpret for STUDENT, she required some familiarity with the subject matter and curriculum in advance of STUDENT's classes. As a member of STUDENT's support team, she also needs time to participate in regular meetings regarding STUDENT.

Additionally, given that STUDENT is deaf-blind and cannot independently communicate with her peers in the absence of an interpreter, the District's proposed schedule leaves STUDENT on her own at lunch time. According to Ms. Anderson-Ruble's testimony, the lack of an interpreter at lunch time is clearly not designed to meet STUDENT's needs. Moreover, Mr. Robinett testified that a majority of organized school social activities take place during lunch. (The District has agreed to provide the interpreter for other school activities on an as-needed basis and with prior approval.) As discussed above, there is general agreement that STUDENT's social skills are lacking and STUDENT's IEP includes goals and objectives to improve her social skills and communication with peers. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District must provide STUDENT with an interpreter during lunch. Therefore, to provide STUDENT with an appropriate education, her interpreter's hours must be increased a minimum of 1.5 hours per day to allow the interpreter to accompany STUDENT at lunch time and to allow the interpreter time to prepare for STUDENT's regular education classes and to consult with team members.

ISSUE NO. IV: What, if any assistive technology does STUDENT require to receive a free appropriate public education?

Petitioner contends that she requires assistive technology to allow her to more effectively access information presented in class; to allow for face-to-face communication with non-signing persons; and to prepare her to more effectively be responsible for class assignments, projects, and tests. Petitioner requests that the District provide her with the following assistive devices, which were recommended by STUDENT's VI teacher, Bev DeWitt-Moylan:

(1) Arkenclone computer system for word processing by STUDENT and for teachers to give assignments and directions.

(2) 20 inch color monitor to provide access to more text with less magnification needed to get a larger print size.

(3) An open book unbound with scanner to allow for direct input of documents without retyping into the computer, which then allows for braille display output.

(4) HP Deskjet printer for printing of large or standard print documents.

(5) Megadots braille translation software to translate a print entry into braille.

(6) Zoomtext plus screen magnification software to enlarge screen images on monitor.

(7) Lite touch communicator to provide face-to-face communication, telephone access, and note-taking through a combination of TDD and paper-less braille.

(8) Alva refreshable braille display (40 cell) to allow access to computer screen braille.

(9) Wordperfect for DOS which is a word processing program for IBM compatible computer.

(10) Braille lite disk drive which allows entries to be made into braille lite to be stored on disk for computer use.

(11) Braille embosser for braille printouts of computer entries.

(Petitioner's Exhibit 1)

The District has agreed to purchase some of the items recommended by Ms. DeWitt-Moylan. During the course of the hearing, Dr. Thomas-Anderson provided a copy of a purchase order for items for STUDENT. Those items include:

(1) DOS Pentium model computer system Class B certified, 100 mhz, 840 mb hard drive, 1 mb PCI Video Card, 8 mb RAM, one 3.5" floppy drive, 4-speed CD-ROM Drive, 14.14 fax modem, Commo, FaxTalk and Doorway Software, 2 serial ports, 1 parallel port, 101 KB, DOS 6.22.

(2) 17" SVGA Color Monitor, .28 Pitch.

(3) Hewlett Packard DeskJet 600C Printer.

(4) MegaDots Braille Translation Software.

(5) ZoomText Plus Screen Magnification Software.

(6) WordPerfect 6.1 for DOS; and Access Tool Set.

(Petitioner's Exhibit 28)

The District has also requested from SEOC low incidence funding assistance to purchase additional items for STUDENT. At the end of the hearing, there was no resolution as to which items, if any, would be purchased.

The District asserted that the Tri-Counties Regional Center had agreed to provide STUDENT with an alternative communication device. As to what additional technological support STUDENT requires, the Hearing Officer notes that Ms. DeWitt-Moylan did not testify at the hearing nor did anyone else with expertise in augmentative/assistive communication devices or any other technological devices. Because STUDENT is deaf and blind, her needs are complex and there are many devices currently available to provide augmentative and assistive communication or other technological support. It is impossible without further information for the Hearing Officer to determine what devices STUDENT may need. The Perkins School, Mr. Perreault, SFSU, and the California School for the Deaf have recommended that an assessment of STUDENT's technological needs be undertaken. SEOC made a similar recommendation. The Hearing Officer adopts their recommendation and concludes that the District must assess STUDENT's technological needs and evaluate how those needs should be met.

ISSUE NO. V: What is the appropriate level of speech and language services for STUDENT to receive a free appropriate public education?

PARENT contends that STUDENT requires individual speech and language services to address deficits in pragmatics and that the interpreter must be available to assist STUDENT when she receives speech and language services. The District has offered weekly consultation by a speech and language specialist.

One of the recommendations resulting from the Perkins' assessment of STUDENT was that a speech and language pathologist consult with STUDENT's teachers. (Petitioner's Exhibit 9) The District's offer of weekly consultation appears to satisfy this recommendation. There was no persuasive evidence at the hearing to substantiate that STUDENT needs individual speech and language therapy, rather than weekly speech and language consultations as proposed by the District. The witnesses who testified did not include a speech and language pathologist or anyone who had assessed STUDENT's speech and language needs. The Hearing Officer concludes that, absent evidence to the contrary, the weekly consultation by a speech and language specialist is sufficient to meet STUDENT's needs in this area.

ISSUE NO. VI: To receive a free appropriate public education, does STUDENT require that someone be designated to coordinate and oversee her educational program?

Petitioner contends that she requires the designation of someone with knowledge of her educational needs as a deaf-blind student to coordinate and oversee her educational program. This person has been referred to as the "point person," "case manager," or "primary teacher." Petitioner contends that this responsibility should be fulfilled by STUDENT's special education teacher. PARENT and Ms. Roger testified that, in 1994, the SFSU program recommended that a point person be designated to fulfill the following roles and responsibilities: to provide follow through with STUDENT's program next school year; to support inclusive education for a case load of students; to streamline the process for development and implementation of curriculum adaptations; to develop and implement a variety of co-teaching strategies in the general education classroom; to coordinate functional assessments; to coordinate development and implementation of adapted curriculum-based functional assessments; to facilitate peer support strategies across school environments; to coordinate specialists; to coordinate team building; to include parent expertise in program planning; and to facilitate team meetings with educational staff, administration, and family. The recommendations at that time were for someone with a strong curriculum background in general education, with special education expertise and understanding of how STUDENT learns, and with expertise in positive behavioral support analysis and plans. (Petitioner's Exhibit 10-C) Mr.

Perreault and Mr. Wheeler made similar recommendations. A letter dated May 2, 1995, from Michael T. Collins, director of the Hilton/Perkins Program of the Perkins School for the Blind, states that STUDENT's program requires one special education professional who is responsible for coordinating and implementing her services. (Petitioner's Exhibit 8)

A majority of the testimony elicited from the District's witnesses focused on who should have the responsibility of overseeing STUDENT's educational program. District witnesses testified that a teacher does not generally have administrative credentials and does not supervise other service providers. The District proposed that either the high school counselor or the department chair of the high school special education department serve as STUDENT's case manager.

Education Code § 56363(a) states in relevant part:

Designated instruction and services...shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. (FOOTNOTE 11)

In addition, the Code of Federal Regulations defines related services as

...transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services as are required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education,.... [emphasis added]

34 C.F.R. § 300.16(a)

The note to Section 300.16 states:

Each related service defined under this part may include appropriate administrative and supervisory activities that are necessary for program planning, management, and evaluation. [emphasis added]

Based on the code sections above, the Hearing Officer concludes that, under certain circumstances, case management is a related service.

In this case, as previously discussed, STUDENT has complex needs which are met by a number of service providers, teachers, and interpreters. There was also testimony regarding the lack of coordination in the past, which has led to disputes between STUDENT's special education teacher and her interpreter and which may have resulted in the special education teacher duplicating material that was already available or that should have been the responsibility of the VI teacher to prepare or adapt. There is also substantial evidence that the eighth grade was a relatively successful year for STUDENT. One of the components present during that school year, which was not present in prior school years, was one individual who coordinated support team meetings for STUDENT. That person was Ms. Heuer, who served as a case manager.

Based on the testimony of the experts in inclusion and in deaf-blind education, the complexity of STUDENT's needs, the number of persons supporting her, and the fact that the case manager was helpful in STUDENT's achieving success during the prior school year, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires that someone be designated to coordinate and oversee her educational program. That person shall be known as the "case manager."

As to who can fulfill that function, the Hearing Officer determines that it is at the discretion of the District to appoint someone. Generally, school districts have program managers or someone of Ms. Heuer's experience and qualifications to fulfill the role of case manager.

ISSUE NO. VII: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

In Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington v.

Department of Education of Massachusetts (1985) 471 U.S. 358, the Supreme Court concluded that equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA. Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th cir. 1994).

Petitioner contends that she is entitled to compensatory education based on the District's failure to remedy the gaps in her education and to provide her with an interpreter during certain periods, particularly when she was in the seventh grade. The District does not dispute that STUDENT has gaps in her learning and that the District's attempts during portions of the seventh grade to obtain an interpreter for STUDENT were not successful.

Mr. Perreault attributed the gaps in STUDENT's education to a number of factors, including the changes over time to STUDENT's educational settings, the lack of persons with expertise in deaf-blind education on STUDENT's support team, and the fact that STUDENT misses incidental learning because of her vision and hearing losses.

The remedy sought by Petitioner is additional interpreter services and additional special education services. The Hearing Officer has already determined above that the hours proposed by the District for STUDENT's teacher and interpreter must be increased to provide her with an appropriate education. To address STUDENT's gaps, the District has proposed a special education teacher for three periods per day to provide one-to-one instruction to STUDENT in math and English. Moreover, the District has agreed to provide educational services for STUDENT for an additional year beyond the standard four years for high school. On page "11 of 12" of STUDENT's IEP proposed by the District, it states that "a 5-year Academic Plan will be developed with SELPA, administrative, an counseling department staff by January 1997." (Respondent's Exhibit 15) Therefore, because the District has already agreed to provide additional services to STUDENT beyond the regular four years of high school, it is unnecessary to make a determination at this time regarding STUDENT's entitlement to additional compensatory education.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

ISSUE NO. I: To receive a free appropriate public education, must STUDENT's IEP include:

(A) additional goals and objectives?

The District substantially prevailed on these sub-issues.

(B) additional components?

Petitioner prevailed on two of six sub-issues;

the District prevailed on four.

ISSUE NO. II: What is the appropriate level of services from a special education teacher for STUDENT to receive a free appropriate public education?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. III: What is the appropriate level of interpreter/tutor services for STUDENT to receive a free appropriate public education?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. IV: What, if any, assistive technology does STUDENT require to receive a free appropriate public education?

Neither party substantially prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE V: What is the appropriate level of speech and language services for STUDENT to receive a free appropriate public education?

The District prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE VI: To receive a free appropriate public education, does STUDENT require that someone be designated to coordinate and oversee her educational program?

Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE VII: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

ORDER

(I) Within 20 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team to amend STUDENT's IEP to:

(A) Add the following objective: STUDENT will participate as an active member in a social circle that meets on a regular basis. She will demonstrate the ability to communicate and problem solve effectively in social situations.

(B) Add the following components to the description of STUDENT's educational program:

(1) A general in-services training/awareness will be made available to the general educators and school staff prior to the first day of school.

(2) Meetings of STUDENT's support team shall be arranged on a monthly basis.

(3) STUDENT shall have the services of a case manager.

(4) STUDENT shall have the services of a special education teacher for 30 hours per week.

(5) STUDENT shall have the services of an interpreter for a minimum of 5.5 hours per day.

(II) Upon receipt of this decision, the District shall increase the hours of STUDENT's special education teacher to 30 hours per week.

(III) Upon receipt of this decision, the District shall increase the hours of STUDENT's interpreter by a minimum of 1.5 hours per day.

(IV) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall appoint someone of Ms. Heuer's experience and qualifications to serve as STUDENT's case manager to coordinate and oversee STUDENT's educational program.

(V) Within 20 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall prepare a plan to assess STUDENT's augmentative and assistive technology needs. The District shall complete the assessment within the timelines set forth in the Education Code.

(VI) All of Petitioner's other requests for relief are denied.

DATED: September 25, 1996 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. Kathleen Romano is presently known as Kathleen McKinnon.

2. As of January 31, 1996, Ms. Vanaman no longer represented STUDENT. 3. Attorney Bobbie F. Albanese represented the District at mediation. 4. The parties agreed to hearing dates of June 27 and 28, 1996. Five additional days of hearing took place in July and August 1996. 5. At the hearing, the District indicated that it had posted a 60% teaching position, which is 21.5 hours per week.

6. Various witnesses interchangeably used the terms "primary teacher" and "point person" to designate the individual responsible for STUDENT's educational program and materials.

7. At the deposition, Mr. Ellison appeared on behalf of STUDENT and attorney Ryan Bezerra appeared on behalf of the District.

8. In fact, the IEP proposed by the District for STUDENT includes on an addendum such program components as "STUDENT will receive daily 1:1 instruction, 3 periods per day....a 4-hour per day interpreter will be provided for all classes other than those taught by the teacher specialist....Prior to the first day of school, STUDENT and Orientation and Mobility Specialist will be given access to the school to establish immediate mobility needs...." (Respondent's Exhibit 15)

9. Additional statements are included on the Petitioner's proposed "Supplemental Page for STUDENT IEP." (Petitioner's Exhibit 1) This decision only addresses Petitioner's proposed additional statements that are not substantially similar to those contained within the District's proposed IEP (Respondent's Exhibit 15) or that have not already been agreed to by the District.

10. Peer communication, social science, and PE were regular education classes proposed for STUDENT for the fall of 1996.

11. Designated instruction and services (DIS) is California's term for related services.